I am french and of course I love Penaud, he is in the top 3 for me but Cheslin Kolbe is a legend, probably the best winger since Lomu. So Kolbe is top 1 for me
Never thought I'd see 2 Argentinian wingers on a list like this based on their history. 3 South Africans in the top 10 makes me proud. Some might not want to put Penaud at the top but I don't think there's much between the top few. I'd have James Lowe and Will Jordan higher up on the list, 3rd and 4th.
@@alpozongo1485outpace him while Penaud was on the backfoot ? Amazing play by Kriele, but any decent winger should have scored that try. Kolbe is amazing, and more complete than Penaud. But Penaud is unmatched in terms of raw attacking abilities. Escaped 75% of the tackles attempted on him in 2023, and averages 1 try per game since Galthié took over. They’re both the best, depends on what criterion. But Kolbe was average at Toulon and had a poor season in Japan, he’s an amazing player but playing with the best forward pack in the world makes your life much easier
Kolbe best winger right now.....,speed, strength,step,stamina,good gameplay read, electrifying acceleration,all round even his last game against NZ he become Hooker😂..Penaud is not even close to cheslin.... even if we go back in history he makes the Top 3,his cemented his legendary Status... he ahs the most word cup tropy aa winger and present on all occasions😅
It surprises me that Duhan van der Merwe is even on this list. Two tries scored by Telea against Scotland and both because of Duhan leaving the gap on the outside - he is so bad that he is responsible for almost as many tries against Scotland as he has scored for them.
@@rugbybuzz I get that. My top 10 would be almost identical, albeit subjectively in a different order. So in the spirit of having a bit of fun, let's say we replace Duhan and let's say we need to give the North a bit more leeway... Mack Hansen or Josh Adams. Even Darcy Graham and Kyle Steyn are better than Duhan in my humble opinion - just as good with ball in hand even if they don't have the same brute strength, not as selfish with the ball and both good defenders.
@@Karma-qt4ji Great points! Duhan on one wing and Darcy on the other for Scotland is tasty! Darcy is RAPID! Steyn is underrated I feel? What other Top 10's would you like to see?
Kurt Lee Arendse is better than Duhan. How is Damian penaud better then Cheslin Kolbe, when Kolbe literally left him in the dust in the quarterfinals when chasing the gruber kick
Sevu Reece is number 1. He just does way more off the ball stuff than any other wing in the world. He was the only reason NZ won that game against England yesterday. He scored a try, a 50/20, tackled and took high high balls PERFECTLY and got the decisive turnover in the match. He's easily the best winger in the world with the best alround skillset and daylight second. Jordan scores tries thats it he does nothing else. Talea is top 10 just from his carrying ability and clark behind him. So again this list is by someone that only watches northern hemisphere rugby.
@@kungfukhi2378 oh they’re coming…I’m splitting them into “Inside” and “Outside”…”Top 10 Inside Centres” video is already in the works 💪🏻 It’s like you read my mind 👀 In hindsight I should’ve split the wingers too…oh well there’s always next time!
Penaud and Kolbe should swap, I think Jordan is better than Telea and Van der Merwe, maybe even Arendse and Penaud too (He is on a try a game!). James is also too Lowe, and so is Koroibete. Then you missed Mapimpi and Tuisova. I like Semi too, but I would rather pick Tuisova. Great list none the less.
Security Reece will outplay 10-3 on most days, and Kolbe is just on fire this year (and for a while now)… while @Damian Penaud is amazing in many ways, I think Kolbe would be my starter….
@@LolwethuAqhamileKahla his recent form has maybe made him top of this list now…Kolbe and Penaud are my favourite wingers - DVDM is also incredible imo!
We're not sleeping on him, he's just not good enough to be no.1. That is why only 1 team from the NH has ever one a world cup. You overestimate your playing capabilities
Not one of those wingers is near the level of cheslin kolbe. Kolbe is the best winger and arguably the best rugby player. Please update your list. Mark Telea is not even a top 6 rugby winger.
