Heath, me and I’m sure many other people, love what you do but because we don’t make comments doesn’t mean that we don’t appreciate your amazing and passionate work. Keep up the good work, you are on the right track.
Heath, I have seen you struggling these past few videos and I just want to let you know that there are plenty of us out here that appreciate your videos and particularly your passion. I don't always comment and I struggle to articulate how much this channel means to me but ill try. Watching movies is my main hobby and up until a few years ago I was just watching the mainstream stuff. Your passion for film has opened me up to SO MANY different genres and eras of film. Movies I would have never heard about. I'd never watched a noir film prior to finding you channel. I had written off black & white films like so many other young people thinking there was nothing to gain from watching "old movies". Now I can't get enough. My journey right now has lead me to Vincent Price and all the classic horror movies he stared in (these are great!). Another actor that wasn't on my radar and again I thank you for your Icons of Horror video. I've been watching all your new release videos and to be honest I watch those 30 minute videos just to hear the 2 minutes where you actually talk about the movies themselves. I wish there was more push to here you talk movies but apparently people just want to see what's coming out that week....kind of a bummer. I don't blame you for doing that. Regarding more recent movies, you put me onto Horizon Part 1 and The Bikeriders and both of those are amazing. Horizon feels so epic and brutal and real. If I had listened to the other morons on RUclips I would have never experienced that film. That example right there has really showed me that movie reviews, for me, are useless. If Horizon isn't regarded as great by the people than I don't trust the people anymore.
Agree! Heath, keep up the good fight. If nothing else, close the comments down on the videos and seek out conversations on your website, Patreon and other fan-supported platforms.
Totally agree 100%. I loved Horizon Part 1 and Bike riders. I also really enjoy listening to your commentaries, that is also opening my eyes to movies I never knew existed before. Keep up the AWESOME work Heath.
Heath, this channel means so much to me. You have taught me so much about movies and made me a much better appreciator of fandom. Please keep it going. I appreciate you so much.
I haven't gone anywhere, but there are changes coming. This video is a plea for my fellow movie fans to stop letting anger and hate lead the conversation.
Honestly man, you are doing some of the best work on RUclips on this topic. I love watching all of your videos and listening to your podcasts, I think you should keep doing you. It’s wonderful
Came to your channel years back now, drawn in by the pop culture in analogue tag and got to say watching you go movie hunting was the joy backed up by substance of the reviews and descriptions. Getting movies sent to you must have seemed like the dream however you have definitely become noticeably more dour (good scottish word) and jaded over the years. Got to find your happiness again, my tuppence worth is to limit the "look at these movies I got sent" videos, pick the ones you want to highlight and share as they mean something to you and you will find those who do appreciate you and your insights shall be there for you. Keep up the good work, you deserve success for the work you put in so dont let those haters get you down Its too easy to be the troll, the talent is with the creator and there are plenty of us who appreciate you and what you do.
Heath, I love your channel. But after listening to your commentaries, I can tell that film history is your passion. Your commentaries on discs and written word, have made films I've always enjoyed, become more special. That's a rare talent and I appreciate it. In a nutshell follow your heart life is short. You have more to offer than RUclips Videos.
I love your channel Heath. Keep up the good work. For me, I have the opposite problem where I love most movies but don't have the means or time to watch them all. There are very few movies I've seen that were outright bad. Almost every movie has some redeeming quality.
i love your videos, sorry people suck. some people always have to ruin or put there hate at everything, especially online. really hope you and the channel don't go anywhere soon. been watching for at least 5 years now, probably longer.
Heath, I always appreciate the honesty and how up front you are with your audience. As far as my opinion, I watch your videos about discs to hear about film. When you have all those new releases, I can't wait to hear what you have to say. Packaging is cool, but I watch those videos to find new films that I might not have heard about. I'm all about expanding my horizons in film. A great example, I don't know if I saw it in your video or someone else's. But I believe it was yours. A Bittersweet Life from Umbrella, I bought and watched that film. I was really surprised and blown away by it. I would've probably never known about it without the coverage I saw. So thank you and keep up the great work. You're a special one.
I hope you continue to make the content that you do because I just came across your stuff and subscribed. The problem with the internet, and society as a whole right now, is instead of people just moving past things they don't like and focus on what they like themselves... they instead feel the need to waste their time in their angry little bubble they have made for themselves purposely watching/reading things they don't like just to blast the individual who made it. There are way too many self righteous people nowadays who like to hide behind keyboards. At the end of the day (and it is tough to do) it really does come down to making content on things you enjoy and are passionate about and stay true to that, knowing you are never going to please every person that comes across your content. If you make a video and you're happy with it and what you shared then focus on that rather than focusing on negative jerks. No one is making them watch. No one is making them comment. Their toxicity is on them, not you.
I couldn’t do what you do. I was on Facebook once for like a month 12 or more years ago and couldn’t stand social media then and nuked the account. Even as a YT viewer, I can’t read most of the comments. I’m still glad to hear what you actually like even if I have trouble getting to the movies these day (I think I’ve done 2 this year).
Heath, I love your channel and the insight you bring. You've turned me on to movies I would have never known about. Keep doing what you're doing. Love the intellect and humor you bring. Ready to eat more Cereal At Midnight
Oi oi oi!!! I guess anger is easier to be spotted than thankfulness! Because angry people are louder… I absolutely love the work you do. I watch your videos almost everyday on my way to work. I’ve learned a lot about movies with you and picked up on so many movie recommendations you make. I appreciate what you do, it’s smart, funny and very informative. I hope you keep going! Thank you.
Heath, I just love that your approach to talking to us. Thank you for telling it like it is. I'm 29 and tired of people telling me what to watch, I have fun at the theatre. Megalopolis is a weird movie, but it was enjoyable at times. I always want to hear your opinion.
I really like what you do man, and I like hearing your perspective even when/if I disagree with ya. I hope you keep making stuff, whatever form it takes!!
Who needs it. WE NEED IT… the real fans who actually watch movies, classics and new movies alike. Your tribe is out here, Heath. We’re just surrounded by those who don’t get us.
@@CerealAtMidnight I know you know how to separate the wheat from the chaff (I’ve been in the Midwest too long). It’s getting harder but the quality within is still there.
I'll admit I love the IP however I love finding those movies that offer more. I generally ignore the critics but due to your track record I take your opinions on a movie into account to my movie choices. Missed the bikeriders at the cinemas but picked up the disc based on your review, loved it (as did my daughter who was in the room and got hooked). Horizon is another example this year, saw it at the cinema. Local cinema has akira kurasawa series atm. Last night saw red beard. Omg what a masterpiece, the cinematography, the challenging story and the performances. 3 hr movie, would have happily sat there for another hr. 3 films so far and my tickets at purchased until the end. Every Tuesday night through to the 1st week of December. I do see your problem however with the channel as it's one of the ways you support your family and it forces you to get clicks. When to do so all you do is pick up discs and go here it is and then get blasted when you have an opinion or want to get off the beaten path then I understand why you're questioning the channels future. You do have a happy appreciative audience, we're just silent most of the time, we also have lives and limited time. Social media only brings out the outrage in comments as it powers the need to spend our time to type a response. Anyway, love your work. You keep doing it and I'll keep clicking in.
Heath, you're a true talent and your voice is needed on RUclips. As a longtime fan of the channel, I would say don't change a thing, your approach is genuine and unique. You bring a sincere and rare sense of joy to cinema fandom and I appreciate every video you drop. Though I dig all that you offer, your interviews are a personal favorite and an area where you really excel. Your recent conversation with Charlotte Barker being a particular standout. Comments across the internet are largely a cesspool populated by miserable and talentless clowns that seem to be obsessed with consuming product they'll never actually watch. There is really no reason to engage with the slip cover deep throaters, just keep hammering and doing what you do best. I've turned many on to you over the years and most of my close friends continue to subscribe and watch regularly going years without posting a single comment. The silent majority are behind you. Stay up, brother. You're appreciated by those that actually love film.
I am glad you made this video. Many of us feel the same way you do, pal! I hope you keep it up because I really enjoy your videos and your interviews. I wouldn't have seen (or purchased) The Tin Star or Last Train from Gun Hill if it weren't for you and those are two of my favorite movies now!
