Fish farms and ranches are necessary, but farming is better because the wild species in our oceans are generally not affected by it and the consumption requirements for humans can still be met without risking extinction of the wild population.
This is not true. Farmed fish have to eat, and most of what they eat is wild fish caught from the oceans. Fish farming has disastrous ripple effects on our oceans.
Sorry if this is a braindead question but: if I’m allergic to soy and the fish are fed soy based things, and I eat one of the fish, am I going to have an allergic reaction to soy?
I am using your youtube video in my presentation to my fisherman community as a reference. Its exciting. We are going to start tuna fillet company in West Papua. If its running then we will make video of it.
Lo vuelan desde Japón a California cuando en Baja California México tiene un criadero idéntico a ese de Japón con la misma calidad ya que los atunes nacen en Japón y migran a México. Lo japoneses nos compran el 85% de la producción, que alguien le avise a ese restaurante 😅
What is in the fishmeal that they feed the tuna? this video is good but it seems to build an extremely positive picture of things, which makes me wonder who the real owner of the video is, everything is perfect, sustainable, right balance... too good to be true..
It says at the end that it's sponsored by Mark Foods & Japanese company Mitsui & Co. I looked up Mark Foods' website and seems like they are a supplier of high-end & MSC certified seafood. They probably supply this farmed fish. I agree it's probably not perfect but at least it's an improvement in the right direction?
@@jeffwang2250 I watched a several documentaries that show that hatcheries are decimatign wild fish populations. the best way to have fish abundance is to change our bad behaviours and allow nature to keep doing what she does best. We keep misbehaving then tryng to reinvent the wheel by trying to 'replicate nature in the lab. we are not clever
I’m a little bit suspicious about these Bluefin being 100% farmed and not ranched from what I have read in the past it would cost way to much money to get a Bluefin to juvenile school size artificially. They also never showed any actual tiny bluefin in the holding tanks something smells fishy here 😂
Fish farming is seen as a solution and I am glad that they are checking soil below the pens. I know that salmon farming in the Nordic countries is causing a lot of pollution due to the concentration of waste below the pens. Finally Japan is doing something good for the world and the environment. Now we need to educate China and Vietnam on better fish farming.
difficult for me to believe that tuna farming/ ranching doesn't maintain any of the same issues that other kinds of fish farming does (parasitism, disease, pollutants to avoid these issues, and pollution to the environment.) It's kind of irresponsible not to touch on any of this, as it's clearly something that affects any kind of fishery that isn't wild. This is going to inform someone's view about fish farming and a lot of the facts are missing.
agreed. i would love if they got into how they deal with parasites... feed sourcing... the farmer did touch upon testing the sea under the tuna to see if their is build up of hydrogen sulfide? but i wish to know more.. like if they medicate their tuna if they get sick... like in salmon farms or if they have parasite issues when they are in a pen like that... feed sourcing also.... doesn't help if we use soy when the soy can go into feeding humans... but i guess with the 1 million dollar price tag for some of these fish it makes sense.. i would love to see an expert compare the farm fish with wild counterparts....
that's a poor outlook. Every country who's population and economy demands the tuna is just as guilty. It's the responsibility of the whole world to fix this problem.
This is absolute nonsense! Nothing about fish farming is "sustainable." To grow the tuna, you have to feed them tons and tons of wild-caught mackerel and other small fish. Where do you think these fish come from? The open ocean of course! The tuna consume many times more weight and calories than they provide to humans - it's a basic biological fact (look up "the 10% law" of biology). On average, it takes FIVE POUNDS of wild fish to raise ONE POUND of farmed fish. Not to mention, the process of catching all those small fish destroys wild ecosystems in the ocean and kills all kinds of other unwanted species. On average, 40% of all ocean fish are unintended catch (called "bycatch"), and are thrown overboard, dead and dying. Don't believe the nonsense claims of this video; all fish farming is DISASTROUS to our oceans.
