Not going to lie. The original may not graphically stand toe to toe with the Next Gen version. But 0:55 seconds into it I can already say I prefer the originals walking animation. The Next Gen one seems to jagged. Too stiff and robotic. His pace is a second too fast as well. The first one had a more natural gait as he walks.
Yeah it's not supposed to be so fantasy is it, it looks like another monster hunter. Sharp and unnaturally colourful, there's a part in Toussant if that's what you want but it's hard to get back into the majority of the game with this 😒
I tried it thinking it was going to be unnoticeably better than the original, it blew my mind. Almost a whole new feeling of immersion, especially toussaint, mind blowing graphics
I felt underwhelmed. 15% general improvement like: vegetation density, illumination quality, and reflections in water is hard to be named mind blowing upgrade.
@@Lee_Aeon It's definitely more than 15%. The game looked great without the update, sure, but there's a lot too it that definitely is showing it's age. The update makes it look as if came out yesterday.
@@Lee_Aeon colors in original were super oversaturated, sand and especially tousaint were just insane bright, that was fixed in this upgrade. also look at tress/bushes/leafs they look way more realistic
Yeah but the update sucks Edit: they should have removed the map and replace it with Ubisoft like map where, there is only a line above the screen, telling you the only point where you want to go and objectives. Mods still look far better by it. Apart from ray tracing (which doesn't even looks good) all they added were some textures. Only good details i could find was an animation for picking plants.
Well, nah, original definetely had its flaws if you compare it to its earliest trailers. The fire, the WATER especially, and the strong wind during sailing on the ocean, the waves etc. was completely removed. At least, the update fixed the oil like looking water back from the original.
@@izanazir7088 i dont think so. They fix fall dmg (the best change for me), the bridge, add/unlock some little scenes, ....so the update itself is quite nice especialy for a 7 yrs old game and absolutely free. The graphic is nice for ppl who dont use mod and i believe ppl dont use mod on console right ?
@@theskywalker8416 yeah i am on console and the reduced fall damage is pretty great. Now i can do as much parkour as long as i can in Toussaint lol. But as a whole, the hype they created for creating this update made it seemed like a bunch of new textures. They could have just put some community mod for ray tracing atleast. My point being it could have been so much better and if someone says that the game without the update still looks phenomenal just says that the update isn't great enough. Other than that, i am not too happy about the map system.
For me, one of the biggest improvements are the lightning and the antialiasing. The antialiasing in the old version was for me a big downer. So great that their improved that game so much after years, that's when you care about the community.
bro when the game came out in 2015 i thought it was the best looking game ive seen up to that point. 3 years later and it stilll held up . the graphics were ahead of its time for a game of this size. the next gen update truly improves it and low key think its the best game of all time.
@@MGrey-qb5xz What? It's a great upgrade for something free, I'm just saying I always felt the colors are too saturated and could be better. People like you really likes to say everything is bad hm if it was not free, ok, but, man, why are u like this?
@@MGrey-qb5xz I don't think it looked "that good" in a lot of parts. Everything have space for improvements. And they improved some little things, which is see it's good
I'm more drawn to the old versions stylistic approach, the orange colors do a lot for the mood and the water feels better to me etc. It's a cool update though, field day for anyone that values realism more
Dude the performance mode is insane on the ps5 absolutely stunning it’s looks like a whole new game!! Having a blast with it even without the ray tracing mode it looks ridiculous and so smooth!!
@@GAMEDESKY You better read that comment again. He didnt even say anything against your point, so wtf you want from him? Let him enjoy the Ps5 version.
Even without RT, the upgraded 3D models looks details and awesome! The only thing that's still there which they didn't fix since day one is the ground layered texture. The ground looks transparent and you can see the layered which really break the immersion.
I dislike that they removed HBAO which sucks because it is far better than the other options we have. Sucks because for me the game looks worse now and i cant run rtx rn
@@kahnsealable It looks worse if you cant run Ray Tracing. FSR look more blurred and they removed HBAO which added a lot of realism. Sadly they removed this, making the grass etc look worse since there are no shadows on the grass. Hope this helps
@@thehiddenone2875 so because you don't have a rig powerful enough to run RT that makes the game look worse? You are literally making a fuss about ONE setting which doesn't make a big difference because the lighting system is overhauled. You completely ignore all the other upgrades that come from the HD rework mod they used.
@@kahnsealable Those were quite irrelevant to me since i played with the mods CDPR added to this version of the game before they updated it so the game looks worse now because they removed the AA option HBAO+ so for benchmarks rtx will look better in comparison to the normal game. If you dont believe me go look it up on youtube. The 3D Models look without a doubt better but if you dont have proper shadow on grass, barely any reflection it sucks
You know, sometimes old looks better, or at least to me. The orange tones, the moving trees and grass, and even the imperfect all contribute to a sense of nostalgia. And sometimes, things don't need to be so clear or bright because that's what makes them look vintage and thus effectively captures the passage of time.
In my opinion, the water in the original looks a lot more realistic. It's the waves and the splashes. The next gen updates water is too flat and the splashes look more like mist. Other than that though, the update is great.
