when red velvet come to their velvet side its mean sexy and classy. Another level of sexy. I love this side more tbh, not so many idol has this concept but sadly korean more like music like red side.
i love the velvet side more and i really don't get that cute stuff, cause wtf, theyre grown up women, it's ok to be a bit playful, but not EVRYTHING CUTE AND ON EVRY VARIETY AEGYO and how they cringe obviously, aegyo is a interesting thing, cause kt matters how a person does it, but not EVERYWHERE
Yeeeees i this more because yeri wasnt added here im sorry but red velvet had so much potential in this era they dont have to adjust with yeri but now they are becoming easy on steps and jolly songs because yeri cant do so :((
savi pun Yeah, I agree. And they seems very professional. You can see that they are serious. It's sad that SONE, Affecxion, EXO-L didn't like them because they debut on the worst moment of 2014. Hope that 2015 they willl shine with their own SONG DANCE and PERFORMANCE. They are really talented at singing, dancing, visual, professional;;;;;;
@booma A Try to do the choreography, while catching your breath and singing, especially those long notes. Plus being alert on finding where the cameras are to make eye contact, it's not that easy. Seulgi @1:12 had to dance weaker than usual in order to concentrate more on singing and having a clearer voice.
Anybody who says these girls can't sing live clearly needs their ears checked. Like, the only grip I have with this live is when they mix their vocals in the chorus and all slide up to the high note cuz one person always sticks out. Always. But besides that, they sound great. ESPECIALLY with the difficulty of this choreography. Like, I know senior girl groups who can't even do a simple cat walk and sing with a steady voice. Like, stop people. These girls have decent vocals. That and both Wendy and Seulgi, with more vocal training and practice, are gonna be vocal powerhouses as they mature and go farther in the industry.
delay cious No, they ARE bad for a SM rookie group that SM had hoped would blow the socks off of everyone. They are not now....nor will they ever be anywhere near as good as snsd or F(x). This group of girls can't sing that well and they are very very very bland. There is nothing about them that stands out.
All those hair flips and no one looked like Sadako. Now that is skill. I remember when Suzy and Hara did a sexy dance battle; I laughed my ass off at Suzy.
Wendy's confidence in their debut era is undeniably strong. Just look at her. 🥺 I just hope we can get this wannie back. Her stage presence during their debut days is so stunning and mesmerizing. I don't know what happened exactly but you can tell there's a difference between then and now. I miss you Wendy. Hoping to see you soon performing with Red Velvet again.
it's 2020 and i just read comments from 5/6 years ago that really broke my heart. many people said rv will flop and didnt deserve the attention they're getting. i just couldnt imagine the struggles they had in their rookie years. im really happy and proud with what they have now. red velvet fighting!!
Sameeeeeee~ im really proud of red velvet because they overcame those struggles when they were still rookies......it must have been really hard for them to continue but they continued anyway despite the hate they get from others, i really love these girls and im really proud to be a reveluv........im glad that i stan them♥️♥️♥️
omg their voices are so amazing live i love irene and joy, they're so cute! seulgi and wendy have such incredible stage presence and voice. red velvet fighting!
Looking at the comments a lot of people are focusing on their looks instead of their talent. What they say is true. K-pop is all about the looks instead of the talent. Big mama is the perfect example. Literally a group of power house vocalist that who I admit were not the prettiest women out their, but their vocal talent was literally so GLORIOUS looks were not important it was even stated in their contract that they were not allowed to get plastic surgery. So it's sad to see in 2015 people are still ignoring the fact that red velvet has talent and focusing on strictly their looks. All 4 girls can sing. All 4 girls can dance. All 4 girls can dance and still sing and have stable voices and perfect harmonies. Also for someone to say they'll never be great as SNSD or F(x) I'm a huge fan of those two groups. But let me tell you SNSD is a group of 8 girls 2 of them can actually sing live really well. Their 2 lead vocalist struggle live. 1 of those lead vocalist lacks technique and is overrated and their Choreo is not as difficult as red velvets. Then you have F(x). SM named Luna "little BoA" because of her dance and vocal talent. Then you have krystal she's decent. Then you have Sulli she's decent as well people just hate her so much to realise that. Then you have Amber the groups rapper but she's actually a better vocalist than rapper (SM doesn't see it that way though) then you have Victoria who is the main dancer who isn't really that good at singing. So with that being said stop hating on red velvet already and just realise that they actually have talent A LOT more than a lot of these girl groups out here.
