@Toonfight Fan no israel accept the borders that the UN said but the palestinians didnt so they got into a war and they lost its their problem now the land is israeli land
Well, yes. God has, over and over, chastised the Jewish people very harshly. Had you read your bible, you would know that He sends a prophet or prophets to warn Israel before He acts against them. God get pissed, absolutely furious, with Israel many times. At most times, it is because of worshipping the foreign gods of the people He instructed the Jews to slaughter in the first place. God said flat out he was sending the Assyrians the slaughter Israel, then the Babylonians, and then the Greeks and Romans. He said the survivors would return to Him out of desperation. That is what happened in the Holocaust. The Jews returned to Israel, where it was prophesied he would return them.
Dear Mr naftalli , this is great video strong stand from your side and very good consistency this is whatthe jewish and israeli people need. Thank you!! we also need you to rais the historical facts about the ties between between haj amin al hussaini the plo,fatah and the nazis please Mr Bennet why no one is talking about this issue ?
Thank you, Naftali. It's about time Israel had a proud, articulate emissary who unapologetically told the world that Israel will do what it must, and to hell with them if they don't like it. I just encourage you to not forget that Husain was correct--the Arabs living in the Land of Israel had no desire to see a Jewish State established alongside their own, and took measures over the next 20 years to wipe it out any way they could. They only began talking about "statehood" following 1967.
"Palestine" is the name the Romans imposed upon Judea to erase the Jewish connection to the land. The Roman Empire disappeared yet Israel remains. The word "Palestinian" came in vogue in the 1960s so Arabs could pretend they were something more than Arabs. But the "p" sound doesn't exist in Arabic so they call themselves "Filastiniyyun," not realizing that Palestine entered Latin from Greek which in turn came from the Hebrew "Plishtim" meaning invaders.
OnceUponAtimeInLeb UN is a corrupt office which rules by payola from Islamic countries. It invented Muslim Palestinians by deeming all who flocked to Palestine and stayed 2 years as Palestinians. There were no Muslim Palestinians for 2,000 years before Arafat stole this name from Jews.
I am a Muslim, and based on the rules and laws of my religion, I stand up strongly for Israel's right to defend itself against indiscriminate targeting of it's civilians by missiles launched from the Gaza Strip. I pray other Muslims join me in discouraging others from ignoring this great injustice and tragedy of civilians being indiscriminately targeted. There is only a right side and a wrong side like the Israeli said in the video. Israel is doing the right thing by only targeting missile sites
You're putting the cart before the horse. In the first place, Hamas starting rocketing Israel BEFORE the blockade started. Khaled Meshaal was questioned FOUR TIMES OVER by Christiana Amanpour about whether he would ever recognize Israel. Instead of just answering "no" , he dodged the question every time and just said "we would accept return" of pre-1967 territories but wouldn't answer when she pressed him about destroying Israel altogether.
Ohhhhhh how GRACIOUS of the Palestinians to recognize Israel in the 1967 borders! I'm so touched by their generosity I'm getting al tear-eyed over here. A technical detail, however, trumping this courageous concession for peace is that the 1967 borders DO NOT EXIST, it's just the armistice lines from 1949 that some foreigner scrawled carelessly, arbitrarily on the map with a green pen (hence the term "Green Line") and legally speaking they are a concept void of any meaning. The final borders will be determined in direct negotiations with no preconditions, and if you don't like it you can follow the advice of the late Yasser Arafat and drink up the sea.
The difference between you and Israelis is that we stay in Israel, because it is our homeland, we will stand up to Hamas. Also, how in the world is Naftali Bennett obnoxious? He waited for Ed Husain to finish before speaking, even stopped because Ed interrupted so many times and had a very simple message: Israel DOESN'T WANT WAR EVER. We will only fight (if attacked or) if there are people trying to kill our civilians-- We will never instigate war. IDF: Israel DEFENSE forces (not offense)
Yes, Bennett's parents are American and most people in Israel's parents or grandparents may have come from Europe, but we were only in Europe temporarily. We have always had a Jewish presence here and ever since we were exiled, have always thought about and tried to return back to our homeland
Actually, waiting 2000 years and still returning shows how much more connected we are to the land-- it shows that even 2000 years of suffering and exile isn't enough to stop us from wanting to return. Yes, we are cultural, so what? I don't know if you know this, but Einstein strongly considered to be the first president of Israel. As for the Palestinians, you should do better research-that term was made up 150 or so years ago. Also, we aren't like the Nazis-we don't persecute other religions!
Mr. Husain with his slick accent and habit of interrupting with his own grandstanding speech, completely ignores the fact of who started this recent conflict. Hamas did! By kidnapping and brutally killing 3 Israeli teenagers, then when Israel was rounding up suspects, by bombarding Israel with hundreds of rockets (!!). Just glosses over it, like Israel itself was the instigator or as if he didn't recognize, like Hamas, Israel's right to exist. He also overlooks the tons of humanitarian aid Israel has given to the Palestinians, living both in Israel and outside of it. In 2009 and 2010, for instance, amazing amounts of aid in the form of cattle, powdered milk, grain--the list goes on endlessly. And the life-saving operations Israeli doctors have performed on Palestinian people, and the humane visits by Israeli doctors to Palestinian villages to render free medical care...So what does he refer to by dialogue? Hamas doesn't negotiate; and even when they reach an agreement, they can't be trusted. So how can you negotiate with terrorists whose charter says "Destroy Israel"? How can you negotiate with Hamas who doesn't recognize the existence of the Jewish state? With Hamas, it's all or nothing; their way, or a war. So Mr. Husain, you need to talk to Hamas, not Israel. Stop berating Israel and get off their backs.
Ed Hussein is absolutely right. Israel has to rethink their entire strategy, going to war every few years and then expecting the terrorist murderers we're fighting to uphold a ceasefire is, in fact, ridiculous. He's right. we need to stop it once and for all. Let's hope this is the beginning of the end of terrorism, of Hamas, of stupidity. To the IDF I say, FINISH THE JOB! Good job, Naftali Bennett.
