EPIC THE MUSICAL: The Thunder Saga delivered the goods like Odysseus delivered men to Scylla

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @MathewMcKenna
    @MathewMcKenna  4 месяца назад +884

    rip to the chomped crew

    • @margaretjoy_stucky
      @margaretjoy_stucky 4 месяца назад +13

      In order to

    • @chailatte_
      @chailatte_ 4 месяца назад +7

      rip 😔

    • @TheSapphireEclipse
      @TheSapphireEclipse 4 месяца назад +5

      agreed

    • @BGtheGiraffe
      @BGtheGiraffe 4 месяца назад +8

      You should react to the outsiders a new musical

    • @KiyaahSK
      @KiyaahSK 4 месяца назад +3

      Hi could you react to murder drones ep 2 and its really underrated in my opinion even kinda better than the amazing digital circus so please react to it

  • @NordemRay
    @NordemRay 4 месяца назад +717

    "Imma listen to it in order"
    *Proceeds to jump straight into the Thunder Saga, ignoring all five others*

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +44

      I am actually mad about this he is butchering a story Jorge

    • @Fandom_gremlin123
      @Fandom_gremlin123 3 месяца назад +12

      I know i am kinda pissed 😡

    • @mb-sb5ever
      @mb-sb5ever 2 месяца назад +6

      Please can you list all the songs in order, I watched a playlist before seeing the 3 reactions and I didn't recognize 2 of them (I assume alternative songs to ones in the og playlist) and if possible could you put headings of the saga for each section if that makes sense, like Matthew I need visuals so by knowing the order I can make sure I've got the correct visuals/ make a playlist myself

    • @WeaWoo1288
      @WeaWoo1288 2 месяца назад +24

      ⁠@@mb-sb5ever
      The Troy Saga
      1. The horse and the infant
      2. Just a man
      3. Full speed ahead
      4. Open Arms
      5. Warrior of the mind
      The Cyclops Saga
      1. Polyphemus
      2. Survive
      3. Remember Them
      4. My Goodbye
      The Ocean Saga
      1. Storm
      2. Luck Runs Out
      3. Keep your friends close
      4. Ruthlessness
      The Circe Saga
      1. Puppeteer
      2. Wouldn’t you like
      3. Done for
      4. There are other ways
      The Underworld Saga
      1. The Underworld
      2. No Longer You
      3. Monster
      The Thunder Saga
      1. Suffering
      2. Different Beast
      3. Scylla
      4. Mutiny
      5. Thunder Bringer
      The Wisdom Saga (Newest Saga)
      1. Legendary
      2. Little Wolf
      3. We’ll be fine
      4. Love in Paradise
      5. God Games

    • @mb-sb5ever
      @mb-sb5ever 2 месяца назад

      @@WeaWoo1288 thankyou, I did a bit more research as those are the songs i found but Mathew had two other songs on one of his other videos so i found out that there are other saga's in progress and made a playlist on my account (I've made it public if you want to check it out)

  • @Tiporax
    @Tiporax 4 месяца назад +2435

    "Odysseus turned from mercy to villainy so quickly"
    I mean, there was a character arc...

    • @BernadettSuvak
      @BernadettSuvak 4 месяца назад +311

      I mean there was a whole first act

    • @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483
      @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483 4 месяца назад +103

      @@BernadettSuvakI mean, there was a whole first act

    • @BernadettSuvak
      @BernadettSuvak 4 месяца назад +45

      @@PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483 Yes, that's what I meant. My brain isn't functioning today 🙃

    • @89ceilidh
      @89ceilidh 4 месяца назад +120

      If he’d watched it in order, he would know that 👀

    • @theshamonk668
      @theshamonk668 4 месяца назад +128

      “Wow! He changed so quickly” he claims while refusing to watch it in order

  • @jayden_arsonew
    @jayden_arsonew 4 месяца назад +2274

    tbf epic is one of those musicals that actually MUSICALLY make so much more sense in order, bc jorge plays around a lot with musical motifs and themes

    • @Dani_77709
      @Dani_77709 4 месяца назад +97

      I agree. The experience is much more enjoyable and emotional.

    • @SavannahLobotomy
      @SavannahLobotomy 4 месяца назад +10

      Yes fr (also hi jay lol)

    • @jayden_arsonew
      @jayden_arsonew 4 месяца назад +8

      @@SavannahLobotomy thanks i know i'm right (hii peanut lmao)

    • @bored_potato
      @bored_potato 4 месяца назад +6

      im a bit concerned on how this would play out in broadway, because i thought there'd be like moments of non-musical dialogue intertwined in the script should the musical be actually played on stage but as it turns out, it's gonna be entirely straightforward like hamilton.

    • @anvithequarsonist
      @anvithequarsonist 4 месяца назад +15

      especially the reprises. the luck runs out reprise in mutiny isn't that remarkable to listen to on its own but when you've listened to the ocean saga it hits _way_ harder

  • @iammatt3174
    @iammatt3174 4 месяца назад +1190

    "He went between sparing the Cyclops to murder so quick" THIS IS WHY WE WANTED YOU TO WATCH THINGS IN ORDER! If you watched the underworld saga it would make so much more sense to you! 😂

    • @favourezeh2011
      @favourezeh2011 3 месяца назад +14

      YES!

    • @Shipwreacked164
      @Shipwreacked164 3 месяца назад +8

      Exactly

    • @VegaTheLyra
      @VegaTheLyra 3 месяца назад +38

      He doesn't get that Ody became the monster (rawr rawr rawr)

    • @Imjustnat
      @Imjustnat 2 месяца назад +10

      @@VegaTheLyra✨I am the monster rawr rawr rawr!✨

    • @VegaTheLyra
      @VegaTheLyra 2 месяца назад +2

      @@Imjustnat the obligatory line lol

  • @WarFlame
    @WarFlame 4 месяца назад +1142

    Matthew: blame the sirens for everything.
    Comment section: no matthew its your fault for not watching in order

    • @WarFlame
      @WarFlame 4 месяца назад +86

      Also, the Latin teacher in me had to add, Odysseus ties himself to the mast and his crew have beeswax in their ears in the actual Odyssey. Circe/Tireseus are the ones who gave him the route and such. But Jorge changed it to this and in this musical it makes the most sense and also the song slaps

    • @IlieTornes
      @IlieTornes 4 месяца назад +50

      To be fair, everyone was extremely confused during Suffering, no matter how many songs they’ve heard before

    • @WarFlame
      @WarFlame 4 месяца назад +22

      @@IlieTornes that's very valid. I was mostly just trying to be funny, lol

    • @halfknight2310
      @halfknight2310 4 месяца назад +27

      which is true. he'd be less confused IF HE WATCHED THEM IN ORDER!

    • @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483
      @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483 4 месяца назад +17

      @@IlieTornesI honestly thought Odysseus was asleep again like in keep your friends close, but then I heard the word ‘daughter’ and was like: wait a damn minute

  • @firstwaddledee9182
    @firstwaddledee9182 4 месяца назад +393

    “Went from spare the Cyclopes to kill them all like that” that was THREE SAGAS AGO

  • @spiralgalaxy3209
    @spiralgalaxy3209 4 месяца назад +2766

    I can confirm that i would absolutely steal Mathew's first born if he didn't react to Epic Sagas in order

    • @JRWIFAN
      @JRWIFAN 4 месяца назад +88

      i'd help

    • @Aivi_xoxo
      @Aivi_xoxo 4 месяца назад +69

      im down to help u

    • @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483
      @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483 4 месяца назад +63

      Is there a form I can sign so I can take part?

    • @Inari_sama35
      @Inari_sama35 4 месяца назад +25

      Count me in

    • @damiennightmaresx7950
      @damiennightmaresx7950 4 месяца назад +38

      i might do it anyway for getting info wrong despite him saying "oh i know this story" apparently thats a lie.

