*LINE COMPARISON* Basically, this video has two distributions in one. I will compare two versions of the same song and show the difference of the seconds. The striped bar will show the difference between the versions and I added an extra timer for those members who cover other lines. Probably this video it's more accurate than my previous distribution of Catch Me If You Can, so yeah, it happens. :P If you like the idea, please say in the comments, will help me to know what kind of videos do you like and do you dislike. If you want, you can also send me some request of songs that I can compare.
I really love Taeyeon's high note here, but is true, Jessica's version of the high sounds so amazing, I think I like it more! Even now, 4 years after I'm still sad that we can't listen again to these amazing girls sing together :c But.. At least we can still hear Jess in her music and we can keep supporting our Soshi girls ♡ Fighting SNSD! Fighting Jess! ♡
hibiki jaeger I agree. If you watch their live performance for Into The New World in Seoul concert. TaeYeon voice is good alone but right when Jessica join the harmonize and song just sounds so good.
Disagree. I really enjoyed lion heart album and sailing without Jessica's voice. You only hear the difference when you listen to them sing past songs when Jessica is there and when she isn't. Jessica wasn't the only person who made up the vocal line. They are still fine with or without her
The pressure is really hard on OT8, this is the 1st song without jess and at that time they also practiced for tokyo dome concert. i think they are also afraid like how ppl will receive them after jess left.
All the members just look aggravated in the ot8 version. I think they were probably irritated and disappointed that they had to film it all again, especially as 8 and not 9.
Divine I'm pretty sure was made after this song. This song was made way before and someone even found a clip of Jessica singing a small part of it during the reality show with her sister (she stopped herself though because spoilers). Divine was supposed to be her last song aka her goodbye song
Actually, the ot9 version of cmifyc was recorded around June because they recorded "vocally" right after they promoted Mr. Mr. If Jessica was still on the team all the way through The Best Live Tokyo Dome Concert, they would've perform Catch Me If You Can as a surprise for their Japanese fan. But either way, w/ or w/out Jessica, ot9 is still in our hearts.
Mohamad Faiz Md Said divine is her last song, CMIYC ot9 was recorded before Divine but this video was leaked to public after divine, so people who doesn't know, think that CMIYC ot 9 is her last song, i mean can you use your brain please ? this video doesn't even include to their official video and some SONE still think this video is jessica's last video with snsd ! Ha 😂 GOD please !!!
You can easily tell that after Jessica departed from SNSD, the feels of the songs and performances aren't the same anymore because we all know that they lack something. They do not lack the talent, visuals or vocals but Jessica, they lack a precious member. Just what like Yuri said when they won Daesang Award *"We can only shine brightness as SNSD and when SNSD stand on stage as NINE."* Still, support them as a group and individually. 💓
J • you are so fucking annoying hun. You are freaking everywhere related to Jessica's comments. We are here to reminisce some memories of ot9. Can you give a space for us too. Gtfo. If you don't like Jessica, get over it already bcs shes not in snsd anymore. I bet you're fucking happy and satisfied enough
J • lmao what kind of rubbish talk is that? I don't give a fuck about your non fave otp or whatever you want to call it. If you just said your Taeyeon deserves better well guess what, Jessica deserves better too hun. Don't be so damn biased about this thing just to fit your self liking for your only fave 😂😂
Catch Me If You Can will always have a special place in my heart. After it came out I was so sad with that clip of Jessica singing part of it in jessica and Krystal I knew she was suppose to be in it. The fact that we not only got the song, but the video too? Amazing. Bittersweet and perfect closure for me. Imagine how many other songs they could have versions of with her in them. I'm convinced sunny's bit right before the last chorus in You Think was originally Jessica. With songs like Boomerang being from 2008 and sitting on a shelf until 2012 who knows how many 'new' SNSD songs we are getting with her cut out of them.
True.. I think there's many more ot8 songs were originally ot9 songs.. Not cmiyc only.. They needs time to learn the song, recording, arrange n rearrange, choreography n many more.. If solo or duet maybe need less time but group with many members needs longer time for it..
