Ya know its funny. I think the Luke and Vadar hallway scenes are so well received is because they portray Luke in Vader in the way fans wanted to see them. Full powered Vader finally being able to show himself off with the proper set up in the movie. And Jedi Master Luke finally appearing in ways people so desperately wanted to see him
But as much as I hate to admit it, it didn't amount to anything in the end. In BOBF, he makes the same mistakes of the old Jedi order, forbidding attachments when he of all people should know damn well why attachments are a good thing. It was his attachment to Vader that saved himself and Vader. But it's all pointless. He still ends up training Kylo. He still ends up shitting on everything everyone had worked so hard to build since the Empire. As long as KK's fan fictions exist, this scene will be nothing but flash and nostalgia. And as it turns out, that's all it's ever going to be.
@@QuantumNaut holy shit i just realized that. That could correlate to how when Luke was training he had his eyes shielded, so that means he was using force instinct
What makes it truly Iconic.. is it redeems Vader AND the Star Wars franchise after the awful prequels.. Vader is Death incarnate, his full glory, what we always wanted that never got.. Same as the Luke scene, completely redeemed him after the awful Sequels and with it, the franchise.. The Obi Wan series, just wasnt necessary, but its a wash for me, some good, some bad, doesnt move the needle either way..
@antedote1 Prequels were goated, tf u on about. Got the best lightsaber fights, Anakin vs Obi-Wan, Darth Maul vs Qui-Gon Jinn & Obi-Wan, Yoda vs Palpatine, Count Dooku vs Yoda etc along with good storytelling. Yes, the dialogs could have been better, but that doesn't make the prequels terrible. They were about Anakin and I liked his story.
From technical standpoint, Luke had the toughest enemies, Obi-Wan had the toughest circumstance having to protect Leia as well as being out of practice.
I would say kenobi had the toughest all around on top of what you said he had to fight off blaster bolts from two directions and then also had to hold the window from shattering and drowning him and Leia
I think, it would be better, if this series tell us about New Jedi Order Academi, in which Luke with another Jedi, who have survived the Order 66 and imperial time, educated new generation of Jedi and complete some missions in galaxy to help the New Rebublic government. In this missions and lessons we could see the formation of Ben's character and his fall to the dark side, because of his disappointment in his parent's and rebels ideals. Also there we could show the social and political crisis in New Rebublic, which create conditions for the next war with impire's fragments. And of course, we ignore the Disney's sequels.
Vader "I killed everyone in the hallway" Maul "I killed everyone with the hallway" Luke "I killed no one in the hallway" Obi Wan "Everyone in the hallway killed themselves... except for that one trooper and the water"
As Iconic and poetic as the mirroring hallway scenes are for Luke and Vader with one bringing hope against adversity and destruction among despair. I do love the Obi-Wan scene because Luke and Vader's are two force users who are highly proficient due to their activity at the time whilst Obi-Wan is that of a man who hasn't used a Lightsaber in 10 years just jumping back on the wagon and rediscovering himself
@@IRMentatWhich is why it isn't canon. He never cut himself off from the force. That's idiotic. Why would he do that when he could need it at any random moment to protect Luke, like what we see in Rebels? Disney managed to contradict not just the OT and prequels, but even their own trash 😂
@@TheStraightestWhitest Brutally maims best friend and leaves him to die from being burned alive by lava, fails to stop the sith lord. Jedi Order falls, all your comrades die. And you're here thinking: "Why would he have PTSD or cut himself off from being detected by other force users who can sense the strength of those with it?"
@@slimeplayz116 not all the time you see the troopers walk up to him and then he attacks them when they get in frame but they could've shot him multiple times before then
I'm really happy the actor that played Baylan got to join this club before his passing. He was truly the perfect fit for his role and he'll be greatly missed.
@@lucyhardy-styles-shield2728 The show itself was lame, but the Baylan was a promising character. He had much more charisma than all the others, including - sadly - Thrawn.
Vader hallway scene was one of the best parts of rogue one, Vader as a character was so into it that he risked his life just so that he could be menacing
George wrote Luke the same way in his sequel scripts lol. Nothing wrong with giving Luke a new arc. If Rey met Luke with him knowing everything and being highly proficient in his ability it would have made no sense for him to be in exile on the island in the first place. If you're mad at Luke's character in that movie the blame is to JJ Abrams, not Rian Johnson.
@@insahnayeh u cant deny they still got a lot with Luke wrong in TLJ. Bruh he literally just met rey and was being such a dick to her for no reason (50 ish year old man vs 18ish year old girl) instead of cordially saying he cant join her, and the throwing of his fathers lightsaber was just ridiculous
And this is where Kenobi shows himself the grandmaster of Form III. Out of practice with a child to escort, and he still blocks every shot, while having the presence of mind to then use the collapse of the walls to drown his adversaries in one stroke at just the right moment. He’s not a living typhoon of destructive saber combat or a Force god like Luke or Vader. But he acquits himself splendidly under the circumstances while facing a far worse handicap than the other two.
