Blame Game Victims? Why Afghan Refugees are Being Forced Out of Pakistan | Vantage with Palki Sharma
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- Blame Game Victims? Why Afghan Refugees are Being Forced Out of Pakistan | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Pakistan is expelling thousands of Afghan refugees. This move is set to impact more than 200,000 Afghan refugees living in Pakistan.
Islamabad and the Taliban have reached a new low with this. The Taliban has said that it will not be "responsible for Pakistan's failures".
Furthermore, the UN has widely criticised Pakistan's decision to force Afghans out.
Palki Sharma tells you more.
Also read: www.firstpost....
---
Afghan refugees | Pakistan | Taliban | Mass Exodus | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#afghanrefugees #pakistan #taliban #massexodus #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.c...
Firstpost is now 3 million+ strong!
Thank you viewers for your support.
Firstpost, you are supporting Pakistan indirectly! I do not like or support Talibans but they are the government of Afghanistan at present! Neither Taliban nor Afghanistan are supporting the TTP or pakistani talibans! As a matter of fact Pakistani intelligence agency ISI is the real TTP or Pakistani taliban! This fake talibans (TTP) is a covert wing of pakistani intelligence agency for their games inside Pakistani politics and regional politics.
You are supporting Pakistan!
If this act was done by christian country against the Afghanistan, Muslim brothers will carry placard and protest every where, but now they have lost their cards and voice's.
Muslims hate non Muslims more than loving their fellow Muslims.
Islam has a rule. What ever Muslims do is right. If the other religions do it's wrong. They feel they have the rights to rape and kill other religion people, but if the same was done to them they'll play the victim card and the brain-less Western Countries support them.
Absolutely
If you have only heard half of the news then you could have this view. However, it’s the undocumented people who are being sent back. So no need for any country to raise their voices in protest. Simple
@DullahChadarmod Unfortunately you are absolutely right!
This should be one more example which Bharat should consider in expelling Rohingyas and Bangladeshis. A few years back, Pakistan conducted successful an anti-terrorist operation and we (Bharat) should take a lead.
Lmao expel Bengalis 😂😂?? From where. We created india from Britian bcoz you were too weak and scred. There's 2 million rendians working in Bangladesh. They will be forced out along with you
O Humin toh pata hi nahe tha😱😱😱
Don't even think about it. When a Muslim country does something like this, the rest of the Muslim world is very quiet about it. If anyone else does it then these hypocrites across the world will come out protesting. Very entitled people these are, it is only them that are entitled to do anything.
Yes, we need to expel Rohingyas..
Even malaysia expels them
Go and do it urself instead of commenting
Currently, Palestinians and Afghans are going through the same situation. Both are forced to leave their home. The only difference is that, islamic nations are mute since a muslim country is oppressor in the latter case!
and afgans did not supported terrorists
Afghan leaving their houses ? Are you kidding they're living on our land, and those 2 lac people were undocumented. Would you indians allow anyone to come to your country without documents and live there?
Dude, you must know that there are stealth sanctions on your channel.
It is becoming harder to reach your channel.
@@farhanmalik-94 KPK is Afghan land. Pakistan needs to get the fuck out. The British handed it over to them that rightfully belonged to Afghans. No Punjabis!
@@farhanmalik-94 I agree, but they are sent to the whhyte West. Not our people. Not our problem. The only people responsible for people are their own leaders and countrymen. Not the world. All these people in the West must be sent back to their countries. We are dumping grounds.
India needs to make sure that those expelled from Pakistan are not infiltrating to India
This is the part where I am getting worried
😂
Do you know geography? 😅 The refugees are going west into Afghanistan not east into your country. Also I thought you guys love Afghans. 😅
@@sohaila6086 we love Afghans but we are over populated country
If Pakistan can expel Afghans,then Israel , Bangladesh, India , EU ( mainly Sweden , UK, France, Norway etc) countries can also...
Exactly!!!!… OIC will always maintain silence when it’s Muslim vs Muslim.. When if it’s anything else, they will all join forces and play victim card..
Bro Pakistan is expeling only illegal settlers.
Non Muslim countries not allowed to expel.. They will be tag as anti Muslim.
