Hope you liked the video? Our experts recommend the Best Buy worth your money, after analysing your requirements. Click on this link & submit your query motoroctane.com/car-consultancy
@@sumitindori8029 most times they don't because VW and Skoda have everything same especially interms of engine and also it's specs and driving dynamics, suspension and build... So only Rapid or Vento Kushaq or Taigun... But maybe the case is different with Slavia and Virtus. Because weight and dimensions of Virtus is not same as Slavia as far i know..
We got an Astor to our place a few weeks back. I have driven it for more than a thousand kilometres, and I must say that the driving experience with the car has been fabulous. I love it!
@@ghandhi43 japnese cars have a feel of their own which only the owners can understand. It's just about the infotainment system which should not be important to people who enjoy driving like me and similar ppl. It's second best in terms of performance compared to German cars but are super reliable to keep it for an entire decade 👌🏻👌🏻
Agreed, Astor is best value for money among this, yeah diesel variant is disadvantage but as you said, from the base to top it offer the best in best features which makes it better then other vehicle.
@@bhaveshsalvi4437 i don't think so Autocar india didn't make this much detailed video Points like these are really important for a detailed video - PAINT QUALITY - WIPER - ROOF RAILS GROUND CLEARANCE - ANTENNA - PANEL GAP - TYRE SIZE SPARE TYRE - BOOT SPACE - KEY - INTERIOR BOTTLE STORAGE PHONE STORAGE AND CHARGING PORTS CUP HOLDERS - TOUCHSCREEN RESPONSE REVERSE PARKING CAMERA MUSIC TEST STEERING ADJUSTMENT HORN TEST DOOR THUD SEAT ADJUSTMENT DOOR OPENING GETTING IN AND OUT SECOND-ROW SEATING DRIVE BRAKING TEST HILL CLIMB - SPEED BREAKER TEST - HEADLIGHT TEST
Autocar channel are biased And proof is bcoz kia karnival is discontinued in the global market and its 2nd gen had been launched in the global market but still no 2nd gen in Indian market still autocar channel had given car of the year to kia carnival This proofs that autocar is a biased channel
Kushaq having the best review on: 1: Performance 2: Safety 3: Ride Quality What else do you want in a car.. Add on features that others have are all good to have but they cannot be weighed against the basic requirements of safety, performance and comfort. As Skoda says ‘CHOOSE WHAT REALLY MATTERS’ - Proud Owner of Kushaq 😃🎈.
Driving quality of kicks is lowest among other cars shown in the video. However its my personal opinion and no offence to kicks fan. To me the best driving quality I felt was in Astor and Kushaq
Overall I like the MG Astor above all just because of his jam-packed with segment-first features. The AI feature is certainly entertaining. Its infotainment system was fantastic. Also, the Digital Key feature will be a great solution in times of emergency.
After your last review with Astor i purchased its SAVVY Varient...... Now i m happy with it .... It's drive is very addictive sice i m a tech savvy person..... Its 360 camera although not that much clear but is very useable in tight city spaces....... Its AC is quite powerful.... ADAS is full paisa wasool... Especially its adaptive cruise control works amazingly well in city traffic.... And Blind spot detection is cherry on top... Also Intelligent Headlamp control works pretty well too on highways..... Overall great car u cn definitely go for it if not an enthusiast....
That’s great. Congratulations. You should definitely share your experience with our audience. Pls do share your details here for Owner’s Review of your car motoroctane.com/mystory
@@nmanmeet Mileage in city sucks ....that is 8.5-10 With ac it sucks even more.....that is 5.5 to 7 They both are in bumper to bumper traffic.... On highway with out ac i managed to gain 21 kmpl.... With Ac i gained 17.5.... So mileage on highway is good... But not in city.... Sunshade does not create heating issue as much..... As the AC works pretty well..... Though when u touch the glass portion it is hot but the heat gets dissipated effectively..... So hot weather and sunroof won't be a problem for u ..... And also don't expect high performance from a CVT gearbox...... If want performance go for turbo varient
Glad you added kicks in the comparison. I get all the necessary features in my manual kicks top variant 1.3 turbo xv pre option. A 360 camera, cruise control cornering fog lamps, rain sensing vipers, rear defogger idle stop , full leatherite good ac etc that too at 14.2 lac ex showroom . Show me a single manufacturer who is providing a top variant turbo at this price point … plus a ground clearance of 210mm and a solid build quality and japanese nissan gtr dna mirror coating tech together with a gem of an engine even used in merc benz a200. I am not sure why people are missing on this japanese gem for some gimmicky low build quality , no use features… For sunshades i can buy a sun shades for rs 50. Have enough space in the car to keep different items… its a no nonsense go anywhere car … you will stand out for its sheer size which is biggest in the segment… A sunroof reduces safety if a car topples . We dont live in europe to enjoy a sunroof in this hot weather. Kicks has a usable roof rails capable of carrying 100kilo load…. Truely made for India… sadly Nissan is not good at marketing and gimmicky features… and how come creta is a new car . Its an old car facelifted.