1:24 I remember the whole movie theatre let out a gasp at the same time. Me and my dad looked at each other. I never saw him smile like that. My dad was born in 1968 and was at the grand launch of star wars. Can't imagine what he felt at that moment. His entire childhood made a comeback. And at the end of the scene, my dad told me to rush to the car to watch a new hope with him so we can experience like a transition I love my dad Edit: my dad watched the launch of every star wars movie since 1977 Rogue one was his fsvourite because he spent it with me
Unpopular opinion: "Rogue One is my favorite Star Wars movie." I love all of them though. Yes even (regardless of them not being very good) the Sequel Trilogy.
I love the difference between Obi-wan's scene compared to the other two. While the other two were moving forward and dominating their opponents, Obi-wan was on the defensive the whole time and blocking/redirecting shots. While the other two triumphed with their strength, Obi-wan turned the tides by turning a dire scenario (the window cracking) into an advantage, showcasing his quick thinking instead.
The Skywalkers are powerhouses not hesitating to show off their gifted affinity with the Force while Obi Wan is a crafty fox. He is surgical with his force usage and strengths which makes him and his fights such a treat to witness.
Dawg the obi wan and Luke scene were from the past two years or so and the Darth Vader one is from rogue one which is less than 10 years old just like the comment above stated 😂
Yeah Luke fights in motion with no wasted movements, but Vader dominates with pure force and aggression that makes any attempt just feeble. Luke moves through the battlefield, Vader pushes back the battlefield until you’re cornered. And Obi-Wan defends against both sides of the battlefield at the same time.
I like how they all have different fighting styles. Obi Wan has the Jedi’s defensive style, mainly focused on deflecting blaster bolts away. Vader is more offensive, attacking a lot of the time and only deflecting attacks when required. Luke is a mix of both, deflecting shots while attacking fiercely, and sometimes even using the dark side to destroy his enemies.
Kenobi had to take that style as he wasn't alone but making sure the girl wasn't harmed. Both Vader and Luke didn't have anyone to take care not to harm in the hall. So it makes for Kenobi to go with a defensive style. Kenobi is a master duelist. Meaning that he would know many styles. But that's the character. There is also that of the 3 is was the only scene with an actor and not a 3d character. Given that, it was not bad.
Haha, That means they had the same problem twice in the same fortress and never did anything about now exposed structural vulnerability that let enemies of the empire escape.
I was gonna say, couldn’t Kenobi just slash at the glass? But my small brain didn’t realize that he was actually luring the troops into a water trap and submerged them all while staying alive himself. That happened again just now.
Lightsabers don't work well underwater. It needs oxygen to fuel the plasma energy it emits. Without any modifications, Obi-wans saber would've likely just short-circuited upon contact with the glass and water, leaving him with a broken saber and a ton of stormtroopers.
Those rebel soldiers in that hallway had only heard of the frightening rumors of a Jedi hunting machine-man, and then suddenly the rumor appears, bathed in the red glow of a bleeding kyber. That Vader scene was fking awesome. What a great ending to a great movie.
Vader's moving slowly, but being unstoppable is like a slow death to the troopers. Like nothing they could do to save their own life. Feel the fear and desperation in their scream and eyes
Obi-Wan's has the added factor that it's the one that brought him back to the game. He got his skills back by being immediately dropped into action in order to protect Leia.
Budget-wise, it was Obi-wan's that was lacking, but for the story of him trying to relearn all that and finally seeing him get back into it makes up for it.
Obi Wan’s really exemplified who he is. Doesn’t straight up massacre the base but if you attack him then very best of luck to you. Galaxy is filled with OP dark side characters who have had various bits chopped off.
Obi-Wan’s was Desperation to get Leia away. Vader’s was the anger from the sheer gall the Rebellion had to steal the Death Star plans Luke’s was the hope that the Mandolorian and Co. were going to be okay.
I think what made Luke's hallway scene really awesome is that he didn't held back at all. He knew the dark troopers were just droids, so he was given the chance to unleashed all his mastery of the force and lightsaber skills against them. He would've never slashed through the hallway like a meat grinder if the troopers were living beings inside since he's a true and compassionate Jedi that serves to protect, not kill
All fantastic scenes. I love seeing Obi-wan getting his confidence back throughout the scene. Vader's is fantastic. My favorite however will go to Luke. Balanced, grounded, and surgical.
As the original hallway scene Vaders is the best, it was totally unexpected and the sheer brutality of it in the cinema was awesome. Lukes is great as well, as it was also a surprise, but the original is the best.
Obi-Wan is criminally underrated. Dude force held billions of pounds of water back. Vader pulls a ship and everyone's jaw dropped. This is 1000× more impressive
You can tell that Ewan is using a heavy sword that emits actual light. He’s much clunkier with this than the lightweight CGId-over swords of the prequels.
I think Vader’s was best from a cinematic experience. The fear of the rebel soldiers, and the sudden shock and the evil creativity of how he dispatches them. Luke’s had potential but I think fans are more happy to see him than anything else because of what the sequel trilogy did to him. Obi-wans was just not shot well and lacked creativity as well as dominance-hard to cheer for him.
