Whats that country, im curious. Even in Turkey which is mostly secular but the majority are Muslims, treatment of women is not good at all, i mean its good just superficially
Muslim woman: "My husband is constantly beating me and thus repeatedly disrespecting your direct orders, oh, Prophet!" Mohammed: "Sending thoughts and prayers." How cowardly. Shameful. 😢😡
@@miovicdina7706 Is this the way a woman say about her husband yes he beat her it's wrong may be there is a provocation and may not be but that man did Lot's of good thing's to you he provided you taken care you and children Helped you when you was ill and you only focus on his short comings or bad deeds he drained his most for you what about that...
You can feel how the imam is saying it, telling the story, with salawat and the way he say it, making it absolutely holy, and magical. This is what Islam does. Wrap up bullshit and sell to muslim as gold and diamonds.
I once had a conversation with a Muslim who accused an ex-muslim of being a wannabe victim and islamphobe. I explained that he had death threats and had to leave his country and what he thought about that. The muslim replied that it is right that ex-muslims are killed because Allah commands it and he cannot go against Allah. My point is that many Muslims just want people to shut up talking about these issues that make Islam look bad rather address the issue. God willing it, is not an answer.
It is sad really, the problem is most Muslim follow hadith written 200 years later rather than the Qur'an alone, I mean the hadith have some very extremist stuff in there whilst the Qur'an teaches the complete opposite
I heard similar from other Muslims. They call people who leave and criticize Islam traitors, and compare them to people who betray their country (like war traitors) who also get the death penalty in some Western countries, so it all makes sense to them.
Not really (out of context). There are many very clear and simple instructions about how to treat non-believers. Remember that the Quran is supposed to be eternal, pre-existing the universe, so the often-used Muslim excuse of "historical context" for example doesn't make any sense. And, there is no indication of that in the text itself (the hadiths can of course give historical context to the revelations, but that just shows that the Quran is a man-made text for the occasion, and that the final revelations (which abrogate the earlier ones) are supposed to be binding for all time (but that again makes little sense if the book is eternal).@@amigos2841
These Imams have to work with such poor material and struggle so hard to dress it up to make it look good, I almost feel sorry for them. It reminds me of when I gave Khutbahs back in the day. I had to search so long and hard to find anything worthy of including in my talks.
I went to jumuah last week and the whole khutbah was about how we shouldn't question allah or momo. He quoted a hadith where a man was sitting in the presence of momo having a meal but eating with his left hand. Momo told him to eat with his his right hand to which the man replied "I can't". Momo then said "May it be that you are never able to eat with your right hand again" and the man went paralyzed in his right hand for the rest of his life. Tried to look for the hadith to no avail but the way people were listening to this dude and absorbing his nonsense khutbah was really telling.
Allah and his co-god: It is not for a believing man or woman-when Allah and His Messenger decree a matter-to have any other choice in that matter.1 Indeed, whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has clearly gone ˹far˺ astray. Surah 33:36
I was a guest at the home of 'Umar one night, and in the middle of the night he went and hit his wife, and I separated them. When he went to bed he said to me: 'O Ash'ath, learn from me something that I heard from the Messenger of Allah" A man should not be asked why he beats his wife, and do not go to sleep until you have prayed the Witr."' And I forgot the third thing. Sunan Ibn Majah 1986
Mind you, Imam Omar Suleiman is considered a moderate/liberal imam. So much so that he frequently has interfaith events with other religions. He is called out by Muslims as being tooo liberal. If you people are repulsed at this guy who is a MODERATE Muslim that sugarcoats misogyny, then take a look at the truthful Islamic speakers from the Muslim world who tell it like it is,
I saw a video years ago of Omar Suleiman with his little daughter (around 2 years old) and the little girl was wearing a hijab, so I don’t think he’s as moderate as he tries to look
@@tanjavankessel8942come on he has to act the part if his daughter doesn’t do it then people will say look at this imam he can’t preach to his own family. ( mind you sickos even forget she is 2 years old girl )
This was the piece he gave her for no doubts it was from him: I asked `Aisha about the clothes soiled with semen. She replied, "I used to wash it off the clothes of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and he would go for the prayer while water spots were still visible. " حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا يَزِيدُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا عَمْرٌو، عَنْ سُلَيْمَانَ، قَالَ سَمِعْتُ عَائِشَةَ، ح وَحَدَّثَنَا مُسَدَّدٌ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الْوَاحِدِ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا عَمْرُو بْنُ مَيْمُونٍ، عَنْ سُلَيْمَانَ بْنِ يَسَارٍ، قَالَ سَأَلْتُ عَائِشَةَ عَنِ الْمَنِيِّ، يُصِيبُ الثَّوْبَ فَقَالَتْ كُنْتُ أَغْسِلُهُ مِنْ ثَوْبِ رَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم، فَيَخْرُجُ إِلَى الصَّلاَةِ وَأَثَرُ الْغَسْلِ فِي ثَوْبِهِ بُقَعُ الْمَاءِ. Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 230
For serious, if I were the husband, I'd suspect that "being under M's protection" meant, that she were one of his side chicks. Especially after she brought me his clothing!!! - But I COULD imagine that a public prayer to A. to curse wife beaters by sending them to hell if they don't repent - that might have had some effect, but - o no, they only recite surahs. I hope he did not recite the verse encouraging to beat your wife....
You know a religion's real values by seeing for what it legislates punishment in the real world, and what it relegates for punishment in the afterworld. Islam has legislation for punishment against stealing, for misappropriating war booty, for insulting prophet and his companions, But for domestic abuse all it has time for is prayers.