Semi is playing league and has been in the news recently for some not great things…Reece - agree he’ll be on my next list when I go another one in a 6 months
Koroibete is not even Australia’s best winger right now, and that says a lot. Duhan is overrated. 1 Kolbe 2 Penaud 3 Jordan 4 Telea 5 Arendse 6 Lowe 7 Clarke 8 Mapimpi 9 Duhan 10 Moodie
@@rugbybuzz he is an absolut star against average teams, so 95% of the time he looks amazing, but when the real heat is up in for instance world cup games against real pressure teams in high pressure games then he has no answers, so he definitely isn't no 1. He performs really well when france has the upper hand, in that south african 1/4 final he probably would have been a star if france had the upper hand and was leading all the time but the pressure was so much that you could see the panic in his face, if it wasn't for Dupont france was gonna loose bad that day. Dupont, now there is a crazy good no 1 player for his 9 position. You should do a best player in the world, would be interesting to see the comments
Anyone we've missed??? 👇
Colbe and damain have to switch
Damian is overrated in my opinion
@@KyeCummings-lm1pzagreed very overrated
I would swap Will Jordan and Penaud 100% even though Jordan is injured he is astonishing
you missed Julian Savea and Rieko Ioane they're both from AllBlacks
I am french and of course I love Penaud, he is in the top 3 for me but Cheslin Kolbe is a legend, probably the best winger since Lomu. So Kolbe is top 1 for me
Many of them are interchangeable…I had to choose one! ☝🏼
yes
@@rugbybuzz yeah i quite agree
Cheslin should be number one
Fair play!
How is Cheslin kolbe 2nd?????
Penaud is a great player but don't forget how Kolbe made Penaud eat grass in the quarter finals
Ooh come on from one game? Look both are unreal! I would happily have both as my wingers 😛
Really, Penaud above Telea, Will Jordan, kolbe and Kurt Lee? Not a chance
all days mate, penaud break 3/4 of the tackles in 2023, he have a peculiar way to run that makes him almost impossible to tackle
May Maybe it s because he scores a lot more than others
Haha I disagree thundercat - but we all have an opinion - many top pundits are of a like mind to this list so I feel it’s pretty accurate
@@rugbybuzzyour option is Kak
Leak of rugby brains
Penaud is great but I think Kolbe is much better
Kolbe is king period
I agree
Yes, but his current form says otherwise
@@nixz7622 who’s your Top10 or Top5?
@@rugbybuzzSame as yours, just involving Mapimpi and Will Jordan in the top 3
Never thought I'd see 2 Argentinian wingers on a list like this based on their history. 3 South Africans in the top 10 makes me proud. Some might not want to put Penaud at the top but I don't think there's much between the top few. I'd have James Lowe and Will Jordan higher up on the list, 3rd and 4th.
Interestingly Telea's father is also South African. So you can make it 3 and a half South Africans in the top 5 :p
I'm French and i agree penaud is not better than will Jordan, telea or mapimpi, kolbe or arendse.
Penaud is leagues behind kolbe
Clearly admin Mr. Admin forgot what Kolbe did to him in the World Cup 😮💨
😮 😢 noooooo can’t be true
@@alpozongo1485outpace him while Penaud was on the backfoot ? Amazing play by Kriele, but any decent winger should have scored that try. Kolbe is amazing, and more complete than Penaud. But Penaud is unmatched in terms of raw attacking abilities. Escaped 75% of the tackles attempted on him in 2023, and averages 1 try per game since Galthié took over. They’re both the best, depends on what criterion. But Kolbe was average at Toulon and had a poor season in Japan, he’s an amazing player but playing with the best forward pack in the world makes your life much easier
Kolbe complete player , top of the pile..
Hmmmmm maybe you’re right?
Neutral fan here, seeing all comment saying Penaud is overrated is mad, not saying hes better than Kolbe or Kurtlee, but overrated is so wrong.
🙏🏻
Kolbe best winger right now.....,speed, strength,step,stamina,good gameplay read, electrifying acceleration,all round even his last game against NZ he become Hooker😂..Penaud is not even close to cheslin.... even if we go back in history he makes the Top 3,his cemented his legendary Status... he ahs the most word cup tropy aa winger and present on all occasions😅
Great points!!
Kurt Lee over Talea and Duhan for me.
Oosh
Cheslin Kolbe is number 1 winger in the world ❤❤❤
🙏🏻
That Van Der Merwe try against Eng. Outstanding.
Sevu Reece should be on the top 5 imo
He's the best winger in the world right this minute. And he'll be world player of the year if he doesnt get injured.
