AirPulse A80 vs Edifier R1700BTs || Sound & Frequency Response Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
- Edifier R1700BTs on amazon DE: amzn.to/2IObgzJ
Edifier R1700BTs on amazon UK: amzn.to/3n3NQoD
AirPulse A80 on amazon DE: amzn.to/2Eyzv38
AirPulse A80 on amazon UK: amzn.to/3hWhbyB
----------------------------
Follow me on:
Instagram - / digitalstereophony
Facebook - / digitalstereophony
-----------------------------
Contact me at:
digitalstereophony@gmail.com
----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
-Sound recorded using pair of SE Electronics SE8 mics and Zoom H6 recorder
-Frequency measurements done in semi treated room using UMIK-1 microphone
-Levels matched using SPL meter
-All tone controls set to neutral 
Наука
Instagram - instagram.com/digitalstereophony/
Facebook - facebook.com/DigitalStereophony/
As you can see from the past videos, the R1700BT series has been tested in this channel in numerous showdowns, which may prove to some extent how well it performs
I buying Edifier R1700BTs four days ago and they awesome for they price!
Airpulse is better in this test than Edifier.
Interesting to compare Airpulse A80 with KEF LSX.
A80 は全音域を余すところなく出す、原曲に忠実な音ですね！
R1700BTs は…低音が濁る傾向があるようですね…。
でも、お安く手に入るのがいいところですね！
I love my edifiers 1700bt and 1280bt ! But I really like these A80. They are awesome!
Thank you for these videos! Keep up the good work! :)
I don't own any of two but i already experienced the both sound at the showroom. There is a reason why the Airpulse is more expensive. ;)
Its ribbon tweeter. 😁
More wider soundstage?
What input you used in the R1700BT, BT or RCA? If it was RCA did you notice benefits in audio with a DAC?
For newbies who wanted to get an Edifier r1280t/r1280db my advice is go for something higher like r1850 or r2000db. I just got my r1280t a month ago and now...I wanted more!! EDIFIER builds awesome speakers for an affordable price.✌
i recommend 1700BTs paired with a sub, i have it and love it
Do you use it for gaming or music?
I feel like you're setting the R1700BTs as a benchmark speaker standard cause its the standard of "Good sound and good price" and the extra that you're paying for better sound beyond that point is only something you could tell if you have it side by side. I still cant tell the difference at some tracks with my eyes closed TBH.
I bought the R1700BT because of this channel and they really sound that good
I thought the 1700's were ok. But now I'm impressed!
A80 are 4 times more expensive, i guess they are better but not 4 times better
Once Alain, Edifiers are giant killers! For just a fraction of the price of the Airpulse!
Well, airpulse is under edifier too
Can’t find any justification to pay up to four times more for the Airpulse. R1700’s sound just as good...
I have the R1700bt speakers in one room, linked via RCA to an old cheap record player and also to my Sony TV via blue tooth v4.1. Great sound from both audio sources!
I also have the R1855db speakers in another room linked to a CD player via a 3.5mm headphone outlet to RCA on the speakers and a TV via optical cable and a new record Sony record player via RCA link. The sound from all three sources is fantastic.
Both sets of speakers also have the option of bluetooth (v5 in the 1855’s) for use with my iPhone or laptop if I wish.
I have no complaints with sound whether bass minds or lows or tweeter....
I have the r1600 and just got the A100 and i am disappointed. I think I will return the A100 because they don't really justify their price. I think it's a 10-20% increase in quality which you dont hear when you listen at regular volume levels. The high pitched sounds are played out better on the a100. But come on... 8x more for that? Should I stay with R1600, or upgrade to R1855db? I have everything hooked up to Aune X1S and both speakers do play better through that DAC, especially the A100s! They sound way better.
@@piotrpix ; I am not an audiophile nor a sound engineer expert. However, I would think that with your DAC, your 1600s will sound just as good as the 1855’s, at low volume levels.
But when you crank up the volume you should get a better performance from the 1855’s.
If you want even better again, then go for the R2000DB’s or the S1000MKiii’s.
I’ve now got the S1000’s and there is a marked difference between them and the S1855’s.
@@Driver2616 exactly, you gotta 'use' them a bit harder to feel the extra value they have. I cannot do that as the house where I live sort of vibrates the walls etc and the floors in between feel (neighbors hear it).
Although the R1700BTs has a noticeable dip between 1kHz and 2KHz, it doesn't seem to be suffering from serious ill effects. But why only the link to Airpulse is listed?
