Is Forza Motorsport a Failure?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 июл 2024
- For the final day of 2023, I thought it would be a good time to ask the question: is Forza Motorsport a Failure? While it can be difficult to tell with Xbox player numbers being unavailable, we can see Steam and we can see reviews.
►Support me on Patreon and watch videos early: / jsr_devon
My stuff:
►Twitter: / jsr_devon
►Facebook: / jsr.devon
►Discord: / discord
►Xbox: JSR Devon
►PSN: JSR_Devon / noveD_RSJ
►Join my club on Xbox: JSR Devon (I will send an invite if you request one)
►Big thanks to all Patreon backers: (All get access to videos early on Patreon and on my Discord server)
FearTheReaper, Billy Sahlen, Aidan Szalanski, Delusion_Khan, chierimerhi, Garrett Taiji, LMP Juicebox, AXR Scarhand, HJD, JSR John, Some Random Person, TSR_Tomsoft, TurboSlothy.
#ForzaMotorsport #Forza #fm8 
Игры
![Eminem - Tobey (feat. Big Sean & Babytron) [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9xn0OHEZZ8Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Read the Steam numbers wrong: average player count for November wasn't 1227, it was down by 1227, average was even worse at 963...
Fun fact about Nurburgring GP: considering the game is promoted as "built from the ground up", it's funny the track model is from at least 2009 when it was introduced in Forza 3. Turn 4 is the giveaway: the banking on the inside of the corner has never existed in real life nor in any other game, it has however existed since Forza 3 when the track first appeared in the series.
A big yes
I bet Forza still has the brake and FFB bug too where below a certain speed brakes don't work and nor does FFB.
I've played EVERY Forza game aside from Horizon 5 and Motorsport... Such a shame to see the franchise basically died after FM4. Still love FM2 and have good memories from it... Tragedy really because Forza as an IP before FM5 was stellar, like genuinely, probably the best IP Xbox had pound for pound. Now though, it's just hollow... Kinda makes me sad... So easy to fix the game too if they had someone with passion at the helm KNOWING what the fans wanted and knowing what's wrong with the game
The peak the past week was 900.
I’ve been playing since Forza 2. Just recently switched to PlayStation and gran turismo. I noticed that turn 4 difference IMMEDIATELY on this circuit lol. I always liked going on 2 wheels there
I’ve been playing since Forza 2. Just recently switched to PlayStation and gran turismo. I noticed that turn 4 difference IMMEDIATELY on this circuit lol. I always liked going on 2 wheels there
I'm not quite sure how to explain it, but Forza's biggest problem for me personally is the whole game feels... hollow, empty, or soulless. There isn't really anything trying to keep me playing other than just chasing numbers and going for podiums over and over. Buy a car, drive around in circles, race with it, repeat. Yes that is the requirements for being a racing game i know, but it just feels.. cold.
Built from the ground up ... by shareholders and middle management.
The game clearly lacks personality. Everything feels so generic and unemotional. Even the voice actors who introduce the tracks and cars sound like they're completely bored. Sometimes I even get the feeling that they're not real voice actors at all, but AI.
Nailed it. I agree with everything except for the going for podiums. With no stats even those are meaningless. I have played a lot, currently Prestige 1 level 600+. Its a dreadful wanting to try a new car. The upgrade unlock process is monotonous and boring. The only thing I am playing now is Rivals on Hardcore. Lots of top 10's and couple #1's.
Amen to that. It’s clearly made by people that read something somewhere about cars and racing, not by petrolheads or racing enthusiasts. It’s like ChatGPT-generated. I see no point in playing it. To be honest I have more fun with Grid Legends.
I’ve played every forza title and this one was my least favorite one. Even Forza Motorsport 5 had passion somewhat, I mean look at the forza vista in that game. 7 and 6 introducing new things like weather, there was passion there too, 360 titles, don’t get me started. Forza Motorsport 8? We get ray tracing, okay nice! Full 24 hours of dynamic weather. So better lighting and times of day. They messed that up ☠️☠️☠️☠️.
I think my biggest problem is that there's been absolutely no acknowledgement of the games issues asside from generic bug fixes each update.
The social channels just keep pumping out announcements of limited time content, the last thing this game needs.
It reminds me of halo infinite, what's supposed to be a reboot ends up screwing up the tech, the core gameplay has great potential, but the content is lacking and unpolished. At least 343 admitted their mistake early on, it's been radio silence from Turn 10
Turn 10 has never been good with communication, and it used to be even worse, but I agree, acknowledgement would help whatever goodwill is remaining in the community
Yes, this is a big factor really. And for a simple example... They still havent even fixed the bug where settings reset on every game start. Have anyone even seen this bug before anywhere? And then seen how bugs like that doesnt get fixed in a short period of time.... But no, the indie studios behind FM are busy pumping out "content" that noone asks for. Dead game... unfortunately
@@Speedyey pointing to individual bugs is pretty meaningless unless they're absolutely game breaking. There are always going to be issues that don't take priority, but it's the broader trend that's the issue
Agreed. I have a lot of issues with the game but honestly if they just came out and say we F’ed up, we hear you and we’re working on it. I would be ecstatic.
Many T10 defenders over the years have said they communicate poorly because MS keeps a leash on them, but another MS studio, Undead Labs, does a good job communicating so I don't see how that could be the case.
The guys and gals at Undead Labs do patch release streams where they go down the list of every patch note while playing the game showing the changes, and discussing what the changes are in detail and what the goal of the change was and how they will monitor the change going forward for further adjustments. They also answer questions from the live chat, and if there is a bug or an issue they acknowledge it, and often explain where they are at with fixing it and a way to avoid it until another patch can be put out.