I know how you feel finding things off the beaten path is what makes collecting and enjoying movies, music and books so much worthwhile really enjoy what you do man keep it up
Even if I don't comment on every video, I appreciate your honest opinions and deep dives into films and not just the physical releases. I do love your Kino Lorber spotlight videos because they are my go to boutique label due to the classic line and modest pricing. I'll be honest and say I hardly ever make it to the theater anymore. By the time I take the family out it would cost seventy bucks for a matinee of a movie most of us will be lukewarm about. I love older films much more than modern cinema, and I'm ok with that. I'm not going to come up here and pee in your cocoa krispies because you liked a movie that flopped. Some of the best films of all time were box office failures. The loudest voices are always going to be the most ignorant, unfortunately. I hope you can see the path through the weeds and keep doing the good work. We appreciate your open, unfiltered, unbought, and heartfelt opinions and look forward to seeing more from you well into the future.
I absolutely love you and support everything that you do. I love your passion for movies and the stories they tell, love hearing you talk about movies and learning not only about the movies but behind the scenes content and history as well! I love your channel and your amazing web site and you will always have my support in everything that you do! Do whatever makes YOU happy because in the end there all that matters my friend. You are a true treasure in this world and I am thankful for everything that you do, always! 🙏🏻
Love the channel and thanks for your time making all the videos!! Really need your voice out here for people that love talking and listening about movies! Have a great day.
Also! It was because of your video review on Abbott and Costello’s Africa Screams that led me to follow and back the following Kickstarter campaigns for Jack and the Beanstalk and The Abbott and Costello Show. And now I have an official film cell from their TV show as a bonus add on from it. So thank you, Heath!
i can't stand it when some criticises me for a film i like, if they don't like it thats fine and their choice, one of my favourite films is geostorm it flopped badly but i think it was a great watch
You’re probably the closest to me in terms of our experiences with movies because of how close our ages are, and it really warms my heart to know someone like me is out there talking about movies the way I would have if I have even a sliver of your gift for the gab. I think the trade-off for having a huge social media following nowadays is having to deal with the negativity. In fact, I see it as a badge of honour that people even bother to use their precious time to come spew crap into the comment sections of your videos. But you also have to understand that they do not represent reality, or your true fan followings. I think some of your followers have already mentioned here about how they do not necessarily engage or leave comments even though they absolutely loved and looked forward to every video you put out. Have faith that the silent majority are enjoying and benefitting from the content, and that the toxic commentators are just part and parcel of the insane internet space that we have today. I mean, they may complain and b*tch a lot, and yet, they’re still here.
Hey Heath first time commenting and long time subscriber and liker. I am a HUGE movie lover and cinefile and love your videos and your take on movies. I spend every weekend watching your videos and would be so sad to see you leave but understand where you're coming from with all the negativity. Unfortunately if not engaging with the comments for you to stay on and talking about your love on movies that would be fine. Stay positive brother and long live film.
I agree you should just post and ignore the comments. I expect that it's something you have to do as you grow on the internet, even if you're working in a field that you think would be mostly joyful. It's the reason why superstars have assistants to manage their social media and open their mail. There are angry, confised and scary people out there.
I haven't seen Joker 2, so I'm not going to offer an opinion on whether it's good or bad, but I confess I have no desire to see it, and I will say that it seems questionable business sense for a movie that targets comic book fans to also be a quasi-musical. I just don't see those two different kinds of audiences intermingling much - if there even still is much of an audience for musicals at the movies. But anyhoo, yeah, I agree that we ourselves should be the final arbiters of what makes a good or a bad movie, and should be careful about jumping to any conclusions based on influencers or whomever calling films out based solely or mostly on their supposed politics or agendas. I'm not saying none of that stuff exists, that there are not any agendas, but again, we need to decide more often for ourselves whether a movie is ultimately good or bad. Take some chances, occasionally go see a movie that ordinarily might not be your first choice but that you suspect you COULD like, and sometimes you will be rewarded. Hell, maybe I'll take a chance on Joker 2. (Well, okay, probably not that one. ;)
I agree with you. I go to the theater at least once a week and I’ve seen some amazing films this year. Most of the movies that really landed for me didn’t exactly light up the box office and I saw a few of those films because I saw your review and it piqued my interest. I sincerely hope you will keep doing what you do because your opinion is always welcome and appreciated.
Keep up the great work Heath. Thank you for talking about film/art for art's sake. I always love your videos where you just talk about movies. Even when I disagree with your thoughts on a film, I appreciate your honesty despite the naysayers. Also, I really enjoyed your article on the bubble gum pop cd set. I'd love to see more music/film history videos and spotlights on specific topics.
Movie fandom might be a reflection of larger movements in US society that thrive on outrage. People have been trained to choose a stance, be inflexible, intolerant and outraged about almost everything. 😂
The negativity toward movies comes down to people not seeing the big picture as to not knowing what it takes to make a movie. Not understanding the ideas that comes from top to the bottom in the scale of making movies. Cause everyone involve want to make the best of what they are handed by the studios producers directors and writers. As a movie collector i also have heard complains. With me mostly why you keep spending money on movies when you have so many and with having no family what are you gonna do in the future as you get older. My answer is when i come to that road i will try to solve it. Some of the people i know are really movie haters of so many genres. Well to each its own. My way of thinking is i dont let it get to me. Heath keep doing what you do cause its out of passion and love for movies. Dont let it get to you. You have a great web page and your knowledge is bar to none. Getting close to 38k.
I enjoy your videos. I can see your passion for movies coming through, and I like hearing it all. Like talking about the movies or just showing off some of the new releases because it does help me learn about movies I've never heard of and would like to check out. I like when you get into the older movies or tv shows and talk about film noir. I agree this has been a good year for movies. I loved The Bike riders. You're review for Kneecap got me excited, and I made sure I saw it in theaters, and loved it. I was disappointed with Joker 2. Even though the reviews weren't good, I went in thinking positive. I didn't think it was bad, just maybe a little too long maybe like 10 minutes could have been trimmed off somewhere. Though I will watch it again in the future and re-evaluate it. I do agree that there is a lot of negativity in the movie community. Like how a movie gets picked on because it's the new thing to make fun.
First, love the channel. Second, I totally understand where you are coming from. It's so frustrating to have a passion about something, only for people to crap all over it. I love talking films and music, but find it increasingly harder to have a meaningful conversation with others about them
Your channel is fantastic, and I appreciate your hard work on it. Don't give up hope. There are a lot of people that want honest, non-clickbait videos about cinema. I tend not to comment on social media sites and the like because of the negativity, and honestly, I have thin skin. After watching this, I will be more proactive about commenting and giving kudos to those that deserve is, like you!
Thanks for that! Really, the whole scene has become a lot of obnoxious yelling and people treating movies like baseball cards, i.e. slipcovers, art wraps and so on. I just want to talk about my love for stories. I'm not that interested in discussing transfers, upgrades, and formats. We've lost the forest for the trees, and now I'm actively seeking new and better ways to be a geek without the drama.
@ I totally agree. Talking movies should not be about shouting matches and insults. It’s art and it’s subjective and I appreciate various opinions but it should never be combative.
I agree; there are so many films this year I have enjoyed. So many great films. And I have noticed, not only are people not showing up - people are raging. People just have an addiction to being negative and critical today. And they rather watch talking heads moan and complain versus enjoying actual media art. In grateful for you and what you do. Keep sharing and keep preaching. Movies forever.
Heath I just feel you've outgrown this medium. Maybe time to move on while you still associate it with good times and good memories? And I speak as someone who's followed you for years.
I love your channel, because like most RUclipsrs I subscribe to, your content and delivery is unique. I rarely comment on videos, but perhaps I should if you think the negativity outweighs the positives. Don’t give up, f**k the haters, you’re awesome!
I agree with a lot of what you said. I love movies by that I mean the entire movie making process. Continue posting the videos you want. The fandom will balance itself out.
Keep up the good work Heath! I now consider myself a movie watcher over a movie collector (2000+ physical media) I love watching movies and talking about what I have seen, I enjoy going to my local theatre again (seats have been upgraded to full reclining) and my kids are at the age they are enjoying some of the same movies as me. Sure there are some bad movies out there but you can’t crap on a movie until you’ve watched it. It’s tough to find “Your tribe” I have no problem finding people to he see Deadpool but to go see Jigra (a Hindi action movie) no one will go with me….could turn out to be the best action flick that none of my friends will ever see… Oh less starfield background, was getting motion sickness
There is real dignity & worth in being a “voice in the wilderness “ I suppose I’m an unlikely sub because of my preference for tentpole/commercial film-but I enjoy learning about cinema from your interesting perspective….so keep going for moviegoers like me that benefit from your channel
I'd hate to see you go. I really only discovered ypur channel within the recent couple years of having health issues. I love your enthusiasm. I get what you're saying. It's like a teacher with students at the back that are a few grades behind and not bc of legitimate learning disabilities. They just want to spitball and make noise. How to solve it is the question. The thing is there are followers who are enjoying the learning and the excitement. If you put up a pay wall of some kind then you may lose too many followers. If you just block everyone who's negative there may be a small risk to living in an echo chamber. Please give lots of thought before walking away. Perhaps , having a partner /sidekick may show more strength to the naysayers and they'll walk away. Hope this helps at least get the ideas flowing. Sending my best!