Jedi aren’t dominant. Thinking they should be is missing the whole point. Jedi are supposed to fight with economy-to control their environment, and to protect others. Luke does it. So does Obi-Wan.
Rian Johnson: "What do you expect? I take a laser sword and fight the entire first order my self?" Me: "Yes! Rian! That's what we expect from Luke! That's THE ONLY thing we expect from a Skywalker!"
I will never forget the asshole in the theatre during Rogue One. Guy sitting right in front of me already saw the movie, and we're now getting to the Vader scene. It's dark and you hear Vader's breathing and you're totally sucked in this moment just like the Rebels on the edge of your seat or at least I was completely glued to the screen and just as Vader ignites his lightsaber you hear the guy make a light saber ignition sound so loud you don't even hear the audio from the movie of the ignition and it completely took me out of the moment. Still irritates me to this day whenever I see the clip.
This shows why Jedi and Force users were so feared and respected. From the point of view of a regular unit/soldier, they were unstoppable go-get-it machines.
The crazy thing to think about is the obscene amount of blaster fire obi-wan and anakin experienced during the clone wars. and now, Kenobi is rusty and Vader is mostly machine, but they can both handle it just fine.
The set-up for Luke's hallway scene was impeccable. The Dark Troopers were established as such a threat that even The Mandalorian almost got killed by just one of them in a one-on-one fight. Then Luke comes and treats them like absolute fodder. Truly establishes the power of Luke
Luke was great in that episode. Din struggled so hard against a singular murder droid, whereas Luke just flies in, decimates the entire squad effortlessly, crushes the last one just to show off... and then politely waits by the door to be let in. Seeing him in action was great, but it's that last part that really makes me love his hallway scene
The scene in this video is The Mandalorian season 2 finale. Luke is the big event that caps off the season. He also shows up in the Book of Boba Fett, I think in episode 6, after the writers ran out of Boba Fett content and turned the show in The Mandalorian S2.5, which, honestly, wasn't all that bad of a decision
@@Swirl_of_StarFireIt's anticlimactic for that reason. Lukes fighting is great but these guys don't even put up a fight. And blasters and fires can't even touch them but the lightsaber goes right through. It doesn't seem right with the aura that the show created for these guys. Watching it out of context is great because you can just enjoy Luke's fighting without wondering why these droids suck so much now.
Holy crap! I just realized something. As Obi-Wan begins to re-master the Force, he does so in every scene, including the climax. In other words, in every episode, he goes from being a Force-sensitive to a talented padawan to a knowledgable Jedi, to a skilled Knight, and ultimately, in the end, Jedi Master. In the course of the show, we see the journey of a Force User from start to finish. How sublime.
Obi-wan was defensive, which was perfect for that situation Darth Vader was just aggressive, he probably could've just simply struck them all down, but he added intimidation into the mix. The way the guy at the end of that clip is screaming shows that And Luke, the way he fought was honestly just graceful
It was the Luke scene that convinced me to actually watch most of the new canon shows. I was and still am extremely disappointed with the sequel films but the TV shows have delivered some rewarding experiences. While I might never get to see Luke fighting Shimrra or the Clone Palpatine or C'Baoth, at least we do have one good scene of Jedi Master Luke Skywalker kicking some battle droid ass!
That's every Jedi scene in Star Wars dude, they never shot when they have their chance. Too much spinning, too much coreography, not enough realism or danger. The prequels were at least better in showing the speed of the Jedi, wich made everything more belivable.
Obi wan has the hardest circumstances bc he was protecting leia whilst being out of practice, Luke was pure skill and deadly, calculated movements, and Vader was pure unmatched brutality. All were amazing
I’d say Luke’s scene was the best display of skill and RAW force powers! The level of danger due to those trooper droids, they posed the greatest threat!
I actually didn’t mind a new actor playing as Luke. Why is Disney so scared of proper change? They just had to super Sci-fi his face to look like the old actor. They are only hurting themselves in the long ru- what’s the point anymore…..
In my opinion, Kenobi’s scene was truly a shame. On the other hand, Vader’s was perfect and I really enjoyed watching how strong Luke has become in this scene, as it reminds us he’s a Skywalker after all.
Ah yes! The epic hallway scenes of Uncle Grandpa, Dad Vader, and "Chosen Two? Chosen the Sequel, Chosen Second? Ah screw it green lightsaber it is"! Lmao I love Star Wars 😂
He was trying to keep it from breaking on him, if you watch the scene, you can see the crack first start. He only used it as a weapon when the stormtroopers broke through the door.
My favorite part about Vader is thinking about how he used to be or technically still is Anakin. Its always what made me love Vader. The fact a nice guy who loved his family who only wanted them to survive turned into that
Кино![All Lightsaber Duels In Star Wars [UPDATED 2022]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8TqfOYYOWAE/mqdefault.jpg)
![All Lightsaber Duels In Star Wars [UPDATED 2022]](/img/tr.png)
Note to self: If you see someone in the hallway with a light saber run
unless you have one as well
Unless you're Daredevil... He's the king of hallway fights.
