26:55-27:58 I can actually do one better regarding Star Giant's point here - there are other reviewers who have voiced their distaste for "'Twas the Fight Before Christmas". Specifically, way back in the day, Pieguyrulz (the cartoon reviewer most famous for the "Every Episode of Spongebob Reviewed" series) did a video where he went over the Christmas specials of every Cartoon Cartoon. During the section on the Powerpuff Girls, he goes into how awful "'Twas the Fight" is for... basically the same reasons Star Giant does, but MUCH better explained. Specifically, his review clarifies that the "drag" is severely slow pacing. He notes that it feels like the episode wasn't originally supposed to be 42 minutes as, while all the scenes included are important, there's massive pauses between every line of dialogue and/or major action. So the problem is less that there's unneeded scenes and more that the plot was padded to the point pillows would be envious (which should answer your question on that). Additionally, Pieguy mentions that there's no fight scenes in the entire first half, which is pretty bad for an action oriented show like the original Powerpuff Girls, before it goes into a single fight that lasts 15 MINUTES, further accentuating that it's a pacing issue. And he has other issues on top of that to boot! Here's the link to said review, the part about the PPG special starts at 23:04: ruclips.net/video/aijbMRgtevA/видео.html Now, do I expect Star Giant to have known about this video? No, of course not. It's nearly 8 years old now; Pieguy didn't grow to anywhere near the same degree as his contemporaries, still sitting at less than 100k subscribers; and he hasn't posted anything in more than 6 months. The only reason I knew about his review was because I was a huge fan of him before he petered off. However, this does go to show not only is Star Giant not the only one who doesn't like this episode, but not even the only one who dislikes it for the reasons she gave. And given Pieguy's video still got 24K views and mostly positive reception, I'm inclined to say that a lot more people agree with that opinion than she's leading on.
Another problem with the Powerpuff Girls trying to get a truce going for Christmas is that they're children. Adults do not listen to children the majority of the time. I can buy it in Danny Phantom because the vast majority of ghosts are adults who I can thus believe had a reasonable conversation about this and decided to give themselves a day off. I cannot buy that kids asked adults nicely to behave and then adults did it.
For those who don’t know, Star Giant has a seething hatred for The Loud House of all cartoons, and I genuinely cannot figure out why, even after watching one of her videos on it. I think she has even said that it’s one of the worst Nicktoons to her, which…how?
@nixxgen9574 That is no excuse. SpongeBob and The Fairly OddParents have gone downhill, and yet she doesn’t seem to treat those shows the same way she treats The Loud House.
@@fernandodavidpaezcontreras6586 the reasons why she likes Spongebob and Fairly oddparents is because she grew up with them that's why she likes these shows but hates the Loud house, she has a more nostalgia connection to them where as the Loud house is a recently new show even though the show does suck.
0:41 Okay as Rebeccah's thumbnail artist i have a few things to say about this. A. Call it Lazy all you want, I was only given 5 - 10 minutes to work on this thumbnail after just getting home from grocery shopping. B. Rebeccah doesn't pay me for photoshop jobs so I gotta make it look nice enough to get people to click (and it worked) C. I'm given specific instructions on what she wants in a thumbnail so I gotta meet the criteria Honestly I'd like to just draw thumbnails for Rebeccah but she obviously can't afford that, nor do I have the time. So working with Rebeccah feels more like volunteer gig in the grand scheme of everything I actually do
What's new, Scooby-Doo? We're coming after you. You're gonna solve that mystery. I see you, Scooby-Doo; The trail leads back to you. What's new, Scooby-Doo? What's new, Scooby-Doo? We're gonna follow you. You're gonna solve that mystery. We see you, Scooby-Doo; We're coming after you. What's new, Scooby-Doo? Don't look back! You may find another clue. The Scooby snacks* will be waiting here for you. What's new, Scooby-Doo? We're coming after you. You're gonna solve that mystery. I see you, Scooby-Doo; The trail leads back to you. What's new, Scooby-Doo? Na, na, na, na, na Na, na, na, na, na Na, na, na, na, na, na, na Na, na, na, na, na Na, na, na, na, na What's new, Scooby-Doo?
