Challenges in Asia-Pacific and China-US Competition
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- Webinar: Challenges in Asia-Pacific and China-US Competition
Speaker: H.E. Kishore Mahbubani
Keynote Speech: Prof. Dr. Yelda Ongun
Moderator: Fatih Ceylan
Date: 24 January 2023 Tuesday
Time: 11.00
Thank you Mr. Mahbubani for your expertise on the world issues and you are the voice of ASEAN. From your perspective and your experienced from Singapore government position and to UN, I can say not so many world politicians can fully understand China. Whatever the West throw at China, unfortunately most the world don’t see China as threat but to work together with China. The West talks so much about war but China talks about growth and improving the people livelihood. Yes, it not perfect but most people are safe and happy.
It is a threat to the usd domince, thereby usa or west dominance, and a choice for many nations to break out of the cage imposed by the unipolar world. Now that is definitely a threat to the world order, as many will get out of line.
Chinese culture is peace n harmonious living with each other n the universe. Thus respect for all beings n the universe is the key principle. The leaderships are walking their talks. Unlike the collective West led by the so called Americanos politicians who lied n cheated n selfish greed for own self historically n don't walk their talks or ??!! 👀🤑💰💸🧐🤔🤡🥳
@GOH Siew Hau It is not about cheating or being selfish actually. It is about keeping lucrative system that extract 'life blood' to keep going. Without such life blood, it will 'die'. So it is about survival. Imagine yourself a MOB head feared by all others, and they pay up- knowingly or otherwise through the USD world reserve system.
@GOH Siew Hau I am very sure MOBS also rule in a "fairy tale "harmonious Chinese society
The "big" countries want you to have democracy as your form of government, not because they love you, but it is easier for them to manipulate you (or interfere in your elections) by meddling in your own domestic politics.
Definitely Prof Mahbubani has certainly enlightened the Turkish who has a very typical western view of China. Exchange is a good thing.
Mahbubani on why ASEAN is more geopolitcal competent than Europe which he describes as geopolitcally incompetent because of war happening in Europe now. The difference between ASEAN and EU is one group is totally subservient to US geopolitical interest (besides NATO, trade, technological, financial issues). Despite boasting about their democratic and liberal values, there is no strategic independence. For example, when Nordstream 2 was blown up, not a whisper from Germany and EU on which countries are responsible. ASEAN basically politely tell the US that we are not interested in siding with you as we want to be neutral and friends with both. Africa is doing the same infact South Africa is even courageous in telling off the US.
EU leaders left their "balls" in DC. When Nordstream was sabotaged, EU leaders all kept quiet!!
Europe has been at war since time immemorial, long before Columbus discovered America. What you know as the two World Wars were mostly European Wars.
Prof Mahbubani never disappoints with his clarity & rational approach!
Running dog of the ccp
Prof. Mahbubani insight and knowledge in China history on her 100 years humiliation is an utmost importance to today’s and the future generations, so they can have more empathy to China and prevent them from false accusations to China so easily despite the so call ideology indifferences.
If I were HKSAR CE, Prof. Mahbubani is to be invited to speak in all our academic institutes.
@H.M. Li I am nobody, but still better than him in my understanding
What are you gonna guys get over your humiliation? The rest of the world is sick of your belly aching
A cogent geopolitical view needs to include an economic perspective, otherwise it is half done and probably not accurate.
The big countries want you to have democracy as your form of government not because they love you, but it is easier for them to manipulate you by meddling in your domestic politics.
Brilliant! Kishore is great.
And Turkish intellectuals are very sophisticated and understand things well.
Phil T. Turk
Thanks Prof Kishore,
you are the best in giving truth and fair comments unlike western media which twist and twisted news.
Well Done Prof Krishore 👏 Aspecially all your truthful and genuine Answers. ASEAN or INDO PACIFIC are very similar in Tradition, Foods(🍚) and Multi Cultures. Economic growth and 👍 Infrastructures will lead to Harmony and Stronger Relationships but definitely not WAR'S.
Brilliant answers by Prof Mahbubani. Salute !
Prof. Mahmubani, Prof. Jeffrey Sacks, Prof. John Mearsheimer, Prof. Martin Jacques are all in the same class.
I agree except for mearsheiner he’s a racist supremacist
Top of the class👍👍👍
Add Prof Michael Hudson. His book Superimperialism explains how US exploits its Financial global dominance to effect "covert colonisation" of the world in the past 7-8 decades.
