Justin Blatt I think she gets a little extra scrutiny because she is the only girl and happens to have only the second highest vocal range :D. It's just great to see that they most likely haven't peaked yet.
averyaugust I think it's true that we take certain things for granted. Everything that Mitch does is shown off more because his upper range amplifies what he sings. Then, Scott takes the lead of the lot of the time and he's also the most resilient. But after Pentatonix became their own band, she gained her own traits.
averyaugust actually kirstie has the highest if you look at some of their videos where their just fooling around, kirstie hits higher notes than mitch can, but I love them both so much.
Hannah Roman Apart from the whistle range segments, Mitch is a stronger upper soprano. Listen to their rendition of Aha and then look for a comparison.
MC they absolutely have. I mean, it’s been what, 7 years now? Voices mature a lot in that time. Plus three of them were only teenagers when they did the sing off
That white dude judge is pretty cool. He's not just padding their confidence because they gave a good performance, he's giving a real critique and I think what he said in this video was a major influence on their current sound. All their stuff now really plays up the dub step, techno, the trippy things they can do with their voices.
+Gyozomroka Haha that's cool. Ben's not really a mainstream celebrity, more of a musician/composer, which is why his comments are so constructively critical :)
It's kinda funny that this was considered their worst performance. "The risky arrangement that you chose, didn't quite work for me." Was the only criticism they got during the whole show.
@@nickthegarvey and to be fair, I agree with Ben Fold's assessment that the decision to apply a melody to the top didn't quite work. Like Shawn says... Ke$ha kinda sing-talks. The only other possible critique they got was on their first performance when they "came out of the gates a click too fast"
Its because this is still the point where the judges are like okay we have to find criticisms. Then after a few more songs they were luck f it, i can't do this you guys are amazing.
He was using his talents as well as they had developed at that time. Since then, with experience, lessons and just age, his talents have expanded just like everyone else in Pentatonix.
Lymarie Guzmán Pérez i know, I was just pointing out that receiving that comment didn't discourage them from making more risky arrangements and they ended up winning a Grammy for best arrangement
It entertains me comparing how Scott basically screamed the note at 3:11 to how he sings Problem now. If that isn't vocal growth, I don't know what is.
I feel like Kirstie deserved more recognition in this series. It was great to hear her recognized here, but I don't think she gets the same sort of credit the guys (who do all have INCREDIBLE voices, don't get me wrong) do.
taiblademaster Kirstie is amazing and has such a pure, clean, clear voice and it’s amazing so you’re right, she deserves a lot of recognition but I have to say, I always think of her as the queen of this show given that she is the only woman to win out of all five seasons.
I agree to an extent...but during these performances she was sometimes off key. Not a lot, just a bit. She's improved immensely and is a fabrastic singer, but here she was a bit insecure.
A lot of the time she sang backup for Scot with Mitch. But when she really shined especially in Since you been gone and Oops I did it again they loved it
To be fair Pentatonix had only been a group of five for 2 weeks before their audition. They had to find a groove that worked and stick to it in order to build a performance each week. After they won they had the time to experiment and grow.
Going back and rewatching this. Your comment made me lol so hard. I picture a chick watching her computer, laptop, whatever, and just yelling "scomiche"!!!! Awesomeness!
what I love about this show is that they give constructive criticism that will actually help the contestants unlike a lot of the other competition shows
omg..... when shawn started complimenting mitch, a smile made its way onto my face, and I couldn't make it go away, even if I wanted to! :D They should see Mitch now. He was good here, but now it kills people. Because people in the comments of some of their new videos say "When I heard Mitch's voice I died." haha! ;D
Lmaoo I love love love this comment the fact that we’re in 2023 where the first reaction for literally EVERYTHING is to take out your phone and record it says a lot about how far this world has come for the good and bad, I guess what I’m trying to say is I miss the old days when capturing a true awesome moment was from the heart and soul and it came out so naturally when being around your friends outside with no technology was so pure and real when life felt like if you were on ecstasy without the actual ecstasy, no drugs, no technology just pure fun and Mother Nature🥺😏😌😊😇
I started watching them once I figured out who pentatonix was and then i started watching superfruit and i always wanted them to react to these vids and i freaked out when i saw the title of there latest vid
+Allison Nelsen Lol i already watched it twice i just couldnt get over when mitch lost scott and then scott found mitch and mitch was like daddy i was done after that
+TasteFulCash365 I'm in love with their friendship!! goals for real. When Scott turns around like "There you are! I can not go 2 seconds without seeing you." ooh it melted my heart!!
