The inaccuracies said by the guide are very unfortunate. Such an important piece of history deserves a more unbiased and grounded view . I'm not sure if the guide was official or not but this makes me sad that I cannot take everything said at face value. Still very fascinating and thank you Karl for showing me
Yah this guy seems to explain things but fails to put it in any context. The sewers may be a good example. Yes it is sewers, but the context would have been, it was very advanced and impressive for that time and civilization, innovation etc.
Man, the name "Harappa" alone brings back such a distant memories. Not because I've been at the location but because Harappa and Mohenjo Daro (Mohenjo Daro - Harappa civilization) was such a unique name when we learn about them back in... middle school if I'm not mistaken. So unique the impression last until now as that was tens of years ago 😅 Thank you for showing us what it actually looks like And man I was suprised for real as I'm writing this part when I hear the man raised their voice. I thought you got into some problem fr which turn out to be the bike issue lol So much drama 😂
Very sad to see a priceless heritage of humanity is not managed or maintained well (like villagers / kids freely accessing the site). The guide, although a nice person is so funny - combining all local myths (the bad king of the region and the curse which turned the city to ruins!) and telling a story that is far from history. Thanks Karl for showing this place. As an Indian, although my heart wishes to visit these places, but the politics of the region would make it very difficult to get visas to visit these places. To all Pakistani brothers / sisters, please do protect this priceless gift of ancient ruins. Generations in the future will be thankful to you. Love from India.
What’s wrong with them accessing the site. These are already ruins they won’t ruin it more. We trust our people unlike Indians breaking mosques to build temples and planning on converting taj mahhal to a Hindu temple
Mohenjo daro and Harappan civilization also known as lost cities had no evidences of kings or queens it was likely governed as a city-state, perhaps by elected officials or elites from each of the mounds. The primary deity which was worshipped is Pashupatinath Or Lord Shiva. In the year 1940 archaeologist M. S Vats discovered 3 Shiva lingas dating more than 5000+ yrs. Just to get the bigger picture Harappan civilization was spread across the Northeast of present day Afghanistan, Pakistan and North West India. This is the glimpse of history which is taught in our textbooks from 6th standard onwards. P. S I love u Karl keep rockinn 🎸🎶🎶
Go and read ling puja devi puja tree worship etc is part of harapa, you converted are so confused, proud of your ancestors you bloody arabic cult😂@@thayab
Harappa looks so cool! Loved how you brought the history to life, especially with the whole GoPro dying moment-kinda spooky. Pakistan has such amazing places like this, and it’s awesome to see you exploring them. Can’t wait for the next adventure!
such a useless guide, not even a proper guide. However, you must watch his video about Ganish village. The guide was brilliant there so we can't just generalise an entire country with just one person
Can people (including the guide) stop spreading absolute nonsense lol ? Harappa and Mohenjo Daro script has NEVER been deciphered. We have NO idea what happened. All we know is that the civilisation was not centered around any deity temple/ king’s palace. It may have been the world’s first true democracy. They were neither Hindus, nor Jains, or Muslim. These are facts. Please don’t twist basic fact to feed a propaganda. This is an extremely important archaeological site.
From where did the guide get the story of Zalim King of Harappa? Nobody has deciphered the script of Indus Valley Civilization so far. Nobody can distort history like Pakistanis do. Basically, their motivation is always to show that the civilization pre Islam was cruel and backward and Islam brought peace in the region. The guide should get an award for making up stories.
@@PS-ug7nmTrue bro i met a pakistani in canada. He had story for every town related to islam😂. He could not agree Lahore was lavapuri full of hindu temples, multan was mulasthan, taxila was takshila. They think rawalpindi was named after a muslim sufi while it was there before islam entered named after bappa Rawal who massacred arabs
Real over smart guide and administration. The security could have kept a distance without making the tourist uncomfortable, but this looks like they didn't wanted you to roam free (for whatever reasons). Really disappointing.
