Which BACK SCABBARD style is best? with Nate V
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 янв 2023
- Comparing different types of back scabbard systems with Nate V: / @natev7193
If you like the content and want to support the channel, you're welcome to do so through Utreon, Subscribe Star or Patreon:
utreon.com/c/shadiversity
www.subscribestar.com/shadive...
/ shadbrooks
Come check out my other channels!
THE SHADLANDS: / @theshadlands1142
KNIGHTS WATCH: / knightswatch
Subscribe to my website so you don't miss an upload: www.shadmbrooks.com/
Follow me on Facebook: / shadiversity
Follow me on twitter: / shadmbrooks
My novel, Shadow of the Conqueror Audio Book affiliate links:
US: www.audible.com/shadbrooks
UK: www.audible.co.uk/shadbrooks
CA: www.audible.ca/shadbrooks
AU: www.audible.com.au/shadbrooks
Ebook, Paperback and Hardcover available from most major book retailers, here are a few of the main ones:
Amazon affiliate link (be sure to navigate to your country's amazon site):
amzn.to/2XErUaR
Barnes and Noble:
www.barnesandnoble.com/w/shad...
Kobo:
www.kobo.com/au/en/ebook/shad...
Awesome Shirts and chainmail print clothing: teespring.com/en-GB/stores/sh...
Visit Calimacil for the best replica foam swords and LARP weapons: calimacil.com?aff=38
Buy my sword IMPERIOUS from Calimacil: calimacil.com/products/imperi...
Community run discord server: / discord
#functionalfandom
#medievalcombatreference
This medieval fair was a great example why the backscabbard is perfect for certain situations. Just before you walked in the gate I had gotten rid of my sword - because walking through crowds with a sword on your belt can become a real hindrance as the crowds build up, and keeping it secure when it's on your back is super easy - possibly even more secure than it is on your waist.
Backscabbards aside though, it was great to finally meet up face to face - hopefully we can find the time to catch up again near future!
Can't wait! Until then stay awesome man
Great seeing you around, miss your content. I thought it was interesting when it was mentioned that the garb was crusades themed, as my initial thought on seeing it was the headdress had an middle east look to it. Any thoughts of putting up your re-enactment group activities on the channel?
@Nate V I just mention it because you said I can pick on you (German reenactor here who is once a year in Israel for the reenactment of the battle of hattin) . the leather bracers aren't authentic. Your trousers are not either, the legs should be separated and way tighter. In addition the coat de arms should go till the middle of your lower leg at least, but it looks self made, so continue with that :) . The Gambeson also should be way longer and - I tried it, trust me - not be black. I got a heatstroke because of that after only a 15 km walk in Israel ( still finished the other 10 km though). your headwear is very nice ! The shoos look way to overload and not turn sewn. Wooden pattens would be a great addition.
hi Nate. why did the content stop? hope to see some again.
This _really_ pisses me off. For years, I've been using, and suggesting, the exact same technique - Yet every time I would mention it on some video where some "expert" was insisting that you literally can't draw a sword from a back-scabbard (Invariably by trying to draw a longsword from their right shoulder with their right hand), virtually everyone in the comments would dogpile me insisting I was an idiot or a fraud. Seriously, the amount of abuse I've sat through on the subject, and the actual blatant *_anger_* of the people hurling it would astonish you. So, really, where have you been for the last 10 years when I needed something to refer these people to? I'm going to hold you personally responsible for your absence...
I love these videos where shad is talking to another enthusiast. You can see the inner child like excitement start to come out.
Shad + Other people is always an interesting combo
@@NerfThisBoardGames I think people like Nate and Rosalie are good at drawing out the better of Shad, and he's good at asking the right questions in balance with providing his own opinions.
Just wondering… could you back draw a zweihander by the ricasso?
Two sword enthusiasts talking about the back scabbard and how it can be useful and I was thinking that these 2 should make a short fantasy film together and that would be awesome.
Fantasy or historic fiction! I'd be good with either if these guys were behind it!
@@xendordawnburst9969 YES SIR!!!!!
It should be Death Proof style. Like there's some assassin who kills warriors by stealing the sword off their belt or something. But then in Act 2 shad comes along and he is befuddled 🤣
♥
Shadrik: "Quick Chadrik! Help me vanquish the peril! Use the new improved back scabbard I gave you!"
Chadrick: "Yeah, alright."
I would watch the hell outta that.
