Really? Her voice is amazingly beautiful, but I think that's the downside to it. In EV's much older shows she would be fighting to catch breath, but I think it was just because she was jumping around. In this one she sounded great because it was just one song and she wasn't jumping around. If you look at her newer shows she sounds FANTASTIC! I've went to three EV shows in my life, all for their three diff albums, and the one for the third album was definetly my favorite.
I remember seeing Seether play this live and Amy Lee wasn't there, so the audience had to sing her parts. It was a much more emotional experience but I would have preferred to hear her sing. She sounds great live.
This was such an awesome song back in the day, I listened to it so much, there will never be another like Amy Lee. Songs just don’t have this sort of weight anymore. Or maybe that’s my age.
Saw seether sing this with I think three days grace and it was so beautiful hearing 2 male voices do it. Amy Lee is such a beau singer, as bad as their relationship went we got some amazing music from it .
For those talking about Shaun fucking the song up, it's probably because more than likely he's hammered up. He was battling alcohol addiction during this time period so he'd probably been drinking before he came out. He usually sounds awesome.
My boyfriend turned me on to Seether and so many more great bands i dont know where i would be without this awesome band and i thank you Tommy Jules....
Hands down, both she and Seether made an undoubtably good song, I love how she comes in the 2nd verse making it more unique with different lyrics connected to the 1st, Amy Lee, you are so beautifully amazing and talented. And Seether too lol
Amy is beautiful. No single freaking doubt. She is more gorgeous than the models they have in magazines. And, unlike most singers, she can sing. And I mean SING. She's got a voice like an angel. I might get to see her in concert in a few days, and if I get to meet her, I might just die.
Its been so long since they came and sing this song together , i got chills back then for the first time i listened to this , and i still got chills every time i listen both singing this one ... I dont think that this music works well any other way then with these 2 amazing voices ... Love you Amy ;) ...
If music doesn't have a meaning or elicit a response then its not good music. The fact that all it took was one note from her shows how much it to you as a song. So no not at all.
I've met her twice, both times briefly after shows for the most recent album (which is fantastic live, by the way). She's *devastatingly* pretty in person. Absolutely gorgeous, even at the end of a tour after a two hour show, with little make up on and what looks like no sleep for a week. The coolest thing about her? How kind and humble she is. She really pours out her heart to her fans, and it shows. Hence why I was able to kiss her on the cheek with her husband standing right next to me. :p
Sure, she's changed, but what artist hasn't? She's still just as lovely, and her style hasn't changed all that much from what most people are used to. Love her anyway, if you're a fan. Support her.
Logan Priest Plenty of rappers who don't talk thuggish though. I'm a fan of Eminem, Joe Budden, Joell Ortiz and a bunch more. But those 3 I named, carry themselfs very well, they talk normal. And yes I know you mean the people that listen to it, but I don't talk like that at all, because I don't really listen to those kind of rappers.
Much love to Amy and your comment!!!!!!!!! xoxo Thank you for sharing ...I've been bitching about this 'stereotype cast' for too long.Amy is beautiful no matter what.. inside and out. She's an icon!!
They have some of the best singing voices. Even live they are incredible which is better than allot of bands singing live. Shaun has one of my favorite male singer voices. Amy Lee is definitely number one female singing voice. Her voice is just beautiful. Not to mention her herself
Yes Char... this was the first time I saw her in jeans. Everytime I've seen her perform she look goth but this was more casual... Very nice!! And not bad for live. Schecter guitars, rock on !!
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Amy's live singing is so damn perfect.. gosh, I love it! *-*
Really? Her voice is amazingly beautiful, but I think that's the downside to it. In EV's much older shows she would be fighting to catch breath, but I think it was just because she was jumping around. In this one she sounded great because it was just one song and she wasn't jumping around. If you look at her newer shows she sounds FANTASTIC! I've went to three EV shows in my life, all for their three diff albums, and the one for the third album was definetly my favorite.
It's surreal how good she sounds live on this song
@@CuteJemi I agree. She still moves around quite a bit but the jumping around came down and right away the vocals stabilised. Fantastic.
what makes perfect is when your listening while reading those comments. makes the era flashback
I remember seeing Seether play this live and Amy Lee wasn't there, so the audience had to sing her parts. It was a much more emotional experience but I would have preferred to hear her sing. She sounds great live.
please can I have a link of that? Im kinda obsessed with seether
She's like the perfect girl
Not like...She is the perfect girl
WHAT?! 2004? 10 years ago o.o Wow. I feel old. Great performance
20 yrs old😂
Actually, your comment is now 10 years old. Hope all is well.
How about another 10 plus years? :D
This was such an awesome song back in the day, I listened to it so much, there will never be another like Amy Lee. Songs just don’t have this sort of weight anymore. Or maybe that’s my age.
