Yes, once we had large Soviet battle cruiser, the KRI Gajah Mada. Now we have only, corvettes, from the West. Quite embarrassing for a large maritime nation. But not to worry, we are building our navy. But obviously we can never be big if we source hardware from the West. We will be, bankrupt, just like them.
was once a formidable maritime empire? i watched/read thousands about world history but im certain there's no such thing. only how the western colonial powers have an easy pickings on brown/black races
@@leexingha The Majapahit Empire, it was early to mid medieval period, but the Empire broke apart into rival kingdoms long before European colonizers got to the region.
*I have a lot of Indonesian and Filipino friends back in college they are jolly and I love being with them. And another similarity is that they are brave people, they always wear that smile but they never back down, I miss them because I love being with them* Indos, Filipinos.. south east Asian people, please keep on standing up for what is right. God bless you guys. 🙏
@@davinxi5926what conflict? Indonesia and Philippines have strong connection for years. Hell even sultanate of sulu in Phillipines will become Indonesia greatest delight if they could acquire their lands from malaysia 😂
Kalau ingin aman dari China cobalah memperbaiki hubungan bilateral dengan China dan bernegosiasi soal keamanan laut China Selatan seperti yang di lakukan oleh Indonesia yang di mana mempererat hubungan China Indonesia
Lah Indonesia aja menaruh kapal perang di Lcs biar china ga main². Filipina udh menjalin hubungan yg baik tapi emang china aja yg tukang bully dan mau klaim Lcs.
im a filipino with high regards to the military power of my indonesian neighbor. Indonesia is poised to become the top military power in southeast asia. If you think the indonesians are getting weak, well you better have your self checked out by a psychiatrist...a 1+ trillion dollars economy with a population of 200+ million and a vast natural resources that can drive their economy higher are indications that indonesia is not getting weak. They can even manufacture their own navy warships now.
I agree. Indonesia should purchase new frigates and destroyers from China as soon as possible. Submarines can be purchased from France and Germany. Chinese amphibious landing ships are a great choice, you can refer to Thailand's 071, buy a hull, and install weapons yourself.
@@kevinrich5222 The Philippines is weak now, but just you wait. The 3rd phase of its military modernization is its biggest yet, with a fund of $35Billion over a span of 5 years. The plan includes buying more Multi-Role Fighters, Submarines, HIMARS, Frigates, and other big ticket arms purchases.
@@whoami66669 from what country are u from? Both Indonesia & Philippines are the strongest economies in SEA (Southeast Asia) now. Let see who the poor countries are after ten years from now. Just go back to my comment after 10 yrs. 😄
after visit Manila recently , i agree we are mostly same pare we need less recto and rizal ave , and more makati and BGC we need lift as many people as possible to better economically , not bigger navy Indonesia too need to lift as many people as possible to better income
@@supriadiramlan5545 I agree, South East Asian nations have to focus more on improving their economies and uplifting their people from poverty. BUT, China's actions in South China Sea, threatening the territorial integrity of Indonesia, Vietnam, Philippines, Malaysia, and Brunei, has forces an arms race in the region. All those money could've been used for social welfare instead of arms purchase. This is what we call the "Guns v Butter" concept in Economics. Every arms you buy, is a man not clothe, fed, or sheltered. But it's important to balance security with prosperity too... because those who chooses wealth over security, ends up with neither.
@@JustCassually did u look what China did? they stop war, and focusing t heir working age productivity to become rich,. when u rich u can dispute in internationla law, thats how world works and US will fight China to last Taiwanese, Pinoy or even Indonesian.... like US fight Russian till last Ukrainian and who they send to battle field? every common people ... where the rich boy and preident son's gp? shopping to US with private jet :) idid u really wanted become sacrifcial goat for US? lol i am bot and trying t o info my fellow countryman not while why so eager to die for USA?
Di era pak Prabowo ber ambisi untuk memodernisasi secara besar-besaran untuk memperkuat di semua Matra dan memang masih fokus ke pembangunan infrastruktur dan pendidikan untuk memperkuat ekonomi
Kalau ingin aman dari China cobalah memperbaiki hubungan bilateral dengan China dan bernegosiasi soal keamanan laut China Selatan seperti yang di lakukan oleh Indonesia yang di mana mempererat hubungan China Indonesia
Lah Indonesia naro kapal perang biar china ga main². Filipina udh berkali-kali baik tetap aja diterobos kedaulatannya. Tukang bully kayak china kok dibela?
@@vidarodinson5246 ya2 mau bikin perang Ukraina jilid 2 ya tau lah Filipina terlalu dekat dengan Amerika jadi ya tunggu saja kedepannya ?? Kita lihat saja nanti 😁😁
Indonesia is not an invasion country, Indonesia does not want to go to war with any country, but Indonesia protects its homeland from invasion by foreign powers.
@@indonesiaforlifeIf you study the invasion of East Timor in 1975, all the hardwares, the tanks, the helicopters were all still bore the markings of US military in Vietnam. Indonesia was basically, Ukraine of 1975. The US supplied the armaments, we supplied the soldiers. It also showed that our soldiers were better than US soldiers in battle. East Timor was a mistake of being Philippines of the day. And we have to live with it. It was an important lesson about having dignity, not to be dictated by other, interests.
In 5 years recently Indonesian Navy is under huge modernization under Minister of Defense and newly elected President Prabowo Subianto. Not only Navy but also Army and Air Force.
@@tyopratomo5688 You sure? They happily let their middle class move borderline to poverty. While Jokowi has installed the private jet flying son and his other son in high posts ✌
@@vidarodinson5246 most of your army and navy militarily hardware are from Australia garage sale. what irony is, Australia gives Zelensky state of the arts of modern warfare for free whereas Indonesia has to pay 4 it
Yes it's true but not their big bully neighbor! Whether we like it or not we need to modernized our militaries capabilities on territorial defense. The storms was on the horizon and it's coming!😮😮😮
Hard to believes when Indonesia only spent less than 1% of it's national GDP for defense, but worry not, Prabowo will surely changed it after his presidency started, i hope Indonesia can spend 1.5-3% of it's gdp
@@tianmingchen-mc7xdthere is no south china sea, specially there imaginary 10 dash line all are just based on there beliefs that everythings is belong to them since ancient time 😂
Indonesia, the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia must unite and must carry out frequent defense exercises in this sea and I hope that the Indonesian maritime army can be even more powerful
The Indonesian government, specifically the Ministry of Defense, has a kind of regulation not to publish the country's defense strategy, so meetings with parliament are held behind closed doors. So I am quite sure that the Indonesian defense information published will not be completely accurate both in terms of finances or funding and defense equipment.
Apa yg mau disembunyikan dari negara superpower kaya china dan usa Tinggal liat satelit keliatan semua Kapal, pesawat, lapangan terbang,tank🤣 Blm lagi agen mata2 mereka yg beroperasi diseluruh dunia
we got it worse in philippines, despite spending 1% of gdp for defense, 80% of it went straight to soldiers salary and huge ass pension, 15% for maintenance only 5% remain for acquisition. for 3 years we still have no new acquisition after the 2 corvettes and 6 opv. yet they billions for AID which isn't economically developing.
@@sayfolman7752 Yeah, you are right. $10 billion is not enough. China has 3 aircraft carriers and about 350 warships. Some of them are quite advanced. China is going to build at least 3 more aircraft carriers.