Shad, the Lad, and Nate, the Mate just being bros.
It's just adorable to see two enthusiasts geeking out about a shared passion 😆
Andrzej Sapkowski mentions basically Nate V tecnique in his novels. Pulling the belt forward and drawing the sword.
Is that in the Witcher novels?
@@chrispaton3489 i don't know if he wrote other novels to which they're referring to, but yes, Andrzej Sapkowski did indeed write the witcher books
@@MysticCat21 He wrote Hussite Trilogy too, some say it's even better than Witcher. All 3 books are available in English.
@@chrispaton3489 Yup, in "A grain of truth" he shows of that trick to Nivelen, who was about to kick him of his property.
@@chrispaton3489 Yes it is.
Geralt of Rivia is a character who typically wears his sword across his back. In the books, it is described the very same way as Nate's technique of pulling the belt and adjusting the sheath.
"The witcher's right hand rose, as fast as lightning, above his shoulder while his left jerked the belt across his chest making the sword hilt jump into his palm." The Last Wish (A Grain of Truth) by Andrzej Sapkowski
Dude's sword draw is like a "top down" version of a Kendo iajutsu! kinda cool!
♥
Just happened upon this channel. As reinactor myself I really appritiate what I've found. Having seen many duals the back scabbard does seem to be very functional.
I wish I could do medieval re-enactments, but I'm Canadian without a major city in my county, so there's no armored combat groups like you'd see in Europe or Australia
Watching two enthusiasts chatting like this is great. Also, glad to see Nate V again.
2 Geeks just geeking out about some amazing topics! And thanks VosperCDN - had to take a bit of an extended break, but it's good to pop back in every now and again for things like this while I'm getting everything else in order.
When I saw Nate’s original video, I figured a single edged sword could probably avoid the throat cutting problem, like a Katana or Messer.
A leather band around the neck would do the trick.
These interactions are great and that medieval fair looks like loads of fun! Hope the graphic novel production is going relatively smoothly and excited to read it!
I think it's obvious; the best back scabbard is one that simply holds the sword while the sword itself is completely wrapped up in a long cloth ribbon attached to the bottom of the grip. Especially if that sword is a gigantic single-edged sword that can be compressed down into a reasonably-sized sword by yelling, "Bankai!"
These festival videos are spectacular. Thanks Shad!
For as cool as it is looks, his sword draw right next to his neck gives me chills every time :/
Easy to solve though.
Might not be a problem if you wear a gorget.
Maybe one of those stylish pauldrons with a wing or something, to protect the neck & get that asymmetrical look
It would be great for a single edged sword.
The simple sling of Nate I see more of adventurer starting out, a scout for armies, or spies. Simple and keeping everything to a minimum.
Shad’s sheath I can see as more of a experienced adventurer, Berserker that’s not afraid of taking a strike to strike down harder, or Noble’s wanting to show off their wealth with the scabbard on their back being extremely ornate like the guard, grip, pommel, and blade itself.
I still prefer Shadow of Mordor’s hollowed out center sheath going for about a third the length of the blade. Though I know that would be difficult to clean of mud far more than Shad’s because of the stiff edges meant to hold the blade better.
That state of wealth is also reflected in their armours, or lack thereof. Nate is like the new guy ready for their first adventure, Shad is the one who came back with the loot and invested it in gear.
the only major issue with the SoM scabbard is that the sword is not completely protected, with the third of the length of the blade still exposed to the elements. water could seep in, rust could form, and the sword wouldn't be able to stay in a properly maintained, oiled state for the entirety of the blade. it's practical for other purposes though, especially for quick deployment i think.
@@artezui indeed. It would require more maintenance than a normal scabbard. But it would also keep your sword out of waist deep waters your crossing at the cost of being more exposed to rain. But having to crawl around it would also keep it out of the dirt, but you’d have to be aware of the hilt to make sure it doesn’t catch on anything overhead in tight places.
Just a comment for the algorithm
I am engaging with your comment.
Comment engagement for the algorithm.
Praise the algorithm, may it bless this video
May this comment become a continuation of the engagement of the comment for the algorithm.
Is the suggested comment for the algorithm on YT mobile
I really likes nates design. It uses the body alot which helps with the drawing. Mechanically sound.
♥
Wow actually caught the drop on this vid. Thanks for the cool vids, Shad!
One point I would add is sense of style. While many things are done for efficacy of use, but many more things were made out of style (male endowed armor). I would consider Shad’s back scabbard is more stylish and awe inspiring. Nate’s is far simpler and at times easier but isn’t as dramatic.
