Taliban Reject Pakistan, Cosying up to India? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июн 2024
- Taliban Reject Pakistan, Cosying up to India? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
As Pakistan began expelling thousands of Afghan refugees from its soil, Indian diplomats held talks with Taliban representatives in Doha. While relations between the Taliban and Pakistan have deteriorated, the Afghan group appears keen to build ties with India. How should New Delhi respond to these overtures? What explains the Taliban's position? Palki Sharma tells you.
---
India | Afghanistan | Taliban | Diplomatic Relations | Pakistan | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#india #taliban #diplomaticrelations #afghanistan #pakistan #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
From Pakistan, we learned how to destroy our country, but from India we learned how to be on top! It's an Afghan's statement
End to endia 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I hope we get rich and prosperous together.
@@tesoridellasia in your dreams only fakistani
@@tesoridellasianow it's Bharat. All subcontinent peoples are descendants of great King Bharat and Devi maru. Respect your father.
@@sitarampradhan8488 no its india even today .. read premeble of India
Pakistan surrounded by enemies from all side. 😂😂
Think again
@@shortsking6471 Afghanistan, Iran, India and now China too 😂😂😂
@@subhashishbagchi3191irán also
It's a final settlement now.
When Afganistan and Pakistan in disputes, its China who calls the shot for peace, not India.
We will see in the long run, when Hindus pressurise Muslin minority again, India will face backlash.
Not even Taliban like Pakistan.. that tells you how bad Pakistan is
Biggest mistake if India gets involved.
Indias opinion is irrelevant when china owns you 😂😂
India is worst than Pakistan in terms of hunger index. Development is not about adani and Ambani
Tal are people with honor, they have been demonised by the west.
Porkijeet larping 😂😂😂@@muhammadmafaz8530
Pakistan has been playing a double game with the Taliban and the US to extract as much money possible from the Americans while Afghans paid a terrible price.
India's no better. India sponsored terror groups too while the US was trying to support the Democratic government. I know because Palki admitted on this channel but downplayed the action.
This is the right answer.
Oh Really...and how conveniently you guys forgot who invaded Afghanistan, your God Father, USSR in 1979. why their is now mention of it and its always Pakistan you have to held responsible for all the mess ??? We all know, its the presence of RAW/KHAD agents in the guise of refugees and if successfully expelled, your plans would come to an end !!
true but behind the scene taliban is dogs of pakistan they were created funded and trained there but our people love india but taliban leadership is under full control of isi sometimes they say things but it is just politics taliban leaders faimly 99% of their family still live in pakistan
I saw this right after the World Trade Center attack
To be honest, as an Afghan, We thankful India for playing positive rule in Afghanistan. India supported education, construction, and health sectors. While Pakistan Establishment supported the destruction of Afghanistan by dirty politics whenever Afghanistan have good relationships with its neighbors pakistan gets jealous. Love 🇮🇳 from Afghanistan 🇦🇫
How is the taliban govt? Seems like the women is suffering
@al-amak6710 Not true. Dont believe in media news. Im not Pro Taliban yes I dont like some of their laws but most their works are good In reality, it's different women go to outside freely universities, and tutions are open for women only schools after class 7 for girls are closed womens are working in private business like media channels , banks, police , hospital , schools, NGO,s but it will open they are not against women education its political issue between UN and other big powers beacuse we are also confused about this issue.
@@ML-ql7osDude He is from Pakistan trying to be Indian
Sometimes they even name themselves Indian so they could spread propaganda
The free air that you are breathing is because of Pakistan. You destroyed your own country. Stop blaming Pakistan.
@@ML-ql7osonly thing i know about afganistan is mostly from books *a thousand burning sun* great book you should read. And it tells you how the Russians fked the country when the Taliban happened. Afghanistan was far better than 😢
Being an Afghan, we do not like double games as Pakistan and it's agencies kept for last few decades with Afghanistan. No country help other without his own interest. As the Taliban replaced, Pakistan has taken a u turn, instead of supporting the new regime in Afghanistan. They started a new game to defame the Taliban and convict them terrorists supporting country, although it all Pakistani agencies activity. It was and is the stragedy of Pakistani's agencies to weaken and destroy the governing government in Afghanistan.
My brother have been following afgan developments last two years and I wish I could know afghanistan is fully secure for all groups?
What I want to know is Afghanistan going to help India in its war on terror funded by Pakistan.