Naftali Bennett is a great man and saying true thinks and don't forget that from 1948 each war between Israel and the Arabs was started after an Arab aggression.
to say somehting liek that..being a Muslim man you have my full respect. I wish the world was full of more people like you :) it would be much better place to live in~
The neighborhood bully just lives to survive He’s criticized and condemned for being alive He’s not supposed to fight back, he’s supposed to have thick skin He’s supposed to lay down and die when his door is kicked in He’s the neighborhood bully
thank you for the honest reply, my muslim cousin! the middle east needs more people with balls to say the truth, so we could finish this endless conflict and start to live a real and calm life. Greetings from Israel buddy
יפה אז יש לך ראש אני רואה ! נכון 2 הדרכים יכולות להוביל למלחמה כל הזמן אבל ברגע שנשלב את 2 הדרכים , גם נראה להם שאנחנו לא מבליגים כמו עכשיו נראה להם שלא מוותרים ונכנסים בהם ולאחר מכן נגיע להסכם מסודר נוכל לפתור את הבעיה . אני מעריך את בנט כי נראה לי שהוא מבין שצריך לפתור את זה לפי מה שהבנתי מהדברים שלו
You completely missed the pt. I was showing exactly what the Hamas charter itself says concerning Israel. I had to split it up into 3 posts due to space constraints. I support Israel and condemn all terrorism, whether from Hamas or others. By the way can you express yourself without profanity? The other 2 parts are below. Some comments excuse Hamas' actions. I thought I would let Hamas speak for itself and let people decide for themselves.
I'm an Israeli and I definitely DON'T approve of Naftali's message. His opinions are of the radical right wing and it's too bad that he was the voice representing Israel in this international communication platform. His entire speech was empty and based on fear, while Ed Husain spoke with maturity and intelligence. The situation is complicated and there have been many victims on both sides, but MANY of us believe in 2 states and oppose our government's current actions.
People in the United States and Canada often make light of the fact that everything said with an English accent sounds educated and intelligent. Ed Husain disproves this idea, demonstrating that those with the most English of accents can still be terribly ignorant and lack any reason or logic.
עזבי ענייני הכבוד אנו עוסקים בביקורת בונה. זאת עובדה שהשאלות והטענות חוזרים על עצמם אבל אנחנו אף פעם לא מוכנים עם התשובות היותר מחודדות. צריך להקים צוות שיימפה את הראיונות מהסוג הזה וידגיש לאילה טענות לצפות במהלך הראיון ובאילו מסרים ובאיזו ביטויים להשתמש. צריך מנגנון בקרה הסברתי שהדוברים למיניהם ישתמשו בו באופן רציף לשיפור תמידי לפני ואחרי כל ראיון. ברור שהדבר לא נעשה בוודאי לא בגזרת מחנה הימין. וזו בעיה שחוזרת על עצמה כמעט עם כל המרואיינים בכל הרשתות בפנים ישראל בעברית וק"ו בזירה הבינלאומית.
"There is a right side and a wrong side" - how childish and arrogant. I'm an Israeli and this kind of attitude makes me feel really embarrassed. Both sides are being led by a group of stupid ,arrogant war mongering politicians. That's the main problem.
and that is absolutely what the palestinians did, "israel stop occupying" "israel stop detaining" "israel stop killing" then fire home made rockets back at occupied land.
0:46 "The carnage on both sides doesn't necessarily help anybody", but that DID NOT answer the question: "Is there a 'right' side and a 'wrong' side?" You cannot say "it's not as black and white as that"; because if there are 2 sides, one has to be 'right' and one has to be 'wrong', unless they're both being manipulated and neither of them knows what they're doing. So it NEEDS to BE "as black and white as that", otherwise they're BOTH 'wrong'! And if they're BOTH 'wrong', well as Einstein states about Stupidity, "Even Genius has its limits." So the situation would be HOPELESS! 1:06 Well I agree with that. There shouldn't be "the Jewish state". Nothin' ta do with Judaism that one! There should just be The Land of God/The Nation of Peace. Yĕrūshalayim is "possession of peace" (traditional interpretation). How can we start having "the Jewish state" and "the Arab state" and all this nonsense?! 1:21 WHO turned it into a launchpad?? Which EXTERNAL power? 1:27 Wo wo wo! "We owe it to the Western world"?? Judaism is responsible for MOSHIACH and WORLD PEACE! NOT for Western World Peace! He's gettin' seriously off topic here! And the holocaust happened IN 'the Western world'. So I wouldn't be 'owing' anything to 'the Western world' specifically. The plan is that Judaism owes WORLD PEACE to THE WHOLE WORLD. 2:10 So? Why's a Brit worried about 'anti-Americanism'? Why's he been told off for "fueling anti-Americanism" with a bossy Englishy voice?? And why does Israel care about 'anti-Americanism'? Isn't Israel a U. S. state? And why is a British Muslim worried about 'anti-Americanism'? Is this supposed to be a comedy? 2:18 Well it's 'ethnic cleansing' I guess. For the Americans? 2:43 I don't understand what that means "hold the West hostage". Israel does the advanced intel for "the West". 3:10 Well the U. S. invaded and occupied an entire nation for 20 years, apparently over ONE person, (although it started with the building of an oil pipeline). 4:16 We're not all interested in "the long term safety of the state of Israel". We're interested in the long term safety of Judaism and it's ENTIRE population, which is still too tiny. So we need a single integrated nation. Not this "Jewish state"/"Arab state" claptrap. 4:25 Well "the battle of hearts and minds" starts at Al Aqsa. With the information that Muslims and Judahians are being 'played' against each other by greater EXTERNAL forces. And the STRESSING of THE FOUR FUNDAMENTAL FACTORS OF 'MARTYRDOM', so that the Muslim youth understand EXACTLY WHAT constitutes TRUE 'martyrdom' and what DOES NOT. Because the Muslim youth get brainwashed at the 'martyrdom' level. Constant 'retaliation' ad infinitum is merely 'ethnic cleansing'. A 'real' war would see Israel 'invade', rescue all the abandoned Muslims, because they really are being 'sacrificed', and secure ALL borders for the whole nation and build the new integrated nation. WITHOUT interference from the manipulative EXTERNAL forces. 