Pakistani curriculum: Sir syed gave idea of two nation theory Allama Iqbal proposed a land for Muslims Rehmat Ali gave name of Pakistan 1948 Quaid e Azam made Pakistan 😂😂 bas itna hi btatay hain ❤
🕊I’m based in Karachi and it will be an honour to work as your assistant...voluntarily. Can devote quality time to help you Sir. It was painful to know that DR. Mubarak Ali’s contributions have still not received due recognition...All respect to truly inspiring Dr Mubarak. Ali.
I am sindhi speaking and I truly appreciate of Dr Mubarak Ali who share real information about history He is legend and I think he seen a lot of difficulties 😔 in life
It's Not only the person Who is Delivering the Knowledge But the Impact Of that Person Who is asking These Questions Deliberately To acquire the Finest Knowledge. Thank Both Of You❤
i am sorry for my commemnt but now i cant tolerate any foriegn language or fake history in sindh ......................................... we sindhi want our language as a national langauge..............india have 25 national languages so why we dont have 5 national languages?????????????
مبارک علی صاحب کو فوری طور پر ایک ٹرسٹ قائم کرنا چاہیے اور اپنی تمام کتابوں کو اس ٹرسٹ کے حوالے کرنا چاہیے تاکہ ان کتابوں کو صحیح طور پر شائع کیا جا سکے اور مبارک صاحب کی اشک شوئی بھی ہو سکے۔
ماشااللہ! بہت ہی معلوماتی پروگرام تھا۔ نہایت ہی عمدہ شخصیت اور بہت ہی اچھے سوالات تھے۔ دو گزارشات تھی۔ اول یہ کہ ہم جیسے طالبہ کے ذہن میں بھی بہت سے سوالات ہوتے ہیں، تو برائے کرم کوئی ایسا پروگرام بھی شروع کریں جس میں ہم براہ راست اپنے سوالات پوچھ سکیں۔ کیوں کے اس چینل کے سوا ہمارے علمی تجسس کو اور پیاس کو کوئی اور پورا نہیں کرتا۔ دوئم یہ کے اگر کوئی بااقتعدار شخص اس پروگرام کو دیکھ رہا ہے اور میرے اس کمنٹ کو پڑھ رہا ہے تو خدا رہ ڈاکٹر صاحب سے تعاون کریں یہ آپ کا پوری پاکستان قوم پر احسان ہوگا۔ جزاک اللہ
Amazing! This man refers to Shyam Benegal, Chander Mohan, Roti film (old), art films, Satyajit Ray, Bimal Roy's Do Bigha Zameen, etc. as part of people's history. Great man!
بہت اچھے انداز میں فیصل صاحب نے ڈاکٹر صاحب کا انٹرویو کیا ہے۔ صبر اور تحمل سے زیادہ سے زیادہ وقت بولنے کے لیے اپنے مہمان کو دینا کسی میزبان کے لیے آسان نہیں ہوتا۔ زبردست فیصل صاحب۔ اور آداب اور دعائیں ڈاکٹر صاحب کے لیے۔
I totally agree with you but what about the lie's we've been teaching to our nation from 1947⁉️ The history will destroy your identity, if you destroy your history🤔
Lol. Then all historians need to come and tell their version and then awam will decide what's truth and what's not... no need to pick and choose stuff which suit certain narratives only. Two nation theory continues to comeback to prove its worth.. we have seen everything in last few decades the realities (what's happening in Hindustan and their ground realities make everything clear)
@@arpittiwari7605 Lol , that's because of terrorism promoted by ur state , indian muslims can't anything openly which seem even slightly anti state otherwise we all know the situation. We all know what's happening in Occupied Kashmir for 70 years, Kashmiri Muslims want indepence from Hindu india, Muslims of India have no freedom as well that's why when they go abroad they don't want to come back and they realize they are better outside than in India because they have more freedom even in foreign countries . stop living in fools paradise. Bollywood Lies get exposed very easily whenever anyone goes to India and see the reality or talk to Indian muslim or anyother minority
Dr. Mubarak Ali is an institution in himself. Thank you for inviting him. I love your line of questioning. It reflects how well read and articulate you are. More power to you.
ماشاءاللہ آپکی ہر ویڈیو بہت انٹرسٹنگ ہوتی ہے۔۔ ان میں اتنے معلومات، علم سے اتنی بری ہوئی ہوتی ہے کہ مجھ جیسے چھوٹے دماغ والے کو ایک بار میں ساری باتیں نہیں سمجھ آتی یا نہیں یاد رکھ سکتا۔۔ اس لیئے 2 یا 3 بار سُنّی پڑھتی ہیں۔ ماشااللہ اسے جاری رکھیے۔۔۔میری دعائیں آپکے ساتھ۔۔۔۔۔
Dear warraich sb ,I live in Manchester UK ,i love ur work I am ur regular listener, u r a hope and silver lining of Pakistanis, please keep it up, I wish you long happy and healthy life Ameen.