Would you like to be everything you eat to be like a domesticated cow. Wild fish have a whole other value than farmed fish. The meat of a fish that has lived ten years in the wild has much more information for our body than simple nutrients ( I know this sounds esoteric but I think it's true ). The only solution to fish eating is to eat less fish, but wild fish from sustainable fishing. Farming fish is no solution, same problems as farming everything else, high density stocks, gene selection only for fast growing individuals, waste on the ocean floor, disease, antibiotics, food for the fish comes from the ocean anyway, we almost only eat predatory fish, which need fish for food and on and on. If we go on like this the ocean will look like our farm land and in the end you eat degenerated animals like farmed pigs. Everything only for money. Poor outlook
For fish feeding scientists are developing an insect base feeding meaning we don't have to fish the oceans in order to feed the farmed fish Yes the quality of wild fish is better but it's not sustainable at all By 2049 commercial fish will go extinct Fish farming isn't a choice but a necessity
@@baha3alshamari152 And what will the insects be feeding on, and the rest of the problems ( waste from the high density fish farming, antibiotics etc ) you don't even adress. The only solution is eating less fish and by the way also much less meat, and we can feed everyone easily.
@@franzschafer5079 People will always want more meat in their diet A meatless diet is very disgusting to even imagine besides people are producing enough food for 20 billions people per year We don't have a shortage of food in the world Other than Madagascar and north Korea the only places in the world that suffer famines are war zones Feeding bugs is easy usually just plants and food remains which are wasted by people anyway
@@franzschafer5079 Don't even say it again 🤢🤮🤮🤮 Veggies taste like a disgusting old bitter smelly yucky sucks Can't imagine life without steaks or chicken
I tried tuna steak at home once, it didn’t taste like tuna out of a can or anything else. It wasn’t a big deal. I’m not sure what tuna that isn’t in a can is supposed to taste like.
Wow now they are feeding unnatural foods pellets to the tuna just like they do with farmed salmon, chicken and cows. Farmed fish is never going to be the same as wild caught ones. Grass fed chicken and cows are never going to be the same as grain fed ones. On another note, you did not eat a fatty tuna. You clearly don't know much about tuna.
Compare the taste of a farm-raised catfish and one caught out of the Colorado River. The *real* Colorado, not the one running through that gully in AZ. I'll take river-caught over fake catfish any day.
This is such a well made video. I can't believe it only has 5k views.
47k now. June 2021
68k March 2022
1.3b now. December 2048
80k now in 2024
This should be lower in Mercury than wild caught tuna as they are only eating mackerel, which is pretty low in the food chain. Nom nom nom!
Mackerel contain a fair bit of mercury
This was awesome!! Never knew tuna could be farm raised!
same. i thought they couldn't do it properly?
Almost everything could be done nowadays
Just watched a video saying bluefin tuna couldn't be farmed, ended up here
10:19 idk, looking from the red color there. The part that you ate, was not fatty at all. The fatty part will be more pink.
I just feel that she doesn't really know about shashimi, tuna fat or even the lean meat
the part she ate was akami, which is lean. If you want to eat fattier tuna, it will be chyu-toro or oo-toro
“It’s so fatty, so lean at the same time” lol
Totally worth it, at least they're not leading to the extinction of a whole species
Fish farms and ranches are necessary, but farming is better because the wild species in our oceans are generally not affected by it and the consumption requirements for humans can still be met without risking extinction of the wild population.
This is not true. Farmed fish have to eat, and most of what they eat is wild fish caught from the oceans. Fish farming has disastrous ripple effects on our oceans.
That's not entirely true, antibiotic runoffs can be an issue
The deep red color of the fish is the actually the cheap cut akami. I prefer the fattier pink cut called toro and chu toro
Sorry if this is a braindead question but: if I’m allergic to soy and the fish are fed soy based things, and I eat one of the fish, am I going to have an allergic reaction to soy?
No
they freeze tuna before retailing. dat makes Japanese tuna free from parasitic eggs.
She ate the lean part of the tuna. The fatty party is pink with visible layers of fat.