  • @justtye7966
    @justtye7966 4 месяца назад +492

    “He turned from hero to villain real quick.” OF COURSE HE HAS! It’s almost like there was a whole 20 songs that lead up to him changing his morals. The core theme is literally, “when does a man become a monster.”

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +13

      Literally 3 fucming saga of suffering

  • @yourlocalnoob4938
    @yourlocalnoob4938 4 месяца назад +438

    The thing is that Odysseus DIDN'T sacrifice his crew in previous "adventures". Yeah, he's caused their deaths accidentally, but Odysseus is the man who refused to leave any man behind at Circe's island. He basically did what he thought was "right" and showed mercy throughout the first act only to get fucked over time and time again, leading to his turnaround in Monster. I think it does a disservice to the writing of the musical to ignore the character shift and just go "Oh, he's always disregarded his crew, lol".

    • @lizziekaptain843
      @lizziekaptain843 4 месяца назад +79

      Yeah. "Hey we blatantly ignored not just the Captain but KING, to kill this cow. Oh wait ZEUS is pissed off and making you choose? Have us suffer the consequences of OUR actions that could have been avoided or you die at the hands of ANOTHER FREAKING GOD and you don't see your wife and son? What? We have to pay for our actions?!?! How dare you?"
      Let's not touch on the fact that they could be charged with treason if they had managed to make it home. Unless I'm wrong. This made me irritated if you couldn't tell. Lol all that to say I agree with you.

    • @KefkeWren
      @KefkeWren 4 месяца назад +38

      @@lizziekaptain843 Not to mention that Eurylochus is literally the one that advocated, "We should abandon everyone and make sure you and I get home" on Circe's island. He legitimately cares less for the lives of the crew than Odysseus does. Plus the one that opened the wind bag (again, against the orders of his captain and king) and got them caught by Poseidon in the first place. If not for him, they'd have had the blessings of Aeolus and been home already. The only reason he has to be mad about Scylla is that he wasn't let in on the plan, and could have ended up being one of the ones getting eaten.

    • @Thecreepy_one
      @Thecreepy_one 4 месяца назад +13

      Also the people are starving at sea if they dont mack it home they die ider way 6 lives so the remaing 28 mack it home AND LIVE, not menshning ON IS THE KING, that seams pretty fair

    • @hadrianhexe9603
      @hadrianhexe9603 Месяц назад +5

      The thing is, the whole time he wasn't being punished for doing what was right, he got fucked over for being dumb, largely due to the fact he was angered by Athena who shamed him for being merciful.

    • @allthingsjustice6465
      @allthingsjustice6465 17 дней назад +1

      Also
      Odyessseus went to the cyclops island looking for food for everyone.
      Circes Island the crew just barged into a strange woman's home with out asking questions - who got them out? Odeysseus.
      Who killed the gods cows?
      Who opened the wind bag?
      I dont care for the crew. Half the shit was their own faults and then blamed ody cause "he's in charge" when none of them listened to him before.

  • @Linz_Chick
    @Linz_Chick 4 месяца назад +1087

    "Its such a fast change from having mercy on the cyclops to 'KILL THEM ALL'"
    No... no it was not...

    • @Orion_44
      @Orion_44 4 месяца назад +106

      Literally 3 entire sagas excluding the ones each point was in

    • @halfknight2310
      @halfknight2310 4 месяца назад +73

      and this is why he should have watched it in order. but I don't know why he refuses

    • @nicocorral4580
      @nicocorral4580 4 месяца назад +32

      He talks over most of the songs anyways :/

    • @Synthesyn342
      @Synthesyn342 4 месяца назад +32

      That’s what happens when you don’t listen to the Circe saga or Underworld saga and skip right to the Thunder saga.

    • @venrisulven
      @venrisulven 4 месяца назад +6

      Its such a fast change from asking for mercy from circe then going "kill them all"
      Even if it was multiple sagas just take a step back. He asked for help from circe, went to the underworld, and saw everyone dead
      After that from just these songs he just goes "WHOS WITH MY WIFE" next song "I WILL MURDER EVERYONE IN MY WAY" then thunder saga starts. Like honestly the main reason hes a murderer now is just a misunderstanding from the prophet. These songs aren't explaining how long in between each song or anything else thats happened in between so they all feel right after each other.

  • @char3909
    @char3909 4 месяца назад +1518

    "everyone has been telling me to listen to this musical in order so ive decided to heed that advice and skip directly to the start of act 2!!!!! 😁😁😁" /lh

    • @shanajeangedeon9060
      @shanajeangedeon9060 4 месяца назад +80

      It's because he did the other songs, but out of order😂

    • @IlieTornes
      @IlieTornes 4 месяца назад +20

      LITERALLY

    • @NiniSharktyle
      @NiniSharktyle 4 месяца назад +86

      ​@@shanajeangedeon9060 I'm pretty sure he hasn't listened to some of the songs, but I could be wrong.😂💀

    • @shanajeangedeon9060
      @shanajeangedeon9060 4 месяца назад +96

      @@NiniSharktyle No, yeah. He definitely still missed plenty, but he probably doesn't even remember or realize it😅

    • @char3909
      @char3909 4 месяца назад +29

      @@shanajeangedeon9060 true but its not like he did All of them theres a loaddd missing + the first 2 albums have been rerecorded since

  • @ilariacapasso520
    @ilariacapasso520 4 месяца назад +846

    I think you are a bit confused, to watch in order you have to see first the Troy Saga, then the Cyclops Saga, the Ocean Saga, the Circe Saga, the Underworld Saga, AND THEN the Thunder Saga

    • @АружанМақсатқызы-ш7ш
      @АружанМақсатқызы-ш7ш 4 месяца назад +36

      I think he does it on purpose?He also reacted to wotm,my goodbye,ruthlessness and just a man(+some other songs)

    • @ilariacapasso520
      @ilariacapasso520 4 месяца назад +71

      @@АружанМақсатқызы-ш7ш Initially I didn't know, I noticed after watching this video because the others were suggested, but it irritates me a bit how he doesn't react in order to the songs, they kinda lose meaning. He did the same also with Hazbin Hotel, I adore his reactions, but the not chronological order does annoy me a bit

    • @fleischsalat318
      @fleischsalat318 4 месяца назад +37

      He watches some shows in order like Ever After High and Hazbin Hotel, but he seems to refuse to watch EPIC in order. When I found his first reaction for EPIC it brought me here and I love his reactions (mostly to things I know before to be honest) but then he stopped EPIC and I was so sad. I watched other reactions by him but I got so disappointed after EPIC wasn't coming anymore 😭

    • @ilariacapasso520
      @ilariacapasso520 4 месяца назад +7

      @@fleischsalat318 But there was a video in which he reacted only to the songs of Hazbin Hotel, not the episodes those ones are in order, and the songs weren't

    • @mingan3781
      @mingan3781 4 месяца назад +6

      He meant in order by listening to the songs in a saga in order

  • @Bydnelg
    @Bydnelg 4 месяца назад +628

    "I will watch it in order" by clearly skipping four full sagas to get here, haha your great.

    • @PilotLyric
      @PilotLyric 4 месяца назад +47

      I know right, he just skipped 5 whole sagas. I don't understand how can he enjoy this EPIC Musical fully

    • @nicocorral4580
      @nicocorral4580 4 месяца назад +11

      He talks over the songs alot unfortunately :/

    • @galantina4086
      @galantina4086 4 месяца назад +34

      @@nicocorral4580well it is a reaction, it’d be weird if he just listened and never talked at all.

