How Much of Indian History Is Really True? | Sanjeev Sanyal | Rewriting Indian History |

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 янв 2016
  • "It is no secret that conquering cultures peg themselves as ‘superior’ and denounce everything that came before them as an ‘age of darkness’. Equally true is the African proverb, “As long as the lions do not have their storytellers, history will always glorify the hunter”.
    We Indians know intuitively that the history imposed on us is not our history at all. It is the history of invaders glorifying their invasions. And yet, for over 70 years of independence, we Indians have not managed to cleanse the biases of the colonial imposition of history on us. Sanjeev Sanyal makes a case for telling Indian history the way it happened to us - from the perspective of Indians.
    About Speaker: -
    Sanjeev is an Indian writer, environmentalist and urbanist, who is considered as one of the world's leading financial sector economists. Sanjeev was the Global Strategist and Managing Director at Deutsche Bank till Oct 2015. He is also the author of three best-selling books, including the "Land of the Seven Rivers: A Brief History of India's Geography."
    Subscribe to our RUclips channels:
    RUclips English: / sangamtalks
    RUclips Hindi: / sangamhindi
    Follow Sangam Talks on social media :
    Telegram : t.me/sangamtalks
    Twitter: / sangamtalks
    Facebook: / sangamtalks
    Instagram: / sangamtalks
    Website: www.sangamtalks.org
    Donate: www.sangamtalks.org/donate
    #SangamTalks
    #RewritingIndianHistory

Комментарии • 2 тыс.

  • @useless_fella
    @useless_fella 5 лет назад +418

    I am even more glad to read your own history Sanjeev!!! Your great grandfather Sachindra Nath Sanyal was mentor to Bhagat Singh and Chandrasekhar Azad!!!

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад +1

      निकम्मा ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @AnkurPandeyef
      @AnkurPandeyef 4 года назад +10

      Wow didn't know that!

    • @rounak73
      @rounak73 4 года назад +16

      not great grandfather but grand-uncle.

    • @sonukumar-gm5hf
      @sonukumar-gm5hf 3 года назад

      Really

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @Aleksandr_Gelyevich_Dugin
    @Aleksandr_Gelyevich_Dugin 3 года назад +127

    Sachindranath Sanyal fought against British through Anushilan Samiti, HRA etc. and now his nephew is fighting the same fight through pen...Kudos to Sanjeev Sanyal sir.

  • @lovkeshsaini8607
    @lovkeshsaini8607 3 года назад +24

    "Everyone has right to an opinion, but do not have right to facts" Well said!

  • @lulu1788
    @lulu1788 5 лет назад +304

    I am not Indian, I LOVE and admire its history, the country and its people. Please could you put the most important terms in bracket in English? Many non Indian people will be very thankful. Namaste.

  • @prince8980
    @prince8980 5 лет назад +313

    That lady from DU got destroyed 😂 story of every pseudo intellectuals from JNU and DU can't stomach facts can they

    • @sanketraghuvanshi
      @sanketraghuvanshi 3 года назад +38

      DU history students have a so called "superiority complex". Mera vachan hi shasan hai type

    • @abhinavshukla2202
      @abhinavshukla2202 3 года назад +4

      @@sanketraghuvanshi true

    • @sukritsingh8456
      @sukritsingh8456 2 года назад +23

      @@sanketraghuvanshi I studied in DU, and believe me when I say this- most of the acquaintances I had with people, they were stupid as fuck, which is the reason why I only had acquaintances. There was this girl in my course, who believed Kejriwal to be a great economist in him offering free electricity and water- I was like lulz, okay, so what should I do with that stat.

    • @sanketraghuvanshi
      @sanketraghuvanshi 2 года назад +4

      @@sukritsingh8456 same here bro
      Except I was lucky enough to find a lot of nationalist friends

    • @kushal4956
      @kushal4956 2 года назад

      @@sukritsingh8456 kejriwal might've given out some freebies and some of it is good but the delhi economy has done great under him

  • @raghvendrasingh9984
    @raghvendrasingh9984 4 года назад +82

    Sir I am a part time teacher, I teach classes from 6-10. I personally love history a lot. I have seen many times that text books, perticularly pvt publishers Glorify the invaders, AKBAR THE GREAT, THE GREAT MUGHALS, THE TIGER OF MYSORE TIPU SULTAN etc. But nowhere I see our great Rajput kings like Maharana Pratap, Rana Sanga (who defeated Ibrahim lodhi), Rana kumbha (who never lost the war), Baji rao who defeated Mughals at Delhi and Bhopal. Why Qutub minar is called that it was built by Qutub ud din Aibak, since clearly one can see hindu symbols all over that mimar and in the complex. Alauddin tried to make one but can't, because he doesn't had that kind of architectural engineering to build that kind of minar. I request our government to History books needs to be written again.

    • @NoMornings
      @NoMornings 4 года назад

      Naṭarāja: Pādādikeśa Varṇanam (Description from Head to Toe) - Dr. R. Nagaswamy ji in conversation with Prof V Ramanathanruclips.net/video/bgG6e1OARjM/видео.html

    • @santasingee9065
      @santasingee9065 2 года назад +7

      With regards to Qutub minar. I am not an indian but had a chance to visit the said place in 2019. Its quite obvious that the layout, structure and materials used for the religious buildings in that area seem to have been salvaged from some hindu temple or building. One can even see parts of temple blocks, complete with hindu god images, being used as parts of d current religious buildings there.

    • @nadatarangam8106
      @nadatarangam8106 2 года назад +1

      👍👍👍👍👍

    • @GowthamV07
      @GowthamV07 Год назад +6

      SIMPLE ANSWER to your questions is BECAUSE OF CONGRESS and NEHRU favoruing his islam religion over the real truth.

    • @yugmathakkar4023
      @yugmathakkar4023 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@santasingee9065 There's some credible theories regarding the construction of Qutub Minar. They talk about how some 14 odd massive Jain temples were completely razed down to the ground by the invading Islamist forces, and then used the materials from these temples to build the Qutub Minar.

  • @purijagmohan
    @purijagmohan 8 лет назад +227

    It's a pity that only 20000 people watched this video. Should be mandatory viewing for 100 crore Indians.

    • @LalitKumar-cu5iu
      @LalitKumar-cu5iu 6 лет назад +3

      jagmohan swain
      More than 100 thousand views now.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      jagmohan swain ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад +1

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @situn4377
      @situn4377 7 месяцев назад +3

      More than 6 million views now

    • @lifejrahatke
      @lifejrahatke 4 месяца назад

      😅😅

  • @VJBlues
    @VJBlues 7 лет назад +144

    After watching the video I have to say that I do agree with him 100%. Many Indians don't even are aware of their true history.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      VJ Blues ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @gottlobfreige1075
      @gottlobfreige1075 2 года назад

      bullshit, there's no such thing as true history..

