Fitbit Inspire 3 : Full Scientific Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 июл 2024
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 267

  • @TheQuantifiedScientist
    @TheQuantifiedScientist  Год назад +5

    🔴 General Amazon link*: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist
    🔴 Fitbit Inspire 3*: geni.us/Fitbit_Inspire3
    🟢 Instagram: instagram.com/quantified_scientist/
    🟠 Shorts: studio.ruclips.net/channel/UCcpARGzXNaC62UQWns2dh2Q
    🔵 Newsletter: www.robterhorst.com
    🟡 Twitter: @QuantifiedRob
    * Affiliate (paid) links support the channel by earning me a commission on any sale, and it doesn't cost you any more! My opinions are completely my own, and this content is not sponsored.
    ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
    👇 $30 off any new WHOOP membership, affiliate* (paid) link, supports the channel!👇
    join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScientist ($30 off any new WHOOP membership)

    • @alessandrolanfranchi5913
      @alessandrolanfranchi5913 Год назад

      Can you test the Verity sense??

    • @lj9656
      @lj9656 Год назад

      Can you test the new updated algorithm of Oura ring 3?

    • @ParbodhCBali
      @ParbodhCBali Год назад

      Hi, Qualified Scientist, what do you recommend as best watch /band per value for money. Not needing luxury or status concerned product. would be highly obliged

  • @felixbrandau4751
    @felixbrandau4751 Год назад +424

    The only one who compares the watches seriously

  • @haythemkarchoud5986
    @haythemkarchoud5986 Год назад +146

    Good freaking job man ! As a data scientist I always struggle with reviews that are not backed up by data and are too subjective. This just hits the spot for me !

  • @tnjar
    @tnjar Год назад +6

    THANK YOU! Your content is great, and this video is exactly what I was searching for. The comparison chart of all the tested products is more helpful than I know how to say. Thanks again man.

  • @khreon27
    @khreon27 4 месяца назад +3

    this is one of the most thorough analysis videos I've ever came across. great job man

  • @chrispaulin1482
    @chrispaulin1482 10 месяцев назад +5

    Subsribed, never seen a reviewer as competent as you. Your work is appreciated.

  • @DJTwinky
    @DJTwinky Год назад +8

    This video is amazing! The amount of depth & research put into testing and production is the most useful review I've seen from so many 'wearable' videos bar none. I'm happy to discover this channel as an alternative to click-bait-y RUclipsrs merely regurgitating the product specs. Bravo!

  • @dutchdude7180
    @dutchdude7180 Год назад

    Thank you for the great review! Ordered one last week and I am wearing it now 😊

  • @kanakraj3198
    @kanakraj3198 Год назад +1

    Best Review, data backed, graphs, comparison, correlation! As a Data Science Research person couldn't have asked for more!

  • @nicolasc-m8139
    @nicolasc-m8139 Год назад +21

    Hi Rob, Thanks a lot for all these tests, videos, advice and comparaisons. It is a huge and great job that you make for your community and anyone who is looking for objective datas. I post here in the last video I found for ask if you have plan to test the last creation of withings (the body scan). Yes it is not a watch but, like you did the sleep analyzer I thought that could be in your plan ;^p.

  • @Pradeesh...13
    @Pradeesh...13 Год назад

    Thanks you sooooooooo much, i have been waiting for this video for 3 months. U r awesome 👌

  • @jonathag2000
    @jonathag2000 Год назад +1

    Absolutely love your videos! Right up there with DC rainmaker which is high praise

  • @humanmale6424
    @humanmale6424 Год назад +8

    Bought it in October and had to return due to screen touch error (it kept manipulating on the screen itself). However, I highly appreciate its ability to track sleep - super accurate every time I wake up in the middle of the night or wake up in the morning.

  • @Ghillieye
    @Ghillieye Год назад +4

    This was an amazing video! I really appreciate the data-driven approach you take comparing both to the industry gold-standard and across the industry as a whole.
    I wish you also compared Sp02 as well! Maybe next time =)

  • @zeehont6159
    @zeehont6159 Год назад +5

    Yess was waiting for this review :)

  • @KrishanSharma-hk3zv
    @KrishanSharma-hk3zv Год назад

    Another excellent review keep up the great work mate 👍

  • @floralpatriarch7782
    @floralpatriarch7782 Год назад

    Other videos where good at guiding me here but this was ultimately the best review & analysis I have seen for sleep tracking devices.

