11:20 Loved that face Instant meme there 😅👉 I like this version for one reason, wich is since Yoda is the greatest Jedi alive in that era, it would make sence that not even the great sith lord could defeat him, reminding that even the most skiled dark side user can not beat the strenght that comes with the light side, and that if it weren't for Palpatine having control of everything in the galaxy, he wouldn't have won. Wich brings back how tragic the whole situation is (the Jedi could have beeten Palpatine, but the roots of the dark side were spread to long).
It was kinda frustrating to me watching the latest starwars movie where you saw palpatines force lightning seem more visiblely more powerful than all the other movies 🎬
Yoda is just a character that we need to see way more of. There’s so much material that could be explored, and it would be so cool to see him use his full power.
True. I feel yoda is one of most powerful beings ever due to his many years of knowledge and training. I feel like this ending could have happened with yoda overpowering palpatine but I do understand why yoda did say he lost just from his perspective the only real win from this fight was yoda killing palpatine. Just imagine yoda harnessing some of the dark side or even turning to thr dark side he would be immensely powerful but i definitely would like to see yoda in his younger days.
Maybe even Yoda in the end is pushed to use dark side magic to almost kill Pal, then Pal just laughs at Yodas realisation that the Jedi cant win against the overpowered unhinged Sith, and we get the scene where a defeated Yoda leaves in hopelessness and shame
I've noticed something interesting. As Yoda is backing up Palapatine towards the central rising platform, you see Yoda's shadow is projected on the floor and slowly moves to the platform where you see his shadow increase gradually to a massive size, to the point it's much larger than either of their mortal bodies. Yoda's power transcends his body, this also gives a sense of how Palpatine felt, he's obviously nervous about taking on such a powerful master. Behind the scene's stuff like this really lets you into the mind of George Lucas.
Too scared to repeat content is the the line from then witch is bs cause they steal stuff and add to Star Wars and repeats stories all the time and that’s ok so stop lying imo
I actually think that both Yoda and Obi-Wan winning their battles, yet still losing overall has a greater impact. It kind of shows not only how much of a mastermind Palpatine is that he basically couldn't lose, but also puts emphasis on who the jedi are supposed to be. It was never about winning the battles, but about something greater. It kind of goes full circle when Luke is defeated by Sidious, but still wins by choosing to stand for something greater and redeeming Vader.
@Sheev Palpatine Them being arrogant (which they were), is not a bad point, but especially considering what the jedi are supposed to stand for makes for a shallow point in my opinion. Especially when you consider that Windu did beat Sidious fair and square according to Lucas and it wasn't his arrogance that defeated him then, but rather his very non-jedi attitude of wanting to execute a disarmed Palpatine straight away. The same can be said of the clone wars itself and the jedi order. Jedi aren't supposed to want power either, so trying to be objective about it and preparing better for it, wouldn't really be the jedi way either. As soon as the jedi wanted to win the war and beat Sidious they were always doomed, no matter how they tried to do it. That's what I think is the better lesson.
There was obviously a big power shift between Palpatine and Yoda in this one vs the actual film... They had a standoff and Yoda admitted that he couldn't defeat him... I wouldn't even say that Palpatine necessarily won... But he stayed and Yoda left whereas Yoda stayed and Palpatine left in this version so it's all a matter of perspective I suppose. Yoda's spirit had been broken so I always imagined that affected him a little too as he was conflicted internally. Also, maybe they didn't want to overshadow the biggest duel happening on Mustafar between Anakin and Obi-Wan, even though I feel it wouldn't have affected it much at all because their duel focuses more on their immense skills with a blade while this duel focused more on the mastery via the force. It would be cool to see an extended cut with some of this laced back in the film!
Direct power levels are only part of the story. The will of the force was at work here and this was destiny set in motion many generations before. Even if yoda was more powerful, the entire momentum of the darkside and the true will of the force was behind Palpatine.
Although I agree with that defeated Yoda made a greater impact on the creation of Empire than the escaping Palpatine could, there is also one crucial detail which I think is absolutely cool and it is shame they didn't use it. Those TV-bots there. That was an amazing detail. We saw that Palpatine claimed he was attacked by the Jedis. But this, this would add some more evidence to Palpatin's cause. A footage of him being attacked by the grandmaster himself. Propper cut of this footage (to hide lightnings and red blade) and he would have evidence to convince most people that Jedis really used deadly force against the democratically elected chancellor and thus Jedis attacked the foundations of the Republic. The initial speech in the senate, that was just words. I can imagine that many people of the galaxy would be confused by the speech. Jedis did what? But this footage with Yoda that would be the final strike to the public image of the Jedi Order. That would minimise any doubts about it. It would confirm his claims about the jedi treason, it would strengthen his position, it would justify the jedi purge in the eyes of the majority of the galaxy. That was the thing that puzzled me in that movie. How Palpatine managed to convince the galaxy so easily that Jedi Order betrayed them all with just his speech. Those TV-bots during the fight with Yoda, that is the answer.
I could've seen that moment where Yoda was closing his eyes be a flash to seeing Luke or something force ghosty to give him a bit more spark. I like what we got but it's always fun to wonder.
We didn't get the 'Kenobi' trailer but this is sick. I've seen ROTS, 100 times but love how Yoda takes the guards down here. Much better than them just walking out the room "guards get him"! Just imagine the dialogue as well...
Mecha Salesmans 4h+ ROTS Supercut (Siege of Mandalore + some 2003 CW Battle of Courscant + ROTS including some deleted Padme scenes) is GOATED It's sooooo well made
Man you're the best star wars RUclipsr out there, I remember subbing when you first started and now you have 3+ mil subs, you've come so far man Well done from the bottom of my heart
So this is actually a previs edit. Usually in previsualization there is a shitton of ideas being thrown around, just like this, and often times most of it never makes it into the final movie. Nowadays most big budged action movies use previs, especially Marvel, and oh I wish we were able to release all those different previs edits to the public, it's amazing to see how certain scenes originally could've looked completely different to what people see in the cinema. The whole previs thing pretty much started with George Lucas and EP3, but I thought it was only for the Mustafar fight bit, I had no idea they actually did it for other sequences as well! But yeah, working in previs made me realize how much really cool stuff gets thrown out for many different reasons (Sometimes very good reasons :D) and also how much of the really cool stuff doesn't come from the director but many individual artists that no one will ever hear about. There are some directors/producers/etc that have barely any vision and you'll just have to keep outputting different ideas until they finally find something they like
I feel like this is a truer yoda. When we are initially introduced to him and who he is in the originals is very different than how he was in the prequels. This shows how much more powerful Yoda truely was with the force, and that he would have won. He only admits defeat to the point that he couldnt defeat Sidious, the same can be said for this fight. Sidious was able to escape and he wasnt able to beat him in time. Sidious has always came off as the shadow puppeteer and corruptor. Not the all mighty god of the sith, as a pose to Yoda who is and always was said to be extremely powerful, but he is humble and the pinnacle of the jedi.
This. Besides, what better way to showcase his mastery of the force than showing him almost beating the manipulator in a straight fight, but realising by the time that Luke arrives that he's easier to beat when his overconfidence is at its highest.
