Who Wrote the Qur'an | What Sources Were Used?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 дек 2021
- Islamic Prophets Family Tree:
Chart - usefulcharts.com/products/isl...
Video - • Islamic Prophets Famil...
Watch Al Muqaddimah's video on the Sana'a manuscript:
• What do the Sana'a Man...
Who Wrote the Bible? Episode 1:
• Who Wrote the Torah? (...
Video Credits:
Narration/Charts: Matt Baker usefulcharts.com/
Animation: Syawish Rehman / @almuqaddimahyt
Audio Editing: Jack Rackam / @jackrackam
Intro music: "Lord of the Land" by Kevin MacLeod and licensed under Creative Commons Attribution license 4.0. incompetech.com
Watch Al Muqaddimah's video on the Sana'a manuscript: ruclips.net/video/HMeXNm88Z-g/видео.html
Have you re uploaded this particular video.
Did you reupload this again
@@andrewwake8607 yes, he did
@@Omer1996E.C Thanks Omer. I wonder who he's offended.
@@andrewwake8607 I think he just wanted to upload the video after "al muqaddimah" did
I am an elderly Muslim woman. I love to watch your highly objective vedios. I loved this one too. I don't think it would hurt any one's feelings. I refrain from expressing my own views as my community is highly sensitive about these matters. People are not ready for objective discourses on religious matters.
Sir please do something to bring different communities, specially Jews and Muslims to see eye to eye and believe in one common religion that's humanity
Stay blessed
My respect to you, really! Hope you have a wonderful life.
Wow ! 🥰i like the way you think
U giving so much hope dear. This so normal opinion is lack among all the culture, in the west too.
@Jai Bholenath जय भोलेनाथ it cant work with the 99 percent idiots but with normal persons its okay. Just they shall then fortify themselfs
Look into the Sufi community - there are channels on here, such as Seekers of Unity, that talk about them and religious unity
I think this is the most inoffensive and respectful video about Islam comparing to other videos🤝
Inoffensive? It's not offensive, it's just ignorant about the vast differences of the quran and other books, I was just watching an old video from "many prophets, one message" on RUclips, and the quran and Bible can never be copy of one another
@@Omer1996E.C nevertheless... if u think about it, during the period of Prophet even if these supposed texts were there floating around, he was someone who cannot read or write. For someone like that to compile the stories would be extraordinary. In-depth analysis of Quran, the arrangement of surah and numerical miracles and some scientific facts and predictions are too many coincidences to occur at once.
Faith is something u cant explain with solid proof but u believe in it anyway.
This video increased by faith in the Quran and its authenticity.
Thanks
@@ixoh7754 how to know if he was lying about being illiterate
@@soar865 - imagine if he claimed to be a doctor… now his mom gonna say “don’t come near me when I am sick u are not a real doctor”.. he friends be like “Yo, u never went to med school all these years u been with us playing in the fields”… his followers be like “dude.. u know very little about medicine”.
1500 years later… me “he was not a doctor”
And you be like “how do u know he is not a doctor ?”
I’m like “bro.. wtf”
@@ixoh7754if faith, as you say, is believing something without evidence, then there would be no need to seek evidence for authenticity… unless your faith was weak. If you have strong evidence, you don’t need faith. So considering the tremendous evidence you’ve found for the truth and authenticity of your holy book, you don’t really have to have much faith at all. Whether that’s a good thing or a bad thing, I don’t know!
Truly an excellent presentation on the subject and brilliant for its graphic presentation/representation of the relationship between matters being discussed......of course I hit the subscribe button and will now go right through your catalogue of material.
It is wonderful to come across such a well structured and organized source.......
"And if you are in doubt about what We have revealed to Our servant, then produce a surah like it and call your helpers other than Allah, if what you say is true."
Quran 2:23
very powerful verse >>>
@@bajang1897is it ?
@@ReinaldoKyesse yep ... to me ... and to you ?
@@bajang1897 I don’t know
Abu lahab's wife did produce a verse that was even better. Go read it.
My religion is Islam, I am a Muslim, But I judge and question everything, it's my nature...I always try to know the historical and scientific view of religion. Thanks for your research...Very grateful ❤️
TELL ME PLEASE WHAT IS THE MUSLIM SALVATION.
@@davidway4259
My brother David: In Islam, we do not need to shed the blood of an innocent person in order for God to forgive a sin that we did not commit. To forgive sins in Islam, all you have to do is turn to God alone without a mediator and repent of your sin and not return to sin. Bloodshed is not required, in ezec 18 "The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, neither shall the father bear the "iniquity of the son
@@davidway4259 In our religion, Adam repented of his sin in the first place, and God forgave him. In your religion, Adam sinned by eating from the forbidden tree. Imagine, in order for God to forgive this sin, he has to incarnate and sacrifice his son, who is God, and he himself is God, meaning that he sacrifices himself to forgive us for a sin we didn't commit.
You can refer to dialogues between Muslim preacher and Christian common people , as well as missionaries. In the speakers' corner, just write the speakers' corner, duaa. I am inclined and I love Sheikh Othman. You can listen to some of these conversations if you have free time. We believe in Christ and we all respect him as a human being and a prophet, and we believe in his virgin birth And all the prophets
HOLY MEANS WHAT
as a Muslim I was always curious about the point of view of Quran by a non-Muslim. so how I felt. thank you for the experience!
read the Quran brother you know whats their view
The Quran, at least in its early part is quoting much of the bible and especially Musa about 73 or maybe 74 times. It suggests to the Bani Israel to go back into their land in the name of Alla, and not leave. The Children of Israel are sometimes referred to as Ummat Al Kittab and there is nothing wrong with that. I wonder if in the name of peace we could stick to the good parts and put aside the less peaceful parts. Those who believe in the Hebrew Bible did it and nobody is claiming that an eye for and eye is justice. I think that some of the less peaceful parts in the Quran may have come from traditional and tribal times preceding or after the life if the Nebi.
@@gershonperry5952 That is an interesting parallel between the different Holy Scriptures, to lay aside the violent parts. But at some time one needs to address the purpose God had in each of these instances to utilize violence. Nevertheless, it does start us on a more level playing ground. Peace
Its a fools paradise
@@gershonperry5952 As they say, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. Omitting anything from what one believe is the word of God is a disrespect to him. anything that is there exits for a reason. what you're saying is similar to sayin "why not only talk only about the inventions and technology Americans have contributed to the world , and how they abolished slavery, and omit the part of history books where they talks about what they did to the native americans and the african slaves, just for the sake of peace and harmony?"
Similarities between the Quran and the other books don't mean someone copied from the others but means that there is one source behind all the Abrahamic religions who is trying to deliver his message to all humanity over and over.
Or it was copied lol😂😂😂😂
But one could argue that since Torah and Bible predates the Quran, Quran may copy scripture from the Torah and Bible, Quran claim the original scripture is corrupted which is why Torah and Bible still exist now but different, but THIS IS ACCORDING TO QURAN
from a neutral perspective, one could argue that if it's possible that Torah and Bible is "corrupted", then it's also possible to say that Quran just copied a scripture from other scripture including Torah and Bible
and your god failed to send this message many times? that's even worse
@@m070samthe message was delivered but the people rejected or corrupted it over time and so the message was sent again to their successors by other Prophets of God. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was the last messenger of Allah ﷻ sent to all humans.
@@normalactivity7404it is a fact, not just possible that the bible and torah is corrupt, this is proven by the text itself and you can also prove the Quran did not copy them because if it did then the Quran would also have the same mistakes that the bible has.
Even after you gave a "heads up" that watching the second half of the content could offend the watcher, I found your discussion of who wrote the Qur'an from another point of view really respectfull (even censoring the depiction of Abraham and Mary as in how the Muslims always censor the depiction of their theological figures) and was delivered with amazing objectivity. Of course, this does not change my faith (as I am sure it was not what you wanted to achieve to begin with) and today I gained new knowledge from your videos. Please keep on making videos!
There is nothing to be offended about regardless of your religion. It’s actually good to listen to different points of view and how other interpret the holy books
Islam is not a religion it's a crime family
Try telling that to the guys who tried to murder Salman Rushdie for referencing controversial Quranic scholarship in his work.
Its weird how "historically" we can reject that the hadith tradition is written about 200 years after the prophet muhammad but we accept acounts of Alexander the great after a Melania
@@Goyim-phobic Well I never gave Melania much credence, but hey, sometimes you have to get an immigrant to do disgusting stuff that no local would do!
@@Goyim-phobicActually that is not true. The Hadith were compiled as early as 80 years after the prophet. Many know the name Bukhari but few know the name Sufyan at Thawri. But critical use of the Hadith began with the companions themselves.
there's an error in this video regarding the compilation of the quran, and unfortunately its a very widespread common misconception
uthman wasn't the first to compile the quran, it was actually abu bakr, who reigned for 2 years after the prophet passed away.
after a battle with apostates, a sizable number of muslim memorizers who had the quran memorized died in the battles, which worried umar ibn al khattab, and he asked abu bakr to compile the quran. after much convincing, he accepted to do so
abu bakr had the quran compiled at his time, and the quran was kept at his house
during the reign of uthman, the muslim empire had already held a huge amount of land, and people generally had the quran passed around and memorized orally. issues arose when people on the fringes of the empire started arguing and debating on what the actual verses were, and so uthman got some scribes to make several copies of the quran, and sent a copy to the main districts of the empire, so that people in those regions, if they differ, they can go check the true version. and even after that for the most part people memorized it orally(and the extra copies were pretty much backups in case anyone messes up)
thats also when uthman ordered the destruction of all other written copies, because the actual true one was already compiled by abu bakr decades before uthman's reign, at most 2 years after the prophet's death(im not sure exactly during which point during abu bakr's reign the quran was compiled, but he reigned for 2 years so its not more than that)
so no, the quran wasnt written down in a whole book form 20 years after the prophets' death, but at most 2 years.
and so theres a saying that goes "abu bakr gathered the quran, while uthman gathered the people on the quran", its still a pretty wide misconception even among muslims.
Thanks for the clarification
Spot on. I learned this in school and am surprised it's not common knowledge.
Ma sha Allah brother please if you know how to contact this person tell him to delete this video
Yea uthman only burnt all the korans he could get hold of then rewrote it to his own interpretation
@@tommynoblethecouncilofheav4657 here comes the clown
I tell him that the quran already existed in book form 2 decades before uthman's rule, and he says uthman wrote it
Even if it's heavily influenced by Syriac literature or whatever that is, the question is became: How Muhammad can be able to recite it all back in Arabic while Arabic, Syriac and Aramaic is far too different to be able to bridged by a man who know nothing about Aramaic or Syriac?
As we know that Arab's tradition of preserving events by oral and those kinda literature must be held by some people with high status like rabbi yet Muhammad family doesn't have such status, therefore probability of obtaining such text is slim, if not impossible.
To be able to create a book (or oral tradition which later canonized) from other language to Arabic is just like asking some random shepherd from Mongolia to come up with a book like Art of War by Sun Tzu by hearing its content here and there in the original language.
The fact that his direct followers preserved the book by memory makes it a not-so-far fetched feat. Besides, the obvious differences between the Syriac and the Arabic story may then account for the paucity of information recounted from memory, plus its additions
@@pstbukkie Then how can Muhammad get such high status mentor who have the book and teach him to memorize some stories? Do you think that such book can be owned by everyone like nowadays?
Also Muhammad compiled such stories into a literature (Qur'an) which is unifying and standardizing Arabic language.
Like I said, like asking random Mongolian shepherd to come up with Art of War by Sun Tzu AND asking to make it to unify and standardize the Mongolian language.
Mind you, unifying nomaden Arabs and Mongols is hard, it is even harder using literature as the unifying aspect.
@@alfred2018 I don't think that the stories were that esoteric. While I can't speak with any degree of certainty (and neither could anyone else), it is entirely possible that Bible stories were common in the region he lived in. Moreso, the fact that Jews and Christians are referred to as the people of the book shows that he is aware of some book. And while the book wasn't as common as it is now, the stories were also taught and a lot of people memorised it like they do the Qur'an. Not entirely miraculous for an Arabian Shephered to be able to recount
It says that it took 23 years to receive all the relations. So I don't think it would be hard for anyone to memorize anything if they had 23 years. Especially if it was given in portions randomly throughout the 23 years. Also he had followers who were like his assistants that kept tabs of everything he said and memorized it as well. So he had backup.
@@maverick7291 Muhammad's first followers mostly slaves. Why? Because Islam teaches equality for all which is the enemy of feudalistic nomaden Arabs. It appeals slaves, not nobles ofc.
How can you expect bunch of slaves be able to do such thing? You have to remember that Muhammad is not born in todays era. Apply the circumstances of Arabian desert at that time and look again how impossible it is to do what you said.
Great video. Super informative. Thanks for putting in the effort!
I am happy you admit your biases or your background so that the audience gets an idea of what lens you view the question through. Some youtubers just don't admit they have a bias and say stuff as matter of fact .
why doesn`t trinity is written in bible,,.;'[.
How does Quran have how many scientific evidence which has only been discovered by modern scientists.
@@JustIssybee ,it`s a core evidence islam is ultimate truth,that`s why islam is the fastest growing religion in the world as per western media said unanimously,peace maz
Exactly! the Koran writer didn't even know what Christians believe! The writer of the Koran didn't even know that God became man according to Christianity! The writer of the Koran did not even know the most important foundations of Christianity!
Malachi 3:6 = Reading helps! This is about good and bad!!
***********Exactly!!! God is not a human! Even if God adds a human body to himself, God still remains God!**************
I am a muslim, and although I am certain in my belief that Quran is a divine text, I am not offended by you raising the topic. Infact, I really appreciate your interest, time and efforts on the center of our faith.
I'm curious.
Is there any Muslim you know that would be offended? If you were to estimate, what percentage?
Actually I'm more interested in the percentage that are understanding of the question, like yourself. I assume it's like 85-90%, but I've been taught and experienced that it's best not to discuss religion with Muslims.
Textual variants in kooran
Surah 37:12
Hafs بَلْ عَجِبْتَ وَيَسْخَرُونَ (But you wondered while they mocked) *عَجِبْتَ*
Duri بَلْ عَجِبْتُ وَيَسْخَرُونَ (But I wondered while they mocked) *عَجِبْتُ*
@@zitools "but I've been taught and experienced that it's best not to discuss religion with Muslims." // If you understand russian, I strongly recommend to listen Geydar Djemal's lections and speech. He worked out the question about "discussing" the religion very well. If you don't understand russian, it is worth to begin to undestand. One of the points is: the language itself (not only the content written or spoken in a language) is a revelation.
@@zitools okay so the thing is, the spread of islam was pretty fast. A major contributing factor to this quick spread was the fact that islam was offering equality to every human being, which if you go a 1000 year back, was a big deal. especially in places such as Indian subcontinent, which was plagued by a cruel caste system, in which privileged upper castes (which were a minority) ruled over lower castes, that lived their lives in very destitute conditions.