  • @itsmeravikiran
    @itsmeravikiran 6 лет назад +696

    Currently, Tipu Sultan is being projected in the same light as Ashoka by the urban mughals. :)

    • @siddharthsiddharth7106
      @siddharthsiddharth7106 6 лет назад +3

      Ravi Kiran Tipu sultan was a fictional figure like Rani Padmavati

    • @ssi44
      @ssi44 5 лет назад +80

      Tipu Sultan was a tyrant like other Mughals. He has destroyed many temples and also forced conversion.

    • @manmathsinghdeo5220
      @manmathsinghdeo5220 5 лет назад +13

      There is no difference between the two..

    • @akshaykumer194
      @akshaykumer194 5 лет назад +39

      There was no limit as to the loss the Hindu temples suffered due to the military operations of Tipu Sultan. Burning down the temples, destruction of the idols installed therein and also cutting the heads of cattle over the temple deities were the cruel entertainments of Tipu Sultan and his equally cruel army.

    • @akshaykumer194
      @akshaykumer194 5 лет назад +10

      @Vijay Kumar that 100% congress in hour country like UK government

  • @anantnarayan8274
    @anantnarayan8274 5 лет назад +70

    i am a student of history it pains my heart to see that we are so fucked hard!!!damn we hindus lost it man..seriously check ncerts of 6 to 8th..damn!!!!

    • @MS-ov9sv
      @MS-ov9sv 2 года назад +2

      Yes ...it's total lies....just read the book by Neeraj Atri jj Brainwashed Republic

    • @krishanuchattopadhyay7006
      @krishanuchattopadhyay7006 2 года назад +6

      True. NCERT is fucking us hard in history. 😑😑

    • @rupendrasharma6291
      @rupendrasharma6291 Год назад +2

      Yes we lost but lets fight again and win this time

  • @blackStar-fr3nh
    @blackStar-fr3nh 8 лет назад +125

    nehru-socialism started collapsing economically over two decades ago. Its political and ideological collapse is picking up pace in recent years. A great time to be alive to see indian transformation and rediscovery

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      black Star ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @abeninan4017
      @abeninan4017 2 года назад

      The Nehru socialism collapsed from the get go. Please check the chart of rupee devaluation. At the time of independence the value of Indian rupee and us dollar was equal.

  • @sha133n
    @sha133n 8 лет назад +246

    9:08 blew my mind. Pasis are considered dalits today, but a millenium ago they were proud warriors who defeated the mighty Turk army. Amazing! I wish our textbook had tidbits like this, that showed Indian social history was anything but static.

    • @theindianamerican1772
      @theindianamerican1772 8 лет назад +14

      Since when are Paris considered Dalits today they are one of the most successful religious groups economically and socially and have never faced persecution in India and are definitely not a socially backward group

    • @sha133n
      @sha133n 8 лет назад +40

      Nick kaushal
      Suhaldev was a Pasi (note the absence of 'R') king. Pasis are a dalit community who today often take the surname "Paswan". As far as I am aware there were no Parsi (with 'R') kings in India.

    • @bmniac
      @bmniac 7 лет назад +1

      confused

    • @renukanair831
      @renukanair831 5 лет назад +1

      Ratan Tata is a Parsi

    • @yogeshroy9913
      @yogeshroy9913 4 года назад +15

      There wasn't anything called Dalit in our culture. It was invented by Nehruvian Leftists. The SC status is granted by government, not by society. For example, Rajbanshi people, who ruled Coochbehar from 13th century to 1947 has become SC!!!

  • @petermoore5750
    @petermoore5750 7 лет назад +154

    India needs its true history researched by Indians. Not what the British conquerors have written. Remember conquerors write history to make them look good and to serve their agenda. Indians mind need to be decolonized. People need to think not to swallow what foreigners say. Indians need to think for themselves and get out of the invaders mental control. Think positive about yourself and not the negative things foreigners say about Indians and be proud of yourself and your past.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад +1

      Peter Moore ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @SUD1438
      @SUD1438 3 года назад +2

      The story of "Divyavadanam" are real or fictional, let’s see
      Divyavadanam is a Sanskrit text containing divine stories. It is believed to have been written in the 2nd century. But if you look at the stories and places It seems to have been written in the 7th century or later.
      What are these stories? Of these, 38 stories are very mythical similar to be in line with the ideology of “Mul Sarvastivism an sub cult.
      It has an 11th story called "Ashokavadan". There is evidence that it was written from the 5th century to the 16th century. The story describes Emperor Ashoka's cruelity, his relationship with the Buddha Dhamma, and how he brutally murdered the Niganthas to promote Buddhism. Basically there is no historical fact in this. It describes the assassination of Ajivika by Emperor Ashoka. If Emperor Ashoka had killed Ajivik, would he have donated the first caves in India to Ajivik Sangh? Another example of these stories being fictional is that the Pushymitra Shunga (killer of the brahmadatta) is shown to be of maurya descent.
      These stories will be suitable for fiction literature but not facts or that they will useful to know the right names for the places otherwise there are no proofs. In ancient time to deify any personality such stories were added in literature and this similar to that type.
      A video of Sanjeev Sanyal has been aired on this, in which questions have been raised about the existence and deeds of Emperor Ashoka. Basically, Sanyal works as a principal economic advisor in the Prime Minister's Office. We should all realize that this is an attempt to "brainstorm". The current political rulers are not in favor of Ashoka's actions, but their ideology has shown many times that they are angry with Emperor Ashoka. Sanyal's current attempt seems to be to show history from a different point of view - through myths. In this, Sanyal only comments on the thoughts of the present ruling party as expected! But beware of such self-proclaimed historians and be ready to answer them as they are ...
      Divyavadanam is a myth and therefore we have to decide how much importance we should give to these stories. There are stories of these unhistorical events and they should be seen only as a fictional literary work but at the same time we should emphasize to the world the deeds of Emperor Ashoka ...

    • @vanshstalin1402
      @vanshstalin1402 2 года назад +1

      Our history is written by anti Hindu marxist historians

    • @PragyaTGupta
      @PragyaTGupta 2 года назад

      @@vanshstalin1402 and ur surname is Stalin .. ironical 🤔

    • @gottlobfreige1075
      @gottlobfreige1075 2 года назад

      nah, that's not true...

  • @AvinashSingh047
    @AvinashSingh047 6 лет назад +762

    The history "student" sounds more like a lawyer of islamic invaders.

    • @prayank22
      @prayank22 4 года назад +80

      Bastards glorifying plunders looters rapists and mass murders as neo Renaissance rulers........who nvr invented anything in there 1000 year history........

    • @rudramath5949
      @rudramath5949 3 года назад +25

      She seems like Maulani...

    • @abhaypundir4363
      @abhaypundir4363 3 года назад +12

      True this

    • @shrustidesai6557
      @shrustidesai6557 3 года назад +24

      Why it is taking so long to rewrite right history???