I'm still heart broken about Sica leaving But I'm proud that Sooyoung got a lot more solos. She's my ultimate bias and she's so underappreciated a lot of the time
Seriously who wouldn't like this idea? I used to comment on your videos the exact same OT8 thing you did at the end of the video (with the up/down arrows and stuff xD) So yes please make more of these :D
back to when jessica is still sm fav. most of you guys said without her others get more line which i can’t deny but admit it, her voice blend perfectly in every songs especially the harmony high notes with taeyeon. there’s always something we lose and gain in life but you need to cherish every moment. that’s what i think everyone should do ot8 or ot9. even if you move foward(ot8) you don’t forget the past(ot9)
One thing I have noticed since Jessica left and the others (Taeyeon, Tiffany, Seohyun, YoonA (Station & K2 OST)), Jessica was the sound of SNSD. That is to say, she is the only solo that stills sounds like SNSD. Taeyeon is a great singer and I really like YoonA's Station releases and Amazing Grace (K2), but it was Jessica's voice that I missed during 'Lionheart' and 'Holiday Night' promotions. I was not fully back onboard with SNSD until OH!GG Fermata.
I love ot9 version because Jess is #1 and her high note was beautiful. I love ot8 version because Sooyoung is #2. Her voice has improved so much. She should have more lines in snsd's next comeback.
At first, SM town set jessica’s position to A leader, main vocal and lead dancer of snsd. She is 2nd Boa of SM. Everybody must know this fact. After that taeyoen take leader instead her and promote soo, yuri, yoona to lead dancer instead. Lastly, Tiffany take her main vocal line. But for old fan, we know she always leader, Main vocal, Lead dancer and Perfect visual too.
Although SM probably really assigned Jessica to be one of the members of dance line, I don't think Jessica dances that well when comparing to Hyoyeon and Yuri, or even Sooyoung and Yoona. When I see them doing the same choreography, Jessica's steps looks a little different and she looks a little weird.
@@rychan78 nah she only lost to Hyo and Yuri. She obviously better than other members even there a reason why she is center in ITNW opening. SM can chose Hyoyeon or Yoona to became center in ITNW opening but no, SM chose Jessica instead. Thats just show Jessica not only have vocal, but dance and visual. I can say that at least she in 3rd place when it came to dancing after Hyo and Yuri. It just she became lazy years by years since she has anemia, and she also a main vocal, so she chose to not focus on dancing.
Jessica always has a different vibe, though she has a high pitched voice the way she delivered is perfect. Also her vibrato is something always admirable. And her part are always tacky. And she uses chest voice most of time. Great ❤
That's means Jessica has a lot of lines in last song I'm so happy but it's kinda sad too at the same time another 3 members has left then the only 5 members in SNSD now I wish someday they will perform and comeback soon as a complete 9 members for the fans only I hope SM company will my wish someday I know some fans want to see them as 9 members like they did to S.E.S they're complete as 3 members
It's actually less fair now because sunny and seohyun get less lines now and there leads vocals. I luv tiff but she literally taking all the lines for the distribution now .
The line distribution isn't actually fair even when Jessica is still in SNSD. I know that Taeyeon is really a great singer and all but common let's face it that when it comes to distribution of lines she has like every single line. Back then, they excused that Taeyeon is the main vocal and the leader of the group. Hello there! Jessica is also the main vocal but there's a time that she only got a few lines, and when it comes to the leader thing, I believe you don't use that excuse when it comes to the music industry like some of the leaders in a KPop group has a few lines because they give the chance to others. And when you say that Sooyoung finally had the chance to be number 2? like I really like Hyoyeon, Yuri, Yoona and Sooyoung but what exactly is their position in the group? I remember that Yoona and Sooyoung are the lead dancers while Hyoyeon and Yuri are the main dancers, right? I'm not saying that they have to stick to their position in the group but I think that is their position because that's what they do best. So don't expect that they'll receive more lines than the main and lead vocal of the group. Don't take my comment in a negative side. I just want to clear those mind of yours. I hope it helps.
This is a great idea. I have suggestion, though! You could totally use this for a center distribution. One bar for when they're actually in the middle and the other for when they have the spotlight, whether it's in the back or at the sides. It would make more sense, I think! Great job, totally liking this vid! Also I finally subscribed. Every time you upload I check out your channel, Idk why I wan't subscribed yet. Anyway, love this!