1:21:21 Identity Crisis of Pakistan 1:26:00 Punjabi Domination and their Exploitation in Pakistan 1:29:40 Populism in Pakistan 1:31:50 Misinterpretation of Liberalism 1:35:05 Philosophical Discussion - Morality 1:38:30 Why doesn't our system produce quality humans? 1:41:50 Favourite Historians, Recommendations and Learning Resources 1:45:25 Satisfied with Learnings and Writings? and complains? 1:54:50 When and How did the eyesight incident happen? 1:57:00 Outro
@@basitawan5959 good..............ye gandgi isi qabil he...............lunlushtun khi k..............bus hr jgah punjabio ko apni ammi pesh krne ajate he.................or ye gatiya log dekho punjab ko lut kr kha rhe he or yha ate bhi punjab me............begert
mtlb tm log gulam ho punjabio k????????? or such bat he.............hm punjabio ne tm logo ko afghanistan se alg kia tha yad kro sikh raj jb pushtuno ne shalwar pehani ......................................................... kab afghanistan ka part bnoge??
Great program, today I looked history another direction. The best thing in this broadcast is "" Identity crisis "" may be we as a Nation ( Pakistani) think about it. Respect from Connecticut USA
This is how we treat our true heros! Sadly there is no respect for people like Dr. Mubarak Ali sahib. What a tragedy indeed. May Allah keep him healthy and safe. Ameen
Oh ! It was great and wonderful to listen to Dr Mubark Ali Sahib. What a great unbiased historian with scientific and philosophical approach to subject. Today, both in India and Pakistan, ruling elte and religious fundamentalists are hell bent to distort and destroy to common history and culture of the sub continent. ❤❤❤ Friend! I have been watching your videos . Your video presentation of histical events is really appreciable. Well done 👍👍👍
I am from INDIA. Very informative information presented in a very interesting way. hearing it once isn't enough does not pay attention to time while listening.
I listened to the end. This is an extraordinary interview. No doubt Mubarak Ali is well read and very knowledgeable man. And your questions and style was very appropriate. Thanks
Dr Mubarak is a legend, it is a privilege to listen to him . Shame on “The News”for not paying him for his column writing . If he writes regular column it would be a great service to ordinary citizens
What a gem of person and when I heard he was being paid only 60k per month for all his work was just heart aching!! There's a reason Pakistan as society has failed. Faisal sb you can collaborate with him and share revenue with him in the vlogs that he works for you on. 🙏
فیصل برادر! آپ "سیر اعلام النبلاء " جو امام ذھبی نے لکھی ہے اس ضرور مطالعہ کیجئے گا اس میں بیشمار عام لوگوں کی سچی کہانیاں ہیں۔ یہ کام الحمدللہ ماضی میں بہترین طور پر ہوا ہے۔
I am student of law.A lot of Respect for Sir Dr.Mobarak Ali and Sir Faisal.After hearing complete podcast iam in so much pain that iam still a student ,not a practicing lawyer who can help sir Dr.Mobarak Ali to get what's his right from the publisher. Sir we are in debt of both of you Legends.....
پاکستان و اردو زبان میں انفارمیشن کے لیے آپ بہت اچھا کام کر رہےہیں ۔ ان کی طرح مزید سینیئرز۔ کے انٹرویوز کریں تاکہ ان کا کام ان کی حیات میں محفوظ ہو سکے۔
Dr Mubark ali sahib is very clear minded about subject you raised he elaborated throughly NO LAG LAPET Hats off to him I m from Delhi migrated from Chiniot
اسلام وعلیکم میں آپ کے چینل کا اس وقت سے سبسکرائبر ہوں جب آپ کے 200k سبسکرائبر تھے میں آپ کے اس چینل سے بہت متاثر تھا اور آپ کا چینل کے بارے میں سب کو آگاہی بھی دیتا تھا اور اب آخر کار ہمیں وہ باروڈکاسٹ مل گیا ہے جہاں اداکار اور سیاستدان کے علاوہ مختلف شعبہ جات کے قابل ترین افراد کا انٹرویو لیا جاتا ہے سے ہمیں مختلف معلومات حاصل ہوتی ہی ہے اس کے ساتھ ساتھ ان کی محنت ، قابلیت اس ملک سے محبت کا بھی پتا چلتا ہے اور ان کی گمنامی کا بھی خاتمہ ہوتا ہے اور یہ اطمینان بھی ہوتا ہے کے پاکستان میں صرف گوار اور بے حس لوگ ہی نہیں محنتی اور کا بل لوگ بھی موجود ہیں
You never disappoint me Faisal. I used to read his article in dawn what a great gem we have. Thankyou so much Faisal your work and your professionalism reflects how good you are as a person too. Stay Blessed
My suggestion whould be you should do regular vlogs with him so he can earn something. Or maybe he can start his own channel with any host that can help him. He is a mind full of knowledge. As time is changing so I thing his knowledge should be saved in digital form(videos) so it can be a record for new genrations
Usually in our society the person who speaks truth is the one who suffers rather than being rewarded that’s what is happening to Dr sahib Hats off to his courage for standing up and speaking the truth he has a great service to Pakistani If his books are taught in our institutions it will transform our thinking
What a great teacher Dr mubarak ali. Learn alot of things from his different books and now he explain history of pakistan in the podcast in such a way that i am watching this podcast again and again and it give me a lot of knowledge. Thank you Dr mubarak ali, thank you Faisal.