![Red Velvet (레드벨벳) - Be Natural [Music Bank HOT Stage / 2014.10.31]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7HDKmtypBAg/mqdefault.jpg)
when red velvet come to their velvet side its mean sexy and classy. Another level of sexy. I love this side more tbh, not so many idol has this concept but sadly korean more like music like red side.
completely agree
AGREE!! i think be natural and automatic is amzing song and more addicted for me.
i love the velvet side more and i really don't get that cute stuff, cause wtf, theyre grown up women, it's ok to be a bit playful, but not EVRYTHING CUTE AND ON EVRY VARIETY AEGYO and how they cringe obviously, aegyo is a interesting thing, cause kt matters how a person does it, but not EVERYWHERE
But now Korean people likes Bad Boy which is Velvet side
Yeeeees i this more because yeri wasnt added here im sorry but red velvet had so much potential in this era they dont have to adjust with yeri but now they are becoming easy on steps and jolly songs because yeri cant do so :((
i miss this era 😭 and their hair too lol no bangs and dark colours 💞
sidhad SAME😭😭😭😭😭
isn't peek a boo doing the same tho?
same here
Black Velvet they still have bangs in peek a boo
@@los5280 Rbb say hello
Wendy live is awsome! Sooo stable. You can see she is so enjoyed
Flora Miao coz she is main vocal..
I miss the era when backsound is not really loud so we can hear the singer’s real voice which is like this video
I miss this era when they are wonderful as same :(
Their Debut era is really Wendy's golden era . She's the prettiest among them with black hair w/o bangs.
Ariann Elago Nam Jeon i think the term prettiest is relative tho because i thought joy looks the prettiets here :)
Ariann Elago Nam Jeon prettiest*
Ariann Elago Nam Jeon i think in these era seulgi shined the most 'cause of her body😍😍😍
agree! wendy is so sexy and elegant here. but she's still sexy til now.
Natasha Baizley still depends on you about the prettiest in here, but still seulgi for me but wendy is prettier in this era than now
I am probably goona get hate for this but I think red velvet is one of the best groups who is really good at singing live with hard dance.
savi pun Yeah, I agree. And they seems very professional. You can see that they are serious.
It's sad that SONE, Affecxion, EXO-L didn't like them because they debut on the worst moment of 2014.
Hope that 2015 they willl shine with their own SONG DANCE and PERFORMANCE.
They are really talented at singing, dancing, visual, professional;;;;;;
You're absolutely right! This song is incredibly hard to sing alone.
Fightfor Marina I think its not. I'm an EXO-L but I love Red Velvet too. ^^
-,- u sure they r singing good?
@booma A
Try to do the choreography, while catching your breath and singing, especially those long notes. Plus being alert on finding where the cameras are to make eye contact, it's not that easy. Seulgi @1:12 had to dance weaker than usual in order to concentrate more on singing and having a clearer voice.
이때 나 왜 덕질 안했냐...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 그나저나 진짜 이 노래 개 높고 어려워보이는데 연습생때 많이 연습했나보네ㅠㅠ 확실히 개잘함
나 또한 스스로에게 묻고 있다, ㅠㅠ 나는 데뷔 이후부터 팬이 되었어야 했다 ㅇㅅㅇ
난 또 왜 올해 빠져버렸나ㅠ 밀린 영상 차곡차곡 보고있는 중..
난 이 노래 너무 사랑해..원곡부터 개사기인 곡이지만 레벨버전도 너무너무 좋다구 ㅠㅠㅠ
아니 어떻게 저런춤을 추면서 라이브라니......