Yeah, I've been watching videos that feature him. Thanks for reminding.
Mearsheimer wants war with China.
Three lessons, how not to do a video for rest of the world to see.
1) If the host is late. Cut those minutes out, before you upload the video.
2) Ban people to ask long winded questions. Send them to special training sessions first.
3) Viewers don't need to see 25 faces on screen. That's the worst distraction, which improved slightly after 45 minutes.
As expected, Kishore saved this meeting with his insightful views.
This made me a little more optimistic in Europe :D ! Thanks to everyone especially to Mr. Mahbubani ! - The metaphor about living next to an elephant was just awesome and perfectly fitted!
Nah I’m Chinese, I don’t think there’s much hope, the EU leaders n nato leaders r just insane obedient to the US, the politicians was not elected to serve the people but US. Nothing is going to change
@@Steve-iu5hy I still hope Your government and USA's government can find the way to align with each other and start promoting calm and peace in this world! - this is all I can say: hope plus baby steps with faith to build up some floor again
@@istvandarvas3372 thank you though, you r one of the rare ones who support peace and working together. I always see Europeans or Americans promoting wars and conflict. Like don’t you guys get a bit sick of the hypocrisy of your countries in the west that when you guys keep talking about human rights democracy n values, like you guys represents the whole world but the things is except colonizing the world and steal from us, now you become this moral god, Millions of Muslims killed and continually been slaughtered by EU and America n hey China you are biggest Muslim threat, we grow up learning the France is romantic America is super dope, Germany is so good with cars, but all the lesson n infos you guys get from your school is that we Chinese are bad lols. I’ve been to Europe been to America, all are amazing but I see lots of horrible things too definitely not as amazing as we’ve been told here in school by our teachers and books. Chinese know the world way more than the west knows about us. On BBC DW CNN all these western media, you see all these so called China experts who doesn’t even live here or lived here, I always watch them make up stuff about china and the audience are like yes that china, the villain.
BRI is a substantible environmental transit network and global growth network enhancement. Not a conquer the world project like the West portraited. It is a project to grow the pie of the world bigger and increase the size of middle class in the world. Imagine how many cars and planes trips could be replaced by high speed electric trains. Countries in Asia don't like and don't want wars. They like to solve problems diplomaticly, often through private talks between countries. They understand NATO is trying to create instability in the region. They are trying to resist it as much as they can. Sorry to say, western media narratives created a very narrow biased view in their people.
Thank you for this excellent discussion, Prof Mahbubani is among the best of academics analysing and reporting on contemporary geopolitics. My only criticism of such reporting these days is the tendency of most academia to underestimate the level of neocon insanity now driving US foreign policy and Presidents of either persuasion.
About Asean members' tensions with China is actually USA's depictation of the situations, not actually
happening between Asean n China
Hearing the questions and thinking of the audience, it is no wonder why the west is in decline rapidly.
Class act. Learnt tremendously.
Judge them by their actions , not by their words
It's great to discuss and share the thoughts.
Most of the US/Western Politicians words just can't be trusted. We are surprised this specky guy has taken what they said so seriously. We don't as their words do NOT match their deeds.
Well, when the input of his knowledge was from the West, his judgement would be totally wrong. It is not totally his fraud. He just have no idea how corrupted and bias the western media are when it comes to geopolitics.
Professor Mahbubani’s response is simple and straightforward: stop watching Anglo-Saxon media 😂
@@JS-ih7lu I had stopped watching CNN, MSNBC, BBC and a few others since Trump's presidency.
I Am young, that I, Always Open learn from you all
Bir musibet bin nasihatten iyidir. Why is Ceylan Bey is so skeptical with Kishore regarding toxic Western narratives? When you read any English news on Türkiye-Greece relations, PKK, Cyprus, it is overwhelmingly negative. We are not stupid. They're doing the same thing to the Chinese. They are not stupid either.
TURKS RULED ALL CYPRUS NORTHERN SYRİA AGAİNST PKK AND TURKS HELP AZERBAYCAN AGAİNST ARMENİANS NEXF TURKİSH MİLLİTARY NATO LARGEST MİLLİTARY AGAİNST GREECE.
So true, he talked about infrastructure building projects like "Belt and Road" and "Made in China 2025" like some sort of nefarious world conquering plan despite not providing any concrete evidence, just pure assumption built on top of the western media "evil Chinese" narrative, it's kinda insane to hear that from an academic, its like for a lot of those ppl Chinese folks are not human beings, they must always be assumed guilty until proven innocent.