    • @rudramath5949
      @rudramath5949 3 года назад +21

      @@shrustidesai6557 Still the Left People are playing in the Right field with strict rules of left leaving less space for Right people.Lets hope Right people take more responsibility and higher levels of commitment to write the Correct History.

  • @SanjayPednekar
    @SanjayPednekar 7 лет назад +53

    this was an eye opener

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      Sanjay Pednekar ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

  • @rajibkumarsanyal7783
    @rajibkumarsanyal7783 2 года назад +9

    Sanjeev Sanyal is not only an eminent economist but also he has a rare quality of digging into the deep rooted truth of the original history of South-East Asia! Just an amazing experience in listening him!

  • @kpsudhakar
    @kpsudhakar 8 лет назад +33

    Great talk by Sanjeev Sanyal. Appreciated!!!

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      KP Sudhakar ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

  • @cholepuri
    @cholepuri 2 года назад +25

    I started questioning Indian historians when I read Greek history, especially pertaining to Alexander's invasion of India. We were taught in Indian history textbooks that he won against Porus(real name Pururaj) and then proceeded to forgive him his life. But when I read the Greek history, it clearly says that he was defeated really badly by Pururaj at the bank of river Indus and if anything, there was a stalemate and subsequently his armies retreated due to fear of other armies joining Pururaj in the battle.

    • @akkkkk813
      @akkkkk813 7 месяцев назад +1

      Can you please tell me bro in which Greek book you have read this part of history I am really interested

  • @goddog7870
    @goddog7870 6 лет назад +75

    He is a guy who has no any pro beliefs ..Just puts facts..Yes we need such type of historians

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      God Dog ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

  • @shantanuc31
    @shantanuc31 4 года назад +185

    There should be debate between, (Sanjeev Sanyal and Rajiv Malhotra) vs (Romila Thappar and Irfan Habib). Btw Rajiv Sir has challenged Romila Thappar and asked for a debate many times, she refused it.

    • @SUD1438
      @SUD1438 3 года назад +4

      The story of "Divyavadanam" are real or fictional, let’s see
      Divyavadanam is a Sanskrit text containing divine stories. It is believed to have been written in the 2nd century. But if you look at the stories and places It seems to have been written in the 7th century or later.
      What are these stories? Of these, 38 stories are very mythical similar to be in line with the ideology of “Mul Sarvastivism an sub cult.
      It has an 11th story called "Ashokavadan". There is evidence that it was written from the 5th century to the 16th century. The story describes Emperor Ashoka's cruelity, his relationship with the Buddha Dhamma, and how he brutally murdered the Niganthas to promote Buddhism. Basically there is no historical fact in this. It describes the assassination of Ajivika by Emperor Ashoka. If Emperor Ashoka had killed Ajivik, would he have donated the first caves in India to Ajivik Sangh? Another example of these stories being fictional is that the Pushymitra Shunga (killer of the brahmadatta) is shown to be of maurya descent.
      These stories will be suitable for fiction literature but not facts or that they will useful to know the right names for the places otherwise there are no proofs. In ancient time to deify any personality such stories were added in literature and this similar to that type.
      A video of Sanjeev Sanyal has been aired on this, in which questions have been raised about the existence and deeds of Emperor Ashoka. Basically, Sanyal works as a principal economic advisor in the Prime Minister's Office. We should all realize that this is an attempt to "brainstorm". The current political rulers are not in favor of Ashoka's actions, but their ideology has shown many times that they are angry with Emperor Ashoka. Sanyal's current attempt seems to be to show history from a different point of view - through myths. In this, Sanyal only comments on the thoughts of the present ruling party as expected! But beware of such self-proclaimed historians and be ready to answer them as they are ...
      Divyavadanam is a myth and therefore we have to decide how much importance we should give to these stories. There are stories of these unhistorical events and they should be seen only as a fictional literary work but at the same time we should emphasize to the world the deeds of Emperor Ashoka ...

    • @yash-lu7qp
      @yash-lu7qp 2 года назад +13

      Sanjeev Sanyal and Rajiv Malhotra are not academics. One is an excellent economist but a terrible historian and the second one is a source of a lot of conspiracy theories.
      Romila Thapar and Irfan Habib are trained historians. I don't have a problem with right wing historians. Jadunath Sarkar and Arun Shourie have done some great work but these people like Sanyal and Malhotra are just conspiracy theorists. Add Swamy too.

    • @SR-mv2mf
      @SR-mv2mf 2 года назад +4

      The fact she refused itself proves her level of knowledge

    • @jajatinayak1971
      @jajatinayak1971 2 года назад +4

      Also add Vikram Sampat along with Rajiv Malhotra. He is a fantastic historian.

    • @jajatinayak1971
      @jajatinayak1971 2 года назад +11

      @@yash-lu7qp Arun Shourie?? You can talk about Vikram Sampat. It's not necessary to be trained historian. Rather it should be based on references and facts. Does Romila Thaper give good references?

  • @shaikh2020
    @shaikh2020 8 лет назад +156

    100% I agree with the Sajeev, that we should right our own history. Either we are bad or good, the fact should be documented as our history. And the text books must be replaced with real one.

    • @bitthalsarangi5471
      @bitthalsarangi5471 7 лет назад +5

      I am ashamed for Rudra Verma's comment. We are not Hindus till we respect Islam.

    • @bitthalsarangi5471
      @bitthalsarangi5471 7 лет назад +2

      Bhai, kabhi to dimag lagaao, Allah kaise bolenge? Mohammed ko to Jabril ne aake bataya tha to Quran likha gaya Mohammed ke chelon ne! Shabd Allah ke ho sakte hain, lekin likhawat to Aadmi ki hai.

    • @thedescanteer
      @thedescanteer 7 лет назад +7

      +B Nilotpala S Haan, bilkul sahi. Par agar likhawat aadmi ki hai to fir the so-called "religion" of peace bhagwan ka kahan se hua?? Zara khud bhi to dimaag lagaiye! Abrahamism was an idea that was used to invent political tools of subservience for empire-building, right from its very inception. Islam is nothing but its 2.0 version - the final one. It was fabricated to do what version 1.0 (Christianity) was no longer tenable to do, mainly because it would have screwed up the home turf (largely Mediterranean Europe) and the power structure it had built (the Church system/the Vatican) if it carried on with the way Constantine used it. They needed to preserve & aestheticize 1.0, and 'outsource' the dirty evil work to the deserts of the Bedouin, from where it could be spread like cancer far & wide by hook or by crook (usually crook & bloodshed). You should simply read the history of Islam along with its main texts, not only of the period when Mahomet was alive, but the days, years, decades right after his death, and the centuries of horror that followed. This history is not too old and very well documented & corroborated. Once you know it, you'll lose your fake reverence towards it or its parent ideology as some of benevolent spiritual/religious/cultural legacy that we must "respect". Its like someone telling me that I must have respect for Nazism to become a true "Hindu" (obviously without having the first clue what this very term signifies either).

