I'm an 82 year old Bach, Beethoven, Vivaldi, Mozart, Handel, et al kind of music fan. Never listened to Metal. Didn't particularly care for Simon and Garfunkel or the Sound of Silence. Then one day a year or so ago while looking for a particular piece of music I ran across this song where this bald guy with lots of face jewelry and an angry voice was belting out this song, the kind of thing I normally just quickly pass on by - which I did - and continued on my quest to find that piece I was looking for. But after a few minutes I got to wondering what that video was all about so I started looking for it and finally found the link. I started the video and my musical life changed. Forever. Long story short. Started listening. Something, David Draiman's voice? reached in and grabbed my soul, I listened, goose bumps appearing, eyes watering, getting choked up to a degree which I had never experienced before. I later learned that people were creating reaction video's on RUclips so I watched several addressing this cover to see if others had experienced similar emotions and was relieved to find I wasn't alone. I must have watched over a hundred reaction videos at this point because I enjoy watching the joy this song has given others. I have to say that yours has provided the most informative best presented reaction I have yet witnessed. Thank you for that.
You are not alone. I am only 49 and have the same experiences. And also learning alot of new bands through reaction videos such as Bad Wolves, My Chemical Romance, etc
Jim, being a 61 yo music lover of multiple genres, you seriously should check out Floor Jansen who can sing everything from opera to symphonic metal as the classically trained lead singer for Nightwish. If you don't check her out you will doing yourself a great disservice. Cheers
RUclips is great as there are so many reaction videos from different backgrounds, from recording to composers to vocal coaches and everyone has a different piece of knowledge on the same piece of work. It's amazing! This is definitely one of the great analyses of this performance.
My thoughts, exactly. I have watched dozens of reaction and analysis videos to this song. This is, by far, the best break down and explanation of all the details of what David Draiman is doing with his voice. Each choice, each skill, the ability needed to make it happen, and the impact of doing it correctly. Beautiful.
We laymen instinctively know Disturbed's version is exquisite, but don't understand exactly why. It's so great to have an expert explain and validate for us. Grazie mille!
This you hit the nail on the head my friend. As a layman myself I also feel the same and appreciate the efforts given by the knowledgeable and am learning a lot. This has been an informative video.
Before watching your analysis, there was only one other reaction that I've found to this performance that I felt was unique and honest and humble and genuine. Most miss the mark and have generic comments or criticisms right off the cuff and it cheapens the experience for the viewer. I don't speak a word of Italian, yet nothing was lost in translation because your emotion and intellect when discussing something you're obviously passionate about shines through. Your English subtitles were excellent and convey the exact sentiments you wanted to express. Your channel and efforts are incredibly underrated and I hope so many more people receive the opportunity to learn from you. Thank you!
I.ve listened to 40+ analysis of this performance both live and this one the video version. Hands down best analysis and Roberto is only one who goes back and forth to rehear sections as should be done with a masterpiece. Bravo.
You are the only reaction who deserves the "Vocal Coach" keyword. I was raised speaking english, but I understood all of your Italian and am incredibly impressed at your insights
David Draiman....IMO THE best male vocalist out there. Can go from warm baritone to tenor, to clear as an angelic bell to grit/rasp and back on a DIME. What a powerful voice! Awesome talent and amazing voice control! He has been singing for over 25 years or more...knows how to do distortion WITHOUT harming his vocal cords. His voice has a timber I've never heard before. Loved your commentary and reaction....could tell you appreciated it too.
I have been a fan of Disturbed for over 20 years, this song (thankfully) has shown so many people how good David really is. This video really shows a very indepth look at the song and the smile on your face shows real adoration. Just a joy to watch thank you
Definitely. I'm a Disturbed fan and many people underestimate David's vocal range. He can have a voice of an angel and the voice of a devil. He can create sound effects with voice. It saddened me when this beautiful cover came out and so many accused him of using auto tune. It was insulting for some fools to think that. I know better because David is very talented. I know his music and that he had vocal training in school.
I agree. This is the case with other heavy metal singers too. People say they are not good singers, they are being judged because of what type of music they sing to, rather than how good and how difficult it really is. I have heard people trash Corey Taylor in Slipknot for "just screaming" and "not being able to sing" in their songs and then I play lets say Vermillion pt 2 and all of a sudden they say "well this guy sings better than the previous song".. When I say it's the same singer then they start trying to find reasons to dislike the singing they just a second ago liked. It is such a shame.
I loved this analysis of this vocal. Most reaction videos I have viewed merely say how they feel when listening, but you’re obviously extremely educated and well versed and this expertise was wonderful. Ty for sharing your much appreciated professional analysis
I have watched many of these analyses of Disturbed's version of this song . And I must say , I have enjoyed yours the most . Not only with your musical expertise , but the sheer joy you show discovering this exceptional version of this song . Thank you . 😃
I love the delight and joy you express when hearing this. You understand the music on a different, more in-depth level than most people, but that seems to add to your enjoyment rather than taking away from it. This was one of my favourite reaction videos.
Absolutely the best, and most interesting reaction / analysis of this amazing rendition I have ever watched. You were on point with every comment. You are clearly not just a vocal coach, but an artist in your own right, with the ability and musical awareness to analyze this performance in a holistic way. Great job.
This 'Reaction' video was, by far, THE best I have seen. You dissected so many different techniques - examined them at the most base level. You explained those techniques and the power behind them. You are also one of the very few who give credit to the interpretation and musical arrangement of this song. It isn't just David Draiman's voice that makes this rendition so amazing, it is vocals, arrangement, interpretation, the entire package. Thank you so much for sharing your insight.
I have been addicted to watching reaction videos for this song for over a year now. "People writing songs that voices never share" is for me, the most beautiful line in the whole presentation. Not only are the lyrics poignant, but the execution is so beautiful. This is the first reaction that has given this line the attention I think it so richly deserves. Wonderful reaction and analyzes. Thank you
Roberto along with being a sweetie, is definitely a true professional. I can’t imagine the hours and years he must have studied to know all the in-depth knowledge that he has. Plus I totally enjoyed watching and listening to his reactions on Disturbed. Like the rest of the comments it’s obvious we viewers are pretty much of one accord with Robertos reactions, as well as emotions we experienced when first listening to Disturbeds version of Sound of Silence. When I first heard David sing Sound of Silence, I’m not sure I was even breathing till the last note finished resonating. He took my breath away as he led me through a wide array of emotions with the most awesome, heaviest, music video ever made. The concept developing and producing every single part of what Disturbed brought to our ears, eyes, our hearts and minds was nothing short of genius. ♥️ 🇺🇸
Yours is one of the most insightful reactions to this performance that I have seen. Although I have seen this video and the Conan show live performance many times, I didn't make the 'Cello' association before. It is a perfect metaphor. Thanks for your work here.
I agree 100% I loved your breakdown of the song. Your accent had something to do with it I think lol love it! Seriously you sounded like you understood what he was doing with the song. He built it up so great. I've watched this song atleast over 100 times and each time gives me chills and watery eyes...lol This video I feel is more about the story of the song. The Conan Show version I feel is more about all the instruments around him. Both showcase the powerful vocals of David. And during Conan he was really sick and the band made him sit during it because they didn't want him to passout. The show wanted to use auto tune but the squashed that idea. I do believe they used it on one part from what I hear but I can't tell where but regardless being sick he killed it as well!! I can't say enough about this song! Amazing!!
I find it absolutely amazing that I have listened to just about every reaction to this song, and yours is the one I enjoyed the most. And you weren’t even speaking my language!! Usually, I get annoyed when the reactor keep stopping the song to comment, but every time you did it, I was anxious to hear what you had to say. Thank you for a very interesting and professional reaction. Be sure to watch the live version of the song on Conan. David is actually sitting and still belting that song out with strength and emotion. Add to that is the fact that he wasn’t well that night. Thank you for your reaction and you have a new subscriber!