Pakistan has historically maintained a complex relationship with Afghanistan, often benefiting from its conflicts, instability, and refugee crises. Over the past four decades, Pakistan has received billions of dollars in international aid, purportedly to support Afghan refugees settling within its borders and the Mujahideen groups (today`s terrorists). However, much of this aid has been allegedly misappropriated by Pakistan's intelligence agency, ISI, and its politicians.
During the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Pakistan played a pivotal but controversial role by training and financing Mujahideen fighters receiving billions from NATO allies. This support was ostensibly aimed at toppling the Soviet-backed communist regime in Kabul, but Pakistan also diverted arms received from NATO allies for its own security needs.
After the fall of the communist regime, Pakistan continued to influence Afghan affairs, contributing to the country's descent into civil war by backing factions like Hizb-e Islami and the Northern Alliance, funded by Russia. Millions of Afghans sought refuge in Pakistan during this period, leading to further international aid inflows.
Following the Taliban regime's collapse in 2001, Pakistan profited from selling Taliban members to US intelligence and securing contracts from NATO allies. However, Pakistan's policies became increasingly double-edged, as it received funding from China and Russia to support the Taliban against NATO forces in Afghanistan.
As Afghanistan stabilized post-2001, Pakistan's fears of a strong, prosperous neighbor intensified. The Afghan government, under Taliban rule, focused on infrastructure development, security reforms, and curbing opium production, while forging ties with regional powers like China. Consequently, international aid to Pakistan dwindled, Afghan refugees began returning home, and Pakistan faced economic strain.
Pakistan's alleged response was to resist Afghan stability, evident in its alleged support for groups like the National Resistance, formerly Northern Alliance terrorists, through ISI-backed meetings in Islamabad. This has exacerbated tensions with Afghanistan, seeing Pakistan as a regional destabilizer.
In essence, Pakistan's strategic interests often clash with Afghan stability, positioning it as a contentious actor in regional geopolitics, viewed by some as a disruptive force in Central Asia. Pakistan views Afghanistan through a lens of strategic and economic (cash cow) interests, often treating it as a source of financial opportunities rather than a stable neighbor.
Don't u have a plan to create insurgency 2.0 in kashmir but with whole new command loyal to taliban pathan masters in afghanistan and not in pakistan... u were paid 10mil to assassinate kashmiri militants in pak under isi and u did that and now u have fitted ur own people into all terror outfits working for kashmir... so u r playing double games huhh
@@java2architectAfghanistan is the one creating terror in Pakistan of course they're not gonna stop their own work...
Welcome back Palki
Welcome Back Palki Sharma.
🧐🤔❓ कहाँ से welcome back?
@@yash1152 palki Sharma ne chood diya tha
At least India is transparent and friendly for them
India : Hinduism vs Islam
Sri Lanka : Buddhism vs lslam
China : Atheism vs Islam
Israeli: Judaism vs lslam
France: Christianity vs Islam
Myanmar: Buddhism vs Islam
Middle East: Islam vs Islam
UK: Christianity vs Islam
I must say islam is very peaceful religion.
And i am proud of that, sorry for the sarcasm.
@@hooooman. 💯 you right .
Sri Lanka is ethnic Sinhala vs Tamil issue not religious one
moment of silence for you cuz you think Israel-Palestine is just a religious issue.
In China and Myanmar muslim ethnic Ugyhurs and Rohingya are being persecuted by their government so here they are the victims here
France and Europe in general have immigration issue it just so happens that majority of immigrants are muslims from middle east and north Africa, well I won't blame Europeans for more anti immigration polices cuz they do have this problem with high crime rates.
I not defending Islam cuz I also agree Islam has the most amount of radicalization as it is evident in Europe with high crime rates but get your facts checked before you comment with half assed knowledge constantly defaming muslims just because to soothe your own agenda.
Sri Lanka is ethnic Sinhala vs Tamil issue not religious one
moment of silence for you cuz you think Israel-Palestine is just a religious issue.
In China and Myanmar muslim ethnic Ugyhurs and Rohingya are being persecuted by their government so here they are the victims here
France and Europe in general have immigration issue it just so happens that majority of immigrants are muslims from middle east and north Africa, well I won't blame Europeans for more anti immigration polices cuz they do have this problem with high crime rates.
I not defending Islam cuz I also agree Islam has the most amount of radicalization than any other religion as it is evident in Europe with high crime rates but get your facts checked before you comment with half assed knowledge constantly defaming muslims just because to soothe your own agenda.
