Lone Survivor | Navy SEAL Breaks Down Lone Survivor-Part 2: Fight Scene 1
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 окт 2024
- In this video former Navy SEAL Jason Pike breaks down the first fight scene with a consideration to real Navy SEAL tactics and mindset. A few verbal hiccups but the show must go on.....
Disclaimer: In no way is Jason challenging LT. Murphy and the men of Operation Red Wing's tactics. I am only looking at what Hollywood has created in the movie.
Have a great day and God bless,
Frogman Tactical
Please help us feed kids in Africa by visiting and purchasing from our Amazon Affiliate link below.
Website: www.frogmantactical.com
Affiliate Products: www.frogmantac...
Instagram: / frogman_tactical
Great points about the straight and round objects. One of the first things they taught us in Sniper school was that exactly, laying prone on your toes, your boot heels can be seen a mile away. Always laying prone, inside edge of foot flat against the ground. Target Detection 101. And I feel ya on the comms. Carrying your bag plus a 117G, 152, and batteries, crap gets heavy.
Great breakdowns, should do more, possibly zero dark thirty or 13 hours
12 horses
11 penguins
Definitely 13 hours.
13 hours would be a great one!
10 lords of leaping
Another fantastic critique of what to do and what not to do. I subscribed. As a fellow USN veteran I salute you.
I love the exasperation, eye roll, head shake, and big drinks every time an RPG hits. Especially the last one where all 4 tactically got blown up together.
I saw the movie so long ago that I really don’t remember it.
Thank you for the break down - food for thought.
Merry Christmas to all!
I've watched it so many times I can't forget it
Thank you brother, I love your channel, but mainly its you that I really like, and how observant and careful and professional you handle each and every thing you say, I am impressed by you as a man, let alone, a hero of our great states.
Thank you for the words. 🙏
God bless
Thank you for your service ! Really enjoyed and learned a lot here . Looking forward to see more and learn more . God bless our veterans and troops .
You definitely have a great channel. I appreciate your breakdown videos, they are probably the best I've seen. your cadence and ability to dissect these situations is engaging and well thought out.
Probably the most eye opening thing you talked about to me was the effect of an RPG, I thought since it was a rocket propelled grenade, it had a rough equivalent to a regular grenade (which is still substantial but not as bad as what you were saying) especially the percussion part. Can’t wait for the next part!!
Regular hand grenade has amount of explosives ca. 100 grams, warhead of RPG has amount of explosives ca. 1 kg. Feel the difference...
Technically concussion, not percussion.
@@d3ltaohniner261 "percussion" might be applicable since it'd blow your eardrums out... haha
I'm legit pumped for this - watched series 1 now I'm ready. Thanks for everything
I enjoy watching these videos with my son. I feel that it helps him (and me) stay grounded in reality and manages expectations when we're training. BZ
That it does. It helps create deeper bonds in things such as this.
The BEST breakdowns on RUclips! 100% reality! Truth seems harsh only to weak emotional people!
MUCH APPRECIATED! 🙏
Because of this video I have not watched the movie, everything said is absolutely accurate! I’m no snake eater but I was a 11B / Recon Grunt in the Guard for 20 years, I’m now a subscriber.
It kind of ruins you for sure.
Have a good night and God bless.
I have always felt that Hollywood movies were 100% entertainment only and held very little in the way of reality (outside the possible reality of the clothing that is worn) within the actual life of soldiers or armies.
Thank you for your video, awesome.
really enjoyed this video Mr. Pike..... thank you for your bravery!
Thank you Logan. Much appreciated.
Have a great night and God bless.
When you have to be critical. This is how you do it.
I saw a video on the Deep Net that was made by the enemy during this battle. Very difficult to watch. The video shows the enemy stripping the bodies of, Danny Dietz and Michael Murphy. And yes, Murphy was wearing that Red Patch that you talked about. The video also shows a Panasonic Toughbook that had a bullet hole through it. And it showed an enemy combatant turning the laptop on and scrolling through it. And based on the condition of the bodies it was evident that they went through hell before they were killed.