    • @bitthalsarangi5471
      @bitthalsarangi5471 7 лет назад +3

      Sayantan Bhowmik Nicely written brother. This was also true for Hitler, when he wrote Mein Kampf. Whatever you have written, I have already read it and know the consequence of it. Following Islam itself is disastrous for the Idea of Diversity. All the Islamic Lies apart, Muslims who defy Islamic rules and adhere Humanity, they shouldn't get stamped out in this process. That's the concern. Otherwise future generations will ascribe Hinduism as mere Nazism, which grew out of hatred towards a religion called Islam, and it owe it's existence till the destruction of such religions.

    • @thedescanteer
      @thedescanteer 7 лет назад +10

      B Nilotpala S Do you even hear yourself boss? Your line of argument is going haywire. Your logic is absolutely topsy-turvy. The things you're saying are completely disingenuous, especially since you claim to understand the "lies" & history of Islam. You started by explicitly saying on this thread that "We are not Hindus till we respect Islam". Now you're shifting the goal-post to "concern for Muslims". If you already know & agree that most muslims are victims of an evil expansionist political ideology called Islam, then why the heck are you conflating the two? You're so well-versed in the subject, yet you talk as if you don't know that "Muslims who defy Islamic rules" are no longer muslims, but apostates to be executed under the sharia. Don't you know the status of Ahmediyas in Islam? How many people do you know who openly "defy Islamic rules" and are still practicing/proud muslims? I'll not count "activists" who live in non-Islamic pseudo-secular or 'first-world' nations, and have vested political backing. These handful of individuals are either useful idiots who eventually pay the price, or they're Islamo-fascist moles backed by NATO/Saudi to lead the taqiyya, tawriya, kitman & muruna in these non-muslim majority societies. Your statement that "future generations will ascribe Hinduism as mere Nazism" is an illogical strawman argument - I don't need to be "Hindu" or an Indian or a Japanese or a Zulu or a Maori to cognize the aforementioned reality of Islam; its got nothing to do with how the "existence" of "Hinduism" or any other kuffar, heathen, pagan cultures/religions will be perceived in future. Rather, the survival of all such diversity is under ever-expanding threat. And how can you still go on proclaiming Islam as a "religion", even after studying & understanding it so well from the outside? Its obvious you want to somehow hold onto the bigoted position you've taken by 'hook or by crook'. Its called cognitive dissonance boss. Get rid of it.

  • @darksoftpetals
    @darksoftpetals 7 лет назад +42

    I grew up with stories of Marthanda Varma :) It was THE story for nights with no electricity (this was in Chennai in the 90s) - I must have heard it a few dozen times but still it was the only story my bro and I clamoured for while swatting mosquitoes and sitting expectantly on the floor in front of our Dad's easy-chair :) #Nostalgia

  • @8arierep
    @8arierep 6 лет назад +23

    Very interesting we need to know more of our History true facts should be known.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      Anthony Pereira ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

  • @viveknsharma
    @viveknsharma 6 лет назад +29

    One of the most eclectic, awakening, and landmark lectures on Bhartiya Itihas...

  • @adityarukmangad
    @adityarukmangad 8 лет назад +133

    Great talk. Syrian Christians coming to india in 2nd century BC was a slip. He might have wanted to say AD.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      adityarukmangad ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @Drzakkubaby-naik
      @Drzakkubaby-naik 3 года назад

      There is no proof in it.

    • @Drzakkubaby-naik
      @Drzakkubaby-naik 3 года назад +2

      They told 1st century AD first. Now it's become 2bc century bc? Either ways it can't be true. Thats a period of rich Sangam age. None of those Sangam sources mentions of St Thomas visitation to south. If st Thomas visited south India during that time means then Christianity might have grew up atleast to some extent by 8th century AD. Adi sankara came in 8th century ( according to secularist historians who change his appearance date from time to do fit their narratives). So adi sankara recorded his arguments with existing indian culture of that time Hinduism Jain Bhuddhas. Why no arguments against Sikhs and Christianity even in 8th century AD? Atleast why no mentioning of St Thomas in any of those Sangam literature of the said period?

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад +1

      @@Drzakkubaby-naik
      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏
      Satvic movement RUclips channel bhi subscribe kar lena ok 👍🙏

  • @viditdamele7906
    @viditdamele7906 3 года назад +14

    It's 2021 now and i have started the year by reading Legend of Suheldev by Amish Tripathi.

  • @Seevawonderloaf
    @Seevawonderloaf 2 года назад +3

    "As long as the lions do not have their story tellers, history will always glorify the hunters". That sums it all up. Excellent talk. Just by learning indian history, we could all get United

  • @theindianamerican1772
    @theindianamerican1772 8 лет назад +196

    Our history was written by foreigners and showed there victories and only Hindu Indian losses and denigrated Hindu and Indian culture

    • @mridulagrawal6687
      @mridulagrawal6687 6 лет назад +2

      The Indian American plzzzzzzzzzzzz yr don't call it Hindu,call it indian victories,India had Jews,Syrian Christian,and Muslims,baba banda Singh bahadur and gobind Singh ji,it's indian victories not hindu

    • @mridulagrawal6687
      @mridulagrawal6687 6 лет назад +2

      Rig Veda also says ekam satva,viprah vedanti,which means truth is one wise humans speak it differently,this is pluralism or secularism ...

    • @soumendraphukan2679
      @soumendraphukan2679 6 лет назад +5

      Mridul Agrawal well today's secularism is not comparable with the ancient times'

    • @kumar.samvad
      @kumar.samvad 5 лет назад +1

      @@mridulagrawal6687
      Ye upnisad ka vaise jo bata diya rigved ka

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      The Indian American ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

  • @siddharth__pandey
    @siddharth__pandey 6 лет назад +76

    At 55:00 aunty thinks she knows more about Babur than his own grandson

  • @sanjayvaidya4925
    @sanjayvaidya4925 7 лет назад +26

    Brilliant. More please

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      Sanjay Vaidya ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

  • @shwetapannu3339
    @shwetapannu3339 4 года назад +11

    Sanjeev, I have been a great fan of your relentless work in bringing out the truth, where we have been brainwashed into believing lies for so many years. Your work is inspirational, pathbreaking and so important

  • @anilrao2485
    @anilrao2485 8 лет назад +53

    Reminds me of what S.N. Balagangadhara has been saying for 20 years already :)

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      Anil Rao ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

  • @vishwasjoshi2471
    @vishwasjoshi2471 6 лет назад +16

    Very good talk/presentation. Brings me back to ancient India! For example, Manusmriti is put forth of as "the main and the only reason" for "castism " is actually a commentary by Kulluka Bhatta on the commentary by Govindaraja on Manav Dharma Shashtra despite the fact that more than 50 manuscripts of "Manusmriti" from different timelines have been found. So debates like this should be conducted the way they were conducted in ancient India.

