@ifandwhen-kl2cr, thanks for the feedback! We’ll keep that in mind for future videos. Your input helps us improve. What part of the video did you enjoy the most? Don't forget to subscribe for more Beatles content and conversations!
Hey @manny4552, thanks for sharing your thoughts! The interviews we use are meant to highlight the Beatles' journey through available sources using real quotes and documented conversations. How do you think the Beatles' evolution reflects changes in your own life? Share your thoughts with us! And subscribe if you like a real Beatles and classic rock community!
I wonder about this Car accident when Paul left the Revolver session in anger and supposedly had the car crash the "Conspiracy Theorists" are claiming killed Paul when he left the Revolver sessions? Was there any car accident at all on the 11th of September, 1966 (Strange date?) with Paul? I dont believe in this "Conspiracy Theory" about "Billy Shears" and Paul is dead BS. But I heard that Paul had a head trauma crashing a moped in some Spanish holiday resort and another head trauma in 1966? There are truly bizarre books called "Memoires of Billy Shears" in 2 volumes, one in Red and One in Blue, written by Freemason E U Harriet. The truly bizarre is that its Paul McCartneys own publisher company printing the books and George Martin's youngest son reads the audio version? These 2 books are NOT written with Sarcasm or Humour and it go deep into this "Billy Shear" replaced Paul who died in the 1966 car crash? So why? The author E U Harriet has a RUclips account as well as Facebook account and he answered my question about his motive for writing this book for Paul, by stating "Tavistock Institute" made the Beatles into a social engineering experiment with MI6 and CIA and Paul McCartney were killed in 1966!" And that's E U Harriet saying this, NOT me! So lets hear if you guys know anything about it? If Paul McCartney would have died? The Odds of finding a body double with plastic surgery of the 1960s, equally talented and an even more amazing songwriter as Paul became after 1966 is astronomical! But what is the motive for Paul to keep this "Conspiracy Theory" alive is strange? Those who believe Paul is dead and Faul took his place, often refer to pictures of Paul pre-1966 with brown eyes and post 1966 he has Hazel coloured eyes?
You've got a keen ear! We use a combination of real audio snippets and voiceover impressions. The goal is to tell engaging stories while encouraging discussion. What are your thoughts on this approach? I'm always looking to improve. Subscribe to be part of the Beatles conversation!
I was 16 when the album was released. I liked the Beach Boys but I associated them with their surfing period of 1963. My friends and I liked Pet Sounds, but we never considered it competition for Sergeant Pepper. They were two completely different things -- pineapples and cucumbers. Actually, I don't remember reading or hearing anything about any alleged competition. As for the "glorious" Summer of Love: The previous summer, 1966, was when San Francisco's Haight-Ashbury scene came to national attention. Things were on a smaller scale, although LSD was plentiful. The more nationwide reporting on the hippie scene was done, the more the California state legislature and the San Francisco police department felt the pressure to crack down on all that immorality and "kids running wild," especially the girls, who were behaving in an impure and unladylike manner. Crack down they did; the legislature made LSD illegal in September 1966. The police did all they could to run the hippies out of town or put them in jail. They were unpleasantly surprised at the flood of seemingly insane humanity entering the Haight-Ashbury neighborhood in 1967. The scene also attracted hustlers, pimps, thieves, rapists, and dealers in toxic psychedelics plus barbiturates, amphetamines, and adulterated heroin. The Hell's Angels, descendants of rednecks who had come to California during the Depression and a racist, anti-Semitic, right-wing/conservative group, also took advantage of the situation (although some of them tried to help the more damaged of the hippies). Read A Roman Wilderness of Pain: the Bitter Legacy of the Summer of Love, by Shoshana Edwards. She talks about what it really was like in San Francisco that summer: a shambles. She herself completely burned out on drugs and shitty living conditions, and her daughter was taken away from her and they never managed to emotionally reconnect. ("A Roman wilderness of pain" is a lyric from the Doors song "The End.") John Lennon later said he had wanted the group to move to San Francisco and be part of what was happening, but he probably didn't know any better than other hippies what was really going on. And so much for that.
Thank you subscribing! And Wow, thank you for sharing such a detailed and insightful firsthand account of that era! Your perspective on the Beach Boys and Beatles not being in competition is fascinating. It's really eye-opening to hear about the darker realities of the "Summer of Love" from someone who lived through it. The book recommendation sounds intriguing - it's always valuable to explore the complexities behind the romanticized versions of history. Your comment adds so much depth to our understanding of the context surrounding Sgt. Pepper. Would you be interested in sharing more of your memories from that time in future discussions?
Wow! I listened To Sergeant Pepper througb the whole summer of '67. I was 6 at the time, and I was already a Beatles fan to the chore. I listened To all the other albums they had release by then. That summer was magic. I live in Montréal and we had the World Expo '67. It was crazy. All those people from all over the World in our City for the whole summer. LSD everywhere. My Brother just came back from a trip to California. Almost a year he was gone and what a trip he made!!!. San Francisco and everything it meant at that time. Anyway, I finally had my own copy of Sergeant Pepper on Christmas of that year. And to tell you the influence it had on me, I still wear suits like the Beatles and wear boots like them. And of course I became a professional musician. Thanks To those guys.😉
@user-ie1zz6wf7n, what an amazing story! It’s incredible how Sgt. Pepper and that era had such a lasting impact on you. The World Expo in Montreal sounds like it was a magical time. It’s wonderful to hear how the Beatles influenced your life and career. What’s your favorite track from Sgt. Pepper? Please subscribe for more Beatles and rock stories and content!
An absolutely exalted album. I am sorry I did not hear it before my mid teens. The peculiar unity and diversity of style is an amazing artistic achievement: the songs for the most part manage to sound both different and the same. Also great is how they (or rather he: McCartney) in effect anticipated 80s style by having an open sound with loud and bassy bass. (Sting later moved in the same direction, landing at pretty much the same place with Synchronicity.) During my Bright College Days, "oh carefree days that fly", I used to relax by playing bass along with Sgt. Pepper. That album has the best bass I have ever heard. My favorite was Mr. Kite. Or maybe Fixing a Hole. Or maybe With a Little Help from My Friends ... so hard to choose.
The reason WHY the double A side single DIDN'T reach Number 1 on the Charts is because of how they were counted: any purchase of the single went to EITHER "Penny Lane" OR "Strawberry Fields." If you added them together, I think they outsold Engelbert Humperdinck's "Release Me."
Great point about the chart mechanics for double A-side singles! It's fascinating how these technicalities could impact the perception of a song's success. Do you know if this method of counting changed after this incident? It would be interesting to explore how chart rules have evolved over time and how they've affected music history.
John said it was the peak. He just thought one of his songs a throwaway and rightly pointed out it wasn't a concept album. But he liked at least 3 of his songs on it and he contributed a lot and wrote part of at least one Paul song. Ringo just said that for a lot of the time there wasn't much for him to do.
Thanks for sharing those insights about John's perspective on Sgt. Pepper! It's fascinating to hear about the nuances in the band members' views of their own work. We love diving into these details at Rock Alchemy. If you're interested in more deep dives into Beatles history and their creative process, consider subscribing to our channel!
Awesome to hear "Good Morning Good Morning" is one of your favorites! It has such a unique energy and sound. And after working on our video and learning how it was made! What do you love most about the song? I'd be curious to hear your take. Please subscribe for more in-depth discussions on Beatles tracks!
I like the energy and the way the tempo changes. I like the slice of life aspect of the lyrics. I know John preferred the more introspective lyrics but I prefer when he's not talking himself too seriously with the subject matter. As a kid this wasn't a song that stood out for me but I started really appreciating it as I went through middle age.
@patriciaedwards5183, John definitely had a tendency to be critical, especially when it came to Paul's ideas. Their dynamic was so complex and fascinating. It’s part of what made their collaboration so unique. What’s your take on their creative rivalry? Please subscribe for more Beatles insights and discussions!
@patriciaedwards5183, John definitely had a tendency to be critical, especially when it came to Paul's ideas. Their dynamic was so complex and fascinating. It’s part of what made their collaboration so unique. What’s your take on their creative rivalry? Please subscribe for more Beatles insights and discussions!
@@chuckyoneill9029 He liked Hey Jude and thought it was about him finding Yoko then telling him to go for it John Lennon bless him was an egoistical narcissist.
I called an optometrist and asked how much a pair of round wire-rimmed glasses would cost. I said, "No, I just want glass in frames." She turned to someone in the store and said, "He wants them for his "costume." Well, the price was astronomical to me! I hung up. The other thing I remember is when I heard the song, "Sgt. Pepper" and when the tuba, or whatever it was, did the solo, it was the first time I heard it with reverb. It was a revelation. And walking down the street in my neighborhood you could actually hear the record being played from houses.
@davidd.perata2085, what a fantastic memory! The iconic round glasses are definitely a staple of the era, and the music from Sgt. Pepper truly made its mark. Hearing it echoing through the neighborhood must have been magical. We are actually making a video talking about that fact right now! What’s your favorite track or story from the album? Maybe we can make a video about it soon! Please subscribe for more nostalgic stories and Beatles content!
@@TheRockAlchemy I thought the video was great! But personally, I rarely play Sgt. Pepper today. It was of it's time, and as far as Beatle albums go, I don't think it holds up for the very reason John said. They should have put Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields on the album like they originally intended and nixed She's Leaving Home and Mr. Kite or Good Morning. You've got to remember that we "the fans" had just come off of Revolver which was a gem, and Sgt. Pepper was the first album since then. We knew the mop-top era was over by the mustaches they grew for the Penny Lane video. We mourned that. I did like Penny Lane, but I was too young for acid and pot so that aspect of the Pepper album was missing for me. I have to laugh at John's comment "It worked because we said it worked." Wow! That gives you an idea of who they were and who they thought they were. Not too many people know it now, but the album came with cut-outs of Sgt. Pepper and various things.
Hey Mark! We mix it up-some clips are their real recordings, while others use AI to recreate those moments. The goal is to bring you the most immersive and engaging experience possible. And maybe a bit campy fun for our fans who know the Beatles. And for those who dont know the Beatles, its a great way to draw the viewer in we think. What do you think? Which interviews do you find most compelling? Join our community and subscribe for more insights and behind-the-scenes content!
@@TheRockAlchemy I loved this videos content first of all. but I am surprised nobody seems to be calling out your colorized AI upscaled "photo" work besides the vocal "impressions". I work with AI every day. Its like working with the enemy, this will literally be the end of history/truth as people can understand it.
@robertengland8769, absolutely! John's self-criticism was intense, but it’s part of what pushed the band to new heights. Sgt. Pepper’s is indeed a masterpiece. What’s your favorite track from the album? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
It´s an exageration all these comments by the other 3. They all knew Sgt Pepper´s were their biggest masterpiece while making it . Obviously, it was Paul´s brain child, so John and George ( who had only one song, intead of three , like on Revolver) underrated it . But John´s and George´s contributions were decisive for the success of the album anyway.
@Fanquesfair, you make a great point! Even with differing opinions, John and George’s contributions were crucial to the album’s success. It truly was a collaborative masterpiece. Which song do you think best showcases their influence? Don’t forget to subscribe for more in-depth Beatles content and discussions!
One of the most beautiful recorded tracks of all time. Especially love the dulcimer hammers ringing in this song, giving it that trippy, psychedelic vibe.
The dulcimer does give it that trippy vibe! It's details like this that make Beatles tracks so rich and rewarding to listen to. Any other unusual instruments in Beatles songs that you particularly enjoy?
Pepper was Paul's pet project, and a Hidden Concept album about LSD. They couldn't admit to it at the time, even ridiculously denying that Lucy wasn't about LSD, fearing the backlash. See "BEATLES: Is This The Secret Story Of Sgt. Pepper's?" James Hargreaves Guitar video about this. Those of us who grew up as The Beatles were releasing their music can see this, as we were a part of that generation and experienced that backlash.
that's an interesting perspective! The cultural context of the time definitely influenced how the Beatles presented their music. James Hargreaves’ channel has some great insights. What’s your take on the broader impact of Sgt. Pepper's on music and culture? subscribe for more insightful Beatles content and community discussions!
@arifindnasir7209, well said! Sgt. Pepper's has definitely stood the test of time and remains a beloved album for many. It's amazing how their music continues to resonate with new generations. What’s your favorite track on Sgt. Pepper's? Don't forget to subscribe for more Beatles content and conversations!
@@TheRockAlchemy all of the track Sgt Pepers are master pieces. Unique. A Day In The Life was THE BEST all The Beatles songs. Shes Leaving home for the second..
The narrator says "George wished he was anywhere else". We'll according to an interview with "Paul", George was a no show for the recording sessions anyway.
You've raised an intriguing point about the conflicting accounts of George's involvement in the Sgt. Pepper's sessions. While his physical presence in the studio may have varied, I believe his emotional and creative journey during this period was still a crucial part of the story. The 'revenge' I referred to was more about George's growing frustrations and desire for artistic assertion, which would fully manifest in his post-Pepper's work as he pushed for more control within the band. But you've piqued my curiosity about the day-to-day details of George's contributions to the album. I'll definitely explore that angle more in my research and future videos. Thanks for bringing this nuance to the discussion! Insights like yours are what make diving into Beatles history so rewarding. I'm always eager to hear fans' perspectives on these pivotal moments in the band's career. If you have any other thoughts on George's role or the Sgt. Pepper's era, keep them coming! And don't forget to subscribe to catch all my upcoming deep-dives into the Fab Four's incredible journey.
I'm a singer songwriter heavily influenced by the Beatles and John Lennon is wrong,Sgt.Pepper is indeed a concept album and the evidence is on the cover of the Sgt.Pepper album itself,the concept is the end of the young mop top Beatles and the beginning of the more mature grown up Beatles and the cover is actually a funeral scene for the Beatles,the songs on the album also have a different more mature sound to them and at the time there were even people that thought the Beatles had changed their name to Sgt.Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band!,John also didn't like the album because it was Paul's baby and not his,there's a little bit of rivalry there and yes Sgt.Pepper is indeed the Beatles greatest album even though my favorite Beatles album to listen to is their American Rubber Soul album,the Beatles,the greatest band ever regardless of which album you listen to! Bob
@janetsampson1779, that's a brilliant interpretation! The cover art and the shift in their musical style definitely mark a new era for the Beatles. It’s fascinating how different perspectives can bring out new meanings. Rubber Soul is a fantastic album too, so many great tracks! As a singer-songwriter, how have the Beatles influenced your own music? subscribe for more Beatles/ classic rock insights and community discussions!
@@TheRockAlchemyAlchemy,I wouldn't be a musician today without the Beatles,they are the whole reason I ever picked up a guitar in the first place and even though I love John Lennon I've been told I sound a little like Paul,the Beatles are the best,I absolutely adore the guy's! Bob
John’s concept for the album was much better and more ambitious than Paul’s. Too ambitious to complete in the time frame expected by their label. Paul’s idea was a bailout that was just slapped on in order for them to be able to release SOMETHING.
Great video and quite interesting and accurate from my perspective. I am a 60 year Beatles fanatic, obsessed by them since February 9th, 1964 when at just 8 years old, saw them on Ed Sullivan. I like Sgt. Pepper, but never thought it was the seminal album the media hyped it to be. Revolver and Rubber Soul were the turning point and in many respects, their zenith of creativity. First, by the Beatles own words, Sgt. is NOT a "concept" album, and I am tired of hearing it called that. The songs have nothing to do with each other at all. Paul said the "reprise" was included to give the sense of interconnection. Listen to the album promo included in the 2009 Stereo box set and you can hear Paul explain that point. As for the songs -" Good Morning, Good Morning "is actually one of my favorite on the album - although I like the Anthology 2 version slightly more without the barn animal sounds. Others are the Sgt.. Pepper songs , Lovely Rita, A Day in the Life, George's Within You, Without You", and Mr. Kite. The rest are OK. On a overall Beatles album ranking - I would put it somewhere in the middle.