Weather is mostly better in Next-gen, during storms waves are awesome, in original they were same no matter what's up with weather. Original has better wind effects on foliage and i really miss that "Wind's howling" effect. Splashes are so-so original too generic NG somehow flat. Shallow water much better in original, deep water better in NG. Colors hmmmm, i miss that yellow-redish note from original but ambient occlusion is sooo better
@megitsune714 I have a PS5, XSX, and an Alienware R10 (Ryzen 9 5900x, RTX 3080 10gb, 32gb RAM, 1T SSD). So yeah, I have a lot of games. Like I said, when I get to it. Going to finish a bunch of games before SF6 comes out in June. So now you know something, and you don't have to pretend like the other idiot🖕😏.
@@brando3342 I can understand that, it does lose out on a lot of its original "witcher" vibe without the specific hues of greens and yellows in the environments.
I like that the environment has become more realistic, because of which the outdated character models (especially NPCs) are much more visible. And now it turns out that the characters are knocked out in terms of quality relative to the environment, like damn graphic mods for GTA 4, whatever you do, the age is still visible from the models of NPCs and characters.
I've played the entire game twice with its dlcs, side quests and all (old version)....totally awesome...unfortunately can't do it a third time with the next gen update, just burned out with the open world formula now, thanks Ubisoft.........story based single player games is what I look forward to now.
It's str8 up amazing. I just got my p5 and as much as I love the witcher 3 it's on another level now...Replay replay replay is a must. It's that gorgeous.
in my opinion the effect of the wind on the trees in the next gen looks static while in the old version it looks more realistic moving fast when exposed to the wind, i preefrer still like look old version looks more realistic with the wind effect
Well, the yellow is nice, but overall Velen still looks drab and kindof grayish in a way. That changes when you get closer to Novigrad, the nature around there is differently lit, brighter yellowish. I think the way they used colours in the original is brilliant. Even Novigrad is drab when you compare it to Touissant.
Perhaps the weather is just less windy that day? Didn't it vary in the original too? I also noticed in the video how static everything was, making the old game looking more lively, which is nice.
I remember firing it up on my ps4 back in 2015 on my 720p TV and being blown away. The thing that got me right off was the way the flora moved in the wind. Now I'm playing it for the 4th time on my RX6600xt and my 4k monitor, 4.04 next Gen patch and I'm blown away all over again. One of the greatest games to ever grace us as gamers. Really hope The Witcher 4 can hold up to it, they set a high bar.
I can see a major difference, I also have it set to ultra and it suns smooth, of course your going to have your exception, like major populated areas and lots of animations, but over all it was a great Next-Gen update, and I've only played like 4 hrs of it since it came out, So kudos to CDPR for a great job, I hope the CP 2077 DLC that's coming will be just as good, hers to hopping😁
Can’t really relate with the atmosphere when I played this game in Southeast Asia. Now that I’m currently in north west Europe, can’t believe how immersive the atmosphere’s graphics and soundtrack was done. CDPR is a beast. Just don’t rush them 😅
I actually prefer the warmth of the original to the sharpness of the update. They should have left the orange filter on. It gave the game a more unique look.
Legit didn’t try the game on my ps5 until this upgrade now it’s time to start atleast 2 to 3 more play throughs on what I believe to be the greatest game ever
Sí, no entiendo por qué esa necesidad de que los juegos sean lo más realista posible. Si quiero eso salgo a la calle y ya está. Las cosas fantasiosas y diseño artístico son los elementos que visualmente más atrapan la atención. El viento y las hojas cayendo en ghost of tsunami son exagerados, pero la sensación e impresión que tienes al jugarlo va más allá de el realismo
My god... How much the game improved with RT and new foliage system with improved/upscaled textures... The original looks ecstatic for 2015 title... But now 7 years later with the next gen upgrade... It trumples most of 2020-2022 open world games. I am playing it at RT ultra+ with 3090 and I just can't stop bloody staring at the game. I just don't want to use way teleports and don't want to run to the mission... but rather walk and just stare at the beauty of it all... The only really thing left is to polish some visual anomalities created by RT at some places (with the light leak probably 2 walls not properly joined etc....) and the heavy FPS toll that is unreasonable for what the game produces and is obvious there is severe engine CPU limitiation which needs to be worked on to have better perf overall.
I am playing on an RTX 3080 and do the same with RT Ultra+. I have spend 50 hours in the game and havent even gone past Velen. The only issue is the game needs to better use multiple cores in the CPU. Apart from that, its amazing
@@DeebanFR Aye... 30 hours in and man... I haven't used ONCE teleport... I'm just roaming with roach (using mod that kind of copied RDR2 horse controls) and soaking in all the beauty of the world... And just slaying what needs slayin'. 30 hours and I haven't touched much of actual main quests... Just side quests/contracts and question marks... Really if they properly optimize DX12 version and improve the performance by 15-20% (or more) it would be amazing. Like I am running 50hz with vsync to experience somewhat smooth experience as with 60hz its just constant jerk fest as the game is floating around 50-60 fps. Only other thing I wish I saw updated was the NPC animations... Would have been cool to see more modernized animation and movement... Also utilizing the facial expressions tech that they have implemented in CP77... Overall i'm mad impressed...
@@DeebanFR i5 11400. Got smooth gameplay at 50fps about 90% of the time, where it is sitting above 50fps but in some villages in velen it goes to 47-49fps. While exploring it is 50fps locked flatline. Novi grad will probably slaughter me at 30-35fps as well as oxenfurt.