I respect Shad's creativity, but visually, it's a no for me.
Any excuse to have Nate back on the channel would be a good one in my opinion. What a swell guy
♥
Always fun to see two passionate people dicuss a topic
Always satisfying to watch a conversation between two pashionate people, even if you yourself are very far from their topic, it is still intoxicating, thanks, mates)
♥
It just occurred to me that modern mentalities around carrying guns were probably similar to what ancient people thought about carrying their weapons.
For modern guns, either conceal or open carrying handguns, or soldiers carrying rifles in combat situations, the purpose is self defense and quick response. In life threatening situations, seconds matter. For that purpose, a gun must be easy to draw, in a safe position, and ready to use, as quickly as possible. That means handguns are usually kept around the waist in a holster, woth a round in the chamber. In combat situations, soldiers keep rifles slung forward (administrative carry, quicker to get to a ready position than slung over the back), or carry them with the muzzle down. In less life threatening situations, like hunting and moving from place to place, rifles are slung over the back for comfort.
Why wouldn't ancient peoples think the same way? This would explain why ancient soldiers would more likely keep swords slung to their side, rather than to their back, in a scabard, if possible. It makes the weapons easier to get to, quicker to draw, quicker to get to a ready state, in a safe position, for the purpose of defending themselves. As much as back scabards are cool, they're less efficient for personal defense than carrying at the waistline, and as such, back scabards would be more common for less life threatening situations and for travelling.
Lovely nerdy episode, I can feel the passion through my screen!
I'm looking back at old videos because of missing Nate.... AND I CAN'T BELIEVE I FOUND WHEN SHAD MET HIM.
I just noticed how nice Shad's tunic looks.
Nate, from what I’ve heard, something that could help your kit is to have your belt at your natural waist, where a cuirass would end, rather than at your hips.
Little did they know how much they would be seeing each other in the future
When I'd go hiking to go practice in the woods I'd tie my sword to my bag so I could drop the bag and draw at the same time.
Skall did a video on this exact technique! - Just search for "Best Way for Adventurers to Carry a Sword on the Back?"
Absolutely stunning video as always. Since it is Disney 100 could you make an updated video of the Disney intro castle? The new Disney100 opening shows it from the side and gives more angles. I hope you can remake your digital model and showcase the difference. Thank you so much for all your videos. I came from Jazza but saw your Harry potter and Disney accuracy videos and fell in love with the channel.
Everybody hates Disney.
Does this mean you can hold 3 swords efficiently? Three sword style time.
You Gotta Pump Those Numbers Up, Those Are Rookie Numbers!!! 😂
One reason I believe in back scabbards, at least partly, is because of a mention of one being worn by a Chinese emperor in a story. The story revolved around an assassin trying to kill him, and the emperor was struggling to remove the sword from his back in the heat of the moment while hiding behind pillars.
I made the Back Shabbard for my Calimacil Highlander ||| and it works wonderfully
I'm getting the Doppelsoldner AND IT'S 6 FEET LONG!!! I can't wait to make one for it cause it's such an amazing design, plus it LOOKS SO COOL!
The draw BACKS! Haha I caught that
😉
I've been waiting very anxiously for the video to eventually come. Great to see it! 👍🏻👍🏻
I would like to see this tested with the Kriegsmesser. The curved blade would facilitate an easier draw and no worries on neck cut.
Little did Shad know, not far in the future, Nate would have more screen time in some of his videos than he did.
Sympathetic Dudes talking about Back scabbards is a wholesome content I never knew I need.
And I can't even carry my sword on my back because its nearly as long as I am XD
I have decided that my main fantasy character will have both of these back scabbard designs
For the algorithm and Shad.
Babe, wake up, new Shadiversity video just dropped.
I will say... To keep the peasentry under the radar. The best back scabbard is the one with the poor seem work and maybe a pint or 5 of ale in the peasentry to keep them in the peak fighting state.
Love your work. I also had a video idea that came to my head. What would be the best scabbard placement for a creature that used swords but had twice the length in their arms (with matching flexibility throughout the arm for fun) or maybe a scabbard for a person lacking an arm. Since you do have the limited range of motion for combat. But war never said it had to be clean. Is there any stories about soldiers rising above that infliction to tell their stories? (Doubt it considering... But it's something I'm sure you'd find fun ways to play with it.)
