i don't get it why would people hate this,this is RV's best choreo so far imo they are so in sync here people are so rude they were still a rookie back then
i guess bc this was like a remake of their sunbae's song so ppl usually expect more of a remake but that time usually rookies use cute concepts so i guess ppl didnt like it but that sucks.. it was rlly nice
@@janinebaybado1751 AGREE!! hahaha wendy is soooo pretty here thats why SM change her style from Icc era till now. Cz SM already decide that no one can beat Irene visual on RV 🤦♀️
This choreo right here is the epithomy of kpop to me, their best and what all group should aspire to. Ofc not to copy, but to have this level of originality, beauty, classyness, talent, sheer quality in production and execution. If all of kpop were this well crafted, idealized and executed, kpop would already have gained the world twice. Thats why i think theres no comparison, no contest really, with other groups, to me at least, every other rookie groups fall for cliche concepts, obvious and regular stuff with some good points here and there
not all of kpop. i love this type of classy, mature concept but i also love the typical cute and innocent concept most rookie girl groups go for. but i want more songs like this and i want more badass concepts as well.
@@kiwisa2626It is much better this kind of genre in kpop. We have different taste but this is so good perhaps this time this kind of genre will be much appreciated. It suits really well
We need a red velvet solo concert, because I want them to perform everything. And I want the full choreography to Autimatic, Lucky girl, etc. SM gave EXO a solo almost immediately. Honestly the unfairness in the way they treat their groups pisses me off.
Funny how haters couldn't bash Red Velvet for their talents and instead find fault in the pettiest of things like the synchronicity of the dance or how boring the song is lmao That's when you know you stanned the right group 😂😂 This is one of the many reasons why I prefer them much much more than overrated girl groups nowadays 😛
Wtf do y'all mean it's not synced?! I replayed this video like a hundred times already and they were damn perfect in their choreography. I don't get why people are hating because they're not in sync or lip syncing. Seriously, dancing that shit and singing at the same time is already hard enough for rookies especially when they're live on stage. And is this the first time y'all have seen an idol group lip syncing? I'm sure you've all seen your idols lip sync too. This song is not meant for everyone's tastes because I love the jazz and velvety feelings of this song. So stop looking at them negatively and comparing them to other groups 'cause I'm sure none of y'all can do what they're doing perfectly on live stage.
Still one of their best choreos to date honestly. Shame people that time was hellbent on hating them. If this were to be released now, the reception would be far different. This song also really shows their vocals pretty well. Smooth and suave girl crushes indeed. Also, Wendy my baby had good styling and fair screentime lol
the screentime is nothing more of the director confusion of who's the visual. i mean me myself thought the visual was wendy at first. hence they cover her forehead since Ice Cream Cake onward.
Omg😂😂 tbh yes... when i saw their happiness era, i thought wendy was the visual. I dont notice irene at all😂 the member that catch my attention is wendy in that era. She's the prettiest for me. And now im loving her purple hair 😍
Can we talk about Irene's dancing for a second? This concept and the choreography botb fit her so well and her moves are so precise and powerful... Can we also talk about how straight her leg was during that move at 2:58? Like damn, she's flexible
This here is the epitome of elegance, refinement, just..... absolutely stunning. If RV ever redoes this in the near future with Miss Katy Kim, safe to say I can leave this earth with the knowledge that this masterpiece will be plastered on my grave.
just to remind u guys: the song is a remake of s.e.s.'s song, be natural. s.e.s. (1997-2002) are a former girl group that used to be under sm (check them out too !)