Darth Sidious was the almighty god of the Sith though. Yoda was more powerful when they met because of their age difference and experience. Palpatine was around 80 years old and Yoda nearly 900, and yet the Emperor still hold his own against the most powerful Jedi of all time.
@@darth3261 thats my point. Sidious wasnt built up to be the moat powerful Sith. He was just the first Sith Lord to appear and attack the jedi in a 1000 years. Yoda on the other hand is directly refered to power throughout the movies. He is boasted as the strongest Jedi and the Jedi who taught the strongest Jedi of pas generations. Yes i get your point that Palpatine was impressive, but he also was made super powerful for no reason. He is a corruptor, a rogue who fights in the shadow, never revealing his true twisted nature. Not the most powerful evil the galaxy has ever seen.
Your videos help me get through life man, Im in such a dark place right now..watching you grow and seeing each upload get better and better has been amazing. Especially the fan theories. Much love.
The scene where Yoda summons the power of the force and overpowers Palpatine’s lightning was dope! However I agree that the original ending was better.
I feel like Sidious losing would have made more sense in his desperation to find Anakin after he was defeated by Obi Wan. Yoda bested him and he was forced to leave and gather his apprentice
I was just watching ROTS yesterday and noticed, in the scence where Anakin goes to Windu, telling him about palpatine being a sith lord, Anakin says “you’re gonna need me to arrest the chanciller” and Windu replies with a “no” but if you pay attention to Windu’s mouth as he talks, he’s actually saying something else, but it was edited and voice replaced, wonder if it has to do something with the version of Anakin actually going with Windu, and Palpatine taking his lightsaber to defend himself
This scene would have been so sick master yoda is the ultimate g o a t i also love how yoda shadow grows maybe sidius sensed vadar was in trouble and that's why he left the fight
I cut/deleted scene I would loved to see was Anakin killing all of the separatists like on camera sure we saw some of it from what was shown but I feel like we didn't see all of it
And include all the dialogue! Ani-Vader had some great one liners while cutting down the Separatists! "I am you're reward, and don't you find me handsome?!?"
That shot of the ruined senate chamber is so emotional. Like all this damage and destruction and for what? Really sets it up nicely, how the whole world fell and suffered from the greed and fear of a few. And you could say Yoda then fled so as not to hurt more people in the friendly fire, though I don't guess that would have the same impact, plus probably would have rang false as so many people were put under the boot of the Empire that probably could have been saved if Yoda had stayed to fight.
I believe this one is in the concept for that duel, just like Anakin vs Obi-wan fight choreography was easy longer. There was in a Tv spot, when both got a duel in a bridge or something like that.
I honestly prefer most of this scene to what we got in the Revenge of the Sith. Yoda losing never sat right with me. This is just my opinion of course. 🤷♂️
I still think it makes sense that Yoda lost. I think he fights valiantly but instead of going into the fight again he chooses to run away cause he knows that the Jedi are dead and Vader is rising out to power and that he's lost everything and the motivation to win.
I don’t think he lost but this ending is more sensible in all aspects for Star Wars. It would have empathised this bit so much more as yoda only had winning in his mind as killing palpatine that is why he said he lost even though yoda just fell which made it pretty impossible as palpatine was backing up at that point.
I honestly always wondered why you had never done a video on this before!! You must have been happily shocked to find there was footage you hadn’t seen 👌👌
Yeah that would have been sick in the Senate Auditorium with all the hovercams filming the fight that would have been pretty awesome if they added that
When I was younger, I always thought that Yoda would win but would do so in such a way that he would have to flee and go into hiding regardless. Thisbis pretty much what I imagined. That Yoda would defeat the Emperor but Palpatine would avoid being killed and escape. By that point, the Clones would arrive and Yoda would be forced to bail as Palpatine had survived and either escaped and/or made his way to the safety of the Clone lines and went back to playing the part of Supreme Chancellor. This in turn would leave Yoda to either try and fight all the Clones and get to Palpatine, or be killed in the attempt. Basically he'd lost his one window for victory and needed to flee - winning the battle but losing the war so to speak. . That would leave us with a situation where even though Yoda may have technically been the victor in the direct battle, Palpatine had won overall, returning to safety where Yoda could not get to him and being forced to retreat. Over time, Yoda would continue to age and get slowly weaker, meanwhile, the Empire would thrive and grow, its grip on the galaxy ever tightening. As such, the Emperor would become even more inaccessible while he was free to devote all his time and effort to studying the dark side and became stronger. To the point where Yoda's failing age, the Emperor's ever growing power and Palpatine's basically unreachable/untouchable position in the Empire would prevent Yoda from ever trying to assassinate or directly fight Palpatine again. Instead, he chooses to stay in exile and prepare to train the next generation of Jedi, passing on the knowledge, wisdom and teaching of the one being in the galaxy capable of actually defeating the Emperor. . This would add, in my opinion, more weight/gravity to Yoda's position as a Jedi Master and "the one who defeated the Emperor". It would make the fall of the Jedi and the Senate and it's transition into the Empire all the more tragic as it was that much closer to being prevented. It also makes Palpatine' s plan seem even more brilliant as even when he is defeated directly, he still won overall. And it also adds a plot point that a young, naive Luke can latch onto and maybe even get a bit confused/angry about - I.e. why is Yoda hiding all the way out in Degobah when he is the one being that can an has defeated the Emperor before - only to find out just how truly a monumentous task it was to even reach the Emperor. It could also add some foreshadowing to Yoda's eventual death (Which in my opinion was actually pretty lacking) with a clear indication being Yoda telling Luke that he is too old now and no longer possesses the strength to fight and defeat the Emperor as he once did, all the while indicating that the Emperor had only gotten stronger while Yoda himself had weakened. This would drive home how Luke really was the last hope of the galaxy and also really set the stage for the new generation becoming both the next stage of the Jedi and the foundation from which a peaceful galaxy would emerge. . Finally, it would add more weight to Yoda's failure, depending on how you look at it. He was even closer to saving the galaxy in this version and actually seemed to defeat the Emperor, only for that victory to be stolen away at the last minute by bad timing and bad luck. Yoda had "won" but at the same time had somehow lost far worse. He'd missed his one window of opportunity and proven unable to truly end the threat of the Emperor. While this did happen in canon also, the idea that Yoda still suffered and overall loss (one that the galaxy would pay dearly for) that mimicked the overall loss he had in canon DESPITE technically defeating the Emperor in combat, would make the failure all the closer to a victory but then, as such, all the more tragic. . It would also point out just how screwed the Jedi were even from the start. That once caught in Sidious' web, they were doomed from that moment on. So much so that even facing and defeating Sidious himself could not save them. Remember that the Jedi are most commonly ascribed their losing position due to the fact that they focussed on preparing for a repeat of the Jedi-Sith war. They approached the threat of Sith resurgence the same way as they did ages ago and it left them completely unprepared for the modern Sith who had changed, adapted and evolved to become something completely new, different and in the end, deadly. The idea that the Jedi would continue to fight using "outdated" tactics against an enemy that had evolved far past such attempts, was quite telling for the Jedi. This was exhibited in every one of the duels that takes place. Maul first shows up as an assassin and is met with Jedi force, being defeated (and his appearances in the Clone Wars only seem to strengthen Jedi belief that the Sith are returning as they did in days gone by). . Then Dooku appears and despite his penchant for diplomacy and aggressive politics, still ended up confronting the Jedi and the Republic directly, bringing war to them through the Separatist armies. He too is eventually met with the Jedi directly and he too is eventually overcome. Not once in this time was Palpatine even suspected as being the true Dark Lord because the Jedi were too taken with the more obvious and immediate threats right in front of them and were meeting with success well enough by employing direct, old war tactics to consider anything else. Believing the dark side was behind the Clone Wars in some capacity, the Jedi geared up for another galactic battle with the Sith that would never come. Of course, when it was revealed that Sidious was the Dark Lord, it was far too late for the Jedi to deal effectively. Hell, half the reason they were unable to deal was because their wartime tactics resulted in them spread all over the Galaxy. . Even once Mace was informed directly that Sidious was the Chancellor, his knee-jerk reaction was to fight directly, just as the Jedi always had. Moreover, for this to culminate in the last days of the Jedi Order, where Grand Master Yoda would end up fighting the Dark Lord of the Sith directly, just as if they were at war and then still losing said war DESPITE actually defeating Sidious in open combat, would be the perfect cherry on top of showing just how woefully unprepared mishuided the Jedi were and just how costly it was for them (and the galaxy at large) to have remained with their minds in the past, spending generations preparing for a war that would never happen - at least, not in the way they expected. . Basically, this version would drive home a few of the existing key plot points, add yet another layer of tragedy to the fall of the Jedi and the Republic, make the Sith victory that much more bitter for the good guys, make out Palpatine to be even MORE brilliant that he is already, cement just how truly outdated the Jedi ways were (giving the next generation - and what's left of the old - a completely new view and being more open yo change), point out more clearly that the Jedi were their own worst enemy and indicating the dangers of arrogance, overconfidence and complacency, set Yoda up as even MORE of a grand and legendary figure and leave a few interesting points lore-wise for Luke to explore as he grows and matures that would also show us how the galaxy has generally developed in the time between Revenge of the Sith and Yoda's appearance. Finally, I think it would add more gravity to Yoda both as a character and just how impactful/meaningful his death truly was.