  • @wayoonpimdee8295
    @wayoonpimdee8295 Год назад

    Thank you for the information about the Fitbit Inspire 3. After watching this video, I clicked to order immediately.

  • @Babak7712
    @Babak7712 Год назад +2

    Thank you for this great review.

  • @PamWD
    @PamWD 2 месяца назад +1

    Great information! An interesting thing I found for when Inspire 3 counts steps when it shouldn't---when ringing handbells! Obviously, not something that the majority of people do, but when I am rehearsing handbell ringing, it definitely counts that as steps. Originally discovered this by accident when the "you've reached your step goal" notification went off close to the end of a rehearsal (we stand at a table when ringing, so no walking around). But it does not count steps when pushing a cart around the grocery store, so I figure it sort of evens out!

  • @lozovic
    @lozovic Год назад +13

    Best and only fitness tracker channel worth watching... in my humble opinion

  • @elirhm5926
    @elirhm5926 9 месяцев назад

    Thanks man! You saved a lot of my time❤

  • @mfahlers
    @mfahlers Месяц назад

    To produce the best of any product is an amazing feat. Your videos are the best in this area.

  • @Deepslumber.
    @Deepslumber. Год назад

    Thank you! Was looking forward to your review and it's almost what I expected it to be. I only wish I could use an apple watch on android, or find a similar alternative. Keep up the good work!

  • @felipecirne
    @felipecirne Год назад +3

    Thanks for the reviews

  • @genkishan
    @genkishan Год назад

    Dankjewel Rob

  • @SizoRaZ
    @SizoRaZ Год назад +1

    Thank you for doing these informative videos!
    Are you planning on doing a review of the new polar ignite 3 watch?

  • @MrHawkshadow
    @MrHawkshadow Год назад

    Great video definitely subbing

  • @CrasyFingers
    @CrasyFingers Год назад +3

    omg my watch finally thanks!

  • @billphister
    @billphister 2 месяца назад

    I've had one of these for about 2 months now, and I absolutely agree with this review. I love the slim, inconspicuous design, and the functionality is all that I wanted, and more. The low price isn't a bad thing, either.

  • @blasebaker
    @blasebaker Год назад

    Thank you!

  • @gsadventures678
    @gsadventures678 Год назад

    All hail Rob! Just bought my Fitbit Inspire 3 today!

    • @vsg9944
      @vsg9944 Год назад

      Same bro. Display is quite awesome

  • @jean-christophe281
    @jean-christophe281 Год назад +5

    Hi !
    Congratulations for your awesome work!!
    What about SPO2 measure of this watch? Do you recommend for this measure?

  • @rosiegb21
    @rosiegb21 Год назад

    Thank you so much for your effort in reviewing a bunch of smartwatches.
    Can you review amazfit gts 4/4 mini? Haven't seen a serious review for these devices. Wanna know if they improve their sleep tracking.
    Thanks.

  • @mehmetaliyurtofficial
    @mehmetaliyurtofficial 6 месяцев назад +2

    I wish I could discover your channel before my purchase, I would definitely go for this Fitbit device. Next time hopefully 😅

  • @user-hi5ir3tt4j
    @user-hi5ir3tt4j Год назад

    thanks for every thing u test
    your video is ver scientific and summarized

  • @zakialbetiyan449
    @zakialbetiyan449 Год назад +1

    Can't wait for the GTR4 review

  • @yusungchoi3099
    @yusungchoi3099 10 месяцев назад

    Dude deserves all the thumbs ups

  • @shoaibaalam8978
    @shoaibaalam8978 Год назад

    I bought my Huawei watch fit 1 after watching your video last year 😊😊. Thank you Rob.

    • @The52Hz
      @The52Hz Год назад +1

      How is your experience with it so far?

  • @danegossett154
    @danegossett154 Год назад

    Ordered this model! Thank you for your videos--love them. Quick question.. what glasses are those. I've been looking for frames like this.

