Did PhD Student Plan the Perfect Murder to Gain Infamy? | Bryan Christopher Kohberger Case Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- This video answers the question: Can I offer an update on the Idaho quadruple murder case including the arrest of Bryan Christopher Kohberger?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/...
References:
www.nbcnews.co...
www.idahostate...
www.cbsnews.co...
www.dailymail....
www.foxnews.co...
I am absolutely astounded that none of the internet psychics found Brian. Their magical powers must be waning.
😆🤣 I agree Derek but what do you want to bet the Psychics will come back with some explanation!
@@Andre-cr7sv Their crystal-balls ran out of batteries.
I drink paint thinner!
🤣😂🤣😂 That was hilarious, tysm!!!
Reminds me of that Southpark episode where Cartman becomes a “psychic detective” 😂
Hi Dr. Grande. I fell asleep listening to you one night last week. I dreamed that we were working together at an Ohio State research facility (I'm an alum, so no surprise there!) and we got in this huge argument! I was telling you "Just diagnose him! He needs help!" And you replied, "I'm not diagnosing anybody. I. ONLY. SPECULATE." Lol... sorry I know it's off topic but I wanted to tell you that. I hope you see this. I'm a big fan who has been with you since 200k.
LOLOLOLOL
Happy New Year!!!
@@Surge_LaChance Happy New Year to you, friend! 💜⭐🎈😃
Hilarious! 😆
this is great
thirsty
I was also a social reject and was rejected brutally, I was also abused at home, but I decided I didn't like being treated that way and would never want to do it to anyone else. There's always more to it than how a person is treated, there's more going on with the person themselves.
Give in to your anger....and your journey towards the dark side will be complete!
-the Troll
Exactly. If anything it's given me more sympathy.
You transformed negative energy into positive. Men behave different too, more rage and tend to be more aggressive.
Shockingly, not every human being is the same or reacts to situations in the same way you did.
@@dianaprince3176 if they did, there would be no violence to not react with violence to…
Did you notice that he got that seatbelt citation about 5 minutes from the girls’ house, at 11:40 at night, less than three months before the murders?
It was a campus community. Almost everywhere there is less than 5 minutes from each other. Great connection and point out though!
Yes. Because he himself lived 10 minutes from the girls house.
And 5 minutes away from his home.
5 minutes is a long time when we're talking about a town of 6.9 square miles. You could drive over half the length of the entire town in 5 minutes. If you're driving 35 an hour you can traverse the entire town in 11 minutes.
@@kylewinkler9925, @kevintroy4329
he lived 10 MILES away across the ID/WA stateline in a different town & a different state college campus. The towns themselves r 15 minute drive apart
He has a vegan diet, and 2 of the victims worked at a well known vegan restaurant in Moscow.
this could be very relevant!
Good tip for detectives
I think he followed 2 of them on Instagram.
Stalking was admitted in court by prosecutor to be false days ago
Brain deprived of fats and the body protein
Please keep analyzing this future case and the events that surround this. Thank you.
Yes! I value Dr Grandes perspective
Was the dude not a vegan?
@@citizenjournalist2533 He was an obsessed vegan, in fact, he made his parents buy new pots. I feel bad for his parents. I wonder if he did others. He went to a bar in Bethlehem, went to two Allentown schools. I am happy they got him.
@@melindaaimeeroth5580 that's what I thought and I'm wondering why Todd didn't mention this in the video.
@@citizenjournalist2533 I don't think he listens to the youtubes, he has just begun to evaluate this prisoner, and I look forward to his assessment, that and the ne'er do well Harry who gave up his country and position for a sociopathic narcissist.
When I was in college in late 80s, I briefly dated a girl who was a Psych major. Based on that one short relationship and subsequent experiences, I developed a theory that a large number of folks like her only entered into the Psych field to fix their own issues. I see parallels here.
I did that 😂
But thats kind of natural, isnt it?
@@tazerdemt7354 normal if you psycho!🤦
That's not a new concept. It's actually a proven fact.
I am 40 years old and a Psych graduate and it's true 😂
Knowing how to demonstrate empathy can be learned. But the actual ability to empathize, to actually feel compassion for another, is an entirely different ability.
It will be interesting if anymore unsolved cases get linked to this case.
Wouldn't surprise me if he had killed before. I doubt most killers or serial killers start out with 4 victims in one go.
@@Colstonewall Pat Brown a well known profiler did a first pass profile on youtube, saying he is most likely a Spree killer ( like a school shooter), vs serial killer. Out for the big experience and attention to his act.
@@Colstonewall Good thing you aren’t in charge of investigations
Doubtful he had killed before. Other than the amount of victims in one place, all other indicators are a targeted attack. Would've been much scarier was he more methodical and worked up to a level of multiple victims with each consecutive murder. But in reality, he not very good at getting away. Left a lot of evidence behind. He must've been spitting bricks over the white Elantra, surprised he didn't try to get rid of it. Although, I guess no one in this country has sold one for over the last month or so to anybody.
They found a butchered dog, gutted and skinned hanging on a fence near the kids’ house a couple of weeks before the murder!! Never make me believe he didn’t do that too!!!
Rest In Peace to the young lives that were taken. The holidays must be so hard for the families and I sincerely wish them peace.
Their Christmas was completely ruined by the death of their loved ones.
The neighbors probably appreciated him
@@Handlebrake2 you’re sick person
Take a break you absolute legend, you deserve it. Happy New Years Dr. Grande and thank you for all the top tier content throughout the year!! ❤️✌🏻
He’s definitely a legend, for sure!
Don't you think 'Grande' is an arrogant name (especially for a psychologist)
@@random19911004 Is your brain broken? That's a weird to say.
@@random19911004
Grow up!
That was a pretty good analysis, but the police are holding information from the public, as they should to protect the case, so there is a lot we still do not know. After more comes out about this suspect I would like to hear you do another analysis and possibly comparing it to your present analysis. Thank you.. God Bless.
Thank you Dr. G. This particular case is absolutely heartbreaking on so many levels. It is always evident in your videos that you strive to provide the highest quality in content.
Wishing you a very Happy New Year!