Although Taeyeon is the backbone singer and strongest vocal of the group, it’s mainly Jessica’s uniquely soothing voice and adlibs that elevated majority of their songs to a higher level. Without Jessica, yes, Taeyeon and the remaining vocal line can still carry the songs, but they just sound flat and dull. None of them can cover Jessica’s lines and adlibs the same way that it used to harmonize with Taeyeon’s vocals quite beautifully - not even remotely no matter how Seohyun and Sunny trained to be at their best.
I don't know why, but that's the first video where I find that OT8 better that OT9 version. I am really happy that yoona and sooyoung has most part of jessi's line. For that, they really can prove that they have really awesome voice
this is interesting... Yoona Sooyoung and Yuri benefited the most by Jessica not being in the group for this first song.. but in the end Jessica's voice is so unique no one could replace her... we will never know the full truth but .. SooYoung's parents are said to have put up a big fight over Jessica... I do believe Jessica was voted out.. I also believe Sunny could have stopped all of it since her uncle was an executive at SM... but sunny didn't want to stop it.
I've known Girls generations since 2008, when I was a kid. I remember the good times that watching her videos and trying to dance with my cousin provided me. Seeing this video really hurts for me, I miss Jessica :((((
Am I the only one who liked the OT8 one better..? It looked cleaner and more together, and of course I'm never gonna say no to more lines for YoonYulSoo WOO 😁👍❤️
Please do more of these for their older songs and for groups that are missing a member. Either way for this song, Hyoyeon is still last, she basically kept all her lines
The time when I heard Yoona's high notes, I know it's exactly belong to Jess. It's really rare to see Yoona's high note even though I know she is also a good singer. Mostly groups will immediately disband when they lost a member but thank you for the rest of 8 members who keeps SNSD name alive.
Jessica 1 lugar 25.9 Taeyeon 2 lugar 24.0 Tiffany 3 lugar 20.8 Sooyoung 4 lugar 20.6 Sunny 5 lugar 16.6 Seohyun 6 lugar 16.5 Yoona 7 lugar 13.0 Yuri 8 lugar 11.5 Hyoyeon 9 lugar 11.4
don't cry for Sunny she had the power to stop this Sunny's uncle is Lee Soo-man is the founder of SM Entertainment and he had the ability to end it. Sunny wanted Jessica out of the group.. we will never know the reason why but it is most likely all about Money and maybe misplaced honor.. Jessica was dating a Billionaire and started a Clothing Line with stores in NY and other Cities. Their contract agreement is all outside ventures and endorsements are shared by the group and SM. SM gave the OK for Jessica to keep everything from her clothing line.. then the girls realized how big her business could become and they wanted part of it. SooYoung's parents are said to be one of the biggest reasons .. they are wealthy and probably decided to sue SM for a breach of contract and the amount would have been so big that it would have seriously hurt SM... Greed broke up GG... and then that Greed was the end of GG... so foolish... even SM never recovered.. they don't have any top acts anymore and always were at the top... I would like to see Jessica be backed by one of the Big recording companies and I would bet she would be a top performer today even considering her age.. If JYP gave Jessica a chance and some good songs and high quality MVs for her songs she would still pull an audience.. as it is she is on her own and she is still an influence bigger than the other girls in GG that have big companies behind them but can't get ahead... only Taeyeon does ok but people have soured over the breakup.
Omg this is so cool Kinda like an idea I had where at the start of the song Jessicas bar was full and when someone covered her part her bar decreased and the covering members bar increased but in blue for Jessica. but this is way better!! Could u do other GG songs like Mr Mr etc?? :D
![JESSICA - LINE EVOLUTION (while in SNSD) [2007-2014]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/K77qnTPD240/mqdefault.jpg)
![JESSICA - LINE EVOLUTION (while in SNSD) [2007-2014]](/img/tr.png)
*LINE COMPARISON*
Basically, this video has two distributions in one. I will compare two versions of the same song and show the difference of the seconds. The striped bar will show the difference between the versions and I added an extra timer for those members who cover other lines.
Probably this video it's more accurate than my previous distribution of Catch Me If You Can, so yeah, it happens. :P
If you like the idea, please say in the comments, will help me to know what kind of videos do you like and do you dislike. If you want, you can also send me some request of songs that I can compare.
ultimatekpop Loved it
Great idea! Please do more. Happiness - Red Velvet (OT4 ver/OT5 ver), Rum Pum Pum - f(x) (OT5 ver/ OT4 ver), and EXO's songs ^^
This is such a cool idea, would love to see videos like this with KARA, Nine Muses and AS comparisons.