@EDWARD KALISPELL No, I know exactly what he's talking about. There's real life footage of the battle. You can identify Dietz by a tattoo he had and Murphy by comparing him to a photo off the internet.
@@coolited520 Can confirm John Coffeit. The video is very hard to watch. You can see the Taliban stripping one of the guys gear (Dietz maybe?) and his face is blown apart.
@@YahbiiCotWatched it once, never again.
Worth noting that Luttrell was also extremely dishonest in recalling the events.
@@fraser311 how? Please can you clarify in that?
Merry Christmas and Much Respect from Northern AZ! 🙏🏼🇺🇸🙏🏼
The "that was bull shit sips" kill me!
great stuff.....its amazing that so many people think the movie is accurate....the red patch Murphy wore was from New York City Fire Brigade...he wore it in honour of all the firefighters that died on 9/11.
🙏
Awesome breakdown video! Thank you for sharing your experience and expertise. Your channel is filled with amazing information.
You might want to ask people to tag the beginning of their comments if it's a question with the word "Question" so they're easier to see and sift through. I can imagine all the questions can become overwhelming if you have to sift through every comment to see them. Great channel!!
Awesome I can’t wait till part 3!!
The breakdowns are getting harder. I believe the next scene is the hardest to do. I should be done with it in the next couple weeks. I have a few more videos in front of it.
Have a great night and God bless.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge. In life I learn there is a time to talk and a time to listen. I would really injoy being in one of your classes, because of my health this would never happen. Thanks for the sharing your knowledge. God Bless.
You did a great job breaking down this part of the movie! I actually saw this gun fight from the POV of the Taliban. The video is on Reddit. They actually were wearing their red insignia patches. They stripped the gear off Danny Dietz, and Mike Murphy. They didn't disrespect their bodies like Alchida. But it was still hard to watch! You could hear them yelling back and forth to each other during the gun fight. Even heard Mike Murphy screaming for Marcus to help him at one point! It looked like around 8-12 Taliban fighters with a couple PKM machine guns, a couple guys with RPG's, and the rest will AK's. The SEAL's were carrying a ton of gear! What a sad day! The Taliban had the high ground, and I think the whole goat herder story was made up for OPSEC. Seemed like they heard the infill, then tracked them from where the helo dropped them off. They were unable to recover the fast ropes. So the SEAL's did they're best to hide them. But they were in the Talibans back yard. The scenery looked the same though same exact woods, and mountain terrain! They really were being pushed down the mountain, alot like what it shows in the movie. Not to that extreme that I could tell. But it was definitely some rough terrain! This movie definitely could use a part three with you giving your opinion on it. I don't know if you've seen the video the Taliban filmed while fighting the SEAL's. But it's definitely a good way to truly visualize what really went down. Because you can see and hear alot of what went down! It must be hard on Marcus! I couldn't imagine losing my brother's in arms all in one day like that! Including the helo that was shot down! When you mentioned the crypto and other gear that should be destroyed. Instead of letting it get into the hands of the enemy. All I can think of is how much of our gear the Taliban is rocking now! If we have to go into Afghanistan again, we'll be fighting through our own equipment! What a mess!!!!
You are correct. The movie is false in most aspects.
🙏
Just watched another video about the guy who saved Marcus. Apparently they had a falling out when the guy contradicted Luttrell's version after he saw the movie.
Is that video still around?
@@mitchr482 I found it recently. Only a few weeks ago. It was on Reddit. That's the only place I could find it. I saw it years ago before the movie was made. But didn't realize the significance of what I was seeing until after I saw the movie and heard some of Marcus's speeches. The mountain they filmed the movie on was very similar to the real thing. The Taliban had the high ground too, but it was only 8-12 guys. Not over 200. I don't think they ran into any goat herders either. Watch it on Reddit, read the comments, then decide for yourself what you think happened.
