When you think about it Padme and Ahsoka represented two emotions Anakin lacked during the Clone Wars. Padme was Anakin’s reason and Ahsoka was his patience. Without either around, Anakin was easily corrupted by Sidious.
Interesting analysis! I never thought about it like that. I see Padmé as the person who soothes Anakin and calms him down. Ahsoka gets Anakin to laugh and smile a lot, so she brings a lot of joy into his life.
Yea, but if you also think about it, those conversations Anakin was having with Sidious would've been ones he would have with Qui-Gon were he still alive.
I liked this one a lot. A lot of fan fic ultimately highlights the fragility of Palp's plans. And while this one doesn't destroy how silly his plans were, it takes a path that shows plausible contingencies he could have in place.
@@starwarsquill He had to have anticipated someone finding out. What if it were a separatist aligned senator who did and revealed his identity to create disquiet in the republic and the separatists then come across as the savior.
The Jedi and their allies could have made a counter-argument against Palpatine's false accusations by pointing out he already controls much of the courts and justice system including the intelligence departments.
@@starwarsquillPalpatine is a master of 5D chess, he’s always several steps ahead of everyone else. The prequel Jedi order and the Republic were long overdue for change.
The Jedi were already doomed. Palpatine had them in Checkmate position. Now had Padme's vote of no confidence in Chancellor Vallorum failed, or had Palpatine lost the election , that would change everything
Not as much as you'd think. If the vote of no confidence hadn't gone through, Vallorum's time in office was very nearly up and Palpatine could have campaigned using the victory at Naboo as a way to sway votes especially by campaigning as a tough on corpos. He could have turned the victory on Naboo as a rallying cry against the corporate powers, which would sway those whose sympathy he was originally banking on in the no confidence vote. He and Plagius already had a good number of senators in their pockets.
@30:24 For someone who uses Dark Side users own alignment against them in battle, he never learned why negative emotions are a hindrance. His lack of patience, despite being a Jedi Master, proves to once again allow Palpatine to enact Order 66.
Tbh, if I was a senator in the Senate during that scene, you have no IDEA how furious I'd be at the Senate as a whole. That could not more obviously be a discredit tactic. XD he doesn't even address the accusations of being a sith lord or controlling both sides, he just literally ad-hominems. I would literally leave and tell the leaders of my planet that the Republic was too corrupt to save and we should join the Neutral Systems. Can't wait to see part 2. :3
Teckla Minnau wasn't alive during ROTS, she died on Scipio in "Pursuit of Peace" episode of TCW. Also I think Padmé would have been at the apartment already since it wouldn't have taken that long for the "Padmé's Ruminations" scene to take place. Fun fact, she was first introduced as a background character in Attack of the Clones, serving Anakin the pear which he cut a piece and flew it for Padmé with the force. I wasn't aware of this fact until recently.
The Chancellor just straight up dissappear's, it's never properly investigated or explained, and power smoothly transitions to a new Chancellor who surrenders their emergency powers and its back to business as usual... because if there's one thing you don't do in a high stakes political game, it's show your hand to Padme.
What if there was a Star Wars game set just before order 66 with u having to escape the Jedi temple on Coruscant with us rescuing Gungi before being separated but seeing the Wookiee escape as well as Jedi Master Quinlan Visas we make our own escape
Hi Star Wars Quill what an excellent Video based on What if Anakin told Padme about Palpatine instead of Mace Windu. Can you please create a part2 based on What if Anakin told Padme about Palpatine instead of Palpatine instead f Mace Windu? Whicjh I also believed it could have happened instead Mace Windu being known about Mace Windu in the Episode3 The Revenge of the Sith.
If I were a Jedi I would remind Anakin about Ulic Qel-Droma, who decided to conquer Dark Side from within and ended murdering his beloved brother. He did turn to light, but only after being stripped from the Force and years of self-hate.
you really upload these early. good morning to everyone from the us and abroad. there are only a few questions i have about the episode. why is kuat against the war when they are profiting from it? aside form that great what if as always. only suggetion i have is invest in learning audio processing and effects. it would take your videos up a notch. that's all have a nice day my friend.
i have an idea: what if the force existed relatively recently? like, within the last hundred years or so. you'd have all of the familar faces including yoda because why not. lets say hes the one who made the force exist in the first place.
