These types of comparison videos is full waste of time when in the end you give 50-50 verdict. Why you are making such video when you yourself can't decide the best in the end. Stop telling if you want this... this one is best if you want that that one is best. You are comparing it atleast you should say clear winner in totality. Real disappointment!
Astor is now one of the safest and best build quality cars on the market. After seeing the NCAP result. Creta will no longer be my choice. Astor offers better features and safety. 👍
How is Astor one of the “safest and better build” car when it has not been crash tested? Also, Astor was launched just last year, it’s not even a year. So we don’t know how things would be in long run, especially keeping its Chinese background in mind.
@C1PH3R 1.0 why are you probably unintentionally trying to misguide people? The mileage you’ve mentioned is no where close to real life efficiency. Astor in city give around 8-9km/litre where as on highways it’ll return some where around 12-13.
Creta is the most over priced car ever! Base model Petrol doesnt have anything except Engine.. Yes Just Engine Nothing else. Thats alright, its reasonable bcoz its a base model but the cost is mad! Booked Astor
@@manoja538 As of now they stopped bookings for time being since their plant is full with orders. They will resume soon. Plus if Astor does not have base model I can't spend 15.5 lakhs for S variant of Creta which is an SUV but elder people cannot get Back seat arm rest when travelling 700 kms on a trip. Hahaha 15.5 lakhs on road and no armrest at the back for the elderly. Claps
MG Astor and Creta have tough compition, But I'll choose Astor over Creta because the build quality and road presence of Astor is way better Even Astor has a lot more features than Creta, Including Safety features. When you check the Aftersale service of the car, then I guess MG is doing better than Hyundai, So, one more reason to go for Astor.
I have personally driven astor , I think there is not much difference between creta and astor AT !! But , if someone really best package , go for astor sharp variant with manual transmission , that is by far best in the segment
brother what about space, astor isnt as spacious as creta right?? plus the under thigh support in the back seats is also not good,,what do u say???i have to choose between the two..
@@prashantvismil9064Hi bro, I have booked Astor MT Smart. It seems good spacious and decent underthigh support. If these two are your major concerns take some test drive with both cars and you can find a very very slight difference in your points. Astor would be good for Road presence too. I like the 2019 Creta design than this new design.
Comparison is fairly accurate but safety and build quality should take centre stage. There is no excuse for shoddy bulid quality whether the car costs 2 lakhs or 30 lakhs.
That is correct. That would have been a 4 cylinder unit too instead of the 3 cylinder mill currently. However, the 1.3 turbo engine of the Astor is an extremely refined unit for 3 pot mill.
@@umairarifshaikh5095 waah what a stupid comparision....covid wasnt there 2 years ago...but accidents and death were there for decades bit you didnt even care about safety untill tata started advertising... What hipocrisy
@motorbeam you're unable to decide but I can, in these two Astor is better then the Creta in terms of features and build quality plus Astor is a (Non-official) 5-star safety rating at the ASEAN NCAP as it is based on the same MG ZS platform.
booked Astor base variant when official bookings started, yet to receive any update on the car except the delivery date going to Q4'23. they are prioritising only top variants.
@@aditya_gupta i know i lived a few years in the domenican Republic and I bought myself the cheapest car over there a jac s2 it's also Chinese but a fortune for the normal domenican people ! But here in Spain it is one of the cheapest as well I am not rich but Chinese cars are very good for what you pay for them
Creta- a complete package of ride and handling??? Better learn what handling is before you make such reckless and unfair comments. What about build quality? you did not mention it at all. As a reviewer, you have to be very open minded and ready to accept the surprises, be it pleasant or unpleasant. Only that makes you a reliable source. Astor is indeed better in handling and steering feedback though it lags somewhat behind creta in power delivery, FE, etc.