Sri Lanka is ethnic Sinhala vs Tamil issue not religious one
moment of silence for you cuz you think Israel-Palestine is just a religious issue.
In China and Myanmar muslim ethnic Ugyhurs and Rohingya are being persecuted by their government so here they are the victims here
France and Europe in general have immigration issue it just so happens that majority of immigrants are muslims from middle east and north Africa, well I won't blame Europeans for more anti immigration polices cuz they do have this problem with high crime rates.
I not defending Islam cuz I also agree Islam has the most amount of radicalization as it is evident in Europe with high crime rates but get your facts checked before you comment with half assed knowledge constantly defaming muslims just because to soothe your own agenda.
Hon'ble Best Prime Minister Mr Narendra Modi of India
@smahmedhasan6643 You say horrible and then best Prime Minister Modi of India.Where did you learn this sort of nonsensical language?In a madrassa?
@@ajmersingh3043 Hon'ble is one way of saying Honourable. He never said Horrible. Theek se pad
@@HariPrasad-lu6vf Thanks.Sorry I misread.Apologies.
Business Gulf
Modi is a clown
Friendship between Afghanistan and India natural in nature.
Welcome back Palki Shama
We Afghans want peace in region (Afghanistan/Pakistan/Iran/India/)no more war of words or violence.
Pakistan 🇵🇰 can't live in peace 😢😢 past month they attack innocent kashmiri and hindi pilgirims
Then Afghans must stop attacking other nations.
Welcome back Palki Sharma.. we miss you... Happy to see you
India should maintain better relationship with both Afganistan and Iran ❤
Pakistan's role in the destruction of Afghan society absolutely goes without saying! Their nefarious double-dealing in using foreign aid to enrich top individuals in the Pakistan army is shameless. That selfish greed has crushed the Afghani & the Kashmiri people without a doubt, & created a massive terrorism problem. India feels for its Afghan brothers & sisters & will help them any way possible.
India feels for its Kashmiri people....really, with all the atrocities india committing in the indian occupied Kashmir, does india really feels the pain and agony of the people of IOK?? India forcibly occupied Hyderabad but lets see for how long india would succeed in suppressing the voice of Independence !!!!
@@SajidKhan-mf8tsIndia is your father.....Hindu converted Muslim and shameless madrassa chap....learn your history first.....
@@SajidKhan-mf8ts What about Balochistan, I am from Balochistan.
@@SajidKhan-mf8tsno they didn't. Pakistan caused all the causalities
@@Unknownlens703 If you are from Balochistan then go and ask Bugtis who chewed up all the royalties given to them from Islamabad. Go ask them if you have any courage !!!
Jai hind and jai afghanistan
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
India should have reached out to the Taliban from the beginning. Ignoring the Taliban serves no purpose.
Finally favourite news anchor is back 🎉 🎉
Where was the Anti Taliban Palki then
This woman is just too good. Professionalism at its peak
Nonsense...her professionalism is anti-China or at least bias?
@@yaphonghor4409 yes she was anti- china fo what? Most of Chinese bot are anti-india. Cry more about
@@yaphonghor4409 she is a Nationalist
@@yaphonghor4409She isn't even talking about china🤦♂️ You are the one obsessed with her 😂
India also wants to be on the Taliban good side it goes both ways. India also wants trade with Afghanistan.
Yes but India is much more powerful and bigger than Afghanistan. It's like a giant and an ant. Both can help each other but the giant can help the ant more
@@sachinnair91 No offence but somthing very childish about the way you speak haha. Are you a 9 year old kido?
@@harshvardhansingh8883 thank you for the compliment, im actually 3 years old
@@sachinnair91 wow you are actually quite well spoken for a 3 year old 😄 hood on you bro
Anyone one who is friends with Taliban will be seen as enemy in Afghanistan and India is no different. People hate Pakistan in Afghanistan because they were supporting Taliban. It is up to India which side they want to choose.
Ms. Palki is back!!🙏💯
*The people of India always loves the people of Afghanistan*
Cringe - the last Sikh/Hindu families were driven out of Afghanistan!
@@mlg1279do you know what cringe is
@@khyalwazeer4032 cringe is believing afghans love India when they have driven out the last Sikh/Hindu families from Afghanistan
India and Afghanistan Zendabad🇦🇫 🇮🇳
Go Afghandu go
Population of Japan = 125 million. Population of Muslims in India = 200 million.