  • @extraordinaryhuman1806
    @extraordinaryhuman1806 Год назад

    best review i have ever seen on youtube

  • @shubhamtaneja4284
    @shubhamtaneja4284 Год назад

    You deserve more views!

  • @valarmorghulis3773
    @valarmorghulis3773 Год назад +2

    WOW! Not some generic azz review and you actually tested things
    you earned a follow and a like my friend❤
    Is there a step tracker you recommend?

  • @michaelhansel5851
    @michaelhansel5851 Год назад

    thanks!!!

  • @Sofian350z
    @Sofian350z Год назад

    Hello, Thanks for this great review. Did you will do the review of the new Polar Ignite 3 ? i want to by this watch but i wait to see a test of you in the future ? Thanks.

  • @forgetmyname5166
    @forgetmyname5166 7 дней назад

    Hi your recommendation are indeed good, thanks

  • @al_x_ander
    @al_x_ander Год назад +2

    Thanks!

  • @callmesenpai9717
    @callmesenpai9717 Год назад +2

    I really like your videos ! Can you please review the GTS4 / GTS4 mini please !

  • @burnoutslo
    @burnoutslo Год назад +1

    Thanks Rob. Please do the new Amazfit series (GTR4/GTS4)

  • @SoutrikDG
    @SoutrikDG 4 месяца назад

    Instantly subscribed. Kind of content I would pay for.
    My Inspire 3 will be ariving today. Not really happy with how bpm tests came out.
    Can you please tell me if I do not carry along my mobile while swimming , will it still track distance and other parameters ?

  • @vassilstanev3867
    @vassilstanev3867 Год назад

    Great video, thank you. Also i really appreciate that you spend time to answer questions in the comments. That's really something. I have a question :) -
    I need a watch, mainly to be able give me a good measure for my Vo2 ma and hearth rate. I am planing to buy and use the chest POLAR H10, so i will have even better hearth rate data and HRV information. I just want an overall good watch with accurate Vo2 Max. So now i am currently looking for Garmin forerunner 55( now on sale in my country), forerunner 245( even tho i think is not an good option), and maybe something else in this budget range.( I am considering venu 2, but it is a lot of money). I woul really appreciate if you answer me and give me some help. :)
    It's absolutely okay if there is Huawei, or other good watch which will do the work. :)

  • @Juanjo191
    @Juanjo191 Год назад +32

    Amazing video as always. I just bought my Inspire 3 a week ago and I am super happy with its performance. I can’t put it in numbers like the video, but I believe that the heart rate monitor is accurate enough for spinning and doing some exercise at home. I do believe that i counts more steps, but overall I’m happy with the performance. The app shows a lot of information (even without the premium subscription) and I find it very helpful as a health tracker over all

    • @TheQuantifiedScientist
      @TheQuantifiedScientist  Год назад +3

      Happy to help!😊

    • @solodolo6018
      @solodolo6018 Год назад

      I have it and it definitely counts extra step. I can swing my arm back and forth and it will count this as steps.

    • @televizorfan-pz1yq
      @televizorfan-pz1yq Год назад

      May I ask which version of Android you are using?
      (My favorite device runs 8.1, so the app can be installed but not updated. So I wonder about compatibility...)

    • @HarshDivecha_FTR
      @HarshDivecha_FTR Год назад

      @@TheQuantifiedScientist Which one would you recommend for sleep ? inspire or charge ?

  • @Visqo1
    @Visqo1 Месяц назад

    Great video

  • @suppsuppa2773
    @suppsuppa2773 Год назад +2

    Thanks for your efforts!
    I'll wait for your gtr4 review and then I'll make my decision on my next smartwatch (current one just died from salt water xD )
    Keep up the good work

    • @TheQuantifiedScientist
      @TheQuantifiedScientist  Год назад +3

      Thanks so much! Hi! I collected a lot of data with the GTR4 and GTS4 already, just need to find the time for a video on it😊. Also keep an eye on my shorts channel ;-)

  • @timschulz1084
    @timschulz1084 Год назад +1

    Please do a Review of Polar Ignite 3! Would love to get the accuracy of it, especially on heart rate!

  • @CaptainJonathan
    @CaptainJonathan Год назад +5

    I finally gave in and bought a Versa 4. It's not perfect, but since I won't go Apple, there's not much choice. We'll see how it goes. Thank you for the informative videos!