I thought Horizon: American Saga Chapter 1 was fantastic. I’m glad I didn’t listen to the negative feedback on that one, feedback that was probably mostly from people that didn’t see it. It does seem like so many people today form opinions on what others say (whether it’s News/Politics or Influencers as you say) over making up one’s own mind. It truly is a baffling time we find ourselves in. I’ll keep watching movies in hopes of finding something I truly love, even if I don’t like something, I can move on to the next movie w/ that same hope and from time to time I’ll be pleasantly surprised and want to talk about how great it was. That sure beats wasting time talking about something I didn’t like. I don’t know, maybe i’m wrong. But that’s the way I’ll continue to approach my cinematic journey. I guess i’m set in my ways at 53… 🤷🏻♂️ Just keep talking about those movies/genres you love and sharing some new things you discover. 👍🏻
Hi Heath, I have noticed your frustration recently with all the negativity, but please don’t give up. I’m one of those people who watch all of those long form videos where you feature all of the film releases for one month from a particular distributor. But I admittedly don’t post a comment to every video. That doesn’t mean I didn’t like the video. I appreciate that you, like myself, thoroughly enjoy the oldies. I came of age as a real movie fan in the mid-80s when some of our greatest actors and actresses were struggling to keep making movies and the films they were making inspired me to look for-and later purchase-Bette Davis, Barbara Stanwyck, Joan Crawford, Henry Fonda, the late, great Kate Hepburn and James Stewart’s films of the 30s through till their last films. In fact, some of my all-time favourites are movies such as, ‘All About Eve,’ ‘Double Indemnity,’ most of the Tracy-Hepburn films, ‘Philadelphia Story,’ ‘Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?’ ‘Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf’ (with one of my favourite actresses, who left us much too soon-Sandy Dennis), ‘Autumn Leaves,’ and ‘Rebel Without a Cause.’ I am still a sucker for a weeper or a serious, thought provoking movie. And I still get excited every time you announce the release of a new title in those categories! I know it’s easier said than done, but try and ignore the negative thoughts expressed by the keyboard warriors living in mommy and daddy’s basement and instead focus on the positive and neutral commenters. The rest is just noise!
I enjoy your channel brother 👍 been watching for years all the way from the uk 🇬🇧. Don’t worry about numbers so much even if you have a 100 views but they enjoy it it’s all good
Do what you feel is right. I don't always agree with you but I trust the honesty of your opinion. And the "pitchfork crowd" on the internet needs to be ignored anyway. Opinions are like.. well.. you know what.
Hey man sorry to hear that you’ve been getting a lot of rage cause you sound like you got a level headed takes and wonderful appreciation for films!🤘🏼🔥 will try to keep up with your reviews!
Few disorganized thoughts for you. 1) I've always enjoyed your content, but it's more important that you enjoy your content, 2) Watch some old episodes of Cereal at Midnight (the one's you're most proud of or brought you the most joy) and maybe that can be a template. 3) Normies don't get cinephiles. Never have. Never will. You're doing specialized content for a self-selected audience. Some will and should fall by the wayside. 4) The internet is full of idiots and trolls. The bigger you get. The more likely you are to encounter them. If you want to keep doing this, you can't let them ruin your day. You can make fun of them.
I come to this channel not for what makes other channels cool or beneficial. You have a cool vibe and niche that best when your doing what you want to be doing, like informative interviews, talking about movies you love, cool new films, and revealing which new blurays, theatrical, or streamers were cool discoveries for for you. I say stay in that realm, and don't worry about showing everything that has come out. Talk about what you like the most or most intrigue you and that it. 2024 has been the best year since Covid for sure.
Dude. I love your videos. You are a tentpole, when it comes to pop-culture. Great taste in movies and great taste in music. Your videos are top tier and help a lot of people to discover music, movies and art. I understand it may be tough sometimes as the hateful comments stand out and obviously hurt. All I can say, there must be a lot of people who would be absolutely shattered if you left. There are currently only two channels that make sense - Cereal at midnight and the 4k Kings. If RUclips is making your passion fade, quit it! It would be a huge loss for all us. Anyway thanks for all!
Sorry to see you down on your passions. I don't have any answers, but I really hope you find a way to do what's best for you. Peace man! 10/10 fricheks
Just to echo some of the below i watch a lot of your content Heath and have for a while, but very rarely get involved in either reading the comments or adding to them. It really surprises and dismays me hearing the abuse you receive. Maybe its more of a US thing (im in the UK) or maybe i just avoid all that stuff but man, it really should be about the films and respected each others opinions (based on actually watching the content as you say). I really hope you dont give up on RUclips. If it was me i would just not respond to the negativity, just don't engage with it. At the end of the day those folks are just lacking in emotional intelligence and respect for each other, something you clearly try to promote everywhere you go!
Everybody I know at my job brags that they pirate every movie and show they watch. I feel like I'm the only person in the world that still buys discs or goes to the theater sometimes. You do you man. Talk about whatever you want on your channel and if people don't like it then they can go frack themselves.
Man, I’m bummed that the negativity is affecting you that way… I can totally see why, and I don’t even deal with a fraction of what you’re probably seeing/hearing etc. But that’s unfortunate that we can’t come together on the positives more than the negatives more often. Seems that way with so many things anymore. I do appreciate your voice, thoughts and perspective on this stuff (movies) though. Even when I disagree, I still appreciate your knowledge on the subject. I hope that you do continue and that you’re able to find your tribe Heath. Thanks for what you do.
Ignore the dummies. Most people who watch your channel want to hear your takes and are truly interested in film. I love the niche you have made with this channel and I enjoy hearing what you have to say about film.
I know exactly who you're talking about the so called youtube critics. Ignore them, they're awful. They're culturally bereft. You have to keep going because we need your input talking about the films of all ages.
I will reiterate what so many others are saying here--long time fan and subscriber who highly values your opinions and insight but has never commented because i just don't tend to do that (i'm old)--honestly i do watch your review and off the cuff vids more now because like yourself i find myself caring less and less about the deluge of discs (mostly mediocre) that are being shoved down our throats--i feel fortunate to own the films that mean the most to me and my ears do perk up now and again--anyways this a long winded way of saying please keep up the great work even if that means moving away from this channel--just please let me know where to find your current works if you do--cheers!
Here's the thing -- why should you change anything? Why react to the negative minority? There will always be complainers and malcontents who dislike stuff. But there are also a larger portion of your audience who are typically more silent (such as me) because I don't really have any visceral reaction to what you've presented. I enjoy the videos where you show off new releases, but I don't go out and buy every one. Sometimes you pique my interest in something and I buy it. Sometimes I'm happy because you've clued me in to a release of a movie that I want and wasn't aware that it was being released. I enjoy the interviews you do as well. I commented on the recent video about The Fly movies you did with Anastasia Elfman because, ironically, I was actually in the midst of going through those movies myself (I'd only ever seen 2 of the 5) so hearing comments while I was in the middle of the set was really interesting. I've enjoyed every video you've done with Max Alan Collins (one of them prompted me to go and stream the Quarry television series based on his novel series wihch was quite entertaining). Similarly, I've enjoyed every video you've done with Brian Krey because it's interesting to hear about the approach that Alpha Video takes, but more so, about some of his interests outside of those movies (such as his comic fandom). I enjoy the movie reviews you do. I don't always agree with them -- there are movies you've liked that either I was lukewarm to or outright didn't like. But I respect your insights and enjoy hearing your takes on the films even if I had a different reaction. I also think it's interesting to hear your thoughts, particularly when you delve a bit behind the scenes (such as the recent Joker review). In summary, I like the channel. I like the content you provide. I don't think you should do more of any one thing or less of any one thing. I think you should continue on the path you've taken. Perhaps the only change I would suggest, which is a difficult one, is to ignore the negativity (or at least don't let it drag you down). The vocal minority shouldn't have more sway on the channel than the silent majority who enjoy the content.