Holy shit I just googled Fatih Ceylan, he is literally a NATO Representative, everything he said makes sense now lol
Turkey is an amazing country, I visited in 2016 and I miss so much. Look forward to visit this friendly country again.
Asian political analyst comprehends the western politics issue 3X more than than western political analyst over Asia issue, refusing to study Asian market will not bring any good to the west especially US
An ordinary Asian people understand the west culture is 10X of ordinary western people about Asian culture， this is fact, this explain why Asian countries are growing so fast, we know our limitations and try to avoid western mistakes in the past decades
All these learned minds here and no one ask what International rules base order of the west mean.
Many Türks understand the West's yellow peril fear of the Chinese very well. The West has Islamophobia and Türkophobia.
It is just so great to be able to listen to people with a Turkish perspective intelligently discuss global issues together.
Who is the moderator? Does he look like a Turk to you?
He looks like an Anglo Saxon, talks like an Anglo, thinks like an Anglo, fear China like an Anglo, and omg, he is an Anglo.
Brainwashed!
He's indeed an Anglo-Saxon 😂
I googled him, his name is Fatih Ceylan, quite literally a NATO agent XD
US competition is based on the Tonya Harding strategy, crippling your opponent. The US strategic competitions are economic sanctions, technology sanctions, diplomatic pressure, and military alliances. They have no serious policies to address domestic issues such as income inequality, healthcare, education, racial inequality, infrastructure, housing affordability and homelessness, the opioid epidemic, and gun violence.
In the past, there was a direct correlation between a country's population size and its wealth. Countries with larger populations tended to be wealthier. However, this correlation has changed with the advancement of technology. With each new wave of technology, productivity has increased, and countries with smaller populations have been able to achieve dominant economies through technological advances.
The Belt and Road Initiative is a multi-generational effort aimed at ensuring that all countries have access to these advances and can reach their full economic potential, regardless of population size. This is achieved by fostering interconnectivity and promoting economic growth among nations.
Economic growth alone is not enough to ensure equitable benefits for all. Each country must have policies that promote fairness and ensure that the benefits of economic growth are widely distributed.
Countries that have yet to experience the benefits of technological advances have a strong motivation for the success of the Belt and Road Initiative. About 78% of the countries of the world have joined the BRI, and a handful of them are developed countries.
Countries that have already benefited from advanced technologies see restricting the spread of technology as a way to maintain their edge in the global arena. They are gifting their shared values, rules-based order, democracy, freedom, and human rights to the less developed countries rather than helping to build water, electricity, education, healthcare, sanitation, transportation, and communication infrastructure.
China is largely unsuccessful in its efforts to encourage developed countries to join the BRI. China hopes that its Global Development Initiative (GDI) will convince them. China also hopes its Global Security Initiative (GSI) will ease their apprehensions about China's intention.
The west should recieve with open heart the rise of asian countries, the west should to cooperate not to dictate and try to contain other countries rise. Hope the west can become a wiser society.
The concept of Democracy vs Autocracy is actually a non issue ! First the definitions are subjective.
If you examine US actual international behaviour carefully, it was never democratic towards other countries.
In fact US subotarge n overthrew many democratically elected governments like Iran in 1956, n those central n south american governments to instal non-democratic parties for their corporate benefits
PLEASE RESPECT ALL WE HERE, OPEN EYE, OPEN MINDS
it;s a good and fair speech.
Jianyun Lu
0 seconds ago
This host Cryton' s question has hundreds of words and takes 10 minutes to deliver🙀I lost my patience😳
most of the questions are lean and bias to China's futuristic suspected problems which are very speculative and non realilty in event. why no questions were raised regarding to the origin of global problem, which is USA?
First 15 mins are wasted time.
😂
Thank you. I started from 15 min
Prof Mahbubani said China didnt handled the exit of covid controls well, i think this time he is wrong
Great guest, poor shortsighted western-minded moderator.
Lol, Kishore can talk for days.
CIAAA, CHINA , India, ASEAN, Africa, America
What substance that guy is smoking when said l quote 'Who knows in a couple of years time India might surpass China".what nonsense is he talking. CHINA'S gdp is five times larger than lndia's. Having almost the same population l certainly cannot see how that could happen.