It is heartbreaking 💔. I think of their horror & demise, then the parent’s nightmare forever. My brother was murdered 40 years ago & it’s never over, questions never answered 😢
@@Taluta394I am so sorry for the needless death of your brother. The death of a loved one is always difficult, but to lose a loved one through homicidal violence must feel unbearable even forty years removed. The pain may soften somewhat, but would never be forgotten. For that reason, I hate when people use the term "closure" as there would never come a point where one could simply check off the grief as being complete.
Sending a big virtual hug.
@@Taluta394 💜🙏🏼
@@MM-gd1dw 👏💔🙏
@@Taluta394 😢
I was gonna watch the news coverage but I thought "nah I'll just wait for Dr Grande to cover it" 😊 Happy New Year to you and yours Dr! God bless and keep you
He did an earlier video about this as well. It's good. Check it out!
Facts 💯
You nailed it. 100%. Hope you continue with this case for us. Valuable insights. Thank you.
4 feleony counts of murder and 1 felony burglary....thats the equivilant of the sunny corleone hit.....they shoot him 1000 times the 1 guy comes up to him and kicks his face
Not really. He knew he would be caught as soon as he cut himself at the crime scene and saw that they were looking for his car.
It's amazing how far off the criminal profilers often are.
OH really? Why didn't he just torch the house? I would think that if the mob would torch a house that contained murdered bodies, a criminology major would know to do the same thing. So he didn't use his knowledge of criminology to plan the murders. He acted impulsively. He continued to act impulsively and didn't use his knowledge of criminology to get away with committing the murders. Apparently, he didn't even use his knowledge criminology to clean his car of the evidence,aybe he did. We have known it for weeks that they saw his car. Let's see how this all plays out. Let's hope this gets to a trial in about 3 years.
@@jeffk464 off? The only thing Dr. Grande can "legally" discuss is what the criminal profilers permit. It's up to Dr. Grande to create "interesting" material for the YT world, from there.
I appreciate your insight. This is a frightening case because it shakes our perceptions of who may perpetrate this kind of crime. Most everyone will die effectively anonymous to the world. The infamy this kind of person seeks is a peculiarly toxic form of narcissism that views others only as tools to be used and discarded. What scares me is that this has become common in our day and age.
Exactly
And now we know bk is innocent, and the real killers are long gone ☄️
@@y2y66 He is still the main suspect and will be tried for the murders, and rightfully so. There haven't been any developments that we know of that he's "now innocent".
@@leni0210 he's 💯% innocent
@@y2y66 Sure, dream on.
Happy New Year, Dr. Grande! Thank you for your steadfast and unwavering dedication to provide informative and interesting content for your listeners in 2022. 👍
Glad they got him.
This is a terrible crime.
He brought so much misery.
I hate to say it, but he’s innocent until proven guilty. At this point we can only hope they got the right guy
@@nathanr4633 Exactly!
oh well lol
What makes this crime more terrible than otter murders?
@@donaldvonglitchenberger4108 who said it was?
I was so hoping that you would quickly do an analysis of him. Thank you for not letting us down
These serial killers cant hide the madness in their eyes!👁
Yes. He looks manic. Possessed. Clearly sick.
I liked the video not because of the killer but because you are a great storyteller and factual. Thank you
This guy sounds like a robot or a serial killer himself. You got to be kidding, right?
Why did you have to clarify that? 🤔 who actually likes the killer?
Thank you for clarifying that
@@Makinbaconpancakes913 I like the killer. So do you. He has given us all a story to follow and content creators a chance to make a profit. Murder is a for profit business just like anything else. In a few weeks you'll be bored of this story and you'll be following another tragic death.
@@Thizzamajig you are so edgy. Grow up, it is very cringey to read this Joker-esque, pseudointellectual take.
As usual, a very thoughtful, concise and interesting breakdown.
These type of videos are so intriguing
Totally agree!!
Yes... no waffle. Getting to the point.
Happy New Years Doc .. all the best for 2023.
Why does no one bring up the possibility that, if guilty, the murders may not be his first.
Because that's just pure speculation at this point. One step at a time.
I dont think they are his first. that's a big step to go right to killing 4. check Washington, Idaho and PA for unsolved murders probably women.
That is a great poin, for some reason everyone including myself think it is his first kill!
Maybe not...but he sure made enough mistakes on this one. Seems like he would have been caught on any earlier ones? Maybe he started with rapes or animal torture? I'm sure we'll find out more as time goes by. I'm glad he's in custody, and I hope there weren't earlier murders.
Oh, I am sure they are looking into this! He surely wasn't too smart, considering his studying criminology! That's why I think he might not have minded being caught! No one paid attention to him as a strange and odd human that had a hard time fitting in, but Now...everyone knows his name and face!
I'll be very curious to learn whether any of the criminology professors that have encountered Bryan over the years ever noted any red flags, whether they raised any official concerns, and if so, what was done about it.
You are my"go-to" for this case. No bias, just facts and analysis. Dr. Grande, you are the GOAT!!!!!
You don't plan the perfect murder by DRIVING YOUR OWN CAR TO THE CRIME SCENE ... this guy was about as sharp as a bowling ball
It’s bizarre to see a channel you watch often talk about the girls you graduated from high school with. Hearing your small town talked about nationally on tv and on RUclips is strange. Kaylee and Maddie were in a lot of my high school classes. I was never close with them, but I knew their faces and their names and their laughter. I was set to attend U of I and live on their campus this fall semester, but I changed my mind at the last minute. This has been a heartbreaking case that has shaken our community. I can’t even describe how awful it feels to see so many people online who never knew these kids speculate and accuse so freely. Thank you for covering this in an unbiased manner.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts so eloquently! My deepest condolences on the loss and pain the victims' families and your community have had to endure. 😢💞🕊
Did they grow up in the same town this happened? I thought most college students went to school in other towns?
People tend to ignore the different or oddball characters. More supervision for these guys for sure. Would love to know what his teachers are thin king about now.
The same thing happened with me my former teacher was killed by another one it made national news. Things like that hit different when it's people you knew.
Happy New Year Dr Grande! 🎉 Thank you so much for covering this. There is a plethora of videos at the moment analysing this case and individual, obviously, but I always look forward to your analysis of high profile cases. Measured and not caught up in the hysteria. All the best for 2023. 😊 Can't wait to see what else you have in store for us.
I’m so tired of ppl giving these disgusting murderers the excuse of “being brutally rejected by their peers” so we could sympathize with these psychos, they are sick in the head and are attention seekers. So many other people have been bullied or worse and they don’t go out and MURDER innocent people. He needs to be put in isolation for the rest of his miserable life. May the souls that were taken too soon rest in paradise.
