Edward Snowden vs Anatoly Yakovenko: Is Solana Centralized?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 окт 2024

Комментарии • 60

  • @longfield8978
    @longfield8978 23 дня назад +14

    If validators need to be KYCed ( as Solana does), that is centralized.

  • @rakly3473
    @rakly3473 23 дня назад +15

    "They are unable to say what makes it centralized."
    No they don't, you just ignore the valid definitions. Centralized is about control; Who has control over the network? That's what Snowden was referring to when he said that every one moves their stakes to the same thing giving it the ability to influence maliciously. (paraphrasing) - I have to dance around the wording because of youtube censorship.

  • @readysetmood9473
    @readysetmood9473 23 дня назад +18

    I will take an ex NSA analyst's word who risked it all to tell us the truth over Solana overlords...

    • @19battlehill
      @19battlehill 12 дней назад

      HE IS A FRAUD. He didn't risk his life -- this is a chess move. Snowden if part of "fake resistance" --- if you study these clowns like Greenwald, and idiot Weinstein Brothers, Joe Rogan, RFK jr, and Jordan Peterson you see they have HUGE HUGE inconsistences in their narratives. Peterson worked for WEF and Harvard, RFK jr is a lying corporate environmentalist, Weinstein Brothers - one just happens to be at the epicenter of the WOKE nonsense and the other worked at MIT and met Epstein (he knew he was evil and a fraud) --- try doing your own deep dive readysetmood --- you are fool that repeats others narratives.

  • @themistoclesofathens4178
    @themistoclesofathens4178 23 дня назад +19

    nice "vs" when they aren't even face to face. Take an out of context quote from Snowden and then give a biased interest 3 full minutes to spin a reply. How much you getting paid for these "interviews"?

    • @bobbyjonas2323
      @bobbyjonas2323 23 дня назад

      XDC will kill Ethereum and Solana! XDC is the REAL Ethereum and Solana Killer! 😎👍

  • @themistoclesofathens4178
    @themistoclesofathens4178 23 дня назад +9

    By the way I tried to get into Solana, I read the whitepaper, asked questions about it and was told it doesn't work in the way the whitepaper described anymore at all. Asked where I could find info on current consensus and the time slots (which get assigned pretty much manually), was told to contact discord users. Really tells you all you need to know, doesn't it.

    • @OldmanCrypto100
      @OldmanCrypto100 23 дня назад

      actually that doesent tell you anything

    • @bobbyjonas2323
      @bobbyjonas2323 23 дня назад

      XDC will kill Ethereum and Solana! XDC is the REAL Ethereum and Solana Killer! 😎👍

    • @bobbyjonas2323
      @bobbyjonas2323 23 дня назад

      @@OldmanCrypto100 XDC will kill Ethereum and Solana! XDC is the REAL Ethereum and Solana Killer! 😎👍

  • @FesteringRatSub
    @FesteringRatSub 23 дня назад +11

    Anatoly tries to lie his way around decentralization but just talks crap.

  • @APerson-ol1kj
    @APerson-ol1kj 23 дня назад +5

    It's called the Edinburgh decentralization index. And it's a thorough and objective measurement that Solana does somewhat poorly on.

  • @wantstocomment7092
    @wantstocomment7092 21 день назад +1

    Here. I'll define it in an objectively measurable way: SOL distribution is heavily centralized and the chain has no slashing. This makes SOL a game of chicken prone to self-reinforced spiriling.
    Ownership distribution and diversity are the most important aspects of network decentralization. State transition verifiability is besides the point when a handful of folk control upgrades.

  • @davycrockett8886
    @davycrockett8886 23 дня назад +7

    Anatoly fails to tell you the validators on Solana are largely owned by the Solana Foundation. He twists the truth. His and SBF's involvement show the culture of Solana.

  • @spacewanderern
    @spacewanderern 23 дня назад +2

    Snowden is right about Solana

  • @siriuswake705
    @siriuswake705 23 дня назад +6

    solana is finished

    • @dani88ization
      @dani88ization 23 дня назад

      @@siriuswake705 Like you?

    • @spiritofalaska
      @spiritofalaska 22 дня назад

      yeah ada and eth are like way ahead right. solana is down like 99% and ada and eth are now releasing this firedancer wich will take adas and eths tps to 1 million. also ada and eth are now dropping their 3nd phone. yeah sol i finished🤣

  • @andie9150
    @andie9150 23 дня назад +1

    I’m not shore about centralization , Eth is also questionable. I still find Solana the easiest, and most enjoyable block chain to interact with

  • @lawrencehutson2478
    @lawrencehutson2478 22 дня назад

    Wow, what way of admitting that Solana is centralized without staying the word

  • @deltacodealpha
    @deltacodealpha 23 дня назад +1

    add tornado cash to Solana and we'll see how centralized it is

  • @AliceKehew
    @AliceKehew 23 дня назад

    Thank you so much for this amazing video! A bit off-topic, but I wanted to ask: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (behave today finger ski upon boy assault summer exhaust beauty stereo over). Could you explain how to move them to Binance?

  • @ayeshashehzadi-j5z
    @ayeshashehzadi-j5z 9 дней назад

    Shiba Shootout's blockchain-based achievement system securely verifies player milestones. 🐕🏅

  • @irsoftware8195
    @irsoftware8195 18 дней назад

    Sounds centralized to me.

  • @SamanthaJohns-bb4zk
    @SamanthaJohns-bb4zk 13 дней назад

    Memebet Token's integration with virtual sports is providing round-the-clock betting opportunities. ⏰💰

  • @powerralley
    @powerralley 23 дня назад

    Seems like mainstream adoption is starting to happen and ethereum is the winner.

  • @geoffl
    @geoffl 23 дня назад +1

    more convinced by Toly here

    • @GordaoSemFuturo
      @GordaoSemFuturo 23 дня назад +1

      Sure. Why would he tell the truth and admit it is centralized, right?

    • @geoffl
      @geoffl 23 дня назад +1

      @@GordaoSemFuturo rewatch the video. Take notes.

    • @Jadeite12
      @Jadeite12 23 дня назад +2

      just watch Mashinsky, SBF, Kwon Do, and you will be convinced by them as well, except in their case the bubble already burst and we know what they are and how solid were their projects (Celsius, FTX, Terra Luna). P.S.: And of course, it's not a red flag at all that SBF had Solana as his darling.

    • @geoffl
      @geoffl 22 дня назад +1

      @@Jadeite12 you sound like a trader and not a coder

    • @Jadeite12
      @Jadeite12 22 дня назад

      @@geoffl value investor (so I am not interested into jumping into something that I have little or no faith in, which traders actually like cause they like high volatility).
      You want random coders interested into hype? Maybe they're into Solana, they're kids after all and they can just use AI to create their bots that inflate Solana metrics and help extract value from the Solana users who may or may not know that they are used for pumps and dumps.
      You want professionals into cryptography, go to Cardano, Algorand, not Solana.

  • @Martin-is5vw
    @Martin-is5vw 18 дней назад

    anatoly is full of shite

  • @StefansDream
    @StefansDream 23 дня назад

    4

    • @bobbyjonas2323
      @bobbyjonas2323 23 дня назад

      XDC will kill Ethereum and Solana! XDC is the REAL Ethereum and Solana Killer! 😎👍

    • @StefansDream
      @StefansDream 23 дня назад

      @@bobbyjonas2323 never heard of