i have finally realized why winwin is there in the music video. so basically, this girl comes along and is taeils first crush. she breaks his heart and winwin picks up the pieces afterwards. the she get with doyoung, she is happy with him through the video but winwin knows its gonna happen again and is waiting for it to. when we see him on the bus he is on his way to go comfort doyoung because it jumped to the future. then jaehyun is the boy she gets with in the future. he sees how taeil and doyoung look at her and know the same might happen to him but he cant help it. and so when he ends up with her and she subsequently breaks his heart winwin swoops in to save the day and comfort him. but what no one realizes is that winwin isnt alive or human. he is their gaurdian angel. taeil dies and thats how we see him on the bus. winwin has been watching over the three and trying to stop the same thing from happening to all three so he shows jaehyun in the form of dreams what he saw happen to doyoung and taeil to try and stop it from happening to him to. thats just my theory.
In nct I love the most is Taeil and bubu. But what happened today is really shocked me to the core. Now I cannot hear nct song like used to be anymore… 😢 Oh taeil what have you done. Your voice is literally give soul to every nct songs. In the future we cannot hear it again. Regards, momo. 😢
Imagine being nctzen since the smrookies era and after the 8 years hearing the news......I don't even have to imagine...... He has that talent why on earth he did that? I can't wrap my head around it
Taeil: The girl is from his past Doyoung: the girl is with him in the present Jaehyun: The girl is with him in the future Winwin: The girl will end up with him in the end, his true love.
kaiivee Omg finally a comment that is about Taeils visuals and with hundreds of likes 😭😭 Thought no one else except for a few others would recognize his beauty
But that started in 2018, he was innocent here (I'm never ever defending him) so I can listen to this freely. But I couldn't in walk😔 I couldn't watch the screen when it was his parts😔
Winwin is a time traveler. He observes the girls life with the other boys. That's why he only sits in the bus, he travels with it. PROBLEM FOR WINWIN SOLVED!
MY theories are like Taeil: The girl was with him in the past Doyoung:The girl is with him in the present Jaehyun: the girl is with him in the future Winwin: The guy that made it all happen
@@whiteribbon17 I think this would help. This is a theory of NCT's whole concept. NCT's Dream and Reality Concept Theory. It's pretty amazing and it matches pretty well. It explains about the connection with NCT units mv's also including wayv. NCT's first debut songs play a big part. The 7th sense and Without U mv. Here's the link to those who are interested and curious about the theory. ruclips.net/video/0-CRNE2U4jQ/видео.html And maybe winwin really is the boy from the nct commentary... We don't really know
My theory: So basically in the present Doyoung is with the girl 0:49 . The girl faces a disease 3:10 and has very less time to live so Doyoung stays with her to make her happy till her last moment. So taeil works in a restaurant 0:31 where Doyoung comes with the girl 1:52 . Taeil recalls that the girl was his childhood crush 1:56 , but the girl doesnt remember him cause of the disease she has. Now in the future, jaehyun time travels 1:24 to see the girl in the past which is the present 1:36 . (not to back) He sees that doyoung makes the girl happy in her last moments 1:31 . And he also sees that taeil sees her in the restaurant or cafe 2:03. Jaehyun sees all her lovely moments from birth to death as he sees also taeil's past with the girl. Jaehyun basically time travels in his dreams (as you can see him sleeping in 1:18 ). After the girl dies, she comes in the form of winwin in the after life bus 2:18 (as in the bus you don't see anything realistic from the window of the bus). Then u see taeil also entering the bus which means he also had died 2:16. And when taeil walk passes through winwin, he could feel that taeil was related to him/her. 2:23. as the girl was dying doyoung kept her happy and allowed her to do anything like tattoos 3:00. so......... edit: OMG THANKS FOR THIS MANY LIKED. I READ ALL THE COMMENTS AND YOU ALL ARE CALLING ME SMART OMG IM CRYING YOU ALL.
in 2:16 he was thinking of suicidal and then he arrived in the after life bus that's when Winwin (the other form of the girl in the mv as u said) appears and then they both recall memories of there life
its been 5 years since "without you" released, but the power that this song and this trio (+winwin) hold will always be remembered and legendary forever .
The fact that Winwin had more screentime here, and in boss he didn't have the screentime to feed his stans. Great song thou, vocals + visuals = yes! Taeil's highnote is everything
@@lalalandlalalala7428 I think it is from the videos of Nct Life in Osaka cause I heard this song from those videos, the intro of the Nct Life in Osaka.