  • @tykemonster6416
    @tykemonster6416 7 лет назад +149

    Hmmm..evrything in history that has been written in India is just to defame hinduism. Like the Ahom example,no mention in history textbooks because hindus were the victors here. Similarly, the Ashoka example, books mention he was a hindu and killed people and then converted to buddhisim and then attained peace. This kind of shows hindusim in bad light and buddhism in good light.

    • @LalitKumar-cu5iu
      @LalitKumar-cu5iu 6 лет назад +1

      Tyke Monster
      You idiot, the term Hindu is a geographical tag first mentioned in persian inscriptions.
      Everybody was not equally evolved so some people followed the yogic way and others didn't.

    • @chilarai1
      @chilarai1 5 лет назад +10

      @Raj Narayanan That is true. Additionally to Tyke Monster's point, Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism are as "Hindu" as Vaishnavism, Advaitism, Shaktism, Shaivism etc as all have at their core the concepts of karma, reincarnation, dharma, atma, moksha through the practice of yoga. No other religions share these concepts. They have been splintered by outsiders out of fear because it stretches from Punjab to Japan and from Mongolia to Sri Lanka. It is bigger than Islam almost as big as Christianity and far more profound and alive than either. But these same outsider have no problem in declaring Islam to include shia, sunni, sufi, ahmediya etc and Christianity includes protestant, catholic, Lutheran, Calvinist, Baptist, Adventist ext. All humbug.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      Tyke Monster ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @VJ-cj2uk
      @VJ-cj2uk 3 года назад

      What textbook where you studying from . I studied about the Ahom kings

    • @ssuke2534
      @ssuke2534 3 года назад

      As if Buddhism is a bad religion.

  • @SambitRath007
    @SambitRath007 2 года назад +2

    Great and fantastic talk about Mr Sanyal on the true picture of Indian History the Truth has to come out 👏👏

  • @ramyadav8475
    @ramyadav8475 7 лет назад +121

    Gandhi and Nehru called Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj a small time robber. If this is the understanding of our great leaders about a King who fought with Mughals and established his empire named as "Hindvi Swarajya" (Self rule). Later Maratha empire spread up to Attock of Afghanistan to Cuttock (Orrisa) to Thanjavur (TN). Shivaji's Swarajya was not only in name but in practice. Ideal administration. He never lived in large aristocratic palaces or wore gold & jewels. Did not keep any Janankhana.

    • @imdeep5839
      @imdeep5839 6 лет назад +1

      Ram Yadav afghanistan ??? no it wasn't that big

    • @rameezraja6771
      @rameezraja6771 6 лет назад +2

      Ram yadav---- Sivaji was a rebel against the Sultan of Bijapur. The Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb encouraged Sivajis rebellion , as he wanted to create civil war in Bijapur and make it easier for him to conquer it. Sivaji was a willing ally of the Mughals. He even attended the Mughal Durbar of Aurangzeb as his loyal Mansabdar and was given Mughal honours. But he wanted more importance. His ego was responsible for his rebellion against the Mughals not his religion. Sivaji looked every inch the loyal Mughal mansabdar with his muslim style beard, his Mughal court costume etc etc .His later political philosophy of Hindu Pad-Padshahi was also based on Mughal style geo-politics.

    • @rameezraja6771
      @rameezraja6771 6 лет назад +1

      Shubham ------Silly girl! I am a Hindu a Brahmin and an Indian. Are you a Wahabi Muslim?

    • @siddharthsiddharth7106
      @siddharthsiddharth7106 6 лет назад +2

      rameez raja They were all foreigners , invaders . At some stage ppl of subcontinent need to stop living like foreigners in their land .

    • @vaijuaphale8048
      @vaijuaphale8048 5 лет назад +2

      @@imdeep5839 actually its true...raghunathrao placed the maratha flag in attock now in afghanistan

  • @smitaadani5071
    @smitaadani5071 2 года назад +5

    Informative and fascinating talk! 👌🏼

  • @guptapawan6822
    @guptapawan6822 6 лет назад +114

    Suhail dev Pasi was great Indian. But he is totally neglected by Congress.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад +1

      Gupta Pawan ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад +1

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @Drzakkubaby-naik
      @Drzakkubaby-naik 3 года назад

      *gangress☝️😳

  • @debabratabanerjee7461
    @debabratabanerjee7461 2 года назад +15

    Nehru had asked Mr Ramesh Chandra Majumdar to write the history of India after independence. Mr Majundar insisted on the condition of no interference. Nehru withdrew his request.

    • @sarvomar1
      @sarvomar1 4 месяца назад

      Then why do so many schools in India have A history of India by Majumdar on their syllabuses. I myself have had it. How can this be possible if he never wrote it!!!!

    • @shivamchaubey516
      @shivamchaubey516 11 дней назад

      ​@@sarvomar1he was talking about official history of India. After RC majumdaar refused, the above task was given to tara chand.
      Rc majumdaar's history books are some of the best books on history, how can any sensible syllabus maker leave legends like jadunath sarkar, rc majumdar

  • @jaihindjaibharat7376
    @jaihindjaibharat7376 4 года назад +88

    We marathi people's have defeated Aurngjeb and his mughal empire. We fought that war for more than 25 years with out our king of that time.

    • @dimplesingh4299
      @dimplesingh4299 4 года назад

      Until 1802 maratha is soo good
      Even maratha empire when became confederation it is still good but when maratha forget it's goal then their is bad things happen

    • @akshaysinha1993
      @akshaysinha1993 4 года назад +6

      Ab maratha chauhan side me rakho. Agle 50 saal pehle bharatiya rastrawadi ban ke raho.

    • @dimplesingh4299
      @dimplesingh4299 4 года назад +10

      @@akshaysinha1993Chatrapati Sivaji maharaj is the reason hindutva survive the brutality of muslims rulers of Aurenzeb era.....
      Chauhan and maratha side mea hai bro only sanatana Dharma is main focus in present era.....

    • @varunkharayat4251
      @varunkharayat4251 4 года назад +5

      @@dimplesingh4299 not only him there were sikhs and assam.people also that were able to defend sanatan dharm

    • @dimplesingh4299
      @dimplesingh4299 4 года назад

      @@varunkharayat4251 rt. Bro.....

  • @Saratchandran27
    @Saratchandran27 3 года назад +41

    The battle has not stopped! The methods of invasion have changed. Disinformation, power of money, committed converters, poor resistance by the long oppressed natives with poor self esteem and the non- nationalist Governments in office since 'independence' are the new challenges! The battle for our civilisation and culture is truly on, all of us must conscript ourselves into that ongoing battle to preserve ourself! Can't take the eye of the ball !

