My main take away from her QNA video is She likely - Doesn't know how to tell a good story - Doesn't know how to write flawed characters - Won't know how to establish character dynamics and write around those - Will write herself to be a Mary Sue Girl Boss - Doesn't know how to write character motives - Doesn't know how to design villains and establish THEIR motives - Is shamelessly ripping off Modoka Magica and is still directly and indirectly spoiling it more for me (I'M STILL UPSET ABOUT THAT BY THE WAY!) - Also keeps shamelessly copying ideas and character designs from Mr. Enter - Will write Mr. Enter into the story somehow JUST to be petty about her firing - Still doesn't know how to manage her workers if the editing is the main financial need for this show - Might just take her "Miscellaneous Funds" and spend them on materialistic items like going to conventions and stuff and not pay a musician - Has double standards for bringing up the Across the Spider-Verse production team when she's clearly no better of managing her video productions, let alone an "animated series" - Is very consistent with her words and might not write characters or stories consistently - Won't succeed in this show at all - Just needs to quit Like I sad before, this is just sad, if a crowd funding didn't work for Mr. Enter, it ain't gonna work for Rebeccah because this whole show screams unoriginality. Regardless of her excuses that originality is hard to pull off these days With that said, I have 0 hope for her, and I will just point and laugh when the project goes south
A few things I took away from the video and recent developments, to sum it up, she is gonna base the episodes on her experience, and pull a lot of stuff from Madoka Magica, a show she happens to really really love
@@Channeleven2345789 And it’s a show I genuinely wanted to watch, but as previously stated, I practically know what’s gonna happen because of Rebeccah spoiling it
The kicker about her whole tangent about originality and her show not being based on and original IP is that the cat she has is just a recolor of Kyubey from Madoka Magica. Granted I think they’re meant to be the same creature, but if you’re gonna say you’re “heavily inspired by Madoka” while also saying it’s not based on any IP, it’s gonna raise eyebrows.
"if you’re gonna say you’re “heavily inspired by Madoka” while also saying it’s not based on any IP, it’s gonna raise eyebrows." If anything, it could lead to a snowball effect, as other characters/aspects may be called into question, as in there could be plenty other characters that were 'inspired' by others. Also, I figured that cat's design was borrowed from somewhere, I just didn't know what show it came from, good eye.
I’m not too versed in Madoka to know exactly what was lifted directly from it (Saw a few episodes once years ago). I’m assuming more stuff was stolen from it but you’d need a hardcore fan to verify that. I will say her recent obsession with the show and the elements of it she’s throwing in should be put into question
Didn’t even realize it, but it makes sense. If possible can you provide clips from Madoka’s Homuras plot? I may make another video comparing the Q&A and Madoka. The fact Rebeccah has a cat resemble another character is another smoking gun
@@Channeleven2345789 Oof, that might be difficult and I don't want to do something illegal. Pretty sure its on Netflix. The big Homura thing is (if I remember correctly) episode 10. It's also less like she plagiarized the story and more like she looked at it, decided that she didn't like the tragic parts and decided to make it "wholesome" and that the ship actually "sails".
I’m debating rewriting and redesigning these characters and stories since it’s just “Madoka Magica but PG 13”. She doesn’t give anything for us to really know the characters past their purposes in the story, “She’s the leader” yes, then what? Is this character going to be important or just a road for exposition? Mami (the original character this bootleg is based off of) was more than a leader, she was an example of what becoming a magical girl in the world of Madoka Magica entails. It’s infuriating for Rebecca to go off about “originality” when these characters are about as original as a blade of grass.
The fact that Rebecca tried to claim that moving JPEG stills counts as animation is the stupidest thing I've heard. Animation requires the proportions of a human body or the convey effects to move. You can't get away with just having the stills move. Also the stills changing doesn't count as animation either, because they just swap between frames.