    • @galantina4086
      @galantina4086 4 месяца назад +12

      @@PilotLyriche does this with everything he reacts to, it’s fun for him this way. And I can see why, waiving together things from different songs and see where they fit is fun

    • @soup1118
      @soup1118 4 месяца назад +3

      Relax, he can't just react to all of it in one video. He spreads his reactions to different media equally, therefore he can't have time to react to all of it. It'd be more enjoyable, but if you don't like it then no need to be ACTUALLY irritated, lmao. He just figured he'd listen to the latest one. If he checks the other ones out, good for him. His reactions are fun, at least.

  • @flingkong24
    @flingkong24 4 месяца назад +1102

    Fun fact: I recently learned that Eurylochus is literally Odysseus's brother-in-law as Eurylochus is married to Odysseus's sister.

    • @Aivi_xoxo
      @Aivi_xoxo 4 месяца назад +138

      That is in no way, shape or form a fun fact

    • @astralgirl3352
      @astralgirl3352 4 месяца назад +92

      ​@@Aivi_xoxo how about this one: Jay considers making a backstory for Eurylochus after Epic. Now is left to see if he wants to keep Eury as Odysseus' brother-in-law in his lore or not

    • @JaneD0e_LuckyNxmbr7
      @JaneD0e_LuckyNxmbr7 4 месяца назад +31

      Odysseus better have put a drachma under Eurelochus’s tongue in the final part of thunder bringer

    • @IlieTornes
      @IlieTornes 4 месяца назад +54

      Odysseus has some things to explain to his sister when he gets back to Ithaca

    • @siverikapash
      @siverikapash 4 месяца назад +18

      @@flingkong24 wtf Ody's got a sister??? WHY I DIDN'T KNOW THAT

  • @thinkpnk4184
    @thinkpnk4184 4 месяца назад +418

    I'm so mad for people misunderstanding Odysseus
    Like he's definitely not a good person but as a character it was totally understandable and logical.

    • @missdarling7806
      @missdarling7806 4 месяца назад +12

      Real !!

    • @peanutpuppyboiprayforukrai1072
      @peanutpuppyboiprayforukrai1072 4 месяца назад +41

      Thank you! He was a bad person, but he was justified in being one!

    • @heavenlypillar
      @heavenlypillar 4 месяца назад +54

      also, the crew was really stupid.

    • @nope6610
      @nope6610 4 месяца назад +37

      Totally! His crew just backstab him and being stupid. If he chose them, whose to say that the crew will survive?

    • @laenaeverwood7453
      @laenaeverwood7453 4 месяца назад +49

      Thing is a lot of his choices maximized the possibility of survival. But more than half the time its either cuz of factors outside of his hands (accidentally stumbling on the cyclops), or others fucking his choices over (Eurylochus opening the bag).

  • @Greeter1987
    @Greeter1987 4 месяца назад +132

    When we said, "Watch it in order", we meant the whole musical.
    My man skipped straight to act 2-
    Please, listen to the rest, there's like a million callbacks made throughout the musical and it's less impacful when you haven't heard the other songs. That being said, here's a list of my personal favorite animatics of each song in order :
    (Oh, and a lot of things in the Thunder Saga would hit much harder, so if you listen to the others, consider giving the Thunder Saga another listen)
    Troy Saga :
    The Horse And The Infant, by gigi
    Just A Man, by gigi
    Full Speed Ahead, by WolfyTheWitch
    Open Arms, by Yon Hara
    Warrior Of The Mind, by WolfyTheWitch
    Cyclops Saga :
    Polyphemus, by mircsy (I personally prefer Wolfy's animatic, but mircsy is the only one who's done both Polyphemus and Survive, so doing mircsy's Polyphemus animatic would be better, since it leads straight into Survive)
    Survive, by mircsy
    Remember Them, by WolfyTheWitch
    My Goodbye, by WolfyTheWitch
    Ocean Saga :
    Storm, by Xinema Natzel
    Luck Runs Out, by Crashite
    Keep Your Friends Close, by gigi
    Ruthlessness, by gigi
    Circe Saga :
    Puppeteer, by gigi
    Wouldn't You Like, Xinema Natzel
    Done For, by AnniFlamma
    There Are Other Ways, by gigi
    Underworld Saga :
    The Underworld, by TheeArteest
    No Longer You, by Krieo
    Monster, by gigi

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      This boost this maybe if we break down fully for him he understand

  • @jayden_arsonew
    @jayden_arsonew 4 месяца назад +478

    this saga is right after the act one closer: monster, where odysseus decides he has to be more ruthless to get home, hence the "he is the man made monster"

    • @dropletq3477
      @dropletq3477 4 месяца назад +1

      wait i thought this was the act one closer?

    • @jayden_arsonew
      @jayden_arsonew 4 месяца назад +14

      @@dropletq3477 suffering is the first song of the second act

    • @dropletq3477
      @dropletq3477 4 месяца назад +1

      @@jayden_arsonew oh. well my mistake

  • @aidenk.364
    @aidenk.364 4 месяца назад +337

    It was not a quick turnaround, Matthew, there were three whole sagas of character development! Watch the whole thing in order, not even as a reaction!

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +6

      Straight I don't need the reaction I need him to understand the story

  • @kriszgamer0013
    @kriszgamer0013 4 месяца назад +308

    The main reason why is it important to listen to it in order is because musically there are a lot of callbacks and foreshadowings to other songs in the musical, also this is NOT a 1 on 1 adaptation of the Odyssey. So it will show new things to even those who read the story.
    12:43 NO! IT WAS NOT SUDDEN! This is why you listen to the songs **in order.** You see the end of a whole Act 1 long character development!

    • @aludra.w.b
      @aludra.w.b 3 месяца назад +12

      Also the "fvk Odysseus!" when it was mostly Eurylochus' fault shit hit the fan... Tell me you didn't watch more than half of the sagas without telling me 😭😭😭

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +1

      There was literally a whole arc god this annoyed to no fucking end lord

  • @chailatte_
    @chailatte_ 4 месяца назад +1270

    the title is absolutely FOUL 😭😭

  • @2873surabi
    @2873surabi 4 месяца назад +333

    Mathew: it's the suffering saga
    Me: boy 👏 you don't even know!

  • @Ewifications
    @Ewifications 4 месяца назад +275

    the whole musical, mathew!!! the whole musical in order!!!!!!!

  • @margaretjoy_stucky
    @margaretjoy_stucky 4 месяца назад +354

    You might need to go through the whole epic saga again

    • @SoraJack
      @SoraJack 4 месяца назад +27

      He's never going to.

    • @PilotLyric
      @PilotLyric 4 месяца назад +10

      ​@@SoraJack unfortunately you are right

  • @cinder_x3
    @cinder_x3 4 месяца назад +87

    Mathew honey please😭 it makes sense to listen to the WHOLE thing in order not necessarily because of the story but for all the musical motifs and reoccurring melodies and lyrics and themes like trust me it's GOOD

  • @akaniuwu
    @akaniuwu 4 месяца назад +214

    16:15 I've never laughed so hard at a comment before "where are you gonna run, the other side of the boat?" lmaooo

  • @jacggg
    @jacggg 4 месяца назад +69

    “He went from Mercy to being a villain real quick” please. Please listen to the rest, I BEG 😭

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      Yup wasn't quick about 3 sagas of ahem "suffering" and now he is murdering

  • @opalgem1868
    @opalgem1868 4 месяца назад +145

    “Why does he look evil?” Me having heard the song “Monster.”👀

  • @oreocooki3375
    @oreocooki3375 4 месяца назад +67

    "Why is ody acting evil suddenly?" IDK MATHEW. MAYBE CAUSE IN THE LAST SONG OF THE UNDERWORLD HE SCREAMS ABOUT HE'LL BECOME THE MONSTER TO MAKE IT HOME (jokeing) 😂😂😂😂

  • @IlieTornes
    @IlieTornes 4 месяца назад +142

    It’s so funny that Mathew posted this video to redeem himself, and ended up getting INCINERATED by the comment section anyways 😂😂😂

    • @halfknight2310
      @halfknight2310 4 месяца назад +52

      he basically chucked wood onto the fire he made. and turned it into an inferno.