Бред насчёт провала.
In frequency they don't appear to be far apart but the soundscape from the 1700BT is much wider that the 80. I think the AirPulse 100 performs much better against the 1700BT and I think only a hundred bucks more compared to the 80, now that you were spending way more anyway.
I have the r1600 and the A100 and gotta tell you the difference is tiny when you listen on low level of volume, even normal. When you turn up he A100 they do sound 20% better, and instruments such as the sax or violent sound noticeably better. Honestly not worth the 8x price. I will be returning my A100 this week....
@@piotrpix Fair enough. Spend the money on a woofer if you don't have one yet.
@@yourtubisfilled7164 that's the thing. I can't... That's why I went 2.0. The wall rattling issue.
that is because the airpulse tweeter and all ribbon/planar tweeters are shite.
A80 vs A100 plz! I bought A100 for ￥2500, about $300, in China, i wonder how they compare
Wow, that's a steal. Holy f. Every Friday its black Friday in China I suppose. I got the A100's for 800 cold hard euros a week ago but with an extra year on the warranty for what it's worth. Really happy with them though. Awesome sound stage, really analytical and crisp from the mids to highs. Those horn tweeters are magical. I already augmented them with an XTZ 8.17 sub to add the frequencies you miss with any small speakers and I can really recommend those too. Perfect set-up now and all in white, it looks awesome.
Win airpulse but cost about $500 more
you pay for the smooth top end and also some bottom end.
both great, the airpulse is more true to the source
I dont really hear any difference to be honest, I think its because the test tracks used are fairly easy for these two speakers to play.
How about a more demanding and complex test tracks? I recommend Triad by Tool and Kascade by Animals as Leaders, I have the R1700BT and it really struggles to bring out the details on these two tracks
I have the r1600 and the A100 and gotta tell you the difference is tiny when you listen on low level of volume, even normal. When you turn up he A100 they do sound 20% better, and instruments such as the sax or violent sound noticeably better. Honestly not worth the 8x price.
не думал что r1700Bts настолько хороши, они реально практически не уступают а80! Фантастика!!!
I would like try to see the difference between A80 and A100. Which better for buy and save place on table.
If the space is an issue than go for A80. They sound very close with just a little bit more of bass on A100
@@DSAUDIOreview I always reduced the bass, because I am not a lover of it. A80 perfect for me. Thank you.
A80 is a different league. How does the 1700BTs compare to the original 1700BT?
BT and BTs sound more or less the same when fed signal via analog inputs
If I was using bluetooth, would the 1700bts sound better than the 1700bt?
Yes, there will be an audible difference in favour of BTs
60hz-20khz vs 52hz-20khz from edifier website..
1700BTs + sub vs R2000db or A80 ?
Awesome review! Can you please do a comparison for the 1700BT and Micca PB42x
Of course AirPulse!
Тот случай, когда слушаешь на Microlab Solo 1 и у тебя они играют так охуенно, что ты между R1700 и А80 не видишь разницы.
i hate edifier's bass buzzing.but it is a fact that are price-performance
Edifiers plus any cheap $100 sub are at a different level all together and still $400 less.
No output for a sub.
@@ghawk78 both models have sub out
@@miguelmanuel9618 My R1700bt's do not have a sub out.
@@ghawk78 you should have r1700bt not r1700bts
@@miguelmanuel9618 Ohhhh...You are correct!
Edifier r1700bt or 1700bts for the pc. Price difference about 60$ USA.
Microlab b77 cost 90 $
Love my 1700BTs and my S350DB 2.1
hey man, I have the R1700BT but I think the deep bass (kick drum) is lacking. Is it worth it to upgrade to S350DB in terms of this deep bass? cheers
@@kunxv15 yeah for me it is worth
Edifier speakers sound like they got better highs... Maybe it's just me, Anyway I ordered a pair of the R1850DB's last night... I'll be satisfied
A80搭配t5，還是A100搭配t5??
Edifier R1700BTs исполняют рок качественней , сочно и вкусно .
AirPulse A80 is nice .. !
Hi guys! =) Hello from Russia) I choose between Edifier R1280DBs and Edifier R1700BTs, I understand that Edifier R1700BTs should be better in sound, but there is no spdif. Planning to use them with my pc, gigabyte aorus ultra z390 motherboard. Does it make sense to buy R1280DBs just for the sake of spdif? what do you think, which ones are worth taking for the best experience?
Why don't you get edifier r1855db?
