@@hanabisakura1266 just because you don't understand something doesn't mean it must be 'magic' ... that's a 'god of the gaps' argument. If you think a god exists, provide some evidence for it...otherwise, have a nice day :)
@@hanabisakura1266 insanity is when a fifty year old MoMo forces himself on a 9 yr old. Insanity is when a 50yr old lusts for his own Son's wife.Above all this is cherished by the God
@@hanabisakura1266 Insanity is believing that all happens by the power of Allah , it has all being explained by science and now even us humans can fly in our planes , do planes fly by the power of Allah ?
@@rooibos786 The world has always been full of millions of gullible naive people who will fall for deception, that will never change, so never is probably apt
@@stoneworshipper2599 every detail of injustice, even doing good, is recorded. Absolutely nothing will go unrewarded or unpunished. Read the English translation of the Quran.
I have no idea whether Muhammad suffered from epilepsy or not, but you raise a very good question. Why would God allow his prophet to suffer such symptoms? After all, God is omnipotent and could have sent revelations to Muhammad without causing such a reaction in him. Today, the link between religious delusions and the various forms of psychosis is well established. Psychiatric hospitals are full of people who believe they are in communication with God. God would have course known about such a link with mental illness, yet appears unconcerned that it might cause doubt and skepticism of his crucial and final message to mankind. Whether Muhammad was epileptic or not, one has to admit that it is reasonable to expect an Omniscient and Omnipotent God would avoid causing such doubts.
What you said is absolutely correct. Some of the prophets in the Biblical tradition seem to be literally mentally sick. Take Abraham for an example. Abraham was a very old man and claims to have spoken with God on numerous occasions. These conversions often ended up in serious harm. On one instance, Abraham amputates his own foreskin and declares all of his descendants to go down the same mutilation, "as a covenant from God." And then later on something worse occurred. Abraham believed that God was telling him to sacrifice his son on Mount Moriah to see if he loves God more than his son Isaac. Fortunately the sacrifice didn't occur as "God intervened." I personally believe that Abraham is loosely based off a real person that explains the origins of the Jews and their most important customs, but that isn't the main point if Abraham is real or not. If someone like this existed today, we would all call that person insane. Believing God is talking to you and demanding that you and your offspring must circumcise as a mark of the flesh or demanding his son to be sacrifice to him, does not seem like a benevolent entity.
That's the same issue I had with the muddy spring verse in particular and all the other controversial verses in general. Even if it actually means what apologists say it means, why would God, knowing of, for example the Egyptian belief that the sun travelled in a boat to its setting place and similar superstitions, frame this verse like that. Is it to cause doubts? Why do we need to know how Zulkarnain perceived the sun to be setting and the nature of the spring? In general, why does the religion have to look so similar to the superstitions it came to replace? Why the black stone? Why the story of the wall gecko being the only animal blowing in Abraham's fire? Why won't grandpa Zakariah speak for three days as a token from God...?
God didnt coddle muhammad a mere human by not making revelation easy, therefore it's not from god? Your argument sucks. We are are talking about a god that burns people in hellfire and u care about a little shiver lol.
When my son had epilepsy ,he was losing consciousness,but sometimes, he would shout and make strange gestures,One night I had to stop him from jumping from the window while having a strange episod of epilepsy. Looks like he had the same episodes like Mohammad.. Thanks God he was successfully treated and he is fine now
I presume it was not god that treated him, but the nurses and doctors at the hospital?? I don't see you thanking these people who spent so much of their time studying and learning and practising their skills to help heal people. There is NO good convincing evidence that gods exist... doctors and nurses on the other hand are very definitely real.... maybe you should give thanks to where it is actually due and not to some fairy tale.
How is this similar to what the prophet experienced? I've yet to see a case of someone getting seizures and producing literature. Let alone using said literature to build a civilization. All these epilepsy explainations for what the prophet (pbuh) experienced seem far fetched.
It is deeply regrettable that medical science was not developed in the era in which Mohammad lived. Had it been, he could've gotten the help he needed and Islam would not have been thrust on the world.
It's funny how apparently a man who had epilepsy Conquered Half the world fought 70 wars and did not die Defeated Romans and Persians made a Law still countries Follow which are functioning today
@@yikis7989 He only conquered areas which is roughly the size of saudi before he died of poisoning, his jihadist genocidal ideology was carried on by this successors to invade the other countries. Byzantine & Sasanid empires was already in decline ages fighting each other before the arab muslim conquest(not muhammad). Sharia is a failed system enforced on its population by dictators in which most of their population migrate to the west to live under secularism
This a Topic alone is really enough to destroy the whole base of this religion . A totally eye opener and the one who is honestly and critically have to see the veil of truth.
As a matter of fact no single verse in the Quran can be quoted saying that Allah sent an angel called Gabriel to his servant Mohamed to deliver a message of Quran. Non. This is all from I n ishaq who was not eyewitness nor met Mohamed 100 years after his death. How do we rely on this Not eyewitness Allah in Quran doesn't mention it Then the stranger behaviour. Giving correct information like God is one which Muslims brag about is known by Satan And in bible it reads you say God is one you do well but even demons know and they shudder
Poor Mohd, he was born at a time where mental illness was not understood. Perhaps, had he lived today, he would've received the treatment he needed. The world would certainly have been much different 🤷♂️
When Muhammad met the angel Jibril in a cave in Hira and chokeslammed him making him see visions, he was in fact having a violent epileptic seizure. OMG.
@@kameelffarag Official psychiatric reports would help, but I sometimes wonder if they would not be too public about it because they do not want to offend religions.
That doesn't work most of the time, they'll just claim that Muhammad was the seal of the Prophets and everyone after him who claims to hear God is a liar.
I want to Muslims to think about why previous so called prophets especially Moses who talked directly to God didn't get any of these symptoms? which is supposed to be harder getting a revelation through an intermediary like an Angel as Mohammed did or getting it directly from God like Jesus and Moses and many others? heavy message my @s
Lmfao you guys are so silly, that’s why everything is called a sign. The signs are not supposed to be obvious, they guide like any other sign in this world, it can be possible he was epileptic, and that maybe that was an advantage to take in terms of “well now is the best time to communicate to him” but other than that, your argument, and yes with a completely open mind, is weak.