    • @strider-pubgmobile757
      @strider-pubgmobile757 Год назад

      Throwing your money away

    • @micahjohnson9184
      @micahjohnson9184 Год назад

      Try a Whoop strap! that's what I'm planning to get since it has 12 months free when you first purchase it and rob regards it to be pretty accurate overall for everything. Although if I did get a Fitbit the inspire 3 would be the one. Especially after having the inspire 2 it was great.

    • @micahjohnson9184
      @micahjohnson9184 Год назад

      @@PietriGuitars Yes, like I said the first 12 months are free and after that I can just pay the annual fee to see the data all year long. Rob recommends it for overall health tracking because it gives accurate and reliable data on top of giving great suggestions for improving your health which is intuitive, more so than many health and fitness trackers. Doesn't matter to me as long as the data is accurate my health matters more. If it helps me stay healthier in the long run personally I'm fine with it. It's one of the best recommendations for people that don't have Apple devices or want them and Apple only works with Apple so yeah. At the very least you won't be throwing away that same amount of money on a cheap fitness tracker there are only a few reliable ones out there and they're either really good at one thing and very poor/ mediocre in another. Highly likely they're bad in both the cheaper you get.

  • @andreabui85
    @andreabui85 Год назад

    Hi!! Your channel is very interesting!! Can you test the "Muse S" device for the sleep tracking?

  • @pamppusnegger
    @pamppusnegger Год назад +6

    Polar ignite 3 seems pretty interesing at least for me. Do you have any plans to test it out? Would be interesting how it performs versus Garmin or more traditional watch like pixel.

  • @CrasyFingers
    @CrasyFingers Год назад

    you know if huawei or samsung have more watches coming out soon? i'm debating if i should wait for some new ones to come out or just get a huawei gt3 pro. and when some newer watches are a TINY bit worse than the previous one, like galaxy 4 and 5, is that a lab error or is the galaxy 4 actually more accurate than the 5?

  • @thachly5452
    @thachly5452 10 месяцев назад +1

    What a freaking great job you have done, always, with so smart watches. Man you should get $xM for the time and effort you put into serving humanity.

  • @uttamkalika597
    @uttamkalika597 Год назад +2

    I watched your huawei gt 2 pro video. You promised you will do some further test. Please do

  • @NicksStuff
    @NicksStuff Год назад +10

    I know you wanna test the accuracy of the watches rather than read the datasheets but mentioning some important features would be cool. Like some tracker don't offer a smart alarm: to me that renders the sleep analysis a *lot* less useful. You could even test it: check whether or not it wakes you up when the EEG finds you are in light sleep

  • @WoLF_Rko
    @WoLF_Rko Год назад +1

    Fitbit is great for sleep tracking it is small and comfortable for me than Apple Watch in bed. But this is just my opinion. Apple Watch are overall the best . But I am considering Huawei GT3 pro for day and this Fitbit just for sleep tracking. Thanks for reviews u are doing very good job. Nobody does this deep research about smartwatches/bands.

  • @Djaenk
    @Djaenk Год назад +1

    I think calculating mean squared error for heart rate measurements relative to the polar would be a good metric to show. It can address some of the deficiencies with correlation like you mentioned in this video. I don't think it'd be that hard to retroactively calculate either, assuming you still have the data from previous reviews.

  • @demonslayer3570
    @demonslayer3570 Год назад

    hey the quantified scientist can you make a series of videos doing a comparison of different CGM (Continuous Glucose Monitor) devices accuracy and precision against Accu-Chek® Aviva glucose meter for diabetes patients

  • @iGp0wn3d
    @iGp0wn3d Год назад +2

    I am just interested in a good sleep tracker... Oura and Whoop is to expensive... Then i thought lets go for a one time purchase Fenix 7 or Venu 2 Plus since they have multiple other sports-features i would like to have. However with a fenix I can't sleep anyway.
    May based on those accuracy tests i just buy the fitbit inspire 3 for sleep tracking. Good idea with bang for the bucket?

  • @flowerpixel
    @flowerpixel Год назад

    Hello! I am debating between inspire 3 and a pulse oximeter...are pulse oximeters more accurate/better technology?

