So true. This girl did not go on idol to be on tv for five minutes or to be a viral RUclips star, she did it because she thought she was good and that she could win and be a worldwide music sensation. And I think that’s so beautiful.
Staged or not staged I still felt sorry for her. She was a nice person but just a little bit weird with her solo act. I think she actually could have a good background voice. But she just can't sing solo so far as I've seen. She tried God bless her she's a lot more brave than I could ever be.
It’s like she wants to go really hard on every note, but then doesn’t follow through on any of them. Like she’s just constantly tapping her foot on the gas pedal
It’s like trying to sing with the same energy and punch as the original, but she realized her pitch ruins it when she tries, so she goes back to doing it quieter where she can control the pitch better, and then back and forth
She was completely right about being original and totally committed to this performance. She may have been wrong for Idol, but she’s memorable AF and gave a show. Go Mary!
She was a theatre person who auditioned as an experiment, she knows she was singing terribly. This is not her being genuine, she was having a laugh, seeing how far she could take it.
@urhypeboy Her audition was staged....Mary is a comedic actress. At the end when she sings again, notice she almost breaks character and starts to laugh.
Mary now works as an assistant manager at a bait and tackle shop in Jacksonville, Fl. On weekends she sings in a tribute band to Patsy Cline at a place called Scooter's Ranch.
It’s crazy, cause I know there’s real people out there that act like this and (mostly kids) and they just are so unaware of what’s really happening compared to their version of reality
Think about her is, I think she has a beautiful speaking voice; and she should do voice overs or commercials or voice acting of some kind. I've watch this numerous times because I like to hear her speak. Strange.
She needs to work on vocal cord closure (you can tell because she even SPEAKS breathy), drop the weird poorly done Rob Thomas impression, and work on breath support and projection (aka become louder, working on vocal cord closure would help this a lot.) and voila, you now have a singer on your hands. She could also potentially benefit from working on darkening her tone a bit as well but that depends more on her own personal preference. Source: I'm a classically trained singer. Singing has a lot more components to it than any non-singer knows, she has a lot of potential. Edit: also, if you told me she's actually able to sing and she's just an actor hired to perform badly to spice up the show I would fully believe you.
I completely agree. It made me feel so bad for her, i wish her friends would have been honest with her. She didn’t deserve to be absolutely humiliated on national television. But I guess i would like to think she knew the risks going into this and she was in fact going to be JUDGED. lol. and bless her heart for continuing to try and show her skills at the end interview lol.
"All my friends have told me that I have an amazing voice" This is why you shouldn't lie to your friends. If you can't tell them they suck, at least do not encourage them
I love me some Mary Roach. I just bought her lastest release, Mood Swings and Inner Voices. Brilliant album from a very disturbed genius. She scares me, and I like it. I like it, a lot.
Mary Roach is my ALL TIME favorite audition. She commanded everyone's attention. We all receive criticism and try to keep our composure. We strive to be honest and listen to our inner voices.
@@NickNutjob at which point you see her breathing her character? because i don't see it at all. She was on Instagram for a short time, she's ain't an actress. If she was we would surely hear about her
Scripted isn't the right word cause that would imply the show told her to do this. She was playing a character by choice and the producers often pick "unstable" people for ratings. She knew exactly what she was doing
No. Actually I think she can sing well, really, hear me out: Watch the last two minutes of the video where she sings for the camera. Also, her speaking voice is really soothing. And, it could be she was nervous and her voice choked up at the audition.
@@janetpattison8474No. Some people can squander their money on voice lessons. But, they will never sing in a manner that will draw an audience or lead to a career in music.
This hurts my heart to see the stress this young lady is going through. As for her friends that told her she has a good voice.,they lied to her giving her false confidence . MEAN nasty FRIENDS
Mary Roach would be great in the M✫vies!🎥🎞️ Her sweet soft voice & her ability to stay straight face without breaking would be fantastic for comedies,Horrors & Dramas!
