From: Interesting Facts and Detailed Discussion part 2 ruclips.net/video/7zQZYDkk0as/видео.html If you enjoy our content and want to support our channel, you can do so with a subscription or a donation. Your support helps us grow, improve the quality of our videos, and create even more exciting material for you. Thank you so much for your help! 😉paypal - molegaze1@gmail.com 🤑USDT (TRC20) - TMhszt9G8YsBfo2wheYGQxEr73FWzJcq26
Also the most annoying thing about the series is that the people don’t communicate well with each other about thier hallucinations sightings or experiences otherwise it would have been much quicker and easier for them to figure things out
I think what really sealed the deal for me with her is when she brought the morphine to Marianna. She just so happened to have morphine and brought it to the drug addict…. It’s like she was trying to sabotage
Ok, here's my two cents worth: Tabitha wrote the dates on the light house wall! It's very clear. She found a way back into Fromland but each time she went to the "wrong" date. When she arrived at the incorrect date, like we saw in her dream when the town was empty, she did "two" things: she marked the bottle tree with bottles and dates so she could locate the tree and indicate what date she arrived at the tree. She also wrote the dates on the light house wall to allow herself to remember what date she just left. She will "jump" from the light house over and over again until she gets the time right!!!!!!
Hard to tell but in one of the flashbacks Victors mom is wearing a bracelet that looks like the one Tabitha claimed to be the one she made. Its really quick so it could just be a coincidence or is it? What if the time jumping idea works both ways? Tabitha gets out, ends up years before being in fromland, swipes the bracelet before getting back into fromland. Then starts doing what you're talking about, befriends Victor's mom gives her the bracelet. 🤷♂
I still think this is the world of IT... the scary place is FROM, the monsters are THEY and the EVIL is IT...also Stephen King is a consultant on the show.
i have gone through hundreds of theories online but this one seems to be the most accurate and in every way it makes sense. Hats off to your hard work and analysis. After watching this video i realised i have got some of my questions answered and now i can sleep peacefully. Again a huge round of applause for your analysis.
I still think this is the world of IT... the scary place is FROM, the monsters are THEY and the EVIL is IT...also Stephen King is a consultant on the show.
Y'all, cut this poor guy a break. Theres no need to shame, or theory shame. He made a very thought provolking, provocative, and insightful video. I, for one, very much appreciate your thoughtful theories. And appreciate the time and effort you put into developing them. Moreover, taking the risk of posting through a translator in a language not your own is brave. I applaud it! If you're still in Ukraine, please stay safe. It has to be incredibly difficult there. I hope projects like these help 🙂 Thank you for sharing with us!
@@ElizRued I agree. I thought he did brilliantly! Don't know if the horrid comments remain, but people were being incredibly cruel and hyper-critical of someone putting out a great video. He said in a response to some of those comments that he is Ukrainian and put the video together using a translator which I found impressive - to go through that added effort to express himself creatively, especially amidst such chaos and horrors as are occurring in his country. Hats off to him!
@@DrDeb2005 yeh cause I don’t care about his accent 😂 Yall get ur foot off my neck and da OG comment is her opinion damn 🤦🏾♂️ dis ain’t English class and mane cut dat out it’s da internet wha ya want a FN cookie
Tabitha made that bracelet from her father in law's bootlace, so she couldn't have come out of fromville with it as a child, because she didn't make it until she was an adult. It went missing when she gave birth though, so maybe her dead son brought it with him somehow?
@@jadakissable9 Watch the new trailer- you'll see Tabitha wearing Victor's lunchbox (you only see the string strap, but it's obviously the lunchbox). That tosses the simulation theories or the "they're all in comas" ideas.
@@kevinnicholas6721 oh yeah I’ve been wondering about that movie. It looks similar now that you say to watch it. Thank you now I’ll definitely check it out!
After Tabitha woke up back in the real world (or what we assume to be the real world), I was wondering if everyone who dies in From-ville wakes up back in the real world. It'll be interesting to see whether or not Tabitha's body is found in From-ville in season 3.
Why did Victors dad not ask about his daughter. Only asked about Victor. Why was he not more inquisitive. If Tabitha thought she was going back , why did she not bring back supplies. Like medicine, soap, cleaning supplies. Shampoo, i mean some laundry soap. I have questions.
I dont think she ever said she was trying to get back; she was trying to figure something out. even then why would that be the first on her mind when she doesn’t know where she is? And the dad thought all of them died tabitha only said victor was alive too
She didn't even know that she was going to fromville when she was in an ambulance. They were heading to the hospital and then she saw a tree on the road n all happened so fast.
Very cool! Love your attention to details I was not sure about so far, I've watched the seasons twice. One person pointed out that the 8 trees on the talisman could also be a deconstructed spider web. Not impossible considering the spiders are a theme that haven't been discussed or connected in the show yet. But Ethan talks about spiders right off the bat when he wakes up in the RV and his leg is impaled. We only saw the spiders once in the forest, but maybe they are a bigger clue than what the writers have given us so far!
Based on what everyone’s saying about Tabitha. What if she’s really Victor’s sister that survived and escaped somehow. But over the years she forgot, I mean this would be very traumatic for anyone look at Victor . She meets Jim and makes him a bracelet similar to her mother’s. Jim loses it. The bracelet she finds in the town is not the one he lost but her mothers (just speculation idk, haven’t finished season 2 lol)
Your attention to detail and analysis is above all other that I've heard from the dozens of other videos I've watched on YT. I agree that this is likely a game being played by supernatural beings (as you mentioned in your second video), though I'm unsure if it is the 4 players you've mentioned or merely generic demons/evil entities.
At 22:10 you speak of the Dark Horse in the prayer circle, while there is a couple holding hands observing from "above"...just like the drawing on the cave wall.
I like the idea with the stones. Maybe they are mini maps as well as protection. They show the paths for the faraway trees to help the people there avoid mosters. Like a minimap and fast traveling in games
One thing, you say that there are three trees depicted but that there are 8 trees. The three trees depicted are the ones that have a set warp point, the others are all just random.