I’m a “salesman “ so I meet all kinds of people. Years ago, the Muslim woman told me if she don’t obey her husband, she will be the fuel in hell. A real threat to the innocent, closed minded woman.
@@theshortangry To be fair the Qur'an literally says men are in charge of women, and should even beat them if they keep disobeying in verse 4:34. So it's not much of a logical inference to get that not obeying your husband is a sin that can inevitably mean go will torture you eternally according to Islamic scripture if you reach some threshold point.
@@James-wc3fc wdym “to be fair” lol? Clearly you don’t know Arabic and took that verse out of context from some Islamophobic subreddit. As Muslims, we know very well that our educated scholars and books of tafsirs have clarified that what is meant here is a light tap (on the arm or such, not on the face), and this is only as a last resort if the woman has gone over the limits and persist in harm in spite of multiple words of advice. Have you not read the report that Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) strictly condemned the beating of women, and would even declare a man a kafir if he persisted in abuse of his wife? If the husband does not fulfil the wife’s rights, then he will be the one punished; why are you bringing up a single part of the contract and making it out to be something it’s not?
a@@theshortangry Lmao I don't think you know Arabic and I certainly didn't get my info from an atheist sub-reddit. And just to be clear you are okay with a husband beating his wife lightly if she keeps disobeying him?? Also can you imagine if the actual method was literally tapping someone that does absolutely nothing and doesn't solve any problem, that is what the all-knowing God commanded really? You can read scholarly opinions from mainstream orthodox sunni Islam for the last 1400 years who all condone wife-beating explicitly stating the quran and hadith state this, as do many parts of the world today, with Qatar coming out with a video on how to do it, the Taliban quoting scripture and Imams today all over the world supporting it. Are you telling me everyone has read the verse wrong for the last 1000+ years and only now you understand it? Including Al-Tabari, Ibn Kathri, Al-Jalalayn, the best of all? There is absolutely nothing about doing it lightly in the Quran or on a specific part of the body - which is the supposed perfect word of God. The hadith, which are always a contradictory mess say: Sahih Muslim Book4 2137 Aisha says 'Yes. He struck me on the chest which caused me pain'. Sahih Muslim 7:2803 you can beat them, but not severly. Sunan Abu Dawad 11:2141 has Muhammad giving men including Umar permission to beat their wives. Sunan Ibn Majad 3:9:1986 A man should not be asked why he beats his wife. Sahih Bukhari 8:73:68 You should beat your wife like a horse or slave.
@@theshortangry Why wouldn't it mean beat, an extremely patriarchal religion. I do not see how you cannot go to hell if you have even the very slight tiny bit of feminism in you.. Verse 4:34 says men are in charge of women, because they excel them. And they can deal with disobedience by beating/hitting/striking them. Would you like me to quote you the Hadith that confirm Muhammad folly approved of beating women?. 2:228 says men are above women. 2:222 says for men to stay away from women who are on their period as it is a sickness. 2:282 says the testimony of a woman is worth half of a man's. 4:11 says women get half the inheritance of a man. 2:223 says you make take your wife whenever and however you please (nothing of course is mentioned about the wife's consent) Qur'an 17:40, 43:15-16 and 37:149-156 actually mocks the idea that God would take a daughter as a partner over sons. Qur'an 70:29-30 says you can have s*x with your wives and FEMALE SLAVES 4:3 women can only marry one person while man can marry up to four, and have sex with as many female slaves as they desire - and you should take a female slave if you can't deal justly with your wife. There is absolutely no such thing as sexual assault (zina) in Islamic law against wives or slaves either... 44:51-54, 55:56-58, 78:31-35 Men get light skinned virgins with big breasts in heaven, while women get nothing like that (I assume they just sit there while their husbands f**k them) 60:10 Muslim men can get married to Christians and Jews while Muslim women can only marry Muslim men (2:221) 24:31 Women wear a headscarf while men have no such requirement 64:5 explicitly gives the rules around child marriage 👍 Nice.. It is significantly easier for a husband to divorce his wife than vice versa where the wife has to ask permission and go through a waiting period. And this is only the Qur'an. Would you like me to quote you the authentic hadith on these verses as well? Mohammad honestly sounds like Borat on women.
What a shocking story which must be true. The Prophet simply threw the poor woman under the bus, as he did countless other women. Yet present day Muslim women continue to sing his praises.
Absolutely, they're brilliant. I wish every nominal Muslim or potential 'revert' could watch these videos after listening to all the garbage these Dawah nut jobs and bullies come out with.
@@AronGirma man worship? That's idolatry sir, a man who couldn't save himself, you want people to depend on him? He prayed and his prayers got neglected
@@adeyemostephen1986 Jesus is full God and full man not just man and why he save himself from crucifixion when he was doing it to save us from our sins.check this verses jesus said I AM the alpha and the omega the first and the last the beggining and the end THe Almight.Jesus prayed to his father because he is communicating with him.But your God AL-lah brayed to your cult prophet does that mean your prophet momo is your God?I adivice you to follow the holly jesus the only way to heaven.
Thanks for posting this. And it is not mentioned what that prayer did. The "just pray" or "turn it over to a deity or universe" response by the religious and spiritual as always felt unsatisfying to me (maddening actually) and I now recognize this as an attempt to regulate and deal with the anxiety a person is feeling. Better for you and for others to use tools of psychology as they are not burdened with the constraints of religion. And as you mention FExM, other alternatives Mohammad could have taken are not mentioned or explored. He can deal harshly with those who anger or insult what he values, or receive messages from a deity to directly intervene in his favor, or prohibit alcohol but he does nothing outside of dua for a woman being hit, after issuing protective statements. It comes off as quite pitiful and Mohammad comes across as a very limited man who is not able to leverage his connection to a deity to help someone, because that connection is fabricated and he has no real power.