They've been trying to do this in Australia for 10 years and failing because they do it inside instead of in open water
How do they source the little fish that they feed to the tuna?
Commercial Net fishing
I am using your youtube video in my presentation to my fisherman community as a reference.
Its exciting.
We are going to start tuna fillet company in West Papua.
If its running then we will make video of it.
where are you from??
@@sadatate976 I am from Biak, West Papua.
10:35 I can tell you didn’t like that
Lo vuelan desde Japón a California cuando en Baja California México tiene un criadero idéntico a ese de Japón con la misma calidad ya que los atunes nacen en Japón y migran a México.
Lo japoneses nos compran el 85% de la producción, que alguien le avise a ese restaurante 😅
Great video from A to Z
What is in the fishmeal that they feed the tuna? this video is good but it seems to build an extremely positive picture of things, which makes me wonder who the real owner of the video is, everything is perfect, sustainable, right balance... too good to be true..
It says at the end that it's sponsored by Mark Foods & Japanese company Mitsui & Co. I looked up Mark Foods' website and seems like they are a supplier of high-end & MSC certified seafood. They probably supply this farmed fish. I agree it's probably not perfect but at least it's an improvement in the right direction?
@@jeffwang2250 I watched a several documentaries that show that hatcheries are decimatign wild fish populations. the best way to have fish abundance is to change our bad behaviours and allow nature to keep doing what she does best. We keep misbehaving then tryng to reinvent the wheel by trying to 'replicate nature in the lab. we are not clever
Thats good tell them......no more tuna don't cry
Let's gooooo!
7:07 and very importantly, less mercury!!!
I love video's like these
I’m a little bit suspicious about these Bluefin being 100% farmed and not ranched from what I have read in the past it would cost way to much money to get a Bluefin to juvenile school size artificially. They also never showed any actual tiny bluefin in the holding tanks something smells fishy here 😂
Solutions!
Fish farming is seen as a solution and I am glad that they are checking soil below the pens. I know that salmon farming in the Nordic countries is causing a lot of pollution due to the concentration of waste below the pens. Finally Japan is doing something good for the world and the environment. Now we need to educate China and Vietnam on better fish farming.
Finally Japan is doing something good????
Very informative , but Tuna called as Bugadi in our local language in India has a different way to be consumed unlike the Sushi way.
So?
difficult for me to believe that tuna farming/ ranching doesn't maintain any of the same issues that other kinds of fish farming does (parasitism, disease, pollutants to avoid these issues, and pollution to the environment.) It's kind of irresponsible not to touch on any of this, as it's clearly something that affects any kind of fishery that isn't wild. This is going to inform someone's view about fish farming and a lot of the facts are missing.
agreed. i would love if they got into how they deal with parasites... feed sourcing... the farmer did touch upon testing the sea under the tuna to see if their is build up of hydrogen sulfide? but i wish to know more.. like if they medicate their tuna if they get sick... like in salmon farms or if they have parasite issues when they are in a pen like that... feed sourcing also.... doesn't help if we use soy when the soy can go into feeding humans... but i guess with the 1 million dollar price tag for some of these fish it makes sense.. i would love to see an expert compare the farm fish with wild counterparts....
Bluefin do not eat jellyfish and octopus.
Japanese caused the tuna shortage problem.
It's their responsibility to fix it.
that's a poor outlook. Every country who's population and economy demands the tuna is just as guilty. It's the responsibility of the whole world to fix this problem.
@@stevenju6115 Dude you sound like a Democrat. Wake up.
By "we" you should have said Japanese
Was she eating those big chunks of it raw‽??
Can bluefin tuna live in fresh water?
Ofc not
Na.
Set them free!