Great video. I do agree we are being misled at times, I compare it to Jade's idea of a puzzle. That cavern is like an end piece in some ways. I think the town is in Michigan. There is a 1974 calendar in Trudy's room and the sponsor is Rendez-Vous. Boyd's family arrived with one in tow. Now owned by a Nova Scotia business, it started in Michigan. Someone on reddit mentioned seeing Creel Cola somewhere but couldn't find it on Google. Deeper dives and lateral thinking is important. I found a guy named Creelman who sold his beverage company, I think it was started in the 1930s, and they did make soda and the guy was in Michigan. We already have other connections in the show. Just something to pass on. You have a lot of great stuff in this video. Much appreciated.
I know i am dumping too many comments i really wish i could make a theory video myself but i have some important exams in January So couldn’t actually make one so i wish to share it with you your video seems more sensible to me . Well now here are some of my theories or bobservations: 1) that the scarecrows might have something to do with the man whom jade saw when he was in the snow , since he saw him nailed on the tree and was grabbing him it seems to me that he could be an evil entity , if u observe carefully when jade spots the guy we see one on the scarecrows too so i feel the makers might be dropping some hint here and my theory is that these scarecrows are actually some kind of witchcraft mediums like used to trap evil entities , so when jade pulled out the metal rods to rescue Kristy like he literally destroyed one of the scarecrows and idk if it is really the one that was shown in the scene when jade encounters the nailed guy but i think he actually undo the thing and let this guy escape so now its like he is unattached from the tree and u could clearly make out with that blood drink in skull things that his intentions aren’t any good. 2)the man in yellow : my theory is he could be Boyd and if we go by the reincarnation theory then he might be the previous version of Boyd like Tabitha also has same messages from fromville just like Miranda the same way the man in yellow from Miranda’s paintings could be someone like Boyd who was searching for answers . 3) the lake lady that elvin sees might be Miranda now don’t ask me why but it could be or maybe not 4) this is some observation from the scene where jade spots the nailed guy on so he first sees the red rocks in the snow i thought they might have blood on them so i keenly observed thinking that they might be a part of his hallucinations if u watch closely when jade walks near the second rock the red colour kinda shrinks from the bottom now idk what to make of this it could be an editing glitch or something else because the red stones still stay when the others from the group arrive for jades help . 5) we know from victors observations that the trees move so my theory here is that it could be that when the fromville allows a new guests from the outside world to enter ,the geography of the place like shifts or changes so Ig it changed the place again because the ambulance was to arrive in the town in season 3 . 6) another thing i observed that could be a potential hint that in the scene when Tabitha walks out of the confession box in the church in season 3 you can see some numbers on the church wall on the left side of the exit sign it shows 104 at top and 19. 20 at the bottom of it now i am not a Christian and idk if it actually means something in the church related to Christianity but to me it appears it might have to do something with the numbers on the lighthouse maybe as a hint idk maybe it could be a hint to something. 7) ok soooooooooo its now this ones kinda creepy we know that in the upcoming episode the ambulance carrying Tabitha and victors father enters fromville now this might be a future prediction in the series earlier when Tabitha is in the lighthouse hallucination there’s a toy ambulance and also the bottle from the bottle tree so i wonder if it was like the prediction of what happened after Tabitha was sent to the real world that her ambulance will come back to the fallen tree That’s all for now i think i might put this up as a Reddit post if i have time with proper pictures and screenshots for reference i really wish you would give me a shoutout if u plan to put my theories in your next video .
8:34 Could it be that Victor made these drawings himself? If you look at the drawings in his room (you can look up Victor's Drawings on From Wiki) you can see he draws trees sometimes in the same way (the F looking shape).
Great video and you bring out so many things that are missed on the first or even second watch. Thank you! The Tabitha storyline is very interesting and I did not think about the possibility she could be Victors sister at all, but it is very likely. Especially when Victors mother had the same bracelet - it can not be a coincidence. Also, I have to watch again the last episode - I totally missed that the reflection of her in the hospital is different. Another thing you mentioned - Tilly. Tbh She did seem a bit questionable from the start. At one point she seemed like the necessary mother figure, that was previously Donna, but someone here mentioned she has SEVEN grandchildren?! That makes you wonder... Telling Fatima that she is pregnant actually is not so special - for some women, there are some common small symptoms or things we do, when we are pregnant and actually no one who has been pregnant will understand these or if you do not put your attention on the person. But still, she is very questionable! Thanks again!
Another show where all the fan theories are gonna turn out to be 100X better than what we will get because the writers have absolutely 0 answers to their own show and are just making it up as they go 😂
What about the stacks of stones Tabitha sees in the cave and later Ethan builds on their porch? Could that have been a symbol for the tower/lighthouse?
I didn’t finish season 2 yet but it’s good to have a knowledge about a series I’m watching. I was thinking that maybe everyone was in a coma but then towards the ending explanation that probably wouldn’t have been the case. But it would be kinda cool concept that there in a coma and the monsters are death and one they take u then u die in the real world.
I saw this video the other day and heard you speak of Tillie's prayer as being strange, unheard of before, and I laughed and laughed and laughed because EVERYBODY has heard Psalm 23 before. It's quoted so commonly that Coolio included it in his biggest song, "Gangsta's Paradise." How have you not heard it? 😂😂😂
You said almost word for word what I said to my son. Anyone who has ever been to a funeral received a card for the person who died. With what verse on it? 23rd Psalm. I am astonished and saddened that he didn't know this. I think I would have Googled the words before saying there was a strange and unrecognizable prayer being spoken. When I started quoting it to my son, who's agnostic, he recognized immediately that it was lyrics from Coolio's song. 😂😂😂
I think Tilly is just enjoying her life because she has a terminal illness so she’s just happy everyday. But you know what I thought about people had to have been able to leave the town come and go as they please because there is the post office why build a post office someone has to deliver the mail come and go so people had to have been able to leave at a time. Also I strongly believe those creatures are vampires. You know vampires from long ago looked identical to those creature the similarities are there. I didn’t even notice the reflection of a person when Tabitha looked out the hospital window. These are the producers from the hit series LOST and that series was amazing same situation people stranded in a place they couldn’t escape and Boyd was part of that series as well trying to find a way out and strange things happened on LOST all the time.