I remember a long time ago, I read a very old book online called "The History of the Origin, Family, Birth, Education and Teachings of the Great False Prophet Mohammed" published by Broer Jansz in 1640. He was a book printer in 17th century Netherlands and he wanted to debunk Islam. The book isn't the most accurate thing in the world and it contains illustrations, which shows 7th century Arabs in Contemporary European clothing (which was common in illustrations at the time). But one of the big claims this book made was a new revolutionary idea. That Muhammad didn't see the Angel Gabriel nor was he cursed by the Devil, but he suffered an epilepsy which caused him to hallucinate. From my research on Muhammad's life, I find this to be most likely what happened in that cave. Of course, the author being Christian, this logic can also apply to his own prophets, but that's a discussion for another day.
Fortunately for Broer Jansz, there were probably no Muslims in the Netherlands during the time in which he lived, otherwise he may have come to a grim end.
As a practicing muslim i had heard about these epilepsy theories and i was shocked how people could stoop so low . our scholars screamed its a zionist and western conspiracy to defame our prophet and finish off islam.Later in life when i read the hadiths in detail his symptoms during revelation shocked me how could divine revelation be so painful .
Islam is the only religion to offer solutions to the world's problems. All other religions are happy clappy. Not practical solutions. Aspects of alcoholism, gambling, modest dress, interest, etc
@@brotherben4357 most Muslim countries have no major degeneracy into alcoholism, gambling, toxic feminism, emasculating men, crippling interest rates and high poverty( except those that have been invaded by the west), homosexuality, transgender issues. Rape statistics are low or nearly non-existent. Crime generally is low. Family values are thriving with women having more than the average children in western countries. Decrease in the population in the west will lead to dire consequences in terms of the economy.
'A'isha reported that Harith b. Hisham asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): How does the wahi (inspiration) come to you? He said: At times it comes to me like the ringing of a bell and that is most severe for me and when it is over I retain that (what I had received in the form of wahi), and at times an Angel in the form of a human being comes to me (and speaks) and I retain whatever he speaks. Sahih Muslim 2333b Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: The bell is the musical instrument of the Satan. Sahih Muslim 2114 DING! 🔕🔕🔕DOOOONNNNGG!!!!
This whole epilepsy thing should be milked to the bone. You and/or the other Abdul should try to have a debate about this on modern day debate wit some Muslims.
Might be schizophrenia he suffered from before his prophethood. But later and particularly after Khadija's death, he used his condition to make people believe his verses.
Hi Abdullah. There is a channel/guy called "The friendly Muslim" and he seems like a nice guy. It would be so cool to see you and him converse about the evidence for the Prophet's epilepsy and how he thinks Farid responds refuted that, or just some other things about Islam. "The friendly ex Muslim featuring the friendly Muslim."
Very interesting! It's interesting to see how these Muslim scholars unwittingly prove that Muhammad was an epileptic madman. Keep up the great work! No amount of cope and denialism from the Dawahgandists can just say that these Muslim scholars are wrong.
Mohamed Ayad has an interesting video ,manufacturing of a prophet’ about his version. Like how Khadijah wanted to make her husband a prophet, to save their marriage, since she was too old to find another husband. Otherwise he would be declared to be crazy. And her cousin told him he’s a prophet to save her marriage.
@@zigzig9938 it never made any sense to me that Allah’s prophet is so confused and that too about the divine revelation ...its Khadijah who lectures him about his noble character.
Gabriel always removed the fear from the people he appears to by saying fear not, But muhammed knew what he saw , he said he saw a demon . Warakah misled muhammed by telling him it was Angel Gabriel.
@@soulmate5443 It is ironic, it took a Christian to make the basis of Islam lagit. If waraqa said nothing then we would not have Islam, or at least not in this way.
Dear Abdullah's, thank you for this. Keep addressing all aspects (emotional, psychological, textual, philosophical, historical, medical, factual, etc.) of religion. Despite believers saying both epilepsy and reevaluation can exist the messages need to get out.
This is great work Abdullah and is becoming more and more persuasive as time goes on. There are many pieces of the Islamic jigsaw puzzle from a balanced modern perspective, and this helps explain why even Mohammed and his companions thought he had received spiritual inspiration.
Iblees lives among angels . He refuses to obey Allah’s command even dares to argue and challenge him .. and on the other hand Allah’s beloved prophet sweats and shivers after seeing jibreel .. strange
Growing up I would randomly get seizures, shaking, very often combined with hallucinations... maybe I am the final prophet? They could never tell me what it was, wasn't epilepsy or anything... and now I am fine...
@@brunoheggli2888 In my first revelation Snakegod has told me to get rid of Islam, the Snakegod will be much pleased with this outcome... also he loves to be pleased by outcomes.
I am an epeleptic who did a degree on human vibration in relation to visual perception and interpretation. I have all types of seizures and did alot of research on this subject. There is so much that explains in great detail why neurological problems and environment can change your perceptions. sorry to say there is no soul as the word is made up by thiest also an individual experience is not enough to prove anything and never once didnt conect to somthing already in your body or mind . Even with countless studies of recorded events it always comes down to being learnt or enviromental factors that shows specifically that individuals only have visions of thier specific faiths e.g near death experiences when they see thier heaven as it was already described. There is alot we know and more to learn but it is extreemly frustrating if you dont have an answer to just insert god or faith its harmful and prevents people getting help they need. maybe mohamad would of got it if people had the right support. Its obvious he wasnt well even crazier people couldnt understand it so just enabled his dillusions n still do to this day. I have experienced pure happyness during a seizure and if i was a thiest i would of described it that way . As an athiest it can cleary be explained by chemicals in different parts of my brain n the part responsible was the area usually effected when on psychodelic drugs and religious revilations there is explinations if you look. Thank you for the video helps towards stopping stigma of these conditions and also misrepresentation so its apreciated.
Trance is a state of semi-consciousness in which a person is not self-aware and is either altogether unresponsive to external stimuli (but nevertheless capable of pursuing and realizing an aim) or is selectively responsive in following the directions of the person (if any) who has induced the trance. Trance states may occur involuntarily and unbidden. The term trance may be associated with hypnosis, meditation, magic, flow, prayer, and altered states of consciousness.
After hearing what? A stupid people and scare people. You can not stop Islam entering your homes and family’s life. It’s not possible and those lies are nothing but spreading Islam and people will notice the clips that are added is nothing but a lies.