@@carlover5763 get your facts corrected , i used to stay in mexico the test which you are mentioning here is the one conducted in nissan kicks sold there (brazil mexico) which is a small sub 4 meter one.. also the variant tested is without esc electronic stability control. Nissan kicks was a small suv sold there in mexico and it looks like chevrolet beat .
MG Astor is truly the best package in terms of Safety, build quality, premiumness, technology like ADAS and Gender neutral looks no matter a female or a male drives it. I believe this is the future ready car because these days cars with ADAS is the new trend.
@@shobhitraj16 bro already done with the test drive. The rear seat comfort is good but not the best at its a sufficient space for two people and three people can sit but will be little uncomfortable and can be tiring for long drive. Rest the cushioning is good lacks little under thigh support and has more than sufficient over headspace for 5.11 person and decent for anyone above that height.
@@Sam.RoyalRider yes mileage is poor i am getting the lowest as 9 and highest 10.5 but the power for 1.5cvt did not disappoint me it was good yes there is a rubberband effect but that’s common in cvt. Also for more power you can go for turbo 1.3 which is 3cylinder.
The most underrated and most value for money of this lot is surely Nissan Kicks. Excellent driving dynamice, ride quality, stability, engaging performance, superb steering, top notch NVH and last but not the least, a true tried and tested engine (same on entry level Mercedez too).
I own Astor and I have no complains about it. I even tested creta and seltos before buying it. But surely in this price range Astor was giving much more than others like safety and tech.
@@kiddit_ Bhai tere ko kya problem hai mere ko proud feel hota hai to tere ko kahe pareshaani ho rahi hai 25000 mein 5 saal ki free service and uske service waale spare parts mile hain 5 saal tk ek Paisa nahi lagna Mera , 2 lakh tk dealer se discount Milla Tin k dabba se best hai , Kahe faltu mein pareshan ho chacha 🙏😂
Very good video. My notes below, Dimensions- kicks #1 Engine power - kicks #1 Ground clearance- kicks #1 NVH insulation- kicks #1 Torque - Kicks #1 Wheelbase - kicks #1 Suspension- kicks #1 Wipers quality - kicks #1 Off-road drive - kicks #1 Top model CVT on-price value for money- kicks #1 Highway overtaking - kicks #1 Luggage space- kicks #1 0-100km acceleration-> kicks #1 (you can see those comparisons on youtube) Tyres qualify - Apollo Aptera- best in segment- kicks #1 Dashboard premiumness - astor #1 Electronic features - Astor #1 Feel good features - creta #1 Resale value - creta #1 One Chinese car, two Korean cars, two German cars and one Japanese . P.s: I own a kicks cvt and my friends have pretty much all these models. All models are infact good midsized SUVs
Wow, Rachat is considering Nissan Kicks for comparison even in 2022 March. I own XV Premium CVT and it is way better than others. Astor is another classic car. One observation is Insulation in XV Premium CVT has best NVH levels in the class.
I bought 1.5 Petrol MT astor sharp variant and I don't think at all that it is underpowered !! It is more than sufficient and can go uphill very easy without any problem , moreover the crossover design makes it more aerodynamic .
Test drove all the cars except the Astor, and went with the Kicks Turbo Petrol XV premium. It delivers immense power off the line, like in the video. True the automatic lacks punch at the top end, but shifting it to manual makes it an amazing car to drive. I have been finding excuses to drive the car everyday.. Its a joy! Yes, the interiors are drab..but i dont mind it.. Its functional and works for me, especially at such a low price point compared to the others. I kept up with an Audi A8 on the highway at over 120kmph without breaking a sweat.
I own creta diesel and i think one should go for it for sx executive as it's best and real value for money variant among all. I loved it's performance features and especially it's comfort is best among all
i am proud owner of Nissan Kicks love to drive in city or highway or hilly areas it is so comfortable to drive even the milage which claim by company is 13-14 on Highway, i always had milage of 20-22 on Highway and sometimes I went for 24 kmpl in city i usually get around 12-13 in Mumbai City which is too good it's an amazing car. I have CVT turbo and has excellent pickup....
Nice comparison sir we also want a comparison on KIA Carens and Maruti Suzuki XL6 By the way love your review sir❤❤ I am a 15 years old and I am very passionate about automobiles sir and I gain so much of knowledge 🤓
if you are okay with economy of 8-12 kmpl in petrol engine.. close your eyes and book carens. It will beat maruti in every way. If you want Diesel.. just go for carens blindly. If CNG, then go for ertiga CNG VXI. I have researched a lot ! Carens is better than XL6.