@@odyshopody9387 I've seen the same movie. I'm thinking Marcus had to change the real story for operational security and to paint the SEAL's in a different light than what actually happened. If you know what I'm saying. Either way, stuff definitely went very bad for those recon SEAL's that day. However Marcus made it out was a miracle!! And only Marcus, the Taliban, and whoever got to see the video the Taliban made when they were fighting them on that mountain. I'm sure whoever saw the full version of the video knows more than anyone. Even Marcus. It's crazy that they filmed it! Showed the dead bodies, and the equipment and patches were all SEAL issued equipment. Either way I think the movie was awesome! I bet Marcus has a different story he tells his family and close friends in the team's what really happened that day. From what I saw, the part that the Taliban had the high ground. And were pushing them down the mountain, and Mike Murphy did yell out to Marcus for help in the middle of the gun fight. Like it happened in the movie. Gulab the Afghan that protected Marcus said he didn't have any gun shot wounds and had his kit and full mags on him. I don't know why he would lie, Gulab that is. But I really want to believe Marcus. Just because I can't imagine what he went through that day. And however it went down I'm sure the government had to approve how the story was told. So it wasn't totally true. So really who really knows. Either way it's definitely something I thought about for awhile. And was just a little disappointed that we didn't get a full real story. But that's just life for us. We live in a manufactured reality that can be difficult to navigate through. So I don't fault anyone for doing what they gotta do! If you know what I'm saying, you know what I'm saying. Take care my friend!!😎🤜🤛🦅🇺🇸🦅🇺🇸🦅
Fantastic breakdown of the movie scenes. What a contrast between Hollywood version n reality.. U provided valuable info we can use in real life. Kudos for vid. New subscriber because of this vid. Anticipating ur next one.
This is great content! Keep it up. Would love to see 13 hours or some scenes from Seal Team.
Great breakdown, thank you. The one thing I would give the movie credit for though is the use of semi-auto fire instead of Hollywood's normal full auto everything.
That’s a great point. Honestly that never crossed my mind while making these but definitely a valid point. “The endless magazines”.
Have a great day and God bless
@@frogmantactical God Bless you as well Sir and Merry Christmas.
Mr. Pike I have the up most respect for you brave men and Women. I'm in Law enforcement and I enjoy listening to the tactics you provide. I'm a subscriber and look forward to more videos from you. God bless you sir!!
I’ve really been looking forward to this since the last one. Great breakdown, thank you!!!
Wish the video was longer. This shit was entertaining
The way you word your considerations has taught me much in 5 minutes, things i knew by different words.
Thank you sir, good review/breakdown.
Much appreciated.
I appreciate what you do always! First I thought ... who is this? LOL You shaved! May God Bless 🙏🏻
as brother pike says that almost 90% of the population does not grasp and understand is yes these movies are awsome, BUT..... NO movie should nor does show the full detail of what and how any branch especially spec ops. actually does there warfare and tactics for a reason... the whole world watches these movies, and common sense (which i know does not always prevail) would tell you that they would not compromise and show/give away alot of our stuff. people see these movies and immediately think this is how it works and NO it does not. atleast not all of it. we are the best for a reason. you wanta know how it truly works.. join and experience it in real time. thankyou brother for your videos i have enjoyed them and understand them.
Thank you for your service. Really appreciate. I am lucky enough as a veteran to have a few ex SEAL friends in San Diego. A pleasure sir.
The last shot when they fell down the cliff with the rpg explosion behind them reminds me of when all the power rangers get blasted by the villain and go flying. I don’t see why movies feel they need to be made this way the more realistic the more you get immersed and lost in the world and that’s what you pay for
Indeed
🙏
Another excellent teaching session. Fantastic. Thank you!
I want to Thank you! I play airsoft and paintball and ever since I came across your channel I have changed my play style! Yes I have taken what you point out to heart! I tell myself when I mess up that you would be disappointed!