Unscripted are some of my favorite videos you do. I guess it is just like a movie star that gets to a certain level. They stop signing autographs and interacting with fans and have to have security and whatnot. It then becomes this lonely way of life in service of the art. I hear you brother. Whatever you end up doing, I'll be there. I really think maybe ending interaction with the trolls is the way to go. I follow a pretty big tik-tok guy (political guy) and when he goes through his comments, he deletes and blocks ever single troll. That is what I did on my FB account and have never looked back.
Haven’t commented before but just wanna send some support. I’m sorry it’s been so bad with certain types of commenters. Plenty of people like you out here listening and watching. I personally appreciate your passion for film and I started watching your Blu-ray release rundowns as I work in that industry (designing covers) and as a cinephile I love the overview of the releases. At the end of the day do what’s best for your mental health, maybe taking a break if needed, but know there are plenty of like minded people out here. All the best dude!
Re: finding your people, just want to reiterate that it’s frustrating and upsetting that your videos get infiltrated with trolls like that. The cinephiles ARE here and ARE watching.
Thank you for stopping me in my tracks and making me realise that I have been getting caught up in a runaway train. I just got off it. I love your channel. I like your insights. I am not a hater. But I have been caught up in a lot of the movie hatred that has been spread by influencers this year without realising it. What right do I have to slam Joker 2 or Trap when I haven't seen them? You've opened my eyes to what is happening. Keep going, man. I need you!
It's disheartening that there's so much hate directed at your channel. I love your videos. Frankly, if people aren't happy with your channel they can tune out. I'd hate to see you go, but you gotta do what you gotta do. Maybe a long break or vacation is in order. Hope this helps. Keep up the excellent work.
Fantastic Video! Everything I currently feel in articulated words..The ultimate Mic drop was the vinegar syndrome phenomenon..I just don’t get that one they have a handful of films I love but it just doesn’t speak to me.
Don’t let this guy fool you. He’s tripping on people. I left a peaceful comment and he called me a troll and threatened to ban me from commenting on his channel. Had to unsubscribe.
I wouldn’t say it’s one of the greatest years - but I would say that there’s something for everyone. You have massive flops like Joker 2 and then you have massive indie horror hits like Longlegs and Terrifier 3. Then you have big budget auteur flops like Horizon and Megalopolis. My top 4 of the year so far are: Furiosa Longlegs Horizon Alien: Romulus I’m hoping Nosferatu rounds the top 5 before year’s end.
I have gotten so many recommendations for movies that are so interesting, some of which I have seen some of which I have not had a chance to see but I always look forward to your thoughts I am a kindred spirit when it comes to movies music and books keep on Truckin man
This video is SPOT ON. 💯 ✔️ Hell, 1000 % correct. No one seems to care, so why should we? (as creators). People /viewers take sh*t SOOOO seriously if you don't like their favourite movie/actor/fighter/band etc etc. It's like a personal attack to them. They react like you just slapped their mother. It's absolutely INSANE these days. In other news, could you consider doing a video on "why you should care about Kino Lorber" for those of us who have no idea who they really are or put out? Would be nice!!!
Hi, Heath! Please, don't stop talking about movies (both new releases and classics) and physical media in a positive, passionate way. I'm sure there are many of us who enjoy watching the content from a true lover of cinema. I'ts not easy to find such an space like yours. Have a nice rest of the week!
I like your hope,I used to go to the theater at least twice a month but this year Horizon and Megalopolis were the only titles that interested me and I enjoyed both.Thankfully I'm still finding old titles from places like Hamilton and Movies Unlimited.I truly hope selection gets better because it bothers me not to support my local theater Keep the faith,like hearing you talk about movies
I don't usually comment but I thought that the experience of Pete at Sea of Tranquillity youtube channel might be of some use to you. SOT is a music review channel for fans of rock music and has been going for many years but over the last few years he noticed negativity in the comments towards content, guests on his show and other members and he has seen fit on several occasions to call these negative people and their behaviour out in videos, and I presume for serial offenders banning people who continued their bad behaviour. I'm sure he still gets negativity but it does seem a whole lot healthier now than it has in years gone past as these people are no longer as vocal as they used to be. He also around 12 months ago decided to reduce the output on his channel as the workload was just becoming unmanageable for him, and it has benefitted him and his channels content for the change. It might be an idea to reach out to have a chat with Pete to talk through some of these issues and see how he copes with this very angry world we live in now. He also does a great show on horror films on a Thursday called The Monsters Den so maybe a coop show on horror films would be a good idea? Anyway keep up the great work, hope you are encouraged by the positive response to this video.
Heath, are you posting for the numbers or for the love? If only ten people like your video, is it worth it to have those connections even if it’s only ten people.
On your point about the review-bombing before a picture is even released, usually to the negative side: this is what almost kept me from enjoying the 2017 Joey King picture Wish Upon (because the reviews of it [mostly negative] were written so forcefully negative that it was like I felt like I was being told [I'm autistic] that I was not allowed to make up my own mind, and that I should not even try to enjoy it); I got it on a thumb-drive from my nephew, saw it, and truly enjoyed it (so much so that I have it on physical media now [DVD/Blu combo pack], and it's one of 6 pictures of hers that I have and have truly enjoyed [my physical media of her projects also including Universal Home Entertainment's Blu of her 2019 Hulu limited series The Act]).
I say ignore the hate. Easier said, "Then done," but I watch your channel for your knowledge, your experience, and your opinion that's different from mine so I can learn something. So keep the good work. Movies are the highest form of art to me, and art is subjective.
Talk about what makes you happy. I don't watch cereal at midnight just to see discs I watch this channel because of you're passion for westerns, noir and whaterever genres you are into. I don't think the new releases videos are sustainable and you have said it yourself. What I would like is that you would make highlight videos of releases that you like.
My criticism on Joker 2 is making it into a musical. I think it was a bad idea to make it a musical. The movie flopped because of it. We don't know if people actually watch a particular movie. Don't let the trolls get you down. Do whatever you want on your channel. Let's celebrate the art of movies.
I agree with you on how good the movies for this year was. I’ve seen about 30-40 movies this year and I’ve only seen about a half dozen that I’d say was bad or meh. All the rest was good to great for me. I’ve seen movies that I think are pretty good or great and seen people say it’s absolutely crap. Course I’ve also seen vice versa.
Yeah, this is actually the reason why we need people like you on here more than ever before! To at least try and balance out all the surface-level "critics"/fanboys out there
Haters will come and go. Your tribe will stick with you. Just keep following your passion. Maybe it would help to turn off the comments for a while just to get a breather? I know that’s counter productive when it comes to having a conversation about movies but hey.. it’s an option. Been following you for years now, and I never really read or leave comments, but it sucks to watch you struggling with this problem. The danger of welcoming a conversation in the comments is people tend to confuse the term “debate” with “argument”. I recently listened to your podcast episode of The Fly, loved it.
Heath, me and I’m sure many other people, love what you do but because we don’t make comments doesn’t mean that we don’t appreciate your amazing and passionate work. Keep up the good work, you are on the right track.
Heath,
I have seen you struggling these past few videos and I just want to let you know that there are plenty of us out here that appreciate your videos and particularly your passion. I don't always comment and I struggle to articulate how much this channel means to me but ill try.
Watching movies is my main hobby and up until a few years ago I was just watching the mainstream stuff. Your passion for film has opened me up to SO MANY different genres and eras of film. Movies I would have never heard about. I'd never watched a noir film prior to finding you channel. I had written off black & white films like so many other young people thinking there was nothing to gain from watching "old movies". Now I can't get enough.
My journey right now has lead me to Vincent Price and all the classic horror movies he stared in (these are great!). Another actor that wasn't on my radar and again I thank you for your Icons of Horror video.
I've been watching all your new release videos and to be honest I watch those 30 minute videos just to hear the 2 minutes where you actually talk about the movies themselves. I wish there was more push to here you talk movies but apparently people just want to see what's coming out that week....kind of a bummer. I don't blame you for doing that.
Regarding more recent movies, you put me onto Horizon Part 1 and The Bikeriders and both of those are amazing. Horizon feels so epic and brutal and real. If I had listened to the other morons on RUclips I would have never experienced that film. That example right there has really showed me that movie reviews, for me, are useless. If Horizon isn't regarded as great by the people than I don't trust the people anymore.