1. She should have explained the Premise and the Characters Personality in her Trailer. That Way she wouldn´t have had to make a second Video 2. Like I said before, I´m pretty sure now that the brown haired Character is based on Sally Dunn from Growiing Around. Not just because of the Hair, also because of her Attitude She seems to confuse Animations with Slide Shows. Honestly, I don´t think she is scamming anyone. I think she is just that incompetent
1. Indeed, perhaps produce a doc or uploading stills on deviantArt with descriptions of the characters to provide a rough idea. 2. I think a big giveaway for me was not just the hair, but the head-structure; it kinda reminds me of how Enter draws his characters. But the fact she is established to have a quirky personality like Sally, and Rebeccah's penchant to copy other stuff, it was worth a comparison. Not to mention, I'm learning now that Rebeccah may've copied a character design from Magical Madoka (Kyubey). In the video she claims slideshows constitute as animation as long as there's movement. Incompetence sounds about right.
About the spoilers part, I feel very off with spoiling the project that has little content because I don’t have any interest if the protag survives without briefly explaining the stakes, but I would be fine if this was like the first episode or main premise. Protag hides her identity. Side girl makes a sacrifice for her love. The villain breaks the team apart. Also, those descriptions should have belonged in the CHARATER section so that they wouldn’t seem one-dimensional. For the cyborg girl, I would say that she got into an accident and struggles with her new body, so she acts rebellious to mask her insecurities. The villainess would not be revealed to be the villain, but some of her character traits such as doing dirty work, being brash, and hard can make viewers speculate her true motives. Those sections just make the video feel so scattered and difficult to follow. I would at least categorize the questions into cast, worldbulidng, story, etc. Finally, I can’t even take spoilers seriously cuz it’s like: “This girl wishes that she and her crush would become immortal despite her wish’s terrible implications. The pictures: Girls posing and smiling for long periods of time In fact, the entire video is just PNGs posing like they are in Project X Zone or something, it at least that game has dialog, voice acting, a cohesive plot (though not the best), and animation.
At worst it sounds like a desperate attempt to gain interest, never reveal too much all at once. Unless it's just revealing the framework with which the motivations and what have you can be established. Agreed. With the way she describes most of the characters there, only to go into more detail in the spoilers can really throw people off. And those do sound like more interesting traits. That makes sense, especially for a project that's essentially in a vacuum. Yeah, honestly she should've spent more time commissioning other assets, or just avoiding instances where there needed to be variance. And yet somehow Witches carries a 25k price tag.
I am laughing my ass off at those terrible character designs lol! It's like if Chris Chan ran Dingo Pictures in a day care. I wouldn't make fun of them if this was a simple passion project or something. But keep in mind Rebeccah expects people to pay THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS for something that she has been doing for years with little to no improvement! That and her history of being a toxic narcissist with no empathy or remorse for other people, even going as far as turning a blind eye to a CHILD PREDATOR UNDER HER WATCH! KNOWINGLY! FOR 8 MONTHS!
I highly doubt this is a passion project no matter what she says about this being 10 years in the making, like... 😂 No! No it isn't! You watch this one anime spoil it, and decide "I'm gonna make a show like THAT just because I really really wanna!" She's passionate about said anime I'll give her that but ya know what a passion project actually looks like? Having a story in mind with enough heart behind it, years worth of concepts like characters and world building ideas being tossed around left and right and enough of both to really know what you're doing (Trust me, I've spent almost 6 years coming up with my own) But Rebeccah has proven time and time again that she isn't the brightest bulb and this whole campaign can just be boiled down to her just wanting free money if her "Miscellaneous" profits are anything to go by. There's no way she's hiring a musician talented enough to carry this project Watching this project all fall apart is going to be fun
@@kingemerald4622 I was yeah, most recently she used a bedroom background she didn't pay for and she probably wouldn't have had my friend not given her shit about it These days however I notice she's been changing thumbnails to videos I was either in or made thumbnails for, rendering my hard work meaningless, such as her main icon, her Spider-Verse podcast, and her Owl House Podcast (even though I didn't draw that one)
@@matti_a. She also ripped off phantom striders editor by having him work under terrible conditions with no payouts just pleasing Rebecca's sorry ass which is ashame because he's a nice bloke just done dirty but Rebecca's incompetence. she broke so many people she worked with
Holy shit thats way to much money for a project like this! Like Star when you ask people to give you bread your setting yourself to fail with prices like these!