You can do with Red Velvet's song
Yey you're doing SNSD!!!! You haven't done SNSD for a long time :')
Jessica's high note is the best part.
Girls generation's creation, is the best part.
I really love Taeyeon's high note here, but is true, Jessica's version of the high sounds so amazing, I think I like it more! Even now, 4 years after I'm still sad that we can't listen again to these amazing girls sing together :c But.. At least we can still hear Jess in her music and we can keep supporting our Soshi girls ♡ Fighting SNSD! Fighting Jess! ♡
9
I liked Taeyeon’s more...
EVEEEEERRRRR
Jessica is a big part of SNSD's songs. She sings most of their chorus with taeyeon.
Technically SNSD relied on Jessica's vocals a lot. As much as I love SNSD, you can tell that there's this gap in their songs without her voice.
Raina i agree she has a high voice ! and this is thank of high voices all the others voices can really fit together ...
It's more like Jessica has such a unique voice that she can either harmonize with the group or add flare to the whole song
hibiki jaeger I agree. If you watch their live performance for Into The New World in Seoul concert. TaeYeon voice is good alone but right when Jessica join the harmonize and song just sounds so good.
taengsic no 1
Disagree. I really enjoyed lion heart album and sailing without Jessica's voice. You only hear the difference when you listen to them sing past songs when Jessica is there and when she isn't. Jessica wasn't the only person who made up the vocal line. They are still fine with or without her
I got instantly sad when I heard Taengsic hit that high note together…😿😿😿😿
It's a godly sound
Reminds me of The Boys 😭
Snoopy Mochi Gee
0:43 BLESS YULSIC 😍😍
Who's your bias in SNSD ? (OT9)
That was so good
Magnificent Vocalist Mine is Jessica Tiffany and Yoona ❤❤❤
YulSic😍
YulSic 💖💖💖😍😍😍😍
*They all obviously looked HAPPIER in the OT9 version. 😔😔 Especially SUNNY.*
J • Okay. If OT8 is what you call happy is. 👌 I won't disturb your opinion.
J • Okay? 😂👌 Noted.
I got what you mean tho.. like comparing to both video... like eyes say it.. kinda...
Tyas NP Yes. That's exactly what I was trying to say.
The pressure is really hard on OT8, this is the 1st song without jess and at that time they also practiced for tokyo dome concert. i think they are also afraid like how ppl will receive them after jess left.
Sunny's face looks happier in ot 9 😿
I was gonna say tht
All the members just look aggravated in the ot8 version. I think they were probably irritated and disappointed that they had to film it all again, especially as 8 and not 9.
right . Sunny looks happier and has powerful dance on the ot9 version the whole time (if you look at clearly )
Actually, Sunny is the only one who's less smiling in the ot8 version. All the others one are more dynamic. :')
She's like whatever fuck this shit 😭😂
"Like" if you repeating the part of taeyeon and jessica's high notes
Congratulations. U got 142 likes
I have been waiting for this line distribution since the OT9 version was discovered. Thanks so much! You should do others!!
Still Jessica is a big loss to Girls' Generation. Huhu I MISS THE OT9 😭
Exactly
4 title tracks in 2015
0 in 2016
2 in 2017
0 in 2018
It really is especially since she was one of the main vocals of Girls Generation. 😞
I meant Girls’ Generation in general. Not the sub-units.
Jermaine Remegio Miss you so much 😭😭😭😭😭
This idea is so good.
And that thumbnail is on point !
thumbnail is TaengSic ❤💘
SO Jessica wins ;)
#1 For her last song
Are you suure ? I hesitate between both !
But In Divine she's still #1 :p
Divine I'm pretty sure was made after this song. This song was made way before and someone even found a clip of Jessica singing a small part of it during the reality show with her sister (she stopped herself though because spoilers). Divine was supposed to be her last song aka her goodbye song
Actually, the ot9 version of cmifyc was recorded around June because they recorded "vocally" right after they promoted Mr. Mr. If Jessica was still on the team all the way through The Best Live Tokyo Dome Concert, they would've perform Catch Me If You Can as a surprise for their Japanese fan. But either way, w/ or w/out Jessica, ot9 is still in our hearts.