I went there in 2012 I think. They didn't let us use the camera. But then they said: "since you look serious about the history (as others don't spend that much time here and just come for photoshoot etc) you may take pictures" lol
Pakistan has a lot of potential, people instead of fleeing in massive proportion to Europe, they should rise that country, but the strong Islamic ties limit their development
For all the Indian Brothers who want to explore & experience something like this they can go to dholaveera in Gujarat where they have something similar to the harappan civilization, added bonus is that you have see the fossils plus drive through the beautiful kutch ❤
there is a tomb every 30-40 kms in rural Pakistan, (mostly in Sindh and Punjab) of a saint who was unbelievably tall, I fell for it the first one I saw but when you come across so many you start seeing the trend 🤣,,,they need better guides for sure
I enjoyed the tour. I did have difficulty trying to separate the old city build from what looked like new bricking and concrete. It was still interesting tho. tx for sharing.
I'm interested to know about indian historical culture india is more then 7000 year old society and indus is 5000 years so it's interesting to know about that people living lifestyle culture and maybe their genetic test from bones (if bones are not completely rotten)🫤 then clear where indians come from😂 btw this guy is making stories..., (btw its not india its pakistan old civilization)
True. Some of my Indian friends who visited Pakistan (and visa-versa for Pakistan folks visiting India) are required to report to the local police station every day !
Such rich history, probably older than Byzantine empire, etc. which the Turks explained in so much detail.. SHAME on Pakistan for making a sham of a site that holds such deep historical importance to trace the roots for all us South Asian countries. We should proudly let the world know of what this land used to be, prior to everything that the Brits and Other invaders did to it. Islamization ruined it all
Don’t spread hatred. Your most important site is made by Muslims. Taj Mahal. India was never famous but became famous and civilized under the 1000 rule of Muslims.
What was that temple called? Please don't make stories, There is no word Hindu written in baghavand Gita vedas puranas or any other religious literature, Hind Hindi Hindustan names were given by Arab Mughal Persian and Turk Islamic conquest, Name Endia given by British Empire in1859 after occupation of what is no Pakistan , This is Pakistani civilisation ,
I always wanted to visit harappa. I am an enthusiast and learner of the Indian civilization. But due to this random borders built between this two nation, I cannot visit those sites. Those sites are in terrible state because they belong to an Islamic state, unfortunately.
1:07 talking about magnificence of Indus Valley's urban innovations while showing the poor state of modern Harrapa 😂 Any Pakistani reading this don't get angry, this applies to many Indian cities too.
Slap slap, they can beat someone else's child. Who is your father? He will get a visit. It was beautiful and creepy at the same time. A better guide, guess they all lie . I went to Jamaica once year's ago and had to be escorted by police all day we were guarded. I remember getting a picture with them 😂. Must have been the tequila 😅. They were nice though as other's told me it wasn't allowed 😂. I was younger then. I was nervous watching Karl and I could tell you were to. Tour is over, i heard? It was like they didn't trust you. So sad for such an ancient civilization to be explored and shown to the world. No wonder the police were there, not to really protect you, get the impression to make sure you don't film something. Thank you sir Karl 😂 for risking your life literally, dangerous place and the go pro dying wasn't a coincidence 😮. Stay safe! ❤
All tour guides do not lie. At least I can vouch for "official" guides in India. At most monuments you can check whether the guide is a licensed guide or not. To become a tour guide in India, applicants must complete an elaborate training program that includes a written exam and a bachelor’s degree in any field. The primary requirement for becoming a tour guide is to obtain a license from any government authority, whether at the regional or state level.
I appreciate your efforts. Whatever the guide is telling you isn't true. You can make a better video by doing your own research. It would be great or have a talk with some historian or travel writer. It would be great If you could manage a talk with "Salman Rashid".
Tour guide was very unprofessional, mixing lot of ridiculous fiction with the facts. A nine yard warrior saint, who walkes even after beheading and whose rings turned into heavy rounded stones. A Raja whose tyranny resulted in inundating Harrappa when his niece cursed him on her wedding day. The guide also unethically suggested the tourist to bring and sat his wife on the ruins. It is very embarrassing for a Pakistani to hear such bullshit.
Great video showcasing Pakistan's rich history, as a dude from Indian going around showing the similar side of Pakistan your doing the work of an ambassador for these two people who are so close yet so far
I heard this sites in pakistan is not safe all famous for robbers group and gang with lack of population police and security staff better not go if they want to visit these sites should visit Lahore museum instead.