I agree this reaction is the best I ve watched so far and I dont speak Italian either! I really liked how you got how special my favorite part of the song is. I love how he sings the line "Take my hand so that I might reach you"
Hello Roberto, my name is Martin from Ireland. I've known and loved Disturbed for years, I've watched dozens and dozens of reactions to this song of which some have been good but yours, well its beyond a shadow of doubt the most honest, the most genuine, the most pure, the most amazing one. You listen and enjoy it like a lifetime fan of the band does but you as a lifetime fan of music. You pay David and the entire band, and all the producers of the song as much credit and respect as you too deserve for your expertise, knowledge and appreciation for music. I'd love for David to watch your reaction to his reaction as you made me feel watching your "beautiful" and "wow" comments, you listening and re-listening, your in depth analysis and your smile grow as you were listening to it the way you appear to of felt listening to them perform. I never, ever have or would subscribe to you tube videos or follow people but you my friend have made me change to subscribing to you as I wait with interest and joy to see what you do next. My children and wife too will be seeing you and your amazing qualities both as a person and an expert. Well done bravo bravo 🙏
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline Thank you Roberto for acknowledging and commenting to me. You have made my day in return my friend so thank you too. My wife and children (3yrs & 5yrs old) are asking me "who is this gentleman you are listening to each day after work?" and its you and your reactions. You are so inspiring to the appreciation of music. I'll be commenting on your other videos (if you don't mind) with what you are teaching me by me simply watching you. Thanks again and 'slan' for now.
This was absolutely fascinating to watch. Your facial reactions and the excitement and joy you expressed were authentic. I really enjoyed your breakdown of how professional the arrangement was and it made me understand how much thought must have been put into this version. Thank you for sharing it all with us!
Been watching 1st time listening to this cover from various channels for hours, and to me, yours is the most intuitive and constructive critic so far! Thanks!
I am so glad you liked this cover of the sound of silence and actually took the time to break it down and point out some of what makes it such an amazing song. I have watched a lot of reaction videos on this song and they all say wow, great song, and they love it but that's all they say. Well anybody can do that! Thanks for breaking it down and putting words and explanations to how this was done that I couldn't put words to! Great job
I would simply echo what many have already said. Namely, that out of the many "reaction and analysis" videos I have watched, this one is the best. I don't need someone to tell me this vocal performance is truly special; I can hear that for myself. But I do need some help understanding the techniques employed to make it so very special. Your analysis and explanation did that for me. Thank you.
So enjoyed watching the delight on your face, as you traveled through this version of the song. The love of music, and it’s intricacies are so visible on your face. It brought sunshine to my day...and extra enjoyment of this remarkable rendition of the “sounds of silence “ Thank you 💫💫💫
Thank you so much for sharing this video. It is a saying "You learn something new every day." Though I am in my seventies you just taught me many points on how to properly listen to music and understand what the performer is doing that affects you as it does. You shared how to use one's voice to capture and hold attention. You showed how singing is a skill developed through practice and attention to the details of your vocal actions. I would like to express so much more of your affect on me but I will just reiterate my thanks. Be blessed.
I’ve watched many, many reactions to this video because I not only love this version but I love seeing the reactions of first time listeners! I am amazed every time I hear him sing this song, with the control and dramatic tone to his voice. But I will say, your reaction is one of the best I’ve seen. I love that you want to listen repeatedly to the different vocal changes and/or what those changes bring dynamically. You listen to it with the same enthusiasm, awe, admiration and respect as I. Great review!
Lol what I like is most reactors tell you that they're going to rewind it. Roberto not giving a damn lol.....he'll rewind it 8 times if he wants to without saying anything. But his knowledge is truly a pleasure to hear.
I am charmed and delighted by the song-like quality of the Italian language as well, and Roberto delli Carri's spoken voice is like a beautiful instrument.
@@JustMe-vk4fn yes, I never thought of a cover version displacing the original in what has been one of my top five all-time list for 30 years or more,but think it must.
Good subtitles, I could listen to Italian all day long. My mom was 100% Italian, so I grew up around it but never learned to speak it, though I wish I had. It always brings me back to childhood holidays, especially Christmas when she would make the traditional courses of Italian fish, eel, baccala, etc. Sounds like you have a great voice as well. Good reaction and good breakdown of what David is doing, he’s a phenomenal singer and from what I’ve heard he’s an incredibly humble and nice guy.
Roberto, yours was the most in-depth and informative analysis of this song and of David Draiman's voice in particular. I learned some things from you and, bonus! I was enchanted to hear it in your beautiful language. I've subscribed, and look forward to your future videos. Thank you!
I have seen elsewhere, that Simon and Garfunkel's version was a warning, this version is anger that the warning was ignored. Such a beautiful analysis of this song!
Agreed. Never been a big Disturbed fan, but they now own this song! They way he conveyed emotion with the lyrics is absolutely something special that nobody else could accomplish to this level! The first time I heard it, my overly manly. 6'5", 270lb self had my eyes watering afterwards.
I can't thank you enough for your amazing analysis of a song that has come to haunt my thoughts and live in my heart. Your technical understanding, yet uncomplicated explanations of the technics used by Mr. Draymond, even I ( a complete novice) could understand and try to imitate. If I was a serious singer I would be on the first plane out to you for lessons! I am however going to buy you book tomorrow and read it. I find how the voice works extremely fascinating. I've liked and subscribed to your site and hope to watch more reactions from you. Once again Ty for sharing your knowledge. ~ Claire
You, sir are far too humble! Your reaction was so very educational and a pleasure to watch. I loved your facial expressions along with your great expertise. Thank you!
My first time on your channel. This is one of my favorite covers so I was curious. I almost kept scrolling but with the captions I was able to follow well enough. Really enjoyed your responses. Thank you.
Thank you for the insight. Very well done. Very thoughtful. PS: that's probably the best immitation of Dave's fry/distortion push I've heard, in listening to vocal coaches react to Dave. i'm sure your wife enjoyed it. very passionate all around.
I have listened to hundreds of reaction videos for this cover. Yours is the only one that has prompted me to post in response. Thanks for the education. Your video is as so well done, I think I was understanding Italian by the end!
I have never commented on a reaction before but couldn't resist here. You broke this down in a way I haven't seen before and gave a good 'lesson' on what was going on with the vocals. I always had a view of this version of the song as better than the original. I now have a better appreciation and understanding of what David did with the song and how he vocally performed it. Thank you Roberto. :)
this version of the song is simply beautiful .... and one of the proofs is your reaction, especially you as a professional singing teacher ... I love to see such passion and sensitivity to the sounds of music that you have shown
Another absolutely fascinating and thoroughly enjoyable video, thank you once again. Also far and away the most complete and informative reaction to this song I've seen from anyone. Always so impressed with you videos and your enthusiasm for music and voice always makes me smile too. Thank you!
I have been singing for 48 of my 60 years on this planet, performed in Carnegie Hall, Covent Gardens and Cathedral of the Madeleine in Paris. a fan of any kind of music short of Heavy Metal and Rap. Well his song fixed my Heavy Metal problem, I have watched many of Disturber's videos since I experienced this song. The first time I watched this I just sat with my mouth hanging open, stunned at the end. then I watched it at least15 more times in that sitting, and countless times since. One time I saw a reaction video of this piece of music and I have seen 40 or 50 since then, I like to watch the reviewer and there facial reactions to this song, and see their facial expressions change as the song morphs and changes throughout. Most interesting. Today I saw a click bait for your reaction Roberto and i said "ooo one I have not seen!!" and when you started speaking in Italian I was somewhat bummed until i saw the sub-titles, and off we went into this amazing piece of music. Being a singer myself, I like voice coach reviews of David's amazing voice. Elizabeth Zarhoff (The Charismatic Voice) and you give the best insight into the techniques he has. I truly enjoyed your reaction and will subscribe to see more from you. The most common word I hear in watching reaction videos for this song is "WOW' which I think you said at least 5 times. In all the darkness and sadness anger of this video I have yet for anyone to comment on the rya of hope that is present at the very end, did you see it Roberto in your follow up viewings of this? Thanks for the great review. Richard
Hi! This is the first video I have watched on your channel and I'm impressed by the extent and detail of your analysis - most reaction videos only scratch the surface, you commented a lot - I really enjoyed that. The subs are really great, I don't speak Italian good enough to undestand you, but it was extremely enjoyable to listen to your voice and the melody of the Italian language in addition to the music. You have a new subscriber :)
I have watched almost every one of these reactions to this song and its funny . Almost all of the people dont know anything about Disturbed and always say they were surprised when he goes up and adds the fry and is in total control of it . However for myself and people that I know that were Disturbed fans before hearing this I remember being surprised at his low slow clear singing in the beginning. You also might be interested in listening to the Live version of this on Conan , and knowing he was sitting down because he was so sick with the flu that they didnt even think he could stand the whole time
As many others have said, I have watched a lot of reactions to this song. Yours was by far the best. So much heart in your reactions to this both physically and in your explanations. I am normally not a huge fan of remakes but he just nailed this song. I love how you gave this song the reaction it deserves. You have a new subscriber! Thank you! 😍❤😍
David Draiman/Disturbed has a live presentation recording on Conan that you will be able to see some of his techniques better. Although I had to read your sub scripts, I loved your explanations of how he was able to do such a magnificent job! Thank you.