When this population was introduced to islam, they were quick to accept it, as it was offering them an escape from the derogatory system they were used to off.
Since the time of our Prophet, it has always been the poor who have been in the forefront to accept islam. The wealthy class obviously resists it, as it is beneficiary of the status quo.
While this enables islam to gain huge numbers, the down side is that majority of them are poor and uneducated. Now, partially due to how world works, and partially because of our failure, we havnt been able to lift everyone out of this illiteracy, and impoverishment. Which means we have a sizable population among us with very little understanding of their own faith. Financial security causes frustration, which is vented out in the form of intolerance.
So yeah, I would say about 50-60% of muslims wont be open enough to take the question in point academically. they tend to be more sentimental about these things. But i guess, this would be the same for any group of human beings.
Yeah in most Religions the poorest people are in the majority of mass following until someone gives mankind a different type of leadership in terms of faith and Religion.
In Gh we have the study of Religuous Practice and of course all our varied tribes do not condone Homosexuality in all its forms as it is practiced in the Western World.
This is excellent IMO. Thank you.
Thank you, it was a wonderful explanation. Greetings to you from Libya
Quran never say it's a new religion but a continuetion of Judaism and Christianity and was revealed to correct the privous scriptures so definitely there will be a lot of similarities
Islam is not a continuation of neither of those man made religions. It is the original teaching of God.
@@samboy90 "man-made" lmfaooo kay sure fam whatever floats your boat
All revelations are named by the mighty Allah is Islam. According to the Quraan
حُرِّمَتْ عَلَيْكُمُ الْمَيْتَةُ وَالدَّمُ وَلَحْمُ الْخِنْزِيرِ وَمَا أُهِلَّ لِغَيْرِ اللَّهِ بِهِ وَالْمُنْخَنِقَةُ وَالْمَوْقُوذَةُ وَالْمُتَرَدِّيَةُ وَالنَّطِيحَةُ وَمَا أَكَلَ السَّبُعُ إِلَّا مَا ذَكَّيْتُمْ وَمَا ذُبِحَ عَلَى النُّصُبِ وَأَنْ تَسْتَقْسِمُوا بِالْأَزْلَامِ ذَلِكُمْ فِسْقٌ الْيَوْمَ يَئِسَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا مِنْ دِينِكُمْ فَلَا تَخْشَوْهُمْ وَاخْشَوْنِ الْيَوْمَ أَكْمَلْتُ لَكُمْ دِينَكُمْ وَأَتْمَمْتُ عَلَيْكُمْ نِعْمَتِي وَرَضِيتُ لَكُمُ الْإِسْلَامَ دِينًا فَمَنِ اضْطُرَّ فِي مَخْمَصَةٍ غَيْرَ مُتَجَانِفٍ لِإِثْمٍ فَإِنَّ اللَّهَ غَفُورٌ رَحِيمٌ ﴿۳﴾
You are forbidden (to consume) the dead, blood and the flesh of swine; also flesh dedicated to any other than Allah, the flesh of strangled (animals) and of those beaten, that which is killed by falling, gored to death, mangled by beasts of prey, unless you find it (still alive) and slaughter it; also of animals sacrificed on stones (to idols). (You are forbidden) to seek division by the arrows, that is debauchery. Those who disbelieve have this day despaired of your religion. Do not fear them, but fear Me. This day I have perfected your religion for you and completed My favor to you. I have approved Islam to be your religion. (As for) he who does not intend to commit a sin but is constrained by hunger to eat of what is forbidden, then surely Allah is Forgiving, Merciful. (3)
So it's "the word" revelation revealed to prophets and messengers that Allah put guidance to individual communities and humanity as a whole.
Allah choices is not up to academia to evaluate as it is bound by human ingrained weakness. Therefore your choice is just a childish try to discredit the almight control.
@@thepilgrim1581 How could JESUS(pbuh) save us when he couldn't save himself.
@@MDSAIF-uy3xz oooooooh XD do not make it to hard for him XD
I would love a series on who wrote the Avesta. It would probably be the most difficult to make out of all of them, but it would be interesting to see how much is known. Zoroastroanism is very scarcely talked about on RUclips, and it would be amazing to cover in this series the Gathas and the Avesta.
@@luigianchondo7241 In my case it is based on Luigi from Super Mario. Quite an old username. Let's hope the video on the Avesta comes out. I really think there should be more information on RUclips about zoroastroanism and Ancient Iran in general.
i second this.
Agree!
I wrote the Avesta in college with George Lucas. We basically just spent a week locked in our dorm with an ounce of pot and a big bag of adderalls. AMA
The Avesta is really interesting especially when compared to the Vedas
Thanks. Your explanations and visuals are very clear.👍
That's a perfect way to present such a sensitive topic .
Slight Correction, Sunni Tradition holds that even before Uthman, the Quran was compiled into a single copy under Abu Bakr RA, 6 months after the Prophet SAW died, due to a bunch of reciters getting killed during the Battle of Yamama. What Uthman RA did was was standardized it and make many copies of it and respectfully retire the minor variations (called Ahruf) (the Quran is retired like a Flag in America, throwing it away is considered as disrespectful so we burn out of respect)
This copy was kept by one of poet Mohammed's wife, but was lost.
Also, acording to the young girl Aisha much was lost, and the cow 🐮 surah was longer.
This PH guy has no idea what he's talking about. There are no legitimate sources to prove his comments. Just rubbish conjecture.
@@sonofagun00 just because you want to protect your silly deen from criticism.
@@sonofagun00 when a girl turns 10, she is not good any more... the good ones are like Aisha.
I just wanted to say thank you for your subtitling. I know it is a lot of work but it is so helpful for people who need it.
Brilliant work as always
It's entirely plausible that he doesn't do the subtitling himself. There are tons of people online who you can pay to do subtitles for videos (Fiverr has many such people).
Also, one excellent newer feature of youtube is the ability to edit the auto-generated subtitles. Because Matt speaks so clearly and precisely, I bet that he uses this method, and likely has to make barely any edits to them in order to make them 100% correct.
why doesn`t trinity is written in bible,,.;'[.
why doesn`t trinity is written in bible
@@lufhopespeacefully2037 Because it's not Biblical, that's why. The ending of Mathew that mentions The Father, Son and Holy Spirit was added very, very late. It was not found in the early Greek manuscripts. Jesus' disciples did not believe that Jesus was God during his life, they started believing that he became divine when he was exalted tovheaven after his alleged resurrection.
I would be interested in an episode on who wrote the buddhist Pali Canon (and potentially also follow ups with the question who wrote the Mahayana Sutras)
Sanskrit mostly for chinese
That would be like a 500+ hour video
I'm a Muslim but honestly that would be extra interesting
Interesting study and comparison❤❤❤
Would love to see a video about who wrote the Homeric poems, but I'm not gonna pressure you man. It's your channel and it's up to you to decide what content you want to make next.
I on the other hand will pressure you.
As will I. DEW IT
This is most funniest TOPIC I feel like even I can write pedophilia Religion 😭
I would love this!!
D'oh
I really love how respectful you always are to religious people in your explanations!
felt more like fear than respect, with his meandering disclaimer. lol
@@valerianmonye402 Yeah, sounds like he’s trying to avoid death threats more than simply being respectful
@@potts995 why should other have to be respectful to their religion? That's already kind of terrorism.
@@potts995 Extremly religius people are cinda scary i remember talking to someone and they argued that the Only morals we got is What comes from the bible (the person was Christian btw )
That made me realise What would those people do If they Dident belive in something like that
Would they be normal and have Basic understanding What is right or wrong
Or
Would they be a lunatic😂
@@IwasUnknownUser no it’s not it’s respect. How did you equate respect to terrorism. Everything deserves respect
This was amazing
Great video as always. Thanks!
🤔Thank you for the research, knowledge and great efforts in doing your work.
it contains just perhapses that's not knowledge that's an opinion and to be frank he cited some incorrect things like the Quran was not written in life time of the Prophet Muhammed that's not right because the compagnions of the Prophet did write it in his time and one of the very famous historical figure that did it was the first ommeyad Calife muawiyah ibn abi soufyan and it was compiled in one book called al Musehaf and the Book used by Uthman to standardize the Musehafs across the state was that of the wife of the Prophet Muhammed called Hafsa bint Umar ibn al khattab so he does not know that and for the Book being based on Syriac and as an Arabic speaker that is mostly a Bull shit, Syriac and Arabic belong to the same family tree everybody who tried to do this manoeuvre indeed tried to distort the meanings of resembling words that have different meanings in the two language and that is a deliberate corruption based on fallacies, for the Sanaa manuscript I don't know his position exactely but it has a very known story for a later time to tell but he is assuming that inconsistencies existed in the text that 's also a declaration made to out-proportion the dialectal differences in Quraysh tribe's ( the Prophet's Tribe) language that used to exist in the way of recitation, these differences are very minor and don't distort anything neither in the text nor in the meaning and the most important of that they are very known and classified and very very few dialectal differences , this Book is very well preserved because everybody in that time learned it by heart directly from a chain of well known people traced to the prophet so for the language beeing without vowel that's a void and wrong argument because the Book at that time was taught verbaly and no one was allowed to teach it or to recitate it in prayer without learning it verbaly from someone who also learned it verbaly from another till the chain ends up to the prophet, the one who learn it just from the mushaf was called a musehafi and it was a kind of pejorative description.
As an ex-mormon, I am so excited for the "Who wrote the Book of Mormon" video.
If you haven't already. I would suggest looking up Mosiah Priority. I think it's a very interesting theory that explains the odd structure of the book, and fits well with what was happening to Joseph Smith at the time.
Joseph Smith and Muhammad have a lot in common.
The book of Mormon is just a single taken book of the bible I forget which one it starts with a D, I had a book of Mormon one time and compared it with the bible book and it was the same.
@@AnDyity There are a number of differences between The Book of Mormon and Deuteronomy. I look forward to Matt's coverage of this, because there's not an obvious answer.
@@AnDyity You could be thinking of Isaiah. The entire book of 2nd Nephi in the Book of Mormon is cribbed word for word from Isaiah in the Old Testament.
Mormons and early Muslims have so much in common. I wouldn’t be surprised if Mormons evolve into the 5th big Abrahamic religion, behind Christians, Muslims, Jews, and Baha’i
1:10 the way you didn’t make picture/graphics of the islamic prophets.. is very respectful of you Sir. ❤ thank you for making this vid☺️
Which prophets? The ones who marry 6 years old girls like Muhammed ?
@@suprememasteroftheuniverseIn the time stamp it reads: Moses, Abraham, Elijah, David.
No mention of Muhammad.
Very well explained
4:55. I am a Muslim, I am not offended, I continue watching, I want to hear alternative theories. I am good. I respect your views which I may or may not agree but nothing wrong listening to the alternative theories..
allah says in quran :
"And if you have any doubt as to (the truthfulness of the Qur'ân) which We have revealed to Our servant from time to time, produce a single Sûrah (- Qur'ânic chapter) like any of (the chapters of) this, summoning (to your assistance) all your helpers (that you have) beside Allâh, if you are truthful (in your doubts),"
"But if you fail to do (so), and never shall you do (it), then guard against the Fire, the fuel of which will be human beings (who are deviating from the way of truth) and stones, (it is) prepared for the disbelievers.
"
quran chapter 2 verses 23 and 24
1400 years since this verse was revealed on the prophet and to this day no one was able to fulfill this challenge
then you're one in a million. Muslim take holiness of quran extremely seriously
@@SaeedAcronia Nah , most of us are like it , unless you watch fox news.
@@SaeedAcronia extremist muslim (NOT ISIS) should get secular academic with skepticism , islam intersect the secular(human) and the spiritual(divine)
••Quran encourages verification of any news that reaches to a believer.
"O you who have believed, if there comes to you a disobedient one with information, investigate, lest you harm a people out of ignorance and become, over what you have done, regretful." (Quran 49:6)
••Quran also encourages that believers must reflect upon religion and not just obey religion blindly. Allah says in Quran:
"And those who, when reminded of the verses of their Lord, do not fall upon them deaf and blind." (Quran 25:73)
@@mt000mp That's a circular logic. If it turns out that Quran was written by humans and not God, then you wouldn't be a muslim because being a muslim means believing quran is from God. Also you wouldn't be able to refer to Quran anymore because it was fake in that case.
Amazing overview , analysis and insight into the multiplicity and overlapping derivations of sacred scriptures . There wouldn’t be enough hours in the day for one to read all the texts / books , so WOW ! Thanks a lot !
The Holy Qur’an differs from the rest in that it is only one copy in all the countries of the world, and even in the written texts, it is the only word that has not been changed.
@@FuhhFyuhb-wb1zp😂lol yeah right 🤣
Next!
@@FuhhFyuhb-wb1zp There have been some manuscripts that have slightly different words in it (though, yes, the Qur’an appears to have been scarcely edited, at least relative to other holy books). And the book was originally written/dictated in Arabic, which was translated to other languages, thereby changing the semantics anyway. But the book has pretty much stayed the same, at least of what we know of.
@@FuhhFyuhb-wb1zp WHAT A LOAD OF BULLSHIT HAHAHA
@@FeedYourBrainChannel All manuscripts of the Qur’an are identical to the Qur’an that we have today. The simple errors you are talking about in the Sanaa Manuscript are simple spelling errors, and the owner of the channel has a video titled The Sanaa Manuscript in which he shares the whole matter.
This is so great! Thank you! Would you be able to do one of these videos on the Book of Mormon? I know a lot of the contents are of 19th century theology or culture. This video is just so well done!
Already done sir :) ruclips.net/video/1ZsTw0_CnNk/видео.htmlfeature=shared
Fascinating thank you
🤔You bring joy to the people because your materials are so addictive, interesting and lovey in many ways. Thank you for your work, effort and understanding 🤔
Non-sense...!!! Quran thru Gabriel and written by God.. utter nonsense..
use some common sense here of when was Quran written and when was Old Testament written. BC and CE.
🤣🤣🤣Whoever the author of this video is, just look into the facts and then say Jew'sTorah and Bible are one and the same, whereas the Bible emphasizes on the old and new Testaments.
To add to your old videos on the moon of Muslim worship
The crescent of the new moon signifies the beginning and end of fasting during Ramadan. *However, this symbol did not originate with Islam; it was adopted for the first time by the city of Byzantine (which later became Istanbul).*
@@chj3289 this is the secular idea of the creation of the book, not the religious one
@@vecturhoff7502 Explain to us then. Is queer'an created or uncreated?
@@doyoufeel...thatyoulackcri6760 created of course
Great explanation with a super useful chart indeed!
it is not a great explanation at all ; quite contrary it is a very foolish explanation , according to him because the similar stories are found in other books ,he thinks they are inspired from other books , that's not necessarily correct . if there are similar apples inside two different baskets it doesn't mean the apples bounced from one basket to the other , it proves the similar apples were put in the baskets by a single God who created them at first place . the genuine source of all information is Great Allah ,whether you like it or not ...