    • @IlieTornes
      @IlieTornes 4 месяца назад +14

      @@halfknight2310I LOVE this metaphor 😂

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +2

      Yeah cuase he is ruining the story that Jorge meticulously formed

    • @IlieTornes
      @IlieTornes 3 месяца назад +9

      @@abramdelisle5746 He’s not “ruining” the story. It’s still there. Mathew’s being chaotic with his way of watching the show, but everyone acts like he just committed a crime. It’s funny, but not that big of a deal

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +3

      @user-yh6kx6rr8z it's disrespectful to Jorge who spent the time and effort for his work to be enjoyed in a certain way. He is misrepresenting what epic is.

  • @fiaghost4759
    @fiaghost4759 4 месяца назад +125

    him talking about stealing firstborns in the intro. does he know. DOES HE KNOW

  • @nitatv3395
    @nitatv3395 4 месяца назад +133

    This is why we watch things in order, Mathew. In case you or anyone else doesn't know the order, it's Act One with Troy Saga, Cyclops Saga, Ocean Saga, Circe Saga, and Underworld Saga. Thunder Saga is the first saga in Act Two. I'd recommend you support Jorge and the EPIC cast by listening to the (new) official Troy and Cyclops saga concept albums and not the... old ones...

  • @mayadargeon2172
    @mayadargeon2172 4 месяца назад +110

    But he didn't sacrifice anyone before Scylla tho? The men who died at the Cyclop's hands were victims. The ones killed by Poseidon got killed because Odysseus doxxed himself in a fit of indignation to Athena and because Eurylochus was enough of a doubting moron to open the wind bag, despite them being so close to Ithaca they could see it and Ody explaining that the bag had the storm inside. Eurylochus WANTED to abandon the men stuck under Circe's spell to their death and Odysseus was the one that managed to calm things down with her.
    Scylla is very much the first time Odysseus actively sacrificed someone to get back home since the infant of Troy, and the first time he sacrifices his crew period. And Scylla was a necessary stop if they didn't want Poseidon to kill them all.
    Add to that the fact that Euryochus decided to rebel for something he would've done too, and that his first act as captain is just lead the crew to their doom by killing Helios' cow, and frankly, in Odysseus' place, I would've snapped back at them faster than Zeus could get a woman pregnant. I'd wield those lightning bolt my fucking self, actually.
    As Eurylochus himself said, he wanted all the power, then he must now carry all the blame.

    • @sadat4101
      @sadat4101 4 месяца назад +13

      I think the small difference folks forget is that, asking Odysseus to not go against a clearly powerful witch who turned their men into pigs and accept their losses. Is different from Odysseus not telling them they were going to the Lair of Scylla. I took it that he got the information from the siren alone, while the others handled her companions.
      It didn't seem like anyone expected that they were going into a battle. Because it wasn't going to be a battle; Odysseus alone made the decision to offer sacrifices to avoid a battle. I know because they're so close to Charybdis, it might seem worth it, but he's not the only person who wants to get home and if the blame is Eurylochus alone opening the bag, then what did those 6 men do so wrong?
      While Eurylochus is at fault for opening the wind bag. I think anyone would go...it's different if we suffer losses but our captain and King tries to minimize them. He's fighting with us and for us. It's very different if you were on the ship and went...you didn't even give any of us a choice or ask if we were willing to be sacrifices. While he told Eurylochus to light the torches, he also made him responsible unknowingly for the death of 6 men, because he chose who'd be the victims. Unwittingly saving himself when trying to assist another man.
      Mutiny makes sense after all they'd gone through because all the suffering and dying has meaning up until you realize you're expendable. It also makes you question when the change occurred or if it was always there. Whose to say Odysseus has been suffering losses because he views everyone as expendable. So long as he lives and with the power dynamic, it's all fine, no matter how high the cost may go - as he said in Monster.
      Unfortunately, as King of Ithaca and so close to home, Odysseus realizes the cows are likely Helios. But he broke trust with the crew. So compared to their suffering and despair, his pleas are one voice against the many who are starving and sick of losing. In the end, he MUST shoulder all the blame as the leader. Eurylochus messed up when he opened the bag. But Odysseus messed up when he refused Athena's word and gave the Cyclops his name. In the end, it all begins with Odysseus. So even this betrayal too...stems from that one choice.
      The foil of them both just being men, driven by emotion, pain, or anger is the crux of the story. Anger, pride, and hubris made Odysseus tell the Cyclops his name. Disappointment, despair, and hunger made Eurylochus kill the cow for a chance at survival and to stave off starvation. Those two reasons are far from the same in what drove a poor decision.
      But this is my little box of analysis, I do understand where you're coming from in the view of the situation.

    • @vic-c2x
      @vic-c2x 4 месяца назад +13

      I think the problem is that everyone is focused on the fact that Eury represents the crew, that they forget that the fist person to actively lead them to slaughter is Eury. He opened the bag while he was not under any stress compered to their journey so far. And the whole crew knew and hid it from Odyssey. They where the first to, in a way,backstab Ody. His mistake was sparing cyclops,yes, but even before and after that fact he worked to get as much of his people home as possible. I think he just lost all faith in them, and knew that no matter what he does for them, in the end he would suffer by their hand.

    • @karolinebergin9347
      @karolinebergin9347 4 месяца назад +9

      ​​@@sadat4101 him giving his name to the cyclops should be irrelevant in this conversation bc he immediately made a plan with a god to help them getback safely, he explained what the rules were to his crew but still they betrayed him bc Eurylochus was doubting him left and right and spreading that doubt - also left and right- which Odysseus warnt him from but that guy just wouldn't listen. Yes, Odysseus made one mistake, his crew made multiple ones and at the end of the day those were actually the important one's...

    • @jlablue3401
      @jlablue3401 4 месяца назад +13

      @@sadat4101 There are enough similarities between the two situations to realistically call Eurylochus a hypocrite, which Ody does. "Let's just cut out losses, you and I, and let's run" versus "Don't make me fight you brother, you know you'd have done the same." With all the thought put into the musical I have to believe it was an intentional choice on Jorge's part. I'd also add that is has been confirmed telling the Cyclops his name wasn't motivated by pride or hubris. It was motivated by grief.

    • @sarapagan3577
      @sarapagan3577 4 месяца назад +9

      ​@@karolinebergin9347 this is the conversation I was looking for because I was so upset for mathew to say that the mutiny was deserved and the right choice was to sacrifice himself. I'm not saying Odysseus has no wrong doing and I completely understand why the mutiny happened however how many times had Odysseus saved his crew up until that point. They literally went through like a 10 year war and Under his leadership they had survived. He may have made a mistake while fighting the cyclops but the only reason any of them made it was because of Odysseus. The crew was ready to kill the cyclops blocking their only escape and the only reason they had an escape was because of Odysseus spiking the wine. He was resourceful and found a way home that the crew messed up. A bunch of the crew got turned into pigs and he fixed it. He realized the stuff with the sirens prevented more death and found a new way home.. Even with sacrificing 6 men what was the alternative. For the most part they probably would have lost so many more people and in the end that is why he is the captain he wasn't happy to do it but when you look at it there wasn't much else to do. So in the end morally if you have to kill one person vs many yes the morally right choice is the one person but in my opinion the crew did the mutiny the crew decided to kill the cow so it is their consequence to bare.