She’s my favorite & I’m always hoping to see her on TV. She would be great as an actress & singer. I’m really surprised that her singing/acting career didn’t take off. Hoping someday! ❤
I remember a few hours before going on a camping trip at 8 years old seeing this episode of American idol where Mary roach appeared and I must say, that’s one memory I’ll never forget! This episode brought me so much laughter and joy .
@@Lovelysoul024 same. But do you notice they do air the worse of the bunch as well as the best. As those are entertaining. But never the mid ones. Why is that?
Sometimes I wonder if this auditions were real or just made from the production for more fun and audience following....really seems no real such a crazy people.....
Ahh what a simpler time this was.
Right
So true. This girl did not go on idol to be on tv for five minutes or to be a viral RUclips star, she did it because she thought she was good and that she could win and be a worldwide music sensation. And I think that’s so beautiful.
Staged or not staged I still felt sorry for her. She was a nice person but just a little bit weird with her solo act. I think she actually could have a good background voice. But she just can't sing solo so far as I've seen. She tried God bless her she's a lot more brave than I could ever be.
@@dharmallarsnah this was staged asf. She even has a blog about it
Ugh- thought the same thing!! 😢
I knew she was messing with us when she said “Gilbeaux” 🤣🤣🤣🤣
*Guilbeaux
I don't think she was.
😂
It was staged, you can tell and all they wanted was ratings. It was funny to watch though.
@@PlayfulFruitLPer she's done other stuff,it was a troll. Shes a comedian
“How did you think you did”
“Not too shabby”
Gets me every time😂
Now look where she's at now. She became one of the biggest artist off all time. You're such an inspiration Lady Gaga.👍
🤣🤣🤣😊
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
@@JeffJeffJeffJeff33yes before the knee surgery and rhinoplasty
😂😂😂
“At least I’m not gonna walk out here crying.”
Literally starts crying after walking out.
Dude, she’s crying. On her way home in a taxi or airplane or however she got there she’s crying believe me she’s crying.
She had real reason to be upset. Watch the last minute and think again.
She appeared to be on the verge, but managed to hold her tears back.
That's what they always do in theatre
@@youtube-user73424what do u mean
She has a very pleasant and soothing speaking voice, she could read audiobooks 😊
Simon should suggest that lol
That's what I said.
You're very kind😊
I thought the same!!
I can not believe I am the only one who can easily see that the woman is a genuine nutcase. Guaranteed Hitchcock-level nut. I guarantee it.
She's 18???? Christ, I thought she was in her 30's!
Its because she's overweight
@@Codduct She's not. It's the styling that makes her look older.
Agreed, I would have guessed about 30, 32. 18? Wow...
@@MissTootle Do you even know what morbidly obese means?
She looks older but sure as hell reacted like an 18 year old 😂
It’s like she wants to go really hard on every note, but then doesn’t follow through on any of them. Like she’s just constantly tapping her foot on the gas pedal
It’s like trying to sing with the same energy and punch as the original, but she realized her pitch ruins it when she tries, so she goes back to doing it quieter where she can control the pitch better, and then back and forth
Can we go back to this era?😭😭🤣
She actually;;y turned put a serial killer it was on the news
?? Proof ?? Link
@@Tade-1474 I'm not
What for? Back then people were complaining about going to a different era anyway because they didn't like that one
Trust me you don't want to 😂
"All my friends tell me I'm an amazing singer" randy jackson: "whaaat"
Ikr 😂😅
All her friends were winding her up!
@@dainethompson6531 Her friends were too scared to tell her the truth = Bunny Boiler.
She was completely right about being original and totally committed to this performance. She may have been wrong for Idol, but she’s memorable AF and gave a show. Go Mary!
She was a theatre person who auditioned as an experiment, she knows she was singing terribly. This is not her being genuine, she was having a laugh, seeing how far she could take it.
@@willarcher7929says who. Stop spreading lies
@@willarcher7929 Surrrrrrrrre.
She was entertaining.