I'm Muslim and I must say after watching the entire video that it is very informative and very insightful and most of it actually doesn't challenge the divinity of the Quran. Knowing that Muhammad was a trader before he settled with a well known tradeswoman and his first wife, Khadijah, he met all sort of people that made him question the paganism in Mecca, it was God's will that he meets those people, the ancient Christians and Jews and doesn't settle for worshiping the idols. There is one hadith where Muhammad tells us to debate Christians and Jews and they'll teach us a lot about our own faith and he is right, here I am learning more about my faith from a Jewish man, thank you so much. Also even the Syriac thing is very plausible, remember, the Quran standrised Arabic, and if that standardized Arabic was influenced by ancient Syriac Christians then that fills me with joy as well because I'm Lebanese, my ancestors were probably those people, and therefore we are the same people as ancient Arabs we didn't just adopt their culture, we merged.
Exactly. History does not challenge divinity of any religion. Denying history to push an ancient dogmatic narrative will only hurt your religion. Religion can and do evolve to incorporate new ideas and new understanding.
@@kyoungd Well said, I agree wholeheartedly.
So much cope smh. It's a fabricated collection of other stories.
@@DannyDoGood My bro of course you'd say that, otherwise you'd be Muslim, so if you didn't believe it's a collection of stories with some advice here and there, then it would appear to me that you've adopted Islam, which you have not.
My only problem with faiths in general, not just my own is that people tend to stick their own traditions and older faiths and try to sell those new old tenants as part of the faith, they're not, a lot of ancient Arab traditions should be split from Islam in my opinion, Islam is its own thing plus ancient Arabs were pagan.
@@Barakeh But it's not its own thing. We know where the influences come from.
Absolutely excellent!!
Enjoy ur videos so much.
Not too long, packed w/info, extremely exiting, & educational to boot.
Thank U so much.
Many Blessings to All 🙏 🇺🇸
There are so many issues with this video. I recommend that people see Hythem Sidky (an actual high quality secular academic) and his interview on Blogging Theology instead of this nonsense. Actually watching that will show exactly why I call this video nonsense and smoke and mirrors essentially.
Do people really just believe anytime on the internet like that? Does it make you fell Good to hear information that fits your narrative
Excellent presentation as usual 👍
very interesting. thanks
please release more videos on this topic
A minor correction at 20:25 : The Arabic language does indeed have vowels (all human languages have vowels), but rather it is the traditional Arabic script that typically or mostly does not express them in written form. Several other writing systems historically expressing other Afro-Asiatic languages, such as ancient Egyptian and Hebrew, also have this feature.
Come on! Arabic vowels are central to the language and writing. The first letter of the Arabic Alphabet is Alef, which is a vowel! The letter Wao is our O, and it looks like the English comma, also means AND. It is part of the decimal system and punctuation of European languages - an Arabic vowel!!! A third vowel is Yaa, which sounds like i and e and y depending on the word. The Arabic language is based on 3 or 4 letter root verbs, and these roots often contain one or two vowels. If you trace the origin of the vowel-less legend about Arabic you will find an idiot or an orientalist, which is the same thing often. 😢
@@youseffarawila8125 he means harakaat
There is no correction there you just said it yourself arabic does not recognize vowels you are adding to his point you are confused
@@isaiahdelacruz6221 Arabic (and all semitic languages) have long vowels, it's short vowels specifically that are embedded in each letter
There are diacritics included in my copy of the Qur'an... Which give an indication of the vowel sounds (I'm a total beginner at Arabic but very interested in it). Are these added for modern interpretation?
Brilliant work, Dr. Matt. Thank you!
Non-sense...!!! Quran thru Gabriel and written by God.. utter nonsense..
use some common sense here of when was Quran written and when was Old Testament written. BC and CE.
🤣🤣🤣Whoever the author of this video is, just look into the facts and then say Jew'sTorah and Bible are one and the same, whereas the Bible emphasizes on the old and new Testaments.
To add to your old videos on the moon of Muslim worship
The crescent of the new moon signifies the beginning and end of fasting during Ramadan. *However, this symbol did not originate with Islam; it was adopted for the first time by the city of Byzantine (which later became Istanbul).*
⚠️⚠️🚨🚨🚨This is my response to you:
14:10 *(The story of Abraham breaking idols)*
You said, *"It comes from a commentary on the Book of Genesis, written by a rabbi, sometime between 300 and 500 CE So, it's certainly possible that Muhammad was familiar with the story"*
But you only mentioned half the truth. The scholars indicated that this text had been subjected to *distortion, and that it was subject to always for long and short additions* (1)
Even the scholar *Becker* described it as an *“open text”* because it is an expandable commentary (2) , and that it *"appears to have been revised in a belated way in the Middle Ages."* (3)
And it was stated in the *"Encyclopaedia Judaica 7/449”*: *"There are several parts in Genesis Rabbah whose style, language and exegetical character do not represent an integral part of the original midrash, but rather they are late additions"*
The story of “Ibrahim” with idols and fire appears in chapter 38 of the Midrash, *it is among the chapters that scholars have said that it has been subject to distortion and belated revision.* And although it resembles the Qur’anic story, it is noted here:
*The Midrash story contrasts with the Qur’anic story in detail in many ways.*
* This midrash has been subjected to *severe change*, and Orientalists and evangelists do not have an argument for the *authenticity* of this story in this midrash or for the proof that it existed in it before *the time of the Prophet Muhammad,* noting that the oldest manuscript of this midrash in our hands today: (Vat. 30) dates back to 400-500 years after the appearance of Islam!!(4) Also, the text published today in the original language, which was prepared by Theodor and Albeck (1929 AD), does not match any ancient manuscript due to the many
differences between them!
*#################################################*
15:29 *(Mary And the Palm Tree)*
You said, *"a very similar story is told about Mary and the palm tree"* and claimed that there is only *one difference* between the two stories.
But the truth is that there are at least 6 differences between the two stories *(in the place, time, characters of the story, what miracle happened, what caused it and who did it)*
15:40 You said, *"Pseudo-Matthew was written around the same time as Muhammad lived"* But many scholars such as *(Robert Miller, Lynette R. Muir, J.K. Elliott, and J. A Tasioulas)* say that it was written in the eighth or ninth century, i.e. *after the advent of Islam.*
(5)
15:58 You said, *"its more likely is that this was simply a well known story that was floating around at the time and that both authors were familiar with it"* But the scholar *(G. K. Eliot)* explicitly stated that the *Pseudo-Matthew was not known in the East*
Stephen J. Shoemaker said, *"It appears that the apocryphal gospel of Matthew was written somewhat late, which prevents it from having an impact on the Qur'anic text, and most importantly, this apocryphal gospel was composed in the beginning in Latin somewhere in the Christian West and was completely unknown in the Christian East"* (6)
*#################################################*
16:12 *(SLEEPERS IN THE CAVE)*
As for the story of (The Seven Sleepers), it is a historical event mentioned by the Qur’an in order to take a lesson from it, and the Qur’an never claimed that there is no other book that preceded this story!! . And your saying that it is a well-known story to other nations, this supports the fact that this story occurred because it has historical testimonies!
*#################################################*
16:12 *(DUHL-QARNAYN)*
You did not mention any book before the Qur’an that narrates the story of Dhul-Qarnayn, but you most likely mean the book of Alexander Romance, especially the Syriac version of it, which some orientalists claim to be a source of the Qur’an, but the truth is those Syriac versions of Alexander the Great were written after the advent of Islam under the Islamic rule.
Ernest Wallis Budge says in his book (The life and exploits of Alexander the Great: being a series of translations of the Ethiopic histories of Alexander by the Pseudo-Callisthenes and other writers, with introduction, etc) about the *Syrianc versions of Alexander Romance were inspired by the Arabic culture and were written under the rule of Islam* This means those Syrianc versions were written and inspired by the Arabic culture, *not quoting from the Greek ones*
He also said it was written by a *Syrianc Christian person who lived in the Islamic countries under the rule of the Abbasid Caliphate during the 10th century AD*
B. M. Wheeler says, *"A more discerning examination of the different texts show that the later recensions of the Alexander stories are dependent upon the Qur'an as understood through the medium of early Muslim commentators. Key elements of the later stories, such as the appellation of "Dhu al-Qarnayn" attributed to Alexander owe their origins to the commentaries"* (7)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1- The Jewish Encyclopedia, 3l64
2- Chaim Milikowsky, ‘On the Formation and Transmission of Bereshit Rabba and the Yerushalmi: Questions of Redaction, Text-Criticism and Literary Relationships,’ in The Jewish Quarterly Review, New Series, Vol. 92, No. 3/4 (Jan. - Apr., 2002), p.526
3- Scott B. Noegel and Brannon M. Wheeler, Historical Dictionary of Prophets in Islam and Judaism, Maryland: Scarecrow Press, 2002, p.124
4- L. M. Barth, An Analysis Of Vatican 30, 1973, Monographs of the Hebrew Union College No. 1, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute Of Religion, pp. 88-89 (Quoted by, M S M Saifullah, The Story Of Abraham And Idols In The Qur'an And Midrash Genesis Rabbah)
5- Robert Miller, Born Divine, the Births of Jesus and other Sons of God, California: Plebridge Press, 2003, pp.309-310
Lynette R. Muir, The Biblical Drama of Medieval Europe, New York: Cambridge University Press, 2003, p.89,
Richard P. McBrien, eds. The HarperCollins Encyclopedia of Catholicism, New York: HarperCollins, 1995, p.53
J. K. Elliott, The Apocrypahl Jesus, Legends of the Early Church, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008, p.11
J. A. Tasioulas, ‘Between Doctrine and Domesticity: The Portrayal of Mary in the N-Town Plays,’ in Diane Watt, ed. Medieval Women in their Communities, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1997 ,p.228
6- J K. Elliott, The Apocryphal New Testament, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005, p.84
Stephen J. Shoemaker, Christmas in the Qur'an: The Qur'anic Account of Jesus' Nativity and Palestinian Local Tradition. Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 28 (2003), p.19
7- B. M. Wheeler "Moses Or Alexander? Early Islamic Exegesis Of Qur'an 18:60-65", Journal Of Near Eastern Studies, 1998, op cit., p. 214
It is very easy to refute Islam! Because the God of Islam does not know that according to Christianity God incarnated
True love = the love of God!
*God himself went to the cross for you out of love for you as a human being*
Philippians 2:5-8
@@rosalia2940 lol easy to refute islam because it doesn’t confirm my made up beliefs about worshiping a human 😂😂😂 get real woman
@@intuitive_data_science *surah 4:80* alLah associates muhammad a partner with alLah and makes him god.
Do you think alLah will be able to forgive alLah for the sin of comitting shirk?
Good analysis
Unscientific stuff in Quran:
(Q20.53, 71.19) The earth is a stationary carpet pegged by mountains to keep it stable.
(Q18.86) The sun sets into a pond.
(Q71.16) The moon emits light.
(Q2.260) Dead birds can fly.
(Q17.66) Ships float because of Allah's power. Really?? LOL
(Q16:79) Birds fly because of Allah's power. Really?? LOL
(Q16.66) Milk comes from the belly.
(Q86.5-7) Semen comes from backbone and the ribs.
Quran 36:37-40 - resting place of the sun non-existent in reality
Quran 18:86 - muddy spring where the sun dwells
Quran 18:90 - place from where the non-existent sun rises
Quran 41:11-12 heaven created together with the earth big-bang has an age of 13.8 billion years ago, the earth has an age of 4.5 billion years
Quran 41: 11-12 heaven and earth united together, it is not true since the earth is 9 billion years younger than the universe
Quran 2:29 earth created before heaven (same as above)
Quran 37:6-10 stars as protection against devils and angels beyond the stars
Quran 67:5 stars as lamps and as arrows for devils
Quran 75:8-9 the sun and moon cannot unite because they are in different orbits
Quran 36:40 In eclipses the opposite happens and the moon can also be present during the day
Quran 69:16 Heaven formed by a rigid structure that will become fragile
Quran 52:44 The sky may fall to pieces
Quran 34:9 The sky may fall to pieces
Quran 22:65 The sky may fall
Quran 21:104 The sky can be rolled up
Quran 39:67 The sky can be rolled up
Quran 25:45-46 Allah lengthens the shadow, in reality it is the inclination of the light
Quran 23:12-14 It says that first the bones are formed and then the flesh, in reality it happens at the same time
Quran 75:37-39 People are born only from sperm, that's not true. I hide with the union of the egg.
Quran 86:6-7 Sperm created between the spine and ribs
Quran 77:20-22 People are born only from sperm
Quran 23:13 People are born only from sperm
Quran 80:18-19 People are born only from sperm
Quran 76:2 People are born only from sperm
Quran 23:14 Sperm becomes coagulated blood to create man
Quran 96:2 Man is born from a blood clot
Quran 51:49 Species created in male and female, there is a type of lizard that is only female in addition to the botanical species
Quran 36:36 Species created in male and female, there is a type of lizard that is only female in addition to the botanical species
Quran 75:39 Species created in male and female, there is a type of lizard that is only female in addition to the botanical species
Quran 39:6 Fetus wrapped in three darknesses, Greek idea of the doctor Galen that the fetus was wrapped in three membranes
Quran 22:46 The heart is used for reasoning, a false discovery by Aristotle and others but copied into the Quran out of ignorance
Quran 11:5 The heart is used for thinking, a false discovery by Aristotle and others but copied into the Quran out of ignorance
Quran 17:46 The heart serves to understand, a false discovery by Aristotle and others but copied into the Quran out of ignorance
Quran 16:66 Absence of knowledge of the mammary glands
Quran 2:187 Fasting until sunset, impossible near the poles
Quran 17:78 Morning and evening prayers impossible near the poles
Quran 43:10 [He] who made the earth a bed for you
Quran 71:19 Earth like a carpet, there are no spherical carpets
Quran 2:22 Earth as a bed, there are no spherical beds
Quran 78:6-7 Earth as a non-spherical expanse
Quran 51:48 Non-spherical spread earth
Quran 15:19 Earth like a carpet, there are no spherical carpets
Quran 20:105-107 The earth is a curveless plain, impossible as it is spherical
Quran 18, 85-89 Reaching the point where the sun sets and where it rises, impossible as it is spherical
Quran 18, 85-89 Sun setting in a puddle
Quran 55:18 He does not know the north and the south
Quran 70:41 It does not know the north and the south
Quran 25:53 Non-existent division between waters
Quran 27:61 Non-existent division between seas
Quran 55:19-22 Non-existent division between seas
Quran 43:10 roads that you may be guided, no knowledge of compass or other tools for orientation
Quran 16:15 Rivers and seas for guidance, no knowledge of compass or other tools for orientation
Quran 16:15 The mountains serve to keep the earth firm
Quran 16:15 The mountains are cast upon the earth
Quran 6:125 The chest contracts with altitude, in reality the opposite happens
Quran 29:37 Earthquake is for those who deny Allah
Quran 17:68 Tornadoes raining stones
Quran 43:11 It rains on dry land, no knowledge of rainforests or the water cycle or evaporation or floods (it says it always rains in due time)
Quran 24:43 Mountains of hail in the clouds
Quran 13:13 Lightning is for Allah to strike
Quran 27:18-19 Ants recognize men and soldiers
Quran 39:6 Existence of only 8 types of livestock
Quran 6:142-144 Existence of only 8 types of livestock: sheep, goats, oxen and camels does not know Reindeers (a species of deer) or Alpacas (a particular breed of camels)
Quran 16:8 Horses born for the use of humans must actually be domesticated
Quran 6:38 Jaguars and leopards are exclusively solitary or a type of lizard
Quran 16:79 Birds are kept by Allah and not by the dynamics of flight
Quran 67:19 Birds are kept by Allah and not by the dynamics of flight
Historians:
Quran 5:116 Mary divinity
Quran 5:72-75 Allah ⅓ of 3: Misunderstanding of the trinity where all three are always God, they are not a fraction
Quran 19:27-28 Mary, sister of Aaron
Quran 3:33-36 Imran father of Mary when he is actually the father of Moses
Quran 9:30 Ezra son of God for the Jews, never considered such he was only a priest and scribe
Quran 87:9-19 False description of hell in the writings of Abraham and Moses
Quran 18:96-101 Iron wall between two mountains never existed
Quran 34:10-11 David the inventor of iron chain mail
Quran 21:79-80 David the inventor of chain mail
Quran 12:41 Corcifixion in the time of Joseph 1600 B.C., crucifixion is a technique from 500 B.C.