Meanwhile with T10, we have desync issue going on right now causing other cars to disappear off your screen in multiplayer so you can be ramming someone and not even know it, but they haven't said a word about it and we are left hoping "maybe the January patch will fix it?" The issue has existed since launch though, and was actually made worse in the December update, so I guess we are the idiots for hoping.
To me, it appears that this Forza was made by someone not passionate about motorsport. Every Forza, from 1 to 4, had something that defined it. You could feel the JDM/F&F culture of the first two games, or the Top Gear approach of 4. This one feels empty.
It is empty pal. I’m also an avid Forza player of 1-4, I remember when forza multiplayer first started in FM2, everyone in the lobbies were talking to each other, sharing ideas and competing to the max. Now nobody talks ever, there’s no community, no teams and no Nordschlieff!! So not 1 challenging circuit in Forza. I’ve played the hell out of it, tuned 100 cars desperate for the competition to start because the driving physics are great but the game is empty, I’m feeling washed out, I’m winning every multiplayer race by over 10 secs and I’m bored! Going back to Day Z until they put Nurbs back in, or Grindlewalt, or Fujimi or anything challenging. Peace out bro’s, the dummies can take over the game. Raceboy and Grandma the only 2 real racers left in the game, lol.
I started on Forza Motorsport 3. The thing that initially kept me in the game was infected / king of hill, etc. They've completely removed it from the game.
They ruined the game mode in Forza horizon 5 by giving shitty off-road tracks that aren't even fun to play in. It removes the aspect of skill.
The people they have making the content in these games have no passion for the game and it's obvious. They don't know what people like and they assume that lower player count for the game modes is because the game mode isn't interesting, but the reality is they poorly implemented it in recent games so it sucks to actually play it when the game mode itself is EXTREMELY addicting in previous titles.
The people who made this game are blue haired diversity hires who don't give a crap about racing.
The biggest difference between GT7 and FM8 is that GT7 shows passion for racing and automobiles. FM8 shows the passion of shareholders.
yeah sure we saw the passion for money and microtransactions from gt7 when it launched. User metacritic says everything you need to know about gt7. A mediocre game with worse driving model and a really bad microtransaction plan.
@PrivaPower The additional dlc in GT7 are free while all other dlc in FM cost money. Need I say more?
For me, what sealed the deal, was fact that T10 dont care about cars at all. As a petrolhead I just cant look at these outdated models, childish fire from exhaust, and massive shift delays in DCT transmissions. Uninstalled the game and Im done with it.
An AI update that make the AI actually raceable would be nice
Nobody plays single player on Forza, it's not gonna happen.
@the_red_star8825 that is all i play on Forza. Single player, free play, long races. Not interested in 5-10 minute multiplayer races at all.
@@jamesmoore7858 The problem with the Forza AI is that it was made by some kind of AI itself and is not "handmade" like it used to be.
@@daniel_KeelhI played the hell out of multiplayer in all the previous motorsport titles but haven't touched it in this one. I just want to hop in A class and drive all my cars, but having to waste precious play time on qualifying laps and scheduled classes have really turned me off of the multiplayer. I did the first of the 3 required races for the safety rating, won, and haven't touched it since
i think the fact that you enjoyed more on the multiplayer side shows the development direction they are missing, when single player mode is treated as a thrown-away rather than core of a racing game.
Unfortunately, that's how most games feel these days. Of course there are still good single-player games. But many of them have recently been given a multiplayer mode that gets all the attention. Forza Horizon had a good single-player mode until 3. Since then it's been dumbed down more and more to put more time into the multiplayer. Another example is Test Drive Unlimited. 1 and 2 had tonnes of single-player content. The new instalment looks like there's no single-player at all...
It's a failure to me. I fundamentally hate how it feels
Every other critical point is irrelevant to me because the core experience, the driving, feels like utter ass. I always feel like I'm understeering at any speed in any car and I hate every camera option provided also
I generally play the career mode myself. The main reason I stopped playing is the ai. I'm no expert, more of a casual gamer and I find myself playing on a 5 to 6 difficulty at which point one drivatar is impossible to catch while the remainder of them are abysmally easy ruining the desire to increase further.
Also I find the car level rather annoying, level 25 to 30 is generally where I will end a car, and have to force myself to grind out the remainder feeling monotonous.
Overall I have such mixed feelings and truly expected so much more out of this game.
Yeah I think we all expected more but hopefully it will get better over time the main thing I would like to see is some hopper lobbies and maybe a new open airfield type map
Translated by Google:
What worries me about Forza Motorsport is that if they continue down the same path that the multiplayer is broken and the penalties are also broken, in the end 90% of the players will lose. For me, seeing how the state of Forza Motorsport is, I find it very difficult to recover from all these problems.
The 3 biggest issues I have with the game I think would bring back a ton of people. Mainly car points, what an incredibly dumb idea that they won’t give up on… then there is the lack of tracks especially the ones missing from the last game. And finally the car sounds, exhaust notes have never been weaker imo. ACC spoiled me bad with that that’s the only game to ever really have some emotion thru sound for cars.
remove the car points would make the game more stupier
the idea i have is that if they are working on it, they are working in remake the career mode so they can have be clean to remove it
Changing the game with an update will upset many people who got used to the current state and user interface etc. etc. It's understandable they don't want to confuse the majority of players and gain a shitstorm bigger than they already received.
Forza Motorsport has been going downhill since Forza Motorsport 5, this is just the latest step down.
The FH franchise made the FM franchise pointless.