진짜 고급스러움 난 ses버전보다 레벨 버전이 더좋은데 이런노래 언젠가부터. 발매가 안됐었네. 벨벳이 생각해보면 초창기엔 공포감보다는 약간 심미적인 위험해보이는데 또 고급스런 느낌인듯 약간 사람들이 크리피한거를 좋아하니까 약간 그쪽 노선을 더 보여주는데 ses느낌도 주는게 전통깉고 좋은듯
![Red Velvet (레드벨벳) - Automatic / Ice Cream Cake [Music Bank COMEBACK / 2015.03.20]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VtRoyuxOzzs/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Velvet (레드벨벳) - Automatic / Ice Cream Cake [Music Bank COMEBACK / 2015.03.20]](/img/tr.png)
![Red Velvet (레드벨벳) - Be Natural [Music Bank HOT Stage / 2014.10.31]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7HDKmtypBAg/mqdefault.jpg)
![YoungBoy Never Broke Again - Missing Everything [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dTYeMZGzOzw/mqdefault.jpg)
i don't get it why would people hate this,this is RV's best choreo so far imo they are so in sync here people are so rude they were still a rookie back then
i guess bc this was like a remake of their sunbae's song so ppl usually expect more of a remake but that time usually rookies use cute concepts so i guess ppl didnt like it but that sucks.. it was rlly nice
It will be rock if the mv released recently, i mean their choreo so lit and in sync i really love it
Red velvet JJANG!
they were just ahead of their time, this would crush in 2022
They were amazing before and now. Idc what haters say, they are missing the good stuff, their loss
wendy's visual is so underrated.
May Ann Capuchino
I literally just posted why she wasn't the visual/center/face? Sooooo beautiful!
May Ann Capuchino ikr
She was the prettiest and the most eye-catching to me in their happiness era. I love her without bangs!! 😭😭
She's very attractive because of her foreigner looks. Really pretty during this Era that Irene was outshined. Lol
@@janinebaybado1751 AGREE!! hahaha wendy is soooo pretty here thats why SM change her style from Icc era till now.
Cz SM already decide that no one can beat Irene visual on RV 🤦♀️
This choreo right here is the epithomy of kpop to me, their best and what all group should aspire to. Ofc not to copy, but to have this level of originality, beauty, classyness, talent, sheer quality in production and execution. If all of kpop were this well crafted, idealized and executed, kpop would already have gained the world twice. Thats why i think theres no comparison, no contest really, with other groups, to me at least, every other rookie groups fall for cliche concepts, obvious and regular stuff with some good points here and there
You should check S.E.S. out, it's their song.
yourstripperadam I know
not all of kpop. i love this type of classy, mature concept but i also love the typical cute and innocent concept most rookie girl groups go for. but i want more songs like this and i want more badass concepts as well.
@@kiwisa2626It is much better this kind of genre in kpop. We have different taste but this is so good perhaps this time this kind of genre will be much appreciated. It suits really well
WENDY IS SO PRETTY OMG OMG. Even my non-kpopper sister told me she's pretty 😍
the choreography was art, and they execute it so well damn seulgi, damn bae, damn smooth joy, damn son wen. oh wow ive never been so impressed O.O
welcome to my heart inside. We gonna get to become one. Just holding you forever in my mind
never forget
hi are you still there
They slayed with this choreography
데뷔 초에만 볼 수 있는 분위기와 얼굴, 완벽한 노래와 안무 비내추럴 너무 좋아ㅠㅠㅠ
its already 2016 and here i am wishing and waiting to see them perform this again
Omfg imagine it with Yeri THE TOTAL PACKAGE
i miss this era.
yumee blythe lee
and taeyong
We need a red velvet solo concert, because I want them to perform everything. And I want the full choreography to Autimatic, Lucky girl, etc. SM gave EXO a solo almost immediately. Honestly the unfairness in the way they treat their groups pisses me off.
Pink Princess oh they got a solo concert now lol
Oh my wendyyyyy. I love her in this era
Funny how haters couldn't bash Red Velvet for their talents and instead find fault in the pettiest of things like the synchronicity of the dance or how boring the song is lmao That's when you know you stanned the right group 😂😂 This is one of the many reasons why I prefer them much much more than overrated girl groups nowadays 😛
same here 💙
None group is overrated.
They all deserve their fame.
But I agree,Red Velvet stands out.
It’s hilarious that people really thought this song was boring😭 like it must’ve not been that boring if it was a smash hit during 1st gen
this is why I fell in love with red velvet, when they do sexy concepts it's not overly done, it's classy, and that's how to do it right!!
0:32 When you pick something off the ground in front of your crush
My little chipmunk Rosé Hahahahah sexyyyyy ahaha
BTCH IM CACKLING SKKKKKSKSKSK
HAHAHAHA
lol 😂😂😂
Wendy is so beautiful!