Now were are Palestinians supporters , wont stand for Afghani brothers and sisters? Why they aint yours 😂
Why no one in #Kerala state shouting against this. Why #MamtaBanerji and team not shouting against it? These two team always shout against India on such things. But keeps silent against China and islamist countries. So their intention is clear , I hope.
Secular Hindus are the real enemies of holy India 🇮🇳 Bharat 🇮🇳
As if RSS and BJP are shouting and crying about this.
@@YtubeUserr Why should they ? Did they ever take this hypocritical stand like you do all the time ? They know very well what they are dealing with. They never changed it. But you do. You always do this. That's the difference.
India should free south Indian and south eastern states from north Indian occupation who hate them just for their skin tone 😂
@@EnoughIsEnough571 bullshit. Why would Indian political parties and that too a party that is NOT in power talk about other countries??
Shows your lack of intelligence
Videos about Afghanistan and Pakistan's geopolitical History would be very appreciated🙏
These are complex topics and from a western point of view like mine, they are quite confusing.
Your sharp and clear explanations are a good way to learn about the world. Merci!
Afghanistan & Pakistan was Hindu ancestral lands.Turkey mslm invaders invaded Pakistan, kill men & forced women to breed half breed converts. After generations Afghan convert did the same to Pakistan & converted Pakistan. Afghan Muslim converts are Pakistani Mslm converts daddies and Turkey mslm converts are Paki converts grand daddies
We are from india.we don't spreak propaganda like western people and western media.
@@CRICKETi-Fiwe do, no Country can be considered completely unbiased. Its better to see Different sources, proves and draw your own conclusion
@@It-gx1gkgknidhi is a dog of modi foreign people dont know much about godi media I'm following wion and nidhi for past 7 year she criticise every step taken by Mr Xi but never ever take Mr modi name especiall during during covid, note bnadi, farmer protest nothing nil
@@CRICKETi-Fiaaj dhanteras hai aaj toh jhut mat bol... Apno ki marna se fursat nhi milti bahar kon sunta hai indian news channels ki
Taliban and Baloch should go on the 1970 - 71 Birth of Bangladesh.
so if pakistan iterferes in kashmir which is a disputed territory ,you call it terrorism. But at the same time you intervene in balochistan which is not even a disputed territory. so who is supporter of terrorism?
Very peacefully comunity 😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Bharat
Palki- no double standards. No refugee is allowed to
Stay as refugees forever! Big deal - let the afghans go back.
They had 2 million refugees for 30years now they have agreed with the Taliban for there return. Thi is not even an issue. The refugees are happy with there Pak brothers for keeping them safe for 30 years
Aaah, the peacefull communitie's global ummah their brotherhood is overwhelming.
India introducing CAA
Le liberal: how can you do that. Everyone has right to live.
West and Islamic countries doing the same.
Le liberal: silence 🤐
Indian should take them for the next 45 years India is Neighbor and Afghan love, India !!
pakistan shouldn't force out afghanistani refugees as pakistan is responsible for making them refugees in the first place, for making afghanistan unstable.
If this happens in USA niw people will b condemning them
I feel bad for the Afghans
Why? They want Taliban, they get Taliban.
If they want change, then they need to fight/ work for it.
What happened to ' Tera Mera rishta kyaa.... '?
Pakistan is running out of money 😂
We afghanies wanted to live in India with our Indian friends
Oic is silent 😂
Ummah is exposed
The days of overstaying in subcontinent are over for Afghans.
And pak says they will fight for hamas, when neighbouring Muslim brothers are pushed out, hypocrites
No one expected this to expel Afghans from Pakistan as both are Muslims. Afghans when US invasion came to Pakistan Afghans came to Pakistan as refugees Now they were overthrown. Pakistan will get divided into 4 countries very soon and at that time Afghans should throw all Pakistanis from Afghanistan if they ask for help
Compare this with our response to illegal migrants from Bangladesh and Myanmar
some of these afghans deported have been in pakistan since 1947, you think india wont throw out muslims there from 1947? if they commit a crime they might.
And shine of our radicalised Muslims dream that Muslim countries will safeguard their interest!!!
Power army Pakistan isi markhor gonam mujahideen zindabad lion people in the world Pakistan ta kaymat watan inshallah ❤❤❤pak army ❤❤❤❤
Pakistan is willing to send All Afghan refugees to India. So my question is that India is open to get all Afghan Refugees?.