@urhypeboy Her audition was staged....Mary is a comedic actress. At the end when she sings again, notice she almost breaks character and starts to laugh.
Mary now works as an assistant manager at a bait and tackle shop in Jacksonville, Fl. On weekends she sings in a tribute band to Patsy Cline at a place called Scooter's Ranch.
Are you serious??
@@WCYUM IM Going to see her...lol
@@Yoda999.9 what is the tribute band called?
looks like I’m going on vacation to Jacksonville
queenie
“you don’t wanna hear ‘em 😏” shook the panel
It’s crazy, cause I know there’s real people out there that act like this and (mostly kids) and they just are so unaware of what’s really happening compared to their version of reality
Her speaking voice is so soft and soothing, how the hell does she sing like that? 😭
I think she is an actress. You can see her almost break character and start to life at 6:11. 😂😂
Girl you're right
This was a character she was doing. The real Mary Roach was trying to become a comedian and this was her trying to make a debut
I actually think no, she was genuine. She was too tense before her audition. If that was an act, she's a better actress than Meryl Streep.
I always thought this was mightve been a plant for views.
@@darrenhenderson3 yes she has a blog about it and wrote a book
"Are you just saying that to get on my nerves" such a psychotic response🤣
Think about her is, I think she has a beautiful speaking voice; and she should do voice overs or commercials or voice acting of some kind. I've watch this numerous times because I like to hear her speak. Strange.
it's really interesting to me how people's talking voice and speaking voice could be so different
Yes, you are strange. As is Mary.
She needs to work on vocal cord closure (you can tell because she even SPEAKS breathy), drop the weird poorly done Rob Thomas impression, and work on breath support and projection (aka become louder, working on vocal cord closure would help this a lot.) and voila, you now have a singer on your hands. She could also potentially benefit from working on darkening her tone a bit as well but that depends more on her own personal preference.
Source: I'm a classically trained singer. Singing has a lot more components to it than any non-singer knows, she has a lot of potential.
Edit: also, if you told me she's actually able to sing and she's just an actor hired to perform badly to spice up the show I would fully believe you.
I completely agree. It made me feel so bad for her, i wish her friends would have been honest with her. She didn’t deserve to be absolutely humiliated on national television. But I guess i would like to think she knew the risks going into this and she was in fact going to be JUDGED. lol. and bless her heart for continuing to try and show her skills at the end interview lol.
The way she speaks is cringe... Get some help
The confidence…I would love just an ounce of it
Me too
Her talking voice was very soothing tho
She did put on a show!
She actually;;y turned put a serial killer it was on the news
@@Tade-1474 you just made that up!
@@riggamorrischan look it up
@@riggamorrischan look it up bro
I think people were terrified into telling her she had a good singing voice
I think they were terrified to tell her the opposite
She looks and acts like she came straight from the 70’s
What a fuckin iconic performance
I teach a psychology course to my students , every time I touch upon on the subject of delusion , I show them this video ...
@Les yeah I’m gonna need a link to that video noW
@Les need link now
@Les this is false
It’s very obviously an act, she was paid to bomb, as are a lot of people
She not delusional she is acting, she is a comedian and went on this show as a skit/joke. You are spreading misinformation.
i love her so much omg she’s actually insane
😂
Insane in the membrane
she looked like she wanted to punch simon,really scary!
Paula actually looks sympathetic. Like she knows there's something wrong with her
She almost breaks character at 6:09
Are they just playing?
@@kyrak.4143 I think she’s a comedian and this was promo for her career but I’m not sure
@@kyrak.4143 i think she was serious
@@valleyofparadise she’s trolling
maybe she found herself funny
"All my friends have told me that I have an amazing voice"
This is why you shouldn't lie to your friends. If you can't tell them they suck, at least do not encourage them
She has a pleasant speaking voice
I feel the earth MoOooOOOVE
Her rehearsal as the guys were standing there 😄
Right! That had me 💀 😂😂😂
Not too shabby
I love me some Mary Roach. I just bought her lastest release, Mood Swings and Inner Voices. Brilliant album from a very disturbed genius. She scares me, and I like it. I like it, a lot.