I am so glad to see you and Nate working together. He is an excellent addition to the crew.
Just two dudes whipping out their swords for comparison.
The best back scabbard, would be one turned upside down with a system to keep the sword in place, that can easily release the blade.
Very informative conversation, love it.
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎁
glad you brought up the distribution of weight when a long heavier sword is on your back. it doesn't cause as many problems if a sword like that is on your side.
If the scabbard you wear while on horseback counts as a back scabbard, I think we have a winner.
Cool meet-up, and For The Algorithm!
Thanks for this.
The Back Scabbard Society
It's funny watching this now, because RUclips never gave me this video to watch until now, and since then obviously Nate has been much more prominent on the channel. Cool video though! Had no idea about the foam haha
Loving seeing more on drawing from the back and i like how nate's style seems to be an evolotion of something that was down in the past as well.
Shad still seems to have the market on the big swords cornered but that other technique looked very achiveable and slick and probally was why most people never went to a full scabard because it was the low cost alternative.
I have even could see a variation in armour either on the neck of the chest piece or the helmet for something like a slightly sturdier/cut resistant panel yo allow you to draw with less risk to your own throat.
And i must admit that brigadine piece is still thoughly amazing i had an inclin it might have been that piece not because i could tell from the piece itself but i noticed the very shad based set up and the trousers were quite the clue that you were set up for comfort and i know you mentioned that was an area the foam pieces exceled at...but it only genrated an inclin that it might be that and was cool to see someone who is an also very into sowrds and armour not notice the difference as well a great live test caught on camera.
this was great content. i loved it so much. still learned some good stuff as well
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎁
I love this conversation so much, and I'd love to see the videos that were mentioned about throwing back scabbards
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎊
can we just take a moment to appreciate....THOSE FLIPPIN PAULDRONS, MAN
THOSE LOOK EXCEPTIONAL, really pairs well with the Brigadine
Nate V’s design is far more practical and simple. Think it’s more likely to have been done than Shad’s design. It’s limitation can easily be mitigated with a single edged sword. Also sheathing two swords on the back seems more practical with this design.
TY♥, it's just the 'use what you have on hand' version!
@@NateV-SwordSavvy a simpler solution is usually better than a complicated one.
This whole video felt like a fantasy cutscene haha.
For REAL long swords, you also have the "two points sling scabbard". You carry it on your shoulder, you take it off the shoulder to draw (it's actually quite fast to do).
You should experiment with the strapping with a regular scabbard or sheath. Maybe mimick the various slings used for firearms, using buckles and fasteners commonly used during the medieval period. You've already hit on strapping for your custom scabbard, I would think that the strapping would be cheaper to customize than the scabbard, and maybe some people might have gone that route, if they did sling it behind them.
Maybe the lack of artwork is because explorers used it mostly, and few artists followed them to see it? I wonder though, it is odd. You'd think more than a few would recognize the benefits for certain situations.
I don’t know if anyone has said it yet, but the way that he pulls on the belt and draws is exactly how it’s described in the first Witcher short stories.
Is it really? That's a cool detail then
The videos coming out of that event are awesome. It feels even more educational.
Please review A Knight's Tale...erm, I mean, yeah Review A Knight's Tale, or else...😁
when i did saxon reenactment, my sword was quote short, something like 2 ft something, the scabbard had an over shoulder baldric attached, i foind that i could wear the sword at the nape of the neck , draw it from back easily, a small leather thing attached bottom to belt where the tip ended, and could be worn with cloak and was hidden, even surprised someone when i dropped bow as they charegd in and drew sword which they didnt realise i had. Im surprised Shad doesnt like using quivers on the back, he always side wears quovers, if he uses a shorter bow and shorter drawlength, and shorter arrows, very easy to draw from back, and fast.
What a crossover!
When Shad and other RUclipsrs were debating back scabbards and were they usable, I said stop tying it to your waist belt, I never had the materials to test it but clearly that was the answer.
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎊
The return of Shabbard
Some great comparisons here. I actually do Star Wars cosplay as an armored Sith with a lightsaber blade kept tucked under my belt when not in use during conventions. I've found many of the same problems with belt hanging in crowded places, so I might actually try a shoulder hanging sheath for my next one.
I never thought about a back sheath, I think the flexible nature really benefits it
Shad should get into medieval firearms, as well.
Such a nice place! I’ll have to give Nate a check and all, but I do have to say I’d go with the classic Shabbard.