4:31 Well Gerry Adams was instrumental in the Northern Ireland peace process actually. 4:37 Yes. "Reaching out via third parties" is a good idea. So will the British army help with the invasion? 4:41 I say leave the two-state solution on the death bed; where it belongs. It's NOT the TRUE solution! Yĕrūshalayim; "possession of peace" is the EPICENTER for WORLD PEACE. With BOTH Al Aqsa and The Third Temple on the Temple Mount! So there will NEVER be peace if there are 'two states'. Two states is a concretization of apartheid and the inability to integrate. A wealthy nuclear power next door to a little impoverished non-militarized state. If Palestine wouldn't be trusted to be 'militarized', then why pretend that two-states would work? It's a TRICK! 5:22 Well then come up with the strategy Ed! Everyone's expecting Naftali to come up with it on his own! All the time! What is he MOSHIACH? 5:42 There is NO WAY for us to be sittin' around waiting for people to "get some sense"!! ANYWHERE! A 'STRATEGY' is a STRATEGY! You can SEE it or you can't! But a 'strategy' is a CLEAR plan leading to an END! NOT an excuse for 80 years of 'ethnic cleansing'! And NOBODY needs to 'worry' about the long term safety of Yisrael. If Yisrael DOESN'T fulfill its purpose to bring MOSHIACH and WORLD PEACE, HaShem will destroy Yisrael HIMSELF, and there won't be a damn thing anyone can do about it! We need to forget about politics here, and stick to the spiritual PLAN that was put in place for Man! If 'invasion' is what is needed, then 'invasion' is what is needed. But there has to be an END, and there HAS TO BE, WORLD PEACE! According to REVELATION; THE CUBE OF PEACE; Holy Yĕrūshalayim; "possession of peace", is 2,500 kilometers cubed. REVELATION 21:15 And he that talked with me had a golden reed to measure the city, and the gates thereof, and the wall thereof. 16 And the city lieth foursquare, and the length is as large as the breadth: and he measured the city with the reed, twelve thousand furlongs. The length and the breadth and the height of it are equal. - That stretches from Mecca to the Black Sea and from Lybia to Iran. And that's PEACE IN THE MIDDLE EAST. Yar all too flimsy. I would simply install THE CUBE OF PEACE, and anyone who fires a SINGLE bullet inside THE CUBE OF PEACE; JAIL! Judaism is responsible for The Third Temple on the Temple Mount. Judaism and Islam are responsible for THE PEACE HAVEN on the Temple Mount with the Mosque and the Dome and the Third Temple and the Interfaith Center and and all the beautiful green spots and so on. Christianity is responsible for THE CUBE OF PEACE. OR, you send a few kids to Mars to build a TEMPORARY obelisk. Because that's all that you've got left as options. PEACE or a few surviving the nuke holocaust in mars.
Naftali repeated himself to much, he could have just asked Ed Husain "do you believe that if Israel will draw its forces - their will be no shooting from the Gaza strip tomorrow, or any othey day in the next days after tomorrow?..." - Ed would have serious problem to answer, because he doesn't like the fact that there is simply no problem with the Israeli attitude, since we want peace more than anything. on the other hand, Hamas - given the chance - would have wiped Israel today, not tomorrow.
I will , as long as you also acknowledge the Arab occupation of Algeria (natives are Berbers who were driven into the mountains) and Kurdistan + 900 000 Jewish refugees driven out from Arab countries after 1947.
Ed Husain wrote a book named: "The Islamist: Why I Joined Radical Islam in Britain, What I Saw Inside and Why I Left". That's another arabic that looks like he is closer to the west but in fact he is supporting Hamas, The Islamic Jihad, Taliban, and El Kaida! EL KAIDA!
2 main groups of Jews from the Diaspora, Ashkenazic and Sephardic. 750 000 Jews were expelled from Arab countries after '48 including my grandparents from Egypt. Keep reading homeboy
Israel can't be an "occupation", because in order to become that, Israel's land should have belonged to someone else, which is clearly not the case. There have never been a "Palestinian" state for Israel to occupy. The only thing that was, is the UN partition plan, which was rejected by the Pal's. And hamas isn't "resistance", it's a fundamentalist terror organization.
is no excuse for terrorists to fire missiles from the middle of their own civilians to another country's civilians. The world is watching and has passed judgement.By the way,I support a Palestinian state,alongside a Jewish state,existing within secure and recognised borders. Time for the Palestinians to understand that this is how they get their state. Israel is not going away any time soon,and is not handing over the keys to Tel Aviv to the murderers.
,I live in Israel and I really can't understand how come that the palestinians don't want peace! they want war and the Israelians are blamed in everything! please please please try to understand that we(Israel) don't want to fight! I don't want my cousine or my friend's brother to die in a stupid war, but we have to fight in order to defend our selfs! we just want peace. we just want quiet. we just want to live!!
what BS, whether you like him or not, most certainly was not 'owned' there. Look at the body language and you see Husain's eyes flickering nervously halfway through.
I did not write that. It is from the Hamas charter translated into English so that people can see for themselves what Hamas believes concerning Israel who I support. Yes, those who wrote it are deranged. That was the pt.
This is symbolic "discussion". This Arab's behavior is revolting, not letting the opponent say a word, and the Jew politely waiting when the other side's verbal diarrhea stops. What kind of dialog is possible at all with a man who fires 100 w/min of sheer propaganda bullshit?