@@larrymonrock8193 idk man if I see Vader in the hallway I’m gone 🏃🏾♂️💨
@@larrymonrock8193 Unless you are Revan. I wouldn't recomend to face any Skywalker on a hallway.
*gets force choked then slammed into the ceiling then slashed in the stomach
Ya know its funny. I think the Luke and Vadar hallway scenes are so well received is because they portray Luke in Vader in the way fans wanted to see them. Full powered Vader finally being able to show himself off with the proper set up in the movie. And Jedi Master Luke finally appearing in ways people so desperately wanted to see him
Disney for some reason thinks that we want to see Luke drinking milk of Homunculus Loxodontus
@@fraisertinkolol
@@fraisertinko But this Luke is also Disney
@@Sesuaki19 yes, but from the normal director) not from some dumb useless director
But as much as I hate to admit it, it didn't amount to anything in the end. In BOBF, he makes the same mistakes of the old Jedi order, forbidding attachments when he of all people should know damn well why attachments are a good thing. It was his attachment to Vader that saved himself and Vader.
But it's all pointless. He still ends up training Kylo. He still ends up shitting on everything everyone had worked so hard to build since the Empire. As long as KK's fan fictions exist, this scene will be nothing but flash and nostalgia. And as it turns out, that's all it's ever going to be.
Obi-wan is defense
Vader is Offense
Luke is both
And Maul is final boss
He is the apprentice of Kenobi, and the son of Skywalker. It's like poetry, it rhymes
and Luke did it blindfolded has his hood was over his eyes 3:38
@@QuantumNaut holy shit i just realized that. That could correlate to how when Luke was training he had his eyes shielded, so that means he was using force instinct
Like master and apprentice, like father and son
Nothing beats Vader's hallway scene. It's iconic at this point.
And they made Luke's similar to Vader's...like father, like son 😊
@@lucyhardy-styles-shield2728 Indeed, like father, like son.
IDK. Luke's was pretty damn good
What makes it truly Iconic.. is it redeems Vader AND the Star Wars franchise after the awful prequels.. Vader is Death incarnate, his full glory, what we always wanted that never got.. Same as the Luke scene, completely redeemed him after the awful Sequels and with it, the franchise.. The Obi Wan series, just wasnt necessary, but its a wash for me, some good, some bad, doesnt move the needle either way..
@antedote1 Prequels were goated, tf u on about. Got the best lightsaber fights, Anakin vs Obi-Wan, Darth Maul vs Qui-Gon Jinn & Obi-Wan, Yoda vs Palpatine, Count Dooku vs Yoda etc along with good storytelling. Yes, the dialogs could have been better, but that doesn't make the prequels terrible. They were about Anakin and I liked his story.
From technical standpoint, Luke had the toughest enemies, Obi-Wan had the toughest circumstance having to protect Leia as well as being out of practice.
And vader was straight up vibing
I would say kenobi had the toughest all around on top of what you said he had to fight off blaster bolts from two directions and then also had to hold the window from shattering and drowning him and Leia
He was also dying because his life support was off, you can tell because there were no lights on his chestplate@@Bibyte
Vader had the toughest objective.
@@achaudhari101 I respectfully agree with you on this
You can see how much Luke evolved from RTOJ. His movements are effortless and you can tell he wasn’t even trying. We need a Jedi Master Luke series
I think, it would be better, if this series tell us about New Jedi Order Academi, in which Luke with another Jedi, who have survived the Order 66 and imperial time, educated new generation of Jedi and complete some missions in galaxy to help the New Rebublic government. In this missions and lessons we could see the formation of Ben's character and his fall to the dark side, because of his disappointment in his parent's and rebels ideals. Also there we could show the social and political crisis in New Rebublic, which create conditions for the next war with impire's fragments.
And of course, we ignore the Disney's sequels.
@@user-cr2yx6ky4y Yea that’s the only way Disney can redeem themselves from that disaster
. . No. We need less cheap Star Wars TV series with no soul or passion.
Sadly, I think Disney would find a way to screw it up.
“Effortless… not even trying.” Yeah that sure sounds like compelling television.
Vader "I killed everyone in the hallway"
Maul "I killed everyone with the hallway"
Luke "I killed no one in the hallway"
Obi Wan "Everyone in the hallway killed themselves... except for that one trooper and the water"
Lmao 😅
In fairness, Luke was fighting robots.
Doesnt make his statement any less true though.@@IRMentat
Also Vader "except that one guy who escaped"
Then Kylo who killed the hallway
As Iconic and poetic as the mirroring hallway scenes are for Luke and Vader with one bringing hope against adversity and destruction among despair. I do love the Obi-Wan scene because Luke and Vader's are two force users who are highly proficient due to their activity at the time whilst Obi-Wan is that of a man who hasn't used a Lightsaber in 10 years just jumping back on the wagon and rediscovering himself
Yeah, all good observations
Pretty terrible behaviour for a Jedi master and bodyguard in a harsh land filled with gangsters and raiding tribes.