I just became an nctzen last last week and damn I heard this song somewhere and heard Taeil's voice so I searched for it and now I'm addicted to it.. can't believe that this is their debut song this is so beautiful ㅠㅠ
I wish they make more music like this. It's very soothing and easy to listening. Also, it lets the vocal lines show how beautiful and powerful voices they have.
For real Winwin is the only idol who can debut even without a single line and that is why he is so ICONIC and just LEGENDARY. I mean, even Haechan who partly sang in 7th Sense wasn't in the MV like wow! Happy 8th Debut Anniversary NCT!!
@@taesanschocolate the 7th sense was released on april 9, 2016 and without you was released on april 10, 2016. they’re only a day apart, but technically, t7s was first. i’d say they debuted at the same time
Moon Taeil… it hurts so much. to think about the type of person i supported for so long… how i was praising your voice while another girl was terrified of hearing it… It hurts so much… why did you lie in our faces like nothing was happening? Do you not have any shame or remorse?
taeil you just wasted all this talent and threw everything away for nothing. your voice carries emotion but it all seem like a lie now. this is one of my favorite nct songs and idk if i should keep listening cuz i really like his voice. this is just really sad dude
Same. He was my ultimate bias in nct, I loved him and his voice so much, he was the best for me in nct. But now I'm so hurt, so betrayed, so disappointed that idk what to say. All these years I was hoping for his solo album but all we got was those news. I just can't listen to nct any more... 😢
Ya'll, NCT is on their way to becoming something big in the future, I can feel it. Netizens can hate on them all they want on social media, but NCT will prove themselves to the world. They're such a diverse group full of unique individuals and I feel blessed that I'm going to be able to watch all of them grow as artists and a group.
To me, the 7th sense and without you are still the best, maybe because at that time I was waiting for them to debut for so long that I felt so highhhhhhhhhh when they released these songs
Still remember 4years ago when NCT not famous like now . And now they really deserve nice treat from company , a lot of fans , more active . I'm literally crying after watching this again . they have been through a lot of obstacles since SM rookie but they never give up and keep making us happy . Lol I'm like parents who proud to my sons sorry for being so emotional
Have y’all seen the nct universe theories? I keep getting a feeling winwin is really important, like he’s a link between them all or something, bc he wasn’t just randomly on that bus, like maybe he’s a link between 127 and wayv? Idk just my thoughts
listening to this, i feel like crying, because i just feel so free, like i can do anything and not get judged by it? like..??? listening to this makes me feel genuinely happy and i just love it so much...
What I understand from this video: -Doyoung has a girlfriend who was Taeil's crush since he was young. -Jaehyun has a crush on Doyoung or Taeil but I personally think it's Doyoung. -Winwin for no reason is sitting in the train and looks at Taeil when he passes. (Does he have a crush on Taeil...? I'll have to investigate)
Not to mention several allusions to pulse rate and blood and injections. Taeil was probably in a fatal condition that needed blood transfer and the girl gave it to him while he fell in love during the process. That meant that literally half of taeil's heart is the girl and now he's living without her.
Thank you Taeil for the beautiful memories, i loved you, loved your sweet voice. But now we’re all disappointed in you and will not support you in the future.
Taeil: The girl is from his past
Doyoung: The girl is with him in the present
Jaehyun: The girl is with him in the future
Winwin: Is the girl
Best comment i've seen so far
Yes😍😍
이조안나 LMFAOOAJHAHAHA
Winwin crying look this theory 😂😂😂
@@oktavurirp1409 yes. This comment so fun🤣🤣
SM don't be shy, give NCT this kind of song again
Totally agree. I listen to it everyday for 4 years now.
Just no comment this song wooooow
Ikr
OMG PLS. THIS IS ONE OF MY FAV NCT SONGS OF ALL TIME🥺
Nah.. i agree with you..
Okay, so
Taeil: His Past
Doyoung: His Present
Jaehyun: His Future
Winwin: present, wonwon: past
SpringBreeze lmao
Lolll😂
lmao
very funny
Willwin: Future
This song is so underrated it's literally one of the best nct songs
Fr
Facts
I’m glad we share the same opinion
Literally
Just discovered it and I have to agree
Winwin was on a journey looking for his lines and that's why he looks so thoughtful on the bus.
I smiled :)
Maybe he’s part of this but he just has no lines
@@doker1154 🤔
so funny and sad at the same time
Not funny
So ... Doyoung has a girlfriend and Jaehyun likes the girl, then Taeil is the girl's childhood friend. then, winwin is a cameo sitting on the train.
and winwin is the girl ㅋ ㅋㅋㅋ
the plot twist HAHAHA
Winwin was the origin kid that's why
@@chochoyin9403 yess Winwin transitioned after that
Taeyong must have been there in place of that girl😂
SM we need more NCT Band songs.....
