Special thanks to the World of Tanks team for helping out with the episode! If you're interested in becoming a World of Tank player yourself - why not check out redir.wargaming.net/w7fwclmx/?pub_id=Sabaton and get your hands on some cool in-game stuff for free. If you would like to gain early access to our Sabaton History episodes and actively support this awesome project that we are so passionate about, you can do so by joining our Patreon community. There are some pretty cool perks when you become part of the Patreon family. Find out more and join here 👉 www.patreon.com/sabatonhistory
What better than to quote Sabaton themselves: "There is no enemy, there is no victory, only young men losing their life in the sand" Sabaton, Clifs of Gallipoli
You are correct. After all, decades later, there is no enemy. There is no victory either. Only young men, who had to pay the price, at least twice, and wrote their names in the sands of time. I am a German, born 1994. I salute each and every single dead soldier of both wars. Your death was without reason, but not without cause. And now, we live in Peace. Remember that.
Fun Fact: J.R.R.Tolkien wrote this line to keep his sanity in check Frodo: I wish the Ring had never come to me. I wish none of this had happened. Gandalf: So do all who live to see such times, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to us. And out of this war, with his broken mind, broken soul, he wrote lord of the rings to keep himself together
I think you're wrong. In WW1 his ideas (of story telling) were very much different than what we see in LOTR (or even the SIL). Also, "Shadow of the past" was written in the 30's, when the future loomed dark. And finally, while the war did influence his writing, he vehemently denied direct influence (i.e. the lines "this and that" were written because of one memory or another). (Well, except those very rare occasions where he outright said so, in interviews and lettera)
Dearest Marie: As the war ends for me, i have no regrets, I’ve seen too much horror I hope fate has been more merciful to you. Our time on Earth is brief, and mine has been filled with so much joy, that i can only be thankful for how much i’ve been blessed, most specially for the wonder you brought into my life. This letter is my last, I’ve been found guilty by a military court for the death of an officer. It was not my intention to kill him. War makes men mad. Though i failed Karl, i know my sacrifice has not been in vain. I fought for my country and my liberty, my honour is assured. Since it is the will of God to separate us on Earth, i hope we’ll meet again in heaven. Keep me in your prayers. Your loving papa, Always. -Emile’s last letter in Valiant Hearts.
This poem and it's musical interpretation is indeed a powerful one. I got quite emotional and had to blink back tears during this episode. You just cannot fathom the futility of war in itself, but it's so much worse to know that those in command insisted on throwing away their men's lives just mere hours before the war has ended....it makes me really sad. Thank you for this episode, it's an important one, I think.
I truly hope that your opinion of ruthless commanding officers can be softened a bit by remembering the Christmas Truce story, when for at least some time former enemies forgot about war and ideology and were just regular human beings who shared the holiday spirit regardless of their nation.
I really enjoyed this episode, even though the poems, and hearing Indy's voice starting to crack a little bit, gave me the chills. What a great idea it was to give attention to the poems of the war. Thank you for this, and stay safe guys!
now here we are a hundred has past of a war which was so cruel and vast but remember we all trough sabatons song we see the history and sing it along and stories told by indy neidell who always is prepared so well THANK YOU TEAM, for all your hard work *tank
The part: "Short days ago we lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow. Loved and were loved, and now we lie in Flanders Fields." makes me cry every time I hear it. The writing is just beautiful!
If only the angry French had listened to President Wilsons suggestions on how to deal with Germany maybe the second world War could have been prevented
! you who sleep in Flanders Fields, Sleep sweet - to rise anew! We caught the torch you threw And holding high, we keep the Faith With All who died. We cherish, too, the poppy red That grows on fields where valor led; It seems to signal to the skies That blood of heroes never dies, But lends a lustre to the red Of the flower that blooms above the dead In Flanders Fields. And now the Torch and Poppy Red We wear in honor of our dead. Fear not that ye have died for naught; We'll teach the lesson that ye wrought In Flanders Fields. By Moina Michael,1918
I'm Belgian. When we first touched on WWI in school (I was about 11), we were taught about this poem as the most epic peace poem there ever was and ever will be. So, when I got home, I looked it up, and read it completely, not just the first part. The next day I asked the teacher what was so peaceful about a poem that tells people "I died, but now it's your duty to keep on fighting" That's 21 years ago, and I still don't feel I deserved that detention!
Yeah, you probably didn't deserve detention. The question makes sense and seems fairly reasonable as there is an argument to be made that someone could use it to argue for war just as much as peace. "Take up our quarrel with the foe" would seem to be the biggest line calling for war, and the "If ye break faith with us who die" is asking for people not to give up the war. For me looking pack on it if there was no context to the poem then we would never know who that foe is, and even who the dead are. What does the torch represent? I think that the poem makes more sense when viewed after the as there is now a more obvious seen of "crosses, row on row," where you might have seen the during the great war but it would likely not have been what the reader would have seen. It simply doesn't sound like a poem meant for other soldiers as by the time they will relate to the poem most is probably after their friends have died. However, for someone on the home front they will relate to the song most after the war, not during it. There is also the problem of lack of identification in who anyone is. All we get is a "We are the Dead" and "Take up our quarrel with the foe", but who's dead and who's foe. I haven't seen any translates of this poem, but I imagine it would to possible for someone of another country to put the same kind of value from the poem. A lot of countries fought in Flanders from the Triple Entente and Alliance. It is a guarantee that everyone will know the dead but they may not know the foe. The lack of who is who helps the poem be a symbol of peace just as much a symbol of war, but understand that for as much as it means to you it may mean equally has much to someone who you may call foe. I personally think it is best as a poem for peace because we really don't know who the foe is, and the poem can relate to someone else who would have been on the opposite of the Great War. This mystery makes sense to me in that we have all been given a "torch" and while I don't know what it means I do have a light, and in a world of mystery it must be dark. However, when you are in the dark it is easier to find someone else with a light, and in doing so there will be less mystery. In this way perhaps the foe is not someone else the darkness of mystery and fear, and coming together perhaps we can drive away that mystery and fear. Though this is obviously a purely subjective argument and because of that you can take it or leave it.
"We went up that hill as Quebecers, Ontarians and Newfoundlanders, we came down it as Canadian's" From one Canadian to the world, to Sabaton and the crew, Thank you for remembering the work of one of our best, in one of the worst times this world has seen. I will admit. I cried during this video. Being a history buff and hearing this, both the poem to song and Indy saying it brought tears to my eyes. All of you stay safe. Love from Canada. 🇨🇦
We must never forget the sacrifices that the entire world made; but more so we must never forget those Commonwealth nations whom travelled so far from home in the name of the Commonwealth. I think it is terrible how at times, understated are the sacrifices of the Canadians, Austrialians, New Zelanders, South Africans and Indians made during either WWI or WWII or both. Keep safe everyone, Love from the UK
As one of four family members who have served in CAF, ( my brother, nephew and step son have also served or still serve) this also has a lot of meaning since I was the only one not combat deployed.
There have been worse things. There were soldiers in Germany who had loyally served for 6 years of war and on the last day they got shot for desertion because they didn't see the point anymore on the last day at the eastern front. Imagine that.
I can say with experience that reading 'in flanders Fields' is bloody impossible to read without crying. i have to say well done and thank you Sabaton for making this.
The older I get the more ANZAC day means to me and emotions overwhelm me. And when I've been on duty for the services (st john ambulance volunteer) I have to keep a tissue or 2 in my pocket.
@@michellemelville8979 I am currently 18 but with how I was raised, with stories from relatives and talking to many people on top of my general love for history as a subject.. I have appreciated everything many millions of people did for this world and it horrifies me how little my generation understands or cares for the past, especially in a time like this. 1 reason why I love Sabaton so much, allows me to learn more about individuals or groups on both sides not just mine (im british).
I bet lots of soldiers make humorous poems. Some about cacaphony, their own tinnitus or ptsd. Sad poems, happy poems, funny poems... all make the world go around
We're not there yet. 7 months before the Eleventh day of the Eleventh Month and even on that day, there were still high casualties. Which makes it just ironic. Some officers were right in their mind and others were just stupid. Still, that is one great way to remind this. And also, great day guys to upload this video. I got my sweaters and shirt that I ordered online today. One of the sweaters said this at the back. What's so fucking Great about it?