How can Pakistan become a “normal” country without having a secular constitution with equal rights for all citizens, meanwhile the threats of blasphemy and religious zeal continue to excuse murder and persecution?
Such a down to earth person is dr.mubarak ali. Such a great person. One can learn too much by just spending 2 mins from him. Best content i have ever seen anywhere. It has encountered many illusions that we are living in our whole lives. It is very sad that his books aren't published properly. Pakistanis aren't fortunate enough to understand his works.
فیسل بھائی آپ ایسا کوئی گروپ یا ایسی آرگنائزیشن بنائیں جس میں ہم سب لوگ اپنے ان قیمتی اثاثوں کو سنمبھال سکیں یعنی انکی کوئی مدد کر سکیں اور جو منتظمین ہوں وہ بھی زیادہ تر انہی لوگوں میں سے ہوں۔
Alot of respect for faisal for being invited to Dr Mubarak Ali, the great historian of Pakistan. We are dead people who don’t know the value of great minds.
Sir you are our teacher, we are really very, very..... thankful to you. We learnt and learn from your books 📚. Your books are the asset of the country for facts and reality base knowledge.Sir again thank you a lot. I think, may be you will not see my comment.😢❤
بہت زبردست اسکالر جین۔ بڑی معلومات مین اضافہ ھو۔ مین ایک تاریخ کی طالبعلم ھون۔ یہ گفتگو سن کر پتہ چلا کہ تاریخ کو توڑ مروڑ کر پیش کیا جاتا ھے حقائق حدف کر دیہی ے جاتے ھین۔ پروردگار ان کی آنکھوں کو روشنی عطا کر۔ یہ جماتا بہت بڑا سرمایہ ھین
Faisal bahi, you doing excellent job always, I was waiting Dr. Sahib in front of you you did it, thanks. I surprised to hear story of Dr. Sahib we are unfortunate nation (May be) we always forget our real hero. Faisal bahi keep it up!!!
Excellent. Dr. Sahib's point of view and narrative is undeniable. We could not agree more. Thanks a lot, dear Faisal Warraich for your massive contribution to educating the nation towards delivering knowledge.
Excellent 👍 contributions to take comprehensive PODCAST with Dr. Mubarik Ali, I studied earlier and was very inspired because he highlighted scientific approach in the writing of history of Sub continent, we can take serious lession from our history if we study of history along with DR MUBARIK
This is so unfortunate for Pakistan to not appreciate our intelligent and intellectuals. I am so sorry he had such a hard time.😢. May Allah make it easy and happy for him. Ameen.🤲❤️
بہت خوبصورت اور پر مغز گفتگو ،جو ہم سب بالخصوص ملک کے با اختیار طبقے کے لئے لمحہ فکریہ ہے اور باعث رہنمائی بھی۔ ڈاکثر صاحب ہمارا اثاثہ ہیں،دوسرے ہیروز کی طرح ہم نے ان کی بھی قدر نہیں کی۔۔
Rulers often play a significant role in shaping the course of history, and their actions and decisions can have far-reaching consequences for their nations and even the world. When studying history from a ruler's point of view, several factors come into play: Decision-making: Rulers are responsible for making critical decisions that impact their realm. Their choices are often influenced by a variety of factors, such as political considerations, personal beliefs, strategic calculations, and the prevailing circumstances of their time. Understanding the decision-making process of rulers is crucial to comprehending historical events. Power and authority: Rulers possess considerable power and authority, allowing them to enact policies, establish laws, wage wars, and shape the destiny of their nations. This authority enables them to exert significant influence over historical events and leave a lasting legacy. Statecraft and governance: Rulers are tasked with governing their territories, maintaining order, and promoting the welfare of their subjects. Their approach to governance, administrative policies, and reforms can have long-term effects on the socioeconomic development and stability of their nations. Wars and diplomacy: Rulers often engage in wars and diplomacy to protect their interests, expand their territories, or maintain a balance of power. Their military strategies, alliances, and diplomatic negotiations significantly impact the course of history, leading to the rise and fall of empires, the redrawing of borders, and the shaping of international relations. Legacy and historiography: Rulers leave behind a historical legacy that shapes how they are remembered. Historiography, the writing and interpretation of history, can be influenced by various factors, including the ruler's own propaganda, biased accounts, or subsequent assessments by historians. Rulers may be remembered as great leaders, tyrants, reformers, or conquerors, depending on the perspective and biases of those recording and analyzing history. It is important to note that studying history solely from a ruler's point of view can present a partial and potentially biased understanding of events. Broader perspectives that consider the experiences and contributions of various social groups, ordinary individuals, and marginalized communities are essential for a comprehensive understanding of history.
Dr. Sahib is very respected and a great reductionist who is attributed for his work for enlightenment to the people seeking knowledge and education. We should not confuse our religious dimensions with the local cultural values. We as a Muslim very rightly asked for a separate country based on two nations theory.