Sebenarnya indonesia sedang membuat pondasi militer untuk meregenerasi ke sistem modern dan itu butuh waktu,tidak bisa sekonyong konyong langsung menaikan anggaran pertahanan tanpa terperinci untuk apa saja dana tersebut di gunakan pada tahun penggunaannya , anggaran yang di butuhkan harus terperinci dengan baik dan besar kecil anggaran tergantung kebutuhan pada tahun yang akan di lalui,mungkin jika pondasi militer sudah terpenuhi bisa jadi anggaran militer indonesia kedepan naik menjadi 1,5 persen dari GDP karena di masa itu adalah masa produksi alat militer skala besar untuk mengisi pondasi yang telah terbentuk dan saya kira indonesia sedang menuju ke hal tersebut
Very informative about the Indonesian Navy put in a strategic context from top politics to the local fishermen. Moreover, it's a good idea to interview retired officers because from them you get a more complete story.
Ingat pepatah "kamu berfikir ekonomi tapi jangan kau lupakan kekuatan fisikmu" so jika kamu terlalu terjebak di ekonomi namun lupa menguatkan kekuatan militermu maka siaplah kedepan akan dilibas oleh lawanmu,
Let's swipe the e economic affairs aside for a moment, we must build our tough armed force mainly focussed to deter another country which initiated the dispute. The government must gain the consciousness about potential threat that will be faced in the future not to fulfill for temporary satisfaction.
@@evannave9718yes we have example for the country which has biggest military budget in ASEAN. But, from that case we could use as reference for the modernity of our forces
Kekuatan maritim masyarakat Indonesia sudah dimatikan sejak jaman VOC, Dan sekarang Indonesia terlalu mengikuti Mataram Islam yang bersifat negara Agraria, belum lagi zaman Soeharto terlalu menganakemaskan Angkatan Darat, KRI irian aja gak tau dimana rimba nya.
Era Soeharto gk ada kasus2 melanggar maritim nak,eh bocillll... Om lahir era Soeharto.. gk ada kkasus2 pelanggaran teritorial, Soeharto macan Asia pda wkt itu ditakuti bhkan Soeharto jd penengah konflik perang di bosnia pd wkt itu
@@greenhat4833jaman Soeharto RRC masih negara berkembang coy. Pendapatan per kapita aja di bawah Indonesia. Setelah 1998, Indonesia tenggelam, RRC malah menjulang... Indonesia baru sekitar 2004 kembali ke situasi ekonomi level 1997. Kita kehilangan 7 tahun yg berharga...
indonesia . jangan goyang..mau adidaya,dan negara maju mencoba mengganggu..kita sigap selalu..semboyan kita,tidak mengganggu tapi kalau di ganggu..kita kan siap
Indonesia is the lead in ASEAN and should increase its military budget to 3% of its GDP to catch up with the increased in spending of neighboring countries like Singapore, Malaysia and Philippines. China's PLA is slowing encroaching on 4 of ASEAN countries and Indonesia should support the four countries sovereignty from China's incursion on their respective territories.
There's investment to increase the capacity of Indonesian Navy. What lack still is investment for Bakamla/Coast Guard. Fisheries and resources protection should be part of coast guard job, not navy. Navy job is for defensive and offensive capabilities, not naval constabulary duties. That's coast guard job. The others in SCS also put coast guards mostly on the job, including China. Coast Guard job to shown maritime jurisdiction, and using coast guards agains each other's better for conflict diplomacy then Navy.
jalasveva jayamahe dilaut kita jaya, saya pelaut sebagai bagian dari maritim sangat mendukung pemerintah untuk meningkatkan kekuatan angkatan laut kita.
tiongkok pandai dan paham untung ruginya jika menyeret indonesia dalam situasi ini, semua negara negara di laut yg natuna utara/yg berpotensi konflik dengan tionkok pasti sedang dan sudah bersiap siap untuk membela diri.
Thx to our elected president Prabowo subianto and as active defence minister Our navy and air force got huge modernization We just launch new vessel but we still have more work to get done
@@indonesiaforlifeobviously.. It's like huawei vs nokia and motorola.. But nobody buy huawei coz no legit os.. It's like still nobody believe with china😂
Indonesia had insisted to Philipine, Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei since long time ago since Soekarno's Plan in Manilla Agreement. And these ideas has nowdays proven and relevance to international geopolitic issues. With Confederations strategies along the countries it will consolidate thus power and have capability to develop more to mapping its potential threats and spread the economics strategy and defense along the waters of the sea from any foreign pressures. neither US, China, or even India.
Its never happen. Indonesia is not a stupid country that is easily incited to become a US puppet. They more understand about Geopolitical Situation than you Filipino.
Yes, this news is produce the conflict and tension between Indonesia and China to destroy our trust. China invest a lots in Indonesia, so they want Indonesia become better and build the high speed rail in Jakarta.
Stop Your Bullshit Propaganda Chinese Communist,A Few Day Ago China Coast Guard Enter Malaysia And Indonesia Maritime Zone And Demand Both Country Stop Extract Oil From Sea Bed
Fokus jokowi insfratruktur, kita liat Prabowo dia paham tentang pertahanan pasti akan ditingkatkan dan beliau mengerti utk menglola negara Indonesia. Sy optimis dibawah kepempinan presiden Prabowo nanti ekonomi, pertahanan akan kuat. Jangan di tanyakan tentang pertahanan Indonesia walau dari segi anggaran kurang tapi Indonesia jiwa petarung dan mempunyai banyak pengalaman perang dalam maupun luar negeri. Media Singapura dipikir Indonesia itu bodoh, jangan salah Indonesia itu cerdik punya banyak strategi. Setiap analisis Singapura dari jaman Soeharto sampe skrg meleset kurang tepat. Indonesia itu ahli strategi
Bener juga ya, Media Singapura seperti mempunyai grudge kepada Indonesia. Dari IKN sampai ini, seperti mereka merendahkan kita, ya begitulah negara kecil tapi egonya tinggi.
Indonesian Navy and Coastguard should utilize those fishermen as intelligence agents that will inform the military for any intrusions by foreign vessels or fishermen. Provide them with satellite communication devices or other communication equipment.
It is always quality vs. value. Buying 2nd hand stuff works to build up quickly a force but are mostly maintenance sensitive. Spnt less on hardware, but spent more on maintanace
The increase in Indonesian military strength was initially not triggered by China, but by acts of provocation and humiliation by the Malaysian military, culminating during President SBY's visit on a warship and there was an act of cheap provocation by a Malaysian plane that deliberately flew over the ship carrying SBY's presentation, from the moment That's when the MEF (military force arrangement) started, and look now the Malaysian military is actually lagging behind
Prabowo could create a military industrialization movement to develop Indonesia's human resource and build up it's military, 2 birds with one stone. Build it's own military gear, feed and train it's citizens in the fields of military engineering. it'll be a long and hard struggle, but one that's worthwhile for sure looking at rhe current geopolitical situation.
Indonesia compared to the Philippines can easily modernize it's military with its current GDP and growing Middle class. Go Indonesia, the Rise of ASEAN Malays
@@Edgar_Ramirez471yes we are😂 we Filipino and Indonesian are same color, some of word are similar, just search in internet what Filipino look like, in Asia 😂
Unlike Singapore with urban warfare tactics, Indonesian Defense doctrines are actually similar with Vietnam, even many Indonesian tactical generals trained with Vietcong in the 90s. Enemy can enter Indonesia but can't get out...
99% Conflict With China And Not Just Indonesia But All ASEAN Country That Have Maritime Dispute With China Because Other Also Have Interest In That Region The Question You Should Ask Will Those Country Enter The Conflict Directly Or Indirectly Directly All ASEAN Go War With China Indirectly Fund Separatist In China Soil Or Funds Country That Going To War With China
The problem is also in doctrines, Indonesia mainly adapt to the aging jeune ecole of France where quantity and quality focus more on the production of powerful smaller ships. The doctrine also entice to a more green water navy alike, sure our ocean is vast but it's also shallow, our docks that could held such large ship are only in the southern hemisphere.