@Evert de rijke it was only a armictice, not the end of the war. It was not even over at signing of Parijs peace treaty,... Because This treaty was only between Alices and Austria and germany, not the rest. The Balkan part was not jet done, neither the Russin or greco turkish part. Only to reegnite 20 years later. Even today the war is not complete over (sykes picet treaty still ignites),... Thats why i Will keep a fieldflowerbed in my garden. Daisy for the belgian Cornflower for the french Forget me not for prussia, Poppy for the commonwealth,... Wij zullen ze gedenken Nooit vergeten, altijd bij ons.
@@beeldpuntXVI Da's wat de generaal zei. Een wapenstilstand voor twintig jaar. En dan nog, het begon opnieuw en opnieuw. In elk geval, in grote delen van de wereld stopte het conflict. Een oorlog die alle oorlogen zou eindigen. Wat een zieke grap.
Imagine: the end of a concert, instead of the band playing To Hell and Back, Joakim says ´´I have an idea: instead of singing To Hell and Back, like we always do, we all sing the last song from our recent album, In Flanders Fields´´ and everyone in the crowd is singing. My god, wouldn't that be a fantastic way to end a concert?
@@MastemaJack That's unfortunate, but I assure you that McCrae's poem is famous all around the world. It's easily one of the most, if not the most, famous poems of all military history and the fact that he fought for Canada is not lost on us at all.
Here in Canada, because of who wrote it, we have this as a cultural poem recited religiously at every Remembrance Day ceremony in remembrance of every Canadian death in wartime. I can say honestly, with certainty and without bias that the Sabaton version is the best and most emotional rendition in existence
"The End of the War to End All Wars" is a powerful epic song. "In Flanders Fields" is a haunting and powerful end to the album, and makes those seconds of silence after the album is ended such a mix of emotions and a hellova headspace trip.
This video reminds me of the last episode of Blackadder Goes Forth. The characters we've come to know and love going over the top at the end, and then the completely silent end credits
As a Canadian, Flanders Fields is memorized in school and is at part of our history, is a part of us. coincidentally, today(April, 9) marks the 103 years for the battle for Vimy ridge.🇨🇦
Fellow Canadian here from Ottawa. It is a beautiful poem and i'm glad they did a song about it. Canada does not get enough rep for its wartime contributions
You are so right. I live near Halifax, with all the military history that Halifax and Nova Scotia has, they will not allow a Military/war museum here"it promotes hate". IT'S OUR HISTORY!. also we have the last WW2 corvette here in Halifax (HMCS Sackville) they want to build a battle of the Atlantic museum and put her up on the shore , but again people are saying it is a "waste of money"
Bruce Oakley it’s so sad that people think that way, museums especially war museums promote remembrance and shows us what can happen when hate goes to far, how can we avoid repeating our past mistakes if no one remembers what they were.
I remember 3 years ago in High School during Remembrance Day, school was doing a moment of silent and some student recite this poem over the speaker. What’s iconic about it is considering that most kids who gives no shit during Anthem were actually quiet and reflecting during that 2 minutes of silence. No phones, no noise, everyone just standing there listening to that beautiful poem
There is no shame whatsoever in weeping for the memories of those who gave everything for us. They suffered horrifically - the least we can offer is to push our way through some emotional pain while we think of them.
Here's something I've written on 11/8/18 when Indy & crew uploaded the "Armistice, But Peace?" episode for the Great War channel: On November 11th, 1918. On the 11th hour. A soldier heard the news. He leaped for joy. Dancing where he stood. His heart knew no greater joy. "Huzzah! Huzzah! The war is over! We can go home! Huzzah! Huzzah!" When he came to his senses. And looked all round. His world abruptly halted. On his left were hundreds of dead. On his right, hundreds more. All were as still as statues. Before the 11th hour. An attack was made. To breach the enemy trenches. No one knew why. No one wanted to go. But everyone went in the end. When all was said and done. When the fighting finally ceased. One would think the date was 1914. For no ground was gained. The enemy never budged. And all that was left was this one lone soldier. All whom he laughed with. All whom he struggled with. All have now gone to meet their maker. He cried in disbelief. Weeping where he sat. His heart knew no greater pain. "Huzzah. Huzzah. The war is over. We can go home. Huzzah. Huzzah." A noise in front of him. A now-former enemy soldier. Making his way to him. They both stared at each other. Waiting to see who would make the first move. Then his counter part held a chocolate bar. "I was saving these for when the war ended. But I saw you sitting there and thought you might need a friend. Want one?" The soldier was silent, trying to make up his mind. In the end he shrugged. And took the offered bar. Some of my folks suggested I should submit it to some magazine or something but I never did.
Im Canadian and ever since I was a kid we always had to recite in Flanders fields in school in November and to this day on rememberance day i still recite it word for word and i always cry. I hope all of the brave men that served are resting in peace i didn't know any of them but I will always honor them.
Such a touching episode, the chills this video gave me, beautiful narration indy really, felt it deep. Congratz to the team. Great video. Stay safe have a good week
Such a moving song and poem. Indy and Par really did it justice in this video, as did sabaton in general with the song. In war, death is the only constant. And that is something that these poems can really translate to us.
Yes, I'd say every Canadian knows this poem. I learned it by heart in elementary school, as most of of us do, and it's read aloud at ceremonies and on the radio every Remembrance Day. It's always been one of my favourites. I don't know how well-known it is outside of Canada, but this is a beautiful way to honour those who are serving now and who have served, in every country. Thank you for this, Sabaton. 🇨🇦❤
As a former Servicemember of the Canadian Armed Forces I can tell you this poem is well known among not only the British Commonwealth soldiers but American, Russian, and even forces you wouldn't expect to know it. I had a Japanese Self Defense forces solider quote the poem to me once. Verbatim and in English. And I cannot to this day even think of the poem without tears.
As a Brit where Remembrance Day (and wearing + selling poppies) remains a significant event in the national calendar, your adaptation of this poem hit me like a truck after the rest of the album. Even just this video made me emotional - I really respect your decision to make this the final song.
Such a beautiful way to end the album, can't help but think of my great grandfather who faught at Ypres in 1917, lost his left arm in the battle. Spent over a year recovering physically but never mentally I am sure, could tie his shoes with one hand still, rode I have a picture of him on horseback. Lived until he was 92 and its was a privilege to have him in my life, visit his grave every November. RIP William Barber.
I remember when I first listened to this song. I had no idea what to expect from it. I did not expect to sit in silence for a few minutes with a few tears down my face. A truly moving poem and you guys definitely executed it brilliantly. A great end to the album ❤️
Thank you from Canada... When I saw that on the album I exploded with Maple Pride. And when the album was over... And I heard your rendition of McCrea's poem... I sobbed. We recite the poem in Canada every Nov. 11 and it in a way has lost its power up here as a thing we all had to do every year. This made it hit me again like when I first started learning my nations history!!
Before hearing this on the album, I had never heard this poem sung before, even though I have it memorized. Songs may be poetry set to music, but not all poetry sounds good being sung. This poem is absolutely beautiful as a song. I am so glad you guys included this in the album.
As a kiwi this truly this resonates with me now approaching ANZAC day in two weeks this hits even harder i give my thanks this without a doubt is the most powerful episode you've done it truly hits home down here And even in lock down we draw on the tales of these brave young men who made the ultimate sacrifice least we forget Thank you Sabaton for the strength you give us all and in remembrance we salute you
I never actually knew the true symbolism or the inspiration of the red poppies had after the war, only knowing it became the symbol for the dead during ceremonies and memorial services. But hearing in this video on how they continued to grow and how their petals being blown in the wind was like the blood of the dead painting the Earth once more truly struck a cord with me, this video was truly a splendid one.