So 18-20 lakhs for a suv with all safety features , all that techno security features may be good to a certain extent , but how come the Creta scored barely scraped through 3 Stars GNCAP , poor Creta is a tin ka dabba , car reviewers ka favourite dibba,😂😂😂
Hi MotorBeam Team ✌️ Which would be a better choice between Creta E/Ex and MG Astor Style variant in terms of front and rear comfort and as overall package to go for around 12-13 lakhs? 🤔🤔🤔
Build quality is good in Astor but it looks like a cross over and cramped too. Creta is no where a winner in this case as well due to average build quality. Engine and Transmission combination in Astor is patheric while Creta scores a bit in this department. Features in Astor are all gimmicks and we never know when they will fail. End of the story, both the cars nor perfect and I can't select any of the two.
Creta is not a safe car especially for high speeds. How can you make such a reckless remark that one cannot just go wrong with creta? Coming to handling, creta is just average, and leaves a lot to be desired. It does not even come closer to kushaq/taigun etc. You better stick to review of various features and funtions in the car, and do not give your verdict.
You should have highlighted properly creta 3 star rating, it's coffin for buyer in case of accidents, you should have highlighted it fully, but you went quick, seems to be a paid video
I had test driven astor manual, it was pulling like my Alto. That was a big turn off for me and likewise Astor is still a car, looks more like a hatchback, it is nowhere near to look as suv or compact suv. Creta kills it out on the suv looks. Creta is a well finished product, it doesn't have to over do to sell itself. When you sit in creta and drive, it only makes one statement. "This fits me in every aspect" Sales numbers are not a joke.
Thumbs down video. No safety creta. No suspension. The interior are better in one. Its lenghtier and wider than other. Who makes sit a person in boot. 😮. Will stop watching biased videos
Hello #MotorBeamers, what would you buy if you were in the market with Rs. 20 lakh to spend?
MG Astor.
Mg astor
Mg astor
When's the mt15 v2 review coming?
Ofcourse MG
These types of comparison videos is full waste of time when in the end you give 50-50 verdict. Why you are making such video when you yourself can't decide the best in the end. Stop telling if you want this... this one is best if you want that that one is best. You are comparing it atleast you should say clear winner in totality. Real disappointment!
Yess bas views chaiye
Exactly bro
This is what happens when anybody tries to become an auto journalist
yrrrr yeh sirf specs padte hai.....
these are journalists, not car enthusiast, expert or car-anything...... inse itna hi ho skta hai....
Astor is now one of the safest and best build quality cars on the market. After seeing the NCAP result. Creta will no longer be my choice. Astor offers better features and safety. 👍
Absolutely but the mileage is an issue for most of the customers.8-12 is very low
@C1PH3R 1.0 20?🙆
Even the company doesn't offer such mileage bro.I have ridden two astors and both mileage is 9-11 max bro..
How is Astor one of the “safest and better build” car when it has not been crash tested? Also, Astor was launched just last year, it’s not even a year. So we don’t know how things would be in long run, especially keeping its Chinese background in mind.
@C1PH3R 1.0 why are you probably unintentionally trying to misguide people? The mileage you’ve mentioned is no where close to real life efficiency. Astor in city give around 8-9km/litre where as on highways it’ll return some where around 12-13.
@@Aniruddhm You need to do some more research on the car on other markets. Expected to be the same unlike Hyundai Creta.
MG Astor is the most beautiful and loveable Car in 2022 ❤️🤩
Very smooth engine.. comfort raide quality...
Creta is the most over priced car ever! Base model Petrol doesnt have anything except Engine.. Yes Just Engine Nothing else. Thats alright, its reasonable bcoz its a base model but the cost is mad! Booked Astor
Astor doesn't even have a base model lol
@@manoja538 As of now they stopped bookings for time being since their plant is full with orders. They will resume soon. Plus if Astor does not have base model I can't spend 15.5 lakhs for S variant of Creta which is an SUV but elder people cannot get Back seat arm rest when travelling 700 kms on a trip. Hahaha 15.5 lakhs on road and no armrest at the back for the elderly. Claps
@@manoja538 by the way I booked Astor Base itself (style)
@@manoja538Bro , Astor has Base variant from 10.7 Lakhs
Creta is 3 star safety
Astor looks more luxurious, loaded with amazing advanced features as compared to Creta. I'm thinking to book astor now😍😍
13 lakhs base model haha😂 and mg is not even taking bookings of astor
Good choice 👍
ya u can buy astor because i have a mg and it
go for it... its safe
@@Cyrax210 13 lakhs? 10 lakh bol
MG Astor and Creta have tough compition,
But I'll choose Astor over Creta because the build quality and road presence of Astor is way better
Even Astor has a lot more features than Creta, Including Safety features.