Fair play!
Penaud is Good but honestly feel like he's being over-rated quite often!!!!
All a bit of fun! Who's your top 10?
Kolbe is much better
It surprises me that Duhan van der Merwe is even on this list. Two tries scored by Telea against Scotland and both because of Duhan leaving the gap on the outside - he is so bad that he is responsible for almost as many tries against Scotland as he has scored for them.
All a bit of fun! Who's your top 10?
@@rugbybuzz I get that.
My top 10 would be almost identical, albeit subjectively in a different order. So in the spirit of having a bit of fun, let's say we replace Duhan and let's say we need to give the North a bit more leeway... Mack Hansen or Josh Adams. Even Darcy Graham and Kyle Steyn are better than Duhan in my humble opinion - just as good with ball in hand even if they don't have the same brute strength, not as selfish with the ball and both good defenders.
@@Karma-qt4ji Great points! Duhan on one wing and Darcy on the other for Scotland is tasty! Darcy is RAPID! Steyn is underrated I feel? What other Top 10's would you like to see?
Mateo carreras esta entre los mejores cinco!
Good list, but 1 and 2 need to be swapped.
Fair play 💪🏻
Putting that French guy above two time world cup winner Cheslin Kolbe is what cost you a subscriber.. Great video tho
@@WmRowe-yx8iq hahaha “that French guy” 😂😂😂 I’d happily have either at no1…I think they’re far above the rest…thanks for the feedback 🙏🏻
99% of the comments say kolbe is No1 ...how did you miss that @rugbybuzz ?????
Because most of the people commenting are South African 🇿🇦 😜
@@rugbybuzz then your list is bias
@@Homeboy8686 bias? I’m neither French nor South African…I think this list is very fair and balanced…🧐
Kurt Lee Arendse is better than Duhan. How is Damian penaud better then Cheslin Kolbe, when Kolbe literally left him in the dust in the quarterfinals when chasing the gruber kick
Just our opinion! They’re interchangeable really 🤔 All amazing players!
Theirs no way Penaud is better than Kolbe. Kurt Lee is also a better finisher than Penaud, and what strength does Penaud have?
All a bit of fun! Who's your top 10?
Penaud's strengths are his vision of the game, his creativity and his effectiveness in duels.
But I agree, Kolbe is the best winger in the world.
No way Penaud is better than Kolbe
I THINK COLBE SHOULD BE FIRST HE IS SO FAST AND THE BEST WINGER
@@ChristanSwanepoel fair enough buddy! I would be happy with Kolbe or Penaud as no.1 - both feel like a step above the rest imo 💪🏻
C'mon how can you have Kolbe anywhere other than 1!
I was 51% Penaud 49% Kolbe at No.1. So hard to pick! All amazing players!
Cheslin Kolbe is nr 1 all the way Penau could not touch Kolbe in the world cup
But this is more than just 1 game…
Cheslin should have been 1st
Fair play!!! Great player
TOP 3 CHANGE LIST (on on my bros phone) I’m from nz btw
1. Kolbe (unstoppable)
2. Telea (unstoppable
3. Penaud (mid asf😊)
Fair play bro!!! 👊🏼
Sevu Reece is number 1. He just does way more off the ball stuff than any other wing in the world. He was the only reason NZ won that game against England yesterday. He scored a try, a 50/20, tackled and took high high balls PERFECTLY and got the decisive turnover in the match. He's easily the best winger in the world with the best alround skillset and daylight second. Jordan scores tries thats it he does nothing else. Talea is top 10 just from his carrying ability and clark behind him. So again this list is by someone that only watches northern hemisphere rugby.
This list was done before all of these recent internationals…everyone has an opinion 👍🏼
Kolbe did make him a fool in World Cup from Jessie kriels kick
Kolbe ,Will Jordan and Koribete are my top three .
Koroibete in his twilight years - still a scary player!!!
So cool
Penaud is a great winger but his no Chesley kolbe
Oooooh
Kurt Lee is my goat I like how he plays I think Kurt Lee Arendse wil soon be better than Cheslin Kolbe 😢😊
Oosh! He is quality!!!