I am canadian I was born in and still live in canada and I can attest to what Indy says and in school we learn about canadian independance movements and major independent moments in canadian history and the majority of the most prominent ones happened after the great war, the chinook crisis (where canada refused to send men to help Britain in the middle east) and the halibut treaty (a treaty signed solely by canada and the Americans for fishing rights in the north atlantic) are ones that come to mind. So I just wanted to say thank you Indy for remembering a country's history that most times is just bunched in with the British
I have been to the place where Mcrae first wrote in Flanders Fields (though obviously it cannot be exactly pinned down). All that is left of the war is a cemetery, and the empty concrete remnants of the advanced dressing station. It is always surprising how much suffering can be hidden beneath such inconspicuous surroundings.
From my first listen-trough of The Great War, I knew that this in my opinion was the best song ever to close an Sabaton record! Some of the craziest chills I've ever gotten was when The War to end all Wars fade out with the cannons, and the last cannon echoes out into eternity, for this song to take over
IrrSinn Rainer I was driving and listening to the album in rush hour traffic when it came out... I legit had to pull over and just sit for a good 5 minutes afterwards before I could start driving again since I couldn’t see the road through the tears... I know what you mean completely
The end of The Great War album reminds me of the end of Blackadder Goes Forth. All build-up, emotion... and then relative silence. It just hits you so hard.
No matter how many times I watch that I always end up crying. Especially when George admitted he was too scared to go over the top. Absolutely broke my heart
being Canadian, i grew up hearing this poem every November 11th. ever since i was old enough to truly get a feeling for the horror of the world wars and what the young men and others went through in them this poem has always just gutted me emotionally and almost brought tears to my eyes. The one time i was chosen to read it publicly i did so with tears running down my cheeks. i can not put into words what it meant to hear it at the end of your album, The Great War. thank you
I am Canadian. We ALL had to memorize this poem in school. We were taught what the words meant. Wearing a poppy MEANS something to anyone who has been through the Canadian school system. Check out "Death of the Ball Turret Gunner" by Randall Jarrell.
I didn't know about this song at all. I saw the poppy's and I saw flanders. So I immediately knew this was gonna be about ww1. Either the belgians or the canadians. As many died there in Ypres. I didn't expect it to be the poem. But it was great. And got me to cry a lott.
Every time you hear this poem, it is impossible not to tear up. Even the strongest of men will eventually break. For those who fought and died, we honor their sacrifice for all eternity. From the Americans and British, who fought in these wars, to the ANZACS and Germans, who gave it their all, let us not forget the sacrifice these men made. And the pain and suffering their loved ones endured. At the going down of the sun, We will remember them. Lest we forget.
I went to a school named after John McCrae and every remembrance Day (November 11) we would gather in the gym to read the poem as a school. It was one of the experiences that got me to really look into Canadian history and find the deeds of men and women to be truly proud of. Thanks for bringing this poem to a wider audience.
On the 103rd Anniversary of Canada's becoming a nation on the Fields of France, this is a perfect Sabaton song to discuss. From the pen of a Canadian Officer lamenting the loss of a friend but determined to carry on.
Little Fact: The last death in WW1 was a American, he died at 10:59am on November 11th, he was pinned down by a machine when it stopped firing just before the war would end, he then rushed at it although his friends and even the Germans were telling him to stop, he fired at the machine gun crew and missed, the machine gunners killed him in self defence.
I agree 100% with ending the album with this song. I am a combat veteran, served 2 tours in Iraq. As well as an avid history enthusiast. I took a trip to Belgium a couple years ago and insisted on going it Ypres and see the history and the Menin Gate in person. While there we decided to walk along the canal and found ourselves at the Essex Farm Cemetery where Maj John McCrae wrote In Flanders Field while stationed at the dressing station on the farm. It is a very powerful poem that evokes a lot of emotion. Especially for those who have seen the horrors first hand. As well as standing on that hallowed ground. Thank You
Throughout the Great War series I was a bit disappointed, unfairly, that Indy never gave WWI poetry the emotional, heartbreaking treatment it deserved. Now I know why. This video seemed to age him by 3 years, it was vintage 1914 end-of-video war futility rant Indy and I am grateful to have finally seen it. This was one of the most powerful WWI videos you guys have done, it's clear Indy was struggling to keep it together at the end. Thank you for all that you do.
I want to thank Sabaton for bringing all these storys to us in song and Sabaton History for bringing these storys to life. I am very interested in the history of war and especially the first world war and this channel is a big reason for igniting my interest in the first world war. War is a terrible thing, but it is our duty to not let them be forgotten and you are doing a big part in inspiring young people, such as myself, to learn more about these themes.
Really powerful song and interpreted so beatifully! Plus, Indy really nailed it. This bromance between Sabaton and Indy is a win win win for Sabaton, Indy and all of us. Please keep making these episodes. I'm a big fan of the series!
As a Canadian, I've heard in Flanders Fields since I was a toddler. We did school projects every year on WW1 in grade school. They used to have 'Canadian heritage' commercials on tv, and Lt. Col. Dr. John McCray had his own. It's nice to see someone read it, who doesn't have false teeth that defy gravity while they speak
As a soldier myself, this song carries a deep meaning. I was lucky to never see action because I‘m swiss. This song still carries such a deep meaning. It breaks my heart to listen to this song but also represents the sense of duty these soldiers felt when going into battle. Truly a heartbreaking and beautiful masterpiece. There could have not been a better song to end this album with, truly beautiful and heartwrenching at the same time. I salute my fellow soldiers from both sides, they have suffered more than enough. May they rest in peace, they‘ve earned it a thousand times over.
This song always brings tears in my eyes 😢. Can't imagine the torment they endured and horror they've seen. Of all tragedies that came upon the human kind, a war is the worst one! Thank you Indy ❤ and Sabaton ❤ for reminding us what happened!
I'm an Hardened Infantry Man fresh From terrorist attacks but Listening To this reminds me back of countless Cries and plight both Us and our Innocent Selves and Civilians....damn I'm crying so bad.....also I've learned Sabaton songs after some guy in the internet send me a link of few music cause he doesn't know how to express thanks on what my unit and Fallen Brothers went through and did...
In Flanders Fields the poppies grow, Between the crosses I walk along. A hundred years have yet gone by, The larks, that still keep singing, fly But I can hear them down below.
I live. We all live, but many years ago They suffered, died, for king and country, For those they loved, and now they remain Forever in Flanders Fields. A quarrel for a world without war we owe Those who stayed where poppies grow. So let us light a new torch! And let us hold it high For freedom, for peace and for those who lie Forever in Flanders Fields. - Irina Kiauka
IN FLANDERS FIELDS: In Flanders fields the poppies blow Between the Crosses, row on row, That mark our place: and in the sky The larks, still bravely singing, fly, Scarce heard amidst the guns below. We are the dead. Short days ago we lived, felt dawn. saw sunset glow. Loved and were loved. and now we lie In Flanders fields. Take up our quarrel with the foe. To you from falling hands we throw the torch. Be yours to hold it high. If ye break faith with us who die We shall not sleep, though poppies grow In Flanders fields. BY LT. COL. JOHN McCRAE. Of MONTREAL. WHOSE BODY LIES IN FLANDERS FIELDS.
Far and away one of the best episodes. The discussion portion is what I watch this channel for and this one did not disappoint. I really loved how you related it to a context well beyond WW1 and the image at the end was what finally brought me to tears. I only contribute to the timeghost army RIGHT NOW but I am so glad as a longtime Sabaton fan you guys have managed to put this whole thing together and do such a FUCKING WONDERFUL job. Truly, thank you. I know this probably won't bring in as many likes as some exponentially lower word count, edgy meme comment will but you do a great job of reading all comments and I just hope you see this and tell everyone including those behind the scenes how much we appreciate them.
Be it the other song we heard, the Sabaton version or soundtrack version of this, they all never fail to induce such emotions. I wonder at the end of The Great Tour, they play this song at the concert's and all poppy flowers will drop to the audience. That would be powerful and symbolic; a fitting tribute to those who died.
