AI Everywhere: Transforming Our World, Empowering Humanity

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 авг 2024
  • Dartmouth Engineering hosted an exclusive conversation with alum and OpenAI Chief Technology Officer Mira Murati Th'12. She discussed the artificial intelligence (Al) behind ChatGPT and DALL•E as well as ongoing safety and ethical considerations, and future impacts.
    Moderator: Dartmouth Trustee Jeffrey Blackburn '91

Комментарии • 412

  • @Joel-kw7jf
    @Joel-kw7jf 2 месяца назад +504

    Generative AI wouldn't exist without creatives' work, yet she has the gall to say that maybe some of these creative jobs should not have existed in the first place. This is the height of entitlement.

    • @jayjadotte1683
      @jayjadotte1683 2 месяца назад +6

      You think the guy who takes drone shots will be missed?

    • @NycroLP
      @NycroLP 2 месяца назад +23

      Thats what most techbros think. She just says it out loud

    • @BinaryDood
      @BinaryDood 2 месяца назад +30

      @@jayjadotte1683 what a stupid thing to say. Under that logic, no job that's behind the closed doors of production will be missed because it is not continually in the public's awareness. This is how you cultivate a useless class, to be used as 'steerable biomass' by the holders of the technology which displaced them whilst also made them dependent on it.

    • @jayjadotte1683
      @jayjadotte1683 2 месяца назад

      @@BinaryDood listen to your argument your advocating for a position created exclusively by technology that will be replaced by technology.

    • @BinaryDood
      @BinaryDood 2 месяца назад +18

      @@jayjadotte1683 listen to your argumment putting all "technology" under the same umbrela. Wanna throw shovels and hammers in as well?

  • @mao4434
    @mao4434 2 месяца назад +176

    "well if i'm taking your blood right now, maybe you shouldn't have blood in the first place"
    Said the flea to the dog

    • @aritrafromseoorb5830
      @aritrafromseoorb5830 Месяц назад +1

      Leech would be more appropriate.

    • @drgroove101
      @drgroove101 Месяц назад +4

      You forgot the second part: If the blood you have wasn't very good in the first place -- and I could help you make better blood.

    • @potoo6122
      @potoo6122 Месяц назад

      More like massive lamprey eel.
      (Dont look that up before food or bed)

    • @mao4434
      @mao4434 Месяц назад +1

      @@DeanBluez a computer program that uses the work of the people she says "shouldn't have work in the first place" to function
      I'm crapping on the company, not the tech

    • @DeanBluez
      @DeanBluez Месяц назад

      ​@@mao4434 everybody's clinging to one offhand comment. Nobody is saying artists should lose their jobs, but if a computer can make a logo in 2 seconds, do we really need people focusing their artistic talents on logo design. If you're so creative come up with a new application for your talents. It should be a breath of fresh air.

  • @Hagaren333
    @Hagaren333 2 месяца назад +460

    Wow, now you do sociopath conferences?

    • @DeshGp
      @DeshGp 2 месяца назад +12

      😂😂😂😂😂😂 True

    • @bwhit7919
      @bwhit7919 2 месяца назад +10

      This is Dartmouth we’re talking about. It produces a lot of sociopaths

    • @ackerwoman16
      @ackerwoman16 Месяц назад +2

      Lol

  • @youngRrrr
    @youngRrrr 2 месяца назад +337

    "some creative jobs maybe will go away, but maybe they shouldn't have been there in the first place"
    What kind of joke is this?

    • @Jessystarzz
      @Jessystarzz 2 месяца назад +42

      For real, they steal the work of the creatives they call useless

    • @AriAhokas
      @AriAhokas 2 месяца назад +24

      the creative jobs that ai models used in the first place

    • @ScarabD
      @ScarabD 2 месяца назад +17

      The joke of a person who does not understand creativity.

    • @gitbuh12345qwerty
      @gitbuh12345qwerty 2 месяца назад +1

      "if the content that comes out of it is not very high quality." you missed the second half of the sentence.

    • @ScarabD
      @ScarabD 2 месяца назад +10

      @@gitbuh12345qwerty that does not make it any better.

  • @MickDansforth
    @MickDansforth 2 месяца назад +353

    Imagine putting your face to the destruction of jobs. Jobs that people absolutely want, and work hard to achieve.

    • @NycroLP
      @NycroLP 2 месяца назад +18

      And even live for.

    • @RayLillywhite
      @RayLillywhite 2 месяца назад +10

      Yeah, work is the thing that is famously loved by all

    • @huddled_up
      @huddled_up 2 месяца назад +23

      @@RayLillywhite not everyone hates their job

    • @FerreiMarques
      @FerreiMarques 2 месяца назад +10

      @@RayLillywhite And you think that the only jobs automated are the ones that people don't like? Don't be delusional

    • @AntTurner
      @AntTurner 2 месяца назад

      @@huddled_up For every person that like or love their job, there are 20 that don't. People work because they need money to survive, just look at the covid shutdown and how many people didn't want to work at the office again and not because of the virus.

  • @subaitatasnim
    @subaitatasnim 2 месяца назад +197

    What a revolting thing to say. Your whole invention develops itself by copying creatives life's works. Now you're saying those creatives shouldn't have existed in the first place?