이때 웬디 너무예뻐.. 데뷔초 웬디 진짜 넘 예뻐.. 아크케때도 개이뻤는데.. 데뷔초때 스타일링 보고싶어.. 웬디 데뷔초느낌 데뷔초웬디밖에 못내.. 조이 글고 완전 애기다.. ㅠㅠ 귀여워잉.. 슬기도 이때 냉미녀느낌 완전 낭낭함 오짐 ㅠ 아이린은 말할것도없고..
Irene natural beauty💋
응, 이런 스타일의 웬디를 다시 봐야 해, 정말 잘 어울리잖아?
레벨영상보면 외국인들도 다 이 얘기함ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
아치형 눈썹에 깐머 존버....
전 웬디 지금이 더 이쁜듯
Seulgi Kang is a goddess. Her stage presence is a no joke. She's gorgeous. OMG! :)
IKR? 😍 Your username... I thought I was the only who thinks Seulgi = Victoria's Secret model.
YASSS
She is so beautiful. Goddess.
wendy looks amazing without bangs 😍 i think it's because you can pay more attention to her face
ikr personally she looks better without them
지금의 레벨도 좋지만 어색하고 풋풋하면서도 열심히 하는 ㅠ 그런 데뷔 초 느낌 가득한 느낌이랑 컨셉 너무 그립다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Seulgi just predict peek A boo #thumbnail
Its an Illuminati sign.. Btw
@@lailakhan1677 you actually believe in those shit? lol
@@BouBBleBu ikr i cant believe they are that brainwashed that they believe in that eyed triangle shit 💀💀💀
Star Estrella it’s a joke
@@lailakhan1677wtf lmao
seulgi is the real life fire emoji in human form
THE ACCURACY OF THIS COMMENT
YES I KNOW RIGHT
lolll 🔥🔥
IT IS A FACT
i'll kill the one who will question that
Anybody who says these girls can't sing live clearly needs their ears checked. Like, the only grip I have with this live is when they mix their vocals in the chorus and all slide up to the high note cuz one person always sticks out. Always. But besides that, they sound great. ESPECIALLY with the difficulty of this choreography. Like, I know senior girl groups who can't even do a simple cat walk and sing with a steady voice. Like, stop people. These girls have decent vocals. That and both Wendy and Seulgi, with more vocal training and practice, are gonna be vocal powerhouses as they mature and go farther in the industry.
this is also a cover, and thats how the original is... lol
I think YOU have a big glob of earwax stuck in YOUR ears. This is just horrible!
+103917158834634052589 Not at all. Clearly that's you. The chorus part may be rough, but they all sound fine, especially Wendy and Seulgi.
they're not bad as a rookie group but still hv a lot of room to improve
delay cious
No, they ARE bad for a SM rookie group that SM had hoped would blow the socks off of everyone. They are not now....nor will they ever be anywhere near as good as snsd or F(x). This group of girls can't sing that well and they are very very very bland. There is nothing about them that stands out.
Wendy! she is the best! OMG ver voice is amazing
강슬기 진짜 미쳤다 너무 잘하네.....
I love that in every be natural performance Wendy always gives joy this cute smile when they push their chairs together!
0:26 조이 미친거 아니냐 진짜 분위기 뭐야 어떻게 저렇게 애기같인 애한테서 저런 몽환적인 분위기가 나오뮤퓨 스엠이 비공개한 이유가 있었네 있었어...
조이 완전 애기다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 둥둥이 시절
I love how Wendi looks like she loves what she does :)
Wendy Is Amazing
ㅁㅊ 역시 갓드벨벳 거의 생라이브네
seulgi voice is so sweet.
Seulgi is so beautiful in the thumbnail
this choreo was life
yoonmin rise Created by Kyle Hanagami ❤
숨소리 들리는것 보소...저 춤에 저정도 실력의 라이브라니ㅜㅜㅜ
Seulgi and Wendy just killed it!