Yes, this one is truly insecure and unsupervised. Very ill and scary to be roaming around out there. I would freak out if this was one of my relatives.
As soon as I saw they made the arrest I thought "I can't wait to see the case covered on Dr. Grande's channel." Great video as always & happy new year!
I had a dream I was hitting the dougie with Soulja boy
My guess had been that an incel did this crime. And I still think he must have had a run-in with them in which he was rejected.
I went to college in Moscow. Lived really close to where this happened. This case is so heartbreaking, I’m so glad they caught him. You never really know what kind of people you’re dealing with… it’s so terrifying. Lock your doors lock your doors lock your doors!
👍
Wrong guy, he is a skinny vegan. This is your future learn to love it.... THREADS
@@dragonflydreamer7658 you've commented the same thing three times what do you mean by this?
@@idonhaveanyideawhattocallm1472 No idea. It's funny when people try to communicate but refuse to speak clearly in a way that makes sense to the majority of viewers. I'm just going to assume they have an obsession with knitting. What else would threads be for?
@@dragonflydreamer7658 No, he was tall and in shape.
I’m sure he doesn’t even care he got caught. He ruined four extended families and went on to celebrate his birthday, Thanksgiving and Christmas with no remorse. Not to mention he finished his school semester. If he is guilty, he definitely did it for the recognition and social media will solidify that. Don’t attack the messenger.
He is a spree killer, not a serial killer according to profilers, so you are right, fame and Infamy!
He’s probably killed before.
He's a mass murderer
he sounded very immature, narcissistic
@@beaulieuc8910 ...this is what this country is intentionally creating.
Imagine what those students are feeling now
after discovering they sat with him in the same classroom while
discussing this event ‘before’ he was arrested.
Just speculating, but Brian must have been near exploding with enthusiasm
while withholding all the knowledge of the crime.
Psychopaths don't have feelings and are totally perplexed by shows of enthusiasm. They have to teach themselves how to imitate shows of excitement, sorrow and all other emotions because they don't understand them at all. They are also fearless for the same reason.
Only one of 19,000 tips paid off…stay aware folks…
Wrong guy, he is a skinny vegan. This is your future learn to love it.... THREADS
@@annedodgson8677Only one in 19,000 tips paid off.... How do you know that???
@@rick3747 Agree !!!
I am really interested to hear the police report when they can release it. The chief said on the news this morning he is 100 percent sure they got the right guy
Red flag. Cops were 100% OJ was guilty also. No conviction.
The arrest warrant can't be unsealed until BK appears in Idaho court....
well yeah, DNA doesnt lie
@@mbuckholzagreed!!! probably his blood mixed with their blood too!
The DNA evidence is going to be impossible for him to explain his way out of, and especially with a car identical to his observed at the crime scene at the time of the murders.
The other thing I do not like is it just helps push the narrative that socially awkward people just want to hurt others. I'm socially awkward as I never had many friends and then for many years escaped into alcoholism to try and make friends which has just made it even harder for me to try and make friends as I've gotten older but I don't think about going out and hurting others, even if they try and hurt me. I'm sure 99% of socially awkward people feel the same.
You're personalizing this.
Socially awkward, he used heroin for awhile, but the difference is he is a psychopath, not just a shy well meaning guy. Lots of shy awkward folks find their mate, because they aren't evil.
I appreciate your honesty. All of us are misfits in some way. Even those who seem to be a social butterfly have hidden flaws. We (humanity) can only overcome these flaws by turning to God, our Lord and savior Jesus Christ.
Ugh, I hate it too. I have social anxiety and can be awkward in social settings. I hate when they describe someone that didn't something horrible as being that way. They have much more going on with them than that.
I agree. I have Aspergers and Borderline personality disorder, I am prone to psychosis and have crippling anxiety, so bad that without Xanax I can't get out of bed, and the other medications I take makes me feel so tired, and that doesn't exactly help to get out there and meet people. Most people would certainly describe me as socially awkward, and I really really hate when that is one of the things they *always* mention when they find "their" killer. And it *really* fucking sucks. There are other traits they can push in front of the cameras, socially awkward people would rather stay inside and not meet people at all than go out and kill somebody and risking being pushed in front of the spotlight, or not succeed and be terrified of people laughing at them. If a killer is socially awkward, it's most likely because of a lack of empathy - not something like Aspergers or social anxiety.
Isn’t it ironic that they raided his parent’s home at about 3 am just like he raided the victim’s home around the same time.
Raids usually happen then bc guards are lowered and people are asleep and more vulnerable so it makes perfect sense yeah
Not really ironic at all.
Nah
probably the least ironic thing ever
Hair of the dog!
Great analysis doctor. Please keep it up!!
I agree!!!
You have very thoughtful and cogent analyses of these cases, and this is one reason I enjoy your channel (besides your sense of humor). I agree that Kohberger appears to have strong narcissistic traits (a sense of superiority, self-centeredness, and entitlement) coupled with a lack of empathy, which I believe are almost universal traits of serial killers. He's innocent until proven guilty, but the investigators probably have significant evidence against him. If Kohberger is the killer, then I applaud them for finding him so quickly, because he would have done this again.
Who know if these were his first four murders! The FBI should build a timeline and trace his whereabouts to murders that took place in the the same areas during the time he was in each of the places on his timeline.
@@MacBigUSA I'm sure they are.
Wrong guy, he is a skinny vegan. This is your future learn to love it.... THREADS
@@MacBigUSA He hasn't been convicted yet...
Dr. Gande did not refer to Bryan as a narcissist and said it was unclear if he lacked traits of empathy. Someone bullied so cruelly wouldn't lack empathy. He or she would be hypersensitive.
Happy New Year Doc to you and your Family. I am a retired Deputy sheriff. Years ago I investigated a child molestations and sex crime cases. One of my cases, the suspect was a reputed psychologist, who proved to be a fraud. Long story short, he thought he was the smartest person in the room. Biggest mistakes most offenders make is they don’t know when to stop talking. With the exception of only one occasion in my ten years, everyone wanted to give their side of the story which always led to their downfall and conviction. The only one who ever refused to talk to me was a four time loser in the prison system. Sometimes I got to the point that I thought they wouldn’t stop talking. PS: provable lies from suspects are better than silence.