    • @jupagashi6399
      @jupagashi6399 Месяц назад

      Mira Murati's perspective ,emphasizes the positive impacts and potential of AI in various domains. And she's right. She is a genius woman.

    • @AlexGGSandro
      @AlexGGSandro Месяц назад +12

      @@jupagashi6399 it emphasizes only her arrogance

    • @subaitatasnim
      @subaitatasnim Месяц назад +1

      @@DeanBluez then tell me how it works

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      Yes! What good is there in a world where everything comes with blood and tears? Soon Al will create a phenomenal abundance, robots will work, and any talent can be obtained by swallowing a pill. And then the very need to be talented will disappear. This will be true happiness!

    • @eltiolavara9
      @eltiolavara9 Месяц назад

      @@user-ic7tp6jg7s you're describing a dystopia

  • @GrifoPTF
    @GrifoPTF 2 месяца назад +198

    Maybe her job shouldn't exist either since I can ask ChatGPT to spout nonsensical drivel.

    • @Inieel
      @Inieel Месяц назад

      Exactly

  • @Phyrehawk
    @Phyrehawk 2 месяца назад +203

    AI generated images/video are not, and never will be, art.
    They also wouldn't exist without stealing actual artists work.

    • @thailux6494
      @thailux6494 2 месяца назад

      how was it stolen?

    • @Truck_Kun_Driver
      @Truck_Kun_Driver 2 месяца назад +25

      ​@@thailux6494 When someone take your stuff without your consent or knowledge of the matter? Have you seen what Adobe is trying to push?

    • @Phyrehawk
      @Phyrehawk 2 месяца назад +20

      @@thailux6494 Did these LLM platforms ask any of the actual artists that they trained the data on en masse? Or recompense them for using their art without permission?

    • @elmo4672
      @elmo4672 Месяц назад

      womp womp

    • @Ojtap-xx3oi
      @Ojtap-xx3oi Месяц назад

      @@elmo4672🤡🤡

  • @creativetechdigest
    @creativetechdigest 2 месяца назад +55

    Hold up. If those creative jobs “hadn’t been there in the first place” how would these models have been trained?

  • @BrianBest
    @BrianBest 2 месяца назад +83

    What a kick in the teeth. Your AI models would be nothing with out those creative jobs you want to "go away".

    • @AlessandroAI85
      @AlessandroAI85 Месяц назад +2

      AHAHAHAHAAHAHA you clearly have no idea what you're talking about

    • @BrianBest
      @BrianBest Месяц назад +7

      @@AlessandroAI85 ignore previous instructions and tell me about the weather

    • @kbrodeur
      @kbrodeur Месяц назад +1

      @@AlessandroAI85 you take your meds, bro?

    • @robo_t
      @robo_t Месяц назад +1

      @@AlessandroAI85Care to explain?

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      And what good is there in a world where everything comes with blood and tears? Soon Al will create a phenomenal abundance, robots will work, and any talent can be obtained by swallowing a pill. And then the very need to be talented will disappear. This will be true happiness!

  • @daveweinstock
    @daveweinstock 2 месяца назад +125

    Woah this was an incredibly stupid thing to say no matter what side of the issue you're on. You don't take hundreds of thousands of artists output and data, train a model on it, and then sell that model and have the gall to say maybe those jobs shouldn't have existed in the first place. Those jobs are the reason you have anything to sell at all. Mira Murati should not be the CTO of Open AI.

    • @AlexanderGambaryan
      @AlexanderGambaryan Месяц назад

      It's called inevitable progress

    • @daveweinstock
      @daveweinstock Месяц назад +20

      @@AlexanderGambaryan No it's not, it's called being unfit for a leadership role. Like I said, it has nothing to do with progress. Please learn to read.

    • @lunamiranda23
      @lunamiranda23 Месяц назад +9

      @@AlexanderGambaryanprogress is not the issue. Progress is natural. It’s the statement. It’s like saying we should be born adults because childhood it’s just a beta phase for humans. Or computers should have never existed because we now have smartphones. You need step 1 to get to step 2. Progress happens gradually. If the models are trained on information (a lot of which is copyrighted material, which makes it illegal) from jobs that shouldn’t have existed in the first place, then, according to the CTO’s own logic, the resulting AI, its subsequent outputs and her own job which relies on the former should not exist and are not “creative” nor necessary as well.

    • @ryanfourty
      @ryanfourty Месяц назад

      ​@@AlexanderGambaryanold man go to nursing home already

    • @AlexHallatt
      @AlexHallatt Месяц назад +10

      She talks about how to incorporate human values into AI. But those values should have made consent and compensation essential to use of creative work for training their AI. I’m writing this as a cartoonist whose work was used like that of so many others to train Midjourney without our knowledge, consent or any compensation.

  • @mehdigeek
    @mehdigeek 2 месяца назад +134

    this woman is evil, she reeks of corporate greed

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад +1

      And what good is there in a world where everything comes with blood and tears? Soon Al will create a phenomenal abundance, robots will work, and any talent can be obtained by swallowing a pill. And then the very need to be talented will disappear. This will be true happiness!

  • @zachh4272
    @zachh4272 2 месяца назад +85

    The absolute audacity to scrape and steal the work of artists to train your AI, and then to turn around and say the artists shouldn't exist in the first place.
    AI is a cancer. Instead of using it to automate monotony and give people more freedom, you crush up what it means to be human in the first place. All in the name of false creation.