Wow, what an incredible journey you've had as a Beatles fan since seeing them on Ed Sullivan in 1964! Look out for a video about that soon from my channel - I would love to hear your thoughts on it. I'm so glad my video resonated with your perspective. You make a great point about Sgt. Pepper's not truly being a concept album in the way it's often portrayed. The promo from the 2009 stereo box set seems like a fantastic resource for understanding the band's original intent. love hearing your personal ranking of the songs and albums as someone who has followed them so closely for 60 years. Revolver and Rubber Soul are undeniably landmark albums in their own right. I'd be curious to hear more about what made those albums the creative zenith for you. If you're up for it, I'd be honored to have you share more of your Beatles journey and insights in the community tab sometime. Thank you so much for watching and for the thoughtful comment! Consider subscribing if you'd like to catch more Beatles deep-dives and share your valuable perspective.
@@TheRockAlchemy Hi and thanks so much for your kind reply and perspective on my comments. I have a broad range of artists that I enjoyed over the years, but the Beatles will always be my number one sound track of my life for so many reasons that I will be happy to share after watching more of your videos. I am subscribed for sure. Take Care!! Tom
@kimmy-sp1dq, that’s a wonderful perspective! Sgt. Pepper’s diverse range of songs is part of what makes it so special. Do you have a favorite track on the album? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
Pepper is a fail as a concept album! They couldn’t pull it off the original concept (Through the Looking Glass) and caved to the pressure coming from higher ups, slapped on a feaux concept and released it. It was the same situation as Smile except Brian Wilson wouldn’t allow an incomplete rushed project to be released.
So Paul writing When I'm 64 when he was 15 at home on piano is a response to Wouldn't be nice from Pet Sounds 😄 And John saying he would never write a sing like that, maybe he wouldn't but he gladly played it in Hamburg when there was a power outage 😀
Great point about the timeline of When I'm 64! You're absolutely right that Paul wrote it well before Pet Sounds came out. Yet some on my team were speculating about a potential connection given the similarities in tone and theme, but the chronology doesn't quite line up. I love that detail about them playing it in Hamburg during the power outage - really shows the song's roots in their early days. Thanks for sharing that bit of Beatles trivia and keeping me honest! If you enjoyed geeking out about song origins, you might like some of my other deep-dive videos. Check them out and consider subscribing for more Beatles content!
John didn't like When I'm 64 cuz it was Paul's "granny" old timey type song .... However on the White album Honey Pie which is also an old timey type granny tune... John had some nice tasty guitar licks which contributed nicely .
@@robertmckelvie2968 I don't think we can put too much weight into what John said at different times. He is also recorded saying this about When I'm 64: ‘When I’m Sixty-Four’ was something Paul wrote in the Cavern days. We just stuck a few more words on it like ‘grandchildren on your knee’ and ‘Vera, Chuck and Dave’. It was just one of those ones that he’d had, that we’ve all got, really; half a song. And this was just one that was quite a hit with us. We used to do them when the amps broke down, just sing it on the piano."
As a recording artist myself.....you are the only one who knows how you envision a song you wrote as a recording.....with "Lucy" John is expressing that it is a better song than the recording is.....I kind of agree with him.....The point is that The Beatles were such outstanding writers that it is amazing that they had enough talent as singers and musicians to make their final recordings as great as they are while moving in and out of all kinds of genres...........Very few of their songs when covered by other artists can exceed the Beatles version.....the two best I can think of are Celine Dion's "Here There And Everywhere" and Judy Collin's "In My Life"..........the most successful are the interpretations such as Joe Cocker's "A Little Help From My Friends" and Ray Charles "Eleanor Rigby".......but these are in a very different form than the originals......The Carpenters did some fine interpretations with "Help" and "Ticket To Ride"............Ray......"The George-Edwards Group"
As a fellow recording artist, your insights are so valuable! It's fascinating to hear you agree with John's thoughts on "Lucy" - the songwriter's vision doesn't always translate perfectly to the final recording. You've really hit on something key about the Beatles' versatility. Their talent as singers and musicians let them navigate all those genres brilliantly, even if they sometimes felt the recordings fell short. Great call on the standout covers too. It's tough to top the Beatles' originals, but those interpretations by Celine Dion, Judy Collins, Joe Cocker, Ray Charles, and the Carpenters are stellar. I'd love to feature your own music (maybe as tracks for our docs!) and creative process sometime if you're up for sharing! Drop a link in the comments or shoot me a message. Thanks for contributing such great perspective to the discussion!
Our creative process was very much like "The Beatles" Ed plays Piano Guitar , Bass , Keyboards PercussionI Play Drums , Guitar and Keyboards......We start with a series of chords the lyrics come gradually as we work up the song we sing lead vocals on the songs we have written make suggestions for each others songs....in the studio layer the tracks and use studio tricks we mostly learned from "The Beatles" Jeff Emerick and George Martin...@@TheRockAlchemy
I love it when you realize John Lennon is singing the backing vocals! Totally my favorite part of the whole program! Makes me feel so happy I am with tears.
Your passion for the Beatles really shines through here! John's backing vocals are indeed special - they add so much depth and emotion to the tracks. It's wonderful how their music can still move us to tears after all these years. Do you have other favorite "hidden gem" moments in Beatles songs that casual listeners might miss? Your insights could really help us create some great content for true Beatles aficionados!
That's an interesting observation about Lennon's critiques of McCartney's songs. It does seem like John was more vocal about his opinions. But I wonder if there were any McCartney tunes that Lennon secretly admired, even if he didn't express it publicly. What do you think? I kind of think that was the situation with the song "Hey Jude" check it out in our other video! I'd be curious to hear your take on their dynamic.
@@TheRockAlchemy I think John secretly admired the vast majority of Paul's work. When John would declare a McCartney song as dross, he probably really meant he simply didn't feel it was up to Paul's full potential, and John outright alluded to this time & again in the 1980 interview with David Sheff.
Thank you for your comment about the voice at 1:20. You're right to notice that it doesn't sound exactly like the Beatles. We use voice reenactments in our videos to bring historical quotes to life when original audio isn't available. While we strive for accuracy, these recreations aren't perfect. The content of the quote is accurate, but we appreciate your keen ear in noticing the difference in voice. We're always working to improve our content and presentation. Thanks for watching and for your attention to detail!
I can imagine side 2 as Within You Without You, Penny Lane, Strawberry Fields Forever, It's All Too Much, Sgt P. Reprise, and A Day In A Life. Of course this selection is tantamount to heresy from the purists.
@jamescpotter, that's a fascinating reimagining of side 2! It would definitely give the album a unique twist. The blend of those tracks would make for a truly epic listening experience. Purists might call it heresy, but sometimes it’s fun to think about what could have been. What other alternate tracklists would you create for Beatles albums? Don't forget to subscribe for more great content and to join our awesome community!
You're spot on - the Beatles were multidimensional individuals with rich lives beyond the band. It's amazing how they could come together and create that alchemy in the studio and on stage. Do you have a favorite moment or story that you feel captures their unique chemistry? I'd love to hear your perspective. Subscriber insights like yours are what bring these videos to life and check out the community polls soon about where the channel is heading!
I'm with you - while I appreciate Sgt. Pepper's innovation and cultural impact, it's not necessarily my go-to Beatles album either. (Abbey Road!) There's something to be said for the simplicity and directness of their earlier records, or the more back-to-basics approach they took on the White Album and Let It Be. But that's the great thing about the Beatles' catalog - there's something for every taste and mood. I'm curious which albums you prefer and what it is about them that resonates with you. Sparking friendly debate about the band's best work is one of my favorite things about this channel. And if you want to dive deeper into the making of the Beatles' various masterpieces, be sure to subscribe so you don't miss any upcoming videos. Thanks for chiming in with your perspective!
Great mention of The Byrds' "Younger Than Yesterday"! 1967 was such an incredible year for music. How do you think that album compares to Sgt. Pepper in terms of innovation or impact? subscribe and hopefully catch a video of this subject soon!
Around this time, in November 66 we had the LP Da Capo by Love, and in November 67 Forever Changes by Love. Now I know that Love and Arthur Lee never really made it very big outside of California, but "the Summer of Love" was pretty distinctly a California-centric thing, and so I would say that, at least behind the scenes, the group Love and Arthur Lee had a huge influence on the so-called "Summer of Love"; I bet their music was almost as ubiquitous that year as Sgt Pepper was, there, in LA and San Francisco. It's just they don't seem to get as much mention as all the other bands; I mean, there were SO MANY amazing bands and records that year, with The Doors, Hendrix, The Mamas and the Papas, with their 'California Dreamin' and Monterey Pop Festival, (on 6/16/67), The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds (5/66), and on and on. May 67 had Scott McKenzie's anthemic "San Francisco", with the 'flowers in your hair' line; penned by John Phillips of the Mamas and the Papas. Who knows how many thousands of bright eyed, tie-dyed, garlanded bubble gum groupies showed up to get strung out and pregnant thanks to that bit of divine propaganda? There was so much original and revolutionary music around at that point, it's no wonder it culminated in a so called "Summer of Love" that was really over before it actually started. By the time the kids were showing up at Haight Ashbury with their paisley bell bottoms and patchouli, it was now the mob, and smack, acid and meth that were ruling that scene... :/ See George Harrison's heartbreaking report on his visit to Frisco on 8/7/67 (mere months after "Pepper's" release) for a rather sad and different take on the whole thing.
@PaisleyPatchouli, you’ve painted such a vivid picture of the era! Love and Arthur Lee definitely deserve more recognition for their influence on the Summer of Love. The sheer amount of groundbreaking music from that time is astounding. George Harrison's visit to Haight Ashbury indeed offered a sobering perspective. What’s your favorite album/ memory from that revolutionary year? Please stick around and subscribe for more engaging Beatles and 60s music discussions!
I think that if John had lived longer, he would have mellowed out some. It's too bad most of the things he said were in the immediate years following the breakup, so he still had that sharp sense of bitterness and denial. Same with George to some degree. At least we still have Paul and Ringo, and all the greatness that the Beatles gave us when they were together. Thank GOD...
You make a great point about how time might have changed John's perspective. It's interesting to consider how the Beatles' legacies and relationships might have evolved if circumstances had been different. Do you have any thoughts on how John's later work showed signs of that potential mellowing?
@@TheRockAlchemy Hi Again! From accounts that I read of people close to John from summer 1980 before he died, they were all saying how he was very "Positive", and "Upbeat" and "Enthusiastic" in general that summer, especially while in Bermuda and when making "Double Fantasy". Songs like "Watching the Wheels", "Grow Old with Me", and "Woman" I think seem to reflect and personify somewhat an attitude of "mellowing out" of his personality, acceptance of aging and him reflecting on life. It seems so tragic that just as John had finally found some peace and true happiness in his life, it was cut short by a madman for NO reason.
@macharper8214, John definitely had some strong opinions! His feelings about the Beatles' albums and Yoko’s music are often debated. What’s your take on his solo work compared to his Beatles contributions? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
William,er,Paul was the band leader on those records which were both his concept & execution. He would even go back & rerecord some of the band's parts if he felt they weren't perfect.Not only Lennon resented him but the rest of the band as well when he took over.
John was a pinball who bounced off bumper-from-bumper about The Beatles and even about his own work. He would outright contradict himself in interviews. Weird guy. I always admired him, but the older I become, the more I realize how messed up John Lennon could be sometimes. And I cared for very little of his post-Beatles music.
Have you seen the video of John Lennon and Chuck Berry playing "Johnny B. Goode" together? In the middle of it, Yoko, who was just sitting there with a microphone in front of her, suddenly burst into her "Wow-ow-ow". The engineer quickly shut off her mike, but the expression on Chuck Berry's was truly memorable. His eyes widened in utter disbelief.
It's interesting how John and George seemed to sour on Sgt. Pepper's over time, isn't it? I wonder how much of that was genuine dissatisfaction vs. just the natural tendency to be more critical of your past work. Do you think there were particular reasons they were inclined to distance themselves from it later on? I'd love to hear your take! If you enjoyed this kind of analysis, consider subscribing for more explorations of classic rock and Beatles history and lore.
Ha, fair point about the Beach Boys' unshakeable sense of identity! They definitely knew who they were as a band. I think George's comment was more a reflection of his own insecurity and frustration at that point in the Beatles' career. He was feeling a bit lost in the shuffle and overshadowed by John and Paul, so he projected those feelings onto the idea that the Beatles as a whole had lost their way. The Beatles could never be anyone but themselves, even as they pushed their sound in new directions. If you're interested in learning more about George's perspective during this era, I've got a whole video diving into his complicated relationship with Pattie and Eric and the song "Something!" Check it out and consider subscribing for more deep dives into the individual Beatles' stories. Thanks for watching and sharing your reaction!
@yelloworangered, haha, John definitely had a rebellious streak! His going against the grain is part of what made him so interesting. It’s interesting to see how that attitude influenced his music and relationships. What’s your favorite John Lennon song? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
@charlesbronson4282, the Monkees definitely had a huge impact and were incredibly popular during that time! It was an exciting era for music with so many great bands vying for the top spot. What’s your favorite Monkees song or memory? Maybe we will make a video about it! Please subscribe for more Beatles and 60s music content and discussions!
@stucarmichael4561, thanks for sharing your thoughts! The Beatles definitely set a high bar, and Sgt. Pepper’s is a classic for many. The comparisons with other bands are always interesting but can be subjective. What’s your favorite aspect of the album? Please subscribe for more engaging Beatles content and discussions!
You're absolutely right about John's rebellious nature and how his childhood influenced him. It's a crucial part of understanding his art and personality. Are there any specific examples of how you think his background shaped his music or lyrics?
Great point about Sgt. Pepper's impact on the '67 Haight-Ashbury scene! It really captured the spirit of the times. How do you think the album influenced the hippie movement and counterculture? That could be a great video if our community likes this discussion! Subscribe to explore the connections between music and culture and thanks for sharing your mind!
You're absolutely right about Sgt. Pepper's impact on recording techniques! It really did revolutionize the industry. Do you have a favorite innovative moment from the album? I'm interested to learn about the technical aspects that fans appreciate. subscribe for a great community and more great content. Always improving!
I wonder about this Car accident when Paul left the Revolver session in anger and supposedly had the car crash the "Conspiracy Theorists" are claiming killed Paul when he left the Revolver sessions? Was there any car accident at all on the 11th of September, 1966 (Strange date?) with Paul? I dont believe in this "Conspiracy Theory" about "Billy Shears" and Paul is dead BS. But I heard that Paul had a head trauma crashing a moped in some Spanish holiday resort and another head trauma in 1966? There are truly bizarre books called "Memoires of Billy Shears" in 2 volumes, one in Red and One in Blue, written by Freemason E U Harriet. The truly bizarre is that its Paul McCartneys own publisher company printing the books and George Martin's youngest son reads the audio version? These 2 books are NOT written with Sarcasm or Humour and it go deep into this "Billy Shear" replaced Paul who died in the 1966 car crash? So why? The author E U Harriet has a RUclips account as well as Facebook account and he answered my question about his motive for writing this book for Paul, by stating "Tavistock Institute" made the Beatles into a social engineering experiment with MI6 and CIA and Paul McCartney were killed in 1966!" And that's E U Harriet saying this, NOT me! So lets hear if you guys know anything about it? If Paul McCartney would have died? The Odds of finding a body double with plastic surgery of the 1960s, equally talented and an even more amazing songwriter as Paul became after 1966 is astronomical! But what is the motive for Paul to keep this "Conspiracy Theory" alive is strange? Those who believe Paul is dead and Faul took his place, often refer to pictures of Paul pre-1966 with brown eyes and post 1966 he has Hazel coloured eye
The 'Paul is gone' conspiracy theory is certainly a fascinating rabbit hole! While I don't personally believe Paul was replaced, the various 'clues' and rumors are intriguing from a cultural perspective. You've highlighted some of the key elements - the alleged car crashes, the 'Memoirs of Billy Shears' books, the astronomical odds of finding an exact McCartney duplicate. It's a lot to unpack! Without more direct info from Paul or the author, the true motives behind the conspiracy and the books remain a mystery. But it's fun to speculate! At the end of the day, I think Paul is amused by the whole thing and likes to playfully fuel the rumors, even if some fans take it quite seriously. Regardless of where one stands on the theory, it shows how much The Beatles affect the whole world. It's the kind of legend that only springs up around true cultural icons. Thanks for the thought-provoking comment! I'm always happy to respectfully discuss these theories, wherever people land on them. Let me know what you think about the voice reenactments in my videos - I'm experimenting with new ways to bring Beatles history to life, and I'm curious to hear your perspective!