No disappointment. War is part skill and part luck honestly. You aren’t hard to kill, nor am I. That’s why we train so hard. To have the edge over the enemy.
Each op requires different approaches based on intel, abs what you see upon approach.
Please consider joining Patreon. It helps us keep producing content and gives you the opportunity to train with us in CA for free.
www.patreon.com/Frogmantactical
This assessment is absolutely SPOT ON!!
Need more content like this! Great breakdown
Thank you. Working on it!
Have a great week and God bless.
Great, honest breakdown!
I was in Mosul in 2009. What you said about RPG is what Marcus said in his book of how close it hit. He embellished a lot to make something that much worse. He didn’t need to embellish the firefight at all we would’ve understood with him just telling the story. Yes Mikey wore that firefighter patch in combat. You can see it on him from the Taliban video taken during the firefight.
Paused the video so I could go purchase that sleep aid spray. Cbd and hemp is the way to go in a world of full of highly addictive substances. I can get addicted to anything and won’t lie I enjoy feeling good so I have to be careful. Thanks for sharing.
I think you will really like the spray. It knocks me out.
Have a great day and God bless.
Another great informative video. Many thanks
They were actually dug into the side of the mountain when the Taliban came. They looked right at them a few times but couldnt see them until finally Marcus had to make the 1st move even then they just shot random they still didnt see them. The book is way better
Thank you for sharing your insight and knowledge with us.
I coud listen this man for days ,amazing speaker
I don't know if this has been mentioned, and I can't say I thought of it when I first watched the movie, but they are fighting with their rucks still on. Through my military carreer (roughly 10 years and counting) we never fought with our rucks on. We did leave our big rucks in a ruck hide close to the OP, kept our 3 day bags on us and if engaged just dumped them. It's quite hard to fight with them on and it takes energy away from you. Granted they thought they'd need it after the fight. Are SEALs trained to dump their rucks? Great video!
Love the movie. Had some thoughts about there "Hollywood" version but all in all well done. Thank you for your professional opinion and most of all your service. God bless.
Great video thanks for sharing it!
This video was awesome! So much information and details!
Thank you! I took a lot from this break down
been waiting forever for this thanks
Loved this. Your explanation was very interesting. Wonder what Marcus would think.
This is my all-time favorite movie I've watched and read everything I can find about Marcus Luttrell you make excellent points breaking down this video I would love to see a breakdown of their Weapons Systems
Honest evaluation from a professional. Jason shares with us the truth, which our minds sometimes don't want to accept because it is Hollywood. We wish that war movies were accurate, but ask yourself if they were would you really find them entertaining? Probably not.
Loved this! Dispense with the Hollywood BS! SUBSCRIBED
Thank you!
God bless
Always enjoy your videos sir. That is for the insight. 🇺🇸
Nothing better than a Navy Seal saying, “Let me tell ya a story......”
In the ending shot of this breakdown, we watch the team jump off the cliff edge, would you have jumped, scaled down or lowered each other down if possible. Jumping seems like it would only compound the force and injuries about to be received? Respectively I/we were not there, so this is just an objective assessment of options that you may have done in this situation. Also taking into consideration the milliseconds of time to make decisions under this kind of pressure. Your thoughts are greatly appreciated. Thank you for your videos and knowledge you share and mostly for you Service 🇺🇸
That is why I stopped it right there. I will cover that on the first part of 3 but you are exactly right for that exact situation.
Have a great day and God bless
Being that this was filmed in America...if I was a betting man the mountains of the Hindu Kush has to be steep and tall considering there is snow on the peaks at night and Hot during the day...IDK thou wasn't there...
@mayhem4u !!!
Marcus Luttrelll answers your question in this speech I link below...
Watch from 10:45 - 12:08 and you will have your answer to that...
ruclips.net/video/SaKK2yJCI6g/видео.html
I also wanted to say that a book called, 'Victory Point', highlights 3 different platoons of Marines went in after these Anti Coalition Fighters of Ahmad Shah about 3 weeks later and had a hell of a time with them. I couldn't imagine just 4 guys versus those mountaineer warriors if platoons of Marines had a hard time with them...