Raina if divine suppose to be her last song..then why did she record this song..omg.. cant u even use your logic..
Mohamad Faiz Md Said divine is her last song, CMIYC ot9 was recorded before Divine but this video was leaked to public after divine, so people who doesn't know, think that CMIYC ot 9 is her last song, i mean can you use your brain please ? this video doesn't even include to their official video and some SONE still think this video is jessica's last video with snsd ! Ha 😂 GOD please !!!
You can easily tell that after Jessica departed from SNSD, the feels of the songs and performances aren't the same anymore because we all know that they lack something. They do not lack the talent, visuals or vocals but Jessica, they lack a precious member. Just what like Yuri said when they won Daesang Award *"We can only shine brightness as SNSD and when SNSD stand on stage as NINE."*
Still, support them as a group and individually. 💓
Imagine SNSD have a comeback as OT9 again! I would get a heart attack
RachelStewartA.R.M.Y won't happen (I wish, Jessica was their biggest loss)
SM won't allow it
SNSD ot9 was at dangerous boy series so maybe it could be like that in the comeback
i thought i was over this but seeing taeyeon sing jessica's line Immediately brought angry tears to my eyes lmao
Who else was gon sing it💀
@@JaWorld7 .... Jessica.
@@qetzia no jackass in ot8 I don’t see why you would get angry tears over a high note😭
2:31 TaengSic is so nice
cheap taengsic unite!!!
彭佑民 miss taengsic
No one will attend your funeral.
J • you are so fucking annoying hun. You are freaking everywhere related to Jessica's comments. We are here to reminisce some memories of ot9. Can you give a space for us too. Gtfo. If you don't like Jessica, get over it already bcs shes not in snsd anymore. I bet you're fucking happy and satisfied enough
J • lmao what kind of rubbish talk is that? I don't give a fuck about your non fave otp or whatever you want to call it. If you just said your Taeyeon deserves better well guess what, Jessica deserves better too hun. Don't be so damn biased about this thing just to fit your self liking for your only fave 😂😂
this is my favorite song cause this is the last video with JESSICA #OT9FOREVER
Ariel Shipper emm... Divine?
for me the last video with her is Divine
same for me it's the song that her vioce shined the most between all the members
the first and maybe the last time that sooyoung is the 2nd most line in OT8
That SooSic combo in the bridge is 😍 my 2 biases are the best! #fighting ❤
I got goosebumps at 2:32 when taengsic came in. Their voices really complement each other
I CANT SEE THE DIFFERENCE HELP
@@YoonaHolic876 because Jessica and Taeyeon have the same vocal flavour, that's why. The are considered as the twins of SNSD.
Catch Me If You Can will always have a special place in my heart. After it came out I was so sad with that clip of Jessica singing part of it in jessica and Krystal I knew she was suppose to be in it. The fact that we not only got the song, but the video too? Amazing. Bittersweet and perfect closure for me. Imagine how many other songs they could have versions of with her in them. I'm convinced sunny's bit right before the last chorus in You Think was originally Jessica. With songs like Boomerang being from 2008 and sitting on a shelf until 2012 who knows how many 'new' SNSD songs we are getting with her cut out of them.
MIKE Could you imagine her voice in Lionheart? Amazeballs
Tomy Roe yeees ah ; - ; that makes me sad to think about lol
True.. I think there's many more ot8 songs were originally ot9 songs.. Not cmiyc only.. They needs time to learn the song, recording, arrange n rearrange, choreography n many more.. If solo or duet maybe need less time but group with many members needs longer time for it..
I miss ot9 😭💖
Can we talk about how wonderful the TaengSinc high note sounds?
Sooyoung SLAY
With Jessica it's 100 times better :)
I'm still heart broken about Sica leaving
But I'm proud that Sooyoung got a lot more solos. She's my ultimate bias and she's so underappreciated a lot of the time
thats the only song sooyoung sing...
But she didnt leave so...