Muhammad said: "A man will not be asked about why he beat his wife." {references provided} Mishkat al-Masabih 3268 Riyad as-Salihin 68 Sunan Ibn Majah 1986
'He took it seriously' but did nothing about it. Someone coming on a public space to say this in defence of his religion is simply insulting listeners intelligence except they are people like him.
I can't comprehend how inteligent people believe that Allah would really fly down an Angel from Heaven to whisper in their Fake Prophets ear..."Subjegate or kill all Non-believers wherever you may find them". And also, Mohammad would fly to all 7 Heavens on a winged Donkey, to negotiate with Allah...how many times a day Muslims should pray to Allah. With a Resurrected Moosa being Mohammad's adviser. Heaven??? Is it a left turn at Andromeda Galaxy, or right? Let's all hope the James Web telescope spots it. Islamic Scriptures say the flying time between Heaven and Earth is a 1000 years. Ha Ha Ha. 1000% support to all Ex Muslims from 7 billion of us (many Muslims included).
He should have seen the man in person, or made an example of him, and truly protected this lady by giving her a place to stay and allowing divorce if that is what she wanted
we are missing an important detail in the discussion, the woman didnt want to reveal her identity, so the prophet SAW couldnt go and confront the man or send someone else to handle the situation.
Where was Gabriel when we needed him. No ayah was revealed? He took it seriously but Allah didnt?. Did the duaa help? Was it a cursing duaa or was it a guidance. Pffff!
Why didn't the "prophet" just tell the woman to show him who she was and then order her to lead him to her husband so that he could order the husband to stop? This is so pathetic. This is so islam.
This would have been great opportunity for the Prophet to say no beating women is allowed but he didn't. Why? He forbid so many things in Islam. Why not this?! Was he scared to lose the support of his fellow men or was it that he didn't think it was wrong.. then why pray for the woman. Makes zero sense
If the prophet's dua' to Allah against her husband is as good as his dua' to Allah to help him bare a son who will be his heir like Ibrahim before him - this poor lady is screwed!!!
Like the Jews morphed into apes and monkey in the Quran. King Solomon's army of birds, he died standing up without nobody noticing until a worm ate his stick and he feel to the ground. A sacrificed yellow cow's limb that resurrect a dead man to tell who killed him and he became dead again...
@@aiya5777 Lmao what a ridiculous stereotype.. do you honestly not find it appalling he didn't do anything to stop an abused woman? Would you be comfortable with the men in your life doing this? Do you support slavery and domestic abuse as mentioned in the Qur'an too? Or the value of a woman's testimony being half that of a man in court? These are genuine questions I would love to know.
@@James-wc3fc actually, *women's testimonies* are fundamental for the foundation of islamic teachings where did the majority hadiths come from? they came from the wives of prophet muhammad, and ofc they're all women, so women's testimonies are a lot more important than you think
@@James-wc3fc ruclips.net/video/lf1wPcF-fXw/видео.html on 3:48 a neuroscientist says, "eyewitnesses' testimony in the court cases can be *very* unreliable" now after we're getting a general idea of how very unreliable eyewitnesses' testimony are by default we have women who are well know for being especially susceptible to emotions, on top of that they keep getting Nerfed by their Periods every month which of course blur their judgments even more. and things can get even worse for women if they're suffered from dysmenorrhea, which of course blurs their judgments even more eyewitnesses' testimony in the court cases can be *very* unreliable, and women eyewitnesses' testimony are indeed *very* unreliable
Muslim women would be better off going to a Maffia/cartel boss for help. When those tell you you're under their protection, you can bet your life on it, literally, and people (lest they want to be made an example of) come correct accordingly...
He had all the power in the world to protect the woman given that both the husband and wife are under his jurisdiction. Yet he does nothing. How responsible and protective of him. Muhammad's behaviour in this particular narration (I don't know where Omar Suleiman got it from) is reminiscent of what is narrated about Muhammad's behaviour towards the divorced wife of Rifa'a as narrated in Sahih Bukhari 5825 (Another isnaad, this time going back to Ibn Abbas instead of just Ikrimah narrating on the authority of Aisha is mentioned by Al Albani in Irwa Al Ghalil 6/299 and Ibn Taymiyyah in Fatawaa Al Kubra 6/303, though it seems to be a weak isnaad) and also the wives that came around to him to complain about their abusive husbands in Sunan Abu Dawud 2146(Sahih by Al Albani).
Many of the things you describe happen in most ultra funfamentalist christian churches as well. Their response: repent, repent, submit, obey, and thoughts and prayers. After all it is your fault your husband is abusive. You simply are not doing enough or trying hard enough. You should be grateful he is rebuking you. This seems to be a universal problem.
I know little about Islam but from an outside perspective this video seems to be a very disingenuous reading of the piece of islamic text. Sort of approach I would expect from fundamentalists. For example it's obvious what is meant by the piece of garment.
The reason why Muhammad didn’t help because actually if you read the full Hadith Muhammad was gonna get him punish but his been told that was one his best fighter that’s why Muhammad was toying with her sending her back and forth Typical cult leader
I pray for the poor women a more important the young girls ive seen it on utube i watch what thay do marrying 9 year old girls to 50 year old man theys are barbaric it brings me to tears thank you for putting this out iam a Christian and we love it just dosent make sense to me how can a man hert hes wife or enyone love concers all godbless ❤️
The Original uncorrupted Koran states that The Prophet of Islam preached that one must be born again and be redeemed by the blood of the Lamb. Allah = All Law! Islam = Is Lamb. Coincedense? I think not! Islamb addresaws the English speaking people to come out.