I personally have been enjoying it. Squashing those bugs would tremendously help the game! Possibly increase car XP gain for those that actually do practice laps before the race event to give incentive for more practice!
As a player idc if I’m the only one but I love this game. The leveling up of the cars is the best thing for me as it makes me actually enjoy them. I switched over to the Xbox when FH3 came out because I loved the idea of an open world game. Over time time I realized that I was only playing to not drive but to collect the new cars for the month and it’s very prevalent in FH5 where now I dread playing it because it feels like a chore just to get the new car to just sit in my garage and to only drive it when I need to. Motorsport makes me work for the car and in turn I appreciate the cars more as I level them up. The time segments in practice are really fun for me and ofc are great to level up my cars. I understand that when you start from scratch you will run into problems but the community seems to be blind to that. They just want cars handed to them and I hate that because theirs no reason to get them or use them. In Motorsport when a car gets gifted to you via car pass or series your reason to drive it is to unlock the parts so that it’s better, but everyone just wants to buy the parts which yes is convenient but when I download a tune it’s a one time thing. Maybe players are lazy nowadays but take away the bug problems and mechanical problems, this is by far the best racing game I’ve played since Gran Turismo 6, and that’s the greatest racing game to me imo
The reason to drive the cars is enjoying driving and racing cars, not some little XP bar to fill up and if that's the only thing that makes you drive then you are probably playing the wrong genre of game.
Suggesting that people are lazy because they don't want to grind in their video game is one of the dumbest arguments you can make for something that is supposed to be a form of recreation.
I appreciate cars that are fun to drive, and cars that I get to race competitively with other people. Making me grind to put parts on the car to make it fun to drive (if it didn't drive nice stock or whatever) and to make it competitive does not make me like the car more, and I'm pretty sure I'm not at all alone in that.
The percentage of negative reviews... ouch 😳
Steam is not relevant with Forza.
@@daniel_Keelh Both Microsoft and Sony are releasing games on Steam (which is the biggest PC storefront). It's quite relevant.
@@daniel_Keelh Xbox store was 1.9 bruh
@@daniel_Keelh 4:36
So im a old Gamer with 43 Years,that means i played Everything you know and more…
I love Gaming,at most Racing and Survival.
The Problem now is that the Games are not as god tested as the pre online Era Games they coudnt fix after Release.
So the fix of the Problem is that there sould be a law that says if you bring out a 1.0 Game for over,lets say 10 €,it has to be finished and there are no fixes allowed after the Release Day,only add ons and Dlcs.
That would make sure that Crap like that Game dont happend to Costumers any more😊
Sorry for bad English,im to angry to Google atm😂❤
My biggest worry is that with the launch being a failue (at least on PC, Xbox numbers besides the bad ratings seems that maneged to get a bunch of players on multiplayer) is that MS will just give up on motorsport and forcing people to go to horizon or drop the plataform altogether if they want sometthing like Gran Turismo
The problem with companies isnt that they dont think "users dont use mush beacuse he had not enough, we need do better", they think \"nobody likes motorsport anymore, lets go cash all in in horizon and leave motorsport in some archive somewhere in seattle"
That would be a shame, as Horizon is becoming less and less appealing to me with every instalment. Horizon used to be a passion project. Nowadays it's just a soulless mass product.
@@benn8793 Horizon has been getting Significantly more Passionate again recently since Torben Ellert took over as the Chief Creative Director with "Midnights at Horizon" , so it seems a *lot* of the issues with 4 later in its Life and 5 for its First Year, before Torben took the Reigns, were because of Mike "Not even a Car Enthusiast!" Brown just not having the Faintest Idea what on Earth he was doing in making a Car Game, so, now he has quit/possibly been given the Boot, hopefully FH6 Might (although I am tempering this with a lot of Caution) be a big Improvement on 4/5.
Remember, Brown, Exactly like Esaki, behind all the Casual Clothes, was, as given away by the Fake Vegas Smile, the Dead Eyes, and the Constant Feed of Buzzwords, Flavour Text and Marketing Spiel, Clearly a Corporate *Suit* ! Pining for its Chair in the Boardroom!, Torben, meanwhile, being "Renegade Gallifreyan Timelord Pretending to be an 1970's English Bohemian" (Yes, I refer to Tom Baker's Doctor there) Levels of..Odd... Clearly holding himself back from spending the next 8 hours of any stream he is on (I imagine his frequent absence is due to being busy helming the In Development as we speak Sixth Horizon Game, and hopefully removing any last shred of "Mike Brown Malaise" that may be within it!) discussing every element of the Core code, Dedicated to ensuring the Community is actually Heard as much as MS, The PEGI/ESRB, and the Increasingly Hostile Car Companies will allow them to be Heard, and clearly Excited to be working on the Games, is Clearly an Actual Gamer, and that, hopefully, could mean Horizon may well be in Safe Hands again for the First time since FH3.
Another thing to add on - which I agree on what you mentioned, the PC port doesn’t really feel or even *Optimized* to play on PC in general. Textures glitch out/disappear, game tends to freeze on results or on Loading screens, when it lags on trying to give you a Practice lap - you spawn with car damage and probably you lap already neglected.
I play the game on Steam, and I also have GT7 on PS5….and tempted of going back to Horizon 5 because FM just doesn’t run like it should as for the Xbox would.
@@simeonyves5940 I know that many are happy with the development of Horizon over the last year or so. But for me it hasn't made any difference and hasn't brought me back to the game. Just delivering new cars all the time doesn't make the game better, contrary to popular opinion...