@@TheRockAlchemy I think you nailed it with their voices. And speaking of voices they have compared Paul's voice before and after the supposed car crash in 66. A computer analysis of Paul came from the same person in 1965 and 1989.
John always hated Paul's non POP-ROCK SONGS.....but these songs gave the Beatles even more great versatility......Songs like "Ob-La Di Ob-La Da"....a Polka......and his 1920's inspired efforts "When I'm 64"......"Honey Pie"......."Martha My Dear" and "Your Mother Should Know"
Great point about how Paul's non-rock/pop songs added so much versatility to the Beatles' catalog! Songs like Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da, When I'm 64, Honey Pie etc. aren't always the most celebrated, but they showcased Paul's incredible range as a songwriter. The 1920s-inspired tunes in particular add such a delightful, whimsical element. Do you have a favorite among Paul's genre excursions? Let me know in the comments! If you want to hear more about the stories behind Paul's stylistically diverse compositions, make sure you're subscribed with the notification bell on. I have some new videos in the works you won't want to miss! Thanks so much for watching and sharing your insights.
@@TheRockAlchemy "Martha My Dear" is one of my favorite Beatles cuts.....great melody.....use of horns in a 1930's style.....fine piano work by Paul.....perfect bass for the tune.......
When Elton gets all those keyboard tracks in the middle bridge, to use language perhaps a little dated at the time, the song is so "far out", it's really trippy. It's said that Lennon's reading of Lewis Carroll, the author of "Alice in Wonderland" was an influence in his imagery in this song. I've just seen a Beatles documentary where John is recorded as saying that he felt Paul, at times, would "subconsciously sabatoge" his songs. In support of this, John said they were always very careful with Paul's songs, working a long time to clean up the tracks. "But when it came time to work on my songs, all of a sudden a spirit of experimentality crept in. . ."'Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" was not made right. I mean it's a good song, but the song wasn't made right. Would be interesting to see, given the fact that Lennon participates on this track (most dramatically when the song broke into reggae) what he thought of the two versions; which one he would like better. I hazard to guess John probably preferred this version of his song, and if John's perceptions were indeed correct, there certainly was no "subconscious sabatage" by Elton of this song! The two worked beautifully together on this song!
I think John was full of paranoid bs about the "unconscious sabotage" of his songs. The truth is more like John didn't really know what he was after half the time, as opposed to Paul who seemed to have had very clear ideas about what he wanted done with his own songs. In short, I think John was envious of Paul's creative focus, and John sideways blamed Paul for his own lack of it.
@@BigBri550 I think you're right on in that assessment. Unfortunately, Lennon was a very damaged human being. Check out the movie "Nowhere Boy" to look at his very damaged childhood and his troubled relationship with Paul, who also lost his mother. Lots of psychological depth here between these two, and George as well. Ringo always just wanted to fit in with these three.
One of many to do a cover of this song. Natalie Cole, Nat King Cole's daughter who passed away in the past five years or so at the age of 65, also performs a beautiful and worthwhile version of this very same song.
Thanks for subscribing and joining the community, DJ! And thanks for mentioning Natalie Cole's version! It's always interesting to hear how other artists interpret Beatles classics. Do you have other favorite Beatles covers we should check out?
I really enjoy Good Morning. Ringo's drumming is great & John's vocal is outstanding. It truly , ,wonderfully captures a day in the life of a suburbanite.
Glad you enjoy "Good Morning"! You're spot on about Ringo's drumming and John's vocal performance. It's a great snapshot of suburban life. Do you have other favorite examples of the Beatles capturing everyday experiences in their songs?
Lennon know sgt peppers was a peak he never called it garbage he just said that about one song...but he liked the white album better...ringo knew it was great too but he liked the white album better too... And Harrison was getting into indian culture and musicbl and not really mentally tuned into sgt peppers
@manny4552, you’re right! Each Beatle had their own unique perspective on Sgt. Pepper's. John’s criticism was specific, and their preferences evolved over time. It’s interesting to see how their individual tastes influenced their music. What’s your favorite Beatles album or story? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
We appreciate your feedback on the background music. We're always looking to improve the listening experience. What kind of background elements do you think would enhance the video without being distracting? subscribe to see how we make our content unable to click away from more and more!
Great observation about Nigel Olsson's drumming! Those cymbal crashes really add power to the solo. Do you have other favorite drum moments in classic rock?
Is there anyone else out there who couldn’t get through this video because of the monotonous background music? How long can you can you listen to a two Bar Loop? I wanted to pull my finger nails out just to perk things up.
Oh no, I'm so sorry the background music loop was so grating! I definitely don't want anyone pulling their fingernails out. 😉 Seriously though, I appreciate you taking the time to give that feedback. I'm still learning and experimenting with the music beds. I'll work on finding some less repetitive tracks or changing them up more frequently throughout the video. If you have music available to you that you would like me to feature, that would be awesome! Thanks again for watching and let me know what you think!
@patrickkiely1098, that’s awesome to hear! 'Good Morning Good Morning' definitely has a unique charm and energy. What do you love most about the song? Don't forget to subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
@@TheRockAlchemy I guess it's the energy of the and I can just so relate to the lyrics, who hasn't had one of those days where you just don't go to work and let your feet take you on a random journey and just go with the flow of the day
@krsnaloka333-po9cp, thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it. Do you have a favorite Beatles album or song? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and community discussions!
Absolutely! The syncopation in "Good Morning" is truly impressive. It's amazing how John could take inspiration from something as simple as a cereal commercial and turn it into such a complex and engaging song. Do you have any other favorite examples of clever lyrical or rhythmic techniques in Beatles songs? Your ear for musical detail is fantastic!
@@TheRockAlchemy How about the end of For No One? It opens in the key of C major. They add a B♭ toward the end of the first verse which resolves to the tonic. Interesting sound. The chorus is interesting. It seems to modulate to D minor. But this is where the real spice is in my opinion. The last line goes A7 (the dominant) to Dm (the tonic) to (the subdominant) Gsus4 G. It's a Minor Plagal Cadence. Who did that in pop music in the 60’s? They also used it in In My Life.
You're absolutely right, "The Piper at the Gates of Dawn" was another landmark album from 1967. Thanks for mentioning it! How do you think Pink Floyd's debut compares to Sgt. Pepper in terms of its impact on psychedelic rock? Maybe we should make a video about them soon!
Interesting take on John's feelings about the album! (how did i know you were talking about John?) The dynamics within the band during this period were certainly complex. Do you think John's attitude towards Sgt. Pepper changed over time? We'd love to hear your thoughts on how the album impacted the group's relationships.
Thanks for the feedback and for watching! I appreciate you letting me know the royalty-free music was a bit distracting. I am partnering up with a company that could provide us with hit tunes as background music soon! I'm still experimenting with the background music and will definitely keep that in mind for future videos. If there are other topics you'd like to see me cover or ways I can improve the viewing experience, let me know in the comments or community tab. And of course, if you liked the video overall, subscribing is the best way to support the channel!
@normanglussier6473, absolutely! Their influence on music and culture is immeasurable. What’s your favorite Beatles accomplishment or contribution? Maybe we can make a video about it! Please subscribe for more Beatles and rock content and discussions!
I really appreciate the kind words about the documentary! I'm so glad you found it engaging overall, we are all really enthused and engaged in creating these for you all but also for ourselves! And thanks for flagging the repetitive guitar riff - you're not the first to point that out (facepalm), and I totally hear it now. Definitely going to be more mindful of mixing up the background music in future videos. I never want the soundtrack to distract from the story. If there are particular topics or angles you'd like to see explored in upcoming episodes, let me know in the comments or on the community tab. And if you want to catch all the latest deep-dives, consider hitting that subscribe button. Thanks again for watching and taking the time to share your feedback - it genuinely helps me refine and improve the channel. More Beatles (and other rock star ;)) content coming soon!
George had his own contract with Northern Songs. Paul and John GAVE George and Ringo that small share in THEIR songs as both helped make the songs. George did leave Northern when he could and created Harrisongs to publish his songs. Pepper did begin as a concept album with Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields, and as you claim, only a Northern Song Then Paul made it a fake band concept. The Pepper band could have made all the songs, though George's song would have not been likely as part of the concept.
Thank you for sharing those details about the Beatles' publishing arrangements and the evolution of Sgt. Pepper's concept. It's fascinating to consider how the album's theme developed over time. That could be a whole other video! Do you have a favorite song from the album that you feel best embodies the "Sgt. Pepper's Band" concept?
You're spot on about "Axis: Bold As Love" - it's a true masterpiece that showcases Hendrix's incredible talent and innovation. That would be another interesting video for us to make! We love exploring these groundbreaking albums and their impact on rock history. If you enjoy discussions about influential records like this, consider subscribing to Rock Alchemy. We're always diving into the stories behind the classic albums that shaped rock music.
Jeez John was a whinger ! That effect after WYWY was crowd like to add the vibe and also on BFTBOMK! the whole atmosphere was circus crowd and show and the carry on in GMGM was conducive to the whole atmosphere of the concept and finally ditto for LITSWD !!! So lets compromise and call Pepper Quasiconcept Psychedelic !! 🌈💈😹👁️🤡
Lennon did pretty good reggae in the '70's. We'll need to check out his posthumously released song with the ironic title, "Living on Borrowed Time". Eerily prescient of John on some level to do a song like that.
You're right, Lennon did explore reggae in his solo work. "Living on Borrowed Time" is hauntingly prescient. Have you checked out his other reggae-influenced tracks?
Firstly Penny Lane & Strawberry Fields Forever outsold Please Release Me by 40% it's just that in those days in the U.K. a double #1 sales were halved ; secondly they could've kept their songs on Pepper only half the LPs didn't and George Martin regretted that mistake and lastly John due to his mental state was often rubbishing perfectly good tracks for example And Your Bird Can Sing! 😹
@johnbyrnes7912, great points! The sales strategy in the UK back then definitely impacted the charts. George Martin’s hindsight on those decisions is fascinating too. John’s critical nature, especially during that rocky period, certainly shaped their music in unexpected ways. What’s your favorite underrated Beatles track?
There was definitely some complex band dynamics around Sgt. Pepper. Even if it was Paul's baby, every Beatle made crucial contributions. What's your take on how their interpersonal relationships shaped their music? Subscribe to dig deeper into Beatles and classic rock history with me and the community!
Good ear! We use a mix of AI voices for the Beatles' quotes and a human narrator from Ohio for the main content. We're constantly working on improving the audio experience. What do you think of this approach? We're always open to feedback from our viewers.
This album does have a lot of songs on it that are all horn and string driven so musically they didn't even play on those ones; they just sang on them. That could account for the boredom in those cases. In any event, even though it was enjoyable to listen to, the earlier stuff they did before SSgt pepper was really nothing to write home about musically but from this album on was when their music was starting to mature and was going somewhere. It likely wasn't the music on the album that John didn't like, it was likely more that since he wasn't involved in writing the music his ego kicked in because he didn't have that degree of control anymore. That's what I think he really didn't like.
@jimo3173, you bring up some great points! The orchestral arrangements on Sgt. Pepper’s were a big departure from their earlier, more guitar-driven work. It makes sense that this shift in their creative process could lead to some boredom or frustration. And you're right about John’s potential feelings-creative control is a huge factor for any artist.... or really, anyone! It's fascinating how their music evolved from that point on. What’s your favorite post-Sgt. Pepper Beatles album? Please subscribe for more great content and conversation!
Johnny Rivers' "Realization" is a great pick for an overlooked Summer of Love album! It definitely deserves more recognition. Maybe we could do a video on it! What do you think makes it stand out among the other releases of that era? Subscribe for more deep dives into classic rock gems!
@risteardohaodha23, glad you enjoyed the video! Sometimes a bit of humor makes the stories even more fun to revisit. Do you have a favorite Beatles impersonator or parody? Please subscribe for more engaging Beatles content and conversations!
This is rubbish. Pepper is one of the greatest Albums ever written and u are over exaggerating what went on . Brian Wilson admitted he spent his life trying to write songs that as good as THE BEATLES and h will hear him saying this on a video . George caused the trouble he had started writing and wanted more of his songs on the Albums but he should have been grateful because if John snd Paul got them to the top. There has never been a band to equal THE BEATLES
Your passion for Sgt. Pepper is clear! It's undoubtedly a landmark album. Our video aims to explore some of the lesser-known aspects and challenges during its creation, which don't diminish its greatness but add depth to its story. What's your favorite track on the album and why?
Interesting perspective on John's critical stance! You're right that his opinions could be quite harsh at times. It's interesting to compare his views on different albums throughout his career. How do you think John's solo work compares to the Beatles' albums? We'd love to hear your thoughts on his musical evolution. What other stories would you want to see into videos? Subscribe for more and check out the community page and shorts for more. thanks, Stuart!
Hey Dirk! Great catch on that musical mismatch in the editing! The harp run doesn't quite align with George's sitar studies. We want our content to be tongue-in-cheek but still accurate and engaging, especially for true fans like yourself! I really appreciate your keen eye (and ear) for detail. We're always striving to refine our storytelling techniques. What kind of musical transitions do you think would work well for George's Indian music journey? Subscribe to be part of the creative process as we hone our craft!
1967 our Grandparents gave us a 4 track player with 4 songs from Sgt Pepper. Sgt Pepper/ With a Little. / LSDiamonds/ Being For The Benefit...... It would be 1972 before I bought the LP! I LUV IT!! And I love The Stones Their Satanic Majesties Request!!!
What an amazing introduction to Sgt. Pepper! Those four tracks alone showcase the album's incredible range. It's cool to hear how your appreciation for the album grew over time. And yes, Their Satanic Majesties Request is another gem from that era! It's often seen as the Stones' response to Sgt. Pepper. Speaking of the Stones, we're actually working on a video about their album Bridges to Babylon and how it relates to the Beatles' journey. I don't want to give away too much just yet, but it explores some fascinating connections between the two bands. Stay tuned for that! In the meantime, I'd love to hear your thoughts on Sgt. Pepper and Their Satanic Majesties Request. Do you feel like the two albums share any common vibes or themes? How do you think they complement each other? Your insights could even inspire future videos! Thanks for sharing your story.
You make a great point about Lennon's harsh and shocking statements. Even if Sgt. Pepper's isn't your favorite, it's true that the Beatles' entire catalog has artistic merit. Which album or era of their music resonates most with you personally? I'm always eager to hear different fan perspectives!
I loved Good Morning!! One of the better songs on the album. I think John wanted to just mouth off. He could get very moody and arbitrary when he wasn't feeling right. I think it's a great song. Plus it fits very well where it was placed.
Ooh interesting pushback on John's Good Morningx2 take! You raise a fair point about his moodiness sometimes coloring his opinions on the band's work. He was definitely known for his hot-and-cold relationship with their catalog post-breakup. I agree that Good Morningx2 is a solid album cut and serves an important role in the Pepper's tracklist. The rooster sound effects and horns give it a really distinct flavor that stands out. At the same time, I can understand John feeling like it was a bit disposable compared to his more weighty, personal contributions. Curious if you think his dismissal might've also been a veiled dig at Paul's increasing control over the album/band at this point. This is the kind of juicy Beatles debate I live for! If you're down to dissect more Fab Four hot takes, sound off in the comments or head over to the community tab. And definitely hit subscribe if you want to keep exploring the highs, lows, and dramas of their career - I've got tons more videos in the works. Thanks for watching and sharing your perspective. Gotta love a good Beatles nerd-out sesh!
i agree with John. I have always felt Lucy in the sky with diamonds does not sound good. Never understood why it was so popular. I guess lyrics are interesting. maybe it is the lyrics that makes it popular. It COULD be made to sound like a good song. I think this is what John is saying.