@@frogmantactical when are you doing the part 3 ? Cant wait.
@@frogmantactical we need more of this it's really good info !
You're good people man, keep it goin. 🤙
Thank you.
🙏
I read the book Lone Survivor, and one thing that puzzled me was, after releasing the goat herder’s, why didn’t the team move to higher ground? Why didn’t they try to improve their defensive position conditions if they planned to engage the enemy? The mission should have been aborted once the team was compromised. The goat herders could have been detained, until the team was extracted. Thanks, for your insight on how real training vs Hollywood reality.
I’m a MK12 junkie, so I appreciate all the Hollywood MK12 money shots this film provides.
Great videos!! Please make more of different war films
Hey I appreciate your content. Keep up the good content and keep crushing it
Thank you very much for your insights.
I love your videos.
Enjoy the videos and hopefully one day I’ll be able to make it out to your training sessions it’s on a bucket list of mine
I have always wondered if SEALS and other elite soldiers get an adrenaline dump or tunnel vision surge the way people do in sanctioned fighting. Or if you are trained to mitigate that stuff. Random but interesting to me. Love your content! New fan/follower
Always stay with your swim buddy.
Great help and saving teammates, thanks
He had his unit wear the bright orange patch of FDNY Engine Co. 54, Ladder Co. 43 - “El Barrio’s Bravest” - on their uniforms as a team symbol and constant reminder of 9/11 and why the SEALs were in Afghanistan there’s a reason .
During filming Marcus Luttrell argued to with Peter Berg about the details.
Marcus wanted the actors to wear face paint camouflage because they wouldn’t go into the woods without it. Peter didn’t like it because it was difficult to who was who through the camera in specific lighting.
The movie doesn’t do the reality justice although it was a great movie.
I wish I could have you as a weapons and tactics instructor. I'm from Maryland and it would be nice to have instructors who taught realistically and not Hollywood
You’re in luck. You can come to CA/TX to train with me, I can come to you if you have a group that wants to train or even a private group. You may also sign up here as a member for $4.99/month. You will have perks that will help you get a higher level of training.
ruclips.net/channel/UCETndT02VX0XyQVvvpdQUqwjoin
🙏
Shootstabkill aka americasforces! Miss you god bless and hope your holidays are filled with love and joy!
Climb to Glory!
Stay alert stay alive!
Irizarry out!
Man, I was just thinking about you the other day. Where have you been?
@@frogmantactical Florida my man! Funny how a thought of someone and boom they appear.. I had a few people I enjoyed on Instagram, you are definitely one of my favorite people in the world! Always keeping it real and that’s the best part about you! Much love man good to see you doing your thing!
@@johnirizarryjr6508 Likewise brother. Be safe and God bless.
I was a Tanker in Habbaniyah Iraq 05-06. My very first day in sector, we haven't even taken over yet, just doing our right seat rides, I was a driver, my TC was in the loader spot and there were 2 Marines that were showing us around. Went out the back gate, hooked a right, went about 100 meters and the whole fucking tank shook like nothing I've ever felt before. That a 70 tons tin can and it moved. The Marine TC yelled "contact right 2 o'clock driver move NOW, find that fucker(talking to his gunner)". Some things happened, we moved, yada yada, I said"what the fuck was that" That Marine TC said, "welcome to the show, you boys just survived your first RPG round". We weren't on the MSR for, 15 min. It was the begining of 12 months of hell in that road. I had the privilege on a few occasions, of being a taxi for some of your boys, if I remember right, it was team 7, because my tank was outfitted with a CSAMM and liked to see what it could do, incase they needed a way out. Used to zero that thing on a 1" fence post at 1800 meters. Fuck I miss that shit
What a first day brother...
