Okay but can we say that I know Yeri when she filmed Automatic it was her first time wearing heels and she still killed it!!! When I wore heels for the first time I wore heels I almost broke my ankles
@@罒中 Actually in Korea it’s common to refer to kisses as ice cream. So ICC is really just about really wanting to kiss someone. I remember seeing a korean comment this on a translation vid for ICC
Can we just talk about Wendy's hair in automatic??? I lovvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeee it. Yasss Wendy, Slay. Also, with this comeback, they don't seem Korean. The hair and they blue contacts make them seems America. Not saying that all Americans has that style. But... yeah
Coming back here after killing voice… used to be sensational pop stars, now they are artisanal singers who respect and perfect their crafts. Brava to these girls. The entire industry is kowtowing to their music and vocals
Look at how they go from 'Automatic' to 'Ice Cream Cake' Two completely different concepts, two different sounds, THE FLAVOR!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm so glad I decided to start listening to their music :)
Back from the future here. RV is already in their 6th year and I’m out here watching their past stages. I noticed that the camera focused a lot on Wendy in this era when right now camera tends to focus on Irene. I don’t have anything wrong with that it’s just interesting
just look at them, they are so great and watching their performances there is no doubt that they are talented. Im not a fan but Rv is the best female group Sm made debut. and about fame Im sure they are the second best female group.
I love RV and they will definitely improve with experience but the Best female group sm debuted is really CSJH The Grace.They were just really unlucky to enter hiatus right when they start to gain recognition in Japan.
I still dont get why Automatic Irene did not become legendary. She gave it her ALL here, danced and emoted the song the best BY FAR. In this genre, she's probably SM's best female dancer actually. I dont sympathize with people that complain about her energy now. You should have appreciated it when she did.
I miss this time when SM used to promote RV better than now. There was one song for "red "and another for "velvet" side and the clothing was better in this era too. The good thing is RV have been always giving their best in performance that has not changed, proud of these girls. My cute Baechu rapping so cool~
Their hairstyle in automatic is just BOMB like TF Irene's wavy something hair, Yeri's slick straight hair, Joy's retro hair, Wendy and Seulgi's businesswoman-looking hair 😭😭💖💖💖
Seulgi is damn beautiful 💛 all of red velvet 's members are gorgeous but there's something about Seulgi that always gets my eyes 😄 btw who's the main vocal ? Is it Wendy or Seulgi?
![Red Velvet - Rookie [Music Bank HOT Stage / 2017.02.24]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oYIPa0t372w/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Velvet - Rookie [Music Bank HOT Stage / 2017.02.24]](/img/tr.png)
Seulgi is one of the most beautiful women in the world, seriously.
How old is she?
+David Dacus she's 21 in international age
true i think its mostly her eyes
yeah
naega hoshit # 76 , Irene ranked in the 20's i think
The moment when you realize that in Automatic performance, they colored their nails according to their respective color code.
omg Joy is soooo pretty
That hair is like wow you can make anything look good joy 😱😘
Okay but can we say that I know Yeri when she filmed Automatic it was her first time wearing heels and she still killed it!!! When I wore heels for the first time I wore heels I almost broke my ankles
I can barely walk
MrsMarie Orton '
2:08 the way Joy looks at Yeri is so cute :3
Ptoud at the maknae UwU
Waw
Wendy Looks proud too :)
Is no one gonna mention how cute Joy is? She's just so huggable and she suits any concept. I love her voice and her body is perfect.
**automatics starts**
Me: Yerim is too young for this
**ICC starts**
Me: that's better
EverTriedDrawing4Once ICC lyrics are way worse
icc is way more explicit and sexual
@@罒中 Actually in Korea it’s common to refer to kisses as ice cream. So ICC is really just about really wanting to kiss someone. I remember seeing a korean comment this on a translation vid for ICC
@@罒中 yeah I know a few lyric dosen’t make any sense but it for fitting the concept
fuck ICC, automatic is the best! i own the automatic version of the album as it is a title track of theirs too. They barely performed it.
Seulgi's so beautiful
روعه حيل 😘
yeah she so beautiful
Is no
@@LucasOliveira-ue9in ?
The blonde girl is really good!
nicetube ....Which one? 😂
Wendy
So cute :)
Wenrenejoygiri
Ikrrr
Joy's good at singing, its girly and innocent. Sm should have her sing more.
ia vang she sing a lot
it seems like Sm heed your wishes my friend 🥰 she sings a lot now
your wish came true haha
Now she sings more and rap less lol
And now sm announce of Joy Solo😭💚
omo joy so pretty!!!!