I've just been playing the next gen mode on PC recently with all RT options on and it's absolutely beautiful. In combination with its art direction it's one of the best looking games I've ever played.
It Improved in some areas. The color palette is def less yellowish but some of the grass is noticeably blurrier as if it has lost definition. The terrain, itself has improved and it's more detailed but in some cases, it seems the trees went from 4K to 2K and there is less variety. You could clearly see the detailed leaves on the trees before the Next-gen update and now they are all some sort of mass of different greens. The next-gen walking is atrocious, it's like The Witcher is losing his walking rhythm every 2 or 3 steps.
Literally *all I could notice* is how awkward and robotic the walking looks in the newer version. It looked SO much more fluid before... no idea how they messed that up IoI
@@finnplotzki4774Nah IoI. Some improvements are really nice, while other changes are noticeable downgrades. The walking animation in next gen looks ESPECIALLY worse.
@finnplotzki4774 I've never owned a console in my life. Never will. All my games are heavily modded. Just my Skyrim has over 2,600 mods and runs always over 60 FPS without even sweating. I always thought that consoles are (in general), for people who can't afford a decent pc.
Seeing this side by side. Getting rid of that orange look makes it feel like some of the original setting got lost in this update. Overall really happy with that update. Especially considering its free. Still love playing this game.
I doubt it, the grass looks much better in the next gen, not even beautifullgrass or meadowns mod with the tweaks in engine.ini come close to the new grass. and I highlight the grass over the rest because it's what we will see the most in the whole adventure, lol.
@@metroplex29 on my taste old grass better, they should've give a choice between old graphic and new, with other changes which i like. But maybe it's too hard to do, i don't know.
@@nikoooo57 the old grass was absolutely horrible 😂 it was just 2 plane meshes with an alpha map applied on top. The new ones are far better. With each individual blade of grass being rendered.
Me too actually. It was nice to do another playthrough on the remaster, but the original is just right.. They even mucked about with the combat system for the remaster, and I frankly don't like those changes at all.
It might just be me, but the added contrast, "difference between bright and dark elements" is just too high on the next gen version, especially on a oled. The old version is much easier on my eyes.
I loved CD Project RED, this game was my favorite. I even bought Game of The Year Edition on PS Store Russia. But you cheated me with a free upgrade to the Next-gen version. Should I re-buy the game in another region??? Now I hate not only CD Project RED, but also the Poles! (Although before that there was great respect for you!) Я любил студию CD Project RED, эта игра была моей любимой. Я даже купил Game of The Year Edition на PS Store Russia. Но вы меня кинули с бесплатным обновлением до Next-gen версии. Я что долэен заново покупать игру в другмо регионе??? Теперь я ненавижу не только CD Project RED , но и поляков! (Хотя до этого было большое уважение к Вам!)
Well, except Toussant ofcourse.. And well, even all the other parts of the game use different colours to have a different kind of look. Not all are suppose to look as grim and dark as Velen, even outside Novigrad things lighten up significantly. Kaer Morhen has more of a cold white tone, and Skellige more of a cold blue tone. This is good use of colours actually, in the original, pretty brilliant actually.
No big differences. I like the colors of the non next gen (not look cold). Trees seems more dark and LOD is better at distance. Wind power have been reduced too. Water has a white foam (additional material change). And i think that's all.
You're missing the added foliage, higher quality textures and mainly the new lighting/reflections and shadows. You can see at 1:44 (on the right side) that instead of it being a blob of shadows meshed together you can see the individual branches and twigs/leaves casting shadows and can make them out their shapes easily. Seems like a decent amount for a free update imo.
@@groogi9649 adding foliage is not a part of a next gen game. But you're right. New one is slightly better. Maybe i should play it on a big screen, cause on my phone it's not clear and i cannot enjoy texture.
@@asdfghjk2933 no. I can see better light/shadows. Maybe some texture are better. But for me the original game was already good, so the new one has not a huge difference. It's my point of view dude. Maybe i should play it on a large screen to enjoy it..
The new version doesn't have HBAO+ which is why objects use shitty SSAO and it looks too flat without RT. They removed it on next-gen version of the game seemingly to make RT shadows look better in a side by side comparison - really disappointed CDPR would do this. Like they should have at least left HBAO+ in DX11 mode where there's no RT anyway....
Is it weird that i like the non next gen version better? I find the next gen is overly bright and blurred to hell, I like the lighting more in the original as well because for some reason almost everything has this glow effect in the next gen version.
Distant detail looks more complex, better atmospheric effects (especially far away haze), improved water reflections, more vegetation rendering up close. But the old version still looks great
Why scale of the interface is changing when you do slide comparison? I can't think of anything else except old gen is in 1080p and new gen is anything higher than that.
Nice one. I love how people complain under other videos, and thinking "next-gen NO RT" is an old game with broken optimization. (thats how they are doing compartion - "next-gen RT off" for them = "OLD GAME" :D ) They set "uber+" and complain they have lower FPS than before... I dont get it, nowadays people are so stupid? They dont understand this game looks totally different than 2015 W3, even without RT?