Tajikistan= 1 crore but more ckean
@@HasnainKhan-lh6si India very very rich compared to any "stan" :))))))
@@JesseJames-no7ik I visited India and all the stans except the fake one pakistan. Indian plains are dusty, noisy and super hot. Few resources more people. In contrast the stans are snowy, less population, clean cities. Central asia is 80% empty
As you answered yourself. The more the crowd the more the waste. So no need to compare barren lands with a vibrant country@@HasnainKhan-lh6si
Palki is back with the bang 😂😂 " India cosying up with Taliban"
It's Taliban cosying up with India, read clearly.
Dealing and adjusting with Taliban is the same as dealing with radical muslims of India. So there is enough practice. Same Quoran which is read by Taliban and Indian Muslim 🤷♀️ ultimately it is the same thing. They practice what is written, In India they hide behind democracy and practice.
Pakistan has historically maintained a complex relationship with Afghanistan, often benefiting from its conflicts, instability, and refugee crises. Over the past four decades, Pakistan has received billions of dollars in international aid, purportedly to support Afghan refugees settling within its borders and the Mujahideen groups (today`s terrorists). However, much of this aid has been allegedly misappropriated by Pakistan's intelligence agency, ISI, and its politicians.
During the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Pakistan played a pivotal but controversial role by training and financing Mujahideen fighters receiving billions from NATO allies. This support was ostensibly aimed at toppling the Soviet-backed communist regime in Kabul, but Pakistan also diverted arms received from NATO allies for its own security needs.
After the fall of the communist regime, Pakistan continued to influence Afghan affairs, contributing to the country's descent into civil war by backing factions like Hizb-e Islami and the Northern Alliance, funded by Russia. Millions of Afghans sought refuge in Pakistan during this period, leading to further international aid inflows.
Following the Taliban regime's collapse in 2001, Pakistan profited from selling Taliban members to US intelligence and securing contracts from NATO allies. However, Pakistan's policies became increasingly double-edged, as it received funding from China and Russia to support the Taliban against NATO forces in Afghanistan.
As Afghanistan stabilized post-2001, Pakistan's fears of a strong, prosperous neighbor intensified. The Afghan government, under Taliban rule, focused on infrastructure development, security reforms, and curbing opium production, while forging ties with regional powers like China. Consequently, international aid to Pakistan dwindled, Afghan refugees began returning home, and Pakistan faced economic strain.
Pakistan's alleged response was to resist Afghan stability, evident in its alleged support for groups like the National Resistance, formerly Northern Alliance terrorists, through ISI-backed meetings in Islamabad. This has exacerbated tensions with Afghanistan, seeing Pakistan as a regional destabilizer.
In essence, Pakistan's strategic interests often clash with Afghan stability, positioning it as a contentious actor in regional geopolitics, viewed by some as a disruptive force in Central Asia. Pakistan views Afghanistan through a lens of strategic and economic (cash cow) interests, often treating it as a source of financial opportunities rather than a stable neighbor.
*stop it radical Hindu.
@@AhmadAli-ez8dbyour comment is same in every section
So your unemployed 😂😂😂
Quran does not preach hate.its our politics they want to use for own benifits.
So why india invest Afghanistan 🏳️🏳️ India should out Afghanistan and china will win in Afghanistan and Russia
INDIA MUST FULLY SUPPORT IN DEVELOPMENT OF AFGHANISTAN. AKANDA AFGHANISTAN 💕 AKANDA BHARAT 💕
Lunda Bharat
❤❤❤❤🙏🙏🇮🇳❤️
Afganistan was a part of India gandhar
regardless of the government policy India Afghan have special respect for India, India has cooperated in different sectors with Afghanistan from providing scholarship to agriculture sectors ,road constructions and Salam Dam construction in west region of Afghanistan , Thanks India
Certainly india must use any leverage available to secure some liberty for afghan people.
But we should always keep in mind a highly radicalised group is dangerous its only a matter of time.
Hope our bureocrats and top legislators will do the job cooperatively yet cautiously.
India could never affoed to be complacent espeacially with sensitive afghanistan region
Pakistan has historically maintained a complex relationship with Afghanistan, often benefiting from its conflicts, instability, and refugee crises. Over the past four decades, Pakistan has received billions of dollars in international aid, purportedly to support Afghan refugees settling within its borders and the Mujahideen groups (today`s terrorists). However, much of this aid has been allegedly misappropriated by Pakistan's intelligence agency, ISI, and its politicians.