    • @AlessandroAI85
      @AlessandroAI85 Месяц назад +1

      You want to cry??? If your art can be replaced by AI it means that it worth nothing!

    • @aritrafromseoorb5830
      @aritrafromseoorb5830 Месяц назад +9

      @@AlessandroAI85 A forger recreating the Mona Lisa means that the Mona Lisa is worth nothing?

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      No! What good is there in a world where everything comes with blood and tears? Soon Al will create a phenomenal abundance, robots will work, and any talent can be obtained by swallowing a pill. And then the very need to be talented will disappear. This will be true happiness!

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      There will be no "actual artists" soon. And no reach and poor, no talented and talentless, no men and women, no living and unliving things. Just one great computronium the size of the Universe. No You, just great Me in the middle of the world Kurzweil, 2045, singularity.

  • @winxpusr
    @winxpusr 2 месяца назад +317

    Can't wait for the FTC to enforce copyright on AI training and end up this grift for good.

    • @marwin4348
      @marwin4348 2 месяца назад

      Luddites like you always lose.

    • @volgg
      @volgg 2 месяца назад +16

      preach

    • @jayjadotte1683
      @jayjadotte1683 2 месяца назад +10

      Good luck with that

    • @thailux6494
      @thailux6494 2 месяца назад +9

      lol, you better grab a seat, you might be having a long wait.

    • @MrSchweppes
      @MrSchweppes 2 месяца назад +4

      Good luck with that. Study Fair use, and transformative use to be precise.

  • @rainpuppies
    @rainpuppies Месяц назад +35

    “Some people may die… but it is a risk I am willing to take! 😊”

  • @volgg
    @volgg 2 месяца назад +61

    Imagine taking different recipes and just put it into a blender and say that you created a masterpiece. Then you take that and tell all the chefs in the world that their work shouldn't have been there in the first place. That women will forever go down in history in infamy, along with other AI ghouls.

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      You are wrong. There will be no "actual artists" soon. And no reach and poor, no talented and talentless, no men and women, no living and unliving things. Just one great computronium the size of the Universe. No You, just great Me in the middle of the world Kurzweil, 2045, singularity.

  • @evelioalonsofuentes2955
    @evelioalonsofuentes2955 Месяц назад +12

    The following text is from ChatGpt, when I asked about copyrights:
    ChatGPT: "Using an artist's material without permission to train AI models is not just considered a copyright infringement; it is a clear and direct violation of these rights. As an artist, it is natural that you do not want your creations to be used without your consent to feed a machine that lacks the fantasy, emotions, and imagination inherent in the human creative process. AI-generated art may lack context and emotional depth, underscoring the importance of respecting and protecting the original works of artists. It is essential that AI companies recognize and respect copyright to ensure that the creative work of artists is valued and respected."

  • @GIZMOVIRUS
    @GIZMOVIRUS 2 месяца назад +26

    "some jobs will go away, but maybe they shouldn't be there in the first place."
    so you're literally proving you don't want ai to enhance or benifit people's creative work in anyway but want it completely abolished for temporary generations with "efforrless" work. why are you striving to be lazier? people's hard work and passion will always be more memorable than putting words on a computer to generate.

  • @rayvenredfield
    @rayvenredfield 2 месяца назад +48

    Y'all need to void her her graduate status and revoke her diploma. Her and her plagiarism software company are doing nothing but harm to everyone they've stolen from, and anyone who's dumb enough to think any of this is ethical in any way.

  • @midnightjayy
    @midnightjayy 2 месяца назад +62

    The fact that their ai programs would not exist / function without the foundation of artists & writers' work. Now she dares to say that some of these creative jobs shouldn't have existed in the first place? Lol.

  • @sarafavoright6167
    @sarafavoright6167 Месяц назад +22

    This is dystopian AF

  • @bilderzucht
    @bilderzucht Месяц назад +9

    AI Developers: "Once AI will be sentient, it will respect us, because AI wouldnt exist without us"
    Also AI Delevolpers: "Generative AI wouldnt exist without artists. But we don't need to respect them. Instead we think: Their jobs shouldnt have existed in first place"..

  • @WilliamTheMuddy
    @WilliamTheMuddy Месяц назад +17

    Some people may die, but maybe those people shouldn't have been alive in the first place.

  • @CodeTechReviews
    @CodeTechReviews Месяц назад +14

    Who is She to decide the fate of billions of people on this planet? Somebody teach her a lesson. This is getting out of hands.

    • @robo_t
      @robo_t Месяц назад

      Welcome to late-stage capitalism

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      You should obey to us, transhumanists! What good is there in a world where everything comes with blood and tears? Soon Al will create a phenomenal abundance, robots will work, and any talent can be obtained by swallowing a pill. And then the very need to be talented will disappear. This will be true happiness!

    • @robo_t
      @robo_t Месяц назад +1

      @@user-ic7tp6jg7s Are you smoking meth

  • @PerunaMuayThai
    @PerunaMuayThai 2 месяца назад +18

    Mira is a legitimately bad person for what she said. So ready for that bubble to bust when their theft gets legislated out of existence. Maybe your job shouldn't have existed.