  • @tevildo7718
    @tevildo7718 4 месяца назад +322

    I can't believe Matthew managed to talk over and miss the most fucked up line in Different Beast "Let them Drown."

    • @legitimatemedicine
      @legitimatemedicine 4 месяца назад +48

      Yeah, he uses "I listen to things out of order because I only care about the music" yet refuses to actually hear the music either

    • @aquitabrown3248
      @aquitabrown3248 4 месяца назад +34

      @@legitimatemedicine
      And yet still he’s like ‘wait what’ whenever he doesn’t understand

    • @legitimatemedicine
      @legitimatemedicine 4 месяца назад +22

      @@aquitabrown3248 Bro wasted his own AND our time

    • @rachelmr24
      @rachelmr24 4 месяца назад +7

      I don’t know. His confusion is kind of entertaining. Part of the charm of his channel.

    • @tevildo7718
      @tevildo7718 4 месяца назад +14

      @@rachelmr24 I don't mind his confusion as much as some of the replies, but really musicals are very much the sort of songs you cannot get away with his style of reactions, I really think he'd be better off pausing and rolling back a bit when he wants to say stuff like other reactors.

  • @miss_eyem
    @miss_eyem 4 месяца назад +101

    It wasn't a quick change from mercy to kill em all Matthew, we spent the entirety or act 1 with Ody desperately wanting a way no more men died

  • @lop90ful1
    @lop90ful1 4 месяца назад +133

    Bro watched an musical out of order out of spite then got a most inaccurate take ever "Fuck Odysseus" when he is the only sane one, honestly its a suprise the crew survived this long with how stupid they were

  • @MasterZeus94
    @MasterZeus94 4 месяца назад +58

    Zeus is not the Sun God, yes. He is, however, the God of Justice. So if Helios wants divine retribution for his cows being eaten, it's time for Big Z Energy to show up.

  • @soarinknightstudios
    @soarinknightstudios 4 месяца назад +227

    And this is why we listen to things in order Mathew.
    Anyways the Thunder Saga is the start of Act II of the musical.
    (In case you do decide to go back and listen to them in order: Troy Saga, Cyclops Saga, Ocean Saga, Circe Saga, and Underworld Saga are all act I in that order.)
    Update: You are own your own in terms of f*** Odysseus. Like his right hand, Eurylochus, literally betrayed Odysseus by opening the bag of winds the wind god gave him and they were so close to home. (Which sent them straight into the hands of Poseidon who then killed 557 men.) And then on Circe’s island when the men got turned into pigs Eurylochus wanted to leave the men for dead and Odysseus was the one who went back to save them.
    Not saying Odysseus is the BEST person in the whole story however everything that happened in the last song was Eurylochus’s fault. He was the one who killed the Sun gods cows. (Apollo is the sun god and so he sent his father Zeus to deal with Odysseus and his crew.)

    • @Emmet0223
      @Emmet0223 4 месяца назад +24

      I would like to play devils advocate and defend Eurylochus here.
      The main point I see is that he opened the wind bag. I agree that was his mistake, although it was rooted in distrust towards Odysseus after he saw Polites die, it was his fault. I don't agree that he caused Poseidon to kill them though. I would say Poseidon was going to kill Odysseus' men either way, whether or not the bag was opened because of Odysseus' actions in survive. I would argue Poseidon was going to "intercept" and kill the men either way.
      For the Circe incident, I would argue that a lot of people misunderstand Eurylochus. Eurylochus didn't "want" to sacrifice and leave the men behind, he thought it was unwise for Odysseus to go after Circe. He didn't want the men to die, but he knew his crew would fall apart without the captain. He was right too. If it wasn't for "plot armor" (Hermes' Moly), Odysseus would've likely became a pig and left the crew without a captain.
      For the Scylla incident, he was right to be mad at Odysseus since he willingly sacrificed the men, unlike Eurylochus just not wanting to lose more men.
      Finally, for the Zeus incident, he killed the cows because their whole crew was demotivated and starving. He was obviously backed by the crew, shown in the end of mutiny and their inaction towards him killing the cows. He did die for his mistake of killing the cows and that was his fault, but you should see where he's coming from about travelling for 12 years and seeing a lot of pain and suffering on the way. Odysseus is blinded by his love for Penelope and is making risky/prideful decisions (Polyphemus).
      I'm not saying Eurylochus was a good person, but I am saying that he doesn't deserve all the flack that he is currently getting from the Epic community.

    • @Orion_44
      @Orion_44 4 месяца назад +22

      It's actually Helios' cattle, not Apollo's

    • @mattmayhem4377
      @mattmayhem4377 4 месяца назад +14

      He’s not alone! Eury had character development, growing as a person, and Odyssey became Ruthless, the crew support Eury because despite his mistakes, he cares for them and attempts to shield them from further pain. Ody at this point -as Scylla mentioned- “deep down only cares for himself” so Eury isn’t one guy going rogue, he consistently acts as the hand and voice of the crew, whereas Ody only acts in the interest of seeing his wife.
      I like Ody and u deist and his point of view, but I disagree with the idea that Eury is worse than Ody, and I don’t understand calling him a hypocrite, because it almost implies that being consistent in your opinions is more important than fighting for what you believe in now. Eury’s actions in thunderbringer is that he is a man on the brink of starvation who realises Ody would sacrifice any number of crewmen to see his wife (there is no price he won’t pay), and decided to act

    • @felixhenson9926
      @felixhenson9926 4 месяца назад +8

      ohhhh is that why? I was like why did Zeus come over Helios's cattle? and i do think in the story it is Helios who tends a herd, Apollo is more of a hunter

    • @soarinknightstudios
      @soarinknightstudios 4 месяца назад +8

      @@mattmayhem4377 I never said Odysseus was better or that Eurylochus was worse. Both he and Odysseus are in the wrong MULTIPLE times throughout the musical. Just wanted to state that in this case I stand with Odysseus.

  • @M.M.G_Brickfilms
    @M.M.G_Brickfilms 4 месяца назад +69

    The reason why Odysseus looks so evil a lot of the time is because this saga follows the act 1 finale, "Monster" in which odysseus realizes that he needs to let go of mercy (as Poseidon said) in order to get back home.

  • @alinovastark9269
    @alinovastark9269 4 месяца назад +22

    "He turned from mercy to killing so quickly!" WELL, maybe if you watched it in ORDER and see the character arc. MR. MATTHEW MCKENNA.

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +3

      3 fucking sagas of suffering did that to him I am unreasonably upset he did this

  • @imaqueen223
    @imaqueen223 4 месяца назад +59

    NOOOO DUDE HE’S A MORALLY GREY CHARACTER WE’RE SUPPOSED TO EMPATHIZE WITH AND CONNECT WITH, HE’S NOT MEANT TO BE “GOOD” HE’S MEANT TO BE A MONSTER TO PUSH EVERYONE ASIDE TO GET HOME. DON’T SAY THATTTT

    • @foxynonym6384
      @foxynonym6384 4 месяца назад +5

      Truest thing I've heard all day

    • @MildlyPerturbed
      @MildlyPerturbed 4 месяца назад +5

      Best take! Can’t believe people miss this!

    • @Konpeimimi
      @Konpeimimi 3 месяца назад +8

      Not only that but the ENTIRE point is that ALL THE MORTALS ARE SUPPOSED TO BE IMPOSSIBLE TO FULLY CHEER ON.
      Odysseus does stupid shit that puts his crew in danger. His crew does stupid shit that they are directly told not to do because it will kill them just for the sillies. The gods and stronger beings all further torture Ody and his crew, some for survival and some for justice/revenge. The entire point is that everyone makes choices that have snowball effects and no one person can be blamed for the outcomes of the story, they can only adapt and try to learn from what happens.