Favorite part: *Jessica's high note.*
Seriously who wouldn't like this idea? I used to comment on your videos the exact same OT8 thing you did at the end of the video (with the up/down arrows and stuff xD) So yes please make more of these :D
back to when jessica is still sm fav. most of you guys said without her others get more line which i can’t deny but admit it, her voice blend perfectly in every songs especially the harmony high notes with taeyeon. there’s always something we lose and gain in life but you need to cherish every moment. that’s what i think everyone should do ot8 or ot9. even if you move foward(ot8) you don’t forget the past(ot9)
One thing I have noticed since Jessica left and the others (Taeyeon, Tiffany, Seohyun, YoonA (Station & K2 OST)), Jessica was the sound of SNSD. That is to say, she is the only solo that stills sounds like SNSD. Taeyeon is a great singer and I really like YoonA's Station releases and Amazing Grace (K2), but it was Jessica's voice that I missed during 'Lionheart' and 'Holiday Night' promotions. I was not fully back onboard with SNSD until OH!GG Fermata.
I love ot9 version because Jess is #1 and her high note was beautiful. I love ot8 version because Sooyoung is #2. Her voice has improved so much. She should have more lines in snsd's next comeback.
Jessica's voice was FAN.TA.STIC in this song. Such a difference :(
Wow! I knew sooyoung was amongst the members who had the most lines but 2ND Get it sooyoung.
Proud of Sooyoung 💖
Same
2:32 I like Jessica high note more than taeyeon #Ithink
Super true 😘😘😘
Well i think you're an idiot
Me too, Jessica has a amazing voice for my ears
Taeyeon is better
It all comes down to preference, *which is an opinion* so downgrading someone for their opinion is invalid. Totally not @ing anybody
At first, SM town set jessica’s position to A leader, main vocal and lead dancer of snsd. She is 2nd Boa of SM. Everybody must know this fact. After that taeyoen take leader instead her and promote soo, yuri, yoona to lead dancer instead. Lastly, Tiffany take her main vocal line. But for old fan, we know she always leader, Main vocal, Lead dancer and Perfect visual too.
I really don't care about their positions, I just love Sica and that's all the matters :)
Although SM probably really assigned Jessica to be one of the members of dance line, I don't think Jessica dances that well when comparing to Hyoyeon and Yuri, or even Sooyoung and Yoona. When I see them doing the same choreography, Jessica's steps looks a little different and she looks a little weird.
@@rychan78 nah she only lost to Hyo and Yuri. She obviously better than other members even there a reason why she is center in ITNW opening. SM can chose Hyoyeon or Yoona to became center in ITNW opening but no, SM chose Jessica instead.
Thats just show Jessica not only have vocal, but dance and visual. I can say that at least she in 3rd place when it came to dancing after Hyo and Yuri. It just she became lazy years by years since she has anemia, and she also a main vocal, so she chose to not focus on dancing.
I honestly LOVE this ❤️❤️❤️
Who started crying when TaengSic was harmonizing the high note? Cuz I was!
Jessica always has a different vibe, though she has a high pitched voice the way she delivered is perfect. Also her vibrato is something always admirable. And her part are always tacky. And she uses chest voice most of time. Great ❤
2:32 angel 😢😢 jessica omg i miss that angel highnote
That's means Jessica has a lot of lines in last song I'm so happy but it's kinda sad too at the same time another 3 members has left then the only 5 members in SNSD now I wish someday they will perform and comeback soon as a complete 9 members for the fans only I hope SM company will my wish someday I know some fans want to see them as 9 members like they did to S.E.S they're complete as 3 members
The Line distribution is so much fair without Jessica... I'm happy cause Sooyoung finally get #2, but I feel empty without Sica..
bitch wtf the line distribution in ot9 is so much fair too 😉
what do you expect the dancing lines can get tons of lines like the vocal lines
Fair ? Lol
Ask Hyo about that
It's actually less fair now because sunny and seohyun get less lines now and there leads vocals. I luv tiff but she literally taking all the lines for the distribution now .