Very honest review, i love the way you have explained about seltos and Astor features. If we talk about build quality and interior MG astor is far better than all, driving skoda & kick, features again MG astor with some distance, Best value Astor base and kick, stylish Seltos ( my personal opinion). Verdict if your budget is 12 then go for Astor and Kick, 15 to 18 can't say however Kusaq or seltos but if you have 20+ then try anyone but don't miss Astor bcz they offer ADAS value of money.
@@GauravYadav-in5tt some how agree, but most selling varient of any car has now longer waiting period. You can look at any car like XUV700 or kia carnes,. But here we are talking about waiting period, we are discussing best value of money.
@@wethekidsz yea but if are thinking for any other brand's top model u need to pay the same amount only but here additionally u ll get ADAS. Some features are still missing out it seems they are adding them with new model
My choice Skoda Kushaq because I Love * Looks * Engine Refinement * Day To Day Life Practical Features not like seltos/creta type bla blaa blaaa features * Brand Value * Built quality
Hlo Bhaji...my friend is selling his Nissan Kicks Petrol ...just 7000kms run...and I'm planning to buy it as it's in my budget ..iv driven this Car .. seriously it's a dope ...can I go for it ..? What you say .. people say .. Nissan Spare parts are costly .. ?kindly give ur suggestion.
Hi rachit. Thanks for this video. And keeping kicks in the comparison. U said kicks does not have functional roof rails. But I think it is functional and can take 100 kgs of load. Can u check
This was a very useful review. However bit unfair to Nissan Kicks like you didn't mention it has remote start option with key. It has best ride and handling package better than any other can as its dimension are larger than rest. As far as build quality is concern Kicks use Graphene Steel and feels like a tank it has maximum crumble zones the only downside are its dated interior though manual top model looks decent. Kushaq has gone down a bit on the quality and please don't mention anything about Creata high speed stability. The steering feels lifeless and suspension is too soft korean cars are not meant for driving fun only features
I have personally driven my friend's Kicks. Shit steering Shit insulation Lacks some necessary up to date features. Graphene steel aint gonna be a buying point for people. They aint gonna go around slamming walls or some shit. Its got good ground clearance. That's the only plus in my books.
You could speak to our team of auto experts & seek professional car buying advice motoroctane.com/car-consultancy click on the link and book your call.
Motoroctane let me tell you one thing. Mark my words. You have a gem reviewer in your hands . Do not let him go. He is one of the most versatile car reviewer I have ever seen . He is an outstanding person with great speaking and reviewing skills. 👏 . Outstanding comparison. He is a 💎.
Bhi aap se aacha explain kisi ne nahi kiya Jitne bhi vdos mene dekhe... App har point tak gaye aur ek dum ache se explain Kiya ..bas dimensions me creta aur Aster apas me exchange ho gye shayed...
Half way through the review and I'm liking what I'm seeing, Creta kushaq and Seltos seems good on top varient, Kicks is out of discussion here and Astor is good for the interior quality otherwise it ain't the best feature wise. Watched the full review and If we are talking about top model I'll pick Creta over Seltos and then I'll pick kushaq. But if i were a enthusiast I'll buy kushaq over any other vehicle.
If you’re an “TRUE” motorcar enthusiast - you would’ve picked kicks. So effortlessly you ruled out it whereas it’s engine n drive quality is second to none among the lot.
Hope you liked the video? Our experts recommend the Best Buy worth your money, after analysing your requirements. Click on this link & submit your query motoroctane.com/car-consultancy
Always add timeline plz
49:20 the Creta's length is displayed incorrectly as 3995. Venue is sub-4 m. But this is 4.3 m in length
Hi Rachit
As usual, just awesome.
I just have one comment. I think Nissan Kicks has functional roof rails supporting up to 100 kg.
Why VW taigun is not considered in this comparison??
@@sumitindori8029 most times they don't because VW and Skoda have everything same especially interms of engine and also it's specs and driving dynamics, suspension and build... So only Rapid or Vento
Kushaq or Taigun... But maybe the case is different with Slavia and Virtus. Because weight and dimensions of Virtus is not same as Slavia as far i know..
We got an Astor to our place a few weeks back. I have driven it for more than a thousand kilometres, and I must say that the driving experience with the car has been fabulous. I love it!
Which powertrain - 1.5L or the turbo ?
I have astor sharp
Is it manual or cvt? What's the mileage? And does the sun roof shade being transparent creates heat issues? Thanks in advance.
How much days we will get the car
@@shanhere2008 I can vouch for turbo. I have one. It's great
Proud Owner of Nissan Kicks. Good riding quality, Build quality, Powerfull engine, Moreover Japanese engineering....