Is it normal for countries to evict its refugees on such a short notice? like one month right..? How come someone who has been living in a country for around 40 years be told to leave in a month. Wont they need more time atleast..
What happened to The Worldwide Ummah? OMG 😱
We request India being good friend of Afghanistan . Take these afghan refugees as their guest & for development of India in population. 😂
India should accept Afghans in their country too
As a Pakistani I'll support our Government act because Pakistan has the right to send back Afghan refugees to whom Pakistan has helped out in their War time and give them safe shelter.
No Doubt Afghan are Our brothers but I think this act is logically righteous and a step for good and stable relation between both countries.
2:28 what's your stance on this? Will you still justify your government?
Then stfu if india send back rohingya.. tab Umma ki khujli nikal aati hai.
Pakistan is running out of money..UN, America,IMF has stopped funding Pakistan.. that's the reason
@@orientalguy9462he was a refugee who came during Soviet invasion and Pakistan hosted him but their country is no longer war stricken hence they must move back thanking the host and develop Afghanistan.
Where are muslim friends for support only dazas
Thanks God for separating Paxistan from India.
now living with cows
@@MAA...KALI... : better than living with terrorists 😅
@@MAA...KALI...one country needs IMF begging money for survival and the other country is progressing year by year 😂😂
Abhi secular dogs kuch nhi bolenge. Justice for Afghani refugees.
It’s an part of Talibans and Pakistan’s plan.
By sending mostly Pashtun-Afghans and Pakistani citizens to Afghanistan, Talibans wants to grow Pashtun population in Afghanistan. This Pashtuns have been already planned to be settled in non Pashtun areas.
Taliban have shown the list of resettlement of this Pashtuns. And it looks very bad for non Pashtun areas. Because 50 000, 60 000, 70 000 etc will be resettled in non Pashtun area.
Being a British Pakistani iam greatly appalled and saddened by the behaviour of the care taker government against the poor Afghan community in Pakistan. Yet these officials are so thirsty for British,,European, American and Canadian citizenship, it's hypocritical and totally against humanity.
Afghanistan is progressing and the neighbouring country is getting jealous inshallah we will rise long live afghanistan and the brave people o afghanistan who welcomed their brothers and sisters with flowers all afghans should return to afghanistan
Not true. Afghanistan's condition got worst. Less likely to progress when no other country recognize Taliban. All intellectuals and proffessionals left the country. Now its a brain drain and no good education for the next generations.
Heard that department of women persecution is progressing well, congrats Islam😂
Lady don’t comment on Pakistan’s Afghan refugees india only has around 19000 😂
and millions of refugees from Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, and the 19k will not be expelled any time in the near future.
Why is no one or the Arab world protesting??
India should learn from Pakistan...How to send the Refugees out
When will India do this???
Keep it Simple! The Afghan refugees in Pakistan have RIGHT to RETURN to their homeland ✅ Secondly, the 🆕 TALIBAN government faces Labour Shortage because of the EXODUS of able bodied talented Afghans since the occupation and the illegal war, therefore its a Win 🏆 Win 🏆 for both Pakistan and Afghanistan 👍
Nobody else to fight . Except non foreigner colonists
These Afghans refugees have no ID or other certificate given by pak so better for them to leave
Forced out? will india let them be in india
They already are, and that's why CAA was proposed, and your musIim brotherhood swntiment, started barking
Is it true that Moodi is going to open borders for Afghan refugees?
baby especially update yourself on PAKISTAN.
You are Zero regarding PAKISTAN internal temperature. Do you know who are these people. They were all settled illegally in PAKISTAN.
For the last 40+ years we helped them. There are approx 35 million Afghanis. Majority are staying legally on 14 millions who are staying illegally are told to leave Pakustan. Due to them crime rates has increased to many fold. They had nothing to loose. Drugs, kidnapping, robbing were there hobby. From the camps they scattered themselves in different part of the country.
Enough is enough.
Can india give such freedom to the people of other nationalities. From the camps to all the cities.
As Pakistan has done it for free. It has taken billions of dollars for these people
India has given shelter and refugee to largest number of Islamic refugees
@@shobhitdagur1086 bared wire. How many and for how many years.
Did these refugee robbed, killed, kidnapped indians, were they allowed to roam freely in all parts of India with zero documents...