  • @prof.anadipande9552
    @prof.anadipande9552 2 года назад +4

    Very eloquent and educative. Thankyou Sanjeev!

  • @icsandesh
    @icsandesh 2 года назад +3

    It is also possible that Ashoka's knowledge of Buddhism was rudimentary and that it was only after Kalinga, and a spiritual journey through which he sought peace and self-forgiveness, that he chose Buddhism from among the other options available. Whether the one or the other, Ashoka would embrace Buddha's teachings in so far as he could as a monarch and establish Buddhism as a prominent religious school of thought.

  • @jaynitpethani2266
    @jaynitpethani2266 3 года назад +5

    In Britain, they don't teach about Colonialism....

  • @suen3634
    @suen3634 5 лет назад +19

    As a student of history I deeply appreciate your nuanced balanced take on indian history. Thank you. True history evolves and thrives on different schools of interpretations. While it's difficult to be objective in history an ethical historian should consider all evidence and not pick and choose only the ones that suit their narrative. And above all be open to new evidence, scrutise them by all means but be academically honest and allow that original hypotheses may change.

  • @sridharrao7691
    @sridharrao7691 3 года назад +3

    Informative and thought provoking

  • @tesla5297
    @tesla5297 3 года назад +2

    India needs more sons like Mr. Sanjeev Sanyal .

  • @sandeepranjanv702
    @sandeepranjanv702 2 года назад +2

    Great eye-opener sir, thanks🙏

  • @prashantkumarpathak9360
    @prashantkumarpathak9360 2 года назад +7

    9:40 sir has mentioned about Suheldev in Ayodhya Faizabad and Bahraich region King. Yes we were not told about him in our schools. We were told about the Dargah Sharif mela of baharaich but not about Suheldev who destroyed turks

  • @ninasalian6199
    @ninasalian6199 4 года назад +26

    Yes yes yes !!! Even as a kid who knew nothing, I intuitively knew it was all garbage and mishmash

    • @himdude9637
      @himdude9637 3 года назад +3

      Same here
      I never believed

    • @SR-mv2mf
      @SR-mv2mf 2 года назад +2

      Ya same here. I got irritated reading so much about the greatness of Akbar which was basically 70% of my NCERT history text, I was hungry for a more diverse history

    • @kanikakanika8377
      @kanikakanika8377 Год назад

      True true true my grandfather never agreed to this garbage taught in textbooks now he's no more but never agreed to this bullshit

    • @pradaxina
      @pradaxina 4 месяца назад

      so true. My dad always used to tell me that maharana Pratap was great, not Akbar.

  • @rajnidwivedi5230
    @rajnidwivedi5230 3 года назад +1

    Good 👍effort..God bless you

  • @djjee-one352
    @djjee-one352 4 года назад +1

    Superb topic.so much information and learning

  • @sharmishtharanawat7190
    @sharmishtharanawat7190 3 года назад +5

    Sanjeev is such an impressive chap and he speaks so well. Erudite.

  • @RK-ln5kx
    @RK-ln5kx 5 лет назад +11

    I recently learnt that the army of king zamorin of calicut defeated the Portuguese 3 times before succumbing to them. Our history textbooks in schools never mentioned the victories of zamorin against the Portuguese.

  • @humanculturesareautonomous3020
    @humanculturesareautonomous3020 7 лет назад +2

    A very enlightening and in several ways heartening talk and responses to questions by Sanjeev Sanyal. Many thanks Sanjeev. I'll be looking for more of such talks by Sanjeev on RUclips and elsewhere.

  • @narayant1866
    @narayant1866 4 года назад +1

    Amazing presentation.... I am very proud of you and the facts you had put it very convincingly.

  • @9fine
    @9fine 4 года назад +49

    I am surprised everyone here goes only to the extant of changing the history on state, CBSE and ICSE boards. What about state and central government competitive exams?
    What about UPSC? The administrators that we train and appoint are educated in the same history?

    • @anantambisht4895
      @anantambisht4895 3 года назад

      This is attack on titans personigied

    • @IdkIdk-dd9go
      @IdkIdk-dd9go 3 года назад

      UPSC is extremely influenced by foundations like Zakat foundation, which is an Islamic foundation and glorifies Mughals and Aurangzeb

    • @SiniSimon
      @SiniSimon 2 года назад

      I think everyone forgot 8th standard history, in my time all premughal history is covered in 8th class, all the regional kingdoms like Martha's, empires like gupta , Maura etc.... myghals are only in 9th. Then 10 th there is bit of everything and repetition of some 8th and 9th stuff.
      Aryan theory is absolute trash, not taught in school but lot of North Indians used to think they are Aryan and therefore superior to Dravidian South Indians. The were very obnoxious about it in school.

    • @RAIRADIO
      @RAIRADIO 2 года назад +1

      @prajnana How do they know... do they get some kind of message from God?

    • @yinyang.333
      @yinyang.333 2 года назад

      @@SiniSimon If you just scratch your head you would know any normal being likes to portray their superiority if it's possible. If someone citing a lie thus showing is superiority is just a human nature so spare anyone who does that. If you wanna blame then blame government who support such lies to create the divide between South and North which they seem to have succeeded sèeing your pretty strong anti North views

  • @aschwinnie
    @aschwinnie 5 лет назад +10

    Dear Sanjeev, I realy enjoined your short explanation , and as you said, many of us know the Facts of Indian History, that includes me, w/o even reading History books after 10 class, it was explained by my Parents.

  • @rama815
    @rama815 2 года назад +2

    One of the best talk i ever heard !! And great audience btw !!

  • @SuperAdobeFlash
    @SuperAdobeFlash 7 лет назад +1

    Very informative . Thank you Sanjeev

  • @kulkarninitish97
    @kulkarninitish97 3 года назад +4

    Highly enlightening talk by Sanjeev ji

  • @shekarman
    @shekarman 4 года назад +13

    Another thing I read recently is that Indians defeated Alexander and he was wounded by an army formed by city states in Sind. We only read about Alexander defeating Porus but not about the Indian city states wounding Alexander and making him turn back (and incidentally the wound is what killed him).

    • @Yashcky_
      @Yashcky_ 2 года назад +1

      Even takshashila didn't have record s of alexander invation ...and even porus was a small king compare to other empires in india that time....
      I think like alexander idol hercules he didn't cross hindukush parvata😂

    • @rocky49able
      @rocky49able 2 года назад

      Don't blindly believe the propaganda of the BJP. Alexander was too sick to continue fighting. He had to face mutiny from his soldiers who wanted to go back home as they were away from home for years and years. Alexander died due to his greed. He didn't know when to stop

    • @thewittiewolf
      @thewittiewolf 2 года назад +1

      @@rocky49able we brought BJP in debate you just won

  • @venkatagovindaraghavan6637
    @venkatagovindaraghavan6637 2 года назад +1

    Brilliant work

  • @vidyawitch
    @vidyawitch 6 лет назад +12

    So in a nutshell, the battle is still not entirely over. Picture abhi baki hai!
    good day n thanks.