@@IRMentatWhich is why it isn't canon. He never cut himself off from the force. That's idiotic. Why would he do that when he could need it at any random moment to protect Luke, like what we see in Rebels?
Disney managed to contradict not just the OT and prequels, but even their own trash 😂
and you can see as he fights he gets less choppy and smoother
@@TheStraightestWhitest Brutally maims best friend and leaves him to die from being burned alive by lava, fails to stop the sith lord. Jedi Order falls, all your comrades die. And you're here thinking: "Why would he have PTSD or cut himself off from being detected by other force users who can sense the strength of those with it?"
Maul had his hallway scene too
HAHA yess! and maybe future we get an Ahsoka Tano too XD?
@@ktmysticlight it would be nice
Seems like it the mando got one too
ezra too
Baylan too
Luke’s was the best of the three. Perfect mix of offensive & defensive power plus unstoppable yet serene confidence.
Luke is beautiful to watch. Very harmonic and languorous.
it was kinda slow tho, he stops for no reason and the troopers could've easily killed him every time he did
Vaders was better and it’s not even close
@@LANGIMATIONhe was using force choke on them
@@slimeplayz116 not all the time you see the troopers walk up to him and then he attacks them when they get in frame but they could've shot him multiple times before then
I'm really happy the actor that played Baylan got to join this club before his passing. He was truly the perfect fit for his role and he'll be greatly missed.
Ray Stevenson? Yeah, I'm glad he was on this list. Sadly, Ray never saw how well liked Ahsoka was
ahsoka is sitting at a 5/10, which is a shame because Baylan is easily the best character in the entire show
@@lucyhardy-styles-shield2728Ashoka is not well liked lmao
@@lucyhardy-styles-shield2728I dunno how to break it to ya bud… 😬
@@lucyhardy-styles-shield2728 The show itself was lame, but the Baylan was a promising character. He had much more charisma than all the others, including - sadly - Thrawn.
Vader hallway scene was one of the best parts of rogue one, Vader as a character was so into it that he risked his life just so that he could be menacing
Lol yea turned off his life support just to scare tf out of some random rebels. 10/10 style
@@Nebin20he didnt turn it off, you still hear him breathing. he just turned off the light.
로그원은 시리즈 중에서 가장 저평가받고있어😅
All he had to do was force grab the guy with the plans. That whole scene was as useless as it was stupid.
That fact when Luke is more scary then Vader is gosebumps. Pure confidence as he walks and strikes. But still light side.
How is that a fact that he’s ‘scarier’. Says who? What makes him scarier? You are talking absolute nonsense
I think mainly because he's moving faster
@@shauna.a8701 Luke moves faster than anakin? Since when? Literally never
@@nissy9220 Lol, not Anakin - Vader. Vader's physical speed is limited due to his injuries.
@@shauna.a8701 fair call
There's always light at the end of the tunnel. The light: 1:31
Lmao this made me laugh
Thats actually a good one
Luke as a Jedi Master is something we needed to see and boy how great is Luke as a Jedi Master here than in that silly sequel they made.
They couldn’t keep Luke a master it doesn’t fit their liberal agenda
George wrote Luke the same way in his sequel scripts lol. Nothing wrong with giving Luke a new arc. If Rey met Luke with him knowing everything and being highly proficient in his ability it would have made no sense for him to be in exile on the island in the first place. If you're mad at Luke's character in that movie the blame is to JJ Abrams, not Rian Johnson.
@@insahnay
George had a similar vision for Luke, but even that wasn't nearly as bad as the set up that the Sequels gave for it
@@insahnayKnowing George, he would dedicate the entire trilogy for Luke's arc and flesh it out much more than the sequels we have now
@@insahnayeh u cant deny they still got a lot with Luke wrong in TLJ. Bruh he literally just met rey and was being such a dick to her for no reason (50 ish year old man vs 18ish year old girl) instead of cordially saying he cant join her, and the throwing of his fathers lightsaber was just ridiculous
Luke is beautiful to watch. Very harmonic and languorous.
And this is where Kenobi shows himself the grandmaster of Form III. Out of practice with a child to escort, and he still blocks every shot, while having the presence of mind to then use the collapse of the walls to drown his adversaries in one stroke at just the right moment.
He’s not a living typhoon of destructive saber combat or a Force god like Luke or Vader. But he acquits himself splendidly under the circumstances while facing a far worse handicap than the other two.
1:24 I remember the whole movie theatre let out a gasp at the same time. Me and my dad looked at each other. I never saw him smile like that. My dad was born in 1968 and was at the grand launch of star wars. Can't imagine what he felt at that moment. His entire childhood made a comeback. And at the end of the scene, my dad told me to rush to the car to watch a new hope with him so we can experience like a transition
I love my dad
Edit: my dad watched the launch of every star wars movie since 1977
Rogue one was his fsvourite because he spent it with me
That’s so wholesome 🥹
나도 아빠랑 같이 영화를 봤는데, 마지막 장면에서 정말 흥분했었지ㅋㅋ
You are a Jedi, like your Father before you 🫡
@@6.0roze46 Thank you.