@@benn8793 I do agree that the Constant dump of Cars does not make the Game better, Especially as the way they are Added ties into one of the Biggest Problems of the Mike Brown era, the Disgusting Use of FOMO mechanics (Seriously, FOMO Mechanics need to be made *illegal* IMO!) in order to drive up Gamepass Numbers, and I can only hope the Sudden Upsurge in DLC that has come under Torben is a sign FH6 is going to Drop the FOMO Nonsense and go back to the Old Model of "Straight to Autoshow" for Returning Cars and Paid DLC for New To Forza Cars, Granted It means the Game is going to Be Ludicrously Expensive, it always is when DLC based, but I will take Paid DLC over FOMO any day of the Week! and the Game, indeed, is NOT going to feel anything other than a *Chore* at times unless the FOMO Nonsense is thrown down the Garbage Chute, but, outside of the Chore Chart, it is Improving.
Where the Game has been Improving is in the Vastly more imaginative use if the "evolving world" Feature (Just a Shame that the Mexican Government will not allow many of the Additions, such as the Neon Air-Strip, to be Permanent :( ), the complete Re-Do of Event Lab, the Multiple Bug Fixes, the Additions of Community most Wanted Features such as a Permanent Extension to the Night Cycle, More Apex Road Races, better Anti Cheat Implementation, the Festival feeling a lot more "Present" in the "Evolving world" Editions, Better music on the new Stations, Less...Wokeness (it is still there due to some of it being baked right into the core mechanics such as the Character Editor (Seriously, Torben, if you ever read this, and if the Core Code even allows it, Kindly Patch out the Pronouns and add a Gender Lock to the Cosmetics Please, the things they Promote have been proven in a *court of British Law* to be Harmful to Children, so they really do not belong at a PEGI 3/ESRB E at the end of the Day.) but it is nowhere near as Highlighted as it once was in the (Sadly still abysmal) Dialogue, thank goodness) Etc, the Fact it feels like there is a Gamer in Charge again, and not an Out of Touch and Clueless Corporate Suit!
Not only is the Team becoming increasingly more Imaginative, more Competent (the Game is getting a lot less Buggy, and when a Bug does occur (such as the "constant winter cutscene loop" bug) it gets patched a Lot Faster, is listening more to the Community, adding more Community Requests, at least those that work with the Increasingly Elderly Graphics Engine, and what they can get past the ever shrinking Budget from Microsoft, the Downright Hostile Car Companies many of whom do not want to be in Games *at all* anymore as they are worried that Gaming is Damaging their PR Images and are looking for any Excuse to Remove their Licenses, and most Importantly, the ESRB/PEGI (Sadly, many of the Requests would up the Age Rating, making them no Go.) and the Game feels like it is in the Hands of a Passionate and Motivated Team that wants to Work on it, It no longer feels like its being made by a Burned out and Demoralized Team just going through the Motions like it did during the Peak of the Mike Brown Malaise. It just feels like its in Safe Hands again for the First Time since FH3. That Feeling is a massive Improvement on what we had, when it felt like it was in the Hands of a Team that did not even care anymore, and a Lead without even the Slightest Idea what he was doing.
It Gives hope that, so long as Torben was Sensible, Scrapped Browns Vision for 6, Implemented his own, and moved the Action from Communist China (just No! I have Boycotted TDUSC over it being set in Communist China and will do the Same for FH6 if it is set there, Communist China has *Far* too much Blood on its Hands for me to ever accept it as a Viable Location outside of the Game "doing a Flight Simulator" and going Global!) to Europe, FH6 may actually be a Truly Great Game like the First 3 Titles were!
We never had that Hope under Brown, and the fact it is there now, is a Massive Improvement!
Failure? It's a disgrace. A disaster.
There is no offline career,only 4 group of events
Graphically is poorly made
It's boring
Yes
The game is dead amd it deserve to die
Ever since FM7 I have been counting down the days for the next motorsport game, now that its here and has been since October, I feel as through I am missing out on nothing by not playing it, it genuinely looks incredibly boring, and it appears that many people think the same. This could be a blessing, turn 10 hyped this game up so much on their social networks, they made it appear like the racing game that everyone had been craving since FM7 which was released... 6 years ago? Only for it to be a copy of previous titles with recycled content and not a whole lot more new ideas going on. Hopefully they learn from this for future development, whether it be updating this game or future launches.
The reason why people have been waiting for this game so much is because the previous games left a lot to be desired. Many people hoped that the long development time would improve things. I wanted to give the game a chance and tried it out for a good number of hours via the Game Pass. A few weeks later, I uninstalled it again. I don't miss anything.
It's just so sad that I throw FM4 or FM3 into my old 360 and it's just a great time to be having. I actually deleted FM from the Series X, and continue playing 3 and 4 on the old 360.
Timeless classics
The lack of cars at launch definitely hurt the game for me
Am I the only one who thought the game was just extremely short? Like the career page with all the career races, I expected there to be another page of races. Just seemed very short..
You are not alone. It finished pretty quickly. It would be nice if you could adjust the career mode race lengths. I'd like making them longer with forced pit strategy. I know I can make that happen on my own, but, it's nice to have options.
Well. The length is one thing. But the career is also extremely boring. Game developers have completely forgotten how to make good careers.
Whos knows what they will do with updates but its not off to a good start
I wanted to buy Forza Motorsport but the 'Mostly Negative' rating on Steam is extremely hard to gain and even harder to ignore, all 3 Forza games are still good on my XBOX 360 but I question my use of the word 'good'. Why? I haven't 100% completed any Forza game other than the original Forza Motorsport on the first XBOX and I've bought four Forza games (and yet Turn 10 have made the new game even harder??!?).