The crux of the matter is Mo claimed to receive revelations following his fit and not before in response to experiencing the divine as some Muslim apologist would try to beguile others.
It's scientifically proven that immediately after a seizure people become poet and recite poem's. Some times these poem's hour's long. This is very common. Ask anyone who had seizure
I mean this is hilarious. Can someone tell me what happens to a person who lies deliberately and what happens to their body? Shiver and shaking because if he gets caught he will die and he knew it! xD
I'm not even religious, but even if you believe this stuff what kind of god/ angel makes you feel cold? Don't people feel cold when there's a ghost nearby? Seems like an unsettling presence tbh.
If you are a, Muslim, and reafing this, RUN!, RUN!, RUN!, from Allah, MuhamMAD, the Quran, and Islam. Repent and believe the gospel(Mark 1:15) while you still have breath in your body.
On what basis do these people assume that an epileptic seizure was a revelation from God? My uncle had seizures, but we were never ignorant enough to think he was talking to God.
In the pre- scientific age , among all peoples , strange but not totally outlandish mental states and the accompanying physical symptoms , occurring in s person were thought of as indicative of " possession" by some " supernatural " entity , good or evil , depending upon the person and the context . Not different for the tribes of Arabia of the 7th century . The writers of Hadeeths and other accounts thought so too - it was vindication that a "supernatural " force was active when such states happened to Mohammed. Otherwise they wouldn't have described them in detail. That conclusion was wrong , as we very well know now !
One of the figures that spring to mind is Rasputin in Russia and how he gained so much influence over the royal family especially the czarina in their time of crisis.That deep sinister look in Rasputin's eyes and the stories of Rasputin's sexual prowess.There is always a link with this type of person.
It could also have been an act on his part. I'm not convinced that these episodes were not him play acting to make it seem like something dramatic was happening to him.
Hypochondria, schizophrenia, dementia, fits, hallucination, megalomania, sadist traits,and all that disgusting stuff in one body😢 Really sickening to see his unfortunate ilk.😊
But when we read previous scriptures no where did this happen In tanakh the angels introduce them selves No fainting No panicking So Mohamed had issues and got false stuff. Accept this Muslims Allah couldnt kerp hom harm. Why figmer prophets never had this All thus looks satanic accept.
satan did nothing of the sort, since there is NO good convincing evidence that gods or devils exist... all part of your mythology... and not part of reality.
Qathem al-Quraishi claimed that a divine revelation called him to prophecy, and gave him the Koran. The traditional Islamic teachings tell us that Muhammad claimed to have been dominated by spirit when he was retired in the cave of Hira. He was forty years old. That spirit squeezed him so hard three times that he could not breathe and thought he would die by suffocation (Bukhari, Alwahi 3.1.1). She then gave him the first Qur'an, which contained the first mistakes of the Qur'an, which is that God “created man from a relationship” (Al-Alaq 96: 2). That was clearly a demonic evil spirit, because he tried to harm him. No one saw this alleged meeting. For this can not be proved. At first, Muhammad thought that a jinn or demon😈was deceiving him, or the cave might be inhabited. But his first wife, Khadija, and her cousin, Waraqa ibn Nouffal (his real father), urged him to believe it was divinely alive. It is impossible for this to be a noble appeal to prophecy. The Quran was already Waraqa's as he was a writer of Nasara Quran as a Nasara. Seek the true Messiah, who hears you through his living Spirit, he will judge the world and can transform your life, do miracles and show you the true one God.
It is clear the whole thing was fake. The first fright maybe happened. But the fact that his so-called revelations about the Last Day are taken in part almost word for word from the Gospel of St Matthew which was known to the Nazarene and Ebionite Christians around him at the time, the fact that he had the supposed Night Journey to Jerusalem shortly after the tribes of Medina said he might be the Messiah the Jews talked of, the fact that the Quraysh accused him of having people recite to him day and night, the fact he had scribes to write down his so-called revelations and that one of them, Abdullah b. Sa'd fled to Mecca saying 'If Muhammad's a prophet I'm half a prophet!' The fact that Muhammad had Abdullah's name on a death list when he conquered Mecca and the atrocities that he and his followers committed at the Battle of Badr show a ruthless desire for vengeance and conquest. Within five years of his arrival in Medina in 622AD, all the Jews who rejected him were exiled or dead. This guy was no weak epileptic. Even Aisha saw through his act saying how 'convenient' his later revelations were as a pretext for action. When the men did not want to attack Tabuk in the hot season, the 'revelation' came down 'The fires of hell burn hotter!' There is not a line in the Quran that cannot be explained by what was going on in his life at any given moment. 😁
Why Allah use a sick man? Can Allah not heal Muhammad if he wants to use him? Is Muhammad telling the truth? Is Muhammad a self proclaimed "prophet"? Is Muhammad qualified to be a prophet of God?
Jesus healed all with epilepsy and other fits . He cast the demons from them The devil causes sickness and evil. Both books know that the Lord Jesus Christ is the only virgin birthed blameless, sinless messiah or savior who is still alive in Paradise having successfully accomplished his mission as the lamb sacrifice for the sins of the world. Both books agree that the Lord Jesus is returning to Jerusalem to the Mount of Olives. to Judge and rule and reign as King of Kings and Lord of Lords.
That is some wild ass assertions/claims there, my deluded little friend. There is absolutely NO good convincing evidence that god exists, and here I am referring to yahweh/jehovah... the god of the jew and xtian.... and since there is NO good convincing evidence that this character exists, then if a historical yeshua ben josef actually lived, he would have been 100% human, just like you and I... he may even have been a 'great teacher' but he was never divine... and thus, did not heal anyone, he did not cast out devils (since there is NO good convincing evidence that THEY exist either) etc etc... He was never named in any extra-biblical sources at the time... and he was not mentioned until about 70 years after the so-called cruci-FICTION.... if a man like what you xtians describe this jesus existed, he would have been written about/mentioned in the writings of the time... he was not
This is certainly not befitting for someone people believe to be a masoom prophet. I'm NOT a christian, but if we compare the angels that came down to the biblical prophets, they came with a very calm and controlled approached, according to the bible. But Gabiel came to Muhammad quite brutally. Consider what happened in the cave of Hira. Have similar symptoms been recorded for other so-called prophets that allegedly also received revelations from above? Dont think so.