As a Canadian who met his great great grand father and was lucky enough to talk to him before he passed, him and a few vets when I was a kid, this totally makes me cry, it's beautiful, it's a poem that made me wanna write poetry as a kid, its a proud part of Canadian identity
I am very familiar with the poem In Flanders Fields. I cannot read it or hear it without shedding a tear. Sabaton's music video and arrangement had me bawling like a baby, and I'm not ashamed to admit it. Despite the final verse urging continuing hostilities, I think it sums up the sorrow and futility of the Great War like nothing else I've ever heard. Bravo, gentlemen. Now if you'll excuse me, I have to open a new box of tissues...
In writing background material for a book, there is this monument graveyard, where they place a single small white stone for each life that has been lost in conflict, both for those who defended them and those who attacked them. This being a science fiction novel the empires are huge and so are their fleets, the graveyard holds more than 20million of these stones all laid out in seemingly endless circles around 1 larger stone in the middle which reads: “These stones mark those who fought to defend us and attack us, each doing simply their duty. May we honour their sacrifice and forever question the reason as to why they had to find their demise in conflict.” This and the story around it was written with WW1 firmly on my mind. There is so much we can learn from history and yet it feels as if we rather just forget it existed all to often. I am glad to see people learning about through many sources just like this one here and I sincerely hope that all of us who learn about history, also will learn from it.
To me the most powerful piece of poetry from the Great War is 'In Memoriam' by E.Alan Mackintosh, a British officer eventually killed at Cambrai in 1917. "Happy and young and gallant, They saw their first-born go, But not the strong limbs broken And the beautiful men brought low, The piteous writhing bodies, They screamed, "Don't leave me, Sir," For they were only your fathers And I was your officer."
grew up near Paschendale, and going down the tyne cot Cemetery is one of the most daunting experiences I have ever felt. The little museum beforehand that keeps listing of names of the lost (all below the age of like 22) and then, as soon as you turn past the door you see an ocean of graves, each grave containing multiple names and it is all surrounded by a gigantic wall, which upon further inspection is also just one gigantic collection of names.
"the final attack had achieved nothing but more death. Who could justify the fate of those last soldiers dying in this war? what could have been said to the hundreds of grieving widows, parents and friends that this bloody mourning has caused?" That maked me cry. You are absolutely right, Indy. And guys, what a song for one of the most heavy poems ever. Astonishing view and sensibility over the subject. That's what really makes Sabaton the best band now a days.
I'll never be able to listen to this song the same way again. Thank you, Sabaton, for including this gem as the closure for The Great War. And thank you, Indy, for bringing the stories to those of today so we have the chance to understand of those decades, and a century, gone by. My birthday is just a few days before Remembrance Day, and I thank you all for giving me a chance to honor those 2 mins. Thank you, dearly, from a Canadian fan.
This song means a lot to me, as I grew up and still live in the same city as LtCol McCrae and went to the same high school he did. This history is held close in my city.
While I served in the German army, a part of my Company was deployed in Afghanistan. When they came back some of them gave a Rock-Concert. They covered some of their favorite songs and played in their deployment Uniforms (they are sand colored instead of the normal green).
In Italy we have Ungaretti, one of our most important poets and a veteran of WWI . He also wrote about his memories of the war in many poems.. like this (roughly translated) Autumn: Here we are, like autumn’s leaves on the trees. And the obvious meaning is, we are dead
I started to tear up listening to this song the first time, and I was tearing up by the end of this episode. I think that because it isn't Sabaton's metal, instead a choir singing a 100 year old poem written by someone who was actually there, makes this all the more powerful and emotional. I truly believe that this is the best way to end the album. Lest we forget.
![Diary Of An Unknown Soldier - Lost in the Great War - Sabaton History 063 [Official]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZazU1-cxTRQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Diary Of An Unknown Soldier – Lost in the Great War – Sabaton History 063 [Official]](/img/tr.png)
![The Ballad Of Bull - Leslie "Bull" Allen - Sabaton History 070 [Official]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ts_iAftE8Jo/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Attack of the Dead Men Pt.2 - Gas! Gas! Gas! - Sabaton History 095 [Official]](/img/1.gif)
Special thanks to the World of Tanks team for helping out with the episode! If you're interested in becoming a World of Tank player yourself - why not check out redir.wargaming.net/w7fwclmx/?pub_id=Sabaton and get your hands on some cool in-game stuff for free.
If you would like to gain early access to our Sabaton History episodes and actively support this awesome project that we are so passionate about, you can do so by joining our Patreon community. There are some pretty cool perks when you become part of the Patreon family.
Find out more and join here 👉 www.patreon.com/sabatonhistory
Three steps to listening to 'In Flanders's Fields'
1)Try not to cry
2)Lie down
3)Cry a lot
4) continue laying down
5) sleep
@@ashenwuss1651
6) Repeat this but in flanders fields.
I'm not crying; I'm washing my beard.
@@OffensiveJestr My eyes, they are burning up. It's just sweat. Move along
@Jackson Crook
1) Try not to cry + doesn’t work = I am crying. Liebe grüße Alex 🤘🏻
"Only the dead have seen the end of the war"
-Plato
*dead
Modern Warfare. I see you’re a man of culture
*Pluto
@@gameryazov8327 o Scuse me, im french and I justed translated in my mind. Thank for the correction.
@@TheSkilfingar Thank for the correction.
What better than to quote Sabaton themselves:
"There is no enemy, there is no victory, only young men losing their life in the sand"
Sabaton, Clifs of Gallipoli
You are correct.
After all, decades later, there is no enemy. There is no victory either.
Only young men, who had to pay the price, at least twice, and wrote their names in the sands of time.
I am a German, born 1994. I salute each and every single dead soldier of both wars. Your death was without reason, but not without cause.
And now, we live in Peace.
Remember that.
@@DGARedRaven We only hope that we may have learnt something, but fear maybe we have already started to forget.
Oh lordy lord, the onion-chopping ninjas visited again
they also came to my house
Damn ninjas move so fast they stirred up some dust that got in my eyes
THISE NINJAS JUST KEEP ON SNEAKING
Those bastards got me too!
FAST AS THE WIND THE ONION CHOPPING NINJAS HAS BEGUN
Fun Fact: J.R.R.Tolkien wrote this line to keep his sanity in check
Frodo: I wish the Ring had never come to me. I wish none of this had happened.
Gandalf: So do all who live to see such times, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to us.
And out of this war, with his broken mind, broken soul, he wrote lord of the rings to keep himself together
I think you're wrong.
In WW1 his ideas (of story telling) were very much different than what we see in LOTR (or even the SIL).
Also, "Shadow of the past" was written in the 30's, when the future loomed dark.
And finally, while the war did influence his writing, he vehemently denied direct influence (i.e. the lines "this and that" were written because of one memory or another).
(Well, except those very rare occasions where he outright said so, in interviews and lettera)
Wasn't he writing the Silmarillion in the trenches, not Lord of the Rings? LotR was a sequel to the Hobbit, the Hobbit being published in the 30s.
Another fun fact, if only marginally related:
Tolkien was also one of the many considered for employment at bletchley park
Dearest Marie:
As the war ends for me,
i have no regrets,
I’ve seen too much horror
I hope fate has been more merciful to you.
Our time on Earth is brief,
and mine has been filled with so much joy,
that i can only be thankful for
how much i’ve been blessed,
most specially for the wonder
you brought into my life.
This letter is my last,
I’ve been found guilty by a military court
for the death of an officer.
It was not my intention to kill him.
War makes men mad.
Though i failed Karl,
i know my sacrifice has not been in vain.
I fought for my country and my liberty,
my honour is assured.
Since it is the will of God to separate us on Earth,
i hope we’ll meet again in heaven.
Keep me in your prayers.
Your loving papa,
Always.
-Emile’s last letter in Valiant Hearts.
That game is an underrated classic.
@@FieldMarshalYT i agree Lannes
"Dearest Marie" hits almost as hard as "We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow"
No....not this as an Army Guy who was DM on watching this game....I shed a tear men....now I'm remembering it again
that hit me hard and the onions are everywhere
This poem and it's musical interpretation is indeed a powerful one. I got quite emotional and had to blink back tears during this episode. You just cannot fathom the futility of war in itself, but it's so much worse to know that those in command insisted on throwing away their men's lives just mere hours before the war has ended....it makes me really sad.
Thank you for this episode, it's an important one, I think.
me too.