Sad to see the Pakistani Govt is least bothered about the Archeological sites it can boast about.. Harappa Sites are invaluable! It's disheartening to see the poor management.. sorry to say, but the guide is not properly trained or has knowledge to be a guide for this site.. What was the story of "King Gilgamesh taking the newly wed wives" have to do with Harappa Sites? Also the story on Baba Noor Shah being a companion of the Prophet is totally fake, let alone the myths associated with it. Anyways I don't blame the guide, it's the Government that is showing such lack of interest in the country's own geographical past.. sad indeed
What did you find interesting in this tour?
Next, I visit an incredible 1000-year-old silk route village
ruclips.net/video/uvRw4hj2Xrk/видео.html
Hi Karl my family lives in Auckland n m looking forward to visit soon hope to meet u n ur beautiful wife there n learn about new zealand
more than 8000 year old
Harappa’s history is wild, but the GoPro drama? Priceless! 😂 Pakistan’s got so many hidden gems-can't wait to see more!
The inaccuracies said by the guide are very unfortunate. Such an important piece of history deserves a more unbiased and grounded view . I'm not sure if the guide was official or not but this makes me sad that I cannot take everything said at face value. Still very fascinating and thank you Karl for showing me
Its not an official guide, the site is a work in progress
The guide in Hunza Ganesh had a class. His information and narrating skills were excellent compared to what we are seeing and listening in this video.
Yah this guy seems to explain things but fails to put it in any context. The sewers may be a good example. Yes it is sewers, but the context would have been, it was very advanced and impressive for that time and civilization, innovation etc.
Definitely need that pinch of salt to go with the Guide’s stories! Thanks for highlighting some of these amazing locations during your travels.
Man, the name "Harappa" alone brings back such a distant memories.
Not because I've been at the location but because Harappa and Mohenjo Daro (Mohenjo Daro - Harappa civilization) was such a unique name when we learn about them back in... middle school if I'm not mistaken.
So unique the impression last until now as that was tens of years ago 😅
Thank you for showing us what it actually looks like
And man I was suprised for real as I'm writing this part when I hear the man raised their voice.
I thought you got into some problem fr which turn out to be the bike issue lol
So much drama 😂
I really enjoy how much we learn about local cultures from your videos. Sometimes unintentionally!
Very sad to see a priceless heritage of humanity is not managed or maintained well (like villagers / kids freely accessing the site). The guide, although a nice person is so funny - combining all local myths (the bad king of the region and the curse which turned the city to ruins!) and telling a story that is far from history. Thanks Karl for showing this place. As an Indian, although my heart wishes to visit these places, but the politics of the region would make it very difficult to get visas to visit these places. To all Pakistani brothers / sisters, please do protect this priceless gift of ancient ruins. Generations in the future will be thankful to you. Love from India.
What’s wrong with them accessing the site. These are already ruins they won’t ruin it more. We trust our people unlike Indians breaking mosques to build temples and planning on converting taj mahhal to a Hindu temple
Mohenjo daro and Harappan civilization also known as lost cities had no evidences of kings or queens it was likely governed as a city-state, perhaps by elected officials or elites from each of the mounds. The primary deity which was worshipped is Pashupatinath Or Lord Shiva.
In the year 1940 archaeologist M. S Vats discovered 3 Shiva lingas dating more than 5000+ yrs.
Just to get the bigger picture Harappan civilization was spread across the Northeast of present day Afghanistan, Pakistan and North West India.
This is the glimpse of history which is taught in our textbooks from 6th standard onwards.
P. S I love u Karl keep rockinn 🎸🎶🎶
There was no Hinduism during harrapan reign, Vedic religion and culture came later from the west through indo aryans.
@@sadmanrakin yeah these pajeet study in WhatsApp University and have no truth to rely on. 😅
That were not actual lord shiva that were proto shiva
Go and read ling puja devi puja tree worship etc is part of harapa, you converted are so confused, proud of your ancestors you bloody arabic cult😂@@thayab
Harappa looks so cool! Loved how you brought the history to life, especially with the whole GoPro dying moment-kinda spooky. Pakistan has such amazing places like this, and it’s awesome to see you exploring them. Can’t wait for the next adventure!
This guide beautifully and perfactly depicts the level of merit and competency in this country
such a useless guide, not even a proper guide. However, you must watch his video about Ganish village. The guide was brilliant there so we can't just generalise an entire country with just one person
maybe he is there cuz not a lot of tourists visit the area = less revenue = less salary for good guides
@@aprendoespanol6833 Khewra mine ka guide is so level
Can people (including the guide) stop spreading absolute nonsense lol ?