Only judging from the video, the updated version seems to look better overall, but also looks less sharper than the original... look at Geralt's chainlink armor, or his belt, in the side by side comparisons at ~01:00 The grass is more refined in the new version, but also more blurry... look (even pause) at 01:01 for example. Same goes for the ground or rocky roads... 03:41 or 04:07 for example. At first I thought the new version was played on a console, because of this issue, then I saw the video description, and couldn't believe it's on PC... maybe it's DLSS on a setting less than "quality" and without Sharpening? Doesn't seem to be related to Motion Blur... Graphical settings are not detailed in the description, unfortunately... I have yet to test the update for myself, I will do that in the near future to see what's what... hope my RTX 3090 can run the new version in 4k at an acceptable framerate :D
Not going to lie. The original may not graphically stand toe to toe with the Next Gen version. But 0:55 seconds into it I can already say I prefer the originals walking animation. The Next Gen one seems to jagged. Too stiff and robotic. His pace is a second too fast as well. The first one had a more natural gait as he walks.
yes because your eyes are used to it, so you tolerate it i guess
Wow the game looks much more fantasy like now, so grateful that it isn’t a paid upgrade like many newer games are.
Yeah, and I am posting many videos in my chanel, plis visit me
Yeah it's not supposed to be so fantasy is it, it looks like another monster hunter. Sharp and unnaturally colourful, there's a part in Toussant if that's what you want but it's hard to get back into the majority of the game with this 😒
@@valandil7454 Wtf you smoking my nigga
@@valandil7454 You think it looks MORE fantasy with the update? From what I can tell, almost every aspect of it looks more realistic.
@@valandil7454 a game where u fight monsters shouldn’t be fantasy yup ur so smart
I tried it thinking it was going to be unnoticeably better than the original, it blew my mind. Almost a whole new feeling of immersion, especially toussaint, mind blowing graphics
I felt underwhelmed. 15% general improvement like: vegetation density, illumination quality, and reflections in water is hard to be named mind blowing upgrade.
@@Lee_Aeon It's definitely more than 15%. The game looked great without the update, sure, but there's a lot too it that definitely is showing it's age. The update makes it look as if came out yesterday.
@@Lee_Aeon colors in original were super oversaturated, sand and especially tousaint were just insane bright, that was fixed in this upgrade. also look at tress/bushes/leafs they look way more realistic
@@Lee_Aeon I guess you're blind and didn't noticed that every single texture has been SIGNIFICANTLY improved.
@@HPblu3 there was mod for HD texture no need for this next gen
Tip for everyone, turn the gamma wayyy down and then turn up the TV gamma settings and shadow detail. Game looks insane then
you know it is a great game when even without the update the game still look phenomenal
Yeah but the update sucks
Edit: they should have removed the map and replace it with Ubisoft like map where, there is only a line above the screen, telling you the only point where you want to go and objectives.
Mods still look far better by it. Apart from ray tracing (which doesn't even looks good) all they added were some textures. Only good details i could find was an animation for picking plants.
Well, nah, original definetely had its flaws if you compare it to its earliest trailers. The fire, the WATER especially, and the strong wind during sailing on the ocean, the waves etc. was completely removed. At least, the update fixed the oil like looking water back from the original.
@@spartacuscreator but the water looks worse. previously the waves looked much better and real, now its like stiffened up.
@@izanazir7088 i dont think so. They fix fall dmg (the best change for me), the bridge, add/unlock some little scenes, ....so the update itself is quite nice especialy for a 7 yrs old game and absolutely free. The graphic is nice for ppl who dont use mod and i believe ppl dont use mod on console right ?
@@theskywalker8416 yeah i am on console and the reduced fall damage is pretty great. Now i can do as much parkour as long as i can in Toussaint lol. But as a whole, the hype they created for creating this update made it seemed like a bunch of new textures. They could have just put some community mod for ray tracing atleast. My point being it could have been so much better and if someone says that the game without the update still looks phenomenal just says that the update isn't great enough. Other than that, i am not too happy about the map system.
For me, one of the biggest improvements are the lightning and the antialiasing. The antialiasing in the old version was for me a big downer. So great that their improved that game so much after years, that's when you care about the community.
bro when the game came out in 2015 i thought it was the best looking game ive seen up to that point. 3 years later and it stilll held up . the graphics were ahead of its time for a game of this size. the next gen update truly improves it and low key think its the best game of all time.
@@Damdebase yeah TAA makes game blurry. Old version of Witcher 3 isn't blurry because of it uses FXAA.
The original still looks awesome in 2022. CDPR really nailed the art direction
You tryna get exchanged or what my boy
@@Zz0Z79u tryna be noticed after several months or what my lil' boy
The best thing to me is the lighting and the colors of the floor. Before, Velen looked like it was too yellowish, but now it's much better
really "colors of the floor", kinda far reaching for any positives here aren't we
@@MGrey-qb5xz What? It's a great upgrade for something free, I'm just saying I always felt the colors are too saturated and could be better. People like you really likes to say everything is bad hm if it was not free, ok, but, man, why are u like this?
@@vitor.com_acento So it is ok for developers to release broken updates because "It's free" ?