😳😜😵💫🥴😱🤪🤯😂😂😂😂😂
I really love her. She is such a sweetheart. Gods honest truth I think she actually could make some good music and I love her heart
Nah this bitch crazy she just has a manipulative sweet talking voice
She does have heart you are right. And no she's not the worse singer I have ever heard
This very well could be fake but she seems really cute on her instagram. She has really pretty brown hair now!
@@alexanderl7059 this also isnt real..... she’s one of the fake crazy auditions they plant into the show
No
Her voice wasn’t terrible, you can tell she has something there and will lessons she would be great
Stop 😂 you’re kind for trying to see potential in her but let’s be for real 😂😂😂😂
@@joeyconvery2055or she was just laughing bc saw others laughing at her?
Her voice was in fact, terrible
What? Are you kidding lol
I am thinking, we watched two very different videos!
Narrator really did her ass
“With the voices in her head saying she did okay” 😵💫😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
This is a great character actress.
one of my favorite auditions
@Julian Roane she has an IG profile but it doesn't look like she continued singing.
@Julian Roane uhmm, I dunno bout dis.
Mary Roach is my ALL TIME favorite audition. She commanded everyone's attention. We all receive criticism and try to keep our composure. We strive to be honest and listen to our inner voices.
i love her so much
Lay off her. She just got off a long shift at Target. 🤣
She had me rolling with the Paula Abdul comment 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I quote "whatever" while shrugging my shoulders in my day to day life because of her
Best contestant ever
She really gave it her all 😂😂😂
Not even joking I would listen to her album if she released one.
no.
Why?
I would listen to it too lol it would be pure comedy.
Get ur ears cleaned
Did you have the subtitles, switched on, or is your hearing aid batteries flat 😂
All her friends tell her she is a great singer because they want to live.
The judges are looking at her like what has been unleashed on us. 😆
We laugh. But Mary had the last laugh.
She was actually acting throughout
that's not true
@@vivi6121yes, it is. You can literally see her break character at the end
@@NickNutjob at which point you see her breathing her character? because i don't see it at all. She was on Instagram for a short time, she's ain't an actress. If she was we would surely hear about her
ICONIC
Paula saying “hang in there honey” hurt my soul 😅
All her friends and random people that told her she could sing played her
I go around the house singing this song the way she did. Even the dance lol.
I’ve always loved the “whaaatever 😐”
I know She may seem a little chemically imbalanced, but that doesn't stop Me from thinking how beautiful I think She is! 😍😍😍
Paula looks terrified 🤣🤣🤣
Icon, legend, the moment
She is original asf!
If 1970 was a person.
Mary Roach is the reason celebrities have security guards.
She would make an great asrm artist
I agree. Her voice had me so mesmerized. I can't stop replaying this video
“Not too shabby”
She'll have her own comedy show in a few years, nice performance!
There's no way this is not scripted, her speaking voice sounds like she can sing, the performance looks like she's purposely tries to sound bad
Scripted isn't the right word cause that would imply the show told her to do this. She was playing a character by choice and the producers often pick "unstable" people for ratings. She knew exactly what she was doing
Can you imagine what terrible friends she has if they let her get humiliated like that and encouraged her to go in front of Simon?
Really, absolutely ridiculous, so called friends to actually lie to her. She can’t sing now, but she can learn to sing, or maybe act.
Perhaps it was a trick and they set her up
No. Actually I think she can sing well, really, hear me out: Watch the last two minutes of the video where she sings for the camera. Also, her speaking voice is really soothing. And, it could be she was nervous and her voice choked up at the audition.
@@janetpattison8474No. Some people can squander their money on voice lessons. But, they will never sing in a manner that will draw an audience or lead to a career in music.
@@janetpattison8474There's no accounting for taste. Her friends may honestly believe she sings well.