*ugly
@@LucasOliveira-ue9in ure uglier
Seulgi's & Joy so beautiful
flashback to strawberry blonde Joy
This automatic performance.. WENDY, I QUESTION MY SEXUALITY BECAUSE OF YOU!
same its ok
+mewantspocky I loled hard xD
Me too especially when she smirked waaaaaa
Still impressed that Joy did all that floor stuff and manage to rap so GOOD AND STABLE. JEEZ, THIS WOMEN ARE AMAZING!!!
The way Joy looks at Yeri in 2:07 its sooo cute!! She looks soo proud!! Joy bias!! Irene second bias Yeri Third bias!! Love RV!!!
;_;
Joy is so beautiful. 😍
yes!!!
girl in the thumbnail so gorgeoussssss...joyyyy
I love all of them, but Joy just melts my heart omg **o**
they're not lipsync and every member have a visual and good looking. who's watch this in 2017??
2020 actually
2020
2021
2021
2022
아니 언제 5년이나 지났지...? 레드벨벳은 항상 얼마 안된거같아
Theyre all so pretty performing Ice Cream Cake on this one, especially Joy & Seulgi 💕💕😍
Joy is very pretty
yes.she is very preety.
인정각
+prime 고레기.r2t 저기요,강슬기년이라뇨?말씀이 좀 심하시네요
그런 생각은 구지 표현하셔두 대여 ㅎㅎ
Uglyyyyyyy :p
went back to watch this after watching the russian roulette performance and I feel like Joy has lost so much weight since ICC era
I mean it does it matter?
As long as she's healthy...there should be no problem
SEULGI = Goddess ( She's so pretty.) ❤️
ㅇㅈ
ikr
+마하 what's ng j??
+HeyIm Finn ㅇㅈ
南名井 mhy7
Can we just talk about Wendy's hair in automatic??? I lovvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeee it. Yasss Wendy, Slay. Also, with this comeback, they don't seem Korean. The hair and they blue contacts make them seems America. Not saying that all Americans has that style. But... yeah
Coming back here after killing voice… used to be sensational pop stars, now they are artisanal singers who respect and perfect their crafts. Brava to these girls. The entire industry is kowtowing to their music and vocals
joy look so pretty i love her sh's the best💚
Mygosh! Joy rapping while dancing Is hard!
THE AUTOMATIC STAGE GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS! THEY ARE GORGEOUS!
This is exactly why they are the most versatile girlgroup ever. No one can change my mind
irene and seulgi i love both of them
Irene
Look at how they go from 'Automatic' to 'Ice Cream Cake' Two completely different concepts, two different sounds, THE FLAVOR!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm so glad I decided to start listening to their music :)
I would cross the world and the seven seas for someone like Red Velvet, specially Wendy
Yeri and Joy look so young here 😂😂💘love this group
Yeri's so energetic! that's what you call Newbie's high!
Seulgi bias altho im noy a super fan yet.
Seulgi is perfect and I know it!! 😍
Damns those vocals
하웬디 진짜좋다ㅜ
4:23 Seulgi just coolly strutting like a boss
they slayed... without lipsync .. i love them very much. they can control their breath and voice since dancing
Back from the future here. RV is already in their 6th year and I’m out here watching their past stages. I noticed that the camera focused a lot on Wendy in this era when right now camera tends to focus on Irene. I don’t have anything wrong with that it’s just interesting
I noticed that too! Over time the camera leaned towards Irene more.
It should be on Wendy more now! I'm not sure what's wrong with the camera man 🤣🤣🤣
아스케 초반 예리 파트 때 조이 눈빛 보고 사망... 진짜 어화둥둥 내 새끼 눈빛이였어요...
웬디도... 8ㅅ8♡♡♡♡
joy is soooooo beautifulllll
This era really compliment Seulgi’s looks and voice 😍 even tho she looks and sounds good in every era
joy 😚😚😚😚
JOY!!!!! MY QUEEN!!!!!
Before this comeback ends, they better wear the fluffy light up jackets! I will cry if they don't!
Samia Stewart lol i see this everywhere ^.^ what are the fluffy light up jackets?