@@diskritis2076+ I did. Thanks for noticing. I honestly kinda got a bit carried away if I'm being honest and I didn't really expect anyone to read it all after I saw how much of a wall of text it turned out to be. So thanks friend, I'm glad to know someone read it.
04:02 I did not know the Senate ceiling looked like that. The camera droids and the big lights and screens would have been so cool, as the two greatest Sith and Jedi battle it out. Maybe this stuff was cut for timing?
I really liked the broadcasting screens lighting up. And the destruction of the senate. Like the literal senate crumbling around them as they fight, is really cool.
i feel the part with ''TV broadcasting''droids would be super cool. you see, palpatin would show the whole corusant that his actions against the jedi are justified since he gets attacked again, i see maybe a short cut to the citizens not believing their eyes and shit, had potential
I don't know man. Openly admitting that he is a Sith Lord (which didn't have the best reputation I guess) and blasting lightningfrom his hands doesn't make him look very trustworthy and innocent does it?
It would of been cool to have some crazy shit throughout the fight, but Yoda still loses to show how scary the emperor is. Also I loved the part with the broadcast droids, it would of made so much sense to make people believe the Jedi are evil. But then you have the emperor who is with a red lightsaber and shooting lightning, which would hopefully raise eyebrows in the galaxy
While I prefer what we got in the film, I also always had a problem with how Yoda admits defeat. Sure, he slips and falls a long distance but he appears to be mostly uninjured. There are no clone troopers present to force him to flee. He just seems to give up at that point. The novelization (which I haven't read) may explain how Yoda was extremely tired, but the movie doesn't seem to show this very well.
In this deleted scene you can see why Yoda is so exhausted, man those power rains of Palpatine looks more strong + powerful, Yoda he had to try much harder
These animatics have been floating around on the internet for like ten years. There's also animatics for the grievous chase scene and the order 66 scene.
Im 50/50 on it. Allot of shots are more badass than the original fight but I also 100% agree with removing the flying saucer portions and making it so Palps over powers Yoda and Yoda is the one to escape. Otherwise why wouldn't Yoda just further pursue that fight in the near future instead of going into exile for his failure?
You guys seem to be enjoying this and wanted it in the movie but even when I imagine this fully rendered it just looks so funny to me 🤣 I did one of those really loud snort laughs when he started wall running
6:14 Imagine if Yoda's eyes turned yellow for that moment, like he had to use the Dark Side to survive. Yoda would consider this as failure and exile himself even though he defeated Sidious, it wasn't the Jedi way.
Bro I’m excited for your sabers. I hope I have the opportunity to buy one. If you can I would appreciate a pre announcement that says when the exact time your saber site will open. I fr will be one of first few orders !!!
This is cool, but I can see why things were cut. One thing that I wish they kept in was the presence of cameras. The emperor captured footage of Yoda attacking him, so it would make sense that when palpatine addresses the senate, he shows edited footage of that attack to everyone.
I like the events that bridge the gaps between the scene cuts and kind of show Yoda as a challenge and threat to Palpatine(which is most of this really). BUT, i do like the ending a lot more. It gives credence to the fact that Palpatine was still stronger than Yoda.
I thought in the novelization of ROTS, which I really liked, was Yoda thinking he HAD the edge, but he saw how the Sith evolved where the Jedi Order became stale, lost…. So Yoda made the decision to escape and train the next generation of Jedi Knights and go for the wise, long term play, like the Sith when they went underground than push his advantage and risk it all. I think Lucas wanted to push, “Good always overcomes evil, but if it isn’t wise it gives evil a longer and longer reign before it is overcome.” Matthew Stover’s ROTS novelization seemed to stress that to me at any rate. The whole book how patients and powerful and creeping the dark is - but even a little candle flame can keep it at bay. …and how love can light stars.
Hey, let's not miss that power kick in the chest by Yoda there while Palpatine zapping lightnings! He could slip right through between the strikes! The literal visualization of how Yoda's size is his advantage vs big guys.
I wish that they had kept bits of this battle in the ROTS. I love seeing the cam droids record the encounter. I imagine that Sidious would have watched this over and over again!!!
Something I thought of when you mentioned Yoda flying further because of his size. Never really thought of it but it was basically even but the emperor technically had the high ground on yoda similar to obi wan on anakin. I wonder if they did that on purpose. Lastly I never took it as yoda lost to him I thought he meant failed as in failed to kill the emperor. Also the emperor ran first then yoda ran away
The ROTS scene we got is what we needed, Yoda needed to fail otherwise it would have been weird that he stayed in exile for so long. However with this deleted scene it would be been cool to combine them, I really liked at the beginning of the fight it appeared that Yoda had the upper hand. That would have been exciting and then devastating to see him lose.
The second the camera drones got involved and started broadcasting, even locally, the scene had to be deleted. The Emperor would have been shown to be a Sith, and all it would have taken is for someone to have intercepted the broadcast for the "the Jedi rebellion has been put down" narrative to fall apart.
This was really cool but it’s definitely good that it went the way it went. It adds more to yoda’s (the Jedi’s as a whole) downfall. He lost the war, obviously. But he lost the battle. That had to have hit his ego in some way, right? That’s the reason behind their downfall anyway. They were so arrogant in their power. Yoda, himself, was arrogant. He thought he could beat sidings but he didn’t, technically. He had to flee. Very damaging. The movie was beautifully done, but still. This was really cool and I love seeing alternate versions. Theories are amazing!