Muhammad's clothes were always soaked in semen. That was the reason he sent one. Narrated `Aishah: I used to wash the semen off the clothes of the Prophet (ﷺ) and even then I used to notice one or more spots on them. Sahih al-Bukhari 232
@5:15 nooo, for sure it was his shirt stained with seemen that Aisha scraped with her little fingernails 😅 A guarantee maybe that if he did that again he'd come and take her away and for himself
Misogyny in the Bible “Women should be silent in the churches. For they are not permitted to speak, but should be subordinate, as the law also says … it is shameful for a woman to speak in church …”); or 1 Timothy 2:11-12 (“Let a woman learn in silence with full submission. I permit no woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she is to keep silent
Actually that section was about women in a synagogue upstairs yelling to their husbands downstairs to ask a question but true that making one religion bad doesn’t fix the bad in Islam because all religions are used to oppress people especially women and children.
@@She_iswisehe said he is an atheist, having no guidance has no meaning, but yeah, Christian applauding him are kinda embarassing😂 Christian criticizing muslims for misogyny is top tier hypocrisy
It actually made perfect sense. For some reason you keeping ignoring the fact she wouldnt reveal her identity. Hes not going to force her to say who she is or who her husband is. Clearly she is protecting her abuser. By her not revealing her identity doesnt leave the prophet many options. Lastly, who better for a protector than Allah swt?
I lived in an 15lam1c country for four years. I found the treatment of, and attitude to, women and girls to be truly heartbreaking.
As an ex muslim still living in one im disgusted by them too
Whats that country, im curious. Even in Turkey which is mostly secular but the majority are Muslims, treatment of women is not good at all, i mean its good just superficially
@@whatever2206 morocco im not saying all of them but every religious person ik they treat them bad
@@whatever2206 Bangladesh, in the North.
@@mrduck1128 Truly, I don't know how you can bear it. It really destroyed my faith in humanity.
Muslim woman: "My husband is constantly beating me and thus repeatedly disrespecting your direct orders, oh, Prophet!"
Mohammed: "Sending thoughts and prayers."
How cowardly.
Shameful.
😢😡
I would give Muhammad by Middle finger for that response
@GimlinPatter Horrific, truly.
Lol
poor women, i feel so ashamed for them..
@@miovicdina7706 Is this the way a woman say about her husband yes he beat her it's wrong may be there is a provocation and may not be but that man did Lot's of good thing's to you he provided you taken care you and children Helped you when you was ill and you only focus on his short comings or bad deeds he drained his most for you what about that...
You can feel how the imam is saying it, telling the story, with salawat and the way he say it, making it absolutely holy, and magical. This is what Islam does. Wrap up bullshit and sell to muslim as gold and diamonds.
This is the most hallal comment I've ever heard, it deserves thousands of likes.
Yup! So true!
It wraps bullshit ! I like that!
you're describing it so accurately!
So this disprove Islam? 😂
I once had a conversation with a Muslim who accused an ex-muslim of being a wannabe victim and islamphobe. I explained that he had death threats and had to leave his country and what he thought about that. The muslim replied that it is right that ex-muslims are killed because Allah commands it and he cannot go against Allah. My point is that many Muslims just want people to shut up talking about these issues that make Islam look bad rather address the issue. God willing it, is not an answer.
It is sad really, the problem is most Muslim follow hadith written 200 years later rather than the Qur'an alone, I mean the hadith have some very extremist stuff in there whilst the Qur'an teaches the complete opposite
@@amigos2841quaran is pretty bad.
@@maverick7291 not as bad as hadiths though and many verses can be taken out of context
I heard similar from other Muslims. They call people who leave and criticize Islam traitors, and compare them to people who betray their country (like war traitors) who also get the death penalty in some Western countries, so it all makes sense to them.
Not really (out of context). There are many very clear and simple instructions about how to treat non-believers. Remember that the Quran is supposed to be eternal, pre-existing the universe, so the often-used Muslim excuse of "historical context" for example doesn't make any sense. And, there is no indication of that in the text itself (the hadiths can of course give historical context to the revelations, but that just shows that the Quran is a man-made text for the occasion, and that the final revelations (which abrogate the earlier ones) are supposed to be binding for all time (but that again makes little sense if the book is eternal).@@amigos2841
Islam does not allow for Critical thinking. Just take what you see with a pinch of salt.
Grin and bear it?
These Imams have to work with such poor material and struggle so hard to dress it up to make it look good, I almost feel sorry for them. It reminds me of when I gave Khutbahs back in the day. I had to search so long and hard to find anything worthy of including in my talks.
Did Molly pray when someone insulted him 🤔
So u left Islam now?
@@ravinderdhupia4779 Yes
@@ravinderdhupia4779yes he has his own YT channel. Very enlightening
Always wonder how much research new converts do before joining this religion, when the materials are that obviously bad at first glance
This misogynistic tyrant has the most evil influence on the earth 😢
I'm honestly surprised Muhammad's reaction wasn't to just beat her himself
Lmao
Well may be he offered to beat her lightly unlike her husband beating her harshly? Perhaps he asked hubby to use a tooth brush to beat her
I went to jumuah last week and the whole khutbah was about how we shouldn't question allah or momo. He quoted a hadith where a man was sitting in the presence of momo having a meal but eating with his left hand. Momo told him to eat with his his right hand to which the man replied "I can't". Momo then said "May it be that you are never able to eat with your right hand again" and the man went paralyzed in his right hand for the rest of his life. Tried to look for the hadith to no avail but the way people were listening to this dude and absorbing his nonsense khutbah was really telling.