+Allison Nelsen the thing is I totally ship them and everybody wants them to date but ik its not gonna happen because they have been best friends since they were like 10 i just dont think its gonna happen
I don't care what people say this group is beyond great, their skills are phenomenal and how well they work together is amazing. I was so happy when Kirstie got to sing by herself because you never get to hear just her sing and she never gets enough credit for her amazing singing voice, but the boys are amazing to, Avi's base, Scott and Mitch's singing, and what Kevin can do is just so awesome. Also i don't care if Scott and Mitch are gay or straight, they are both still amazing in my opinion same with the others... well that is all I needed to say so bye
Grace Willoughby thank you for agreeing with me it's good to know we actually have smart and intelligent people out there who don't care just about what gender one prefers and who is better than another
Dam. Seeing them today, then seeing where they came off from. o_o its like man, they were pros before they even started. xD. i would of quit if this was my competition
I love in these that Scott led from the front as he was at the time the most developed of the 3 main singers. Nowadays Kirstie and Mitch have grown in leaps and bounds and they take solos and shine while Scott leads from the back. But he is the backbone of the group...no doubt...then and always.
Its good, there's nothing wrong with this one but I don't think its the best one out of all their performances, it doesn't have as much punch the other performances did, to me anyway.
***** yeah scott and mitch are definantly gay, have you ever watched SuperFruit? its there little youtube vlog thing. its pretty funny but it definantly proves there gay ahahaha
I personally loved this performance you rarely see people who mix up songs like this and I wish more people did because it showcases what the song represents and the lyrics in a new way
Oh, how they've grown. My heart soars every time I watch these older videos and hear them talking about how they hope to do this for the rest of their lives.
Am I the only one who actually liked this performance? Like man, they went with the "typical" gentle/close to the original beginning and suddenly we arrive to Pentatonix's own niche! Like my reaction went from "this is pretty good" to "OH MY GOSH!"
I adore how they remixed it. I adore it!! Even this early in the lifetime of PTX, they already had that same originality and creativity to them, to the point where they had the balls to take such a giant risk with remixing this song and then completely nailed it. And Kirstie really shone in this.
I'm just gonna say this - Pentatonix is the best group that has EVER been on this show. There is not a single genre that they haven't rocked, even the ones that I don't care for. They're very theatre, very tight, and very intelligent.
Mitch pretending to be straight in this song is great xD
Couldn't have said it better
He dated Kirstie before though, lol. xD
U was looking for this comment 😂
Scott is gay also XD
Ace Johnson They're dating.
It's amazing how much they've grown as singers. Mitch is noticeably a much stronger singer now.
I think Kirstie has grown the most.
Justin Blatt I think she gets a little extra scrutiny because she is the only girl and happens to have only the second highest vocal range :D. It's just great to see that they most likely haven't peaked yet.
averyaugust I think it's true that we take certain things for granted. Everything that Mitch does is shown off more because his upper range amplifies what he sings. Then, Scott takes the lead of the lot of the time and he's also the most resilient. But after Pentatonix became their own band, she gained her own traits.
averyaugust actually kirstie has the highest if you look at some of their videos where their just fooling around, kirstie hits higher notes than mitch can, but I love them both so much.
Hannah Roman Apart from the whistle range segments, Mitch is a stronger upper soprano. Listen to their rendition of Aha and then look for a comparison.
"Mitch you have a great voice." Shawn you have no idea man
ikr oh my god
+queen-ofthe-sandbox I feel like PTX has really evolved into an even better group since their Sing-Off days.
it got even better
MC they absolutely have. I mean, it’s been what, 7 years now? Voices mature a lot in that time. Plus three of them were only teenagers when they did the sing off
i knowww omg more like angelic voice
MITCH'S HAIR IM CRYING
So was I
Namalella Krútt Don't craft....
CRAFT
I love how the phandom is here too. 😋
its everywhere you cant avoid it
His flawless hair.... gone.....