Yes these are clients of PT PAL or alliance of Indonesia navies for sure including the Philippines of course 😊😊 The Philippine Navy has two PT PAL ships:BRP Tarlac and BRP Davao Del Sur, but the other two are still under construction and expected to commissioned soon 😊😊
Indonesia and Philipina are same in culture, etnis, and more than others country. We are same how to protect our home land. Indonesia dan pilipin hmpir sama secara budaya dan kebiasaan dlm keseharian nya.
Indonesia is the only country in South East Asia that can build its own warships.Indonesia just finished construction on two Indonesian warships.Indonesia is certainly not lagging behind its neighbours.
Tetangga itu tdk akan mngncam. Tapi klo dr china gmn... juah bumi dan lngit ajuh nya..😅 Jika bertanding jangn cri lawan yg lemah. Agar terlihat perkasa.
@@Orangbiasa_45indonesia tak pernah cari musuh , tapi indonesia juga tak pernah takut sama bangsa mana pun,, siapa yang ngusik indonesia , maka indonesia juga akan lawan.
Kami rakyat Indonesia ngk peduli kami kalah jumlah alat tempur dan kalah jumlah tantara kami rakyat Indonesia ngk takut ama negara manapun karna kami di jalan yng benar, klo negara lain mau ngajak perang kami siap mati demi kebenaran
Kalau baru tahu, nggak mungkin kita sudah bangun frigate dr beberapa tahun lalu. CNA n bolo2nya yg baru notice. APBN militer kita naik, jadi kita sudah mampu bayar. Waktunya buat tipu2 lagi seperti dulu. Corvette seharga battle cruiser. Komisi dong! Korupsi dong! Yang penting kan duitnya. Daripada bikin infrastructures that you do not need kan baikan duitnya kasih kita. Komisinya gede lho.
@@Phoenix-bq7lw masih banyak kok blm tau kalau TNI AL kuno. yng percaya ranking2. CNN Indonesia tu 16 Agustus keluar berita TNI AL rank 4 dunia😂. Formidable mya SG dibangun dari awal2 tahun 2000, 2004 jadi aktif 2007. Jadi memang TNI AL kalau baru mulai dibangun FMP itu tertinggal.
@@hendrasutrisno4191 2 class martadinata itu masih baru,5 class ahmad yani itu baru tua,negara lain juga banyak yg masih mengoperasikan kapal tua,seperti kd lekiu milik malaysia itu juga udah tua hampir sama dgn class ahmad yani tapi masih jadi unjung tobak angkatan laut malaysia
@@Stuntend Ya apa ideal nya spt itu? Kan tidak. Masak kompare sama malaysia mulu. ANZAC class nya Australia sdh pensi pdhl 30 thn lbh muda. Ahmad Yani blm ada penggantj nya.
It's a bit strange that CNA is more focused on dragging Indonesia into conflict with China where it's clear there hasn't been any direct aggression from China. As long as the Natuna block runs smoothly, why should Indonesia act further ? So far, China has more often disturbed Philippine territorial waters.
Jai Hind. War is good money for suppliers of military hardware, According to Utube, the US will be lapping up all of the Ukraine national resources based on the 1 trillion arms aid so far.
ingat bro. china masih mengklaim laut natuna utara sebagai wilayahnya dan sampai cina berhenti mengklaim laut natuna sebagai wilayahnya, kita gak akan berhenti berkonfrontasi dengan cina.
@@freemanol Tama na ang pagpapanggap. Filipinos crave attention and hate criticism, we slowly becoming collectively narcissistic people. Filipinos rather die being praised than being criticised for good. Mga pilipino tamad, asa sa gobyerno. Believe me, our country will never be a fully developed nation within the next 100 years.
@@freemanolThen why is Indonesia better than Philippines? We are very different to Philippines. For one, we are making effort to address the problems.
@@Phoenix-bq7lw better in what?? indonesia has the biggest slum in SEA, highest crime & corruption rate, unrecognizable as well as nobody in the world knows about indonesia. Overall 🇵🇭🇹🇭🇻🇳🇲🇾🇸🇬>>>>>>>>>🇲🇨
@@tailsorange2872If China not become a thief, ASEAN countries doesn't really much worry about "arm race". Just stay focus on economy development. A thief is a thief, and thief will always lie.
The unity of south east asean is very strong we are brothers and the same ancestors from austroneseans🇵🇭 china is greed of power but we asean love peace
Indonesia has never bothered other countries and does not want to be bothered by other countries... If any other country interferes, your enemy is not only the military but also 270 million Indonesians, when it comes to the government we are divided but when it comes to the homeland we are united and stand together.
I laughed when China claimed that They really thought inner 9 dash or 10 dash lines marine territory belongs to them. What kind of country in Earth assert opinion like this😂😂😂
Well laugh all you want if you don't know anything. The none dash line does belong to China! It is in the UNCLOS. Do you not even know nine dash line of what? Just nine dash line? It is an UNCLOS clause under lined by nine dash line! Philippines signed UNCLOS, the US does not! That is why UNCLOS signatory nations never go against China on the nine dash line, except Philippines. We are all law abiding nations, not I am the law like the US. We do not want to obey the US, but we do not want to be bullied by the US either for the perception of siding with China. So, silent is gold. The UN defines UNCLOS, not the US, and certainly not the permanent court of arbitration.
Indonesia has the 4 largest navy in the world... Indonesia has strong guts,for the sake of the country they don't care about their lives.. Indonesia has deadly weapons,the people and the TNI will unite to defend their homeland..learn from our history..🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Minority People In Afghan,Syria,Yemen Etc Also.Say That In The Beginning But Cannot Succumb To Hunger And Starvation Patriotic Have No Value, When Your Family Starving And Hunger
Tertinggal atau tidak itu bukan masalah penting. Yang PENTING adalah Rakyat Indonesia memiliki Nasionalisme & Patriotisme yang tinggi dalam membela Negaranya. Saya YAKIN - China tidak akan gegabah menghadapi Bangsa Indonesia..... beda kalau mereka menghadapi Malaysia/Piliphina.
Is Indonesia’s Navy Lagging Behind? NO! Try observing the PH, Indonesia is more far ahead than that country. Unlike PH who seeks appeasement and shown cowardice. INDONESIA has shown resolved!
Shoutout from a Pinoy in Scandinavia ❤❤❤ the world should not think about the past instead lock forward and be alongside with international community so that we can strengthen the international law and law of the sea 🌊 or else the world will go back to a Stone Age system.
Considering SG only need to defend small Islands... it is ok. They even have more submarine (8vs4) and frigate than Indonesia(6 Formidable vs 2 REM, formidable also heavier)
Di masa bayang-bayang konflik seperti ini bersyukur presiden yang terpilih lebih tegas, pembangunan sudah berjalan di era Jokowi, sekarang kita punya Prabowo, semoga pertahanan Indonesia makin kuat dan tidak diremehkan bangsa lain
*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea: - parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭 and Indonesia 🇮🇩, - the rest of it is the international water, - no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
Hey bro, republic of china and the people republic of china have no sea territory dispute with Indonesia. Do you studying the geography lesson? You can searching the geography to check detaily and you should pay more hard to studying the geography and fact check by yourself, ok?
C'mon Indonesia was once a formidable Maritime Empire, it can be again. Best wishes from Thailand 🇹🇭🇮🇩
Yes, once we had large Soviet battle cruiser, the KRI Gajah Mada. Now we have only, corvettes, from the West. Quite embarrassing for a large maritime nation. But not to worry, we are building our navy. But obviously we can never be big if we source hardware from the West. We will be, bankrupt, just like them.
was once a formidable maritime empire? i watched/read thousands about world history but im certain there's no such thing. only how the western colonial powers have an easy pickings on brown/black races
@@leexinghagoogle europe horse meat consumption
@@abmong never believe Singapore media, they are the eternal enemy of Indonesia
@@leexingha The Majapahit Empire, it was early to mid medieval period, but the Empire broke apart into rival kingdoms long before European colonizers got to the region.