Harappa and Mohenjo Daro script has NEVER been deciphered. We have NO idea what happened.
All we know is that the civilisation was not centered around any deity temple/ king’s palace.
It may have been the world’s first true democracy.
They were neither Hindus, nor Jains, or Muslim.
These are facts. Please don’t twist basic fact to feed a propaganda.
This is an extremely important archaeological site.
From where did the guide get the story of Zalim King of Harappa? Nobody has deciphered the script of Indus Valley Civilization so far.
Nobody can distort history like Pakistanis do. Basically, their motivation is always to show that the civilization pre Islam was cruel and backward and Islam brought peace in the region.
The guide should get an award for making up stories.
why blame everyone for one persons fault?
They are expert at converting History as well 😂
It's just some urban stories the locals made up... No need to be so but hurt about it
@@muhammadazeem1346You also shouldn't get hurt when someone tells truth about your community bro 😢
@@PS-ug7nmTrue bro i met a pakistani in canada. He had story for every town related to islam😂. He could not agree Lahore was lavapuri full of hindu temples, multan was mulasthan, taxila was takshila. They think rawalpindi was named after a muslim sufi while it was there before islam entered named after bappa Rawal who massacred arabs
Amezing
Real over smart guide and administration. The security could have kept a distance without making the tourist uncomfortable, but this looks like they didn't wanted you to roam free (for whatever reasons). Really disappointing.
Pakistanis are followed every step in India for many many years. That should disappoint you more
Hi Karl, Great to see how your Channel and Subscribers have Grown
🎉😊 As always take care and stay safe 😊
Karl Rock, you are certainly kicking it up in north pakistan! Do you enjoy being in pakistan compared to any other place?
I went there in 2012 I think. They didn't let us use the camera. But then they said: "since you look serious about the history (as others don't spend that much time here and just come for photoshoot etc) you may take pictures" lol
What does mosque and grave have to do with Harappa?
Well done brother 👍
Always wanted a tourist POV of Mohenjo Daro and Harappa...!! Thanx Mate...!!
Pakistan has a lot of potential, people instead of fleeing in massive proportion to Europe, they should rise that country, but the strong Islamic ties limit their development
For all the Indian Brothers who want to explore & experience something like this they can go to dholaveera in Gujarat where they have something similar to the harappan civilization, added bonus is that you have see the fossils plus drive through the beautiful kutch ❤
The guide has no knowledge about the history of this historic site
The Guide is a fool and very irritating.
He doesn't know anything about Indus valley civilization.
He is not even qualified.
Looks like a scam to me.
Is a scam
there is a tomb every 30-40 kms in rural Pakistan, (mostly in Sindh and Punjab) of a saint who was unbelievably tall, I fell for it the first one I saw but when you come across so many you start seeing the trend 🤣,,,they need better guides for sure
Thanks Sir
What a usless guide! But Karl Rocks!
Nah man they butchered the English names of SAARC countries
I know right ? And Bangladesh was literally a part of their own country lol
Quiet Amazin!
I have been to Harappa. But there was no guide that day or maybe because I was taken for a local so they did not bother with me.😂❤
What is the process to get a visa to visit these places (for an Indian) ?
0:43 i think ticket rates rs 20 for sarc countries are different then other countries. But spelling of Afghanistan is written wrong
I enjoyed the tour. I did have difficulty trying to separate the old city build from what looked like new bricking and concrete. It was still interesting tho. tx for sharing.
next trip to zagros mountains, very nice place
GoPro died because of the constant BS the guide was spewing 😅😅
Harappa looked probably better than modern day Pakistan Harappa.
17 seconds ago is like crazy bro
Will you be visiting Mohenjo Daro?
his head cut off and he didnt realize hes dead. Karl can you ask the guide what drugs is he on?
One place i have always wanted to visit . Thanks Karl. I remember the security convoys in Egypt from hergarda to luxur . Not sure if it still happens
Terrible Guide, just yapping
Thank you for this truly fascinating tour Karl. I have always wondered how Harappa looked like. Enjoyed this video !