This guy perfectly speaks like anime characters
🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤
It tastes raw bruv
This is absolute nonsense! Nothing about fish farming is "sustainable." To grow the tuna, you have to feed them tons and tons of wild-caught mackerel and other small fish. Where do you think these fish come from? The open ocean of course! The tuna consume many times more weight and calories than they provide to humans - it's a basic biological fact (look up "the 10% law" of biology). On average, it takes FIVE POUNDS of wild fish to raise ONE POUND of farmed fish. Not to mention, the process of catching all those small fish destroys wild ecosystems in the ocean and kills all kinds of other unwanted species. On average, 40% of all ocean fish are unintended catch (called "bycatch"), and are thrown overboard, dead and dying. Don't believe the nonsense claims of this video; all fish farming is DISASTROUS to our oceans.
Would you like to be everything you eat to be like a domesticated cow. Wild fish have a whole other value than farmed fish. The meat of a fish that has lived ten years in the wild has much more information for our body than simple nutrients ( I know this sounds esoteric but I think it's true ). The only solution to fish eating is to eat less fish, but wild fish from sustainable fishing.
Farming fish is no solution, same problems as farming everything else, high density stocks, gene selection only for fast growing individuals, waste on the ocean floor, disease, antibiotics, food for the fish comes from the ocean anyway, we almost only eat predatory fish, which need fish for food and on and on.
If we go on like this the ocean will look like our farm land and in the end you eat degenerated animals like farmed pigs. Everything only for money. Poor outlook
For fish feeding scientists are developing an insect base feeding meaning we don't have to fish the oceans in order to feed the farmed fish
Yes the quality of wild fish is better but it's not sustainable at all
By 2049 commercial fish will go extinct
Fish farming isn't a choice but a necessity
@@baha3alshamari152 And what will the insects be feeding on, and the rest of the problems ( waste from the high density fish farming, antibiotics etc ) you don't even adress.
The only solution is eating less fish and by the way also much less meat, and we can feed everyone easily.
@@franzschafer5079
People will always want more meat in their diet
A meatless diet is very disgusting to even imagine besides people are producing enough food for 20 billions people per year
We don't have a shortage of food in the world
Other than Madagascar and north Korea the only places in the world that suffer famines are war zones
Feeding bugs is easy usually just plants and food remains which are wasted by people anyway
@@baha3alshamari152 You just don't seem to want to see the problems. Maybe you should try some good vegetarian dishes once:-)
@@franzschafer5079
Don't even say it again 🤢🤮🤮🤮
Veggies taste like a disgusting old bitter smelly yucky sucks
Can't imagine life without steaks or chicken
I tried tuna steak at home once, it didn’t taste like tuna out of a can or anything else. It wasn’t a big deal.
I’m not sure what tuna that isn’t in a can is supposed to taste like.
videos like this create absolutely deplorable seafood consumers that only accelerate the decline and waste of oceanborn proteins.
Alhamdulillah 😃
praise the lord
You are so beautiful
beautiful girl and a very nice video
0:27 eat tuna raw? that called sushi? wth
it's sashimi
Miyuki hoshigawa wtf man
its our tradition. we can eat it raw because its fresher than any other country
@@ryuyanaka271 People eat tuna raw all around the world... Nothing to do about Japan having it "fresher than any other country"
Please cut out the crappy music.
Bullshit!
Wow now they are feeding unnatural foods pellets to the tuna just like they do with farmed salmon, chicken and cows.
Farmed fish is never going to be the same as wild caught ones. Grass fed chicken and cows are never going to be the same as grain fed ones. On another note, you did not eat a fatty tuna. You clearly don't know much about tuna.
MapleMeHoney I mean the wild tuna are practically extinct so this is better in every way.
Compare the taste of a farm-raised catfish and one caught out of the Colorado River. The *real* Colorado, not the one running through that gully in AZ. I'll take river-caught over fake catfish any day.
sorry your refined sensibilities are offended. perhaps you'd prefer we catch wild tuna to extinction instead, my liege?
She is beautiful...
Sustainable and environmental? Such BS. Just don't eat fish if you care about the environment so much.
Yes eat jellyfish instead
@@widodoakrom3938 and/or lion fish
@@catscratchfever7540what about my girlfriend's fish?
Thanks so much for making this video! 🤍