@@vitor.com_acento the original game looks so good that these hd texture mods barely make the game look any better, cope
@@MGrey-qb5xz I don't think it looked "that good" in a lot of parts. Everything have space for improvements. And they improved some little things, which is see it's good
I'm more drawn to the old versions stylistic approach, the orange colors do a lot for the mood and the water feels better to me etc. It's a cool update though, field day for anyone that values realism more
Racist! Poland will never again bring weapons to Ukraine you racist fxxx..
same here. I like the classic tone. Novigrad in the newer version is too dark for me.
The orange tone and the moving trees and grass make a great aesthetic
Well, I'll play the new version, it's much better
I'm very happy that the overly saturated tones are largely gone (except at sunsets, when it is anyhow more appropriate)
Dude the performance mode is insane on the ps5 absolutely stunning it’s looks like a whole new game!! Having a blast with it even without the ray tracing mode it looks ridiculous and so smooth!!
bro the game is played on PC not ps5, check description
@@GAMEDESKY You better read that comment again. He didnt even say anything against your point, so wtf you want from him? Let him enjoy the Ps5 version.
@@_MrToast_ YEA HE BETTER
You'll enjoy it even more when you play it on PC with a high end graphics card.
@@Hboogie182yeah you just gotta find one in stock and pay 5x the amount of the ps5. So nice
Yup, definitely time for another playthrough.
Even without RT, the upgraded 3D models looks details and awesome! The only thing that's still there which they didn't fix since day one is the ground layered texture. The ground looks transparent and you can see the layered which really break the immersion.
I dislike that they removed HBAO which sucks because it is far better than the other options we have. Sucks because for me the game looks worse now and i cant run rtx rn
@@thehiddenone2875 You seriously think the game looks WORSE? Lol. Please stop it. You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.
@@kahnsealable It looks worse if you cant run Ray Tracing. FSR look more blurred and they removed HBAO which added a lot of realism. Sadly they removed this, making the grass etc look worse since there are no shadows on the grass. Hope this helps
@@thehiddenone2875 so because you don't have a rig powerful enough to run RT that makes the game look worse? You are literally making a fuss about ONE setting which doesn't make a big difference because the lighting system is overhauled. You completely ignore all the other upgrades that come from the HD rework mod they used.
@@kahnsealable Those were quite irrelevant to me since i played with the mods CDPR added to this version of the game before they updated it so the game looks worse now because they removed the AA option HBAO+ so for benchmarks rtx will look better in comparison to the normal game. If you dont believe me go look it up on youtube. The 3D Models look without a doubt better but if you dont have proper shadow on grass, barely any reflection it sucks
You know, sometimes old looks better, or at least to me. The orange tones, the moving trees and grass, and even the imperfect all contribute to a sense of nostalgia. And sometimes, things don't need to be so clear or bright because that's what makes them look vintage and thus effectively captures the passage of time.
In my opinion, the water in the original looks a lot more realistic. It's the waves and the splashes. The next gen updates water is too flat and the splashes look more like mist. Other than that though, the update is great.
Yes water physics are horrible.
I think it depends on the weather
@@gyro0232 what? He talk about wave when main character swim… dont understand?
Weather is mostly better in Next-gen, during storms waves are awesome, in original they were same no matter what's up with weather. Original has better wind effects on foliage and i really miss that "Wind's howling" effect. Splashes are so-so original too generic NG somehow flat. Shallow water much better in original, deep water better in NG. Colors hmmmm, i miss that yellow-redish note from original but ambient occlusion is sooo better
Nah, with update is more realistic
Impressive upgrade. I've been wanting to try this game. When I'm finished playing a bunch of other games, this one's next.
So never
@@elisel2308 🖕😄😁
@@Apollyon_Rev911 haha!
This game has great stories to sit back and play.
@megitsune714 I have a PS5, XSX, and an Alienware R10 (Ryzen 9 5900x, RTX 3080 10gb, 32gb RAM, 1T SSD). So yeah, I have a lot of games. Like I said, when I get to it. Going to finish a bunch of games before SF6 comes out in June. So now you know something, and you don't have to pretend like the other idiot🖕😏.
The vegetation density is absolutely insane in the next gen version. Witcher 3 already had insane vegetation to begin with.
I prefer the older version.
2:45 water foam not convincing and unstable reflections.
3:50 trees and shadows sway much less and more pop up.
The colours now feel a lot more subdued and natural to me. I like it.
That's exactly what I don't like about it lol
@@brando3342 I can understand that, it does lose out on a lot of its original "witcher" vibe without the specific hues of greens and yellows in the environments.
@@esscee96 Thanks to CD Project, now Velen looks even more like a gloomy swamp from which you want to escape
@@thehosdadal4542Ikr? And that music lol
I like that the environment has become more realistic, because of which the outdated character models (especially NPCs) are much more visible. And now it turns out that the characters are knocked out in terms of quality relative to the environment, like damn graphic mods for GTA 4, whatever you do, the age is still visible from the models of NPCs and characters.
I've played the entire game twice with its dlcs, side quests and all (old version)....totally awesome...unfortunately can't do it a third time with the next gen update, just burned out with the open world formula now, thanks Ubisoft.........story based single player games is what I look forward to now.
It's str8 up amazing. I just got my p5 and as much as I love the witcher 3 it's on another level now...Replay replay replay is a must. It's that gorgeous.
in my opinion the effect of the wind on the trees in the next gen looks static while in the old version it looks more realistic moving fast when exposed to the wind, i preefrer still like look old version looks more realistic with the wind effect
Nice. It compliments the game well, looks more rich and adds volume to the environment.
is it just me or the old yellowish filter had some special "sad" vibe, which perfectly fitted the game timeline.