I like your video so much bro
Pakistan and their history is just like wow!! 😂
You must visit Mohenjedaro
Really you are doing a very video
I'm interested to know about indian historical culture india is more then 7000 year old society and indus is 5000 years so it's interesting to know about that people living lifestyle culture and maybe their genetic test from bones (if bones are not completely rotten)🫤 then clear where indians come from😂 btw this guy is making stories..., (btw its not india its pakistan old civilization)
Karl how do you know I need this one today for my preparation in my clg 😅
LoL from India 🇮🇳
the security escort and police guys weren't for your safety, they were because they didn't trust you enough not to keep tabs on you, I think
True. Some of my Indian friends who visited Pakistan (and visa-versa for Pakistan folks visiting India) are required to report to the local police station every day !
Pakistanis are great at turning History to His story😂😂😂
Hey Karl!
Basically it's an abandoned civilization, due to prolonged drought plus change in course of Indus river!!!!
Check latest research data
Such rich history, probably older than Byzantine empire, etc. which the Turks explained in so much detail.. SHAME on Pakistan for making a sham of a site that holds such deep historical importance to trace the roots for all us South Asian countries. We should proudly let the world know of what this land used to be, prior to everything that the Brits and Other invaders did to it.
Islamization ruined it all
Don’t spread hatred. Your most important site is made by Muslims. Taj Mahal. India was never famous but became famous and civilized under the 1000 rule of Muslims.
Islam made Taj Mahal a site famousin India what did the Hindus made?
What was that temple called?
Please don't make stories,
There is no word Hindu written in baghavand Gita vedas puranas or any other religious literature, Hind Hindi Hindustan names were given by Arab Mughal Persian and Turk Islamic conquest,
Name Endia given by British Empire in1859 after occupation of what is no Pakistan ,
This is Pakistani civilisation ,
@@rahulkamath44 as if India does any better
P@jism ruined it
I always wanted to visit harappa. I am an enthusiast and learner of the Indian civilization. But due to this random borders built between this two nation, I cannot visit those sites. Those sites are in terrible state because they belong to an Islamic state, unfortunately.
7:11۔۔۔۔گھر کے نیچے گھر کی جڑیں ہوتیں تھیں اوئے یہ گائیڈ کدھر سے آئے یہ تو گھر کی بنیادوں کو گھر کی جڑیں کہہ رہا ہے😂
this video is prime example of how to fuck up with history ....... so many made up facts
Hy Karl why dont you go north especially Swat & Kumrat
I went, do check it out ruclips.net/video/XqgjkjJu3O8/видео.html
He has been there
They guild said tik hai about 100 tines 😂😂😂
1:07 talking about magnificence of Indus Valley's urban innovations while showing the poor state of modern Harrapa 😂
Any Pakistani reading this don't get angry, this applies to many Indian cities too.
Thank you for showing this beautiful place……. Mosque ?….prophet ?….. and usual lies by these guys ……
Never heard of any Sahabi with the name of Noor Shah. This guy doesn't know the difference between Sahabi and Waliullah
Funny to think back when these ppl were around there was no concept of pakistan nor India
But there was definitely Bharat/Hind
Yes bharat is 2 trillion years old. Even before big bang. Bharat was thriving. Hayee mera lindustaani @PS-ug7nm
Nope none of it that thing started about a thousand year after IVC ended
No religion, no countries, no borders. Just vibes ❤
@PS-ug7nm ,
No Bharat no Endia
Slap slap, they can beat someone else's child. Who is your father? He will get a visit. It was beautiful and creepy at the same time. A better guide, guess they all lie . I went to Jamaica once year's ago and had to be escorted by police all day we were guarded. I remember getting a picture with them 😂. Must have been the tequila 😅. They were nice though as other's told me it wasn't allowed 😂. I was younger then. I was nervous watching Karl and I could tell you were to. Tour is over, i heard? It was like they didn't trust you. So sad for such an ancient civilization to be explored and shown to the world. No wonder the police were there, not to really protect you, get the impression to make sure you don't film something. Thank you sir Karl 😂 for risking your life literally, dangerous place and the go pro dying wasn't a coincidence 😮. Stay safe! ❤
All tour guides do not lie. At least I can vouch for "official" guides in India. At most monuments you can check whether the guide is a licensed guide or not. To become a tour guide in India, applicants must complete an elaborate training program that includes a written exam and a bachelor’s degree in any field. The primary requirement for becoming a tour guide is to obtain a license from any government authority, whether at the regional or state level.