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline please keep in mind that David had the flu during the Conan show. The sound guy used some auto tune and after the show David was furious ! He wanted his vocal to stand on their own, flu or no flu !
It's still an amazing performance, despite being sick, but it's also why I prefer the official video-- you get the full power of Draiman's vocal techniques.
I have watched about a half a dozen reaction videos tonight on this song and I have to say that yours was the most informative and best reaction, because of your knowledge of the technical side of the song. I have watched grown men cry in reaction to this song. I myself tear up every time I hear it. It is an extremely powerful rendition of a great song. Thank you for being the cherry on the cake tonight ;)
It certainly helps that the subtitles are actually in good, solid, very understandable English. Even if a writing teacher would probably ding a few points for the wanton overuse of ellipses. 😅
I don't know if you understand the English words, but you obviously understand the emotion of the lyrics and song. I am 76, heard the Simon & Garfunkel original in 1964, and did not understand the song then. About a year ago, I came across this version by Disturbed, I called my younger son and told him to listen to it and that I finally understood the song. Your face showed how you became engrossed in the song. You are NOT alone.
Roberto was so in tune with the song the he even flushed. (Min. 15 and 35sec) .No wonder his wife started to worry... 🤣🤣🤣 cheers Btw, I agree with the comments, he is by far the best at explaining and feeling the song!!!
I have watched over 100 reactions to this song and none compared to this honest and sincere analysis. The songs author, Paul Simon, who wrote this sitting in the dark on his bathroom floor after the assassination of Robert Kennedy, met David Drayman in person and said to him "Now, this song belongs to you, David." I encourage you to view the live performance on the Conan O'brien show. Just show patience for him as he was I'll with a fever and chills but insisted he still wanted to sing on this night...with no auto-tune; something that many vocal coaches think they here! Lastly, RUclips has a video of David speaking about the writing and performance of it which you may enjoy viewing. CHAO!
Had to use subtitles because I had no idea what Roberto was saying but the breakdown and analysis of this was the best I've seen. I've listened to this version so many times and every time I get goose bumps and watery eyes. Thank you for your great interpretation of David's voice. I love this version because it brings out so many aspects and ranges of his voice and truly shows what a great singer he is.
I know that your reaction was from over 3 years ago now, but I HAD to send this to you. Grazie Mille! LOVED your take and breakdown of this fabulous cover. I was a musician and vocalist in high school, and as a young man in my mid-20s, was stationed in southern Italy at San Vito dei Normanni Air Station in the early 80s. This cover touches me deep within my soul .... hearing your language as I read in English what you are saying was MAGICAL for me ! Thank you SO MUCH !!!❤
Years ago I listened to this version of The Sound of Silence because I liked the original but now I only listen to Disturbed singing it. After I heard it I couldn't wait to check out other Disturbed songs because David Draiman's voice was so amazing and I got a shock that they are a heavy metal band. I ended up liking a number of their songs but I don't think any of them showcase David's voice like The Sound of Silence. Thanks for the fantastic analysis of the song, I always learn from your reactions. Cheers!
David Draiman is one of the best metal vocalists around. He was classically trained in the church/Synagogue. An amazing talent, with impeccable control. Having said that, your review is amazing, and even with the language difference, I agree with everything you analysed. You have an amazing voice too. Greetings from Austria.
I think that you reacted exactly as the cover wished!! It is exactly how I interpreted this arrangement. I'm 80 years old, female, and a huge Disturbed fan. He is a trained vocalist. I did sing in a chorus and am aware of some facets of arrangements and phrasing so I really love this guy's talent!!! You did the very best reaction and description of this cover than any other of the many reactors that are on RUclips!! I thank you for your intelligent and emotional reaction!! Bella!!
Thank you. It is said that anything one understands, can only be born out of what one has experienced. There is much that I haven't experienced..... Your passionate quest and insightful comments, has added much to my understanding. Yours is not the talk which captures many of the 'reaction junkies,' rather, your voice adds to the chorus of wisdom seekers. The joy and wonderment you share, are indeed, appreciated. Bravo!
Disturbed version of The Sound of Silence will be remembered forever and more,its sn EPIC,like a volcano building pressure from unfathomable depth ready to explode full blast with the almighty fire.
I have to agree with all the others that have praised your analysis. Like many, I love watching knowledgeable people discover this gem but your video is the first of the dozens I've watched that motivated me to watch more of your work and to subscribe to a channel, something I almost never do. On top of all that, if I were going to seek out voice instruction over the Internet there's no question you would be my choice due to your clearly demonstrated expertise, your ability to clearly communicate, and your passion. Exquisite.
Another fantastic analysis roberto, I look forward to many more informative videos. I love that as an English speaker I can follow with the subtitles while picking up on some Italian words at the same time ! I am trying to learn your beautiful language, it's taking me a long time though.😄 take care.
I do not speak Italian so I was very grateful that you had subtitles. I have watched a ridiculous amount of these reaction videos to this song. And you are by far the best reaction video I’ve seen. The sheer joy in your face is so pure. You give such a beautiful and detailed analysis of this version. This song and the way he sings it has touched me to my very soul. If God had a voice I could only imagine that this voice would be what it would sound like. Thank you so much for this video. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
I just enjoyed your response to this version nearly as much as I do the song! I love this cover and have been watching vocal coaches and composer/arrangers reactions to it and I must say that although I don't speak your language, I thought your reaction was the most honest I've seen. It was quite obvious how moved you were by it. I love that you likened his vocals to a cello...spot on! As I've said many times, no matter how many times I hear this, it brings tears to my eyes ( not unlike Pavarotti singing Nessun Dorma) I look forward to watching your videos. Grazie
All I can say is "Wow!!!". I won't repeat what others have said so well. You are brilliant and talented. Yes I have watched many others analyze and react to this Disturbed performance. Now I much more fully understand how the voice works. And the success of this arrangement.
This is the most extensive breakdown I've seen of this. Well done! His range is amazing as he can do the lyrics justice. The first refrain or two is a melancholy, depressing musing on the situation which the singer nails. The next is semi-optimistic, which he goes up an octave and increases his energy. The final lyric of this mood is "hear my words that I might teach you, take my arms that I might reach you" and then switches to raspy anger with "but my words, like silent raindrops fell" (no one is heading his warnings) and continues to the "praying to the neon gods they made", which is the most raspy and aggressive part of his version. Sadly, the song is way ahead of its time since we now see everyone with their heads bowed and hands clasped as if praying, but is actually just their focus glued to the bright lights of "the neon gods they made". The theme of a lack of direct communication with each other is consistent, but much worse than it was back when this was written.
I enjoyed your comments so much. I learned from them. I love this song. I am 66 I was around when first version by Simon and Garfunkel came out. David's version touched my heart and soul. You are so kind. Thank you.
This song got me through my most difficult year of law school. I have seen many reactions to this version of the song. With each one its like experiencing it for the first time. Gives me chills everytime still. I enjoyed your reaction.
I've heard to so many reactions to this song, but this is the best. The way Roberto Carri explains each melody movement, variations, voice timbers and the fantastic work of the vocalist David Draiman is really touching. I've heard this song a hundred of times and Disturbed work touches me deep.