לא נראה לי שהם הבינו על מה הם מדברים, אחד מדבר על הרשות הפלסטינית, השני מדבר על חמאס, שני גופים נפרדים בעלי אידיאולוגיה שונה, נראה שהיה פה קטעי מונולוגים של שניהם כל אחד משלים את המונולוג שלו ברגע שהראשון מסיים...
הלוואי שהייתי מאמין בלב שלם לבנט , אם זה כל כך נכון ואנחנו רוצים שקט ושלום והם לא , למה אנחנו ממשיכים את הבנייה בשטחים למה אנחנו גוזלים קרקעות מהערבים למה לא פשוט לפתח ולהתמקד במה שיש , אי אפשר להעלים עין מזה שבגדה אנחנו כובשים וממשיכים בשיא הכוח בדיכוי ואז מה אנחנו מצפים שיאהבו אותנו ? חבל שזה כך
wars really never get us anywhere. but I think it's just the right of everyone to fight for their lives and the land given to them when times like this come. middle east people stop trying to eradicate The Israel Nation. you'll never stand a chance. you may fool the world but what YHWH has opened, no one can ever shut out. SHALOM ISRAEL. EL-ELOHE-ISRAEL is with you.
Israel goes to war ? What's this guy talking about he's a little confused defending yourself against daily rockets is not going to war, but this contributor believes only his warped version of events and hopes the viewer's will swallow the same. If he's really concerned about the welfare of the people of Gaza then might I suggest he preach this words of Peace to Hamas the only ones who can sort this out.
ed, it is not true that hamas is ready to accept the 1967 borders. they are not ready to accept the 1948 borders or any borders of a jewish state. the defensive wars of israel are not an unsuccessful habit, they are the opposite. some things are, in fact, black and white. if you want to help the "palestinian" arabs you might explain to them what the people of israel are doing in the land of israel well enough so that they will understand it and accept it and respect it.
i actually thought that it was a good debate. i agree with bennett but i thought it wasnt biased as the show host is jewish as well. if anything it was biased for palestinian side
Ed Husain, I thought your title is Senior Fellow, Council of Foreign Relations! If you listen to your questions and arguments, does that reflect your position? There is no way you can win argument over Naftali Bennet ...is that simple! He is too smart for you😀
This so called human being or look like at least is asking the lady What would you do if someone shot rockets at your house? If she is aware of the crisis will ask him the following: What would you do if someone occupied ur land? What would you do if some one killed ur SON DAUGHTER BROTHER FATHER MOTHER SISTER UNCLE ....? What would u do if some one eleminated ur whole family and bombed your house streets infrastructure power supplies....? What would u do if some one came suddenly to ur place where ur father and grand grand grand grand father born and lived in to tell u hey am coming from Africa USA Russia......... get out from my land?!!! But remember the nationality of the killers of JESUS.....Do u know?
Where were u before 1948? Lost in the desert searching for your country as a baby searching for her doll? Then a state for u was established by the still going processes of massacres and bombardment of villages and the daily killing of kids in their parents' laps ..If u can cover the sun in Africa ur homeland u can convince the world that ur so called state in Palestine is not a state of BLOOD
Failed Policies of the last 60 years? Israel is still there. I think their doing OK.
FAILED POLICIES !!! ?
THESE IDIOTS CAN OBVIOUSLY
GET THEIR MOUTHS TO SAY ANYTHING.
I guess last word means Naftali gets to start his sentence & Ed Husain gets to cut him off at every juncture.
To mister Ed Husain (if you'll read this)
let me ask you: who started the '48 war?
@Toonfight Fan no israel accept the borders that the UN said but the palestinians didnt so they got into a war and they lost its their problem now the land is israeli land
The concept is simple: Self Defence. You leave me alone, I leave you alone. You shoot rockets at me, you want me to just sit and take it?
Naftali, amazingly strong words at the end. Truth will always prevail.
God bless Bennet. God bless Israel. AMEN
LONG LIVE ISRAEL.......GOD HAS NEVER ABANDONED HIS PEOPLE.
IF MEXICO SENT ROCKETS TO SAN DIEGO.......WHAT WOULD THE PRESIDENT DO?
Well, yes. God has, over and over, chastised the Jewish people very harshly. Had you read your bible, you would know that He sends a prophet or prophets to warn Israel before He acts against them.
God get pissed, absolutely furious, with Israel many times. At most times, it is because of worshipping the foreign gods of the people He instructed the Jews to slaughter in the first place.
God said flat out he was sending the Assyrians the slaughter Israel, then the Babylonians, and then the Greeks and Romans. He said the survivors would return to Him out of desperation.
That is what happened in the Holocaust. The Jews returned to Israel, where it was prophesied he would return them.
@@TheMMSpirit d
@@TheMMSpirit s
Good Job Naftali !
Tom Ben-Hur fuck u and fuck israel
@@Stillillgal ruclips.net/video/c2NaiX-hvVQ/видео.html
Dear Mr naftalli , this is great video strong stand from your side and very good consistency this is whatthe jewish and israeli people need. Thank you!! we also need you to rais the historical facts about the ties between between haj amin al hussaini the plo,fatah and the nazis please Mr Bennet why no one is talking about this issue ?
Thank you, Naftali. It's about time Israel had a proud, articulate emissary who unapologetically told the world that Israel will do what it must, and to hell with them if they don't like it.
I just encourage you to not forget that Husain was correct--the Arabs living in the Land of Israel had no desire to see a Jewish State established alongside their own, and took measures over the next 20 years to wipe it out any way they could. They only began talking about "statehood" following 1967.
Israel never started a war. All the wars waged by it were defensive wars.