Biblical prophets that suddenly collapsed showed in those moments symptoms of at least atonic seizures which while mild are still seizures not to mention being temporarily unable to speak is common with seizures. You can also look up published work about Ezekiel and epilepsy that has been around for over 20 years.
It's good to see the apologists playing catch up on the analysis and research carried out by ex Muslims. Didn't Farid fo all he could to deny they.mohammed had fits?
It’s Khadijah(1st wife),who told Mohammad first with the help of a Waraqah ibn Nawfal, that, he’s a Prophet not Angel Jibrel or Al Lah, plus in the quran Angel Jibrel never introduced himself as Jibrel when he first met @ cave Hira.. This makes it clear , Mohammad either was mental disorder or the one he spoke was Satan..🤦🏽♂️🤦🤦♀️
Which one you loves most - 1. Adam Seeker 2. Sachwala 3. Sahil official 4. Harris Sultan 5. Apostate Prophet 6. Zafar Heretic 7. Galib Kamal 8. Yasmin Khan 9. Storm Pilot 10. Ahamad
Have you heard about the woman who went to mohammad because she was concerned about her hijab when she had seizures? What do you think about that, it seems they were aware of the occurance of some epileptic symptoms.
According to the Muslims, Allah sent 124,000 prophets to the world. Can they name one Prophet that when God sends revelation to him he goes into seizure like someone receiving revelation during a West African Voodoo session. No difference at all.
muslims don't read the books muhammad rewrote. otherwise they would know the angels who warned Abraham and Lot about the destruction of sodom and gommorah looked like men. men that the perverts of sodom and gommorah were interested in meeting. unlike jibril the angel who was invisible to everyone.
If you are q, Muslim, and readind this, RUN!, RUN!, RUN from Allah, MuhamMAD, islam, and the quran. Repent and believe the gospel(Mark 1:15) while you still have breath om your body.
6:55 I don't remember that guy name but he's not an apologist. He's a shia that rejects the mainstream historical narrative and criticizing the books he mentioned because shia believes muhammad so extremely perfect he's almost a god. Anyway, I disagree with mislabeling him as an apologist like the rest when he actually has opposite opinion to them.
WHY DON'T ANY MUSLIMS QUESTION IF THE PROPHETS BEFORE MOHAMMED MANIFESTED ANY OF THIS WEIRD BEHAVIOUR;MARY A WOMAN SUPPOSEDLY SAW THE ANGEL GABRIEL WHY DID SHE NOT MANIFESTED THE SAME BEHAVIOUR; BEEN A WOMAN ONE WILL THINK IT WILL BE MORE DIFFICULT FOR HER TO CONTAIN THAN IT WILL BE FOR MOHAMMED WHO IS A MAN
blah blah blah.... more mythology without anything credible or sufficient to warrant belief. Keep your delusions to yourself.... may reality give you a swift kick in the tush and you wake up from these false ideologies.
"Believing your own hallucinations is called insanity, believing someone else's hallucinations is called religion"...
🤣🤣🤣👍👋👋👋👋👋
@@hanabisakura1266 just because you don't understand something doesn't mean it must be 'magic' ... that's a 'god of the gaps' argument. If you think a god exists, provide some evidence for it...otherwise, have a nice day :)
@@hanabisakura1266 insanity is when a fifty year old MoMo forces himself on a 9 yr old. Insanity is when a 50yr old lusts for his own Son's wife.Above all this is cherished by the God
@@hanabisakura1266 Insanity is believing that all happens by the power of Allah , it has all being explained by science and now even us humans can fly in our planes , do planes fly by the power of Allah ?
@@hanabisakura1266yet, we can describe really well how these things work and how they develope, you absolute religious mor0n
Abdullah is talking. Islam is shaking.
Never🤣
@@rooibos786 The world has always been full of millions of gullible naive people who will fall for deception, that will never change, so never is probably apt
@@rooibos786 and Momo is getting the hoors ready in Jannat forgetting Palesthine, Syria, Iran, Sudan .....
@@stoneworshipper2599 every detail of injustice, even doing good, is recorded. Absolutely nothing will go unrewarded or unpunished.
Read the English translation of the Quran.
Ironically his name is abd of Allah😂
I have no idea whether Muhammad suffered from epilepsy or not, but you raise a very good question. Why would God allow his prophet to suffer such symptoms? After all, God is omnipotent and could have sent revelations to Muhammad without causing such a reaction in him. Today, the link between religious delusions and the various forms of psychosis is well established. Psychiatric hospitals are full of people who believe they are in communication with God. God would have course known about such a link with mental illness, yet appears unconcerned that it might cause doubt and skepticism of his crucial and final message to mankind. Whether Muhammad was epileptic or not, one has to admit that it is reasonable to expect an Omniscient and Omnipotent God would avoid causing such doubts.
"why would God...bla bla bla"? look a small ingrate human mind is dictating what God should or should not do. lol....
What you said is absolutely correct. Some of the prophets in the Biblical tradition seem to be literally mentally sick. Take Abraham for an example. Abraham was a very old man and claims to have spoken with God on numerous occasions. These conversions often ended up in serious harm. On one instance, Abraham amputates his own foreskin and declares all of his descendants to go down the same mutilation, "as a covenant from God." And then later on something worse occurred. Abraham believed that God was telling him to sacrifice his son on Mount Moriah to see if he loves God more than his son Isaac. Fortunately the sacrifice didn't occur as "God intervened." I personally believe that Abraham is loosely based off a real person that explains the origins of the Jews and their most important customs, but that isn't the main point if Abraham is real or not. If someone like this existed today, we would all call that person insane. Believing God is talking to you and demanding that you and your offspring must circumcise as a mark of the flesh or demanding his son to be sacrifice to him, does not seem like a benevolent entity.
That's the same issue I had with the muddy spring verse in particular and all the other controversial verses in general. Even if it actually means what apologists say it means, why would God, knowing of, for example the Egyptian belief that the sun travelled in a boat to its setting place and similar superstitions, frame this verse like that. Is it to cause doubts? Why do we need to know how Zulkarnain perceived the sun to be setting and the nature of the spring?
In general, why does the religion have to look so similar to the superstitions it came to replace? Why the black stone? Why the story of the wall gecko being the only animal blowing in Abraham's fire? Why won't grandpa Zakariah speak for three days as a token from God...?