I enjoyed the fact you kept going back and re-listening, because you caught so many little changes in his voice (on the first listen!) as the song progressed upwards. It was also humorous that your introduction to David Draiman's vocal abilities was reversed......in that you heard the singing voice most of us DONT associate with his music first, then when the gritty metal rock sound we all have heard for decades started up, it was more of a shock to hear. Most Disturbed fans were more shocked by the first 2/3 of the song, then the finale took us back to what WE were familiar with!
I love watching relationships videos to this song. It is so great seeing how people respond to this. Every single reaction, everyone is amazed at this song. Your video was truly spectacular. You analyzed it so indepth and really gave a good view of what he is doing to get to each stage. I truly was amazed by your analysis. It was so interesting and so informative. I truly enjoyed what you had to say. This was great, cheers to you!
Of all the vocal coaches reacting to the Disturbed version of the Sound of Silence this is by far the most in depth , honest and informative of them all. Thank you so much for teaching us on how a good voice coach listens to music and voices and points out the extraordinaire things he finds while listening. You my friend, are one of the few who really GETS this song and the way David Draiman has envisioned it. For this I salute you and praise you. Thank you very much for this great video, I wil definitely like and subscribe, you have absolutely earned it. Multi grazie !
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline Enjoyed the technical review. What about Home Free's "Man of Constant Sorrow" and on Peter Hollens RUclips channel Peter Hollens featuring Tim Foust singing "Misty Mountains"
I can't express how close my enjoyment of your re-action and break down of this piece of art, matched my obsession with this particular singer and his vocal choices. Thank you for sharing your talent and insight.
Would love to hear you react to another Disturbed song, Hold Onto Memories. Disturbed is a heavy metal band so what you've just reacted to isn't their typical sound. Neither is Hold Onto Memories. Down With the Sickness is their iconic song. David Draiman has a truly fantastic voice.
Thank you so much for such an informative and insightful analysis of this piece. Having watched dozens of reactions, I think yours and the one by another vocal coach, The Charismatic Voice, are the two that really explore and explain what is technically happening with each note. So satisfying to watch. Especially since i am not a musician, just an avid listener. Thank you.
I love how Disturbed made this song, it's one of my favourites. But I really admire the way you talk about it. Your reaction has purity and genuine emotion, you look like a child discovering a new, amazing toy and abandoning himself to the joy of playing. It is not a common attitude for an adult. I think, Roberto delli Carri, that you are a beautiful human being. Vale!
Ciao caro Roberto✨ Grazie mille! Your nuanced analysis left me immersed in the melody & lyrics of this classic I’ve heard before over the years. But, today it was especially impactful to me given the turmoil here over the last several months. I’m left saddened at the inability to be able to speak and hear each other, which leaves us unable to love each other. Excellent presentation ... Music when done right can be powerful, no? 🤍 Tica 🇺🇸
I love this reaction. Your beautiful way of expressing the review made points I've never heard pointed out before. I'm so happy for the subtitles that translated for me!
I really do love your break downs. I've heard this version several times, but I wouldn't say I'm truly familiar with it, so I liked when you pointed out the more legato phrases in the beginning vs more accented words with the next verse. It was a recognizable thing, but something I didn't pay attention to/notice. I feel that being made aware of that added another layer for that section of the song. Thank you for posting, and I hope your wife wasn't too worried. Lol!
I've been watching vocal coach reactions of this song for the last two days. This reaction, really listening to the rendition (especially rewinding to the surprises constantly) and the best explanation really makes your 22 minuttes video an enjoyment.
Io sono stonatissima...amo cantare e amo la musica, non potrei vivere senza. Non avrei mai immaginato che qualcuno potesse parlare cosi di musica catturando davvero tanto la mia attenzione. Il tuo è un gran dono...grazie di condividelo con tutti noi. Grazie di ❤
This is the best reaction video I have seen. Your remarks were very insightful. I loved your delight when the singer first introduced distortion, which in English is called 'grit' or 'fry'. My compliments to the translator who allowed me to appreciate your discussion.
When I first heard this version I was completely transfixed. Visions of a dystopian future, I could see some lonely figure walking the streets following some great disaster, maybe the last person on earth. Your analysis has added so much to my enjoyment of this amazing rendition of a classic song. Thank yiu
Wow.... Just 'Wow'. I am 70 yo and live in Australia. I have watched thousands of reaction. This was one of the most interesting and inciteful reactions I've ever seen. You have a new subscriber my friend. Keep up the good work!
I'm an 82 year old Bach, Beethoven, Vivaldi, Mozart, Handel, et al kind of music fan. Never listened to Metal. Didn't particularly care for Simon and Garfunkel or the Sound of Silence. Then one day a year or so ago while looking for a particular piece of music I ran across this song where this bald guy with lots of face jewelry and an angry voice was belting out this song, the kind of thing I normally just quickly pass on by - which I did - and continued on my quest to find that piece I was looking for.
But after a few minutes I got to wondering what that video was all about so I started looking for it and finally found the link. I started the video and my musical life changed. Forever. Long story short. Started listening. Something, David Draiman's voice? reached in and grabbed my soul, I listened, goose bumps appearing, eyes watering, getting choked up to a degree which I had never experienced before.
I later learned that people were creating reaction video's on RUclips so I watched several addressing this cover to see if others had experienced similar emotions and was relieved to find I wasn't alone. I must have watched over a hundred reaction videos at this point because I enjoy watching the joy this song has given others. I have to say that yours has provided the most informative best presented reaction I have yet witnessed. Thank you for that.
That is a WONDERFUL story, Jim! Thanks for sharing it!!!
You are not alone. I am only 49 and have the same experiences. And also learning alot of new bands through reaction videos such as Bad Wolves, My Chemical Romance, etc
Jim, being a 61 yo music lover of multiple genres, you seriously should check out Floor Jansen who can sing everything from opera to symphonic metal as the classically trained lead singer for Nightwish. If you don't check her out you will doing yourself a great disservice. Cheers
@@brewswillis9783 and of course there is Dimash
@@micheleanderson3173 Objectively he's got an amazing voice, he just doesn't move me emotionally. But yes, everyone should check him out.
This is by far the most in depth analysis of this performance I've ever seen, and I have seen many. Thank you for posting.
Thank you SO much Alienart!!!
This is a the best analysis of this phenomenon that I have found.
Cheers, from Toronto ✌
I agree I loved your reaction and comments.
RUclips is great as there are so many reaction videos from different backgrounds, from recording to composers to vocal coaches and everyone has a different piece of knowledge on the same piece of work. It's amazing! This is definitely one of the great analyses of this performance.
My thoughts, exactly. I have watched dozens of reaction and analysis videos to this song. This is, by far, the best break down and explanation of all the details of what David Draiman is doing with his voice. Each choice, each skill, the ability needed to make it happen, and the impact of doing it correctly. Beautiful.
We laymen instinctively know Disturbed's version is exquisite, but don't understand exactly why. It's so great to have an expert explain and validate for us. Grazie mille!
This you hit the nail on the head my friend. As a layman myself I also feel the same and appreciate the efforts given by the knowledgeable and am learning a lot. This has been an informative video.
Before watching your analysis, there was only one other reaction that I've found to this performance that I felt was unique and honest and humble and genuine. Most miss the mark and have generic comments or criticisms right off the cuff and it cheapens the experience for the viewer. I don't speak a word of Italian, yet nothing was lost in translation because your emotion and intellect when discussing something you're obviously passionate about shines through. Your English subtitles were excellent and convey the exact sentiments you wanted to express.
Your channel and efforts are incredibly underrated and I hope so many more people receive the opportunity to learn from you. Thank you!
Eric, you have no idea how much your kind and encouraging words are NOT underrated by me! Thank you for your support! Roberto
I.ve listened to 40+ analysis of this performance both live and this one the video version. Hands down best analysis and Roberto is only one who goes back and forth to rehear sections as should be done with a masterpiece. Bravo.
Thank you VERY much kmcon55!!!
I could not agree more!
When singers and vocal coaches have a face of bewilderment, shock, and truly heart-touched you know it's got to be great.