That white dude judge is pretty cool. He's not just padding their confidence because they gave a good performance, he's giving a real critique and I think what he said in this video was a major influence on their current sound. All their stuff now really plays up the dub step, techno, the trippy things they can do with their voices.
+Gyozomroka You mean Ben Folds? He's a legend. Gotta love him.
tororobanana Yeah, sorry, I didn't know his name. I'm not much into celebrities.
+Gyozomroka Haha that's cool. Ben's not really a mainstream celebrity, more of a musician/composer, which is why his comments are so constructively critical :)
tororobanana Awesome! Yeah, he was on point. Much more than most judges on these music contest shows.
+Gyozomroka Judging the judges.
It's kinda funny that this was considered their worst performance.
"The risky arrangement that you chose, didn't quite work for me." Was the only criticism they got during the whole show.
Baelor yeah that was literally the only kind of negative comment in the entirety of their appearance.
@@nickthegarvey and to be fair, I agree with Ben Fold's assessment that the decision to apply a melody to the top didn't quite work. Like Shawn says... Ke$ha kinda sing-talks. The only other possible critique they got was on their first performance when they "came out of the gates a click too fast"
@@ohifonlyx33 And they were "out of tune for the first time this season." On Forget You/Since You've Been Gone.
Its because this is still the point where the judges are like okay we have to find criticisms. Then after a few more songs they were luck f it, i can't do this you guys are amazing.
@@nickthegarvey I do agree with him tho
MY BABIES WERE SO YOUNG
SO BEAUTIFUL CHILDREN
+Mariana Crawford Mitch has changed so much since then. I feel like he wasn't using all of his talent and his voice during this.
FETUS PTX KILLS ME
He was using his talents as well as they had developed at that time. Since then, with experience, lessons and just age, his talents have expanded just like everyone else in Pentatonix.
"mitch, you're like the ying to scott's yang." CALLING SCOMICHE BEFORE IT WAS EVEN A THING. shawn stockton, original scomiche shipper
I was literally just gonna say that #scomiche
+Gabbyrella Munguia so was I hahaha
Lmao, so true.
"Stockton"
Shawn - Captain of the Scomiche Club,
''the risky arrangement didn't quite work'' and 4 and a half years laterthey won a Grammy for a ''risky arrangement''
*3 and a half, I'm dumb
I'm pretty sure he said it didn't quite work for HIM. As it, it's just his opinion.
Lymarie Guzmán Pérez i know, I was just pointing out that receiving that comment didn't discourage them from making more risky arrangements and they ended up winning a Grammy for best arrangement
+Frédérique Blais Yeah, but he wasn't trying to discourage them in the first place. He even congradulated then for it, because it is very important.
Lymarie Guzmán Pérez I KNOW I WAS JUST POINTING OUT THE IRONY
5:06 The first ever Scomiche shipper.
Shawn was the first Scömìche shipper, Sarah was the first Kavi shipper, and Ben was the first Scirstie shipper.
+Lili Madison McDonald I was just about to say that! XD
+Sam Wolf omg yas
"You're the yin to Scott's yang" I can't it's so true
HAHAHA YES IT IS BEAUTIFUL
It entertains me comparing how Scott basically screamed the note at 3:11 to how he sings Problem now. If that isn't vocal growth, I don't know what is.
When Scott and Mitch had to act straight during the sing off
acting is an important skill for a singing performer.
that is okay... he got his scomiche feel right beforehand!!!!
Mya Blackmon
Rachel Ayers
😂
"You're the ying to Scott's yang." OMG i went awwwwww :D
Yy Dr y cc gwf
It has been shipped
hashtag scomiche
First Scomiche shipper.
Shawn ships Scomiche!!!
I do 2
Shawn: "Your the ying to Scott's yang."
Me: SHAWN IS A SCOMICHE SHIPPER I KNEW IT.
they're literally all fetuses in these and I'm obsessed. i've watched all of their performances like 1000 times.
Madison, I LOVE your videos! ❤️
I still dooooo !!
I feel like Kirstie deserved more recognition in this series. It was great to hear her recognized here, but I don't think she gets the same sort of credit the guys (who do all have INCREDIBLE voices, don't get me wrong) do.
taiblademaster Kirstie is amazing and has such a pure, clean, clear voice and it’s amazing so you’re right, she deserves a lot of recognition but I have to say, I always think of her as the queen of this show given that she is the only woman to win out of all five seasons.