I love how she looks so hot when she dresses casually.Not all girls can pull off but beauty is whats on the inside.
Amy, I'm in awe. And Lzzy, too, she can belt.
Thank you.
The song about their break up. Amazing how it fits lots of our lives.
Amy Lee = Perfection!
This performance is undoubtly one of the best live performances I have found on RUclips
This song helps with my mom passing in 2012:, (
The harmonies are so raw, it's pure guts they're both using and it kicks so much ass
Awesome song one of my faves Amy Lee*
Saw seether sing this with I think three days grace and it was so beautiful hearing 2 male voices do it. Amy Lee is such a beau singer, as bad as their relationship went we got some amazing music from it .
great voice! and I 'm talking about Amy.
she rocked it foe shoo
Obviously this song is a showcase for her. Shes got some pipes for sure
Great performance they sound just as good live as on the actual track. Amy lee's voice is amazing love that girl!
Amy Lee is freakin awesome singer and this live version of broken is the best she probably the only artist I like to hear live
For those talking about Shaun fucking the song up, it's probably because more than likely he's hammered up. He was battling alcohol addiction during this time period so he'd probably been drinking before he came out. He usually sounds awesome.
wasn't this the reason they broke up?
nobody can sing like her. i mean nobody!!!!!!
My boyfriend turned me on to Seether and so many more great bands i dont know where i would be without this awesome band and i thank you Tommy Jules....
WHATS WRONG WITH THAT CROWD!? ONCE AMY HIT THAT STAGE YOU WOULDA HEARD ME FUCKING SCREAM!
I was wondering the same thing pffff .... losers they're sleeping
Agree with you man
because most the crowd there to hear metal. Soft rock just some break for them.
Hands down, both she and Seether made an undoubtably good song, I love how she comes in the 2nd verse making it more unique with different lyrics connected to the 1st, Amy Lee, you are so beautifully amazing and talented. And Seether too lol
I love the way the lead singer of Seether said "I wanna see your fucking hands in the air"
Amy is beautiful. No single freaking doubt. She is more gorgeous than the models they have in magazines. And, unlike most singers, she can sing. And I mean SING. She's got a voice like an angel. I might get to see her in concert in a few days, and if I get to meet her, I might just die.
moja śliczna Amy
widzę polska fanka Ev
Marta Kościńska
Tak :) \m/
marczi lee głębokie -.-
Its been so long since they came and sing this song together , i got chills back then for the first time i listened to this , and i still got chills every time i listen both singing this one ... I dont think that this music works well any other way then with these 2 amazing voices ... Love you Amy ;) ...
how beautiful is amy lee
and Amy Lee is one of few performers who actually sing great live..no lip syncing.
is it bad if when amy began her first note of her verse i immiediately started crying?
no. not at all. music is very emotional.
Actually I've said the same thing to a friend of mine, I suppose it's not that bad :D
When Amy starts singing, I really can't hold myself
If music doesn't have a meaning or elicit a response then its not good music. The fact that all it took was one note from her shows how much it to you as a song. So no not at all.
peterkray Go listen to your Justin Beiber and don't judge someone for listening to a song that has meaning to them.
No not bad but how you felt the need to post a comment telling us how you were crying is quite odd
I've met her twice, both times briefly after shows for the most recent album (which is fantastic live, by the way). She's *devastatingly* pretty in person. Absolutely gorgeous, even at the end of a tour after a two hour show, with little make up on and what looks like no sleep for a week.
The coolest thing about her? How kind and humble she is. She really pours out her heart to her fans, and it shows. Hence why I was able to kiss her on the cheek with her husband standing right next to me. :p
What the hell?!! Is that crowd sleeping or what?
Need more beer!
srsly ? 2004 seether playing in portugal for first time.. never heard about them since that day..!!
Yeah I would die if I was there lol
Amy Lee is not only extremely gorgeous, but my god the voice of an angel
I was expecting the crowd to just go apeshit when Amy stepped on stage... were they on Prozac?
She is absolute perfection! You people are insaaaaaaaaaaaane!!!!
am i the only one who thinks that she has changed???? :/
Sure, she's changed, but what artist hasn't? She's still just as lovely, and her style hasn't changed all that much from what most people are used to. Love her anyway, if you're a fan. Support her.
Now she's more ladylike, I think, but it isn't bad. Everybody grows.
considering it's been 10 years and she's not 22 anymore...i'd kind of expect some change
everyone changes
Everyone changes
I cant get this song out of my head ..........love it ,They Have great voice!
I feel like i. The only black person tnat listens to rock lol. Barely listen to rap
I know how you feel. I'm the only black guy that listens to rock at my school and I'm one of the few guys who listen to rock.
No bro you're not alone !