Congratulations sir 🎉🎉not a Korean car
Kicks feels like a tank. Rest of the barnd makes gharelu gaddi. Nissan has a heritage of making sports cars.
@@ghandhi43 japnese cars have a feel of their own which only the owners can understand. It's just about the infotainment system which should not be important to people who enjoy driving like me and similar ppl. It's second best in terms of performance compared to German cars but are super reliable to keep it for an entire decade 👌🏻👌🏻
Which varient??
Xv premium cvt turbo
Agreed, Astor is best value for money among this, yeah diesel variant is disadvantage but as you said, from the base to top it offer the best in best features which makes it better then other vehicle.
Proud to buy astor
@@elitethrongaming1747 congratulations
Disadvantage of mg astor is diesel
There is no diesel
Only Motoroctane Can make this Maha Comparison Video With all Details, Great work👍
Checkout autocar India's last video. You ll be amazed
autocar's comparison was better
@@bhaveshsalvi4437 i don't think so
Autocar india didn't make this much detailed video
Points like these are really important for a detailed video
- PAINT QUALITY
- WIPER
- ROOF RAILS
GROUND CLEARANCE
- ANTENNA
- PANEL GAP
- TYRE SIZE
SPARE TYRE
- BOOT SPACE - KEY
- INTERIOR
BOTTLE STORAGE
PHONE STORAGE AND CHARGING PORTS
CUP HOLDERS
- TOUCHSCREEN RESPONSE
REVERSE PARKING CAMERA
MUSIC TEST
STEERING ADJUSTMENT
HORN TEST
DOOR THUD
SEAT ADJUSTMENT DOOR OPENING
GETTING IN AND OUT
SECOND-ROW SEATING
DRIVE
BRAKING TEST
HILL CLIMB
- SPEED BREAKER TEST - HEADLIGHT TEST
@@shubham------- they are biased for mg hyundai and kia
Autocar channel are biased
And proof is bcoz kia karnival is discontinued in the global market and its 2nd gen had been launched in the global market but still no 2nd gen in Indian market still autocar channel had given car of the year to kia carnival
This proofs that autocar is a biased channel
Proud Kicks owner. Truly a beast when it comes to performance. A macho.
milage ?petrol
@@manojkumarpottepalem7967 diesel. 14 average
Bhai Aur Koi Car Nahin Mila Kya Jo Kicks le liye.I am confused between Creta and Kushaq.
Finally someone has considered the Nissan Kicks. 👌
Kicks*
What’s the mileage claim on kicks?
13-15/L
Kicks diesel 12 -13 in city . 16-17 in highway
@@aravindhanswaminathan9713 kics diesel aata kaha hai?
Only Motoroctane team can make this maha comparison happen with great details.
Proud owner of kicks 1.3 turbo
do you have a manual or CVT
what is the mileage you are getting
@@sbsbajwa I have 1.3 turbo xv manual...i am getting 10.5 in city and 15to 16 on highways
Happy to see Kicks being added here.
Highly underrated but most VFM car..
For me... The VFM is the Astor
logically when you buy budget SUV nissan kicks is the best in class 11.25Lac 1.5 XV-NA variant and Astor 13 lac approx (base variant)
Have you driven Kicks?
@@speakamreet12345 yes, i have nissan kicks
@@harshudhani2432 3rd class company and 3rd class car 😂😂
Kushaq having the best review on:
1: Performance
2: Safety
3: Ride Quality
What else do you want in a car..
Add on features that others have are all good to have but they cannot be weighed against the basic requirements of safety, performance and comfort. As Skoda says ‘CHOOSE WHAT REALLY MATTERS’
- Proud Owner of Kushaq 😃🎈.
Me too
@@januyelkayan6935 : Agree, diesel would have be an add on.
Kushaq and Kicks is best for performance but sadly Kicks is so much underrated car now 😔😔😔
Love kicks ❤️🙏❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
kicks is Value for money terms of performance ,Space, comfort and i personally love that boot space.
Driving quality of kicks is lowest among other cars shown in the video. However its my personal opinion and no offence to kicks fan.
To me the best driving quality I felt was in Astor and Kushaq
@@speakamreet12345 yea sure. Pls tell that to Mercedes. ☺
@@speakamreet12345kicks is the most riding quality car
Bought MG Astor. Absolutely loving it! 😍😍😍
@C1PH3R 1.0 what do you do for a living mate?
What is NCAP rating of MG Astor?
@@Tiger-Blitz35 euro ncap m e 5
@@Tiger-Blitz35 same chassis as zs ev. That is 5 star rated.
@@Tiger-Blitz35 same as european market....
Insightful and well-explained video. MG Astor is a masterpiece in this segment. Especially its features are impressive compared to others.