  • @ashuuvatikaa
    @ashuuvatikaa 4 года назад +6

    This is called a competent historian....

  • @poornimasrihariprasad1820
    @poornimasrihariprasad1820 2 года назад +4

    This video is awakening and very intriguingly interested. Kudos to you Sir. I agree that it's time that our history is rewritten with academian experts like you. 👍

  • @naturemeets
    @naturemeets 3 года назад +1

    A wonderful presentation Sir.

  • @Karan-wz7pt
    @Karan-wz7pt 2 года назад +2

    Being a student of history , I must say Sanjeev ji was really good and so was that Lady student from DU.

  • @SA-dk5zx
    @SA-dk5zx 3 года назад +19

    Current day uttrakhand (Garhwal & kumaon were never conquered by mugals) despite continuous attacks for so long period.
    in fact garhwal queen Rani karnawati defeated orangzab and returned his army with their noses cut.

  • @anikroars
    @anikroars 5 лет назад +3

    This is an excellent video. I am astonished to know how Mr. Sanjeev funda time for all this given his actual profession is

  • @guharup
    @guharup 3 года назад +1

    Brilliant and timely

  • @VENU-d7t
    @VENU-d7t 3 года назад +1

    Excellent explanations 👍🌹🏵

  • @theseeker3141
    @theseeker3141 8 лет назад +4

    Sanjeev sanyal ji thanks for the lovely enriching talk which bolstered many of my thoughts that were beginning to crystallise about our realistic History . Will now buy your book and please keep doing this job for us as you are independently working so can be fearless and by the way since I come from the southern part of the country I have heard from the elders from our family so many unpalatable things about Tipu sultan which happened in and around our ancestral villages and homes during his times that I wonder how could these guys call him the great.

  • @anuragsinghal1200
    @anuragsinghal1200 3 года назад +3

    It's 2021 and I just found this gem!

  • @rishabhsoni9154
    @rishabhsoni9154 2 года назад

    Great insights 👏🏻👏🏻

  • @TPHBLIB
    @TPHBLIB 8 лет назад +35

    Dear All - Please read BEING DIFFERENT BY RAJIV MALHOTRA to know what facts are. He too seems to be a partial sepoy.

    • @sahajization
      @sahajization 6 лет назад +2

      TPHBLIB wait wiat... Who seems to be a partial sepoy?

    • @maryvong8974
      @maryvong8974 6 лет назад +1

      Cap Ajit Vadakayil too

    • @liliesandtulips2000
      @liliesandtulips2000 3 года назад +2

      Exactly. I mean the way he is "generalising" everything indian by saying "we have been enriched by everyone who came from outside. So everything good that india has is not indigenous". Our knowledge and traditions were always ours. That soft power never came from outside. People from world over used to come here to study math, science and what not. The % of good things that Bharat got from outside is very very less as compared to the % of everything good that Bharat gave to the world. So, diluting of Bharat's greatness is unacceptable!!!

    • @liliesandtulips2000
      @liliesandtulips2000 3 года назад

      @@sahajization sanjeev

  • @ridhirajgor9398
    @ridhirajgor9398 3 года назад +3

    I really liked the suggestion of sources, it will encourage everyone to explore, work hard and have informed opinion

  • @vijaynuthakki3567
    @vijaynuthakki3567 2 года назад +21

    "After all if a nation has existed for thousands of years, you cannot have a father of the nation and a chacha of the nation" 😂😂😂
    I bow infront of you Sir, for this fantastic yet ironical truth 🙏🙏🙏🙇🙇🙇

  • @rajibdhar3148
    @rajibdhar3148 5 месяцев назад +1

    Great lecture.

  • @amulurdhwareshe6795
    @amulurdhwareshe6795 3 года назад +2

    Eye opener!

  • @shreyashukla2223
    @shreyashukla2223 3 года назад +6

    Brilliant talk. This is why I could never connect the dots between inscriptions on sites to my history knowledge/wikipedia. It leaves most Indians confused and we assume that there must be more going on that historians concluded a certain way. But this irresponsibility of most historians is not at all amusing anymore.
    A british friend of mine once asked how does an Indian identify him/herself as an Indian; he meant how does one reconcile the complicated history and identify as an "Indian" alone - only recently have I started to find the answer for myself. It is sad that "truth" is so hard to find; the silver lining though is that it's not impossible. All it needs is an alert seeker.
    If we probed and learnt our true history we would be proud of our contributions as a civilization.

    • @abhinavshukla2202
      @abhinavshukla2202 3 года назад

      Garg or bhardwaj?

    • @thendino1
      @thendino1 2 года назад

      Ask your British friend how do Scots, Irish, the Welsh, etc identify themselves as British when they are clearly NOT

  • @arashid0
    @arashid0 6 лет назад +27

    I concur with Sanjeev Sanyal that history should be written objectively with hard evidance. Fooling around by copy writing from this book & that book without having any proven fact is just like sheep herd. I also beleive that history is like a fish on a fishmongers slab, where it differs is when one start using hard facts then its at much purer source else it has high chance of being stained. Well done & thank you Sanjeev

    • @sahajization
      @sahajization 6 лет назад +9

      Abdul Rashid yayaya... First of all your name itself speak a lot about you and secondly, he isn't the only person who is working on this. There r a lot of ppl who r working on creating a grand Indian narrative ending up with the same facts and evidence. So obviously what he is stating true. If u still don't believe, then just wait for a few years until your future offspring will read the true history of India in the future, which will happen for sure.

  • @vipulagora1325
    @vipulagora1325 3 года назад +2

    Awesome

  • @karthikeyanpillai
    @karthikeyanpillai 5 лет назад +2

    Thank you very much sir for the completely new facts.

  • @rajankumarrk174
    @rajankumarrk174 3 года назад +9

    I always considered my grandfather that he did not know anything.
    I realize my mistake now, he was true😭😭❤️😭🔥🔥🔥

  • @sahajization
    @sahajization 6 лет назад +107

    Basically the confidence of Sanjeev Sanyal and Rajiv Malhotra comes from the fact that the entire history of India factually proves that Hindus are native to India and remained so throughout the timelines. So after you start talking about all the historical events, which is a matter of 1000s of years,a few 100s of years of the Mugals and British periods will barely mean anything in our history. Lol so clever, convenient and TRUE.