We will,, we CAN'T get back green to save we world,
Hello,
Yes, MALAYSIA ITS MY COUNTRY,
its all about America's threat and expansion on this planet
In first I learn law in Cambodia, Africa, that why BIDEN use that to Take Away all my money out
What you all meeting today
It is unforgivable for the host to be late.
Agree. That was strange.
Never scare the all DEBT,
As an 86 year Goan Indian American born raised & educated in India -50years an - Elec Engineer and 36 years in Georgia US, & NOT a politician like Kishore & certainly not having his great reputation, my humble opinion is that Kishore sounds to me like a smooth Sindhi car salesman who says 1) he loves the US & wants to give them “ wise advice” & 2) that China has only “goodwill towards the world”. But as an ex-Indian like me, he should be aware that China wants a “ one China Policy” for itself but does NOT want a “one India Policy” for India - has brutally occupied Previously Autonomous TIBET & now parts of the Indian Himalayas- 100,000 Indian- Chinese troops are presently facing each other there on the LAC eyeball to eyeball at the moment & war can breakout between the two if this persists.
India got its Independence in 1947 after not “ 100 years of humiliation” but almost 200 years of humiliation by the same colonial powers that China had endured. So Kishore talks as if this “humiliation” happened only to China and not to the whole of Asia & Africa.
This selective opinion shows his bias towards China - why I can’t fathom- does book sales have something to do with it ?
The Communist Peoples Republic of China was established by Mao in 1949. At that time India & China had about the same GDP- however the U.S. switched its allegiance from from the KMT (30 million?)to the the over 1 billion PRC ( bigger future market for its goods) & then collaborated with Communist Dictatorial China over “democratic India “ - much against its “freedom & democratic principles” with heavy investment by its companies in China thus raising its present GDP to 6x times India’s - near 19 trillion U.S. $ that it is today.
Of course China’s hard working people & Autocratic Govt’s had much to do with it verses Indias “ democratic & easy going people” - something I prefer- with 1.4 billion people & 2.4 billion opinions. India will catch up but will take another 20 years- with its intelligent & enterprising people with its more than 4000 year civilization - of which Kishore should be aware of.
Sydney Desouza a Goan Indian American immigrant from India now in the U.S. Georgia for 36 years
Wonderful sharing as usual, Prof.
Euro its first Take me, before get me to use Strong Security to save me move with Grow all my TRADE IN MORE YEAR
I Am world trader, Can't get me Some Clues, Now,,, what Can't I do
I be save with China, because XI not bully me, BIDEN its to old for all this Now, BIDEN its lol, lose memory
The host is clearly biased leaning toward the mainstream media narratives of the West.
Luckily for the audience Kishore smack him back in place.
That's as obvious as Day and night. Trying to frame the BRI as something to be suspicious of falls perfectly into the western narrative to demonise and slander China. The extreme hypocrisy of the USA with regard to that is that the Biden regime itself announced its own version of the BRI, the Built Back Better or BBB, which has proven still born anyway.
@@stephenlock7236 BBB hasn't even left the womb! I think it might be a miscarriage.
The interviewer is obviously biased against China picking on her BRI and the defense mechanisms that China has pre-emptively built to defend herself in case of foreign aggressive invasion. Professor Kishore’s answers reveal his statesmanship and diplomacy to rebut the negative undertones of the interviewers prejudice and lack of geopolitical reality.
It's not difficult to see what the interviewer's views would be if you merely just look at the portrait of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk hanging behind him.
He reads and believes the Anglo Saxon narratives. Will he also believe what the same Anglo Saxon media's Turkey - Cyprus narratives?
I will GIVE you all Now, s, New Malaysia Minister DATUK SERI ANWAR IBRAHIM & MY OWN STATE SARAWAK ITS DATUK PATINGGI TAN SRI ABG JOHARI,
Discussion about asia but all except for a few asian faces.
It's indo pacific
Use my THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT / WORLD BANK GLOBAL ASSET OWNER, I DON'T WANT TO STAY BE BIDEN ALLY, I BACK TO MY SARAWAK STATE NOW,
China its keep work all my stake, that I keep push all CHINA PROJECT
peace and prosperity with respectful intention does all much better... wars or trade wars we can do without US needs to get back to diplomacy not insanity for world affairs.
I wonder how will China overcome the US chip and high end technology sanctions on China? Will China be able to make her own chips?