The line distribution isn't actually fair even when Jessica is still in SNSD. I know that Taeyeon is really a great singer and all but common let's face it that when it comes to distribution of lines she has like every single line. Back then, they excused that Taeyeon is the main vocal and the leader of the group. Hello there! Jessica is also the main vocal but there's a time that she only got a few lines, and when it comes to the leader thing, I believe you don't use that excuse when it comes to the music industry like some of the leaders in a KPop group has a few lines because they give the chance to others. And when you say that Sooyoung finally had the chance to be number 2? like I really like Hyoyeon, Yuri, Yoona and Sooyoung but what exactly is their position in the group? I remember that Yoona and Sooyoung are the lead dancers while Hyoyeon and Yuri are the main dancers, right? I'm not saying that they have to stick to their position in the group but I think that is their position because that's what they do best. So don't expect that they'll receive more lines than the main and lead vocal of the group. Don't take my comment in a negative side. I just want to clear those mind of yours. I hope it helps.
This is a great idea. I have suggestion, though!
You could totally use this for a center distribution. One bar for when they're actually in the middle and the other for when they have the spotlight, whether it's in the back or at the sides. It would make more sense, I think!
Great job, totally liking this vid! Also I finally subscribed. Every time you upload I check out your channel, Idk why I wan't subscribed yet. Anyway, love this!
콱아론 Very interesting idea!
콱아론 that's actually a great idea! I like it 😄
it's crazy how ot9's distribution was more fair
im happy for sooyoung though! when she's usually at the bottom, seeing her climb from 4 to 2 makes me happy.
For me the song is better with jessica tho 😢 I miss Sica
Jessica 2:32-2:36 No one else can sound that angelic/otherworldly. OT9 version is clearly better.
Sooyoung really Control this song
Although Taeyeon is the backbone singer and strongest vocal of the group, it’s mainly Jessica’s uniquely soothing voice and adlibs that elevated majority of their songs to a higher level. Without Jessica, yes, Taeyeon and the remaining vocal line can still carry the songs, but they just sound flat and dull. None of them can cover Jessica’s lines and adlibs the same way that it used to harmonize with Taeyeon’s vocals quite beautifully - not even remotely no matter how Seohyun and Sunny trained to be at their best.
YESSSS! I've always thought of this idea, and I really wanted one of the K-POP RUclipsrs to cover it~ YOU DID WELL!
I don't know why, but that's the first video where I find that OT8 better that OT9 version. I am really happy that yoona and sooyoung has most part of jessi's line. For that, they really can prove that they have really awesome voice
Ikr? Usually they always in the bottom especially Yoona but i am so happy to see Yoona ranks 4th for this song..my fav💜💜💜
Sunny in ot9: 😃
Sunny in ot8: 😐
whenever jessica is in a line distribution, Taeyeon and Jessica rule the Line distribution, but wothout her, its more even
We miss you Jessica...Very miss you😢😢😢
good video
My Queen Sica dominated! I miss OT9 so much especially with the 10th anniversary album coming up. So sad :')
Dominated???? Lolll. Are you being delusional. She only has an extra 1 second. Idiot
Tiffany stays unbothered what a concept 😌
Yoona Seohyun
this is interesting... Yoona Sooyoung and Yuri benefited the most by Jessica not being in the group for this first song.. but in the end Jessica's voice is so unique no one could replace her... we will never know the full truth but .. SooYoung's parents are said to have put up a big fight over Jessica... I do believe Jessica was voted out.. I also believe Sunny could have stopped all of it since her uncle was an executive at SM... but sunny didn't want to stop it.
Sooyoung was one of the reason Jessica left ryt
Glad to see you are coming back \0/
Seohyun has sunny's catch me if you can during the first dance break
I've known Girls generations since 2008, when I was a kid. I remember the good times that watching her videos and trying to dance with my cousin provided me. Seeing this video really hurts for me, I miss Jessica :((((
Am I the only one who liked the OT8 one better..? It looked cleaner and more together, and of course I'm never gonna say no to more lines for YoonYulSoo WOO 😁👍❤️
OT8 was shot after but OT9 had the vocals
Much better with Jessica 😔
0:57 THE BOYS DANCE
Wow you're so creative this video so amazing thanks to make this video. 😆😆😆😘😘
JESSICA ❤❤❤❤❤
Thumbnail Taesica ❤️
Sooyoung
Girls' Generation - Catch Me If You Can (With Jessica) (Line Comparison)
OT9 ver:
Jessica: 25.9 sec 16.2%
Taeyeon: 24 sec 15%
Tiffany: 20.8 sec 13%
Sooyoung: 20.6 sec 12.9%
Sunny: 16.6 sec 10.4%
Seohyun: 16.5 sec 10.3%
Yoona: 13 sec 8.1%
Yuri: 11.5 sec 7.2%
Hyoyeon: 11.4 sec 7.1%
OT8 ver:
Taeyeon: 29.7 sec 18.5% (+3.5%)
Sooyoung: 28.2 sec
This is such an awesome idea and the execution is amazing! I hope you do more of this in the future 😄
Please do more of these for their older songs and for groups that are missing a member. Either way for this song, Hyoyeon is still last, she basically kept all her lines
They could have done a better job at distributing the lines among the 4 dancers because Hyo still came in last...