It's just you.
Well, the yellow is nice, but overall Velen still looks drab and kindof grayish in a way. That changes when you get closer to Novigrad, the nature around there is differently lit, brighter yellowish.
I think the way they used colours in the original is brilliant.
Even Novigrad is drab when you compare it to Touissant.
I ws thinking the same thing, the yellow one looked better to me.
The movement of the branches, the environment with heavy wind looks more realistic than the updates
This game is pure masterpiece that never ever can be something like it again
Yes, sadly you're right.
without the update the game still look phenomenal
2:18 why such a terrible tree in the distance for the next gen?
I love all the wild flowers and the improved textures in the game. Nice touches
3:50 I liked the windy effect on oldrim.
Why did they remove the strong wind effect? Bending trees and grass perfectly showed the power of nature and the feeling of cold😢
Holy shit I actually didn't even notice they removed this. I remember loving seeing how the wind made the trees move!
The trees/wind effect was pretty broken and would always be on. It looked pretty bad.@@Boop417
Perhaps the weather is just less windy that day? Didn't it vary in the original too? I also noticed in the video how static everything was, making the old game looking more lively, which is nice.
@@johnwayne-kd1pn nah, it was ALWAYS on. always. It was broken.
@@Magnesius Actually yea, I remembered that when you said it, and before I posted. Nonetheless always on is better than always off IMO.
I remember firing it up on my ps4 back in 2015 on my 720p TV and being blown away. The thing that got me right off was the way the flora moved in the wind. Now I'm playing it for the 4th time on my RX6600xt and my 4k monitor, 4.04 next Gen patch and I'm blown away all over again. One of the greatest games to ever grace us as gamers. Really hope The Witcher 4 can hold up to it, they set a high bar.
has anyone noticed the floor textures being lifted off the actual floor
is it with RT on or off?
I can see a major difference, I also have it set to ultra and it suns smooth, of course your going to have your exception, like major populated areas and lots of animations, but over all it was a great Next-Gen update, and I've only played like 4 hrs of it since it came out, So kudos to CDPR for a great job, I hope the CP 2077 DLC that's coming will be just as good, hers to hopping😁
What happened to next gen, they stopped patching it?
3:30
The trees move with the wind in the original but in next-gen, they look static, they don't react to the wind...
Can’t really relate with the atmosphere when I played this game in Southeast Asia. Now that I’m currently in north west Europe, can’t believe how immersive the atmosphere’s graphics and soundtrack was done. CDPR is a beast. Just don’t rush them 😅
I actually prefer the warmth of the original to the sharpness of the update. They should have left the orange filter on. It gave the game a more unique look.
i love the yellower tint in the original, hope they have included a toggle for that ambiance
Legit didn’t try the game on my ps5 until this upgrade now it’s time to start atleast 2 to 3 more play throughs on what I believe to be the greatest game ever
This definitly brings me a feeling of going to the countryside in my country. The forest especially is really similar.
i think it looks even better without the update
Yep. Same here. Talking about water splashes, shadows and wind effect on vegetation.
Yep. Same here. Talking about water splashes, shadows and wind effect on vegetation.
Why is the new one blurry?
I came here because of the next gen Fall out 4 lol
why are shadows popping in on trees when getting closer to them?? it's very noticeable and annoying, seems like it's only on next gen
El movimiento de los arboles en el original me resulta mucho mas genial. Aunque no fuese realista le da un toque bello al juego
Sí, no entiendo por qué esa necesidad de que los juegos sean lo más realista posible. Si quiero eso salgo a la calle y ya está. Las cosas fantasiosas y diseño artístico son los elementos que visualmente más atrapan la atención.
El viento y las hojas cayendo en ghost of tsunami son exagerados, pero la sensación e impresión que tienes al jugarlo va más allá de el realismo
What’s that gear when you switch to the next gen version? That’s beautiful.
I prefer the original at 3:40 That yellow tint gives a diffetent atmosphere
This made me appreciate how good the original game looks
7 ½ damn years apart
Imagine a game with the fidelity and detail of RDR2 and the setting of The Witcher 3... Now that's what I hope The Witcher 4 is going to be like!
My god... How much the game improved with RT and new foliage system with improved/upscaled textures... The original looks ecstatic for 2015 title... But now 7 years later with the next gen upgrade... It trumples most of 2020-2022 open world games.
I am playing it at RT ultra+ with 3090 and I just can't stop bloody staring at the game. I just don't want to use way teleports and don't want to run to the mission... but rather walk and just stare at the beauty of it all...
The only really thing left is to polish some visual anomalities created by RT at some places (with the light leak probably 2 walls not properly joined etc....) and the heavy FPS toll that is unreasonable for what the game produces and is obvious there is severe engine CPU limitiation which needs to be worked on to have better perf overall.
I am playing on an RTX 3080 and do the same with RT Ultra+. I have spend 50 hours in the game and havent even gone past Velen. The only issue is the game needs to better use multiple cores in the CPU. Apart from that, its amazing
@@DeebanFR Aye... 30 hours in and man... I haven't used ONCE teleport... I'm just roaming with roach (using mod that kind of copied RDR2 horse controls) and soaking in all the beauty of the world... And just slaying what needs slayin'. 30 hours and I haven't touched much of actual main quests... Just side quests/contracts and question marks...
