ABNORMALITY DANCIN' GIRL(アブノーマリティ・ダンシンガール) - what's the song about??

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 янв 2025

Комментарии • 115

  • @riverthecrybaby9448
    @riverthecrybaby9448 11 месяцев назад +180

    Guchiri recently announced in a tweet in his private account (which i am oh so honored to follow as he no longer allows new followers) that mene never committed s*icide and is still alive. specifically he said something along the lines of
    "I was rereading comments on abdan and kept seeing people say mene is dead. how come?
    Theres no way shes gonna die. On the contrary, how could she die from that situation?
    However, its everyones personal opinions, so i don't mind ignoring it."

    • @ktostam35
      @ktostam35 11 месяцев назад +16

      Thank you people see shoes and chairs and immediately think suicide and it's concerning at this point

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  11 месяцев назад +39

      oh! i didny follow his private account so i didn’t know, this is my interpretation because of the hints related to suicide i mentioned in the video, thank u for telling me!! im glad he is very open on how people interpret his song~

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  11 месяцев назад +30

      the whole point of my videos are to try to interpret things from little hints here & there, from the MV and lyrics, shoes and chairs are in fact used a lot as a symbolism for suicide and even tho the producer himself clarified that it is not suicide(which i didnt know when making this video), i dont think it is “concerning” to interpret it this way…
      to me personally, and i have always say it repeatedly, everyone is free to interpret a song the way they want to, if you think it is unrelated than you are also free to think that way without belittling other people’s interpretations :(

    • @xanh-00
      @xanh-00 11 месяцев назад +21

      I actually have a theory. If Mene atually didn't commit, and Miya, or some1, saved her, then the flowers on the table might resembles her thought of "You're too good, I should've received something like that instead", as in the possibility that she still thinks lowly of herself.

    • @ifreakingIovecats
      @ifreakingIovecats 5 месяцев назад +8

      i always assumed the flowers marked the death of her “ordinary” self, and the new her has been born

  • @CoriandertheIridescent
    @CoriandertheIridescent 11 месяцев назад +43

    First off, amazing analysis! Second off, this song feels like the opposite to PinnocioP's reincarnation apple, where in Reincarnation Apple, the singer starts with her reincarnation and throws away the idea of reincarnation, whereas Mene hyperfocuses on the thought of reincarnation and lets it eat away at herself.

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  11 месяцев назад +4

      omg maybe i should analyze reincarnation apple👀

  • @requiemthethethe
    @requiemthethethe Год назад +99

    I don't know if this was mentioned or if anyone has mentioned this but in the MV when Mene talks about becoming a butterfly the text around her kind of look like wings. (especially near the end when she's her "butterfly self")
    example timestamps:
    4:37
    14:36

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +13

      omg... thats a cool observation!! i didnt notice it!!

  • @uhh...nasturtiium
    @uhh...nasturtiium 5 месяцев назад +13

    UNEXPLAINED SCENES: (Still good interpretation!)
    12:00 To Mene, Miya is perfect. And, she wants to intimate her, because, she's a full, transformed butterfly (AKA someone who became "bad and old" to "perfect and new.") Mene is willing to go as far as dissecting her so she too, can be a butterfly. (Which is definitely a sign of obsessive "love.")
    13:45 As Mene just breaks, she starts becoming delusional, and this can be called DPD (disassociative personality disorder.) Basically is just 2 or more distinct personalities. After accepting the "truth" that she's "ugly, normal and untransformed" she can't handle the pain anymore so she cracks. She copes by filling herself with lies that she's "perfect" just like Miya although her definition of perfect was supposed to be "extroverted and good student."
    When you numb out for so long with flickering feelings, you start to confuse yourself and this looks to suicidal thinking. It's unbearable so they take the easy way out.
    15:10
    With all these negative feelings, you can physically get sick, a fact as someone who does herbs for fun, and known by general people. Mene starts displaying a scene of schizophrenia (hallucination disorder) by saying shut up. If you sleep too little or long, you may start to have hallucinations, leading to worse physical health. With all this bad physical health, everyone else's voices are 10x worse. In her diary, it's revealed she hates everyone because they're untransformed butterflies like herself, leave flowers (telling her to die already) and rumors.
    15:57 Apparently, Mene will be freed once she becomes a butterfly, which she "transforms" at the end though (again) she didn't get good grades. It's another lie she tells herself, and being a butterfly, "perfect and renewed" you may notice is not free. Even Mene's outfit has threads at her legs. Being a "good" student like Miya requires a lot of studying, and pressure.
    16:10 It changes to normal Mene right after her being a butterfly. This is another sign she's delusional. And, at the very end, she flies. Not in the way you think, if being a butterfly is rebirth, to rebirth, you have to die first.
    In scenes, 2:34 foreshadows she's going to commit suicide. In Japan, chairs surrounding you signifies death. Shoes as well appear, another sign of suicide. And thus, she rebirths, and (probably) jumps off something, like a butterfly, and flies up to the heavens.