What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
I feel mace windu would have told the senators if things went wrong they eoulr ro it their way and have an alternative plan. Whether or not that plan would have succeeded is something else. But he would have prepared for "aggressive negotiations"
fun vid, though i find myself generally disagreeing with most of these sorts of alternate timeline fics. one main thing highlighted quite clearly in the expanded lore is that jedi/sith are basically a niche religion in the republic, a republic that gives huge deference to religious freedoms. calling palpatine a sith is basically meaningless and would more likely be viewed as intolerant religious persecution. any sort of official hearing would be entirely focused on the war crimes side of things i’d think.
No need to add the pics. Tbh extra detail isn’t needed. Like we don’t need the make and model of each star-fighter/ship. You can just say, “speeder,” or, “personal speeder.” Also in Padmé’s case, just say assistant or something, again there isn’t a need for the unnecessary information such as the name of her assistant. Ofc this is all my opinion, and I ultimately do enjoy your work, just not the over explaining. You don’t need to over explain. 😅
Honestly some of the simplest what if's are probably the best Just telling a different person On that note, it's interesting how even swapping the genders Padme and Anakin have been born with is interesting What's Darth Sidious supposed to do about a pregnant woman? And how is Anakin supposed to hide it from the Jedi, they can't be that oblivious, right?
This is a Correct Alternate Story of Star Wars if Anakin Skywalker didn't tell to Mace Windu About Chancellor Palpatine is A Sith Lord instead of Senator Padme Amidala After the executed of General Grievous and Padme Amidala is A Senator Anakin Skywalker should tell first to Padme Amidala Before telling to The Jedi Temple About Chancellor Palpatine is a Sith Lord Because Padme Amidala is a Senator and Anakin Skywalker Should Focus About Padme Amidala Pregnancy if Anakin Skywalker tells to Senator Padme Amidala About Chancellor Palpatine Secrets as a Sith Lord Chancellor Palpatine will be charged with impeachment on The Galactic Senate and Order 66 will revealed Mace Windu will Fight Chancellor Palpatine in The Senate Hall in Episode 3
How stupid! They should have dealt with the emergency powers and then told the Senate about Palpatine! They should also have waited for Ashoka and Maul's testimony. I hope Anakin tells the Jedi the danger Padme's children pose to the Jedi and his destiny!
When you think about it Padme and Ahsoka represented two emotions Anakin lacked during the Clone Wars. Padme was Anakin’s reason and Ahsoka was his patience. Without either around, Anakin was easily corrupted by Sidious.
Interesting analysis! I never thought about it like that. I see Padmé as the person who soothes Anakin and calms him down. Ahsoka gets Anakin to laugh and smile a lot, so she brings a lot of joy into his life.
You would think that patients would be represented by Obi-Wan, but since when does Anakin actually listen to him?
Yea, but if you also think about it, those conversations Anakin was having with Sidious would've been ones he would have with Qui-Gon were he still alive.
Yet obi wan was both
Jedi and the D2000: We've uncovered evidence that you are using this war to further your own goals, Chancellor!
Sidious: no u
I liked this one a lot. A lot of fan fic ultimately highlights the fragility of Palp's plans. And while this one doesn't destroy how silly his plans were, it takes a path that shows plausible contingencies he could have in place.
7:52 May's Window
10:29 Agent Cola
14:46 Batman
21:19 May's Window (again)
Sidious in Starwarsquill's universe is Beast Wars Megatron. Always 3 steps ahead in the planning stage
@@marsandcobblesproductions3501 the guy always did give off a “it’s all proceeding as per my design” kinda vibe lol
A mystical Bond Villain? 😁
@@starwarsquill He had to have anticipated someone finding out. What if it were a separatist aligned senator who did and revealed his identity to create disquiet in the republic and the separatists then come across as the savior.
@@rodgerscott8808
Ah Master Windu, I've been expecting you
@@starwarsquillcan you do What If… The Terminator was sent to kill Anakin Skywalker?
10:28
The split second it says Agent Cola instead of Agen Kolar is so funny
The lesson of this story talk to your wives
Just not all of them at the same time 😅
@@itzxsliick7036😂😂😂😂😂😂
You are hilarious !!!!
You are either a woman or single .
@@lordofpain3476 And you obviously don't trust ur wife
The Jedi and their allies could have made a counter-argument against Palpatine's false accusations by pointing out he already controls much of the courts and justice system including the intelligence departments.
I really hate/love these kind of stories. Cliffhangers suuuuck. But your narration is superb as always. Can't wait for the next part!
You're a really good story teller bud
@@DefileOdds thanks :)
@@starwarsquillPalpatine is a master of 5D chess, he’s always several steps ahead of everyone else. The prequel Jedi order and the Republic were long overdue for change.