So I have zero reason or incentive to get the latest game, making the new game even harder to complete was totally unwarranted, then there are technical issues. Turn 10 will either learn from their mistakes or vanish.
Hopefully they added multiplayer and Bathurst and Road Atlanta and Charlotte Motor Speedway and more to come
i’ve personally had lots of fun on forza coming from asseto corsa.
The career mode is not very career , the limited time event and cars reward is annoying instead of motivated
Wish they can add more cars
I hope they keep patching this game and eventually turn it into something people really love.
I wanted to like this game, I really did. To me personally, I feel FM7 was better. FM7 kept me coming back playing. FM8 is doing the exact opposite, things that do that is the multiplayer/hopper lobbies, same customization we had for YEARS!, leveling of cars, tracks, buggy and unfinished game. There's more that I can't think of at the moment. In total from launch, I played the game a total of 1hr 15minutes. This is what happens when you don't please the players and only please the developers. They need something really big or game changing for me to come back.
True on all accounts, yet this one strikes a near perfect balance between Sim and Arcade for me, so I'm sticking with it (and enjoying it - when not being rammed into oblivion).
Even liking their driving phisics I absolutely call this game a disaster, everything else is broken. They don't even have actual tyre wear because the tyres of both sides of the car always degrade by the same amount no matter the track.
I gave the game it's fair chance, but it failed hard. Super Woden GP 2, that is a tiny game made to look like a granturismo for the SNES, has a better carrer mode and better AI in their game. If that doesn't put in perspective how much of a failure this game is, nothing will.
Not saying you're wrong cause I full believe they'd do that with tyre wear but I've had races with significantly more left/right tyre wear depending on the orientation
@@xILoveFishyx In the eagle rock short oval I had exactly equal tyre wearing on both sides, and being a short race with the softs of both sides ended with the same wear.
Terrible car progression system, lack of hopper lobbies for A class and S class, also qualifying and practice for said lobbies, huge disparity in AI pace are just a few things that have really put me off of this game. I’ve always been a quick driver who’s loved hopping into A class or S class lobbies and fighting at the front - used to spend hours in lobbies using different cars for different tracks but have lost all motivation to play this game now. Such a let down, was so excited for this game being someone who’s played every Forza since FM2
This generation of FM is a 🤡 as a fanboy who purchase Ultimate Edition every time I'm completely pissed off
I’ve been only playing the game when me and my friends are hosting a private lobby. I refuse to play it any other time. This game has been an utter joke since launch and I am starting to lose hope in the franchise.
The game just feels unfinished and underwhelming. Even compared to forza 6 I had a lot more fun with that game than I've had with this one.
Interesting numbers, for sure! Do you have comparables for Gran Turismo? What did their numbers look like post launch, 6 months out, etc?
Hope you've had a good Christmas and Happy New Year to you and your family mate
In FM4 some tracks had a million players set a time, in FM8 the busiest rivals have around 25,000 quite a big drop off, the game can be fun, but the rotation of multiplayer races has become boring and only having 2 open class multiplayer lobbies is really bad, especially when its E class or X class, nothing inbetween
Wow, Forza 4 really had a crazy amount of players. At time I remember feeling the guys at t10 had finally raced past gt. However, it was always one step forward and two steps backward from there. Sad how t10 has to this date failed to build on what they had with fm4 magic and expand on it. I will give them credit for really nailing the physics, but man did they drop the ball with this new game out the gate. I do believe it will be a fine product in a couple years once development is complete, we’re just paying beta testers right now
I actually like it but there is tons to improve on. A race engineer to help with wet weather races would be good, get rid of car levels and I hope they bring out tons more tracks.
A road map for updates would be nice to see where they actually think this game is going. Ive not played Motorsport for a long time not properly since FM3/4 played Horizon in between on and off and was genuinely excited for this game even went as far as getting a wheel. I love the game but theres so many features missing and also missing a sense of personality, from the menus to the cars to the UI to the AI. I hope they can turn this game around but i wont hold my breath.
I usually average about 6 to 7 hours per week of game play time in featured multiplayer so am very casual when it comes to play time and I hate to say it but the multiplayer is good enough for me, I drive the car that I feel like driving against other people and I end up turning off the Xbox with a satisfied feeling and I think that most players are casuals just like me trying to play a racing game with no purpose other than racing
While I agree with the vst majority of what you said, I will push back on one thing, that being the lack of competitiveness in the multiplayer hoppers. I did an experiment, and joined and left lobbies 5 straight times in less than 2 minutes. I ended up in 5 different lobbies, 4 of them being brand new. Given it only takes a couple minutes for lobbie to fill, at least in the GT/TC lobbies, that is plenty of players alone to create a competitve lobby, not counting all the players that could oin over a 25-30 minute period. Matchmaking simply doesn't work. It fills lobbies too fast, but I also suspect something else. When you build a multiplayer group, your rating gets inflated. 4999 group rating is the norm even with a wide range of individual player ratings. If this happens in lobbies, it won't really know where to put you. Regardless of the actual reason, as it could just be it fills them too fast, lobbies are effectively entirely random. If I join a lobby at 4999 at lobby open, I'm guarunteed to be in a different lobby to another 4999 player that joins 2-3 minutes later, 10 minutes later, 15 minutes later, or at the end of the join period.
Also, 9 of the top 20 requested cars are LMDH/Hypercars, and 4 GT3 cars. Almost all of them are race cars of some sort of race car. The lack of spec lobby racing and rivals in single player is a travesty for those who prefer spec racing.