@@entityontheinternet No Fucking shit! What was she expecting? Some dude thats Oprah rich to give that number of money to her! It also doesn't help that Star does have a really bad reputation as a person and a you tuber. Which she is in super denial mode! Do to her bad actions people don't want to give a bad selfish jerk money.
Ok first, off she wants to have 500 videos on her channel and that she has 250 videos and this is a problem she has deleted a couple of other videos such as the adressing my abuse the my little pony G4 spin off and many others im not saying you should have more reviews im saying make both 2 parts of videos on your channel not just reviews but also something in the second part like vlogs cooking ect don't dedicate your channel as a review channel like channel awesome is yeah i know they have fan fiction videos but there not as out as they are now. Rebbechah please have a second catagory or end up like watch mojo with there top 10 videos like your never ending reviews.
side note i didn't bring this up so here i go, i forgot to say about how the "leader" aspect is completely different in other stories like how in sml junior is the leader of his friend group joeseph and cody you can say its none canon but i think its canon. but yeah overall its mostly women and not alot of guys but i know the story of the nature is girls but i don't know if rebbecah is into woke but im gonna say she is.
@@otakusanimeoffical1266 Not sure how to tell you but Rebecca is a Man (who choose not to transition because family issues) And i will not using female pronouns for a Dude who claimed to be trans women while *Put Zero Effort* into transition 🤷🏼♂️
I just choose not to bother with mainstream drama. I have little to add to it. In spite of how small she is, Rebeccah is a RUclips villain in and of herself, or just so incompetent that it's worth talking about. Why, where're you coming from?
He has made Fun of SSSniperwolf, so no. And being a small RUclipsr doesn´t make someone above Criticsm. Especially if that someone knowingly had Predators on her Server
rebeccah literally has 25 times the amount of subs channeleven has. this is still punching up, even if the bar isn't very high. also, like entity mentioned, smaller creators are not above criticism, and this is criticism of a project by a smaller creator that relies on people donating their own money to it of their own accord.
![[ARCHIVE] Witches: The Star Giant Productions Q&A](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cFJvi38K0qU/mqdefault.jpg)
7:23 "Everyone thinks she's a nice person, but over time she manipulates them more and more." Wow, Rebeccah. That sure sounds fucking familiar.
LoL
My main take away from her QNA video is
She likely
- Doesn't know how to tell a good story
- Doesn't know how to write flawed characters
- Won't know how to establish character dynamics and write around those
- Will write herself to be a Mary Sue Girl Boss
- Doesn't know how to write character motives
- Doesn't know how to design villains and establish THEIR motives
- Is shamelessly ripping off Modoka Magica and is still directly and indirectly spoiling it more for me
(I'M STILL UPSET ABOUT THAT BY THE WAY!)
- Also keeps shamelessly copying ideas and character designs from Mr. Enter
- Will write Mr. Enter into the story somehow JUST to be petty about her firing
- Still doesn't know how to manage her workers if the editing is the main financial need for this show
- Might just take her "Miscellaneous Funds" and spend them on materialistic items like going to conventions and stuff and not pay a musician
- Has double standards for bringing up the Across the Spider-Verse production team when she's clearly no better of managing her video productions, let alone an "animated series"
- Is very consistent with her words and might not write characters or stories consistently
- Won't succeed in this show at all
- Just needs to quit
Like I sad before, this is just sad, if a crowd funding didn't work for Mr. Enter, it ain't gonna work for Rebeccah because this whole show screams unoriginality. Regardless of her excuses that originality is hard to pull off these days
With that said, I have 0 hope for her, and I will just point and laugh when the project goes south
A few things I took away from the video and recent developments, to sum it up, she is gonna base the episodes on her experience, and pull a lot of stuff from Madoka Magica, a show she happens to really really love
@@Channeleven2345789 And it’s a show I genuinely wanted to watch, but as previously stated, I practically know what’s gonna happen because of Rebeccah spoiling it
you forgot one thing: She will never improve in any way. As a content creator or as a person. She will always fail.