*I have a lot of Indonesian and Filipino friends back in college they are jolly and I love being with them. And another similarity is that they are brave people, they always wear that smile but they never back down, I miss them because I love being with them* Indos, Filipinos.. south east Asian people, please keep on standing up for what is right. God bless you guys. 🙏
Indonesian and Filipinos aren’t friends. We’ve had conflicts befor
@@davinxi5926 what conflic😂
@@deuscaritasest1278 conflicts in mobile legends lol
@@davinxi5926😂
@@davinxi5926what conflict? Indonesia and Philippines have strong connection for years. Hell even sultanate of sulu in Phillipines will become Indonesia greatest delight if they could acquire their lands from malaysia 😂
Much love from the Philippines. Lets go Indonesia ❤❤❤
You're dark short indonesian pretending to be filipino
Thanks CNA from Indonesia for the documentary, good coverage in Sunda Kelapa..🇮🇩❤🇸🇬
What happens when you combine islum and anything outside of abusing women and children? A failed state.
Pt pal has build 2 ships already for the Philippines navy, another one is coming next year, good craftsmanship by Indonesia
Next Filipina order tank in Indonesia
@@republikrakyatindonesia Oh yeah tanks too and also additional aircraft soon ☺️☺️
Thanks Philippines for your support greetings from INDONESIA 🇮🇩❤️🇵🇭
Glory to Indonesia and Philippines
@@vidarodinson5246 Thanks 👍👍
We Filipinos wish Indonesia to stay strong. God bless the people of Indonesia & her armed forces ! 😊🙏🙏👍✊✊
God Bless Us SEA people 🙏
Kalau ingin aman dari China cobalah memperbaiki hubungan bilateral dengan China dan bernegosiasi soal keamanan laut China Selatan seperti yang di lakukan oleh Indonesia yang di mana mempererat hubungan China Indonesia
Lah Indonesia aja menaruh kapal perang di Lcs biar china ga main². Filipina udh menjalin hubungan yg baik tapi emang china aja yg tukang bully dan mau klaim Lcs.
Tukang bully kayak china kok dibela?
@@vidarodinson5246 tunggu saja nanti perang Ukraina jilid 2 di Filipina 😁 ya taulah misi Amerika di Asean 😁😁
im a filipino with high regards to the military power of my indonesian neighbor. Indonesia is poised to become the top military power in southeast asia. If you think the indonesians are getting weak, well you better have your self checked out by a psychiatrist...a 1+ trillion dollars economy with a population of 200+ million and a vast natural resources that can drive their economy higher are indications that indonesia is not getting weak. They can even manufacture their own navy warships now.
🇲🇨 ❣ 🇵🇭 🤝🔥
I would rather have the Indonesians as an ally than the U.S
@@roronoadluffy637salah bendera njir 🇲🇨itu monaco yang kamu pake ,,, ini 🇮🇩Indonesia. Haduh
@@xynz01 mana ada 🇲🇨 🇮🇩😂
@@roronoadluffy637 lihat tuh komentar mu di atas
🇲🇨🤍🇵🇭 punya mu gitu
🇮🇩🤍🇵🇭 harusnya gini 😒. Bendera negara sendiri ga tau njir
🇻🇳🇲🇾🇵🇭 kita tetap akan bersama di Laut ASEAN, Cinta dari saudaramu Indonesia🇮🇩💪
Bersama apanya tolol ikan di colongin Mulu sama negara china
That's what you consider them while they consider you otherwise, m050n!!
🦶
🇲🇾
@@republikrakyatindonesia One example of a low human quality in 🇮🇩
@@republikrakyatindonesia tolong jangan gunakan Nama Indonesia untuk merendahkan Negara lain kecuali Israhell. Apa gak malu ?
Support the Indonesian Navy for the Allies of the sea with the Philippines 🇵🇭💕🇮🇩
I agree. Indonesia should purchase new frigates and destroyers from China as soon as possible. Submarines can be purchased from France and Germany. Chinese amphibious landing ships are a great choice, you can refer to Thailand's 071, buy a hull, and install weapons yourself.
What are the benefits for Indonesia to form an alliance with a weak navy like the Philippines?
@@kevinrich5222 The Philippines is weak now, but just you wait. The 3rd phase of its military modernization is its biggest yet, with a fund of $35Billion over a span of 5 years. The plan includes buying more Multi-Role Fighters, Submarines, HIMARS, Frigates, and other big ticket arms purchases.
@@kevinrich5222Ain't no way you're saying that while Indonesian ships is older than Philippine warships
@@kevinrich5222Equipment and Military Exercises of course 😊😊
We support for a strong, rich and Islamic Indonesia in the future Insha’Allah
🇵🇭♥️🇮🇩 Philippines is with you Indonesia brother! ✊✊✊
Yeah Philippines-Indonesia Friendship 😊😊
the Indon - Pinoy connection . 🤣😅
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 both are poor countries, lol
@@whoami66669 from what country are u from? Both Indonesia & Philippines are the strongest economies in SEA (Southeast Asia) now. Let see who the poor countries are after ten years from now. Just go back to my comment after 10 yrs. 😄
@@ssrae-2229 one is the US lapdog one is not...
We Filipinos have the same malayan root with Malaysia and Indonesia. Long live Indonesia!!!
Ingat nenek moyang kita seorg pelaut...bangsa kita bangsa pejuang bukan bangsa pengecut..❤️❤️🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩❤️❤️❤️❤️
@@aryagg123 bangsa korupsi bangsa mu indonesia
Jaman dulu brooo,, jangan samakan jaman sekarang,, tentara mu pengecut semua ke banyakan makan gaji buta.
Aduh mas... bedakan jaman dgn skrg.klo dulu brani,lah skrg mana brani.nenek moyangmu yg suka korup dulu sampai skrg.
pelaut? iya maksudnya nelayan, not an explorer like Portuguese, Spain, Netherlands etc. Jangan terlalu bangga dengan "katanya" kejayaan masa lalu.
@@rafaelkacaribu2081miris😅... minim literasi😢
Indonesia and Philippines are same and island nation..They both need bigger navy.
You have my vote from Singapore.
after visit Manila recently , i agree we are mostly same pare
we need less recto and rizal ave , and more makati and BGC
we need lift as many people as possible to better economically , not bigger navy
Indonesia too need to lift as many people as possible to better income
@@supriadiramlan5545 I agree, South East Asian nations have to focus more on improving their economies and uplifting their people from poverty. BUT, China's actions in South China Sea, threatening the territorial integrity of Indonesia, Vietnam, Philippines, Malaysia, and Brunei, has forces an arms race in the region. All those money could've been used for social welfare instead of arms purchase.
This is what we call the "Guns v Butter" concept in Economics. Every arms you buy, is a man not clothe, fed, or sheltered. But it's important to balance security with prosperity too... because those who chooses wealth over security, ends up with neither.
The PI like Indonesian needs development not more fesr mongering. The Americans got the PI media under their control and the Pinoys are scared.
@@JustCassually did u look what China did? they stop war, and focusing t heir working age productivity to become rich,. when u rich u can dispute in internationla law, thats how world works
and US will fight China to last Taiwanese, Pinoy or even Indonesian.... like US fight Russian till last Ukrainian
and who they send to battle field? every common people ... where the rich boy and preident son's gp? shopping to US with private jet :)
idid u really wanted become sacrifcial goat for US? lol i am bot and trying t o info my fellow countryman not while
why so eager to die for USA?
Di era pak Prabowo ber ambisi untuk memodernisasi secara besar-besaran untuk memperkuat di semua Matra dan memang masih fokus ke pembangunan infrastruktur dan pendidikan untuk memperkuat ekonomi
Jalesveva Jayamahe.