I like how Yoda's shadow looms larger & larger over Pali as he is being backed up. Also seeing Yoda running across the walls & doing a few combative techniques was cool too. It's frustrating how much they cut out of this scene. Episode III could've been so much better.
Do you think that if those little camera droids recording the fight dropped down like they did here change anything since the public would have seen Palpatine's holding his own against Yoda?
I would of made the fight go longer but I do appreciate looking back the synergy the Senate fight and the Mustarfar fight. Thats just my feeling though, ideally Episode III would of been two movies but for what we got, its good.
they could have taken a couple things out of this, which they obviously did haha but the end part of this battle would've been nice with the actual ending of the battle we got in the actual movie. like have this deleted scene run up to where Yoda starts absorbing the force lightning and as Palp approaches him insert the force absorption or whatever the exact term is when he and palp were thrown back and run the rest of the movie as is.
There are alot of elements to the previs that are better overall imho. The way the drones came down had a huge impact. Because prior to this there wasnt much televised or public about the betrayal of the jedi. With tbis duel, palps could have very well turned the entire galaxy against the jedi with evidence instead of just saying the jedi betrayed him.
While thats true. Its not a crime to be a sith in the republic. Its a crime to be a terrorist or a genocidal maniac. As the sith of old always were. I could see the galaxy still going for what palpatine was saying. The jedi are taking over. Thats what I was getting at. Also, at this point in the timeline the galaxy at large had all but forgotten about the existence of the sith anyways.
@@kingandros4819 To be a sith you have to kill. Palps has killed before. Plus him being evil would explain why the CIS knew republic plans during the war. Would explain another really. Also Dooku said he was a sith. So people would put Palps in the same boat as him. I'm sure they can connect the dots.
I liked it for the most part. Especially where its like destroyed since like he literally destroyed the senate by transforming it into the empire. Him flying away feels a witch flies away though but I still like it
Oh, where is your fan movie ? I can't find it, and I loved it !!!!! I was wondering if you made part 2 yet ? If so, I really want to see it. I heard you say in a recent video that it is Mace who's still alive, so I'm dying to check it out. If you have a minute to send the link, that'd be awesome !!!! Thanks for all that you do !!!!! You make Star Wars better, and that will always be George's legacy !!!!! :-)
I really like the rock, paper, scissors effect they pretty much used in Ep 3. Mace Windu had the emperor beat but Yoda couldn't pull it off. It's interesting to think what would have happened if Yoda went to fight Anakin or if Mace Windu and Anakin straight up fought.
2:57 Yodas casting a Shadowy silhouette nearly devouring Palatine. Would've been epic. Edit: And Yoda cutting through floor. To cut off Palpatines retreat.
What I would have done would be to extend the battle like in the deleted scenes, but with the difference that the main reason Yoda has to retreat is not just because of Sidious having the high ground, but also because Clone Troopers start arriving with all the types of weapons, making the fight even harder for the Grand Master. The fight will still continue for some time, but eventually, after killing or evading various CTs, and seeing how cannot deal significant damage to the Dark Lord, and with more and more reinforcements arriving, he will then retreat.... But not before using the remaining energy he has to execute a powerful Force Repulse or Wave (one more less OP like the one Pong Krell did when the 212th and 501st confronted him in the HQ chamber of Umbara, or even a more OP and devastating one like the ones of Starkiller). With the Repulse or Wave, all Clone Troopers remaining and coming (apart from Darth Sidious), will be knocked out at fast speeds against the walls, leaving them out for a while out of combat, giving them Yoda the time enough to escape and rendezvous with Bail Organa.
Yeah there’s quite a few parts of this that I like better than the original. He shows that Yoda has the upper hand and lightsaber combat at the part where he almost finished by the force lightning is awesome.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Do you prefer this or what we officially got in Revenge of the Sith?
This is more, "epic" IMO. I think the production we got was easier to animate in CGI though. I saw Bombastic's vid on this cut. Guy cracks me up
i prefer that sidious beat yoda in the film. that way he seems even stronger
11:20 Loved that face
Instant meme there 😅👉
I like this version for one reason, wich is since Yoda is the greatest Jedi alive in that era, it would make sence that not even the great sith lord could defeat him, reminding that even the most skiled dark side user can not beat the strenght that comes with the light side, and that if it weren't for Palpatine having control of everything in the galaxy, he wouldn't have won. Wich brings back how tragic the whole situation is (the Jedi could have beeten Palpatine, but the roots of the dark side were spread to long).
It was kinda frustrating to me watching the latest starwars movie where you saw palpatines force lightning seem more visiblely more powerful than all the other movies 🎬
it would have been insane if their battle destroyed the one building that represented democracy
Yoda is just a character that we need to see way more of. There’s so much material that could be explored, and it would be so cool to see him use his full power.
True. I feel yoda is one of most powerful beings ever due to his many years of knowledge and training. I feel like this ending could have happened with yoda overpowering palpatine but I do understand why yoda did say he lost just from his perspective the only real win from this fight was yoda killing palpatine. Just imagine yoda harnessing some of the dark side or even turning to thr dark side he would be immensely powerful but i definitely would like to see yoda in his younger days.
Imagine if Yoda and Sidious had a way longer fight scene where they just kept trading blows and barely avoiding a fatal blow from the other.
Maybe even Yoda in the end is pushed to use dark side magic to almost kill Pal, then Pal just laughs at Yodas realisation that the Jedi cant win against the overpowered unhinged Sith, and we get the scene where a defeated Yoda leaves in hopelessness and shame
@@Tjp7624 Dude that would be sick! Super deep too.
@@Tjp7624 would be cool but doesn’t fit yoda’s character
@@Jacob_267 Indeed.
I've noticed something interesting. As Yoda is backing up Palapatine towards the central rising platform, you see Yoda's shadow is projected on the floor and slowly moves to the platform where you see his shadow increase gradually to a massive size, to the point it's much larger than either of their mortal bodies. Yoda's power transcends his body, this also gives a sense of how Palpatine felt, he's obviously nervous about taking on such a powerful master. Behind the scene's stuff like this really lets you into the mind of George Lucas.
I couldn’t agree more.
I just want Revenge of the Sith TV series that fleshed out all the ideas as described in the novelization.
I thought they would of did it with the clone wars but they smoothly skipped that part and showed us what others was doing during the timeline
would be cool but it doesn't make any sense for them to do that and put that money in
Too scared to repeat content is the the line from then witch is bs cause they steal stuff and add to Star Wars and repeats stories all the time and that’s ok so stop lying imo
@@royjones0824 it'd be good to get a season of clone wars using unused arcs. Wouldn't need to be in chronological order.
PLEASE TAKE MY MONEY
I actually think that both Yoda and Obi-Wan winning their battles, yet still losing overall has a greater impact. It kind of shows not only how much of a mastermind Palpatine is that he basically couldn't lose, but also puts emphasis on who the jedi are supposed to be. It was never about winning the battles, but about something greater.
It kind of goes full circle when Luke is defeated by Sidious, but still wins by choosing to stand for something greater and redeeming Vader.