Definitely. Here's hoping to a long lasting peace
and then there are stories such as hearts of iron. Although that song is set in WWII, it shows quite the opposite of behavior from higher-ups.
@@MrXPeaceLP That's true. Precious song of a decent officer.
I truly hope that your opinion of ruthless commanding officers can be softened a bit by remembering the Christmas Truce story, when for at least some time former enemies forgot about war and ideology and were just regular human beings who shared the holiday spirit regardless of their nation.
I really enjoyed this episode, even though the poems, and hearing Indy's voice starting to crack a little bit, gave me the chills. What a great idea it was to give attention to the poems of the war. Thank you for this, and stay safe guys!
You too!
@@SabatonHistory I'll do my best!
@@Thomas.Wright Emotion is what makes us invincible. Or maybe not, I'm just trying to be motivational lolol
@@ashenwuss1651 great job, gave me a nice laugh :3
@@MrXPeaceLP hehehehehehe. Take care!
“Loved and were loved” that hits me hard every time
Linus Van Pelt's oration of this poem and that one line hits the hardest.
@@katey1dog oh goodness you HAD to remind me of that (opens another box of tissues)
@@charlesgrybosky1916 yes. It slaps the tears out of me.
Were loved? I would believe to this day, still loved.
now here we are
a hundred has past
of a war which was
so cruel and vast
but remember we all
trough sabatons song
we see the history
and sing it along
and stories told
by indy neidell
who always is
prepared so well
THANK YOU TEAM, for all your hard work
*tank
damn, that is a nice one
Beautifully said.
As a German, I have only one thing to say:
Honoured dead, You may now rest in Peace,
For your sons, now friends, live in harmony.
Can we have a moment of silence
@@godofrapeofficial a moment of silence for all fallen
This shit right here is straight fire
"A generation lost, we are forever in debt.
One hundred years hence, lest we forget."
The part: "Short days ago we lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow. Loved and were loved, and now we lie in Flanders Fields." makes me cry every time I hear it.
The writing is just beautiful!
As Ferdinand Foch said, *_"This is not peace. It is an armistice for twenty years."_*
He didn't say it because he thought the terms of the armistice were too hard, as many people think, but because he thought they weren't hard ENOUGH.
@@MrTrellheim He was right either way. And after WW2 they did listen to him and they disassembled Germany as a country for many years.
If only the angry French had listened to President Wilsons suggestions on how to deal with Germany maybe the second world War could have been prevented
@Dr Ludwig Army soldier The Italians were promised a lot of land that they were not given by the British and French tho
@@Altrantis made it into a liberal country so the aristocracy couldn't harbour militant ideas.
! you who sleep in Flanders Fields,
Sleep sweet - to rise anew!
We caught the torch you threw
And holding high, we keep the Faith
With All who died.
We cherish, too, the poppy red
That grows on fields where valor led;
It seems to signal to the skies
That blood of heroes never dies,
But lends a lustre to the red
Of the flower that blooms above the dead
In Flanders Fields.
And now the Torch and Poppy Red
We wear in honor of our dead.
Fear not that ye have died for naught;
We'll teach the lesson that ye wrought
In Flanders Fields.
By Moina Michael,1918
I'm Belgian. When we first touched on WWI in school (I was about 11), we were taught about this poem as the most epic peace poem there ever was and ever will be.
So, when I got home, I looked it up, and read it completely, not just the first part.
The next day I asked the teacher what was so peaceful about a poem that tells people "I died, but now it's your duty to keep on fighting"
That's 21 years ago, and I still don't feel I deserved that detention!
Frederik we ne er learned much about ww1 😒 Also belgian here 🤘🏼
Yeah, you probably didn't deserve detention. The question makes sense and seems fairly reasonable as there is an argument to be made that someone could use it to argue for war just as much as peace.
"Take up our quarrel with the foe" would seem to be the biggest line calling for war, and the "If ye break faith with us who die" is asking for people not to give up the war.
For me looking pack on it if there was no context to the poem then we would never know who that foe is, and even who the dead are. What does the torch represent? I think that the poem makes more sense when viewed after the as there is now a more obvious seen of "crosses, row on row," where you might have seen the during the great war but it would likely not have been what the reader would have seen. It simply doesn't sound like a poem meant for other soldiers as by the time they will relate to the poem most is probably after their friends have died. However, for someone on the home front they will relate to the song most after the war, not during it.
There is also the problem of lack of identification in who anyone is. All we get is a "We are the Dead" and "Take up our quarrel with the foe", but who's dead and who's foe. I haven't seen any translates of this poem, but I imagine it would to possible for someone of another country to put the same kind of value from the poem. A lot of countries fought in Flanders from the Triple Entente and Alliance. It is a guarantee that everyone will know the dead but they may not know the foe.
The lack of who is who helps the poem be a symbol of peace just as much a symbol of war, but understand that for as much as it means to you it may mean equally has much to someone who you may call foe.
I personally think it is best as a poem for peace because we really don't know who the foe is, and the poem can relate to someone else who would have been on the opposite of the Great War. This mystery makes sense to me in that we have all been given a "torch" and while I don't know what it means I do have a light, and in a world of mystery it must be dark. However, when you are in the dark it is easier to find someone else with a light, and in doing so there will be less mystery. In this way perhaps the foe is not someone else the darkness of mystery and fear, and coming together perhaps we can drive away that mystery and fear. Though this is obviously a purely subjective argument and because of that you can take it or leave it.
Slowjam Sliver a bit to much english for me 😁 but i understand your point ! 👍👍
@@Seune205 Sorry. The only other language I got is French, and I'm really really bad at it.
Slowjam Sliver en vlaams is bie goed genoeg voor u ofzo ? 😁😁
"We went up that hill as Quebecers, Ontarians and Newfoundlanders, we came down it as Canadian's"
From one Canadian to the world, to Sabaton and the crew, Thank you for remembering the work of one of our best, in one of the worst times this world has seen.
I will admit. I cried during this video. Being a history buff and hearing this, both the poem to song and Indy saying it brought tears to my eyes.
All of you stay safe.
Love from Canada. 🇨🇦
We must never forget the sacrifices that the entire world made; but more so we must never forget those Commonwealth nations whom travelled so far from home in the name of the Commonwealth.
I think it is terrible how at times, understated are the sacrifices of the Canadians, Austrialians, New Zelanders, South Africans and Indians made during either WWI or WWII or both.
Keep safe everyone,
Love from the UK
Thomas Cushing this song is engrained in our national conciseness as Canadians, but every time I hear it it always brings tears to my eyes
I salute my brothers to the north
As one of four family members who have served in CAF, ( my brother, nephew and step son have also served or still serve) this also has a lot of meaning since I was the only one not combat deployed.
Right back at you brother. It's odd how such a tragic, needless conflict could forge our country, like a tree from individual roots. 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
"The tragedy of the last man killed in the last war." somebody wrote.
There have been worse things. There were soldiers in Germany who had loyally served for 6 years of war and on the last day they got shot for desertion because they didn't see the point anymore on the last day at the eastern front. Imagine that.
@@LeutnantJoker Holy shit, I literally have no words for that ._.
I can say with experience that reading 'in flanders Fields' is bloody impossible to read without crying. i have to say well done and thank you Sabaton for making this.
The older I get the more ANZAC day means to me and emotions overwhelm me. And when I've been on duty for the services (st john ambulance volunteer) I have to keep a tissue or 2 in my pocket.
@@michellemelville8979 I am currently 18 but with how I was raised, with stories from relatives and talking to many people on top of my general love for history as a subject.. I have appreciated everything many millions of people did for this world and it horrifies me how little my generation understands or cares for the past, especially in a time like this. 1 reason why I love Sabaton so much, allows me to learn more about individuals or groups on both sides not just mine (im british).
nathan Gathercole @nathan Gathercole
My greatest respect for you 🤘🏻Liebe grüße Alex
Michelle Melville @Michelle Melville
You have my greatest respect 🤘🏻not only in these days everytime !!!!