I finished all the career mode in a week. I still have not finished Motorsport 4 Career Mode. They should just report that to current gen. No reason they could not include every track from the start
I’m happy to say, I’m in the “s” safety class group of racers, which is supposed to be top tear. Still getting rammed, bashed off track and even rolled in my last race! I feel like chucking the Xbox out the window!!😡😡😡I just want to race against actual racers! People who respect racing lines, give a cards width when passing or being passed. What’s the bottom class look like?
Fun and comradery was always the thing that made ppl want to come back.
Forza 4 was (almost) a perfect concept.
Clubs, club garage, super easy to join friends and club members online even in private lobbies,
Decent single player career mode, and no upgrade unlock system, so you could test and max out any car instantly.
Watching and sharing of (clips) replay was easy and great for content creators.
And that content attract more players. That is a positive loop that gives the game a strong community and long live.
Now, no clubs, no replays (GT Lobby) no way to join friends easy, no lobby system, terrible unlock system ect ect.
All in all a lot less fun..
On top of that the artificial stuff like aerowash for the leading car, or the game changing your spring setting each time you jump to the next race and/or change tires makes the racing (cars/tune) unreliable and therefor less fun.
Consistency is key in racing and if you can not trust the car (settings) due to the game mechanics and structure...
Then what is left? It could be such a great game because the core is strong (IMO) but the way they managed to "influence" the game and gamers for whatever reason is destroying what was left of the game and community.
Many moved on and likely will not come back. We saw a similar fall out with previous FM titles.
And instead T10 learning from it, they continue that self destructing path.
GT is really good, i can see why super GT does not do Forza so much, because it is that much better and more fun.
Even the multiplayer lacks variety, every month FORZA GT and TC cycle through the same track/length combinations. Most of the cars are tuned with absolutely horrendous understeer where you’re just waiting to get back on the throttle through the corner and the driver rating system does literally nothing. If turn10 fixed these three issues I’d play the game but currently I have played in weeks and have no plans to return while these issues persist
I l havent played the game yet and only see complaints on Instagram. Is it that bad ?
It’s good on Xbox x. ❤
From everything I've done, I'd say the game itself as a racing game alone is not a failure however. The Physics are amazing (in comparison) however all major things that I've done is Private lobbies online with friends and AFK car leveling.
The Ai even on Level 8 are just too slow and not fun to race so career is pointless for me to play and featured multiplayer I was 4,974 Skill and S Safety rating after my 3 intro races even though I quit 2 of them.
Just a little thing I disagree with about the video, I heavily disagree with your claim that Fujimi would somehow make the game do better. That’s just outright nonsense.
Yes, people always act as if one track or car completely transforms a game. I agree with you.
Why is it nonsense. Its been the most requested track since fm4. Even without a drift scoring system, it would bring in the drift community, who would post videos, which would bring in more players. Why do you think he brought up supergt, its a big problem that no one's making videos.
When you get the right car and track combo, it is great to drive...
That's the issue. Not race. Drive. It is a great hot lap game, sure, the trying to string together sectors on a hot lap is great when the car and track work well together. But those great combos are few and ar between an I don't have the patience to try every car on one track, to find out what cars work great with a track, then move on to the next one, and th the next one, an so on.
That's my biggest issue. Spa in a 962C, Laguna Seca in the 962C when it kicks sideways at the top o the Corckscrew, with the tires spinning up then the run down the hill? That is when it is working great, when it is fun. Spaa shines in almost everything, Lime Rock in a mid class car is a ton of fun.
But there's tracks that are just boring and make me not want to run them. eagle Rock, Hakone, and Yas Marina, the latter being the worst one on the list. It looks dull and boring on TV, it is soulless to play.
THe AI is just....I don't know why they are programed how they are but they are not fun to race, at all, not in the leastit
I stopped playing because of terrible PI system balancing and poor multiplayer conduct going unpunished.
I don't expect either of these to change, so I very likely will never play Forza Motorsport 8 again.
The single player is shockingly bad
Live service games just need to be a thing of the past, it clear they all tried to be like fortnite and every company has failed completely.
Agreed, Live Services, Like FOMO Mechanics, Lootbox Gambling, Mictrotransactions, and Forced Multiplayer, really do need to be made *illegal* IMO!
Does it have issues that need fixing, yes definitely. Is it a failure, no it's a really fun game.
I agree with this video, I gave it a shot was never gonna be main game but I gave it a shot after a while got so bored I went back to ACC.
The only problem that this game have its the content, it lacks a lot of content, not only singleplayer but also multiplayer.
The car point system its also a dumb idea, with this you are forcing people to just use meta cars and nothing else, they dont want to waste time exploring other options because of the time it would take them to level up a car only to find out that it is rubbish.
This is my first Forza so I can't directly compare it to other previous versions. but one thing I will say - within my longevity in racing games - that despite the very beautiful graphics and such, other than that, it doesn't hold a candle to a racing game that I loved most of all time: TOCA Race Driver from 2002 It was my first semi-arcade racing game with a career story mode that made me fall in love on the first day with the iconic sound of the classic band Lynyrd Skynyrd with the wonderful Sweet Home Alabama playing in the background in the interactive menu inside the trailer... There were others Golden times that, although they didn't have the same effects and ultra-realistic graphics as today, had the soul of creators who were passionate about what they were doing.