I agree to an extent...but during these performances she was sometimes off key. Not a lot, just a bit. She's improved immensely and is a fabrastic singer, but here she was a bit insecure.
A lot of the time she sang backup for Scot with Mitch. But when she really shined especially in Since you been gone and Oops I did it again they loved it
To be fair Pentatonix had only been a group of five for 2 weeks before their audition. They had to find a groove that worked and stick to it in order to build a performance each week. After they won they had the time to experiment and grow.
0:43
Avi-"Hey guys, let's go climb that tree and sing. We totally won't fall!"
Avi the rebel over here!!
When he said "You're the ying to Scott's yang" I screamed "SCOMICHE" judge me I don't give a what
I dont blame you. I did the same
I would've done the same thing, but it's past midnight and my family would kill me if I woke them up, so I screamed internally.
Going back and rewatching this. Your comment made me lol so hard. I picture a chick watching her computer, laptop, whatever, and just yelling "scomiche"!!!! Awesomeness!
Who where when and why also? Or is it just what?
I love at 4:58 when Shawn says "Mitch," and Mitch waves his hand. That's so cute. Love Avi as usual.
2:45 was probably one of if not the most different thing to have happened on the sing off stage. first vocal remix that went that far into the remix.
And my favorite part
yep
and now literally everyone copies that
i really wish ptx hadnt got criticized for this, because the whole breakdown here is one of the most innovative things in acapella everrrr.
The breakdown wasn't what the judges were criticizing. The beginning was what at least Ben Folds was criticizing.
what I love about this show is that they give constructive criticism that will actually help the contestants unlike a lot of the other competition shows
Mitch saying " That Pentatonix Flavor"
It's making me laugh SO hard
This song was just too 2016 for 2011
In other words ONE OF THEIR BEST SING OFFS
Galaxia I totally agree...with YOU, not Ben Folds on this. I loved it!
Galaxia I know, right?
This arrangement is smoother than liquid gold. "Fck the haterrrs" (Mitch 2016)
omg..... when shawn started complimenting mitch, a smile made its way onto my face, and I couldn't make it go away, even if I wanted to! :D They should see Mitch now. He was good here, but now it kills people. Because people in the comments of some of their new videos say "When I heard Mitch's voice I died." haha! ;D
omg....... I watched it again...... IT HAPPENED AGAIN! :D
Me too AlexSilverStone Gaming&Vlogs lol. AND I read your comment beforehand so you would think I would have been prepared.
lololol
I agree with you SOOOOO MUCH!
More reasons PTX is cooler than you- they rehearse in a tree.
So true
Omg. 🤣🤣
Lmaoo I love love love this comment the fact that we’re in 2023 where the first reaction for literally EVERYTHING is to take out your phone and record it says a lot about how far this world has come for the good and bad, I guess what I’m trying to say is I miss the old days when capturing a true awesome moment was from the heart and soul and it came out so naturally when being around your friends outside with no technology was so pure and real when life felt like if you were on ecstasy without the actual ecstasy, no drugs, no technology just pure fun and Mother Nature🥺😏😌😊😇
I'm here rewatching the Pentatonix song off videos after the new Superfruit reacting video
I started watching them once I figured out who pentatonix was and then i started watching superfruit and i always wanted them to react to these vids and i freaked out when i saw the title of there latest vid
+TasteFulCash365 I'm in love with everything Pentatonix. In case your interested and don't already know they have a documentary on Netflix.
+Allison Nelsen Lol i already watched it twice i just couldnt get over when mitch lost scott and then scott found mitch and mitch was like daddy i was done after that
+TasteFulCash365 I'm in love with their friendship!! goals for real. When Scott turns around like "There you are! I can not go 2 seconds without seeing you." ooh it melted my heart!!
+Allison Nelsen the thing is I totally ship them and everybody wants them to date but ik its not gonna happen because they have been best friends since they were like 10 i just dont think its gonna happen
i love how at the beginning they were just chilling on a tree and singing
This is the straightest Mitch and Scott have ever been!
