You’ve got 3 All Blacks on the list, but 1 South African. Scrumhalf is probably South Africa’s deepest position right now. At least one of Grant Williams or Cobus Reinach has to be on the list if not both. Finlay, White, TJ and Lucu, none of them are better than Reinach or Williams.
I just went with my gut on this one! Tough position to call! I’ve got an overall Top 10 best players vid dropping in a few days - let’s see what ya think of that one ☝🏼
He’s not even among the best 9s in the top 14. Couilloud, Jauneau, Arrata, Serin, Le Garrec are all better than him. And to be fair, any 9 in the world would appear good with the South African pack in front of him. But Reinach at Montpellier is bang average
How can u not put grant williams here he has been the best scrumhalf in south africa for 2 years now and the racing 92 scrum half also deserves to be here since he plays similar to dupont 🤦🏽
@@jameswyatt4443 haha I know but it still means his quality is there 🤷🏻♂️ He’s only fresh out of the ABs…this time next year his standard will have likely dropped playing in Japan, so probably wouldn’t make my Top10…
How can u not put grant williams here he has been the best scrumhalf in south africa for 2 years now and the racing 92 scrum half also deserves to be here since he plays similar to dupont 🤦🏽
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Love this videos
You’ve got 3 All Blacks on the list, but 1 South African. Scrumhalf is probably South Africa’s deepest position right now. At least one of Grant Williams or Cobus Reinach has to be on the list if not both. Finlay, White, TJ and Lucu, none of them are better than Reinach or Williams.
Saffas always whinig. Be lucky Faf is even on the list. He is a mad dog and a very good rugby player, but doesn't stand out as a scrumhalf
@@sebastiengarrigues6703 All the South African scrumhalves would start over the players I named.
I just went with my gut on this one! Tough position to call! I’ve got an overall Top 10 best players vid dropping in a few days - let’s see what ya think of that one ☝🏼
@@rugbybuzzu need to do better research we the World Champs but your list is not showing that .
@@burtonjacobs5407 that’s a team effort mate…I’m doing individuals here…
can u make a top ten players in World Rugby
It’s like you read my mind - video in the works!
How can you put Ben White above Baptiste Serin when he is Serin's substitute at Toulon?
I just think White is the more complete no.9 🤷
@@rugbybuzzwell you know better than their coach Mignoni then ? If it wasn’t for Dupont, he would have 80+ caps for France
Were is nolann le garrec ?!
Tough to leave him out!
Who?
The bronze goes to the guy who won the gold two times! 😂
Well yeah because rugby is a team sport. Not individual.
Because he s far from being even close to the best . Period
I hear ya but I could say second yes but surely Dupont is better…?
I go with Cam roigard
Grant Williams is great but he not in his prime yet 🙄
True! Looking forward to seeing how he develops!
Finlay I am not too sure about though.
@@igsaan8573 roigard would be in there instead but his injury put him out of my current list
Christie?
🤔?
Christie being on this list over Conor Murray is wild.
You’re wrong
@@leightonparsons3472 you'd have Christie? Please tell me when he has shown up for the All Blacks?
@@liamwilliams6651 I like to live dangerously…
Cobus Reinach is better than most of them from the list.
I'm surprised why he was not on a list, he should have been on a top Six
💭 hmmmmm I need to think about this one
He’s not even among the best 9s in the top 14. Couilloud, Jauneau, Arrata, Serin, Le Garrec are all better than him. And to be fair, any 9 in the world would appear good with the South African pack in front of him. But Reinach at Montpellier is bang average
Yes but does Finlay have a soul? 😁
Lost me at Finlay Christie no way hes in the top 10.
who takes his place instead? Cam Roigard would've been no.10 in Christie's place but we have no idea what his level is after this nasty injury! 🤷♀
And none of them come close to Gareth Edwards.
This Gibson park over faf
You don’t rate him?
How can u not put grant williams here he has been the best scrumhalf in south africa for 2 years now and the racing 92 scrum half also deserves to be here since he plays similar to dupont 🤦🏽
The best for 2 years he is not even a contender for the springboks anymore ?
@@xaviervanbreda4560 u clearly don't know rugby mate I think u should just 🤫
@randomvids3621 i replied to your comment to help you out brother , go and educate yourself again .
Bro has only played 8 game with SA
Great shout but I can’t fit him in this list 🤪
Im French ans lucu is never in thé top 10
Agreed. He could have been, last year, but now I would take Le Garrec, Serin or even Couilloud over him any day.
C clair......
Ooh la la! The French have SO MANY great scrum-halves it’s not fair on the other nations 😂
@@rugbybuzzits thé only poste we have a good player , we are not a great nation of This sport
@@rafaelait-cherif you're not French or you clearly don't know rugby.
I don’t get why you include retired players. Aaron Smith is done.
Retired as an All Black but still playing in Japan...
@@rugbybuzz I know, but still.
IMO he would still walk into the AB side…
@@rugbybuzz But he’s not going to.
@@jameswyatt4443 haha I know but it still means his quality is there 🤷🏻♂️ He’s only fresh out of the ABs…this time next year his standard will have likely dropped playing in Japan, so probably wouldn’t make my Top10…
Faf, Reinag and williams must be no 1 2 3
@@martinvanrensburg4441 haha are you a Bok fan by any chance sir? 🇿🇦
Anyone we’ve missed? Unleash in the comments below 👇
Ben Spencer is in with a shout
How can u not put grant williams here he has been the best scrumhalf in south africa for 2 years now and the racing 92 scrum half also deserves to be here since he plays similar to dupont 🤦🏽
You forgot Grant Williams
Nolan Le Garecc