Not sure about that, it was clear Conrad was uncomfortable with the entire first interview. Later when his father goes to see Berger I thought a very compelling part of that scene: Berger asks the dad about Conrad and the dad admits he feels he's on a fence and the mom and Conrad are on opposite sides of that fence. Then he says "I can see her not being able to forgive him (Conrad)". Watch Berger's reaction. He seems very taken aback by that revelation. This movie is perfect.
Robert Redford did a fantastic job director his first movie he got a fantastic cast powerful script in my opinion I would give the four actors a Oscar there performance was fantastic and brilliant
@@noellecox3952 And he took big chances with casting both Hirsch and Moore against their television types and giving such a prominent role to an unknown young actor. Really, the only one of the four main characters who was a big name in film at the time was Donald Sutherland, and he was cast in a role different than what he was known for playing as well.
Who would've thought the guy from the silly sitcom Taxi would be so convincing as a psychiatrist? Judd Hirsh is so underrated and talented. I love him.
He can play a funny cab driver, a compassionate psychiatrist, and a sociopath in network movies. Very versatile, but Tim's performance gave him the win. I admired both performances, though.
Taxi had the same creative people involved that were involved in The Mary Tyler Moore Show. Both are classics to me. And Judd Hirsch’s Alex Reiger was the nuanced anchor to a wonderful ensemble of a show - compassionate, bright, funny. I loved him in that. And coming across this again is a real treat for me because he is excellent in this as well (starting from a great character to work with).
Hirsch gets to the heart of what's bothering Hutton very quickly. He initially peppers him with basic questions, e.g. feeling OK? Depressed, on stage? Family and friends worrying about you?, no issues? Hutton keeps giving stock answers, yes, no issues, all ok, etc. until finally Hirsch asks bluntly "Then why are you here?". He's forcing Hutton to address his issues. So well acted. BTW the part of the shrink was originally offered to Gene Hackman. Can't imagine even as great an actor as Gene could have been better than Judd Hirsch.
I saw this movie as a teenager and loved it. Timothy Hutton reminded me of Holden Caulfield and Elizabeth McGovern reminded me of the girl he talks about (Jane I think is her name).
Gone are the days when people actually listened, today it's "I don't have time to listen, but here's a label & a pill that will fix everything"; it's sad.
Psychiatrist is always your best friend. I feel happy after every session with mine. You can always tell your dr. Anything.. I even cried when I’m very down.
I can watch this POWERFUL FILM/MOVIE by Robert Redford, the STELLAR PERFORMANCES by Donald Sutherland, Judd Hirsch and of course Timothy Hutton, I always cry 😢 especially the scenes that emotionally make you feel for these people's PAIN and SORROW.
There's a subtle message sent by the state of Berger's office: "I'm not in this for the money." The movie pays a lot of attention to little details like that. I think they may have overdone it just a little, though. It's hard to imagine any working psychiatrist having an office that looks like the school counselor's office in a 1920's-built high school.
I mean in general most therapists and psychologists don't make a ton of money, I mean, if you establish a good practice and make a name for yourself you totally can, but a lot of psychologists are looking for work in a overcrowded market. Funnily enough, I actually used to see a therapist in downtown highland Park (where this movie was set and shot) and it looked exactly like this lol. Might even be the same building which would be hilariously ironic.
@@jonaswhitt4322 Well, that is interesting. Maybe I was wrong. Berger is a Psychiatrist, with an M.D., but I can imagine ONE Psychiatrist with an office like that.
@Ethans Husband Technically, yes. However, at least IMO, I've always considered the first few years of any decade to be a "holdover" from the previous decade.
@Ethans Husband Sorry for your loss. Movies like these tend to resonate with so many people because a lot of them have suffered a tragedy like this, or at the very least, know how it is to lose a loved one. Not just humans, but dogs and cats and other pets.
Just the look on Conrad's face when asked about the boating accident...incredible. One of the best performances of all time.
Serious PTSD
One of my all time favorite movies. I saw it when I was 20 yrs old. I’m now 60. This movie has stuck with me ..
66 here same feelings
65 here and l feel the same way
Saw it when I was 19, 59 now, it had a big impact on me, regarding healing and validation:)
I was 16, it hit me then and still today !!
@@benoitmorin7182 55. Common problem
As soon as he mentions his mom he gets so defensive, 2:56. It was at that point, Berger realized the mother was the problem.
Not sure about that, it was clear Conrad was uncomfortable with the entire first interview. Later when his father goes to see Berger I thought a very compelling part of that scene: Berger asks the dad about Conrad and the dad admits he feels he's on a fence and the mom and Conrad are on opposite sides of that fence. Then he says "I can see her not being able to forgive him (Conrad)". Watch Berger's reaction. He seems very taken aback by that revelation. This movie is perfect.
One of the greatest movies ever made.
Agreed. It's a masterpiece: Fun fact: Donald Sutherland was the original choice to play Dr Berger, but he felt would be better as the father.
The subtly of how rough Conrad looks at the beginning of the movie and how he progressively looks healthier as it goes.
Robert Redford's directorial debut and he NAILS it!!!!! Incredible movie.
Given all the great writers and directors that he’d previously worked with, it’s almost like his acting career was a paid internship, heh.
Beyond incredible, actually.
Robert Redford did a fantastic job director his first movie he got a fantastic cast powerful script in my opinion I would give the four actors a Oscar there performance was fantastic and brilliant
@@noellecox3952 And he took big chances with casting both Hirsch and Moore against their television types and giving such a prominent role to an unknown young actor. Really, the only one of the four main characters who was a big name in film at the time was Donald Sutherland, and he was cast in a role different than what he was known for playing as well.