Like all other series if it runs for a long time the stories will become sillier and siller every season like Under the Dome or even Lost, the ending of which made us all unsatisfied. I hope they don't run for too long
im new in to the show but the dates Here’s a breakdown of whether solar eclipses occurred in the years you listed: 1506 - Partial eclipse in Europe. 1609 - No significant solar eclipse. 1672 - Total eclipse visible in Europe. 1752 - Total eclipse visible in northern Europe. 1773 - Annular eclipse in South America. 1864 - Annular eclipse visible in the U.S. and South America. 1888 - Total eclipse in the Pacific and Australia. 1931 - Annular eclipse visible in parts of Asia and the Pacific. 1978 - Partial eclipse visible in North America. and October 14, 2023 - An annular solar eclipse, where the moon covers the center of the sun, leaving a "ring of fire." April 8, 2024 - A total solar eclipse, where the moon completely blocks the sun, casting a shadow across parts of the U.S., including Texas, Ohio, and New York. so that mite be it
15:24 That part where Julia recognized the young man made no sense because later on we learn that her brother died when he was a baby. So I also originally thought that this must have been her brother. But how would she recognize him as an adult when he died as a baby? Some of these things seem more connected to a child 's vision of what monsters are. I noticed that spiders didn't appear until the little boy mentioned them. So is this Julia's vision of what her brother would have looked like had he lived and she saw it in a dream? Because dreams seem to have a big impact in this world.
the s3 trailer line 'the forest feeds on hope not fear' will be the key to everything think we discover a group/cult thats been in the 'woods dimension' happily/getting 4 seasons a yr etc cuz they gave up on hope/accepted this new life that they can live happily
and everyone who got taken to Fromland was for this reason, but some got taken along cuz they were in the car etc (never heard of a group coming on on a bus and only SOME of them ending up in Fromland and some not making it 'through' - it seems kind of all or nothing so obv innocent kids could poss be given a chance to go back...im also curious how time passes irl when theyre in fromland.... But i think they'll be better off in this idealized fromworld where they're safe and provided for by nature etc and maybe, to twist the knife - while the real/tabitha world will fall into a pandemic/ww3/catastrophic natural event etc
Regarding the spiderwebs in the forest. When I looked at it from high angles / wide shots. I could see the spiderwebs were only in a narrow path / corridor that Boyd walked through. While only a little to the side, the trees of the forest was clear. I didn't see any good shots in this video of yours, but you could still notice it, if you pause at 25:30, you can see the trees in the background to the right doesn't have any spiderwebs on them.
We never saw what Randall was carving on top of the bus. I'm guessing he carved himself a Talisman to see if it'd work like the stone version. We never saw what happened with that, did we?
The people in boats are obviously on a river. You can see the black curvy lines right there that make the river banks. The symbols (which I think you are right, might represent trees) and the triangles (which might be regular trees) are on either side of those curvy lines - like a forest on either side of a river. Maybe the first people that got here did so by boat. Either way the drawing is showing people on water in boats.
Also, I don't think that building on the cave wall is the light house - it's the church. And there's more than the three places you get to in the trees. At least one tree puts you in a shaft inside an alternate dimension you can only get back to with a torch.
Also i think that some trees are simply portals that are connected to a place in the same timeline or dimension but the other ones like the one boid went through are the ones that can make u timetravel
Heres a comment someone else posted that ive expanded on and i fully believe it was the core inspirstions for the shows concept "It's Carcosa, more closely, the Dreamlands from Lovecraft and Eldrich lore. Symbol is that of Atlach Nacha, evil spider god that links dimensions. The walkers are ghouls, and Hastur is the big bad controlling the entire realm." Hastur per the original writings was know as the king in yellow. We see so many uses of the color yellow in the show. Even certain scenes filmed with a yellow filter. We see a painting of a man in a yellow suit in the basement. Atlach nacha was a spider god that "resides in a cave system and it spins a great web, forming a great bridge between the Dreamlands and the waking world."
I ran the dates through ai, and don't know if they are connected to the story in the show, but: 1506: While not directly related to U.S. history, Christopher Columbus, who opened the way for European exploration of the Americas, died in this year. 1609: Henry Hudson explored parts of North America, including the river that would later bear his name. 1672: The first recorded monthly Quaker meeting in the U.S. was held in Sandwich, Massachusetts. 1752: Benjamin Franklin conducted his famous kite experiment, proving that lightning is a form of electricity. 1773: The Boston Tea Party, a pivotal event leading up to the American Revolution, took place. 1864: Significant events during the American Civil War, including General Ulysses S. Grant being put in command of all Union forces. 1883: The Brooklyn Bridge opened, a marvel of engineering at the time. 1931: The Empire State Building opened, and “The Star-Spangled Banner” was adopted as the U.S. national anthem. 1978: The Camp David Accords began, leading to a peace agreement between Egypt and Israel.
22:05 How is the prayer "quite strange"? It's one of the most recognizable psalms from the bible. Psalms 23;4 "though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I shall fear no evil, for thou are with me." Never saw Pulp Fiction? 😅
I like some of the suff you say but it really bothers me when you state things so factually when in fact we don't know much. Here are some: 1. How do we know this was ever a normal town? Victor showed Tabatha the car his family arrived him so he is not a 'local'. We don't know how the monsters form is decided, are they past victims? If the town already existed then that doesn't explain the electricity/vires leading no where. 2. How do know what attacked Boyds tent? Could've been a massive spider for all we know. 3. They have the same puppet at the colony house. That might have been why Victor was so freaked out. 4. Tabatha stated that she made the braclet from Jim's late fathers boots. So the bracelet is still very confusing if Victor mom had it because it's made from something that belonged to Jims father. 5. We don't know if they tried to kill the monster any other way. Even Boyd hid for years. The only reason he finnaly attacked the monster was so that he could safely pass on what Maritin gave him without killing anyone else, and after that save his sons life. The reason why the monsters are so dried up (as well as Smileys organs when they open him up) could be because of the sun/day. For all we know the monsters just enjoy slowburn torture as it was stated in the show ("they know that they will get you eventually"), this could be the reason why they don't run, and if they don't need to eat to stay alive theres no reason to rush the killing, it's all about the suffering (perhaps to feed the forrest?). They also know that eventually everyone in town will be murdered like in Vicors childhood. 6. Tilly is very sus but then again she's also dying, maybe she's just happy to be along for the ride as long as it may last. My theory is that she somehow knows about this place and chose to go there in order to extend her life (Fatimas infertility is gone, Boyd's parkinsons, Ethans leg heald in like 5 days.) 7. The time in the real world and Fromville is connected, we know this because of the medic and her fiancee, also Victor aged. That would mean that if Tabatha keeps swiching dimensions she would still age. I think this is her first time experiencing Fromville and escaping it.