Di Lautan, Kita Jaya.
At the Sea, We Triumph.
Love TNI from Filipina🇵🇭
Love Philippines military from Indonesia...
Kalau ingin aman dari China cobalah memperbaiki hubungan bilateral dengan China dan bernegosiasi soal keamanan laut China Selatan seperti yang di lakukan oleh Indonesia yang di mana mempererat hubungan China Indonesia
Lah Indonesia naro kapal perang biar china ga main². Filipina udh berkali-kali baik tetap aja diterobos kedaulatannya. Tukang bully kayak china kok dibela?
Aneh aja tukang bully china dibela🤦♂️
@@vidarodinson5246 ya2 mau bikin perang Ukraina jilid 2 ya tau lah Filipina terlalu dekat dengan Amerika jadi ya tunggu saja kedepannya ?? Kita lihat saja nanti 😁😁
Indonesia is not an invasion country, Indonesia does not want to go to war with any country, but Indonesia protects its homeland from invasion by foreign powers.
@@masud3338 East Timor 🫣
And your Country No planning to Support Neighborhood??
Just only them, your self.???..
@@indonesiaforlife when Indonesian under Soeharto which is Western dog? We Indonesians never agree about that
they took East Timor in the past and in the period of Konfrontasi, sent commandos on terrorist missions all over Malaysia and Singapore.
@@indonesiaforlifeIf you study the invasion of East Timor in 1975, all the hardwares, the tanks, the helicopters were all still bore the markings of US military in Vietnam. Indonesia was basically, Ukraine of 1975. The US supplied the armaments, we supplied the soldiers. It also showed that our soldiers were better than US soldiers in battle.
East Timor was a mistake of being Philippines of the day. And we have to live with it. It was an important lesson about having dignity, not to be dictated by other, interests.
Korupsi - nepotisme masih menjadi musuh tersulit di Indonesia
tepat. KKN (Korupsi, Kolusi dan Nepotisme)
ya sejak dari dahulu kala ... udah ada istilah londo ireng ...
In 5 years recently Indonesian Navy is under huge modernization under Minister of Defense and newly elected President Prabowo Subianto.
Not only Navy but also Army and Air Force.
Prabowo can do better if there is no element in our govt who though there is no needs military present in our sea and air !
@@jeannebadu8356 Exactly !
With the rampant corruption? 😂 They will have planes and ships without fuel 😅
@@reaganjananto5467 I'm 100% sure our govt wouldn't let that happen.
@@tyopratomo5688 You sure? They happily let their middle class move borderline to poverty. While Jokowi has installed the private jet flying son and his other son in high posts ✌
Long live Indonesia 🇮🇩 🙏 💕
Indonesia lost East Timor to Australia, next West Papua.
@@TanksBradley-bf8ntEast Timor are independent you fool, and they are Portugese colony not Dutch.
@@TanksBradley-bf8ntWest Papua will always be part of Indonesia
@@vidarodinson5246 most of your army and navy militarily hardware are from Australia garage sale.
what irony is, Australia gives Zelensky state of the arts of modern warfare for free whereas Indonesia has to pay 4 it
@@TanksBradley-bf8nt most of our Weapons actually dominated from Germany when they are still active produce weapons.
Indonesian, Malaysian and Filipino are one race divided only by nations politics and religion. We can unite as one.
@@markielearnstovlog4411 this comment touch me
Indonesia dulu pernah dimasa emasnya, Dan dimasa depan Indonesia akan kembali kemasa emasnya.
ASEAN is a peaceful and neutral countries. That's why some of ASEAN country don't invest too much on their defense budget.
Yes it's true but not their big bully neighbor! Whether we like it or not we need to modernized our militaries capabilities on territorial defense. The storms was on the horizon and it's coming!😮😮😮
Peaceful means you spend more on military. The more youre secured, the more your region is peaceful...
become a concubine of great rich china then lol
But recently we increase our spending cuz the big bully china led by xi jinpooh want to stole ASEAN rights in 9 dash line.
Aesan Setuju teman sama
Hard to believes when Indonesia only spent less than 1% of it's national GDP for defense, but worry not, Prabowo will surely changed it after his presidency started, i hope Indonesia can spend 1.5-3% of it's gdp
There is no choice, as long as there is no serious effort to eradicate rampant corruption, don't ever hope to have a good defense.
Makanya demo RUU perampasan aset. Bukan malah demo calon gubernur😂
"Where are we supposed to earn a living?"
Is the question too of our Filipino fishermen in the West Philippine Sea.😢😢😢
There is no West Philippine Sea in the world.
@@tianmingchen-mc7xdthere is no south china sea, specially there imaginary 10 dash line all are just based on there beliefs that everythings is belong to them since ancient time 😂
@@tianmingchen-mc7xdthere is no south china sea, nor china, there is only West Taiwan and ccp occupied the West Taiwan...
@@robertanthonygarcia5921 South China Sea is literally the geographic name of the sea, what are you talking about?
Indonesian ❤️ Philippines Teman setuju 😊 sama
Philippines will always support Indonesia and our ASEAN brother. stay strong ASEAN brothers 💪🦾💪
Great ❤❤❤ from Philippines 🇵🇭💯💖
Indonesia perlu menambah alusistanya dan meningkatkan kemampuannya lg mengingat ibukotanya pun bergeser
That’s why they are not getting into conflicts with China. Since China has poured many investment in indo infrastructures
@@hectorar7890China also invest in PH. It is not a guarantee
Indonesia, the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia must unite and must carry out frequent defense exercises in this sea
and I hope that the Indonesian maritime army can be even more powerful
Dont forget INDIA the most populated country in Asia
Indonesia army ready to protect all ASEAN countries 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩💪💪💪
The Indonesian government, specifically the Ministry of Defense, has a kind of regulation not to publish the country's defense strategy, so meetings with parliament are held behind closed doors. So I am quite sure that the Indonesian defense information published will not be completely accurate both in terms of finances or funding and defense equipment.
Apa yg mau disembunyikan dari negara superpower kaya china dan usa
Tinggal liat satelit keliatan semua
Kapal, pesawat, lapangan terbang,tank🤣
Blm lagi agen mata2 mereka yg beroperasi diseluruh dunia
@@valentinussofa4135 bang... prabowo aja udang ngeluh di dpr...
mau raker tertutup macem apapun juga, kalo di dpr pasti bocor lagi bocor lagi.
Wow such a great documentary by CNA👍👍👍
we got it worse in philippines, despite spending 1% of gdp for defense, 80% of it went straight to soldiers salary and huge ass pension, 15% for maintenance only 5% remain for acquisition. for 3 years we still have no new acquisition after the 2 corvettes and 6 opv. yet they billions for AID which isn't economically developing.
War tools should be used for tourism, not for war. peaceful , Love from indonesian people..
🇮🇩❤️🇨🇳
Indonesia and Philippines is one people by blood...
Iisang dugo kalokohan mo di nga kaya ipag laban ng mga Filipino ang Philippines buti bansang Indonesia nag kaka isa
Indonesia need to spend min of $10 billion for the next 5 years for navy only
Please Do It Let See Indonesia Still Exist After 2030 $ 10 Billion Not Enough Increased It To $ 100 Billion
@@sayfolman7752
Yeah, you are right. $10 billion is not enough. China has 3 aircraft carriers and about 350 warships. Some of them are quite advanced. China is going to build at least 3 more aircraft carriers.
@@kwokholuk8723 just enough for a detterence effect, and china usually prefer cooperation anyway (even if it can be forced coop) unlike US
That's only USD$2 billion per year, not much at all.