Overall I like the MG Astor above all just because of his jam-packed with segment-first features. The AI feature is certainly entertaining. Its infotainment system was fantastic. Also, the Digital Key feature will be a great solution in times of emergency.
ride quality is not good of mg
Mileage ..not daily use car ..🤣
I like this car🤩just wow
Seems like you are buying a smartphone not a car
Whats the mileage in city(petrol)
After your last review with Astor i purchased its SAVVY Varient......
Now i m happy with it .... It's drive is very addictive sice i m a tech savvy person..... Its 360 camera although not that much clear but is very useable in tight city spaces.......
Its AC is quite powerful....
ADAS is full paisa wasool... Especially its adaptive cruise control works amazingly well in city traffic.... And Blind spot detection is cherry on top...
Also Intelligent Headlamp control works pretty well too on highways.....
Overall great car u cn definitely go for it if not an enthusiast....
That’s great. Congratulations. You should definitely share your experience with our audience. Pls do share your details here for Owner’s Review of your car motoroctane.com/mystory
What's the mileage? And does the sun roof shade being transparent creates heat issues? Thanks in advance.
@@nmanmeet
Mileage in city sucks ....that is 8.5-10
With ac it sucks even more.....that is 5.5 to 7
They both are in bumper to bumper traffic....
On highway with out ac i managed to gain 21 kmpl....
With Ac i gained 17.5....
So mileage on highway is good... But not in city....
Sunshade does not create heating issue as much..... As the AC works pretty well..... Though when u touch the glass portion it is hot but the heat gets dissipated effectively.....
So hot weather and sunroof won't be a problem for u .....
And also don't expect high performance from a CVT gearbox...... If want performance go for turbo varient
Glad you added kicks in the comparison. I get all the necessary features in my manual kicks top variant 1.3 turbo xv pre option. A 360 camera, cruise control cornering fog lamps, rain sensing vipers, rear defogger idle stop , full leatherite good ac etc that too at 14.2 lac ex showroom . Show me a single manufacturer who is providing a top variant turbo at this price point … plus a ground clearance of 210mm and a solid build quality and japanese nissan gtr dna mirror coating tech together with a gem of an engine even used in merc benz a200. I am not sure why people are missing on this japanese gem for some gimmicky low build quality , no use features…
For sunshades i can buy a sun shades for rs 50. Have enough space in the car to keep different items… its a no nonsense go anywhere car … you will stand out for its sheer size which is biggest in the segment…
A sunroof reduces safety if a car topples . We dont live in europe to enjoy a sunroof in this hot weather. Kicks has a usable roof rails capable of carrying 100kilo load…. Truely made for India… sadly Nissan is not good at marketing and gimmicky features… and how come creta is a new car . Its an old car facelifted.
Nissan kicks is good choice current time for SUV lover's terms of performance, comfort , space and i love the Boot space
Check Moose test result for Kicks
@@carlover5763 get your facts corrected , i used to stay in mexico the test which you are mentioning here is the one conducted in nissan kicks sold there (brazil mexico) which is a small sub 4 meter one.. also the variant tested is without esc electronic stability control.
Nissan kicks was a small suv sold there in mexico and it looks like chevrolet beat .
how is the ergonomics ? is there any issue of not having a dead pedal?
@@dipeshbasu1510 and Nissan also giving discount s on kicks
MG Astor is truly the best package in terms of Safety, build quality, premiumness, technology like ADAS and Gender neutral looks no matter a female or a male drives it. I believe this is the future ready car because these days cars with ADAS is the new trend.
what about rear seat comfort? and suspension setup go test drive astor then decide
@@shobhitraj16 bro already done with the test drive. The rear seat comfort is good but not the best at its a sufficient space for two people and three people can sit but will be little uncomfortable and can be tiring for long drive. Rest the cushioning is good lacks little under thigh support and has more than sufficient over headspace for 5.11 person and decent for anyone above that height.
@@SS-re1ws thats why creta is the best😂
Its mileage is so poor, power poor
@@Sam.RoyalRider yes mileage is poor i am getting the lowest as 9 and highest 10.5 but the power for 1.5cvt did not disappoint me it was good yes there is a rubberband effect but that’s common in cvt. Also for more power you can go for turbo 1.3 which is 3cylinder.
I'm so impressed with the MG astor features😍😍😍
I love the design of Astor. Looks really premium compare to others in the segment.
For me Seltos
Seltos best looking in segment
Astor is easy winner
The most underrated and most value for money of this lot is surely Nissan Kicks. Excellent driving dynamice, ride quality, stability, engaging performance, superb steering, top notch NVH and last but not the least, a true tried and tested engine (same on entry level Mercedez too).