I'm very concerned at the media coverage, even in the UK: so many seem to assume 'this is the guy' when he's only been arrested on suspicion & IS innocent until proven guilty, beyond a reasonable doubt. I can't imagine how it must feel to be in this situation, if you're innocent.
We may still have the killer on the loose - something that's happened plenty of times in the past. A suspect may be all-sorts of things, their behaviour may be odd, they may have had bad interactions with others - but that doesn't mean they're guilty of anything. Let the course of justice run.
It’s guilty until proven innocent in America.
That’s why you have to pay a bondsman to get out on bail before your even convicted.
Then you have to pay a lawyer, take time off work, gas money,all of which you never get back when acquitted. Not even the bail money.
It’s a business in America.
Bullying comes in to play ALL THE TIME in cases like these. People…. If you see something, SAY SOMETHING! Monitor your kids in school. Address the schools for bullying you witness. Speak up when it happens anywhere around you. This is a huge issue. Be kind to each other or leave each other alone.
Exactly. People wont care unless it directly affects them
Almost every fight I have ever been in when I was younger was defending someone else. People I didn’t know, people I didn’t like. Sometimes defending them from my own friends. If you aren’t someone who will step in at least get help.
@@amberkelly3187 100%!
@@amberkelly3187You’re SO virtuous. The world is a MUCH better place with you in it. You’re like a virtue signaling super hero! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
🌹I experienced s3xual harassment in middle school, I guess a form of bullying. I had to change schools, because no one would stop it. I was told to ignore it, when I feared being r8ped.
I witnessed A LOT of different types of bullying in that school which was a very good school, high-caliber people. I had to move to a lesser school where I didn't learn as much.
I always wondered why no one in authority stopped the bullying. They even acted like it was good for us; it would make us stronger. BS! My education wasn't as good because of it.
It's very possible for people in authority in and outside of schools to stop the bullying. I think it's highly egregious for them not to.🌹
I was just watching new on this and was literally hoping you’d cover this, when you posted this. Thank you so much for your incredibly valuable expert analysis. 🙏🏻
It is not known if Bryan had a juvenile record or an expunged record. Also if he has committed crimes that he has gotten away with. People may be reporting these things as you record this. Hard to believe he started with this awful "big" thing.
Its completely possible they got the wrong guy
@@benjamindover4337, no...., it's NOT!
@@intenseday06 well, it definitely IS possible. That's why we have trials.
I think they usually start small, kick the cat,beat the dog,squish the gerbil or hamster under their feet,you get the picture.He may have also commited other crimes.Probably thinks he,s Neitchze Superman.
@@benjamindover4337 the FBI followed him for 3 or 4 days before arresting him as they were tying to obtain a DNA sample. The DNA incriminated him.
Could you analyse the case of the parents of Lacey Fletcher? Lacey Fletcher was the woman who passed away due to 12 years of gross medical neglect in the home of her parents. Could you address why these parents did what they did? They were supposed to go to trial in Louisiana in March, but it has been postponed until June as the parents are claiming they have some type of illness/disability that caused them not to take care of Lacey. Thanks, Dr. Grande.
I graduated from DeSales with him. Completely different majors and I have never seen him before but I've been hearing a lot of people saying he was really weird on campus. Crazy to think that I was in the same room as him as we graduated
What weird things was he doing
@@belinalug6928 I havent heard specific examples but the gist I've heard is he always tried to be right about everything, had some obscure interests, and didnt really have a lot of friends
@@jjjt2597 those 80 percent can be divided into subcategories
An excellent analysis. You were spot on before Bryan was implicated in the murders. He turns out to be a very Bundy-Esque personality, in some respects, as you predicted. I’m sure he would’ve continued with the murders, had he not been stopped so soon. He would’ve moved into the serial killer realm sooner or later. You really pegged this man’s personality quite accurately. Great work! We’ll have to see what the rest of the investigation reveals about this case.
I have been stalked a few times by men. Each person mistook my kindness for something else and were angry with me when I did not have feelings for them or when they found out I had a boyfriend. And when I say kindness, it is just as simple as smiling and saying hello each time I saw them. These situations can be very scary. People's brains work differently and sometimes bad experiences can be taken out on innocent victims simply bc the person they hurt reminds them of someone in their past. Most people just want to be liked or acknowledged. If this man ends up being the murderer, I am very curious to see what he was thinking about and why he did it.
Yes, if one of the 2 pretty blonds rejected and scorned him after he put the hit on her.
I think he chose the house based on the relative lack of light and lack of cameras in that area. not sure what he knew about who lived there
🌹I've been stalked NUMEROUS TIMES. I did my best to avoid it. It never worked.
A friend recently told me to not smile, be careful whom I smile around. I at first thought how can that be a problem?
It turned out he was right. I'm a naturally happy person, so smiling is something I used to do without thinking. Now I think about it first.
This probably sounds ridiculous. If you've been stalked, you'll understand.🌹
Thanks for always staying calm. We need more people like you. It’s comforting. 🌸
This is going to be a very interesting case. Would love to hear his alibi and the probable cause affidavit once it's released
do you know how long it could take for info to be released?
He's got that pesky little DNA thing to overcome..
It should be as soon as he gets to Idaho, within the next few days
Do not put the Unabomber, Ted, in this group. He was dissolved by LSD. He was ruined by the system from a very early age and well if you haven’t read Industrial Society and It’s Future…..well it shows in Society. He was right yet you see him as a crazy. No he was pushed to be that.
@@kenamaro3942 As someone else in comments told me that it was a constant party at the house. He could have been at one of their party's in the house and perhaps that's how his DNA is present.
In the USA it's still Innocent until proven guilty.
Yes, when I first heard about this crime, I immediately thought of Ted Bundy attacking that sorority house. Main difference is Ted Bundy was able to fit into society, have long term girlfriends, socialize, and appear completely normal and well adjusted. Whereas this dude was basically the opposite. I guess that’s what made Ted so dangerous.
He was also well-educated.
@stancexpunks really good point
@@GrumpyMeow-Meow A law school grad. He could have made something out of himself.
this is so not Ted Bundy. Ted bundy had a completely different MO then this Jaggoff. Not to aggrandize serial killers but at least Ted Bundy looked normal was very social and handsome and had any girl he wanted. This guy is from loser Ville and kills from sour grapes and jealousy. Serial killers kill for fun and the joy of making women suffer. Also Ted Bundy was a republican(can you imagine) a young up and coming politician who ever one seemed to loke. Men and women.