Agreed!
Agreed.. heath keep up the movie love and share it with us.
Agree! Heath, keep up the good fight. If nothing else, close the comments down on the videos and seek out conversations on your website, Patreon and other fan-supported platforms.
Agree!
Totally agree 100%. I loved Horizon Part 1 and Bike riders. I also really enjoy listening to your commentaries, that is also opening my eyes to movies I never knew existed before. Keep up the AWESOME work Heath.
Heath, this channel means so much to me. You have taught me so much about movies and made me a much better appreciator of fandom. Please keep it going. I appreciate you so much.
I feel the same but if it makes him hate his passion... Dude's got to do what he's got to do. Huge loss for all of us, though.
I haven't gone anywhere, but there are changes coming. This video is a plea for my fellow movie fans to stop letting anger and hate lead the conversation.
Honestly man, you are doing some of the best work on RUclips on this topic. I love watching all of your videos and listening to your podcasts, I think you should keep doing you. It’s wonderful
Came to your channel years back now, drawn in by the pop culture in analogue tag and got to say watching you go movie hunting was the joy backed up by substance of the reviews and descriptions. Getting movies sent to you must have seemed like the dream however you have definitely become noticeably more dour (good scottish word) and jaded over the years. Got to find your happiness again, my tuppence worth is to limit the "look at these movies I got sent" videos, pick the ones you want to highlight and share as they mean something to you and you will find those who do appreciate you and your insights shall be there for you. Keep up the good work, you deserve success for the work you put in so dont let those haters get you down Its too easy to be the troll, the talent is with the creator and there are plenty of us who appreciate you and what you do.
Heath, I love your channel. But after listening to your commentaries, I can tell that film history is your passion. Your commentaries on discs and written word, have made films I've always enjoyed, become more special. That's a rare talent and I appreciate it. In a nutshell follow your heart life is short. You have more to offer than RUclips Videos.
This is the internet. No matter what you do there will be angry people. You do great interviews. Keep up the great work. Keep loving movies.
I love your channel Heath. Keep up the good work. For me, I have the opposite problem where I love most movies but don't have the means or time to watch them all. There are very few movies I've seen that were outright bad. Almost every movie has some redeeming quality.
No anger here man. I still think you are one of the most fun, insightful and talented guys on youtube.
We’re part of your tribe!!! 2024 has been a great year for film, we couldn’t agree more.
Sending you a high five for that Vinegar Syndrome comment!
Yes you are part of my tribe!
I will always support boutique Labels but Vinegar Syndrome offering I have seen them offer have been of 0% interest to me personally.
i love your videos, sorry people suck. some people always have to ruin or put there hate at everything, especially online. really hope you and the channel don't go anywhere soon. been watching for at least 5 years now, probably longer.
Heath,
I always appreciate the honesty and how up front you are with your audience. As far as my opinion, I watch your videos about discs to hear about film. When you have all those new releases, I can't wait to hear what you have to say. Packaging is cool, but I watch those videos to find new films that I might not have heard about. I'm all about expanding my horizons in film. A great example, I don't know if I saw it in your video or someone else's. But I believe it was yours. A Bittersweet Life from Umbrella, I bought and watched that film. I was really surprised and blown away by it. I would've probably never known about it without the coverage I saw. So thank you and keep up the great work. You're a special one.
I hope you continue to make the content that you do because I just came across your stuff and subscribed.
The problem with the internet, and society as a whole right now, is instead of people just moving past things they don't like and focus on what they like themselves... they instead feel the need to waste their time in their angry little bubble they have made for themselves purposely watching/reading things they don't like just to blast the individual who made it. There are way too many self righteous people nowadays who like to hide behind keyboards.
At the end of the day (and it is tough to do) it really does come down to making content on things you enjoy and are passionate about and stay true to that, knowing you are never going to please every person that comes across your content. If you make a video and you're happy with it and what you shared then focus on that rather than focusing on negative jerks. No one is making them watch. No one is making them comment. Their toxicity is on them, not you.
I couldn’t do what you do. I was on Facebook once for like a month 12 or more years ago and couldn’t stand social media then and nuked the account. Even as a YT viewer, I can’t read most of the comments. I’m still glad to hear what you actually like even if I have trouble getting to the movies these day (I think I’ve done 2 this year).
Heath, I love your channel and the insight you bring. You've turned me on to movies I would have never known about. Keep doing what you're doing. Love the intellect and humor you bring. Ready to eat more Cereal At Midnight
Oi oi oi!!! I guess anger is easier to be spotted than thankfulness! Because angry people are louder… I absolutely love the work you do. I watch your videos almost everyday on my way to work. I’ve learned a lot about movies with you and picked up on so many movie recommendations you make. I appreciate what you do, it’s smart, funny and very informative. I hope you keep going! Thank you.
Heath, I just love that your approach to talking to us. Thank you for telling it like it is. I'm 29 and tired of people telling me what to watch, I have fun at the theatre. Megalopolis is a weird movie, but it was enjoyable at times. I always want to hear your opinion.
I really like what you do man, and I like hearing your perspective even when/if I disagree with ya. I hope you keep making stuff, whatever form it takes!!
Who needs it. WE NEED IT… the real fans who actually watch movies, classics and new movies alike. Your tribe is out here, Heath. We’re just surrounded by those who don’t get us.
You're right, my tribe is here, but it's being drowned out by angry people who don't love movies.
@@CerealAtMidnight I know you know how to separate the wheat from the chaff (I’ve been in the Midwest too long). It’s getting harder but the quality within is still there.
I'll admit I love the IP however I love finding those movies that offer more. I generally ignore the critics but due to your track record I take your opinions on a movie into account to my movie choices. Missed the bikeriders at the cinemas but picked up the disc based on your review, loved it (as did my daughter who was in the room and got hooked). Horizon is another example this year, saw it at the cinema.
Local cinema has akira kurasawa series atm. Last night saw red beard. Omg what a masterpiece, the cinematography, the challenging story and the performances. 3 hr movie, would have happily sat there for another hr. 3 films so far and my tickets at purchased until the end. Every Tuesday night through to the 1st week of December.
I do see your problem however with the channel as it's one of the ways you support your family and it forces you to get clicks. When to do so all you do is pick up discs and go here it is and then get blasted when you have an opinion or want to get off the beaten path then I understand why you're questioning the channels future.
You do have a happy appreciative audience, we're just silent most of the time, we also have lives and limited time. Social media only brings out the outrage in comments as it powers the need to spend our time to type a response.
Anyway, love your work. You keep doing it and I'll keep clicking in.
Heath, you're a true talent and your voice is needed on RUclips. As a longtime fan of the channel, I would say don't change a thing, your approach is genuine and unique. You bring a sincere and rare sense of joy to cinema fandom and I appreciate every video you drop. Though I dig all that you offer, your interviews are a personal favorite and an area where you really excel. Your recent conversation with Charlotte Barker being a particular standout. Comments across the internet are largely a cesspool populated by miserable and talentless clowns that seem to be obsessed with consuming product they'll never actually watch. There is really no reason to engage with the slip cover deep throaters, just keep hammering and doing what you do best. I've turned many on to you over the years and most of my close friends continue to subscribe and watch regularly going years without posting a single comment. The silent majority are behind you. Stay up, brother. You're appreciated by those that actually love film.
I am glad you made this video. Many of us feel the same way you do, pal! I hope you keep it up because I really enjoy your videos and your interviews. I wouldn't have seen (or purchased) The Tin Star or Last Train from Gun Hill if it weren't for you and those are two of my favorite movies now!
I’m 48. I only watch your channel on RUclips for movies. Please don’t change because of bad apples.
I know how you feel finding things off the beaten path is what makes collecting and enjoying movies, music and books so much worthwhile really enjoy what you do man keep it up
Even if I don't comment on every video, I appreciate your honest opinions and deep dives into films and not just the physical releases. I do love your Kino Lorber spotlight videos because they are my go to boutique label due to the classic line and modest pricing. I'll be honest and say I hardly ever make it to the theater anymore. By the time I take the family out it would cost seventy bucks for a matinee of a movie most of us will be lukewarm about. I love older films much more than modern cinema, and I'm ok with that. I'm not going to come up here and pee in your cocoa krispies because you liked a movie that flopped. Some of the best films of all time were box office failures. The loudest voices are always going to be the most ignorant, unfortunately. I hope you can see the path through the weeds and keep doing the good work. We appreciate your open, unfiltered, unbought, and heartfelt opinions and look forward to seeing more from you well into the future.