Unpopular opinion: "Rogue One is my favorite Star Wars movie."
I love all of them though. Yes even (regardless of them not being very good) the Sequel Trilogy.
I love the difference between Obi-wan's scene compared to the other two. While the other two were moving forward and dominating their opponents, Obi-wan was on the defensive the whole time and blocking/redirecting shots. While the other two triumphed with their strength, Obi-wan turned the tides by turning a dire scenario (the window cracking) into an advantage, showcasing his quick thinking instead.
OYA totally agree with this!!
Obiwan is a great character but the directing and scenario for this serie were so bad
The Skywalkers are powerhouses not hesitating to show off their gifted affinity with the Force while Obi Wan is a crafty fox. He is surgical with his force usage and strengths which makes him and his fights such a treat to witness.
Late for the party, but I’m not a fan of how obiwan scene was just a copy of cal in fallen order.
Obiwan was not at his strongest. I would say, he was at his weakest, while Luke and Vader was when they were at their peak.
The fact that I actually enjoy watching two of these and don’t start cracking up at stuff actually says a lot about how well they hold up
They all are less than 10 years old…
Dawg the obi wan and Luke scene were from the past two years or so and the Darth Vader one is from rogue one which is less than 10 years old just like the comment above stated 😂
Vader slaps hard.
But I never seen a light saber fight as fluid as Luke's hallway scene its like a figure skater on ice always in motion.
Yeah Luke fights in motion with no wasted movements, but Vader dominates with pure force and aggression that makes any attempt just feeble. Luke moves through the battlefield, Vader pushes back the battlefield until you’re cornered. And Obi-Wan defends against both sides of the battlefield at the same time.
I like how they all have different fighting styles. Obi Wan has the Jedi’s defensive style, mainly focused on deflecting blaster bolts away. Vader is more offensive, attacking a lot of the time and only deflecting attacks when required. Luke is a mix of both, deflecting shots while attacking fiercely, and sometimes even using the dark side to destroy his enemies.
Obi wan uses soresu, Vader uses juro and occasionally uses djarm so
But Luke on the other hand, is disputable
@@DarthJarJar6Form 3 and Form 5 😊
@@bayonetta8418 perfect combo for offense and defence
Kenobi had to take that style as he wasn't alone but making sure the girl wasn't harmed. Both Vader and Luke didn't have anyone to take care not to harm in the hall.
So it makes for Kenobi to go with a defensive style. Kenobi is a master duelist. Meaning that he would know many styles. But that's the character. There is also that of the 3 is was the only scene with an actor and not a 3d character. Given that, it was not bad.
@@DarthJarJar6 Luke could use Djem-So or Niman, which is everything at once.
I love how with the Obi-Wan scene they took huge inspiration from the Jedi Fallen Order game. Great reference.
Haha, That means they had the same problem twice in the same fortress and never did anything about now exposed structural vulnerability that let enemies of the empire escape.
I was gonna say, couldn’t Kenobi just slash at the glass? But my small brain didn’t realize that he was actually luring the troops into a water trap and submerged them all while staying alive himself. That happened again just now.
Lightsabers don't work well underwater. It needs oxygen to fuel the plasma energy it emits. Without any modifications, Obi-wans saber would've likely just short-circuited upon contact with the glass and water, leaving him with a broken saber and a ton of stormtroopers.
@@underthesun-ml4mu Disney doesn't understand how Lightsabers work.
Man Vader’s they just nailed it like man that shit is perfect
Those rebel soldiers in that hallway had only heard of the frightening rumors of a Jedi hunting machine-man, and then suddenly the rumor appears, bathed in the red glow of a bleeding kyber. That Vader scene was fking awesome. What a great ending to a great movie.
Vader's moving slowly, but being unstoppable is like a slow death to the troopers. Like nothing they could do to save their own life. Feel the fear and desperation in their scream and eyes
Like master and apprentice, like father and son
Watching Luke pick those dark troopers apart was glorious.
Obi-Wan's has the added factor that it's the one that brought him back to the game.
He got his skills back by being immediately dropped into action in order to protect Leia.
Budget-wise, it was Obi-wan's that was lacking, but for the story of him trying to relearn all that and finally seeing him get back into it makes up for it.
I wish i could go back to the cinemas and re-watch the vader scene again. my jaw was on the floor.
I know they were in peril with the stormtroopers, but I love the way Obi Wan held Leia’s hand guiding them through.
2:12 love the way you made that fade out
Obi Wan’s really exemplified who he is. Doesn’t straight up massacre the base but if you attack him then very best of luck to you.
Galaxy is filled with OP dark side characters who have had various bits chopped off.
Luke as a Jedi is a product of both Anakin & Obi-Wan, two of the best to ever do it. IMO he has the best scene. But Vader's is iconically ominous.