Quran 20:71 Crucifixions in the time of Moses 1200 B.C., crucifixion is a technique from 500 B.C.
Quran 20:85 Samaritans in the time of Moses (l-sāmiriyu with the definite article, "the Samiri", so this is a descriptive title rather than a proper name)
Quran 20:95 Samaritans in the time of Moses (l-sāmiriyu with the definite article, "the Samiri", so this is a descriptive title rather than a proper name)
Quran 12:20 Countable currency in ancient Egypt, non-existent, quantities were weighed
Quran 5:20 Jewish kings before Moses
Quran 71:23-26 Arab gods from the time of Muhammad already in the time of Moses who exist after the flood that should have destroyed them
Quran 19:7 Name of John given first in the world to the son of Zechariah, false there was a king John Hyrcanus I who died in 104 B.C. hence the name was used
Quran 17:1 Ancient holy mosque in Jerusalem, never existed
Quran 40:24 Haman advisor to Pharaoh in the time of Moses, but was the advisor to the king of Persia for the Jewish book of Esther
Quran 95:1-3 Mecca as a haven of peace suffered many attacks after Muhammad
Quran 16:36 Every nation had a messenger, never happened
Quran 35:24 Messengers in every people of the world, never happened
Quran 46:27 Cities destroyed near Mecca, no archaeological finds
Quran 11:40 Part of the flood waters come out of an oven
Quran 23:27 Part of the flood waters come out of an oven
Quran 43:3 The Quran is in Arabic because it is easy to understand, today only 3.4% of the world's population uses it
Quran 2:282 Women have mental deficiencies compared to men, this is not scientifically true
Quran 2:65 Human beings transformed into monkeys
Quran 20:88 The Ora calf of Moses is capable of lowing
Quran 5:114-115 A table with food from heaven descends to Jesus
Quran 27:16-17 Solomon knew the language of birds
Quran 27:20-23 Solomon knew the language of birds
Quran 17:1 Muhammad reaches Jerusalem in one night
Quran 24:24 The parts of the body will be able to testify
Quran 38:36 Solomon can control the wind
Quran 2:73 The dead are raised by pieces of heifers (cows that have not given birth)
@@user-iu2rs
"Religion began when the first scoundrel met the first fool." ----- Voltaire
@@AtamMardes
Generalizing is always wrong.
@@user-iu2rs Honest people won't deny the fact that man made Allah, the God of the Bible, Romulus, Zalmoxis, Osiris, Krishna, Zeus, Satan, Bible, Quran, heaven, hell, angles, Garden of Eden, Adam & Eve, sin, savior, sacrifice, resurrection, parting the Red Sea, walking on water, splitting the moon, UFO sightings, Santa Clause, Tooth Fairy, Superman, Batman, Darth Vader, etc.
@@AtamMardes The truth exists and is in the Lord Jesus.
This dropped in the middle of my finals schedule and I needed this badly! Thanks for this series, this channel is probably one of the best finds I've made this year.
Good luck on your finals!
There are so many issues with this video. I recommend that people see Hythem Sidky (an actual high quality secular academic) and his interview on Blogging Theology instead of this nonsense. Actually watching that will show exactly why I call this video nonsense and smoke and mirrors essentially.
@@John-lf3xf You can't just say the video is shit without providing any explanation or reasoning. It's dishonest.
@@gmansplit True. I did in a long comment which you will find if you look through recent comments and scroll down to the comments which are from around the date of the reply above you are looking at on this chain.
why doesn`t trinity is written in bible,,.;'[.
Idk how to thank you for your whole painful effort on the research, the subtitles, and the cute, eye-catching, colorful charts. Thank you soooo much..
Non-sense...!!! Quran thru Gabriel and written by God.. utter nonsense..
use some common sense here of when was Quran written and when was Old Testament written. BC and CE.
🤣🤣🤣Whoever the author of this video is, just look into the facts and then say Jew'sTorah and Bible are one and the same, whereas the Bible emphasizes on the old and new Testaments.
To add to your old videos on the moon of Muslim worship
The crescent of the new moon signifies the beginning and end of fasting during Ramadan. *However, this symbol did not originate with Islam; it was adopted for the first time by the city of Byzantine (which later became Istanbul).*
Islam is formed with Forces, Swords ⚔️, Bullets, Killings, means all are Converted from other religions.
No self ideology,,No laws,, Only Men's are rulling,, Womens are tortured,, Womens are machines for producing 20,30, 50 childrens.. 4/5/6 wives...Talak TALAK Talak 3 words to destroy Women's,,,
Interested in 72 HOORS with very big size Breast....Ladies have no place in society.
Hum converted SUWARS Hai.
Hum KALAMA Padhate hai...
Huma-me JAJABA hai...
Hum TALAK de sakate hai...
Hum HALALA bhee karate hai(enjoyment)...
72 HOORS with big boobs for us...
We can produce 20/30/50 kids , hamara Penis عضو تناسل Powerful Hai(4/6 wives)...
Kya huwa, hamare bachche بچے Pancharwala Beggers Hotel worker Butcher Riksha puller hai to,, JIHADI bhee hai, inshallah....
@@chj3289 ah i see. You say the Al quran is copy of Bible
*Who explains to us why the Koran says Christians believe God has a biological son!*
To all Muslims! Son of God means NOT SON! What is called the son of God is the word of God = god himself! Which has nothing to do with a child (son)! Thus, the Son of God is incarnated as the human Jesus and the human Jesus is therefore referred to as a son, which does not mean a son!
Hebr 1,2 Hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son, whom he hath appointed heir of all things, *by whom also he made the worlds;*
as everyone can see the term Son of God refers to the Word of God = god himself! For through that God created the worlds! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
I'm a Muslim (a convert actually from Christianity) I enjoyed your videos and I find it interesting to hear what scholars have to say..
I'm not offended by anything you said.
I appreciate your respectful and professional time throughout your video.
I also wanted to add my two cents
About Dhul Qarnayn not all Scholars agree on who he was..
There is a opinion that I follow that Dhul Qarnayn was actually King Cyrus of Persia.
He built the fortifications of Derbent, defeated the Babylonians ending the Exile of Israelites from the Holy Land and rebuilt the Sacred Temple (Solomon's Temple).
Anyways thanks for the info.
I'm ex Muslim from Pakistan🇵🇰❤❤love your video😍😍
There are some misrepresentations in this. Most Muslims believe the Quran was written down in the time of the Prophet. The Prophet encouraged this and had dedicated scribes. This collection of writings were gathered together during the reign of Abu Bakr, immediately after the Prophet's death. Importantly, there were several spoken forms of the Quran, somewhat like how different dialects pronounce the same words differently - this was approved and accepted in the time of the Prophet. In the time of Uthman, as the Muslim community expanded massively, there were fears that different spoken forms would lead to conflict, so 6 skilled Quran scholars were appointed to compile a definitive "version" of the Quran. This group used the Quraishi dialect and interviewed all available companions in Medina who memorised parts of the Quran to compile a robust version. This version was cross checked with the Abu Bakr version. Thus, there were no material differences in the Quran, there were just oral differences that were aligned under Uthman. This is a key difference in understanding between Muslim scholars and Orientalists.
David Wood, Al Fadi, Jay Smith and Apostate Prophet have debunked all these claims you've made.
@@eugeneteddyowusu4289 💀them clowns did nothing, why not look to opposing views before concluding that?
@@eugeneteddyowusu4289 very easy to say so and so debunked this, which sounds clever until you realise you haven't said anything at all. Why don't you tell me which point isn't accurate and why, and I can respond. BTW those ppl you mention themselves make numerous misrepresentations of Islam. They are not scholars, they are individuals with a ready made conclusion who look for arguments to support their conclusion.
Just to add, the main reason Abu Bakr decide to compile the Quran in the first place was because he noted that a number of Muslims who memorized the Quran by heart died in battle during the Ridda War. However, the movement didn't take place until the time of Umar since Abu Bakr was prioritizing in quelling the rebellion and strengthening the Muslims in order to face the Byzantine and the Sassanid.
@@eugeneteddyowusu4289 Lmao david wood says a bunch of bs in his videos, but when it comes down to debates, david wood loses pretty much all of his debates
As much as I hate to start any conversation with "uhh as a....", I have to say, as a Muslim born and raised in Madinah (where the prophet Muhammad went to after leaving Mecca), I clicked on the video with a TON of bias and preconceived notions but by the end of it I can say that I truly appreciate your work for it's value.
I still have my opinions and faith, but regardless I can see value in this video. And I do understand that people don't really like to speak about anything even loosely related to Islam or prophet Muhammad for fear of offending almost 1.7 billion human around the globe, so props to you for doing this regardless.
However, I do have a slight issue with the video though. The statement you make at 19:03 seems a bit off, I don't know if it's an issues of translation or lack of sources but there are in fact a bunch of examples were the Quran mentions things that were impossible to know at the time. A quick example I can mention- and perhaps you'd like to research more into this- is when the Quran mentions the process of conception. It details the process and the steps a fertilized egg go through right up to birth in great detail and with very specific choice of word. This example can be found in surah 23, verses 12 through 15. There are however other examples with things that cannot be seen without a microscope and such.
Regardless, thank you for spending the time and energy to make this video, and for making extra effort to make sure that you don't offend anyone and using very pleasant and neutral words. If for nothing, at least the video opens the door for conversation between people of all religions and beliefs.
Thank you.
Also the beginning verses of 'Surah Roome'
Excellent response.
Thanks for expressing your views. As a catholic I really like to investigate the aspects of other religions, though I remained convinced of my faith. I will pray for your soul and possibly your conversion. May God be with you.
Hmmmm … should we take the Quran as a scientific book? I probably won’t advise for that as that water is quite shallow….. the whole idea of scientific miracles in the Quran is the paramount example of cherry picking… … it’s a theme that has been promoted in the last 50 years … but will not stand the test on several affirmations of the Quran. Even in the example you have brought forward of the development of the fetus, the step of و كسونا العظام لحما is incorrect.
@@tarikberair9562 yeah, even some muslim apologists believe that we can't use 'scientific miracles' to justify quran.
Nice video, you forgot to mention that there are millions of Hafiz around the world who have memorised the entire Quran from cover to cover in its original form. No other scripture / religion have this advantage and dedication from its followers.
Indeed.
Have you ever heard of the Pali Canon? If not, I have to disappoint you. The entirety of the early Buddhust scriptures were memorized orally for some centuries before being written down to preserve them from being lost due to political turmoil. Even after being written down, the oral memorization continues to this day among certain groups of Theravadins. During the sixth Buddhist council in the 20th century, when official versions of the Pali text were decided on to be transcribed into the Singhalese, Thai and Burmese national scripts, elder monks who memorized the Pali Canon were an essential part when deciding on the details of the doctrine. The closest disciple of the Buddha, his cousin Ananda, is attributed to have had an exquisitely trained memory, to the point where he could pretty much dictate the entire life of the Buddha 3 months after the Buddha's total extinguishment (Parinirvana).
@@user-bs4qu7tb2g it could be but is it still memorised by millions ?? The number Hafiz(who memorise Quran) will never fall down.Still all over the world hundreds of thousands people, children are memorising it. That is the beauty of Quran. There so many hafiz among my relatives, childhood friends. And they have other profession as well. That is how Allah(our God) kept it secure.
In Judaism we have many thousands of scholars that memorize every book of the Torah
Their were only 4 hafiz
I like the way the history is being explored here. But as a muslim, I must make some notes.
The Quran and its verses were preserved because it is one of the promises and statements of Allah.
So if Angel Gabreil revealed the verses from Allah to Prophet Mohammed, there was no need for him to come across the biblical/torah stories from elsewhere where.
Another pretty strong evidence of the Quran being divine, are the various scientific processes that were only discovered recently by scientists.
So it’s preserved because it says it is? Just curious, so why did god fail to preserve the earlier revelations? Seems odd.
When someone claims that he was visited by an angel would you believe him, or note that those stories he’s relating were in circulation in oral and written form among the community he lived in? Which would be more probable?
No, none of the so called scientific processes in the Quran are new ideas when it was written. As above, they were in circulation in the 6th century CE, or are so vaguely described that the claim is overstated.
Love it! Definitely keep up the good work
7:50 small addition. It was the caliph Aby Bakr who compiled the first Quran (less than two years after the death of the prophet pbuh)
@Stomp on a leftys Face Oh look ! An angry pagan.
Yes he forgot to mention that, bt rather skipped to when the standardization was completed under Uthman.
Umar made the suggestion to Abubakar, who began the process but the process was completed under Uthman!
This is a vital point that shouldn't be ignored.
He also made a baseless argument that their wasn't any written manuscripts of the Quran during the Prophets lifetime when infact several of his companions had such copies but were discouraged to wait till the revelations were finished so they do not mix Quran with Hadith!
He never made any statement that several Companions memorized the Quran wic was why it wasn't tainted, and the concept of memorization is what makes it the most untainted religious book in history!
@@Professor_GCProcess of memorization wouldnt make it most untained. Rather it would do the opposite. Its well studied human memory can be...tricky. It can be changed and influenced by many things. Sickness, old age, trauma, etc.