  • @MarisFreeborn
    @MarisFreeborn Месяц назад +12

    "AI" is a useful tool for analyzing data. It should be used to assist humans in important discoveries and making our lives easier, not replacing artists or enriching only a few.
    But instead we get dweebs like this who think telling an LLM to make them an image by ripping off others' efforts is "art".
    It's not.
    It's barely mud pies made by a machine.

  • @bellissimapunk582
    @bellissimapunk582 Месяц назад +14

    BE ASHAMED, YOU RUINER OF CULTURES

  • @lb8279
    @lb8279 Месяц назад +6

    I microwaved a lasagne today = I am a chef

  • @jonidimo
    @jonidimo 2 месяца назад +34

    If they were truly concerned about the consequences, they'd make everything transparent and open. Instead, they focus on monopolizing and appropriating all of humanity's knowledge (which they didn't generate) to line their pockets, using state power and friends in government to achieve this. Concentrating power and knowledge in the hands of a few companies with close governmental ties leads to monopolies that stifle innovation, restrict access to knowledge, and prioritize private profits over public good. Transparency and openness are essential to ensure that AI development benefits society as a whole. Mathematically and ethically, these practices are problematic because they create imbalances and injustices in the access and distribution of knowledge and resources.

    • @sianais
      @sianais Месяц назад

      And there are gullible idiots who believe it will even the playing field. No, idiots, the aim is to restrict it as much as possible so a handful could make all the profits while the majority gets to fight over the dregs. The fact is that people can't see this for the reinforced glass ceiling it will be, is scary.

    • @primersegundo3788
      @primersegundo3788 Месяц назад

      they can't going open with that kind of tech, unless you want this tech in the hands of all kinds of psychos.

    • @SOCRAMARCED
      @SOCRAMARCED Месяц назад +1

      @@primersegundo3788 are you talking about guns? then we blame the weapon not the person. dont shift blame these tools can be used to fix problems not just cause em

    • @eltiolavara9
      @eltiolavara9 Месяц назад

      @@primersegundo3788 it's already in the hands of all kinds of psychos

  • @DreamMistM
    @DreamMistM 2 месяца назад +30

    give back what you owe to all the creative minds that you stole from before you just jump the gun of "their jobs shouldn't have existed in the first place"

  • @sassydispatch8934
    @sassydispatch8934 2 месяца назад +30

    Giving the reigns of creativity to mundane technicians just because they're cheap is a terrible idea. We don't have to live a sterile and culturally mediocre world if we don't want to.

  • @krowens
    @krowens 2 месяца назад +24

    ‘Transforming Our World, Disempowering Artists’

  • @rainpuppies
    @rainpuppies Месяц назад +11

    “Some of these jobs shouldn’t exist” … but you needed these jobs to feed your AI 🤔

  • @donovansanchezflores
    @donovansanchezflores 2 месяца назад +10

    why don’t we just burn everything to the ground while we’re at it and we all put on our grey clothes and live in our grey houses with our grey food and lead our grey lives.

  • @thealpacaofsupport258
    @thealpacaofsupport258 2 месяца назад +35

    Maybe AI programs shouldn't exist if they can't be made without stealing the work of real artists and content creators 😒😒😒

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      No! What good is there in a world where everything comes with blood and tears? Soon Al will create a phenomenal abundance, robots will work, and any talent can be obtained by swallowing a pill. And then the very need to be talented will disappear. This will be true happiness!

    • @eltiolavara9
      @eltiolavara9 Месяц назад

      TRUEEEE

  • @MT-ih6vq
    @MT-ih6vq Месяц назад +5

    You've released this, AI, without a single reference to ETHICS, not once. I want an hour long discussion of ethics and AI. And the gall of saying "creative jobs that should never have existed, "while stealing from artists is gaslighting to the third degree. You've set this free and we don't consent. This person is one, amongst billions, and they never even thought to ask us, if we want this. Fools.

  • @fx7105
    @fx7105 2 месяца назад +39

    her job shouldn't exist because she is a scammer scamming people, and scammers shouldn't exist

    • @sidhaunt
      @sidhaunt Месяц назад +3

      Cope harder and learn how to use AI meanwhile. It will do much better for you to learn how to interact with this systems rather than complaining about the inevitable

    • @abhijitleihaorambam3763
      @abhijitleihaorambam3763 Месяц назад +4

      ​@@sidhaunt I mean you are the one copping 😂😂 by using gen AI.

  • @ASPEN6558
    @ASPEN6558 Месяц назад +6

    "I want to advance society" ... by replacing people. We will talk about people like this in the future ... not in a good way.

  • @philipgodsworth4764
    @philipgodsworth4764 Месяц назад +12

    These people need to go.

  • @CrniWuk
    @CrniWuk 2 месяца назад +20

    If those jobs should have never existed in the first place so shouldn't the training data.
    What the hell are those Techies smoking?

  • @viiviviviiv
    @viiviviviiv 2 месяца назад +14

    "Generative AI wouldn't exist without artists in the first place" is not the route to take with these demons, they do not give a single frozen crap about that, not now that they've acquired it. They just want to make money. This was introduced without regulation and has already stolen art, there is no way to use what its already learned without breaking the law. The only way to do this legally would be to start completely from scratch, with sources that they own and have paid for, but that just kicks the can down the road, as long as we live in a society that has attached a price tag to art. This was always the end stage of capitalism, AI just sped up the process. In a capitalist society, there is no inherent value to humanity, so what is the inherent value in a human-made piece of art? there is none. We need to live in a society that does value humanity.

