I started watching your review... stopped right after 7 minutes... went to Netflix... watched the magnificent and beautifully made documentary, wiped off my tears, came back to your review... n here i m posting a comment about it 🤔😀
you might have missed it in the documentary of elephant whisperers but the old man says that he only prefers taking care of baby elephants and not adults. which is why he got the call from the authorities to send away the first elephant and then he was assigned with a new baby elephant in its place
this answers my doubt! I was wondering why would authorities take raghu away from them. But yes i remember Bamman saying that he was once attacked by big tusker hence he prefers to work with young ones.
It is clear ram charan and NTR are not performing at oscar. Dont make a heck out of it. Mm keeravani said in a variety interview it will be group of LA dancers. Watch chandrbose and mm keeravani interview with variety after Oscar luncheon. Ram charan has gone to LA to attend HCA critics awards where RRR is nominated
Dear Korbin, I totally agree with you. At Oscars, the documentaries category is seen as THE MOST COMPETITIVE category simply because this category encompasses the best of the world we live in. Even the maker of "All That Breathes" - Shaunak Sen admitted to this in one of his interviews. We can just be humble that this one is there for the world to see.
This is a long time recommendation from me... 1.sangeetha jathi mullai spb live concert 2. Hello mr. Kadhala.. Prabu deva song from the movie naam iruvar namaku iruvar 3.karu karu karuppayi prabu deve song
Dont be proud kid , the whole film abandoned the poor people , without any basic acting payment and even the poor spend their own money to the film and didn't even give their rewards
I haven't seen either of the documentaries, but it's possible that the Vet didn't take in meat meaning animals because 1. To keep a meat-eating animal, you need to serve it meat and if the caretaker is a vegetarian is problematic. 2. Kites are naturally aggressive and may kill other animals/birds in their care. They would need the proper facilities to handle it.
I am pretty sure that was an exaggerated lie that was manipulatively placed in the documentary. I am surprised that he dint take the bird to a different VET.
The interesting thing here is, most of the animal carers and those who has domesticated animals as their household are the bahujan, working class people. To put it in other words, the people who were subjected to caste discrimination by upper caste hindus are the empathetic people who give everything to the animals they care like they shown in the Elephant whisperers. The vegetarian hindus you were referring to, are the one's who refrain from eating meat and probably even moral shame people who do, but mostly would be associated with a family ran meat export business.
elephant whispers is good but all that breathes was one of the greatest documentary i have ever seen. the documentary showed honest and truthful nature of people and struggles of muslims. i can guarantee that this kind of vegetarian animals thing will mostly happen north india and i am not degrading north india but i am being realistic from my experience once i taken my dog to veterinarian in Delhi, he refused to treat my dog because he said muslims will give meat or non-veg to their dogs. i was astonished and shocked. i know they hate muslims but that day i came to know that they even hate muslim people's pets too. god's grace i came back to south india and state called TAMIL NADU. i never witness one Islamophobic people in tamilnadu. thanks for watching this documentary. #korbin
With respect to All That Breathes, I thought that the documentary was entirely staged and that is not something that you want in a documentary. If you know the nuances of the language you might start doubting if the director asked the "leads" of the documentary to speak some "philosophies" that will make an impact on the audience. All That Breathes could have easily been a short but they just dragged it to a feature documentary. The filmmaking was just dubious and manipulative. I was immediately reminded of the Adam Driver character from the Noah Baumbach movie "While we're young"
Absolutely agree for me film feels like a propaganda more in terms of brothers being shown as phillosphers anti muslim naarrative of india to sell it to West.
First 🥇 pin my comentt
Congrats
Thanks buddy❤️
🎖️
Congratulations 😄
Quietly a Tamil documentary is gearing up to win Oscars in a highly coveted field. Salute to Elephant Whisperer
and Today it Wins the Oscar Award.
S
So you have to make a point that it's Tamil and not Indian
@@Sanatansister5623 it indeed is officially Tamil documentary
I started watching your review... stopped right after 7 minutes... went to Netflix... watched the magnificent and beautifully made documentary, wiped off my tears, came back to your review... n here i m posting a comment about it 🤔😀
ruclips.net/video/knLEYaewJo8/видео.htmlsi=pOYkc8F5j_2g_P3B
Congratulations to Indian Short Documentary-"The Elephant Whisperers" for winning Academy Award/Oscar.
Raghu is a celebrity now ..and people r flocking at the camp to see him ❤❤❤❤(Theppakaadu Elephant Camp)
I missed Raghu, when they were taking him away. I like to know more where is he!
you might have missed it in the documentary of elephant whisperers but the old man says that he only prefers taking care of baby elephants and not adults. which is why he got the call from the authorities to send away the first elephant and then he was assigned with a new baby elephant in its place
this answers my doubt! I was wondering why would authorities take raghu away from them. But yes i remember Bamman saying that he was once attacked by big tusker hence he prefers to work with young ones.