Kryal Castle is awesome - if you're even in Victoria Australia I highly recommend checking it out!
I done my back scabbard draw with a landsknecht kriegsmesser like Nate and it works fantastic.
Contact me for your reward 🥳
I don't have the book - Bronze Age Warfare by Osgood et al - to hand but I recall that scabbards on baldrics were common in the Bronze Age.
Guiding the sword in with the other hand is exactly how Geralt does it in Witcher 3
And don't worry about the outfit being a bit anachronistic. It's sort of a fantasised version of wearing grandfathers pants with the new state of the art armor
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎊
I'd love to see a short video of the baldric hanging method as referenced in the period art..
Both of your back scabbards look kewwl. 😄
6:10 US military: "Modular you say..."
Sad I missed the mediaeval reenactment, was awesome seeing when I was there a few years ago. Interesting conversation, have you looked into scabbard the main character used in the shadow of Mordor? I have always liked that concept.
This stuff hella dapper
Dig it!😊
I have leather straps for a backscabbard that is very uncomfortable since it is a 2 piece like Nate's. Without an extra strap that goes under your other arm, that style isn't comfortable and it SLIDES a ton and rides the neck. A 3 piece strap for a backscabbard is nice. Separately to what Shad is saying around 9:25, Baldrics a GREAT for weight balance, stability, and easy movement. Separate note, Faires and cosplay w/ large weapons is just inherently difficult.
I may have to actually practice that out of curiosity!
Seeing the two back scabbards the obvious difference is in capacity which can beg the question "which sword would you want in a fight?"
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁
3:03 "as you know, half of a swordfight is your footwork"
this... sounds like something that someone could use so a sword wielder protagonist can teach dancing/dance with the princess love interest
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁
I prefer the shabbard. :) Looks far more convenient to wear.
Nice video. 😊
Yup
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎁
FINALLY! SHABBARD'S DANTE NOW FIND IT'S VIRGIL!
Would love to see you try to get both working on the same person at the same time, for smaller and larger sword options for adventurer.
0:58
The *drawbacks* huh? Don't think I didn't notice that pun!
😉
This is more like: "Which is bigger yours or mine?"
What if it’s not about the size but how you use it? 🧐
@@alasdaircook3030 Naaaah
You two should have a sword duel
For me, I prefer essentially the most famous way: a sealed scabbard with the hilt above the drawing arm. I just use a blade that is just short enough to draw with (I am able to draw about 30"). My preferred suspension method would be a simple baldric that attaches at two points on the scabbard and has a side strap to keep the scabbard steady (think of a back quiver).
I have been practicing drawing and sheathing with that position for years and, while not as fast as the side method, am pretty quick. I am also able to wear a diagonally-strapped backpack alongside my sword (I wear both of them when at conventions where I dress as a kitsune in black).
Shows that as with many things, practice is what makes a good swordfighter.
Shad demonstrates that putting the sword back into his scabbard takes a bit longer. But if you put your weapon away, it means there isn't any danger anymore and you have the time. The draw on the other hand is rather quick, and that is the point where the scabbard needs to be fast.
I usually carry a short cutlass and I've found that I could draw equally as fast with either hand no matter which side it hangs. The only drawback is that when it's on the same draw hand, it sometimes catches right at the tip
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎊
My personal draw is from the back, but I draw it from a sheath inside my tunic along my spine. It sounds weird, but it works for me and my sword.
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁
New video, Hello Shad
Had no clue they're Australian up until the moment Nate said their reenactment group is kind of close to "Melbin"
OMG we actually sound like that too!!! 😅
Do a back scabbard using electro magnets. You can have a release mechanism in the gauntlet that deactivates the magnets when it connects to the hilt.
Not sure how well that would fly in most fantasy settings. _Science_ fantasy on the other hand it would be right at home in. I remember Blake from RWBY actually just wears a magnet on her back that her scabbard is attached to.
Shad actually did some tests with magnets. The results were; while it does work to a degree the magnet would have to be rediculously strong to resist the forces of movement. Espsically twisting forces.
ruclips.net/video/kAoLHHgWKTA/видео.html
The opposite side draw is actually very cool
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎁🎊
I just had a random wild idea.
I've been enjoying various isekai fiction books recently, and while watching this suddenly (and completely randomly) wondered what would happen if Daylen from Shadow of the Conqueror didn't fall back into that world at the start but instead into another world.
Contact me for your reward 🥳🎊🎁