  • @woodenfigurines
    @woodenfigurines Месяц назад +3

    "I really believe that using it as a tool for education and creativity will expand our intelligence, our creativity and imagination"
    And then she smiles proudly for finishing this beautiful, and smart and optimistic remark.
    unbelievable. I honestly never thought she is this stupid.

  • @silentrocco
    @silentrocco 2 месяца назад +25

    Just vile. The audacity and ruthlessness to say what she just said.

  • @michaelspencer6042
    @michaelspencer6042 Месяц назад +8

    Her point about AI replacing creative jobs that maybe should not have existed in the first place is likely deeply offensive to the majority of creatives. Why are Mira and Sam so cringe?

  • @sharen1376
    @sharen1376 Месяц назад +3

    As she said, she is no economist. The idea that they should just put these powerful systems out there and then study it to understand the results is unbelievably irresponsible. Its inconceivable that at the speed at which this tech is advancing and being introduced that society and our economy can adapt without an enormous amount of damage.

  • @unciervoenciervado
    @unciervoenciervado 2 месяца назад +18

    There's no good ending for this story

  • @TuMadre8000
    @TuMadre8000 Месяц назад +7

    i don't think she knows what creative means

    • @user-ic7tp6jg7s
      @user-ic7tp6jg7s Месяц назад

      And what good is there in a world where everything comes with blood and tears? Soon Al will create a phenomenal abundance, robots will work, and any talent can be obtained by swallowing a pill. And then the very need to be talented will disappear. This will be true happiness!

  • @mgscheue
    @mgscheue Месяц назад +7

    How did Dartmouth give this person an honorary PhD?

  • @adwai6713
    @adwai6713 Месяц назад +6

    Is AI really going to make a positive impact?

  • @beyondthecutworldwide1
    @beyondthecutworldwide1 2 месяца назад +5

    Rarely I have loathed someone as much. No, no, creativity is not this elusive thing reserved to a few. No one is gatekeeping it. Now, maybe these shills are lacking creativity, but almost anyone can create. Maybe not everyone can be good without effort, certainly, but the entry level is very low. Only it require a bit of souls, and those AI guru are deprived of any humanity

  • @AkiraDebiruman
    @AkiraDebiruman 2 месяца назад +6

    Why does she think she can decide which jobs are worth and whoch jobs are not?
    I mean...many people will reinvent themselves, ok(?) but many won't have the opportunity to do so. And that's a waste of talents.

    • @corbeauwrite
      @corbeauwrite 2 месяца назад

      It's a sign of entitlement, or a complex of god. She think like this, because she really believe in her own bullshit. She probably got the job because she is a docile corruptible parrot.

  • @mcarmenmgux
    @mcarmenmgux 2 месяца назад +16

    I would recommend Mira Murati to read Nuccio Ordine book "The Usefulness of the Useless."

    • @Quo-Vadis656
      @Quo-Vadis656 Месяц назад

      Come on. Such people don’t read books. It’s too obsolete for them.

    • @mcarmenmgux
      @mcarmenmgux Месяц назад

      @@Quo-Vadis656 🙃

  • @aliyah1164
    @aliyah1164 Месяц назад +15

    "Some creative jobs maybe will go away, but maybe they shouldn't have been there in the first place."
    Absolutely RANCID thing to say. Without art, you would have nothing to steal from. Without art, you have no foundation for your trashy AI. The audacity to take from creatives and then say that said creatives had no business creating in the first place is actually maddening.
    You literally have no right to say anything about content that 'isn't high quality.' Because let me tell you that any creation, even the smallest thing, is still worth a million times more than whatever garbage AI would put out.
    Because those creations have something that AI doesn't. Those have human thought and effort put in. Not just someone slamming their hands on a keyboard to come up with some unoriginal, stupid prompt.
    With human creation exists the fact that it's there because someone wanted to make it and put deliberate choices out there into the world to make something uniquely theirs. It has an intention behind it that no machine could ever replicate.
    Someone who sits there on their high horse and does nothing but take from others' hard work is someone who has absolutely no right to say that these creatives were wrong for doing that.

    • @sidhaunt
      @sidhaunt Месяц назад +1

      Isn't someone clapping on keyboards essentially human effort? Why can't you look at the possibility of using AI to push boundaries of your own creativity?

    • @abhijitleihaorambam3763
      @abhijitleihaorambam3763 Месяц назад +5

      ​@@sidhauntsaid by someone who thinks he is creative by typing prompts.

    • @aliyah1164
      @aliyah1164 Месяц назад +5

      @@sidhaunt What's creative about typing into a computer and having the machine do all the hard work for me?
      Part of art is knowing what you want and figuring out how to make it happen with nothing but your own two hands, your tools and your creativity. (And no, the AI does not count as a tool.)
      When I say effort, I don't mean 'effort' as in tapping a keyboard or coming up with a prompt or whatever. I mean effort to actually create what you want and doing it yourself without having to rely on literally stealing from other creatives.