During the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Pakistan played a pivotal but controversial role by training and financing Mujahideen fighters receiving billions from NATO allies. This support was ostensibly aimed at toppling the Soviet-backed communist regime in Kabul, but Pakistan also diverted arms received from NATO allies for its own security needs.
After the fall of the communist regime, Pakistan continued to influence Afghan affairs, contributing to the country's descent into civil war by backing factions like Hizb-e Islami and the Northern Alliance, funded by Russia. Millions of Afghans sought refuge in Pakistan during this period, leading to further international aid inflows.
Following the Taliban regime's collapse in 2001, Pakistan profited from selling Taliban members to US intelligence and securing contracts from NATO allies. However, Pakistan's policies became increasingly double-edged, as it received funding from China and Russia to support the Taliban against NATO forces in Afghanistan.
As Afghanistan stabilized post-2001, Pakistan's fears of a strong, prosperous neighbor intensified. The Afghan government, under Taliban rule, focused on infrastructure development, security reforms, and curbing opium production, while forging ties with regional powers like China. Consequently, international aid to Pakistan dwindled, Afghan refugees began returning home, and Pakistan faced economic strain.
Pakistan's alleged response was to resist Afghan stability, evident in its alleged support for groups like the National Resistance, formerly Northern Alliance terrorists, through ISI-backed meetings in Islamabad. This has exacerbated tensions with Afghanistan, seeing Pakistan as a regional destabilizer.
In essence, Pakistan's strategic interests often clash with Afghan stability, positioning it as a contentious actor in regional geopolitics, viewed by some as a disruptive force in Central Asia. Pakistan views Afghanistan through a lens of strategic and economic (cash cow) interests, often treating it as a source of financial opportunities rather than a stable neighbor.
People in Afghanistan hate Pakistan because they were supporting Taliban, Any friend of Taliban is enemy No.1 of people in Afghanistan. Taliban may not be there for always buy people will be there always.
You are right. India should also be careful of the 400 million of the radicals in its own land.
@@Satanreincarnation-zg6sl Not necessarily my friend .Not all will be radicalised there could be just ,humane and simple people too.We must certainly weed out those bad apples that preach and propagate violence,seccession and hatred
@@ranjith9656 , good luck.
That's the reason we called them namak haram.
That's why we called them bhikari to make money from America 🇺🇸
Pakistan was not a country, it was always India and Afghanistan!
Afghanistan is built upon land of Khorasanis.
NATO Britain - Colony Paxtan is in real Territory belongs to India, Afghanistan & Balochistan!!!
✋🌙🌙🌙🇮🇳
Nato ne Ukraine khtm kr diye aap Use Broshe pr ho
@@trillionstartup Ruthenos Ukraina has betrayed self by trusting NATO America.
NATO America has got double check mate by NATO Ankara, NATO Britain & NATO Lutetia.
The talks about every single American Individual as subject of British Crown, Lutetia Crown, Ctesiphon Crown is really going on.
✋🌙🌙🌙🇮🇳
@@faisalhussainmohammed2815 dont worry brother, soon russia, china and india and of course iran will become too much for nato to handle
Indian softcover help us to hold Afghani peoples in favour and Taliban knows that every Afghani love India for its unconditional help on a humanitarian grounds.
Afghan like Indian, not Afghani like not Hindi. Afghani is local currency. 😊
India should take 2 million 🇦🇫👳🏻♂️refugees rather then use them against 🇵🇰🫵🏼playing double game
@@DarkEdgeMedia007 we have already taken sir after liyaqat agreement 2.5 billions right now!!!
Haw can we justify.not at all.
😂😂 even tailban knows who can be trusted 😂😂😂. Afaganistan should also join BRIC+
Well said Palki
*Pakistan to start second phase of Afghan deportations*
_More than 800,000 Afghans are likely to be expelled in the second phase of the controversial plan._
(June 30, 2024 al Jazeera)
Understood everything, but sentiments should be put aside and thinking must be strategic. Security to every Indian citizen is the Government's duty because you take oath before taking responsibility. God bless us.
No one gives the news straight up as U thank U for keeping us updated on worldwide affairs so accurately .thank U .
Palki the perfectionist
Finally palki is back 😊😊😊
Our heart goes out to people of Afghanistan❤. India wants Afghan to develop its economy.
Afghanistan is starving due to Durand Line, because "confiscating" south asian wealth was Afghanistan GDP.