ہر سکول میں بچوں کو ہومورک میں اس چینل کی ویڈیو دینی چاہیے تاکہ جو نساب میں کمی ہے اس کو پورا کیا جاسکے ۔ ❤
Agreed
Pakistani curriculum:
Sir syed gave idea of two nation theory
Allama Iqbal proposed a land for Muslims
Rehmat Ali gave name of Pakistan
1948 Quaid e Azam made Pakistan 😂😂 bas itna hi btatay hain ❤
بدقسمتی سے ہمیں مکمل طور پہ ٹمپرڈ ہسٹری پڑھائی گئی اور اب ادھیڑ عمری میں جب اصلی تاریخ پڑھی تو ہمارے فوطیے ھی شارٹ ہو گئے ۔۔۔
ابھی تو "نساب" میں "ص" کی کمی ہی نظر آ رہی ہے۔
@@masroor5672
😂😅😂😅😂😅
I really feel that it's time to stand with our intellectuals. Console them for the suffering they suffered from our society. He is a great historian.
🕊I’m based in Karachi and it will be an honour to work as your assistant...voluntarily. Can devote quality time to help you Sir. It was painful to know that DR. Mubarak Ali’s contributions have still not received due recognition...All respect to truly inspiring Dr Mubarak. Ali.
Allah ap ko jizae khair dy
Ye Nation zardari aur Nawaz ki fan ha
In k vision py afsos hi kiya ja skta ha
Jazakallahu khairah
God bless you.
Lol the propagandist
😂 Pakis reject Truth voluntarily
فیصل بھائی مزہ آ جاتا آپکی باتیں سن کر آپ ہمیشہ اگلے بندہ کی بات سنتے ہیے اور ہر طرح کے سوالات کرتے ہیے جس سے ہر طرف کے خیالات سننے کو ملتے ہیے
کتنے معصوم انسان ہیں ڈاکٹر مبارک علی۔ کاش ہماری حکومت اس لائق ہوتی کے ایسے انمول نگینوں کو سر کے تاج میں سجا کر رکھ سکتی۔ 🥺
ہمارے حکمران ہماری اسٹیبلشمنٹ سلیکٹ کرتی ہی، اور وہ اپنی طاقت کھونا نہیں چاہتے سارا مسئلہ طاقت کا ہے
KABHI NAHIN
ایسا لوگوں پو چنا ہوتا تو
تاج محمد اکرم ص۔ حسن ع۔ کے سر پے رکھتا یزید ک نہیں 🙏😭
Civil hakomat Pakistan beybaas hey
Last living historian of Pakistan. Hats off for you sir Dr Mubarak Ali . You are a hero. You are my hero
I am sindhi speaking and I truly appreciate of Dr Mubarak Ali who share real information about history He is legend and I think he seen a lot of difficulties 😔 in life
It's Not only the person Who is Delivering the Knowledge But the Impact Of that Person Who is asking These Questions Deliberately To acquire the Finest Knowledge.
Thank Both Of You❤
i am sorry for my commemnt but now i cant tolerate any foriegn language or fake history in sindh .........................................
we sindhi want our language as a national langauge..............india have 25 national languages so why we dont have 5 national languages?????????????
Lpp
@@vantagehistory1813 I’m Urdu speaking but I fully endorse your views.
Today Pakistan is a lost in Searching its future in Quranic Kitabs and Xihadis Army
@mzkafridi2917 10000000% agreed with you........................ english me science he or Arabic me quran
کیا عمدہ اردو اور کیا ہی خوبصورت باتیں ہیں،، سلامتی کا متمنی
Learned a lot from dear Professor Sir. Take love from Narayanganj,Dhaka 🇧🇩
مبارک علی صاحب کو فوری طور پر ایک ٹرسٹ قائم کرنا چاہیے اور اپنی تمام کتابوں کو اس ٹرسٹ کے حوالے کرنا چاہیے تاکہ ان کتابوں کو صحیح طور پر شائع کیا جا سکے اور مبارک صاحب کی اشک شوئی بھی ہو سکے۔
مجھے انتہائی خوشگوار حیرت ہوئی یہ جان کر کے ڈاکٹر مبارک علی ابھی تک باحیات ہیں. میں نے ان کی کتابیں پڑھی ہیں. آج سن کر بڑا اچھا لگا.
Legendary Dr. Mubarak Ali. As my teacher always used to quote Dr. Mubarak Ali while teaching South Asian History, particularly Mughal period.
Dr Mubarak Ali sahib tuhanu salam from Punjab India 🇮🇳
ماشااللہ! بہت ہی معلوماتی پروگرام تھا۔ نہایت ہی عمدہ شخصیت اور بہت ہی اچھے سوالات تھے۔ دو گزارشات تھی۔ اول یہ کہ ہم جیسے طالبہ کے ذہن میں بھی بہت سے سوالات ہوتے ہیں، تو برائے کرم کوئی ایسا پروگرام بھی شروع کریں جس میں ہم براہ راست اپنے سوالات پوچھ سکیں۔ کیوں کے اس چینل کے سوا ہمارے علمی تجسس کو اور پیاس کو کوئی اور پورا نہیں کرتا۔ دوئم یہ کے اگر کوئی بااقتعدار شخص اس پروگرام کو دیکھ رہا ہے اور میرے اس کمنٹ کو پڑھ رہا ہے تو خدا رہ ڈاکٹر صاحب سے تعاون کریں یہ آپ کا پوری پاکستان قوم پر احسان ہوگا۔ جزاک اللہ
Amazing! This man refers to Shyam Benegal, Chander Mohan, Roti film (old), art films, Satyajit Ray, Bimal Roy's Do Bigha Zameen, etc. as part of people's history. Great man!
