Good lyrics don’t describe emotions, they create emotions. When you’re listening to his songs you don’t just listen, you feel it. Harry is one of the best.
I’m gonna say just two things. One, the guy writes all his songs. Two, before the live presentation he had a rough week that I wish no one has to go through. It was bad.
The thing about that particular live performance is how, leading up to it, he had the worst luck that left him nervous: -his concert that was supposed to be on his birthday got canceled due to poor weather. -one of ex-girlfriends, Caroline, passed away -he had a stalker -and he was robbed at knifepoint I think two-three days before the performance. So I think all of that happening in that same month combined with the fact that he had to perform one of his most emotional songs really affected him and made him really nervous; which you can tell by how he was shaking a bit throughout the thing. I think that’s probably why, while still a good performance, there was a couple nitpicks you mentioned.
@@fernandapalacios8578 Caroline was his ex but they’d always stayed friends and she actually committed suicide. So so tragic. He had guy he was helping as he thought he was homeless and then he became fixated with Harry and used to stand outside his house and stare menacingly at him so he had to go to court and Harry was asked did he regret helping him and he said no. Absolutely love this man
Harry writes all of his own songs, and worked with core group of around 5-7 people for his album, so he did write this song himself. He's said he wrote it in about 20 minutes on the piano with one of his friends/colleague. He just had to get all the feelings out. As for the music video. The set was a metal room which they painted to look like wood. It was shot in Hollywood in the winter so it was super cold. They spent $400,000 to warm up the water for him. They slowly lowered and lifted the set to get all the shots, but by the time they submerged the whole things the whole set got completely destroyed. The shot of him going under was done in 1 take, which is lucky. They worked with a crane and a camera man that swam with Harry, and they filmed it at night time. The smoke you see I think is VFX work rather than actual steam or a smoke machine, and there was a lot of color/editing in VFX to get the feel and look of the video to portray the feel of the song
The room in the music video was actually a built set that they lowered into a pool. I've also heard from someone that the water might have been saline so he could keep his eyes open but I'm not sure. For the live version I'm sure many people are already telling you that his performance was preceded by a series of unfortunate events. The most recent of those events being him being robbed by a group of armed guys and the untimely passing of a loved one. Many were unsure if he would even still perform. I think he did a good job channeling the emotions he probably had into his performance. I had no idea about the vocal fry in the original version. I know nothing about music so it just sounded pretty to me. Thanks for pointing it out. I really enjoyed your reaction and look forward to more. Have a great day.
He get robbed with a knife and his ex-girlfriend suecide happend a couple days before this performance. I think thats why he is a little emotional but he’s performance was incredible to me, he showed his real emotions and he’s beautiful vocals
You can already see in the comments what events transpired right before this performance. I don't have a good ear so I didn't notice any flat notes or things like that but in my mind, his raw emotional performance should make up for anything technical. That song does feel like he's baring his soul and I can't imagine how hard it was to sing it. You can see his nerves by the way he's holding the mic tightly in one hand and never lets go. He doesn't usually do that. He was steadying himself. That high note cuts through your heart. The first time I heard the song when it was released, I cried. It took me a full 30 minutes to get it together!
I think when you get robbed at knife point and could be loosing your life at any moment in that situation and then have you ex-girlfriend committing suicide days before you go up one stage in front of many people you wouldn’t be thinking about the technique you should be singing in to get things right, would you? I thing he did a great job singing the song. It’s definitely not an easy one to sing.
I think this was a great performance, but he was just doing what he was supposed to do by criticizing it. I don’t think there’s any reason to get upset or defensive about what was said. Everyone is human and the fact that he performed anyway speaks volumes, whether or not it was 100% technically proficient.
They warmed up the water for him. They constructed the room and had it on the crane and lowered it into the water. He was really under the water. People think it's CIG but it's not. Reminds me of when he was in the movie "Dunkirk" he was in the water a lot too. If you think about it when he did it live, it was at the Brits awards being seen all over the world, there were really famous people there. I would imagine he was really nervous. I think he did really well.
He found out his ex girlfriend committed suicide a couple hours after he was robbed at knifepoint on Valentine’s Day 2-3 days before this beautiful performance!
I’d like to see you go through what he did and then sing perfectly live. I dislike it when people expect the live version of a song to sound exactly like the original recording 🤦🏼♀️. Harry always gives 100% and is usually just as good (if not better) live. So what if he is a little flat ... the emotion he gives more than makes up for it esp after what he went through to even sing it live.