Really if they properly optimize DX12 version and improve the performance by 15-20% (or more) it would be amazing.
Like I am running 50hz with vsync to experience somewhat smooth experience as with 60hz its just constant jerk fest as the game is floating around 50-60 fps.
Only other thing I wish I saw updated was the NPC animations... Would have been cool to see more modernized animation and movement... Also utilizing the facial expressions tech that they have implemented in CP77...
Overall i'm mad impressed...
@@sermerlin1 What CPU are you on? 50 fps is as high it goes right now without Intel 13th gen
@@DeebanFR i5 11400. Got smooth gameplay at 50fps about 90% of the time, where it is sitting above 50fps but in some villages in velen it goes to 47-49fps. While exploring it is 50fps locked flatline.
Novi grad will probably slaughter me at 30-35fps as well as oxenfurt.
а с какой стороны 4K?
Am i the only one to prefer the old water graphic design, compared to the new one ?
Ye cause the new one doesn’t have that ripple effect
The color was way off though. Ocean blue water in a central european-esque swamp?
@@idontknowidk6077it does. It's just covered in a new foam texture. At 2:13 you can see the ripples in the shallow parts real easy.
I've just been playing the next gen mode on PC recently with all RT options on and it's absolutely beautiful. In combination with its art direction it's one of the best looking games I've ever played.
It Improved in some areas. The color palette is def less yellowish but some of the grass is noticeably blurrier as if it has lost definition. The terrain, itself has improved and it's more detailed but in some cases, it seems the trees went from 4K to 2K and there is less variety. You could clearly see the detailed leaves on the trees before the Next-gen update and now they are all some sort of mass of different greens. The next-gen walking is atrocious, it's like The Witcher is losing his walking rhythm every 2 or 3 steps.
Bro's mad he doesn't have next gen
Literally *all I could notice* is how awkward and robotic the walking looks in the newer version. It looked SO much more fluid before... no idea how they messed that up IoI
@@finnplotzki4774Nah IoI. Some improvements are really nice, while other changes are noticeable downgrades. The walking animation in next gen looks ESPECIALLY worse.
Is it truly different, or is it just that he's walking faster in the next-gen clip? I mean, if the speeds were matched, would it be different?
@finnplotzki4774 I've never owned a console in my life. Never will. All my games are heavily modded. Just my Skyrim has over 2,600 mods and runs always over 60 FPS without even sweating. I always thought that consoles are (in general), for people who can't afford a decent pc.
Next gen has Texture pop in issue, correct the lod before release
the performance loss of the next gen is not worth it imo. original still looks amazing.
Why doesn't the trees move in the wind anymore...
Exactly, thats literaly my only complaint. Ruins immersion
Is it weird that I like the original more than the Next Gen update?
Yes
@@-zeusalmighty-2812 Yeah I was drunk haha, after 140 hours I can certify that the next-gen is 100 times better hands down 😅
Seeing this side by side. Getting rid of that orange look makes it feel like some of the original setting got lost in this update. Overall really happy with that update. Especially considering its free. Still love playing this game.
1:43 look at the windmill
Magnificent game, they did a remarkable work with the remaster tons of improvements ❤
Now it looks a little closer to that one trailer that looked incredible beyond belief. I think it was the reveal trailer
if only i had a computer that can run this on Ultra+ with Ray Tracing :(
Don't worry, you don't miss anything from the other world, you will only see the game as if it had the gama more high, that is, worse
Why is Geralt's walk different?
I'm also recording some gameplay on my channel on my Xbox Series X. The graphics are fantastic too. Very impressive upgrade.
I dont know... Its just different for me. Watching in 1080p I cannot notice any difference in graphics, only in style and colors
are you blind ? just look at the foliage
I have a fully moded PC version and i dare say that it looks much better than the Next Gen version
I think even not modded old version looks better, than this witcher 3 reforged.
I doubt it, the grass looks much better in the next gen, not even beautifullgrass or meadowns mod with the tweaks in engine.ini come close to the new grass.
and I highlight the grass over the rest because it's what we will see the most in the whole adventure, lol.
@@metroplex29 on my taste old grass better, they should've give a choice between old graphic and new, with other changes which i like. But maybe it's too hard to do, i don't know.
@@nikoooo57 i thought i was the only one who prefered old the witcher than new the witcher.
@@nikoooo57 the old grass was absolutely horrible 😂 it was just 2 plane meshes with an alpha map applied on top. The new ones are far better. With each individual blade of grass being rendered.
Did the walking animation change I like the old one better
I don't know why but classic version of witcher 3 i like much more
Me too actually. It was nice to do another playthrough on the remaster, but the original is just right.. They even mucked about with the combat system for the remaster, and I frankly don't like those changes at all.
It might just be me, but the added contrast, "difference between bright and dark elements" is just too high on the next gen version, especially on a oled. The old version is much easier on my eyes.
Original: 180 fps - - - - Next Gen: 56 fps
was it a mistake not to show the cityscape, or are the changes there not significant?
I cannot not play this game without ray tracing. It's just too damn beautiful.