So if running or not is simply thier choice then you're saying if they feels like it they could just chase thier victims at full speed, even thinking about that is giving me chills. I think the about tress being the attackers makes more sense since it's been told to us from season 1 that they're not immobile, they are changing places so maybe forest has a life of it's own and seeing boyd reaching close to the tower made it anxious coz we know boyd is savior type if he managed to find an escape he'll take everyone with him and forest doesn't want that coz it survives of off thier fear and hope.
@@ashukalawat5230 those things running would be horrifying. But they left that girl with the nail through her head alive just to torture her and the townsfolk. And they seem to be pretty speedy when S1 little girl opened the window. So they probably like to take it slow to see the fear in their eyes as they aproach. I could be the forrest but it seems too fast for me, the spiders make more sense imo. What Victor is observing might be the change in landscape including the forrest. The forrest itself might not be special at all, for example, when Tabatha found the cave under her house, the house colappsed. Which means the whole town has a life of its own. When Jim built the antena, the storm came, the season changed. The forrest is not magical, everything is magical.
The tower is the pistol of the flower; allowing a jump over its petals. Within this flesh eating flower it deals with its own pests. Spiders and bugs that wither and eat its leaves.
Tilly is weird and is very possibly the monster grandmother. she is too calm and happy to be normal. Strangers don't usually declare a pregnancy.That is something that happens within a close relationship. I think Tilly can sense/smell the baby and she wants to take it because if children are the normal sacrifice a baby must be a bonus sacrifice. I also think there is more to Kristy's girlfriend appearing in the town. I also think that it matters that Tilly is the one that donated the morphine that she stole, which fits with the nursery rhyme. Somehow, all these people are connected to the monsters.
15:30 In cast Q&As the director said its about the characters story and not the mystery so i doubt all the characters will die except ethan. Im pretty sure season we will meet what is controlling the monsters i hope
Just a theory, what if tilly is da grandmother of the lil gurl in da very 1st season ep 1 & she opend the window thinking it was her but once she realized she said u dont look like my grandmother , but it was too late 😢 sb let me kno if im wrong ❤
From: Interesting Facts and Detailed Discussion part 2
ruclips.net/video/7zQZYDkk0as/видео.html
If you enjoy our content and want to support our channel, you can do so with a subscription or a donation. Your support helps us grow, improve the quality of our videos, and create even more exciting material for you. Thank you so much for your help!
😉paypal - molegaze1@gmail.com
🤑USDT (TRC20) - TMhszt9G8YsBfo2wheYGQxEr73FWzJcq26
Also the most annoying thing about the series is that the people don’t communicate well with each other about thier hallucinations sightings or experiences otherwise it would have been much quicker and easier for them to figure things out
This is exactly what I have been saying.
@@giftedwithmelanin6849 unfortunately we have no way of knowing if there is a reason for it or if it's just bad writing. I'm hoping for the former.
I’m sure it’d be boring, but especially Victor they need to have everyone come together and write down what everyone knows and draw parallels
Yea i noticed that too but i think there are a lot of ppl and ppl like to keep info to themselves irl too
people dont share hallucinations in real life, especially in a place like this.
I don't trust the old lady from the bus purely because she's been getting a LOT of screentime despite not actually doing much
I think what really sealed the deal for me with her is when she brought the morphine to Marianna. She just so happened to have morphine and brought it to the drug addict…. It’s like she was trying to sabotage
@@alexise0226 I was thinking the same thing! I was about to post a similar reply when I saw yours.
Ya I feel the same way and that fact she got there was so happy and dancing when they arrived when everyone else was confused
And don’t forget what she told Jim that sent him running out of the house. She always starting something
@@yahdahhawk613 What was it she told Jim? I don't remember
Ok, here's my two cents worth: Tabitha wrote the dates on the light house wall! It's very clear. She found a way back into Fromland but each time she went to the "wrong" date. When she arrived at the incorrect date, like we saw in her dream when the town was empty, she did "two" things: she marked the bottle tree with bottles and dates so she could locate the tree and indicate what date she arrived at the tree. She also wrote the dates on the light house wall to allow herself to remember what date she just left. She will "jump" from the light house over and over again until she gets the time right!!!!!!
tf makes no sense. That kid pushes her from lighthouse bro
@@I_am_DarthVaderyea but if she’d come back perhaps she’ll jump to go back
Hard to tell but in one of the flashbacks Victors mom is wearing a bracelet that looks like the one Tabitha claimed to be the one she made. Its really quick so it could just be a coincidence or is it? What if the time jumping idea works both ways? Tabitha gets out, ends up years before being in fromland, swipes the bracelet before getting back into fromland. Then starts doing what you're talking about, befriends Victor's mom gives her the bracelet. 🤷♂
I saw where da writers said da plots aren’t leaving dat supernatural world
I still think this is the world of IT... the scary place is FROM, the monsters are THEY and the EVIL is IT...also Stephen King is a consultant on the show.
This is one of the best and most realistic theories I’ve heard. Great job!
i have gone through hundreds of theories online but this one seems to be the most accurate and in every way it makes sense. Hats off to your hard work and analysis. After watching this video i realised i have got some of my questions answered and now i can sleep peacefully. Again a huge round of applause for your analysis.
I still think this is the world of IT... the scary place is FROM, the monsters are THEY and the EVIL is IT...also Stephen King is a consultant on the show.
Y'all, cut this poor guy a break. Theres no need to shame, or theory shame. He made a very thought provolking, provocative, and insightful video.