@@cramax4871 Yes those factors can influence once memorization ONLY if that person stops reciting it daily to keep it their memory. Good thing the Quran exists in written texts that can easily read!
For a person who memorized a musical lyrics and sings publicly, a slight mistake like change of a word could be easily recognized by any random fan who knows such song, not because he reads The lyrics everyday but constantly listen and mym it.
Say what you want the Quran is not like the Bible that needs to be reedited by random fellows for selfish reasons everytime they need to print new copies.
People minds are different when it comes to memorization that's exactly why not every Muslim has the entire Quran memorized but most Muslims always have a copy they read and indeed the 5 daily prayers is also a factor that keeps such memory fresh.
@@Professor_GC "His companions had several copies". Source: Trust me bro.
The Birmingham Quran manuscript is a single sheet of parchment on which two leaves of an early Quranic manuscript or muṣḥaf have been written. In 2015, the manuscript, which is held by the University of Birmingham,[1] was radiocarbon dated to between 568 and 645 CE (in the Islamic calendar, between 56 BH and 25 AH).[2][3] It is part of the Mingana Collection of Middle Eastern manuscripts, held by the university's Cadbury Research Library.
What is written in the single parchment.
How many pages is the Birmingham quran
it was later discovered that it is not as old as it believed initially !
Ugh a Jewish brother doing more justice to Islamic history from an academic and neutral perspective than even some Muslims. Love it. Stay safe my Semitic brother.
Oo come on....
The one who doesn't know the Islamic history and makes video by searching other people's content through internet, cannot do any justice to history.
As of Islamic scholars, just check the history how did they recorded history in most difficult circumstances and tried their best efforts. Just check how hadith was recorded and how they tried to keep the records in most unbiased and authentic manner........
@@hussainhaider5334 I said some Muslims. Not some Islamic scholars, not most Islamic scholars. Some Muslims. Read the comment properly lol.
@@hussainhaider5334 hadith corrupted
@@tananata9657 Corrupted ones would not survive for so long. There is an extremely sophisticated process of judging the authenticity of an hadith and grading it. All the corrupted ones would have long been filtered out in the past 1400 years. Also there are things called weak hadith and strong hadiths.
@@wakilahmed5847 omly 915 hadith true or sahih the rest are fabrication
I like before watching! Thank you for the effort
I will answer some points , the last point mentioned by Luxembourg, Qura'an mentions that was revealed in Arabic to challenge Arabs whom are best known for a language can't be learned by other than Arabs and a challenge to their poetry which they took pride in. The mentioned stories goingback to the Bible are a challenge for people of the Book (jews and Nazarens (Christians now)) specially jews and a call for them to accept the new revelation which affirms the revelation they had from their prophets but with new jurisprudence , Qura'an even dictates what happened in the days of the prophet peace be upon. Qura'an also mentions stories unrelated to bible as Salih and Hud peace be upon them and tells the jews caliming the copying of their texts where those stories came from if that is true. Add to that if your claim are true , the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is quite a man : illiterate yet learned armaic , assyrian greek and hebrew , learned the Bible, apocryphal texts, Talmud (which is recently wrote down) and knew about greek legends. Affirming that God revealed Quraan is easier than affirming that a man with those circumstances where people wage war over a camel came up with this new book after learning 7 new languages and thousands of books.
"إن الله وملائكته يصلون على النبي يا أيها الذين آمنوا صلوا عليه وسلموا تسليما"
Well said
Well put
There was no Arabic Bible and as such we find that there’s barely a place in the Qur’an capable of accurately describing what Christians actually believe. I cannot think of one, but there are many places in which the Qur’an makes errors in describing Christian belief. Furthermore, in other places, the Qur’an repeats the false folklore tales of the Syriac Christians, such as Dhul Qarnayn / Alexander as if it were real history. But we know these stories are not true and where they come from.
It is clear that the author of the Qur’an was not too familiar with Christianity. This is actually a sign of it being all too human, I’m afraid.
@@dd6742 How does Quran get Christianity wrong?
@@dd6742 you're wrong , Qura'an tells about the trinity in Surah al-Ma'idah
73. They disbelieve those who say, “Allah is the third in a Trinity.” But there is no god, except One God. If they do not refrain from what they say, a painful punishment will befall those among them who disbelieve." , tells the father son narratives from both old and new testament:" jews said Uzair is the son of God then nazarens said Issa is the son of god". Qura'an doesn't mention holy spirit explicitly but refers to Jibril (Gabriel) as the trustworthy spirit (Ar'Rouh Al'Amine).
Qura'an also mentions that chistians saying Jesus is God in Surat AlMa'idah
"Surely, in disbelief are they who say that Allah is the Messiah, son of Maryam (Mary). Say (O Muhammad SAW): "Who then has the least power against Allah, if He were to destroy the Messiah, son of Maryam (Mary), his mother, and all those who are on the earth together?" And to Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all that is between them. He creates what He wills. And Allah is Able to do all things" that's for one. For two , the prophet peace be upon him traveled once to Levant when he was young then stayed his hole life and for the second time he didn't speak any language but arabic.
"إن الله وملائكته يصلون على النبي يا أيها الذين آمنوا صلوا عليه وسلموا تسليما "
Thnx man as a Muslim really respect
Yet you won't accept that your text is a forgery smh
14:53 - In Surah Maryam (19:23) it is generally believed to be the voice of an angel who tells Mary to shake the tree for the dates (not figs) to fall for her to eat. The Quran doesn’t state that it was Jesus in the womb who told her to do that.
Correct
@@deurellbussell5469 it doesnt matter
@@deurellbussell5469 LOL how do you know he never did that?did u there ??
@@deurellbussell5469 is there any prove jesus is the son of god?did u see god having sex with mary?
@@deurellbussell5469 this video has msiteks, Babylon wasn't mentioned in the quran. also the Assyrian language is absolutely not different language from arabic. why he failed to montione is that qurain doesn't claim to bring something new but correct what was corrugated. also thu al qarnayn is not known who is he and alexander never bulit a wall anywhere.... and most muslims believe it was cyrus the great.
The Birmingham Quran manuscript is a single sheet of parchment on which two leaves of an early Quranic manuscript or muṣḥaf have been written. In 2015 the manuscript, which is held by the University of Birmingham, was radiocarbon dated to between 568 and 645 CE
That means the parchment was possibly written during the lifetime of the prophet pbuh.
No! It means it was written by Mohammed et al!
Who wrote the Quran - Mohammed, his wife Khadijah, Omar and Khadijah’s cousin Waraqa ibn Nawfal (‘a clever Christian’). What sources did they use, everything that had gone before! But unable to erase ‘religious history’ they plagiarised and then modified it suit their own agenda! During his lifetime people knew he was rewriting myths, tales and other peoples religions.
The Quran mentions these critics of Muhammad; for example Quran 25:4-6 says the critics complained that Muhammad was passing off what others were telling him as revelations. (I can give at least three occasions where Omar admits to feeding Mohammed ideas which were then incorporated into the Quran).
Those who disbelieve say, "This is nothing but a lie that he made up, and others have helped him at it (Khadija & Omar). Tales of the ancients; he wrote them down; they are dictated to him morning and evening."
* If he ‘wrote them down’ then even the traditional ‘fact’ that he was illiterate is a lie! Without lies, Islam dies.
This proves only that the material of the parchment was taken from something that lived during that span of time.
It was 109 years after the traditional death of Mohammed before Mecca was mentioned in any text, and another 100 years after that before Mecca appeared on any map, yet several small towns and cities around its modern day location were mentioned.
Fact check from independent sources, if you dare!
@@venenareligioest410
You mean Waraqa Ibn Nawfal a clever Christian knew about the big bang theory. and the whole Embriology the creation of baby. you mean he knows the people of time of Abraham when they worshipped to a star. even this is not found in the Torah and bible. you mean Waraqa knows that Pharoah body will be kept for future generation. and much more...
You can not deny QURAN.
The Previous Books (Torah, and Gospel) changed and corrupted.
That's why God sent down the Last Testament (Quran) for the whole Mankind.
From Adam to the last Prophet Muhammad (Pbu them all). all were Muslims. and Muslims mean submit to the one TRUE GOD.
There is only ONE TRUE GOD.
From Adam to the last Prophet Muhammad (Pbu them all). all were prostrated to that one TRUE GOD.
even Jesus bow down and prostrated to one TRUE GOD.
and now Christians are following Paul instead of Jesus original message. (Pbuh).
Jews saying Ezra is the son of god.
and Christians saying Jesus is the son of god.
the TRUTH is both were Prophets of one TRUE GOD.
Jesus brought the Moses Law.
Moses never said about Trinity.
Moses knew that same one TRUE GOD of every Prophet.
For Moses God was "Elah, Elohim or Yaweh".
For Jesus God was "Alaha" in his Aramaic language.
The Trinity and Jesus devinity developed later by Church.
and the Jews are also agree with that.
The earlier Ebionites were TRUE followers of Jesus(Pbuh).
they were true Christians. they knew that Jesus was only a messenger of God and The True Messiah.
we Muslims have the updated version of God religions.
because the previous Torah and Gospel changed and corrupted by Men. they became Men made.
I request you Jews and Christians. update yourself before God delete you from the Paradise. 😂
Thank God i am a Muslim.
Peace ❤️✌️
There are three main stages of the preservation of the Holy Quran.
1. In the life of the Prophet Muhammad
2. In the life of the first Caliph, Abu Bakr
3. In the life of the third Caliph, Uthman ibn Affan
The Arabic word Caliph comes from the Arabic word khalifa "خليفة", meaning "successor" or "next in line." Abu Baker was the first leader of Muslims after the Prophet Muhammad's death and Uthman Ibn Affan was the third leader of Muslims.
🔸 In the life of the Prophet Muhammad
Allah granted the Prophet Muhammad the power to memorize the verses He revealed to him. Immediately, the Prophet under his supervision gathered his scribes and orally dictated the verses he just received to them to be written on whatever writing material that was available at that time. Since the Prophet Muhammad was illiterate, he directed his scribes to read back to him what they wrote to avoid writing other than what he received from God.
Afterward, the Prophet Muhammad recited what he memorized to the Muslims around him. Muslims instantly memorized what the Prophet recited to them and started reading what they memorized in their five daily prayers.
The Quran at the time of the prophet was preserved in two places:
1- The written pages.
2- The heart of Muslims.
The Prophet Muhammad also directed his scribes where to place the verses in the growing body of the text.
Allah promised to protect the Quran from being changed or lost:
Allah says in the Quran 15:9 (Interpretation of the meaning)
"Indeed We have sent down the Quran, and indeed We will preserve it."
During the Prophet Muhammad's life, thousands of Muslims memorized the entire Quran, and after his death, the number of Muslims who memorized the Quran kept increasing until we find today millions of Muslims of different nationalities and ages who know the Quran by heart. And many of them do not speak or understand Arabic.
❓❓WHAT DOES THIS MEAN❓❓
It means that if we were to destroy all the copies of the Quran books that exist on earth, Muslims in a different part of the world would be capable of rewriting the Quran exactly as it was revealed to Prophet Muhammad, from their memory, word by word and all the written Quran all around the world will match word by word and page by page. It further means that if anybody tries to add, change, or delete any word or verse in the Quran, Muslims will easily discover it and reject it.
🔸 In the life of the first Caliph of Muslims, Abu Bakr
Abu Bakr, the first leader of Muslims after the death of the Prophet Muhammad, realized the importance of collecting all the written pages of the Quran into one book. He formed a committee and assigned two known companions who memorized the Quran to supervise the compilation of the Quran. To make sure nothing was written by mistake, they double-checked each written verse with the memories of each member of the committee. Finally, the first compiled copy was placed with the Prophet Muhammad's wife Hafsa, daughter of Omar ibn al Khattab.
🔸 In the life of the third Caliph of Muslims, Uthman ibn Affan
One of the questions that many Islam attackers ask Muslims in an effort to disqualify the Quran we have today being the Word of God is: Why did the third leader of Muslims, Uthman, burn all copies of the Quran and keep only one copy during his reign? And point to Quran 15:9 where Allah says He will protect the revealed Quran verses from being changed or lost.
They do not bother to learn because they want only to attack Islam. Please pay attention to what I will write to be able to give a satisfying good answer.
When the Quran was revealed to the Prophet Muhammad there were different Arabic spoken dialects in the area. The Prophet Muhammad's spoken dialect was his tribe's Quraish dialect.
Do different Arabic dialects mean different Quran meanings?
Different Arabic dialect does not mean different meanings for the same spoken Arabic word, it means different pronunciation and is slightly differently written while the meaning stays the same regardless of what Arabic dialect different Arabic tribes speak.
After the Prophet Muhammad's death, the whole Quran was memorized by hundreds of thousands of Muslims and nobody was reported complaining about other people reading the Quran using different dialects.
By the time of the third leader of Muslims, Uthman ibn Affan, the Muslim population had spread over vast areas outside the Arabic Peninsula where there were many people of other cultures and languages. Hudhayfah ibn al-Yamaan, the companion of Prophet Muhammad, warned Uthman bin Affan about the future dilemma of having the Quran written in different dialects. Uthman bin Affan acknowledged the dilemma of Muslims starting to fight about in which dialect the Quran should be recited. Uthman ordered the collection of all the written copies of the Quran. He burned all of them and preserved only the Prophet Muhammad's Quraish tribe dialect copy of the Quran. Afterward, he assigned scribes to write many copies of the Prophet Muhammad's Quraish tribe dialect copy of the Quran and redistribute it to all tribes.
With Allah’s help and guidance to Hudhayfah ibn al-Yamaan and Uthman bin Affan, the Quran we have today, wherever you go, is the same original Arabic Quran that was revealed to the Prophet Muhammad in the Quraysh dialect.
🤔Think about it: Why did history not record any rejection from any tribe for burning its copy of the Quran?
Nobody rejected, it because It did not make any difference for any of them since the Quran verses give the same meaning no matter in what dialect it is written or recited.
Muslims always had ONE CONSISTENT Quran, which is still written in Arabic the original revelation language of revelation.
Please do your research.
@@baonemogomotsi7138
I did and wrote a document I shared it with others 🙂
Now did you do any research about the Bible, I did and also wrote a document I share with others.
How can I copy this comment I want to save it
@@theanimatology9801
1- highlight the text in the reply. You can highlight by clicking the right mouse button at the beginning of the reply and then go to the end of the reply and holding the shit down and at the same time click the end of the reply. The reply will be highlighted. Then click the left mouse button while your mouse pointer is placed above the highlighted area and choose copy.
2- Past it into your Word document by clicking the left mouse button and choosing the "Paste (Keep the text)" option.