TT
Ok
Watch moose test. This car is unstable.
steering isnt great
@@tanmaysinha9632 I own one and I don’t have any issues.
I own Astor and I have no complains about it. I even tested creta and seltos before buying it. But surely in this price range Astor was giving much more than others like safety and tech.
True
Are you sure brother i am confused between seltoa creta kushaq Astor. Should I go for Astor black?
How much mileage do astor gives .
@@dhruvjain7934 kushaq
@@dhruvjain7934 astor or seltos both are excellent cars
Have been using Kushaq Ambition AT 1.0 since last two months. Simply awesome. Value for money.
True ,I am also a Kushq ambition at user..Car is mind blowing
Guys, you both,,,please give the fuel average if you checked.
Astor is actually an amazing car its good with specs and looks. I just got attracted with it.
Thanks Rachit. Impeccable comparison. Skoda Kushaq 1.5 for me 😀
I am feeling proud for being a kicks owner 😍😍😍😍😍
Which varient and year 😄
@@nitrogeared January 2021 xv 1.3
@@ashutoshyadav2962 bhai kitne meh pdi
Kaeka proud sabse bekaar hai kicks
@@kiddit_ Bhai tere ko kya problem hai mere ko proud feel hota hai to tere ko kahe pareshaani ho rahi hai
25000 mein 5 saal ki free service and uske service waale spare parts mile hain 5 saal tk ek Paisa nahi lagna Mera , 2 lakh tk dealer se discount Milla
Tin k dabba se best hai ,
Kahe faltu mein pareshan ho chacha 🙏😂
Very good video. My notes below,
Dimensions- kicks #1
Engine power - kicks #1
Ground clearance- kicks #1
NVH insulation- kicks #1
Torque - Kicks #1
Wheelbase - kicks #1
Suspension- kicks #1
Wipers quality - kicks #1
Off-road drive - kicks #1
Top model CVT on-price value for money- kicks #1
Highway overtaking - kicks #1
Luggage space- kicks #1
0-100km acceleration-> kicks #1 (you can see those comparisons on youtube)
Tyres qualify - Apollo Aptera- best in segment- kicks #1
Dashboard premiumness - astor #1
Electronic features - Astor #1
Feel good features - creta #1
Resale value - creta #1
One Chinese car, two Korean cars, two German cars and one Japanese .
P.s: I own a kicks cvt and my friends have pretty much all these models. All models are infact good midsized SUVs
Wow, Rachat is considering Nissan Kicks for comparison even in 2022 March. I own XV Premium CVT and it is way better than others. Astor is another classic car. One observation is Insulation in XV Premium CVT has best NVH levels in the class.
What could be resale value of 4 year old Kicks XL diesel?
For me Kushaq is the Winner in this Particular Comparison! 🔥
Wait till you drive Taigun
Aisa mat bol yar mai Astor soch rha tha aur tu confuse kr rha hai 🥲
I bought 1.5 Petrol MT astor sharp variant and I don't think at all that it is underpowered !!
It is more than sufficient and can go uphill very easy without any problem , moreover the crossover design makes it more aerodynamic .
What's the mileage? And does the sun roof shade being transparent create heat issues? Any issues on hills? Thanks in advance.
Test drove all the cars except the Astor, and went with the Kicks Turbo Petrol XV premium. It delivers immense power off the line, like in the video. True the automatic lacks punch at the top end, but shifting it to manual makes it an amazing car to drive. I have been finding excuses to drive the car everyday.. Its a joy! Yes, the interiors are drab..but i dont mind it.. Its functional and works for me, especially at such a low price point compared to the others. I kept up with an Audi A8 on the highway at over 120kmph without breaking a sweat.
Audi A8 guy was quite modest
Loved kicks
I Love your channel cuz u cover everything,
Very useful comparison, thank you Motoroctane 😊
Creta scored 3⭐.. As per GNCAP, it has unstable body structure..
Unfortunately the most selling🤫
Most detailed review 👌🏻.. Great job done by the Motor octane team❤️
Mg astor is best one in terms of looks and technology
I own creta diesel and i think one should go for it for sx executive as it's best and real value for money variant among all. I loved it's performance features and especially it's comfort is best among all
what is the mileage given by creta diesel in city as well as highway?
i am proud owner of Nissan Kicks
love to drive in city or highway or hilly areas
it is so comfortable to drive
even the milage which claim by company is 13-14 on Highway, i always had milage of 20-22 on Highway and sometimes I went for 24 kmpl
in city i usually get around 12-13 in Mumbai City which is too good
it's an amazing car. I have CVT turbo and has excellent pickup....
49:20 CRETA ki sabhi dimensions galat likhi hain. Plz add a correction team motoroctane if possible as it may mislead .
Liking it before watching this video 😊😊......I was waiting for this comparison.... thanks alot.....