I absolutely love you and support everything that you do. I love your passion for movies and the stories they tell, love hearing you talk about movies and learning not only about the movies but behind the scenes content and history as well! I love your channel and your amazing web site and you will always have my support in everything that you do! Do whatever makes YOU happy because in the end there all that matters my friend. You are a true treasure in this world and I am thankful for everything that you do, always! 🙏🏻
Love the channel and thanks for your time making all the videos!! Really need your voice out here for people that love talking and listening about movies! Have a great day.
Also! It was because of your video review on Abbott and Costello’s Africa Screams that led me to follow and back the following Kickstarter campaigns for Jack and the Beanstalk and The Abbott and Costello Show. And now I have an official film cell from their TV show as a bonus add on from it. So thank you, Heath!
I love you when you talk about the film to make my mind to go and see the films and other stuff.
i can't stand it when some criticises me for a film i like, if they don't like it thats fine and their choice, one of my favourite films is geostorm it flopped badly but i think it was a great watch
You’re probably the closest to me in terms of our experiences with movies because of how close our ages are, and it really warms my heart to know someone like me is out there talking about movies the way I would have if I have even a sliver of your gift for the gab. I think the trade-off for having a huge social media following nowadays is having to deal with the negativity. In fact, I see it as a badge of honour that people even bother to use their precious time to come spew crap into the comment sections of your videos. But you also have to understand that they do not represent reality, or your true fan followings. I think some of your followers have already mentioned here about how they do not necessarily engage or leave comments even though they absolutely loved and looked forward to every video you put out. Have faith that the silent majority are enjoying and benefitting from the content, and that the toxic commentators are just part and parcel of the insane internet space that we have today. I mean, they may complain and b*tch a lot, and yet, they’re still here.
Hey Heath first time commenting and long time subscriber and liker. I am a HUGE movie lover and cinefile and love your videos and your take on movies. I spend every weekend watching your videos and would be so sad to see you leave but understand where you're coming from with all the negativity. Unfortunately if not engaging with the comments for you to stay on and talking about your love on movies that would be fine. Stay positive brother and long live film.
I agree you should just post and ignore the comments. I expect that it's something you have to do as you grow on the internet, even if you're working in a field that you think would be mostly joyful. It's the reason why superstars have assistants to manage their social media and open their mail. There are angry, confised and scary people out there.
Seems like that's the way forward. It's sad, though, because finding and building community was one of the goals for me.
Hey man, I found your channel a couple of years ago and it is honestly become one of my favorites
I haven't seen Joker 2, so I'm not going to offer an opinion on whether it's good or bad, but I confess I have no desire to see it, and I will say that it seems questionable business sense for a movie that targets comic book fans to also be a quasi-musical. I just don't see those two different kinds of audiences intermingling much - if there even still is much of an audience for musicals at the movies. But anyhoo, yeah, I agree that we ourselves should be the final arbiters of what makes a good or a bad movie, and should be careful about jumping to any conclusions based on influencers or whomever calling films out based solely or mostly on their supposed politics or agendas. I'm not saying none of that stuff exists, that there are not any agendas, but again, we need to decide more often for ourselves whether a movie is ultimately good or bad. Take some chances, occasionally go see a movie that ordinarily might not be your first choice but that you suspect you COULD like, and sometimes you will be rewarded. Hell, maybe I'll take a chance on Joker 2. (Well, okay, probably not that one. ;)
I agree with you. I go to the theater at least once a week and I’ve seen some amazing films this year. Most of the movies that really landed for me didn’t exactly light up the box office and I saw a few of those films because I saw your review and it piqued my interest. I sincerely hope you will keep doing what you do because your opinion is always welcome and appreciated.
Keep up the great work Heath. Thank you for talking about film/art for art's sake. I always love your videos where you just talk about movies. Even when I disagree with your thoughts on a film, I appreciate your honesty despite the naysayers. Also, I really enjoyed your article on the bubble gum pop cd set. I'd love to see more music/film history videos and spotlights on specific topics.
Don't give up. I enjoy every review and love movies. Watched your channel for a long time. The best out there.
Movie fandom might be a reflection of larger movements in US society that thrive on outrage. People have been trained to choose a stance, be inflexible, intolerant and outraged about almost everything. 😂
@@playedout148 It is not just US society, look around the world.
This post outrages me!
The negativity toward movies comes down to people not seeing the big picture as to not knowing what it takes to make a movie. Not understanding the ideas that comes from top to the bottom in the scale of making movies. Cause everyone involve want to make the best of what they are handed by the studios producers directors and writers. As a movie collector i also have heard complains. With me mostly why you keep spending money on movies when you have so many and with having no family what are you gonna do in the future as you get older. My answer is when i come to that road i will try to solve it. Some of the people i know are really movie haters of so many genres. Well to each its own. My way of thinking is i dont let it get to me. Heath keep doing what you do cause its out of passion and love for movies. Dont let it get to you. You have a great web page and your knowledge is bar to none. Getting close to 38k.
I enjoy your videos. I can see your passion for movies coming through, and I like hearing it all. Like talking about the movies or just showing off some of the new releases because it does help me learn about movies I've never heard of and would like to check out. I like when you get into the older movies or tv shows and talk about film noir. I agree this has been a good year for movies. I loved The Bike riders. You're review for Kneecap got me excited, and I made sure I saw it in theaters, and loved it. I was disappointed with Joker 2. Even though the reviews weren't good, I went in thinking positive. I didn't think it was bad, just maybe a little too long maybe like 10 minutes could have been trimmed off somewhere. Though I will watch it again in the future and re-evaluate it. I do agree that there is a lot of negativity in the movie community. Like how a movie gets picked on because it's the new thing to make fun.
First, love the channel. Second, I totally understand where you are coming from. It's so frustrating to have a passion about something, only for people to crap all over it. I love talking films and music, but find it increasingly harder to have a meaningful conversation with others about them
Your channel is fantastic, and I appreciate your hard work on it. Don't give up hope. There are a lot of people that want honest, non-clickbait videos about cinema. I tend not to comment on social media sites and the like because of the negativity, and honestly, I have thin skin. After watching this, I will be more proactive about commenting and giving kudos to those that deserve is, like you!
Thanks for that! Really, the whole scene has become a lot of obnoxious yelling and people treating movies like baseball cards, i.e. slipcovers, art wraps and so on. I just want to talk about my love for stories. I'm not that interested in discussing transfers, upgrades, and formats. We've lost the forest for the trees, and now I'm actively seeking new and better ways to be a geek without the drama.
@ I totally agree. Talking movies should not be about shouting matches and insults. It’s art and it’s subjective and I appreciate various opinions but it should never be combative.
I agree; there are so many films this year I have enjoyed. So many great films. And I have noticed, not only are people not showing up - people are raging. People just have an addiction to being negative and critical today. And they rather watch talking heads moan and complain versus enjoying actual media art. In grateful for you and what you do. Keep sharing and keep preaching. Movies forever.
Heath I just feel you've outgrown this medium. Maybe time to move on while you still associate it with good times and good memories? And I speak as someone who's followed you for years.
I love your channel, because like most RUclipsrs I subscribe to, your content and delivery is unique. I rarely comment on videos, but perhaps I should if you think the negativity outweighs the positives. Don’t give up, f**k the haters, you’re awesome!
You’re doing a great job. Keep it up! I’ll talk about movies with you anytime.
I agree with a lot of what you said. I love movies by that I mean the entire movie making process. Continue posting the videos you want. The fandom will balance itself out.
Keep up the good work Heath! I now consider myself a movie watcher over a movie collector (2000+ physical media) I love watching movies and talking about what I have seen, I enjoy going to my local theatre again (seats have been upgraded to full reclining) and my kids are at the age they are enjoying some of the same movies as me. Sure there are some bad movies out there but you can’t crap on a movie until you’ve watched it. It’s tough to find “Your tribe” I have no problem finding people to he see Deadpool but to go see Jigra (a Hindi action movie) no one will go with me….could turn out to be the best action flick that none of my friends will ever see…
Oh less starfield background, was getting motion sickness
There is real dignity & worth in being a “voice in the wilderness “ I suppose I’m an unlikely sub because of my preference for tentpole/commercial film-but I enjoy learning about cinema from your interesting perspective….so keep going for moviegoers like me that benefit from your channel
I'd hate to see you go. I really only discovered ypur channel within the recent couple years of having health issues. I love your enthusiasm. I get what you're saying. It's like a teacher with students at the back that are a few grades behind and not bc of legitimate learning disabilities. They just want to spitball and make noise. How to solve it is the question. The thing is there are followers who are enjoying the learning and the excitement. If you put up a pay wall of some kind then you may lose too many followers. If you just block everyone who's negative there may be a small risk to living in an echo chamber. Please give lots of thought before walking away. Perhaps , having a partner /sidekick may show more strength to the naysayers and they'll walk away. Hope this helps at least get the ideas flowing. Sending my best!