I read this hadith before sunnah.com/riyadussalihin:159
Allah and his co-god:
It is not for a believing man or woman-when Allah and His Messenger decree a matter-to have any other choice in that matter.1 Indeed, whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has clearly gone ˹far˺ astray. Surah 33:36
It is similar to the context of revelation of Surah 4:65 according to Islamic traditions.
@@FriendlyExmuslim Thanks for the link Abdullah it's like Islam is a zombie conditioning program
Hurry it was a miracle Momo done
I was a guest at the home of 'Umar one night, and in the middle of the night he went and hit his wife, and I separated them. When he went to bed he said to me: 'O Ash'ath, learn from me something that I heard from the Messenger of Allah" A man should not be asked why he beats his wife, and do not go to sleep until you have prayed the Witr."' And I forgot the third thing.
Sunan Ibn Majah 1986
Mind you, Imam Omar Suleiman is considered a moderate/liberal imam. So much so that he frequently has interfaith events with other religions. He is called out by Muslims as being tooo liberal. If you people are repulsed at this guy who is a MODERATE Muslim that sugarcoats misogyny, then take a look at the truthful Islamic speakers from the Muslim world who tell it like it is,
Those telling it as it is are the real mull-slims, not the sugar-coated ones 😂
I saw a video years ago of Omar Suleiman with his little daughter (around 2 years old) and the little girl was wearing a hijab, so I don’t think he’s as moderate as he tries to look
@@tanjavankessel8942come on he has to act the part if his daughter doesn’t do it then people will say look at this imam he can’t preach to his own family. ( mind you sickos even forget she is 2 years old girl )
It’s funny, he was happy to give men a solution for everything. From beatings to divorce. But not for women, she got the “I’ll make dua for you sis” 😅
When I was a muslim. I thought Allah was mo's lord and superior. Now it's more like Allah is mo's wingman
that so-called prophet didn't even't trying to find out the root of the problem.
The whole system is rotten! You are right!
Well done for exposing the cult.
Are you sure Mohammed never gave her his shirt to iron.😂😂😂.
This was the piece he gave her for no doubts it was from him:
I asked `Aisha about the clothes soiled with semen. She replied, "I used to wash it off the clothes of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and he would go for the prayer while water spots were still visible. "
حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا يَزِيدُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا عَمْرٌو، عَنْ سُلَيْمَانَ، قَالَ سَمِعْتُ عَائِشَةَ، ح وَحَدَّثَنَا مُسَدَّدٌ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الْوَاحِدِ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا عَمْرُو بْنُ مَيْمُونٍ، عَنْ سُلَيْمَانَ بْنِ يَسَارٍ، قَالَ سَأَلْتُ عَائِشَةَ عَنِ الْمَنِيِّ، يُصِيبُ الثَّوْبَ فَقَالَتْ كُنْتُ أَغْسِلُهُ مِنْ ثَوْبِ رَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم، فَيَخْرُجُ إِلَى الصَّلاَةِ وَأَثَرُ الْغَسْلِ فِي ثَوْبِهِ بُقَعُ الْمَاءِ.
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 230
😮
For serious, if I were the husband, I'd suspect that "being under M's protection" meant, that she were one of his side chicks. Especially after she brought me his clothing!!!
- But I COULD imagine that a public prayer to A. to curse wife beaters by sending them to hell if they don't repent - that might have had some effect, but - o no, they only recite surahs. I hope he did not recite the verse encouraging to beat your wife....
When they tell you Islam will amaze you, they are not wrong
You know a religion's real values by seeing for what it legislates punishment in the real world, and what it relegates for punishment in the afterworld.
Islam has legislation for punishment against stealing, for misappropriating war booty, for insulting prophet and his companions, But for domestic abuse all it has time for is prayers.
I’m a “salesman “ so I meet all kinds of people.
Years ago, the Muslim woman told me if she don’t obey her husband, she will be the fuel in hell. A real threat to the innocent, closed minded woman.
Ah yes assess a religion based on random customers you meet in public 👌
@@theshortangry To be fair the Qur'an literally says men are in charge of women, and should even beat them if they keep disobeying in verse 4:34. So it's not much of a logical inference to get that not obeying your husband is a sin that can inevitably mean go will torture you eternally according to Islamic scripture if you reach some threshold point.
@@James-wc3fc wdym “to be fair” lol? Clearly you don’t know Arabic and took that verse out of context from some Islamophobic subreddit. As Muslims, we know very well that our educated scholars and books of tafsirs have clarified that what is meant here is a light tap (on the arm or such, not on the face), and this is only as a last resort if the woman has gone over the limits and persist in harm in spite of multiple words of advice. Have you not read the report that Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) strictly condemned the beating of women, and would even declare a man a kafir if he persisted in abuse of his wife? If the husband does not fulfil the wife’s rights, then he will be the one punished; why are you bringing up a single part of the contract and making it out to be something it’s not?
a@@theshortangry Lmao I don't think you know Arabic and I certainly didn't get my info from an atheist sub-reddit. And just to be clear you are okay with a husband beating his wife lightly if she keeps disobeying him??
Also can you imagine if the actual method was literally tapping someone that does absolutely nothing and doesn't solve any problem, that is what the all-knowing God commanded really?