Seulgi be giving us spoilers on 2017 Peekaboo comeback 👏
wendy and seulgi's vocal are totally divas
All those hair flips and no one looked like Sadako. Now that is skill. I remember when Suzy and Hara did a sexy dance battle; I laughed my ass off at Suzy.
akiheavenly6 hey dumbass who brought Suzy in this 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
The Rock lol. So what??😂😂😂😂suzy deserve to get laughed. she is still amazing tho
Lovely performance: these girls are the stand-out "rookies" of 2014!
Yes them and mamamoo i love them both
lsear2905 how did you predict rookie????
Prachi Kondapuram
O.O
One of the groups that literally sang live during their debut and nailed it.
진짜 ㄹㅇ쌩라이브를 이렇게했엇구나,,,, 진짜잘하네 옛날느낌나고 좋다
Wendy's confidence in their debut era is undeniably strong. Just look at her. 🥺 I just hope we can get this wannie back. Her stage presence during their debut days is so stunning and mesmerizing. I don't know what happened exactly but you can tell there's a difference between then and now. I miss you Wendy. Hoping to see you soon performing with Red Velvet again.
What's wrong with now Wendy?
Wendyyy😍
Seungwan's voice is just so good
Seulgi ^_^!!..
Everyone did great especially Wendy. Her High Notes *_*
i actually love this because you can tell they're actually singing and they still managed to sing well while doing their dance!
Seulgi is so damn beautiful, sexy, alluring and charismatic. She's perfect plus she's very talented
Wendy looks so good here
웬디 진짜 잘한다.. 어쩜 저렇게 잘하지
와 이걸 라이브로했었구나...진짜 대단하다
0:39 Seulgi my love
와 레벨 데뷔초 진짜 구ㅣ엽다..ㅡㅜㅜㅜ 근데 이노래는 옛날 노랜데도 불구하고 지금 들어도 좋다....
why did i just realize that wendy is so prettyyy
Yoo Hara
I've been noticed she's the prettiest. I still feel that way to this day!
OMG that Seulgi's hand sign in the thumbnail !!! Peek-A-Boo 👌
이때나 지금이나 여전히 다 이쁘다ㅠㅜㅜ 사랑해 진짜
Wendyyy
I cant stop watching this..... ADDICTED
Wendy on the debut era is so effortless beauty 😍
it's 2020 and i just read comments from 5/6 years ago that really broke my heart. many people said rv will flop and didnt deserve the attention they're getting. i just couldnt imagine the struggles they had in their rookie years. im really happy and proud with what they have now. red velvet fighting!!
Sameeeeeee~ im really proud of red velvet because they overcame those struggles when they were still rookies......it must have been really hard for them to continue but they continued anyway despite the hate they get from others, i really love these girls and im really proud to be a reveluv........im glad that i stan them♥️♥️♥️
둥둥이 너모 귀여워ㅠㅠㅠㅠ...애기네😭
조이 진짜 너무 귀엽다....ㅠㅠㅠ 애기야...ㅠㅠㅠ
COACHELLA 2024 MANIFESTING
I love this side of RV, I hope they show it more in the next album!!
I know that they still are rookie but sing this "live" WOW I get impress :)))))))))) Wendy your voice it killer .
To me there's nothing better than cute girls of RV wearing suits dancing on chairs while singing jazzy K-pop song :')))))
I hear you, for me, too.
벨벳 컨셉 최고야 짜릿해
진짜 애기애기하다~♡ 지금 다시 라이브 볼수있으면 좋겠어요.. 더 어울릴거같아
아직도 보는 사람 없겟지...ㅋ...아오사랑해요
RED VELVET is cute love you
나 이거 왜 이제 봄. 너무 예쁘잖아 ❤
Seulgi ♥
They were killing it ! Vocally and with their dance moves ! Nice!
Wendy bias confirmed. Her voice is amazing...
omg their voices are so amazing live
i love irene and joy, they're so cute! seulgi and wendy have such incredible stage presence and voice.
red velvet fighting!