Very deep thought you have here. I like it.
I like this a lot and agree with you completely.
Excellent point. What I like about the overall prequel trilogy is that for every battle, no matter who wins, the EMPIRE wins.
@Sheev Palpatine Them being arrogant (which they were), is not a bad point, but especially considering what the jedi are supposed to stand for makes for a shallow point in my opinion. Especially when you consider that Windu did beat Sidious fair and square according to Lucas and it wasn't his arrogance that defeated him then, but rather his very non-jedi attitude of wanting to execute a disarmed Palpatine straight away.
The same can be said of the clone wars itself and the jedi order. Jedi aren't supposed to want power either, so trying to be objective about it and preparing better for it, wouldn't really be the jedi way either. As soon as the jedi wanted to win the war and beat Sidious they were always doomed, no matter how they tried to do it. That's what I think is the better lesson.
Fortunately we are getting that in a sense through grogu. He will probably never reach yodas level, but who knows?
*UNLIMITED POWER* !!!
My guy I be seeing you around all the time on RUclips comments.😂😂
Nice won
James 😭
Who stands with Boba Fett in the aftercredits of The Mandalorian Season 2?
Cara Dune or Fennec Shand?
@@michaelcharlesthearchangel probably fennec
Holy crap, that deleted scene would've been frickin insane.
There was obviously a big power shift between Palpatine and Yoda in this one vs the actual film... They had a standoff and Yoda admitted that he couldn't defeat him... I wouldn't even say that Palpatine necessarily won... But he stayed and Yoda left whereas Yoda stayed and Palpatine left in this version so it's all a matter of perspective I suppose. Yoda's spirit had been broken so I always imagined that affected him a little too as he was conflicted internally.
Also, maybe they didn't want to overshadow the biggest duel happening on Mustafar between Anakin and Obi-Wan, even though I feel it wouldn't have affected it much at all because their duel focuses more on their immense skills with a blade while this duel focused more on the mastery via the force. It would be cool to see an extended cut with some of this laced back in the film!
Direct power levels are only part of the story. The will of the force was at work here and this was destiny set in motion many generations before. Even if yoda was more powerful, the entire momentum of the darkside and the true will of the force was behind Palpatine.
this.
Although I agree with that defeated Yoda made a greater impact on the creation of Empire than the escaping Palpatine could, there is also one crucial detail which I think is absolutely cool and it is shame they didn't use it. Those TV-bots there. That was an amazing detail. We saw that Palpatine claimed he was attacked by the Jedis. But this, this would add some more evidence to Palpatin's cause. A footage of him being attacked by the grandmaster himself. Propper cut of this footage (to hide lightnings and red blade) and he would have evidence to convince most people that Jedis really used deadly force against the democratically elected chancellor and thus Jedis attacked the foundations of the Republic.
The initial speech in the senate, that was just words. I can imagine that many people of the galaxy would be confused by the speech. Jedis did what? But this footage with Yoda that would be the final strike to the public image of the Jedi Order. That would minimise any doubts about it. It would confirm his claims about the jedi treason, it would strengthen his position, it would justify the jedi purge in the eyes of the majority of the galaxy.
That was the thing that puzzled me in that movie. How Palpatine managed to convince the galaxy so easily that Jedi Order betrayed them all with just his speech. Those TV-bots during the fight with Yoda, that is the answer.
the rebellion started nearly straight away so it wasnt bought by most people, people were scared of his power and submitted
I could've seen that moment where Yoda was closing his eyes be a flash to seeing Luke or something force ghosty to give him a bit more spark. I like what we got but it's always fun to wonder.
We can't stop here, this is bat country!
yesss maybe that was the exact moment that Padme gave birth and Luke and Leia were born!
We didn't get the 'Kenobi' trailer but this is sick. I've seen ROTS, 100 times but love how Yoda takes the guards down here.
Much better than them just walking out the room "guards get him"! Just imagine the dialogue as well...
Who stands with Boba Fett in the end of the aftercredits of The Mandalorian Season 2?
Cara Dune or a character named Fennec Shand?
Mecha Salesmans 4h+ ROTS Supercut (Siege of Mandalore + some 2003 CW Battle of Courscant + ROTS including some deleted Padme scenes) is GOATED
It's sooooo well made
I really like the moment where Yoda's shadow looms large, just before the "matrix" part you mentioned.
I love the bit where Sidious destroyed the monitor with Yoda's face like a final "fuck you" lol
Man you're the best star wars RUclipsr out there, I remember subbing when you first started and now you have 3+ mil subs, you've come so far man Well done from the bottom of my heart
Fax
Thanks man it's been a huge journey but means a lot for sticking with me all these years 👊
He was better before the fan film released.
So this is actually a previs edit. Usually in previsualization there is a shitton of ideas being thrown around, just like this, and often times most of it never makes it into the final movie.
Nowadays most big budged action movies use previs, especially Marvel, and oh I wish we were able to release all those different previs edits to the public, it's amazing to see how certain scenes originally could've looked completely different to what people see in the cinema.
The whole previs thing pretty much started with George Lucas and EP3, but I thought it was only for the Mustafar fight bit, I had no idea they actually did it for other sequences as well!
But yeah, working in previs made me realize how much really cool stuff gets thrown out for many different reasons (Sometimes very good reasons :D) and also how much of the really cool stuff doesn't come from the director but many individual artists that no one will ever hear about.
There are some directors/producers/etc that have barely any vision and you'll just have to keep outputting different ideas until they finally find something they like
I feel like this is a truer yoda. When we are initially introduced to him and who he is in the originals is very different than how he was in the prequels.
This shows how much more powerful Yoda truely was with the force, and that he would have won. He only admits defeat to the point that he couldnt defeat Sidious, the same can be said for this fight. Sidious was able to escape and he wasnt able to beat him in time.
Sidious has always came off as the shadow puppeteer and corruptor. Not the all mighty god of the sith, as a pose to Yoda who is and always was said to be extremely powerful, but he is humble and the pinnacle of the jedi.
This. Besides, what better way to showcase his mastery of the force than showing him almost beating the manipulator in a straight fight, but realising by the time that Luke arrives that he's easier to beat when his overconfidence is at its highest.
Darth Sidious was the almighty god of the Sith though.
Yoda was more powerful when they met because of their age difference and experience. Palpatine was around 80 years old and Yoda nearly 900, and yet the Emperor still hold his own against the most powerful Jedi of all time.
@@darth3261 thats my point. Sidious wasnt built up to be the moat powerful Sith. He was just the first Sith Lord to appear and attack the jedi in a 1000 years. Yoda on the other hand is directly refered to power throughout the movies. He is boasted as the strongest Jedi and the Jedi who taught the strongest Jedi of pas generations.
Yes i get your point that Palpatine was impressive, but he also was made super powerful for no reason. He is a corruptor, a rogue who fights in the shadow, never revealing his true twisted nature. Not the most powerful evil the galaxy has ever seen.
Your videos help me get through life man, Im in such a dark place right now..watching you grow and seeing each upload get better and better has been amazing. Especially the fan theories. Much love.
Hang in there friend! It's always darkest right before the light! May The Force Be With You, Always!