Love all the videos, and appreciate your takes. Keep doing what you're doing!
The world is really dark right now. Sometimes, you have to be the light.
Do the thing, Heath!
I thought Horizon: American Saga Chapter 1 was fantastic. I’m glad I didn’t listen to the negative feedback on that one, feedback that was probably mostly from people that didn’t see it. It does seem like so many people today form opinions on what others say (whether it’s News/Politics or Influencers as you say) over making up one’s own mind. It truly is a baffling time we find ourselves in.
I’ll keep watching movies in hopes of finding something I truly love, even if I don’t like something, I can move on to the next movie w/ that same hope and from time to time I’ll be pleasantly surprised and want to talk about how great it was. That sure beats wasting time talking about something I didn’t like. I don’t know, maybe i’m wrong. But that’s the way I’ll continue to approach my cinematic journey. I guess i’m set in my ways at 53… 🤷🏻♂️
Just keep talking about those movies/genres you love and sharing some new things you discover. 👍🏻
Keep doing your thing man. If you enjoy watching movies, don't let people take that away from you. I've been watching you for awhile. Ignore the hate.
Hi Heath, I have noticed your frustration recently with all the negativity, but please don’t give up.
I’m one of those people who watch all of those long form videos where you feature all of the film releases for one month from a particular distributor. But I admittedly don’t post a comment to every video. That doesn’t mean I didn’t like the video.
I appreciate that you, like myself, thoroughly enjoy the oldies. I came of age as a real movie fan in the mid-80s when some of our greatest actors and actresses were struggling to keep making movies and the films they were making inspired me to look for-and later purchase-Bette Davis, Barbara Stanwyck, Joan Crawford, Henry Fonda, the late, great Kate Hepburn and James Stewart’s films of the 30s through till their last films. In fact, some of my all-time favourites are movies such as, ‘All About Eve,’ ‘Double Indemnity,’ most of the Tracy-Hepburn films, ‘Philadelphia Story,’ ‘Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?’ ‘Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf’ (with one of my favourite actresses, who left us much too soon-Sandy Dennis), ‘Autumn Leaves,’ and ‘Rebel Without a Cause.’
I am still a sucker for a weeper or a serious, thought provoking movie. And I still get excited every time you announce the release of a new title in those categories!
I know it’s easier said than done, but try and ignore the negative thoughts expressed by the keyboard warriors living in mommy and daddy’s basement and instead focus on the positive and neutral commenters. The rest is just noise!
I enjoy your channel brother 👍 been watching for years all the way from the uk 🇬🇧. Don’t worry about numbers so much even if you have a 100 views but they enjoy it it’s all good
I appreciate your channel. It reminds me what I love about cinema. Thank you.
Do what you feel is right. I don't always agree with you but I trust the honesty of your opinion. And the "pitchfork crowd" on the internet needs to be ignored anyway. Opinions are like.. well.. you know what.
Hey man sorry to hear that you’ve been getting a lot of rage cause you sound like you got a level headed takes and wonderful appreciation for films!🤘🏼🔥 will try to keep up with your reviews!
Few disorganized thoughts for you. 1) I've always enjoyed your content, but it's more important that you enjoy your content, 2) Watch some old episodes of Cereal at Midnight (the one's you're most proud of or brought you the most joy) and maybe that can be a template. 3) Normies don't get cinephiles. Never have. Never will. You're doing specialized content for a self-selected audience. Some will and should fall by the wayside. 4) The internet is full of idiots and trolls. The bigger you get. The more likely you are to encounter them. If you want to keep doing this, you can't let them ruin your day. You can make fun of them.
I come to this channel not for what makes other channels cool or beneficial. You have a cool vibe and niche that best when your doing what you want to be doing, like informative interviews, talking about movies you love, cool new films, and revealing which new blurays, theatrical, or streamers were cool discoveries for for you. I say stay in that realm, and don't worry about showing everything that has come out. Talk about what you like the most or most intrigue you and that it. 2024 has been the best year since Covid for sure.
Dude. I love your videos. You are a tentpole, when it comes to pop-culture. Great taste in movies and great taste in music. Your videos are top tier and help a lot of people to discover music, movies and art. I understand it may be tough sometimes as the hateful comments stand out and obviously hurt. All I can say, there must be a lot of people who would be absolutely shattered if you left. There are currently only two channels that make sense - Cereal at midnight and the 4k Kings. If RUclips is making your passion fade, quit it! It would be a huge loss for all us. Anyway thanks for all!
I enjoy your videos and your comments. This channel for real people that enjoy movies. Keep the good work.
I think you do a fantastic job, and appreciate your positivity and the cinema purist that you are !
Sorry to see you down on your passions. I don't have any answers, but I really hope you find a way to do what's best for you. Peace man! 10/10 fricheks
I liked Civil War, Furiosa & Dune 2. But I found retreads like Twisters, Alien & Planet of the Apes really dull. But I did watch them.
Stay strong dude. I really dig this channel😊
Just to echo some of the below i watch a lot of your content Heath and have for a while, but very rarely get involved in either reading the comments or adding to them. It really surprises and dismays me hearing the abuse you receive. Maybe its more of a US thing (im in the UK) or maybe i just avoid all that stuff but man, it really should be about the films and respected each others opinions (based on actually watching the content as you say). I really hope you dont give up on RUclips. If it was me i would just not respond to the negativity, just don't engage with it. At the end of the day those folks are just lacking in emotional intelligence and respect for each other, something you clearly try to promote everywhere you go!
Everybody I know at my job brags that they pirate every movie and show they watch. I feel like I'm the only person in the world that still buys discs or goes to the theater sometimes. You do you man. Talk about whatever you want on your channel and if people don't like it then they can go frack themselves.
Man, I’m bummed that the negativity is affecting you that way… I can totally see why, and I don’t even deal with a fraction of what you’re probably seeing/hearing etc. But that’s unfortunate that we can’t come together on the positives more than the negatives more often. Seems that way with so many things anymore. I do appreciate your voice, thoughts and perspective on this stuff (movies) though. Even when I disagree, I still appreciate your knowledge on the subject. I hope that you do continue and that you’re able to find your tribe Heath. Thanks for what you do.
Ignore the dummies. Most people who watch your channel want to hear your takes and are truly interested in film. I love the niche you have made with this channel and I enjoy hearing what you have to say about film.
I know exactly who you're talking about the so called youtube critics. Ignore them, they're awful. They're culturally bereft. You have to keep going because we need your input talking about the films of all ages.
I will reiterate what so many others are saying here--long time fan and subscriber who highly values your opinions and insight but has never commented because i just don't tend to do that (i'm old)--honestly i do watch your review and off the cuff vids more now because like yourself i find myself caring less and less about the deluge of discs (mostly mediocre) that are being shoved down our throats--i feel fortunate to own the films that mean the most to me and my ears do perk up now and again--anyways this a long winded way of saying please keep up the great work even if that means moving away from this channel--just please let me know where to find your current works if you do--cheers!
Here's the thing -- why should you change anything? Why react to the negative minority? There will always be complainers and malcontents who dislike stuff. But there are also a larger portion of your audience who are typically more silent (such as me) because I don't really have any visceral reaction to what you've presented.
I enjoy the videos where you show off new releases, but I don't go out and buy every one. Sometimes you pique my interest in something and I buy it. Sometimes I'm happy because you've clued me in to a release of a movie that I want and wasn't aware that it was being released.
I enjoy the interviews you do as well. I commented on the recent video about The Fly movies you did with Anastasia Elfman because, ironically, I was actually in the midst of going through those movies myself (I'd only ever seen 2 of the 5) so hearing comments while I was in the middle of the set was really interesting. I've enjoyed every video you've done with Max Alan Collins (one of them prompted me to go and stream the Quarry television series based on his novel series wihch was quite entertaining). Similarly, I've enjoyed every video you've done with Brian Krey because it's interesting to hear about the approach that Alpha Video takes, but more so, about some of his interests outside of those movies (such as his comic fandom).