You are the only reaction who deserves the "Vocal Coach" keyword. I was raised speaking english, but I understood all of your Italian and am incredibly impressed at your insights
Thank you VERY much, A Danesi!!!
David Draiman....IMO THE best male vocalist out there. Can go from warm baritone to tenor, to clear as an angelic bell to grit/rasp and back on a DIME. What a powerful voice! Awesome talent and amazing voice control! He has been singing for over 25 years or more...knows how to do distortion WITHOUT harming his vocal cords. His voice has a timber I've never heard before. Loved your commentary and reaction....could tell you appreciated it too.
Thank you Ruthie!!!
Wouldn't disagree with anything you have said,but please correct "timber"to "timbre"!
@@richardrichards9180 who are you.....the spelling police?? As for your comment...I care NOT to.
@@ruthiewohlforth5464 ok duzznt mater,anniway,,do it?-?
@@richardrichards9180 No it "duzznt" "mater" "anniway" do it......
I have been a fan of Disturbed for over 20 years, this song (thankfully) has shown so many people how good David really is. This video really shows a very indepth look at the song and the smile on your face shows real adoration. Just a joy to watch thank you
Thank you, Phil!
Definitely. I'm a Disturbed fan and many people underestimate David's vocal range. He can have a voice of an angel and the voice of a devil. He can create sound effects with voice. It saddened me when this beautiful cover came out and so many accused him of using auto tune. It was insulting for some fools to think that. I know better because David is very talented. I know his music and that he had vocal training in school.
I agree. This is the case with other heavy metal singers too. People say they are not good singers, they are being judged because of what type of music they sing to, rather than how good and how difficult it really is. I have heard people trash Corey Taylor in Slipknot for "just screaming" and "not being able to sing" in their songs and then I play lets say Vermillion pt 2 and all of a sudden they say "well this guy sings better than the previous song".. When I say it's the same singer then they start trying to find reasons to dislike the singing they just a second ago liked. It is such a shame.
I loved this analysis of this vocal. Most reaction videos I have viewed merely say how they feel when listening, but you’re obviously extremely educated and well versed and this expertise was wonderful. Ty for sharing your much appreciated professional analysis
Thank you!!!
He’s also a voice teacher and his grandfather taught singing in temple in Jerusalem. He has great command of his voice, very experienced.
I have watched many of these analyses of Disturbed's version of this song . And I must say , I have enjoyed yours the most . Not only with your musical expertise , but the sheer joy you show discovering this exceptional version of this song . Thank you . 😃
Thank YOU, Susan!!!
I love the delight and joy you express when hearing this. You understand the music on a different, more in-depth level than most people, but that seems to add to your enjoyment rather than taking away from it. This was one of my favourite reaction videos.
Thank you VERY much, Helgacabbage!!!
Absolutely the best, and most interesting reaction / analysis of this amazing rendition I have ever watched. You were on point with every comment. You are clearly not just a vocal coach, but an artist in your own right, with the ability and musical awareness to analyze this performance in a holistic way. Great job.
Thank you VERY MUCH, James!!!
I agree 💯
yes the artistic tone of the analysis is a beautiful performance itself
This 'Reaction' video was, by far, THE best I have seen. You dissected so many different techniques - examined them at the most base level. You explained those techniques and the power behind them. You are also one of the very few who give credit to the interpretation and musical arrangement of this song. It isn't just David Draiman's voice that makes this rendition so amazing, it is vocals, arrangement, interpretation, the entire package. Thank you so much for sharing your insight.
Really glad you enjoyed the video, raventroll! Thank YOU!!!
I have been addicted to watching reaction videos for this song for over a year now. "People writing songs that voices never share" is for me, the most beautiful line in the whole presentation. Not only are the lyrics poignant, but the execution is so beautiful. This is the first reaction that has given this line the attention I think it so richly deserves. Wonderful reaction and analyzes. Thank you
Me too. I am obsessed with the Disturbed version
Roberto along with being a sweetie, is definitely a true professional. I can’t imagine the hours and years he must have studied to know all the in-depth knowledge that he has. Plus I totally enjoyed watching and listening to his reactions on Disturbed.
Like the rest of the comments it’s obvious we viewers are pretty much of one accord with Robertos reactions, as well as emotions we experienced when first listening to Disturbeds version of Sound of Silence.
When I first heard David sing Sound of Silence, I’m not sure I was even breathing till the last note finished resonating. He took my breath away as he led me through a wide array of emotions with the most awesome, heaviest, music video ever made. The concept developing and producing every single part of what Disturbed brought to our ears, eyes, our hearts and minds was nothing short of genius. ♥️ 🇺🇸
Yours is one of the most insightful reactions to this performance that I have seen. Although I have seen this video and the Conan show live performance many times, I didn't make the 'Cello' association before. It is a perfect metaphor. Thanks for your work here.
Thank YOU, John!!!
I agree 100% I loved your breakdown of the song. Your accent had something to do with it I think lol love it! Seriously you sounded like you understood what he was doing with the song. He built it up so great. I've watched this song atleast over 100 times and each time gives me chills and watery eyes...lol This video I feel is more about the story of the song. The Conan Show version I feel is more about all the instruments around him. Both showcase the powerful vocals of David. And during Conan he was really sick and the band made him sit during it because they didn't want him to passout. The show wanted to use auto tune but the squashed that idea. I do believe they used it on one part from what I hear but I can't tell where but regardless being sick he killed it as well!! I can't say enough about this song! Amazing!!
I find it absolutely amazing that I have listened to just about every reaction to this song, and yours is the one I enjoyed the most. And you weren’t even speaking my language!! Usually, I get annoyed when the reactor keep stopping the song to comment, but every time you did it, I was anxious to hear what you had to say. Thank you for a very interesting and professional reaction. Be sure to watch the live version of the song on Conan. David is actually sitting and still belting that song out with strength and emotion. Add to that is the fact that he wasn’t well that night. Thank you for your reaction and you have a new subscriber!
Thank you SOO much, CrossingtheRubicon!!!
Me too. I hate when they pause at exactly the _wrong momment!_ But this was the best analysis I have come across. Cheers, from Toronto ✌
I agree this reaction is the best I ve watched so far and I dont speak Italian either! I really liked how you got how special my favorite part of the song is. I love how he sings the line "Take my hand so that I might reach you"
Hello Roberto, my name is Martin from Ireland. I've known and loved Disturbed for years, I've watched dozens and dozens of reactions to this song of which some have been good but yours, well its beyond a shadow of doubt the most honest, the most genuine, the most pure, the most amazing one. You listen and enjoy it like a lifetime fan of the band does but you as a lifetime fan of music. You pay David and the entire band, and all the producers of the song as much credit and respect as you too deserve for your expertise, knowledge and appreciation for music. I'd love for David to watch your reaction to his reaction as you made me feel watching your "beautiful" and "wow" comments, you listening and re-listening, your in depth analysis and your smile grow as you were listening to it the way you appear to of felt listening to them perform. I never, ever have or would subscribe to you tube videos or follow people but you my friend have made me change to subscribing to you as I wait with interest and joy to see what you do next. My children and wife too will be seeing you and your amazing qualities both as a person and an expert. Well done bravo bravo 🙏
You made my day, No No!
Your kind and encouraging words are VERY appreciated.
Grazie, Roberto.
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline Thank you Roberto for acknowledging and commenting to me. You have made my day in return my friend so thank you too.
My wife and children (3yrs & 5yrs old) are asking me "who is this gentleman you are listening to each day after work?" and its you and your reactions. You are so inspiring to the appreciation of music. I'll be commenting on your other videos (if you don't mind) with what you are teaching me by me simply watching you. Thanks again and 'slan' for now.
This was absolutely fascinating to watch. Your facial reactions and the excitement and joy you expressed were authentic. I really enjoyed your breakdown of how professional the arrangement was and it made me understand how much thought must have been put into this version. Thank you for sharing it all with us!
Thank you so much, Mary!!!
Been watching 1st time listening to this cover from various channels for hours, and to me, yours is the most intuitive and constructive critic so far! Thanks!