Fact that Will Jordan’s at 6 😂. He’s better than everyone there only competition is kolbe
Marika koroibetez have folded him n ragdolled him numerous times
Not Penaud? 🤔
Cheslin must go for 1 in rugby buzz
Some say Kolbe some say Penaud! Hard to choose! If they were combined they’d be unstoppable!! 🔥
Kolbe is the hero
Cheslin Kolbe 🐐
Will Jordan and Kolbe
Both unreal!
Kolbe definitely at number 1. Having said that, I think Penaud should come in at a strong number 3.
Koroibete should be in the top 5
While you're at it add edwil ver der merwe
What a list! Hard to argue really! 😅
Thanks 🙏🏻
I think kolbe should take the number 1spot🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦
I bet than in 3 years max, the young french *Attisogbe* will be top 5 of your list, such a talent.
My eyes will be on the lookout!
Todos de primer nivel tres o cuatro sobresalen del resto, buen top pero nuestro mateo carreras mi elegido! 🏉🇦🇷👉
Kolbi IS the best winner off all Time
It was a tough call!
penaud is great but kolbe is mush better
@@sarathrajamuni fair enough! But I wouldn’t say “much” better - I think both are far above the rest 👍🏼
We gotta have the centers next
@@kungfukhi2378 oh they’re coming…I’m splitting them into “Inside” and “Outside”…”Top 10 Inside Centres” video is already in the works 💪🏻 It’s like you read my mind 👀 In hindsight I should’ve split the wingers too…oh well there’s always next time!
Colbe first
Penaud and Kolbe should swap, I think Jordan is better than Telea and Van der Merwe, maybe even Arendse and Penaud too (He is on a try a game!). James is also too Lowe, and so is Koroibete. Then you missed Mapimpi and Tuisova. I like Semi too, but I would rather pick Tuisova. Great list none the less.
“James is also too Lowe” - very good 👏🏻
So many unreal players to choose from!!!
van der Merwe should not even be on the list!
Dane Cole's was the best
Security Reece will outplay 10-3 on most days, and Kolbe is just on fire this year (and for a while now)… while @Damian Penaud is amazing in many ways, I think Kolbe would be my starter….
2 de nueva Zelanda 2 de Sudáfrica y 2 argentinos el hemisferio sur domina 😮😊
I didn't realise I only have 3/10 Northern Hemisphere players!
KOLBE'S BIG MATCH TEMPERAMENT IS OF THE CHARTS.WC 1/4'S KOLBE CATCHED AND PASSED PENNAUD.KOLBE IS THE BEST .
True he steps up in the big games
No offense, no Fijian Winger in this top 10 like Josua Tuisova. Who is the wrecking ball. 😅
I see him more of a centre 🤔
WE ALL KNOW THE TOP SPOT GOES TO CHESLIN KOLBE! 🏆🏆🏆🏆
I wanna smoke what made you place Penaud at No.1😅😅
😆
I left a dislike how is Cheslin Kolbe not First
Definitely Cheslin Colby I the best winger by far followed by Kurtly Arends,please don't bluff yourself
👍🏼
No way Penaud is even close to Kolbe mate.
Oosh not sure about that one 😛
Mateo carreras 🏉🇦🇷👏👏👏👏
Putting kolbe at 2 is criminal.This guy should watch the full games and not the clips
I watch full games my friend. It’s just my opinion - each to their own
Will Jordan should be higher, Talea good and Sevu Reece, James Lowe higher than Damien Penaud.
Kolbe is for sure no one ? Or am I missing something 🤔
Yeah but he might be taking enhancement drugs because a lot of SAs getting banned for taking drugs.
Some say Penaud some say Kolbe! Hard to choose! If they were combined they’d be a superhuman winger 🔥
Colbe must be nr 1
It was tough choice!!!
Penaud above Kolbe??? Are you kidding???
Fijian wingers are the best and more entertaining.
Entertaining for sure!!!
D van der merwe can only attack, he cant defend or even jump in the air, he should be number 10 maybe
All a bit of fun! Who's your top 10?
i also dont agree with no 1 spot, koble and arsende should be 1 and 2
Fair enough! All amazing!
Kolbe left Penaud for dead couldn't handle that speed lol Kolbe nr 1 for me
Cheslin Kolbe is the best
@@LolwethuAqhamileKahla his recent form has maybe made him top of this list now…Kolbe and Penaud are my favourite wingers - DVDM is also incredible imo!