SM pls bring this concept bag, pls pls pls 😍😍😍
Park Chim Chim OMG I LOVE YOUR CHANNEL! PLS POST MORE VIDEOS
Wendy's visual here is my favorite....😍😍
Song for wendy...
Red Velvet NEED to perform this again, its one of their best and most underrated velvet songs
처음에 멤버들 소개장면? 진짜 너무 추억 돋음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저런 느낌 한번만 더 느낄 수 있었으면
happiness and be natural really best wendy era😭🩵
I wish other girls group use sexy concept learn from them
welcome to my heart inside. We gonna get to become one. Just holding you forever in my mind
+raghad spot on
Agree
The only 'sexy concept' that works with actual clothes on so far. That's why i love RV.
raghad I'm saying. I'm in love with Redvelvet. new fan here can anyone help me with named etc
I miss wendy like this
Omg, I can clearly hear Seulgi and Wendy's voice when they're singing together..
아 슬기 춤선 진짜 ㅠㅠ
쉑씨♥~~
I really like this concept though it was not popular. They dance sharply and smoothly and have sense of feminist much.
Wendy I loves you
Wendy is so pretty here. This is her perfect hairstyles
still the best choreo from RV
Seulgi proves that she is one of the most versatile artist in the Kpop industry.
One of the FEW REAL GEM indeed
Wendy looked incredible during this era. Bring back this kind of look for her :O
wendy, she slay everything 😘😘😘😘
노출없이도 섹시하네..ㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠ 넘나 섹시한것..
SM please make a comeback on irene's dark hair!!!>
they will be gray haired for next comeback according to some rumors
She’s BACK
아 옷 안벗어도 섹시할수 있다는게 .. 특히 아이린의 특화된.. 앞으로도 레드적인 것과 벨벳적인것을 계속 반복해서 보여주길.. 현재는 벨벳적인건 아이린 슬기 웬디가 좋고 레드적인건 다들 잘하는거같다.. 앞으로 아이린이 계속 레드적인걸 자랄수록 있어야만 레드벨벳의 성패가 달려있는듯.. 아이스크림케이크 덤덤 최고..
아이린 예쁘다..
Wendy calm down with those vocals!
Irene is so beautiful!!
She is an angel
Damn. They was getting it
Why wasn't Wendy the visual, center, and face again?
give us Wendy's forehead for God sake SM! What's wrong with five visual??!
Lee Anna
Dafuq you mean?
Wendy's one of the most beautiful members!
thats bcs sm didnt want wendy got the most attention to her visual 🙄
Eyebrowstj - Multifandom4Life noo he mean all are beautiful and ppl only focus on ireene visual, but ther enothing wrong with 5 visuals
One of the best concept in Kpop industry. RV NAILED IT!! As expected of SM
Wtf do y'all mean it's not synced?! I replayed this video like a hundred times already and they were damn perfect in their choreography. I don't get why people are hating because they're not in sync or lip syncing. Seriously, dancing that shit and singing at the same time is already hard enough for rookies especially when they're live on stage. And is this the first time y'all have seen an idol group lip syncing? I'm sure you've all seen your idols lip sync too. This song is not meant for everyone's tastes because I love the jazz and velvety feelings of this song. So stop looking at them negatively and comparing them to other groups 'cause I'm sure none of y'all can do what they're doing perfectly on live stage.
Oh this was a performance? I thought it was a hair commercial... soft and silky with volume..
can they perform this again with yeri and taeyong
우와...노래 진짜잘한다
this is both the sexiest and classiest performance in kpop ever.
I lovee the vibe and their voice ❤
Still one of their best choreos to date honestly. Shame people that time was hellbent on hating them. If this were to be released now, the reception would be far different. This song also really shows their vocals pretty well. Smooth and suave girl crushes indeed.
Also, Wendy my baby had good styling and fair screentime lol
the screentime is nothing more of the director confusion of who's the visual. i mean me myself thought the visual was wendy at first. hence they cover her forehead since Ice Cream Cake onward.
this is why sm changing wendy's hairstyle.. if she stay like this, i mean.. irene who?
galah gilang lol kinda unnecessary but kinda true
even right now, i think wendy is the pretties in the group, then irene, then yeri
indeed, myemim is blooming now..
galah gilang when they first debuted i really thought wendy is the visual.