The Elephant whisperers is all ♥️
Those monkeys looked like they were told to provide exposition! 🤣
kudos to the people who watched it before winning oscars like me
It is clear ram charan and NTR are not performing at oscar. Dont make a heck out of it. Mm keeravani said in a variety interview it will be group of LA dancers. Watch chandrbose and mm keeravani interview with variety after Oscar luncheon. Ram charan has gone to LA to attend HCA critics awards where RRR is nominated
Oh no it will be that stupid Nakul’s troupe who’s made a caricature of “Bollywood dancing”
@@globalcitizenn who is nakul. I think there are many southa Asian dance groups in LA. They can hire anybody
@@globalcitizenn that is a big fear for embarrassment 😬😬😬
Group should be like India's kings
Thanks for the wonderful review of the Elephant Whisperer . Amazing documentary
Dear Korbin,
I totally agree with you.
At Oscars, the documentaries category is seen as THE MOST COMPETITIVE category simply because this category encompasses the best of the world we live in.
Even the maker of "All That Breathes" - Shaunak Sen admitted to this in one of his interviews.
We can just be humble that this one is there for the world to see.
I have 2 stray cats in my house that sleeps on my father's bike every night
This is a long time recommendation from me...
1.sangeetha jathi mullai spb live concert
2. Hello mr. Kadhala.. Prabu deva song from the movie naam iruvar namaku iruvar
3.karu karu karuppayi prabu deve song
Woah this year Oscar for Tamil documentary, direction by a malayali and Telugu music composer. ❤ Proud south Indian ❤
Dont be proud kid , the whole film abandoned the poor people , without any basic acting payment and even the poor spend their own money to the film and didn't even give their rewards
I think jr ntr will not perform, as he just had a personal tragedy in his family, these procession itself may take 1-2 weeks.
Neither of them are performing
Tamil movie the elephant whispher congrats Tamil team
Tamilnadu mudhumalai tiger 🐅 reserve 🔥
I haven't seen either of the documentaries, but it's possible that the Vet didn't take in meat meaning animals because
1. To keep a meat-eating animal, you need to serve it meat and if the caretaker is a vegetarian is problematic.
2. Kites are naturally aggressive and may kill other animals/birds in their care. They would need the proper facilities to handle it.
I am pretty sure that was an exaggerated lie that was manipulatively placed in the documentary. I am surprised that he dint take the bird to a different VET.
The interesting thing here is, most of the animal carers and those who has domesticated animals as their household are the bahujan, working class people. To put it in other words, the people who were subjected to caste discrimination by upper caste hindus are the empathetic people who give everything to the animals they care like they shown in the Elephant whisperers. The vegetarian hindus you were referring to, are the one's who refrain from eating meat and probably even moral shame people who do, but mostly would be associated with a family ran meat export business.
So true. Well said .
Hate mongers....
Did you grow up in a Christian mission cut off from reality of India?
Change the tag. Your reviews are Brilliant not Stupid.
elephant whispers is good but all that breathes was one of the greatest documentary i have ever seen. the documentary showed honest and truthful nature of people and struggles of muslims. i can guarantee that this kind of vegetarian animals thing will mostly happen north india and i am not degrading north india but i am being realistic from my experience once i taken my dog to veterinarian in Delhi, he refused to treat my dog because he said muslims will give meat or non-veg to their dogs. i was astonished and shocked. i know they hate muslims but that day i came to know that they even hate muslim people's pets too. god's grace i came back to south india and state called TAMIL NADU. i never witness one Islamophobic people in tamilnadu. thanks for watching this documentary. #korbin
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Your comemnt is so fake bro
Please go to Madurai and ask the hindus about the Muslim areas in Madurai
There is a reason for that fear and phobia, they are constantly threatened by jihadis to leave their homes... Just like kashmir..
Yes, Tamilnadu is good because there is Dravidism which is an anti Hindu model.
Good morning from India ❤️
I guess that is the feeling every American parent has when their child leaves for college! 🥲
2022 YEAR END MEGAMIX - SUSH & YOHAN (BEST 200+ SONGS OF 2022) Give Reaction to the Song.❤️
❤️🇮🇳🙏🌹
With respect to All That Breathes, I thought that the documentary was entirely staged and that is not something that you want in a documentary. If you know the nuances of the language you might start doubting if the director asked the "leads" of the documentary to speak some "philosophies" that will make an impact on the audience. All That Breathes could have easily been a short but they just dragged it to a feature documentary. The filmmaking was just dubious and manipulative. I was immediately reminded of the Adam Driver character from the Noah Baumbach movie "While we're young"
Absolutely agree for me film feels like a propaganda more in terms of brothers being shown as phillosphers anti muslim naarrative of india to sell it to West.
@@sunnnysingh3498 I dont know about that but I felt the film felt artificial and fake
YRF(UCK) 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐
2nd 😊
Oscar is not a World Award, it just merely an American City Award only...Indian National Award is greater than Oscar city Award..
😂😂 the indian awards are a joke. The kashmir files best film 😂😂😂
@@sunnnysingh3498 Ha haha ha.... Thaliban on the spotted...Dirty comment...
@@BharatPadmaTv mirch masala film nepotism awards 🤣🤣. Comparing it to Oscar 😂 what a joke
Oscar is greatest award on earth you fool
If u are talking about national award then I agree