Rachit bro,
I bought Creta after watching all your videos. And i am happy with Creta
Your all videos are good and you have been guiding everyone ✅✅
Nice comparison sir we also want a comparison on KIA Carens and Maruti Suzuki XL6 By the way love your review sir❤❤ I am a 15 years old and I am very passionate about automobiles sir and I gain so much of knowledge 🤓
Me too bro I'm 16 and I love cars too
I m 14
if you are okay with economy of 8-12 kmpl in petrol engine.. close your eyes and book carens. It will beat maruti in every way. If you want Diesel.. just go for carens blindly. If CNG, then go for ertiga CNG VXI. I have researched a lot ! Carens is better than XL6.
Already booked astor savvy 1.3 turbo it’s great package overall
True
MG Sahi hai but only drawback, CHINESE OWNED ....
This comparison was the need of the hour. Well done!
MG ASTOR 👑👑👑
Very honest review, i love the way you have explained about seltos and Astor features. If we talk about build quality and interior MG astor is far better than all, driving skoda & kick, features again MG astor with some distance, Best value Astor base and kick, stylish Seltos ( my personal opinion). Verdict if your budget is 12 then go for Astor and Kick, 15 to 18 can't say however Kusaq or seltos but if you have 20+ then try anyone but don't miss Astor bcz they offer ADAS value of money.
Bro Astor base model now cannot be booked and having 12-18 months waiting period
@@GauravYadav-in5tt some how agree, but most selling varient of any car has now longer waiting period. You can look at any car like XUV700 or kia carnes,. But here we are talking about waiting period, we are discussing best value of money.
Sadly, Astor offers ADAS and panoramic sun roof only with the high-end model - not even mid - that's out of budg for me at approx 21L in Hyderabad :(
@@wethekidsz yea but if are thinking for any other brand's top model u need to pay the same amount only but here additionally u ll get ADAS. Some features are still missing out it seems they are adding them with new model
@@GauravYadav-in5tt Tamilnadu 3week only
My choice Skoda Kushaq because I Love
* Looks
* Engine Refinement
* Day To Day Life Practical Features not like seltos/creta type bla blaa blaaa features
* Brand Value
* Built quality
Bhai Skoda ki kaha hai brand value...
@@harshudhani2432 Skoda ka bhut tagda brand Value...., Driving dynamics and Performance ka baat aata hai toh Skoda aur VW Best
@@saamarthnimaiyar3194 bro brand value hai but India mein... Maintenance...
@@saamarthnimaiyar3194 brand value se india me matlab resale value hota hai bhai
MG Astor is based on ZS ES’s platform
Which scored 5 stars Ancap and Global ncap so safest of all
you can also include 0-100 tests it will tell more about performance , great video as always
Thank you motoroctane!! This really helped!
Drive & handling
1. Kicks
2. Taigun
3. Kushaq
4. Astor
5. Seltos
6. Creta
Fuel Efficiency of Astor CVT & MT shown similar in your video. I think there is a significant difference. Nice video 👍
Yes both CVT and MT have more mileage than shown here
Slavia vs Verna vs Honda City or do consider any other car in this segment pls
Nice in depth analysis
51:47 correction* ventilated seats are not available in mg astor.
Am planning to buy nissan kicks xv 1.5 petrol. Kindly help me with the mileage details. Is it worth buying in 2022 instead of new brezza/ venue
Skoda kushaq is best in 1.5 litre turbo petrol🥰
Best in performance in all better than creta turbo
Hlo Bhaji...my friend is selling his Nissan Kicks Petrol ...just 7000kms run...and I'm planning to buy it as it's in my budget ..iv driven this Car .. seriously it's a dope ...can I go for it ..? What you say .. people say .. Nissan Spare parts are costly .. ?kindly give ur suggestion.
Thanks motoroctane for the Maha comparison. Great job done by Rachit sir and MO team
I like the efforts of u guys...really appreciated
Astor is love ❤️
Very Very Useful and Informative Video....
No Doubt Very Nice Video.....
Astor For the Win 🔥
Well covered. I think you covered more relevant points here. Keep it going
Great comparison. Skoda is good all rounder.
Proud Hyundai Creta Owner Power comfort features safety everything for the win ❤😎
Safety 🤣🤣🤣🤣 what a joke just 3 star
The way motoroctane team works on their content videos their hardwork will keep them growing on and on 😄 vese rachit bhaiya i am also sindhii
Absolutely loved the video rachit sir✌️
According to me Astor is winner in terms of look and features
MG ASTOR IS THE BEST.....SUPERB IN TERMS OF BEING A PREMIUM CAR 💙
Hi rachit. Thanks for this video. And keeping kicks in the comparison. U said kicks does not have functional roof rails. But I think it is functional and can take 100 kgs of load. Can u check
Planning for Kicks , pls advise .