I, for one, very much appreciate your thoughtful theories. And appreciate the time and effort you put into developing them. Moreover, taking the risk of posting through a translator in a language not your own is brave. I applaud it!
If you're still in Ukraine, please stay safe. It has to be incredibly difficult there. I hope projects like these help 🙂
Thank you for sharing with us!
U right because a lot of things can be pieced together but more things can’t be
Victors mom is not tabby sister
wtf are you talking about? No one is giving him a hard time, stop trying to be a hero over nothing…
How is he not an English speaker? He doesn't sound like machine
@@ElizRued I agree. I thought he did brilliantly! Don't know if the horrid comments remain, but people were being incredibly cruel and hyper-critical of someone putting out a great video. He said in a response to some of those comments that he is Ukrainian and put the video together using a translator which I found impressive - to go through that added effort to express himself creatively, especially amidst such chaos and horrors as are occurring in his country. Hats off to him!
@@DrDeb2005 yeh cause I don’t care about his accent 😂
Yall get ur foot off my neck and da OG comment is her opinion damn 🤦🏾♂️ dis ain’t English class and mane cut dat out it’s da internet wha ya want a FN cookie
Tabitha made that bracelet from her father in law's bootlace, so she couldn't have come out of fromville with it as a child, because she didn't make it until she was an adult. It went missing when she gave birth though, so maybe her dead son brought it with him somehow?
It went missing when she gave birth to Julie, not Thomas.
Maybe the Boy In White is Tabitha's dead son...
@@jasoncaldwell5627 Then how was he already there when Victor was young? 😬 Interesting thought though!
Tabitha could have brought it out of fromville if she's Eloise
@@jadakissable9 Watch the new trailer- you'll see Tabitha wearing Victor's lunchbox (you only see the string strap, but it's obviously the lunchbox).
That tosses the simulation theories or the "they're all in comas" ideas.
My brand new favorite FROM breakdowns! This is a must watch for FROM fans who want some answers to the series! There’s nothing like this show!
Honestly please watch the Watchers movie 2024,all will b answered 🤯🤯🤯
@@kevinnicholas6721 oh yeah I’ve been wondering about that movie. It looks similar now that you say to watch it. Thank you now I’ll definitely check it out!
@@kevinnicholas6721what is it about??
Very nice and high quality video with From theories. I hope you will create something also about from.
I don't understand why people think Tabitha's reflection doesn't look like her.
You also have a scene with a family that resembles Boyd and his wife as an advertisement about a boat which is seen a lot through the series
After Tabitha woke up back in the real world (or what we assume to be the real world), I was wondering if everyone who dies in From-ville wakes up back in the real world. It'll be interesting to see whether or not Tabitha's body is found in From-ville in season 3.
That's what ive been saying too like boyds wife was saying when you die you leave so maybe her body is still there
I always enjoy your videos! Hoping you continue then for season 3!
Me too!
Why did Victors dad not ask about his daughter. Only asked about Victor. Why was he not more inquisitive. If Tabitha thought she was going back , why did she not bring back supplies. Like medicine, soap, cleaning supplies. Shampoo, i mean some laundry soap. I have questions.
I dont think she ever said she was trying to get back; she was trying to figure something out. even then why would that be the first on her mind when she doesn’t know where she is? And the dad thought all of them died tabitha only said victor was alive too
She didn't even know that she was going to fromville when she was in an ambulance. They were heading to the hospital and then she saw a tree on the road n all happened so fast.
I caught that too! The dad never mentioned a daughter. Alternate realities????
Very cool! Love your attention to details I was not sure about so far, I've watched the seasons twice. One person pointed out that the 8 trees on the talisman could also be a deconstructed spider web. Not impossible considering the spiders are a theme that haven't been discussed or connected in the show yet. But Ethan talks about spiders right off the bat when he wakes up in the RV and his leg is impaled. We only saw the spiders once in the forest, but maybe they are a bigger clue than what the writers have given us so far!
Based on what everyone’s saying about Tabitha. What if she’s really Victor’s sister that survived and escaped somehow. But over the years she forgot, I mean this would be very traumatic for anyone look at Victor . She meets Jim and makes him a bracelet similar to her mother’s. Jim loses it. The bracelet she finds in the town is not the one he lost but her mothers (just speculation idk, haven’t finished season 2 lol)
Best coherent theory so far!
This was very entertaining. So much information and great theories. Please continue with the new episodes. I subscribed just incase. Great job!
This is the most realistic theory I've heard. Thanks. If people would just talk!!!
Fantastic video! Earned a sub.
Your attention to detail and analysis is above all other that I've heard from the dozens of other videos I've watched on YT. I agree that this is likely a game being played by supernatural beings (as you mentioned in your second video), though I'm unsure if it is the 4 players you've mentioned or merely generic demons/evil entities.
At 22:10 you speak of the Dark Horse in the prayer circle, while there is a couple holding hands observing from "above"...just like the drawing on the cave wall.
I like the idea with the stones. Maybe they are mini maps as well as protection. They show the paths for the faraway trees to help the people there avoid mosters. Like a minimap and fast traveling in games
This is really good content. Good job!! U deserve a comment and a subscriber and u got one!! I love the show.
I just love this series❤❤❤
Would love to know your thoughts about why everything in the show is blue red or yellow. The clothing, the houses, the props, etc.
There is a theory that everything is connected from day, night and moon phase.
Great From videos. New subscriber. Looking forward to more! :-)
Maybe Tabatha is Eloise daughter
I noticed Nothing .. and I was so confused at the end of season 2 .. so grateful for your video ❤
The best breakdown thus far. Great work.
One thing, you say that there are three trees depicted but that there are 8 trees. The three trees depicted are the ones that have a set warp point, the others are all just random.
Excited for your season 3 videos!
Great video. I do agree we are being misled at times, I compare it to Jade's idea of a puzzle. That cavern is like an end piece in some ways. I think the town is in Michigan. There is a 1974 calendar in Trudy's room and the sponsor is Rendez-Vous. Boyd's family arrived with one in tow. Now owned by a Nova Scotia business, it started in Michigan. Someone on reddit mentioned seeing Creel Cola somewhere but couldn't find it on Google. Deeper dives and lateral thinking is important. I found a guy named Creelman who sold his beverage company, I think it was started in the 1930s, and they did make soda and the guy was in Michigan. We already have other connections in the show. Just something to pass on.