@@dg4545
Word, and I've seen some of this behavior first hand
if you want to watch shows like modoka try , sailor moon, pretty cure , and villainess lvl 99, my next life as a villainess , shy
The kicker about her whole tangent about originality and her show not being based on and original IP is that the cat she has is just a recolor of Kyubey from Madoka Magica. Granted I think they’re meant to be the same creature, but if you’re gonna say you’re “heavily inspired by Madoka” while also saying it’s not based on any IP, it’s gonna raise eyebrows.
"if you’re gonna say you’re “heavily inspired by Madoka” while also saying it’s not based on any IP, it’s gonna raise eyebrows."
If anything, it could lead to a snowball effect, as other characters/aspects may be called into question, as in there could be plenty other characters that were 'inspired' by others.
Also, I figured that cat's design was borrowed from somewhere, I just didn't know what show it came from, good eye.
I’m not too versed in Madoka to know exactly what was lifted directly from it (Saw a few episodes once years ago). I’m assuming more stuff was stolen from it but you’d need a hardcore fan to verify that.
I will say her recent obsession with the show and the elements of it she’s throwing in should be put into question
So her story is just the bargain bin version of Madoka Magica.
It would seem so.
*was
her channel is gone. Good riddance
Oh my fucking god, the spoiler section about Ana and Ophelia sounds like a shitty OC-Version of Homuras plotline in Madoka Magica. Holy hell.
Didn’t even realize it, but it makes sense. If possible can you provide clips from Madoka’s Homuras plot? I may make another video comparing the Q&A and Madoka.
The fact Rebeccah has a cat resemble another character is another smoking gun
@@Channeleven2345789 Oof, that might be difficult and I don't want to do something illegal. Pretty sure its on Netflix. The big Homura thing is (if I remember correctly) episode 10. It's also less like she plagiarized the story and more like she looked at it, decided that she didn't like the tragic parts and decided to make it "wholesome" and that the ship actually "sails".
@@alittlelostinthemoment6677 very well. But thanks for the info
but at lest homura was written by proper writers
I’m debating rewriting and redesigning these characters and stories since it’s just “Madoka Magica but PG 13”. She doesn’t give anything for us to really know the characters past their purposes in the story, “She’s the leader” yes, then what? Is this character going to be important or just a road for exposition? Mami (the original character this bootleg is based off of) was more than a leader, she was an example of what becoming a magical girl in the world of Madoka Magica entails. It’s infuriating for Rebecca to go off about “originality” when these characters are about as original as a blade of grass.
I'd say go for it, Rebeccah is long gone now, and it's a good way to practice if you wanna break into writing stories.
@@Channeleven2345789
Got ur reply as I was writing the video script for it lol
@@FacelessCrowd Ha, coindicence. I do wanna see the video, sounds like it'll be great. Good luck
The fact that Rebecca tried to claim that moving JPEG stills counts as animation is the stupidest thing I've heard. Animation requires the proportions of a human body or the convey effects to move. You can't get away with just having the stills move. Also the stills changing doesn't count as animation either, because they just swap between frames.
JPEG images moving is cinema!
I did suggest to her that the villains should carry silver weapons and use them against the witches.
Update that will suprise literally no one: She didn´t hit her Goal
Yep, I’m not surprised. Gonna wait to see if she makes a video or post about it, whether she did it voluntarily or because she failed
and Mr Enter and others is trying to get Rebecca into prison.
@@thecinematicmind I know
And I think she actually spent that money on some guy who claimed to be making a monsters vs aliens sequel
@@Zebra_fandomfella03 Either that or she did it to get reimbursed.
1. She should have explained the Premise and the Characters Personality in her Trailer. That Way she wouldn´t have had to make a second Video
2. Like I said before, I´m pretty sure now that the brown haired Character is based on Sally Dunn from Growiing Around. Not just because of the Hair, also because of her Attitude
She seems to confuse Animations with Slide Shows.