@vs9324 thanks for sharing this with me. Do you think he was credible?
@@DeborahLong7777 Of course not.
I appreciate your efforts. Whatever the guide is telling you isn't true. You can make a better video by doing your own research. It would be great or have a talk with some historian or travel writer. It would be great If you could manage a talk with "Salman Rashid".
when u coming back to india bro
Tour guide was very unprofessional, mixing lot of ridiculous fiction with the facts. A nine yard warrior saint, who walkes even after beheading and whose rings turned into heavy rounded stones. A Raja whose tyranny resulted in inundating Harrappa when his niece cursed him on her wedding day. The guide also unethically suggested the tourist to bring and sat his wife on the ruins. It is very embarrassing for a Pakistani to hear such bullshit.
Otnicka remixer in Pakistan 😅
I am a woman. Never going to Pakistan not even for free.
When you have a police escortwhen you don’t need one, that is them keeping an eye on you, imo.
Karl bhai Indus dekhney gaye, guide unko mazhar dikha raha hai batoa yaar, hadh hai.
Great video showcasing Pakistan's rich history, as a dude from Indian going around showing the similar side of Pakistan your doing the work of an ambassador for these two people who are so close yet so far
hi karl how r u?
YA MULLA NHI SUDHRA G😂😂
YA GIDE V PARCHI H😂😂
06:00 the gopro died because of the overly complicated yet inarticulated way of speaking of the guide.
15:00 ye manat kaise puri krta kuch bhi😂
Go Pro died, Divine Punishment, 😂😂😂😂😂.
0:47 😅 Pakistani English spelling
It was a hindu and jain civilization.. there was hindu and Jain population
No proof of that
Now that's what we call a broken condom argument
We didn’t find a single hindu god or any other god in there its still a mystery who they worshipped
Hindu word didn't even exist back then
And they spoke English too.
India
Bit confused about the babas grave in Pakistan they babas every where and the garaves are always very long
And he was referring to him as a companion of the prophet Muhammad PBUH
@@shahrukhshamim4897😂
AISHA WAS 6 MOHAMMED WAS 54
Don’t care
And you are 12
All religions are fake..don't bring that nonsense here. Just enjoy the views
Rebeca was 3 lil kid read contradictory bible correctly read your history. its sad your whole christianity is based on lies HAHAHHAHA
Aisha R.A was not 6 or 9 go search on youtube Muhammad Quranist about this topic 😎
Pakistani guides are Master of Yapping 😂
Pakistani yapper
Spelling mistake Boss
lovely hindu history
SHAME on us, we destroyed everything.
I would never travel anywhere if I needed a police escort. Have you ever heard of Praveen Mohan?
you couldnt pay me to go to India or Pakistan.. I can see the beauty in 4k online.. without the smells, pathogens, or corruption =D lol
Wonderful ... and we would not get foreign pathogens in our country too. Nothing can be better than that.
Not sure what is worse, the guide or the police. Both are a waste of time. The guide needs to get a job with the police so he can do both jobs
I heard this sites in pakistan is not safe all famous for robbers group and gang with lack of population police and security staff better not go if they want to visit these sites should visit Lahore museum instead.
Sad to see the Pakistani Govt is least bothered about the Archeological sites it can boast about.. Harappa Sites are invaluable! It's disheartening to see the poor management.. sorry to say, but the guide is not properly trained or has knowledge to be a guide for this site.. What was the story of "King Gilgamesh taking the newly wed wives" have to do with Harappa Sites? Also the story on Baba Noor Shah being a companion of the Prophet is totally fake, let alone the myths associated with it. Anyways I don't blame the guide, it's the Government that is showing such lack of interest in the country's own geographical past.. sad indeed
Hello
Namaste Karl Jee. US president Donald and little Putin says hello Karl. 🙂
The “guide” is totally useless
Thek hai 😂
I also dont know this fool thing that many places they allows mobile but other like professional cameras not allowed!
Tomb story to fake hi hogi.
Chinta na kren
WTF man , fire this guide
This guide is like a village boy pretending to be a guide. There is no proper training and no mention of a date and evidence.