Philippine also need 100 billion dollars to boost their navy 🙏
Sebenarnya indonesia sedang membuat pondasi militer untuk meregenerasi ke sistem modern dan itu butuh waktu,tidak bisa sekonyong konyong langsung menaikan anggaran pertahanan tanpa terperinci untuk apa saja dana tersebut di gunakan pada tahun penggunaannya , anggaran yang di butuhkan harus terperinci dengan baik dan besar kecil anggaran tergantung kebutuhan pada tahun yang akan di lalui,mungkin jika pondasi militer sudah terpenuhi bisa jadi anggaran militer indonesia kedepan naik menjadi 1,5 persen dari GDP karena di masa itu adalah masa produksi alat militer skala besar untuk mengisi pondasi yang telah terbentuk dan saya kira indonesia sedang menuju ke hal tersebut
Very informative about the Indonesian Navy put in a strategic context from top politics to the local fishermen. Moreover, it's a good idea to interview retired officers because from them you get a more complete story.
Ingat pepatah "kamu berfikir ekonomi tapi jangan kau lupakan kekuatan fisikmu" so jika kamu terlalu terjebak di ekonomi namun lupa menguatkan kekuatan militermu maka siaplah kedepan akan dilibas oleh lawanmu,
Diluar sana hukum rimba berlaku, klo lemah bakal dibully tapi klo u kuat mereka GK akan ganggu.
@@aboutjava yess.exampel Singapore anggaran militer mereka terbesar di Asia tenggara 😂😂😂🤔
Let's swipe the e economic affairs aside for a moment, we must build our tough armed force mainly focussed to deter another country which initiated the dispute. The government must gain the consciousness about potential threat that will be faced in the future not to fulfill for temporary satisfaction.
@@evannave9718yes we have example for the country which has biggest military budget in ASEAN. But, from that case we could use as reference for the modernity of our forces
@CNA Insider, this is a well researched and presented documentary. Very enriching.
Kekuatan maritim masyarakat Indonesia sudah dimatikan sejak jaman VOC,
Dan sekarang Indonesia terlalu mengikuti Mataram Islam yang bersifat negara Agraria,
belum lagi zaman Soeharto terlalu menganakemaskan Angkatan Darat, KRI irian aja gak tau dimana rimba nya.
Era Soeharto gk ada kasus2 melanggar maritim nak,eh bocillll... Om lahir era Soeharto.. gk ada kkasus2 pelanggaran teritorial, Soeharto macan Asia pda wkt itu ditakuti bhkan Soeharto jd penengah konflik perang di bosnia pd wkt itu
@@greenhat4833jaman Soeharto RRC masih negara berkembang coy. Pendapatan per kapita aja di bawah Indonesia. Setelah 1998, Indonesia tenggelam, RRC malah menjulang... Indonesia baru sekitar 2004 kembali ke situasi ekonomi level 1997. Kita kehilangan 7 tahun yg berharga...
Would be better in English.
@@HerryNovri era Soeharto gk ush cerita nak,lu msh jauh dibwh umur om 😁
analisis ala anak SD? 🤔
indonesia . jangan goyang..mau adidaya,dan negara maju mencoba mengganggu..kita sigap selalu..semboyan kita,tidak mengganggu tapi kalau di ganggu..kita kan siap
Saya membayang kan jika Singapur yang di serang Tiongkok bagaimana cerita ya hahahaha
We suppose Indonesia🇮🇩❤
Her name is Arabnesia not Indonesia.
@@davidivory3234ya
@@davidivory3234 what is that sweetheart are you okay?
Phul sapod saar
@@davidivory3234malayjing
Penting untuk memiliki senjata dan peralatan tempur modern.
Diplomasi international juga amat penting.
Indonesia is the lead in ASEAN and should increase its military budget to 3% of its GDP to catch up with the increased in spending of neighboring countries like Singapore, Malaysia and Philippines. China's PLA is slowing encroaching on 4 of ASEAN countries and Indonesia should support the four countries sovereignty from China's incursion on their respective territories.
Ngapain banyak2 blok??😂😂 1,5% aja udah banyak.. trus rakyat miskin kita dikemanain??
@@TerataiyangberlumpurDi Biarkan Mampus Kebuluran,
correction, Indonesian independence day 17 Augst 1945.
That's world war 2
As an indonesian im very proud cuz we can build our first new submarine
There's investment to increase the capacity of Indonesian Navy. What lack still is investment for Bakamla/Coast Guard. Fisheries and resources protection should be part of coast guard job, not navy.
Navy job is for defensive and offensive capabilities, not naval constabulary duties. That's coast guard job. The others in SCS also put coast guards mostly on the job, including China.
Coast Guard job to shown maritime jurisdiction, and using coast guards agains each other's better for conflict diplomacy then Navy.
jalasveva jayamahe dilaut kita jaya, saya pelaut sebagai bagian dari maritim sangat mendukung pemerintah untuk meningkatkan kekuatan angkatan laut kita.
Vietnam🇻🇳 thailand🇹🇭 Malaysia🇲🇾 Indonesia🇮🇩 Filipina🇵🇭 Harus bersatu di kawasan melawan agresi China 🇨🇳
Yes we will 🇵🇭
Nah Malaysia and Thailand are China's puppets
Yes Sir Agree 100%
🇵🇭🤝🇲🇾
🇹🇭🤝🇻🇳
myanmar and cambodia,don't forget
Thanks CNA
tiongkok pandai dan paham untung ruginya jika menyeret indonesia dalam situasi ini, semua negara negara di laut yg natuna utara/yg berpotensi konflik dengan tionkok pasti sedang dan sudah bersiap siap untuk membela diri.
True....
Thx to our elected president Prabowo subianto and as active defence minister
Our navy and air force got huge modernization
We just launch new vessel but we still have more work to get done
Indonesia and the Philippines should sign a defense alliance.
No need for PH sign any military pact with any ASEAN
Still no match for China
@@indonesiaforlifeobviously.. It's like huawei vs nokia and motorola.. But nobody buy huawei coz no legit os.. It's like still nobody believe with china😂
Indo is playing both side, they care about its people
Indonesia had insisted to Philipine, Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei since long time ago since Soekarno's Plan in Manilla Agreement. And these ideas has nowdays proven and relevance to international geopolitic issues. With Confederations strategies along the countries it will consolidate thus power and have capability to develop more to mapping its potential threats and spread the economics strategy and defense along the waters of the sea from any foreign pressures. neither US, China, or even India.
Indonesia must have a mutual defense treaty with the Philippines to face the aggressor like China. This is the start of NATO in Asia🙏💖
别做梦了！
Its never happen.
Indonesia is not a stupid country that is easily incited to become a US puppet.
They more understand about Geopolitical Situation than you Filipino.
@@andaordos may spy hahahhaa
@@tagged-without_lights00 跳梁小丑
dude they already create nato in asia it call super garuda shield
Indonesia has no territorial dispute with China. Eastern Indonesia perhaps used to be part of Australian continent.
Yes, this news is produce the conflict and tension between Indonesia and China to destroy our trust. China invest a lots in Indonesia, so they want Indonesia become better and build the high speed rail in Jakarta.
Stop Your Bullshit Propaganda Chinese Communist,A Few Day Ago China Coast Guard Enter Malaysia And Indonesia Maritime Zone And Demand Both Country Stop Extract Oil From Sea Bed
The Australian nuclear submarine project is a worrying part.
South China sea - Natuna very close
used to be? eastern Indonesia is part of Oceania lmao
Good documentary video
Fokus jokowi insfratruktur, kita liat Prabowo dia paham tentang pertahanan pasti akan ditingkatkan dan beliau mengerti utk menglola negara Indonesia. Sy optimis dibawah kepempinan presiden Prabowo nanti ekonomi, pertahanan akan kuat. Jangan di tanyakan tentang pertahanan Indonesia walau dari segi anggaran kurang tapi Indonesia jiwa petarung dan mempunyai banyak pengalaman perang dalam maupun luar negeri. Media Singapura dipikir Indonesia itu bodoh, jangan salah Indonesia itu cerdik punya banyak strategi. Setiap analisis Singapura dari jaman Soeharto sampe skrg meleset kurang tepat. Indonesia itu ahli strategi
Kalau Pak Jokowi dijuluki Bapak Infrastruktur, maka Pak Prabowo saya rasa akan dijuluki Bapak Pertahanan
@@mapk1516ngga mungkin fokus pertahanan doang
bambu runcing?