Great point about the lyrics being the main draw of Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds, even if the production doesn't quite land. The vivid, psychedelic imagery and Alice in Wonderland vibes are definitely a big part of the song's enduring appeal. I can see what you (and John) mean about it not being sonically perfect though. There's a sense that the trippiness of the words isn't fully matched by the music, which stays relatively grounded. It would be fascinating to hear a reimagined version that really leans into the dreamlike, hallucinatory feel - maybe with some more experimental instrumentation and effects. drop your other picks in the comments! Love hearing fresh perspectives from thoughtful fans. And if you want to keep diving into the stories behind the Fab Four's hits and hidden gems, consider subscribing. Plenty more to explore
You make a great point about the disconnect between John's opinions and the fans' reception of certain songs. "And Your Bird Can Sing" is indeed a fan favorite despite John's criticism. It just goes to show how art can take on a life of its own once it's out in the world. Are there other Beatles songs you love that John or the other band members weren't fond of? subscribe for more great rock stories and discussions
when i was going through the 'hippie' phases Good morning was definitely one of my favs. Esp. since the solo is one of my favorite guitar solos of all time. I'm sure many songs like Strawberry fields were many people's favorite songs.
Glad Good Morning was a favorite of yours during your 'hippie phase'! That guitar solo is epic. Strawberry Fields is another one that was hugely popular and groundbreaking at the time. I'm hoping to feature both songs in future videos taking a deep dive into the stories behind them. If you haven't already, subscribe and hit the notification bell so you don't miss them!
You can't really trust anything John said at any given moment. He would say something and contradict it a moment later. As he admitted, "It's just comes out of my mouth." And I'm not sure we can even believe that! A good example is "Good Morning, Good Morning." John says he got the song from a commercial, but the rest of the song (a witty look at a normal, humdrum day) was entirely written and recorded before he came up with the idea of using the jingle as a chorus, so he's rewriting history a bit there.
You make an excellent point about John's tendency to contradict himself. It certainly adds an intriguing layer to Beatles history! Your insight about "Good Morning, Good Morning" is fascinating. Do you have other examples of John's 'revisionist' takes on their songs? This kind of deep dive into songwriting origins is always appreciated! Please subscribe and stick around for more great content and community!
Hey narrator, are you really that clueless ? August 21st , 1966 ? Any Beatles fan would know that their final tour concert was on Aug. 29th , of 66' !!! FAIL !! , Dean ( in Syracuse)
@wayofthinkin, thanks for catching that! You’re absolutely right, the final tour concert was indeed on August 29th, 1966. We appreciate the correction and strive to provide accurate information. Thanks for being a dedicated Beatles fan and keeping us on our toes! Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions.
I watched this video to get an idea of what the "real past" was like. I never got into the Beatles, but am recently discovering their actual greatness. Hearing and seeing the generative content was disappointing for me in what was otherwise superb content. I'm looking for some nostalgic "something" from before I was born. I actually think part of the search for this is a reaction to knowing that future media soon will be indistinguishable from ML Generative content. The Beatles are 'real' in a way media/music will never be again. I scanned the comments and many people seemed to notice the generative audio, and I did not see any comments about the generative images. My unsolicited advice would be when doing a historical piece to keep it accurate using a traditional journalistic standard. This will root you in authenticity. Coming from someone who works with AI also and makes chatbots for public use. I know you have to do you, and I don't know how to make a successful channel. My two cents. Good luck and be well.
Thank you for your thoughtful feedback on our content. We appreciate your perspective on the use of generative content in historical pieces. Our goal is to bring these stories to life while respecting the authenticity of the original material. We're always working to improve our content and balance new technologies with historical accuracy. Your input is valuable as we continue to refine our approach. We hope you'll stick around as we explore more "real" moments in rock history!
Let’s just be completely honest here. We all know damn well that if John actually meant what he said. He’d stick “For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite” first lol 😎
@evandylan, haha, you’ve got a point! John’s sense of humor and critical nature were certainly unique. 'For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite' is such a quirky track. What’s your take on its place in the album? Please subscribe for more fun Beatles insights and discussions!
I appreciate your feedback on the background music. We're always looking to improve the listening experience. In future videos, we'll aim for more varied background elements that enhance rather than distract. Thanks for sticking with the video despite the repetitive riff! And subscribe to see content that you want to see. and hear!
Agreed! "Within You Without You" is a deeply profound track that showcases George's growing interest in Indian music and philosophy. It's definitely a song that reveals more layers with each listen. What aspects of the song do you find most compelling? Subscribe and share for more deep dives and thanks!
Paul had great songs during The Beatles i could even say better than from John but obviously i never put down John. He was unique no doubt about it and he showed that more after break up of the beatles. I coukd say both if them were extremely talented. SGT Peppers is one if the best album the Beatles ever made. To me it is timeless classic Just unbelievable idea from cover to songs.
That incident with John was certainly a close call. It highlights some of the dangers associated with... experimentation during that era. How do you think experiences like this influenced the Beatles' music and personal lives?
You make an interesting point about Paul's role in the Beatles' longevity! He certainly was a driving force behind Sgt. Pepper. Do you think the other members' contributions to the album are sometimes overlooked? We'd love to hear your thoughts on the group dynamics during this period. What kind of video would you and your audience like to see next? Subscribe for a great community and content!
@Scotty_Russell_Music, glad you found some humor in the voices! We aim to add a bit of campy fun to the videos. We’re always working to improve them (and their accents!), so your feedback is appreciated. Do you think the voices add to the experience or take away from it? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
@@TheRockAlchemy As a massive lifelong Beatles devotee I have strong opinions about anyone who isn't legitimately associated with the band or remaining relatives of the deceased Beatles resurrecting their voices without express consent. Sorry if that's a downer for you to hear, this is the thin edge of the wedge, the tip of the iceberg, next thing they'll be touring a hologram Amy Winehouse singing Ed Sheeran and Adelle songs with special guest appearances from Elvis and Michael Jackson.
@@TheRockAlchemy On reflection if you must use the AI voices keep them a bit "uncanny valley" and then i can spot the fakery a mile off lol It's all good , good luck with your content and all the best. Cheers
Great observation about the Monkees' "Headquarters"! It's fascinating to consider the musical landscape of 1967. How do you think "Headquarters" compares to "Sgt. Pepper" in terms of its impact or innovation? subscribe for more content and a great community!
You're absolutely right, I didn't touch on A Day in the Life in this video! That song definitely warrants its own deep-dive. A Day in the Life is such a groundbreaking track in terms of its structure, production, and the way it blends John and Paul's distinct songwriting voices. The orchestral crescendos and abstract lyrics really push the boundaries of what a pop song could be. I'm planning to do a whole video on the making of A Day in the Life and its legacy - both as the epic finale to Sgt. Pepper's and as a standalone masterpiece. If there are any particular angles or stories around the song you're curious about, let me know in the comments! I'm always looking to tailor these docs to viewer interests. And be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the other Beatles deep-dives in the works. And hopefully day in the life soon! Thanks for watching and flagging that omission. Plenty more Pepper's (and beyond) to explore!
Wow, what an intriguing interpretation of Sgt. Pepper's! And if it's toung-in-cheek I think its great, too! The idea of existential confusion as the unifying theme and subconscious throughline of the album is really fascinating. It's true that there's a sense of disorientation and searching that runs through a lot of the tracks, even as the surface tone remains whimsical and celebratory. I'd love to hear you expand on this more - which specific songs or moments do you think best capture this sense of existential confusion? And do you see it as a reflection of the band's own state of mind at the time, or more of a general cultural/societal mood they were tapping into? if you enjoyed this deep dive into Beatles lore, consider subscribing to catch all my upcoming videos exploring the band's legacy from different angles. And more rock bands soon, too. Thanks for this thought-provoking comment!
@@TheRockAlchemy Thanks. I am serious. This album has always puzzled me because it doesn’t appear to be a concept album-but it feels like one. The Beatles stopped touring in 1966 and didn’t know who or what to be. They had to conjure up an imaginary band just to get back into the studio. Lennon’s music was almost always personal…but not on this album. He had “nothing to say”. The word “nothing” appears in that song eight times. So he wrote songs inspired by a child’s drawing, a poster, a TV commercial and newspaper articles. Up to this point, McCartney wrote almost exclusively love songs-but not on this album. His songs were anthems to mundane domesticity. Even the middle part of a Day in the Life.
Hah, "Nestugadacht" would've been quite the album title! The Beatles' real titles are iconic, but it's fun to imagine the wild alternatives. What other fantasy Beatles album titles can you dream up? Subscribe for more fun Fab Four (and more classic rock soon!) chats!
Thanks for the AI voice tip! I'm always looking for ways to make these docs more compelling. If you have favorite examples, send them my way! With your impressive 600+ subscribers, I'm curious - do you think your audience might dig my classic rock deep-dives? I've been focused on the Beatles but plan to branch out. What bands, eras, or stories do you think would resonate with your music-loving crew? I'm all ears if you've got ideas! As always, thanks for the inspiration. Subscribe to catch my upcoming rock docs - killer stories in the pipeline!
@@TheRockAlchemy I saw a guy pushing an AI video editor that can do whatever voice (including your own) in any language. I don't remember the name of it, but that sounds perfect for these videos you're doing. Having all the voices sounding exactly like each band member would enhance the experience and not pull people out of the video-watching "trance," causing them to leave a comment about how some band member didn't sound like the real band member. Most of my subscribers are probably bots, so I wouldn't worry about them.
Interesting take on Paul and George! Paul's drive certainly shaped much of the Beatles' output. As for George, do you have a favorite song of his from the Sgt. Pepper era or later albums?
Great additions to the conversation! Those albums certainly made waves in the same era. We love how knowledgeable our viewers are. Any other classic albums from that time you think deserve more recognition?
The retrospective comments by the band members on albums and various songs never come over to me as real, but rather just trying to be controversial for a new audience.
I hear you - it can be tough to parse the sincerity of the band's retrospective comments, especially when they seem to contradict the public narrative around an album or song. There's definitely an element of mythmaking and revisionist history at play, consciously or not. And in some cases, they may be exaggerating their dissatisfaction for effect, or to assert their individual legacies. what do you think? At the same time, I think there's value in considering their evolving perspectives, even if we take them with a grain of salt. Artists' relationships to their own work can be complex and fluid. If you're interested in untangling more of these pop culture mysteries, subscribe to the channel! I'm always trying to read between the lines and separate fact from fiction. Would love to hear your take on other Beatles legends or classic rock lore!
@@TheRockAlchemyyou’ve brought a new perspective on my somewhat negative perception of the Beatles’ retrospective comments, I thank you for that. I think I first formed my opinion when hearing Paul say Got to Get You Into My Life was “dedicated to pot”. While there are potential phrases that possibly could be interpreted as an ode to pot smoking, the lyrics seemed to my naive ears as simply wanting to get a girl he fancied. Love the channel.
Sgt. Pepper's is definitely a departure from the Beatles' earlier work and more raw rock and roll sound. The production is much more elaborate and 'artificial' as you note. I can understand why it might not click for everyone. Out of curiosity, which Beatles albums/periods are your favorites? Or are you a bigger fan of other classic rock groups of the time? I'm always interested to hear how different fans connect with the various phases of their career. Thanks for watching and commenting!
Great point about the mono mix! It really does change the listening experience. Do you have a preference between mono and stereo for Pepper? I'd be fascinated to hear your perspective. Subscribe for more Beatles and classic rock audio geekery!
@@TheRockAlchemy of Course I did like the studio version of Pepper better , but like Kiss they took off the most part of the album is the Pepper outro ( inner groove ) the complete version with AI made the album much more . If I was their manager at this time I would have booked a tour , with the out fits and everything . Maybe filmed a Pepper movie better than Bee Gees !
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Do you have a great story of when you first heard this album? What did you think about our video? Subscribe and thanks for enjoying our content!
You did the whole "Summer of Love" in 1967 , without mentioning "All You Need is love" being played Live on TV.
Please make that guitar riff stop!
@ifandwhen-kl2cr, thanks for the feedback! We’ll keep that in mind for future videos. Your input helps us improve. What part of the video did you enjoy the most? Don't forget to subscribe for more Beatles content and conversations!
Terrible, innit 🤦🤯
Awful
@@meechneek I almost had to turn off what was otherwise an interesting video. Horribly irritating!
Oufffff yes
The interviews are not the real beatles talking
Hey @manny4552, thanks for sharing your thoughts! The interviews we use are meant to highlight the Beatles' journey through available sources using real quotes and documented conversations. How do you think the Beatles' evolution reflects changes in your own life? Share your thoughts with us! And subscribe if you like a real Beatles and classic rock community!
@@JoshMaxPower No, no... Those thanks for sharing his thoughts are heartfelt and genuine! Can't you tell?
Paul's voice may have been synthesized and generated using artificial intelligence software (though with a rather Australian accent).
You have John mispronouncing "reprise". He actually prounced it correctly.
I wonder about this Car accident when Paul left the Revolver session in anger and supposedly had the car crash the "Conspiracy Theorists" are claiming killed Paul when he left the Revolver sessions? Was there any car accident at all on the 11th of September, 1966 (Strange date?) with Paul? I dont believe in this "Conspiracy Theory" about "Billy Shears" and Paul is dead BS. But I heard that Paul had a head trauma crashing a moped in some Spanish holiday resort and another head trauma in 1966?
There are truly bizarre books called "Memoires of Billy Shears" in 2 volumes, one in Red and One in Blue, written by Freemason E U Harriet. The truly bizarre is that its Paul McCartneys own publisher company printing the books and George Martin's youngest son reads the audio version?
These 2 books are NOT written with Sarcasm or Humour and it go deep into this "Billy Shear" replaced Paul who died in the 1966 car crash? So why?
The author E U Harriet has a RUclips account as well as Facebook account and he answered my question about his motive for writing this book for Paul, by stating "Tavistock Institute" made the Beatles into a social engineering experiment with MI6 and CIA and Paul McCartney were killed in 1966!" And that's E U Harriet saying this, NOT me!
So lets hear if you guys know anything about it?
If Paul McCartney would have died? The Odds of finding a body double with plastic surgery of the 1960s, equally talented and an even more amazing songwriter as Paul became after 1966 is astronomical! But what is the motive for Paul to keep this "Conspiracy Theory" alive is strange?
Those who believe Paul is dead and Faul took his place, often refer to pictures of Paul pre-1966 with brown eyes and post 1966 he has Hazel coloured eyes?
Is it just me, but I think a lot of the snippets of dialogue are not spoken by actual Beatles.
You've got a keen ear! We use a combination of real audio snippets and voiceover impressions. The goal is to tell engaging stories while encouraging discussion. What are your thoughts on this approach? I'm always looking to improve. Subscribe to be part of the Beatles conversation!
True
Yes for sure the accent is Australian and not the Beatles.
You can tell RockAlchemy is AI because no real human on the internet is nice like that.
your rite
I was 16 when the album was released. I liked the Beach Boys but I associated them with their surfing period of 1963. My friends and I liked Pet Sounds, but we never considered it competition for Sergeant Pepper. They were two completely different things -- pineapples and cucumbers. Actually, I don't remember reading or hearing anything about any alleged competition.