ALL are Communist Movies .
Poverty p2orn.
بہت اچھے انداز میں فیصل صاحب نے ڈاکٹر صاحب کا انٹرویو کیا ہے۔ صبر اور تحمل سے زیادہ سے زیادہ وقت بولنے کے لیے اپنے مہمان کو دینا کسی میزبان کے لیے آسان نہیں ہوتا۔ زبردست فیصل صاحب۔ اور آداب اور دعائیں ڈاکٹر صاحب کے لیے۔
Imagine yahan Mansoor Ali Khan hota . 😆😂
This channel needed to be aired on national TV to educate our young generation.
I totally agree with you but what about the lie's we've been teaching to our nation from 1947⁉️
The history will destroy your identity,
if you destroy your history🤔
Lol. Then all historians need to come and tell their version and then awam will decide what's truth and what's not... no need to pick and choose stuff which suit certain narratives only. Two nation theory continues to comeback to prove its worth.. we have seen everything in last few decades the realities (what's happening in Hindustan and their ground realities make everything clear)
@@goals27 no muslim from India wants to leave India and go to Pakistan inspite of all things which you have mentioned tells alot about India
@@arpittiwari7605 Lol , that's because of terrorism promoted by ur state , indian muslims can't anything openly which seem even slightly anti state otherwise we all know the situation. We all know what's happening in Occupied Kashmir for 70 years, Kashmiri Muslims want indepence from Hindu india, Muslims of India have no freedom as well that's why when they go abroad they don't want to come back and they realize they are better outside than in India because they have more freedom even in foreign countries . stop living in fools paradise. Bollywood Lies get exposed very easily whenever anyone goes to India and see the reality or talk to Indian muslim or anyother minority
Military establishment won't allow it. They want kashmir news to indoctrination of Pakistani youth
Dr. Mubarak Ali is an institution in himself. Thank you for inviting him. I love your line of questioning. It reflects how well read and articulate you are. More power to you.
Dr Mubarak Ali is a national treasure.
کمال لمحات ہیں جب ساتھ ساتھ کتابیں بھی تجویز کی گئیں ہیں ۔
ماشاءاللہ آپکی ہر ویڈیو بہت انٹرسٹنگ ہوتی ہے۔۔ ان میں اتنے معلومات، علم سے اتنی بری ہوئی ہوتی ہے کہ مجھ جیسے چھوٹے دماغ والے کو ایک بار میں ساری باتیں نہیں سمجھ آتی یا نہیں یاد رکھ سکتا۔۔ اس لیئے 2 یا 3 بار سُنّی پڑھتی ہیں۔ ماشااللہ اسے جاری رکھیے۔۔۔میری دعائیں آپکے ساتھ۔۔۔۔۔
ڈاکٹر مبارک اس دور کے عظیم مورخ ہیں۔ اللّه ان کو لمبی عمر دے
عمدہ گفتگو,,,,, سلامت رہیں ڈاکٹر صاحب,,,, سلامت رہیں فیصل بھائی
Dear warraich sb ,I live in Manchester UK ,i love ur work I am ur regular listener, u r a hope and silver lining of Pakistanis, please keep it up, I wish you long happy and healthy life Ameen.
Faisal sir treating him exactly the way he should be treated. A blend of respect, prou, sympathy and love ❤
1:21:21 Identity Crisis of Pakistan
1:26:00 Punjabi Domination and their Exploitation in Pakistan
1:29:40 Populism in Pakistan
1:31:50 Misinterpretation of Liberalism
1:35:05 Philosophical Discussion - Morality
1:38:30 Why doesn't our system produce quality humans?
1:41:50 Favourite Historians, Recommendations and Learning Resources
1:45:25 Satisfied with Learnings and Writings? and complains?
1:54:50 When and How did the eyesight incident happen?
1:57:00 Outro
Pathan dictator ayub Khan tareen and Pathan dictator yahya Khan ke karnamo ka zikr kiya gaya ha
@@fahadyousafzi 1971 ke waqat koi kirdar Punjabi nahi tha beta
@@fahadyousafzi Pathan dictator yahya Khan Peshawar main dafan ha us ko salute kro jao
@@basitawan5959 good..............ye gandgi isi qabil he...............lunlushtun khi k..............bus hr jgah punjabio ko apni ammi pesh krne ajate he.................or ye gatiya log dekho punjab ko lut kr kha rhe he or yha ate bhi punjab me............begert
mtlb tm log gulam ho punjabio k????????? or such bat he.............hm punjabio ne tm logo ko afghanistan se alg kia tha yad kro sikh raj jb pushtuno ne shalwar pehani ......................................................... kab afghanistan ka part bnoge??