@@pedrogoncalves2948
HI ) what's the difference between them? And support for bluetooth 5 and aptx makes me very happy)
@@pedrogoncalves2948
I just would not say that I consider myself an audiophile, I am not chasing an ideal sound, I just wondered if the difference between them is commensurate with the benefits from spdif, if any ...
@@stereoshock97 i use analog connection, but with r1855db you will have great sound, sub out and digital and analog connections!
@@pedrogoncalves2948
thanks for the advice, I'll think about it)
The Fives for $599 anything better for the price?
Where?
Bro I was soo hyped about r1700bts when i bought them. I had them for week and had deeper listen to them. Turns out powered one had more bass and the bass overall was distorter on higher levels. I was BIG SAD BIG TIME. Waiting for solve.
Souded fire in highs tho that's why I haven't heard messed up lows. And i had a sub soooo
Wait I'm crazy or Air pulse costs 600$? Coz I heard the difference and I was like ye better crossover and more clarity but the price got me......
yep they just dont give about thier customers. They said even after sending my mesurements that speakers where just fine and didnt even gave me a discound or anything
Me too bro.. turn out too much hype about this R1700BTS.. very sad because I already bought it.. Cheap thing no good.. Good thing no cheap..
@@mazju2008 what did you not like about them?
r1700bt really bad perfoms against to a80.the sound drowned in bass.thanks man for your great reviews 👍
Hi, did you test Edifier T5 sub?
Yes, it will be on the channel soon
listening from my R2000DB xD
It's night and day difference. Edifier R1700BTs has that horrible V-shaped multimedia sound. AirPulse A80 sounds lot more balanced and true to the original.
А я бы не назвал разницу night and day. Всё таки есть полно колонок с куда более говеным звуком. Так что 1700 в сравнении вообще топ. Для простых людей, не музыкантов вообще супер колонки. А если уж придираться к нюансам...У меня у самого такие, и я тащусь от звука. Только одна проблема, это басс. Он часто гудит на многих треках, но это можно простить.
@@mlsterlous Я не музыкант, я просто слушаю музыку, и я отчетливо слышу разницу между этими колонками, и, судя по лайкам, не только я.
@@Vsevolod3788 на этом канале в каждом видео чувствуется разница между колонками. Вопрос только насколько она велика, и какое звучание больше по душе. Я понимаю что есть типа "правильный" звук, но почему бы тогда всем фирмам не делать одинаковый звук раз он такой якобы идеальный.
@@mlsterlous Я разницу отчетливо слышу между этими колонками, и для меня она велика. Я не люблю "улыбочный" звук. Вы можете его любить - это Ваше дело. Вы так же можете и не слышать разницы, в таком случае могу за Вас только порадоваться. Я лишь высказал свое мнение и никому его не навязываю. Почему не делают правильный звук - для того, чтобы Вы всегда были чем то недовольны, и шли, покупали их продукты снова и снова.
AirPulse A80 Wins
Edifier r1700bts is available in europe?
Not yet
@@DSAUDIOreview Do you have plans for airpulse a300pro?
@@miguelmanuel9618 nothing concrete yet
VS klipsch r-41 & diamond A1 please....
Maybe for music makers its "big difference", but for normal ppl almost no difference. Don't forget how many really bad sounding speakers are there, which can't compete with 1700.
+1 I listen to the fight on my new A300, and I do not hear the difference of 98% of the time. But perhaps it's about my imperfect human ears.
@@РомаЮрьёв-к5ю That is amazing! Maybe you should try with head phones?
Neh, even normal people have ears and brains to process the signals. Perhaps it's a matter of how much they care about it and how perfect sound reacts with your neurotransmitters and dopamine release :) And yes, the 1700 is pretty good for its price range.
I mean...Is everybody scared to say that they sound 100% indistinguishable?
AirPulse A80 = Kef LSX ;)
Music sounds, but money talks...
EDIFIRE.👌👌👌👌
Listening on my headphones I hear a noticeable difference. Airpulse has more higher mids
Digital Stereophony, would it be too much to ask the brand and model of the blurred out 2.1 set of speakers that show up in several videos? Example video - m.ruclips.net/video/jfjPS7bRYbc/видео.html Tyvm in advance, keep up the awesome comparisons.
There are no speakers playing when the image is blurred. It is the original track/recording emedded into the video
Tyvm for the info, was going nuts trying to find out...silly me XD
well the Airpulse costs like 3x more, so there's that...
Edifier r1700bt