Honestly, I don´t think she is scamming anyone. I think she is just that incompetent
1. Indeed, perhaps produce a doc or uploading stills on deviantArt with descriptions of the characters to provide a rough idea.
2. I think a big giveaway for me was not just the hair, but the head-structure; it kinda reminds me of how Enter draws his characters. But the fact she is established to have a quirky personality like Sally, and Rebeccah's penchant to copy other stuff, it was worth a comparison.
Not to mention, I'm learning now that Rebeccah may've copied a character design from Magical Madoka (Kyubey).
In the video she claims slideshows constitute as animation as long as there's movement.
Incompetence sounds about right.
About the spoilers part, I feel very off with spoiling the project that has little content because I don’t have any interest if the protag survives without briefly explaining the stakes, but I would be fine if this was like the first episode or main premise. Protag hides her identity. Side girl makes a sacrifice for her love. The villain breaks the team apart.
Also, those descriptions should have belonged in the CHARATER section so that they wouldn’t seem one-dimensional. For the cyborg girl, I would say that she got into an accident and struggles with her new body, so she acts rebellious to mask her insecurities. The villainess would not be revealed to be the villain, but some of her character traits such as doing dirty work, being brash, and hard can make viewers speculate her true motives.
Those sections just make the video feel so scattered and difficult to follow. I would at least categorize the questions into cast, worldbulidng, story, etc.
Finally, I can’t even take spoilers seriously cuz it’s like:
“This girl wishes that she and her crush would become immortal despite her wish’s terrible implications.
The pictures: Girls posing and smiling for long periods of time
In fact, the entire video is just PNGs posing like they are in Project X Zone or something, it at least that game has dialog, voice acting, a cohesive plot (though not the best), and animation.
At worst it sounds like a desperate attempt to gain interest, never reveal too much all at once. Unless it's just revealing the framework with which the motivations and what have you can be established.
Agreed. With the way she describes most of the characters there, only to go into more detail in the spoilers can really throw people off. And those do sound like more interesting traits.
That makes sense, especially for a project that's essentially in a vacuum.
Yeah, honestly she should've spent more time commissioning other assets, or just avoiding instances where there needed to be variance.
And yet somehow Witches carries a 25k price tag.
I am laughing my ass off at those terrible character designs lol! It's like if Chris Chan ran Dingo Pictures in a day care. I wouldn't make fun of them if this was a simple passion project or something. But keep in mind Rebeccah expects people to pay THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS for something that she has been doing for years with little to no improvement! That and her history of being a toxic narcissist with no empathy or remorse for other people, even going as far as turning a blind eye to a CHILD PREDATOR UNDER HER WATCH! KNOWINGLY! FOR 8 MONTHS!
I highly doubt this is a passion project no matter what she says about this being 10 years in the making, like... 😂 No! No it isn't! You watch this one anime spoil it, and decide "I'm gonna make a show like THAT just because I really really wanna!"
She's passionate about said anime I'll give her that but ya know what a passion project actually looks like?
Having a story in mind with enough heart behind it, years worth of concepts like characters and world building ideas being tossed around left and right and enough of both to really know what you're doing
(Trust me, I've spent almost 6 years coming up with my own)
But Rebeccah has proven time and time again that she isn't the brightest bulb and this whole campaign can just be boiled down to her just wanting free money if her "Miscellaneous" profits are anything to go by.
There's no way she's hiring a musician talented enough to carry this project
Watching this project all fall apart is going to be fun
@@matti_a.Are you one of many that she commissioned to do work for her with no pay? I bet she was hard work
@@kingemerald4622
I was yeah, most recently she used a bedroom background she didn't pay for and she probably wouldn't have had my friend not given her shit about it
These days however I notice she's been changing thumbnails to videos I was either in or made thumbnails for, rendering my hard work meaningless, such as her main icon, her Spider-Verse podcast, and her Owl House Podcast (even though I didn't draw that one)
@@matti_a. She also ripped off phantom striders editor by having him work under terrible conditions with no payouts just pleasing Rebecca's sorry ass which is ashame because he's a nice bloke just done dirty but Rebecca's incompetence. she broke so many people she worked with
@@matti_a. so much for gratitude i see.