3- Fix it if needed
i am a Muslim and loved your video
Well Quran was written during the life of Prophet Muhammad PBUH during his life, however it was on individual pages, Caliph Uthman unified it in the form of a book. You can still find several such pieces today. 2nd thing is than the different versions of Quran were different in dialects like waladwaleen vs walazwaleen vs waladaaleen. No version was different in text.
his whole claim is retarded and shows that he is ignorant in the three books (quran ,torah,bible) here is why :
1)there was no single Arabic translation of the Bible till the tenth century CE, i.e., three centuries after the Prophet’s death. The available texts of the Bible were either in Syrian, Greek, or Hebrew. If the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) could have any direct access to the Jewish or Christian scriptures, he would have quoted them, being in dire need to challenge his opponents.
2) The Prophet peace be upon him was illiterate, does not read or write, and it has not been proven that he saw the Torah and the Gospel, or read in them, or transmitted from them.
3)let us examine the two texts, the Qur’an and the Bible. The Qur’an was revealed over 23 years in installments to match multitudes of events, issues, and queries, which were finally compiled into surahs, each having a homogeneous flowing narration. On the other hand, the Bible is a collection of 58 (plus 16 disputed) books written by several human authors and groups. These books were originally not intended to be holy scriptures, but were selectively made so by the ecumenical councils of the Church, several centuries after Christ. An academic or even casual hand-on examination by an impartial sound intellect could never fail to witness the deep contrast between the superb text and context of the Qur’an, compared to the fallible human texts comprising the Bible books.
4) If this were true, his enemies from the polytheists would have taken it as a pretext for them, with the aim of defaming it.
5) Further, the Qur’an has vehemently unveiled the Christian and Jewish distortions of the original messages of Moses and Jesus (peace be upon them). The original Injeel and Torah are no longer available. Please read, for example, the Qur’anic correction and reply to the Biblical distortions:
- Abraham was a Jew: 2:140; 3:65
- Allah tired from act of creation? Allah forbid: 50:38
- Jesus the son of God? Allah forbid: 9:30; 5:17
- Trinity: 5:72-73
- Sanctifying the Church: 3:64
- Solomon blaspheming: 2:102
- The first Qiblah: 3:96
Could a copy (i.e., the Qur’an, according to the allegation) correct the claimed original (i.e., Bible)?
5)What happened from the agreement in some of the rulings does not indicate that the Messenger, may God bless him and grant him peace, was taken from them, and he learned from them, but because Judaism and Christianity have their correct origins that are consistent with the principles of Islam, had it not been for the distortion, change and alteration that they experienced.
7)The rulings of Islamic Sharia were descended gradually according to incidents and facts, and the Messenger, may God bless him and grant him peace, depended in ruling on some matters until revelation came down to him, which indicates that he had no prior knowledge, and he did not ask the People of the Book.
8)The Noble Qur’an exposed the Jews and Christians, exposed their veils, and slandered them allah says in quran '' O People of the Book! Commit no excesses in your religion: Nor say of Allah aught but the truth. Christ Jesus the son of Mary was (no more than) an apostle of Allah, and His Word, which He bestowed on Mary, and a spirit proceeding from Him: so believe in Allah and His apostles. Say not "Trinity" : desist: it will be better for you: for Allah is one Allah. Glory be to Him: (far exalted is He) above having a son. To Him belong all things in the heavens and on earth. And enough is Allah as a Disposer of affairs." (4:171)
9)Again, could the Qur’an learn from the Bible?
There are, of course, points of agreement between the Qur’an and the Bible, e.g., the main aspects of the stories of prophets. That is natural as far as the original source of information being the same, divine revelation of Allah through His Messengers teaching essentially the same message. But here again, in the stories of the prophets we witness the profound differences between the Qur’anic narrations and those of the Bible. Compare for example: the story of prophet Joseph in the Qur’an (12:4-102) and the Bible (Genesis 37-45). Here, the brief to-the-point yet lively objective Qur’anic narration to emphasize advice and exhortations can be contrasted to the marginal details listed in the lengthy once-upon-a-time style of the Bible.
While the Qur’an gives due respect and reverence to the prophets as Allah’s chosen inviolable human beings, radiating His guidance to their contemporaries and future generations, the Bible frequently portrays them dishonorably. Consider for example:
Genesis 9:20-24: Noah being drunk and appearing naked in front of his sons
Exodus 32:3-4: Aaron shaping a golden calf for the Israelites to worship 1
Kings 11:9-10: Solomon worshiping false gods 2 Samuel
11:4-5: David committing adultery
Genesis 19:31-36: Lot committing incest with his two daughters
Surah Al-Ĥāqqah
Q69:44-46
44 And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings,
45 We would have seized him by the right hand;
46 Then We would have cut from him the aorta.
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 4428
In-book reference : Book 64, Hadith 450
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 5, Book 59, Hadith 713
Narrated `Aisha:
The Prophet (ﷺ) in his ailment in which he died, used to say,
"O `Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar,
and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison."
Reference : Sunan Abi Dawud 4512
In-book reference : Book 41, Hadith 19
English translation : Book 40, Hadith 4497
Grade: Hasan Sahih (Al-Albani)
Narrated Abu Hurairah:
The Messenger of Allah would accept a present,
but would not accept alms (sadaqah).
And Wahb bin Baqiyyah narrated to us, elsewhere, from Khalid, from Muhammad ibn Amr said on the authority of AbuSalamah,
and he did not mention the name of Abu Hurairah: The Messenger of Allah used to accept presents but not alms (sadaqah).
This version adds: So a Jewess presented him at Khaybar with a roasted sheep which she had poisoned. The Messenger of Allah ate of it and the people also ate.
He then said: Take away your hands (from the food), for it has informed me that it is poisoned. Bishr ibn al-Bara' ibn Ma'rur al-Ansari died.
So he (the Prophet) sent for the Jewess (and said to her): What motivated you to do the work you have done?
She said: If you were a prophet, it would not harm you; but if you were a king, I should rid the people of you. The Messenger of Allah then ordered regarding her and she was killed.
He then said about the pain of which he died: I continued to feel pain from the morsel which I had eaten at Khaybar. This is the time when it has cut off my aorta.
Reference : Sunan Abi Dawud 4513
In-book reference : Book 41, Hadith 20
English translation : Book 40, Hadith 4499
Grade: Sahih in chain (Al-Albani)
Narrated Ibn Ka'b b. Malik:
On the authority of his father: Umm Mubashshir said to the Prophet during the sickness of which he died:
What do you think about your illness, Messenger of Allah? I do not think about the illness of my son except the poisoned sheep of which he had eaten with you at Khaybar.
The Prophet said: And I do not think about my illness except that.
This is the time when it cut off my aorta.
Abu Dawud said: Sometime 'Abd al-Razzaq transmitted this tradition, omitting the link of the Companion,
from Ma'mar, from al-Zuhri, from the Prophet ,
and sometimes he transmitted it from al-Zuhri from 'Abd al-Rahman b.Ka'b b. Malik,
'Abd al-Rahman mentioned that Ma'mar sometimes transmitted the tradition in a mursal form (omitting the link of the Companion), and they recorded it.
And all this is correct with us.
'Abd al-Razzaq said: When Ibn al-Mubarak came to Ma'mar, he transmitted the traditions in a musnad form (with a perfect chain) which he transmitted as mauquf traditions (statements of the Companions and not of the Prophet).
@@endtimeslips4660 I didn't get your point. Why did you mention all this?
@@sikanderali3170 Quran69:44-46
44 And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings,
45 We would have seized him by the right hand;
46 Then We would have cut from him the aorta.
Sahih al-Bukhari 4428
"O `Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar,
and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison."
@@sikanderali3170 Sunan Abi Dawud 4513
On the authority of his father: Umm Mubashshir said to the Prophet during the sickness of which he died:
What do you think about your illness, Messenger of Allah? I do not think about the illness of my son except the poisoned sheep of which he had eaten with you at Khaybar.
The Prophet said: And I do not think about my illness except that.
This is the time when it cut off my aorta.
Would love one about the Book of the Mormon!
Edit: Wrote the comment before finishing the video! So glad to hear you are doing it!
if you want some laughs and some history about Mormons,South Park made an episode about that,meanwhile we'll wait until the realize
😂😂😂 always good to try! Will be interesting on a similar investigation on talmud
The main question is how do we know that the reports of said words of Muhammad were his?
I am loving this series and all the charts! This is a hard subject area to find a good, secular entry point too. Your summaries are amazing and comprehensive! Take as many side quests as you can! Also want to shout out Extra Credit's Early Christian Schisms series as another enjoyable watch in this vein.
There are so many issues with this video. I recommend that people see Hythem Sidky (an actual high quality secular academic) and his interview on Blogging Theology instead of this nonsense. Actually watching that will show exactly why I call this video nonsense and smoke and mirrors essentially. An actual good academic entry point would be there, not this.
No Kidding. There aren't many secular critique or secular view that trying to disagree with The Quran
here we go the truth coming up,actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful ,
O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and had purified you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure the quran verse is comply with the bible itself :So they lifted up stones to stone him. But Jesus did and went out of the temple, passing through them." ( John 8:59 ),let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam hon happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind
@@edwardtimothy3581 .debauchery is quite clear in your bible. don't
ya getting shy when u read song of songs for solimun ,the incest between lot with his daughters,david with his soldier `s wife furthermore david send this soldier to a war for get rid of him does that is a morals of prophets,jacob with his son`s wife, could that is god`s word,undoubtedly that definitely wouldn`t god`s word,prophets of god are honored in quran unlike your bible which had insulting the prophets including jesus who u took him as god or son of god
@@edwardtimothy3581 in your bible on tongue of jesus i do came for sword not to bring peace,the only book in the history which had commanded about killing babies,that why wws,crusader wars,even current war between russia &ukrain christians killing christians triggered by your bible that`s the real love of catechism oh booooooooooy🤣🤣🤣,don`t fool yourself ya pretty well know what i have told u is completely truth,stop beat around the bush &reconsider your belief,i done with u& time&again from bottom of my heart wish u&your family live into a glee forevermore god willing,bye alice forevermore
“And if you all are in doubt about what I have revealed to My servant, bring a single chapter like it, and call your witnesses besides God if you are truthful (24) But if you do not do this, and you can never do this, then fear the Fire which has been prepared for the disbelievers and which shall have men and stones for fuel” (Quran 2:23-24)
“Or do they say that he has invented it? Say (to them), ‘Bring ten invented chapters like it, and call (for help) on whomever you can besides God, if you are truthful.” (Quran 11:13)
“Say: ‘If all mankind and the jinn would come together to produce the like of this Quran, they could not produce its like even though they exerted all of their strength in aiding one another.” (Quran 17:88)
Jinns was an Arabic pagan belief that mohammad borrowed to his own made up religion
@@TheBarser oh please.
@@l4z3r97 please what? Then explain while there is no jinns in the other abrahimic religions, but the pagan arabs where mohammad was raised belived in such?
@@TheBarser the jinn are the unseen. The other Abrahamic religions believe in the unseen just as we do.
@@DARTH-R3VAN pagan religions was often filled with myhical figures like the jinns. It is interesting imo that jinns got to carry over to the Islamic belief.
But you are right people where always scared of the unknown, and the belief in spirits was almost universal globally.
Omg 😮this is super interesting ❤
Length may appear to be the pattern on arranging the chapters, but that's not totally accurate as some shorter chapters are placed ahead of longer ones. There're different says on how it was arranged, the most popular one says it was based on how the prophet read them (i.e. when he recites the full book).
7:22, note: chapter 110, i.e. Surat Al Nasr, is the last whole surah to be revealed, however most people agree that the last revelation is Chapter 5 (Surat alMaidah) verse 3, the verse of the Perfection of Religion.
My legit fav Ayat(verse) in the whole quran!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
There are so many issues with this video. I recommend that people see Hythem Sidky (an actual high quality secular academic) and his interview on Blogging Theology instead of this nonsense. Actually watching that will show exactly why I call this video nonsense and smoke and mirrors essentially.
@@John-lf3xf elaborate please
@@swdrre-upload5423 There is a comment I wrote a few hours ago on the general comment section which you'll be able to find by hitting 'newest first' if youre interested.
Fix: The surahs are not ordered according to their lengths. Surah Kosar is the smallest surah but isn't the last one.
Kauthar* It's an Arabic word, keep it that way
I believe it was mentioned that it is not strictly so, but generally they are roughly in order of length from longest to shortest.
It is not strictly so. But more or less so.
They are definitely ordered by length, just not perfectly ordered.
surah orded are from Allah. And sahabah keep it that way when The Prophet Muhammad read it for the last time with The Angel Jibril.
So there is this super intelligent, all knowing, omnipresent God with a very important message for humanity which answers all their problems and will give them salavation. So what does he do? He chooses to appear to someone In a desert, a warlord and who also happens to be illiterate and reveals the message to him in private. He then goes out and recites it others. Some memorise it (coz they can't write too), and some who can write, note it down.
After 20 years of his death, his followers compile it into a book from their memory through oral recitation and some from written texts, while destroying other variants before coming up with a final version.
My question, is this the best way for a super intelligent God to reveal his message to each and every human on this earth? Is the system of revelation based on oral recitation not flawed? How do we trust the authenticity of the message or the revelation, as it cannot be independently verified as it's 1 man’s word against the rest of the world?
So there are 2 possibilities. Either this God does not exists, or has a very poor understanding of logic and reasoning and standards of evidence as to what should convince a person to believe in him. Personal revelations via a third party have to be the worst possible way if God wants to convince the entire world of his presence.
I totally agree. It is an excellent question. Is this the best that God can do? If I can think of a better way, why couldn't God? Personally, I would have used a laser printer.
God is real
Religions are man's dreams ... for
Example
The universe is a design all working together. So
Now look at say a computer .... it needs to b planned out then drawn up then made manufactured etc to work by someone
Now a computer doesn't just coincidently fall together ...... it takes intelligence and a designer planner
Now look at universe and right down to you and even your eyeball alone is WAY more complex and complcated than a mere computer .... now however and whatever designed the universe and your body to work together
THATS GOD
You and everyone who THINKS or has convinced themselves there's no God
Even the most dedicated Satanist
I guarantee if they're
Say in middle of ocean alone floating in a life jacket at midnight
YOUR WHOLE INNER BEING IS GONNA BE CRYING OUT TO GOD
And you will probably feel his response weather you drown or not
We can all feel God's presence when we want to
As for Religions
Their all bullshit
God can and will guide you without religious mumbo jumbo rules n rituals
You can feel what God wants you to do.....
not read it in a book .
Very good, I would hear a deeper look into the Quran. Jay Smith has done some amazing work on the Quran and the man, the prophet
Hello, I would like to point out some things:
1) you said that the prophet Muhammad (pbuh) had come into contact with various tribes of Christians and Jews.
Let's remind that Muhammad (phub) was illiterate, meaning that these tribes helped him to write the Coran. But what kind of Christians and Jews would help him write that their texts are corrupted, they are disbelievers and will go to hell?