22:44 It doesn't take grocery shopping to plagiarize a review. That plagiarized review of The Simpsons episode "Miracle on Evergreen Terrace" is used on the thumbnail of the original video by the way.
@@andykishore Not sure why you're telling me this because I had nothing to do with the production of the video outside of making the thumbnail, that's it, I wasn't the one writing the script
I know you're a lot better than this. I get it, crunch really sucks, but I can't help but kinda admire the thumbnail. It's a great representation of the quality of her own content. XD
@@WillieManga a year and a half after making that thumbnail, I agree it is pretty lazy, because on top of the crunch time (which under better circumstances wouldn't really be an issue) I wasn't provided any resources. Rebeccah only provided her avatar and told me to spelunking for resources, AS the video was premiering. And because I didn't know what was even featured on the list she told me to find that Simpsons screenshot and left it at that I wasn't paid for that thumbnail in the end, and I don't even think I was credited either.
How strange that her taking the place of one of the Splash Entertainment's execs in John's Norm of the North 2 review is hilariously fitting. And apparently it wasn't John's idea either.
6:55 Putting it out there, but that quote is stolen from Mr. Enter in his Brickleberry segment on The Worst Cartoons of the 2010's. 24:49 This quote is stolen from Mr. Enter on the Butt Ugly Martians segment on his Top 20 Worst Cartoon Theme Song List. It's hilarious how she continues to do stuff like this and get angry when being criticized for being a copycat, and then thinks she has the nerve to out other people for originality. But remember people, recycling is good for the environment.
Don’t forget around 13:27 where she kinda takes enters joke from his review of the fairly odd parents episode “big fairy share scare”….which in this case doesn’t make sense In the said “big fairy share scare” review, enter said that the theme song for that season sounded like a parody song the first few seasons would make about adding a new character to gain relevance Here Rebecca says it sounds like a song she’d see in a parody of An actually good story, which……what the hell does that even mean?
@@Fazmaster Yeah, Rebeccah talks nonsense. Like how Rebeccah literally said that the South Park character, Randy Marsh actually caused COVID-19, racism riots and suicides in the real world.
And this is one of my reasons as to why I hate StarGiantProductions (or Rebecca). Not only is she a terrible person who doesn't learn from her mistakes (see MrEnter's "Regarding StarGiantProductions" and thadmaster 7's "star giant productions is worse than I thought..." videos, but she's not even salvagable as an animation critic.
It's sad that Star and Enter (You know, The Turning Red 9/11 and Anti-Mask Guy) are basically the same person who have proven their wrongdoings in various ways.(if you're wondering why My DA has been inactive, it's because my computer stopped working)
@@TheMovieAndCartoonFanexcept Mr. Enter knows when to take the L, deconstruct his wrongdoing, and actually evolved as a content creator. Star doing any of those three things is as possible as her winning the lottery.
11:23 I would say its wrong to extrapolate to the entire US population, given the sample is not random, but that's the data analysist speaking in me. Good video.
3:38 you mean like taking a popular anime and just replacing the characters with your oc’s and self insert, and having one of your character designs be just a character from another anime just recolored and another character looking suspiciously like a character designed by one of your former artists you screwed over for a more crappy artist? Seriously between this and the “minors should not be on social media” rant from her Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur review, a lot of the stuff Rebecca says seem to age like rotten cheese made form spoiled milk drying in the hot dessert sun for 8 hours in terms of how poorly most of the things she says age
4:00 -I think that point is a tad pedantic. I mean, Seth Macfarlane and his crew aren't just a bunch of teenagers making memes to amuse each other; they're making a show for an international audience of billions of people. Doesn't the audience's reaction matter more, since they're the consumers?
24:42 That is a special which is part of “Winner and the Golden Child”, an Italian/Korean series about a dog and a lion cub who are tasked with raising the son of the princess from a Sleeping Beauty show made by the same studio so that he can defeat the evil enchantress that tried to kill his parents, or something like that. I recommend watching The Media Hunter’s review of the show, it’s how I got most of my information regarding that show.