  • @gokulananth4370
    @gokulananth4370 Год назад

    Your videos are informative, could you make a video on amazfit trex 2

  • @JuanSanchez-rb4qu
    @JuanSanchez-rb4qu 9 месяцев назад +2

    Great review, tho I don't see the fitbit luxe in the sleep tracking chart, is it better or worse than the inspire at that?

  • @anirudhanpm8596
    @anirudhanpm8596 7 месяцев назад

    Big respect for you my guy counting 4000 steps must have been gruesome😂

  • @royalh1261
    @royalh1261 Год назад

    Hi @quantified scientist, i have ordered the honor band 6 as i got it for just 27$ and I hope it is a good watch at health tracking. What is your opinion?

  • @ArmchairAmbience
    @ArmchairAmbience Год назад +1

    I would love to know about calorie burn accuracy of watches...is this just based on heart monitor accuracy?

    • @loafylemon
      @loafylemon Год назад +1

      If you have a 'smart' scale and use it every day, it can use that to compile very accurate data.

    • @ArmchairAmbience
      @ArmchairAmbience Год назад +1

      @@loafylemon That is awesome and makes a lot of sense...I'll look into it immediately

  • @Ignozi
    @Ignozi Год назад +10

    Hi Rob.
    I had a question regarding the new Inspire 3 and the Charge 5.
    I'm looking for a fitness tracker with a focus on good to decent sleep tracking capability.
    Do you think the new Inspire 3 is in any way better or more accurate than the older Charge 5 when tracking sleep?
    My reasoning is that since the Inspire 3 is newer maybe Fitibit have had more time to work on the sensor and it's a bit "better" than the Charge 5.

  • @Ashes3123
    @Ashes3123 Год назад

    I'm wearing the pixel watch, which uses fitbit analytics for sleep etc... and my experience suggests the sleep tracking is way way off. As I work nights and it literally says I'm sleeping whilst at the desk. You'd think typing away would make a difference to its analytics, but it really doesn't. I have Asian colour skin so don't know if its data is so bad because of that or its that I am working whilst everyone else is asleep.

  • @nicholasbibbs1285
    @nicholasbibbs1285 Год назад

    Will you please do a scientific review of the Amazfit GTR 4? it has a whole new host of sensors

  • @KSMP
    @KSMP 5 месяцев назад +1

    Is the sleep tracking on the 3 an improvement over the 2? That's all I want to use a Fitbit for and if I get the same performance from the 2 I'd rather get it and save a bit of money.

  • @hruthikbala5985
    @hruthikbala5985 Год назад

    Hi Rob! Big fan of ur contents. If u dont mind could you do me a favor? I want you to review on Realme Watch S, because my dad is using it who is a really sick heart patient, he is getting demotivated to see his Heart rate go over 120-130 when he is idle. I told him that the watch cant be so accurate and sometimes it may give the false results too. I want you to make a video review about it so i can prove him how accurate is the watch is. Thanks Rob.

  • @jlaw9793
    @jlaw9793 Год назад +2

    I’m looking for a thinner band type fitness watch that is good at both sleep tracking and heart rate. Does this exist? Every review I watch of yours it is either good at HR tracking or sleep but not both.

  • @Jiraiya06
    @Jiraiya06 Год назад

    Could you review amazfit Gtr 4, we wonder if it has any improvement against old ones

  • @YogaWithGail
    @YogaWithGail Год назад +1

    What would be the best EKG, Afib, detection watch, that is not an apple?

  • @Nixeuss
    @Nixeuss Год назад +3

    Hello, i wonder if it's worth it between this and the Xiaomi Band 7 for sleep.

  • @karlijnvanadrichem
    @karlijnvanadrichem Год назад

    Momenteel gebruik ik de Fitbit inspire 3 voor een onderzoek binnen een ziekenhuis om de REM-slaap te detecteren. Je laat in dit filmpje enkele nachtelijke metingen zien. Echter ben ik ook benieuwd naar de overige nachten. Want meet de fitbit over het algemeen alle REM-slapen, maar niet de hele lengte of slaat de fitbit ook vaak een REM-slaap over die wel wordt gemeten met het EEG? Zijn dit dan voornamelijk REM-slapen van korte duur of ook wel eens van langere duur? Zouden de afbeeldingen van de andere nachten gedeeld kunnen worden?