Primer comentario!!
Primer like!!
okay
marifer valencia yeah!!! alguien que habla español ❤
Siiii somos dos
marifer valencia 3 7u7r *muy tarde ya lo c :v*
The time when I heard Yoona's high notes, I know it's exactly belong to Jess. It's really rare to see Yoona's high note even though I know she is also a good singer.
Mostly groups will immediately disband when they lost a member but thank you for the rest of 8 members who keeps SNSD name alive.
You go girl sooyoung finally❣❣❣❣❣
that Jessica's angelic voice😊😊 i miss her so much😭😭😭
Jessica has a lot more line's there than taeyeon
Miss our Queens 9 😭💔
Miss TaengSic so much :( ✨🌹
Love this presentation
Oh thank u Jessica make my day!!
Jessica 1 lugar 25.9
Taeyeon 2 lugar 24.0
Tiffany 3 lugar 20.8
Sooyoung 4 lugar 20.6
Sunny 5 lugar 16.6
Seohyun 6 lugar 16.5
Yoona 7 lugar 13.0
Yuri 8 lugar 11.5
Hyoyeon 9 lugar 11.4
I can't hide our WOW! Thanks!
Tifanny's "meomchul su eopseo" is producing both my life and death even though it is japanese
I feel happy on this distribution.. Oh Sooyoung..
WOW GOOD IDEA ^-^
jessica jung💕
i really love the YoonSic ,YulSic ,SooSic ,& TaengSic part xD
My two biases on the thumbnail 💖💖💖💖
don't cry for Sunny she had the power to stop this Sunny's uncle is Lee Soo-man is the founder of SM Entertainment and he had the ability to end it. Sunny wanted Jessica out of the group.. we will never know the reason why but it is most likely all about Money and maybe misplaced honor.. Jessica was dating a Billionaire and started a Clothing Line with stores in NY and other Cities. Their contract agreement is all outside ventures and endorsements are shared by the group and SM. SM gave the OK for Jessica to keep everything from her clothing line.. then the girls realized how big her business could become and they wanted part of it. SooYoung's parents are said to be one of the biggest reasons .. they are wealthy and probably decided to sue SM for a breach of contract and the amount would have been so big that it would have seriously hurt SM... Greed broke up GG... and then that Greed was the end of GG... so foolish... even SM never recovered.. they don't have any top acts anymore and always were at the top... I would like to see Jessica be backed by one of the Big recording companies and I would bet she would be a top performer today even considering her age.. If JYP gave Jessica a chance and some good songs and high quality MVs for her songs she would still pull an audience.. as it is she is on her own and she is still an influence bigger than the other girls in GG that have big companies behind them but can't get ahead... only Taeyeon does ok but people have soured over the breakup.
with jessica was better but well she now following her dreams .. ._. hope all best for her
Sooyoung baby u are the best
2st
Safa Natiq there's no 2st. it's 2nd lol
Omg this is so cool
Kinda like an idea I had where at the start of the song Jessicas bar was full and when someone covered her part her bar decreased and the covering members bar increased but in blue for Jessica. but this is way better!! Could u do other GG songs like Mr Mr etc?? :D
3BenjNZr Your idea would be very triggering for me lol
My bias (OT9) and my bias (OT8) on the thumbnail 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
when the one kicked out gets the most lines in her last song...
I mean she always that girl 💅✨
Wow!! Jessica has the highest lines with 25.9. Thanks for the videoo.
Yoona voice - hunny
jesssssicaaaa ❤
Thumbnail is TaengSic 😍😍😍 so nice ❤💘😙😘😚
The only thing better in the ot8 was their hair and makeup