Liebe grüße Alex
"Hear the words I sing,
War's a horrid thing,
So I sing sing sing...ding-a-ling-a-ling"
- Private S. Baldrick
Boom, Boom, Boom, Boom,
Boom, Boom, Boom,
Boom, Boom, Boom, Boom,
Boom, Boom, Boom
Private S. Baldrick.
The German Guns
Aliasalpha beat me to it
"I can go on all night"
"Not with a bayonet through your neck you couldn't"
I bet lots of soldiers make humorous poems. Some about cacaphony, their own tinnitus or ptsd. Sad poems, happy poems, funny poems... all make the world go around
We're not there yet. 7 months before the Eleventh day of the Eleventh Month and even on that day, there were still high casualties.
Which makes it just ironic.
Some officers were right in their mind and others were just stupid. Still, that is one great way to remind this. And also, great day guys to upload this video. I got my sweaters and shirt that I ordered online today.
One of the sweaters said this at the back. What's so fucking Great about it?
That is a great shirt!
@@SabatonHistory Nope, I got the sweater. Great one.
Also, guys. Please get new Angels Calling T-shirts restocked. I really hope to get one.
@Evert de rijke it was only a armictice, not the end of the war. It was not even over at signing of Parijs peace treaty,...
Because This treaty was only between Alices and Austria and germany, not the rest.
The Balkan part was not jet done, neither the Russin or greco turkish part.
Only to reegnite 20 years later. Even today the war is not complete over (sykes picet treaty still ignites),...
Thats why i Will keep a fieldflowerbed in my garden.
Daisy for the belgian
Cornflower for the french
Forget me not for prussia,
Poppy for the commonwealth,...
Wij zullen ze gedenken
Nooit vergeten, altijd bij ons.
@@beeldpuntXVI Da's wat de generaal zei. Een wapenstilstand voor twintig jaar.
En dan nog, het begon opnieuw en opnieuw. In elk geval, in grote delen van de wereld stopte het conflict.
Een oorlog die alle oorlogen zou eindigen. Wat een zieke grap.
Imagine: the end of a concert, instead of the band playing To Hell and Back, Joakim says ´´I have an idea: instead of singing To Hell and Back, like we always do, we all sing the last song from our recent album, In Flanders Fields´´ and everyone in the crowd is singing. My god, wouldn't that be a fantastic way to end a concert?
How well known is that poem outside of Canada?
MastemaJack Very well
@@ea.fitz216 I only ask because the guy who wrote it is Canadian. Most of the time we don't get recognition for anything we do.
@@MastemaJack That's unfortunate, but I assure you that McCrae's poem is famous all around the world. It's easily one of the most, if not the most, famous poems of all military history and the fact that he fought for Canada is not lost on us at all.
@@MastemaJack I'm from Belgium, and we had to learn it by heart in school. So I can ensure you allot of people know it!
Here in Canada, because of who wrote it, we have this as a cultural poem recited religiously at every Remembrance Day ceremony in remembrance of every Canadian death in wartime. I can say honestly, with certainty and without bias that the Sabaton version is the best and most emotional rendition in existence
Imagine being so bloody prideful you send men to die knowing an armistace is in place.
"It is well that well is so terrible, else we should grow too fond of it."
- Robert E. Lee
"The End of the War to End All Wars" is a powerful epic song. "In Flanders Fields" is a haunting and powerful end to the album, and makes those seconds of silence after the album is ended such a mix of emotions and a hellova headspace trip.
This video reminds me of the last episode of Blackadder Goes Forth. The characters we've come to know and love going over the top at the end, and then the completely silent end credits
@Necroglobule That was a sad but fitting end of one of the best comedy shows ever. And we'll never know Baldrick's last cunning plan.
- Don't forget your stick Lieutenant.
- Bravo, Sir. I wouldn't want to face a machine-gun without this.
@@rhoddryice5412 Wasn't that the splinter on the ladder? And the plan would be to hurt himself, preventing him from fighting?
As a Canadian, Flanders Fields is memorized in school and is at part of our history, is a part of us.
coincidentally, today(April, 9) marks the 103 years for the battle for Vimy ridge.🇨🇦
Fellow Canadian here from Ottawa. It is a beautiful poem and i'm glad they did a song about it. Canada does not get enough rep for its wartime contributions
You are so right. I live near Halifax, with all the military history that Halifax and Nova Scotia has, they will not allow a Military/war museum here"it promotes hate". IT'S OUR HISTORY!.
also we have the last WW2 corvette here in Halifax (HMCS Sackville) they want to build a battle of the Atlantic museum and put her up on the shore , but again people are saying it is a "waste of money"
Bruce Oakley it’s so sad that people think that way, museums especially war museums promote remembrance and shows us what can happen when hate goes to far, how can we avoid repeating our past mistakes if no one remembers what they were.
I remember 3 years ago in High School during Remembrance Day, school was doing a moment of silent and some student recite this poem over the speaker. What’s iconic about it is considering that most kids who gives no shit during Anthem were actually quiet and reflecting during that 2 minutes of silence. No phones, no noise, everyone just standing there listening to that beautiful poem
@@nobelissimos8719 Dude.....this is not the time and place for that.
The song made me cry.
There, I said it.
My father was a reenactor: he had this poem framed on the bookshelf at home.
There is no shame whatsoever in weeping for the memories of those who gave everything for us.
They suffered horrifically - the least we can offer is to push our way through some emotional pain while we think of them.
@@stickiedmin6508 Waw. That was beautifully written. And yes, I agree with your statement.
Here's something I've written on 11/8/18 when Indy & crew uploaded the "Armistice, But Peace?" episode for the Great War channel:
On November 11th, 1918. On the 11th hour. A soldier heard the news.
He leaped for joy. Dancing where he stood. His heart knew no greater joy.
"Huzzah! Huzzah! The war is over! We can go home! Huzzah! Huzzah!"
When he came to his senses. And looked all round. His world abruptly halted.
On his left were hundreds of dead. On his right, hundreds more. All were as still as statues.
Before the 11th hour. An attack was made. To breach the enemy trenches.
No one knew why. No one wanted to go. But everyone went in the end.
When all was said and done. When the fighting finally ceased. One would think the date was 1914.
For no ground was gained. The enemy never budged. And all that was left was this one lone soldier.
All whom he laughed with. All whom he struggled with. All have now gone to meet their maker.
He cried in disbelief. Weeping where he sat. His heart knew no greater pain.
"Huzzah. Huzzah. The war is over. We can go home. Huzzah. Huzzah."
A noise in front of him. A now-former enemy soldier. Making his way to him.
They both stared at each other. Waiting to see who would make the first move. Then his counter part held a chocolate bar.
"I was saving these for when the war ended. But I saw you sitting there and thought you might need a friend. Want one?"
The soldier was silent, trying to make up his mind. In the end he shrugged. And took the offered bar.
Some of my folks suggested I should submit it to some magazine or something but I never did.
Im Canadian and ever since I was a kid we always had to recite in Flanders fields in school in November and to this day on rememberance day i still recite it word for word and i always cry. I hope all of the brave men that served are resting in peace i didn't know any of them but I will always honor them.
You made me cry today, guys, but for those tears I can only say thank you, it was strong🖤
Never forget
Such a touching episode, the chills this video gave me, beautiful narration indy really, felt it deep.
Congratz to the team. Great video. Stay safe have a good week
Thanks! Stay safe!
Such a moving song and poem. Indy and Par really did it justice in this video, as did sabaton in general with the song. In war, death is the only constant. And that is something that these poems can really translate to us.
"War knows no nation"
Yes, I'd say every Canadian knows this poem. I learned it by heart in elementary school, as most of of us do, and it's read aloud at ceremonies and on the radio every Remembrance Day. It's always been one of my favourites. I don't know how well-known it is outside of Canada, but this is a beautiful way to honour those who are serving now and who have served, in every country. Thank you for this, Sabaton. 🇨🇦❤
As a former Servicemember of the Canadian Armed Forces I can tell you this poem is well known among not only the British Commonwealth soldiers but American, Russian, and even forces you wouldn't expect to know it. I had a Japanese Self Defense forces solider quote the poem to me once. Verbatim and in English.