Ted wasn’t a law school grad. He was in his first year of law school when he first got caught and he was failing because he never showed up to class due to his bloodlust increasing. But yes, he could have made something of himself
I'm happy they found him. I've been waiting for your video thank you. Love your videos
Brian is vegan and the two girls upstairs worked at a restaurant that serves vegan food. Might of encountered him there. That’s were the possible stocker came about… interesting to know more in the upcoming weeks when he he’s in Moscow
Now that the timeline of events on the night/morning of the murders has been established - I'm a bit troubled as to the logistical possibilities of BK's physical ability to park a vehicle, walk to the house and enter it effortlessly (somehow managing to avoid collision with a Door Dash delivery car/person). Then, find his way to the 4 individuals, at least one who was evidently eating/drinking her Door Dash delivery, stab each one of them to death (allegedly one of them fought back), manage to walk (NOT run, per DM's description of the masked man she observed) - down the halllways and out the sliding glass doors, to his car and drive away - in only 13 minutes. I suppose it could be accomplished - by a professional. But, a first time guy? Tik-tok activity must have been interrupted by being stabbed. What about Chapin? While his girlfriend was ordering Door Dash and using Tik-tok, was he so sound asleep that he didn't wake up to stabbing sounds? Did each of the 4 not utter a single scream? And... before the arrest, it was stated that one of the victim fought back and the police were sure the killer would have some sort of resulting marks on his body. ??? Surviving roommate, DM, reports hearing what she describes as a possible whimper. I so hope the police focus on not putting ALL their eggs in one basket in this case. The glove wearing isn't as strange in Kohberger's generation as one might imagine. Mask wearing/glove wearing, even obsessively, has become common these days. Too many unanswered and glaring questions remain - what about the Door Dash delivery person? Could they perhaps be the masked man seen by DM? DM and the other surviving roommate simply don't sound believable. Bottom line for me keeps throwing me back to that timeline though. If BK is the killer, he gets the gold for being the most expeditious multiple killer of all time. First time out to boot!
Thank you for your continued expeditious analysis of current events and particularly this one. We are all intrigued by this seemingly random connection between these victims and this most unusual suspect, as well as this unfortunate crime itself. So sad. Praying for these families. Thank you and Happy 2023 Dr. Grande!
When I first heard that he had asked if anyone else had been arrested over this I thought that maybe he was hoping he wasn’t the only one on their radar.
That's what I was thinking too.
That, and maybe he was trying to already set up speculation that he hadn't acted alone.
Happy New Year Dr. Grande!! Thanks for covering this case…So thankful they caught him.
Happy New Years!
Amazing analysis and thank you for what you do....and how you relate to "real life people and real life situations". So appreciate your knowledge Dr. Grande.
I turned 30 four days before the murders and I will never forget it because all I could think about is that I was living, got to reach 30, and these young individuals didn’t. Great analysis, thanks for sharing, and so sorry to these young ones and their families. You gotta be a real sicko to do this.
Of course the young white woman has to make it about her. Love attention
Happy belated birthday.
I often think the same way.
I am 63 now and love life.
I feel so sad for these young people who had the world as their oyster.
This murderer is disgusting.
Happy New Year, be safe!
🥳🇨🇦
@@panushjo calm down. It’s not about me at all. This is a comment. A speck. Just like yours. Rather than making it about me, like you are, let’s just be bummed about this sad shit.
@@abelis644 you too ❤️ take great care. It’s just so sad how it takes so many lives, especially so young.
30 is still extremely young 💀 I hope I won’t be thinking like this when I get there in six years
I was waiting for your opinion. I do believe, as wild as it sounds, that he had the hypothesis of “how to commit the perfect murder” and wanted to test it for his PhD dissertation. Happy 2023.
My thoughts as well.
He wanted to test it for his PhD.... dear Lord.. if that's true this is one of the craziest stories I've ever heard. Just wow. If he would have got away with this he would have probably tried to make a "hypothetical" book on how he "thought" the killer would have done it to get himself rich. 😳
@@someoneout-there2165 So how he got into the house? Something don’t add up.
I agree. I also think he wanted to commit the perfect murder, and that his selection of a house of girls was chosen not due to “rage at being rejected by women in his past”, but because women, especially petite women (if he first scoped out the house ahead of time to see who occupied the residence) are easier to
stab to death than men. I believe he is a sadistic psychopath who kills for the thrill of killing. He didn’t need (or want) to sexually assault any of the young ladies because the act of killing them in the manner he killed them satisfied his sexual urges, as he equates violence with sex. Plus,
sexually assaulting them and leaving
his ejaculate at the crime scene would
make it that much easier for LE to identify and catch him.
@@SimboSays I agree - he had stabbed 4 students, he would had been COVERED with their blood.
A Sociologist I was listening to likened him to Patrick Bateman in American Psycho. A sociopath blending well into society but whose control was shattering.
He kinda has the Patrick Bateman look too.
Any sociologist, should question to why they are invested in this case, yet never cared for the countless others to be stabbed fatally before. Selective empathy is disingenuous and overshadowed by one’s indifference to the countless others, that have died in similar circumstances. Perhaps this case spoon fed provides the right amount of sensationalism required to keep interest, in an otherwise void of indifference you people have shown to others? Introspect.
@@automatoncollectives7237 you sound very confused
@@automatoncollectives7237 Ok, bot. That's enough word salad.
@@automatoncollectives7237 Brian K. illustrates intellectuals are not precluded from serious and less serious mental and personality disorders. Please be less harsh on we the less intelligent.
I love your monotone so we really don't know what your thinking. As always good insight and clarity.
But he is actually saying what he's thinking.
I’m almost falling asleep to it, his voice is so relaxing
I’m still the most curious about when/how he decided on these particular victims.
Was a sexual motive. Brian himself posted it on fb saying he “thinks it was sexually motivated” basically telling everyone his motive
I think one of those Girls blew him off and he got crispy about it.
Everything about him screams 'Incel'.
Allegedly his sister lived close by to the house where the 4 victims lived
The 2 girls lived online. He followed them, they didn't return the follow. His school is close to theirs, 20 min drive. So we don't know how many visits he made to the area, or to the bar, and was perhaps waiting for the opportunity to get the 2 sorority girls home alone as he perceived they rejected his attention online.