Plz SM.....
yes pleaseee
@@dimasavira8736 hope they make a nct unit that is band
Agreed
YESSSSSS
I think the same
7 years have passed and this is still my favorite NCT song
Cause this song is vibe of that years
нуы
i have finally realized why winwin is there in the music video. so basically, this girl comes along and is taeils first crush. she breaks his heart and winwin picks up the pieces afterwards. the she get with doyoung, she is happy with him through the video but winwin knows its gonna happen again and is waiting for it to. when we see him on the bus he is on his way to go comfort doyoung because it jumped to the future. then jaehyun is the boy she gets with in the future. he sees how taeil and doyoung look at her and know the same might happen to him but he cant help it. and so when he ends up with her and she subsequently breaks his heart winwin swoops in to save the day and comfort him. but what no one realizes is that winwin isnt alive or human. he is their gaurdian angel. taeil dies and thats how we see him on the bus. winwin has been watching over the three and trying to stop the same thing from happening to all three so he shows jaehyun in the form of dreams what he saw happen to doyoung and taeil to try and stop it from happening to him to. thats just my theory.
Oooohhhh I like this
Woah, you're genius one!
you are genius man ! i really like you !
This lowkey gave me chills- I like this thoery
This theory makes the most sense!!!
I hope no one's forgetting about this song, which is also their debut single.
i literally watch this mv everyday, it’s one of my favorite song’s.
@@lilyfragoso1971 me too
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
@@clairerose8674 b
@@arachan1421 c
4 years has passed and I'm still wondering why this is so underrated
facts
I love it.
TT
100% AGREE, this song deserves more
ikr i love this song sooo much
I always listen to this song because of you, taeil.. How could you waste such a beautiful voice by doing that.. why just why..
unpopular opinion: this is the best nct u song
one of the best
Agree! Alongside with Timeless and Coming Home.
Agreeee
agree this and yestoday are superior
Honestly that’s the tea ☕️
Who's still here even after the OT23 MV today??? Then ur a true NCTzen♡
Thanku for the likes guys. Let's support our boys♡
I’m here 💚
Not only today,i came here everyday
@@neofuturetechnology3540 same tho : )
i'm here :)
Proud to be here eventho im new to nct! 🤟🏻
Jaehyun is breathtaking. He's just so handsome.
Ley S ....right omg
no wonder he got awards to manipulated memories of first love haha
Ley S true
Well said 😊
He has actor vibes.
In nct I love the most is Taeil and bubu. But what happened today is really shocked me to the core. Now I cannot hear nct song like used to be anymore… 😢
Oh taeil what have you done. Your voice is literally give soul to every nct songs. In the future we cannot hear it again.
Regards, momo. 😢
the way nct u debuted with 7th sense and without you is just legendary
straight fact
agree
Beyond legendary💕
This proves that Taeil didn’t age and he’s 26 years old today
He looks frozen 24 to me
He looks like 24y.o and never get old again
Dang, he's a year younger than me lol. In other news, Jae from Day6 is my age! Yay for old people!
Teil is walking through the frozen time.
I mean 26yo is still pretty young :/
Past: Taeil
Present: Doyoung
Future: Jaehyun
Yuta's husband: Winwin
Lol yes
Yesss😂
Lol yes! :)
No
@@athifa822 ok
This was my comfort song, after what the incident happened recently. I can’t listen to this song the same way.
rhe nct nation in japan performance is just sung by kun, doyoung and jaehyun!
@@127moreadays yeah ik that
feel the same way here... and this is the third time I had a favorite song of mine change because well... Yeah
ONE BIG SIGH
Don’t let that criminal ruin this for you! Hope u will feel okay listening to ur fave songs again
Unpopular opinion - NCT needs more of such emotional but still upbeat and fast-paced pop rock songs.
I really hope this happens when NCT 2021 comes out
WE NEED MORE!!!!
I have keep coming back for this...
I feel like SM heard u ....
They need a collab with Day6 or a song written by YoungK
It’s really sad that most NCTzens don’t know that this song is also NCT U’s debut song.
The 7th Sense came out a day prior to, but yes.
okay now I know, thank you
But in the description of this song, the date is 10 April. The 7th sense came out on 9
@@ohdaddy1490 The 7th Sense was released a day prior to Without you but this is also NCT U's debut song.