"Palestine" is the name the Romans imposed upon Judea to erase the Jewish connection to the land. The Roman Empire disappeared yet Israel remains. The word "Palestinian" came in vogue in the 1960s so Arabs could pretend they were something more than Arabs. But the "p" sound doesn't exist in Arabic so they call themselves "Filastiniyyun," not realizing that Palestine entered Latin from Greek which in turn came from the Hebrew "Plishtim" meaning invaders.
Naftali!!! The USA is behind you 100% please continue your hard work! We love you you & keep you in our prayers!!
Hmmm. Israel is being accused of illegally occupying Israel, even building apartments in Israel.Terrible crime because Islam will dominate :(
Israel is building in occupied land, United Nations says so, not arabs...
why don't you go back to Poland and elsewhere, the war is over.
OnceUponAtimeInLeb UN is a corrupt office which rules by payola from Islamic countries. It invented Muslim Palestinians by deeming all who flocked to Palestine and stayed 2 years as Palestinians. There were no Muslim Palestinians for 2,000 years before Arafat stole this name from Jews.
Joseph Shellim I get better result arguing with a wall than you.
Ha that islamist got owned.
לדבר עם הסי אן אן זה כמו לדבר לקיר ובכל זאת הצלחת, כל הכבוד לך!
I am a Muslim, and based on the rules and laws of my religion, I stand up strongly for Israel's right to defend itself against indiscriminate targeting of it's civilians by missiles launched from the Gaza Strip. I pray other Muslims join me in discouraging others from ignoring this great injustice and tragedy of civilians being indiscriminately targeted. There is only a right side and a wrong side like the Israeli said in the video. Israel is doing the right thing by only targeting missile sites
You're putting the cart before the horse. In the first place, Hamas starting rocketing Israel BEFORE the blockade started. Khaled Meshaal was questioned FOUR TIMES OVER by Christiana Amanpour about whether he would ever recognize Israel. Instead of just answering "no" , he dodged the question every time and just said "we would accept return" of pre-1967 territories but wouldn't answer when she pressed him about destroying Israel altogether.
I feel bad now that i voted for Yair Lapid instead of him in the last premier election.
Ohhhhhh how GRACIOUS of the Palestinians to recognize Israel in the 1967 borders! I'm so touched by their generosity I'm getting al tear-eyed over here. A technical detail, however, trumping this courageous concession for peace is that the 1967 borders DO NOT EXIST, it's just the armistice lines from 1949 that some foreigner scrawled carelessly, arbitrarily on the map with a green pen (hence the term "Green Line") and legally speaking they are a concept void of any meaning. The final borders will be determined in direct negotiations with no preconditions, and if you don't like it you can follow the advice of the late Yasser Arafat and drink up the sea.
The difference between you and Israelis is that we stay in Israel, because it is our homeland, we will stand up to Hamas. Also, how in the world is Naftali Bennett obnoxious? He waited for Ed Husain to finish before speaking, even stopped because Ed interrupted so many times and had a very simple message:
Israel DOESN'T WANT WAR EVER. We will only fight (if attacked or) if there are people trying to kill our civilians-- We will never instigate war.
IDF: Israel DEFENSE forces (not offense)
am Israel hi, am Israel hi , am Israel am Israel am Israel hi!!!!!!
Yes, Bennett's parents are American and most people in Israel's parents or grandparents may have come from Europe, but we were only in Europe temporarily. We have always had a Jewish presence here and ever since we were exiled, have always thought about and tried to return back to our homeland
don't compare Palestinian right to Singapore and don't offend Singapore it self.
Actually, waiting 2000 years and still returning shows how much more connected we are to the land-- it shows that even 2000 years of suffering and exile isn't enough to stop us from wanting to return. Yes, we are cultural, so what? I don't know if you know this, but Einstein strongly considered to be the first president of Israel. As for the Palestinians, you should do better research-that term was made up 150 or so years ago. Also, we aren't like the Nazis-we don't persecute other religions!
Mr. Husain with his slick accent and habit of interrupting with his own grandstanding speech, completely ignores the fact of who started this recent conflict. Hamas did! By kidnapping and brutally killing 3 Israeli teenagers, then when Israel was rounding up suspects, by bombarding Israel with hundreds of rockets (!!). Just glosses over it, like Israel itself was the instigator or as if he didn't recognize, like Hamas, Israel's right to exist. He also overlooks the tons of humanitarian aid Israel has given to the Palestinians, living both in Israel and outside of it. In 2009 and 2010, for instance, amazing amounts of aid in the form of cattle, powdered milk, grain--the list goes on endlessly. And the life-saving operations Israeli doctors have performed on Palestinian people, and the humane visits by Israeli doctors to Palestinian villages to render free medical care...So what does he refer to by dialogue? Hamas doesn't negotiate; and even when they reach an agreement, they can't be trusted. So how can you negotiate with terrorists whose charter says "Destroy Israel"? How can you negotiate with Hamas who doesn't recognize the existence of the Jewish state? With Hamas, it's all or nothing; their way, or a war. So Mr. Husain, you need to talk to Hamas, not Israel. Stop berating Israel and get off their backs.
Poor husain he almost cried he triggered,look at his sweats flowing on his face😂😂😂😂pathetic husain
Love from India. To Israel. Keep it up. These Islamist terrorists should not be spared on any account
Thanks man
Ed Hussein is absolutely right. Israel has to rethink their entire strategy, going to war every few years and then expecting the terrorist murderers we're fighting to uphold a ceasefire is, in fact, ridiculous. He's right. we need to stop it once and for all. Let's hope this is the beginning of the end of terrorism, of Hamas, of stupidity.
To the IDF I say, FINISH THE JOB!
Good job, Naftali Bennett.
well done Bennet, speak the truth.
Being louder doesn't make you right. Neither does being obnoxious.
Naftali Bennett is a great man and saying true thinks and don't forget that from 1948 each war between Israel and the Arabs was started after an Arab aggression.
Great speech from Mr. Bennett
YHWH bless Israel!!!
Blessings from England.