This preference was extremely emotional for Harry that's why he was a little wobbly at first he had just been mugged at knife point on valentine's day and then I think the day before this performance his ex girlfriend who he was still good friends with committed suicide it was so sad it makes me cry everytime you can just feel the pain and he wrights his own stuff you should checkout his live performance of Adore you on the Graham Norton show it's Amazing x
The fog was probably at least partially coming from the water/pool the temperature was pretty warm bc it was filmed in January in California so it was a bit chilly then when they filmed it at night and outside.
FYI, similar to all songs on his two solo albums, with a few cowriters, Harry Style wrote this song, and it has some specific references to a recent breakup. Thank you for reacting to video, studio recording, and live performance. Please respond to live performance on Feb14 at the BBC radio 2 studio. It is acoustic so voice is not manipulated much by production.
Every time one of your videos pops up in my recommended- I’m asking myself how did a I make it to 43 and never having dated a Jewish guy. Wowza, Adam. So handsome. 🔥💕
Thanks for this one as well. I've just listened to your reaction to Watermelon sugar. If you scroll down, others already explained why his performance was so "dark" that specific day. So many bad things happened with him within less than 2 weeks. One additional note about the shooting: Harry said in an interview that he time to time swam out from the water to check back the footage, then swam back to continue. Insane :) If you would like to hear his own backing vocal on the studio take, here's the link to the official acapella ruclips.net/video/qgU2xfodfak/видео.html
Don't lie This is one of the few times his song hasn't been upto mark. So you got to accept that fact and don't make reasons to say why his performance was dark
Hey adam hope you're fine ive got a question When people do lip trills they say they feel it in the mask in the nose nd forehead but i always feel it in the mouth an i doing something wrong
Marta Losada its definitely inspired by Camille, there are a lot of clues in the music video: If you look close at the window you can see the Eiffel Tower and he has Camille her ring on (on his pink) but i guess it has a different meaning to all of us🤷🏻♀️
Do this with Niall's song Put a little love on me. The performance on The Late Late show is the most recent one ( ruclips.net/video/oIkfpqUsDE4/видео.html )
Adam, in a constructive way, this was overly cut even with YT copyright infringement rules, lazily commented on without context as a fill-in piece devoid of any critique of any value. This is a shame with you and other earlier reactions where you actually seemed to care artistically and appreciating the artist, or not - but at least in a way that seemed you had the time or could be bothered 😕. An annoying one there with far deeper and more interesting vocals and visuals deserving better. Waste of my keen & expectant time. Shame 👎🏻❌ D&A
Fun fact: Harry wrote falling in twenty minutes in a towel
I swear he is the only one capable of doing that
Sounds like something Harry styles would do-
well somebody watches the zane lowe interview
@@kallinpetty6739 i watched it at 3am because i woke up and felt so sick, harry’s voice healed me lol
@@marykate6898 I think harry's magical he can heel you
Good lyrics don’t describe emotions, they create emotions. When you’re listening to his songs you don’t just listen, you feel it.
Harry is one of the best.
Agreed x
I’m gonna say just two things. One, the guy writes all his songs. Two, before the live presentation he had a rough week that I wish no one has to go through. It was bad.
How do you know it was bad?
He had been mugged & lost a friend to suicide.
The thing about that particular live performance is how, leading up to it, he had the worst luck that left him nervous:
-his concert that was supposed to be on his birthday got canceled due to poor weather.
-one of ex-girlfriends, Caroline, passed away
-he had a stalker
-and he was robbed at knifepoint I think two-three days before the performance.
So I think all of that happening in that same month combined with the fact that he had to perform one of his most emotional songs really affected him and made him really nervous; which you can tell by how he was shaking a bit throughout the thing. I think that’s probably why, while still a good performance, there was a couple nitpicks you mentioned.