@@gumxxi okie
fact: nct has one of the best vocalists in this industry.
very popular opinion i support it 😌
Fact
HOW IS THAT AND OPINION ITS STRAIGHT UP FACTS
Yeeeeeessss
Nct has the best of everything in the industry, la crème de la crème
Imagine being nctzen since the smrookies era and after the 8 years hearing the news......I don't even have to imagine...... He has that talent why on earth he did that? I can't wrap my head around it
Yeah, literally someone decent could've gotten his talent instead.
Taeil: The girl is from his past
Doyoung: the girl is with him in the present
Jaehyun: The girl is with him in the future
Winwin: The girl will end up with him in the end, his true love.
i was thinking the same
in the end the girl will end up witb Winwin and the three guys will all be broke
Because win-win don't sing n waiting at the bus with visual
i think winwin is a admirer
I think it's because win-win in someone that knows her plan and is on the bus to find the girl and stop her
THAT MAKES SENSE
Imagine if NCT make a band unit
Guitarist&bassist : Mark, Xiaojun
Vocalist : Doyoung/Taeil
Drummer : Hendery
Keyboardist : Taeil/Kun
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
Yes pleaseeee ㅜㅜ
yessssssssssss plssssssss
how about jaehyun? he is also a main vocal and can play keyboard
Rapper (if needed): Taeyong
Nearly 4 years passed and NCTzen's are still thinking about that Winwin who is staying on that bus since the MV begin
Winwin a grim reaper
Can relate
searching for his lines.
SONUNDA BİR TÜRK!!! ♡ ♡ ♡ ♡ ♡
*WINWIN IS OUR PRECIOUS GEM*
this is my first nct song so listening to it is like a time capsule ☹️ wish i could hear this live somedaaaay
Its not Taeil, Doyoung or Jaehyun who owned this era it was Sicheng.
uwu
mhm
With only visuals
In conclusion
King of visulas
Amen
yes, winwin owned this era even though he never even performed this song, 90% of the comments are all about him. The power of winwin indeed
taeil looks so good i just can't
agree!!!
Omg. Same 😫
He is soooooo pretty :'v
And his voice OMGieoiruiogfisdgfidghasTRIGGEREDhdsgdfjk (?)
kaiivee Omg finally a comment that is about Taeils visuals and with hundreds of likes 😭😭 Thought no one else except for a few others would recognize his beauty
my little brother said to me that if I repeat this song one more time he will smash my head in the keyboard I don't believe mdjfncnfjrddhfhffjej
the only theory that makes sense: the girl is actually winwin and they are all in love with him
thank you good bye
Omg your username
ayyy i spent so long coming up with it lmao
taeilgotmyback doyoungthings winwinonmymind xD
OML amazing haha
taeilgotmyback doyoungthings winwinonmymind
. I love your username
.
im gonna miss listening to this song the same way as i used to before
Same 💔
But that started in 2018, he was innocent here (I'm never ever defending him) so I can listen to this freely. But I couldn't in walk😔 I couldn't watch the screen when it was his parts😔
Theory:
Winwin has nothing to do with the plot in any way. Taeil just demanded that his crush gets put in the video for no reason.
Winwin was the one who stole Taeil away from the girl.
Wendy's not in the video though
I just
foreign swaggers LMAO
Shivani well dude, the original comment is or what, whats your problem
are you against shipping them or what
*PETITION FOR SM TO PUT JAEHYUN IN A K-DRAMA*
I AGREE
absolutley
please petition i will sign it.
nctzura IMAGINE THAT AHH
start it istg ill sign it eight times
Before i know nct i always through that he is an actor , lol
We know that...
Taeil:His Past
Doyoung:His Present
Jaehyun:His Future
Winwin:Going on a bus to sue SM 🤣
Welp that's right
NEO GOT MY BACK Yuta will remember that
Damn the MV predicts the future
Lmao
Lol 😂
I still think this is their best song and they have never lived up to this potential. I mean, this is top tier in all of SM.
agree
They have made better songs than this. Stop living in the past
@@jeelee3096 Can you recommend some?
@@jeelee3096no they didnt without you is something special…
i feel bad for kpop stans who didn’t know that this masterpiece exists
Fr. NCT is more than the "noise music" if only they stan 😏
@@justazy597 they dont even bother to listen to their bsides and they still have the audacity to call their discography like that ://
^
Same
nct stans*
The Holy Trinity of vocals
True af. They're my new religion
mariah carey is SH00K
Haechan is missing :(
천사
Ikr.
" Without You" is a poem
But NCTzens couldn't read her
she deserved so much better... still here everyday tho :))
Finally i've found someone share same thoughts with me. Thank you for this comment.