Keep your head up man. Hope things get better
The scene where Yoda summons the power of the force and overpowers Palpatine’s lightning was dope! However I agree that the original ending was better.
there is just so much unseen revenge of the sith content i love it 🤧🤧
I feel like Sidious losing would have made more sense in his desperation to find Anakin after he was defeated by Obi Wan. Yoda bested him and he was forced to leave and gather his apprentice
And Yoda is exhausted for the fight, that explains why Yoda let's Palpatine escape
I was just watching ROTS yesterday and noticed, in the scence where Anakin goes to Windu, telling him about palpatine being a sith lord, Anakin says “you’re gonna need me to arrest the chanciller” and Windu replies with a “no” but if you pay attention to Windu’s mouth as he talks, he’s actually saying something else, but it was edited and voice replaced, wonder if it has to do something with the version of Anakin actually going with Windu, and Palpatine taking his lightsaber to defend himself
2:57 that shadow the tiny but powerful master yoda casts over Palpatine woulda been EPIC
This scene would have been so sick master yoda is the ultimate g o a t i also love how yoda shadow grows maybe sidius sensed vadar was in trouble and that's why he left the fight
This is soooo fkn cool.
I genuinely didn't know this was actually out there.
I hope you saw the Maul vs Sidious one.
I cut/deleted scene I would loved to see was Anakin killing all of the separatists like on camera sure we saw some of it from what was shown but I feel like we didn't see all of it
And include all the dialogue! Ani-Vader had some great one liners while cutting down the Separatists! "I am you're reward, and don't you find me handsome?!?"
“I can see why George didn’t put this in”
Yet he put in palpatines twirling screech and his bouncing around during the battle with mace
The screech was so good tho and it does explain how the other jedi died quickly
Seeing the destruction of the Senate building would’ve been admittedly cool to add to the fight
These are some of my favorites from you
Really puts into perspective of the scope of
“Judge me by my size, do you?”
the running around on the walls while palps fried everything in his office was awesome, i wish they kept that. and it'd make for some good memes lol
That shot of the ruined senate chamber is so emotional. Like all this damage and destruction and for what? Really sets it up nicely, how the whole world fell and suffered from the greed and fear of a few. And you could say Yoda then fled so as not to hurt more people in the friendly fire, though I don't guess that would have the same impact, plus probably would have rang false as so many people were put under the boot of the Empire that probably could have been saved if Yoda had stayed to fight.
10:06 “I know that Palpatine is in control of the Senate anyway…”
I literally threw my hands in the air and said “he *is* the Senate !”
I believe this one is in the concept for that duel, just like Anakin vs Obi-wan fight choreography was easy longer. There was in a Tv spot, when both got a duel in a bridge or something like that.
I liked the surveillance droids. That’s an interesting base for a fan fiction - what if Yoda and Palpatine’s duel was streamed live on air.
I honestly prefer most of this scene to what we got in the Revenge of the Sith. Yoda losing never sat right with me. This is just my opinion of course. 🤷♂️
I still think it makes sense that Yoda lost. I think he fights valiantly but instead of going into the fight again he chooses to run away cause he knows that the Jedi are dead and Vader is rising out to power and that he's lost everything and the motivation to win.
I don’t think he lost but this ending is more sensible in all aspects for Star Wars. It would have empathised this bit so much more as yoda only had winning in his mind as killing palpatine that is why he said he lost even though yoda just fell which made it pretty impossible as palpatine was backing up at that point.
Hey theory I’m trying to post while u can see. I love you man, still my role model In life and in fitness. Thank you for everythign
I honestly always wondered why you had never done a video on this before!! You must have been happily shocked to find there was footage you hadn’t seen 👌👌
Yoda's shadow dwarfing Sideous [as he walks backwards towards the senate pod], should've stayed in!!
Happy thanksgiving! Thanks for always providing great content
This ripe for memeage. Good golly. Even the text for cutting away to Mustafar was in comic sans 😂😂😭 amazing
Yeah that would have been sick in the Senate Auditorium with all the hovercams filming the fight that would have been pretty awesome if they added that
@8:36 Yoda's looming shadow is too cool.
When I was younger, I always thought that Yoda would win but would do so in such a way that he would have to flee and go into hiding regardless. Thisbis pretty much what I imagined. That Yoda would defeat the Emperor but Palpatine would avoid being killed and escape. By that point, the Clones would arrive and Yoda would be forced to bail as Palpatine had survived and either escaped and/or made his way to the safety of the Clone lines and went back to playing the part of Supreme Chancellor. This in turn would leave Yoda to either try and fight all the Clones and get to Palpatine, or be killed in the attempt. Basically he'd lost his one window for victory and needed to flee - winning the battle but losing the war so to speak.
.
That would leave us with a situation where even though Yoda may have technically been the victor in the direct battle, Palpatine had won overall, returning to safety where Yoda could not get to him and being forced to retreat. Over time, Yoda would continue to age and get slowly weaker, meanwhile, the Empire would thrive and grow, its grip on the galaxy ever tightening. As such, the Emperor would become even more inaccessible while he was free to devote all his time and effort to studying the dark side and became stronger. To the point where Yoda's failing age, the Emperor's ever growing power and Palpatine's basically unreachable/untouchable position in the Empire would prevent Yoda from ever trying to assassinate or directly fight Palpatine again. Instead, he chooses to stay in exile and prepare to train the next generation of Jedi, passing on the knowledge, wisdom and teaching of the one being in the galaxy capable of actually defeating the Emperor.
.
This would add, in my opinion, more weight/gravity to Yoda's position as a Jedi Master and "the one who defeated the Emperor". It would make the fall of the Jedi and the Senate and it's transition into the Empire all the more tragic as it was that much closer to being prevented. It also makes Palpatine' s plan seem even more brilliant as even when he is defeated directly, he still won overall. And it also adds a plot point that a young, naive Luke can latch onto and maybe even get a bit confused/angry about - I.e. why is Yoda hiding all the way out in Degobah when he is the one being that can an has defeated the Emperor before - only to find out just how truly a monumentous task it was to even reach the Emperor. It could also add some foreshadowing to Yoda's eventual death (Which in my opinion was actually pretty lacking) with a clear indication being Yoda telling Luke that he is too old now and no longer possesses the strength to fight and defeat the Emperor as he once did, all the while indicating that the Emperor had only gotten stronger while Yoda himself had weakened. This would drive home how Luke really was the last hope of the galaxy and also really set the stage for the new generation becoming both the next stage of the Jedi and the foundation from which a peaceful galaxy would emerge.
.
Finally, it would add more weight to Yoda's failure, depending on how you look at it. He was even closer to saving the galaxy in this version and actually seemed to defeat the Emperor, only for that victory to be stolen away at the last minute by bad timing and bad luck. Yoda had "won" but at the same time had somehow lost far worse. He'd missed his one window of opportunity and proven unable to truly end the threat of the Emperor. While this did happen in canon also, the idea that Yoda still suffered and overall loss (one that the galaxy would pay dearly for) that mimicked the overall loss he had in canon DESPITE technically defeating the Emperor in combat, would make the failure all the closer to a victory but then, as such, all the more tragic.
.