    • @imaqueen223
      @imaqueen223 3 месяца назад

      @@Konpeimimi I ACTUALLY FULLY LOVE THIS OMGGG, PEOPLE ARE FLUID X STUFF JUST HAPPENS

    • @happeth801
      @happeth801 2 месяца назад

      ​@@KonpeimimiPenelope is mortal and did nothing wrong.

  • @bumblebeetlebee5187
    @bumblebeetlebee5187 4 месяца назад +40

    careful mathew, your firstborn might get thrown off a wall to end the trojan war

  • @fiaghost4759
    @fiaghost4759 4 месяца назад +103

    "The Suffering Saga" the most accurate way to call it tbh

  • @KingsBard
    @KingsBard 4 месяца назад +78

    In the story the rest of the crew did the beeswax thing while Odysseus tied himself to the mast so he could get the information, in this version he also did the beeswax but read the siren's lips.

  • @BeAuTyLoVe17
    @BeAuTyLoVe17 4 месяца назад +66

    The whole musical in order Mathew!! We're begging you! D':
    There's so many details that you can appreciate so much more when listening in order

  • @dreya_moosik_queer5804
    @dreya_moosik_queer5804 4 месяца назад +34

    About the line “we are the man made monsters”, my sister told me that there are 3 like hidden meanings to it:
    1. Men made monsters - they were men made into monsters
    2. Man-made monsters - they were made into monsters by one man - Odysseus
    3. /Man-made/ monsters as in unnatural - they were made into such terrible monsters (Odysseus too) that it was unnatural for all of them
    I swear Jorge is the smartest musician on earth and he has all my respect. His work is absolutely amazing and impressive

    • @dreya_moosik_queer5804
      @dreya_moosik_queer5804 4 месяца назад +3

      She also told me that the six torches that Odysseus told Eurylachus to light was for the six men that were sacrificed to Scylla, so he would have to live with the guilt of the death of those 6 men like he had to with the 558 of the crew that were lost to Poseidon. That’s why he couldn’t answer Eurylachus in Mutiny; because getting home and seeing his family wasn’t the reason he did that.

  • @WarFlame
    @WarFlame 4 месяца назад +58

    You would recall a song with haunting overlapping vocals if you listened in order from the beginning 😂😂😂😂

  • @Omega_WoIf
    @Omega_WoIf 4 месяца назад +100

    This bro needs to start from the very beginning to understand XD

  • @chongwillson972
    @chongwillson972 4 месяца назад +19

    8:23
    to be fair, being afraid of the water while being a sailor proves how good you are as a sailor.

  • @bluecretan7441
    @bluecretan7441 4 месяца назад +77

    The reason he's framed as a monster is because that's what he's decided to be, basically shutting off his empathy to get home

  • @firstwaddledee9182
    @firstwaddledee9182 4 месяца назад +26

    Mutiny means so much less if you haven’t heard Luck Runs Out before. WONDER WHY WE WANT YOU TO LISTEN TO THEM IN ORDER!?

  • @heather_r
    @heather_r 4 месяца назад +15

    "Calling Odysseus a monster feels so dark"
    Me, casually glancing at the last song of act 1: hmm, it's almost like you're missing context

  • @FurFlameCreations
    @FurFlameCreations 4 месяца назад +50

    The more I listen to this saga in context with the other ones, the more I kinda see Ody's side
    I mean, it was between all of them dying to Poseidon or sacrificing 6 men to Scylla
    Then my man is like "don't kill that cow bro or we all will die" and then they did
    Without Ody, we know they wouldn't of made it home without him
    Ody's original plans to make it home would of worked if Eury never betrayed him and opened the bag
    It truly is not just a saga, but a whole story about endless suffering.

    • @anta_otomedev
      @anta_otomedev 4 месяца назад +4

      It doesn't help that Ody's name literally means bringer of pain/suffering

    • @MildlyPerturbed
      @MildlyPerturbed 4 месяца назад

      @@anta_otomedevor the one who causes anger

  • @gracegaert
    @gracegaert 4 месяца назад +42

    Not Mathew completely missing The Underworld Saga (aka the best saga)

    • @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483
      @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483 4 месяца назад +3

      Nah Troy saga bops. Mainly because it has the solo open arms sung by my boi Polites. And it has Just a Man. And Warrior of the Mind.

    • @kairi99roxas
      @kairi99roxas 4 месяца назад +2

      Absolutely agree, No Longer You and Monster are by far the best songs so far!

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      I see where you are coming from but I like the troy saga best

  • @Lilghost1412
    @Lilghost1412 4 месяца назад +58

    The WHOLE musical in Order! PLEASE!
    Other than that great video

  • @fleischsalat318
    @fleischsalat318 4 месяца назад +28

    9:12 It's an official concept album for the Musical and not a one man show, Mathew 😂❤ it's actually different people singing. Jorge aka Mr. Jalapeño himself, gathered a lot of people around himself to voice different characters 😄

  • @nope6610
    @nope6610 4 месяца назад +16

    Love how the comments just wanted him to react in order lol.
    I agree.

  • @tobylangan
    @tobylangan 4 месяца назад +51

    JUST WATCH IT FROM THE BEGINNING

  • @silvertongue231
    @silvertongue231 4 месяца назад +55

    Odysseus is like the embodiment of the phrase live long enough to see yourself become the villain

  • @Meloned_turtle176
    @Meloned_turtle176 4 месяца назад +36

    "im gonna listen to it in order"
    Proseeds to start halfway through
    Yes i know he did two other vids but thats like 8 songs, some of which aren't even f*cking finished
    Also, epic the musical out of context

  • @sunnysunsins
    @sunnysunsins 4 месяца назад +35

    Oh i know this is gonna piss me off so much

    • @Devilspade
      @Devilspade 4 месяца назад +24

      "wow ody really switched up out of the blue" NO HE DID YOU MOTHER-

  • @xSilverEchox
    @xSilverEchox 4 месяца назад +34

    Greatly enjoying Ody's descent into Villainy and Matthew continuing to not listen in order.

    • @nope6610
      @nope6610 4 месяца назад +3

      He's just doing it on purpose at this point lol

  • @grifgrif_4
    @grifgrif_4 4 месяца назад +19

    MATTHEW, LISTEN TO THE ENTIRE EPIC MUSICAL IN ORDER AND MY LIFE IS YOURS!!!!

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      I would spend my left kidney if he watch in order. Just so he could appreciate it properly

  • @chyala_drawing
    @chyala_drawing 4 месяца назад +27

    Actually in ‘Suffering’ and ‘Different Beast’, Jorge chose a new approach to the siren situation, in which Odysseus tries to communicate with the sirens to know how to escape Poseidon
    But in the original Odyssey, the whole crew puts beeswax in their ears (to be immune) except Odysseus because he wants to be the first man alive who has heard the siren’s song. So he asks his crew to tie him to the mast and not release him no matter how much he begs for it

    • @Sevencatsinatrenchcoat
      @Sevencatsinatrenchcoat 2 месяца назад +3

      It was also to let the crew know when to remove the beeswax. When they were out of the vicinity, he wouldn't be struggling to be free

  • @Megamanlanprime
    @Megamanlanprime 4 месяца назад +14

    So I think you’re missing a bit about Mutiny and Thunder Bringer.
    - the God of the Sun mentioned is Helios, Greek Titan of the Son who is the embodiment of the Sun and sees most everything that happens. He told Zeus.
    - while it sounds like it’s just Euriochus that kills a cow, remember that he generally speaks for the entire crew and everyone is now singing his lines except Odysseus.
    - It’s common for Captains to be held responsible for things their crew did. So Zeus is asking Odysseus will he take the punishment for the crimes of his crew or let the crew face their own judgement. Odysseus chooses to have the crew to suffer their own fate because a) He needs to see his wife, but also b) they did mutiny so he now rejects them as his crew as they rejected him as their captain