Thanks for speaking to Dr Mubarak Ali sahab. He is a gem. Hope young people in Pakistan listen to him and read his books.
MashaAllah
Faisal Bhai we are proud of you.
Bar e Sagheer 🇵🇰🇮🇳 ke do behtreen RUclipsrs Faisal Waraich 🇵🇰 and Dhruv Rathee 🇮🇳
❤️❤️❤️
100% agree
Sach may
Dhruv Rathee is biased, watch Nitish Rajput.
@@kuku6116 yes to some extent, he is biased for BJP.
Dhruv Sahb Ki tou kya Baat Hai❤👌
سہیل صاحب اپ کا پروگرام بہت اچھالگتا ہے بہت شوق سے دیکھتاہو بہت نولج ملتی ہے ڈاکٹر صاحب ایک سچھا ادمی ہے ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Excellent conversation with Dr Mubarak Ali Sahib! Always a pleasure to listen to him! This video is precious and a treasure for all South Asians……👏👏👏
l
l
l
Thanks Dekho Suno Jano channel for presenting so knowledgeable and true historian. Ali sahb is really a gem of a person. Thanks.
❤❤❤ from India!…such danishwars rarely get their due either in India or Pakistan…thanks for the insightful show!.
اس طرح کے عظیم لوگ آنکھوں سے محروم رھے دانشور لوگوں کی آنکھیں ھی تو دوسرے لوگوں کی آنکھیں ھوتی ھیں
Great program, today I looked history another direction. The best thing in this broadcast is "" Identity crisis "" may be we as a Nation ( Pakistani) think about it. Respect from Connecticut USA
ڈاکٹر صاحب کی ہر بات سے تو اتفاق نہیں کیا جا سکتا لیکن ان کے لیے دل میں احترام بہت ہے۔
What are the things you can’t agree with dr. Sahab on?
This is how we treat our true heros! Sadly there is no respect for people like Dr. Mubarak Ali sahib. What a tragedy indeed. May Allah keep him healthy and safe. Ameen
Namaskar from India. What a man! What depth of knowledge. Respect!
We can’t thank you enough for bringing out such useful and yet interesting history and untold stories of Pakistan-India partition.
Salam Namaste Sat Sri Akaal sab bhai behno ko🙏
Bahut Hi Shaandaar👍👍
Namastay🙏to u Also My Hindustani Bro❤
@@falahbaloch Bro 🙂🙂🙏
@@falahbalochnamashka ka mutlub shirk hai bhai
Oh ! It was great and wonderful to listen to Dr Mubark Ali Sahib. What a great unbiased historian with scientific and philosophical approach to subject. Today, both in India and Pakistan, ruling elte and religious fundamentalists are hell bent to distort and destroy to common history and culture of the sub continent. ❤❤❤
Friend! I have been watching your videos . Your video presentation of histical events is really appreciable.
Well done 👍👍👍
I am from INDIA.
Very informative information presented in a very interesting way.
hearing it once isn't enough
does not pay attention to time while listening.
It's fake history 😂
I listened to the end. This is an extraordinary interview. No doubt Mubarak Ali is well read and very knowledgeable man. And your questions and style was very appropriate. Thanks
You always come up with the best.Much needed video. Young generation should watch this podcast to learn and unlearn history. ❤️
Dr Mubarak is a legend, it is a privilege to listen to him . Shame on “The News”for not paying him for his column writing . If he writes regular column it would be a great service to ordinary citizens
Great job Faisal on getting Dr. Mubarak Ali. A pleasure listening to the legend!
Big fan ♥️
Such an insightful discussion on import matters of Pakistan's history, identity, morality, politics & religion. Hats Off to this channel 👏
What a gem of person and when I heard he was being paid only 60k per month for all his work was just heart aching!! There's a reason Pakistan as society has failed. Faisal sb you can collaborate with him and share revenue with him in the vlogs that he works for you on. 🙏
A man and his love can change the world. Thanks for your contributions.
Highly focused, civilized, and a gentleman!!!
فیصل برادر! آپ "سیر اعلام النبلاء " جو امام ذھبی نے لکھی ہے اس ضرور مطالعہ کیجئے گا اس میں بیشمار عام لوگوں کی سچی کہانیاں ہیں۔ یہ کام الحمدللہ ماضی میں بہترین طور پر ہوا ہے۔
Just few minutes into the podcast and I have goosebumps!
Thrilled to go further!
I am student of law.A lot of Respect for Sir Dr.Mobarak Ali and Sir Faisal.After hearing complete podcast iam in so much pain that iam still a student ,not a practicing lawyer who can help sir Dr.Mobarak Ali to get what's his right from the publisher.
Sir we are in debt of both of you Legends.....