Welcome back maam 🎉🎉
smarter taliban,worldly wise,
but same goals and ideals
so more dangerous.
india should be careful
we indians smarter
Glad you are back palki
It will be shame for India, to join Taliban
Afghan is an Indian ancient territory India never betrays their brothers and never play a double game 🤩
We kpk ppl of Pakistan are openly with our blood brothers afghans ,
thanks from afg we also love our pashtoon but the pakistani goverment is shit
@@user-jt6ho9ou1hwe believe same about our current government and Taliban's.
You are Russian Uk USA Nato army breed not KPK pakhtoon
When the phone rang with a call from an ISI official, Taliban Zabidullah Mujahid's hand shivered upon noticing the caller.😂😂😂😂. Pakistan knows How to fool India
the conditions of pakistan😂😂
Or was it the other way around? Heard ISIsupported terrorists going to 72 hoors on priority visa. Last count 33 of ISI's chosen mujahids have been dispatched to 72 hoors.
Afganistan,Part of Greater India 👍
U have been missed. I was worried without seeing you on Air ❤
Welcome back palki we are all waiting for your video without you not interested to watch first post
The U.S. was disappointed that Pakistan supported the Taliban after U.S. broke Talib's rule in Kabul.
🇮🇳♥️🇦🇫
🇮🇳🤝🇦🇫......Thats all 😊
PALKI SHARMAAAAA!!! SHES BAAACK!!!!🎉
In Urdu we have a proverb which says "nim hakim khatre jaan, nim elm khatre emaan".
Misinforming the viewers about a government decision is spreading lies amongst public.
Pakistan finalised to deport 1.7million NON-REGISTERED afghan refugees out of 4.4million total refugees in Pakistan. Remaining refugees (2.7million) are registered and have database in Nadra, govt database entity, and they can live in Pakistan. The unregistered afghans are sent back to afg for their national identity process, and after completing their process can avail the Pakistani visa as per their need. Hosting non-existing people in a govt database is always a risk to their security.
No doubt it is a political move to suppress talib govt. Taliban 2.0 promised in nov 2021 to take actions against TTP in afg, if they use afghan soil to take actions against Pakistan, but after many promises and many TTP attacks in Pakistan, the taliban 2.0 rejects any involvement of the TTP or their presence in afg all together.
Well who is talking? Paxtan? Lol, the story sounds soooo paxtani. Don't suite you guys. You may stating facts in this case, but you can't be selective after doing so much contributions to neighboring terrorism and double games.
Pakistan has historically maintained a complex relationship with Afghanistan, often benefiting from its conflicts, instability, and refugee crises. Over the past four decades, Pakistan has received billions of dollars in international aid, purportedly to support Afghan refugees settling within its borders and the Mujahideen groups (today`s terrorists). However, much of this aid has been allegedly misappropriated by Pakistan's intelligence agency, ISI, and its politicians.
During the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Pakistan played a pivotal but controversial role by training and financing Mujahideen fighters receiving billions from NATO allies. This support was ostensibly aimed at toppling the Soviet-backed communist regime in Kabul, but Pakistan also diverted arms received from NATO allies for its own security needs.
After the fall of the communist regime, Pakistan continued to influence Afghan affairs, contributing to the country's descent into civil war by backing factions like Hizb-e Islami and the Northern Alliance, funded by Russia. Millions of Afghans sought refuge in Pakistan during this period, leading to further international aid inflows.
Following the Taliban regime's collapse in 2001, Pakistan profited from selling Taliban members to US intelligence and securing contracts from NATO allies. However, Pakistan's policies became increasingly double-edged, as it received funding from China and Russia to support the Taliban against NATO forces in Afghanistan.
As Afghanistan stabilized post-2001, Pakistan's fears of a strong, prosperous neighbor intensified. The Afghan government, under Taliban rule, focused on infrastructure development, security reforms, and curbing opium production, while forging ties with regional powers like China. Consequently, international aid to Pakistan dwindled, Afghan refugees began returning home, and Pakistan faced economic strain.
Pakistan's alleged response was to resist Afghan stability, evident in its alleged support for groups like the National Resistance, formerly Northern Alliance terrorists, through ISI-backed meetings in Islamabad. This has exacerbated tensions with Afghanistan, seeing Pakistan as a regional destabilizer.
In essence, Pakistan's strategic interests often clash with Afghan stability, positioning it as a contentious actor in regional geopolitics, viewed by some as a disruptive force in Central Asia. Pakistan views Afghanistan through a lens of strategic and economic (cash cow) interests, often treating it as a source of financial opportunities rather than a stable neighbor.