Also, that show is a sequel to a show known as Simba Jr. The World Cup, which in turn was a sequel to a Lion King ripoff known as Simba: King Lion. The latter, and Winner also rip off The Jungle Book by featuring a tiger antagonist that both The Media Hunter and Saberspark call “Shere Kahn”. He may have a different name, but I did not see a clip that says it. One more thing, I used the word “show” two times too many in the last sentence of my main comment, I should’ve said “…got most of my information regarding that series.”
It's a sad day when both Enter and Star (Pretty much "Lily Orchard 3.0" [2 0 being Zaid Magenta])end up being shit people and yet Enter ends up being the better critic (mind you, Enter's Turning Red Review [the one where he metions 9/11] and his Anti-Mask ["Healthcare is not a human right" my ass] video still lingers in my mind badly)
25:54 You have a point with the size of the text, but you're not one to talk about pixellated screenshots of text, considering you do exactly that in your videos.
![Addressing The Lies Of Somebody Else [Commentary]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Y8N2_KnnDUA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Addressing The Lies Of Somebody Else [Commentary]](/img/tr.png)
![Lily Orchard Academia [Commentary]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/p_Td3wt3_qU/mqdefault.jpg)
26:55-27:58 I can actually do one better regarding Star Giant's point here - there are other reviewers who have voiced their distaste for "'Twas the Fight Before Christmas". Specifically, way back in the day, Pieguyrulz (the cartoon reviewer most famous for the "Every Episode of Spongebob Reviewed" series) did a video where he went over the Christmas specials of every Cartoon Cartoon. During the section on the Powerpuff Girls, he goes into how awful "'Twas the Fight" is for... basically the same reasons Star Giant does, but MUCH better explained. Specifically, his review clarifies that the "drag" is severely slow pacing. He notes that it feels like the episode wasn't originally supposed to be 42 minutes as, while all the scenes included are important, there's massive pauses between every line of dialogue and/or major action. So the problem is less that there's unneeded scenes and more that the plot was padded to the point pillows would be envious (which should answer your question on that). Additionally, Pieguy mentions that there's no fight scenes in the entire first half, which is pretty bad for an action oriented show like the original Powerpuff Girls, before it goes into a single fight that lasts 15 MINUTES, further accentuating that it's a pacing issue. And he has other issues on top of that to boot! Here's the link to said review, the part about the PPG special starts at 23:04: ruclips.net/video/aijbMRgtevA/видео.html
Now, do I expect Star Giant to have known about this video? No, of course not. It's nearly 8 years old now; Pieguy didn't grow to anywhere near the same degree as his contemporaries, still sitting at less than 100k subscribers; and he hasn't posted anything in more than 6 months. The only reason I knew about his review was because I was a huge fan of him before he petered off. However, this does go to show not only is Star Giant not the only one who doesn't like this episode, but not even the only one who dislikes it for the reasons she gave. And given Pieguy's video still got 24K views and mostly positive reception, I'm inclined to say that a lot more people agree with that opinion than she's leading on.
NGL, her Top 20 Worst Cartoons of 2020 is WAYYYYYYY WORSE
Another problem with the Powerpuff Girls trying to get a truce going for Christmas is that they're children. Adults do not listen to children the majority of the time. I can buy it in Danny Phantom because the vast majority of ghosts are adults who I can thus believe had a reasonable conversation about this and decided to give themselves a day off. I cannot buy that kids asked adults nicely to behave and then adults did it.
Jeez. I watched that vid, and subbed Star Giant Productions and you too. I thought it was okay but here I am. Small world.
For those who don’t know, Star Giant has a seething hatred for The Loud House of all cartoons, and I genuinely cannot figure out why, even after watching one of her videos on it. I think she has even said that it’s one of the worst Nicktoons to her, which…how?
Maybe because its creator Chris Savino has been sexually abusing women.