  • @waterkib
    @waterkib Год назад +99

    FINALLYYY!!!! GUCHIRY SONG IS HEREEE!!! RAAAHHHHHH🎉🎉🎉🎉

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +6

      YYEAAA!!! HOPE YOU'LL LIKE IT!!!!

    • @waterkib
      @waterkib Год назад +2

      @@udinchwan I LOVE IT, PLEASE DO MORE GUCHIRY SONG!!

  • @chiuuuu
    @chiuuuu Год назад +109

    YESSSS I LOVE THIS SONGGGGG
    Also also I have some theories ^^
    From my interpretation, the diary entries at 14:34 may also be talking about Miya rather than Mene’s “butterfly” self. When it says “how happy I would be if I could become a butterfly like you” may be talking about how Mene sees Miya as a fully developed butterfly, she’s reached her final form and is beautiful and perfect in any way; and Mene wants this, she also wants to be a butterfly like Miya.
    Also, in 16:37, I feel that this is when she commits, rather than having actually become a butterfly. During the last scene on the stage, we see normal Mene having a meltdown (as said in the vid) and this may be because she realised that this was all a dream; and she may have realised that in order to achieve her finally form, she’ll have to be reborn, she’ll have to die, which is why she believes she has become a butterfly in the final diary entry. I feel like that’s how her story ends. Also, this ending may have been foreshadowed by the flower vase on her desk, rather than a form of bullying.
    These r just my interpretations ^^

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +14

      aaaa i agree sm!! sorry if i'm not clear enough at explaining but the meltdown after knowing it was one of her 'strange dreams' was what i was trying to say!! also the rebirth i've been mentioning about also means that in order to reach her final form, she needs to basically rebirth/restart her life by d wording(。>﹏

    • @chiuuuu
      @chiuuuu Год назад +5

      @@udinchwan ahhh sorry for misunderstandinggg 🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️
      ya we have the same ideas!! And ohhhh I forgot about that diary entry, in that case the bullying makes sense 😮

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +5

      @@chiuuuuno no its okay!! i did sometimes talk in a roundabout way so😭😭 yeayea!! but again its just implied i think, maybe i was reaching too lol but thats the fun part bcs we can guess things up🤔🤔

    • @chiuuuu
      @chiuuuu Год назад +1

      @@udinchwan yepyep that’s what makes it fun 🤩🤩

  • @ktostam35
    @ktostam35 11 месяцев назад +29

    Didn't guchiry say Mene didn't kill herself?
    Anyways here's my interpretation:
    Mene is being bullied (most likely due to homophobia) and people will say "but the flowers aren't white like they'd be with bullying in Japan so maybe they actually symbolise she's dead" but, notice how her and Miya's uniforms have diffrent colours, I think the color of the flowers is just supposed to show it's for her.
    Now Mene is being bullied and her bullies probably use her grades as an excuse. Mene realises she's being manipulated by them and wants to change that, so she wants to become abnormal through imitating Miya, whom she idolises. Mene starts getting better and better grades and becoming more "abnormal" thanks to that her classmates notice her and she loves all the love and attention (I think so bc in the first chorus you can see the chairs surrounding her are facing her). Than her grades start to slip again, she gets closer with Miya and starts trying too hard to be abnormal so everyone turns away from her (shoes in second chorus aren't facing her). Than she finally gets an identity crisis, she doesn't know who she is - is she old Mene or new Mene, or are they the same? She realises it's driving her crazy but she wants attention and love. So she starts s3xualizing herself (her final outfit). Now if we look at her dairy, we can see she says that she "disappeared" but there are still more entries. ("Look at me" repeated a few times). So to me, she made the old Mene die(hence the su!cide looking like metaphors) but she doesn't realise bullies won't stop bullying her just because of that, and she wants people to look at her. She says she saw a butterfly and became one, and I think she finally started becoming like Miya (symbolised by her pigtails looking like Miya's). Perhaps she was also neglected at home which is why she wanted attention so badly and didn't get help with bullying. She also doesn't seem to want to accept that through changing herself she's doing what ithers want her to fo aka. Manipulating her

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  11 месяцев назад +7

      i didnt follow guchiry’s private twitter so i didnt know, but this interpretation is interesting!! so the suicide metaphors are more like her old self right? not literally her life…i didn’t think of that, thank you for telling me!!