I don't care what people say this group is beyond great, their skills are phenomenal and how well they work together is amazing. I was so happy when Kirstie got to sing by herself because you never get to hear just her sing and she never gets enough credit for her amazing singing voice, but the boys are amazing to, Avi's base, Scott and Mitch's singing, and what Kevin can do is just so awesome. Also i don't care if Scott and Mitch are gay or straight, they are both still amazing in my opinion same with the others... well that is all I needed to say so bye
Grace Willoughby thank you for agreeing with me it's good to know we actually have smart and intelligent people out there who don't care just about what gender one prefers and who is better than another
"YOU'RE THE YING TO SCOTT'S YANG" GURL WE KNOW
Amber Charles And then the comment with the 'ahhh' later cracked me up
I'm still not over the fact that Mitch had to sing "what you've got GIRL is hard to find" 🙄
+McKenna Elyse Ugh, I know, RIGHT?!
What? Lol. Who cares? That's just the lyrics.
+Triffton it's actually "what you've got BOY" because the artist, Ke$ha, it's a girl
😅😅😅 I know right???? He's more of a girl than I am.
its because he's supposed to be singing to kirstie haha
I thought the remix was really good? Like that's my favorite part ever, how did it not work?
ikr
most people's criticisms were everything prior to the bridge where they did the remix.
Dam. Seeing them today, then seeing where they came off from. o_o its like man, they were pros before they even started. xD. i would of quit if this was my competition
"You're the yin to Scott's yang" MY SCOMICHE HEART😭😭
Mitch looks so differents now
Kristie too!
yeah, did mich became fatter or what? or gym? . . lols hehe I love them, we the audience have seen them grow as they perform :D
Kirstie's baby fats went to Mitch. That's how I see them now.XD
mitch is slender now :D
So does Scott. His eyes got smaller and his nose got bigger. o.O
scott is so fetus it's so adorable kill me now
I had a blanket on and I still got chills
I swear I'm still listening with this even after 2015!
I love in these that Scott led from the front as he was at the time the most developed of the 3 main singers. Nowadays Kirstie and Mitch have grown in leaps and bounds and they take solos and shine while Scott leads from the back. But he is the backbone of the group...no doubt...then and always.
the glue :,]
I liked what they did with this song. I think it sounds better than when Kesha sings it.
Lol everything sounds better than when Kesha sings it. Or no, scratch that. When she "sings" it
politicalsheepdog when did Kesha last sing a song? lol
king0228 Ha ha.
Tonight lol
Does anyone else LOVE the fact that this show seems to be the only show that has legitimate judges with LEGITIMATE feedback?
2:41 just seriously breathtaking.
I hate that they discouraged their complete remixing of the song, I think it's exactly wat more artists need to do I think
5:06 and thats why Superfruit was created!
I AM CRYING SO HARD
Lexie Torres I UNDERSTAND LEXIE I DO IT'S 1 AM HERE AND I'M SITTING ALONE WATCHING THIS AND CRYING
Don't cry
craft
Lexie Torres Don't cry
CRAFT!
TheNeveFringe The phandom is everywhere XD
I literally find the phandom in every comment section
I don't care about others' opinions, this-- and their remix little bit in the middle especially-- is one of my favorite songs of theirs.
WHERE IS MITCH'S HAIR AND SCOTT BEING STRAIGHT OMG AND THE ORIGINAL SCOMICHE STRIPPER AH
"stripper" OML I CRYING
the original scomiche stripper.
Scott being straight
LOL
im honestly obsessed with pentatonix they are amazing!
I love how Kevin is STILL the same (personality wise) it's so awesome how genuine he is
I got the chills listening to this song!!!! It was so incredible, especially that middle part. They really did blow my mind with that performance.
Its good, there's nothing wrong with this one but I don't think its the best one out of all their performances, it doesn't have as much punch the other performances did, to me anyway.
that breakdown was outstanding!!
Wait, did I just hear a judge of a singing competition complain that someone was singing too well?
4:59 is my absolute favorite mitch seconds in the world oh my god...
I love how they say they're taking a risk, and they're the hottest a Capella group in the universe.
You can see how much more polished they become over the course of the performances
.
I love how the audience,Sara,Shawn and even the other groups were grooving and then gave them a standing ovation but only Dave didn't like it much. XD
Dave? Did you mean Ben? Lol
Oh, sorry about that. Hahaha.
It's obvious that Kirstie has grown as a singer. While she was really good here, she's gotten so much better.