Stacker?! Wtf info pls
@@fernandapalacios8578 Caroline was his ex but they’d always stayed friends and she actually committed suicide. So so tragic. He had guy he was helping as he thought he was homeless and then he became fixated with Harry and used to stand outside his house and stare menacingly at him so he had to go to court and Harry was asked did he regret helping him and he said no. Absolutely love this man
I've heard this song a million times I love it so much
Harry writes all of his own songs, and worked with core group of around 5-7 people for his album, so he did write this song himself. He's said he wrote it in about 20 minutes on the piano with one of his friends/colleague. He just had to get all the feelings out. As for the music video. The set was a metal room which they painted to look like wood. It was shot in Hollywood in the winter so it was super cold. They spent $400,000 to warm up the water for him. They slowly lowered and lifted the set to get all the shots, but by the time they submerged the whole things the whole set got completely destroyed. The shot of him going under was done in 1 take, which is lucky. They worked with a crane and a camera man that swam with Harry, and they filmed it at night time. The smoke you see I think is VFX work rather than actual steam or a smoke machine, and there was a lot of color/editing in VFX to get the feel and look of the video to portray the feel of the song
The room in the music video was actually a built set that they lowered into a pool. I've also heard from someone that the water might have been saline so he could keep his eyes open but I'm not sure.
For the live version I'm sure many people are already telling you that his performance was preceded by a series of unfortunate events. The most recent of those events being him being robbed by a group of armed guys and the untimely passing of a loved one. Many were unsure if he would even still perform. I think he did a good job channeling the emotions he probably had into his performance.
I had no idea about the vocal fry in the original version. I know nothing about music so it just sounded pretty to me. Thanks for pointing it out. I really enjoyed your reaction and look forward to more. Have a great day.
He get robbed with a knife and his ex-girlfriend suecide happend a couple days before this performance. I think thats why he is a little emotional but he’s performance was incredible to me, he showed his real emotions and he’s beautiful vocals
Caroline wasn’t his ex girlfriend...
However it was a great performance for me, you can see he’s really stressed and emotional
You can already see in the comments what events transpired right before this performance. I don't have a good ear so I didn't notice any flat notes or things like that but in my mind, his raw emotional performance should make up for anything technical. That song does feel like he's baring his soul and I can't imagine how hard it was to sing it. You can see his nerves by the way he's holding the mic tightly in one hand and never lets go. He doesn't usually do that. He was steadying himself. That high note cuts through your heart. The first time I heard the song when it was released, I cried. It took me a full 30 minutes to get it together!
I think when you get robbed at knife point and could be loosing your life at any moment in that situation and then have you ex-girlfriend committing suicide days before you go up one stage in front of many people you wouldn’t be thinking about the technique you should be singing in to get things right, would you?
I thing he did a great job singing the song. It’s definitely not an easy one to sing.
Who is the ex that committed suicide?
@@BFM0 Read the comments
Exactly
I think this was a great performance, but he was just doing what he was supposed to do by criticizing it. I don’t think there’s any reason to get upset or defensive about what was said. Everyone is human and the fact that he performed anyway speaks volumes, whether or not it was 100% technically proficient.
Exactly
They warmed up the water for him. They constructed the room and had it on the crane and lowered it into the water. He was really under the water. People think it's CIG but it's not. Reminds me of when he was in the movie "Dunkirk" he was in the water a lot too. If you think about it when he did it live, it was at the Brits awards being seen all over the world, there were really famous people there. I would imagine he was really nervous. I think he did really well.
He found out his ex girlfriend committed suicide a couple hours after he was robbed at knifepoint on Valentine’s Day 2-3 days before this beautiful performance!
I’d like to see you go through what he did and then sing perfectly live. I dislike it when people expect the live version of a song to sound exactly like the original recording 🤦🏼♀️. Harry always gives 100% and is usually just as good (if not better) live. So what if he is a little flat ... the emotion he gives more than makes up for it esp after what he went through to even sing it live.
HE IS AMAZING
i dont understand. how did you not cry?
This preference was extremely emotional for Harry that's why he was a little wobbly at first he had just been mugged at knife point on valentine's day and then I think the day before this performance his ex girlfriend who he was still good friends with committed suicide it was so sad it makes me cry everytime you can just feel the pain and he wrights his own stuff you should checkout his live performance of Adore you on the Graham Norton show it's Amazing x
Adam Mishan please react to Zayn good years that song is difficult to sing. You can please listen to it please listen please please
The fog was probably at least partially coming from the water/pool the temperature was pretty warm bc it was filmed in January in California so it was a bit chilly then when they filmed it at night and outside.
I’m enjoying u reacting to one direction videos
Please react to more music of Zayn, for example I don’t wanna live forever with Taylor Swift or It’s You, It’s You also has live performances!
Can you react to jhope MAMA 👉👈..i know he is a rapper but his vocal is 👌*chef kiss
FYI, similar to all songs on his two solo albums, with a few cowriters, Harry Style wrote this song, and it has some specific references to a recent breakup. Thank you for reacting to video, studio recording, and live performance. Please respond to live performance on Feb14 at the BBC radio 2 studio. It is acoustic so voice is not manipulated much by production.