As for the "glorious" Summer of Love: The previous summer, 1966, was when San Francisco's Haight-Ashbury scene came to national attention. Things were on a smaller scale, although LSD was plentiful. The more nationwide reporting on the hippie scene was done, the more the California state legislature and the San Francisco police department felt the pressure to crack down on all that immorality and "kids running wild," especially the girls, who were behaving in an impure and unladylike manner. Crack down they did; the legislature made LSD illegal in September 1966. The police did all they could to run the hippies out of town or put them in jail. They were unpleasantly surprised at the flood of seemingly insane humanity entering the Haight-Ashbury neighborhood in 1967. The scene also attracted hustlers, pimps, thieves, rapists, and dealers in toxic psychedelics plus barbiturates, amphetamines, and adulterated heroin. The Hell's Angels, descendants of rednecks who had come to California during the Depression and a racist, anti-Semitic, right-wing/conservative group, also took advantage of the situation (although some of them tried to help the more damaged of the hippies). Read A Roman Wilderness of Pain: the Bitter Legacy of the Summer of Love, by Shoshana Edwards. She talks about what it really was like in San Francisco that summer: a shambles. She herself completely burned out on drugs and shitty living conditions, and her daughter was taken away from her and they never managed to emotionally reconnect. ("A Roman wilderness of pain" is a lyric from the Doors song "The End.") John Lennon later said he had wanted the group to move to San Francisco and be part of what was happening, but he probably didn't know any better than other hippies what was really going on.
And so much for that.
Thank you subscribing! And Wow, thank you for sharing such a detailed and insightful firsthand account of that era! Your perspective on the Beach Boys and Beatles not being in competition is fascinating. It's really eye-opening to hear about the darker realities of the "Summer of Love" from someone who lived through it. The book recommendation sounds intriguing - it's always valuable to explore the complexities behind the romanticized versions of history. Your comment adds so much depth to our understanding of the context surrounding Sgt. Pepper. Would you be interested in sharing more of your memories from that time in future discussions?
Wow! I listened To Sergeant Pepper througb the whole summer of '67. I was 6 at the time, and I was already a Beatles fan to the chore. I listened To all the other albums they had release by then. That summer was magic. I live in Montréal and we had the World Expo '67. It was crazy. All those people from all over the World in our City for the whole summer. LSD everywhere. My Brother just came back from a trip to California. Almost a year he was gone and what a trip he made!!!. San Francisco and everything it meant at that time. Anyway, I finally had my own copy of Sergeant Pepper on Christmas of that year. And to tell you the influence it had on me, I still wear suits like the Beatles and wear boots like them. And of course I became a professional musician. Thanks To those guys.😉
@user-ie1zz6wf7n, what an amazing story! It’s incredible how Sgt. Pepper and that era had such a lasting impact on you. The World Expo in Montreal sounds like it was a magical time. It’s wonderful to hear how the Beatles influenced your life and career. What’s your favorite track from Sgt. Pepper? Please subscribe for more Beatles and rock stories and content!
An absolutely exalted album. I am sorry I did not hear it before my mid teens. The peculiar unity and diversity of style is an amazing artistic achievement: the songs for the most part manage to sound both different and the same. Also great is how they (or rather he: McCartney) in effect anticipated 80s style by having an open sound with loud and bassy bass. (Sting later moved in the same direction, landing at pretty much the same place with Synchronicity.) During my Bright College Days, "oh carefree days that fly", I used to relax by playing bass along with Sgt. Pepper. That album has the best bass I have ever heard. My favorite was Mr. Kite. Or maybe Fixing a Hole. Or maybe With a Little Help from My Friends ... so hard to choose.
The reason WHY the double A side single DIDN'T reach Number 1 on the Charts is because of how they were counted: any purchase of the single went to EITHER "Penny Lane" OR "Strawberry Fields." If you added them together, I think they outsold Engelbert Humperdinck's "Release Me."
Great point about the chart mechanics for double A-side singles! It's fascinating how these technicalities could impact the perception of a song's success. Do you know if this method of counting changed after this incident? It would be interesting to explore how chart rules have evolved over time and how they've affected music history.
Ah, "EH" (in fact one Mr. Dorsey)...the guy who's first name is so ridiculous it could only have been topped by the absurdity of his last name.
John said it was the peak. He just thought one of his songs a throwaway and rightly pointed out it wasn't a concept album. But he liked at least 3 of his songs on it and he contributed a lot and wrote part of at least one Paul song. Ringo just said that for a lot of the time there wasn't much for him to do.
Thanks for sharing those insights about John's perspective on Sgt. Pepper! It's fascinating to hear about the nuances in the band members' views of their own work. We love diving into these details at Rock Alchemy. If you're interested in more deep dives into Beatles history and their creative process, consider subscribing to our channel!
Good Morning, Good Morning is one of my favorite Beatles songs
Awesome to hear "Good Morning Good Morning" is one of your favorites! It has such a unique energy and sound. And after working on our video and learning how it was made! What do you love most about the song? I'd be curious to hear your take. Please subscribe for more in-depth discussions on Beatles tracks!
I like the energy and the way the tempo changes. I like the slice of life aspect of the lyrics. I know John preferred the more introspective lyrics but I prefer when he's not talking himself too seriously with the subject matter. As a kid this wasn't a song that stood out for me but I started really appreciating it as I went through middle age.
It has great energy. George Harrison later seemed to borrow from it for "Savoy Truffle."
John Lennon always had something negative to say. Especially if it was a Paul idea.
@patriciaedwards5183, John definitely had a tendency to be critical, especially when it came to Paul's ideas. Their dynamic was so complex and fascinating. It’s part of what made their collaboration so unique. What’s your take on their creative rivalry? Please subscribe for more Beatles insights and discussions!
@patriciaedwards5183, John definitely had a tendency to be critical, especially when it came to Paul's ideas. Their dynamic was so complex and fascinating. It’s part of what made their collaboration so unique. What’s your take on their creative rivalry? Please subscribe for more Beatles insights and discussions!
John had no problem with the movement you need is on your shoulders, Paul was going to chuck it and John said no Paul I know what it means😅
@@chuckyoneill9029
He liked Hey Jude and thought it was about him finding Yoko then telling him to go for it
John Lennon bless him was an egoistical narcissist.
@@patriciaedwards5183 I know and most genius are
I called an optometrist and asked how much a pair of round wire-rimmed glasses would cost. I said, "No, I just want glass in frames." She turned to someone in the store and said, "He wants them for his "costume." Well, the price was astronomical to me! I hung up. The other thing I remember is when I heard the song, "Sgt. Pepper" and when the tuba, or whatever it was, did the solo, it was the first time I heard it with reverb. It was a revelation. And walking down the street in my neighborhood you could actually hear the record being played from houses.
@davidd.perata2085, what a fantastic memory! The iconic round glasses are definitely a staple of the era, and the music from Sgt. Pepper truly made its mark. Hearing it echoing through the neighborhood must have been magical. We are actually making a video talking about that fact right now! What’s your favorite track or story from the album? Maybe we can make a video about it soon! Please subscribe for more nostalgic stories and Beatles content!
@@TheRockAlchemy I thought the video was great! But personally, I rarely play Sgt. Pepper today. It was of it's time, and as far as Beatle albums go, I don't think it holds up for the very reason John said. They should have put Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields on the album like they originally intended and nixed She's Leaving Home and Mr. Kite or Good Morning.
You've got to remember that we "the fans" had just come off of Revolver which was a gem, and Sgt. Pepper was the first album since then. We knew the mop-top era was over by the mustaches they grew for the Penny Lane video. We mourned that. I did like Penny Lane, but I was too young for acid and pot so that aspect of the Pepper album was missing for me. I have to laugh at John's comment "It worked because we said it worked." Wow! That gives you an idea of who they were and who they thought they were.
Not too many people know it now, but the album came with cut-outs of Sgt. Pepper and various things.
Are ALL the interview clips done with A.I.?
Hey Mark! We mix it up-some clips are their real recordings, while others use AI to recreate those moments. The goal is to bring you the most immersive and engaging experience possible. And maybe a bit campy fun for our fans who know the Beatles. And for those who dont know the Beatles, its a great way to draw the viewer in we think. What do you think? Which interviews do you find most compelling? Join our community and subscribe for more insights and behind-the-scenes content!
@@TheRockAlchemy I loved this videos content first of all. but I am surprised nobody seems to be calling out your colorized AI upscaled "photo" work besides the vocal "impressions". I work with AI every day. Its like working with the enemy, this will literally be the end of history/truth as people can understand it.
John was too hard on himself. Sgt. Pepper was a masterpiece.
@robertengland8769, absolutely! John's self-criticism was intense, but it’s part of what pushed the band to new heights. Sgt. Pepper’s is indeed a masterpiece. What’s your favorite track from the album? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
It´s an exageration all these comments by the other 3. They all knew Sgt Pepper´s were their biggest masterpiece while making it . Obviously, it was Paul´s brain child, so John and George ( who had only one song, intead of three , like on Revolver) underrated it . But John´s and George´s contributions were decisive for the success of the album anyway.
@Fanquesfair, you make a great point! Even with differing opinions, John and George’s contributions were crucial to the album’s success. It truly was a collaborative masterpiece. Which song do you think best showcases their influence? Don’t forget to subscribe for more in-depth Beatles content and discussions!
One of the most beautiful recorded tracks of all time. Especially love the dulcimer hammers ringing in this song, giving it that trippy, psychedelic vibe.
The dulcimer does give it that trippy vibe! It's details like this that make Beatles tracks so rich and rewarding to listen to. Any other unusual instruments in Beatles songs that you particularly enjoy?
Pepper was Paul's pet project, and a Hidden Concept album about LSD. They couldn't admit to it at the time, even ridiculously denying that Lucy wasn't about LSD, fearing the backlash. See "BEATLES: Is This The Secret Story Of Sgt. Pepper's?" James Hargreaves Guitar video about this. Those of us who grew up as The Beatles were releasing their music can see this, as we were a part of that generation and experienced that backlash.
that's an interesting perspective! The cultural context of the time definitely influenced how the Beatles presented their music. James Hargreaves’ channel has some great insights. What’s your take on the broader impact of Sgt. Pepper's on music and culture? subscribe for more insightful Beatles content and community discussions!
Nonsense. John would have been honest about it in later years.
Not Garbage John, Sgt Pepers BEST OF THE BEST Your Album forever...till the end of the world
@arifindnasir7209, well said! Sgt. Pepper's has definitely stood the test of time and remains a beloved album for many. It's amazing how their music continues to resonate with new generations. What’s your favorite track on Sgt. Pepper's? Don't forget to subscribe for more Beatles content and conversations!
@@TheRockAlchemy all of the track Sgt Pepers are master pieces. Unique. A Day In The Life was THE BEST all The Beatles songs. Shes Leaving home for the second..
The narrator says "George wished he was anywhere else". We'll according to an interview with "Paul", George was a no show for the recording sessions anyway.
You've raised an intriguing point about the conflicting accounts of George's involvement in the Sgt. Pepper's sessions. While his physical presence in the studio may have varied, I believe his emotional and creative journey during this period was still a crucial part of the story.
The 'revenge' I referred to was more about George's growing frustrations and desire for artistic assertion, which would fully manifest in his post-Pepper's work as he pushed for more control within the band.
But you've piqued my curiosity about the day-to-day details of George's contributions to the album. I'll definitely explore that angle more in my research and future videos.
Thanks for bringing this nuance to the discussion! Insights like yours are what make diving into Beatles history so rewarding. I'm always eager to hear fans' perspectives on these pivotal moments in the band's career.
If you have any other thoughts on George's role or the Sgt. Pepper's era, keep them coming! And don't forget to subscribe to catch all my upcoming deep-dives into the Fab Four's incredible journey.
I'm a singer songwriter heavily influenced by the Beatles and John Lennon is wrong,Sgt.Pepper is indeed a concept album and the evidence is on the cover of the Sgt.Pepper album itself,the concept is the end of the young mop top Beatles and the beginning of the more mature grown up Beatles and the cover is actually a funeral scene for the Beatles,the songs on the album also have a different more mature sound to them and at the time there were even people that thought the Beatles had changed their name to Sgt.Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band!,John also didn't like the album because it was Paul's baby and not his,there's a little bit of rivalry there and yes Sgt.Pepper is indeed the Beatles greatest album even though my favorite Beatles album to listen to is their American Rubber Soul album,the Beatles,the greatest band ever regardless of which album you listen to! Bob
@janetsampson1779, that's a brilliant interpretation! The cover art and the shift in their musical style definitely mark a new era for the Beatles. It’s fascinating how different perspectives can bring out new meanings. Rubber Soul is a fantastic album too, so many great tracks! As a singer-songwriter, how have the Beatles influenced your own music? subscribe for more Beatles/ classic rock insights and community discussions!
@@TheRockAlchemyAlchemy,I wouldn't be a musician today without the Beatles,they are the whole reason I ever picked up a guitar in the first place and even though I love John Lennon I've been told I sound a little like Paul,the Beatles are the best,I absolutely adore the guy's! Bob
@@janetsampson1779Wow how many records and how many top 20s?
John’s concept for the album was much better and more ambitious than Paul’s. Too ambitious to complete in the time frame expected by their label. Paul’s idea was a bailout that was just slapped on in order for them to be able to release SOMETHING.
Good comment Jan
Great video and quite interesting and accurate from my perspective.
I am a 60 year Beatles fanatic, obsessed by them since February 9th, 1964 when at just 8 years old, saw them on Ed Sullivan. I like Sgt. Pepper, but never thought it was the seminal album the media hyped it to be. Revolver and Rubber Soul were the turning point and in many respects, their zenith of creativity.
First, by the Beatles own words, Sgt. is NOT a "concept" album, and I am tired of hearing it called that. The songs have nothing to do with each other at all. Paul said the "reprise" was included to give the sense of interconnection. Listen to the album promo included in the 2009 Stereo box set and you can hear Paul explain that point.
As for the songs -" Good Morning, Good Morning "is actually one of my favorite on the album - although I like the Anthology 2 version slightly more without the barn animal sounds. Others are the Sgt.. Pepper songs , Lovely Rita, A Day in the Life, George's Within You, Without You", and Mr. Kite. The rest are OK.
On a overall Beatles album ranking - I would put it somewhere in the middle.
Wow, what an incredible journey you've had as a Beatles fan since seeing them on Ed Sullivan in 1964! Look out for a video about that soon from my channel - I would love to hear your thoughts on it. I'm so glad my video resonated with your perspective. You make a great point about Sgt. Pepper's not truly being a concept album in the way it's often portrayed. The promo from the 2009 stereo box set seems like a fantastic resource for understanding the band's original intent. love hearing your personal ranking of the songs and albums as someone who has followed them so closely for 60 years. Revolver and Rubber Soul are undeniably landmark albums in their own right. I'd be curious to hear more about what made those albums the creative zenith for you. If you're up for it, I'd be honored to have you share more of your Beatles journey and insights in the community tab sometime.
Thank you so much for watching and for the thoughtful comment! Consider subscribing if you'd like to catch more Beatles deep-dives and share your valuable perspective.
@@TheRockAlchemy Hi and thanks so much for your kind reply and perspective on my comments. I have a broad range of artists that I enjoyed over the years, but the Beatles will always be my number one sound track of my life for so many reasons that I will be happy to share after watching more of your videos. I am subscribed for sure. Take Care!! Tom
The great thing about Sgt. Pepper is the concept that you can put any song and it would've worked as long as it is a good song.
@kimmy-sp1dq, that’s a wonderful perspective! Sgt. Pepper’s diverse range of songs is part of what makes it so special. Do you have a favorite track on the album? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
Pepper is a fail as a concept album! They couldn’t pull it off the original concept (Through the Looking Glass) and caved to the pressure coming from higher ups, slapped on a feaux concept and released it. It was the same situation as Smile except Brian Wilson wouldn’t allow an incomplete rushed project to be released.
I love how Ringo literally 'Gets By With A Little Help From [His] Friends" on the song.
My favorite song on this LP (which I never bought).