So far I thought it was an ok game. It is challenging both for those who are starting out in the world of racing games and for the equipment they are running, because with the minimum requirements you realize how much graphical processing and CPU overhead it consumes to present a game that has done the basics of basic in a multi-million dollar triple A.
me and many many others have not been able to launch the game since update 3.0 i have over 440 hours of playtime, hopefully update 4.0 maybe we can play again
This is my first foray in to multiplayer gaming in years and I enjoy the racing and my perceived improvements over the last two months. I couldn't even imagine playing this single player though, there's really nothing there to hold my attention.
Of course to me this a 'new' experience (though I did my time in FM2 & 3 back in the day), but if you're a veteran of this genre, then I can understand why this game is considered an empty shell.
The only thing it suffers from is it’s in the world of fun arcade racers. People play those games and expect every game to be unrealistic fun.
Online penalty system makes it a complete failure alone....really need to fix it
The way to upgrade cars annoyed me and the ai were all over the place. Im one of those people who has always been more of a story mode player as opposed to on-line. But the "story" mode kinda sucks.
This was the first forza motorsports ive purchased since fm3. Watching this video and reminiscing made me think how much more exicted i used to be when i wanted to play the game. Its sad
The game just doesn't have anything going for it. If you're serious about sim racing ACC is really inexpensive, and if you're into fun racing with a good career FM is not your best choice
I enjoy the game but the catch is I play other games as well, I dont have serious amount of time to play the career modes and just do a quick online session and that works perfectly for me.
This proves Turn 10 doesn’t care at this point. The new game could have so much more new features other than track racing like rally, motorcycles and others. Motorsport includes, but definitely not limited to track racings.
I don't get why they don't even allow you to upgrade during multiplayer races. How are they going to have a car-level system that 100% requires you to play offline for hours in free play rather than test it in the practice lobbies pre-races.
They've just dropped the budget on the motorsport and are putting all the good people on developing horizon, despite that actual innovation on racing will happen on motorsport and not the super arcade-y horizon mode.
Horizon mode will quickly turn into a crappy NFS if they don't innovate it by using what they learn from motorsport series.
I bought it on XSX. Have 250+ hours. 4600 S saftey rating. The lobbies are 20 people to full lobbies I have cross-platform play off so I haven't played against PC in a long time
The issue with me is how fast I get uninterested in playing the game since starting it up. The truth is there simply is not much to do outside of grinding the career championships and participating in the cycled multiplayer races. It doesn’t help that the game still has pages of issues from day 1 of its release, some of these issues that were stated to have been fixed in prior patches and updates but haven’t. Frankly I think we were promised a product and were given something that is completely not that promised product.
Super GT was playing Forza Featured MP the last 2 days so we should see a new video soon.
Isnt super gt affiliated with gt7 though?
I can’t even put my finger on what turns me off on the game, was so looking forward to it but haven’t touched it in at least a month and only made it through a couple of the series. When I was working on it I had to force myself to launch it instead of horizon.
This is the first game that I ever bought through steam that I demanded my money back. VERY SAD for this to be the case, because I set my calendar to this release. I waited for this title for YEARS!! It was my first love. I have since become quite the SIM Racing enthusiast. Nothing serious, but a G29 wheel setup with GTLite Next Level Racing Frame Pedals SHifter etc. Its a great little set up with my PC. The performance optimization was SO BAD. I couldnt let them keep my money with a clear conscience.
It's amazing that this game actually has anyone playing it anymore. I mean the quality of it is so poor from what I have heard and seen that I really wonder why anyone would actually spend one's time on it.
I bought a Series X to play this game, after the disappointment I bought myself a PS5 and GT7 and I’m impressed by the amount of singleplayer content that game has, plus the physics are significantly better than Forza. Although I’ll check Forza at every monthly update, for now I basically lost interest in FM.
I'm going back to FM7. FH is great with open world, but getting a bit repetitive and grindy. Lego and Hotwheels add ons were great. FM(8) is missing great some great tracks (Alps) and others which might be eventually coming back but the grind isn't worth the wait.
SuperGT and other prominent RUclipsrs only made videos on the multiplayer side of Forza and how bad it was, Turn 10 listened to this and concentrated on making multiplayer better, which arguably they have, but neglected the rest of the game which the majority of people who played the game actually played which is single player. We’ve now got a game that is hollow with no drifting, no drag racing, no fun events and no Don JoeWon Song videos.
Yep. I only play single player and thats just boring. Done all the events in a couple of days. . The ones they add are just variations of the same, allways poxy super cars. How about sone actual events for race cars or lower groups. Ive got used to The upgrade system , but its still crap. . By the time you unlock decent parts the event is over. To make it worse is the stupid amout of XP you need to actually get the parts . Take race tyres, unlock at level 2 but can't actually afford to get them . Have to do a silly amout of races without upgrading to get them.. and why do some race cars not come with race tyres as standard, like most of the group 5 cars, what do they think they raced on ? Street tyres. . . Don't really bother with it much anymore, not interested in any of the new cars they are adding as there is sod all the use them for. . Got the be the weakest and worst instalment so far. 6 years to develop this turd. . Of which you can't polish.
Huge part is none of the cars are really competitive in multiplayer until around level 30 so you’re playing for hours leveling a car up just to race then you have to wait 20 mins to get into a game
I stopped playing because on both PC and my Xbox Series X i faced the same graphics issues with huge frame rate slow down after a couple races, and twxtures popping in and out. It was super distracting. Plus it didnt feel like there was any real progression in the game. Like someone said above. It feels hollow. No real sense of accomplishment.
What’s sad is that all the media and community disappointment and backlash from GT7’s launch got the developer to respond and promise changes. It’s like no one even cares about Forza Motorsport the same way.
it is almost if there has a double standart between xbox and ps huh?