This is a long novel, everyone's to lazy to finish reading it.
true
이 뮤비 처음 들었을 때로 돌아가고 싶다 음악하고 싶었다면서 팬들 마음에 대못을 박냐 근데 이 노래 들으면 너무 좋으면서도 치가 떨린다
Doyoung: Without you
Teil: Without you
Jaehyun: Without you
Winwin: 👁️👄👁️
All three singing it for winwin ....
Win : Win 😭
Winwin no part :(
Yes...Teil...
Foul
years had passed but we can’t deny the fact that this song is still the best
...and the fact that yesterday they just added a new clip to this , I ... am lost for words >_<
love it!
@@MsJoanis98 What do you mean? To the music video, I thought you had to delete a video to edit it.
@@kayleemckinney8742 I meant the "can't live without you" video (which showed clips of their behind the scenes stuff ^-^
@@MsJoanis98 Okay, I know about that I was just confused. Thank you.
I love it but I love FIMLS more.
*ONE OF THE MOST UNDER APPRECIATED SONGS EVER I'M TELLING YOU THIS IS ART*
Rhiannon Edwards IKR! I JUST FOUND OUT THIS SONG AND THIS IS REALLY MASTERPIECE! THEIR VOCAL IS NO TALK
*COMPLETELY AGREE*
This song gave me DAY6 vibes, and I love DAY6 this is the best NCT song, along with Limitless.
AGREE
True that!!!
Gonna miss this vocal trio. Y'all would have went far
they are the perfect trio, why SM didn't keep this trio and why didn't include taeil in the fixed trio subunit😢
I just heard Timeless from this same trio, but I am sure you already know that song as well.
Winwin is the girl. No wonder Taeil, Jaehyun and Doyoung are so whipped towards Winwin
lmao lucas should have debuted in this unit along with mark too 😂
I love this comment🤧
Yuta too
HAHAHA
Hahahahaha now I know
Winwin is a time traveler. He observes the girls life with the other boys. That's why he only sits in the bus, he travels with it. PROBLEM FOR WINWIN SOLVED!
I can’t believe Winwin is miss frizzle now haha
woow
We be formulating our own theories hahahah . Lets just put it that way , it made more sense 😂
Sounds legit to me
I'll go with this theory. lol
MY theories are like
Taeil: The girl was with him in the past
Doyoung:The girl is with him in the present
Jaehyun: the girl is with him in the future
Winwin: The guy that made it all happen
I read your comments and it's give a goosebumps 😨 some agree with you
Yes
But how 😂😂 Winwin is just there
@@whiteribbon17 I think this would help. This is a theory of NCT's whole concept. NCT's Dream and Reality Concept Theory. It's pretty amazing and it matches pretty well. It explains about the connection with NCT units mv's also including wayv. NCT's first debut songs play a big part. The 7th sense and Without U mv.
Here's the link to those who are interested and curious about the theory.
ruclips.net/video/0-CRNE2U4jQ/видео.html
And maybe winwin really is the boy from the nct commentary... We don't really know
@@sunnynahceah2435 honestly I don't remember writing that but omg you're an angel tysm. I'll definitely will watch it :)
he who shall not be named will never ruin this song for me.
Kyuhyun Ryeowook Yesung - Chen D.O Baekhyun - Taeil Doyoung Jaehyun
SM has the best vocalists.
You forget Jonghyun (SHINee) and Max (TVXQ) 😭
+Jessica Jung Sooyeon yeah
Add to that Onew & Jonghyun from Shinee
+ nct127/dream Haechan!!
Nct has many best vocalist dooyong, jaehyun, taeil, chenle, heechan, kun
SM has succeed in creating an MV more (aestheticly) confusing than Love Me Right and 4 Walls
lmfao
4 walls is more confusing tho
Laserfloating LOL I added that in!
Dumb Dumb was confusing as fuck too 😭
😂
My theory:
So basically in the present Doyoung is with the girl 0:49 . The girl faces a disease 3:10 and has very less time to live so Doyoung stays with her to make her happy till her last moment. So taeil works in a restaurant 0:31 where Doyoung comes with the girl 1:52 . Taeil recalls that the girl was his childhood crush 1:56 , but the girl doesnt remember him cause of the disease she has. Now in the future, jaehyun time travels 1:24 to see the girl in the past which is the present 1:36 . (not to back) He sees that doyoung makes the girl happy in her last moments 1:31 . And he also sees that taeil sees her in the restaurant or cafe 2:03. Jaehyun sees all her lovely moments from birth to death as he sees also taeil's past with the girl. Jaehyun basically time travels in his dreams (as you can see him sleeping in 1:18 ). After the girl dies, she comes in the form of winwin in the after life bus 2:18 (as in the bus you don't see anything realistic from the window of the bus). Then u see taeil also entering the bus which means he also had died 2:16. And when taeil walk passes through winwin, he could feel that taeil was related to him/her. 2:23. as the girl was dying doyoung kept her happy and allowed her to do anything like tattoos 3:00.
so.........
edit: OMG THANKS FOR THIS MANY LIKED. I READ ALL THE COMMENTS AND YOU ALL ARE CALLING ME SMART OMG IM CRYING YOU ALL.