I enjoy the movie reviews you do. I don't always agree with them -- there are movies you've liked that either I was lukewarm to or outright didn't like. But I respect your insights and enjoy hearing your takes on the films even if I had a different reaction. I also think it's interesting to hear your thoughts, particularly when you delve a bit behind the scenes (such as the recent Joker review).
In summary, I like the channel. I like the content you provide. I don't think you should do more of any one thing or less of any one thing. I think you should continue on the path you've taken. Perhaps the only change I would suggest, which is a difficult one, is to ignore the negativity (or at least don't let it drag you down). The vocal minority shouldn't have more sway on the channel than the silent majority who enjoy the content.
Unscripted are some of my favorite videos you do. I guess it is just like a movie star that gets to a certain level. They stop signing autographs and interacting with fans and have to have security and whatnot. It then becomes this lonely way of life in service of the art. I hear you brother. Whatever you end up doing, I'll be there. I really think maybe ending interaction with the trolls is the way to go. I follow a pretty big tik-tok guy (political guy) and when he goes through his comments, he deletes and blocks ever single troll. That is what I did on my FB account and have never looked back.
Haven’t commented before but just wanna send some support. I’m sorry it’s been so bad with certain types of commenters. Plenty of people like you out here listening and watching. I personally appreciate your passion for film and I started watching your Blu-ray release rundowns as I work in that industry (designing covers) and as a cinephile I love the overview of the releases. At the end of the day do what’s best for your mental health, maybe taking a break if needed, but know there are plenty of like minded people out here. All the best dude!
Re: finding your people, just want to reiterate that it’s frustrating and upsetting that your videos get infiltrated with trolls like that. The cinephiles ARE here and ARE watching.
I'm feeling you, man - youtube and other social media promotes extremism and negativity.
I personally feel there is as much positivity as negativity but you don’t hear it because, as you said, the negativity gets more clicks and attention
Thank you for stopping me in my tracks and making me realise that I have been getting caught up in a runaway train. I just got off it. I love your channel. I like your insights. I am not a hater. But I have been caught up in a lot of the movie hatred that has been spread by influencers this year without realising it. What right do I have to slam Joker 2 or Trap when I haven't seen them? You've opened my eyes to what is happening. Keep going, man. I need you!
Self-reflection will heal many of our personal problems that we project onto others.
It's disheartening that there's so much hate directed at your channel. I love your videos. Frankly, if people aren't happy with your channel they can tune out. I'd hate to see you go, but you gotta do what you gotta do. Maybe a long break or vacation is in order. Hope this helps. Keep up the excellent work.
Fantastic Video! Everything I currently feel in articulated words..The ultimate Mic drop was the vinegar syndrome phenomenon..I just don’t get that one they have a handful of films I love but it just doesn’t speak to me.
Don’t let this guy fool you. He’s tripping on people. I left a peaceful comment and he called me a troll and threatened to ban me from commenting on his channel. Had to unsubscribe.
I wouldn’t say it’s one of the greatest years - but I would say that there’s something for everyone. You have massive flops like Joker 2 and then you have massive indie horror hits like Longlegs and Terrifier 3. Then you have big budget auteur flops like Horizon and Megalopolis. My top 4 of the year so far are:
Furiosa
Longlegs
Horizon
Alien: Romulus
I’m hoping Nosferatu rounds the top 5 before year’s end.
Box office is never an indication of a movie's merit. Never ever.
I have gotten so many recommendations for movies that are so interesting, some of which I have seen some of which I have not had a chance to see but I always look forward to your thoughts
I am a kindred spirit when it comes to movies music and books keep on Truckin man
This video is SPOT ON. 💯 ✔️ Hell, 1000 % correct. No one seems to care, so why should we? (as creators).
People /viewers take sh*t SOOOO seriously if you don't like their favourite movie/actor/fighter/band etc etc. It's like a personal attack to them. They react like you just slapped their mother. It's absolutely INSANE these days.
In other news, could you consider doing a video on "why you should care about Kino Lorber" for those of us who have no idea who they really are or put out? Would be nice!!!
Hi, Heath! Please, don't stop talking about movies (both new releases and classics) and physical media in a positive, passionate way. I'm sure there are many of us who enjoy watching the content from a true lover of cinema. I'ts not easy to find such an space like yours.
Have a nice rest of the week!
I like your hope,I used to go to the theater at least twice a month but this year Horizon and Megalopolis were the only titles that interested me and I enjoyed both.Thankfully I'm still finding old titles from places like Hamilton and Movies Unlimited.I truly hope selection gets better because it bothers me not to support my local theater
Keep the faith,like hearing you talk about movies
I don't usually comment but I thought that the experience of Pete at Sea of Tranquillity youtube channel might be of some use to you. SOT is a music review channel for fans of rock music and has been going for many years but over the last few years he noticed negativity in the comments towards content, guests on his show and other members and he has seen fit on several occasions to call these negative people and their behaviour out in videos, and I presume for serial offenders banning people who continued their bad behaviour. I'm sure he still gets negativity but it does seem a whole lot healthier now than it has in years gone past as these people are no longer as vocal as they used to be. He also around 12 months ago decided to reduce the output on his channel as the workload was just becoming unmanageable for him, and it has benefitted him and his channels content for the change. It might be an idea to reach out to have a chat with Pete to talk through some of these issues and see how he copes with this very angry world we live in now. He also does a great show on horror films on a Thursday called The Monsters Den so maybe a coop show on horror films would be a good idea? Anyway keep up the great work, hope you are encouraged by the positive response to this video.
Heath, are you posting for the numbers or for the love? If only ten people like your video, is it worth it to have those connections even if it’s only ten people.
Some channels push Buy Buy Buy And some collectors not only do not watch the physical media but don’t even open them.
On your point about the review-bombing before a picture is even released, usually to the negative side: this is what almost kept me from enjoying the 2017 Joey King picture Wish Upon (because the reviews of it [mostly negative] were written so forcefully negative that it was like I felt like I was being told [I'm autistic] that I was not allowed to make up my own mind, and that I should not even try to enjoy it); I got it on a thumb-drive from my nephew, saw it, and truly enjoyed it (so much so that I have it on physical media now [DVD/Blu combo pack], and it's one of 6 pictures of hers that I have and have truly enjoyed [my physical media of her projects also including Universal Home Entertainment's Blu of her 2019 Hulu limited series The Act]).
This is pretty much a reflection of society nowadays! Neighbor against neighbor, me vs the world attitude!
I'm your tribe, Heath. Keep talking about the movies. You speak so eloquently. I'd listen to your detailed take on any film. Any film.
I say ignore the hate. Easier said, "Then done," but I watch your channel for your knowledge, your experience, and your opinion that's different from mine so I can learn something. So keep the good work. Movies are the highest form of art to me, and art is subjective.
I love your videos and respect and value your opinion on movies and love the movies that aren't franchise or ip movies as well.
Talk about what makes you happy. I don't watch cereal at midnight just to see discs I watch this channel because of you're passion for westerns, noir and whaterever genres you are into.
I don't think the new releases videos are sustainable and you have said it yourself. What I would like is that you would make highlight videos of releases that you like.
My criticism on Joker 2 is making it into a musical. I think it was a bad idea to make it a musical. The movie flopped because of it. We don't know if people actually watch a particular movie. Don't let the trolls get you down. Do whatever you want on your channel. Let's celebrate the art of movies.
I agree with you on how good the movies for this year was. I’ve seen about 30-40 movies this year and I’ve only seen about a half dozen that I’d say was bad or meh. All the rest was good to great for me.
I’ve seen movies that I think are pretty good or great and seen people say it’s absolutely crap. Course I’ve also seen vice versa.
Yeah, this is actually the reason why we need people like you on here more than ever before! To at least try and balance out all the surface-level "critics"/fanboys out there
Haters will come and go. Your tribe will stick with you. Just keep following your passion. Maybe it would help to turn off the comments for a while just to get a breather? I know that’s counter productive when it comes to having a conversation about movies but hey.. it’s an option. Been following you for years now, and I never really read or leave comments, but it sucks to watch you struggling with this problem. The danger of welcoming a conversation in the comments is people tend to confuse the term “debate” with “argument”. I recently listened to your podcast episode of The Fly, loved it.