You can read scholarly opinions from mainstream orthodox sunni Islam for the last 1400 years who all condone wife-beating explicitly stating the quran and hadith state this, as do many parts of the world today, with Qatar coming out with a video on how to do it, the Taliban quoting scripture and Imams today all over the world supporting it. Are you telling me everyone has read the verse wrong for the last 1000+ years and only now you understand it? Including Al-Tabari, Ibn Kathri, Al-Jalalayn, the best of all?
There is absolutely nothing about doing it lightly in the Quran or on a specific part of the body - which is the supposed perfect word of God. The hadith, which are always a contradictory mess say:
Sahih Muslim Book4 2137 Aisha says 'Yes. He struck me on the chest which caused me pain'.
Sahih Muslim 7:2803 you can beat them, but not severly.
Sunan Abu Dawad 11:2141 has Muhammad giving men including Umar permission to beat their wives.
Sunan Ibn Majad 3:9:1986 A man should not be asked why he beats his wife.
Sahih Bukhari 8:73:68 You should beat your wife like a horse or slave.
@@theshortangry
Why wouldn't it mean beat, an extremely patriarchal religion. I do not see how you cannot go to hell if you have even the very slight tiny bit of feminism in you..
Verse 4:34 says men are in charge of women, because they excel them. And they can deal with disobedience by beating/hitting/striking them. Would you like me to quote you the Hadith that confirm Muhammad folly approved of beating women?.
2:228 says men are above women.
2:222 says for men to stay away from women who are on their period as it is a sickness.
2:282 says the testimony of a woman is worth half of a man's.
4:11 says women get half the inheritance of a man.
2:223 says you make take your wife whenever and however you please (nothing of course is mentioned about the wife's consent)
Qur'an 17:40, 43:15-16 and 37:149-156 actually mocks the idea that God would take a daughter as a partner over sons.
Qur'an 70:29-30 says you can have s*x with your wives and FEMALE SLAVES
4:3 women can only marry one person while man can marry up to four, and have sex with as many female slaves as they desire - and you should take a female slave if you can't deal justly with your wife.
There is absolutely no such thing as sexual assault (zina) in Islamic law against wives or slaves either...
44:51-54, 55:56-58, 78:31-35 Men get light skinned virgins with big breasts in heaven, while women get nothing like that (I assume they just sit there while their husbands f**k them)
60:10 Muslim men can get married to Christians and Jews while Muslim women can only marry Muslim men (2:221)
24:31 Women wear a headscarf while men have no such requirement
64:5 explicitly gives the rules around child marriage 👍 Nice..
It is significantly easier for a husband to divorce his wife than vice versa where the wife has to ask permission and go through a waiting period.
And this is only the Qur'an. Would you like me to quote you the authentic hadith on these verses as well? Mohammad honestly sounds like Borat on women.
She must not have been hot in his eyes because otherwise he would have stolen another wife.
What a shocking story which must be true. The Prophet simply threw the poor woman under the bus, as he did countless other women. Yet present day Muslim women continue to sing his praises.
"Have some zamzam water, you'll be ok." 🕋
😂😂😂😂
What is Sam Sam water
@@nmac913”holy water” that cleanses and cures😂
@@nmac913islamic ”holy water” that cleanses and cures😂 (found in mecca if im not mistaken)
yup, and then he said "A man should not be asked why he beats his wife", so...
I proud of you 👏🏻 Don't stop making videos
Absolutely, they're brilliant. I wish every nominal Muslim or potential 'revert' could watch these videos after listening to all the garbage these Dawah nut jobs and bullies come out with.
Very well done abdullah... Keep it up don't give uo..
Only a barbaric point of view that agree with this kinda abuse.
Modern human will reject this ancient barbaric way of life
Proud ex muslim from israel 🇮🇱
Israel is a country that actually treats women like human beings.
עם ישראל חי ❤
I hope you accept jesus christ.
Well it is probably the only country in the ME to do that. The rest of the ME is unsafe for women
@@AronGirma man worship?
That's idolatry sir, a man who couldn't save himself, you want people to depend on him?
He prayed and his prayers got neglected
@@adeyemostephen1986 Jesus is full God and full man not just man and why he save himself from crucifixion when he was doing it to save us from our sins.check this verses jesus said I AM the alpha and the omega the first and the last the beggining and the end THe Almight.Jesus prayed to his father because he is communicating with him.But your God AL-lah brayed to your cult prophet does that mean your prophet momo is your God?I adivice you to follow the holly jesus the only way to heaven.
Thanks for posting this. And it is not mentioned what that prayer did. The "just pray" or "turn it over to a deity or universe" response by the religious and spiritual as always felt unsatisfying to me (maddening actually) and I now recognize this as an attempt to regulate and deal with the anxiety a person is feeling. Better for you and for others to use tools of psychology as they are not burdened with the constraints of religion.
And as you mention FExM, other alternatives Mohammad could have taken are not mentioned or explored. He can deal harshly with those who anger or insult what he values, or receive messages from a deity to directly intervene in his favor, or prohibit alcohol but he does nothing outside of dua for a woman being hit, after issuing protective statements. It comes off as quite pitiful and Mohammad comes across as a very limited man who is not able to leverage his connection to a deity to help someone, because that connection is fabricated and he has no real power.
I “just prayed” and ended up an atheist. Because instead of blindly following I just did my research and realize I can't defend this be anymore.
@@feenforpink Good work!
Muhammad said: "A man will not be asked about why he beat his wife." {references provided}
Mishkat al-Masabih 3268
Riyad as-Salihin 68
Sunan Ibn Majah 1986
'He took it seriously' but did nothing about it.
Someone coming on a public space to say this in defence of his religion is simply insulting listeners intelligence except they are people like him.