@@Mila-Nova thats false
It’s frightening to think that there are more like him in the making! We just don’t know!
We do know because new ones are born everyday. I think that if states required DNA samples from license applicants that we could catch serial killers and rapists soon after their first victims.
And those that would or have gotten away with murdering.
Sad but true
@@danielebrparish4271 You realize how ultra rare this is, right? The solution you provided here is far scarier than the occasional mass murderer, who they caught in a month by the way. This isn't the 1970s where killers go undetected for 20 years. Possible? Yes. Extremely unlikely.
Yes there are Tens of Thousands out there like him and a few million people that are capable and would like to kill but just barely keep that compulsion in check.
Happy New Year to my favorite psychologist may you and your family have a very happy New Year
Thank you for providing his birthday! His natal astrology chart has Pluto and Jupiter conjunct 29 degree Scorpio Sun! So much hidden turmoil finding a focus through the “perfect crime.” Jupiter did give him a feeling of protection from murderous impulses. He must have studied his fellow Scorpio Ted Bundy. Saturn squaring his Sun right now … caught by DNA technology (Saturn in Aquarius).
I think you are right on Dr. Grande. One of those girls may have rejected him and he wanted revenge.
Look up the Lauren Gibbons case. It's very similar to this one.
The one major thing that Bryan didn't take into account was how easy it was to overlook critical evidence that could be used against him!
What is the reason for not burning the vehicle once he heard they caught it on camera the evening of/early morning after the murders? (LE didn't have to farther than the campus next door, after checking their own.) Did he own it? Was he afraid of his parents wondering what happened to it if he torched it? He must have hated them, as well as one more than the others in that "party house". It could be at the bottom of a lake, river, quarry in just about half of PA, or any state in between there and Idaho. After yrs of studying dangerous criminals, one would think he'd kill the car/ditch the weapon and wear gloves, like OJ, no?
Yes, I'm reminded of that line from the movie Body Heat (back in the 1980s): "In an operation like this, 50 things can go wrong. If you can think of 25 of them, you're a genius. And you're no genius."
Also, once he heard they had pretty much figured out what his car was, he should have been on the next plane out of the country to Libya (or wherever they don't have extradition to the U.S.). Ditto for SBF. He should have left the Bahamas and headed for parts unknown after he resigned from FTX.
Great video Dr Grande! Oh and your mention of Nikolas Cruz reminds me that you never made an update video on his case/trial. There were some pretty interesting happenings that I’d like to hear your thoughts on
Yeah, like Scarlett Lewis’ interference with Defendant for money making project! Despicable for a Sandy Hook parent of dead child…Parkland parents almost attacked her I bet…
This is the worst analysis I have ever seen from Todd Grande (I reserve "Dr." for practicing medical doctors). In fact this is one of the most unprofessional analysis I encountered EVER. To tag a socially awkward individual as somehow who is intrinsically prone to violence is exceedingly prejudicial and downright dangerous. I stop short of labeling it as "evil".
Is M.D. For other doctors are D.R. first
Medical is M D. After the name.. for none medical is Dr before the name.. he is a doctor
.. attorney arex Dr. Also PhD.. and pharmacist..
Isn't this case textbook? I read "Whoever Fights Monsters" and this guy checks all the boxes. That book is fascinating, btw.
It is read it a few times, you should read his other book.
@@annwethenorth besides the "Monsters" book, which books of his would you recommend? Or maybe all of them? Fascinating subject. Thanx. 📚
Is it a good read? By whom btw?
I was thinking the same thing.
@Ann We The North: Thank you for reminding me, gotta reread both, been awhile. N I encourage everyone else who's interested in this to do the same. 🙂
I think he may have left the roommates alive cause he ether didn't know they were home or he thought one of them would get blamed and throw off the investigation.
He had an erection during the murders. This is suggested by DNA found at the crime scene. He was aroused ...
Bryan’s actions remind me of the man who shot and killed the young actress from “My Sister Sam” some time back. He had built up an infatuation with her and when she acted in a part he did not like, he sought her out and killed her because he felt rejected by her. She didn’t know him at all. Very tragic.
I tend to agree with Dr Grande that this was a 'rejected suitor' type killing, with possibly 3 others that were collateral damage. Exposing yourself to men with a propensity to obsess on pretty girls is a very dangerous thing to do - what if he had followed, say, Kaylee or Maddie obsessively on an internet platform, and then decided he couldn't take any more rejection/teasing (Only Fans?), and decided to end those lives?
Well the internet pinned Jack Showalter as the murderer, and he kind of fits the profile of Bryan, struggles to get along with others, kicked out of fraternity, aggressive towards women. I thought it was Jack Showalter.
@@owainkanaway8345 What does this suggest? Do you think this kind of young man is becoming more common these days?
Thanks for that tidbit. Interesting.
@@Faristol7 These people are a byproduct of the public school system. The purpose of public schools and this is a fact, is to alter behavior. Never-mind the fact that public schools don't prepare kids for the real world, and the majority of of them are gang infested, drug infested, and filled with violence.
This is just one incident. Violence has gone up in the US, broken families are the norm, dysfunctional behavior is the norm, multiple homicides happen on a daily basis. This is what happens when you have a dysfunctional government.
I don't disagree with what you said about him not trying to commit the perfect murder, but I do think he believed himself to be too smart to get caught. I think he was likely shocked when he read the arrest affidavit and learned just how much evidence they have on him. As well as how early in the investigation it was when they were already hot on his trail. I imagine his ego has suffered a mighty blow because of this. Lol. How I would have loved to have been a fly on the wall while he was reading it. What a poor little loser he is... 🤣🤣🤣
I am from Pullman, WA (I have lived in Alaska for five years). My family back in Pullman was shaken to the core by these murders. I am glad that they finally caught him.
Please do an analysis of the surviving roommate who saw Kohberger on the night of the murders. What possible reasons are there that she did not alert police until noon the next day. What possible reasons are that Kohberger didn't kill her. So much speculation, would be good to hear your thoughts on the surviving roommates state of mind that night.
Ok, she was scared!!! And, she wasn't aware the others were dead. Makes sense to me. With kids going in and out all the time, she may have assumed it was a friend of theirs. He probably didn't kill her because he needed to get the heck out of there.