Introduce myself I'm Arif Khan harry I'm software engineer and software development and website development and investors and members United States and students submitted funding for United States
United States is big power. China is big powers 2in 1 Rearesion shif understand very critical and technology and since United States is. Since. The relationship I'm very happily
Now Najib in Jail, I Trust DATUK SERI ANWAR IBRAHIM, AND MY SARAWAK STATE MINISTER, NOW, SLOW SLOW GET ME SEE FIRST, I AM WOMEN, 37 YEARS, I LIVE UNDER SINGAPURA CARE, BECAUSE RUN FROM MALAYSIA MINISTER BEFORE, BUT NOW ITS OK, ONLY NEED YOU ALL DIRECT FOR MY MALAYSIA MINISTER FOR ALL ECONOMIC, THANK FOR ALL SENIOR, BYE,
I Never Destroy any there,
But G20 ITS NOW, INDIA ITS NOWS, NEVER USE BIDEN WAR,
No one is so rational, rather selfish and greedy. At least I would be jealous of any promotion of my colleagues or any my rich neighbors. Same do with those Chinese neighboring countries, except big envying and worry from USA and Japan. No one is willing to reduce their share in world economy pie.
This host's question is terribly long!!
you think only how about other think in in Russia and Ukrainn
Kishorw disappoints
6 minutes of NOTHING ! ! kidding me ! !
Mr Tommy Koh is right on Mr Kishore. Mr Kishore loves China and defends China.
he defends truth, against fake news.
Kishore calls a spade a spade.
Tommy Koh is pro US!
Says another anti China "yellow people" hating racist.
You obviously can't tell White is white, black is black.
This format is not effective! Too many people n too much lag before substance…….I apologize…..just too many people here…..can’t even zoo in to see facial intent on speakers……condensing this format is necessary to dovetail effectiveness! I tuned in to listen to Keshore Mahbubani……n this is just too much rice n no gravy……and I love rice…..no meat even…..or vegetables……just rice! Too much🤷🏽♂️🙏🏽
Kishore Mahbubani came across very confident as recently as three or four years ago. More and more he sounds desperate to make his points.
which points are you talking of!
What part of his talk was desperate? He sounds like his usual poised, confident, and professional self.
I don't see any desperation here, only the desperation of others trying to undermine him.
Desperate?? Perhaps you are brainwashed too! 😄😄😄😄
The main difference with Mahbubani in the past 3-4 years is that he now calls out the west for its “Yellow Peril mindset” (aka racism) and Anglo-Saxon media as trash. It irks the Anglos.
One word : " *Xi JingPooh* "
Prof Mahbubani presents badly
Why? You want him to sound emotional?
Professor Mahbubani presents himself very well and puts his points across without offending anyone who poses questions to him. He handled the awkward points raised by the host very diplomatically too.
Kindly explain the "badly" part. Otherwise it's empty rhetoric.
Only according to you ! Explain..he answers very clearly, what else do you expect?
only to those who are stooges of the West.
As an 86 year Goan Indian American in Georgia US & 49 years in India & 36 in the US - I would say that Kishore suffers from a guilt complex when he says he is wants to “advice” the U S for its own good, but seems to think that China is right. That sounds like a lot of “Sindhi” double talk. Just as India’s greatest Prime Minister during my time in India was charmed by China & Chou-en-lai after Indias Independence in 1947, & thought the 2x Asian giants (with the worlds largest population) could cooperate for the benefit of mankind only to be stabbed in the back by Chinas invasion of Unprepared India in 1962, & hindering its progress in every way politically, so also will Kishore have to eat his words- in spite of the “ high opinion” most have of his past accomplishments, unfortunately I doubt his sincerity- I regret having to say so.
you have become white but dark outside .US has being stealing resources from countries and bully ,Us wants to be top dog in the world Just t look at how America treat the people in Chagos island turned it into a base and has a huge nuclear submarine in Indian Ocean and dumped the islanders from Chagos Island in the Slums of Mauritius. Uk initial ruled these islands and gave it to US.
what about Burkina an atoll destroyed the natives lives US tested the nuclear bomb in the ocean Us is irresponsible has not even built a proper disposable site for its nuclear waste.
eventually the current t nuclear site will eventually leaked and whole of Pacific ocean will be contaminated What about Hawaii Us stole it from Hawaiian Queen in 1893
Lol China lease hong kong 99 years goa was lease to Portugal what happen when india beg and gave their independent they invadet goa and took it but IF you are from goa then you have average iq 82😅