The Vader hallway scene is the best hands down this one goes to Vader
Obi-Wan’s was Desperation to get Leia away.
Vader’s was the anger from the sheer gall the Rebellion had to steal the Death Star plans
Luke’s was the hope that the Mandolorian and Co. were going to be okay.
I think what made Luke's hallway scene really awesome is that he didn't held back at all. He knew the dark troopers were just droids, so he was given the chance to unleashed all his mastery of the force and lightsaber skills against them. He would've never slashed through the hallway like a meat grinder if the troopers were living beings inside since he's a true and compassionate Jedi that serves to protect, not kill
All fantastic scenes. I love seeing Obi-wan getting his confidence back throughout the scene. Vader's is fantastic. My favorite however will go to Luke. Balanced, grounded, and surgical.
Why does the music fit so perfectly at 2:06
As the original hallway scene Vaders is the best, it was totally unexpected and the sheer brutality of it in the cinema was awesome. Lukes is great as well, as it was also a surprise, but the original is the best.
Obi-Wan is criminally underrated. Dude force held billions of pounds of water back. Vader pulls a ship and everyone's jaw dropped. This is 1000× more impressive
You can tell that Ewan is using a heavy sword that emits actual light. He’s much clunkier with this than the lightweight CGId-over swords of the prequels.
Those three have a legacy of hallway fights.
I think Vader’s was best from a cinematic experience. The fear of the rebel soldiers, and the sudden shock and the evil creativity of how he dispatches them. Luke’s had potential but I think fans are more happy to see him than anything else because of what the sequel trilogy did to him. Obi-wans was just not shot well and lacked creativity as well as dominance-hard to cheer for him.
Jedi aren’t dominant. Thinking they should be is missing the whole point. Jedi are supposed to fight with economy-to control their environment, and to protect others. Luke does it. So does Obi-Wan.
Obi wan doesn't use a offense form? What dominance do you want from him?
Say what you want about the Kenobi show, but Ewan Killed it!
Very true
My dawg obi wan been through so much
Rian Johnson: "What do you expect? I take a laser sword and fight the entire first order my self?"
Me: "Yes! Rian! That's what we expect from Luke! That's THE ONLY thing we expect from a Skywalker!"
I will never forget the asshole in the theatre during Rogue One. Guy sitting right in front of me already saw the movie, and we're now getting to the Vader scene. It's dark and you hear Vader's breathing and you're totally sucked in this moment just like the Rebels on the edge of your seat or at least I was completely glued to the screen and just as Vader ignites his lightsaber you hear the guy make a light saber ignition sound so loud you don't even hear the audio from the movie of the ignition and it completely took me out of the moment. Still irritates me to this day whenever I see the clip.
😂😂😂
I just noticed that his reconnection to the force increased massively when he held the hand of the daughter of Skywalker..
Is she Leia?
Luke being like his father had to force crush something 😂
Obi wan got his skills back 🔥🔥🔥
Like father like son indeed
This shows why Jedi and Force users were so feared and respected. From the point of view of a regular unit/soldier, they were unstoppable go-get-it machines.
I like to assume obi wan here is not at his peak as he's trying to regain his skills
It's pretty much obvious since he didn't had any fight in 10 years since Mustafar
Obi wan using full light side. Darth Vader using full dark side. Luke using both. Pretty cool to see.
I really hope they don't just give everyone a hallway scene 😂
There’s one in the ahsoka series now 😭
There’s a lot of hallways in Star Wars so yeah, it could happen.
Jar Jar gets one next... XD
@@shannonrhoads7099Finally, we'll see Darth Jar Jar in his prime 😂
It’s almost as if hallways are strategic choke points or something? Not like this is called Star WARS or anything, right?
The crazy thing to think about is the obscene amount of blaster fire obi-wan and anakin experienced during the clone wars. and now, Kenobi is rusty and Vader is mostly machine, but they can both handle it just fine.
The set-up for Luke's hallway scene was impeccable. The Dark Troopers were established as such a threat that even The Mandalorian almost got killed by just one of them in a one-on-one fight. Then Luke comes and treats them like absolute fodder. Truly establishes the power of Luke
Characters with hallway scene:
Vader
Luke
Kenobi
Maul
Baylan
Luke was great in that episode. Din struggled so hard against a singular murder droid, whereas Luke just flies in, decimates the entire squad effortlessly, crushes the last one just to show off... and then politely waits by the door to be let in. Seeing him in action was great, but it's that last part that really makes me love his hallway scene
What series is Luke in?
The scene in this video is The Mandalorian season 2 finale. Luke is the big event that caps off the season. He also shows up in the Book of Boba Fett, I think in episode 6, after the writers ran out of Boba Fett content and turned the show in The Mandalorian S2.5, which, honestly, wasn't all that bad of a decision
@@Swirl_of_StarFireIt's anticlimactic for that reason. Lukes fighting is great but these guys don't even put up a fight. And blasters and fires can't even touch them but the lightsaber goes right through. It doesn't seem right with the aura that the show created for these guys. Watching it out of context is great because you can just enjoy Luke's fighting without wondering why these droids suck so much now.
so Vader really jamned the door with his force, IT EXCITES ME
Holy crap! I just realized something. As Obi-Wan begins to re-master the Force, he does so in every scene, including the climax. In other words, in every episode, he goes from being a Force-sensitive to a talented padawan to a knowledgable Jedi, to a skilled Knight, and ultimately, in the end, Jedi Master. In the course of the show, we see the journey of a Force User from start to finish. How sublime.