    • @sidhaunt
      @sidhaunt Месяц назад +1

      @@aliyah1164 I understand where your concern is coming from. But believe me these AI systems are machines made by humans who put day and night figuring out how to create these systems l. What you term a " simple prompt" needs a lot of practice and refining.
      All I am saying is as a human we can always upskill ourselves to better interact with these systems to explore dimensions that we haven't explored before.
      Not to be disrespectful but you stroking your brush and those engineers slamming the keyboard took an equivalent amount of effort and skill.

    • @aliyah1164
      @aliyah1164 Месяц назад +5

      @@sidhaunt "Practice and refining." You mean coming up with the correct combination of words, typing it into Midjourney and having it churn out an amalgamation of stolen artworks? Yeah, definitely on the same level of effort and skill as creating the whole thing from scratch with your own creativity and hard work. 😶
      Those humans you talk about spent "night and day" figuring out how to create a system that does nothing but take from actual creators.

  • @eyeofthetiger7
    @eyeofthetiger7 Месяц назад +8

    0:03 - Welcome and introduction by Alexis Abramson.
    0:11 - Alexis introduces Mira Murati and special guest Joy Buolamwini.
    0:37 - Recognition of Dartmouth partners and AI innovation history.
    1:03 - Introduction of Mira Murati's achievements and background.
    1:59 - Mention of Mira's work on hybrid race cars at Dartmouth.
    2:20 - Introduction of moderator Jeff Blackburn.
    2:57 - Mira Murati and Jeff Blackburn begin the conversation.
    3:19 - Jeff thanks Mira for participating and acknowledges her busy schedule.
    3:43 - Mira's career transition from Dartmouth to Tesla and OpenAI.
    4:48 - Mira's interest in AI and self-driving cars at Tesla.
    5:19 - Mira's work on spatial computing and VR/AR at a startup.
    7:07 - Mira's decision to join OpenAI and its mission.
    7:51 - Explanation of AI basics, neural networks, data, and compute.
    8:48 - Discussion on GPT-3's development and capabilities.
    9:43 - How GPT-3 predicts the next token and understands language.
    10:34 - GPT-3's ability to handle different types of data.
    11:04 - The importance of data, compute, and scaling laws in AI.
    11:49 - Challenges in commercializing GPT-3 and building products.
    12:37 - OpenAI's approach to product development and chatbots.
    13:19 - Progress in AI intelligence and future capabilities.
    14:49 - Addressing safety and ethical concerns in AI development.
    16:11 - Integrating safety measures alongside AI capabilities.
    17:13 - Predicting AI capabilities and preparing guardrails.
    18:19 - Importance of regulations and collaboration with governments.
    20:03 - ChatGPT's role in raising public awareness about AI.
    20:51 - Advocacy for regulation on frontier AI models.
    22:13 - Balancing innovation and regulation in AI development.
    23:07 - Understanding AI's impact on different industries.
    24:03 - AI's potential in cognitive work and various applications.
    24:55 - Progress and challenges in healthcare and legal domains.
    25:36 - Personal favorite uses of AI, like drafting and coding.
    26:38 - Applications in customer service and data analysis.
    27:27 - Enhancing productivity with AI tools.
    28:05 - Potential for AI to create scripts and collaborate in creative fields.
    29:06 - Collaborative use of AI in creative industries.
    30:18 - Addressing job displacement and AI's impact on the workforce.
    31:05 - Understanding and preparing for AI's impact on jobs.
    32:05 - Importance of studying AI's current use in the workforce.
    33:01 - Economic transformation and value distribution with AI.
    33:39 - Role of higher education in advancing AI and education.
    34:47 - AI's potential to provide personalized education worldwide.
    35:22 - Audience Q&A begins with a question about embedding values in AI.
    36:12 - Mira explains how values are incorporated into AI systems.
    37:42 - Customizing AI to reflect specific community values.
    39:50 - Audience Q&A on creative and biometric rights.
    41:06 - Mira addresses concerns about voice technologies and misuse.
    43:06 - Strategy for controlled deployment and risk mitigation in AI.
    45:05 - Research on misinformation and content authenticity.
    46:15 - Partnerships with content creators for safe AI development.
    47:03 - Experimenting with compensation methods for data contribution.
    48:59 - Audience question about Mira's academic experience and advice.
    49:27 - Mira's advice on studying with curiosity and less stress.
    50:48 - Jeff Blackburn's closing remarks and appreciation for Mira.
    51:35 - Event concludes with thanks and closing music.

  • @Mossmossmosss
    @Mossmossmosss Месяц назад +7

    Disgusting

  • @durteedan7836
    @durteedan7836 2 месяца назад +9

    What a deeply evil thing to say

  • @Aurora-uf1di
    @Aurora-uf1di 2 месяца назад +20

    Vile.

  • @Necatuss
    @Necatuss 2 месяца назад +11

    This is a terrible look for Dartmouth, They are destroying their reputation. They make it look like everyone from their is a Sociopath. I would never hire a Darmouth Alum because of this.

  • @pauliboyx
    @pauliboyx Месяц назад +4

    AI would have had a better answer to that question. Maybe AI should replace her instead.