@@abrakidabra look who is talking about a country with oppression against their citizens from east to west and south to north, whose involvement in their neighbours speak volumes in the case of bangladesh, pakistan, maldives, china etc. Please don't talk of double standards, at one side you are against muslims but on the other side endia is officially supporting TERRORISTS state, the ones who are suppressing women children and their whole country. Plz refrain from giving lectures. Apne gareban me jaank ke deiko.
@@AhmadAli-ez8db who says no to all those?
But one big question here, if some illiterate army personnel in the past let all those millions of afghans without any database enter into Pakistani boundary, should Pakistan still keep them astray without any data? 1.7million people who have no data are living here and there, it's not about a thousand or two, but millions.
And also Pakistan is not a signatory of UN 1951 Refugees Convention, which gives them lawful right to send all refugees back home,but they are only sending 1.7million UNREGISTERED REFUGEES.
Pakistan is not a country it is a rich military camp with poor civilians,Afghan minister say Pakistan chakla ghar
Very true
They should go to Iran, Saudi Arabia, or Qata
Peace talk is the only solution for solving the problem.
Glad to have you Back ❤Palki it's just not the same without you for sure 🙌🏽🙏🏽
I hope India will host afghan refugees deported from Pakistan. Afghan refugees also have high hopes from India as well.
Remember there are no permanent friends or enemies, there are only permanent interests
❤❤❤❤❤palki is back
But Taliban had denied religious freedom. Our Hindus and Sikh brothers can't even keep religious flag raising in Gurudwara and temple.
The other time when Taliban visited Moscow Palki consistently repeated that they are “Terrorist” but now the friend of India. Palki try to be fare.
Who said the word "Friend"?
They are terrorist - don't get involved very simple.
What's the point of having borders between two islamic nations? Isn't this against the concept of ummah?
i have seen your videos are u pakistani?
@@ahsanj5280
Yeah, he is 'Phoren minister' of Pakistan.
They dont give a damn about religion, despite what the mainstream brainrot says, these groups are not formed from religious intend but resistance, religion is just a motivational excuse, this applies to ALL so called islamic militias.
Now we should have to build our military bases at Pakistan borders in Afghanistan.
Engaging with the Taliban is a first step towards securing minor changes to their internal administration. If the Afghan economy grows, it would require more and more workers and you can see the need arising for all Afghans to start participating with the agreement of the current Afghan administration.
Just remember, your choice of friends says a lot about you.
Exactly, US friendship with pakistan is concerning😂
Unfortunately you don’t understand that geography is non negotiable, love thy neighbors and all that jazz.. you can stay wherever you are but for India, afghans are a geographical reality..
What "friends"? Merely opening an embassy in a nation doesn't mean that that nation is our friend. India has a much bigger embassy in Pakistan and China than it does in Afghanistan. Does that mean Pakistan and China are bigger friends of India than Afghanistan? Room temperature IQ logic.
@@death_parade Look to history for how well supporting repressive Islamic states goes. Good luck with that.
More like the enemy of my enemy is my friend!
India loves afgan people
Pak is locked 😂
Great India 🇮🇳
Awesome reporting, Palki ji! Always loved the content and insight presented by you!
Great. you are back
Afghanis are Real Rulers of India.
💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
all indians have afghan heritage, even hinduism originated from gandhar(modern day kandhar, afghanistan)
Thanks. Your contributions are unique
India should be careful while supporting the Taliban since like Pakistan Afghanistani Taliban is also a Jihadi group 😢😢😢😢😮😮😮
After KICKING ALL HINDUS out of AFGHANISTAN, now they are cozying up with INDIA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Every country has its
Own enemy in the face of opposition ।
Long live Afghanistan.
For people of Afghanistan ,
❤❤ superb ❤❤
Palki is back 🎉yay!!!
After several decades, this is the first step Pakistan took to fix its problems. Pakistan decided to expel millions of Afghan refugees, India should show some reciprocity and take all Afghan refugees to India, that will go very well for both countries. The Afghans refugees will have their Hindu brothers and sisters to welcome them. India is a large country, make some room for them.❤
Why not permanently settle then in balochistan? Heard pakistan army cleansed boloch to make more space there? Well chinese are already there why not afghans?