HOW IS MITCH SO FREAKING CUTE I CANNOT EVEN DEAL WITH IT
Anyone else hear a little bit of Mitch's voice that he has in "Aha!"?
Sean called Scömìche out! He did it!
I don't know how Scott, Avi and Kevin can hang out with Kirstie without doing something about it. Man id be all over that.
***** yeah scott and mitch are definantly gay, have you ever watched SuperFruit? its there little youtube vlog thing. its pretty funny but it definantly proves there gay ahahaha
Shes ..... Scary.... :D
Cant believe she said that on national tv Lmao
I can't believe they have grown so much since this. I still love them.
2:31 It gets real.
my favorite part
Mine too
I personally loved this performance you rarely see people who mix up songs like this and I wish more people did because it showcases what the song represents and the lyrics in a new way
Oh, how they've grown. My heart soars every time I watch these older videos and hear them talking about how they hope to do this for the rest of their lives.
They were singing in a tree and an abandoned factory? They must've had some very strange practice spots.
Okay but like I’m still obsessed with this arrangement okay
6:05 sara's laugh sounds super monotone and im laughing because Kevin literally cannot contain his laughter
Love kristie's solo
I have no idea what the judges were talking about... that remix was freakin' amazing!
It's amazing to see how much they've grown up in almost 3 years !
I agree. I'm looking at this and seeing how amateur they were and looking at them now they're AMAZING.
Am I the only one who actually liked this performance? Like man, they went with the "typical" gentle/close to the original beginning and suddenly we arrive to Pentatonix's own niche! Like my reaction went from "this is pretty good" to "OH MY GOSH!"
same here
ONE OF THE BILLION THINGS I LOVE ABOUT SCOTT IS THAT HE ALWAYS TRIES TO STAY POSITIVE I LOVE HIM SO MUCH
I am so in love with their voice and it was an awesum remix ..best acapella group ever
No doi
its funny how this is considered their worst performance
and yet this is so amazing
+kristine Nah this is my favourite one.
I don't care what this is considered, its one of my favorite performances.
I'd never seen this. watching this is like watching a fan fiction come to life and I love it!!!! that ying yang thing? scomiche af
0:41 anyone else wondering why they are singing in a tree? 😂
I was looking for a comment like this lol
Amber Charles lol, you're welcome then 😂
hahaha, you are right, that's weird
Because they can I guess. I mean, I guess you don't see those 20 people groups sitting in trees😂😂
Cuz they're kids! Well at least Scott and Mitch and Kirstie are
who else died during scott's high note
💀
"You're the ying to Scott's yang"
See. Even shaun ships scômíche
Mitch: "What you got GIRL is hard to find".
Me: I can sense the discomfort behind those words xD
that actually gave me chills why did the judges hate it
where in the world did you get that the judges hated it???
SouthernNYCga in their next performance they were like "we took a risk but the judges responded negatively"
I actually like this performance, i love the arrangement! i cant believe the judges didn't like it!
kristie is beautiful!
WOW they improved so much! From a legit performance to RUclips,
Hearing Kirstie sing gives me goosebumps every time!
"SCOMICHE!! ASDFLKJD~~~" Is what I screamed to my laptop making my family wake up.
No regrets tho 3
They look like babies so cute😂😊😂😊😊
Liked her solo liked hearing her sing it over and over
YES SHE IS GREAT !
My favorite part was 2:42-2:44...yess
The remix part sounds like something that would be played on the radio now, so idk what they were talking about.
Molly Stringer guiyvvvvvvyvryvty to. T. N ny my y c
I adore how they remixed it. I adore it!! Even this early in the lifetime of PTX, they already had that same originality and creativity to them, to the point where they had the balls to take such a giant risk with remixing this song and then completely nailed it. And Kirstie really shone in this.
They're so talented and creative omfg I love them
Loved this! But loved sara saying "she's scarrryyyy" was just even better XD
I'm just gonna say this - Pentatonix is the best group that has EVER been on this show. There is not a single genre that they haven't rocked, even the ones that I don't care for. They're very theatre, very tight, and very intelligent.
their chemistry is sooooo great it would earn me an A+ in science class.....
mitch looks absolutely terrified in that tree haha
Watching this after hearing their cover of “Sounds of Silence” yesterday, they’ve grown so much and so powerfully.