It would also point out just how screwed the Jedi were even from the start. That once caught in Sidious' web, they were doomed from that moment on. So much so that even facing and defeating Sidious himself could not save them. Remember that the Jedi are most commonly ascribed their losing position due to the fact that they focussed on preparing for a repeat of the Jedi-Sith war. They approached the threat of Sith resurgence the same way as they did ages ago and it left them completely unprepared for the modern Sith who had changed, adapted and evolved to become something completely new, different and in the end, deadly. The idea that the Jedi would continue to fight using "outdated" tactics against an enemy that had evolved far past such attempts, was quite telling for the Jedi. This was exhibited in every one of the duels that takes place. Maul first shows up as an assassin and is met with Jedi force, being defeated (and his appearances in the Clone Wars only seem to strengthen Jedi belief that the Sith are returning as they did in days gone by).
.
Then Dooku appears and despite his penchant for diplomacy and aggressive politics, still ended up confronting the Jedi and the Republic directly, bringing war to them through the Separatist armies. He too is eventually met with the Jedi directly and he too is eventually overcome. Not once in this time was Palpatine even suspected as being the true Dark Lord because the Jedi were too taken with the more obvious and immediate threats right in front of them and were meeting with success well enough by employing direct, old war tactics to consider anything else. Believing the dark side was behind the Clone Wars in some capacity, the Jedi geared up for another galactic battle with the Sith that would never come. Of course, when it was revealed that Sidious was the Dark Lord, it was far too late for the Jedi to deal effectively. Hell, half the reason they were unable to deal was because their wartime tactics resulted in them spread all over the Galaxy.
.
Even once Mace was informed directly that Sidious was the Chancellor, his knee-jerk reaction was to fight directly, just as the Jedi always had. Moreover, for this to culminate in the last days of the Jedi Order, where Grand Master Yoda would end up fighting the Dark Lord of the Sith directly, just as if they were at war and then still losing said war DESPITE actually defeating Sidious in open combat, would be the perfect cherry on top of showing just how woefully unprepared mishuided the Jedi were and just how costly it was for them (and the galaxy at large) to have remained with their minds in the past, spending generations preparing for a war that would never happen - at least, not in the way they expected.
.
Basically, this version would drive home a few of the existing key plot points, add yet another layer of tragedy to the fall of the Jedi and the Republic, make the Sith victory that much more bitter for the good guys, make out Palpatine to be even MORE brilliant that he is already, cement just how truly outdated the Jedi ways were (giving the next generation - and what's left of the old - a completely new view and being more open yo change), point out more clearly that the Jedi were their own worst enemy and indicating the dangers of arrogance, overconfidence and complacency, set Yoda up as even MORE of a grand and legendary figure and leave a few interesting points lore-wise for Luke to explore as he grows and matures that would also show us how the galaxy has generally developed in the time between Revenge of the Sith and Yoda's appearance. Finally, I think it would add more gravity to Yoda both as a character and just how impactful/meaningful his death truly was.
Man you worked a lot on this comment
@@diskritis2076+
I did. Thanks for noticing. I honestly kinda got a bit carried away if I'm being honest and I didn't really expect anyone to read it all after I saw how much of a wall of text it turned out to be. So thanks friend, I'm glad to know someone read it.
7:23 Damn, that stormtrooper aim kicked in immediately, lol.
04:02 I did not know the Senate ceiling looked like that. The camera droids and the big lights and screens would have been so cool, as the two greatest Sith and Jedi battle it out. Maybe this stuff was cut for timing?
I really liked the broadcasting screens lighting up. And the destruction of the senate. Like the literal senate crumbling around them as they fight, is really cool.
i feel the part with ''TV broadcasting''droids would be super cool. you see, palpatin would show the whole corusant that his actions against the jedi are justified since he gets attacked again, i see maybe a short cut to the citizens not believing their eyes and shit, had potential
I don't know man. Openly admitting that he is a Sith Lord (which didn't have the best reputation I guess) and blasting lightningfrom his hands doesn't make him look very trustworthy and innocent does it?
It would of been cool to have some crazy shit throughout the fight, but Yoda still loses to show how scary the emperor is.
Also I loved the part with the broadcast droids, it would of made so much sense to make people believe the Jedi are evil. But then you have the emperor who is with a red lightsaber and shooting lightning, which would hopefully raise eyebrows in the galaxy
06:52 now this is something I wish we saw. Blasting shit with lightening looks wicked, but I don’t rlly like him losing.
While I prefer what we got in the film, I also always had a problem with how Yoda admits defeat. Sure, he slips and falls a long distance but he appears to be mostly uninjured. There are no clone troopers present to force him to flee. He just seems to give up at that point.
The novelization (which I haven't read) may explain how Yoda was extremely tired, but the movie doesn't seem to show this very well.
The novel does explain how over a thousand years, the Jedi never changed, but the Sith do. Yoda realizes this, which explains why he went into exile.
@@jedironbo Still, it would have been nice to get a proper explanation beyond "Failed, I have" without having to check ancillary content
In this deleted scene you can see why Yoda is so exhausted, man those power rains of Palpatine looks more strong + powerful, Yoda he had to try much harder
Using the cameras to broadcast Master Yoda’s assassination attempt.
I've seen this one before. I think it's on the 2011 Bluray release
Hahaha that Yoda screne is awesome! I died laughing at him running on the wall haha
These animatics have been floating around on the internet for like ten years. There's also animatics for the grievous chase scene and the order 66 scene.
Im 50/50 on it. Allot of shots are more badass than the original fight but I also 100% agree with removing the flying saucer portions and making it so Palps over powers Yoda and Yoda is the one to escape. Otherwise why wouldn't Yoda just further pursue that fight in the near future instead of going into exile for his failure?
02:57 look at Yoda’s shadow over Palpatine there. To quote Game of Thrones, ‘A small man can cast a very large shadow.’
Wow that was cool. They probably cut this longer fight for pacing. It does go on for a bit compared to the final cut.
You guys seem to be enjoying this and wanted it in the movie but even when I imagine this fully rendered it just looks so funny to me 🤣 I did one of those really loud snort laughs when he started wall running
I really like the music they had while palpating was running. Sounds like a track from the clone wars
6:14 Imagine if Yoda's eyes turned yellow for that moment, like he had to use the Dark Side to survive. Yoda would consider this as failure and exile himself even though he defeated Sidious, it wasn't the Jedi way.
That wouldn't been interesting - if not a little bad-ass.
Bro I’m excited for your sabers. I hope I have the opportunity to buy one. If you can I would appreciate a pre announcement that says when the exact time your saber site will open. I fr will be one of first few orders !!!
Yoda: “…never for attack”
Literally kills two innocent guards like puppets
No way did they die..
Innocent? They’re palps guards…..
This is cool, but I can see why things were cut. One thing that I wish they kept in was the presence of cameras. The emperor captured footage of Yoda attacking him, so it would make sense that when palpatine addresses the senate, he shows edited footage of that attack to everyone.
It’s on the blu ray that has all the extra stuff for prequel 1-3 on it. Go into revenge of the sith then it’s in there. I watched it last week 👍☺️
I like the events that bridge the gaps between the scene cuts and kind of show Yoda as a challenge and threat to Palpatine(which is most of this really).