I am so glad you liked this cover of the sound of silence and actually took the time to break it down and point out some of what makes it such an amazing song. I have watched a lot of reaction videos on this song and they all say wow, great song, and they love it but that's all they say. Well anybody can do that! Thanks for breaking it down and putting words and explanations to how this was done that I couldn't put words to! Great job
Thank you SO much, john!!!
I would simply echo what many have already said. Namely, that out of the many "reaction and analysis" videos I have watched, this one is the best. I don't need someone to tell me this vocal performance is truly special; I can hear that for myself. But I do need some help understanding the techniques employed to make it so very special. Your analysis and explanation did that for me. Thank you.
Glad I could be of some help, James! Thank YOU!
So enjoyed watching the delight on your face, as you traveled through this version of the song. The love of music, and it’s intricacies are so visible on your face. It brought sunshine to my day...and extra enjoyment of this remarkable rendition of the “sounds of silence “ Thank you 💫💫💫
So happy to hear that, Laima, thank you!!!
Thank you so much for sharing this video. It is a saying "You learn something new every day." Though I am in my seventies you just taught me many points on how to properly listen to music and understand what the performer is doing that affects you as it does. You shared how to use one's voice to capture and hold attention. You showed how singing is a skill developed through practice and attention to the details of your vocal actions. I would like to express so much more of your affect on me but I will just reiterate my thanks. Be blessed.
Dear Francis, your kind words are super appreciated. I am truly happy I could help you in some way! Thank you!!!
I’ve watched many, many reactions to this video because I not only love this version but I love seeing the reactions of first time listeners! I am amazed every time I hear him sing this song, with the control and dramatic tone to his voice. But I will say, your reaction is one of the best I’ve seen. I love that you want to listen repeatedly to the different vocal changes and/or what those changes bring dynamically. You listen to it with the same enthusiasm, awe, admiration and respect as I. Great review!
Thank you VERY much, Sharon!!!
Lol what I like is most reactors tell you that they're going to rewind it. Roberto not giving a damn lol.....he'll rewind it 8 times if he wants to without saying anything. But his knowledge is truly a pleasure to hear.
I think spoken Italian is possibly the most aesthetically pleasing language to listen to-so a fitting vehicle for a piece such as this.
I am charmed and delighted by the song-like quality of the Italian language as well, and Roberto delli Carri's spoken voice is like a beautiful instrument.
:D I could listen to this guy talk about this song all afternoon. What a phenomenal cover, eh?
@@JustMe-vk4fn yes, I never thought of a cover version displacing the original in what has been one of my top five all-time list for 30 years or more,but think it must.
Good subtitles, I could listen to Italian all day long. My mom was 100% Italian, so I grew up around it but never learned to speak it, though I wish I had. It always brings me back to childhood holidays, especially Christmas when she would make the traditional courses of Italian fish, eel, baccala, etc. Sounds like you have a great voice as well. Good reaction and good breakdown of what David is doing, he’s a phenomenal singer and from what I’ve heard he’s an incredibly humble and nice guy.
Thank you soo much, clonexx!!!
Same. Sicilian here
Wow is the same in any language! This video always gets a wow! I love it.
Greetings from America!
Really enjoyed your reaction and analysis!!!!!
Thank you, Classic Rock Lady!
Roberto, yours was the most in-depth and informative analysis of this song and of David Draiman's voice in particular. I learned some things from you and, bonus! I was enchanted to hear it in your beautiful language.
I've subscribed, and look forward to your future videos. Thank you!
Thank you SO much, Myra!!!
I have seen elsewhere, that Simon and Garfunkel's version was a warning, this version is anger that the warning was ignored. Such a beautiful analysis of this song!
Thank you, Kerwyn!!!
I'm not even a Distrurbed fan... but they did for this song what Johnny Cash did for Nine Inch Nail's "Hurt."
Agreed. Never been a big Disturbed fan, but they now own this song! They way he conveyed emotion with the lyrics is absolutely something special that nobody else could accomplish to this level! The first time I heard it, my overly manly. 6'5", 270lb self had my eyes watering afterwards.
I was absolutely thinking the very same thing.
Or what KD Lang did for Leonard Cohens Hallelujah!
@@walterpadovani1777 Ah... the 2010 Winter Olympics.
Such great memories.
💯
I can't thank you enough for your amazing analysis of a song that has come to haunt my thoughts and live in my heart. Your technical understanding, yet uncomplicated explanations of the technics used by Mr. Draymond, even I ( a complete novice) could understand and try to imitate. If I was a serious singer I would be on the first plane out to you for lessons! I am however going to buy you book tomorrow and read it. I find how the voice works extremely fascinating. I've liked and subscribed to your site and hope to watch more reactions from you. Once again Ty for sharing your knowledge. ~ Claire
Claire, thank YOU!!!
You, sir are far too humble! Your reaction was so very educational and a pleasure to watch. I loved your facial expressions along with your great expertise. Thank you!
Thank you VERY much, RL S!!!
I love that virtually all the vocal coaches smile and admire the "distortion" effect.
My first time on your channel. This is one of my favorite covers so I was curious. I almost kept scrolling but with the captions I was able to follow well enough. Really enjoyed your responses. Thank you.
Thank you Michelle!!!
Toronto time here and I subscribed! Cheers, from Toronto ✌
Thank you for the insight. Very well done. Very thoughtful.
PS: that's probably the best immitation of Dave's fry/distortion push I've heard, in listening to vocal coaches react to Dave. i'm sure your wife enjoyed it. very passionate all around.
Thank you VERY much, Larry!!!
Roberto, my dear I am very pleased with your critique. So much information delivered in such a beautiful, poetic manner. Thank you for your Bella self
Thank you SO much, Susan!!!
I have listened to hundreds of reaction videos for this cover. Yours is the only one that has prompted me to post in response. Thanks for the education.
Your video is as so well done, I think I was understanding Italian by the end!
Thank YOU, Robert!!!
I have never commented on a reaction before but couldn't resist here. You broke this down in a way I haven't seen before and gave a good 'lesson' on what was going on with the vocals. I always had a view of this version of the song as better than the original. I now have a better appreciation and understanding of what David did with the song and how he vocally performed it. Thank you Roberto. :)
I am really glad that I could be of some help, Robbie! Thank you for writing this comment and letting me know!!!
this version of the song is simply beautiful .... and one of the proofs is your reaction, especially you as a professional singing teacher ... I love to see such passion and sensitivity to the sounds of music that you have shown
Another absolutely fascinating and thoroughly enjoyable video, thank you once again.
Also far and away the most complete and informative reaction to this song I've seen from anyone.
Always so impressed with you videos and your enthusiasm for music and voice always makes me smile too.
Thank you!
Thank you VERY much R B93!!!
I have been singing for 48 of my 60 years on this planet, performed in Carnegie Hall, Covent Gardens and Cathedral of the Madeleine in Paris. a fan of any kind of music short of Heavy Metal and Rap. Well his song fixed my Heavy Metal problem, I have watched many of Disturber's videos since I experienced this song.
The first time I watched this I just sat with my mouth hanging open, stunned at the end. then I watched it at least15 more times in that sitting, and countless times since. One time I saw a reaction video of this piece of music and I have seen 40 or 50 since then, I like to watch the reviewer and there facial reactions to this song, and see their facial expressions change as the song morphs and changes throughout. Most interesting. Today I saw a click bait for your reaction Roberto and i said "ooo one I have not seen!!" and when you started speaking in Italian I was somewhat bummed until i saw the sub-titles, and off we went into this amazing piece of music.
Being a singer myself, I like voice coach reviews of David's amazing voice. Elizabeth Zarhoff (The Charismatic Voice) and you give the best insight into the techniques he has. I truly enjoyed your reaction and will subscribe to see more from you. The most common word I hear in watching reaction videos for this song is "WOW' which I think you said at least 5 times.
In all the darkness and sadness anger of this video I have yet for anyone to comment on the rya of hope that is present at the very end, did you see it Roberto in your follow up viewings of this?
Thanks for the great review.