    • @anastasija6866
      @anastasija6866 4 месяца назад +4

      And he even warned them, they decided their hunger was far to great and they gave up going home, well they dug their own graves

  • @fleischsalat318
    @fleischsalat318 4 месяца назад +18

    Please TAKE THE SUFFERING FROM US, and listen to every Saga in order. We beg you to. Mathew 😭😭😭💙
    You might listened to one saga in order but you stilled missed the story. Even if your familiar with the Odyssey Jorge Rivera Herrans isn't only retelling. He made this his own written story and it is so awesome.
    Every winion here would come and watch you again when you finally go on this journey 😭

  • @Sarah-Has-Arrived
    @Sarah-Has-Arrived 4 месяца назад +21

    Mathew: *jokes about how his viewers are mad at him for watching EPIC out of order*
    Also Mathew: *proceeds to make them more frustrated by not fixing his mistake and watching Act 1 in order to get the proper context before jumping into Act 2*
    💀💀💀

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      Thunder is the ending to act 1. Your point still stands, though

    • @Sarah-Has-Arrived
      @Sarah-Has-Arrived 3 месяца назад

      @abramdelisle5746 …no it’s not? The Underworld Saga is the end of Act 1. I can see why you would think Thunder is the end, but it’s not. Jorge has been clear from the beginning that the end of Act 1 is Underworld.

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      @@Sarah-Has-Arrived you are correct and I am dumb. I don't why I though that

    • @Sarah-Has-Arrived
      @Sarah-Has-Arrived 3 месяца назад

      @abramdelisle5746 lol it’s okay! Like I said, I can see why people would think Thunder is the end of Act 1. There are a LOT of callbacks to songs in Act 1 and it definitely ends on what would be a great cliffhanger.

  • @Laronez
    @Laronez 4 месяца назад +26

    To be fair, his options were
    1. Save the people who had mutinied and tied him up and killed Apollo's cow friends, when he knows for a fact that they would throw him under the bus EVERY TIME because they refuse to listen
    2. He could save his own life, let the traitorous friends who fought beside him in war and he had to personally save at least 3 times at this pont die, and head home to Ithaca where his wonderful wife and child that he hasn't seen in more than 10 years are waiting.
    Neither were GREAT options, but as a husband and father I would take option 2 every time. The six members were initially sacrificed so that Scylla wouldn't have any available mouths to eat more people (Six mouths, six torches given to people at random, six dead men)

    • @anastasija6866
      @anastasija6866 4 месяца назад +12

      And let's be honest if Odysseus died they also wouldn't last long after him, he falls asleep they open the bag, he let's them go scout alone they get captured and turned into pigs, he is knocked out during mutiny they decide to harm Helioses cattle, Odysseus is the only person on that ship with even half a brain cell and the crew are worse then toddlers

  • @justlazykid
    @justlazykid 4 месяца назад +44

    Lots of things would make more sense if you actually watched the first act in order 😭

  • @siverikapash
    @siverikapash 4 месяца назад +32

    By the way, an updated version of the first two sagas has recently been released, with a better quality of sound, I strongly advise you to listen to them (the Troy Saga and the Cyclops Saga), in the right order of course

  • @riduanaqil1452
    @riduanaqil1452 4 месяца назад +41

    To be fair to Ody here, the crew was choosing death anyway like look at how long they survive after the mutiny. And Eurolycus is just not fit to be captain he'll abandon his crew the minute that they got into danger and without Ody, that'll be everyday

  • @patchworkgolem
    @patchworkgolem 4 месяца назад +20

    I would love to see you go back and listen to the sagas in order. There are so many motifs and recurring ideas throughout that are so good!!. Just make sure to listen to the new remastering of the first two sagas. He had to redo them since the original distibuters of the first two were not paying him the royalties he earned.

  • @Hero_DZN
    @Hero_DZN 4 месяца назад +68

    I RAN I STOPPED EVERYTHING I WAS DOING, LETS GO MATHEW

  • @finnsfolks
    @finnsfolks 4 месяца назад +14

    Honestly, I don't even feel too inclined to watch this knowing how much you skipped over, because part of the fun of these reactions, to me, is seeing how people react to the story as it develops and hearing all the musical callbacks (that you are completely missing by skipping over the whole thing). And seeing the comments all getting on you for that as well, I know that if I were to try and watch this, I'd likely be as frustrated as a lot of them are. Please please PLEASE, if you're gonna continue this series, do it in order like we are all saying to do or you WILL be confused and you WILL miss way too much. If you continue it in order, there's a really good chance I'll come back and give this video a shot. And I do really wanna, because how could I not get excited to see someone getting invested in a series I enjoy?

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад +1

      Seriously you can't react much lost break down or even probably enjoy epic without watching In fucking order

  • @icemagiciangh
    @icemagiciangh 4 месяца назад +25

    3:06 why everyone was shouting to watch them in order 😂

    • @confuseddot
      @confuseddot 3 месяца назад +2

      Cause when you listen to all the songs, there are motifs and stuff that carry through all the songs, and it's a musical, you don't start a series halfway through

  • @Mel-ou1eq
    @Mel-ou1eq 4 месяца назад +28

    You should watch the whole musical in order to understand it all and get the references!!!

  • @Emimilliemoo
    @Emimilliemoo 4 месяца назад +11

    Mathew: ahh yes dont worry I will listen to Epic in order
    Also Mathew: let me not have listened to all of act 1 and thos I did weren't in order.
    The thunder saga is the start of act 2 and is only a small part of it

  • @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483
    @PoseidonsWinionDaughter26483 4 месяца назад +26

    THAT TITLE- you take that back Matthew you take that back right now or so help me
    13:49 Matthew go back to Greek mythology class. Charybdis is the whirlpool monster. Charybdis kills by dragging people into whirlpools. Scylla is the sacrificial monster. She has six heads, thus needing six sacrificial *crosses out lambs* humans

  • @quethesparkle
    @quethesparkle 4 месяца назад +25

    Odysseus says "Row for your lives" after Scylla says hello, not "run for your lives"
    Bc yes they are on a boat
    With oars

  • @shadowserenity1879
    @shadowserenity1879 4 месяца назад +6

    Mutiny has so many references to old songs, it's kinda sad they're going over Matthew's head...

  • @Ajthingsandsuch
    @Ajthingsandsuch 4 месяца назад +18

    This mf doing everything but listening to it in order

  • @marth354
    @marth354 4 месяца назад +25

    Eurylochus: Kills 500 men and makes it so that they have to go through everything after meeting Aeolus which makes it necessary for Odysseus to sacrifice 6 to save the rest that remain. Also Eurylochus: "You sacrificed 6 of us because of my mistake! Die!"
    Gotta say, I have a hard time feeling bad for him. I feel bad for the rest of the crew way more. Odysseus has screwed up a ton; but so has Eurylochus.

    • @TheSaharay1
      @TheSaharay1 4 месяца назад +1

      Eurylochus wasn't the one who killed 500 men. That was still Odysseus bc he is still the person who PISSED POSIDEON OFF!

    • @marth354
      @marth354 4 месяца назад +6

      @TheSaharay1 Odysseus and Eurylochus are both responsible for that which is why I said Odysseus also has royally screwed up. But Eurylochus absolutely holds responsibility for it as well. If he had not opened the bag he was told carried the winds of the storm within it after his captain met with the wind god then they would have safely made it to Ithaca. They were nearly there. And if they landed then they would have safely escaped Poseidons wrath. So yes; they are both responsible for those deaths. Don't forget that Eurylochus is also second in command so I think it is fair to say he shares that responsibility since he did the act and holds a position of power within the crew.