So Paul writing When I'm 64 when he was 15 at home on piano is a response to Wouldn't be nice from Pet Sounds 😄 And John saying he would never write a sing like that, maybe he wouldn't but he gladly played it in Hamburg when there was a power outage 😀
Great point about the timeline of When I'm 64! You're absolutely right that Paul wrote it well before Pet Sounds came out. Yet some on my team were speculating about a potential connection given the similarities in tone and theme, but the chronology doesn't quite line up. I love that detail about them playing it in Hamburg during the power outage - really shows the song's roots in their early days. Thanks for sharing that bit of Beatles trivia and keeping me honest! If you enjoyed geeking out about song origins, you might like some of my other deep-dive videos. Check them out and consider subscribing for more Beatles content!
John didn't like When I'm 64 cuz it was Paul's "granny" old timey type song .... However on the White album Honey Pie which is also an old timey type granny tune... John had some nice tasty guitar licks which contributed nicely .
@@robertmckelvie2968 I don't think we can put too much weight into what John said at different times. He is also recorded saying this about When I'm 64: ‘When I’m Sixty-Four’ was something Paul wrote in the Cavern days. We just stuck a few more words on it like ‘grandchildren on your knee’ and ‘Vera, Chuck and Dave’. It was just one of those ones that he’d had, that we’ve all got, really; half a song. And this was just one that was quite a hit with us. We used to do them when the amps broke down, just sing it on the piano."
As a recording artist myself.....you are the only one who knows how you envision a song you wrote as a recording.....with "Lucy" John is expressing that it is a better song than the recording is.....I kind of agree with him.....The point is that The Beatles were such outstanding writers that it is amazing that they had enough talent as singers and musicians to make their final recordings as great as they are while moving in and out of all kinds of genres...........Very few of their songs when covered by other artists can exceed the Beatles version.....the two best I can think of are Celine Dion's "Here There And Everywhere" and Judy Collin's "In My Life"..........the most successful are the interpretations such as Joe Cocker's "A Little Help From My Friends" and Ray Charles "Eleanor Rigby".......but these are in a very different form than the originals......The Carpenters did some fine interpretations with "Help" and "Ticket To Ride"............Ray......"The George-Edwards Group"
As a fellow recording artist, your insights are so valuable! It's fascinating to hear you agree with John's thoughts on "Lucy" - the songwriter's vision doesn't always translate perfectly to the final recording.
You've really hit on something key about the Beatles' versatility. Their talent as singers and musicians let them navigate all those genres brilliantly, even if they sometimes felt the recordings fell short.
Great call on the standout covers too. It's tough to top the Beatles' originals, but those interpretations by Celine Dion, Judy Collins, Joe Cocker, Ray Charles, and the Carpenters are stellar.
I'd love to feature your own music (maybe as tracks for our docs!) and creative process sometime if you're up for sharing! Drop a link in the comments or shoot me a message. Thanks for contributing such great perspective to the discussion!
Our creative process was very much like "The Beatles" Ed plays Piano Guitar , Bass , Keyboards PercussionI Play Drums , Guitar and Keyboards......We start with a series of chords the lyrics come gradually as we work up the song we sing lead vocals on the songs we have written make suggestions for each others songs....in the studio layer the tracks and use studio tricks we mostly learned from "The Beatles" Jeff Emerick and George Martin...@@TheRockAlchemy
I love it when you realize John Lennon is singing the backing vocals! Totally my favorite part of the whole program! Makes me feel so happy I am with tears.
Your passion for the Beatles really shines through here! John's backing vocals are indeed special - they add so much depth and emotion to the tracks. It's wonderful how their music can still move us to tears after all these years. Do you have other favorite "hidden gem" moments in Beatles songs that casual listeners might miss? Your insights could really help us create some great content for true Beatles aficionados!
I've heard of countless McCartney songs that Lennon hated or disliked.....
But not one Lennon song that McCartney disliked.....
That's an interesting observation about Lennon's critiques of McCartney's songs. It does seem like John was more vocal about his opinions. But I wonder if there were any McCartney tunes that Lennon secretly admired, even if he didn't express it publicly. What do you think? I kind of think that was the situation with the song "Hey Jude" check it out in our other video! I'd be curious to hear your take on their dynamic.
@@TheRockAlchemy I think John secretly admired the vast majority of Paul's work. When John would declare a McCartney song as dross, he probably really meant he simply didn't feel it was up to Paul's full potential, and John outright alluded to this time & again in the 1980 interview with David Sheff.
That's because Lennon wrote the better songs. John 100% right. Paul wrote a lot of granny music. John's songs were always cosmic.
@@bendagostino2217 My current granny loves Lennon's music.....
@johnsain your granny must be cool..usually the grannies listen to tracks like Martha my dear.
Whose voice is that at 1:20 saying ‘we don’t want to tour anymore because nobody can hear us’ because it’s not the voice of any of the 4 Beatles!!
Thank you for your comment about the voice at 1:20. You're right to notice that it doesn't sound exactly like the Beatles. We use voice reenactments in our videos to bring historical quotes to life when original audio isn't available. While we strive for accuracy, these recreations aren't perfect. The content of the quote is accurate, but we appreciate your keen ear in noticing the difference in voice. We're always working to improve our content and presentation. Thanks for watching and for your attention to detail!
I can imagine side 2 as Within You Without You, Penny Lane, Strawberry Fields Forever, It's All Too Much, Sgt P. Reprise, and A Day In A Life. Of course this selection is tantamount to heresy from the purists.
@jamescpotter, that's a fascinating reimagining of side 2! It would definitely give the album a unique twist. The blend of those tracks would make for a truly epic listening experience. Purists might call it heresy, but sometimes it’s fun to think about what could have been. What other alternate tracklists would you create for Beatles albums? Don't forget to subscribe for more great content and to join our awesome community!
Each of the four had their lives....they were people outside of their music and job 👍...then when they were together the magic ✨ was there
You're spot on - the Beatles were multidimensional individuals with rich lives beyond the band. It's amazing how they could come together and create that alchemy in the studio and on stage. Do you have a favorite moment or story that you feel captures their unique chemistry? I'd love to hear your perspective. Subscriber insights like yours are what bring these videos to life and check out the community polls soon about where the channel is heading!
I always thought Sgt Pepper wasn't one of their best albums. It's a great record but I like the other ones a lot better
I'm with you - while I appreciate Sgt. Pepper's innovation and cultural impact, it's not necessarily my go-to Beatles album either. (Abbey Road!) There's something to be said for the simplicity and directness of their earlier records, or the more back-to-basics approach they took on the White Album and Let It Be. But that's the great thing about the Beatles' catalog - there's something for every taste and mood. I'm curious which albums you prefer and what it is about them that resonates with you. Sparking friendly debate about the band's best work is one of my favorite things about this channel. And if you want to dive deeper into the making of the Beatles' various masterpieces, be sure to subscribe so you don't miss any upcoming videos. Thanks for chiming in with your perspective!
@@TheRockAlchemy yes its got a day in the life and lucy in the sky,,a little help from my friends thats it in my opinion
The Byrds - Younger than Yesterday, is also a brilliant album from 1967.
Great mention of The Byrds' "Younger Than Yesterday"! 1967 was such an incredible year for music. How do you think that album compares to Sgt. Pepper in terms of innovation or impact? subscribe and hopefully catch a video of this subject soon!
Around this time, in November 66 we had the LP Da Capo by Love, and in November 67 Forever Changes by Love. Now I know that Love and Arthur Lee never really made it very big outside of California, but "the Summer of Love" was pretty distinctly a California-centric thing, and so I would say that, at least behind the scenes, the group Love and Arthur Lee had a huge influence on the so-called "Summer of Love"; I bet their music was almost as ubiquitous that year as Sgt Pepper was, there, in LA and San Francisco. It's just they don't seem to get as much mention as all the other bands; I mean, there were SO MANY amazing bands and records that year, with The Doors, Hendrix, The Mamas and the Papas, with their 'California Dreamin' and Monterey Pop Festival, (on 6/16/67), The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds (5/66), and on and on. May 67 had Scott McKenzie's anthemic "San Francisco", with the 'flowers in your hair' line; penned by John Phillips of the Mamas and the Papas. Who knows how many thousands of bright eyed, tie-dyed, garlanded bubble gum groupies showed up to get strung out and pregnant thanks to that bit of divine propaganda? There was so much original and revolutionary music around at that point, it's no wonder it culminated in a so called "Summer of Love" that was really over before it actually started. By the time the kids were showing up at Haight Ashbury with their paisley bell bottoms and patchouli, it was now the mob, and smack, acid and meth that were ruling that scene... :/ See George Harrison's heartbreaking report on his visit to Frisco on 8/7/67 (mere months after "Pepper's" release) for a rather sad and different take on the whole thing.
@PaisleyPatchouli, you’ve painted such a vivid picture of the era! Love and Arthur Lee definitely deserve more recognition for their influence on the Summer of Love. The sheer amount of groundbreaking music from that time is astounding. George Harrison's visit to Haight Ashbury indeed offered a sobering perspective. What’s your favorite album/ memory from that revolutionary year? Please stick around and subscribe for more engaging Beatles and 60s music discussions!
I think that if John had lived longer, he would have mellowed out some. It's too bad most of the things he said were in the immediate years following the breakup, so he still had that sharp sense of bitterness and denial. Same with George to some degree. At least we still have Paul and Ringo, and all the greatness that the Beatles gave us when they were together. Thank GOD...
You make a great point about how time might have changed John's perspective. It's interesting to consider how the Beatles' legacies and relationships might have evolved if circumstances had been different. Do you have any thoughts on how John's later work showed signs of that potential mellowing?
@@TheRockAlchemy Hi Again! From accounts that I read of people close to John from summer 1980 before he died, they were all saying how he was very "Positive", and "Upbeat" and "Enthusiastic" in general that summer, especially while in Bermuda and when making "Double Fantasy". Songs like "Watching the Wheels", "Grow Old with Me", and "Woman" I think seem to reflect and personify somewhat an attitude of "mellowing out" of his personality, acceptance of aging and him reflecting on life. It seems so tragic that just as John had finally found some peace and true happiness in his life, it was cut short by a madman for NO reason.
John hated Pepper, he hated Abbey Road, but Yoko's music was fantastic. What a joke.
@macharper8214, John definitely had some strong opinions! His feelings about the Beatles' albums and Yoko’s music are often debated. What’s your take on his solo work compared to his Beatles contributions? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
William,er,Paul was the band leader on those records which were both his concept & execution. He would even go back & rerecord some of the band's parts if he felt they weren't perfect.Not only Lennon resented him but the rest of the band as well when he took over.
John was a pinball who bounced off bumper-from-bumper about The Beatles and even about his own work. He would outright contradict himself in interviews. Weird guy. I always admired him, but the older I become, the more I realize how messed up John Lennon could be sometimes.
And I cared for very little of his post-Beatles music.
hes breaking the myth whereas paul is happy that u worship him lol
Have you seen the video of John Lennon and Chuck Berry playing "Johnny B. Goode" together? In the middle of it, Yoko, who was just sitting there with a microphone in front of her, suddenly burst into her "Wow-ow-ow". The engineer quickly shut off her mike, but the expression on Chuck Berry's was truly memorable. His eyes widened in utter disbelief.
John and George are full of it in regards to their views on this album.
It's interesting how John and George seemed to sour on Sgt. Pepper's over time, isn't it? I wonder how much of that was genuine dissatisfaction vs. just the natural tendency to be more critical of your past work. Do you think there were particular reasons they were inclined to distance themselves from it later on? I'd love to hear your take! If you enjoyed this kind of analysis, consider subscribing for more explorations of classic rock and Beatles history and lore.
The Beach Boys see themselves as The Beach Boys; George was silly.
Ha, fair point about the Beach Boys' unshakeable sense of identity! They definitely knew who they were as a band. I think George's comment was more a reflection of his own insecurity and frustration at that point in the Beatles' career. He was feeling a bit lost in the shuffle and overshadowed by John and Paul, so he projected those feelings onto the idea that the Beatles as a whole had lost their way. The Beatles could never be anyone but themselves, even as they pushed their sound in new directions. If you're interested in learning more about George's perspective during this era, I've got a whole video diving into his complicated relationship with Pattie and Eric and the song "Something!" Check it out and consider subscribing for more deep dives into the individual Beatles' stories. Thanks for watching and sharing your reaction!
John had oppositional defiance disorder -- just kidding, but John did love to ruin things for other people.
@yelloworangered, haha, John definitely had a rebellious streak! His going against the grain is part of what made him so interesting. It’s interesting to see how that attitude influenced his music and relationships. What’s your favorite John Lennon song? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
At the time...The Monkees were giving everyone a run for their money when it came to figuring out who was on top
@charlesbronson4282, the Monkees definitely had a huge impact and were incredibly popular during that time! It was an exciting era for music with so many great bands vying for the top spot. What’s your favorite Monkees song or memory? Maybe we will make a video about it! Please subscribe for more Beatles and 60s music content and discussions!
Never heard a guy who tried to be pick holes in a fantastic Album and the other groups he mentioned are not in the same class
@stucarmichael4561, thanks for sharing your thoughts! The Beatles definitely set a high bar, and Sgt. Pepper’s is a classic for many. The comparisons with other bands are always interesting but can be subjective. What’s your favorite aspect of the album? Please subscribe for more engaging Beatles content and discussions!
Stop this AI reply nonsense.
John was a rebel, he had a troubled childhood and that influenced on his personality.
You're absolutely right about John's rebellious nature and how his childhood influenced him. It's a crucial part of understanding his art and personality. Are there any specific examples of how you think his background shaped his music or lyrics?
sgt pepper was a great progression for the beatles and for the 1967 haight ashbury hippie movement
Great point about Sgt. Pepper's impact on the '67 Haight-Ashbury scene! It really captured the spirit of the times. How do you think the album influenced the hippie movement and counterculture? That could be a great video if our community likes this discussion! Subscribe to explore the connections between music and culture and thanks for sharing your mind!
Sgt. Peppers' true legacy is that it changed how albums were recorded. There were so many innovations that are now just standard practice today.
You're absolutely right about Sgt. Pepper's impact on recording techniques! It really did revolutionize the industry. Do you have a favorite innovative moment from the album? I'm interested to learn about the technical aspects that fans appreciate. subscribe for a great community and more great content. Always improving!
I wonder about this Car accident when Paul left the Revolver session in anger and supposedly had the car crash the "Conspiracy Theorists" are claiming killed Paul when he left the Revolver sessions? Was there any car accident at all on the 11th of September, 1966 (Strange date?) with Paul? I dont believe in this "Conspiracy Theory" about "Billy Shears" and Paul is dead BS. But I heard that Paul had a head trauma crashing a moped in some Spanish holiday resort and another head trauma in 1966?
There are truly bizarre books called "Memoires of Billy Shears" in 2 volumes, one in Red and One in Blue, written by Freemason E U Harriet. The truly bizarre is that its Paul McCartneys own publisher company printing the books and George Martin's youngest son reads the audio version?
These 2 books are NOT written with Sarcasm or Humour and it go deep into this "Billy Shear" replaced Paul who died in the 1966 car crash? So why?
The author E U Harriet has a RUclips account as well as Facebook account and he answered my question about his motive for writing this book for Paul, by stating "Tavistock Institute" made the Beatles into a social engineering experiment with MI6 and CIA and Paul McCartney were killed in 1966!" And that's E U Harriet saying this, NOT me!
So lets hear if you guys know anything about it?
If Paul McCartney would have died? The Odds of finding a body double with plastic surgery of the 1960s, equally talented and an even more amazing songwriter as Paul became after 1966 is astronomical! But what is the motive for Paul to keep this "Conspiracy Theory" alive is strange?
Those who believe Paul is dead and Faul took his place, often refer to pictures of Paul pre-1966 with brown eyes and post 1966 he has Hazel coloured eye
The 'Paul is gone' conspiracy theory is certainly a fascinating rabbit hole! While I don't personally believe Paul was replaced, the various 'clues' and rumors are intriguing from a cultural perspective.