Richard
Hi! This is the first video I have watched on your channel and I'm impressed by the extent and detail of your analysis - most reaction videos only scratch the surface, you commented a lot - I really enjoyed that. The subs are really great, I don't speak Italian good enough to undestand you, but it was extremely enjoyable to listen to your voice and the melody of the Italian language in addition to the music. You have a new subscriber :)
Thank you VERY much, Frank!!!
I have watched almost every one of these reactions to this song and its funny . Almost all of the people dont know anything about Disturbed and always say they were surprised when he goes up and adds the fry and is in total control of it . However for myself and people that I know that were Disturbed fans before hearing this I remember being surprised at his low slow clear singing in the beginning. You also might be interested in listening to the Live version of this on Conan , and knowing he was sitting down because he was so sick with the flu that they didnt even think he could stand the whole time
He wasn’t happy with his performance on the Conan Show, as he was sick I love the visuals of this video ☮️💜
As many others have said, I have watched a lot of reactions to this song. Yours was by far the best. So much heart in your reactions to this both physically and in your explanations. I am normally not a huge fan of remakes but he just nailed this song. I love how you gave this song the reaction it deserves. You have a new subscriber! Thank you! 😍❤😍
Thank you VERY much, Karma!!!
David Draiman/Disturbed has a live presentation recording on Conan that you will be able to see some of his techniques better. Although I had to read your sub scripts, I loved your explanations of how he was able to do such a magnificent job! Thank you.
Thank you, Rainbow Zebra Unicorn Pegasus!
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline please keep in mind that David had the flu during the Conan show. The sound guy used some auto tune and after the show David was furious ! He wanted his vocal to stand on their own, flu or no flu !
It's still an amazing performance, despite being sick, but it's also why I prefer the official video-- you get the full power of Draiman's vocal techniques.
I have watched about a half a dozen reaction videos tonight on this song and I have to say that yours was the most informative and best reaction, because of your knowledge of the technical side of the song. I have watched grown men cry in reaction to this song. I myself tear up every time I hear it. It is an extremely powerful rendition of a great song. Thank you for being the cherry on the cake tonight ;)
Craig, thank YOU so much for your kind words. I am truly glad that you enjoyed my video! Roberto
I'm not a big fan of subtitles but this was a great reaction/breakdown of Disturbed's version of The Sound of Silence.
Thank you, I am a Groot!
It certainly helps that the subtitles are actually in good, solid, very understandable English. Even if a writing teacher would probably ding a few points for the wanton overuse of ellipses. 😅
I don't know if you understand the English words, but you obviously understand the emotion of the lyrics and song. I am 76, heard the Simon & Garfunkel original in 1964, and did not understand the song then. About a year ago, I came across this version by Disturbed, I called my younger son and told him to listen to it and that I finally understood the song. Your face showed how you became engrossed in the song. You are NOT alone.
Roberto was so in tune with the song the he even flushed. (Min. 15 and 35sec) .No wonder his wife started to worry... 🤣🤣🤣 cheers
Btw, I agree with the comments, he is by far the best at explaining and feeling the song!!!
Thank you SO much, Andrew!!!
I caught that too. That was the look of pure admiration and love. We were right there too.
I have watched over 100 reactions to this song and none compared to this honest and sincere analysis. The songs author, Paul Simon, who wrote this sitting in the dark on his bathroom floor after the assassination of Robert Kennedy, met David Drayman in person and said to him "Now, this song belongs to you, David." I encourage you to view the live performance on the Conan O'brien show. Just show patience for him as he was I'll with a fever and chills but insisted he still wanted to sing on this night...with no auto-tune; something that many vocal coaches think they here! Lastly, RUclips has a video of David speaking about the writing and performance of it which you may enjoy viewing.
CHAO!
Thank you SO much, Bruce for you comment!!!
Had to use subtitles because I had no idea what Roberto was saying but the breakdown and analysis of this was the best I've seen. I've listened to this version so many times and every time I get goose bumps and watery eyes. Thank you for your great interpretation of David's voice. I love this version because it brings out so many aspects and ranges of his voice and truly shows what a great singer he is.
Thank you VERY much, LucidDreamer68!!!
I don't know a word of Italian but subtitles have never stopped me! Wonderful knowledge of the human voice.\
Cheers, from Toronto ✌
I know that your reaction was from over 3 years ago now, but I HAD to send this to you.
Grazie Mille! LOVED your take and breakdown of this fabulous cover.
I was a musician and vocalist in high school, and as a young man in my mid-20s, was stationed in southern Italy at San Vito dei Normanni Air Station in the early 80s.
This cover touches me deep within my soul .... hearing your language as I read in English what you are saying was MAGICAL for me !
Thank you SO MUCH !!!❤
Years ago I listened to this version of The Sound of Silence because I liked the original but now I only listen to Disturbed singing it. After I heard it I couldn't wait to check out other Disturbed songs because David Draiman's voice was so amazing and I got a shock that they are a heavy metal band. I ended up liking a number of their songs but I don't think any of them showcase David's voice like The Sound of Silence. Thanks for the fantastic analysis of the song, I always learn from your reactions. Cheers!
Thank you Terry!!!
David Draiman is one of the best metal vocalists around. He was classically trained in the church/Synagogue. An amazing talent, with impeccable control. Having said that, your review is amazing, and even with the language difference, I agree with everything you analysed. You have an amazing voice too. Greetings from Austria.
Thank you VERY much, Stephendavidallen!!!
Loved your analysis. I learned a lot. And hearing it in the beautiful Italian language was an added treat! Graci!
Thank you Teresa!!!
I think that you reacted exactly as the cover wished!! It is exactly how I interpreted this arrangement. I'm 80 years old, female, and a huge Disturbed fan. He is a trained vocalist. I did sing in a chorus and am aware of some facets of arrangements and phrasing so I really love this guy's talent!!! You did the very best reaction and description of this cover than any other of the many reactors that are on RUclips!! I thank you for your intelligent and emotional reaction!! Bella!!
He works very hard to maintain his voice and regularly works with a vocal coach. If you’ve been in the metal genre for over 20 years it’s a must.
Thank you. It is said that anything one understands, can only be born out of what one has experienced. There is much that I haven't experienced..... Your passionate quest and insightful comments, has added much to my understanding. Yours is not the talk which captures many of the 'reaction junkies,' rather, your voice adds to the chorus of wisdom seekers. The joy and wonderment you share, are indeed, appreciated. Bravo!
Thank you SO much for your kind words, Shihan Sensei!!!
Disturbed version of The Sound of Silence will be remembered forever and more,its sn EPIC,like a volcano building pressure from unfathomable depth ready to explode full blast with the almighty fire.
I have to agree with all the others that have praised your analysis. Like many, I love watching knowledgeable people discover this gem but your video is the first of the dozens I've watched that motivated me to watch more of your work and to subscribe to a channel, something I almost never do. On top of all that, if I were going to seek out voice instruction over the Internet there's no question you would be my choice due to your clearly demonstrated expertise, your ability to clearly communicate, and your passion. Exquisite.
Jon, thank you SO much for your kindness! Roberto
Another fantastic analysis roberto, I look forward to many more informative videos. I love that as an English speaker I can follow with the subtitles while picking up on some Italian words at the same time ! I am trying to learn your beautiful language, it's taking me a long time though.😄 take care.
Thank you Vikki!
I do not speak Italian so I was very grateful that you had subtitles. I have watched a ridiculous amount of these reaction videos to this song. And you are by far the best reaction video I’ve seen. The sheer joy in your face is so pure. You give such a beautiful and detailed analysis of this version. This song and the way he sings it has touched me to my very soul. If God had a voice I could only imagine that this voice would be what it would sound like. Thank you so much for this video. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Roberto... Este es por lejos el mejor análisis que vi de uno de los mejores covers que escuché en mi vida. Gracias!
¡Me alegro que hayas disfrutado! Muchísimas gracias, Pablo!!!
I just enjoyed your response to this version nearly as much as I do the song! I love this cover and have been watching vocal coaches and composer/arrangers reactions to it and I must say that although I don't speak your language, I thought your reaction was the most honest I've seen. It was quite obvious how moved you were by it. I love that you likened his vocals to a cello...spot on! As I've said many times, no matter how many times I hear this, it brings tears to my eyes ( not unlike Pavarotti singing Nessun Dorma)
I look forward to watching your videos. Grazie
Thank YOU, Cheryl, for your words! Truly appreciated! Roberto
All I can say is "Wow!!!". I won't repeat what others have said so well. You are brilliant and talented. Yes I have watched many others analyze and react to this Disturbed performance. Now I much more fully understand how the voice works. And the success of this arrangement.