پاکستان و اردو زبان میں انفارمیشن کے لیے آپ بہت اچھا کام کر رہےہیں ۔ ان کی طرح مزید سینیئرز۔ کے انٹرویوز کریں تاکہ ان کا کام ان کی حیات میں محفوظ ہو سکے۔
Hats off to you for the interview of respected Dr Mubarak Ali sahib. very well done
Dr Mubark ali sahib is very clear minded about subject you raised he elaborated throughly
NO LAG LAPET
Hats off to him
I m from Delhi migrated from Chiniot
kabi aao milny
@@shaam7433
Thanks a lot
Aap kahan se ho ?
اسلام وعلیکم میں آپ کے چینل کا اس وقت سے سبسکرائبر ہوں جب آپ کے 200k سبسکرائبر تھے میں آپ کے اس چینل سے بہت متاثر تھا اور آپ کا چینل کے بارے میں سب کو آگاہی بھی دیتا تھا اور اب آخر کار ہمیں وہ باروڈکاسٹ مل گیا ہے جہاں اداکار اور سیاستدان کے علاوہ مختلف شعبہ جات کے قابل ترین افراد کا انٹرویو لیا جاتا ہے سے ہمیں مختلف معلومات حاصل ہوتی ہی ہے اس کے ساتھ ساتھ ان کی محنت ، قابلیت اس ملک سے محبت کا بھی پتا چلتا ہے اور ان کی گمنامی کا بھی خاتمہ ہوتا ہے اور یہ اطمینان بھی ہوتا ہے کے پاکستان میں صرف گوار اور بے حس لوگ ہی نہیں محنتی اور کا بل لوگ بھی موجود ہیں
You never disappoint me Faisal. I used to read his article in dawn what a great gem we have. Thankyou so much Faisal your work and your professionalism reflects how good you are as a person too.
Stay Blessed
It is so unfortunate that we don't honor such intellectuals like Sir Mubarak Ali. His knowledge of history is paramount.
Huge appreciation for you Faisal sb from Sindh. I am a student from History where Dr Mubark taught his last time in Sindh. Sallam
سلام ڈاکٹر مبارک علی صاحب اور فیصل وڑائچ صاحب برصغیر اور پارٹیشن پر حقیقی معلومات فراہم کرنے پر ہم لوگ آپ کے مشکور ہیں
My suggestion whould be you should do regular vlogs with him so he can earn something. Or maybe he can start his own channel with any host that can help him. He is a mind full of knowledge. As time is changing so I thing his knowledge should be saved in digital form(videos) so it can be a record for new genrations
Agreed 👍💯
check it out sir have a channel
I agree with this suggession. It must be started on priority basis.
May Allah grant Dr. Sahab long and healthy life, Aameen
Usually in our society the person who speaks truth is the one who suffers rather than being rewarded that’s what is happening to Dr sahib Hats off to his courage for standing up and speaking the truth he has a great service to Pakistani
If his books are taught in our institutions it will transform our thinking
What a great teacher Dr mubarak ali. Learn alot of things from his different books and now he explain history of pakistan in the podcast in such a way that i am watching this podcast again and again and it give me a lot of knowledge.
Thank you Dr mubarak ali, thank you Faisal.
My heart bleeds after listening what the greatest Pakistani Historian has gone through 😢
😢
😢
Great Podcast Faisal Bhai You're Doing great Job InshaAllah One Day our New Generation Will Understand their Real History And End this extremism
Yes this is the real reason behind all this.. targeting the future generations..who will depend on internet for their knowledge of history..
How can Pakistan become a “normal” country without having a secular constitution with equal rights for all citizens, meanwhile the threats of blasphemy and religious zeal continue to excuse murder and persecution?
آج بہت بڑے مصنف کو دیکھ لیا۔ اللہ پاک ڈاکٹر صاحب کو شفاہ دے آمین۔
I love the way you interviewed, gave whole time to Dr. Sahab.
Faisal bhai love from Karachi ,,, thanks for giving us authentic knowledge ❤
Such a down to earth person is dr.mubarak ali. Such a great person. One can learn too much by just spending 2 mins from him. Best content i have ever seen anywhere. It has encountered many illusions that we are living in our whole lives. It is very sad that his books aren't published properly. Pakistanis aren't fortunate enough to understand his works.
great. Waiting for discussion on this topic for a long time. Cant wait to hear.
Salute to Sir! Lots of respect from India
فیسل بھائی آپ ایسا کوئی گروپ یا ایسی آرگنائزیشن بنائیں جس میں ہم سب لوگ اپنے ان قیمتی اثاثوں کو سنمبھال سکیں یعنی انکی کوئی مدد کر سکیں اور جو منتظمین ہوں وہ بھی زیادہ تر انہی لوگوں میں سے ہوں۔
Your quest for truth is appreciated.
Mubarik sb ko sun k bht acha laga realistic baten 1 podcast or hona chye
main bht km comment krta hon pr mubarik sir deserve krty hen
Alot of respect for faisal for being invited to Dr Mubarak Ali, the great historian of Pakistan. We are dead people who don’t know the value of great minds.