May's Window's(07:51) and Agent Cola(10:29)
You thought that we won't notice, didn't you? 😂
tv
14:47 as Anakin grappled with this new information, Batman stepped forward.
this is one of the best star wars what-if's i've ever heard, also funny subtitles easter eggs
The Jedi were already doomed. Palpatine had them in Checkmate position. Now had Padme's vote of no confidence in Chancellor Vallorum failed, or had Palpatine lost the election , that would change everything
Not as much as you'd think. If the vote of no confidence hadn't gone through, Vallorum's time in office was very nearly up and Palpatine could have campaigned using the victory at Naboo as a way to sway votes especially by campaigning as a tough on corpos. He could have turned the victory on Naboo as a rallying cry against the corporate powers, which would sway those whose sympathy he was originally banking on in the no confidence vote. He and Plagius already had a good number of senators in their pockets.
@30:24
For someone who uses Dark Side users own alignment against them in battle, he never learned why negative emotions are a hindrance. His lack of patience, despite being a Jedi Master, proves to once again allow Palpatine to enact Order 66.
Tbh, if I was a senator in the Senate during that scene, you have no IDEA how furious I'd be at the Senate as a whole.
That could not more obviously be a discredit tactic. XD he doesn't even address the accusations of being a sith lord or controlling both sides, he just literally ad-hominems. I would literally leave and tell the leaders of my planet that the Republic was too corrupt to save and we should join the Neutral Systems.
Can't wait to see part 2. :3
@10:28
I love the flicker of subtitles here!!
Talk about a twisting story.
I look forward to seeing the next chapter.
Teckla Minnau wasn't alive during ROTS, she died on Scipio in "Pursuit of Peace" episode of TCW. Also I think Padmé would have been at the apartment already since it wouldn't have taken that long for the "Padmé's Ruminations" scene to take place.
Fun fact, she was first introduced as a background character in Attack of the Clones, serving Anakin the pear which he cut a piece and flew it for Padmé with the force. I wasn't aware of this fact until recently.
Part two, please! This was a great what if.
Me reading the title: When did Anakin tell Padme about Mace Windu?
Read the title again. He told her about Palpatine, not Mace.
He told her about Palpatine instead of Mace Windu. Which means in original timeline he told her about Mace Windu
I hope you will also release part 4 of “ What if Anakin was already a Master “ soon:)
I ‘ d be both glad and grateful, thank you!:)
What if Luke Skyscraper was really tall?
@@TheStrayWarrior he would’ve had the high ground on Vader
@@starwarsquill That didn't work on Vader when he jumped on the catwalk in the second death Stars throne room.
@@starwarsquillyou don’t need the high ground, when you ARE the high ground.
"aren't you a little tall for a stormtrooper?"
Agent Cola is my favourite character, Agent Cola FTW
Haha
@@starwarsquill about 20 min thru the video, damn good work as usual.
the padme/batman switch was hilarious
this definitely needs a part two
Palpatine is a manipulative !@#$%^&. Well done. I look forward to more
A part two would be greatly appreciated.
Arriving in a few hours:)
The Chancellor just straight up dissappear's, it's never properly investigated or explained, and power smoothly transitions to a new Chancellor who surrenders their emergency powers and its back to business as usual... because if there's one thing you don't do in a high stakes political game, it's show your hand to Padme.
What if Saesse Tinn attacked Palpitine while he was stabbing Agen Kholar.
Part 2 make it happen
Bro I need part 2
What if there was a Star Wars game set just before order 66 with u having to escape the Jedi temple on Coruscant with us rescuing Gungi before being separated but seeing the Wookiee escape as well as Jedi Master Quinlan Visas we make our own escape
Need a part 2
Hi Star Wars Quill what an excellent Video based on What if Anakin told Padme about Palpatine instead of Mace Windu. Can you please create a part2 based on What if Anakin told Padme about Palpatine instead of Palpatine instead f Mace Windu? Whicjh I also believed it could have happened instead Mace Windu being known about Mace Windu in the Episode3 The Revenge of the Sith.
lets be honest Mace Windu is an idiot to hiss his ligthsaber and attack like that!!
What if StarwarsQuill was the sith lord instead of palpatine?
@realrosesaretrulyred would’ve tripped on my robes and fallen down the reactor shaft.
@@starwarsquillDarth Quill would be the most iconic and popular and powerful sith lord there is who’d surpass even Vader.
@@starwarsquill Do not underestimate the power of the dark ink!