Red Velvet proved that you don’t need to reveal your skin to be “sexy.” It’s all about the confidence and I stick by that!
Seulgi 😍😍😍😍
they are very pretty！
Irene smile though ♥ And SEULGI killed it gossh! :)
Looking at the comments a lot of people are focusing on their looks instead of their talent. What they say is true. K-pop is all about the looks instead of the talent. Big mama is the perfect example. Literally a group of power house vocalist that who I admit were not the prettiest women out their, but their vocal talent was literally so GLORIOUS looks were not important it was even stated in their contract that they were not allowed to get plastic surgery. So it's sad to see in 2015 people are still ignoring the fact that red velvet has talent and focusing on strictly their looks. All 4 girls can sing. All 4 girls can dance. All 4 girls can dance and still sing and have stable voices and perfect harmonies. Also for someone to say they'll never be great as SNSD or F(x) I'm a huge fan of those two groups. But let me tell you SNSD is a group of 8 girls 2 of them can actually sing live really well. Their 2 lead vocalist struggle live. 1 of those lead vocalist lacks technique and is overrated and their Choreo is not as difficult as red velvets. Then you have F(x). SM named Luna "little BoA" because of her dance and vocal talent. Then you have krystal she's decent. Then you have Sulli she's decent as well people just hate her so much to realise that. Then you have Amber the groups rapper but she's actually a better vocalist than rapper (SM doesn't see it that way though) then you have Victoria who is the main dancer who isn't really that good at singing. So with that being said stop hating on red velvet already and just realise that they actually have talent A LOT more than a lot of these girl groups out here.
Wow....Preach much?
Sorry?
Like I agree with u 100% PREACH🙌
Oh!! Thank you 😅🙈
+Raini Kim Ikr i agree
완전 애기들이야ㅜㅠㅜㅡ언니들인데 이땐 너무 귀여워서 우쭈쭈해주고 싶다... 곡은 차분하고 성숙한데 지금 모습이랑 비교하니깐 너무 귀여워ㅜㅠㅜㅜ
Wendy looked stunning in this era!
I'm falling love with Seulgi she is so talented and pretty girl ❤
Wendy without bangs reminds me of Park Min Young both are so gorgeouss
Wendy is so pretty. Cant wait for their comeback!
their harmonization is out of this world.. and yah this was selugi's era her movements are so sharp
Their live 😍
I stan the right group so proud
오랜만에 보니까 눈물이 나요
please SM give them more outfits like this. THAT STYLE IS AWESOME. do not let them have only girly styles.
Seulgi is sich a vampire she doesnt age. Her face is still the same. Trully the goddess of youth
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ이 때도 잘하긴하는데 약간 신인티 난다 다들 귀여워...특히 조이 살짝 지금보다 포동한게 넘나 졸귀
나 이거 초딩때 많이 들었는데 지금 들어도 진짜 좋네ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
당시에 진짜 많이 들었던 노랜데 추억이다 ㅜㅠㅠ❤️
JOY IS LIFE !1!1!1!1!
아 이때 레벨 너무 조아해ㅛ써 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 예쁘니덜,,
This and Automatic are still 2 of the hottest dances ever in Kpop in my opinion!
I'm reminiscing and all I can say is that they ate cd and still eating. Their voices is just 😍❤
진짜 한 명도 빠짐없이 4명 다 매력있다.
와 슬기언니 존예..애기+여신 느낌
Joy so amazing
i love wendy with bangs, she actually inspired me to get bangs and i haven’t gone back, but she really rocks this look 😍
진짜개이쁨 ㅜㅜ
생라이브 굳굳
They looked so classic, elegant and gorgeous in this era. So Natural.
너무 이쁜 언니야들
난 이때 레드벨벳이 너무 좋음 밸런스가 진짜 기막힘 그리고 네명이라는게 그룹분위기에ㅡ너무 잘맞아서 유니크함
아이린만 미래에서 온사람같네 그대로야;; 다른멤버는 화장이나,볼살땜에 지금이랑 조금다른데
Wendy