The only problem with people who listen to rap is that they start talking like them white or black and they sound trashy
fuck that,,,black or white is not important,,,all people are the same,,,
Logan Priest Plenty of rappers who don't talk thuggish though. I'm a fan of Eminem, Joe Budden, Joell Ortiz and a bunch more. But those 3 I named, carry themselfs very well, they talk normal.
And yes I know you mean the people that listen to it, but I don't talk like that at all, because I don't really listen to those kind of rappers.
She was so nervous and sang beautifully after all.
Love you eternally Amy 🖤🤘🏽
they sound bad :(,
I agree, they seem to be unusually slow and off key.
what? no they sound good to me....
maybe it's hard to sing or play live
live never sounds as good
Robin Fleming Mmmnope , see Avenged Sevenfold live in the LBC :)
seether and evanescence are my two favourite bands this was awesome!!!
Much love to Amy and your comment!!!!!!!!! xoxo Thank you for sharing ...I've been bitching about this 'stereotype cast' for too long.Amy is beautiful no matter what.. inside and out. She's an icon!!
i just cant stop hear this song Emylee is the most pure voice D:
ijust cant feel right when u gone away
What a great song during a breakup ...I love how they kept it together
this song never ever gets old! love love love it and I always will. so beautiful :)
♥♥ amy's voice is perfect ♡ in live and video *-* she's always perfect ♥
Seether gives me chill! One of the very few guys who actually have talent.
They have some of the best singing voices. Even live they are incredible which is better than allot of bands singing live. Shaun has one of my favorite male singer voices. Amy Lee is definitely number one female singing voice. Her voice is just beautiful. Not to mention her herself
This song gives me goose bumps, I hope Seether write another song and has Amy sing it with them. The collaboration here is fukin electric!! :) xx
My God THANK YOU!!!! I am short and built like a classic build!! I'm not skinny as a rail like most of these girls!
His voice is always like that. It fits his songs perfectly. Especially this song -.-
Amy Lee brings a whole new dimension to Seether.
amy lee é diva ainda com seether PERFEITO!!!
Amy's voice is like a cherry on a sundae: it makes the sundae perfect, as well for the concert! HER VOICE IS PERFECT!!
Major props to the drummer for wearing a DARE t-shirt in concert. That earned a load of respect from me.
Love this Song , so awesome !
Ohhh her voice live is as good as recorded. Insane. And dont get me started on how cute she is.
I loooooooove this song, their voices together freaking EPIC
She's so young yet so beautiful here... Love her
GOOSEBUMPS when amy starts singing!
Such an amazing performance.
gotta love rock songs featuring other artists and then seeing them live!!!!!! :D
Amy Lee is so freaking amazing!!!!! I LOVE her soooo much!!!
Amy Lee is perfection. Enough said
I just came back from an Evanescence show in my city... AMAZING.
She's effortlessly beautiful
Wow this is very clear definition for 2004! awesome
because of this song, i fell in love with Evanescence and seether
To much emotions gona explode and that Amy Lee live voice.. DAMN ^^
Both of their voices are fucking perfect live. Pure talent. You guys are amazing
I'm an Amy Lee fan. She was an ANGEL ^_^
Look how humble and adorable she was.
She still is ;D
She's absolutely stunningly beautiful.
perfect song with perfect singers.. I Like it so much
beautiful song. beautiful voices. beautiful music
Luv the song ! Nobody knows unless u been broken
Amy is beautiful. With that angelic voice....whew....
She is AWESOME live!!!! :-O holy crap!!!!
This song never gets old
just finished a tour with the biggest rock band of the last decade seems like a pretty good place to be... Seether is dope.
the worst is over now and we can breathe again ..... amy lee you are my angel i love you so much
her voice is amazing!!!!
omg, i miss this. feeling to many feels right now.
I bet everyone cheers when he announces what the song is because it means Amy Lee is coming onstage :D
best version ever of broken ... love this ex-couple
Amy Lee makes this song even more perfect
Rock is for the hurt, the broken, and anybody else who can handle it.
the cute clean voice together with that graspy voice is just meant to be.
even 10 years later she still looks great.
My favorite seether song of all time
NO WAY this song came out 10 years ago! Makes me feel old!
I can still remember that Amy Lee was my 1st crush ever of female rockers!
way back in 2000
AMY LEE IS GORGEOUS AND SO IS HER VOICE
There's only a billion other guys that can sing like Shaun, and a select few that can sing like Amy. Yeah, HE'S godlike.
Nossa ,a Amy é muito perfeita ! amo ela mais que tudo !!!
amy's style of dressing is just so awesome!
Amy is the best ! I will forever love her
MY FAVORITE SONG !!!
i love amy's voice sooo much
just makes me cry
Yes Char... this was the first time I saw her in jeans. Everytime I've seen her perform she look goth but this was more casual... Very nice!! And not bad for live. Schecter guitars, rock on !!
i love this song and amy lees voice is awesome
My favourite song. Makes me cry :c