You've highlighted some of the key elements - the alleged car crashes, the 'Memoirs of Billy Shears' books, the astronomical odds of finding an exact McCartney duplicate. It's a lot to unpack!
Without more direct info from Paul or the author, the true motives behind the conspiracy and the books remain a mystery. But it's fun to speculate!
At the end of the day, I think Paul is amused by the whole thing and likes to playfully fuel the rumors, even if some fans take it quite seriously.
Regardless of where one stands on the theory, it shows how much The Beatles affect the whole world. It's the kind of legend that only springs up around true cultural icons.
Thanks for the thought-provoking comment! I'm always happy to respectfully discuss these theories, wherever people land on them. Let me know what you think about the voice reenactments in my videos - I'm experimenting with new ways to bring Beatles history to life, and I'm curious to hear your perspective!
@@TheRockAlchemy I think you nailed it with their voices. And speaking of voices they have compared Paul's voice before and after the supposed car crash in 66. A computer analysis of Paul came from the same person in 1965 and 1989.
John always hated Paul's non POP-ROCK SONGS.....but these songs gave the Beatles even more great versatility......Songs like "Ob-La Di Ob-La Da"....a Polka......and his 1920's inspired efforts "When I'm 64"......"Honey Pie"......."Martha My Dear" and "Your Mother Should Know"
Great point about how Paul's non-rock/pop songs added so much versatility to the Beatles' catalog! Songs like Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da, When I'm 64, Honey Pie etc. aren't always the most celebrated, but they showcased Paul's incredible range as a songwriter. The 1920s-inspired tunes in particular add such a delightful, whimsical element. Do you have a favorite among Paul's genre excursions? Let me know in the comments!
If you want to hear more about the stories behind Paul's stylistically diverse compositions, make sure you're subscribed with the notification bell on. I have some new videos in the works you won't want to miss! Thanks so much for watching and sharing your insights.
@@TheRockAlchemy "Martha My Dear" is one of my favorite Beatles cuts.....great melody.....use of horns in a 1930's style.....fine piano work by Paul.....perfect bass for the tune.......
When Elton gets all those keyboard tracks in the middle bridge, to use language perhaps a little dated at the time, the song is so "far out", it's really trippy. It's said that Lennon's reading of Lewis Carroll, the author of "Alice in Wonderland" was an influence in his imagery in this song.
I've just seen a Beatles documentary where John is recorded as saying that he felt Paul, at times, would "subconsciously sabatoge" his songs. In support of this, John said they were always very careful with Paul's songs, working a long time to clean up the tracks. "But when it came time to work on my songs, all of a sudden a spirit of experimentality crept in. . ."'Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" was not made right. I mean it's a good song, but the song wasn't made right.
Would be interesting to see, given the fact that Lennon participates on this track (most dramatically when the song broke into reggae) what he thought of the two versions; which one he would like better. I hazard to guess John probably preferred this version of his song, and if John's perceptions were indeed correct, there certainly was no "subconscious sabatage" by Elton of this song! The two worked beautifully together on this song!
I think John was full of paranoid bs about the "unconscious sabotage" of his songs. The truth is more like John didn't really know what he was after half the time, as opposed to Paul who seemed to have had very clear ideas about what he wanted done with his own songs.
In short, I think John was envious of Paul's creative focus, and John sideways blamed Paul for his own lack of it.
@@BigBri550 I think you're right on in that assessment. Unfortunately, Lennon was a very damaged human being. Check out the movie "Nowhere Boy" to look at his very damaged childhood and his troubled relationship with Paul, who also lost his mother. Lots of psychological depth here between these two, and George as well. Ringo always just wanted to fit in with these three.
One of many to do a cover of this song. Natalie Cole, Nat King Cole's daughter who passed away in the past five years or so at the age of 65, also performs a beautiful and worthwhile version of this very same song.
Thanks for subscribing and joining the community, DJ! And thanks for mentioning Natalie Cole's version! It's always interesting to hear how other artists interpret Beatles classics. Do you have other favorite Beatles covers we should check out?
I really enjoy Good Morning. Ringo's drumming is great & John's vocal is outstanding. It truly , ,wonderfully captures a day in the life of a suburbanite.
Glad you enjoy "Good Morning"! You're spot on about Ringo's drumming and John's vocal performance. It's a great snapshot of suburban life. Do you have other favorite examples of the Beatles capturing everyday experiences in their songs?
Lennon know sgt peppers was a peak he never called it garbage he just said that about one song...but he liked the white album better...ringo knew it was great too but he liked the white album better too... And Harrison was getting into indian culture and musicbl and not really mentally tuned into sgt peppers
@manny4552, you’re right! Each Beatle had their own unique perspective on Sgt. Pepper's. John’s criticism was specific, and their preferences evolved over time. It’s interesting to see how their individual tastes influenced their music. What’s your favorite Beatles album or story? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
Gawd! That looping riff is infuriating!
We appreciate your feedback on the background music. We're always looking to improve the listening experience. What kind of background elements do you think would enhance the video without being distracting? subscribe to see how we make our content unable to click away from more and more!
I love the continous cymballs when Nigel Olsson, Elton John's drummer, does his short but powerful drum solo at the end of the song.
Great observation about Nigel Olsson's drumming! Those cymbal crashes really add power to the solo. Do you have other favorite drum moments in classic rock?
@@TheRockAlchemy his cymbals are compressed there so suttle spelled very wrong on yellow brick road for sure
Is there anyone else out there who couldn’t get through this video because of the monotonous background music? How long can you can you listen to a two Bar Loop? I wanted to pull my finger nails out just to perk things up.
Oh no, I'm so sorry the background music loop was so grating! I definitely don't want anyone pulling their fingernails out. 😉 Seriously though, I appreciate you taking the time to give that feedback. I'm still learning and experimenting with the music beds. I'll work on finding some less repetitive tracks or changing them up more frequently throughout the video. If you have music available to you that you would like me to feature, that would be awesome! Thanks again for watching and let me know what you think!
Good morning good morning is actually one of my favourite songs on the album
@patrickkiely1098, that’s awesome to hear! 'Good Morning Good Morning' definitely has a unique charm and energy. What do you love most about the song? Don't forget to subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
@@TheRockAlchemy I guess it's the energy of the and I can just so relate to the lyrics, who hasn't had one of those days where you just don't go to work and let your feet take you on a random journey and just go with the flow of the day
Last living Monkee is fond of that tune
Mine too because IT ROCKS!! :)
Great video!
@krsnaloka333-po9cp, thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it. Do you have a favorite Beatles album or song? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and community discussions!
I love Good Morning. The way he syncopated the lyrics is really amazing.
Absolutely! The syncopation in "Good Morning" is truly impressive. It's amazing how John could take inspiration from something as simple as a cereal commercial and turn it into such a complex and engaging song. Do you have any other favorite examples of clever lyrical or rhythmic techniques in Beatles songs? Your ear for musical detail is fantastic!
@@TheRockAlchemy How about the end of For No One? It opens in the key of C major. They add a B♭ toward the end of the first verse which resolves to the tonic. Interesting sound.
The chorus is interesting. It seems to modulate to D minor. But this is where the real spice is in my opinion. The last line goes A7 (the dominant) to Dm (the tonic) to (the subdominant) Gsus4 G. It's a Minor Plagal Cadence. Who did that in pop music in the 60’s? They also used it in In My Life.
You missed the Piper at the Gates of Dawn, Pink Floyds depute.
You're absolutely right, "The Piper at the Gates of Dawn" was another landmark album from 1967. Thanks for mentioning it! How do you think Pink Floyd's debut compares to Sgt. Pepper in terms of its impact on psychedelic rock? Maybe we should make a video about them soon!
@@TheRockAlchemy pink floyd blows that away. :)
Mad because the album was not his idea…
Interesting take on John's feelings about the album! (how did i know you were talking about John?) The dynamics within the band during this period were certainly complex. Do you think John's attitude towards Sgt. Pepper changed over time? We'd love to hear your thoughts on how the album impacted the group's relationships.
Pretty good thank you, however the royalty-free 'Slow Ride' in the bg drags this down
Thanks for the feedback and for watching! I appreciate you letting me know the royalty-free music was a bit distracting. I am partnering up with a company that could provide us with hit tunes as background music soon! I'm still experimenting with the background music and will definitely keep that in mind for future videos. If there are other topics you'd like to see me cover or ways I can improve the viewing experience, let me know in the comments or community tab. And of course, if you liked the video overall, subscribing is the best way to support the channel!
The Beatles did plenty of good while they were together.
@normanglussier6473, absolutely! Their influence on music and culture is immeasurable. What’s your favorite Beatles accomplishment or contribution? Maybe we can make a video about it! Please subscribe for more Beatles and rock content and discussions!
Good documentary. The only problem is that guitar riff that keeps repeating in the background. It is extremely annoying.
I really appreciate the kind words about the documentary! I'm so glad you found it engaging overall, we are all really enthused and engaged in creating these for you all but also for ourselves!
And thanks for flagging the repetitive guitar riff - you're not the first to point that out (facepalm), and I totally hear it now. Definitely going to be more mindful of mixing up the background music in future videos. I never want the soundtrack to distract from the story.
If there are particular topics or angles you'd like to see explored in upcoming episodes, let me know in the comments or on the community tab. And if you want to catch all the latest deep-dives, consider hitting that subscribe button.
Thanks again for watching and taking the time to share your feedback - it genuinely helps me refine and improve the channel. More Beatles (and other rock star ;)) content coming soon!
George had his own contract with Northern Songs. Paul and John GAVE George and Ringo that small share in THEIR songs as both helped make the songs. George did leave Northern when he could and created Harrisongs to publish his songs.
Pepper did begin as a concept album with Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields, and as you claim, only a Northern Song
Then Paul made it a fake band concept. The Pepper band could have made all the songs, though George's song would have not been likely as part of the concept.
Thank you for sharing those details about the Beatles' publishing arrangements and the evolution of Sgt. Pepper's concept. It's fascinating to consider how the album's theme developed over time. That could be a whole other video! Do you have a favorite song from the album that you feel best embodies the "Sgt. Pepper's Band" concept?
Axis Bold As Love came out in 67. That is still one of the greatest albums of all time.
You're spot on about "Axis: Bold As Love" - it's a true masterpiece that showcases Hendrix's incredible talent and innovation. That would be another interesting video for us to make! We love exploring these groundbreaking albums and their impact on rock history. If you enjoy discussions about influential records like this, consider subscribing to Rock Alchemy. We're always diving into the stories behind the classic albums that shaped rock music.
Jeez John was a whinger ! That effect after WYWY was crowd like to add the vibe and also on BFTBOMK! the whole atmosphere was circus crowd and show and the carry on in GMGM was conducive to the whole atmosphere of the concept and finally ditto for LITSWD !!! So lets compromise and call Pepper Quasiconcept Psychedelic !! 🌈💈😹👁️🤡
Lennon did pretty good reggae in the '70's. We'll need to check out his posthumously released song with the ironic title, "Living on Borrowed Time". Eerily prescient of John on some level to do a song like that.
You're right, Lennon did explore reggae in his solo work. "Living on Borrowed Time" is hauntingly prescient. Have you checked out his other reggae-influenced tracks?
And on the Lennon reggae bridge part, you can hear the two of them singing together!
Good ear! Those moments when John and Paul's voices blend are truly magical. Do you have other favorite Lennon-McCartney vocal collaborations?
Firstly Penny Lane & Strawberry Fields Forever outsold Please Release Me by 40% it's just that in those days in the U.K. a double #1 sales were halved ; secondly they could've kept their songs on Pepper only half the LPs didn't and George Martin regretted that mistake and lastly John due to his mental state was often rubbishing perfectly good tracks for example And Your Bird Can Sing! 😹
@johnbyrnes7912, great points! The sales strategy in the UK back then definitely impacted the charts. George Martin’s hindsight on those decisions is fascinating too. John’s critical nature, especially during that rocky period, certainly shaped their music in unexpected ways. What’s your favorite underrated Beatles track?
@@TheRockAlchemyThe Inner Light , I've Just Seen A Face and Yes It Is to name 3 !!
It was mostly Paul's album. I sense JEALOUSY.
There was definitely some complex band dynamics around Sgt. Pepper. Even if it was Paul's baby, every Beatle made crucial contributions. What's your take on how their interpersonal relationships shaped their music? Subscribe to dig deeper into Beatles and classic rock history with me and the community!
Are all of these voices Ai?
Good ear! We use a mix of AI voices for the Beatles' quotes and a human narrator from Ohio for the main content. We're constantly working on improving the audio experience. What do you think of this approach? We're always open to feedback from our viewers.
This album does have a lot of songs on it that are all horn and string driven so musically they didn't even play on those ones; they just sang on them. That could account for the boredom in those cases. In any event, even though it was enjoyable to listen to, the earlier stuff they did before SSgt pepper was really nothing to write home about musically but from this album on was when their music was starting to mature and was going somewhere. It likely wasn't the music on the album that John didn't like, it was likely more that since he wasn't involved in writing the music his ego kicked in because he didn't have that degree of control anymore. That's what I think he really didn't like.
@jimo3173, you bring up some great points! The orchestral arrangements on Sgt. Pepper’s were a big departure from their earlier, more guitar-driven work. It makes sense that this shift in their creative process could lead to some boredom or frustration. And you're right about John’s potential feelings-creative control is a huge factor for any artist.... or really, anyone! It's fascinating how their music evolved from that point on. What’s your favorite post-Sgt. Pepper Beatles album? Please subscribe for more great content and conversation!
The overlooked best album of the summer of love after Pepper…Johnny Rivers-Realization
Johnny Rivers' "Realization" is a great pick for an overlooked Summer of Love album! It definitely deserves more recognition. Maybe we could do a video on it! What do you think makes it stand out among the other releases of that era? Subscribe for more deep dives into classic rock gems!
Some very funny Beatles impersonators on this. Still, an enjoyable listen.
@risteardohaodha23, glad you enjoyed the video! Sometimes a bit of humor makes the stories even more fun to revisit. Do you have a favorite Beatles impersonator or parody? Please subscribe for more engaging Beatles content and conversations!
This is rubbish. Pepper is one of the greatest Albums ever written and u are over exaggerating what went on . Brian Wilson admitted he spent his life trying to write songs that as good as THE BEATLES and h will hear him saying this on a video . George caused the trouble he had started writing and wanted more of his songs on the Albums but he should have been grateful because if John snd Paul got them to the top.
There has never been a band to equal THE BEATLES
Your passion for Sgt. Pepper is clear! It's undoubtedly a landmark album. Our video aims to explore some of the lesser-known aspects and challenges during its creation, which don't diminish its greatness but add depth to its story. What's your favorite track on the album and why?
John just thought that being negative helped his "genius" persona.
If Pepper was garbage, was did that make "sometime in new York city"
Interesting perspective on John's critical stance! You're right that his opinions could be quite harsh at times. It's interesting to compare his views on different albums throughout his career. How do you think John's solo work compares to the Beatles' albums? We'd love to hear your thoughts on his musical evolution. What other stories would you want to see into videos?
Subscribe for more and check out the community page and shorts for more. thanks, Stuart!
George heads to India to learn the sitar - cue intercut - and a harp-run is presented. ... why
Hey Dirk! Great catch on that musical mismatch in the editing! The harp run doesn't quite align with George's sitar studies. We want our content to be tongue-in-cheek but still accurate and engaging, especially for true fans like yourself! I really appreciate your keen eye (and ear) for detail. We're always striving to refine our storytelling techniques. What kind of musical transitions do you think would work well for George's Indian music journey? Subscribe to be part of the creative process as we hone our craft!
It’s the beginning of the song “she’s leaving home”
1967 our Grandparents gave us a 4 track player with 4 songs from Sgt Pepper. Sgt Pepper/ With a Little. / LSDiamonds/ Being For The Benefit...... It would be 1972 before I bought the LP! I LUV IT!! And I love The Stones Their Satanic Majesties Request!!!