Dear CNN, the Israeli side also has heart rending pictures
Why don't you show the picture of the "right side"?
Im support co-existence, But Ed for peace negotiation you need to have someone to negotiate with. WE DONT HAVE THAT!
Do you have legitimate sources to back up these outlandish claims?
to say somehting liek that..being a Muslim man you have my full respect.
I wish the world was full of more people like you :) it would be much better place to live in~
The neighborhood bully just lives to survive
He’s criticized and condemned for being alive
He’s not supposed to fight back, he’s supposed to have thick skin
He’s supposed to lay down and die when his door is kicked in
He’s the neighborhood bully
thank you for the honest reply, my muslim cousin!
the middle east needs more people with balls to say the truth, so we could finish this endless conflict and start to live a real and calm life.
Greetings from Israel buddy
תותח!
יפה אז יש לך ראש אני רואה ! נכון 2 הדרכים יכולות להוביל למלחמה כל הזמן אבל ברגע שנשלב את 2 הדרכים , גם נראה להם שאנחנו לא מבליגים כמו עכשיו נראה להם שלא מוותרים ונכנסים בהם ולאחר מכן נגיע להסכם מסודר נוכל לפתור את הבעיה .
אני מעריך את בנט כי נראה לי שהוא מבין שצריך לפתור את זה לפי מה שהבנתי מהדברים שלו
You completely missed the pt. I was showing exactly what the Hamas charter itself says concerning Israel. I had to split it up into 3 posts due to space constraints. I support Israel and condemn all terrorism, whether from Hamas or others. By the way can you express yourself without profanity? The other 2 parts are below. Some comments excuse Hamas' actions. I thought I would let Hamas speak for itself and let people decide for themselves.
1:45 תראו את הפרצוף של הכתב הפלסטיני, הוא עומד להתפוצץ.....
Naftali! You are amazing! We can't negotiate with Hamas. If you want to understand this feeling try to negotiate with a wall... Good luck,
נפתלי, אתה צריך לעשות עוד עימותים כאלה בכלי התקשורת העולמיים, פשוט מעולה!
I'm an Israeli and I definitely DON'T approve of Naftali's message. His opinions are of the radical right wing and it's too bad that he was the voice representing Israel in this international communication platform. His entire speech was empty and based on fear, while Ed Husain spoke with maturity and intelligence. The situation is complicated and there have been many victims on both sides, but MANY of us believe in 2 states and oppose our government's current actions.
just so you know..
its not an australian accent mate its british/English
Naftali you are right!
Israel forever
People in the United States and Canada often make light of the fact that everything said with an English accent sounds educated and intelligent. Ed Husain disproves this idea, demonstrating that those with the most English of accents can still be terribly ignorant and lack any reason or logic.
נפתלי בנט צריך להיות שר ההסברה של ישראל.
כל הכבוד!
נפתלי אוהבים אותך הבית היהודי לשלטון
עזבי ענייני הכבוד אנו עוסקים בביקורת בונה. זאת עובדה שהשאלות והטענות חוזרים על עצמם אבל אנחנו אף פעם לא מוכנים עם התשובות היותר מחודדות. צריך להקים צוות שיימפה את הראיונות מהסוג הזה וידגיש לאילה טענות לצפות במהלך הראיון ובאילו מסרים ובאיזו ביטויים להשתמש. צריך מנגנון בקרה הסברתי שהדוברים למיניהם ישתמשו בו באופן רציף לשיפור תמידי לפני ואחרי כל ראיון. ברור שהדבר לא נעשה בוודאי לא בגזרת מחנה הימין. וזו בעיה שחוזרת על עצמה כמעט עם כל המרואיינים בכל הרשתות בפנים ישראל בעברית וק"ו בזירה הבינלאומית.
כל הכבוד לנפטלי! ישר כוח!
ותודה על התרגום השארת אותו בלי מילים (:
The collective face of hatred just look at the face on Naphtali 🤬
,best explanations! easy talking, short centences good job!
פשוט מדהים שהם כל הזמן משדרים ברקע תמונות מרצועת עזה.... ישר כח נפתלי!
Bennett and Israel are still around while Ed Hussain has vanished in to oblivion.
OMG,and I thought there isn't even 1 Muslim who think like that.Thank you for expanding my knowledge :)
"There is a right side and a wrong side" - how childish and arrogant. I'm an Israeli and this kind of attitude makes me feel really embarrassed. Both sides are being led by a group of stupid ,arrogant war mongering politicians. That's the main problem.
and that is absolutely what the palestinians did, "israel stop occupying" "israel stop detaining" "israel stop killing" then fire home made rockets back at occupied land.