Thank you for this important video ✊️
A guy was drowning, so he lift his arm for me to grab. So i took it so seriously and I hi fived him. 😂
Thank you for making these videos.
In combination with the ruling of a man won't be asked about hitting his wife, This is all a woman is left with.
I can't comprehend how inteligent people believe that Allah would really fly down an Angel from Heaven to whisper in their Fake Prophets ear..."Subjegate or kill all Non-believers wherever you may find them".
And also, Mohammad would fly to all 7 Heavens on a winged Donkey, to negotiate with Allah...how many times a day Muslims should pray to Allah. With a Resurrected Moosa being Mohammad's adviser.
Heaven??? Is it a left turn at Andromeda Galaxy, or right? Let's all hope the James Web telescope spots it. Islamic Scriptures say the flying time between Heaven and Earth is a 1000 years. Ha Ha Ha.
1000% support to all Ex Muslims from 7 billion of us (many Muslims included).
He should have seen the man in person, or made an example of him, and truly protected this lady by giving her a place to stay and allowing divorce if that is what she wanted
And then Marry her too….😅 ….so I I guess she wasn’t that beautiful ..
damn he literally gave thoughts and prayers like that Bojack Horseman clip lol
Now i wanna see the clip 😅
Excellent job Friendly Exmuslim 👍👍👍
Third time prophet took seriously.
But 2 times he tought it was joke
😂😂😂
we are missing an important detail in the discussion, the woman didnt want to reveal her identity, so the prophet SAW couldnt go and confront the man or send someone else to handle the situation.
So basically "you're under my divine protection" doesn't mean jack shit.
Where was Gabriel when we needed him. No ayah was revealed? He took it seriously but Allah didnt?. Did the duaa help? Was it a cursing duaa or was it a guidance. Pffff!
The Mohammed Institute of Conflict Resolution 😂😂
There is no Allah but only Rasulullah
I wonder what he would do if that woman got killed by the husband will he make dua for her lol.
I mean, there is a reason im skeptic of hadiths
Why didn't the "prophet" just tell the woman to show him who she was and then order her to lead him to her husband so that he could order the husband to stop?
This is so pathetic.
This is so islam.
Thank you for the video keep it going to show expose islam
This would have been great opportunity for the Prophet to say no beating women is allowed but he didn't. Why? He forbid so many things in Islam. Why not this?! Was he scared to lose the support of his fellow men or was it that he didn't think it was wrong.. then why pray for the woman. Makes zero sense
He said "thoughts and prayers miss gurl"
I didn't found the hadith or the original story, can someone tell us the source of this story?
He gave some of his DNA with his clothing ..
If the prophet's dua' to Allah against her husband is as good as his dua' to Allah to help him bare a son who will be his heir like Ibrahim before him - this poor lady is screwed!!!
I’m really not convinced that this event ever happened. It sounds invented to me.
Any muslim that cannot invent fabrications is not a muslim😂
Like the Jews morphed into apes and monkey in the Quran.
King Solomon's army of birds, he died standing up without nobody noticing until a worm ate his stick and he feel to the ground.
A sacrificed yellow cow's limb that resurrect a dead man to tell who killed him and he became dead again...
gullible people can believe any BS however obvious it may be.
Audio is a little off in this one. Great video as always though!
Yeah I forgot to plug in my mic! 🤦♂️
Moral of the story : "No matter how many times or how well you polish a turd. It will remain a turd. "
The Hadith clearly shows no one cared about the prophet in that time.
What hadith is it?
I found this hilarious and fucking sad
She was under his protection.
It might be that every women mated or not was lowfull to prophet
It's not the eyes that's blind, its the heart. If you're a muslim than how many imam is in a rakaat
Lmao I love your sarcastic humour in these videos!
Haha thanks
making sarcastic statements
that's like a typical textbook atheist you can find anywhere
@@aiya5777 Lmao what a ridiculous stereotype.. do you honestly not find it appalling he didn't do anything to stop an abused woman? Would you be comfortable with the men in your life doing this?
Do you support slavery and domestic abuse as mentioned in the Qur'an too? Or the value of a woman's testimony being half that of a man in court? These are genuine questions I would love to know.
@@James-wc3fc actually, *women's testimonies* are fundamental for the foundation of islamic teachings
where did the majority hadiths come from? they came from the wives of prophet muhammad, and ofc they're all women, so women's testimonies are a lot more important than you think
@@James-wc3fc ruclips.net/video/lf1wPcF-fXw/видео.html
on 3:48
a neuroscientist says, "eyewitnesses' testimony in the court cases can be *very* unreliable"
now after we're getting a general idea of how very unreliable eyewitnesses' testimony are by default
we have women who are well know for being especially susceptible to emotions,
on top of that they keep getting Nerfed by their Periods every month which of course blur their judgments even more. and things can get even worse for women if they're suffered from dysmenorrhea, which of course blurs their judgments even more
eyewitnesses' testimony in the court cases can be *very* unreliable, and women eyewitnesses' testimony are indeed *very* unreliable
That sheik’s face is pretty weird
Muslim women would be better off going to a Maffia/cartel boss for help.
When those tell you you're under their protection, you can bet your life on it, literally, and people (lest they want to be made an example of) come correct accordingly...
He behave like a gangster wannabe!
Exactly. That was my first thought. Sweaty stinky shirt....
He had all the power in the world to protect the woman given that both the husband and wife are under his jurisdiction.
Yet he does nothing. How responsible and protective of him.