    • @ktostam35
      @ktostam35 11 месяцев назад

      @@udinchwan oh I don't follow either I just saw someone say that- and no problem I myself only thought of that because actual su!cide interpretation made me uncomfortable, I do agree with her being depressed tho

    • @3MB3Rx134
      @3MB3Rx134 3 месяца назад

      I kinda thought all the allusions to death and suicide where representative of an ego death, or how her “old self is dead”, or something similar

    • @ktostam35
      @ktostam35 3 месяца назад +1

      @@3MB3Rx134 yup I think so too

  • @charieots
    @charieots Год назад +24

    I LOVE THIS AND I AM SO GLAD I RECOMMENDED IT😭 i already went really deep into the lore but this just opened more and more possibilities for my imagination to run wild, genuinely i found out new things i didnt know about this song and i am SO into the lore and i love it so much and how its so relatable, thank you so much for this udin!

    • @charieots
      @charieots Год назад +1

      and you should do i nandesu next! I havent even translated the lyrics yet even tho it being one of my favourite songs, and i want a white canvas to fully enjoy ur analysis and video💯💯

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      YEAAYY thank you for requesting it on the prev video!! im glad u like it!!

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      oh..i love that song!! i'll try to look into it later ;)

  • @ramblingngergre
    @ramblingngergre Год назад +8

    I am so happy this dropped, I was listening to the song a bit before I saw you uploaded this lol
    Amazing analysis, as always. Love your stuff :)
    Just want to add that butterflies can also symbolise death. So at the end, her saying she "became a butterfly" could mean that the only way to get what she wants is to be reborn. As in, commit s and be reborn as someone who can achieve and be what she desires, or be a perfect being in the afterlife.
    That's my interpretation of it at least.

  • @roryroorah
    @roryroorah Год назад +37

    I have a theory that the main cause of the bullying is homophobia due to Mene's classmates realizing how 'close' she is to Miya compared to the rest of them. The reason why Miya is never picked on is because she either started it and is using Mene and stringing her along (which Mene thinks is NOT happening) or because she never noticed Mene's attraction, she was exempt from the bullies. Might not hold up though.

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  11 месяцев назад

      interesting theory!! i can see how homophobia plays a huge role into this :(

  • @KoekoReaps
    @KoekoReaps Год назад +13

    Dont be sorry for long videos, i actually like it cuz it gave more details and explanation

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +2

      aaaa thank you so much!! this really helps me to be at ease since i kept thinking people don't like it if it's too long૮(˶╥︿╥)ა

  • @ramziamar7.2
    @ramziamar7.2 5 месяцев назад +1

    Idk if people already know but at 4:29 the words are in the shape of a Pupa/Cocoon and then at the next lyrics (when the colors get saturated) its shaped as a butterfly wing around Menu which makes your statement of who Mene wants to be (as a butterfly in her true self?) pretty true.

  • @ValeraMoth
    @ValeraMoth 2 месяца назад +2

    Dear Lämp this video was like being splashed with a bucket of ice cold water

  • @_choco.chibi_481
    @_choco.chibi_481 Год назад +3

    Finally being able to keep up to the song’s analysis to the ones I wasn’t able to watch yet. Always like to come to your account for this series when there is nothing to watch on tv

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      yay yayy!! omg not the tv😭😭 hsdhsdh what if the family is listening?? (nervous)

    • @_choco.chibi_481
      @_choco.chibi_481 Год назад +1

      @@udinchwan oh no no I meant to say that whenever I don’t find something good on tv then I go to my phone and watch your videos 👍🏼

  • @ruikasasfixer
    @ruikasasfixer Год назад +25

    I love Abnormality Dancin’ Girl and this analysis is so interesting and awesome to listen to! Can you do Orthodoxia by Guchiry next? (If u want) new sub btw : D

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +4

      im glad you enjoy it!! i do plan to do other guchiry songs i’ll look into it soon!!^^ and thank you sm!!