Omg😂😂 tbh yes... when i saw their happiness era, i thought wendy was the visual. I dont notice irene at all😂 the member that catch my attention is wendy in that era. She's the prettiest for me. And now im loving her purple hair 😍
One of the best choreographys in kpop
I fell in love with Seulgi in this era 🥰
IT CRAZY HOW THEY WENT FROM HAPPINESS TO BE NATURAL, QUEENS EVEN AS ROOKIES 😫
wendy has always been a star
레드벨벳 진짜넘좋다💕💕💕
I want this wendy back. people will be like: "oh red velvet! the one with the girl wendy?"
this choreo is hard af. and this is so classy
They are so great
It's a hard choreography but they can sing and dance perfectly
I jealous with they talent so bad
seulgi is so hot
조이 춤 출땨마다 짜릿한게 진짜 유연하고 박력있게 춤을 춤...
이서 벨벳컨셉이라기보다 완전 섹시해♥♥♥
i wish they'd do this concept more often 😭 i want to see them in more suits!!
miss seungwan is serving IT
“A voice that tickled my ears”
I felt that.
Just dropped by to say "FREE WENDY'S FOREHEAD!"
아이린은 이 때가 젤 이쁜 거 같음...
Wooooow 🥰 my idol all I just comment but I already watching this 6 years 😊🥰
Hope Wendy finds this relaxed air again
Honestly, this is their best concept.
Can we talk about Irene's dancing for a second? This concept and the choreography botb fit her so well and her moves are so precise and powerful... Can we also talk about how straight her leg was during that move at 2:58? Like damn, she's flexible
wendy the prettiest 😭💙
my favorite RV song all of time.... :)
It's an S.E.S. song. I think they both executed their separate concepts flawlessly!
2:55 This part>>>
걸크러쉬 짱♡
Wendy stage presence 😳💙
The 142 people who disliked this are either blind or deaf..Sorry but that was AWESOME!!!
너무예쁘고멋있어여
they sound so much like the original ver. but the choreo is much better.
It's 2018 but still watching this 😍 I miss wendy's hairstyle in hereee
They're so flexible lmao
The stage also the concept is beautiful 💜❤
This here is the epitome of elegance, refinement, just..... absolutely stunning. If RV ever redoes this in the near future with Miss Katy Kim, safe to say I can leave this earth with the knowledge that this masterpiece will be plastered on my grave.
1:03 I'm such a sucker for hair flips. Wendy's voice in the first verse. Bless this underrated concept.
Rookie red velvet ❤❤❤❤❤
Wendy💙
first time seeing them, the dance is still sexy and the song had a good beat to it
My fave concept hand down
Back to this era.
I thought Wendy was the leader and visual. 😂
Seulgi’s voice! 🥰🥰🥰
just loved them
I've always loved that song. Bae-by is 33 now, yet she barely changed
I never thought that a song like this can have a good choreograph as this
PARK SOOYOUNG💚💚💚
Irene
Seulgi
Wendi
Joy
Queens
Rewatch this video everytime i miss red velvet with long silk natural hair era
Irene’s fav era ya’ll!💕
just to remind u guys: the song is a remake of s.e.s.'s song, be natural. s.e.s. (1997-2002) are a former girl group that used to be under sm (check them out too !)
울 애들 완젼 애기얗ㅎㅎ
wish they would perform this with all 5 member + taeyong nct
진짜 고급스러움 난 ses버전보다 레벨 버전이 더좋은데 이런노래 언젠가부터. 발매가 안됐었네.
벨벳이 생각해보면 초창기엔 공포감보다는 약간 심미적인 위험해보이는데 또 고급스런 느낌인듯 약간 사람들이 크리피한거를 좋아하니까 약간 그쪽 노선을 더 보여주는데 ses느낌도 주는게 전통깉고 좋은듯
I'd very much like to see a concept like this from RV again 😭👌 this is art. Beautiful.
Can’t believe I only know this only in 2022😭 but it’s so good, Im gonna watch enough to make up for the past 7 years that I haven’t
I missed seulgi long hair😭💞
Red velvet had the best vocal, agree with u mom
2021 and still hoping that they will perform this song again