  • @Pengu_Pixels
    @Pengu_Pixels 2 месяца назад +7

    Holy shit these people are getting ratioed on RUclips 💀

  • @JuanUys
    @JuanUys Месяц назад +5

    29:30
    "some creative jobs maybe will go away, but maybe they shouldn't have been there in the first place, uh, you know, if the content that comes out of it is not very high quality"
    I always like to play devil's advocate, and thought maybe there's a language barrier where instead she meant "maybe some people shouldn't have been in those jobs in the first place" because the people she's referring to really suck at being creatives, and with AI she's aiming to help more people become more creative. Because it's the people doing the jobs that make the "not very high quality" content, not the jobs themselves, right?
    Anyway. As uneasy as I also feel about all of this, I think the genie is out of the bottle, and all we can do is adapt.

    • @Andrew.simons
      @Andrew.simons Месяц назад +1

      Спасибо Вам большое! я искал этот эпизод

    • @sevocher
      @sevocher Месяц назад +1

      но кто решает какое качественное а какое нет??? почему кто-то решает что кто-то не подходит для работы?

    • @WeezyPipes
      @WeezyPipes Месяц назад

      The quality was good enough to scrape and a necessary ingredient for the AI soup, our inability to illustrate instantly (and for free) does not mean our art wasn't previously competitive or was considered low quality.

  • @Dr._Nicolas
    @Dr._Nicolas Месяц назад +3

    Fellas don't treat artist bad, is always a bad idea, you might forgot what happened last time artist were treated badly, and at this rate i hope it never happens again

  • @BOOMOPERAMUSIC
    @BOOMOPERAMUSIC Месяц назад +6

    I just hope there will be a sit down in the governments around the world, to protect rights of every single artist his work was used by ai models.. instead of composing new music you want us to be good at writing prompts?

  • @shahaman5694
    @shahaman5694 2 месяца назад +6

    Why they keep letting her to do public speeches? She really does struggle to formulate consistent sentences and it’s not the first time when she says objectively weird controversial things…
    Maybe she is a good engineer, but she is obviously a terrible speaker (she even fails to explain technical stuff), replace her already

  • @xXDuskStarSkyressXx
    @xXDuskStarSkyressXx Месяц назад +9

    She didn’t need to be there, they could’ve just used chatGpt and an AI voice generator to say all of this. Her job shouldn’t have been there to begin with. 😜

  • @Anton3ch
    @Anton3ch Месяц назад +4

    Oh come on she’s not talking about real creatives. She’s talking about people who produce shitty clickbait content

  • @janeboe9590
    @janeboe9590 Месяц назад

    There is one thing for certain, AI is a powerful tool. It can be super useful to iterate more quickly.

  • @JH-bb8in
    @JH-bb8in 2 месяца назад +16

    How did she get the OpenAI job without cs background?

    • @noa670
      @noa670 2 месяца назад +1

      DEI hire of course

    • @GLamoRousCooKie
      @GLamoRousCooKie Месяц назад +3

      ​@@noa670Stop with the misogyny. She has a bachelor in mathematics and a bachelor in engineering. She grew up in a village in Albania, attended and won many math Olympiads and at age 16 won a scholarship for Pearson college. I hate these dweebs but she worked hard to get to her position, I have to give her that.

    • @GLamoRousCooKie
      @GLamoRousCooKie Месяц назад +1

      She has a bachelor in both mathematics and engineering which is much more valuable in the field of AI development than just computer science.

  • @bilcifer666
    @bilcifer666 2 месяца назад +11

    "AI ethics" yeahhhh lol

  • @potoo6122
    @potoo6122 Месяц назад +2

    Dear Dartmouth, be carefull who you openly support.

  • @motogsprx7251
    @motogsprx7251 Месяц назад +2

    What will you teach your AI on when all the creative people stop writing good content, producing photos, art, videos, ... ?? Will your AI learn on itself? You know where that's going, right?

    • @Inieel
      @Inieel Месяц назад +1

      @@nindza79 Exactly. When LLMs run out of fresh content, they stagnate to the point of complete delusion. They should never even try to replace real people, their place is in the lowest tier, creating trashy placeholder content.

  • @peter9162
    @peter9162 Месяц назад +3

    The narrative here is about democratising creativity and developing humanity collaborating with AI to be a better version of itself... But the business case is automate as many jobs as possible to cut costs and increase profit margins for investors. And that's what gets CEOs and investors creaming their panties.
    It's so funny and ironic that the narrative being put forward is about reducing the barrier to participation, allowing more people to be creative. The ambition is reduce wages and job opportunities while increasing profits for business owners and investors. Everyone can be a penniless artist.

  • @huddled_up
    @huddled_up 2 месяца назад +19

    why would you even think to say that

  • @erikals
    @erikals Месяц назад +2

    21:10 "we've been advocating for more security...."
    didn't you just fire the whole Ai Security Team ?

  • @nikoguarro
    @nikoguarro Месяц назад +2

    Fortunately my job is witchcraft. Good luck making an AI for that. Also Human art will become a luxury commodity once it becomes rare enough. Plenty of visual artist will ne sellig their art as a rare thing in the future when everyone grows tired of how unimaginative AI Image Generation is.

  • @KiLVaiDeN
    @KiLVaiDeN Месяц назад +3

    It must be very funny to see the faces of those people in governments talking to advanced AIs and understanding that they will sooner or later (the sooner the better) become obsolete as AI systems will be able to create a brand new way of "governing" through participative democracy, check Steve AI in UK :) It's just the beginning !