God didnt coddle muhammad a mere human by not making revelation easy, therefore it's not from god? Your argument sucks. We are are talking about a god that burns people in hellfire and u care about a little shiver lol.
You are right. My elder brother suffered from mental illness. And he many times was convinced that he is Easa (Jesus)
When my son had epilepsy ,he was losing consciousness,but sometimes, he would shout and make strange gestures,One night I had to stop him from jumping from the window while having a strange episod of epilepsy.
Looks like he had the same episodes like Mohammad..
Thanks God he was successfully treated and he is fine now
Sad to hear but glab he is okay now
Wish there was treatment of epilepsy back then,world would be heaven😍
I presume it was not god that treated him, but the nurses and doctors at the hospital?? I don't see you thanking these people who spent so much of their time studying and learning and practising their skills to help heal people. There is NO good convincing evidence that gods exist... doctors and nurses on the other hand are very definitely real.... maybe you should give thanks to where it is actually due and not to some fairy tale.
Is this really real or just for analogy you are making it up
@@truthwillprevail1816 It is real ,didnt you hear about epilepsy
How is this similar to what the prophet experienced?
I've yet to see a case of someone getting seizures and producing literature. Let alone using said literature to build a civilization. All these epilepsy explainations for what the prophet (pbuh) experienced seem far fetched.
It is deeply regrettable that medical science was not developed in the era in which Mohammad lived. Had it been, he could've gotten the help he needed and Islam would not have been thrust on the world.
It's funny how apparently a man who had epilepsy Conquered Half the world fought 70 wars and did not die
Defeated Romans and Persians made a Law still countries Follow which are functioning today
Sometimes I think these ex muslims are just trying to look morons soo more people accept islam
Alan Flynn , points to ponder and deeply too- on what yikis says . Revelations come this way to prophets . Full stop
@@yikis7989 He only conquered areas which is roughly the size of saudi before he died of poisoning, his jihadist genocidal ideology was carried on by this successors to invade the other countries. Byzantine & Sasanid empires was already in decline ages fighting each other before the arab muslim conquest(not muhammad). Sharia is a failed system enforced on its population by dictators in which most of their population migrate to the west to live under secularism
No wonder he always gets Revelation anytime he wants to justify any evil he wants like taking someone's wife and waging arbitrary war
This a
Topic alone is really enough to destroy the whole base of this religion . A totally eye opener and the one who is honestly and critically have to see the veil of truth.
The founder of the seventh day Adventist church had visions in her seizures as well. She admittedly has epilepsy from a concussion as a child.
As a matter of fact no single verse in the Quran can be quoted saying that Allah sent an angel called Gabriel to his servant Mohamed to deliver a message of Quran. Non.
This is all from I n ishaq who was not eyewitness nor met Mohamed 100 years after his death.
How do we rely on this
Not eyewitness
Allah in Quran doesn't mention it
Then the stranger behaviour.
Giving correct information like
God is one which Muslims brag about is known by Satan
And in bible it reads you say God is one you do well but even demons know and they shudder
These apologists are awful and funny at the same time.😱 What a bunch of lunatics.😵💫 Thanks Abdullah for sharing. Live long and prosper. 🖖🤟
The best Muslim is an exmuslim and this brother is one.
Poor Mohd, he was born at a time where mental illness was not understood. Perhaps, had he lived today, he would've received the treatment he needed. The world would certainly have been much different 🤷♂️
When Muhammad met the angel Jibril in a cave in Hira and chokeslammed him making him see visions, he was in fact having a violent epileptic seizure. OMG.
Its in the authentic hadith so they have no choice but to believe it. But u notice they present it as something holy and amazing😂
Believe in what?
To make this argument stronger we need to show cases where epileptic persons of today claim to hear God speak to them.
It happens all the time, ask psych physicians and nurses in big psych institutions.
Go and read about temporal lobe epilepsy and its side effects,hyperreligiosity is the major symptoms even if they were atheist before
@@kameelffarag Official psychiatric reports would help, but I sometimes wonder if they would not be too public about it because they do not want to offend religions.
That doesn't work most of the time, they'll just claim that Muhammad was the seal of the Prophets and everyone after him who claims to hear God is a liar.
That has been done thoroughly in The Epileptic Prophet series available on this channel
I want to Muslims to think about why previous so called prophets especially Moses who talked directly to God didn't get any of these symptoms? which is supposed to be harder getting a revelation through an intermediary like an Angel as Mohammed did or getting it directly from God like Jesus and Moses and many others? heavy message my @s
Lmfao you guys are so silly, that’s why everything is called a sign. The signs are not supposed to be obvious, they guide like any other sign in this world, it can be possible he was epileptic, and that maybe that was an advantage to take in terms of “well now is the best time to communicate to him” but other than that, your argument, and yes with a completely open mind, is weak.
I remember a long time ago, I read a very old book online called "The History of the Origin, Family, Birth, Education and Teachings of the Great False Prophet Mohammed" published by Broer Jansz in 1640. He was a book printer in 17th century Netherlands and he wanted to debunk Islam. The book isn't the most accurate thing in the world and it contains illustrations, which shows 7th century Arabs in Contemporary European clothing (which was common in illustrations at the time). But one of the big claims this book made was a new revolutionary idea. That Muhammad didn't see the Angel Gabriel nor was he cursed by the Devil, but he suffered an epilepsy which caused him to hallucinate. From my research on Muhammad's life, I find this to be most likely what happened in that cave. Of course, the author being Christian, this logic can also apply to his own prophets, but that's a discussion for another day.
Fortunately for Broer Jansz, there were probably no Muslims in the Netherlands during the time in which he lived, otherwise he may have come to a grim end.
As a practicing muslim i had heard about these epilepsy theories and i was shocked how people could stoop so low . our scholars screamed its a zionist and western conspiracy to defame our prophet and finish off islam.Later in life when i read the hadiths in detail his symptoms during revelation shocked me how could divine revelation be so painful .
Islam is the only religion to offer solutions to the world's problems. All other religions are happy clappy. Not practical solutions. Aspects of alcoholism, gambling, modest dress, interest, etc
@@rooibos786 Where in the world at the moment do you think Islam is doing the best job of solving the country’s problems, mate?
@@brotherben4357 most Muslim countries have no major degeneracy into alcoholism, gambling, toxic feminism, emasculating men, crippling interest rates and high poverty( except those that have been invaded by the west), homosexuality, transgender issues.