And I cannot to this day even think of the poem without tears.
imagine:me not crying my eyes out whenever i listen to this song from now on.
Poem
@@MastemaJack poem. I was referring to the sabaton song but yeah,its a poem.
Irina Diaz I already cried my eyes out reading it anyways
@@irina49125 What is a song if not a poem set to a tune?
@@CynderDragoneye can relate
As a citizen of Belgium who lives in Flanders I really appreciate this song thank you Sabaton
I’m visiting one day, I don’t know when but I am
As a Brit where Remembrance Day (and wearing + selling poppies) remains a significant event in the national calendar, your adaptation of this poem hit me like a truck after the rest of the album. Even just this video made me emotional - I really respect your decision to make this the final song.
Such a beautiful way to end the album, can't help but think of my great grandfather who faught at Ypres in 1917, lost his left arm in the battle. Spent over a year recovering physically but never mentally I am sure, could tie his shoes with one hand still, rode I have a picture of him on horseback. Lived until he was 92 and its was a privilege to have him in my life, visit his grave every November. RIP William Barber.
Imagine learning that your friend, brother and/or father died hours before peace, for no reason at all.
I remember when I first listened to this song. I had no idea what to expect from it. I did not expect to sit in silence for a few minutes with a few tears down my face. A truly moving poem and you guys definitely executed it brilliantly. A great end to the album ❤️
"We are as
in autumn
on branches
the leaves"
Giuseppe Ungaretti
Courton Forest, July 1918
I loved how the album ends! Tears are flowing! 😭
Thank you from Canada... When I saw that on the album I exploded with Maple Pride. And when the album was over... And I heard your rendition of McCrea's poem... I sobbed. We recite the poem in Canada every Nov. 11 and it in a way has lost its power up here as a thing we all had to do every year. This made it hit me again like when I first started learning my nations history!!
I better like the french version of the poem
" we went up the ridge as Albertans and Nova Scotians , we came down as Canadians" 🇨🇦🇨🇦♥️
Before hearing this on the album, I had never heard this poem sung before, even though I have it memorized.
Songs may be poetry set to music, but not all poetry sounds good being sung. This poem is absolutely beautiful as a song. I am so glad you guys included this in the album.
As a kiwi this truly this resonates with me now approaching ANZAC day in two weeks this hits even harder i give my thanks this without a doubt is the most powerful episode you've done it truly hits home down here
And even in lock down we draw on the tales of these brave young men who made the ultimate sacrifice least we forget
Thank you Sabaton for the strength you give us all and in remembrance we salute you
I never actually knew the true symbolism or the inspiration of the red poppies had after the war, only knowing it became the symbol for the dead during ceremonies and memorial services. But hearing in this video on how they continued to grow and how their petals being blown in the wind was like the blood of the dead painting the Earth once more truly struck a cord with me, this video was truly a splendid one.
I am canadian I was born in and still live in canada and I can attest to what Indy says and in school we learn about canadian independance movements and major independent moments in canadian history and the majority of the most prominent ones happened after the great war, the chinook crisis (where canada refused to send men to help Britain in the middle east) and the halibut treaty (a treaty signed solely by canada and the Americans for fishing rights in the north atlantic) are ones that come to mind. So I just wanted to say thank you Indy for remembering a country's history that most times is just bunched in with the British
This poem catches me with the goosebumps everytime.
I have been to the place where Mcrae first wrote in Flanders Fields (though obviously it cannot be exactly pinned down). All that is left of the war is a cemetery, and the empty concrete remnants of the advanced dressing station. It is always surprising how much suffering can be hidden beneath such inconspicuous surroundings.
From my first listen-trough of The Great War, I knew that this in my opinion was the best song ever to close an Sabaton record! Some of the craziest chills I've ever gotten was when The War to end all Wars fade out with the cannons, and the last cannon echoes out into eternity, for this song to take over
When I listened to the album for the first time this song hit me completely unprepared. Such a deep and touching interpretation of the poem
IrrSinn Rainer I was driving and listening to the album in rush hour traffic when it came out... I legit had to pull over and just sit for a good 5 minutes afterwards before I could start driving again since I couldn’t see the road through the tears... I know what you mean completely
The end of The Great War album reminds me of the end of Blackadder Goes Forth. All build-up, emotion... and then relative silence. It just hits you so hard.
No matter how many times I watch that I always end up crying. Especially when George admitted he was too scared to go over the top. Absolutely broke my heart
being Canadian, i grew up hearing this poem every November 11th. ever since i was old enough to truly get a feeling for the horror of the world wars and what the young men and others went through in them this poem has always just gutted me emotionally and almost brought tears to my eyes. The one time i was chosen to read it publicly i did so with tears running down my cheeks.
i can not put into words what it meant to hear it at the end of your album, The Great War.
thank you
Yeah, those last few hours of the war are quite depressing and sad becuased they survived the past battles only to die before the war ended.
I am Canadian. We ALL had to memorize this poem in school. We were taught what the words meant. Wearing a poppy MEANS something to anyone who has been through the Canadian school system.
Check out "Death of the Ball Turret Gunner" by Randall Jarrell.
I didn't know about this song at all.
I saw the poppy's and I saw flanders.
So I immediately knew this was gonna be about ww1. Either the belgians or the canadians. As many died there in Ypres.
I didn't expect it to be the poem. But it was great. And got me to cry a lott.
Every time you hear this poem, it is impossible not to tear up. Even the strongest of men will eventually break. For those who fought and died, we honor their sacrifice for all eternity.
From the Americans and British, who fought in these wars, to the ANZACS and Germans, who gave it their all, let us not forget the sacrifice these men made. And the pain and suffering their loved ones endured. At the going down of the sun, We will remember them.
Lest we forget.
We Will Remember Them 🙏
It's even more heartbreaking when you hear Indys voice crack a few times, throughout the video. Powerful song, powerful video and powerful narration.
I went to a school named after John McCrae and every remembrance Day (November 11) we would gather in the gym to read the poem as a school. It was one of the experiences that got me to really look into Canadian history and find the deeds of men and women to be truly proud of. Thanks for bringing this poem to a wider audience.
It's part of our job
This is the reason why I wear my poppy every year with pride and respect to every soldier past present and future thank you
I don't get moved that much. But man... This video gave me chills the whole time and had me almost crying at the end of it.
On the 103rd Anniversary of Canada's becoming a nation on the Fields of France, this is a perfect Sabaton song to discuss. From the pen of a Canadian Officer lamenting the loss of a friend but determined to carry on.
Little Fact:
The last death in WW1 was a American, he died at 10:59am on November 11th, he was pinned down by a machine when it stopped firing just before the war would end, he then rushed at it although his friends and even the Germans were telling him to stop, he fired at the machine gun crew and missed, the machine gunners killed him in self defence.
I agree 100% with ending the album with this song. I am a combat veteran, served 2 tours in Iraq. As well as an avid history enthusiast. I took a trip to Belgium a couple years ago and insisted on going it Ypres and see the history and the Menin Gate in person. While there we decided to walk along the canal and found ourselves at the Essex Farm Cemetery where Maj John McCrae wrote In Flanders Field while stationed at the dressing station on the farm. It is a very powerful poem that evokes a lot of emotion. Especially for those who have seen the horrors first hand. As well as standing on that hallowed ground. Thank You
I cannot hear or read this poem without getting tears in my eyes.
Throughout the Great War series I was a bit disappointed, unfairly, that Indy never gave WWI poetry the emotional, heartbreaking treatment it deserved. Now I know why. This video seemed to age him by 3 years, it was vintage 1914 end-of-video war futility rant Indy and I am grateful to have finally seen it. This was one of the most powerful WWI videos you guys have done, it's clear Indy was struggling to keep it together at the end. Thank you for all that you do.
Moment of silence for this Veterans Day and Remembrance Day. Out of the whole album this last song had the effect on really hitting the point home.
I want to thank Sabaton for bringing all these storys to us in song and Sabaton History for bringing these storys to life. I am very interested in the history of war and especially the first world war and this channel is a big reason for igniting my interest in the first world war.
War is a terrible thing, but it is our duty to not let them be forgotten and you are doing a big part in inspiring young people, such as myself, to learn more about these themes.