0:46 "The carnage on both sides doesn't necessarily help anybody", but that DID NOT answer the question: "Is there a 'right' side and a 'wrong' side?" You cannot say "it's not as black and white as that"; because if there are 2 sides, one has to be 'right' and one has to be 'wrong', unless they're both being manipulated and neither of them knows what they're doing. So it NEEDS to BE "as black and white as that", otherwise they're BOTH 'wrong'! And if they're BOTH 'wrong', well as Einstein states about Stupidity, "Even Genius has its limits." So the situation would be HOPELESS! 1:06 Well I agree with that. There shouldn't be "the Jewish state". Nothin' ta do with Judaism that one! There should just be The Land of God/The Nation of Peace. Yĕrūshalayim is "possession of peace" (traditional interpretation). How can we start having "the Jewish state" and "the Arab state" and all this nonsense?! 1:21 WHO turned it into a launchpad?? Which EXTERNAL power? 1:27 Wo wo wo! "We owe it to the Western world"?? Judaism is responsible for MOSHIACH and WORLD PEACE! NOT for Western World Peace! He's gettin' seriously off topic here! And the holocaust happened IN 'the Western world'. So I wouldn't be 'owing' anything to 'the Western world' specifically. The plan is that Judaism owes WORLD PEACE to THE WHOLE WORLD. 2:10 So? Why's a Brit worried about 'anti-Americanism'? Why's he been told off for "fueling anti-Americanism" with a bossy Englishy voice?? And why does Israel care about 'anti-Americanism'? Isn't Israel a U. S. state? And why is a British Muslim worried about 'anti-Americanism'? Is this supposed to be a comedy? 2:18 Well it's 'ethnic cleansing' I guess. For the Americans? 2:43 I don't understand what that means "hold the West hostage". Israel does the advanced intel for "the West". 3:10 Well the U. S. invaded and occupied an entire nation for 20 years, apparently over ONE person, (although it started with the building of an oil pipeline). 4:16 We're not all interested in "the long term safety of the state of Israel". We're interested in the long term safety of Judaism and it's ENTIRE population, which is still too tiny. So we need a single integrated nation. Not this "Jewish state"/"Arab state" claptrap. 4:25 Well "the battle of hearts and minds" starts at Al Aqsa. With the information that Muslims and Judahians are being 'played' against each other by greater EXTERNAL forces. And the STRESSING of THE FOUR FUNDAMENTAL FACTORS OF 'MARTYRDOM', so that the Muslim youth understand EXACTLY WHAT constitutes TRUE 'martyrdom' and what DOES NOT. Because the Muslim youth get brainwashed at the 'martyrdom' level. Constant 'retaliation' ad infinitum is merely 'ethnic cleansing'. A 'real' war would see Israel 'invade', rescue all the abandoned Muslims, because they really are being 'sacrificed', and secure ALL borders for the whole nation and build the new integrated nation. WITHOUT interference from the manipulative EXTERNAL forces. 4:31 Well Gerry Adams was instrumental in the Northern Ireland peace process actually. 4:37 Yes. "Reaching out via third parties" is a good idea. So will the British army help with the invasion? 4:41 I say leave the two-state solution on the death bed; where it belongs. It's NOT the TRUE solution! Yĕrūshalayim; "possession of peace" is the EPICENTER for WORLD PEACE. With BOTH Al Aqsa and The Third Temple on the Temple Mount! So there will NEVER be peace if there are 'two states'. Two states is a concretization of apartheid and the inability to integrate. A wealthy nuclear power next door to a little impoverished non-militarized state. If Palestine wouldn't be trusted to be 'militarized', then why pretend that two-states would work? It's a TRICK! 5:22 Well then come up with the strategy Ed! Everyone's expecting Naftali to come up with it on his own! All the time! What is he MOSHIACH? 5:42 There is NO WAY for us to be sittin' around waiting for people to "get some sense"!! ANYWHERE! A 'STRATEGY' is a STRATEGY! You can SEE it or you can't! But a 'strategy' is a CLEAR plan leading to an END! NOT an excuse for 80 years of 'ethnic cleansing'! And NOBODY needs to 'worry' about the long term safety of Yisrael. If Yisrael DOESN'T fulfill its purpose to bring MOSHIACH and WORLD PEACE, HaShem will destroy Yisrael HIMSELF, and there won't be a damn thing anyone can do about it! We need to forget about politics here, and stick to the spiritual PLAN that was put in place for Man! If 'invasion' is what is needed, then 'invasion' is what is needed. But there has to be an END, and there HAS TO BE, WORLD PEACE! According to REVELATION; THE CUBE OF PEACE; Holy Yĕrūshalayim; "possession of peace", is 2,500 kilometers cubed. REVELATION 21:15 And he that talked with me had a golden reed to measure the city, and the gates thereof, and the wall thereof. 16 And the city lieth foursquare, and the length is as large as the breadth: and he measured the city with the reed, twelve thousand furlongs. The length and the breadth and the height of it are equal. - That stretches from Mecca to the Black Sea and from Lybia to Iran. And that's PEACE IN THE MIDDLE EAST. Yar all too flimsy. I would simply install THE CUBE OF PEACE, and anyone who fires a SINGLE bullet inside THE CUBE OF PEACE; JAIL! Judaism is responsible for The Third Temple on the Temple Mount. Judaism and Islam are responsible for THE PEACE HAVEN on the Temple Mount with the Mosque and the Dome and the Third Temple and the Interfaith Center and and all the beautiful green spots and so on. Christianity is responsible for THE CUBE OF PEACE. OR, you send a few kids to Mars to build a TEMPORARY obelisk. Because that's all that you've got left as options. PEACE or a few surviving the nuke holocaust in mars.
Naftali repeated himself to much, he could have just asked Ed Husain "do you believe that if Israel will draw its forces - their will be no shooting from the Gaza strip tomorrow, or any othey day in the next days after tomorrow?..." - Ed would have serious problem to answer, because he doesn't like the fact that there is simply no problem with the Israeli attitude, since we want peace more than anything. on the other hand, Hamas - given the chance - would have wiped Israel today, not tomorrow.
I will , as long as you also acknowledge the Arab occupation of Algeria (natives are Berbers who were driven into the mountains) and Kurdistan + 900 000 Jewish refugees driven out from Arab countries after 1947.
And all this time they are showing only pictures from gazza, not from bombarded israel's south. There's definitley no question on which side CNN are.
Ed Husain wrote a book named:
"The Islamist: Why I Joined Radical Islam in Britain, What I Saw Inside and Why I Left".
That's another arabic that looks like he is closer to the west but in fact he is supporting Hamas, The Islamic Jihad, Taliban, and El Kaida! EL KAIDA!
Well done Ed Hussain
2 main groups of Jews from the Diaspora, Ashkenazic and Sephardic. 750 000 Jews were expelled from Arab countries after '48 including my grandparents from Egypt. Keep reading homeboy
Don’t debate Bennett, it’s like debating Ben Shapiro, Both are destined for a loss.
Israel can't be an "occupation", because in order to become that, Israel's land should have belonged to someone else, which is clearly not the case. There have never been a "Palestinian" state for Israel to occupy. The only thing that was, is the UN partition plan, which was rejected by the Pal's. And hamas isn't "resistance", it's a fundamentalist terror organization.