But I cannot play the game with ray tracing because its so damn taxing
@@MrMooMoo89 L
15 fps 😎😎
thats why until i can afford or have to upgrade my 3080 to a 4080+, I won't be replaying it.
40 fps on rtx 4080 lol. I can't imagine what fps is on RTX 2060 with RT
I loved CD Project RED, this game was my favorite. I even bought Game of The Year Edition on PS Store Russia.
But you cheated me with a free upgrade to the Next-gen version. Should I re-buy the game in another region??? Now I hate not only CD Project RED, but also the Poles! (Although before that there was great respect for you!)
Я любил студию CD Project RED, эта игра была моей любимой. Я даже купил Game of The Year Edition на PS Store Russia.
Но вы меня кинули с бесплатным обновлением до Next-gen версии. Я что долэен заново покупать игру в другмо регионе??? Теперь я ненавижу не только CD Project RED , но и поляков! (Хотя до этого было большое уважение к Вам!)
The new water effect is incredible!
The world of witcher is not supposed to be beautiful. It's supposed to look grim and dark.
U never went to a place called crookback bog?
@@TheNissandd everything should be grim
@@TheNissandd everywhere anywhere
Well, except Toussant ofcourse.. And well, even all the other parts of the game use different colours to have a different kind of look. Not all are suppose to look as grim and dark as Velen, even outside Novigrad things lighten up significantly.
Kaer Morhen has more of a cold white tone, and Skellige more of a cold blue tone. This is good use of colours actually, in the original, pretty brilliant actually.
The next-gen version graphics are more realistic and new but I like the Original version more, it has more old-period and fantasy vibes.
Great game and great video👍👍
for the 6th times i played this game and still playing next gen too awsome
The old version locks for me better! 😅
is the a spot the difference test? They look literally the same to me lol.
No big differences. I like the colors of the non next gen (not look cold). Trees seems more dark and LOD is better at distance. Wind power have been reduced too.
Water has a white foam (additional material change). And i think that's all.
You're missing the added foliage, higher quality textures and mainly the new lighting/reflections and shadows. You can see at 1:44 (on the right side) that instead of it being a blob of shadows meshed together you can see the individual branches and twigs/leaves casting shadows and can make them out their shapes easily. Seems like a decent amount for a free update imo.
I think you need to get your eyes check friend.
Either you are blind or you are completely new to gaming
@@groogi9649 adding foliage is not a part of a next gen game. But you're right. New one is slightly better. Maybe i should play it on a big screen, cause on my phone it's not clear and i cannot enjoy texture.
@@asdfghjk2933 no. I can see better light/shadows. Maybe some texture are better.
But for me the original game was already good, so the new one has not a huge difference.
It's my point of view dude. Maybe i should play it on a large screen to enjoy it..
2:33 Next Gen has no water physics
Why I feel that the Original version looks better?
Cap
The water looks 100 times better in the next gen version
Only more saturation of color in the original.
I thought left is next-gen until i saw the top right corner...But why the next gen became blurry?
The new version doesn't have HBAO+ which is why objects use shitty SSAO and it looks too flat without RT.
They removed it on next-gen version of the game seemingly to make RT shadows look better in a side by side comparison - really disappointed CDPR would do this.
Like they should have at least left HBAO+ in DX11 mode where there's no RT anyway....
Is it weird that i like the non next gen version better? I find the next gen is overly bright and blurred to hell, I like the lighting more in the original as well because for some reason almost everything has this glow effect in the next gen version.
Distant detail looks more complex, better atmospheric effects (especially far away haze), improved water reflections, more vegetation rendering up close. But the old version still looks great
One of the best next gen updates I’ve seen
Why scale of the interface is changing when you do slide comparison? I can't think of anything else except old gen is in 1080p and new gen is anything higher than that.
Is it just me or these paths through forest looks sooting and scary at the same time.
bother look great. but i kidna prefer the old style. the new one is more realistic. but the old style was really warm stylized and fantastical.
3:17 what happened on the new one? It looks like some ghosting?
Wht armor is this in ur video i love the length of it
Nice one. I love how people complain under other videos, and thinking "next-gen NO RT" is an old game with broken optimization. (thats how they are doing compartion - "next-gen RT off" for them = "OLD GAME" :D )
They set "uber+" and complain they have lower FPS than before... I dont get it, nowadays people are so stupid? They dont understand this game looks totally different than 2015 W3, even without RT?
Only judging from the video, the updated version seems to look better overall, but also looks less sharper than the original... look at Geralt's chainlink armor, or his belt, in the side by side comparisons at ~01:00
The grass is more refined in the new version, but also more blurry... look (even pause) at 01:01 for example. Same goes for the ground or rocky roads... 03:41 or 04:07 for example. At first I thought the new version was played on a console, because of this issue, then I saw the video description, and couldn't believe it's on PC... maybe it's DLSS on a setting less than "quality" and without Sharpening? Doesn't seem to be related to Motion Blur... Graphical settings are not detailed in the description, unfortunately...
I have yet to test the update for myself, I will do that in the near future to see what's what... hope my RTX 3090 can run the new version in 4k at an acceptable framerate :D
Question. For use the next gen game i should enter the game with direct 12 right?
The free update has a lot more work put into it than several PAID remasters out there.