Thank you soo much, Larry!!!
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline Yes. You are awesome. I am not a singer. I am told I am tone deaf...LOL Larry
This is the most extensive breakdown I've seen of this. Well done! His range is amazing as he can do the lyrics justice. The first refrain or two is a melancholy, depressing musing on the situation which the singer nails. The next is semi-optimistic, which he goes up an octave and increases his energy. The final lyric of this mood is "hear my words that I might teach you, take my arms that I might reach you" and then switches to raspy anger with "but my words, like silent raindrops fell" (no one is heading his warnings) and continues to the "praying to the neon gods they made", which is the most raspy and aggressive part of his version. Sadly, the song is way ahead of its time since we now see everyone with their heads bowed and hands clasped as if praying, but is actually just their focus glued to the bright lights of "the neon gods they made". The theme of a lack of direct communication with each other is consistent, but much worse than it was back when this was written.
This version of The Sound Of Silence makes me feel so happy and comforted.
I enjoyed your comments so much. I learned from them. I love this song. I am 66 I was around when first version by Simon and Garfunkel came out. David's version touched my heart and soul. You are so kind. Thank you.
Thank you SO much, Joan!!!
This song got me through my most difficult year of law school. I have seen many reactions to this version of the song. With each one its like experiencing it for the first time. Gives me chills everytime still. I enjoyed your reaction.
I've heard to so many reactions to this song, but this is the best. The way Roberto Carri explains each melody movement, variations, voice timbers and the fantastic work of the vocalist David Draiman is really touching. I've heard this song a hundred of times and Disturbed work touches me deep.
I enjoyed the fact you kept going back and re-listening, because you caught so many little changes in his voice (on the first listen!) as the song progressed upwards.
It was also humorous that your introduction to David Draiman's vocal abilities was reversed......in that you heard the singing voice most of us DONT associate with his music first, then when the gritty metal rock sound we all have heard for decades started up, it was more of a shock to hear. Most Disturbed fans were more shocked by the first 2/3 of the song, then the finale took us back to what WE were familiar with!
Thank you for your comment, Steve!!!
I’ve watched over 100 of these reaction videos for this song, and this is by far the best voice breakdown and analysis I’ve heard. Well done.
Thank you SO much, Gregory!!!
I love watching relationships videos to this song. It is so great seeing how people respond to this. Every single reaction, everyone is amazed at this song. Your video was truly spectacular. You analyzed it so indepth and really gave a good view of what he is doing to get to each stage. I truly was amazed by your analysis. It was so interesting and so informative. I truly enjoyed what you had to say. This was great, cheers to you!
Thank you VERY much Coronakid!!!
Very enjoyable reaction. The perfect blend of heartfelt and skillful analysis. Thank you.
Thank YOU, T Griffin!!!
*My wifes starting to worry* 16:58 lmao love this entire reaction.
Of all the vocal coaches reacting to the Disturbed version of the Sound of Silence this is by far the most in depth , honest and informative of them all.
Thank you so much for teaching us on how a good voice coach listens to music and voices and points out the extraordinaire things he finds while listening.
You my friend, are one of the few who really GETS this song and the way David Draiman has envisioned it.
For this I salute you and praise you. Thank you very much for this great video, I wil definitely like and subscribe, you have absolutely earned it.
Multi grazie !
Another fantastic analysis!
Thank you Rosanna!!!
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline Enjoyed the technical review. What about Home Free's "Man of Constant Sorrow" and on Peter Hollens RUclips channel Peter Hollens featuring Tim Foust singing "Misty Mountains"
I can't express how close my enjoyment of your re-action and break down of this piece of art, matched my obsession with this particular singer and his vocal choices. Thank you for sharing your talent and insight.
Thank you SO much, Maria!!!
You're welcome Roberto. You're very knowledgeable and have a deep love of music. Anyone who watches your channel can see it.
Mark...THANK YOU!!!
I have watched about 50 of these coach videos. You are the best I've ever seen. You are the best coach I've ever seen. Good on you.
Thank you so much, j c!!!
If you want to know what Disturbed typically sounds like listen to Down With The Sickness.
This voice teacher is simply fantastic. Thank you, Maestro!
Would love to hear you react to another Disturbed song, Hold Onto Memories. Disturbed is a heavy metal band so what you've just reacted to isn't their typical sound. Neither is Hold Onto Memories. Down With the Sickness is their iconic song. David Draiman has a truly fantastic voice.
Thank you so much for such an informative and insightful analysis of this piece. Having watched dozens of reactions, I think yours and the one by another vocal coach, The Charismatic Voice, are the two that really explore and explain what is technically happening with each note. So satisfying to watch. Especially since i am not a musician, just an avid listener. Thank you.
Thanks coach. I would love to hear you sing something!!
I love how Disturbed made this song, it's one of my favourites. But I really admire the way you talk about it. Your reaction has purity and genuine emotion, you look like a child discovering a new, amazing toy and abandoning himself to the joy of playing. It is not a common attitude for an adult. I think, Roberto delli Carri, that you are a beautiful human being. Vale!
It's so beautiful, thank you for such a wonderful reaction ❤
Thank you Cindy!!!
By far the best breakdown of David's voice and technique. The ways in which you describe what you're hearing is so beautiful. Very poetic!
Thank you Cynthia, your kind words are very appreciated!!!
Ciao caro Roberto✨ Grazie mille! Your nuanced analysis left me immersed in the melody & lyrics of this classic I’ve heard before over the years. But, today it was especially impactful to me given the turmoil here over the last several months. I’m left saddened at the inability to be able to speak and hear each other, which leaves us unable to love each other.
Excellent presentation ... Music when done right can be powerful, no?
🤍 Tica 🇺🇸
Yes, Tica. When done right “Music should make you laugh, make you cry or make you think.”
Thank you! Roberto.
I love this reaction. Your beautiful way of expressing the review made points I've never heard pointed out before. I'm so happy for the subtitles that translated for me!
Thank you soo much, chitty luv2!!!
I really do love your break downs. I've heard this version several times, but I wouldn't say I'm truly familiar with it, so I liked when you pointed out the more legato phrases in the beginning vs more accented words with the next verse. It was a recognizable thing, but something I didn't pay attention to/notice. I feel that being made aware of that added another layer for that section of the song.
Thank you for posting, and I hope your wife wasn't too worried. Lol!
Thank you Lyrical Love!!! :-)
I've been watching vocal coach reactions of this song for the last two days. This reaction, really listening to the rendition (especially rewinding to the surprises constantly) and the best explanation really makes your 22 minuttes video an enjoyment.
Io sono stonatissima...amo cantare e amo la musica, non potrei vivere senza. Non avrei mai immaginato che qualcuno potesse parlare cosi di musica catturando davvero tanto la mia attenzione. Il tuo è un gran dono...grazie di condividelo con tutti noi. Grazie di ❤
Prova a prendere lezioni da Roberto e vedrai!
@@silviamontemezzi6417 grazie....sarebbe stupendo! 🤗
Grazie tante Elvira!!!
@@LezioniDiCantoOnline Grazie a te❤
This is the best reaction video I have seen. Your remarks were very insightful. I loved your delight when the singer first introduced distortion, which in English is called 'grit' or 'fry'. My compliments to the translator who allowed me to appreciate your discussion.
When I first heard this version I was completely transfixed. Visions of a dystopian future, I could see some lonely figure walking the streets following some great disaster, maybe the last person on earth. Your analysis has added so much to my enjoyment of this amazing rendition of a classic song. Thank yiu
Thank YOU Lynne!!!
Wow.... Just 'Wow'. I am 70 yo and live in Australia. I have watched thousands of reaction. This was one of the most interesting and inciteful reactions I've ever seen. You have a new subscriber my friend. Keep up the good work!
Thank you SOO much, Kim!!!