I've an suggestion what if the Jedi killed off the Sith (every last one even Bane) 1000 years before The Phantom Menace?
Then the neo-Sith emarges
@@Somethingfs-sx1ft oh?
@@TheHomieZhe darkness will always rise
@@Somethingfs-sx1ft oh oke
@@Somethingfs-sx1ft oh oke
If I were a Jedi I would remind Anakin about Ulic Qel-Droma, who decided to conquer Dark Side from within and ended murdering his beloved brother. He did turn to light, but only after being stripped from the Force and years of self-hate.
you really upload these early. good morning to everyone from the us and abroad. there are only a few questions i have about the episode. why is kuat against the war when they are profiting from it? aside form that great what if as always. only suggetion i have is invest in learning audio processing and effects. it would take your videos up a notch. that's all have a nice day my friend.
i have an idea: what if the force existed relatively recently? like, within the last hundred years or so. you'd have all of the familar faces including yoda because why not. lets say hes the one who made the force exist in the first place.
Yes. It's too easy believable that the Syth lord would be prepared for even this.
Really cool video!
14:47 BATMAN
I don't know why but just seeing padme switch to batman made me laugh
Jajajajajajaja!
What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
I've been thinking about what if danny phantom was starwars and the apprentice of anakin skywalker
I feel mace windu would have told the senators if things went wrong they eoulr ro it their way and have an alternative plan.
Whether or not that plan would have succeeded is something else. But he would have prepared for "aggressive negotiations"
What if general grievous killed palpatine on the invisible hand?
fun vid, though i find myself generally disagreeing with most of these sorts of alternate timeline fics.
one main thing highlighted quite clearly in the expanded lore is that jedi/sith are basically a niche religion in the republic, a republic that gives huge deference to religious freedoms. calling palpatine a sith is basically meaningless and would more likely be viewed as intolerant religious persecution. any sort of official hearing would be entirely focused on the war crimes side of things i’d think.
No need to add the pics. Tbh extra detail isn’t needed. Like we don’t need the make and model of each star-fighter/ship. You can just say, “speeder,” or, “personal speeder.” Also in Padmé’s case, just say assistant or something, again there isn’t a need for the unnecessary information such as the name of her assistant. Ofc this is all my opinion, and I ultimately do enjoy your work, just not the over explaining. You don’t need to over explain. 😅
NAOOOOOO!
@@starwarsquill Lol, still an amazing story!
we probably wont see part 2 for awhile
Same situation in thevofgicw but what if palpatine pretended sidious could posses his body?
What if Quill was isekaied into Star Wars. What would he do? I would help Plagueis or Bane not Sidious.
He would chill with solo and chewwie
Would trip on Luke’s cuffs and fall down the reactor shaft
Honestly some of the simplest what if's are probably the best
Just telling a different person
On that note, it's interesting how even swapping the genders Padme and Anakin have been born with is interesting
What's Darth Sidious supposed to do about a pregnant woman?
And how is Anakin supposed to hide it from the Jedi, they can't be that oblivious, right?
Jedi are not celibate
What if Cin Drallig killed anakin in the temple
Bro, this thumbnail again? 😂😂
This is goooood.
This is a Correct Alternate Story of Star Wars if Anakin Skywalker didn't tell to Mace Windu About Chancellor Palpatine is A Sith Lord instead of Senator Padme Amidala After the executed of General Grievous and Padme Amidala is A Senator Anakin Skywalker should tell first to Padme Amidala Before telling to The Jedi Temple About Chancellor Palpatine is a Sith Lord Because Padme Amidala is a Senator and Anakin Skywalker Should Focus About Padme Amidala Pregnancy if Anakin Skywalker tells to Senator Padme Amidala About Chancellor Palpatine Secrets as a Sith Lord Chancellor Palpatine will be charged with impeachment on The Galactic Senate and Order 66 will revealed Mace Windu will Fight Chancellor Palpatine in The Senate Hall in Episode 3
Padme
…….. A SITH LORD !!!!!!!!
How stupid! They should have dealt with the emergency powers and then told the Senate about Palpatine!
They should also have waited for Ashoka and Maul's testimony.
I hope Anakin tells the Jedi the danger Padme's children pose to the Jedi and his destiny!
This would have made a made a more interesting movie than the original episode 3.
Bill Organo
What if Anakin spoke to Watto about Palpatine instead of Mace?
@@metadude1234 hmm might make that one lmao
@@starwarsquill Rofl; have fun - i'd love to see your take on that