When you check the Aftersale service of the car, then I guess MG is doing better than Hyundai,
So, one more reason to go for Astor.
No after resale service hyundai is doing better
Resale value of creta is much better
@@abhiastic8353Blinded u r
Mg astor looks much stunning in real world😍👌
I have personally driven astor , I think there is not much difference between creta and astor AT !!
But , if someone really best package , go for astor sharp variant with manual transmission , that is by far best in the segment
brother what about space, astor isnt as spacious as creta right?? plus the under thigh support in the back seats is also not good,,what do u say???i have to choose between the two..
@@prashantvismil9064Hi bro, I have booked Astor MT Smart. It seems good spacious and decent underthigh support. If these two are your major concerns take some test drive with both cars and you can find a very very slight difference in your points.
Astor would be good for Road presence too.
I like the 2019 Creta design than this new design.
Astor all the way 🔥
Comparison is fairly accurate but safety and build quality should take centre stage.
There is no excuse for shoddy bulid quality whether the car costs 2 lakhs or 30 lakhs.
Yes creta is only 3 star
@@Legenderguy8756 barely 3 star
Astor has a better road presence than creta, it looks bigger than creta on road
Why is that only TOP end models are used to compare and review. Why not review base model and mid variant?
13:43 MG Motors could've downsided their 2.0L Single Turbo Engine of the Gloster to 1.5L and then plonk in to the Astor.
SAIC would be the one giving the engine, MG just has to plonk that engine in their rebranded car!
That is correct. That would have been a 4 cylinder unit too instead of the 3 cylinder mill currently.
However, the 1.3 turbo engine of the Astor is an extremely refined unit for 3 pot mill.
@@finderskeepers7293 Yes and it is having highest torque among other 3-cylinder engines in its bracket.
@@navdeep_autophile Yes, that is correct. Its torque figures are in the diesel engine territory for that amount of displacement.
@@finderskeepers7293 same torque as in the 1.4L CRDi.
Now mask is becoming the blindfolds 😃 😃
"Complete family package", but barely a 3 star crash test rating? Someone loves their family😂
Did you care about safety or ncap ratings 5 years ago?
Nobody did then , and nobody bothered about it....
Safety ratings doesnt matter
@@aidithk.g4940 waah. Did you care about the covid vaccine two years ago? Par ab ignore nahi karoge na.
@@umairarifshaikh5095 waah what a stupid comparision....covid wasnt there 2 years ago...but accidents and death were there for decades bit you didnt even care about safety untill tata started advertising...
What hipocrisy
@@aidithk.g4940 doesn't mean that we should take safety for granted. Or do you want to be stuck to the mentality we had 20 years ago?
Astor has better build quality than Astor, and it also looks more premium. Creta now won't give that spark. It felt boring.
Creta is not safe. Mg has way better build quality
This Segment is kickstarted by the car which is out of production now and didn't got any comprehensive update to cater the Indian Automobile Market.
Later on, another Car in 2015 dominated and took over the segment to another league.
which car u are talking about?
@@arkaprabhamondal4441 Renault Duster
None of the segment starters survived in India. Be it Duster or Ecosport. Sad
OG Motorbeam comparisons kicked in yo!💥💥💥💥
@motorbeam you're unable to decide but I can, in these two Astor is better then the Creta in terms of features and build quality plus Astor is a (Non-official) 5-star safety rating at the ASEAN NCAP as it is based on the same MG ZS platform.