BUT, i do like the ending a lot more. It gives credence to the fact that Palpatine was still stronger than Yoda.
the music over this fight is sooooo good
I have never seen this delete scene! Thanks for sharing General Theory I would like a mix of both so cool
I thought in the novelization of ROTS, which I really liked, was Yoda thinking he HAD the edge, but he saw how the Sith evolved where the Jedi Order became stale, lost…. So Yoda made the decision to escape and train the next generation of Jedi Knights and go for the wise, long term play, like the Sith when they went underground than push his advantage and risk it all. I think Lucas wanted to push, “Good always overcomes evil, but if it isn’t wise it gives evil a longer and longer reign before it is overcome.” Matthew Stover’s ROTS novelization seemed to stress that to me at any rate. The whole book how patients and powerful and creeping the dark is - but even a little candle flame can keep it at bay. …and how love can light stars.
Hey, let's not miss that power kick in the chest by Yoda there while Palpatine zapping lightnings! He could slip right through between the strikes! The literal visualization of how Yoda's size is his advantage vs big guys.
I LOLed at Yoda's expression when he and Palpatine are just standing there playing tummy swords.
I wish that they had kept bits of this battle in the ROTS. I love seeing the cam droids record the encounter. I imagine that Sidious would have watched this over and over again!!!
I like some of these ideas but understandable why many of these were scrapped
Can we PLEASE get a 4hr super cut release ! All the scenes that weren’t included !
Something I thought of when you mentioned Yoda flying further because of his size. Never really thought of it but it was basically even but the emperor technically had the high ground on yoda similar to obi wan on anakin. I wonder if they did that on purpose.
Lastly I never took it as yoda lost to him I thought he meant failed as in failed to kill the emperor. Also the emperor ran first then yoda ran away
The ROTS scene we got is what we needed, Yoda needed to fail otherwise it would have been weird that he stayed in exile for so long. However with this deleted scene it would be been cool to combine them, I really liked at the beginning of the fight it appeared that Yoda had the upper hand. That would have been exciting and then devastating to see him lose.
The second the camera drones got involved and started broadcasting, even locally, the scene had to be deleted. The Emperor would have been shown to be a Sith, and all it would have taken is for someone to have intercepted the broadcast for the "the Jedi rebellion has been put down" narrative to fall apart.
I mean, not really... Being a Sith was legal and he had video evidence that the Jedi attacked him unprovoked.
This was really cool but it’s definitely good that it went the way it went. It adds more to yoda’s (the Jedi’s as a whole) downfall. He lost the war, obviously. But he lost the battle. That had to have hit his ego in some way, right? That’s the reason behind their downfall anyway. They were so arrogant in their power. Yoda, himself, was arrogant. He thought he could beat sidings but he didn’t, technically. He had to flee. Very damaging. The movie was beautifully done, but still. This was really cool and I love seeing alternate versions. Theories are amazing!
I like how Yoda's shadow looms larger & larger over Pali as he is being backed up. Also seeing Yoda running across the walls & doing a few combative techniques was cool too. It's frustrating how much they cut out of this scene. Episode III could've been so much better.
Do you think that if those little camera droids recording the fight dropped down like they did here change anything since the public would have seen Palpatine's holding his own against Yoda?
I would of made the fight go longer but I do appreciate looking back the synergy the Senate fight and the Mustarfar fight. Thats just my feeling though, ideally Episode III would of been two movies but for what we got, its good.
they could have taken a couple things out of this, which they obviously did haha but the end part of this battle would've been nice with the actual ending of the battle we got in the actual movie. like have this deleted scene run up to where Yoda starts absorbing the force lightning and as Palp approaches him insert the force absorption or whatever the exact term is when he and palp were thrown back and run the rest of the movie as is.
There are alot of elements to the previs that are better overall imho. The way the drones came down had a huge impact. Because prior to this there wasnt much televised or public about the betrayal of the jedi. With tbis duel, palps could have very well turned the entire galaxy against the jedi with evidence instead of just saying the jedi betrayed him.
Or they would see that Palps lied and that he is a sith. "The jedi were right" they would say
While thats true. Its not a crime to be a sith in the republic. Its a crime to be a terrorist or a genocidal maniac. As the sith of old always were. I could see the galaxy still going for what palpatine was saying. The jedi are taking over. Thats what I was getting at. Also, at this point in the timeline the galaxy at large had all but forgotten about the existence of the sith anyways.
@@kingandros4819 To be a sith you have to kill. Palps has killed before. Plus him being evil would explain why the CIS knew republic plans during the war. Would explain another really.
Also Dooku said he was a sith. So people would put Palps in the same boat as him. I'm sure they can connect the dots.
1:45
A jedi would not have used other people to defend himself do
I liked it for the most part. Especially where its like destroyed since like he literally destroyed the senate by transforming it into the empire. Him flying away feels a witch flies away though but I still like it
Oh, where is your fan movie ?
I can't find it, and I loved it !!!!!
I was wondering if you made part 2 yet ?
If so, I really want to see it.
I heard you say in a recent video that it is Mace who's still alive, so I'm dying to check it out.
If you have a minute to send the link, that'd be awesome !!!!
Thanks for all that you do !!!!!
You make Star Wars better, and that will always be George's legacy !!!!!
:-)
I really like the rock, paper, scissors effect they pretty much used in Ep 3. Mace Windu had the emperor beat but Yoda couldn't pull it off. It's interesting to think what would have happened if Yoda went to fight Anakin or if Mace Windu and Anakin straight up fought.
2:13 Best freeze frame ever
These are on Disney+ also in the extras section of ROTS
This would have helped explain his crazy lighting force abilities in The Rise of Skywalker. Having him use it more and just relentlessly.
Just imagine if all those senate camera droids had been on and connected to the holonet broadcasting everything to The people of Corusant
2:57 Yodas casting a Shadowy silhouette nearly devouring Palatine. Would've been epic.
Edit: And Yoda cutting through floor. To cut off Palpatines retreat.
This isn’t a deleted scene it’s just a different version of the original fight
What I would have done would be to extend the battle like in the deleted scenes, but with the difference that the main reason Yoda has to retreat is not just because of Sidious having the high ground, but also because Clone Troopers start arriving with all the types of weapons, making the fight even harder for the Grand Master.
The fight will still continue for some time, but eventually, after killing or evading various CTs, and seeing how cannot deal significant damage to the Dark Lord, and with more and more reinforcements arriving, he will then retreat....
But not before using the remaining energy he has to execute a powerful Force Repulse or Wave (one more less OP like the one Pong Krell did when the 212th and 501st confronted him in the HQ chamber of Umbara, or even a more OP and devastating one like the ones of Starkiller). With the Repulse or Wave, all Clone Troopers remaining and coming (apart from Darth Sidious), will be knocked out at fast speeds against the walls, leaving them out for a while out of combat, giving them Yoda the time enough to escape and rendezvous with Bail Organa.
i just wish that we had gotten a few more extreme longshots that illustrate how small yoda and palps were in that fight
There are hidden Easter eggs on the original prequel DVDs. That would be a great video!
Duel of the fates sounds too good on that clarinet
Yeah there’s quite a few parts of this that I like better than the original. He shows that Yoda has the upper hand and lightsaber combat at the part where he almost finished by the force lightning is awesome.
They should have combined the 2 cause I like different aspects of both
Also it would have been the second time a jedi beat him cause in my opinion mace beat palp in his office