Also calling the Kyuubey rip off "Incubator". Why not just directly ask Magica Quartet to sue her?
that what homura calls kyuubey she calls it incubator
@@hayleymcgough8567"Kyubey" is actually just a shortened version of "Incubator", which is the name of its species
How he thought this was gonna go anywhere is beyond me!
She probably won't pay anyone though
This was a petty thing Rebeccah had done. Thankfully, she's pretty much exiled from the internet.
A godd example of a dramedy is Doom Patrol
I mean Pop Quiz Hotshots at the very least had episodes made from it, but it still felt like a ripoff. Same as Angry Video Game Nerd: The Movie.
The whole plot is stolen from madoka magica they even took kyubey
Holy shit thats way to much money for a project like this! Like Star when you ask people to give you bread your setting yourself to fail with prices like these!
So far she has only four Donors and all of them have paid the lowest Tier
@@entityontheinternet No Fucking shit! What was she expecting? Some dude thats Oprah rich to give that number of money to her! It also doesn't help that Star does have a really bad reputation as a person and a you tuber. Which she is in super denial mode! Do to her bad actions people don't want to give a bad selfish jerk money.
@@entityontheinternet NO FUCKING SHIT! WHAT SHE WAS EXPECTING!
Where can I read Rebeccah's Witches script just to see how bad it is?
Unfortunately it may be gone, as far as I know
That series would probably look like the animation on Enter's Lights Out video LMAO
It's unbearable how you can't even understand her, not even a word she just mumbles the whole way through, and you don't know what she's saying
Her voice doesn't help. It sounds like she plugged her nose so far up in her brain, making her sound like this 💀
How do you turn into a fucking witch? Like…what
Like Danny Phantom silly!
I'm Going Witch! -- Cue transformation theme song.
Ok first, off she wants to have 500 videos on her channel and that she has 250 videos and this is a problem she has deleted a couple of other videos such as the adressing my abuse the my little pony G4 spin off and many others im not saying you should have more reviews im saying make both 2 parts of videos on your channel not just reviews but also something in the second part like vlogs cooking ect don't dedicate your channel as a review channel like channel awesome is yeah i know they have fan fiction videos but there not as out as they are now. Rebbechah please have a second catagory or end up like watch mojo with there top 10 videos like your never ending reviews.
side note i didn't bring this up so here i go, i forgot to say about how the "leader" aspect is completely different in other stories like how in sml junior is the leader of his friend group joeseph and cody you can say its none canon but i think its canon. but yeah overall its mostly women and not alot of guys but i know the story of the nature is girls but i don't know if rebbecah is into woke but im gonna say she is.
Anddddddddddddddd he's running off wit the money and then get scammed, Surprised.
It's between that, or trying to get reimbursed.
*she's
@@otakusanimeoffical1266 Not sure how to tell you but Rebecca is a Man (who choose not to transition because family issues) And i will not using female pronouns for a Dude who claimed to be trans women while *Put Zero Effort* into transition
🤷🏼♂️
@@otakusanimeoffical1266 The original comment was correct. He's a pedo apologist. His feelings don't matter.
You are one of that People who only attacks small Channels because he is to scared about the Big Name RUclips Villains?
I just choose not to bother with mainstream drama. I have little to add to it. In spite of how small she is, Rebeccah is a RUclips villain in and of herself, or just so incompetent that it's worth talking about.
Why, where're you coming from?
He has made Fun of SSSniperwolf, so no. And being a small RUclipsr doesn´t make someone above Criticsm. Especially if that someone knowingly had Predators on her Server
rebeccah literally has 25 times the amount of subs channeleven has. this is still punching up, even if the bar isn't very high. also, like entity mentioned, smaller creators are not above criticism, and this is criticism of a project by a smaller creator that relies on people donating their own money to it of their own accord.
This "Small Creators Bullying" argument again? When will people come up with something new really?
Promo_SM