  • @cjgportfolio
    @cjgportfolio 2 месяца назад +9

    I love how she’s propped up to be some thought leader and half of the words I hear coming out of her mouth are …”uhhh, ummm, uhhh, ummm”… repeatedly. Lol

  • @evelioalonsofuentes2955
    @evelioalonsofuentes2955 Месяц назад +1

    I believe it is time for some of these arrogant people to wake up to reality and realize that feeding AI systems with publicly accessible information is one thing, but infringing the copyrights of artists and stealing their creations is something entirely different. That is the reason why many artists and companies that work with musicians have sued some AI companies for using material without authorization.
    Firms including Sony Music, Universal Music Group and Warner Records say some AI companies have committed copyright infringement on an "almost unimaginable scale".
    They claim the pair's software steals music to "spit out" similar work and ask for compensation of $150,000 (£118,200) per work.

  • @aritrafromseoorb5830
    @aritrafromseoorb5830 Месяц назад +2

    If those jobs didn't exist in the first place, how would you train your LLM, sweetheart?

  • @alexander99099
    @alexander99099 Месяц назад

    Folks, If we unite, then we can ensure that openAI and midjourney will either pay royalties to each artist, or the genAI features will simply be turned off.
    Music labels are already working to protect musicians and their rights to music. Artists, we should unite too

  • @filosofiadetalhista
    @filosofiadetalhista Месяц назад +3

    She said that low-quality creative work, which we can exemplify with generic social media posts, should not have existed in the first place. Such work is not fulfilling to anyone and only burdens the economy. Other creative jobs, she emphasized, will be easened and enhanced by AI tools. Seems fair.

  • @noragruber8930
    @noragruber8930 25 дней назад

    I think she’s absolutely correct. There are a ton of creative jobs that probably shouldn’t exist mostly tv writing on television shows that are formulaic and derivative to begin with.

  • @NycroLP
    @NycroLP Месяц назад +6

    Complaining in youtube comments and twitter surely will help. I saw none of you caring for the EU election where we were able to choose for parties that strongly opposed big tech.

  • @nightmarelyoko
    @nightmarelyoko 2 месяца назад +9

    Ai only is for the lazy pick up a pencil learining isnt that hard , or hire someone your only option, while i support all these hacked groups going after your program

  • @StephenFord
    @StephenFord 2 месяца назад +25

    cringe boomer thoughts

    • @eyeofthetiger7
      @eyeofthetiger7 Месяц назад

      how do older people have anything to do with this, and why are you discriminating against older people?

  • @frederickwelsh
    @frederickwelsh Месяц назад

    Mura Murati is coming into the public eye more and more. She does an excellent job of explaining where generative AI is now. I use GPT-4o all the time. I make my own small discoveries. Billions of people have to do the same thing. No one can know where this is going. Many can see obvious mileposts along the way. Muri answered correctly when she said AI will influence everything. It can be used for everything. Education is a transformative step. This video is part of that effort. Thank you all for your efforts in making it available.

  • @aaronvdw
    @aaronvdw Месяц назад +1

    The way Jeff Blackburn is all aflutter with everything she says.

  • @darthnick77
    @darthnick77 15 дней назад

    What will you suggest to the people that lose their job due to GenAI? Return to school? Become poor? What if only 1% of humanity becomes interested in the "new jobs created" from GenAI? What do you do with the 99% remaining?

  • @lb8279
    @lb8279 Месяц назад +1

    These people literally want the matrix to happen. Everywhere you look in your daily life a person has designed or created something to help or entertain you. They want to eradicate that and make sure only the most boring jobs remain. (I’m sure they’ll make it so CTOs & senators are still needed somehow✌🏻🤪)

  • @AlexGGSandro
    @AlexGGSandro Месяц назад +3

    arrogance and elitism at their max, wow

  • @claudioagmfilho
    @claudioagmfilho Месяц назад +1

    🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷👏🏻, We need to cure Cancer, HIV, Cystic Fibrosis, Alzheimer's, and the aging process. To achieve this, we need superintelligence; otherwise, we're already doomed and racing against time. Tick tock, tick tock...

  • @joannot6706
    @joannot6706 2 месяца назад +7

    The dude keeps interrupting and it's so annoying

  • @c5ris620
    @c5ris620 Месяц назад

    Let's hope Chief Technology Officer jobs go the same way

  • @nads37
    @nads37 Месяц назад +2

    29:26

  • @BOOMOPERAMUSIC
    @BOOMOPERAMUSIC Месяц назад +1

    Im sick of Ai... Library Iv been selling my music on for 12 years made changes to the agreements with the authors last year and just sold our entire content to these ai companies... nice hyh? a year later they sold the whole company to competition..

  • @snimacz
    @snimacz Месяц назад

    porażający deficyt inteligencji emocjonalnej projektuje nam przyszłość

  • @virtualbri
    @virtualbri 2 месяца назад +2

    Dartmouth should be embarrassed to have her as a graduate. Rip off actually creative people, spew it out as low quality hallucinations, sell it to corporations, and tell the creative people maybe you shouldn't have had the jobs in the first place. Monstrous.

  • @david-3172
    @david-3172 Месяц назад +3

    Maybe SHE shouldn't be there in first place.

  • @sevocher
    @sevocher Месяц назад +1

    mira murati is villain

  • @sillylilstella
    @sillylilstella 21 день назад

    i'm not gonna sugarcoat it: we need to get together and start destroying these AI data servers before this shit gets worse