I guess you don't know how things are done in the making of films...pre-records, punch-ins, editing, etc. No doubt she can sing, but that is proven in live performance, not on a screen.
@@hmengland4161 i’m sure this is recorded with an AKG 12 in a really nice room with probably a killer moc preamp. 🤷♂️Maybe they did comps on the vocals but most likely back then she sang it through once. Maybe she did two or three passes the entire song?
This is a wonderful scene from Funny Lady and if you would like to hear a more dramatic version, look for "More Than You Know" on the Simply Streisand album. It's even better.
This is when Barbra is at her best, singing from the Great American Songbook. Nobody does it better, but herself on Simply Streisand(one of her least known, best albums).
I wish some one would do a video box set with all the clips of songs from her movies and ones that did not make it... I assume would be huge copyright problems... but would be pure gold
She ALWAYS sang the Songs LIVE in the movie. She has NEVER allowed lip syncing or allowed her Songs to be edited with her voice Dubbed over in a Studio after the movie was finished with filming any of her scenes. Every Song she sang in whatever movie you watched was done LIVE! So if you want to have any Song that Barbra performed in a scene from every movie she ever sang a song during the movie was/IS BARBRA STREISAND LIVE!Even the song originally done in the movie Casablanca that Barbra Streisand sang in What’s Up, Doc? The scene when she was on top of the piano in the Hotel’s Top Floor and Ryan O’Neal found her sleeping under the tarp & Barbra started to hum “AS TIME GOES BY.” She prompted Ryan to play the Piano by telling him the first NOTE (C minor 7th) she was just singing the song live on top of that piano! Meaning every single movie she’s ever sang a song in is the same song you’re going to hear on any Soundtrack from every movie she had a Soundtrack Album released with that Movie! I don’t know if any of this makes sense but she was singing every single song from every single movie Funny Girl to A Star Is Born to Yentyl to What’s Up, Doc? to Whatever movie she sang a song in any scene is Barbra Streisand Live Every Single Time. I don’t think she sang any songs in NUTS, or Prince Of Tides with a much younger & a lot more Handsome Nick Nolte. But the actor who played her Son in PRINCE OF TIDES Is actually Her Biological Son from her Marriage to Elliot Gould! He does have his Mother’s Vocal Abilities and they have a Duet on one of her Albums. Barbra Streisand & Jason Gould. The Amazing Fact is that Barbra Streisand has Stage Fright so much so that she doesn’t tour much ever since 2000ish?!? If she does Perform Live she still has to Throw Up before she goes on stage every single time for more than 60 years! She has always been afraid she wasn’t good enough to Perform Live.
Cerro' sentada en el trono mas grande el siglo XX, ahora en el veintiuno todos los que crecieron bajo su canto, que llega a molestar de tan perfecto, saben que gozan de un presente bien conducido a voces bellas y jóvenes y a las que casi se pierden antes que ella naciera con su buena suerte.
Great question! I am not sure she did, but Billy Rose was one of the composers so I guess that's how it was chosen to be in the movie. Funny Girl/Lady are terrific films but not super accurate.
I'm just recalling when I saw this flick on the first run, thinking that the factual accuracy was way off; the only ballad I know Fanny Brice to have recorded was the torch song that became her "theme," that being "My Man."
No reverb on her voice, no compression, no takes, just one pass. This is an accomplished vocalist at work kids.
I guess you don't know how things are done in the making of films...pre-records, punch-ins, editing, etc. No doubt she can sing, but that is proven in live performance, not on a screen.
@@hmengland4161 i’m sure this is recorded with an AKG 12 in a really nice room with probably a killer moc preamp. 🤷♂️Maybe they did comps on the vocals but most likely back then she sang it through once. Maybe she did two or three passes the entire song?
@@hmengland4161yes,but,as you may know...she SINGS!!!..here as well as everywhere else!
@@hmengland4161 She sang this live. It was not lip-sync'd to a previously recorded track.