Yeah: GT is a big enough name for people outside of the racing genre to take note of it, Forza Motorsport is not, at least not since FM4.
I think the game is excellent on Xbox x!
Miss the old style where you just hop into a lobby and race no waiting for 20-30 mins
you don't have to wait 20-30mins lol.. after finishing the race, you'll get connected to the next track where usually around 7 minutes are left to do the qualification and setting up your car...
I've become more and more disillusioned with the Forza franchise and it's nothing like Forza 2 that I originally played and became infatuated with. This is the first Forza game I've not bought and have played via gamepass. It's a massive disappointment for me, from the buggy multiplayer at launch, lack of content to be drip-fed later and a boring career mode. The leveling system is my biggest issue, I like to use tunes from the start not gradually add part by part - on every single car.
You can fix bugs but you can't fix boring.
#Turn10out
Fm7 wasnt on game pass on launch, it was like 3 years latter so that game dosent have the inflated numbers the new game has. It was probably had the numbers it had because it launched with the one x and they were saying it would be the best looking game on the console and it was
I mean i am really enjoying the game ? I never played racing games for single player though, as I am usually playing online .
This feels like a nightmare. You wait so long for a game to be released only to find out is just bad. I didn't play Forza Motorsport 4, but from videos looks a lot more fun than this. And the new motorsport game looks.... weird, like the colours are washed out, something with the lighting. The menu looks like it's from a mobile game, it's too simple. Maybe the multiplayet is good, but the whole game is not really a true "forza motorsport" as we once knew.
I know why they did it but having to grind each car for hours before being able to fully upgrade it is a deal breaker. For now. Plus, I think the game looks worse than 7, mostly.
Something i noticed was the percentage on the achievements. I just looked the one that says reach level 50 on 30 cars and noticed it's only 0.13% of players. Not only that one but there are several that have much lower percentages than what you'd expect. Even the multiplayer percentages that I'd expect would be higher (and are higher by far) are still lower than i expected. All they'd have to do to fix the single player game is unlock all the upgrades, and make car points universal. Then they'd just have to keep adding tracks as fast as possible. That's it. That's all they'd have to do. After another 12 to 15 tracks and the car points system being fixed and there you go. Well... not quite, but at least it'd be on the right track. The AI needs to be fixed. The penalty system needs to be fixed. But at least it wouldn't feel like a useless grind.
Game Pass does end up making achievements rarer because more people will try out a game.
Unless you're doing a decent bit of MP, I can't see many people hitting level 50 on many cars at all.
Very sad how BAD this game is. 60 max fps - no triple screen support - terrible CPU/GPU utilization - just so bad. And the AI is HORRID.
In my opinion, the biggest issue is the absurd system to upgrade cars. Upgrade cars were one of the parts that I enjoyed the most in forza, but this system simply feels like artificial farming to upgrade cars.
Short answer: Yes
The multiplayer i find pretty fun to jump on and play. But the single player god what were they thinking its absolutely horrendously bad and boring who signed that off? The car sounds are truely dreadful as well how can a years old game like acc sound so much better is beyond me, i dont even buy any road cars whats the point what am i using them for? Whats the point of upgrading my car if the computer just upgrades at the same car. Again build my car for what exactly?? How is there no replys? No stats? In 2023?
I've deleted it entirely since every loading before a race is infinite after reinstall and cache verify. Just unable to physically play the game. Which solves my original issue of not even wanting to play the game anyway. The newest game in the franchise ive spent almost the same amount of time in as Minecraft. Collectively well over 10k hours.
Motorsport was such a failure, I stopped logging into Horizon 5 for weeklies and cruising. I've just lost interest in the Forza franchise.
The overall problem with Forza Motorsport:
1. Car levels is a good idea implemented terribly. It requires grinding a car for 4 HOURS before you can actually use it in a multiplayer setting. It completely destroys the game for tuners. It's just going to result in people (like me) exploiting the game. I'm literally using a script to evenly level up all cars in the game so that I can eventually try to tune everything to test it out. A Privilege people who don't know how to script won't have. Everyone else just uses rival meta cars because why would they want to be at a disadvantage in a race or have to spend dozens of hours trying out different cars just to see if they are any good or not.
2. There isn't much reason to play online other than just to race. All exclusive cars are in career mode, which NO ONE gives a shit about. I played a ton of forza motorsport already and haven't unlocked a single exclusive car because I'm not going to sit there and race shitty AI who just throw you off track.
3. The penalty system is worse. I find it penalizes me more for good driving than it does for knocking people off track to keep a racing line. If I race against someone and they push me off track I lose time and additionally I can get off-track penalties (which is consistent). If I just throw them off track I now don't have to deal with them and I'm unlikely to actually get a penalty from the only part of the game the penalty system works in (off-track penalties).
4. The matchmaking doesn't work. I'm max rank, 4,980 with S safety rating. I usually start in the back of races on purpose, it's obvious that 80% of the people in the races are really bad and probably would be like a 3,000 rating with a C safety rating at best.
this thing should have tonnes of grip, not sliding around mid corner... Forza need to refine this game. seriously, I like the game but it lacks QUALITY
It’s so bad, I had to buy Assetto Corsa Competizione and I’ve having a blast ever since
I think if they showed that they cared about making it up to the players I would still be playing. But they clearly don't seem to think anything is terribly wrong. We're still just getting the normal monthly schedule of haphazard and untrustworthy patch notes. That's what I'm tired of the most. I spent the first 2 months submitting bug reports and not a single one ever showed up on the known or fixed issues list. Apparently even if you do their job for them, it doesn't lead to anything. It really is tiresome.