@@shobhitdagur1086 that doesn't means that you rob, kidnap, kill the people who sheltered you and what you are talking you were the people who supported USSR during the invasion of Afghanistan.
So don't took foolish. First when Russian came , then American came and you were sitting in Afghanistan for 20 years...when there is Afghani government they should go back now.
@@shobhitdagur1086taken dollars for the legal ones
Appeal to Government and COAS :
We must expedite this operation to send back the refugees and complete before snowfall starts.
When will India do the same.. ?
Afghanistan is developing fast. an increase in a labour force would help with that along as the sanctions are removed
🤣🤣🤣🐷🇦🇫🐷 sinces Najib & Dawood you people have this dream
What about Pakistan...are they against terrorism..what a joke .....
Why no protest for afghan innocent people.
Send them to India . They really care about them 😅
Can the male narrator speak naturally rather than in such animated English. It’s a pain to listen to his English.
When is India going to do it ?
Rohingyas , Bangladeshis ..
Go and protest all over the world ! Snake vs snake !
Damn what the hell
We're going through hellish tough times first the war in Ukraine then gaza isreal conflict now this
Ask their Muslim brother to fight for them😅😢😂😂
What do mean Force out??
This is not there country .they have to return to home land one day which already came
India's favourite topic is Pakistan.
Bcoz it's a part of India
@@shobhitdagur1086Don't live in dreams.
This channel almost always being biased with their reports about Pakistan and always throwing shades at them!!!
They don’t report and talk about wrongdoings going on in India, but can easily point the finger and throw shades at Pakistan.
Totally biased 🙄👎
@@justchill476 Just because of views and trying to be godi Media.
Because it's India's Land..
Not thousands 4 millions. Most of them live in Sindh and demography of Sindh is being changed. Sindhis are being cast out of their cities and replaced with afghans and Punjabis. You guys no nothing about here.
We should also send pending Pakistanis from India
India should take them as they have so much love
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa belongs to the Pashtuns 💯💯
These guys have destroyed afghanistan because they think if there is nationalism in afghanistan... the pashtuns will revolt... and so they countered nationalism with radicalisation... and now they blame afghans... wtf
@@mudshovel289-fu5tx because punjab and sindh are completely flat lands and will not hold up against invasion from any direction... for attacking pakistan from west side there is a pass called khyber pass... so to stop any army from coming in they need to control that part... which means controlling the territory and people
There are more than 4 million Afghans living in Pakistan
India should take a lesson and expel the outsiders as soon as possible.
Значит они, спокойно, могут ехать в Евросоюз. В Германии большая афганская диаспора и там ждут афганцев.
FAKEstan in the bag 🤣👏🏻
That's wrong and india putting rohingya in camps is also wrong,
No unity with same muslim brothers . Afghan had a very bad life in their country like America messed it up and then the others too country is very poor too with constant war and fighting a country cannot progress
So much about global ummah 😂
Very sad situation . They are bulldozing their homes where do you expect them to go when you accepted them ??
Expulsion is there what is illegitimate in it
Get all those clean shaven chickens out of leadership allow ulma to be part of leadership or Pakistan will be always in problems
It's Not about afghan refugees
It's about totally illegal immigrants either from Afghanistan or any corner of World human being
So no one is on the street for that??😂
Can't they just use condoms or
The Last moment withdrawal techniqu
India should provide them shelter inside INDIA
Bharat mata must give shelter to her afghan childrens
we are for very strong Indo Pak ties. we share much more than what Afghanistan shares with each of us. Western border of sub continent was always a route of plunderers, looters, Afghan and Central Asian mercenaries who are a shameful part of sub continental history...
Pakistani deliberately started the exodus just before onset of winter knowing 1000s of babies ,women and elderly would d!e for lack of shelter and medical facilities .Crying for Palestine while forcing helpless Afghan to suffer .
Pak govt is took right decision,if you know the reality
last straw was when Afg beat Pakistan in WC and proved to them they are superior
I see no cries or appeal for these refugees from the community stating religious or humanitarian sympathy towards Palestine! Why this hypocrisy? As the oppressor is also from the same religion?