Sir you are our teacher, we are really very, very..... thankful to you. We learnt and learn from your books 📚. Your books are the asset of the country for facts and reality base knowledge.Sir again thank you a lot. I think, may be you will not see my comment.😢❤
What a man Dr Mubarak. Authority on history.. appreciate your efforts, Faisal Bhai
بہت زبردست اسکالر جین۔ بڑی معلومات مین اضافہ ھو۔ مین ایک تاریخ کی طالبعلم ھون۔ یہ گفتگو سن کر پتہ چلا کہ تاریخ کو توڑ مروڑ کر پیش کیا جاتا ھے حقائق حدف کر دیہی ے جاتے ھین۔ پروردگار ان کی آنکھوں کو روشنی عطا کر۔ یہ جماتا بہت بڑا سرمایہ ھین
Excellent effort to put history straight
Time of historical lies gone
Marvellous, thanks to Dr Mubarak Sahib, interviewer and channel.
an eye opening podcast everyone have to watch this. this is our reality... unfortunately still Pakistan is under company raj
No “Pakistan” is very much the victim of the imported most dangerous Cancer virus called Islam 🆘
"Assalam-o-Alaikum. I kindly request the preservation of the exquisite format of 'Dekho Suno Jano,' as curated by the esteemed Faisal Warraich Sahib."
Watching you Faisal Bhai from Bihar ( India). Both you are really Gems..
Zabardast. What an excellent historical interview with a legend. You have rewritten the factual history. Congratulations.
Stay blessed.
Dr Mubarik Ali is one of the most Authentic Historian in Pakistan
Exactly
وڑائچ سب بہت شکریہ آپ اور محترم پروفیسر صاحب کا
Faisal bahi, you doing excellent job always, I was waiting Dr. Sahib in front of you you did it, thanks. I surprised to hear story of Dr. Sahib we are unfortunate nation (May be) we always forget our real hero. Faisal bahi keep it up!!!
Excellent. Dr. Sahib's point of view and narrative is undeniable. We could not agree more. Thanks a lot, dear Faisal Warraich for your massive contribution to educating the nation towards delivering knowledge.
افسوس کہ ہم نے اپنے حقیقی محسنوں کی قدر نہیں کی۔
Hum khushnaseeb haein Faisal bhae ke hmare door mein ap jese qabil scholars mojood haein
Excellent 👍 contributions to take comprehensive PODCAST with Dr. Mubarik Ali, I studied earlier and was very inspired because he highlighted scientific approach in the writing of history of Sub continent, we can take serious lession from our history if we study of history along with DR MUBARIK
Nice interview and conversation Dr.Sahab is great personalty.Shukria Faisal Sahab.
This is so unfortunate for Pakistan to not appreciate our intelligent and intellectuals. I am so sorry he had such a hard time.😢. May Allah make it easy and happy for him. Ameen.🤲❤️
بہت خوبصورت اور پر مغز گفتگو ،جو ہم سب بالخصوص ملک کے با اختیار طبقے کے لئے لمحہ فکریہ ہے اور باعث رہنمائی بھی۔
ڈاکثر صاحب ہمارا اثاثہ ہیں،دوسرے ہیروز کی طرح ہم نے ان کی بھی قدر نہیں کی۔۔
A great scholar historian who was sadly never given his due and became a victim of the system prevalent in our society!
ماشاء اللہ ، نہایت عمدہ تجربہ
Rulers often play a significant role in shaping the course of history, and their actions and decisions can have far-reaching consequences for their nations and even the world. When studying history from a ruler's point of view, several factors come into play:
Decision-making: Rulers are responsible for making critical decisions that impact their realm. Their choices are often influenced by a variety of factors, such as political considerations, personal beliefs, strategic calculations, and the prevailing circumstances of their time. Understanding the decision-making process of rulers is crucial to comprehending historical events.
Power and authority: Rulers possess considerable power and authority, allowing them to enact policies, establish laws, wage wars, and shape the destiny of their nations. This authority enables them to exert significant influence over historical events and leave a lasting legacy.
Statecraft and governance: Rulers are tasked with governing their territories, maintaining order, and promoting the welfare of their subjects. Their approach to governance, administrative policies, and reforms can have long-term effects on the socioeconomic development and stability of their nations.
Wars and diplomacy: Rulers often engage in wars and diplomacy to protect their interests, expand their territories, or maintain a balance of power. Their military strategies, alliances, and diplomatic negotiations significantly impact the course of history, leading to the rise and fall of empires, the redrawing of borders, and the shaping of international relations.
Legacy and historiography: Rulers leave behind a historical legacy that shapes how they are remembered. Historiography, the writing and interpretation of history, can be influenced by various factors, including the ruler's own propaganda, biased accounts, or subsequent assessments by historians. Rulers may be remembered as great leaders, tyrants, reformers, or conquerors, depending on the perspective and biases of those recording and analyzing history.
It is important to note that studying history solely from a ruler's point of view can present a partial and potentially biased understanding of events. Broader perspectives that consider the experiences and contributions of various social groups, ordinary individuals, and marginalized communities are essential for a comprehensive understanding of history.
Dr. Sahib is very respected and a great reductionist who is attributed for his work for enlightenment to the people seeking knowledge and education. We should not confuse our religious dimensions with the local cultural values. We as a Muslim very rightly asked for a separate country based on two nations theory.