Rape statistics are low or nearly non-existent. Crime generally is low.
Family values are thriving with women having more than the average children in western countries.
Decrease in the population in the west will lead to dire consequences in terms of the economy.
'A'isha reported that Harith b. Hisham asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ):
How does the wahi (inspiration) come to you? He said: At times it comes to me like the ringing of a bell and that is most severe for me and when it is over I retain that (what I had received in the form of wahi), and at times an Angel in the form of a human being comes to me (and speaks) and I retain whatever he speaks.
Sahih Muslim 2333b
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying:
The bell is the musical instrument of the Satan.
Sahih Muslim 2114
DING! 🔕🔕🔕DOOOONNNNGG!!!!
😂😂😂😂 this confirms that satan
Satan was a major source as he was so powrful with MoMo that Satan could put words into his Mouth like the verses of Al-lah and his three daughters 😅
This whole epilepsy thing should be milked to the bone. You and/or the other Abdul should try to have a debate about this on modern day debate wit some Muslims.
Might be schizophrenia he suffered from before his prophethood. But later and particularly after Khadija's death, he used his condition to make people believe his verses.
Wow, what a collection! Great work, Abdullah!!!
As usual, your videos are very informative and your presentation is great. Keep them coming!
Hi Abdullah. There is a channel/guy called "The friendly Muslim" and he seems like a nice guy. It would be so cool to see you and him converse about the evidence for the Prophet's epilepsy and how he thinks Farid responds refuted that, or just some other things about Islam.
"The friendly ex Muslim featuring the friendly Muslim."
This is why all the Christians believe he was possessed.
Christianity is even worse than islam and more non sensical.
Yep. He was either a mad or demon possessed.
Very interesting! It's interesting to see how these Muslim scholars unwittingly prove that Muhammad was an epileptic madman. Keep up the great work! No amount of cope and denialism from the Dawahgandists can just say that these Muslim scholars are wrong.
Do you think if Abu-Waraqa did not tell Muhamed he was a prophet we would have had Islam.
Mohamed Ayad has an interesting video ,manufacturing of a prophet’ about his version. Like how Khadijah wanted to make her husband a prophet, to save their marriage, since she was too old to find another husband. Otherwise he would be declared to be crazy. And her cousin told him he’s a prophet to save her marriage.
@@zigzig9938 it never made any sense to me that Allah’s prophet is so confused and that too about the divine revelation ...its Khadijah who lectures him about his noble character.
Gabriel always removed the fear from the people he appears to by saying fear not,
But muhammed knew what he saw , he said he saw a demon .
Warakah misled muhammed by telling him it was Angel Gabriel.
@@soulmate5443 It is ironic, it took a Christian to make the basis of Islam lagit. If waraqa said nothing then we would not have Islam, or at least not in this way.
Dear Abdullah's, thank you for this. Keep addressing all aspects (emotional, psychological, textual, philosophical, historical, medical, factual, etc.) of religion. Despite believers saying both epilepsy and reevaluation can exist the messages need to get out.
This is great work Abdullah and is becoming more and more persuasive as time goes on.
There are many pieces of the Islamic jigsaw puzzle from a balanced modern perspective, and this helps explain why even Mohammed and his companions thought he had received spiritual inspiration.
Iblees lives among angels . He refuses to obey Allah’s command even dares to argue and challenge him .. and on the other hand Allah’s beloved prophet sweats and shivers after seeing jibreel .. strange
Growing up I would randomly get seizures, shaking, very often combined with hallucinations... maybe I am the final prophet? They could never tell me what it was, wasn't epilepsy or anything... and now I am fine...
Yes you are maybe a new prophet!Its your task to save humanity!Tell us what we have to do to make the snakegod happy!
@@brunoheggli2888 In my first revelation Snakegod has told me to get rid of Islam, the Snakegod will be much pleased with this outcome... also he loves to be pleased by outcomes.
What to say this video is just ultimate , the nail in the coffin. Present and future generations will be thankful to you utmost freindly ex Muslim
I am an epeleptic who did a degree on human vibration in relation to visual perception and interpretation. I have all types of seizures and did alot of research on this subject. There is so much that explains in great detail why neurological problems and environment can change your perceptions. sorry to say there is no soul as the word is made up by thiest also an individual experience is not enough to prove anything and never once didnt conect to somthing already in your body or mind . Even with countless studies of recorded events it always comes down to being learnt or enviromental factors that shows specifically that individuals only have visions of thier specific faiths e.g near death experiences when they see thier heaven as it was already described. There is alot we know and more to learn but it is extreemly frustrating if you dont have an answer to just insert god or faith its harmful and prevents people getting help they need. maybe mohamad would of got it if people had the right support. Its obvious he wasnt well even crazier people couldnt understand it so just enabled his dillusions n still do to this day. I have experienced pure happyness during a seizure and if i was a thiest i would of described it that way . As an athiest it can cleary be explained by chemicals in different parts of my brain n the part responsible was the area usually effected when on psychodelic drugs and religious revilations there is explinations if you look. Thank you for the video helps towards stopping stigma of these conditions and also misrepresentation so its apreciated.
Then Farid no-response will say: none of this evidence is true. And you people are just "twisting" the Hadiths! Pathetic.
Hahaha
Trance is a state of semi-consciousness in which a person is not self-aware and is either altogether unresponsive to external stimuli (but nevertheless capable of pursuing and realizing an aim) or is selectively responsive in following the directions of the person (if any) who has induced the trance. Trance states may occur involuntarily and unbidden. The term trance may be associated with hypnosis, meditation, magic, flow, prayer, and altered states of consciousness.
I like the "Elipepsy" in the thumbnail. ;-)
Thank you for your Video.
How can Muslim by hearing this people still believe that Mohammed is a god messenger
After hearing what? A stupid people and scare people. You can not stop Islam entering your homes and family’s life. It’s not possible and those lies are nothing but spreading Islam and people will notice the clips that are added is nothing but a lies.
Thank you Abdullah for your efforts to unveil the truth
The crux of the matter is Mo claimed to receive revelations following his fit and not before in response to experiencing the divine as some Muslim apologist would try to beguile others.
i dont believe he was a liar.
I believe in psychosis.