  • @patrickkerns2022
    @patrickkerns2022 Год назад

    it appears that the luxe is a bit better for heart monitoring but maybe not that much ?i like the inspire 3 but i think the luxe is a little better i would like to compare the 2.. thanks

  • @rohanraghavan9431
    @rohanraghavan9431 15 дней назад

    Love the methods and data analysis.. Just one thing that I wanted to check. I own a scan watch 2 and was getting poor readings before I reread the instructions where they require you to fasten it higher up in the forearm rather than your wrist. I've I did that readings were much better. Might be worth retesting and ranking of this was not accounted for. Will be good to know either way.

    • @rohanraghavan9431
      @rohanraghavan9431 15 дней назад

      Oh and this video helped me decide! I just bought an inspire3 for the mrs. who just needs the basics.

  • @nailbomb3
    @nailbomb3 Год назад

    Is there any way to display Fitbits nightime oxygen data ? All they show is " estimated variation" in the app. But I know the watches collecting the actual data

  • @chisti556
    @chisti556 Год назад

    Mate, do a review for the aura strap 2 please

  • @oppi263
    @oppi263 Год назад +1

    pls review mz switch watch they say its 95% accuracy in ecg and heart rate tracking, 99,4% if wear belt.

  • @dataskull928
    @dataskull928 Год назад

    Sir can u pls advice which fitness device is most durable n long lasting ....I heard fitbit last less 2 years in most cases

  • @a6m41
    @a6m41 9 месяцев назад

    Hi, i watched your review on the Mi Band 7 and Inspire 3, your step counting you rated a 4.5/5 on the Mi Band 7 but not rating on this one could you tell me which is the most accurate in terms of steps? thanks

  • @ignacypasikonik4163
    @ignacypasikonik4163 Год назад

    This one or Withings Sleep Analyzer? Which should I get if I'm only interested in sleep tracking?

  • @pedroleal8543
    @pedroleal8543 Год назад +2

    Hello Rob, how are you? Just for sleep tracking (and maybe step counting), what you would chose between Inspire 3 and Charge 5? The price difference isn't problematic, just want the more accurate between both parameters. For HR tracking I will be using H10, so the Fitbit device will only be for those 2 things.

  • @AbhineetSinha25
    @AbhineetSinha25 Год назад

    Can you also compare CGMs and their app readings?

  • @TheQciap
    @TheQciap 4 месяца назад +1

    Sir (as a show of my respect) - is there a chance to see your charts where you compare all the devices together per category: HRV, et?
    Would be good for user then to pick proper model with right price/value ratio.
    Thanks in advance
    Cheers

  • @khelgarironfist3301
    @khelgarironfist3301 Год назад

    Oi, can you recommend a tracker for football that won't break the bank? Is Fitbit Charge 5 accurate? Only these 3 points matter to me:
    1. Total distance
    2. Top and average speed (i guess gps is a must here for accuracy, but how accurate are they even with gps? wouldn't like to be a fake Usain Bolt you know)
    3. HR/VO2max would be good as well

  • @lewislebentz9418
    @lewislebentz9418 Год назад

    Would you recommend this over the Mi Band 7?

  • @Tsinepanos
    @Tsinepanos 6 месяцев назад +1

    Maybe make an global google sheets Excel with all the watches with ranking and category ?

  • @danishamjad5807
    @danishamjad5807 11 месяцев назад

    Does it have the smart alarm like in the Sleep Cycle App in Apple Watch?

  • @TristanPope
    @TristanPope Год назад

    You will have to excuse me but you may had skipped over the part that you said in the beginning of "why you may not want to buy one at all" unless that was part of the conclusion of it is just mediocre in GPS and HR?

  • @proscott33
    @proscott33 6 месяцев назад

    The main features of the inspire 3 over the apple watch is... "THE PRICE!!" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 not the nap feature! 🤣🤣 Great video and channel! i give it 4.75 out 5 stars! 😉😉

  • @KoenDeJaeger
    @KoenDeJaeger Год назад

    Could you test 'sleep as android' app once in combination with a mi band 6 or 7? I wonder how good the sleep cycle detection is in this app ... .