Obi-Wan, always grinding!
In fairness, Obi Wan was out of practice this episode. He destroys Vader not too too long after this.
At the end, I can just hear “I’m Luke skywalker, I’m here to rescue you” in my head
Vader and Luke’s entrance were the best especially vaders cause his entrance can give you the chills
Skywalkers are not for kidding
Obi-wan was defensive, which was perfect for that situation
Darth Vader was just aggressive, he probably could've just simply struck them all down, but he added intimidation into the mix. The way the guy at the end of that clip is screaming shows that
And Luke, the way he fought was honestly just graceful
It was the Luke scene that convinced me to actually watch most of the new canon shows. I was and still am extremely disappointed with the sequel films but the TV shows have delivered some rewarding experiences. While I might never get to see Luke fighting Shimrra or the Clone Palpatine or C'Baoth, at least we do have one good scene of Jedi Master Luke Skywalker kicking some battle droid ass!
Nobody ever seems to comment on that amazing twirl and backhanded deflect that Luke pulls at 3:08
0:07 nobody shoot him when he has his back turned for like two seconds or anything.
In slow motion you can see some shots
They shot but missed 😂😂
@@champloo9058 what did you expect, they are stormtroopers.
That's every Jedi scene in Star Wars dude, they never shot when they have their chance. Too much spinning, too much coreography, not enough realism or danger. The prequels were at least better in showing the speed of the Jedi, wich made everything more belivable.
Han Solo had the funniest hallway scene.
I feel obi wan is so underrated. The guy was an absolute beast
Vader hallway scene is a top 5 SW moment. Iconic
Luke’s made me late for my cousin’s wedding 😂 Moments I wish I could relive.
Either Obi pulled a Cal Kestis or Cal pulled an Obi-Wan
Jedi Fallen Order did take place years after he kenobi show,but even then cal wouldn't have known that obi wan have done his before.
I imagine Ghost Force Anaking saying "That's my boy" in the luke scene. :) Like father like son.
Obi wan has the hardest circumstances bc he was protecting leia whilst being out of practice, Luke was pure skill and deadly, calculated movements, and Vader was pure unmatched brutality. All were amazing
I’d say Luke’s scene was the best display of skill and RAW force powers! The level of danger due to those trooper droids, they posed the greatest threat!
Ya man! it was sad this is not shown at the starwars sequel movie!
Need to add Baylon to this now
Star Wars sure love their hallway shots
God Ewan McGregor KILLED it in choreography
I actually didn’t mind a new actor playing as Luke. Why is Disney so scared of proper change? They just had to super Sci-fi his face to look like the old actor. They are only hurting themselves in the long ru- what’s the point anymore…..
Man obi wan was really rusty in that
He hasn’t even used the force in like 10 years
All 3 bits were equally brilliant
Hallway fight scenes are the best type of modern fight scenes. From Star Wars to Daredevil.
In my opinion, Kenobi’s scene was truly a shame. On the other hand, Vader’s was perfect and I really enjoyed watching how strong Luke has become in this scene, as it reminds us he’s a Skywalker after all.
I mean Kenobi's scene was showing him getting warmed up after 10 years of not fighting so it's kinda obvious he is not as flashy as Luke or Vader
Obi Wan was still trying to remember he is THE master of soresu
Obi Wan’s is sick for it’s own reason. If you can’t see why I feel bad for you.
Luke wins this one its the best piece of Star Wars in a while
Dude Vaders breathing gave me maximum chills
omg...Luke's hallway scene is so lit!!
Ah yes! The epic hallway scenes of Uncle Grandpa, Dad Vader, and "Chosen Two? Chosen the Sequel, Chosen Second? Ah screw it green lightsaber it is"! Lmao I love Star Wars 😂
0:11 - A storm trooper hit something?
So we can all agree that Darth Vader's hallway scene was the best by a loooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooong shot
Vader makes it look effortless, it's above everything else.
Bro when obi wan was trying to get window to break by using the force why could he have not just have used his lightsaber
He was trying to keep it from breaking on him, if you watch the scene, you can see the crack first start. He only used it as a weapon when the stormtroopers broke through the door.
@@JoePNG.I thought he was trying to break the glass
@@darrenmilligan-vn8qq Nah, it can look like that, though. They only show the initial crack for like a second or two.
Lukes is the best imo. Its so fluently executed
The people who made kenobi scene definitely took inspiration from fallen order
My favorite part about Vader is thinking about how he used to be or technically still is Anakin. Its always what made me love Vader. The fact a nice guy who loved his family who only wanted them to survive turned into that