I absolutely love her performance at the end of the video.
"You insist that we were WRONG!! Why didn't you realize sooNER!!" 😂😂😂
I love you Mary you’re an Angel!!!!!
This hurts my heart to see the stress this young lady is going through. As for her friends that told her she has a good voice.,they lied to her giving her false confidence . MEAN nasty FRIENDS
I think she has a very good heart 😢 wish her all the best
This looks like a scene from a sitcom
I can't believe it's been almost two decades since my audition!
Did u go to beauty school? I like your voice.
I sure hope that was your first and last audition. Have you faced reality since then?
Mary Roach is a gaw-dam LEGEND 😂❤😂
G I L B E A U X
She'd make a great period drama actress.. like a Western or Victorian aged role.. or phone operator lol
i unironically love her
This woman is the greatest troll in history
Yeaaaah!! I love heeer!
Yeah!!! Looki up J star valentine x factor audition as well. They make the perfect troll couple.
Is she though?
She wasn't trolling trust me she is crazy i can see crazy a mile away
No, the greatest troll has to be male xD
Her dance at 0:15 is so funny 😂
Cracks me up everytime 😂😊
That's why the men behind her were laughing 😂
“Hang in there honey”
Beautiful and pleasant speaking voice
Mary Roach would be great in the M✫vies!🎥🎞️ Her sweet soft voice & her ability to stay straight face without breaking would be fantastic for comedies,Horrors & Dramas!
Mosquito in my room at night:
She’s my favorite & I’m always hoping to see her on TV. She would be great as an actress & singer. I’m really surprised that her singing/acting career didn’t take off. Hoping someday! ❤
All anyone can say to you, is, that you have amazing friends. Don’t ever let them go.
I remember a few hours before going on a camping trip at 8 years old seeing this episode of American idol where Mary roach appeared and I must say, that’s one memory I’ll never forget! This episode brought me so much laughter and joy .
You ever wonder why American idol replays don't show average auditions?
@@thejtrax I really think the ones that are “craziest” are the funniest
@@Lovelysoul024 same. But do you notice they do air the worse of the bunch as well as the best. As those are entertaining. But never the mid ones. Why is that?
@@thejtrax why?
@@thejtrax never thought about it
This was before we were really aware of serious mental issues 😂
what make you think she has one
@@joeyconvery2055 she’s literally laughing throughout
@@joeyconvery2055omg are u serious?!? Source??
@@joeyconvery2055 I saw it. OMG. This whole time she had me fooled. Incredible performance on her part! She sold the shit outta that!!!!!!
I appreciate the info. You definitely opened my eyes. Lol.
Mary Guilbeaux. Lololol
I was digging in my yard today and this popped into my head
Well, you were "moving earth."
Straight to the liveshows and receiving the golden buzzer!!!
she sounds like Cher mixed with Celine Dion. Very forward sounding voice
Sometimes I wonder if this auditions were real or just made from the production for more fun and audience following....really seems no real such a crazy people.....
This one seemed really fake
You've lived a VERY sheltered life if you think there are no "real crazy people". 🙄
I've read comments saying she's a comedic actress and her audition was an experiment
At least she's a charismatic.
They were absolutely speechless 😭
She should be famous she was really unique
I hate this part of American Idol set u to humiliate people
Break a leg.... that's what the always say in theatre. Hint hint. She should have been cast on snl.
They did make fun of her on the show
Aww so down to earth i really feel for her
Love heeeeeeer 💚 💚 💚 💚 💚 💚
Amazing actress 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
"You have a lot of voices, huh?..." "...in your head"
The amount of times I used to watch this back in the day 🤣🤣🤦🏼♀️ wonder where she is now
I wonder what she's doing now too.
She got married. Then sang to her new husband on honeymoon. And he shot her dead . She is somewhere buried in the woods.
True story
She should sing the National Anthem at next year's home run derby.
The eyebrow raise....😂😂😂