You have a lot of great stuff in this video. Much appreciated.
I know i am dumping too many comments i really wish i could make a theory video myself but i have some important exams in January
So couldn’t actually make one so i wish to share it with you your video seems more sensible to me . Well now here are some of my theories or bobservations:
1) that the scarecrows might have something to do with the man whom jade saw when he was in the snow , since he saw him nailed on the tree and was grabbing him it seems to me that he could be an evil entity , if u observe carefully when jade spots the guy we see one on the scarecrows too so i feel the makers might be dropping some hint here and my theory is that these scarecrows are actually some kind of witchcraft mediums like used to trap evil entities , so when jade pulled out the metal rods to rescue Kristy like he literally destroyed one of the scarecrows and idk if it is really the one that was shown in the scene when jade encounters the nailed guy but i think he actually undo the thing and let this guy escape so now its like he is unattached from the tree and u could clearly make out with that blood drink in skull things that his intentions aren’t any good.
2)the man in yellow : my theory is he could be Boyd and if we go by the reincarnation theory then he might be the previous version of Boyd like Tabitha also has same messages from fromville just like Miranda the same way the man in yellow from Miranda’s paintings could be someone like Boyd who was searching for answers .
3) the lake lady that elvin sees might be Miranda now don’t ask me why but it could be or maybe not
4) this is some observation from the scene where jade spots the nailed guy on so he first sees the red rocks in the snow i thought they might have blood on them so i keenly observed thinking that they might be a part of his hallucinations if u watch closely when jade walks near the second rock the red colour kinda shrinks from the bottom now idk what to make of this it could be an editing glitch or something else because the red stones still stay when the others from the group arrive for jades help .
5) we know from victors observations that the trees move so my theory here is that it could be that when the fromville allows a new guests from the outside world to enter ,the geography of the place like shifts or changes so Ig it changed the place again because the ambulance was to arrive in the town in season 3 .
6) another thing i observed that could be a potential hint that in the scene when Tabitha walks out of the confession box in the church in season 3 you can see some numbers on the church wall on the left side of the exit sign it shows 104 at top and 19. 20 at the bottom of it now i am not a Christian and idk if it actually means something in the church related to Christianity but to me it appears it might have to do something with the numbers on the lighthouse maybe as a hint idk maybe it could be a hint to something.
7) ok soooooooooo its now this ones kinda creepy we know that in the upcoming episode the ambulance carrying Tabitha and victors father enters fromville now this might be a future prediction in the series earlier when Tabitha is in the lighthouse hallucination there’s a toy ambulance and also the bottle from the bottle tree so i wonder if it was like the prediction of what happened after Tabitha was sent to the real world that her ambulance will come back to the fallen tree
That’s all for now i think i might put this up as a Reddit post if i have time with proper pictures and screenshots for reference i really wish you would give me a shoutout if u plan to put my theories in your next video .
8:34 Could it be that Victor made these drawings himself? If you look at the drawings in his room (you can look up Victor's Drawings on From Wiki) you can see he draws trees sometimes in the same way (the F looking shape).
Great video and you bring out so many things that are missed on the first or even second watch. Thank you! The Tabitha storyline is very interesting and I did not think about the possibility she could be Victors sister at all, but it is very likely. Especially when Victors mother had the same bracelet - it can not be a coincidence. Also, I have to watch again the last episode - I totally missed that the reflection of her in the hospital is different.
Another thing you mentioned - Tilly. Tbh She did seem a bit questionable from the start. At one point she seemed like the necessary mother figure, that was previously Donna, but someone here mentioned she has SEVEN grandchildren?! That makes you wonder... Telling Fatima that she is pregnant actually is not so special - for some women, there are some common small symptoms or things we do, when we are pregnant and actually no one who has been pregnant will understand these or if you do not put your attention on the person. But still, she is very questionable!
Thanks again!
Another show where all the fan theories are gonna turn out to be 100X better than what we will get because the writers have absolutely 0 answers to their own show and are just making it up as they go 😂
What about the stacks of stones Tabitha sees in the cave and later Ethan builds on their porch? Could that have been a symbol for the tower/lighthouse?
wow true. it could.
I think it feeds on fear and despair and hate happiness and hope.
I didn’t finish season 2 yet but it’s good to have a knowledge about a series I’m watching. I was thinking that maybe everyone was in a coma but then towards the ending explanation that probably wouldn’t have been the case. But it would be kinda cool concept that there in a coma and the monsters are death and one they take u then u die in the real world.
I saw this video the other day and heard you speak of Tillie's prayer as being strange, unheard of before, and I laughed and laughed and laughed because EVERYBODY has heard Psalm 23 before. It's quoted so commonly that Coolio included it in his biggest song, "Gangsta's Paradise." How have you not heard it? 😂😂😂
You said almost word for word what I said to my son. Anyone who has ever been to a funeral received a card for the person who died. With what verse on it? 23rd Psalm.
I am astonished and saddened that he didn't know this. I think I would have Googled the words before saying there was a strange and unrecognizable prayer being spoken.
When I started quoting it to my son, who's agnostic, he recognized immediately that it was lyrics from Coolio's song. 😂😂😂
This video was very well made!
I think Tilly is just enjoying her life because she has a terminal illness so she’s just happy everyday. But you know what I thought about people had to have been able to leave the town come and go as they please because there is the post office why build a post office someone has to deliver the mail come and go so people had to have been able to leave at a time. Also I strongly believe those creatures are vampires. You know vampires from long ago looked identical to those creature the similarities are there. I didn’t even notice the reflection of a person when Tabitha looked out the hospital window.
These are the producers from the hit series LOST and that series was amazing same situation people stranded in a place they couldn’t escape and Boyd was part of that series as well trying to find a way out and strange things happened on LOST all the time.