Dude loves that monster energy. Haha looking for that sponsorship.
Lol. I’m on the fence about it. They are better than Red Bull in my opinion but still bad for you in abundance and I am an extremist.
I was dying laughing near the end when the whole RPG RANT. I think most people would know an explosion can easily knock a few off a few limbs. We need part 3. Also, this isn't hard. Most people love Marcus Luttrell to and the other fallen seals, but Bollywood is Bollywood. Lol
Great channel, subbed!!!!!👍
I could only watch this film once even though I own it. I cried watching the way these men died.
Same
The movie and book is entirely fiction except for "Luttrell was a SEAL"
Holy heck, you look different with a clean shave.
Takes a few years off.
🙏
@20:00 I had literally seconds before, opened the exact same drink & same size can. LMFAO!!
This was really informative, I am going to either BUDS or PJ training in 6 months. I’ve been training, swimming, and shooting for 3 months and would love to get some advice if you have some time.
Outstanding. I just launched a new channel Train_Like_A_SEAL, however I am working on fitness videos. I don’t mentor. It’s too time consuming. 🙏
Good information. Thanks!
Compromised mission over. Smoke + Legs.
Hello brother in Christ, you do a great job breaking down film with truth, just as the word of God has to be interpreted in truth. I am ex military myself Army 13 echo. Hey, can you please explain the old movie US NAVY SEALS. Thanks
Thank you. Charlie Sheen? That’s not a good depiction on any level.
🙏
4x Acog, & Leopold 2.5X 8 on the optics. 1 of the Leopold scope,& Acog also had a micro reddot on top. Believe it was a RMR, or Delta point.
I think they were Doctor mini-reflex sights on the ACOGs. No idea what is on Axel's MR/T though.
*Leupold 2.5-8x
I was looking at the rifle second from the top and we like what kind of optic is that, gotta be a thermal or ir... Then I realized HOLY SHIT THAT'S A TRACKING POINT!!! LoL
I know lots of teams got into it bad and Markus ordeal after the gun fight makes for a good movie.
I don't know if other teams took these kind of losses and may never know.
But each and everyone one of those fight are movie worthy.
I'm afraid after what happened in Afghanistan after what are brilliant leader did plus the mind set of Hollywood those men will never get there stories told.
There has to be thousands of are hero's with amazing stories out there.
Hollywood has turned against what are country stands for.
Any movie with a veteran will be about how bad they where and all they elegal.
I got a bit carried away here but have good reason.
This is the second video of yours i have seen.
Your the best at it more details the better plz make more !
Great videos. Love your style. 2/75 rangers lead the way.
Thank you.
Have a great night and God bless.
I completely agree with most of what you're saying. I'm trying to figure out what is wrong with the front sight on the rifle behind you on the wall. 🤣
Thank you for your insight, keep doing the Lords work....
Thank you.
Hollywood. As successful as Kubrick's 'Full Metal Jacket' was I still have an image of GySgt Hartman wearing his PUC ribbon upside down.
Hey brother I bought the second Battle of Fallujah. I was wondering if you could do some kind of a video on that. Also I was wondering which seal team you were on? Keep the videos coming bro
Serious question....Have you ever been under the same pressure and conflict as Operation Red Wings?
I always thought it was Marcus luttrell that took the headshot on the Taliban that was about to jump on Axelson.
Saved his life.
Not sure.
@@frogmantactical
In part 1, you said you would be in favor of executing the goat herders. Where would you go from there?
Hide the bodies and extract, or complete the mission as planned?
@@maximustiberius3036 Situation depends however that would be mission compromised and you go to extract.
But but but Jason, those RPGs were those pesky Russian or Chintzy Chinese ones. Therefore rocks, sand, American made footwear and BDUs are impervious to them.😂 On the serious tho, you did a great breakdown and critique of Hollowwood portrayals. I am almost certain that, Marcus must of thrown his hands up a few times in disdain for the hollowwood money shots.
Appreciate the video