And ASEAN NCAP tests are even applicable here too. Eg nissan magnite got 4 star in asean ncap and also gncap same as with 4th gen honda city
bro what about spacoiusness????
Sir
Would like to see the comparison video of these two cars with respect to safety features
they wont, no body talk abt safety/
booked Astor base variant when official bookings started, yet to receive any update on the car except the delivery date going to Q4'23. they are prioritising only top variants.
Holy 🤬 . 2023!!!
@@pizmos. yup
you will get it max by 2022 end
@@tanmaysinha7002 the SA is not sure about that
How's your experience with car?
bhai, driving bhi patti lga kr krwate. maza hi aa jata. Asli comparison ho jata.
😂😂😂😂😂
😂
You are forcefully supporting Creta. This is not the way to compare.
When you talk about safety features, talk more about the standard features too, cos most of the buyers end up buying the lower trims
Here in Spain I got this model of mg but here it's called the zs and it's a good cheap car
here we have zs but its electric . its the same car but its just an ev and non ev version is called the astor
@@anuraagpatwardhan1320 i know but this will probably my last fuel car be ! For electric now is still to much hazel
@@TheDirkdams for you guys it may be cheap for us Indians this is luxury. ₹20,00000 is a huge amount for us.
@@aditya_gupta i know i lived a few years in the domenican Republic and I bought myself the cheapest car over there a jac s2 it's also Chinese but a fortune for the normal domenican people ! But here in Spain it is one of the cheapest as well I am not rich but Chinese cars are very good for what you pay for them
@@TheDirkdams yup
Absolutely agree with someone else here, Hyundai's pricing is slightly off... at entry level for sure! Which variants are these 2 ?
Bro has personal issues with astor ... Bro i mean I drived both of these cars , and astor is way better than creta .
Mg astor is the best car below 30 lakhs
Question to people using Astor.
Can u add more tint to the sunroof? It looks too bright on a sunny day even with the shade.
Get a film on it and your purpose is fulfilled.
Instead of buying Seltos, Creta, Astor, Kushaq, taigun better to go for MG Hector
You know it's fake when the are using mask instead of actual blindfolds 😂😂
Astor looks posh but Astor looks like crossover that is big let down
😂creata, safe???
unstable & ⭐⭐⭐
Not even 3 bro it's actually supposed to be 2 , but we all know how much money and pull hyundai has
I have learnt of a new utility for the humble face mask today.😂😂😂
Astor 💯
Oh so when he sat in the rear seat he did not realise creta has a sponge in its headrest
😂😂😂
Exactly my thoughts. 👍🏼👍🏼
Creta- a complete package of ride and handling??? Better learn what handling is before you make such reckless and unfair comments. What about build quality? you did not mention it at all. As a reviewer, you have to be very open minded and ready to accept the surprises, be it pleasant or unpleasant. Only that makes you a reliable source. Astor is indeed better in handling and steering feedback though it lags somewhat behind creta in power delivery, FE, etc.
how abt the safety point of view.
So 18-20 lakhs for a suv with all safety features , all that techno security features may be good to a certain extent , but how come the Creta scored barely scraped through 3 Stars GNCAP , poor Creta is a tin ka dabba , car reviewers ka favourite dibba,😂😂😂
Astor is great… Hyundai had a v good build quality till 4 yrs back…. Not any more
Putting person in boot….what a good way to test
Now ask him to drive and feel the driving.. 😎
Astor❤❤
I don't understand why you need "blindfolds" to test interiors?
Astor ❤
8:26 tell me if that doesn’t look like LAFerrari
Astor looks and price specially base model😘😘😘😘😘
now creta is like honda activa. wherever you see there is 2 3 creta.
Please talk about build quality also
Astor is the best build quality 👍
MG astor
What is this test?
The guy is getting hurt during ingress, sitting in the boot with eyes closed, will be going to give him an awful experience.