Like all other series if it runs for a long time the stories will become sillier and siller every season like Under the Dome or even Lost, the ending of which made us all unsatisfied. I hope they don't run for too long
At 7:48 you see the woman walking up the stairs there lays a playing card the eight of clubs probably hinting to there being eight trees.
Subbing. Best theory video ive seen about my favorite show.
The 2 cards on the lighthouse staircase were the 8 of clubs and 2 of hearts. Matching numbers😊
matching to what?
@@anatolyalekseev101 It was actually a 4 of hearts. So, absolutely no matches!
I really like this one, the idea that Tabitha is actually Eloise makes so much sense to me
So looking forward towards your season 3 theories! Do you have a timeframe? Love your video concepts! 🎉
Excellent video and theory. I did have to watch on 0.75 speed lol but solid vid!! Easy sub. Hey all, sub.
im new in to the show but the dates Here’s a breakdown of whether solar eclipses occurred in the years you listed:
1506 - Partial eclipse in Europe.
1609 - No significant solar eclipse.
1672 - Total eclipse visible in Europe.
1752 - Total eclipse visible in northern Europe.
1773 - Annular eclipse in South America.
1864 - Annular eclipse visible in the U.S. and South America.
1888 - Total eclipse in the Pacific and Australia.
1931 - Annular eclipse visible in parts of Asia and the Pacific.
1978 - Partial eclipse visible in North America.
and October 14, 2023 - An annular solar eclipse, where the moon covers the center of the sun, leaving a "ring of fire."
April 8, 2024 - A total solar eclipse, where the moon completely blocks the sun, casting a shadow across parts of the U.S., including Texas, Ohio, and New York.
so that mite be it
15:24 That part where Julia recognized the young man made no sense because later on we learn that her brother died when he was a baby. So I also originally thought that this must have been her brother. But how would she recognize him as an adult when he died as a baby? Some of these things seem more connected to a child 's vision of what monsters are. I noticed that spiders didn't appear until the little boy mentioned them. So is this Julia's vision of what her brother would have looked like had he lived and she saw it in a dream? Because dreams seem to have a big impact in this world.
this video is so good! so much i didnt know! cant wait for season 3!!
I think getting home might not be possible but if you save the original children the place becomes safer
When that grandman starts the prayer with the people I though she was about to start rapping Gangsters Paradise lol
Exactly!! I was wondering if this line was a part of Bible or something, is it?
I think the house on far right of drawings underground is the colony house and the crops
great job
1:42 the reflection…wtf I did not see that.
Awesome analysis man!!
Appreciate the efforts
thank you
the s3 trailer line 'the forest feeds on hope not fear' will be the key to everything
think we discover a group/cult thats been in the 'woods dimension' happily/getting 4 seasons a yr etc cuz they gave up on hope/accepted this new life that they can live happily
and everyone who got taken to Fromland was for this reason, but some got taken along cuz they were in the car etc (never heard of a group coming on on a bus and only SOME of them ending up in Fromland and some not making it 'through' - it seems kind of all or nothing so obv innocent kids could poss be given a chance to go back...im also curious how time passes irl when theyre in fromland....
But i think they'll be better off in this idealized fromworld where they're safe and provided for by nature etc and maybe, to twist the knife - while the real/tabitha world will fall into a pandemic/ww3/catastrophic natural event etc
Very well explained ❤
I learned so much from this video, this was very well made.
Boyd and Sarah saw a light house when they were in the woods. If Victor took everyone to the light house, they could have escape
This is the best breakdown so far. You are not all over the place.
I regret watching this serie especially after Kenny's mom incident 😢 that shit left me sobbing 😭
Regarding the spiderwebs in the forest. When I looked at it from high angles / wide shots. I could see the spiderwebs were only in a narrow path / corridor that Boyd walked through. While only a little to the side, the trees of the forest was clear.
I didn't see any good shots in this video of yours, but you could still notice it, if you pause at 25:30, you can see the trees in the background to the right doesn't have any spiderwebs on them.
We never saw what Randall was carving on top of the bus.
I'm guessing he carved himself a Talisman to see if it'd work like the stone version.
We never saw what happened with that, did we?
The people in boats are obviously on a river. You can see the black curvy lines right there that make the river banks. The symbols (which I think you are right, might represent trees) and the triangles (which might be regular trees) are on either side of those curvy lines - like a forest on either side of a river. Maybe the first people that got here did so by boat. Either way the drawing is showing people on water in boats.
Also, I don't think that building on the cave wall is the light house - it's the church. And there's more than the three places you get to in the trees. At least one tree puts you in a shaft inside an alternate dimension you can only get back to with a torch.
When Tabitha went up the tower, I think what she was was the real world. That tower is like a portal to the real world.
God bless it's only in Murica
Why don't they move the tree and see where the road will take them
just finished S3, i'll come back here in 2026
Best not to do a puzzle without all the pieces
Also i think that some trees are simply portals that are connected to a place in the same timeline or dimension but the other ones like the one boid went through are the ones that can make u timetravel
What is that song by the end of the video?
I've been looking for it too can't shazam it either 😂
Baba yaga-Phillip Lackovic
@@miguelorta1159 bro your God sent thank you now I got a song when I gotta lean forward in my videogames
@Gaze4u what is the music in the summary? i like it
y2mate.com - Atlantis Audionautix
great video bro, you explained it very well
Heres a comment someone else posted that ive expanded on and i fully believe it was the core inspirstions for the shows concept
"It's Carcosa, more closely, the Dreamlands from Lovecraft and Eldrich lore. Symbol is that of Atlach Nacha, evil spider god that links dimensions. The walkers are ghouls, and Hastur is the big bad controlling the entire realm."
Hastur per the original writings was know as the king in yellow.
We see so many uses of the color yellow in the show. Even certain scenes filmed with a yellow filter.
We see a painting of a man in a yellow suit in the basement.
Atlach nacha was a spider god that "resides in a cave system and it spins a great web, forming a great bridge between the Dreamlands and the waking world."
"Thomas" also appears in the pub when the girl is nailed to the tree. It's the guy Julie saw on the porch.