Every time one of your videos pops up in my recommended- I’m asking myself how did a I make it to 43 and never having dated a Jewish guy. Wowza, Adam. So handsome. 🔥💕
*Adam i've voice crack when i take my voice from Chest to head how can i fix this...😣😣 Especially when i sing Count on me*
💓💓💓💓💓
Please react to ZAYN!!!!
Hi can you react to the one direction boys more often please!!!!
Hey, you should react to loic nottet- million eyes. He is from Belgium and he is an AMAZING singer (and dancer !)
Thanks for this one as well. I've just listened to your reaction to Watermelon sugar.
If you scroll down, others already explained why his performance was so "dark" that specific day. So many bad things happened with him within less than 2 weeks.
One additional note about the shooting: Harry said in an interview that he time to time swam out from the water to check back the footage, then swam back to continue. Insane :)
If you would like to hear his own backing vocal on the studio take, here's the link to the official acapella
ruclips.net/video/qgU2xfodfak/видео.html
They shot the video in 1 year or something
Don't lie
This is one of the few times his song hasn't been upto mark. So you got to accept that fact and don't make reasons to say why his performance was dark
Hey adam hope you're fine ive got a question
When people do lip trills they say they feel it in the mask in the nose nd forehead but i always feel it in the mouth an i doing something wrong
Stay Gold Live by BTS pleaseee ..
Pls react to BTS "still with you " and " stay gold "💜
OMG i love it so much 💜💜
React to daechwita by suga or react to shinee high notes or really I didnt know by chen and baekhyun
Great reaction Adam! Please react to Charlie Puth's new song called "Girlfriend". It came out yesterday and its AMAZING 💚😍
Love it. He has such a pretty voice
Also Adam please react to BTS stay gold and there is a live version of it 🙏💜
plz react to txt 20 cm live REALLY AMAZING VOCALS AND HIGHT NOTE
fun fact, you look like Tom Ellis (Lucifer Morningstar)
Harry wrote this, its about his ex-girlfriend. He actually wrote all his songs.
You don't know that it's about his ex-girlfriend. For me it's more like self-reflexion about himself and the place he was in
Marta Losada its definitely inspired by Camille, there are a lot of clues in the music video: If you look close at the window you can see the Eiffel Tower and he has Camille her ring on (on his pink) but i guess it has a different meaning to all of us🤷🏻♀️
HOW DOES THIS HAVE NO LIKES
Could you please react to even if I die its you by v and Jin
can u react to lauv’s new ep that came out yesterday pls its soo good
When are you going to react to Louis Tomlinson?
Adam please react to stay gold 🥺
Please react to Jungkook’s cover of Falling too. Thanks!
React to Little Mix cover of this song
Kindly react to Linkin Park's The Messenger please, l would love to see that happening😊😁
Here I am no 7 comment Indian fan....
grenade by bruno mars please the song is very nice
Hi, if u dont mind, can u react to jungkook's cover of falling? He just dropped the cover like 3 days ago and I bet u will like it
ariana grande 7 rings
Could you please react to BTS’s Stay Gold or Jungkook’s Still With You? For Still With You I think you would really enjoy the beginning and end!
react to little mix one world touch acoustic !
Do this with Niall's song Put a little love on me. The performance on The Late Late show is the most recent one ( ruclips.net/video/oIkfpqUsDE4/видео.html )
please react to Fairy of Shampoo 🧚♀️ by TXT thank you love your videos💜💜
I feel like this was about Kendall 👀 (his old ex)
react to jungkook's still with you
Plz react to zayn good years
React to stay gold BTS or any Ateez songs
PLEASEEEE REACT TO MORISSETTE AMON!!!!!!!!! AKIN KA NALANG OR FLY LIKE A BIRD 💖💖💖
Plzzz react to wings by BTS
React to bts stay gold live please
Damn u cute
react to stay gold by bts plz
1st comment
bts are better :-)
Adam, in a constructive way, this was overly cut even with YT copyright infringement rules, lazily commented on without context as a fill-in piece devoid of any critique of any value. This is a shame with you and other earlier reactions where you actually seemed to care artistically and appreciating the artist, or not - but at least in a way that seemed you had the time or could be bothered 😕. An annoying one there with far deeper and more interesting vocals and visuals deserving better. Waste of my keen & expectant time. Shame 👎🏻❌ D&A