    • @abhinavshukla2202
      @abhinavshukla2202 3 года назад +5

      Nenu Telugu nerchukuntunnaanu

    • @Yashcky_
      @Yashcky_ 2 года назад

      Yup

    • @rajeshkandukuri1042
      @rajeshkandukuri1042 2 года назад +1

      @@abhinavshukla2202 Wow..Good for u Brother..May I know the reason? Just curious

    • @jayd4ever
      @jayd4ever 2 года назад +1

      hindus are not race

    • @IceQeen1011
      @IceQeen1011 2 года назад

      @@jayd4ever Race is a social construct anyway with no biological backing (hence a half white-half black person is considered white or black based exclusively on what they look like not their actual biological background). The Mughal invaders called all the indiegenous population of the Indus valley civilization as 'hindu'.

  • @bittertruth2027
    @bittertruth2027 2 года назад +2

    Please dont skip ads for this channel

  • @rajnigandha21
    @rajnigandha21 5 лет назад +1

    Superb session.

  • @madhavauk
    @madhavauk 7 лет назад +58

    One of the Ashoka's stone inscriptions which will change the whole narrative is about Shudras. Ashoka in his inscription says that "He defeated 100000 thoroughly battle trained Kshatriays because he is not allowed to kill them he branded them as Shudras and subjected them to enslavement in his Sitamadis (kings farm fields)" - where does this leave us? It means that Sudras were Kshatriyas who were defeated in battles, the entire untouchability and everything related to the caste system is nothing but punishments carried out in brutal manner by Kshatriays against kshatriyas...

    • @sadenb
      @sadenb 7 лет назад +1

      The kaktiyas were a shudra dynasty .. What is wrong with you .

    • @madhavauk
      @madhavauk 7 лет назад

      sanch Sanchayan Go and search the dates. I don't know what you meant by Kakatiyas were a Sudra dynasty.

    • @sadenb
      @sadenb 7 лет назад +6

      Kakatiya dynasty in South India was a shudra dynasty .. The Nanda Empire was a shudra dynasty . Throughout history many shudra dynasties gained power.

    • @bmniac
      @bmniac 7 лет назад +3

      You are right. The majority of the ruling dynasties in India were drawn from Shudras.

    • @DipakBose-bq1vv
      @DipakBose-bq1vv 7 лет назад +3

      This can be true. I am a kayasta, a sudra. But we are called in our part of West Bengal as Ugra Kahatriya.

  • @tiffles3890
    @tiffles3890 7 лет назад +46

    Fantastic talk!!!
    I just cannot believe that I have been so ignorant of our own history. Hats off!!
    And a million plagues upon the children of those bastards who have deliberately persevered to keep us all in the dark.

    • @Sunny-rh6ik
      @Sunny-rh6ik 4 года назад

      Gaurab Chatterjee ruclips.net/video/yHFHxdwpneQ/видео.html

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @bharathivayuvegula1173
    @bharathivayuvegula1173 2 года назад

    Very informative. Agree with the speaker . 👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @srividyaputchha8220
    @srividyaputchha8220 3 года назад +2

    We have to educate youth to love India
    Your lecture is quite interesting

  • @raghu4utube
    @raghu4utube 4 года назад +37

    Only north Indian historians are obsessed with Moghul history. South Indian States strongly teach their respective history.
    Hoysala were the only Hindu Kingdom left in 14th Century. The great Vijayanagara empire rose from the ashes of Hoysala empire.
    There is no race called Aryan or Dravidian. The powerful Karnata empire which ruled South and Central India have the Royal lineages like Sena Dynasty of Bengali, Solankis of Gujarat, Rathore of Rajastan. It is sufficient to tell that we have one origin.

    • @YogirajMD
      @YogirajMD 3 года назад +4

      Nepal. Also

    • @himanshuraj88
      @himanshuraj88 3 года назад

      ye Ujjawal patni Ji ne video banaya tha Sri Rajiv Dixit Ji ke bare me 👇👇
      ruclips.net/video/R9DKJSCFHjM/видео.html
      Ek aur motivational speaker hai Dr. Vivek Bindra Ji unse bahut logo ne request ki h aur karte aa rahe hai per wo abhi tak video nahi banaye hai
      Pata nahi kab banayenge 😩
      Aapse request 🙏 h ki aap jada se jada logo tak ye baat pahunchaye aur bole ki unke channel pe comment kare 👍 jaise maine abhi apko bataya hai
      Accha, ab ek aur baat aap ye channel ko follow kar lo
      1. Fit tuber Hindi👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCDWVNwQce16D16tPc5NBYlQ
      ye aaj Ayurveda ke bare me jada se jada log ko bata rahe Hain bilkul Rajiv Dixit Ji ki tarah
      2. Karolina Goswami Ji - 👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCpelPgePHrkrFYGgtFD8xsQ
      unhe bhi follow karna - ye foreign women hai jo Bharat ke bare me acchi baat logo ko batati hain
      3. Manas Samarth 👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCI6TxUr372D1erctk4h31mw
      and Dr. Vishwaroop Roy Choudhary Ji 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
      m.ruclips.net/channel/UCduHgArmYWcM8GgNFVYTkPQ
      ye to aaj ke jamane me keh sakte ho ki ye 2nd Rajiv Dixit Ji hai abhi Coronavirus ke Ayurveda se ilaaj kar rahe hai aur ek team tayar ki h NICE
      ye naam hai team ka
      Maine sabhi channel ka link unke naam ke sath hi de diya hai kripya 🙏🙏 in channel ke bare me sab ko bataye aur follow karne ko kahe
      Agar aap koi aur aise hi acche channel ko jante h to aap bhi mujhe bataye. Dhanyawad 🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @shrishmishra5066
      @shrishmishra5066 3 года назад

      @@YogirajMD Nepal is indifferent from today's Bharat and always included,but historians never talks about Nepal .

    • @thendino1
      @thendino1 2 года назад

      Agreed bro.....we dont give a f-k about the Mughals...

    • @kanikakanika8377
      @kanikakanika8377 Год назад

      North Nehru-Gandhi family bootlickers distorians to be specific also distorians from Delhi area lutyens delhi 😤😤😤😤

  • @suniljoshi5935
    @suniljoshi5935 3 года назад +3

    Simply superb....I am.buyjng his book...for the first time....what a shame that I have been missing out on this and I am sure still many people are....but I am glad we r talking about our civilization now ...the only civilization which is exsisting from pre bronze age ...

  • @bittertruth2027
    @bittertruth2027 2 года назад

    Great Topic !

  • @seemasunil9
    @seemasunil9 6 лет назад

    Excellent talk...

  • @SambitRath007
    @SambitRath007 2 года назад +6

    Very interesting perspective about Ashoka and how we have been brainwashed to believe the falsehood which has been doled out to us

  • @Stanfromaroundtan
    @Stanfromaroundtan 6 лет назад +7

    What a coincidence! I just got this book, Ashoka: The Search for India's Lost Emperor, and was wondering why it has so little information on the Emperor himself.

  • @rishu2252
    @rishu2252 3 года назад +1

    Thanks sir.

  • @AshwinMaloo79
    @AshwinMaloo79 9 месяцев назад +1

    Dhanyavad Sir Ji 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