@@Rathi002 yes why not, we hosted Afghans since 1979, India and NATO came into Afghanistan after 9/11. Afghans brought heroin and AK 47 with them. After 9/11 India got its hands wet and worked with Afghan proxies and supported terror in Pakistan. Now the tides are turning, as per your Indian media (the original video) India is building relationships with Afghan Talibans. Pakistan did its fare share and hosted millions of Afghan refugees, why not India do the same, it’s 7 times larger than Pakistan. 👆👍
@@ayyazbaluch2552 India never went to any other country after 9/11. Pakistan has to reap what it sowed and this is just a start. You think you will displace Afghans from their home and there will be no backlash? It is just a start. Moreover both Afghanistan and India predates pakistan which is an artificially crafted country
@@Rathi002I humbly request you to do more research.
Pakistan is not displacing Afghan refugees, simply telling them to return back to their home country Afghanistan.
You comment about “India never went to AFG” it’s a hilarious statement. In your next comment you said “the backlash” I am perplexed here, help me understand, telling refugees to return back to their home 🤔 an example 42000 Indians citizens have been deported from US Mexico border back to India, should there be a “backlash” please comment.
Your mindset of anti Muslim rant is evident in your statement about creation of Pakistan.
Finally, both USA and Canada blame India for assassination attempts on Sikh separatists. Your defense minister bragged about carrying out same type of satanic attack in Pakistan strengthens US and Canada claims. Have some faith 😊
@@ayyazbaluch2552 lol.. now you chose to go to world politcs😂 you rest of the comment is not worth responding but India is commited to eliminate terrorists regardless wherever they hide including US and Canada. Why should we have shame in killing them in another country when they don't have shame in giving asylum to criminals in their country?
Happy to see u again
INDIA'S friendly ties should grow stronger with AFGHANISTAN.
Pakistan paid a terrible prize , Taliban was made in pakistanit was a terrible mistakes please donot train your enemy friend or foe to come against you
"Pakistan accuses Afghanistan of terrorism. " 😂😂
Please palki.. at least inform us whenever you are going out for a while.... coz missing you is very costly ❤❤❤
your enemies enemy is your friend...thats what theyre doing..
I think you should look at the Taliban's actions and see that they usually bite the hand that feeds.
😮 ISI propaganda at it’s peak
Well,well we basically went to town when Taliban was cozy with Pakistan....now what happened?The Talibans are the good guys?Wow!
India can benefit from its relationship with Afghanistan in several ways, across political, strategic, and economic dimensions:
Political Benefits:
Regional Influence: Strengthening ties with Afghanistan enhances India's influence in South Asia and the broader region, particularly in Central Asia.
Diplomatic Support: Afghanistan can provide India with diplomatic support in international forums, especially on issues of mutual interest or where their positions align.
Counterterrorism Cooperation: Both countries can collaborate on counterterrorism efforts, sharing intelligence and strategies to combat common threats.
Strategic Benefits:
Strategic Positioning: Afghanistan provides India with a strategic foothold in Central Asia, enabling easier access to resource-rich regions and markets.
Security Cooperation: Enhanced military and security cooperation can help both countries address security challenges, including border security and stability in the region.
Connectivity Projects: India can invest in and benefit from infrastructure projects in Afghanistan, such as roads, dams, and other developmental initiatives, which can further strategic interests.
Economic Benefits:
Trade and Investment: Strengthening economic ties can lead to increased trade between India and Afghanistan, particularly in sectors like agriculture, pharmaceuticals, and infrastructure development.
Resource Extraction: India can explore opportunities for resource extraction and investment in Afghanistan's mineral wealth, which includes significant deposits of minerals like lithium, copper, and rare earth elements.
Energy Cooperation: Collaborating on energy projects, such as pipelines or renewable energy initiatives, can meet the energy needs of both countries and enhance energy security.
Cultural and People-to-People Ties:
Cultural Exchange: Promoting cultural exchange programs can foster mutual understanding and goodwill between the peoples of India and Afghanistan.
Educational Collaboration: Supporting educational initiatives, scholarships, and exchanges can build human capital and strengthen academic ties between institutions in both countries.
In summary, a closer relationship with Afghanistan can offer India political influence, strategic advantages in terms of security and connectivity, economic opportunities in trade and investment, and cultural ties that promote mutual understanding and cooperation. These benefits are crucial for India's broader geopolitical ambitions in South Asia and beyond.
Good presentation
Don't care of news of Pakistan. Indian media should focus of India.
Afghanis take great pride in keeping their words and promises. So they r far better than Chi Pak
Afghanistan should always be a friendly neighbour. We have helped Afghanistan.
Palki, where have you been?
Palki is back 👍🏼