@@onethousandtwonortheast8848 She recorded this live. Not lip-sync'd.
The styling here was impeccable.... all the elements are right
Fantastic and Superb!!! No words .
This is a wonderful scene from Funny Lady and if you would like to hear a more dramatic version, look for "More Than You Know" on the Simply Streisand album. It's even better.
I love the song, but I think that face at the end just makes the whole video!
This is when Barbra is at her best, singing from the Great American Songbook. Nobody does it better, but herself on Simply Streisand(one of her least known, best albums).
The Best ever!💋
I wish some one would do a video box set with all the clips of songs from her movies and ones that did not make it... I assume would be huge copyright problems... but would be pure gold
She ALWAYS sang the Songs LIVE in the movie.
She has NEVER allowed lip syncing or allowed her Songs to be edited with her voice Dubbed over in a Studio after the movie was finished with filming any of her scenes. Every Song she sang in whatever movie you watched was done LIVE! So if you want to have any Song that Barbra performed in a scene from every movie she ever sang a song during the movie was/IS BARBRA STREISAND LIVE!Even the song originally done in the movie Casablanca that Barbra Streisand sang in What’s Up, Doc? The scene when she was on top of the piano in the Hotel’s Top Floor and Ryan O’Neal found her sleeping under the tarp & Barbra started to hum “AS TIME GOES BY.” She prompted Ryan to play the Piano by telling him the first NOTE (C minor 7th) she was just singing the song live on top of that piano! Meaning every single movie she’s ever sang a song in is the same song you’re going to hear on any Soundtrack from every movie she had a Soundtrack Album released with that Movie!
I don’t know if any of this makes sense but she was singing every single song from every single movie Funny Girl to A Star Is Born to Yentyl to What’s Up, Doc? to Whatever movie she sang a song in any scene is Barbra Streisand Live Every Single Time. I don’t think she sang any songs in NUTS, or Prince Of Tides with a much younger & a lot more Handsome Nick Nolte. But the actor who played her Son in PRINCE OF TIDES Is actually Her Biological Son from her Marriage to Elliot Gould! He does have his Mother’s Vocal Abilities and they have a Duet on one of her Albums. Barbra Streisand & Jason Gould.
The Amazing Fact is that Barbra Streisand has Stage Fright so much so that she doesn’t tour much ever since 2000ish?!? If she does Perform Live she still has to Throw Up before she goes on stage every single time for more than 60 years! She has always been afraid she wasn’t good enough to Perform Live.
@@amyray63 I didn't know any of that. Such an incredible talent. Thank ypu for sharing
perfect
sooo loved this movie!
Barbra está elegantérrima com este chapéu nesta cena do filme "Funny Lady".
this lady can sing.... like no other
Yup
Cerro' sentada en el trono mas grande el siglo XX, ahora en el veintiuno todos los que crecieron bajo su canto, que llega a molestar de tan perfecto, saben que gozan de un presente bien conducido a voces bellas y jóvenes y a las que casi se pierden antes que ella naciera con su buena suerte.
I remember watching this late 2007 to early 2008 along with Funny Girl
wow the best
kelly mckay Besides the great Ella Fitzgerald
On TCM tonight at 11:00 pm Pacific time! May 22nd 2023!
♥️♥️♥️
Babs!
Are you listening GB ?
so cute :-)
Nice film and nice music 🎵🎶🎶🎵🎶 utube john bavas cabaret
I wasn't able to find a copy of Fanny Brice actually singing this song. Was it one she actually sang?
It's in Funny Lady
Great question! I am not sure she did, but Billy Rose was one of the composers so I guess that's how it was chosen to be in the movie. Funny Girl/Lady are terrific films but not super accurate.
Ms Streisand. Isn't Mr Can )James?) A bit oldtobeg fora job?
I'm just recalling when I saw this flick on the first run, thinking that the factual accuracy was way off; the only ballad I know Fanny Brice to have recorded was the torch song that became her "theme," that being "My Man."