Jokowi ndukung Prabowo
Liat aja pas jadi Mentri pertahanan banyak keinginan Prabowo dipenuhi
Bener juga ya, Media Singapura seperti mempunyai grudge kepada Indonesia. Dari IKN sampai ini, seperti mereka merendahkan kita, ya begitulah negara kecil tapi egonya tinggi.
Indonesian Navy and Coastguard should utilize those fishermen as intelligence agents that will inform the military for any intrusions by foreign vessels or fishermen. Provide them with satellite communication devices or other communication equipment.
•Keren 🇮🇩👍
Terimakasih
Now they got a taste of their own medicine.
It is always quality vs. value. Buying 2nd hand stuff works to build up quickly a force but are mostly maintenance sensitive. Spnt less on hardware, but spent more on maintanace
The increase in Indonesian military strength was initially not triggered by China, but by acts of provocation and humiliation by the Malaysian military, culminating during President SBY's visit on a warship and there was an act of cheap provocation by a Malaysian plane that deliberately flew over the ship carrying SBY's presentation, from the moment That's when the MEF (military force arrangement) started, and look now the Malaysian military is actually lagging behind
No its by china...the enemey of southeast asia...
Iya, jelas-jelas Malaysia yang merampok sipadan ligitan bahkan mengklaim ambalat, kalo cina menginvasi jiran kita, ya biarin aja 😂😂😂😂
Prabowo could create a military industrialization movement to develop Indonesia's human resource and build up it's military, 2 birds with one stone. Build it's own military gear, feed and train it's citizens in the fields of military engineering. it'll be a long and hard struggle, but one that's worthwhile for sure looking at rhe current geopolitical situation.
Indonesia compared to the Philippines can easily modernize it's military with its current GDP and growing Middle class. Go Indonesia, the Rise of ASEAN Malays
Not true... They are 3x bigger population than Philippines. It will be challenging for them to modernize their military
Ngapain bangkit kan Melayu Indonesia adalah Indonesia Melayu adalah Malaysia kami tidak Sudi dibilangin serumpun dengan kalian
indonesians are related to Papuans not Filipinos
@@Edgar_Ramirez471 No, Filipinos, indonesians and most austronesians are related... they came from Taiwan..
@@Edgar_Ramirez471yes we are😂 we Filipino and Indonesian are same color, some of word are similar, just search in internet what Filipino look like, in Asia 😂
Unlike Singapore with urban warfare tactics, Indonesian Defense doctrines are actually similar with Vietnam, even many Indonesian tactical generals trained with Vietcong in the 90s. Enemy can enter Indonesia but can't get out...
What is the chance of a conflict btw Indonesia and China? I got really confused.
99% Conflict With China And Not Just Indonesia But All ASEAN Country That Have Maritime Dispute With China Because Other Also Have Interest In That Region
The Question You Should Ask Will Those Country Enter The Conflict Directly Or Indirectly
Directly All ASEAN Go War With China
Indirectly Fund Separatist In China Soil Or Funds Country That Going To War With China
Saya rasa konflik ini cuma gitu gitu aja karena konflik ini tidak pernah membawa perang indonesia china
@@andikustiawan6184 I think Indonesia should be concerned about Australia's expanding military strength.
Wumao the pirates of the SEA..breaking the peace and stability in the region..where have you been?
@@SpruceWood-NEGIndonesia and Australia formed an alliance in early September.
The problem is also in doctrines, Indonesia mainly adapt to the aging jeune ecole of France where quantity and quality focus more on the production of powerful smaller ships. The doctrine also entice to a more green water navy alike, sure our ocean is vast but it's also shallow, our docks that could held such large ship are only in the southern hemisphere.
20:32 Filipino, French, and Palestinian flag beside the Indonesian flag on his desk? That's interesting.
Yes these are clients of PT PAL or alliance of Indonesia navies for sure including the Philippines of course 😊😊
The Philippine Navy has two PT PAL ships:BRP Tarlac and BRP Davao Del Sur, but the other two are still under construction and expected to commissioned soon 😊😊
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 That's interesting.
@@hitthedeck4115 Yeah 😊😊
thats UAE not Palestine.
i thing those flags represent the Joint partnerships and costumers of PT PAL
@@Antarsa44 Yeah and including the Philippines too 😊😊
Indonesia and Philipina are same in culture, etnis, and more than others country. We are same how to protect our home land.
Indonesia dan pilipin hmpir sama secara budaya dan kebiasaan dlm keseharian nya.
Indonesia is the only country in South East Asia that can build its own warships.Indonesia just finished construction on two Indonesian warships.Indonesia is certainly not lagging behind its neighbours.
去年我们中国造的船占世界百分之51。也就是说全世界加起来造了百分之49。但是我们没兴趣与邻国战争，美国在亚洲有一百多个军事基地，几乎包围了中国。我们也没有办法。如果亚洲国家都把美军赶出去，我们会更希望一起开发海洋资源。而不是战争。
Tetangga itu tdk akan mngncam.
Tapi klo dr china gmn... juah bumi dan lngit ajuh nya..😅
Jika bertanding jangn cri lawan yg lemah. Agar terlihat perkasa.
@@Orangbiasa_45indonesia tak pernah cari musuh , tapi indonesia juga tak pernah takut sama bangsa mana pun,,
siapa yang ngusik indonesia , maka indonesia juga akan lawan.
@@dancok123-s4slawak antarabangsa 🤣tentera pulau india serang Timor Leste, tentera pulau india serang malaya
@@BudakBelanda ya karna malaya itu penghianat ... lu liat sejarahmu
Bigger defense budget is crucial to protect and increase more patrol at sea, so the fisherman can thrive. It's not only about war.
Kami rakyat Indonesia ngk peduli kami kalah jumlah alat tempur dan kalah jumlah tantara kami rakyat Indonesia ngk takut ama negara manapun karna kami di jalan yng benar, klo negara lain mau ngajak perang kami siap mati demi kebenaran
Ah...yg betoollll...nanti perang bneran,lu lari duluannnn
Perangnya nggak frontal. Seperti sekarang ikannya dicurinsaja
@@Berusaha909harusnya lu itu musnah dari Indonesia, karna tidak cinta, negara...
@@Berusaha909dari bahasamu saja bisa di ketahui km.type manusia pengecut , tdk disiplin dan tdk terdidik dg baik
@@singerstac trus lu cinta gitu?
Semoga pak Prabowo memasukkan bu Susi Pudjiastuti dalam kabinetnya nanti... Dan juga bu Retno... 👍
Baru tahu Navy Indonesia dianggap outdated. APBN militer o.8 % semoga dibaik ke 2%
Kalau baru tahu, nggak mungkin kita sudah bangun frigate dr beberapa tahun lalu. CNA n bolo2nya yg baru notice. APBN militer kita naik, jadi kita sudah mampu bayar. Waktunya buat tipu2 lagi seperti dulu. Corvette seharga battle cruiser. Komisi dong! Korupsi dong! Yang penting kan duitnya. Daripada bikin infrastructures that you do not need kan baikan duitnya kasih kita. Komisinya gede lho.
@@Phoenix-bq7lw masih banyak kok blm tau kalau TNI AL kuno. yng percaya ranking2. CNN Indonesia tu 16 Agustus keluar berita TNI AL rank 4 dunia😂.