***** They had fluffy LED jackets in their music video that I really want them to wear for their goodbye stage. Watch their MV :)
Lmao oh thankyouu!! ^.^
***** No problem :) But they didn't wear the jackets for their last stage which was Inkigayo on Sunday. :(
Awwwh really? I'm sorry :( that sucks :c
I love them all, but look at Wendy at the 0:05 mark! How was she not the visual? Her visuals are so underrated!
choreos like automatic and be natural really shows how amazing irene dances
Wandi with blonde hair is just a real barbie
Automatic: Omy Yeri is so beautiful. So cool and classy
Ice Cream Cake: Wait. Yeri, so cutie!!!!
i really love wendy's outfit!!
and theres also an angle where irene looks like taeyeon (in automatic)
I thought it was only me who thought that 😂👏🏻
Not even close sorry...
+Jillanne Carlos i agree sometimes i thought she was taeyeon
just look at them, they are so great and watching their performances there is no doubt that they are talented. Im not a fan but Rv is the best female group Sm made debut. and about fame Im sure they are the second best female group.
I love RV and they will definitely improve with experience but the Best female group sm debuted is really CSJH The Grace.They were just really unlucky to enter hiatus right when they start to gain recognition in Japan.
I love Wendy's makeup in Automatic. ❤️
Wendy is so very beautiful and her skin is super light like a doll. She is a beautiful living doll.
HOT JOY
I still dont get why Automatic Irene did not become legendary. She gave it her ALL here, danced and emoted the song the best BY FAR. In this genre, she's probably SM's best female dancer actually. I dont sympathize with people that complain about her energy now. You should have appreciated it when she did.
She legendary to me ❤️
soo true=, nobody recognizes Irene's dance
joyy 💕💕
;_; lesbian?
Lucas Oliveira you are an asshole
I miss this time when SM used to promote RV better than now. There was one song for "red "and another for "velvet" side and the clothing was better in this era too. The good thing is RV have been always giving their best in performance that has not changed, proud of these girls. My cute Baechu rapping so cool~
WENDY❤
wendy is everythiinnnggggg.
Wendy is amazing!
Joy is beautiful in and out
i usually prefer more toned down, acoustic songs but for some reason I prefer the red side over the velvet
from joy's part to the front, i hear her voice every single second and i'm not complaining
Ok but Yeri is the cutest thing alive.
One word to describe Wendy: Perfect
oh my sweet seulgi
I love seulgi's and wendy's hair 😍😍😍😍😍
Their hairstyle in automatic is just BOMB like TF Irene's wavy something hair, Yeri's slick straight hair, Joy's retro hair, Wendy and Seulgi's businesswoman-looking hair 😭😭💖💖💖
The choreographer of Automatic did great! I really love it! Although I love ally Red Velvet choreos. One of my fave is Automatic.
omG JOYS BODY EKEJBF IS SO PERFECT
No
@@LucasOliveira-ue9in shut up.
Lucas Oliveira shut the f up
@@LucasOliveira-ue9in
Yes!
She has the best body is Red velvet (along with seulgi)
Automatic is one of my favourite songs from rv! pretty bumped there's no full performance on this :(
Seulgi is damn beautiful 💛 all of red velvet 's members are gorgeous but there's something about Seulgi that always gets my eyes 😄 btw who's the main vocal ? Is it Wendy or Seulgi?
Wendy. Seulgi is the lead vocalist~
Wendy is obviously Main vocal 😁😁😁
joy yeri!!!💖💖💖💖💖
Do both red and velvet in one video
automatic is so fucking iconic no other gg will be able to top what red velvet did here
freaking vocals! i miss this kind of rv they're still baby here huhu and of course the iconic original bridge choreography!!
JOY
They look like babies!! 💚 Joy is looks the youngest.
wtf they look so pretty 😫💗
Irene i Miss You Queen 💜
1:18 I want to lay down in a ball and have them kick me like that like the trash I am
People say Joy's hairstyle looked stupid here in Automatic, but seriously, with that outfit she looks like a rich madame who owns an elite bar.
the blueprint for kpop r&b
Back then many groups had kiiiinda similar concepts to these so i didnt care much
Now
I miss these two concepts soo muuch :/
I really adore and admire the duality of red velvet.
Seulgiyaa 🥺
Joooooooy ♡♥♡♥♡♥♡♥♡
Irene's dancing was so LIT 🔥🔥🔥
can we just talk about how absolutely beautiful each of them look?
take me back . good times
이미이띠인 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 아크케 오랜만에보니까 이시절 뽕실뽕실 솜사탕갬성 한번더 내줘라스엠아 -.,!!!!!
Congratulations 1 M on September 2020
one of the things i love from rv is that they rarely do the lipsync
god damn it!! what a song. I got addicted to this song
Irene's Automatic era and Taeyon's Twinkle era~ their visuals wah the resemblance is so uncanny
Wendy is so beautiful
Seulgi😍