Well the show has been going down hill since Season 5 and when you look at the Loud family they do look dysfunctional
@@nixxgen9574
Yeah, but she acts like it’s the worst cartoon ever, and it’s infuriating.
@nixxgen9574
That is no excuse. SpongeBob and The Fairly OddParents have gone downhill, and yet she doesn’t seem to treat those shows the same way she treats The Loud House.
@@fernandodavidpaezcontreras6586 the reasons why she likes Spongebob and Fairly oddparents is because she grew up with them that's why she likes these shows but hates the Loud house, she has a more nostalgia connection to them where as the Loud house is a recently new show even though the show does suck.
She brought up 1997 because that’s when Toonami started: and ThunderCats was it’s first show
0:41
Okay as Rebeccah's thumbnail artist i have a few things to say about this.
A. Call it Lazy all you want, I was only given 5 - 10 minutes to work on this thumbnail after just getting home from grocery shopping.
B. Rebeccah doesn't pay me for photoshop jobs so I gotta make it look nice enough to get people to click (and it worked)
C. I'm given specific instructions on what she wants in a thumbnail so I gotta meet the criteria
Honestly I'd like to just draw thumbnails for Rebeccah but she obviously can't afford that, nor do I have the time. So working with Rebeccah feels more like volunteer gig in the grand scheme of everything I actually do
What's new, Scooby-Doo?
We're coming after you.
You're gonna solve that mystery.
I see you, Scooby-Doo;
The trail leads back to you.
What's new, Scooby-Doo?
What's new, Scooby-Doo?
We're gonna follow you.
You're gonna solve that mystery.
We see you, Scooby-Doo;
We're coming after you.
What's new, Scooby-Doo?
Don't look back!
You may find another clue.
The Scooby snacks* will be waiting here for you.
What's new, Scooby-Doo?
We're coming after you.
You're gonna solve that mystery.
I see you, Scooby-Doo;
The trail leads back to you.
What's new, Scooby-Doo?
Na, na, na, na, na
Na, na, na, na, na
Na, na, na, na, na, na, na
Na, na, na, na, na
Na, na, na, na, na
What's new, Scooby-Doo?
22:44 It doesn't take grocery shopping to plagiarize a review. That plagiarized review of The Simpsons episode "Miracle on Evergreen Terrace" is used on the thumbnail of the original video by the way.
@@andykishore
Not sure why you're telling me this because I had nothing to do with the production of the video outside of making the thumbnail, that's it, I wasn't the one writing the script
I know you're a lot better than this. I get it, crunch really sucks, but I can't help but kinda admire the thumbnail. It's a great representation of the quality of her own content. XD
@@WillieManga a year and a half after making that thumbnail, I agree it is pretty lazy, because on top of the crunch time (which under better circumstances wouldn't really be an issue) I wasn't provided any resources. Rebeccah only provided her avatar and told me to spelunking for resources, AS the video was premiering. And because I didn't know what was even featured on the list she told me to find that Simpsons screenshot and left it at that
I wasn't paid for that thumbnail in the end, and I don't even think I was credited either.
How strange that her taking the place of one of the Splash Entertainment's execs in John's Norm of the North 2 review is hilariously fitting. And apparently it wasn't John's idea either.
6:55 Putting it out there, but that quote is stolen from Mr. Enter in his Brickleberry segment on The Worst Cartoons of the 2010's.
24:49 This quote is stolen from Mr. Enter on the Butt Ugly Martians segment on his Top 20 Worst Cartoon Theme Song List.
It's hilarious how she continues to do stuff like this and get angry when being criticized for being a copycat, and then thinks she has the nerve to out other people for originality.
But remember people, recycling is good for the environment.
Don’t forget around 13:27 where she kinda takes enters joke from his review of the fairly odd parents episode “big fairy share scare”….which in this case doesn’t make sense
In the said “big fairy share scare” review, enter said that the theme song for that season sounded like a parody song the first few seasons would make about adding a new character to gain relevance
Here Rebecca says it sounds like a song she’d see in a parody of An actually good story, which……what the hell does that even mean?