Formidable mya SG dibangun dari awal2 tahun 2000, 2004 jadi aktif 2007. Jadi memang TNI AL kalau baru mulai dibangun FMP itu tertinggal.
AL sejak zaman Soeharto jadi anak tiri, terlalu fokus ke AD. Baru baru ini aja mulai diupgrade
@@hendrasutrisno4191
2 class martadinata itu masih baru,5 class ahmad yani itu baru tua,negara lain juga banyak yg masih mengoperasikan kapal tua,seperti kd lekiu milik malaysia itu juga udah tua hampir sama dgn class ahmad yani tapi masih jadi unjung tobak angkatan laut malaysia
@@Stuntend Ya apa ideal nya spt itu? Kan tidak. Masak kompare sama malaysia mulu. ANZAC class nya Australia sdh pensi pdhl 30 thn lbh muda. Ahmad Yani blm ada penggantj nya.
Increase personnel and defense equipment for strong national defense !!
-
It's a bit strange that CNA is more focused on dragging Indonesia into conflict with China where it's clear there hasn't been any direct aggression from China. As long as the Natuna block runs smoothly, why should Indonesia act further ? So far, China has more often disturbed Philippine territorial waters.
Coz they can easily bully philippines
Jai Hind. War is good money for suppliers of military hardware, According to Utube, the US will be lapping up all of the Ukraine national resources based on the 1 trillion arms aid so far.
Benar,apakah ini salah satu propaganda??😂
ingat bro. china masih mengklaim laut natuna utara sebagai wilayahnya dan sampai cina berhenti mengklaim laut natuna sebagai wilayahnya, kita gak akan berhenti berkonfrontasi dengan cina.
Mungkin biar indonesia memperkuat jadi singapura bisa terlindungi. Inikan media singapura
It's really the Philippines lagging behind. The navy officers are undisciplined, legislators who allocate funds are so corrupted.
indonesia isn't that different
@@freemanol Tama na ang pagpapanggap. Filipinos crave attention and hate criticism, we slowly becoming collectively narcissistic people. Filipinos rather die being praised than being criticised for good. Mga pilipino tamad, asa sa gobyerno. Believe me, our country will never be a fully developed nation within the next 100 years.
Idiot
@@freemanolThen why is Indonesia better than Philippines? We are very different to Philippines. For one, we are making effort to address the problems.
@@Phoenix-bq7lw better in what?? indonesia has the biggest slum in SEA, highest crime & corruption rate, unrecognizable as well as nobody in the world knows about indonesia. Overall
🇵🇭🇹🇭🇻🇳🇲🇾🇸🇬>>>>>>>>>🇲🇨
Alhamdulillah mantap 🇮🇩🔥
TNI prima 💪🇮🇩
Seriously, to gain some respect from other countries, the Chinese government needs to *stop its lies.*
It's about Indonesia, not china.
They are not interested in respect
@@tailsorange2872If China not become a thief, ASEAN countries doesn't really much worry about "arm race". Just stay focus on economy development.
A thief is a thief, and thief will always lie.
China maling!
@@tailsorange2872
It's about illegitimate CCP trying to distract the oppressed population.
The unity of south east asean is very strong we are brothers and the same ancestors from austroneseans🇵🇭 china is greed of power but we asean love peace
"Sang Saka Getah Getih Samudera"... Flag Navy of Majapahit Empiror.
Indonesia has never bothered other countries and does not want to be bothered by other countries... If any other country interferes, your enemy is not only the military but also 270 million Indonesians, when it comes to the government we are divided but when it comes to the homeland we are united and stand together.
🇵🇭🇮🇩🇲🇾🇻🇳🇹🇭 UNITE VS 🇨🇳
Indonesia dan Singapura harus saling kerja sama untuk menjaga laut Natuna
Natunas belongs to Indonesia not Singapore.
I laughed when China claimed that They really thought inner 9 dash or 10 dash lines marine territory belongs to them. What kind of country in Earth assert opinion like this😂😂😂
Berdasarkan klaim sejarah kata mereka bro..dulu nenek moyang mereka kalau berak di laut cina selatan.
Well laugh all you want if you don't know anything. The none dash line does belong to China! It is in the UNCLOS. Do you not even know nine dash line of what? Just nine dash line? It is an UNCLOS clause under lined by nine dash line! Philippines signed UNCLOS, the US does not! That is why UNCLOS signatory nations never go against China on the nine dash line, except Philippines. We are all law abiding nations, not I am the law like the US. We do not want to obey the US, but we do not want to be bullied by the US either for the perception of siding with China. So, silent is gold.
The UN defines UNCLOS, not the US, and certainly not the permanent court of arbitration.
Propaganda murahan indonesia dan cina baik" saja berita terlalu membesar"kan 😆
Klaim halu tiongkok membuat semua orang terbahak bahak
As long as the military decision maker are too focused on land forces, it's quite a tall order
Don't worry, we will be fine.
Singapore can only provike
Kita memiliki rencana yang sangat besar dan kita bisa menenggelamkan lautan suatu saat
Indonesia has the 4 largest navy in the world...
Indonesia has strong guts,for the sake of the country they don't care about their lives..
Indonesia has deadly weapons,the people and the TNI will unite to defend their homeland..learn from our history..🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
4 largest Navi with minimal armament only patrol ships without oils
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
with old frigate and outdate corvette 🤣🤣🤣 even they done have destroyer
Minority People In Afghan,Syria,Yemen Etc Also.Say That In The Beginning But Cannot Succumb To Hunger And Starvation
Patriotic Have No Value, When Your Family Starving And Hunger
Tertinggal atau tidak itu bukan masalah penting.
Yang PENTING adalah Rakyat Indonesia memiliki Nasionalisme & Patriotisme yang tinggi dalam membela Negaranya.
Saya YAKIN - China tidak akan gegabah menghadapi Bangsa Indonesia..... beda kalau mereka menghadapi Malaysia/Piliphina.
Is Indonesia’s Navy Lagging Behind? NO! Try observing the PH, Indonesia is more far ahead than that country. Unlike PH who seeks appeasement and shown cowardice. INDONESIA has shown resolved!
Indognesial laknattullah
Negara miskin.
Hidup mkn smpah
Ayuh dong kabur.
wkwkwkwk
Dasar bangsa penakut
sometimes it's ok to accept the fact, it won't hurt you' you guys over proud for decades.
Shoutout from a Pinoy in Scandinavia ❤❤❤ the world should not think about the past instead lock forward and be alongside with international community so that we can strengthen the international law and law of the sea 🌊 or else the world will go back to a Stone Age system.
Asia tengara bersatu lah .. terus jaya jangan di pandang remeh oleh negara beua lain ..NKRI harga mati...
What about Singapore Navy, i'm. not sure they brave to facing china with their updated navy
SG playing both sides mate. Not CNA
Lebih baik Singapur saja yg diambil china😂
Considering SG only need to defend small Islands... it is ok. They even have more submarine (8vs4) and frigate than Indonesia(6 Formidable vs 2 REM, formidable also heavier)
@@hectorar7890 bothside 😂, come on
@@rims_86 look at their recent naval drill
Di masa bayang-bayang konflik seperti ini bersyukur presiden yang terpilih lebih tegas, pembangunan sudah berjalan di era Jokowi, sekarang kita punya Prabowo, semoga pertahanan Indonesia makin kuat dan tidak diremehkan bangsa lain
*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea:
- parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭 and Indonesia 🇮🇩,
- the rest of it is the international water,
- no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
International law please
That is the modern international law by the UN. Traditional international law by the Chinese Navy says they are gonna grab everything they can.
how do you know?
Hey bro, republic of china and the people republic of china have no sea territory dispute with Indonesia. Do you studying the geography lesson? You can searching the geography to check detaily and you should pay more hard to studying the geography and fact check by yourself, ok?
It's about Indonesia, not china.