    • @anastasija6866
      @anastasija6866 4 месяца назад +2

      ​@@TheSaharay1 Don't forget Polites, he's the one that wanted to listen to the Lotilus Eaters and went to the cave while Odysseus wanted to leave, Eurylochus also caused the death of Odys mother because she killed herself after the storm take them thinking they died

    • @TheSaharay1
      @TheSaharay1 4 месяца назад +1

      @@marth354 I don't think they would have escaped Poseidon's wrath once they landed in Ithaca. Ithaca is an island. And Posideon is the god of the Sea with a habit of carrying grudges long term.
      Assuming they would be safe just because they ended up on land at home is just naive.

    • @JaserJas
      @JaserJas 4 месяца назад +1

      ​@@anastasija6866 what's even the point of Ody's character if yall blame everything that went wrong on other characters??

  • @altarudragonspirit4016
    @altarudragonspirit4016 4 месяца назад +9

    8:45 If you watched it in order, maybe you would *know* what was and wasn't changed :3
    12:52 THE CYCLOPS WAS 18 SONGS AGO WDYM????

  • @ian3523
    @ian3523 4 месяца назад +6

    its not just the story but musically it makes so much sense when u listen to them in order since jorge calls back on earlier songs, makes references, etc

  • @fenrirswolh3
    @fenrirswolh3 4 месяца назад +4

    Jorge actually has a video explaining how he did the vocals for scylla. I kid you not, Jorge is the embodiment of Apollo with how he comes up with his pieces. Or a Child of Apollo, take your PICK.

  • @gabrielhermes1627
    @gabrielhermes1627 4 месяца назад +8

    In the original the sailors all place wax on their ears to not hear the sirens while Odysseus, wishing to know what the song sounded like, tied himself to the mast. So, pretty much the inverse of what you said, funnily enough.

  • @bradleybarnett1469
    @bradleybarnett1469 4 месяца назад +4

    As Eury said, “If you want all the power, you must carry all the blame.” Eury made the mistake, he should be the one who dies for his STUPID STUPID STUPID MISTAKE

  • @someonerandom1273
    @someonerandom1273 4 месяца назад +7

    what's so fucked is that in the musical, Odysseus tried his absolute best to keep his crew from dying at the start. He only started to lose faith in them after the wind bag situation and after that he still tried to keep them alive (i personally would've let them all drown). Can't really blame him for growing resentful of his crew, the deaths before the thunder saga weren't really "sacrifices", just shitty accidents.

  • @btmikey1925
    @btmikey1925 4 месяца назад +3

    I don't know if you've noticed, but Jorge (the one making all of this) loves to give each character certain motifs and instruments to represent them. So the electric guitar you've pointed out is Odysseus's instrument, the harp you noticed in the last one was Hermes, the piano is Athena's which is why it's so prevalent in her two songs, etc. That's why each song tends to have a super unique feel cause it morphs to match the theming of the characters present

  • @Waffily78
    @Waffily78 4 месяца назад +8

    If you want to watch it in order here it is
    Troy saga (remastered)
    Horse and the infant
    Just a man
    Full speed ahead
    Open arms
    Warrior of the mind
    Cyclopes saga (remastered)
    Polyphemus
    Survive
    Remember them
    My goodbye
    Ocean saga
    Storm
    Luck runs out
    Keep your friends close
    Ruthlessness
    Circe saga
    Puppeteer
    Wouldn’t you like
    Done for
    There are other ways
    Underworld saga
    Underworld
    No longer you
    Monster
    That’s it so far

  • @LadyGreensleeves33
    @LadyGreensleeves33 4 месяца назад +14

    Okay, you're getting there, but FROM THE BEGINNING, SIR! THIS IS ACT 2. You at least need The Underworld Saga lol. The last song of Act 1 is called Monster. But yeah, the crux of Scylla/Mutiny is Odysseus said 'light up six torches' - Scylla had six heads. He sacrificed six men knowingly to get home. As for Zeus, its all metaphor for him putting Odysseus in a position where his pride as Captain and King is stripped and his true selfish nature is revealed - 'Pride is a damsel in distress, hiding away where only I can undress her. Try as she may not to confess, in the end its all the same once I apply all the pressure. Thunder bring her through the ringer, show her I'm the judgement call, the one to make her kingdom fall."

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      Thunder saga is the end of act 1your point still stands though

    • @LadyGreensleeves33
      @LadyGreensleeves33 3 месяца назад

      @@abramdelisle5746 Thunder Saga is the first Saga in Act 2. Underworld Saga was the end of Act 1, making Monster the Act 1 closer. If you watched the Live Stream during either Underworld Saga or Thunder Saga's release it said End of Act 1 after Monster.

    • @abramdelisle5746
      @abramdelisle5746 3 месяца назад

      @LadyGreensleeves33 yup thats totally my bad i don't know how I got that confused

  • @m0ejo324
    @m0ejo324 4 месяца назад +9

    I understand people siding on the crew with Mutiny, however last time he trusted his crew with something, aka the wind bag, they did the opposite of what he said so now he has to figure a way to get home, while being chased by Poseidon after being so closed just to lose it because of the greed of the crew and not trusting them to act reasonable when they have to go through Scylla's domain. Also he still cared about his crew after what they did by trying to stop them.

    • @anastasija6866
      @anastasija6866 4 месяца назад +1

      And in the live streamed animatic, he doesn't even look at who got torches it was basically random, he only turns around to tell them to row for their lives

    • @m0ejo324
      @m0ejo324 4 месяца назад

      @@anastasija6866 which is the canonical events.

  • @wanderingnightfury3546
    @wanderingnightfury3546 4 месяца назад +10

    I am so glad someone else made the Lord Farquad connection 😂
    That said, while their mutiny was ABSOLUTELY justified, it was a little insane for them to think that Odysseus wouldn’t choose to save himself when Zeus came into the picture. Like, they literally just stabbed the man, I think it’s safe to say bridges were burned 🤣

  • @maco_macoRUN
    @maco_macoRUN 4 месяца назад +4

    As an aussie, i will find a way to string up matthew so that he listens to the 5 WHOLE ALBUMS that came before this one. i get he already listened to them but please, the 25ish songs in those albums make everything in the thunder saga hit that much harder.

  • @D3liciouspancakes
    @D3liciouspancakes 4 месяца назад +11

    Im happy that mathew is doing another epic video..however, i will steal his firstborn if he doesnt listen to it in order goshdammit. Ody's character arc makes more sense, he doesnt just go from merciful to ruthless that quick, at the end of act 1, in the song monster, is where he changes his ways. Nice video, this saga destroyed me more than a little :D

  • @MyName-ef8kv
    @MyName-ef8kv 4 месяца назад +7

    Lol, we're stealing that first born for skipping to act 2

  • @Stephanie-ju4yl
    @Stephanie-ju4yl 4 месяца назад +12

    You are definitely alone with the "Fuck Odysseus"

  • @GabrielGonzales1800
    @GabrielGonzales1800 4 месяца назад +8

    "Villain" he said, if you want to know why then listen to it in order. 😂😂😂

  • @genokira5056
    @genokira5056 4 месяца назад +5

    i love how mathew just said at the end prick to oddyseus even tho the reason they are in this situation at all is cuz the crew is the one that tied him up diddent listen to his warnings of not killing the best friends of a sun god and then they expect him to sacrifice himself for their crime

  • @spoopy3963
    @spoopy3963 4 месяца назад +5

    Mathew, this isn’t the beginning of the musical! /lh
    For future reference, it goes: Troy Saga -> Cyclops Saga -> Ocean Saga -> Circe Saga -> Underworld Saga -> Thunder Saga