MG ASTOR IS BEST COZ THE PREMIUM BUILD QUALITY & INTERIOR ALSO SUPERB , ALWAYS GO FOR MG
Still i would say better to go for creta. Plz don't say to me iski safety aise hai vaise hai, pta hai merko, ok🙂
Only astor
Hi MotorBeam Team ✌️ Which would be a better choice between Creta E/Ex and MG Astor Style variant in terms of front and rear comfort and as overall package to go for around 12-13 lakhs? 🤔🤔🤔
go for astor
Astor
They should have tested non turbo version people will buy that
I like certa
how he seen three headrest while his eys closed ...chhukar bhi nahi dekha
Build quality is good in Astor but it looks like a cross over and cramped too. Creta is no where a winner in this case as well due to average build quality. Engine and Transmission combination in Astor is patheric while Creta scores a bit in this department. Features in Astor are all gimmicks and we never know when they will fail. End of the story, both the cars nor perfect and I can't select any of the two.
To Aya kyun dekhne tu😭
Nobody: what will you do with the masks after pandemic ends?
Motor Beam: Hold my car keys! and jump to 2:54 lol
Also the astor is 5 star in build qualtity as it is the same car as the mg zs ev. And 3 stars fir creta. So yes a big deal.
When eyes are closed how does he knows that this car has two headrest only 😀
Cretas extra head chushion / neck rest , that is the indiacator
So he assumed it as creta and he says two headrest
I bought Astor ❤
Try to do the video fully on English. couldn't able to understand Some important things which you're saying.
Creta is not a safe car especially for high speeds. How can you make such a reckless remark that one cannot just go wrong with creta? Coming to handling, creta is just average, and leaves a lot to be desired. It does not even come closer to kushaq/taigun etc. You better stick to review of various features and funtions in the car, and do not give your verdict.
ASTOR🔥
You should have highlighted properly creta 3 star rating, it's coffin for buyer in case of accidents, you should have highlighted it fully, but you went quick, seems to be a paid video
The only thing you should ask MG astor AI is 'Open the sunroof"....lol
Dhanil wears masks like most cab drivers in India
Astor looks like a premium car.
Astor vs city
Bhai Hindi hi bol IND m reh k IND ka subscribe leke launguage frringi wali
For a 3 star car 20 lakh not worth it
Ya
But Astor also ncap not known
If Astor gets 3 star or lower in future what you will do
Then I would prefer waiting for Harrier petrol
@@selvamuthukumaran5016 what ?? Mg astor has scored 5 stars in ncap !!
@@mohitrajput7924 mg astor is really safe , you can go for it
Please don't compare MG Astor with Creta. Creta is not at all close to Astor.
Very misleading video. Creta doesn’t come with 6 airbags in its sx model which is same as sharp. Next time please use 2 models of similar price..!!
😂😂
The MG looks much better
I think Astor has a refined engine...
Let him Drive in blindfolded .
seltos????
Uncle first go and workout reduce your tummy fat and test again you'll feel the difference getting in and out the car
Astor can't be consider as suv
I love creta
People buying astor in comments in reality dad creta black book karwani hai 😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
I paused the video and writing this comment who blind folds with mask??
I had test driven astor manual, it was pulling like my Alto. That was a big turn off for me and likewise Astor is still a car, looks more like a hatchback, it is nowhere near to look as suv or compact suv. Creta kills it out on the suv looks.
Creta is a well finished product, it doesn't have to over do to sell itself. When you sit in creta and drive, it only makes one statement. "This fits me in every aspect"
Sales numbers are not a joke.
Astor far better
Creta is best
who puts a big ass guy in boot space ? Unless you're disposing body. Then better get a Sedan.
Black me to Astor Rabahi lagti hai
Thumbs down video. No safety creta. No suspension. The interior are better in one. Its lenghtier and wider than other. Who makes sit a person in boot. 😮. Will stop watching biased videos
🔥
Close the eyes and try driving
What a rubbish review still can't choose one, I am at the position which I was 15mins earlier
Whats your requirement?
Creta🔥🔥
Biased review
💟🙏💟
Iski video diss like kro
1 comment