Really powerful song and interpreted so beatifully! Plus, Indy really nailed it.
This bromance between Sabaton and Indy is a win win win for Sabaton, Indy and all of us.
Please keep making these episodes. I'm a big fan of the series!
As a Canadian, I've heard in Flanders Fields since I was a toddler. We did school projects every year on WW1 in grade school. They used to have 'Canadian heritage' commercials on tv, and Lt. Col. Dr. John McCray had his own.
It's nice to see someone read it, who doesn't have false teeth that defy gravity while they speak
As a soldier myself, this song carries a deep meaning. I was lucky to never see action because I‘m swiss. This song still carries such a deep meaning. It breaks my heart to listen to this song but also represents the sense of duty these soldiers felt when going into battle. Truly a heartbreaking and beautiful masterpiece. There could have not been a better song to end this album with, truly beautiful and heartwrenching at the same time. I salute my fellow soldiers from both sides, they have suffered more than enough. May they rest in peace, they‘ve earned it a thousand times over.
This song always brings tears in my eyes 😢. Can't imagine the torment they endured and horror they've seen. Of all tragedies that came upon the human kind, a war is the worst one! Thank you Indy ❤ and Sabaton ❤ for reminding us what happened!
Once again, praise Sabaton, Indie and the Crew. Making the world a better place, one step at a time.
*Heroes*
Thanks!
I'm an Hardened Infantry Man fresh From terrorist attacks but Listening To this reminds me back of countless Cries and plight both Us and our Innocent Selves and Civilians....damn I'm crying so bad.....also I've learned Sabaton songs after some guy in the internet send me a link of few music cause he doesn't know how to express thanks on what my unit and Fallen Brothers went through and did...
In Flanders Fields the poppies grow,
Between the crosses I walk along.
A hundred years have yet gone by,
The larks, that still keep singing, fly
But I can hear them down below.
I live. We all live, but many years ago
They suffered, died, for king and country,
For those they loved, and now they remain
Forever in Flanders Fields.
A quarrel for a world without war we owe
Those who stayed where poppies grow.
So let us light a new torch! And let us hold it high
For freedom, for peace and for those who lie
Forever in Flanders Fields.
- Irina Kiauka
IN FLANDERS FIELDS:
In Flanders fields the poppies blow Between the Crosses, row on row, That mark our place: and in the sky The larks, still bravely singing, fly, Scarce heard amidst the guns below.
We are the dead.
Short days ago we lived, felt dawn. saw sunset glow.
Loved and were loved. and now we lie In Flanders fields.
Take up our quarrel with the foe.
To you from falling hands
we throw the torch.
Be yours to hold it high.
If ye break faith with us who die We shall not sleep, though poppies grow In Flanders fields.
BY LT. COL. JOHN McCRAE. Of MONTREAL.
WHOSE BODY LIES IN FLANDERS FIELDS.
Far and away one of the best episodes. The discussion portion is what I watch this channel for and this one did not disappoint. I really loved how you related it to a context well beyond WW1 and the image at the end was what finally brought me to tears. I only contribute to the timeghost army RIGHT NOW but I am so glad as a longtime Sabaton fan you guys have managed to put this whole thing together and do such a FUCKING WONDERFUL job. Truly, thank you.
I know this probably won't bring in as many likes as some exponentially lower word count, edgy meme comment will but you do a great job of reading all comments and I just hope you see this and tell everyone including those behind the scenes how much we appreciate them.
Thanks a lot for your support and your kind comment! Cheers!
This song is just perfect. What a beautiful and haunting way to end the album.
every time i hear this song...I get chills up my spine and can't help but to tear up....humans never learn that war causes nothing but pain and death.
Be it the other song we heard, the Sabaton version or soundtrack version of this, they all never fail to induce such emotions.
I wonder at the end of The Great Tour, they play this song at the concert's and all poppy flowers will drop to the audience. That would be powerful and symbolic; a fitting tribute to those who died.
“Good luck everyone.” - Captain E. Blackadder.
As a Canadian who met his great great grand father and was lucky enough to talk to him before he passed, him and a few vets when I was a kid, this totally makes me cry, it's beautiful, it's a poem that made me wanna write poetry as a kid, its a proud part of Canadian identity
Always remember a fallen soldier, always remember fathers and sons at war, always remember, buried in history!
Yup. Tears achieved.
I am very familiar with the poem In Flanders Fields. I cannot read it or hear it without shedding a tear. Sabaton's music video and arrangement had me bawling like a baby, and I'm not ashamed to admit it. Despite the final verse urging continuing hostilities, I think it sums up the sorrow and futility of the Great War like nothing else I've ever heard. Bravo, gentlemen. Now if you'll excuse me, I have to open a new box of tissues...
In writing background material for a book, there is this monument graveyard, where they place a single small white stone for each life that has been lost in conflict, both for those who defended them and those who attacked them. This being a science fiction novel the empires are huge and so are their fleets, the graveyard holds more than 20million of these stones all laid out in seemingly endless circles around 1 larger stone in the middle which reads:
“These stones mark those who fought to defend us and attack us, each doing simply their duty. May we honour their sacrifice and forever question the reason as to why they had to find their demise in conflict.”
This and the story around it was written with WW1 firmly on my mind. There is so much we can learn from history and yet it feels as if we rather just forget it existed all to often. I am glad to see people learning about through many sources just like this one here and I sincerely hope that all of us who learn about history, also will learn from it.
To me the most powerful piece of poetry from the Great War is 'In Memoriam' by E.Alan Mackintosh, a British officer eventually killed at Cambrai in 1917.
"Happy and young and gallant,
They saw their first-born go,
But not the strong limbs broken
And the beautiful men brought low,
The piteous writhing bodies,
They screamed, "Don't leave me, Sir,"
For they were only your fathers
And I was your officer."
grew up near Paschendale, and going down the tyne cot Cemetery is one of the most daunting experiences I have ever felt. The little museum beforehand that keeps listing of names of the lost (all below the age of like 22) and then, as soon as you turn past the door you see an ocean of graves, each grave containing multiple names and it is all surrounded by a gigantic wall, which upon further inspection is also just one gigantic collection of names.
the whole Great War album is a masterpiece. It's become my daily routine to listen to it once a day every day for several months now.
"the final attack had achieved nothing but more death. Who could justify the fate of those last soldiers dying in this war? what could have been said to the hundreds of grieving widows, parents and friends that this bloody mourning has caused?" That maked me cry. You are absolutely right, Indy. And guys, what a song for one of the most heavy poems ever. Astonishing view and sensibility over the subject. That's what really makes Sabaton the best band now a days.
I'll never be able to listen to this song the same way again. Thank you, Sabaton, for including this gem as the closure for The Great War. And thank you, Indy, for bringing the stories to those of today so we have the chance to understand of those decades, and a century, gone by.
My birthday is just a few days before Remembrance Day, and I thank you all for giving me a chance to honor those 2 mins. Thank you, dearly, from a Canadian fan.
Anzac Day here in Australia today so thought I’d revisit some episodes. Lest We Forget.
I have been really anticipating this episode for a while now. I'm glad that you looked at both the song and poem
This is the saddest and most amazing episode.
Let go a tear 😢
Thank you so much Indy Neidell and the Guys from Sabaton!!
This song means a lot to me, as I grew up and still live in the same city as LtCol McCrae and went to the same high school he did. This history is held close in my city.
While I served in the German army, a part of my Company was deployed in Afghanistan. When they came back some of them gave a Rock-Concert. They covered some of their favorite songs and played in their deployment Uniforms (they are sand colored instead of the normal green).
In Italy we have Ungaretti, one of our most important poets and a veteran of WWI . He also wrote about his memories of the war in many poems.. like this (roughly translated) Autumn: Here we are, like autumn’s leaves on the trees. And the obvious meaning is, we are dead
I started to tear up listening to this song the first time, and I was tearing up by the end of this episode. I think that because it isn't Sabaton's metal, instead a choir singing a 100 year old poem written by someone who was actually there, makes this all the more powerful and emotional. I truly believe that this is the best way to end the album.
Lest we forget.