It's scientifically proven that immediately after a seizure people become poet and recite poem's. Some times these poem's hour's long. This is very common. Ask anyone who had seizure
Crazy to me how these guys openly admit he has neurological issues and he was possessed and then still gaslight themselves into believing in him.
Indoctrination is an extremely powerful tool
I wish Momo got medical help, and not been dragged around like a freak by Omar.
I mean this is hilarious. Can someone tell me what happens to a person who lies deliberately and what happens to their body? Shiver and shaking because if he gets caught he will die and he knew it! xD
One of your best videos
Moses and Paul had Epilepsy
I'm not even religious, but even if you believe this stuff what kind of god/ angel makes you feel cold? Don't people feel cold when there's a ghost nearby? Seems like an unsettling presence tbh.
If you are a, Muslim, and reafing this, RUN!, RUN!, RUN!, from Allah, MuhamMAD, the Quran, and Islam. Repent and believe the gospel(Mark 1:15) while you still have breath in your body.
What happens if I die?
@@Remake5182 You will die. The quedtkon i5 where will you 5pend eternity, in heaven or in hell?.
On what basis do these people assume that an epileptic seizure was a revelation from God? My uncle had seizures, but we were never ignorant enough to think he was talking to God.
In the pre- scientific age , among all peoples , strange but not totally outlandish mental states and the accompanying physical symptoms , occurring in s person were thought of as indicative of " possession" by some " supernatural " entity , good or evil , depending upon the person and the context . Not different for the tribes of Arabia of the 7th century . The writers of Hadeeths and other accounts thought so too - it was vindication that a "supernatural " force was active when such states happened to Mohammed. Otherwise they wouldn't have described them in detail. That conclusion was wrong , as we very well know now !
One of the figures that spring to mind is Rasputin in Russia and how he gained so much influence over the royal family especially the czarina in their time of crisis.That deep sinister look in Rasputin's eyes and the stories of Rasputin's sexual prowess.There is always a link with this type of person.
It could also have been an act on his part. I'm not convinced that these episodes were not him play acting to make it seem like something dramatic was happening to him.
The way they say "SAW" loooooooooool. Sheep
Quite apart from everything else, the requirement for that sheepish repetition is enough to put me off Islam. Do they never get fed up with this!?
They need to keep praying for him. That place must be too hot.
Hypochondria, schizophrenia, dementia, fits, hallucination, megalomania, sadist traits,and all that disgusting stuff in one body😢
Really sickening to see his unfortunate ilk.😊
Without lies islam dies
You don't sweat and shiver with epilepsy or hallucinate you go unconscious and don't remember your name when you wake up from epileptic fit
But when we read previous scriptures no where did this happen
In tanakh
the angels introduce them selves
No fainting
No panicking
So Mohamed had issues and got false stuff.
Accept this Muslims Allah couldnt kerp hom harm.
Why figmer prophets never had this
All thus looks satanic accept.
Ah, Friendly Ex Muslim, Peace be upon you.
All of them muslims dont have an answer... all of them keep saying its possible
Its just an excuse to justify for his kind behaviour. Whenever he wants to do somethimg he says he is receving a revelation from allah.
Why didn't Allah/ Mohammed just predict epilepsy and say he didn't have it?
👏😁
Lol, Awesome compilation.
Why did Satan punish Muhammed like this ?
satan did nothing of the sort, since there is NO good convincing evidence that gods or devils exist... all part of your mythology... and not part of reality.
That shivering and frothing mouth of momo was a clear sign of demonic possesion
Qathem al-Quraishi claimed that a divine revelation called him to prophecy, and gave him the Koran. The traditional Islamic teachings tell us that Muhammad claimed to have been dominated by spirit when he was retired in the cave of Hira. He was forty years old. That spirit squeezed him so hard three times that he could not breathe and thought he would die by suffocation (Bukhari, Alwahi 3.1.1). She then gave him the first Qur'an, which contained the first mistakes of the Qur'an, which is that God “created man from a relationship” (Al-Alaq 96: 2).
That was clearly a demonic evil spirit, because he tried to harm him. No one saw this alleged meeting. For this can not be proved. At first, Muhammad thought that a jinn or demon😈was deceiving him, or the cave might be inhabited. But his first wife, Khadija, and her cousin, Waraqa ibn Nouffal (his real father), urged him to believe it was divinely alive. It is impossible for this to be a noble appeal to prophecy. The Quran was already Waraqa's as he was a writer of Nasara Quran as a Nasara. Seek the true Messiah, who hears you through his living Spirit, he will judge the world and can transform your life, do miracles and show you the true one God.
Noice coverage 👍
These Muslim apologists are rediculous. The madman's rant and his murderous legacy becomes the foundation of a religion.
Robert morey mentions this in debate vs shabir ally yyz 90s
It is clear the whole thing was fake. The first fright maybe happened. But the fact that his so-called revelations about the Last Day are taken in part almost word for word from the Gospel of St Matthew which was known to the Nazarene and Ebionite Christians around him at the time, the fact that he had the supposed Night Journey to Jerusalem shortly after the tribes of Medina said he might be the Messiah the Jews talked of, the fact that the Quraysh accused him of having people recite to him day and night, the fact he had scribes to write down his so-called revelations and that one of them, Abdullah b. Sa'd fled to Mecca saying 'If Muhammad's a prophet I'm half a prophet!' The fact that Muhammad had Abdullah's name on a death list when he conquered Mecca and the atrocities that he and his followers committed at the Battle of Badr show a ruthless desire for vengeance and conquest. Within five years of his arrival in Medina in 622AD, all the Jews who rejected him were exiled or dead. This guy was no weak epileptic. Even Aisha saw through his act saying how 'convenient' his later revelations were as a pretext for action. When the men did not want to attack Tabuk in the hot season, the 'revelation' came down 'The fires of hell burn hotter!' There is not a line in the Quran that cannot be explained by what was going on in his life at any given moment. 😁
Brilliant comment. Couldn't put it better myself
😂 I also get crazy thoughts and speak during my seizures, maybe I should write a new coran 😂
We want the roman and viking gods back!Please tell me they are real!
You might as well just go down to the institution for the criminally insane and start worshipping the first guy you see
Why Allah use a sick man? Can Allah not heal Muhammad if he wants to use him?
Is Muhammad telling the truth?
Is Muhammad a self proclaimed "prophet"?