Thats a good theory :)
And this is how we find out that some people on this earth are raelly smart
and that is how SM get their their comeback ideas.
from creative people like u
in 2:16 he was thinking of suicidal and then he arrived in the after life bus that's when Winwin (the other form of the girl in the mv as u said) appears and then they both recall memories of there life
Pin this comment already
People tend to forget that this is one of NCT U's best songs!!
SM REALLY LOVES TUMBLR
LoL,WHY??..
ikr 😂
hahahah xD
looks how aesthetics those mvs are nowadays XD
whahahha
nct 2020 pls give us another legendary song like this pls
From home
True that
They don’t make songs like this anymore ...
@@yukihei3971 yes I really love such kind of songs
@@yukihei3971 from home crying at the Conner
I’m going to leave this comment too so when someone like this I will be reminded to watch this masterpiece again.
Oops here you go again lol
@@cornonadacob so don't do
@@cornonadacob on my account sometimes notify, if i have too much likes yt stops sending me. But for comments always
Don’t forget to listen to this masterpiece today! Lol
♡
its been 5 years since "without you" released, but the power that this song and this trio (+winwin) hold will always be remembered and legendary forever .
Also with Kun in the chinese version ^^
This song makes you wanna have a good roadtrip.
Definitely
+Reino Bualat I'd love to play it in the car at full volume :O3
It's going to be a long ass ride though
+Mikkie Zhao That's my favorite part from 7th sense lol
+Mikkie Zhao 😂
The fact that Winwin had more screentime here, and in boss he didn't have the screentime to feed his stans. Great song thou, vocals + visuals = yes! Taeil's highnote is everything
Why Park Jisung if you can Drive Jisung idk why this song sounds familiar to me,or maybe I've heard it in a video...idk guys...
your username..
I swear I am getting angry just because of the bad joke
@@lalalandlalalala7428 I think it is from the videos of Nct Life in Osaka cause I heard this song from those videos, the intro of the Nct Life in Osaka.
your nickname 😂 so damn on point! 😂
I still haven't opened my rice and they've already released a new song.
😂😂😂
Omg ahhagagahah
HAHQHAHQHAHAHAH Hali open ur rice now! XD
this made my day
+FXBLous Ph yess
Taeil you just succeed with make all my fav song just painn
unpopular opinion: TAEIL THE BEST VOCAL WITH GREAT ACTING SKILL. STAN THIS OPPA
-sm he deserves more screentime
btw...we have the same name...Karina
ACCURATE
ACCURATE
yess!!!
I'm so disapointed at nctzens for not apreciating the absolute marterpiece that this song is
Maybe they don't know this song. Sad :(
Same :( I kinda come here and comment almost everyday lmao but this song is a gem
I just became an nctzen last last week and damn I heard this song somewhere and heard Taeil's voice so I searched for it and now I'm addicted to it.. can't believe that this is their debut song this is so beautiful ㅠㅠ
Newbie nctzen here♥️
i just know this song just now T_T hope nctzens always use this song when they make a nct vd and put the song title .
ok but taeil's acting skills here is no jokee!
ikrr
YES! SAY IT LOUDER! TAEIL ACTOR! 💚💚💚
IKR HE MADE ME FEEL SAD IT FELT REALT
Yes he’s so handsome
Yeeees i also thought that! I want him in a drama so bad
i hope nct released song like this vibe again plisss
My theory: win-win is actually a part of this song... except SM didn't give him any lines.
He's pretty much a backup vocal in NCT127... My theory is, Winwin is a backup Visual in this MV😂😂😂
Shruthi Muruganandam like in every Song
:,)
LOOL-
Winwin is another additional for this song for Chinesse Version
I wish they make more music like this. It's very soothing and easy to listening. Also, it lets the vocal lines show how beautiful and powerful voices they have.
agree
i think they have like these on some of their b-sides. but tbh this is one of the songs that I like in this group
SM NEEDS TO MAKE NCT THE BALLAD
Agree!
surapat pattamanawin AGREED
3 minutes of silence for people who think that NCT have only 3 members.