There is two different things Afghans r going back to their home country yet for innocent Palestinians they r kick them out of their house killing them torturing them no food no water no fuel. A human with brain and heart will stand for justice
@@RichAsher Pashtuns have lived in the very recent creation that is pakistan for a really long time. So you are sending innocent people out of their house.
@@abhayc576 Not really all I wanted to say @ least Afghans has a land they were welcome by their people and government yet Palastines doesn't have one they r been kicked from their home land. Whatever is happening for both is unjust and unfair.
Expelled for excelling in islamic syllables
Bohot acha faisala ha.Pakistan lakhoon afghanion ko mazeed nahein dehrasakta.Atghanistan mein ab taliban kee hakoomat ha.
I condemn this brutality of Pakistan
Where is alzazeera bbc now
plz take them to india if u are so worried about taliban
Afghanistan says to its migrants - WELCOME HOME
India must take Afghan refugees
Who talked about UMMA 😂
India has not taken billions for them
several afghans did come to india once taliban came to power.
india and other civilized countries should not take muslims at all
First return the Pashtun land back to Afghans then we will take Afghans.
A similar example,
There was a big war in East Pakistan ( bangldesh) in 1971.
Afterwards,
About 600,000 Muslims entered illegally from bangldesh into Arakan ( Rakhine) ,Burma in 1971-1980.
And then ,
The Burma govt declared the state emergency due to the Regional Authority couldn't handle massive illegal inflows from bangldesh in Arakan ( Rakhine ) since 1972.
And then,
Burmese socialist Govt led by Gen- Ne Win tried to forced them out from Burma to bangldesh in 1974.
And then,
Mr khjawah Mohammad kaiser who served as ,the first bangldesh Ambassador to Burma in 1973-1976 Requested the Burmese Senior leaders to understand what happened with bangldesh and be patience with illegal Bangladeshi war refugees in Burma and promised that once bangldesh restores Normal and Will take them back from Burma to bangldesh using his Diplomatic skills in 1973-1976
And then,
Burmese leaders accepted with please of Bangladeshi ambassador and state leaders visited to each country in 1973-1976.
Even Bangladeshi Govt led by Mujibur Rahman sent a thankful text to the Burma govt in 1975.
And then,
Mujihur Rahman and his family were assassinated by some military units and leadership has changed in bangldesh in 1975.
Mr khjwwah kaiser Left Burma for USA to take UN Ambassador post of bangldesh in 1976.
And then,
Illegal immigration issues returned to Burma govt.
The Burma govt conducted Draft immigration Bill at Parliament in 1976 And finished it ( immigration Bill) on October 15,1982 And imposed restrictions on illegal Bangladeshi Muslim settlers in Arakan ( Rakhine) and forced them ( about 300,000 ) out from Burma to bangldesh with a military operation ( Naghar Min in 1982
And then,
Bangladeshi Govt led by Gen Zia and Mr Mohammad kajhawah Kaiser brought Burma govt with forced Mass expelling Bengali Muslims issues at UN office in 1983.
Bangladeshi Govt won the solitary Burma govt with Diplomatic influences,getting strong support from OIC and Western countries,India and China in 1983.
And then,
The Burma govt had to take more than 200,000 Muslims back from bangldesh to Arakan ( Rakhine) under UN pressures embarrassingly in 1983.
Even though Burma govt accepted them under international pressures ,
Burmese govt and Burmese leaders did not Recognize them more than one million of Muslims as citizens of Burma until now.
These illegal Bangladeshi immigrants who fabricated themselves as Rohingya Muslims become stateless Muslims between Myanmar and bangldesh now.
# the important fact is that 1,200,000 Bengali Muslims entered illegally from East Pakistan and bangldesh into bordering Arakan ( Rakhine) province in Burma in 1948-1982.
* Who/ Which Claimed that ?
1) all British official documents and censuses in Arakan and British Burma in 1824-1947.
2) Mr Mohammad kajhwah kaiser admitted to senor Burmese leaders and Mr John O Brein ,British Ambassador to Burma in Yangon on December 23,1975.
3) Letters of Mr Booth ,British Ambassador to Burma in 1980-1984.
4) Common wealth achieved files.
5) letter of German Ambassador in pakistan.
EU is ready to welcome all these 5million people?
Y muslim nations not condemned this 😂
One terrorist country is blaming other terrorist country, (talibani Afghanistan vs Pakistan)