Perfect comparison and very informative. Thank you
Just one correction in 49:25 - Creta is not a sub 4 meter car, it’s 4300 mm
No car here is sub 4 meter
i have driven creta, seltos, kicks, kushaq and taigun. Winner is Nissan kicks.. Damn powerful machine and perfect dynamics. Its a solid bit*h
Skoda kushaq is a clear winner...it provides an overall great package especially keeping build quality in mind...
As usual amazing detailed review
Nice comparison !
But why this type of comparison is not on base model or mid range models as those are most value for money.
Happy kicks owner, crossed 23,000Km in 16 months, amazing car in both highways and city traffic (Bangalore)
Which variant do you own? I'm from Bangalore too.
@@edwindaniel578 XV Turbo
This was a very useful review. However bit unfair to Nissan Kicks like you didn't mention it has remote start option with key. It has best ride and handling package better than any
other can as its dimension are larger than rest. As far as build quality is concern Kicks use Graphene Steel and feels like a tank it has maximum crumble zones the only downside
are its dated interior though manual top model looks decent.
Kushaq has gone down a bit on the quality and please don't mention anything about Creata high speed stability. The steering feels lifeless and suspension is too soft
korean cars are not meant for driving fun only features
I have personally driven my friend's Kicks.
Shit steering
Shit insulation
Lacks some necessary up to date features.
Graphene steel aint gonna be a buying point for people. They aint gonna go around slamming walls or some shit.
Its got good ground clearance. That's the only plus in my books.
Hi sir i am confused with kicks and kiger turbo
Please tell which should i buy
You could speak to our team of auto experts & seek professional car buying advice motoroctane.com/car-consultancy click on the link and book your call.
Motoroctane let me tell you one thing. Mark my words. You have a gem reviewer in your hands . Do not let him go. He is one of the most versatile car reviewer I have ever seen . He is an outstanding person with great speaking and reviewing skills. 👏 . Outstanding comparison. He is a 💎.
Bro, he is the founder of Motoroctane.
Oh my bad. But then too we all love him anyway . Even of he was not the CEO
Super work bro 👍. Kushaq 1.5 sure. With electric seat adjustments would be better
Indeed Astor looks premium.
Just test drive feels like not have enough power in natural aspirated.
Respect all your hardwork.Also how you fulfill our request.
Rear seat headrest cushion and one touch cruise control are also unique features of creta
One touch cruise control is also present on Astor and rear cushion can be added later
Bhi aap se aacha explain kisi ne nahi kiya
Jitne bhi vdos mene dekhe...
App har point tak gaye aur ek dum ache se explain Kiya ..bas dimensions me creta aur Aster apas me exchange ho gye shayed...
Kushaq wins the crown. No redundant statements needed.
Go by what market accept as a leader vs your requirement if you know the insights about it.
XUV 700, Jeep & Creta are the best for me
11:08 MG Astor doesn't get Ventilated seats & 49:23 Dimensions of Creta seems incorrect as shown in video. Nevertheless, booked MG Astor Savvy 👍🏻
Did you get the delivery ?
@@rudransh1593 unfortunately no. Thinking of getting it from different city.
@@randomly6824 Tamilnadu available with in 2week
@@antonypevin3189 That's great, hyderabad has long waiting period, cancelled it.
Nice in-depth review video indeed .. Thanks for this video Team ..Keep up the good work 👏👏👍👍
Is it just coincidence that Autocar and Motoroctane have dropped two very similar videos right around the exact same time? 🧐
Couldn't stop myself from clicking the thumbnail with a Nissan Kicks inside.
HARDWORK at PEAKS! superb video.. btw waiting for my ASTOR :)
Me too
This came in at the right time... I am planning to book kushaq dsg on monday !! Still confused B/W astor top and kushaq top.... heeellpppp
Same here but mostly i will go with skoda style 1.0 MT
CRETA💝
You Put great efforts Guys for this comparison !!👏👏
Nissan kicks 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Please review Kia Seltos GTX (O) variant also
Half way through the review and I'm liking what I'm seeing, Creta kushaq and Seltos seems good on top varient, Kicks is out of discussion here and Astor is good for the interior quality otherwise it ain't the best feature wise.
Watched the full review and If we are talking about top model I'll pick Creta over Seltos and then I'll pick kushaq. But if i were a enthusiast I'll buy kushaq over any other vehicle.
If you’re an “TRUE” motorcar enthusiast - you would’ve picked kicks. So effortlessly you ruled out it whereas it’s engine n drive quality is second to none among the lot.
Proud to be owner of kicks turbo solid car 4 lakhs less than others
You should add time stamps for such a long video...