Is Muhammad qualified to be a prophet of God?
Jesus healed all with epilepsy and other fits . He cast the demons from them The devil causes sickness and evil. Both books know that the Lord Jesus Christ is the only virgin birthed blameless, sinless messiah or savior who is still alive in Paradise having successfully accomplished his mission as the lamb sacrifice for the sins of the world. Both books agree that the Lord Jesus is returning to Jerusalem to the Mount of Olives. to Judge and rule and reign as King of Kings and Lord of Lords.
That is some wild ass assertions/claims there, my deluded little friend. There is absolutely NO good convincing evidence that god exists, and here I am referring to yahweh/jehovah... the god of the jew and xtian.... and since there is NO good convincing evidence that this character exists, then if a historical yeshua ben josef actually lived, he would have been 100% human, just like you and I... he may even have been a 'great teacher' but he was never divine... and thus, did not heal anyone, he did not cast out devils (since there is NO good convincing evidence that THEY exist either) etc etc... He was never named in any extra-biblical sources at the time... and he was not mentioned until about 70 years after the so-called cruci-FICTION.... if a man like what you xtians describe this jesus existed, he would have been written about/mentioned in the writings of the time... he was not
Jesus always cast the demons out and they were restored to right health again
This 'prophet' has too much skeletons in his cupboard! Extremely difficult defending his prophethood.
Yes the Lord Jesus Christ healed all who were overcome with disorders of brain.
And did he leave us the treatment regimen to follow?
Lool the "Epileptic Plagarist" thats a good one. I love how muslims are exposing their own religion 🤭
Why do they say "Sallalahu Aleihu Wasalam" every 2 seconds? Omar Suleiman especially kept on saying it again and again.
habit. and fear.
Surprisingly, muhMad never claimed to have spoken to the so-called Allah.
This is certainly not befitting for someone people believe to be a masoom prophet. I'm NOT a christian, but if we compare the angels that came down to the biblical prophets, they came with a very calm and controlled approached, according to the bible. But Gabiel came to Muhammad quite brutally. Consider what happened in the cave of Hira. Have similar symptoms been recorded for other so-called prophets that allegedly also received revelations from above? Dont think so.
Biblical prophets that suddenly collapsed showed in those moments symptoms of at least atonic seizures which while mild are still seizures not to mention being temporarily unable to speak is common with seizures. You can also look up published work about Ezekiel and epilepsy that has been around for over 20 years.
Wasn’t Moses hearing god and looking at a burning bush?
Just thank you …
Islam, it's just a theory !
It's good to see the apologists playing catch up on the analysis and research carried out by ex Muslims.
Didn't Farid fo all he could to deny they.mohammed had fits?
For no marvel satin transform himself in an angel of light. Muhammad saw satin.
satin is such a lovely fabric.... although I prefer velvet.... Did Mo find a pretty dress in satin, do you think??
If jesus was also a prophet according to muslim, why he not having same kind of symtomps
I always find entertainment watching grown men trying to preach the absurdities of 1slame.
What spin. Would put politicians to shame.
😂😂😂
It’s Khadijah(1st wife),who told Mohammad first with the help of a Waraqah ibn Nawfal, that, he’s a Prophet not Angel Jibrel or Al Lah, plus in the quran Angel Jibrel never introduced himself as Jibrel when he first met @ cave Hira.. This makes it clear , Mohammad either was mental disorder or the one he spoke was Satan..🤦🏽♂️🤦🤦♀️
Sameer, buddy, you are looking quite handsome in this video. Are you exercising these days?
Thank you very much for sharing and exposing the disturbing facts of Islamic
Which one you loves most -
1. Adam Seeker
2. Sachwala
3. Sahil official
4. Harris Sultan
5. Apostate Prophet
6. Zafar Heretic
7. Galib Kamal
8. Yasmin Khan
9. Storm Pilot
10. Ahamad
I don't like Adam Seeker
Christian Prince and Rob Christian!
He had a Jin pulling his nose hairs
Have you heard about the woman who went to mohammad because she was concerned about her hijab when she had seizures? What do you think about that, it seems they were aware of the occurance of some epileptic symptoms.
Please watch Asli Nabi English animated videos and post in your channel - thank you. they do not have any problem with copy rights
Shaikh yaboody will explain it better
Sounds like he was possessed by demons . .
According to the Muslims, Allah sent 124,000 prophets to the world. Can they name one Prophet that when God sends revelation to him he goes into seizure like someone receiving revelation during a West African Voodoo session. No difference at all.
muslims don't read the books muhammad rewrote. otherwise they would know the angels who warned Abraham and Lot about the destruction of sodom and gommorah looked like men. men that the perverts of sodom and gommorah were interested in meeting. unlike jibril the angel who was invisible to everyone.
So.......it's not a new theory or conspiracy that the prophet had epilepsy
If you are q, Muslim, and readind this, RUN!, RUN!, RUN from Allah, MuhamMAD, islam, and the quran. Repent and believe the gospel(Mark 1:15) while you still have breath om your body.
MohamMAD.
Either an epileptic or gibriel was no angel or both lol
6:55 I don't remember that guy name but he's not an apologist. He's a shia that rejects the mainstream historical narrative and criticizing the books he mentioned because shia believes muhammad so extremely perfect he's almost a god. Anyway, I disagree with mislabeling him as an apologist like the rest when he actually has opposite opinion to them.
He can still be an apologist, even if he follows a different sect.
Down with Islam🔥
"To be inspired by Jibril is not an easy task" Yasir Kadiri
WHY DON'T ANY MUSLIMS QUESTION IF THE PROPHETS BEFORE MOHAMMED MANIFESTED ANY OF THIS WEIRD BEHAVIOUR;MARY A WOMAN SUPPOSEDLY SAW THE ANGEL GABRIEL WHY DID SHE NOT MANIFESTED THE SAME BEHAVIOUR; BEEN A WOMAN ONE WILL THINK IT WILL BE MORE DIFFICULT FOR HER TO CONTAIN THAN IT WILL BE FOR MOHAMMED WHO IS A MAN
Blessings upon all through our Lord and saviour Jesus Christ
blah blah blah.... more mythology without anything credible or sufficient to warrant belief. Keep your delusions to yourself.... may reality give you a swift kick in the tush and you wake up from these false ideologies.
And satans blessings on you and your loved ones ❤️