NOOO
HAHSHSHAJSHA LMAO
“have a normal numbered group or draw 20”
sme:
you mean (2)3?^
@@taha_t yeah that's what I mean 😂🤣
For real Winwin is the only idol who can debut even without a single line and that is why he is so ICONIC and just LEGENDARY. I mean, even Haechan who partly sang in 7th Sense wasn't in the MV like wow! Happy 8th Debut Anniversary NCT!!
i seriously fell in love with taeil after i heard this live
SAMEEEEE
his voice is my favorite so far out of the group. 😍
i love both jaehyun and Taeil's voice
Same here
sameeee fam
never forget that "without you" is also one of NCT's superior debut song
exactly
I thought the 7th sense was their debut song, I'm so confused XD
@@taesanschocolate the 7th sense was released on april 9, 2016 and without you was released on april 10, 2016. they’re only a day apart, but technically, t7s was first. i’d say they debuted at the same time
@@michelle0945 Oh, okay
They gave them the best debut song actually out of all the sm group artists. It’s more relatable to souls
THIS IS ART
...
ความทรงจํา ที่เเสนจะธรรมดา
もう太郎. バトスピ千反田 ただし
BOOMING SYSTEM UH UH TY TRACK TY TRACK
YES QUEEN/KING/GENDERLESS ROYAL BEING
Amén amics
Moon Taeil… it hurts so much. to think about the type of person i supported for so long… how i was praising your voice while another girl was terrified of hearing it… It hurts so much… why did you lie in our faces like nothing was happening? Do you not have any shame or remorse?
this looks like the trailer to a bomb ass drama
Janessa Moss omg yasss
YESS OMLLL . TOOK THE WORDS RIGHT OUTTA MAH HART ❤
Well... They used it for their reality show, NCT Life :)
i would watch that entire thing in one night
I watched the first two seasons in one night 😂
Ok, taeil's voice is perfect, but... we need to talk about his visuals cuz yall are sleeping on it, and he's a snack and a half!
fr HE'S SO PRETTY and he's a full course meal ngl
BOI BE SLAYINGGGG I MEAN HE AIN'T EVEN GOT A BAD ANGLE!!! WE STANNNN
This song is like 2000s music and I'm loving it. Emotional and happy.
Same, it's hard to find song like this for now era
same..
1:25
taeil you just wasted all this talent and threw everything away for nothing. your voice carries emotion but it all seem like a lie now. this is one of my favorite nct songs and idk if i should keep listening cuz i really like his voice. this is just really sad dude
Same. He was my ultimate bias in nct, I loved him and his voice so much, he was the best for me in nct. But now I'm so hurt, so betrayed, so disappointed that idk what to say. All these years I was hoping for his solo album but all we got was those news. I just can't listen to nct any more... 😢
This is still my favourite NCT music video, it’s gorgeous. Moon Taeil’s styling was perfect, he’s perfect..
As should queen
Ikr
I'm fall in love with taeil because this song. And pick taeil my bias in nct since him debut
@@tasya_925 You aren't alone (◍•ᴗ•◍)❤
Why isn't anyone talking about Doyoung?? He's such a cutie and his voice here is golden!!
Ikr! He is one of my fav. I can't choose between taeil,do young,renjun and chenle
His voice is gold! My baby 😍😳
he's precious no doubt
Yeah❤️
Vroom Vroom talk show boiiii 😂😂😂😂
Okay it’s already passed 3 years and i’m still giving plot twist
Plot twist: it’s not taeil, jaehyun, or doyoung singing, it’s winwin
Slsksjajsks lmao I hope soo
i always cry listening to this. plus he's the one that got me into nct. and now...
THIS IS THE HOLY SONG THAT MADE ME STAN 18 PEOPLE WOW
yixing’s left ear sameeee
Same
SAME
Same
*21
This is just.. Really good music? Gives me Day6 vibes. I love them.
YES
same!!
very good music
agreed
I really want a cover of this song by Day6 :)))
Ya'll, NCT is on their way to becoming something big in the future, I can feel it. Netizens can hate on them all they want on social media, but NCT will prove themselves to the world. They're such a diverse group full of unique individuals and I feel blessed that I'm going to be able to watch all of them grow as artists and a group.
I believe that they will become big in the future. All boys are so talent
chenkins absolutely agree👍👍👍👍
chenkins
Why do netizens hate them?
Nothing_Too_Sea Here because of taeyong issue
STILL?!