Muhammad's behaviour in this particular narration (I don't know where Omar Suleiman got it from) is reminiscent of what is narrated about Muhammad's behaviour towards the divorced wife of Rifa'a as narrated in Sahih Bukhari 5825 (Another isnaad, this time going back to Ibn Abbas instead of just Ikrimah narrating on the authority of Aisha is mentioned by Al Albani in Irwa Al Ghalil 6/299 and Ibn Taymiyyah in Fatawaa Al Kubra 6/303, though it seems to be a weak isnaad) and also the wives that came around to him to complain about their abusive husbands in Sunan Abu Dawud 2146(Sahih by Al Albani).
I really wonder if oalam made it worse to be a women maybe before islam women had more freedoms
Can someone find the source of this hadith?
Doing a Literature Review of HadithSunnahQuran is actually shredding them.... 🕊️
Isnt it a joke
The same as you can sat divorce three times and you are divorced?
I am confused. Did the guy who was being a domestic abuser get punished??
No
@@FriendlyExmuslim then what is the point exactly?
@@nymgrace1227there is no point , thats the point duh!
@@nymgrace1227 Muhammed can't anything to them man. Muhammed himself legalized beating your wife. By helping the woman, he's brzaking his own rules!
Many of the things you describe happen in most ultra funfamentalist christian churches as well. Their response: repent, repent, submit, obey, and thoughts and prayers. After all it is your fault your husband is abusive. You simply are not doing enough or trying hard enough. You should be grateful he is rebuking you. This seems to be a universal problem.
Abdul is forever lost the People will not see it refuse to see it ✝️❤️❤️❤️🍄🍄🍄
I know little about Islam but from an outside perspective this video seems to be a very disingenuous reading of the piece of islamic text. Sort of approach I would expect from fundamentalists. For example it's obvious what is meant by the piece of garment.
It sounds like a pretty straight forward incident. How would you interpret it
He is the greatest inventor and he should start a religion calls Islam version 2.
The reason why Muhammad didn’t help because actually if you read the full Hadith Muhammad was gonna get him punish but his been told that was one his best fighter that’s why Muhammad was toying with her sending her back and forth
Typical cult leader
Can I get a link to the source?
I think you are using webcam mic or something brother
I pray for the poor women a more important the young girls ive seen it on utube i watch what thay do marrying 9 year old girls to 50 year old man theys are barbaric it brings me to tears thank you for putting this out iam a Christian and we love it just dosent make sense to me how can a man hert hes wife or enyone love concers all godbless ❤️
The Original uncorrupted Koran states that The Prophet of Islam preached that one must be born again and be redeemed by the blood of the Lamb. Allah = All Law! Islam = Is Lamb. Coincedense? I think not! Islamb addresaws the English speaking people to come out.
Hey, not a bad interpretation!!!
what is dua????
Prayer
Why did umar deny the pen to Muhammed please Google this story en make A video
ruclips.net/video/LJQhYeEFKDA/видео.htmlsi=CAPg5pxzOldSVgVY
FR
Muhammad's clothes were always soaked in semen. That was the reason he sent one.
Narrated `Aishah:
I used to wash the semen off the clothes of the Prophet (ﷺ) and even then I used to notice one or more spots on them.
Sahih al-Bukhari 232
⏪ الحمد لله الرحمن الرحيم ⏩
يا رب لك الحمد حتى ترضى ولك الحمد بعد الرضا و لك الحمد دائمًا وأبدًا.
Egyptian Moslem and proud
Such a avoidant response.
@@8_7478
Why
Mashall islam is beautiful
😂
@5:15 nooo, for sure it was his shirt stained with seemen that Aisha scraped with her little fingernails 😅 A guarantee maybe that if he did that again he'd come and take her away and for himself
Just wait till the end..
The story is not end yet..
Maybe the prophet will send his angel to protect
Her..😅
The prophet is a Farmer is planting Potatoes every day unbelievable 😅😅😅😅❤
Source of sunnah?
Wanna debate?
Super
Vid name?
How sweet mo the fool can be funny sometimes
I will beat the day light out of you don’t worry you are under the protection of the prophet no problem ✝️❤️❤️❤️🍄🍄🍄
👌
It is not what you say but the way you are saying it that convince and attract people
This is what islam and scammer do
Misogyny in the Bible
“Women should be silent in the churches. For they are not permitted to speak, but should be subordinate, as the law also says … it is shameful for a woman to speak in church …”); or 1 Timothy 2:11-12 (“Let a woman learn in silence with full submission. I permit no woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she is to keep silent
Actually that section was about women in a synagogue upstairs yelling to their husbands downstairs to ask a question
but true that making one religion bad doesn’t fix the bad in Islam because all religions are used to oppress people especially women and children.
I wouldn’t be surprised if this guy is Atheist. He has no guidance and all these Christians are applauding him 😂
@@She_iswisehe said he is an atheist, having no guidance has no meaning, but yeah, Christian applauding him are kinda embarassing😂
Christian criticizing muslims for misogyny is top tier hypocrisy
@@DarthVaderfr Having no guidance has no meaning to those who have no guidance 🤣 We are guided by Allah (SWT) so we have guidance and it means a lot.
It actually made perfect sense. For some reason you keeping ignoring the fact she wouldnt reveal her identity. Hes not going to force her to say who she is or who her husband is. Clearly she is protecting her abuser. By her not revealing her identity doesnt leave the prophet many options. Lastly, who better for a protector than Allah swt?
In cases like this when there's violence or abuse a therapist would be obligated to take action. In this case the prophet failed her.
How is Allah a protector? The abuse kept happening.
Allah doesnt even exist
Well, Allah failed miserabley, since her husband kept beating her.
What's du'a please?