What an amazing introduction to Sgt. Pepper! Those four tracks alone showcase the album's incredible range. It's cool to hear how your appreciation for the album grew over time. And yes, Their Satanic Majesties Request is another gem from that era! It's often seen as the Stones' response to Sgt. Pepper.
Speaking of the Stones, we're actually working on a video about their album Bridges to Babylon and how it relates to the Beatles' journey. I don't want to give away too much just yet, but it explores some fascinating connections between the two bands. Stay tuned for that!
In the meantime, I'd love to hear your thoughts on Sgt. Pepper and Their Satanic Majesties Request. Do you feel like the two albums share any common vibes or themes? How do you think they complement each other? Your insights could even inspire future videos! Thanks for sharing your story.
Lennon is harsh. He liked to shock. Personally, Pepper does not interest me. But everything they did had merit.
You make a great point about Lennon's harsh and shocking statements. Even if Sgt. Pepper's isn't your favorite, it's true that the Beatles' entire catalog has artistic merit. Which album or era of their music resonates most with you personally? I'm always eager to hear different fan perspectives!
I loved Good Morning!! One of the better songs on the album. I think John wanted to just mouth off. He could get very moody and arbitrary when he wasn't feeling right. I think it's a great song. Plus it fits very well where it was placed.
Ooh interesting pushback on John's Good Morningx2 take! You raise a fair point about his moodiness sometimes coloring his opinions on the band's work. He was definitely known for his hot-and-cold relationship with their catalog post-breakup.
I agree that Good Morningx2 is a solid album cut and serves an important role in the Pepper's tracklist. The rooster sound effects and horns give it a really distinct flavor that stands out.
At the same time, I can understand John feeling like it was a bit disposable compared to his more weighty, personal contributions. Curious if you think his dismissal might've also been a veiled dig at Paul's increasing control over the album/band at this point.
This is the kind of juicy Beatles debate I live for! If you're down to dissect more Fab Four hot takes, sound off in the comments or head over to the community tab.
And definitely hit subscribe if you want to keep exploring the highs, lows, and dramas of their career - I've got tons more videos in the works.
Thanks for watching and sharing your perspective. Gotta love a good Beatles nerd-out sesh!
i agree with John. I have always felt Lucy in the sky with diamonds does not sound good. Never understood why it was so popular. I guess lyrics are interesting. maybe it is the lyrics that makes it popular. It COULD be made to sound like a good song. I think this is what John is saying.
Great point about the lyrics being the main draw of Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds, even if the production doesn't quite land. The vivid, psychedelic imagery and Alice in Wonderland vibes are definitely a big part of the song's enduring appeal.
I can see what you (and John) mean about it not being sonically perfect though. There's a sense that the trippiness of the words isn't fully matched by the music, which stays relatively grounded.
It would be fascinating to hear a reimagined version that really leans into the dreamlike, hallucinatory feel - maybe with some more experimental instrumentation and effects.
drop your other picks in the comments! Love hearing fresh perspectives from thoughtful fans.
And if you want to keep diving into the stories behind the Fab Four's hits and hidden gems, consider subscribing. Plenty more to explore
John said a lot of crazy things Beatles fans love "And Your Bird Can Sing"......John did not
the masses have spoken
You make a great point about the disconnect between John's opinions and the fans' reception of certain songs. "And Your Bird Can Sing" is indeed a fan favorite despite John's criticism. It just goes to show how art can take on a life of its own once it's out in the world. Are there other Beatles songs you love that John or the other band members weren't fond of? subscribe for more great rock stories and discussions
when i was going through the 'hippie' phases Good morning was definitely one of my favs. Esp. since the solo is one of my favorite guitar solos of all time. I'm sure many songs like Strawberry fields were many people's favorite songs.
Glad Good Morning was a favorite of yours during your 'hippie phase'! That guitar solo is epic. Strawberry Fields is another one that was hugely popular and groundbreaking at the time. I'm hoping to feature both songs in future videos taking a deep dive into the stories behind them. If you haven't already, subscribe and hit the notification bell so you don't miss them!
You can't really trust anything John said at any given moment. He would say something and contradict it a moment later. As he admitted, "It's just comes out of my mouth." And I'm not sure we can even believe that! A good example is "Good Morning, Good Morning." John says he got the song from a commercial, but the rest of the song (a witty look at a normal, humdrum day) was entirely written and recorded before he came up with the idea of using the jingle as a chorus, so he's rewriting history a bit there.
You make an excellent point about John's tendency to contradict himself. It certainly adds an intriguing layer to Beatles history! Your insight about "Good Morning, Good Morning" is fascinating. Do you have other examples of John's 'revisionist' takes on their songs? This kind of deep dive into songwriting origins is always appreciated! Please subscribe and stick around for more great content and community!
Hey narrator, are you really that clueless ?
August 21st , 1966 ?
Any Beatles fan would know that their final tour concert was on Aug. 29th , of 66' !!! FAIL !!
, Dean ( in Syracuse)
@wayofthinkin, thanks for catching that! You’re absolutely right, the final tour concert was indeed on August 29th, 1966. We appreciate the correction and strive to provide accurate information. Thanks for being a dedicated Beatles fan and keeping us on our toes! Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions.
@@TheRockAlchemy Nice. Way to own up to the mistake. Things happen. Thank you for taking ownership.
I watched this video to get an idea of what the "real past" was like. I never got into the Beatles, but am recently discovering their actual greatness. Hearing and seeing the generative content was disappointing for me in what was otherwise superb content. I'm looking for some nostalgic "something" from before I was born. I actually think part of the search for this is a reaction to knowing that future media soon will be indistinguishable from ML Generative content. The Beatles are 'real' in a way media/music will never be again. I scanned the comments and many people seemed to notice the generative audio, and I did not see any comments about the generative images. My unsolicited advice would be when doing a historical piece to keep it accurate using a traditional journalistic standard. This will root you in authenticity. Coming from someone who works with AI also and makes chatbots for public use. I know you have to do you, and I don't know how to make a successful channel. My two cents. Good luck and be well.
Thank you for your thoughtful feedback on our content. We appreciate your perspective on the use of generative content in historical pieces. Our goal is to bring these stories to life while respecting the authenticity of the original material. We're always working to improve our content and balance new technologies with historical accuracy. Your input is valuable as we continue to refine our approach. We hope you'll stick around as we explore more "real" moments in rock history!
Let’s just be completely honest here. We all know damn well that if John actually meant what he said. He’d stick “For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite” first lol 😎
@evandylan, haha, you’ve got a point! John’s sense of humor and critical nature were certainly unique. 'For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite' is such a quirky track. What’s your take on its place in the album? Please subscribe for more fun Beatles insights and discussions!
I had the fast forward to get out of that 4-second rift played over and over. But it didn't stop...AAHHH!!
I appreciate your feedback on the background music. We're always looking to improve the listening experience. In future videos, we'll aim for more varied background elements that enhance rather than distract. Thanks for sticking with the video despite the repetitive riff! And subscribe to see content that you want to see. and hear!
there is something wrong with people that hate Within u Without u---the time WILL come
Agreed! "Within You Without You" is a deeply profound track that showcases George's growing interest in Indian music and philosophy. It's definitely a song that reveals more layers with each listen. What aspects of the song do you find most compelling? Subscribe and share for more deep dives and thanks!
@@TheRockAlchemy the slight chuckling at the end is so spot on, makes the whole record
Paul had great songs during The Beatles i could even say better than from John but obviously i never put down John. He was unique no doubt about it and he showed that more after break up of the beatles. I coukd say both if them were extremely talented. SGT Peppers is one if the best album the Beatles ever made. To me it is timeless classic Just unbelievable idea from cover to songs.
I can believe how John almost killed himself taking that LS.
That incident with John was certainly a close call. It highlights some of the dangers associated with... experimentation during that era. How do you think experiences like this influenced the Beatles' music and personal lives?
Without Paul, the Beatles would have been over after Revolver!
You make an interesting point about Paul's role in the Beatles' longevity! He certainly was a driving force behind Sgt. Pepper. Do you think the other members' contributions to the album are sometimes overlooked? We'd love to hear your thoughts on the group dynamics during this period. What kind of video would you and your audience like to see next? Subscribe for a great community and content!
These text to AI voices are funny. Paul McCartney sounds like he grew up in the US or Australia.
@Scotty_Russell_Music, glad you found some humor in the voices! We aim to add a bit of campy fun to the videos. We’re always working to improve them (and their accents!), so your feedback is appreciated. Do you think the voices add to the experience or take away from it? Please subscribe for more Beatles content and discussions!
@@TheRockAlchemy As a massive lifelong Beatles devotee I have strong opinions about anyone who isn't legitimately associated with the band or remaining relatives of the deceased Beatles resurrecting their voices without express consent. Sorry if that's a downer for you to hear, this is the thin edge of the wedge, the tip of the iceberg, next thing they'll be touring a hologram Amy Winehouse singing Ed Sheeran and Adelle songs with special guest appearances from Elvis and Michael Jackson.
@@TheRockAlchemy On reflection if you must use the AI voices keep them a bit "uncanny valley" and then i can spot the fakery a mile off lol
It's all good , good luck with your content and all the best. Cheers
Monkees “Headquarters” was released a week before “Sgnt Pepper”.
Great observation about the Monkees' "Headquarters"! It's fascinating to consider the musical landscape of 1967. How do you think "Headquarters" compares to "Sgt. Pepper" in terms of its impact or innovation? subscribe for more content and a great community!
@@TheRockAlchemy Headquarters topped the charts for one week. Then it was all Sgt Pepper. Artistically? Headquarters was good but not groundbreaking.
Nothing about “A Day in the Life”?
You're absolutely right, I didn't touch on A Day in the Life in this video! That song definitely warrants its own deep-dive.
A Day in the Life is such a groundbreaking track in terms of its structure, production, and the way it blends John and Paul's distinct songwriting voices. The orchestral crescendos and abstract lyrics really push the boundaries of what a pop song could be.
I'm planning to do a whole video on the making of A Day in the Life and its legacy - both as the epic finale to Sgt. Pepper's and as a standalone masterpiece.
If there are any particular angles or stories around the song you're curious about, let me know in the comments! I'm always looking to tailor these docs to viewer interests.
And be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the other Beatles deep-dives in the works. And hopefully day in the life soon!
Thanks for watching and flagging that omission. Plenty more Pepper's (and beyond) to explore!
It was a concept album. The concept was existential confusion…and the Beatles produced it subconsciously.
Wow, what an intriguing interpretation of Sgt. Pepper's! And if it's toung-in-cheek I think its great, too! The idea of existential confusion as the unifying theme and subconscious throughline of the album is really fascinating. It's true that there's a sense of disorientation and searching that runs through a lot of the tracks, even as the surface tone remains whimsical and celebratory. I'd love to hear you expand on this more - which specific songs or moments do you think best capture this sense of existential confusion? And do you see it as a reflection of the band's own state of mind at the time, or more of a general cultural/societal mood they were tapping into? if you enjoyed this deep dive into Beatles lore, consider subscribing to catch all my upcoming videos exploring the band's legacy from different angles. And more rock bands soon, too. Thanks for this thought-provoking comment!
@@TheRockAlchemy Thanks. I am serious. This album has always puzzled me because it doesn’t appear to be a concept album-but it feels like one. The Beatles stopped touring in 1966 and didn’t know who or what to be. They had to conjure up an imaginary band just to get back into the studio. Lennon’s music was almost always personal…but not on this album. He had “nothing to say”. The word “nothing” appears in that song eight times. So he wrote songs inspired by a child’s drawing, a poster, a TV commercial and newspaper articles. Up to this point, McCartney wrote almost exclusively love songs-but not on this album. His songs were anthems to mundane domesticity. Even the middle part of a Day in the Life.
I'm only sorry the Beatles never made an album called "Nestugadacht"
Hah, "Nestugadacht" would've been quite the album title! The Beatles' real titles are iconic, but it's fun to imagine the wild alternatives. What other fantasy Beatles album titles can you dream up? Subscribe for more fun Fab Four (and more classic rock soon!) chats!
@@TheRockAlchemyThe Beatles live on the dark side of the moon😊
I've heard that AI can do perfect voices now. You might want to look into that.
Thanks for the AI voice tip! I'm always looking for ways to make these docs more compelling. If you have favorite examples, send them my way!
With your impressive 600+ subscribers, I'm curious - do you think your audience might dig my classic rock deep-dives? I've been focused on the Beatles but plan to branch out.
What bands, eras, or stories do you think would resonate with your music-loving crew? I'm all ears if you've got ideas!
As always, thanks for the inspiration. Subscribe to catch my upcoming rock docs - killer stories in the pipeline!
@@TheRockAlchemy I saw a guy pushing an AI video editor that can do whatever voice (including your own) in any language. I don't remember the name of it, but that sounds perfect for these videos you're doing. Having all the voices sounding exactly like each band member would enhance the experience and not pull people out of the video-watching "trance," causing them to leave a comment about how some band member didn't sound like the real band member.
Most of my subscribers are probably bots, so I wouldn't worry about them.
The saddest thing is the fact that Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane were not included on Sgt. Pepper as originally intended.
My take is that paul was a control freak but super talented, george was my favorite beatle and liked his songs the best
Interesting take on Paul and George! Paul's drive certainly shaped much of the Beatles' output. As for George, do you have a favorite song of his from the Sgt. Pepper era or later albums?
Surrealistic Pillow (and then After Bathing at Baxter's) by Jefferson Airplane, as well as Days of Future Passed b y The Moody Blues
Great additions to the conversation! Those albums certainly made waves in the same era. We love how knowledgeable our viewers are. Any other classic albums from that time you think deserve more recognition?
The retrospective comments by the band members on albums and various songs never come over to me as real, but rather just trying to be controversial for a new audience.
I hear you - it can be tough to parse the sincerity of the band's retrospective comments, especially when they seem to contradict the public narrative around an album or song.
There's definitely an element of mythmaking and revisionist history at play, consciously or not. And in some cases, they may be exaggerating their dissatisfaction for effect, or to assert their individual legacies. what do you think?
At the same time, I think there's value in considering their evolving perspectives, even if we take them with a grain of salt. Artists' relationships to their own work can be complex and fluid.
If you're interested in untangling more of these pop culture mysteries, subscribe to the channel! I'm always trying to read between the lines and separate fact from fiction. Would love to hear your take on other Beatles legends or classic rock lore!
@@TheRockAlchemyyou’ve brought a new perspective on my somewhat negative perception of the Beatles’ retrospective comments, I thank you for that. I think I first formed my opinion when hearing Paul say Got to Get You Into My Life was “dedicated to pot”. While there are potential phrases that possibly could be interpreted as an ode to pot smoking, the lyrics seemed to my naive ears as simply wanting to get a girl he fancied. Love the channel.
I never really liked Pepper and almost never listen to it, compared to other Beatles albums. Too artificial.
Sgt. Pepper's is definitely a departure from the Beatles' earlier work and more raw rock and roll sound. The production is much more elaborate and 'artificial' as you note. I can understand why it might not click for everyone. Out of curiosity, which Beatles albums/periods are your favorites? Or are you a bigger fan of other classic rock groups of the time? I'm always interested to hear how different fans connect with the various phases of their career. Thanks for watching and commenting!
The album sounds way differently when you listen to Pepper in mono
Great point about the mono mix! It really does change the listening experience. Do you have a preference between mono and stereo for Pepper? I'd be fascinated to hear your perspective. Subscribe for more Beatles and classic rock audio geekery!
@@TheRockAlchemy of Course I did like the studio version of Pepper better , but like Kiss they took off the most part of the album is the Pepper outro ( inner groove ) the complete version with AI made the album much more . If I was their manager at this time I would have booked a tour , with the out fits and everything . Maybe filmed a Pepper movie better than Bee Gees !
John Lennon once said: "You haven't heard Sgt. Pepper, if you haven't heard it in mono".