2)You said the Coran used the Bible as a source, this is not possible since the very first Bible translated in Arabic was in the 9th centuries. Same for the Midrash who was written between 400-1200 CE in Hebrew and had to be translated in Arabic way after. Same for the other texts.
3) Here are some verses of the Coran: "We have built the sky with might, and indeed it is We who are its expanders." (51:47). Here the Coran predicted the expansion of the Universe, something that we discovered with technology in 1920.
"And certainly did We create man from an extract of clay.","Then We placed him as a sperm-drop in a firm lodging.","Then We made the sperm-drop into a clinging clot, and We made the clot into a lump [of flesh], and We made [from] the lump, bones, and We covered the bones with flesh; then We developed him into another creation. So blessed is Allah , the best of creators."(Coran 23:12/14)
The Coran explain in details embryology, Professor Keith L.Moore, who received the Nobel Prize of embryology, said that the Coran was correct about it.
How someone, 1400 years ago, without any technology knew that? Now you may tell me he maybe took inspiration from other religious text, this is not possible because even though some does mention embryology, they do not explain any further.
I am an Arab not here to Criticize but to share knowledge to you. Please read my two points and conclusion
POINT ONE
ISLAM IS NOT ABRAHAMIC RELIGION> These Muslims have lied to people especially to the White Preachers
Abraham is Aramaic from IRAQ and his servant Hagar is an EGYPTIAN so how can the son Ismael be an ARAB
According to Islam the son takes the lineage from the Father so Ismael has to be Aramaic not an Arab. So Muhammad cannot come from Ismael
example if my mother is Chinese and my father is Korean how can I be an Indian. this is the case with Ismael being an Arab.
POINT TWO
In the Bible it says Ismael and his mother Hagar met the TRIBE OF JURHUM this tribe are Arabs from YEMEN
and Ismael learnt ARABIC from them. And thee JURHUM Tribe of YEMEN are staunch ENEMIES of the QURAISH TRIBE of Muhammad. Since Ismael learnt Arabic from the JURHUM TRIBE, Ismael cannot be the father of ARABS since The ARABS were before Ismael and they taught him Arabic language
CONCLUSION
if I were to marry a Chinese woman and learn Chinese I cant be the Father of Chinese since the Chinese were before me and I learnt the language from them. So ISMAEL CANNOT BE THE FATHER OF ARABS AND MUHAMMAD IS NOT FROM ISMAEL AND ISLAM IS NOT AN ABRAHAMIC RELIGION
1) We know that there were both Christians and Jews that interacted with Muhammad and lived within Arabia at the time. There are several instances where Muhammad is challenged and interacts with Jews living nearby. Muhammad was also in contact with the possible ruler or patriarch of Egypt who was a Coptic Christian. It is possible that these people could translate Biblical text into Arabic at some point.
2) Muslims still use these arguments? I thought the early 2010s stuff was fading out but I guess some people still find those old Zakir Naik videos or something. The question I want to ask about 51:47 is what translation is that? Older translations prior to this discovery tend to say something a bit different like Yusuf Ali: "With power and skill did We construct the Firmament: for it is We Who create the vastness of space."
If you notice this translation simply refers to the fact that space is vast, not that it is expanding, it might be a fun exercise to look at the translations prior to the discovery compared to translations afterwards.
The embryonic argument is not only laughably wrong in some aspects but is clearly based on ancient Greek understanding of embryology from Hippocrates and even Aristotle. First of all, where is the mentioning of the egg? You know, a important part in human reproduction? Oh right it hadn't been discovered yet. Also the bones do not develop prior to flesh, it is actually more accurate to say this in the reverse or that they develop simultaneously. There are other blatant errors I won't point out since I am not embryologist but the simple issue with this claim is that this sounds an awful lot like ancient Greek understanding of early embryonic development.
Moving onto Keith Moore, think about this, his book the Saudis funded was only published with these wild claims about the Quranic text within Saudi Arabia. All other versions of the book did not mention it, and when people have attempted to contact Moore to discuss it he has denied those requests. Why isn't Moore a Muslim? Why did he stop talking about this stuff afterwards? All I will say is that money makes people bend their standards.
YOUR ARE DECEIVED AND BRAIN WASHED WELCOME TO ARABS CHRISTIANS WE EXPOSE THE CULT OF ISLAM
The real meaning of Illiterate doesnt mean he could not read and write this is the wrong assumptions by the Muslims since 90% Muslims dont understand Arabic language but memorize them. Read below and know the truth
POINT 1
Quran says the Jews and Christians are Literate means they have the TORAH AND THE INJEEL ( the bible or the people of the Book) and are literate about the knowledge of God but Muhammad was illiterate since he did not have the Bible like "Christans and Jews. thats why he was called ILLITERATE not in the essence of reading and writing but in the Knowledge of God
POINT 2
Muhammad was incharge of the Caravans of Khadija ( his Christian wife) Muhammad sold goods thousands of items in Damascus so if Muhammad was illiterate like you said he could not read and write then explain to me how did he keep accounts of the items he sold for khadija? to keep an account of things you need to be literate thats to read and write
Point 3
WHEN MUHAMMAD WAS ON DEATH BED MUHAMMAD ASK FOR MATERIAL TO WRITE ON. Read below and open your eyes. Muslims lie that Muhammad could not read and write.
Sahih Al Bukhari 4432
Narrated Ubaidullah bin `Abdullah:
Ibn `Abbas said, "When Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) was on his deathbed and there were some men in the house, he said, 'Come near, I will write for you something after which you will not go astray.' Some of them ( i.e. his companions) said, 'Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) is seriously ill and you have the (Holy) Qur'an. Allah's Book is sufficient for us.' So the people in the house differed and started disputing. Some of them said, 'Give him writing material so that he may write for you something after which you will not go astray.' while the others said the other way round. So when their talk and differences increased, Allah's Apostle said, "Get up." Ibn `Abbas used to say, "No doubt, it was very unfortunate (a great disaster) that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) was prevented from writing for them that writing because of their differences and noise."
حَدَّثَنَا عَلِيُّ بْنُ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ، حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الرَّزَّاقِ، أَخْبَرَنَا مَعْمَرٌ، عَنِ الزُّهْرِيِّ، عَنْ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عُتْبَةَ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ ـ رضى الله عنهما ـ قَالَ لَمَّا حُضِرَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَفِي الْبَيْتِ رِجَالٌ، فَقَالَ النَّبِيُّ صلى الله عليه وسلم " هَلُمُّوا أَكْتُبْ لَكُمْ كِتَابًا لاَ تَضِلُّوا بَعْدَهُ ". فَقَالَ بَعْضُهُمْ إِنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَدْ غَلَبَهُ الْوَجَعُ وَعِنْدَكُمُ الْقُرْآنُ، حَسْبُنَا كِتَابُ اللَّهِ. فَاخْتَلَفَ أَهْلُ الْبَيْتِ وَاخْتَصَمُوا، فَمِنْهُمْ مَنْ يَقُولُ قَرِّبُوا يَكْتُبُ لَكُمْ كِتَابًا لاَ تَضِلُّوا بَعْدَهُ. وَمِنْهُمْ مَنْ يَقُولُ غَيْرَ ذَلِكَ، فَلَمَّا أَكْثَرُوا اللَّغْوَ وَالاِخْتِلاَفَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم " قُومُوا ". قَالَ عُبَيْدُ اللَّهِ فَكَانَ يَقُولُ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ إِنَّ الرَّزِيَّةَ كُلَّ الرَّزِيَّةِ مَا حَالَ بَيْنَ رَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَبَيْنَ أَنْ يَكْتُبَ لَهُمْ ذَلِكَ الْكِتَابَ لاِخْتِلاَفِهِمْ وَلَغَطِهِمْ.
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 4432
In-book reference : Book 64, Hadith 454
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 5, Book 59, Hadith 717
(deprecated numbering scheme)
4431
PLEASE EDUCATE YOUR SELVES AND NOT SOME NONSENSE WHAT MUSLIMS SHEIKH PUT ON WEB SITE
Muhammad has no Miracles according to Allah
Quran 17:59 Allah says he did not send Miracles to Muhammad since the former generation did not believe in it
so how can Muhammad have Miracles. Is Allah a Liar or the Muslim Sheikhs and Dawah men
Why islam is not Abrahamic religion
I am an Arab not here to Criticize but to share knowledge to you. Please read my two points and conclusion
POINT ONE
ISLAM IS NOT ABRAHAMIC RELIGION> These Muslims have lied to people especially to the White Preachers
Abraham is Aramaic from IRAQ and his servant Hagar is an EGYPTIAN so how can the son Ismael be an ARAB
According to Islam the son takes the lineage from the Father so Ismael has to be Aramaic not an Arab. So Muhammad cannot come from Ismael
example if my mother is Chinese and my father is Korean how can I be an Indian. this is the case with Ismael being an Arab.
POINT TWO
In the Bible it says Ismael and his mother Hagar met the TRIBE OF JURHUM this tribe are Arabs from YEMEN
and Ismael learnt ARABIC from them. And thee JURHUM Tribe of YEMEN are staunch ENEMIES of the QURAISH TRIBE of Muhammad. Since Ismael learnt Arabic from the JURHUM TRIBE, Ismael cannot be the father of ARABS since The ARABS were before Ismael and they taught him Arabic language
CONCLUSION
if I were to marry a Chinese woman and learn Chinese I cant be the Father of Chinese since the Chinese were before me and I learnt the language from them. So ISMAEL CANNOT BE THE FATHER OF ARABS AND MUHAMMAD IS NOT FROM ISMAEL AND ISLAM IS NOT AN ABRAHAMIC RELIGION
Great video, I’ve always wondered what secular historians make of Islamic texts.
It was interesting to see the stories found in earlier sources because the Qur’an describes itself as a confirmation of revelations that came before.
_"It was interesting to see the stories found in earlier sources because the Qur’an describes itself as a confirmation of revelations that came before."_ Correct, however, you need to consider the nature of those texts: they definitely are not "revelations" in many cases, as they are human commentary on the Jewish scriptures. It seems the compilers of the Quran didn't know the difference.
You also have to consider whether the Qurans "correction" claim makes sense in light of the actual texts. What we actually find in many cases is the Quran copies random details that don't make a lot of sense by themselves, but make perfect sense in the original story.
Quran is like this.
A new religion is born and they belive in a book that considered holy and eternal. Also believing it confirm the bible. but the stories in it are from Dante Inferno, a novel, not a Bible.
@@melissalisaandrean6803 dantes inferno came 900 years after the Quran? were you just making an example?
@@ReasonedAnswers reading a christian writing about "original texts" is laughable!
Original text dated to The Messiah, peace and blessing of The Almighty be upon him and his mother, given by him or his immediate disciples: ZERO
Preserved messages with chains of transmission from Messiah, pbuh: ZERO
Now that is a FACT.
With all the money and evil manipulations at your disposal, yet you are a good way of spreading Islam in every house, and yet you think you are fighting it.
Subhana Allah!
Search Egyptian Kings and Pharaohs of different times and the accuracy of the Quran, once done, compare it to the bible.
Iera channel has a good video of it.
Go check it out and learn.
Times of christian clergy lies is over.
There is a reason for the surge of apostasy in the west, and that is you guys.
For others reading this comment,
wanting to learn more and having questions join the live stream of EFDAWA.
@@melissalisaandrean6803 🤦🏻♂️
You most definitely got your "Islamic PHD" from Fox news, CNN or MSNBC
or even better, from christian apologists.
As a muslim, I enjoyed this video. You covered all hypotheses possible in unbiased fashion. I was waiting until the end to comment: ( you forgot to mention the Syriac influence ) but you mentioned it at the end .. However, I want to add that before Islam, Prophet Mohammed's wife (Khadeejah) was known to have a Christian priest cousin named (Waraqah ibn Nawfal), you forgot to mention him 😁
Hi! I just saw my first video of your series and found it very instructive. A - maybe silly - idea came to my mind: would there be a way to show, to tell a history of atheism as far as it is known? The background of my question ist: if there's something to alter nation state perspective on history, then it's the history of belief, isn't it? Umberto Eco wrote: in what believes a non believer? If we - ideally - knew that we are all schooled without really knowing what 'school' is, we ('we?') would become aware of our responsibility before whatever we know as devine. What do you think about it? Thanks for the video.
I don't know of any atheistic texts from the ancient world, now that you mention it. You ask a good question. I can only cite the ancient atomistic philosphers Democritus and Lucretius off the top of my head in that respect.
I can't wait for your "who wrote the book of Mormon " video to come out!!!! Just minutes before you mentioned it, I was already thinking of leaving a comment requesting just that lol
A little back story; I was raised Mormon, but wanted to learn about other religions when I was 18. I knew very little about Islam and Muhammad at that point, except what my father had told me...which was they believed in father Abraham because all Arabs were desendents of Ishmael. I was never told their faith had anything to do with Jesus. So when I started learning on my own, not only was I shocked about the belief of jesus as a great prophet, but also about the story of Muhammad and the Quran. It was a case of deja'vu lol... the story was eerily similar to the story I had heard all my life of Joseph Smith and the book of Mormon. I have my theories these days, but I'll keep them to myself (spoiler alert, I don't think Muhammad copied Joseph Smith)
I'll be fascinated at any other similarities you find, either to Islam or other texts/sources. If you would like any information about the book of Mormon or the church and what it teaches, I'd be more than happy to answer any questions.
Wonderful video and content!!!
you can already find the video on the channel, I thought it was very well made!
@@MrInsdor thank you! I just watched it, and it absolutely exceeded my expectations. .
@@elibella5660 yeah mine as well. I was only very superficially familiar with the book as I'm an ordinary, irreligious German guy. I've met people from many religious denominations from early on in life, but Mormonism wasn't one of them.
why doesn`t trinity is written in bible,,.;'[.
Joseph Smith came centuries later so would have copied Prophet Muhammad not the other way round
The earliest Quranic manuscript that has been reliably dated by scholars is known as the "Birmingham Quran manuscript." It is a collection of Quranic text fragments on parchment that were discovered in 2015 at the University of Birmingham in England. The manuscript has been carbon-dated to between AD 568 and 645, which is within the time period of the Prophet Muhammad and the early Islamic community. This makes the Birmingham Quran manuscript one of the oldest surviving copies of the Quran in existence.
Indeed this video is rather outdated in regards to that information
how many folios does Birmingham Quran mss. has? Does it have 114 Surahs? Hehehe. Funny response.
@@dtabije08 I see your point but the state of preservation not even a single word was altered and the message of that Sourate to the Christian archeologists found speak louder than if it was 114 found it's like Allah have sent a sign/message to those Christian archeologists who found it! Why didn't they find other chapters and found that specific Sourate with those specific verses!
@@soumayaafilal2931 Hehehe. If you can show me the unchanged & preserved Utmanic Quran, then I will revert to Islam. As of now, I am enjoying reading Hadith that says your prophet was a womanizer, killer & pedophile.