  • @another-niko-pfp-holder
    @another-niko-pfp-holder 10 месяцев назад +2

    came here for the song analysis, left with my japanese grammar knowledge expanded by 1%

  • @신류진-z6x
    @신류진-z6x Год назад +3

    THANK U FOR THIS OMG I LOVE YOU

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      YAYY HOPE U ENJOY ITTT

  • @sillybillysill
    @sillybillysill Год назад +1

    I already loved this song so much but this made it even better oh mu god im crying😭

  • @SharoHeart
    @SharoHeart Год назад +11

    I love this so much!! Guchiry's songs are so interesting to me with how they depict different topics and have their own stories and characters. The way you narrate/describe things is also really fun to listen to and easy to understand!! i loved watching this. I was wondering if you could talk about Schadenfreude by guchiry as well? :D

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      thank you so much!! im glad u like it!! i'll definitely put Schadenfreude on my list ;)

    • @casuals.3.19
      @casuals.3.19 Год назад

      I also noticed something at the beginning during that section where it changes from butterfly to portrait she is depicted as a commonly or “average” butterfly while the Miya is seen as a Morpho Menelaus a very beautiful bright and one of the most beautiful butterflies in the world.

  • @shinydecidueye9593
    @shinydecidueye9593 Год назад +3

    My favorite song getting an analysis video? Fuck yeah

  • @d1avolicstrik3
    @d1avolicstrik3 Год назад +12

    I love your videos and how good your explanations are :D
    I was wondering if you could do "Shinjuku Jack" by Abuse with Hatsune Miku?

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      thank you so much!! ohh ok ill try to look into it later!!👀

  • @janischef2576
    @janischef2576 Год назад +2

    Thank u very much for your work, i really appreciate that. Every your video is so interesting cool and you are showing every time the side of the song that i could find. Thank u , continue your work, it makes a lot of people happy

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      omg...thank you to you also!! im glad you find these things i do interesting i hope i can continue to deliver them as always!!!

    • @janischef2576
      @janischef2576 Год назад

      @@udinchwan thank you! Keep saying quenn!!!!🥳🥳🥳🥳

  • @Mochaandmochie
    @Mochaandmochie 11 месяцев назад +3

    GRAH NO WONDER WHY I KIN THIS SONG

  • @jiraikeii
    @jiraikeii Год назад +4

    YESSSS A GUCHIRY SONG,IM SO HAPPY‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️

  • @sakuraaaxx
    @sakuraaaxx Год назад +3

    this song is kinda a banger (only some of the parts where they sing) but can you do Engeki/Theatre next??? the song that was added to project sekai a few months ago??

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      ohh the niigo song right?? i'll try to look into it later ;D

  • @ChubbyBxnny
    @ChubbyBxnny 3 месяца назад

    loved this video!! new sub!!!

  • @KleeBoom9
    @KleeBoom9 7 месяцев назад +1

    I also relate to her and that's worrying

    • @Suprisename
      @Suprisename 6 месяцев назад +1

      Yeah I relate way to much, I am insane, I hear voices, i hate myself, I cut myself regularly and have gotten seconds away from commiting suicide

  • @axl256gamesx7
    @axl256gamesx7 10 месяцев назад +1

    Dance, oh brand new me!

  • @thatdrroleplayer209
    @thatdrroleplayer209 Год назад +2

    WHFBKDBCD INE OF MY FAV SONGSSSS!!!!!!!
    AND can you do Loveit? And Love eat both by bizxZERA. Both songs are related to each other i think

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      ohhh!! i'll try to look into it later ;D

  • @ayayumiko7768
    @ayayumiko7768 Год назад +2

    Hi! This is my first time commenting here and i really love your content
    If it's fine can i ask if you can make an analysis of i nandesu ? Since the lyrics are kind of confusing and i didn't get the mountin of hubris lyric
    Thank you ^^

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      ahh i really want to do more vids for pjsk commissioned songs but im still reading niigo’s stories rn so i will make them once i finished so i can connect them to the story better!! :D

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      also thank you so much!! im glad u enjoyed them!! :D

  • @Xi_lii
    @Xi_lii Год назад +3

    LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @ItsPanPanIg
    @ItsPanPanIg Год назад +1

    I’ve been watching your videos recently and their very enjoyable and underrated!! ^^ I was wondering if you can make an analysis video for Hensyoku, it’s a very beautiful sounding one, and something that I feel has lots of things to uncover!