Wow thank you for doing this I've been following this case like everyone else and this is mind blowing. These murders really have disturb me like what kind of person could do something so brutal like a horror movie monster. Luckily he got caught i wonder if he has murdered before
I feel that this is not his first Rodeo.
I really would not be surprised if it was discovered that he has killed others and just had not yet been caught.
The Authorities need to look deeper - if he travelled by car to and from his Parent's house, they may want to see if there are any Unsolved Homicides during the time he travelled and in or around paces he travelled through.
Thanks!
This analysis was exceedingly insightful. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts on this, Dr. Grande.❤️
That’s enough for a pair of black tights
@@jragon9215 not funny.
What a horrible life to have been bullied growing up & have it continue as a teen into adulthood. Being socially awkward made Bryan come across as creepy & rejected even more. It is certainly no excuse to murder people. I haven't heard of any ex girlfriends & maybe Bryan was obsessed with 2 of the girls bc he did follow them on Instagram. Perhaps he tried interacting with them & he got rejected by them, too & went into a rage. What a terribly depressed person he must have been. I think Ethan & Xena were just interacting way & not a target. This is heartbreaking for everyone involved. 💔
I read he had ate in the vegan resturant the girls worked in and and had known them there.
@@shirleylay1257 Wow!
I like the way you don’t over dramatise this horrific crime, so many commenting seem to try to do this
The more that unfolds about this case the crazier it gets. Definitely will be made into a made for tv Lifetime movie.
I doubt it. It's too gruesome for Lifetime.
I won't be surprised if there's a home invasion movie that is suspiciously similar with the "based on true events" tagline.
JCS ripoffs gonna have a field day w this one
Made for TV? I’m thinking this is going to be a Hollywood movie.
@@saulgoodman.exe_ They are already talking about getting the interrogation video on him.
I think the motive was incel rage. Funny how the Big Bad Wolf went running back to mommy and daddy after the murders.
Nah, it’s the classic sexual gratification through murder, like Bundy and the rest.
Maybe. It surely doesn't seem to be well planned. I wonder why he was socially awkward in the first place. Why didn't he learn as a child to socialize? Was he a single child? Were his parents socially awkward too? Did he have ASD or another disorder as a child? Also it would be interesting to know why some children are never accepted, why they get bullied and then how to help them so they do not become killers or serial killers one day. I think had he been accepted he would't have chosen to commit the murders. At the end he still chose to murder instead of doing something good and change his negative ways in order not to fit in, but find a good girl that would have accepted and loved him.
@@TeaCup1940 Well said. His parents seem odd and socially awkward too. His father must have been aware of it. He asked a new neighbor if he would invite Bryan over because he had a hard time making friends. This was when he was helping move him into his apartment in Idaho.
I find it odd that everyone is looking at his extreme veganism as OCD, instead of seeing it as a potential restrictive eating disorder. IMO he was bullied for being "weird" and "overweight", perhaps called "Blubber Bryan" or something like that. His school friend says he came back from a summer break one year, and had lost weight and become mean. Was he trying to control and change the narrative of his life in Pennsylvania, but people wouldn't let him? Think about it, bullied at school. Then he goes to a College near to his home, which let's face it, is like going to 13th grade, because someone you've known since kindergarten is there, and "Blubber Bryan" starts all over again. No matter how much he achieves academically he's always the weirdo. Then he tries to do the "Geographical Cure" and move across country, thinking he can start anew, but....he cannot get away from himself, no matter how thin, or what clothes he wears, or how much money, or what grades or how many degrees. This may have been his last effort to change and become someone new. Someone he thought he should be. Someone people appreciated for his genius etc. Yet, here we go again, these little blonde girls are calling him weird, he's getting written up at Seven Sirens for being weird...... he lost out on trying to control his outcome. Imagine the frustration of "I'm giving them what they say I should be. They (media etc.) say lose weight and you'll be happy. They say wear these clothes and we'll accept you. I've changed myself completely, yet they still hate me, and say I'm not good enough." I think moving to Washington was a desperate act. And I think this was his "Sch00l Sh00ting" scenario
Ooooffff that guy. It does make you appreciate that law enforcement knows what they're doing behind the scenes and everyone just needs to let them do their job. It's a long process, ey Dr Grande, not like on TV.
I think law enforcement personnel are underrated. They are some of the smartest people. I watch how they solve crime such as Forensic Files and ID man they use their skills and smart to solve these crimes.
@@donnacaesar-roberts9472You're right... Without that thin blue line...there LITERALLY is no " society "....
@@donnacaesar-roberts9472 They USE the skills of scientists and genetic genealogists to solve cases. These are the people actually responsible for bringing resolution to many cases ...
Yes off that guy!
@@marknewton6984 you don’t even know if he is guilty. Remember Richard Jewel. Did you want to off him too?
Happy New Year everyone. I hope your year’s already started to sparkle. I was thrilled to see this upload Dr. Grande! This case was heart wrenching. I wonder if people had been kinder to Brian, would he have ever done something like this? But at the same time, the fact that he was mistreated in life doesn’t excuse his actions. A lot of people are bullied. Few of them commit any crime, let alone a quadruple murder. Thank you for expounding on this subject Dr. Grande.
It's the bullying and it starts in the schoolyard. It warps and twists the minds of small children and/or teenagers and a few turn out like this. Schools need to have zero tolerance for bullying. These poor 4 college students and their families paid the price of our inaction. People threw things at him? Why didn't someone stop this? I would have. Where were the teachers or bystanders? There's no excuse for what he did and he has to pay. But we have the power to stop some of this in the future.
I appreciate you bringing the subject of kindness to bear on this. All people deserve to be treated with kindness and decency. Of course that isn’t the world we live in so bullying does go on especially among the young who in their youth don’t realize the gravity bullying can have on their peers. They don’t have the life experience. I just wish more attention would be directed to this awful behavior and its impact on lives. I don’t feel sorry for the suspected perpetrator, Bryan, but it does factor into his possible motive for committing such a horrible crime. The whole situation is awful. Maybe he had undiagnosed Aspergers syndrome which would explain his social awkwardness.
