This song is bigger than "singing". It is a story of "American life". A mark on all our hearts, a reality we must all face. A key song in the diaspora, a never-ending reminder of what is true.
It's actually Joan who is singing the melody and Bob who is harmonising pretty well and in tune too. His tone is harsher than hers, of course, which is what gives their duets such a unique texture. The main challenge for Joan at times is Bob's slightly quirky sense of timing with phrasing.
Another song that you might consider is Joan Baez singing "The Deserter", a French song by Boris Vian "Le Déserteur". It was banned from French radio in the fifties.
Where was this recorded? Love Arlo Guthrie singing w Emmylou but this one is a masterpiece. Is it from Ft Collins CO Hard Rain RTR concert or tour 1975?
Joan and Bob sang together for years and were actually a couple at one time, Dylan is singing to the key of the song Joan is singing a 3rd above that is harmonizing. Like Dylan or not you can't say he is out of tune cause he isn't. You must be tone deaf.
@@mrjasondylan You seem to have been deafened by his talent to write songs. You can use an electronic device to check the exact notes if your ears cannot hear well by old age...if you are not technology deaf either.
This is one good song, and this pair's terrific harmony does it well. Shame Commie Jobama and his "Deportees" are taking over what was once America. MAGA Vet.
This song is bigger than "singing". It is a story of "American life". A mark on all our hearts, a reality we must all face. A key song in the diaspora, a never-ending reminder of what is true.
I love Joan and Dylan. They sang this one beautifully
Joan does a great job harmonizing with Bob.
It's actually Joan who is singing the melody and Bob who is harmonising pretty well and in tune too. His tone is harsher than hers, of course, which is what gives their duets such a unique texture. The main challenge for Joan at times is Bob's slightly quirky sense of timing with phrasing.
...... that can't be easy.
Nobody can harmonize with Dylan.
A great song ! Two beautiful artist !
Now you know why I loved these people!
Another sad one but so beautifully sung! Thank you so much! 🙏🏻💙
hi denise💃🏼🎶💃🏼🥰
Semplicemente meravigliosi
Sempre meravigliosa da ascoltare ❤
Another song that you might consider is Joan Baez singing "The Deserter", a French song by Boris Vian "Le Déserteur". It was banned from French radio in the fifties.
what a lady💖
Bob and joan sound good
Great
Where was this recorded? Love Arlo Guthrie singing w Emmylou but this one is a masterpiece. Is it from Ft Collins CO Hard Rain RTR concert or tour 1975?
Love
👏👏
Yes their voices remind us. Sad
Bob dylan , fito paez , charly garcia , juaquin Sabina,
Bruce. Rosalita. Hmm
joan is looking at bob like "seriously dude?? why are you singing like that?" lol
interesting take either way haha
She knows more than u know about him.....a true artist let's his or her actions be a response from something they never expected
Fabulous rendition.......you dont have a name..all they will call you will be deportee......how sad.
Joan tries hard to harmonize with an out-of-tune Bob.
Joan and Bob sang together for years and were actually a couple at one time, Dylan is singing to the key of the song Joan is singing a 3rd above that is harmonizing. Like Dylan or not you can't say he is out of tune cause he isn't. You must be tone deaf.
@@mrjasondylan You seem to have been deafened by his talent to write songs. You can use an electronic device to check the exact notes if your ears cannot hear well by old age...if you are not technology deaf either.
@@cemunluakn2910 I've been a musician for 35 yrs my ears are perfect and so are about 50m other fans worldwide, later .
Nah, Bob isn't out of tune...he sings the way he wants to and gets it how it needs to be...right by me!
Cognitive human biases. Get your ears tuned!
Donald Trump favourite song ... he builded a wall as tribute .
Maclyn Monroe
1 second ago
And you get your ass on the mexican side ass hole
Build The Wall == Make it high and long !
This is one good song, and this pair's terrific harmony does it well. Shame Commie Jobama and his "Deportees" are taking over what was once America. MAGA Vet.