Penaud should be much further down this list, or maybe even misses out on top 10 for me.
Woah!
Maybe not accurate for 2024
@@clementconstant1515 how come? Who’s your Top 10? 🏉
1. Cheslin Kolbe
2. Will Jordan or Kurt lee Arendse
3. Will Jordan or Kurt Lee Arendse
4. Damian penaud
5. Mark Telea
@@MrDude-ht3rv strong - can’t argue 😂 They’re all great! So hard to rank them!
Where is David Niniashvili?
@@giorgigvaberidze6433 he’s in my next video…stay tuned…
I'm a bit confused I thought lol would be at least top 5 😂😮
Arendse is better 2nd 🎉
Fair enough - very good player indeed!!!
Top 3south Africa
Mapimpi not on the list🌚 Chesline number 2 instead number 1👀 . This list is not it
Haha not it for you…it’s just my list buddy! What’s your top 10? 🔥
You're missing the best winger and deserves #1 and that's salesitino Ravutaumada.
Ooosh quality but not sure he makes my list! Let’s see if he makes my next one 🔥
Where is Mazokole Mampimpi
Tough to leave him out 😢
@@rugbybuzz but good list overall just wished he would of been there
Penaud above kolbe, I really can’t agree with that. Penaud is overrated
All open to an opinion! Who’s your top10? Or top3? All a bit of fun 🤩
@@rugbybuzz kolbe, Jordan and tellia
Is this a French channel?
@@jabumalindi 😂 I am not French, no. Lists are made with a few people’s objective opinions 👍🏼
Your so off, top 3 is Arendse , Jordan, Kolbe. Stop playing here.
No Penaud? In the NH he's rated very highly but in the SH people seem to sleep on him 👀
We're not sleeping on him, he's just not good enough to be no.1. That is why only 1 team from the NH has ever one a world cup. You overestimate your playing capabilities
Like really are you serious 😂😂😂 mxim?
Why not? 😛
Kolbe definitely number 1.
Kolbe is better than peanaud and arendse is better than fan de merwe
Not one of those wingers is near the level of cheslin kolbe. Kolbe is the best winger and arguably the best rugby player. Please update your list. Mark Telea is not even a top 6 rugby winger.
Where’s Tuisova 😢
I had him on my inside centres list! I see him more of a centre rather than a wing but he’s great on both to be fair!!!
Kurt-lee is better than Penaud and Duhan and it's not even being funny
Penaud is better than kolbe
Oosh 😢
Where is Semi R.?
Reece?
No Fijian wingers?
Something wrong there.
Semi is playing league and has been in the news recently for some not great things…Reece - agree he’ll be on my next list when I go another one in a 6 months
Koroibete is not even Australia’s best winger right now, and that says a lot. Duhan is overrated.
1 Kolbe
2 Penaud
3 Jordan
4 Telea
5 Arendse
6 Lowe
7 Clarke
8 Mapimpi
9 Duhan
10 Moodie
Nice list! Everyone has their favourites! I try to be as objective as possible!
Never!!!😂😂😂 He's not No.1 we all know..he knows
👀
Kolbe far better than Penaud
I think they’re interchangeable really…Penaud is key for France 🇫🇷 They’re all great! 🏉
penaud is no no 1, a 6 maybe
😮😮😮
@@rugbybuzz he is an absolut star against average teams, so 95% of the time he looks amazing, but when the real heat is up in for instance world cup games against real pressure teams in high pressure games then he has no answers, so he definitely isn't no 1. He performs really well when france has the upper hand, in that south african 1/4 final he probably would have been a star if france had the upper hand and was leading all the time but the pressure was so much that you could see the panic in his face, if it wasn't for Dupont france was gonna loose bad that day.
Dupont, now there is a crazy good no 1 player for his 9 position.
You should do a best player in the world, would be interesting to see the comments
@@thomasVA9707 I did this video recently! Take a look!!!
Penaud it's a joke I rate him 3
Oosh 😢
Where is Matt Hansen
A lot of injury recently - hard to judge his form tbh 🤔
Numéro 2 kolbi?😮😂😂😂 Fake
Highly inaccurate 😂
All a bit of fun! Who's your top 10?