Fragments? 😂
Perfect❤❤
We Muslims don’t need manuscripts because we’ve been learning the Quran by heart from the time of Muhammad peace be upon him so if you’ll find a person in US and in Japan or anywhere in the world they will recite the same thing with no errors
The Quran is protected by god so If you burn all books in the world only Quran will survive , for example every Ramadan Muslims all around the world recite and learn Quran
Then why did the early Muslims destroy copies of the Quran? They were noticing differences in the text.
Muslim pride again.
I congratulate you sir for putting such interesting subjects in the spotlight.
SUWARS are converted in India Pakistan Bangladesh & follow>>>
JAJABA KALAMA HALALA BURKHA HIJAB.
4/6 wives and 20 30 50 childrens, all are Begger Puncher Wala Hotel dish washer Dadagiri Mutton Chicken butcher Atankwadi Illiterate from Madrasas.
Non-sense...!!! Quran thru Gabriel and written by God.. utter nonsense..
use some common sense here of when was Quran written and when was Old Testament written. BC and CE.
🤣🤣🤣Whoever the author of this video is, just look into the facts and then say Jew'sTorah and Bible are one and the same, whereas the Bible emphasizes on the old and new Testaments.
To add to your old videos on the moon of Muslim worship
The crescent of the new moon signifies the beginning and end of fasting during Ramadan. *However, this symbol did not originate with Islam; it was adopted for the first time by the city of Byzantine (which later became Istanbul).*
@@chj3289 hmm look like you are troller
It is very easy to refute Islam! Because the God of Islam does not know that according to Christianity God incarnated
True love = the love of God!
*God himself went to the cross for you out of love for you as a human being*
Philippians 2:5-8
@@chj3289 the Cresent was used way before Byzantine, by the Zorasastrians
just a small misunderstanding; "thou al qarnayn" means "the one who lived for two centuries" you see the word قرن in Arabic means both "horn" and "a century" and since my childhood, as a Muslim kid I've been taught that information so I don't fall into the confusion.
Other than that, I appreciated such an academic level of research this channel never failed to live up to my expectations.
Perhaps this misunderstanding is caused by the people who had come up with the idea that the person mentioned in the holy Quran is to be taken as the one who lived for 200 years or 2 centuries. this idea does not make any sense, because it would employ that the person was of 200 years of age and he had already lived for 2 centuries at the time period during that story. again because you do not give a 30 years old person a name like ["thou al qarnayn" means "the one who lived for two centuries" ]
No one agreed who he was .. any muslim know that
@@Sasori.OfTheRedSand The General consciences points it to be Alexander the Great. The coins of His time with his pictures on those items depict him to be having two Horns,
Thank you. as a Muslim from the west, it's easy for people to fall into this... I'm sitting here watching and my stomach is just turning. Allahu Akbar
@@engineeresemkay6929 some agreed and some not
I’m a muslim and I really appreciate with your work on this topic. If your curiosity based on science needs, I hope you’ll find the truth. Because I think your search isn’t reach the truth, you applied the science methodology on the first but you lay on “if” and “perhaps” on the conclusion.
I suggest you to also read the asbabunnuzul of the quran so you have more view on this topic and more understanding of the quran
Idk are you have read the quran or haven’t yet (but I think you haven’t), in the quran, the author of the quran challenges everyone who has a doubt about quran to produce one surah (chapter) or one ayah (verse) that has quality similar to quran (in content or language), many people try it and failed (you must read those and feel free to laugh).
Some things important if you want to extend this topic, you have to search on how quran could provided many prophetic verse, provided scientific signs accurately and solved many problems in modern society.
"Earth is sphere and slavery are evil." That sentence is better than the Qur'an because it is scientific accurate and clear. If you ask non-Muslims, they will agree with me. If you ask Muslims, they will disagree. It is a meaningless challenge because it is so subjective.
So nice
"I have only sent you (Muhammad) as a giver of glad tidings and a warner to all mankind, but most men do not understand." [Noble Quran 34:28]
I think the irony is that a fifth grader nowadays is smarter than the typical adults back during Muhammad’s time. If you don’t live in a Muslim country of course that’s trying to teach you incorrect things.
@@kaiju4238 ''The opposite of Knowledge isn't Ignorance, but the illusion of Knowledge'' - Stephen Hawkings
No Muslim will ever claim or preach that Pre Islamic Arabia was some land of Literacy or Enlightenment. Rather ALL Muslims say the exact opposite.
And just for the sake of GOD! The US Mainstream News Media literally translated ''GOD is THE GREATEST'' to ''Death to America'' coz it fit their agenda against the Taliban! The US Gov still gave no reasoning for mascaraing of a Million fuckin Iranian Children to death under the allegations of Iranian Govt's link to Bin Laden! Hell they didn't even show any evidence for Bin Laden's charges
Same shit in Almost ALL European countries with very few exceptions.
So please stfu and get yourself something good to eat and some books to learn reality
@@ibrahimhossain8489 Most sane people know that America killed a lot of people in the name of ICBMs. How on earth does that make God the author of Quran?
One million children ? Good Lord ! Thats alot ! That comes out to around 150 children every day , 150 kids Monday, 150 kids Tuesday, 150 Wednesday,150 kids Thursday ,150 friday 150 kids Saturday,150 kids sunday.. Then stsrt all over again for 20 years!
shame on the media for not reporting it ! I mean thats about 1,000 children a week , for about 20 YEARS , those BASTARDS ! Unless......... Nah ! It,s gotta be true., This guy is stating those incredible numbers so EMPHATICALLY !
@@amrita3000 if you you count the prophecies the Qur'an made and Muhammad p b u h in his life time,the chance of them all being true is 0.0000000001,if you consider those two are not from God.They would have to randomly "guess" the outcome,and how strange,they all came to life!Except the ones that are yet to come.Islam is the perfect way of life.Its a whole "science" that you cant learn as a whole in two lifetimes..You just read some pages in hope to get arguments,and hop here to talk about existence of God.Far away are you from knowledge.
Enormously helpful! Your explications supplement & amplify what I learned from my father (an amateur Biblical & Koranic historian) over 65 years ago. Many thanks!!
why him and your father are wrong :
1)there was no single Arabic translation of the Bible till the tenth century CE, i.e., three centuries after the Prophet’s death. The available texts of the Bible were either in Syrian, Greek, or Hebrew. If the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) could have any direct access to the Jewish or Christian scriptures, he would have quoted them, being in dire need to challenge his opponents.
2) The Prophet peace be upon him was illiterate, does not read or write, and it has not been proven that he saw the Torah and the Gospel, or read in them, or transmitted from them.
3)let us examine the two texts, the Qur’an and the Bible. The Qur’an was revealed over 23 years in installments to match multitudes of events, issues, and queries, which were finally compiled into surahs, each having a homogeneous flowing narration. On the other hand, the Bible is a collection of 58 (plus 16 disputed) books written by several human authors and groups. These books were originally not intended to be holy scriptures, but were selectively made so by the ecumenical councils of the Church, several centuries after Christ. An academic or even casual hand-on examination by an impartial sound intellect could never fail to witness the deep contrast between the superb text and context of the Qur’an, compared to the fallible human texts comprising the Bible books.
4) If this were true, his enemies from the polytheists would have taken it as a pretext for them, with the aim of defaming it.
5) Further, the Qur’an has vehemently unveiled the Christian and Jewish distortions of the original messages of Moses and Jesus (peace be upon them). The original Injeel and Torah are no longer available. Please read, for example, the Qur’anic correction and reply to the Biblical distortions:
- Abraham was a Jew: 2:140; 3:65
- Allah tired from act of creation? Allah forbid: 50:38
- Jesus the son of God? Allah forbid: 9:30; 5:17
- Trinity: 5:72-73
- Sanctifying the Church: 3:64
- Solomon blaspheming: 2:102
- The first Qiblah: 3:96
Could a copy (i.e., the Qur’an, according to the allegation) correct the claimed original (i.e., Bible)?
5)What happened from the agreement in some of the rulings does not indicate that the Messenger, may God bless him and grant him peace, was taken from them, and he learned from them, but because Judaism and Christianity have their correct origins that are consistent with the principles of Islam, had it not been for the distortion, change and alteration that they experienced.
7)The rulings of Islamic Sharia were descended gradually according to incidents and facts, and the Messenger, may God bless him and grant him peace, depended in ruling on some matters until revelation came down to him, which indicates that he had no prior knowledge, and he did not ask the People of the Book.
8)The Noble Qur’an exposed the Jews and Christians, exposed their veils, and slandered them allah says in quran '' O People of the Book! Commit no excesses in your religion: Nor say of Allah aught but the truth. Christ Jesus the son of Mary was (no more than) an apostle of Allah, and His Word, which He bestowed on Mary, and a spirit proceeding from Him: so believe in Allah and His apostles. Say not "Trinity" : desist: it will be better for you: for Allah is one Allah. Glory be to Him: (far exalted is He) above having a son. To Him belong all things in the heavens and on earth. And enough is Allah as a Disposer of affairs." (4:171)
9)Again, could the Qur’an learn from the Bible?
There are, of course, points of agreement between the Qur’an and the Bible, e.g., the main aspects of the stories of prophets. That is natural as far as the original source of information being the same, divine revelation of Allah through His Messengers teaching essentially the same message. But here again, in the stories of the prophets we witness the profound differences between the Qur’anic narrations and those of the Bible. Compare for example: the story of prophet Joseph in the Qur’an (12:4-102) and the Bible (Genesis 37-45). Here, the brief to-the-point yet lively objective Qur’anic narration to emphasize advice and exhortations can be contrasted to the marginal details listed in the lengthy once-upon-a-time style of the Bible.
While the Qur’an gives due respect and reverence to the prophets as Allah’s chosen inviolable human beings, radiating His guidance to their contemporaries and future generations, the Bible frequently portrays them dishonorably. Consider for example:
Genesis 9:20-24: Noah being drunk and appearing naked in front of his sons
Exodus 32:3-4: Aaron shaping a golden calf for the Israelites to worship 1
Kings 11:9-10: Solomon worshiping false gods 2 Samuel
11:4-5: David committing adultery
Genesis 19:31-36: Lot committing incest with his two daughters
@@zaid9026 *"1)there was no single Arabic translation of the Bible till the tenth century CE, i.e., three centuries after the Prophet’s death. The available texts of the Bible were either in Syrian, Greek, or Hebrew. If the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) could have any direct access to the Jewish or Christian scriptures, he would have quoted them"*
Please read Sahih al-Bukhari 3392 on what happened directly after M had his first alleged encounter with Gabriel:
_The Prophet (ﷺ) returned to Khadija while his heart was beating rapidly. She took him to Waraqa bin Naufal who was a Christian convert and used to read the Gospels in Arabic_
Would you like to retract your statement and begin your journey out of the sectarian hoax you're immersed in?
The other books mentioned as sources of the Quran from a secular perspective, are there any manuscripts for them that indicate exactly when they were written? Also, there is a lot of scientific information that was not mentioned in any book before the Quran, such as the development of the fetus and the rotation of all parts of the universe. What does the secular perspective say about them?
Interesting you should mention embryology in the Quran. It’s almost the exact same as Ancient Greek beliefs on the subject, written before Muhammad was born.
You’ll find that nothing in the Quran is unique, you just aren’t aware that these ideas were already in existence prior to the Quran being written.
The secular perspective is that there is no scientific information in the Qur'an. The development of the fetus was copied from the Greeks (also copied its error), and astronomy was repeat of six century knowledge (including geocentricism and flat earth). It is Muslim apologetics who reinterpret old verses to fit the new Science which is common for all religion.
This Video is now more then 2years old.. the research on this topic has advanced … especially the date of of early manuscripts Silke the Sa’ana Palimset…
If Muhammed is a prophet then he's a great person and I'd love him, if he wasn't a prophet and it was all his works then I'll admire him, what genius person would create this great teachings and cerate this influence where 1/7 of the world are his followers 1400 years from his death, 10 years and his followers won against the two most powerful nations in the world, 40 years later and they controlled all land between Spain and China, they create one of the 3 most important civilizations in the world (Greek, Arab, European) if one of those civilizations didn't exist we'd be living a different world
WHAT A GREAT GENIUS
Muhammad was not a genius. He was a calculating fraudster and a shameless womanizer.
@@halimrahman1210 well, I'm sure you're better than this "a calculating fraudster and a shameless womanizer", so, whu dont you start creating a religion, I'm sure you'll have massive follower than this "a calculating fraudster and a shameless womanizer" lol
@@noitallnoitall4574 most of the muslims are illiterate, I would say 80% muslims are illiterate in classical sense.
@@noitallnoitall4574 , I am not a fraudster like Muhammad and I don’t want to earn a living by deceiving people.
@@ExammO "most..." blah blah blah assumption lol.. btw 80% is not 100% lol
I find this channel brilliant, and like others have mentioned below, you admit your biases, something I think is paramount. Myself i'm an atheist but find Abrahammic religions interesting and I think it's important to know as much as possible about them. Especially when engaging in friendly debates online
SUWARS are converted in India Pakistan Bangladesh & follow>>>
JAJABA KALAMA HALALA BURKHA HIJAB.
4/6 wives and 20 30 50 childrens, all are Begger Puncher Wala Hotel dish washer Dadagiri Mutton Chicken butcher Atankwadi Illiterate from Madrasas.
Hope you found the best answer soon❤
Non-sense...!!! Quran thru Gabriel and written by God.. utter nonsense..
use some common sense here of when was Quran written and when was Old Testament written. BC and CE.
🤣🤣🤣Whoever the author of this video is, just look into the facts and then say Jew'sTorah and Bible are one and the same, whereas the Bible emphasizes on the old and new Testaments.
To add to your old videos on the moon of Muslim worship
The crescent of the new moon signifies the beginning and end of fasting during Ramadan. *However, this symbol did not originate with Islam; it was adopted for the first time by the city of Byzantine (which later became Istanbul).*
@@chj3289 Your points are illogical and fallacious. Even the presenter of this video was careful in his choice of words towards the Qur'an as well as Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).
You must learn to be objective in your assertions!
You know what .. when you ask people if they're satisfied about the money they earn, they will always complain. and would ask for more money... when you ask people if they're satisfied with their brains... they're more than happy with it, and strangely confident!
I'm a Muslim and I thank you for this video it helps me boosts my Imam and draw closer to Allah (SAW).
I spent the first 2/3 of my life as a faithful Mormon, and the past 1/3 learning about many of the things I was never told about Mormon history. I look forward to your analysis of the Book of Mormon.
I’m sorry, but it baffles me that there are still Mormons today. Every religion has its share of malarkey, but Mormonism out does them all. I say that with all due respect, of course.
@gunny1O1O1 Ok atheist. I’m not Mormon btw lol
@gunny1O1O1 And the evilest of the evil.
you should look into reading the CES letter
Mormonism is a Cult