Life is difficult and cruel in many different ways. While I agree that bullying is terrible for the psyche and people should be kinder, I doubt it makes a difference with some people. People with certain mental pathologies will find a reason to harm no matter what. Their boss made them mad, their spouse made them mad, etc cetera. Don't blame the world. Blame the person who unalived ppl. The difference is a person without certain pathologies will be bullied but never kill someone. A person with certain pathologies will always find a reason why the world owes them more. It's part of the mental pathology. It's part of the delusion of grandeur.
Yes, I think the same here. Bullying is absolutely terrible and damaging. I was bullied a lot as a kid for the way I looked and dressed. It damaged my personality no doubt about it, but I do not want to hurt people, and I am one of probably millions who fit into this category. It seems like there’s another element at work here, possibly in combination with the bullying, that caused him and others like him to become so incredibly violent. Anyways, it’s a relief to see that someone was arrested. Happy new year Dr. G and all!
@@realAnnB Absolute BS. Bullying has existed since the beginning of time. This person has a mental deficiency that likely existed at birth, as opposed to becoming a killer as the result of process of socialization (or what you call bullying)
Spot on analysis. Thank you Dr Grande.
He was spurned by one of the girls, got medicated and things went south...watch...pharma will get blamed for this.
Dr. Grande has also done a few videos about incels. I wonder if this guy fits the bill. Awkward, rejected by women and then becoming dangerous because women would not be interested in him even though he considered himself smart and not bad looking. He kind of reminds me of an Elliot Rodger type. Just a thought.
Such misery caused by this man, for all the victims, including his parents and sister.
Happy New Year, Dr. Grande! Thank you for all your hard work in 2022. May God continue to bless and guide you in 2023 in all that you do 👊💪😊
I enjoy watching your analysis of different cases. Thank you for providing this.
The murder was probably his dissertation.
Well at least he has hands ✋️ on experience. 😶
The trial will be his "thesis defense". If he fails to "defend" his thesis he gets executed.
It could have been, but it's incomplete now❗
His masters was about feelings and crime, so yes his rage won and he did his "disssertation" but failed to be perfect enough to go back to school and make a living writing crime books.
OMG…….just when I thought I’d seen it all……this guy has a deep connection with the BTK killer through Dr Ramsland
That’s a stretch. He studied under Ramsland but that doesn’t mean he has any connection at all to BTK, much less deep connections.
@@scottcastro9383 he wrote to him alot
It will be interesting to see how all of this unfolds. Glad he was caught, but feel very badly for his parents, having their house raided at 3:00 a.m., and having no idea of what was going on..
I feel his parents probably helped create this monster. You've heard about him making his mom throw out all her pots and pans and buying new ones for HIS vegan diet. Who does that? Go buy your own damn pots and pans. Arrested development, and whose paying for those 3 degrees and his apt. Daddy!
Who the hell cares about parents of a killer being awaken at 3 am? Those young people were killed in the middle of the night in their beds. Honestly, you feel bad for a murderer's parent being awaken? Seriously? My sister was murdered and never once did I think about when the killer's family found out that he killed my sister. Didn't care and never will as I am sure the family of these victims don't.
@@mercuryangel5632 It is possible to feel empathy for both the victims’ families and the perpetrator’s family. I’m very sorry for your loss and understand why you might not feel sorry for the family of the murderer. But some of us are capable of feeling empathy for everyone impacted by crime, whether related to the victim or perpetrator.
Wasn’t it sweet how Chris Watts’ mother continued to envelop Chris with the love the Lord in court? I was moved.
@@lovenebelungcats Yep....I'm a nanny. 75% of parents don't know what the hell they are doing. I'm sure if I spent a week at their house I could pinpoint several problems. Its not normal for someone to be weird and a social outcast.
As soon as i read he was a Cr. J. student i thought: he wants his crime unsolved mainly so he could ask his future students: "What do you all think about that famous unsolved ID murder?" Then he'd gloat secretly to-himself how smart he was to have gotten away w it. (Brain-power w/o compassion is a horrible combination. Have you ever met anyone like him in your school days, Dr. G?)
I had a baby with someone like him.
Happy New Year! 🎆 🎉🍾
I’m guessing he’s got mild Aspergers, complicated by OCD, among other things. (Possibly also addiction issues)
Nah I think That’s a narcissist psychopath lol
A common restricted interest (obsession) in individuals with Aspergers or autism can be crime & psychology in order to understand human behaviour and why they may feel like they don’t fit in with others. A lack of social skills (social awkwardness), higher IQ, lower EQ (empathy) extreme SQ (systemising), black and white thinking (I’m right, you’re wrong), multiple failed interactions with peers over time, OCD (co-existing), a lack of understanding the thoughts and feelings of others leads to multiple rejections by peers and subsequent feelings of anger and revenge. A probable drug addiction (to cope with failed social interactions or missed diagnoses) combined with the pain of not being able to ‘connect’ with people over time and mental health issues and/or personality disorder then ultimately lead to externalised rage. Likely, little to no dating or relationship history. Early childhood photos , family history, and childhood developmental profile could confirm this.
Just thought this when Dr Grande was doing his profile and Bryan wasn't fitting in.
This is the first time I’ve heard anyone suggest (and I’ve combed through a lot of material on the case) that he was ok with both outcomes, getting caught or getting away with it. I also had this thought early on, as I learned more about his personality. I think to some extent he thought through both outcomes (to an extent) and weighed whether it was “time” to get caught. This is because I most definitely think this wasn’t actually his first horrendous crime, he just hadn’t been caught yet. I believe his sloppiness in this case was the result of uncontrolled emotions-rage and impulsivity, he finally “snapped” and lost sight of some of his planning skills. Another thought I have is that he initially was only targeting one girl, maybe 2, but murdering 4 people was not in his plan. He encountered Ethan and Xana and wasn’t expecting that. Thus, he wasn’t thinking this was going to be such a high profile quadruple murder case…perhaps he truly didn’t want to get caught, I bet he’s pretty disappointed in himself that he murdered the other 2-3 kids “accidentally”! Thank you Dr grande for your awesome insight.
Love the breakdown. Let's put more decorations on that white wall. Love what you have already. Happy New Year, Dr. Grande! I love your work. ❤️
Bingo. Very astute analysis! A veritable outline for a true crime novel.
Seriously? How many children do you know have asthma?
Happy new year from İstanbul, Dr. Grande. My thoughts and prayers are with the families of the victims...
I'll rather listen 👂🏽 to Doc Grand with case's like this than anyone else on YT... He not only speak facts but knowledge as well...