Christopher is the biggest antagonist we have yet to hear from... The little boy was likely him
I ran the dates through ai, and don't know if they are connected to the story in the show, but: 1506: While not directly related to U.S. history, Christopher Columbus, who opened the way for European exploration of the Americas, died in this year.
1609: Henry Hudson explored parts of North America, including the river that would later bear his name.
1672: The first recorded monthly Quaker meeting in the U.S. was held in Sandwich, Massachusetts.
1752: Benjamin Franklin conducted his famous kite experiment, proving that lightning is a form of electricity.
1773: The Boston Tea Party, a pivotal event leading up to the American Revolution, took place.
1864: Significant events during the American Civil War, including General Ulysses S. Grant being put in command of all Union forces.
1883: The Brooklyn Bridge opened, a marvel of engineering at the time.
1931: The Empire State Building opened, and “The Star-Spangled Banner” was adopted as the U.S. national anthem.
1978: The Camp David Accords began, leading to a peace agreement between Egypt and Israel.
Quaker meeting and Camp David Accords seem the odd ones that don't seem to be relatable to the thematics of the show.
22:05 How is the prayer "quite strange"? It's one of the most recognizable psalms from the bible. Psalms 23;4 "though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I shall fear no evil, for thou are with me." Never saw Pulp Fiction? 😅
Great video. Are you doing S3 vids?
Am I the only person who this series gave him the vibes of "Tales from a lonely broadcast station"?
Damn man, thats really intresting. Did u figure all this on your own?
The road drawn in black is a river.
17:02 does the symbol on the computer screen look similar to the symbol jade sees? Or is it just me
what is name of song used in 25:12
So. When Victor told Jade that this is his home. It really was a town before something took over it?
I like some of the suff you say but it really bothers me when you state things so factually when in fact we don't know much.
Here are some:
1. How do we know this was ever a normal town? Victor showed Tabatha the car his family arrived him so he is not a 'local'. We don't know how the monsters form is decided, are they past victims? If the town already existed then that doesn't explain the electricity/vires leading no where.
2. How do know what attacked Boyds tent? Could've been a massive spider for all we know.
3. They have the same puppet at the colony house. That might have been why Victor was so freaked out.
4. Tabatha stated that she made the braclet from Jim's late fathers boots. So the bracelet is still very confusing if Victor mom had it because it's made from something that belonged to Jims father.
5. We don't know if they tried to kill the monster any other way. Even Boyd hid for years. The only reason he finnaly attacked the monster was so that he could safely pass on what Maritin gave him without killing anyone else, and after that save his sons life. The reason why the monsters are so dried up (as well as Smileys organs when they open him up) could be because of the sun/day.
For all we know the monsters just enjoy slowburn torture as it was stated in the show ("they know that they will get you eventually"), this could be the reason why they don't run, and if they don't need to eat to stay alive theres no reason to rush the killing, it's all about the suffering (perhaps to feed the forrest?). They also know that eventually everyone in town will be murdered like in Vicors childhood.
6. Tilly is very sus but then again she's also dying, maybe she's just happy to be along for the ride as long as it may last. My theory is that she somehow knows about this place and chose to go there in order to extend her life (Fatimas infertility is gone, Boyd's parkinsons, Ethans leg heald in like 5 days.)
7. The time in the real world and Fromville is connected, we know this because of the medic and her fiancee, also Victor aged. That would mean that if Tabatha keeps swiching dimensions she would still age. I think this is her first time experiencing Fromville and escaping it.
So if running or not is simply thier choice then you're saying if they feels like it they could just chase thier victims at full speed, even thinking about that is giving me chills.
I think the about tress being the attackers makes more sense since it's been told to us from season 1 that they're not immobile, they are changing places so maybe forest has a life of it's own and seeing boyd reaching close to the tower made it anxious coz we know boyd is savior type if he managed to find an escape he'll take everyone with him and forest doesn't want that coz it survives of off thier fear and hope.
@@ashukalawat5230 those things running would be horrifying. But they left that girl with the nail through her head alive just to torture her and the townsfolk. And they seem to be pretty speedy when S1 little girl opened the window. So they probably like to take it slow to see the fear in their eyes as they aproach.
I could be the forrest but it seems too fast for me, the spiders make more sense imo. What Victor is observing might be the change in landscape including the forrest. The forrest itself might not be special at all, for example, when Tabatha found the cave under her house, the house colappsed. Which means the whole town has a life of its own. When Jim built the antena, the storm came, the season changed. The forrest is not magical, everything is magical.
The tower is the pistol of the flower; allowing a jump over its petals. Within this flesh eating flower it deals with its own pests. Spiders and bugs that wither and eat its leaves.
Cant wait till all is revealed.
I mean Tilly is dying, she is living her remaing life and being happy dancing in the rain. Some people can actually tell when women are pregnant.
Tilly is weird and is very possibly the monster grandmother. she is too calm and happy to be normal. Strangers don't usually declare a pregnancy.That is something that happens within a close relationship. I think Tilly can sense/smell the baby and she wants to take it because if children are the normal sacrifice a baby must be a bonus sacrifice. I also think there is more to Kristy's girlfriend appearing in the town. I also think that it matters that Tilly is the one that donated the morphine that she stole, which fits with the nursery rhyme. Somehow, all these people are connected to the monsters.
Maybe you are right and we are too suspicious )
Maybe the lighthouse is the 8th portal 🤔💛.
19 : 17
Ethan mentioned that there is sth like dragon cave . Where they keep things of people who passed away
Also the people come across a tree. Its not the same tree each time. I don't know if its important but its not the same tree.
Whoa you broke it down sooooo good
15:30 In cast Q&As the director said its about the characters story and not the mystery so i doubt all the characters will die except ethan. Im pretty sure season we will meet what is controlling the monsters i hope
I think Tabitha will turn out to the the author of the Crominicle book.
Just a theory, what if tilly is da grandmother of the lil gurl in da very 1st season ep 1 & she opend the window thinking it was her but once she realized she said u dont look like my grandmother , but it was too late 😢 sb let me kno if im wrong ❤
Very wrong
@@STNRsports uhh 🙄 Thnk u for really telling me ….
Do you think the talismans work because of what is etched on them, what they’re made from or both?