I hope SM will give NCT this kind of song again, WE NEED TO HEAR THIS KIND AGAIN!!!
4 years and I'm still here... wonder why this song is not popular yet!
Still the best NCT song!
@@WeazelNewsLucid same but also i still wonder what tf was doing winwin in the train😔
Its like antique... its old but gold...and people are tasteless...thats why i hate hoomans
To me, the 7th sense and without you are still the best, maybe because at that time I was waiting for them to debut for so long that I felt so highhhhhhhhhh when they released these songs
okAY BUT WHY DOES NO ONE TALKS ABOUT THE AESTHETICS OF THIS MV?? LIKE, FOR REAL??? PLUS 4 YEARS LATER THIS SONG STILL SLAPS----
When you realize that my boi Winwin has more screentime here than their latest comeback
+Nonaly loves to sleep
ISTG I was so annoyed
Nonaly loves to sleep
:'v
Duele lo que hizo Taeil, pero su voz y sus lines son tan icónicas que difícilmente pueden ser reemplazadas
*TBH THIS IS ONE OF THOSE UNDERRATED SONGS IN THE KPOP INDUSTRY LIKE HEY THIS SONG IS GOLD*
THEIR VOICES TOGETHER ARE SO GOOD LIKE AGHSNEMD
Still remember 4years ago when NCT not famous like now . And now they really deserve nice treat from company , a lot of fans , more active . I'm literally crying after watching this again . they have been through a lot of obstacles since SM rookie but they never give up and keep making us happy . Lol I'm like parents who proud to my sons sorry for being so emotional
Then they performed at last stage THO, have a daesang and got high rank for brand reputation
Dont make me cry... I just come back today because i miss them so much... I remembered when i was listenned to this in the bus to get home
Literally , became nctzens 3 years ago because of jinjido. And I literally listened all of their song.
@æspa winter fanboy nya ikw hawd k? pataka rkag yawyaw draa ha
@æspa winter fanboy
double million sellers suck? well babe u have no taste at all, thanks for coming to this vid and giving us views tho
Have y’all seen the nct universe theories? I keep getting a feeling winwin is really important, like he’s a link between them all or something, bc he wasn’t just randomly on that bus, like maybe he’s a link between 127 and wayv? Idk just my thoughts
Yes he connects nct units. He was even present in 1st nct origin video. His face and taeyong eyes
It was similar on Winwin's situation but actually not
Wish someone made something like this again in kpop...
When I listen to this song... idk how to explain it but I feel like crying? Not out of sadness, but the song is so... anyone get me?
you found it beautiful? yeah, i got you there dear
Yea thats the right word thanks TvT
listening to this, i feel like crying, because i just feel so free, like i can do anything and not get judged by it? like..??? listening to this makes me feel genuinely happy and i just love it so much...
I know right TvT it's been a while since a song so moving was made to me
I FEEL YOUU
it's been five years since this masterpiece was released, and yet it never gets old.
What I understand from this video:
-Doyoung has a girlfriend who was Taeil's crush since he was young.
-Jaehyun has a crush on Doyoung or Taeil but I personally think it's Doyoung.
-Winwin for no reason is sitting in the train and looks at Taeil when he passes. (Does he have a crush on Taeil...? I'll have to investigate)
Taeil randomly screams songs, why wouldn't Winwin be like "wtf dude"
Not to mention several allusions to pulse rate and blood and injections. Taeil was probably in a fatal condition that needed blood transfer and the girl gave it to him while he fell in love during the process. That meant that literally half of taeil's heart is the girl and now he's living without her.
Jonas Amante Awwww
This just leave one question: WTH is Winwin doing there??? I know that Taeil love him but is not "bring your love to work" day... hahahaha
Sumaiya Hasany I THOUGHT THIS IS REAL AHAHAHHA
Thank you Taeil for the beautiful memories, i loved you, loved your sweet voice. But now we’re all disappointed in you and will not support you in the future.
A wild WinWin has appeared
catch him
@@heavenliight9324 dayum. Wish i could 😂😂
Sunnshine !
Did he get lines in this one?
2016: Without you
2020: Can't live without you
No one:
Literary no one:
Not even chittaphrrr:
*Nctzens: it’s been 4 years, why is winwin on the bus*
Not even chittaperrr 😂
Looking for his lines
@@tangoiceblast1291 y
you better say sorry to winwin AHAHAHAHAHA
@@chazzzrom3873 SM should be the one saying sorry to Winwin, justice for winwin and renjun lol
maybe he took the bus out of 127 and into wayv
Without you will always be the queen of all nct u songs. Now give this 100m views pls