Mr Bennett always recites the same lessons they can starts wars onn any pretext folks whatever the circumstances folks
CNN, you are on the losing side of this battle and you need a refresher course in true, honest Journalism.
is no excuse for terrorists to fire missiles from the middle of their own civilians to another country's civilians. The world is watching and has passed judgement.By the way,I support a Palestinian state,alongside a Jewish state,existing within secure and recognised borders. Time for the Palestinians to understand that this is how they get their state. Israel is not going away any time soon,and is not handing over the keys to Tel Aviv to the murderers.
next election ill vote for bennet
,I live in Israel and I really can't understand how come that the palestinians don't want peace!
they want war and the Israelians are blamed in everything!
please please please try to understand that we(Israel) don't want to fight! I don't want my cousine or my friend's brother to die in a stupid war, but we have to fight in order to defend our selfs!
we just want peace.
we just want quiet.
we just want to live!!
what BS, whether you like him or not, most certainly was not 'owned' there. Look at the body language and you see Husain's eyes flickering nervously halfway through.
כל הכבוד , עשית עבודת קודש
I'm not israeli, nor jewish... Just from an external point of view, I found that Mr Hosain did a very bad job against Mr Bennett.
I did not write that. It is from the Hamas charter translated into English so that people can see for themselves what Hamas believes concerning Israel who I support. Yes, those who wrote it are deranged. That was the pt.
Ed Hussain seems to be making a lot more sense..
This is symbolic "discussion". This Arab's behavior is revolting, not letting the opponent say a word, and the Jew politely waiting when the other side's verbal diarrhea stops. What kind of dialog is possible at all with a man who fires 100 w/min of sheer propaganda bullshit?
לא נראה לי שהם הבינו על מה הם מדברים, אחד מדבר על הרשות הפלסטינית, השני מדבר על חמאס, שני גופים נפרדים בעלי אידיאולוגיה שונה, נראה שהיה פה קטעי מונולוגים של שניהם כל אחד משלים את המונולוג שלו ברגע שהראשון מסיים...
major respect
הלוואי שהייתי מאמין בלב שלם לבנט , אם זה כל כך נכון ואנחנו רוצים שקט ושלום והם לא , למה אנחנו ממשיכים את הבנייה בשטחים למה אנחנו גוזלים קרקעות מהערבים למה לא פשוט לפתח ולהתמקד במה שיש , אי אפשר להעלים עין מזה שבגדה אנחנו כובשים וממשיכים בשיא הכוח בדיכוי ואז מה אנחנו מצפים שיאהבו אותנו ? חבל שזה כך
אני הבנתי אותו אבל הוא דיבר כמו ספרן אנגלי מהסרטים
wars really never get us anywhere. but I think it's just the right of everyone to fight for their lives and the land given to them when times like this come. middle east people stop trying to eradicate The Israel Nation. you'll never stand a chance. you may fool the world but what YHWH has opened, no one can ever shut out. SHALOM ISRAEL. EL-ELOHE-ISRAEL is with you.
Israel goes to war ? What's this guy talking about he's a little confused defending yourself against daily rockets is not going to war, but this contributor believes only his warped version of events and hopes the viewer's will swallow the same. If he's really concerned about the welfare of the people of Gaza then might I suggest he preach this words of Peace to Hamas the only ones who can sort this out.
Wasn't America built on other people land ? Yet, are you horrified ?
Do you need more examples in history ?
Naftali Bennett you get my voice in the election!
ed, it is not true that hamas is ready to accept the 1967 borders. they are not ready to accept the 1948 borders or any borders of a jewish state. the defensive wars of israel are not an unsuccessful habit, they are the opposite. some things are, in fact, black and white. if you want to help the "palestinian" arabs you might explain to them what the people of israel are doing in the land of israel well enough so that they will understand it and accept it and respect it.
i actually thought that it was a good debate. i agree with bennett but i thought it wasnt biased as the show host is jewish as well. if anything it was biased for palestinian side
Invincible Israel🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
VIVA Naftali Bennett
LONG LIVE israel
Why I never watch CNN.
Ed Husain, I thought your title is Senior Fellow, Council of Foreign Relations! If you listen to your questions and arguments, does that reflect your position? There is no way you can win argument over Naftali Bennet ...is that simple! He is too smart for you😀
Naftali Bennett will be the embarrassed face of Israel in the coming decade if things don't change. An unapologetic fanatic.
This so called human being or look like at least is asking the lady What would you do if someone shot rockets at your house? If she is aware of the crisis will ask him the following: What would you do if someone occupied ur land? What would you do if some one killed ur SON DAUGHTER BROTHER FATHER MOTHER SISTER UNCLE ....? What would u do if some one eleminated ur whole family and bombed your house streets infrastructure power supplies....? What would u do if some one came suddenly to ur place where ur father and grand grand grand grand father born and lived in to tell u hey am coming from Africa USA Russia......... get out from my land?!!!
But remember the nationality of the killers of JESUS.....Do u know?
you are propaganda takiya arab. ......since when is it your land ?
you had homes and villages in Israel thats all..... never a country .. takiya man
U the Jewish have some houses there as my grandfather said u were few cattle living among Arabs
Where were u before 1948? Lost in the desert searching for your country as a baby searching for her doll? Then a state for u was established by the still going processes of massacres and bombardment of villages and the daily killing of kids in their parents' laps ..If u can cover the sun in Africa ur homeland u can convince the world that ur so called state in Palestine is not a state of BLOOD
takiya
OMG. You are so full of it.
true that. part 2.
איפה בן ארי?
כל הכבוד נפתלי!! ישר כח
כל הכבוד נפתלי, תמשיך עם פעילותך! רק אל תיגרר עם קיצוניים כמו בן ארי