@@Fazmaster Yeah, Rebeccah talks nonsense. Like how Rebeccah literally said that the South Park character, Randy Marsh actually caused COVID-19, racism riots and suicides in the real world.
And this is one of my reasons as to why I hate StarGiantProductions (or Rebecca). Not only is she a terrible person who doesn't learn from her mistakes (see MrEnter's "Regarding StarGiantProductions" and thadmaster 7's "star giant productions is worse than I thought..." videos, but she's not even salvagable as an animation critic.
It's sad that Star and Enter (You know, The Turning Red 9/11 and Anti-Mask Guy) are basically the same person who have proven their wrongdoings in various ways.(if you're wondering why My DA has been inactive, it's because my computer stopped working)
@@TheMovieAndCartoonFan Umm… do I know you from somewhere?
@@fernandodavidpaezcontreras6586 "Wolf-ShepherdDeviant" I recognize your PFP of Twitter
@@TheMovieAndCartoonFan Oh yeah! What’s up?
@@TheMovieAndCartoonFanexcept Mr. Enter knows when to take the L, deconstruct his wrongdoing, and actually evolved as a content creator. Star doing any of those three things is as possible as her winning the lottery.
11:23 I would say its wrong to extrapolate to the entire US population, given the sample is not random, but that's the data analysist speaking in me.
Good video.
It sucks since I really liked the Powerpuff girls Chirstmas Special
3:38 you mean like taking a popular anime and just replacing the characters with your oc’s and self insert, and having one of your character designs be just a character from another anime just recolored and another character looking suspiciously like a character designed by one of your former artists you screwed over for a more crappy artist?
Seriously between this and the “minors should not be on social media” rant from her Moon Girl and Devil
Dinosaur review, a lot of the stuff Rebecca says seem to age like rotten cheese made form spoiled milk drying in the hot dessert sun for 8 hours in terms of how poorly most of the things she says age
Imagine slandering The Amazing World of Gumball. Kinda cringe, not gonna lie.
Bruh there is like no bad episodes of Amazing world of gumball….except the worse fuck that episode.
And the PPG
Also santa was in space in dc
I think I just remembered Lobo 🚨spoiler alert killed him
@@Kingbeat1
Definitely sounds like Lobo tbh.
Fun fact: Santa travels to the planet of Apokolips to deliver coal to Darkseid each year.
@@toganium4175 dope
4:00 -I think that point is a tad pedantic. I mean, Seth Macfarlane and his crew aren't just a bunch of teenagers making memes to amuse each other; they're making a show for an international audience of billions of people. Doesn't the audience's reaction matter more, since they're the consumers?
24:42 That is a special which is part of “Winner and the Golden Child”, an Italian/Korean series about a dog and a lion cub who are tasked with raising the son of the princess from a Sleeping Beauty show made by the same studio so that he can defeat the evil enchantress that tried to kill his parents, or something like that. I recommend watching The Media Hunter’s review of the show, it’s how I got most of my information regarding that show.
Also, that show is a sequel to a show known as Simba Jr. The World Cup, which in turn was a sequel to a Lion King ripoff known as Simba: King Lion. The latter, and Winner also rip off The Jungle Book by featuring a tiger antagonist that both The Media Hunter and Saberspark call “Shere Kahn”. He may have a different name, but I did not see a clip that says it.
One more thing, I used the word “show” two times too many in the last sentence of my main comment, I should’ve said “…got most of my information regarding that series.”
It's a sad day when both Enter and Star (Pretty much "Lily Orchard 3.0" [2 0 being Zaid Magenta])end up being shit people and yet Enter ends up being the better critic (mind you, Enter's Turning Red Review [the one where he metions 9/11] and his Anti-Mask ["Healthcare is not a human right" my ass] video still lingers in my mind badly)
I remember that smoking it has been forever since I saw it.
25:54 You have a point with the size of the text, but you're not one to talk about pixellated screenshots of text, considering you do exactly that in your videos.
does your voice sound like nicktendo?
Also, why is she complaining about crossdressing when she's literally trans?