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      waaa tysm!! im glad you like them!! i'll try to look into it later ;D

  • @hgjhdsgjgkjkhhh
    @hgjhdsgjgkjkhhh Год назад +3

    this song is literally meee hghdhs also i was wondering if you could do non-breath oblige? cause it feels like its talking about something really important and i think a lot of people would find they actually relate to it..

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      its already on my list!! ill do it one day :D

  • @TapeFanatic
    @TapeFanatic 6 месяцев назад

    11:58 Not trying to be rude about this or anything, but Mene is trying to pin Miya to the display like all of the other butterflies, rather than dissect her 😁

  • @9KingP
    @9KingP Год назад +1

    another banger from udin and another song to my playlist 🗣️🔥💯
    also can you cover imperial girl next? it sounds really deep for some reason, or the wording is alot more than it seems. kinda interesting song

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      tysm!! >< ohh!! i'll try to look into it later :D

    • @9KingP
      @9KingP Год назад

      @@udinchwan thanks and take ur time !

  • @schizokoi
    @schizokoi Год назад +4

    YESS A GUCHIRY SONG‼️‼️

  • @XxViolet_DevilxX
    @XxViolet_DevilxX 9 месяцев назад

    i did not know this song was about Depression now i understand it more :)

  • @axl256gamesx7
    @axl256gamesx7 10 месяцев назад +2

    Wdym 65 is below average
    From 0 to 10 you need 5 to pass, and any education system that doesn't do that is just... a complete failure itself

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  9 месяцев назад +1

      in most asian countries it’s different, in my country the average to pass is 75/100 in korea is even higher i think, i dont know much about japan tho🥲

    • @axl256gamesx7
      @axl256gamesx7 9 месяцев назад

      @@udinchwan well then, that mean their education system is a complete failure
      Just look at the s#1cid3 rates among high school students in japan

  • @mywintermochi
    @mywintermochi Год назад +2

    yay!!!

  • @Hyopsodus
    @Hyopsodus Год назад +1

    will you do non breath oblige soon? I love that song!

  • @kamicc5932
    @kamicc5932 Год назад +1

    THIS IS A BANGER!!! When you're gonna do a tale of six trillion years and a story??

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      its been on my list for so long, ill do it one day definitely😭

  • @momoirokeys
    @momoirokeys Год назад +1

    ABNORMALITY DANCING GIRL YAYYYYYY

  • @starpeep5769
    @starpeep5769 Год назад +2

    UDIN UR SO COOL AND FRUCTOSETOLERAFRUCTOSETOLERANT PJSK YAS

  • @tsuki0612
    @tsuki0612 Год назад +1

    im sorry if this is off-topic but could you analyze akuma no odorikata?

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      i'll try to look into it later!! :D

    • @tsuki0612
      @tsuki0612 Год назад

      @@udinchwan thank you!!

  • @Flowery0
    @Flowery0 2 месяца назад

    11:36 not cloudy

  • @mywintermochi
    @mywintermochi Год назад +2

    can you do other guchiry songs?

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад

      hmmm which song do you suggest?? :D

    • @vioveela
      @vioveela Год назад

      @@udinchwanI’m not the commenter but I would love to hear you talk about the song called Orthodoxia by Guichiry!

  • @keltacular
    @keltacular Год назад +1

    WOOOO

  • @soda_fox186
    @soda_fox186 Год назад +1

    9:39 WHY DOES THE BLUE HAIRED PERSON LOOK LIKE TOYA FROM PJSEKAI

  • @mikomappjayajaya
    @mikomappjayajaya Год назад +1

    YAYYYY

  • @mozaikc
    @mozaikc Год назад +1

    I LOVE ABNORMALITY DANCING GIRL YAY THANK U :DDDD

    • @udinchwan
      @udinchwan  Год назад +1

      me too!!!! hope you like the analysis!! >

  • @missymiseryguts
    @missymiseryguts Год назад

    GUCHIRY GUCHRIYT I LLOOVVEEE I LOVE I LOVE EEEHHHHHSBSHAHAGAA

  • @Chrollolvciferz
    @Chrollolvciferz Год назад +1

    🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