Who would've thought the guy from the silly sitcom Taxi would be so convincing as a psychiatrist? Judd Hirsh is so underrated and talented. I love him.
yes
He can play a funny cab driver, a compassionate psychiatrist, and a sociopath in network movies. Very versatile, but Tim's performance gave him the win. I admired both performances, though.
He's my fav
Taxi had the same creative people involved that were involved in The Mary Tyler Moore Show. Both are classics to me. And Judd Hirsch’s Alex Reiger was the nuanced anchor to a wonderful ensemble of a show - compassionate, bright, funny. I loved him in that. And coming across this again is a real treat for me because he is excellent in this as well (starting from a great character to work with).
He was nominated for best supporting actor. 5 star performance.
Absolutely brilliant movie. Each frame is captivating, nuanced and painfully real.
Timothy is so good at conveying awkwardness in this scene 👏🏻
Poor kid's jumping out of his skin.
Judd Hursh’s acting is Mesmerising to watch
Great, highly underappreciated movie. Totally different from the run-of-the mill bang bang shoot-em-up Galaxy wars types so popular today.
I really felt for this kid.
Definitely his best role. Two bad he was nominated against his co-star, for best supporting.
Hirsch gets to the heart of what's bothering Hutton very quickly. He initially peppers him with basic questions, e.g. feeling OK? Depressed, on stage? Family and friends worrying about you?, no issues? Hutton keeps giving stock answers, yes, no issues, all ok, etc. until finally Hirsch asks bluntly "Then why are you here?". He's forcing Hutton to address his issues. So well acted. BTW the part of the shrink was originally offered to Gene Hackman. Can't imagine even as great an actor as Gene could have been better than Judd Hirsch.
So much deep meaning. Excellent movie.
I saw this movie as a teenager and loved it. Timothy Hutton reminded me of Holden Caulfield and Elizabeth McGovern reminded me of the girl he talks about (Jane I think is her name).
You are correct Elizabeth McGovern character name was Jane
@@noellecox3952 I meant the Jane in "The Catcher in the rye".
It’s Janine.
@@Frankie-q5o 👍
Control is a tough nut.
Gone are the days when people actually listened, today it's "I don't have time to listen, but here's a label & a pill that will fix everything"; it's sad.
Psychiatrist is always your best friend. I feel happy after every session with mine. You can always tell your dr. Anything.. I even cried when I’m very down.
They are your best friend because you're paying them.
@@ryanwindsor2407 You have to pay them. Don't be so foolish to think the help is free.
@@patr70 And don't be so foolish to believe they are your best friend.
if strangers were putting dough in my pocket it would be impossible not to listen.
@@ryanwindsor2407I laughed out loud! 🤣🤣🤣
I can watch this POWERFUL FILM/MOVIE by Robert Redford, the STELLAR PERFORMANCES by Donald Sutherland, Judd Hirsch and of course Timothy Hutton, I always cry 😢 especially the scenes that emotionally make you feel for these people's PAIN and SORROW.
An incredible film.
doc: u had a brother who died, tell me about him
con: *looks absolutely hunted and can't seem to find the right words*
Goodwill hunting before there was Goodwill hunting.
Amazing movie, likely the inspiration for Good Will Hunting's therapy scenes.
@Mindeiot91 You think? 😂
@@variousJnames :)
I can relate to Conrad in this scene.😷
😢
Why does the psychiatrist call him 'jared' if his name is conrad?
@@goldbrick2563""Jarrett" is his last name.🎄
@@trippytrellis7033 ah thanks
@@goldbrick2563 You are welcome.⛄
This movie makes me want to return to my practice: DB Manley, PhD
There's a subtle message sent by the state of Berger's office: "I'm not in this for the money." The movie pays a lot of attention to little details like that. I think they may have overdone it just a little, though. It's hard to imagine any working psychiatrist having an office that looks like the school counselor's office in a 1920's-built high school.
I mean in general most therapists and psychologists don't make a ton of money, I mean, if you establish a good practice and make a name for yourself you totally can, but a lot of psychologists are looking for work in a overcrowded market. Funnily enough, I actually used to see a therapist in downtown highland Park (where this movie was set and shot) and it looked exactly like this lol. Might even be the same building which would be hilariously ironic.
@@jonaswhitt4322 Well, that is interesting. Maybe I was wrong. Berger is a Psychiatrist, with an M.D., but
I can imagine ONE Psychiatrist with an office like that.
Lol Judd Hirsch smoking a cigarette here ..... like it was just normal for a dr to do
Gotta love the 70's :)
@Ethans Husband Technically, yes. However, at least IMO, I've always considered the first few years of any decade to be a "holdover" from the previous decade.
@Ethans Husband Sorry for your loss. Movies like these tend to resonate with so many people because a lot of them have suffered a tragedy like this, or at the very least, know how it is to lose a loved one. Not just humans, but dogs and cats and other pets.
They don’t make movies like this anymore… sad
En apariencia, un mundo civilizado, pero lleno de horror en el fondo.
Why didn’t Judd Hirsch win the Oscar for this film????
Bcuz Timothy Hutton did. They were both nominated in the Best Supporting Actor category.
Didn't he use a Platinum Plus razor
Double-edged super blue
Dr Berger knows this is a kid in crisis.
All Conrad needs to do is take a shower and comb his hair!
O.K. Beth.
Psychological problems are funny
@rahree You're funny